FiLMiC Pro vs McPro24fps Android Camera App
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 авг 2020
- Recently an app called McPro24fps has made a good stab at snatching the lead from FiLMiC Pro. And in this video, I’m going to compare the 2 apps and see which one comes out on top.
Get McPro24fps: geni.us/2cZzO
►►GET MORE AS A MEMBER: / silenteye
📕Smartphone Video: Beginner to Advanced
📕Exploring the Film Look
📕Color Grading
📕Guide to Smartphone Gimbals
🎙️Filmmaking Podcast
💬 Exclusive Chat on Discord
🕵🏽 Behind the Scenes Secrets
🎥 Movie: My Smartphone Filmmaking Documentary (36 mins)
🎥 Movies: all 5 Episodes of Silent Eye
EQUIPMENT I USE TO MAKE FILMS
Smartphones
Samsung S9: geni.us/SmgC
External Drives
Samsung T5 Portable SSD: geni.us/NbtN
SanDisk Ultra Dual USB 64GB Type-C: geni.us/J7vhnvs
Lenses
Moondog Labs anamorphic: moondoglabs.com/?ref=gopingk-0oj
Beastgrip Pro Series 3x Tele: geni.us/CLlwYa
Filters
Neewer ND & CPL: geni.us/iDqZx7b
Tiffen Black Pro-mist: 1/4 & 1/2: geni.us/BKf1xAO
Gimbal
DJI Osmo Mobile 3: geni.us/ykCKc2
Microphones
Sennheiser 416: geni.us/G9tM
SYNCO Lav-S6: geni.us/gBGydq
Comica CVM-WS60: geni.us/VC6I5vm
Rode VideoMic Me: geni.us/ZQpO7f
Boya BY-M1: geni.us/Hmyj
Audio Recorder
Zoom H4n: geni.us/SKWCe
Boom pole
Rode Boom Pole: geni.us/z5BZyc
Lights
2 x VIJIM VL-1: geni.us/eqcb
Grips and Rigs
Beastgrip: geni.us/0LXzrz8
SMALLRIG: geni.us/DKj7ZJH
Magic Arm: geni.us/ROls
Flexible Gooseneck and Spring Clamp: geni.us/5GMA
Tripods
Ulanzi Mini Tripod: geni.us/p5BSQVT
Joby GorillaPod: geni.us/As76Ma
T-SHIRTS & SWEATSHIRTS
"Small Cameras Big Ideas": momofilmfest.com/momo-merchan...
SILENT EYE
is our series shot on Samsung devices using FiLMiC Pro
Watch Silent Eye on Amazon (UK, USA, Germany): geni.us/LaeOy
Watch Silent Eye + Behind the Scenes material: (World) / silenteye
Further reading
True Cinematic Gimbal Moves: momofilmfest.com/true-cinemat...
MoMo KIT LIST: momofilmfest.com/the-kit-list/
10 Best Smartphone Gimbals: momofilmfest.com/best-smartph...
Beginner's Guide to Smartphone Filmmaking: momofilmfest.com/the-ultimate...
Basic Video Editing Tips: momofilmfest.com/basic-video-...
Smartphone Filmmaker Diary: momofilmfest.com/diary-of-a-s...
#McPro24fps 
Кино
Always like your videos, clear explaination and such a calming voice!!
Amazing video. Very professional, all videos of this channel are like this. By the way, your voice is perfect. It's like listening stories from another dimension.🙂
My mistake: you can set 24fps and 1/50 shutter in Filmic Pro. There's a 50hz shutter setting in the same menu where you set frame rate. There's also a blog version of this video, if you want to refer to it: momofilmfest.com/filmic-pro-vs-mcpro24fps-android-camera-app-for-video/
the main issue is Filmic Pro hides features in menus rather than McPro24fps which have dedicated buttons.
