Purolator One Oil Filter PL22500 vs. Pennzoil Platinum Oil Filter HPZ-173 Cut Open
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 авг 2024
- Oil Filter Inspection.
Is this Purolator One oil filter the same as this Pennzoil Platinum oil filter? Let's open them up and see what's inside!
Purolator One PL22500: shop.advanceautoparts.com/p/p...
Welcome!
► Want to become part of a Great Story? Please consider donating to this Great Organization. Thank You! www.shrinershospitalsforchild...
► Music: www.bensound.com/
pixabay.com/music/
► Hope you like the video, Please don't forget to Like,👍 Subscribe, and Hit the Bell 🔔 to See Future Videos. Thanks for Watching 👀, and Keep on Wrenching 🔧. Take Care!
► Subscribe: / whipcitywrencher
► Follow on Facebook: Whipcitywren...
►Disclaimer: This video is for entertainment purposes only. Any information and content contained in this video are for entertainment purposes only. I ( WhipCityWrencher) shall not be liable for any injury, damage, loss, or even death to any person or property resulting from watching this video. Duplicating anything in this video is doing so at your own risk.
Fram,
Mobil,
auto oil filter,
AutoZone,
Rockauto,
Advance auto parts,
best oil filter,
Fram oil filter,
automotive,
Champion oil filter,
oil filter cut open,
Fram,
car filter,
Supertech,
K&N,
used filter,
metal end caps,
silicone valve,
Bosch,
anti-drain back valve,
Walmart,
filter media,
Mobil oil filter,
micron rating,
micron,
Purolator,
Purolator boss,
Purolator one,
adbv,
pleats,
ultra,
Fram ultra,
Walmart Supertech,
Supertech,
Pennzoil,
fuel cleaner,
injectors,
Blackstone Lab, 
Авто/Мото
Great video
Thanks!
@@WhipCityWrencher finally came back with a new video and change my name
Great! ruclips.net/channel/UCf6fItuLhPuCYckuxg20OzQ
no my bad ! I seen you opened up a quaker state not long ago from menards ! it just looks like a good filter for the price ! for my older vehicles that i do not drive much !
@@WhipCityWrencher thank you 🙏🏼
They look like the same to me.Both good filters.👍👍
Very similar. Like the yellow Color Penzoil Filter.
I been using Purolator One oil filters for years. I change my oil every 5000 miles, so the 10,000 mile interval is extra safety.
Hi Mike,
5K oil changes are 👍
interesting that Purolator has a better micron rating. Look identical to the naked eye.. Great Video!!!
I used to buy Bosch oil filters off Amazon but they've gotten pricey, so lately I've been buying Purolator ones from my local Menards for $7.99. I'm changing them, using full syn oil, about 5k-6k miles.
73honda350, I bought a dozen Bosch Premium filters from Rock Auto for $3.50 each. But…this was 2 years ago and I’m not sure if the price has gone up since then. In all probability so, since everything else has. 🤨
@@carlovanrijk4039 I used to get them on Amazon for about the same price but several months ago I looked to buy more and the cheapest I could find there was $10.99.
I think the reason they have those 'oil company' branded versions of the Purolator premium filters is for those quick lube type places or service stations (if there's any of those left). I saw that Pennzoil filter and thought it looked pretty nice and a Quaker State version, and another STP filter. You can probably find them at retail locations but I haven't found them to be very prolific. I was just at Walmart last week and saw a regular Motorcaft FL1A selling for $9.99. Crazy! I used to buy that same filter there little more than a year or 2 ago for $3.97 for regular changes because it was such a good deal. Not anymore.
Before Fred’s Department Stores closed they carried a full line of Havoline branded oil filters. They were just rebranded Purolators but my applications could be had for $3 all day long. I cut dozens of them open after running them 5K miles and never saw an issue with any of them. Metal end caps, plain rubber ADBV . I ran them on my Corolla with 350K miles on it and changed them every 5K miles. Folks who are going to change their oil regardless of the condition of it @ 5K miles could save themselves a substantial amount of money by avoiding high end synthetic oils and filters. It’s money to put in the gas tank or other needs. Of course people are obliged to spend their money however they want.
Rockauto has Champ XL synthetic oil filters for around four dollars, that would be an interesting filter to cut open.
He's done one or two of those already. Not a bad filter for the price for sure.
Thanks Pete! Either filter is serviceable and they are definitely related to each other.
Hi Jonathan,
You're Welcome!
Color preference is all these boil down to. I would like to see how these companies test the media to list such ratings.
I would too! They look the same to me.
in a previous video testing fuel system cleaners, you said it wasn't very "scientific." this is as scientific as it gets, aside from testing after exposure to real-life conditions. nice job
Thank You!
