I agree with you that it's good news. I can only imagine how they would have screwed it up. I'm tired of seeing all of my favorite franchises "updated for modern audiences".
@@Mouse_Metal True, but the 2004 version tried a lot of new risky things with the premise that was at least well written. The problem with the "modern audience" stuff we are getting now is that they are not well written and just preaching "our ideology good, their ideology bad" without any nuance or interesting characters to go along with it. And don't get me wrong, BSG 2004 wasn't perfect and they swung and missed on some stuff, but the writing and acting was great enough to push through the not so good parts.
Agreed. Ron Moore’s vision was arguably a work of art. I would never want any other reimagining of the series. Especially with Woke writers trying to insert their identity politics which would make it shitty.
Yeah but the thing is we already know how it ends. Id prefer something totally new. A reimagining maybe. Or maybe the story of another battlestar that made it away from the massacre of the home system.
Just saw "The Creator" movie who's director worked Rogue One. This movie is like reversed Battlestar because Humans take the villain role against Robots. The NOMAD is well done. Just like a Death Star or Battle Star. Battlestar Reboot should learn from this movie. Battlestar should be more Epic.
I’m not upset. Ron Moore’s vision was arguably a work of art. I would never want any other reimagining of the series. Especially with Woke writers trying to insert their identity politics which would make it shitty.
RDM's BSG was a unique product of the era in which it was produced and covered the questions we had about ongoing conflicts in a way that hadn't been done before (or at least hadn't been done well). We had strong characters, both male and female and straight and gay, but that was how the characters just *were* and evolved. Roslin was a strong leader who happened to be a middle aged woman. Gaeta was a navigation and computer wiz who happened to be gay. And on and on. The character's sex or orientation didn't define them, who they were and how they presented themselves did. Today? I think we'd see a cavalcade of cliched tropes being used to beat some social message into us that has nothing to do with the show. All that said, this is welcome news. If it can't/won't be high quality and true to the 2003 series, then I don't want to see anything new. Tell good stories with good characters leaving the SJW/DEI/CRT BS in the dumpster and I'll be interested. Start getting checklists to make sure those boxes are checked and I'll lead the campaign to metaphorically burn it at the stake.
Gaeta being gay was retroactively inserted, originally the "little secret sealed with a very special pen" between him and Baltar was that during the occupation on New Caprica, Gaeta had been sleeping with an 8, to whom he had given names of people that the 8 led him to believe she would save, but in fact became names on the death lists, like the one Roslin, Zarek, and Callie ended up on. So originally, Gaeta was not meant to be gay. They shoehorned that in later
@@Christianos_Theophile Or he could have been bi all along. Either way, that wasn't a defining part of his character - it was just background and part of who he was.
Picard Season 3 isn't exactly the shining example to point to. It took them three seasons to get to a modest budget show that ALSO was respectful of the source material.
I really hope/wish that Richard Hatch's dream of a Galactica revival gets to run. He had gotten a lot of artists together to work on it before he was brought on to the SyFy BSG. I met him in the very early 2000s at a Con and we talked for a while (much longer than I'd expected we'd have been talking) and he had even asked me for a demo tape. (I never made one before and Lightwave 3d was a fun hobby for me at the time.) He had quite a cool vision that he'd outlined in his books. It would have been extremely dope to have seen that dream come to the screen. Richard may have left us, but the vision for Galactica that he had doesn't have to. What they need is someone like Joe Staczynski (who made B5 on a shoestring) and is a great storyteller.
@@majesticmsfc I couldn't remember the name he had for it, but he seemed VERY passionate about making that vision a reality (on screen or tv at least).
If they can find someone with the passion and a decent budget I would love to see it again. The Syfy series was awesome! I’m tired of companies hiring people that know nothing about the IP and just wanting to collect a check! (Star Wars Lately😢)
Don't forget that STD discovery with that useless Klutzman. Franchise killer Jar Jar Abrams managed to kill Star Wars and Star Trek movie franchises as well. If you want to create something new, don't take a well established franchise and stuff it up, rather create something original.
RDM Battlestar Galastica Remake will always been remembered for the quality. It was well written and thought out which is something badly missed from modern shows. I think a lot of fans would prefer it to be left alone rather than attempt some poor quality version. I am very pleased I bought it all on CD so the Streaming platforms can't edit.
I read somewhere else that Peacock canceled the series because the creators didn't have a clear idea what the series was about. I have only one suggestion, and I bet all the fans want it too; a First Cylon War series. No, Blood & Chrome and Razor Flashbacks aren't enough, those two only tell the final years of the war. This series should go from the beginning, show the day of the Cylon rebellion, The war in the colonies would be like Game Of Thrones, battles on land and space battles with a lot of strategy and politics.