Interesting to see an Android only filming app. They seem to have tapped into something there but they definitely need to simplify the interface. Great and detailed comparison. : )
Great tutorial. Probably the best McPro24fps app tutorial available on RUclips.
indeed
This is the first I'm hearing of McPro24fps but it seems really good. Will definitely give it a shot. Seems to have better reviews on the Play Store than ProTake.
I've used Filmic for my past few videos and now that I got the hang of if I really love it. Would love if you could take a look at some of my vids and give me some feedback. All the vids are shot on my S10 Plus.
Thanks for all the good work you do on this channel!
Being looking for this. Grateful I got it here.
Great take on this new app. Thanks, Simon!
I think the main question here is if it works better on given devices, because as we all know Filmic pro has many compatibility issues with most Android devices. When I asked Filmic Pro's technical support what Android device it works best on, they suggested Samsung s10 and note 10, but even the users of these particular devices claim to have problems and crashes.
Although I have Note 10 plus (exynos) and I'm happy how filmic works in general there are moments when I'm tired of seeing how controls flip vertical and they won't flip back to horizontal position ehh (restart is the solution only)
Very informative comparison. Thank you so much.
thank you for your shearing thoughts, always I learned something new..
Thank you for another informative video!
Another great video. Thanks for the info.
6:45 So, in order to gain access to higher frame rates like 120, you need to turn off GPU. I get that, but when you want to access the color profiles 9:59, you need to have GPU on. This obviously will go against what I want to use personally (Flat or LOG with 120fps). So has this been updated recently so that you can have access to both at once now or is it still an either/or option?
Ac
Please what gimbal does the MCpro24fps support?
I think in this case the choice comes down to whether its close enough to FP to negate the need for a subscription to that app. For those that are asking the question, I think the answer would be a resounding yes.
Hello, thank you for uploading a good video. I have a question. Can these two apps support hdr for 4k 60fps? And as of now, which app would be better to use for Android (I'm the LG G8 model)? Since I am a beginner in video, I prefer to be user-friendly and have less video editing (including color control).
From what I've gathered this app caters more to android users.
And also offers at least 7 things that the filmic pro app does not offer to me that makes this the better app for me. But
It's up to each individual film maker to figure that out dor his or herself. Nut really overall a great job in designing and development of this app for cellphone cinematography.
Just a great support tool to have in ur arsenal of tools to use...
Now its about practice and repeating the success and I'm sure there will be updates ahead so it's worth the 14.99 price tag tag in my opinion....
If it does, its one of the few. Almost 80% of these apps available are exclusive to the iphone.
Great video, so many useful informations! If I may ask, do you know how does Mc pro 24 fps works with Huawei p20?
Great video! I have both apps but frankly, the MCPro24 is extremely awkward to use, so I still prefer FilmicPro.
Questions: Do any of these apps let you change the autofocus speed ? The speed how fast or slow it pulls automatically between the focused areas?
I am torn a bit between these two. I need maybe a bit more simple UI but definitely want to experiment with flat profiles... and 10 bit as well but that is supported by both.
I wish you put up a developer team and make a video app for us!
I really enjoy your videos, your calming warm father type voice, the way you don't feel the need to shout as many youtubers do. Thanks.
I'v been hearing lots of good things about this app lately 😎
Thank you for this review. I like FilMic Pro and I like this app also. However McPro24fps gives me more access to my phone camera settings than FilMic Pro which is great. I will continue to use both apps because each one has features that I like.
I was intending to use my LG V40 android phone for filming only when mounted to my DJI OM 4 gimbal. If I install and open the McPro24fps Android Camera App, will the gimbal continue to have the awesome functionality that I get with the DJI Mimo App?
It's funny the things you say about mcpro being cluttered and looking complicated, that's exactly how I felt and still do feel to some degree about filmic pro. I think you just think it's easier to use because you use filmic pro all the time. But filmic pro definitely looks cluttered and is complicated to use for a beginner. I like mcpro's visual buttons more than filmic pro. I'm a visual person and I can more easily associate a feature with an icon than with menu systems.