The Boss is the synthetic media. Good video Pete. No more Pennzoil fiters, can't find them. Just let stp Maxlife. No more. Thanks again Pete.
You're Welcome!
Thanks, my DODGE DEALER, (LIFETIME OIL CHANGE),SWITCHED TO PENZZOIL, ( SOPUS SUPPLIER), over a year ago:: originally in 2016 was PERFORMAX **(* made in Mexico, then ,later, made USA)……I A,WAYS USED NAPA GOLD/ Cabin, & then, *::To PUROLATOR BOSS OIL,,for my personal Buys….(* oddly OEM , for Air Filters
With 2 companies manufacturing the lions share of the filters out there now I guess there will be a lot of overlap among the different brands. Thanks for posting these videos Pete. Helps us to spend our $$$ wisely with the crazy prices for everything anymore.
Your Welcome!
Another fantastic video! Both filters look like good quality pieces that will do the job very well.
Thanks K Beg!
I think they are the same. The last Mobil 1 I bought also is now a Purolator.
They look similar to me; both look pretty good! Another good video and review! Have a great weekend Pete! Merri :)
Thanks Merri!
Have a great weekend and stay cool!
Nice 👍
Off topic, thanks whip city wrencher for the video on the hour meter, bought one for my Honda mower, works great, fixed it on there with Velcro, going to make maintenance easier, thanks for the great channel, all the best.
Your Welcome! and
Thank You. Best to you also.
They both good filters with good paint jobs ,basically a choice between a nice metallic blue vs a screaming yellow paint job 🚙🚕
I bought a Purolator One for my company vehicle, Infiniti QX60. 5000 mile intervals. Confident now that I made a wise choice.
Thanks for sharing!
Hey Whip, thanks for doing the comparison I suggested on the HPZ-173 video. 👍 I said there "Excepting can color, I'll bet they look almost identical." Seems correct. And, I'm going to speculate that even though the HPZ box efficiency (lower) not the same as PL/P1, they are both the same. Same media. I'll bet that with the exception of the nitrile sealing gasket, the equivalent Bosch Prem. (3502?) is also very similar if not identical too. All made by Purolator, same factory. I'm finding the Bosch Prem, for much less and the PTFE coated gasket not worth the difference. Great comparison, excellent vid as usual. 👍
Your Welcome! and
Thank You!
Love your videos.
The comments are fun to read.
A lot of guys are so happy to save $3 or $4 on a filter they buy a few times per year, then they probably spend $8 per night on a six pack.
......oops, I meant $5.49 on a six pack 😁😁😁
LOL,
You could be right!😊
Or $10 a day eating at McDonald's. Lol
@@kansasgardener5844 It used to be 25 cents 😱
I strive to buy the best quality at the best possible price. For my car and my body.💪😎. Thanks for the video
How nice of John to send it to You! Another great video! Learning so much about oil filters on here. Had no idea that there are so many different oil filters on the market until I started viewing your videos. Take Care, Cuz! Stay Cool this weekend! Another four days before the cold front moves in next week!
John👍
Thanks, Ella, can't wait for some less humid air, it sucks to even be outside when it's this humid and hot out.
@@WhipCityWrencher, Agree! July and August are not my favorite months of the year. Hopefully, September will bring much cooler weather. It's one heatwave after another. Too draining for those who like the cooler kind of weather. Stay Cool and Well!
@@WhipCityWrencher, So tired already of these heat waves. Three more days of this heat. Another Heat Advisory for Monday. It has been extended to Monday. Take Care, and Stay Cool!
@@ellalamont6943 Stay Cool!
@@WhipCityWrencher, Trying my best! Thanks! 🙂
► Oil Filter Friday, watch a New Automotive oil filter inspection video every Friday on this RUclips Channel.
The yellow paint probably makes it more thicker as the paint is thicker & contains alot of iron oxide for the pigment then to paint the other can blue
I would go with the purolator, but they sure look almost identical!
Yep, I'm pretty sure Purolator makes the Pennzoil oil filters.
I think both filters look well made it just comes down to which one is available for me the purolator because my local farm supply store carries purolator I have been using them for years thanks Pete 👍
Hi Gary,
You're Welcome!
Guy
Mann Hummel makes filters under several names. I believe some oem ones too. (Motorcraft & Mopar)
in that case, I personally would go for the lowest price, the difference between those two is negligible.
Good call.
The micron rating isn't. But based on appearance one is wrong.
SuperTech premium filters all the way
Dang, that dust up almost got ugly, but it turned out that those two are playing for the same team. Slight difference in can weight could be due to the sticker on the Pennzoil filter.
LOL 😂
I found that model of Purolator at Menards for $7.50. At that price I don't see the advantage of saving $3.50 for the Supertech and other discount filters.