As a huge BSG fan I consider this a good thing. I’ve watched a few channels react to It. One lady really enjoyed it and was sad when it ended while another couple seem to not really understand what they were trying to tell. BSG for ‘Modern Audiences” would be horrible.
This a good thing i’m glad this reboot reimagining whatever it is I call it a bastardization of the original Battlestar Galactica just like Ronald Moore version of Battlestar. Galactica is a bastardization. People need to stop screwing around with classics and leave them alone. You’re gonna play in someone else’s sandbox, you have to play by their rules, not decide to tump over the sandbox
I don't know, I was looking forward to the new gender fluid baltar sparring about the de-colonized colony colonizers and the anti-fascit adama mincing poetically about privilege..... yeah probably better they let the existing good one stand.
I really believe that the brand name of ,"Battlestar Galactica" is stuck in the mud... If disney got their hands on the Battlestar Galactica brand name-- a big screen movie 🍿🍿🍿 would happen...
I would like to see Caprica continue-The actors are too old now, but I was thinking “A Scanner Darkly” type animation drawn over actors style-It could work that way.
Honestly, this is the best news that could’ve ever happened to this franchise. The show itself is perfect. It’s so fun every couple of years to go back and revisit. It’s just so great. I even like the ending. True story I had a 10 minute conversation with Richard hatch at his show several years ago before he passed, and I told him that I was one of the people that actually thought the ending was OK. He did not agree, obviously in a wonderfully nice way. But he was so seemingly disappointed. They should’ve done whatever he wanted to do because he honestly and truly felt that that was a massive letdown both for him as a character and for the show. and it was a totally cool thing to have happen. Anyway, the show would’ve been rebooted with a bunch of 20 something kids and all of a sudden the entire story would not have made any sense. Can you imagine Captain Adama is a 24 year old? Or Starbuck as a pilot/influencer? No offense to any of those people, but how many reboots have basically just said let’s put a bunch of ridiculous young people in positions that they would never have been in and then reboot. Thank God they didn’t do it. I think it’s been three years that we’re getting close to a rewatch at this point
Just let it be dead. The story has been told and has been told very well the last time. A new version will just be used by its creators as a platform for their political ideals and social views. Just like star wars and star trek have been ruined before.
If Hollywood wants to spend more money on an existing sci fi franchise, leave BSG alone and go fund completion of The Expanse with the previous creators at the helm and the original cast in the main roles. Yes there's a 30-year time jump to the final trilogy but with current technology it shouldn't be cost-prohibitive to use CGI to age up the actors.
I've seen all of the BSG shows and movies and I think they should wait until they can get the right people I don't want them to destroy the legacy of any of the BSG shows. Loved the original with Lorne Green and the Edward James Olmos version
This was news to me (thanks for letting me know!) but not surprising to me since this isn’t the only post Ron Moore BSG reboot attempt that went belly up. I think since Ron Moore’s version was so good I’m fine if that ends up as the only remake. In fact, I’d much rather see the last three books of _The Expanse_ adapted or _The Chronicles of Amber_ , which Stephen Colbert and many others are trying to get adapted.
I still stand by the idea of a sequel with a 20 year timejump (bringing back the actors we know and love and adding new ones of course). Exploring the inevitable backlash of the "no technology" policy, children of colonial survivors dying of illnesses that could have been treated with high tech medicine and that sparkling a new conflict. Exploring the question: is technology good or bad? Some survivors never even wanting to see technology anymore, remembering what it did (in its most developed form: as Cylons) to their birth planets, cultures and their loved ones. Some survivors of course never having heeded the policy in the first place and hiding objects (weapons among other things), some of those objects getting into the wrong hands and being used to enslave a newly contacted primitive tribe who think the survivors are gods to be worshipped etc. And those who followed Lee's idea now finding themselves ill prepared to stand up against those who do have technology (kind of like how the Colonial fleet was ill prepared against a Cylon attack through their own stupidity - all of this has happened before and all of this...).
Honestly I think Battle Star Galactica would work really well as an animated series. Like the characters and sets would be 2D animated but all the space battles would be a stylized 3D animation.