McPro has these long lists of settings, like Open Camera. Which is fine if you like tinkering with all these settings
Wow such a Great comparison ❤️
Nice video, thanks. Is there any way to find out how good the app works before buying it? Filmicpro has this evaluator app to check out. Was just wondering as it seems to depend on camera2api and now e.g. I don't know whether the log profiles can also be used on my device. Another question I hope u can answer... Is there an option to also shoot flat profile? Thanks!
hi Marco. If you send them a message via their Facebook page, they are in my experience quick to reply. So far I have had good answers too. In their FAQ they say you can try it and return it within 48 hours if you are not happy mcprotector.lv/faq/
10 bits in a phone video, does it really work? appreciate if you compare it to an 8bit video
I love your video and I shoot behind the scenes with my Samsung Galaxy S10+ but I want to connect a external monitor. And the phone does not go and to landscape mode when you connect a external monitor do you know a solution?
I like mcpro24fps! I have 10bit on my device. I bought the app and have no regrets at all. Cool tutorial! 👍
FilmicPro have suport for many gimbals, McPro24fps are suport for gimbals???
@@EduardFoto No
Awesome! Now can you please show us how to record HDR video with these apps? There are so many settings it gets very confusing!
lol
Thanks for making this video I am finding filmic pro to be over exposing my footage and making it look grainy and not that great even though I had PLEANTY of lighting.
hm strange. Have you tried McPro24fps?
@@SiHorrocks no not yet I was tempted to buy it after this video
Slightly off topic, what are your thoughts about using a dedicated lens/filter mount such as beastcage? Or does the clip suit you better?
I use both, depending on the situation. Clip or cage :)
I have a Moment lens case and I find it super convenient. Only thing is that I don't use the case for every day phone use, only when I'm using one of their lenses.
I was intending to use my LG V40 android phone for filming only when mounted to my DJI OM 4 gimbal. If I install and open the McPro24fps Android Camera App, will the gimbal continue to have the awesome functionality that I get with the DJI Mimo App?
To use the an app with a gimbal it needs a bluetooth connectivity function within the app to the gimbal.
If I Use Filmic Pro on Samsung S10 lite will it work Properly with all Features?
I applaud competition for FilmicPro, even though I very much like that app. The UX implementation on McPro24fps is clearly "1.0", so what we are seeing is the initial expression of what these developers think a proper UX needs to be, with refinements to come over time. Personally, I found FilmicPro completely intuitive right from the start even though I have almost no video experience. So, that's where I'll stay.
you all probably dont care at all but does any of you know a way to log back into an Instagram account..?
I was dumb lost my account password. I appreciate any help you can offer me
@Kamdyn Frederick instablaster =)
Seems to be for Android only. Any other alternatives for iPhone users? I’m using filmic pro and happy with it but always wondered if there’s something better?? Thanks for the video.
Yes, this app is on Android only. And it's give a new level of the video recording.
What do you think is the best Android for mcpro24pfs and filmic pro? My research says S20+ exynos. I don't feel like iPhonying my life. I'd really like to have your input :)
Sony Xperia 1 M2 has largest sensor
Google play Store says it has in-app purchases: what are they in this case, particularly if it already has LOG functions?
Further, probably dumb question but would I be able to use this to shoot in 24FPS on my Huawei if anything below 30FPS gets greyed out in Filmic Pro?
I didn't see any in app purchases. The app itself is not free, log is available for the initial cost. I'm not sure about your device, but the McPro24fps Facebook page is pretty quick to answer questions
I emailed the developer about this. He told me the in-app purchase is just a donation.
@@JonHiddenColey gotcha
@@SiHorrocks Only members of Facebook are able to make inquiries?
Nice video, just a question if we can switch off the digital sharpness of the video in McPro
Yes in video settings
@@SiHorrocks Thank you sir.