The blue one is a puronzoil and the yellow is a pennzulator ! great video ! was there a difference in price ? Other than that to me they are the same !
Hi Scotty,
You have to shop around to find the Pennzoil, AAP has the Purolator One.
@@WhipCityWrencher ya ! i just couldnt see paying more for one than the other ! also if menards still has any quackerstate filters ! Thanks brotha !
@@scottymoondogjakubin4766 I can't say for sure that these are the same as the Quaker State oil filters. I'll compare them someday 😊
Just me or does it look like theres a hole in the filter at 7:07
2 pleats up from the seem just right of center.
Hi, Last hope,
I see it in the video, but I think that was just a spot/discoloration on the filter. I didn't notice any holes when making the video. Also if you look at 11:05 in the video that is the exact spot I cut out a sample. If you look closely you can still see the slight discoloration there.
I doubt the gaskets are PTFE. PTFE (Teflon) tends to be rigid and lack memory. If I were to guess, I would think most gaskets are made from Viton or Buna n. One black and the other that brown/red color. Pliable, with memory and very much petroleum compliant.
I think Penzoil filter is same as Mobil -1 filter both have same media rated at 30 microns
Actually, the Purolator One is better than the Mobil oil filter, the Purolator is 99% at 20 microns.
How do you check the microns?????
I can't, I just post what manufacturers list for specs.
Can you do a Baldwin filter ?
I've done a few, what size filter do you want to see? ruclips.net/video/OZYiaLI5Rtk/видео.html&ab_channel=WhipCityWrencher
ruclips.net/video/TVlQQZHrPBA/видео.html&ab_channel=WhipCityWrencher
@@WhipCityWrencher I just subbed. I use Baldwin filter B160.
@@nickjones8702 Thanks!
Your in luck, I haven't opened the B160 yet, but I have a Fleetguard LF16242, so I'll pick one up and compare the two. I'll try and get the video out sometime in September.
@@WhipCityWrencher thank you
Flip a coin. The same filter. Do you want blue or yellow?
Arrrggg.. Another video where you swap sides...
I dont pay attention to what side the filter is, it can end up on the right or left. Only in the first part of the video is where I match them to the Title, afterwards they end up where ever from moving them around.
Thank God I don't buy pen soil
They may LOOK the same, but they AIN'T the same -- because 30 is 150% of 20, and a 30-Micron rating is UN-acceptible .
It's hard to believe that anyone could claim that "they're the same", when there is such a HUGE discrepency between Micron Ratings.
The go-to standard for Micron Ratings is "ISO- 4548-12 @ 20 Microns".
If those filters ARE the same, SOMBODY is lying about their Micron Ratings !!
Base Plates are identical.
PTFE is generic TEFLON.
Those random digits on the cannister DO NOT tell us when the filters were made.
The Motorcraft FL-820-S usses the same base plate as the 2 filters shown here.
I'm wondering who makes the MEDIA MATERIAL for these oil filters -- The BOSCH Premium oil filters used to feature their FILTECH media, which was excellent at 99% at 20 Microns -- but it doesn't say "Filtech" on the boxes any more. Still 99% at 20 Microns, though !!
Thanks for Comments…. “” appear “”. Interestingly, my MOPAR DEALER switched to PENZZOIL ABOUT a year ago or more. ( Originally, was PERFORMAX ( MExico)..for new car OIL FILTER ( SOPUS SUPPLIERS), Lifetime SERVICES ( oddly I never checked checked why no MOPAR FILTERS , assumed price) .. does have all,other fluids , filters in MOPAR …..
Hi Chuck,
I think they are the same, you can believe what you want but the filter media looks the same to the naked eye, feels the same, and even looks the same under a microscope.
This is why I don't totally believe in the micron ratings that they give us.
@@WhipCityWrencher Yes, I know they look and feel the same, Whip, and I don't dispute that OR the microscopic analysis.
The elephant in the room is the huge difference in published Micron Ratings - because 20 does not equal 30, so if there is 2 different micron ratings for materials that are identical in every respect, then SOMEBODY is lying to us -- and it's NOT YOU !!
I would like to know how many different MEDIA MANUFACTURERS there are, and who their clients are.
I understand that Bosch owns Filtech, but I don't see "Filtech" on the Bosch Premium boxes anymore.
I would like to see the specs on the AMSOIL filtering media compared to the FRAM Ultra.
@@WhipCityWrencher Agree 100% Whip. Good call and you are I believe correct. 👍 I think the HPZ efficiency box info is the one that's incorrect.
@@WhipCityWrencher You're right. They ARE the same. It's just the numbers game as far as rating and the packaging-marketing. It would be MORE expensive to have 2 different medias and production changes rather than one product. It's called economy of scale.