Ideally there should be some kind of continuation-cum-closure of the Original Glen A Larson Battlestar Galactica, or perhaps a new version that is able to be closer to Larson's original core ideas and world-building that was cut-short and overruled by Universal/ABC. Personally I wasn't a fan of the Ron Moore 'Reimagining', and what Moore and Syfy created should have been an entirely different and separate IP altogether, while leaving the door open for a legitimate continuation to materialize....but that was then, and sadly many of the 1978 Galactica alumni have passed away. May the Lords of Kobol bless Battlestar Galactica! 😇😎👍
I'd love more Battlestar Gallactica, but it was starting to sound like they had no actual plan for the show, and didn't really understand what made the previous two shows iconic. If it isn't going to be good or isn't going to advance the genre, then it doesn't need to be made.
If this winds up like the production of "Warcraft" then it will take several years being stuck "in development hell" before it's finally released and will either succeed or divide the fans. I was in high school when the "World of Warcraft" movie was announced and it wasn't released until 2016, but there was a divide between 'diehard' fans who hated it and those who jut saw it as "just another fantasy movie"
Apple TV's problem isn't poor content, its impossible sign up requirements. If you don't own an apple device, be prepared to get on the phone with apple support every time you want to log in.
One can see where the money is being spent on an Apple+ show like For All Mankind......but so many other shows seem to be throwing money away......or laundering it.
Cable might be the answer, but SyFy has long had problems. Support for the final season of BSG was spotty, and they made an absolutely horrible deal when acquiring the Expanse, which is how they lost it to Amazon.
In a way, we already got a taste of how woke another BSG reboot would have been. Remember Another Life with Katee Sackhoff and how utterly despicable it was?
As a fan of the original series I was highly skeptical on the new 2014 reimagining. It gradually grew on me despite the changes in the premise, the timeline, and that stupid argument about how to spell "frack." The new series is a different but very similar story. I really don't think we're ready for yet another one yet. I really enjoyed Leave the World Behind so I know there are good people out there who could do a good job with this. Apple certainly has the money to put into a project like this but they tend to put their money into projects of real quality and this might not fit well alongside something like Foundation, which despite being rather different from the books is still a seriously quality production. It might be a good idea to let it rest for a few decades as the reimagined series did, coming along thirty-five years after the original.
This is not bad news, given what has been done to other franchises, Star Wars, Star Trek, Doctor Who, etc., I'm glad I don't have to see yet another beloved franchise get f--ked in the ass.
Corporate greed, its all about profit. Heaven forbid that input has to go up and profits go down. I won't keep paying more for streaming and have less to watch. Pathetic corporate strategies, nothing more.
Too bad Dr. Who, Star Trek and Star Wars studios can't get that idea of dormancy vs sub par garbage writing just to keep things in the eye of those with short attention spans. Fans will wait for a good story. It's the impatient children of the tik tok age that loose interest if something is out of sight for more than thirty seconds.
Foundation... they spent money on everything but good writers Picard season 3 was bait and switch. That ending was awful I'd prefer they leave BSG alone and invest on something new
B.s.g. is great--- but--- I really don't know what these people know what their going to do... things seem to be unsure... Even I don't know what is going to happen... The future is uncertain... It's crazy...
I think this is for the best, I doubt a reboot would go well, Battlestar's best shot was with blood and chrome where it focused on the first cylon war within the same universe as the 04 reboot. But I feel a new reboot would struggle to meet the expectations set because how good the 04 reboot was. I mean we can see this in many scifi franchises that has continued or been rebooted, be it star wars or star trek, both had moments of success but I feel it is few and far between, star trek's success being Strange New Worlds for the most part.
Good news. We don't need a new series. It was likely to be another wokefest. Enjoy the original and the pre-woke era 2000s series Better not go the slimy, slippery road of Star Wars and Star Trek.
Unfortunately I had very little confidence that this new BSG was going to go forward. This is mainly because I had zero confidence in Peacock. I predict Peacock lasts for no more than another two years. I’m glad NC brought up ST: Picard S3. It was really well done and a relatively low budget. It’s unfortunate that Paramount fumbled any followup. Hollywood needs to learn from Terry Matalas and, more recently, the Godzilla Minus One film that had outstanding special effects for an absolutely tiny budget. Anyways, now I have reason 401932 to never subscribe to Peacock.
I loved the show "V" as a kid, but was very disappointed in the reboot a few years ago. As a BSG fan, I don't want the same fate with this show. Waiting is better than a half hearted reboot.
Somehow I am not surprised. Saddened, but not surprised. I agree.....I'd rather have nothing that something thrown out there simply to chase dollars. Witness what has been done to Star Wars and Star Trek. I'd rather enjoy great memories and nothing more than have the franchise legacy wrecked. But that's just me.