The 10 bit color setting in the mcpro24fp app on LG V60 comes out oversaturated no matter what the settings. Any ideas?
Use the metadata switch
FilmicPro have suport for many gimbals, McPro24fps are suport fo gimbals???
If they make gimbals control integration with the app - that's gonna be the ultimate winner.
When using Filmic Pro and my Xiaomi 9T Pro with the 'standard' settings for cinematic footage, I get a completely blown out, overexposed screen. As soon as my shutter rate is at 1/48 it's unusable. Whereas in McPro it's absolutely fine. Any ideas on this, Simon? It frustrates me that Filmic is supposed to be for smartphone cinematography yet the default settings for cinematic footage are impossible to use on my phone without an ND filter! Awesome tutorial btw.
I believe Filmic have not listed the Xiaomi 9T Pro as being compatible with in this post: filmicpro.helpscoutdocs.com/article/53-android-device-compatibility good to know that McPro works well though. Moment dropped android from their camera app because there's too many devices to handle. Filmic are mainly focused on iOS, although they still maintain their android version. MCPro24fps are dedicated to android though
@@SiHorrocks Annoyingly enough however, they have an app to detect compatibility and the device passes with flying colours!
I'm LG V40 ThinQ user. 10 bit video recording is only available when turning on HDR10 option in LG's native camera app. When shooting non HDR10 videos its only 8 bit. I'm not sure if it's available on LG V50 and LG V60.
ok good to know, thanks
I'm also an LG V40 ThinQ user but new to filming with it. Does McPro24FPS offer significant advantages over Manual Mode in the native LG app?
@@daisypatritio572 yes. It does give us more features than the native camera app on LG V40 ThinQ. I shot 10sec 4K 24fps video clip with native camera app and Mcpro 24fps app. The video clip file size is 69 MB shot with native camera app and the video shot with Mcpro 24fps file size is 182 MB. That's a big difference in bitrate that's what we really wanted. Not just a bitrate there are lot more features than native camera app. Interface of mcpro24fps is not that easy compare to filmic pro and protake. Especially programmable focus points. We need to spend bit more time to understand for the first time.
My favarite McPro24. Using this on my Pocophone F1 around year. Best profesional video recording app on Android. I advise for everyone)))
Pls can u share me it ,I can't afford it(iam a student)
FilmicPro have suport for many gimbals, McPro24fps are suport for gimbals???
@@EduardFoto No it not support gimbals for now. For me a gimbal is a stabilization device, i'm not use button even when I was using Filmic Pro.
@@filmingstorm8760 McPro24 have an a chat on Telegram, there you can download for free.
Nice timing
This app is crazy powerful! Seems like the limit is now the phone hardware.
WHAT AL GIMBALS ARE COMBACTIBLE WITH MC24FPS
Wow i like the mcPRO
Hello, what's the version You are using of this app?? I also can see You have f/1.5 can You change it like i'm a regular camera? I have this app but f does not appear, and also how can I now if My SmartPhone camera supports 10 bits? I have Xiaomi mi note 10 pro Thanks a Lot, great video !!!
I have the Samsung S9 which had dual aputure. Unfortunately Samsung stopped dual aputure, it was just an experiment. You can ask the developer of McPro24fps they respond pretty quickly facebook.com/mcpro24fps
@@SiHorrocks Must I have a Facebook account to make inquiries re McPro24fps?
Please, I need an a updated version of this video
Can you make it real please?
I've contemplated purchasing this a few times but a little voice in my head keeps telling me I don't need it as I've got Cinema Pro on my Xperia 1. However in the app description, the developer specifies it as 'highly recommended for Xperia 1' so I'll probably be persuaded!
might be worth a try!
@@SiHorrocks I have the Xperia 1 and the app and can highly recommend it as it's amazing and better than cinema pro
Developer mention about Sony phones is because they have a 10 bit color depth, and it very good when you use Davinci)))
@@flightpathproductions5579 Ok, persuaded and purchased!
@@JonHiddenColey you won't regret it ')
UI is not good as Filmic pro. Filmic pro is way better UI and ease of access. One thing i really like about MC 24 FPS is that adjustable overlay size. It's gonna be cool if they add to the filmic pro in future updates. I'm using Sirui 60mm lens. When i attach the lens with the lens clip to phone its difficult to change white balance setting.
Seems intresting
I'm using opencamera
I purchased the app the minute i heard about it. I'm still using Filmic when I've been shooting lately because since I know it so well... it's still. the fastest for me to set up. I'm still wrapping my head around 24fps. It has some really good features but I think they need to improve the interface.
you can customise it, I only just noticed. So you can remove some of the buttons from the main screen. But yeah it needs some tinkering
@@SiHorrocks i didn't know that. I just opened it again after watching this video.... just closed it too.. 😂
@@MobileFilmmaking 😂
Hey Simon... what do you know about AMVR Proyect?
the footage I've seen is great, but trying it out on my Samsung the app is still quite crude in UI terms and it basically didn't work
@@SiHorrocks Thanks a lot. Btw which app they are using? (Motioncam or something else?)
@@marckmm I have motioncam installed
@@SiHorrocks Oh great!!!! Check this is the channel I mention it @AdvancedMobileVideoRecording
Edit: I found what they do, they modify the native camera app internally!
Is filmic pro worth the 14.99
I'm an LG V40 ThinQ user but new to filming with it. Does McPro24FPS offer significant advantages over Manual Mode in the native LG app?
I'm afraid I don't know enough about the native LG app to answer
FILMIC pro app is not available in Google Play Store. Where it is available?
It should be available, if not it is your playstore region which you should change to europe or usa. I found filmicpro and im in Thailand (asian region)
ruclips.net/video/4OIwkS0fxE0/видео.html
Is there any such app like McPro 24 fps for iPhone too? I really need it.
No, McPro24 is only on Android.
PoketCam ok. Then is there any other app for iPhone which can be used?
@@hinnag2184 On iPhone there is Filmic Pro, ProMovie and Moment.
Beastcam?
How is stabilization on Mcpro24?
depends on your device, but on mine you can choose to use optical, digital or none. Great to have those choices
wow..!! interesting for me :)
Need to motion blur key of cinema
Pixel4: MCpro24fps has better video quality but does not support shutter below 1/60 and 48fps which Filmic pro does. Sux, both devs should work together to make the killer app for double the price lol.
Two competing companies? That's not likely. Though one may acquire the other to limit competition.
Mcpro24fps is so goooood
#mcpro24fps best app
mcpro24fps is amazing app
I was intending to use my LG V40 android phone for filming only when mounted to my DJI OM 4 gimbal. If I install and open the McPro24fps Android Camera App, will the gimbal continue to have the awesome functionality that I get with the DJI Mimo App?
Which phone are you using it on?
Samsung S9
@@SiHorrocks Does the tele work? Just browsed the vid for now as I'm busy
@@SiHorrocks Oh btw, no 60 fps right??
By far the best alternative to FilimicPro now that they have sneakily underhandedly switched people who paid for it outright over to a rip off subscription. Dump FilmicPro and switch to this. Spread the word!
Filmicpro wants 14.99 Mercy
there is no VS
Perhaps you should mention this Mc24FPS app is US$20 and is ONLY available from the shitty Amazon app store ?
You have to install Amazon Store on your phone and if you delete Amazon Store the app won't work !!!
It's in the Play store too play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=lv.mcprotector.mcpro24fps
@@SiHorrocks Then it's either Geo or OS version limited. I can't see it in my search.
I guess I'll stick with Open Camera...
Apk link
Look on Android Play Store or at Telegram chat: mcpro24_en.
ruclips.net/video/4OIwkS0fxE0/видео.html