I can see a cable network taking a stab at a new BSG series but I don't think it would be Syfy. They have their BSG and it's a true gem of Sci Fi. The problem I see is that I don't know if any network otherwise would be willing to pony up the dough to make another quality BSG series. I think if it were to be made it might end up on something like Max or Prime and it just might be worth a watch if it did, since they both have reputations for quality productions, even if skewed from the source here and there.
I was not enthusiastic about the remake since the Moore reboot got it right. The only battlestar galactica I want to see is a series that takes place during the first cylon war when the galactica was a new ship. If done properly a first cylon war series could be great.
There are those who believe that gender here began out there, far across the safe space, with tribes of Karens who may have been the allies of the Gays, or the Transgender, or the Queer...
I was offered Apple+ for 3 months free. After one week, I cancelled it. Crap TV. Please bring a decent script BG to SYFY. I saw Amazon treat The Expanse with respect. Maybe they might do the same with BG?
I hope it comes back. This attitude that every entry in a series needs to be a mindblowing blockbuster is harming creativity. BSG is amazing, but it can stand alone. Ghost in the Shell is my favorite "IP" and it has all kinds of entries that are good and bad in their own right, but I enjoy everyone for the different paths they take. Characters and settings are radically different but work their own
Even tho I liked season 3 of Picard more than the first two seasons I wud worry that Matalis wud mess up BSG. I never watched the prequel but I thought the writing on BSG was so so great that I wudnt want someone else to try and do another show unless it was the original people. Picard season 3 still had some issues and I dont know all the sci fi writers in depth but all of the ones writing it right now other than Lower Decks and Prodigy havent really put out anything great even tho I liked the last season of Discovery it was that great. Dune is the only other sci fi thing i can think of right now that is good
I think cable is just DOA at this point. But yes, better to see a project languishing in development hell shelved or picked up by someone who wants to MAKE it successful than to destroy yet another franchise chasing the lowest common denominator low-effort low budget garbage that'll crap on the franchise and get cancelled if it doesn't make 500K times its investment in the first twenty minutes. Do it right or don't do it! (And "right doesn't automatically mean the flashiest, highest-budget attempt possible.)
Hit the problem near the 7 minute mark. "Creativity"! Does that even exist anymore? Reboots and bad clones are all I seem to see. Even the so-called new shows are rarely good or creative.
What really set apart Ronald Moore's BSG is that he told a coherent and cohesive story that not only appealed to men but also women who generally are not fans of science fiction. Now if only we would get a remastered 4K Blu-ray version from Ronald Moore.
I know that Disney, like most major Hollywood studios, and not to mention their owners/founders, is plagued with vile rumors. As well as what most would probably agree are questionable business practices at best. Nevertheless, they used to produce quality products. Now look at them.
I am for any of these 2 Reallities. It was a Great series non-theless! I was not happy with the ending, but it Was an endining which huge budget shows do not allways give you! A New, even Small series would be "Interesting", though! These people should do another short story Internet series ant the very least!, Like they did before! I think that the Fans could forgive them! None of these foreruners like "RAZER", was Ever Bad!.. It was done Really Great!
Good… no new scifi series any more in the future… unless they manage to do it without any cost! Maybe we get more grappy fantasy series instead with 50 cent budget!
TBH, I'd rather BSG not be made if it's not done right. But, then again, what is right? Would the world be better with a 3rd BSG series? That's why Hollywood's in trouble-- it's always trying to recreate things because it's too afraid to allow for originality.
5:55 there problems isn’t hostility to the genre it’s the lack of skill when it comes to telling a good story heck ied even be willing for them to just upgrade to telling bad story’s over the good awful tripe they have been putting out of late. I think putting out a bad story may be aiming a bit high maybe we should get them to aim for Awful? At least it’s a step up from godawful.
Thank you for watching this video! If you enjoy my content, please consider supporting me on PATREON: www.patreon.com/nerdcookies
All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again.
Damn, your Statement is Gospel.
So many levels. Top Tier comment.
So say we all!
😂🤣😅🥹
@@chawkes70 So say we all!
*Everyone who loved BSG:* Oh, thank gods
indeed, so say we all.
And leave Firefly alone too!
Don't make a poor version of BSG please
Was about to write the same. Good news.
So say we all 👏
Best news I heard today! BSG for modern audiences would be cringe.
"BSG for modern audiences would be cringe."
You can bet on it!
A very sad truth.
Starbuck would be trans.
@@deadman746 Is that a... pun?
Touch grass, moron.
I agree with you that it's good news. I can only imagine how they would have screwed it up. I'm tired of seeing all of my favorite franchises "updated for modern audiences".
It was already remade for the modern audience with the first remake with pointless -swaps.
@@Mouse_Metal True, but the 2004 version tried a lot of new risky things with the premise that was at least well written. The problem with the "modern audience" stuff we are getting now is that they are not well written and just preaching "our ideology good, their ideology bad" without any nuance or interesting characters to go along with it.
And don't get me wrong, BSG 2004 wasn't perfect and they swung and missed on some stuff, but the writing and acting was great enough to push through the not so good parts.
@@julius-starkI agree. I would say that Ron Moore had a vision and while some episodes were hit and miss, overall with the series was a work of art.
Agreed. Ron Moore’s vision was arguably a work of art. I would never want any other reimagining of the series. Especially with Woke writers trying to insert their identity politics which would make it shitty.
Already been there & done that lol...
I want a modern BSG where we get to see the full First Cylon War. From start to finish. That would be an awesome series.
Yeah but the thing is we already know how it ends. Id prefer something totally new. A reimagining maybe. Or maybe the story of another battlestar that made it away from the massacre of the home system.
Yes, me too
Prefer to warn them before this time and the surprise attack fails with minimal losses.
@@MickyChowMein69 Correct. Branch out and leave the original(s) don't try ANOTHER reboot, thats just sloppy and lazy on the part of writers.
Just saw "The Creator" movie who's director worked Rogue One. This movie is like reversed Battlestar because Humans take the villain role against Robots. The NOMAD is well done. Just like a Death Star or Battle Star. Battlestar Reboot should learn from this movie. Battlestar should be more Epic.
While I do still want to see more BSG content it's probably best if it's not on Peacock especially in the current era of slop.
Sorry, Battle Star fans. I personally have no skin in this franchise, but I know what it's like to get your hopes up only to get them stepped on.
I’m not upset. Ron Moore’s vision was arguably a work of art. I would never want any other reimagining of the series. Especially with Woke writers trying to insert their identity politics which would make it shitty.
They would just wreck it. No more remakes.
Maybe someday all this Hollywood nonsense will end. Only then can we have additions to the IP.
What could you possibly mean? This isn't a reboot, its exhuming grandma's corpse for one more christmas.
Probably for the better
You can bet on it! Hollywood has already destroyed Star Wars, Star Trek and Dr. Who; at least, leave us BSG!
I agree. But it is certainly not for the benefit of the fanbase that they cancelled it.
@@buddygrimfield7954 Yeah that's not necessarily true.
@@undertow5164 Yeah, right lol.
RDM's BSG was a unique product of the era in which it was produced and covered the questions we had about ongoing conflicts in a way that hadn't been done before (or at least hadn't been done well). We had strong characters, both male and female and straight and gay, but that was how the characters just *were* and evolved. Roslin was a strong leader who happened to be a middle aged woman. Gaeta was a navigation and computer wiz who happened to be gay. And on and on. The character's sex or orientation didn't define them, who they were and how they presented themselves did. Today? I think we'd see a cavalcade of cliched tropes being used to beat some social message into us that has nothing to do with the show.
All that said, this is welcome news. If it can't/won't be high quality and true to the 2003 series, then I don't want to see anything new. Tell good stories with good characters leaving the SJW/DEI/CRT BS in the dumpster and I'll be interested. Start getting checklists to make sure those boxes are checked and I'll lead the campaign to metaphorically burn it at the stake.
Gaeta being gay was retroactively inserted, originally the "little secret sealed with a very special pen" between him and Baltar was that during the occupation on New Caprica, Gaeta had been sleeping with an 8, to whom he had given names of people that the 8 led him to believe she would save, but in fact became names on the death lists, like the one Roslin, Zarek, and Callie ended up on. So originally, Gaeta was not meant to be gay. They shoehorned that in later
@@Christianos_Theophile Or he could have been bi all along. Either way, that wasn't a defining part of his character - it was just background and part of who he was.
Oh, for fuck's sake, please touch grass you Anti-Woke moron!
Picard Season 3 isn't exactly the shining example to point to. It took them three seasons to get to a modest budget show that ALSO was respectful of the source material.
I really hope/wish that Richard Hatch's dream of a Galactica revival gets to run. He had gotten a lot of artists together to work on it before he was brought on to the SyFy BSG. I met him in the very early 2000s at a Con and we talked for a while (much longer than I'd expected we'd have been talking) and he had even asked me for a demo tape. (I never made one before and Lightwave 3d was a fun hobby for me at the time.) He had quite a cool vision that he'd outlined in his books. It would have been extremely dope to have seen that dream come to the screen. Richard may have left us, but the vision for Galactica that he had doesn't have to. What they need is someone like Joe Staczynski (who made B5 on a shoestring) and is a great storyteller.
BSG Second Coming would be an outstanding show to watch with a new generation of Colonials.
@@majesticmsfc I couldn't remember the name he had for it, but he seemed VERY passionate about making that vision a reality (on screen or tv at least).
@@SnuffitLabs I remember when the trailer aired it looked so awesome. I would like to see a new BSG series more faithful to TOS
The classic sci-fi TV series doesn't need another reboot.
A reboot is definitely the wrong way to go.
There is SO much else to that universe to make shows about that they don't have to ever reboot ANYTHING.
If they can find someone with the passion and a decent budget I would love to see it again. The Syfy series was awesome! I’m tired of companies hiring people that know nothing about the IP and just wanting to collect a check! (Star Wars Lately😢)
Don't forget that STD discovery with that useless Klutzman. Franchise killer Jar Jar Abrams managed to kill Star Wars and Star Trek movie franchises as well. If you want to create something new, don't take a well established franchise and stuff it up, rather create something original.
@@johnmeneses7039 They discovered that Klutzman has an STD?
What in the world are you babbling about?
@@KalBuir Oh my, Sorry it was WAY over your head. Kurtzman and Star Trek Discovery also abreviated as STD.
I love BSG, but let it rest upon its own merits. We don’t need a rerun of a rerun.
RDM Battlestar Galastica Remake will always been remembered for the quality. It was well written and thought out which is something badly missed from modern shows. I think a lot of fans would prefer it to be left alone rather than attempt some poor quality version. I am very pleased I bought it all on CD so the Streaming platforms can't edit.
I read somewhere else that Peacock canceled the series because the creators didn't have a clear idea what the series was about. I have only one suggestion, and I bet all the fans want it too; a First Cylon War series.
No, Blood & Chrome and Razor Flashbacks aren't enough, those two only tell the final years of the war. This series should go from the beginning, show the day of the Cylon rebellion, The war in the colonies would be like Game Of Thrones, battles on land and space battles with a lot of strategy and politics.
As a huge BSG fan I consider this a good thing. I’ve watched a few channels react to It. One lady really enjoyed it and was sad when it ended while another couple seem to not really understand what they were trying to tell. BSG for ‘Modern Audiences” would be horrible.
This a good thing i’m glad this reboot reimagining whatever it is I call it a bastardization of the original Battlestar Galactica just like Ronald Moore version of Battlestar. Galactica is a bastardization. People need to stop screwing around with classics and leave them alone. You’re gonna play in someone else’s sandbox, you have to play by their rules, not decide to tump over the sandbox
Yeah I didn't really have a lot of confidence that it would be any good tbh.
I don't know, I was looking forward to the new gender fluid baltar sparring about the de-colonized colony colonizers and the anti-fascit adama mincing poetically about privilege..... yeah probably better they let the existing good one stand.
I really believe that the brand name of ,"Battlestar Galactica" is stuck in the mud... If disney got their hands on the Battlestar Galactica brand name-- a big screen movie 🍿🍿🍿 would happen...
I would like to see Caprica continue-The actors are too old now, but I was thinking “A Scanner Darkly” type animation drawn over actors style-It could work that way.
sometimes you have to roll the hard six cable TV
BSG doesn't need a reboot. They should rather make the remaining Caprica episodes or elaborate the story of Blood & Chrome
Honestly, this is the best news that could’ve ever happened to this franchise. The show itself is perfect. It’s so fun every couple of years to go back and revisit. It’s just so great. I even like the ending. True story I had a 10 minute conversation with Richard hatch at his show several years ago before he passed, and I told him that I was one of the people that actually thought the ending was OK. He did not agree, obviously in a wonderfully nice way. But he was so seemingly disappointed. They should’ve done whatever he wanted to do because he honestly and truly felt that that was a massive letdown both for him as a character and for the show. and it was a totally cool thing to have happen. Anyway, the show would’ve been rebooted with a bunch of 20 something kids and all of a sudden the entire story would not have made any sense. Can you imagine Captain Adama is a 24 year old? Or Starbuck as a pilot/influencer? No offense to any of those people, but how many reboots have basically just said let’s put a bunch of ridiculous young people in positions that they would never have been in and then reboot. Thank God they didn’t do it. I think it’s been three years that we’re getting close to a rewatch at this point
Just let it be dead. The story has been told and has been told very well the last time. A new version will just be used by its creators as a platform for their political ideals and social views. Just like star wars and star trek have been ruined before.
If Hollywood wants to spend more money on an existing sci fi franchise, leave BSG alone and go fund completion of The Expanse with the previous creators at the helm and the original cast in the main roles. Yes there's a 30-year time jump to the final trilogy but with current technology it shouldn't be cost-prohibitive to use CGI to age up the actors.
Have the Director of Godzilla Minus one and his team do a BSG SERIES /MOVIE. They would definitely knock it out of the Park
A reboot of the original Battlestar Galactica would be interesting.
I've seen all of the BSG shows and movies and I think they should wait until they can get the right people I don't want them to destroy the legacy of any of the BSG shows. Loved the original with Lorne Green and the Edward James Olmos version
Thanks Elaine
CANCEL DISNEY PLUS
What's this gotta do with Disney?
I'm trying to buy don't know how since it comes with hulu
This was news to me (thanks for letting me know!) but not surprising to me since this isn’t the only post Ron Moore BSG reboot attempt that went belly up. I think since Ron Moore’s version was so good I’m fine if that ends up as the only remake. In fact, I’d much rather see the last three books of _The Expanse_ adapted or _The Chronicles of Amber_ , which Stephen Colbert and many others are trying to get adapted.
I agree this is good news. I loved BSG but enough of the reboots already!
I still stand by the idea of a sequel with a 20 year timejump (bringing back the actors we know and love and adding new ones of course). Exploring the inevitable backlash of the "no technology" policy, children of colonial survivors dying of illnesses that could have been treated with high tech medicine and that sparkling a new conflict. Exploring the question: is technology good or bad?
Some survivors never even wanting to see technology anymore, remembering what it did (in its most developed form: as Cylons) to their birth planets, cultures and their loved ones. Some survivors of course never having heeded the policy in the first place and hiding objects (weapons among other things), some of those objects getting into the wrong hands and being used to enslave a newly contacted primitive tribe who think the survivors are gods to be worshipped etc. And those who followed Lee's idea now finding themselves ill prepared to stand up against those who do have technology (kind of like how the Colonial fleet was ill prepared against a Cylon attack through their own stupidity - all of this has happened before and all of this...).
Honestly I think Battle Star Galactica would work really well as an animated series. Like the characters and sets would be 2D animated but all the space battles would be a stylized 3D animation.
Ideally there should be some kind of continuation-cum-closure of the Original Glen A Larson Battlestar Galactica, or perhaps a new version that is able to be closer to Larson's original core ideas and world-building that was cut-short and overruled by Universal/ABC. Personally I wasn't a fan of the Ron Moore 'Reimagining', and what Moore and Syfy created should have been an entirely different and separate IP altogether, while leaving the door open for a legitimate continuation to materialize....but that was then, and sadly many of the 1978 Galactica alumni have passed away. May the Lords of Kobol bless Battlestar Galactica! 😇😎👍
Thanks the Lords of Kobol. So Say We All!
what was the music in the background of this video?
Thank crap for that, stop with the reboots already, use that supposed creativity and be original.
If this new Battlestar Galactica series gets picked up ; the new show needs a new writer and director. DO NOT FUCK THIS BELOVED SHOW UP!!!
Great news! Lets just hope they leave Babylon 5 alone now as well - Reporting from the 14th colony..
Sci-Fi on Apple? Like "Foundation"? Overbudgeted and underwhelming, losing the novel's impact completely...
If you cant do something properly, don't do it at all.
this news is for the best.
I'd love more Battlestar Gallactica, but it was starting to sound like they had no actual plan for the show, and didn't really understand what made the previous two shows iconic. If it isn't going to be good or isn't going to advance the genre, then it doesn't need to be made.
If this winds up like the production of "Warcraft" then it will take several years being stuck "in development hell" before it's finally released and will either succeed or divide the fans. I was in high school when the "World of Warcraft" movie was announced and it wasn't released until 2016, but there was a divide between 'diehard' fans who hated it and those who jut saw it as "just another fantasy movie"
Apple TV's problem isn't poor content, its impossible sign up requirements. If you don't own an apple device, be prepared to get on the phone with apple support every time you want to log in.
The project had no serious vision behind it. All they had was, "Make it like Ronald Moore's series". That's not good enough to create a TV show.
One can see where the money is being spent on an Apple+ show like For All Mankind......but so many other shows seem to be throwing money away......or laundering it.
Cable might be the answer, but SyFy has long had problems. Support for the final season of BSG was spotty, and they made an absolutely horrible deal when acquiring the Expanse, which is how they lost it to Amazon.
In a way, we already got a taste of how woke another BSG reboot would have been. Remember Another Life with Katee Sackhoff and how utterly despicable it was?
As a fan of the original series I was highly skeptical on the new 2014 reimagining. It gradually grew on me despite the changes in the premise, the timeline, and that stupid argument about how to spell "frack."
The new series is a different but very similar story.
I really don't think we're ready for yet another one yet.
I really enjoyed Leave the World Behind so I know there are good people out there who could do a good job with this.
Apple certainly has the money to put into a project like this but they tend to put their money into projects of real quality and this might not fit well alongside something like Foundation, which despite being rather different from the books is still a seriously quality production.
It might be a good idea to let it rest for a few decades as the reimagined series did, coming along thirty-five years after the original.
This is not bad news, given what has been done to other franchises, Star Wars, Star Trek, Doctor Who, etc., I'm glad I don't have to see yet another beloved franchise get f--ked in the ass.
I *extremely* disagree with Nu Trek: Picard season 3. It spat in the face of Star Trek fans and vandalized the franchise.
Corporate greed, its all about profit. Heaven forbid that input has to go up and profits go down. I won't keep paying more for streaming and have less to watch. Pathetic corporate strategies, nothing more.
I dont know the exact figures, but it is ridiculous that ONE episode of Severance probably costs as much as a whole BSG season.
Too bad Dr. Who, Star Trek and Star Wars studios can't get that idea of dormancy vs sub par garbage writing just to keep things in the eye of those with short attention spans. Fans will wait for a good story. It's the impatient children of the tik tok age that loose interest if something is out of sight for more than thirty seconds.
Foundation... they spent money on everything but good writers
Picard season 3 was bait and switch. That ending was awful
I'd prefer they leave BSG alone and invest on something new
F**K THE WOKENESS.
_"So say we all."_
making a series or never ending story is boring, what is the point of not having a ending.
B.s.g. is great--- but--- I really don't know what these people know what their going to do... things seem to be unsure... Even I don't know what is going to happen... The future is uncertain... It's crazy...
I think this is for the best, I doubt a reboot would go well, Battlestar's best shot was with blood and chrome where it focused on the first cylon war within the same universe as the 04 reboot. But I feel a new reboot would struggle to meet the expectations set because how good the 04 reboot was. I mean we can see this in many scifi franchises that has continued or been rebooted, be it star wars or star trek, both had moments of success but I feel it is few and far between, star trek's success being Strange New Worlds for the most part.
If they can't do it justice, don't do it! Geeze, The Expanse has raised the bar for any show that is Hard Sci Fi based.
In the current creative and cultural climate, I'm kinda relieved.
Good news. We don't need a new series. It was likely to be another wokefest.
Enjoy the original and the pre-woke era 2000s series
Better not go the slimy, slippery road of Star Wars and Star Trek.
Unfortunately I had very little confidence that this new BSG was going to go forward. This is mainly because I had zero confidence in Peacock. I predict Peacock lasts for no more than another two years.
I’m glad NC brought up ST: Picard S3. It was really well done and a relatively low budget. It’s unfortunate that Paramount fumbled any followup. Hollywood needs to learn from Terry Matalas and, more recently, the Godzilla Minus One film that had outstanding special effects for an absolutely tiny budget.
Anyways, now I have reason 401932 to never subscribe to Peacock.
I loved the show "V" as a kid, but was very disappointed in the reboot a few years ago. As a BSG fan, I don't want the same fate with this show. Waiting is better than a half hearted reboot.
@@LaserWoodShapes I loved the original miniseries and the tv series showing what happened after
Peacock did put out twisted metal. Surprisingly good. So maybe peacock wouldn't have been that bad
How can i be so sad yet so relieved
Somehow I am not surprised. Saddened, but not surprised. I agree.....I'd rather have nothing that something thrown out there simply to chase dollars. Witness what has been done to Star Wars and Star Trek. I'd rather enjoy great memories and nothing more than have the franchise legacy wrecked. But that's just me.
Another remake would be only worth it if Starbuck was a man in it.
I can see a cable network taking a stab at a new BSG series but I don't think it would be Syfy. They have their BSG and it's a true gem of Sci Fi. The problem I see is that I don't know if any network otherwise would be willing to pony up the dough to make another quality BSG series. I think if it were to be made it might end up on something like Max or Prime and it just might be worth a watch if it did, since they both have reputations for quality productions, even if skewed from the source here and there.
Battlestar Galactica had a very good ending, I have no curiosity about it. I am more interested in Stargate Universe.
I was not enthusiastic about the remake since the Moore reboot got it right. The only battlestar galactica I want to see is a series that takes place during the first cylon war when the galactica was a new ship. If done properly a first cylon war series could be great.
If Apple, FX, Amazon (The Boys and The Expanse Amazon) or HBO takes it over it will be fine, if Disney takes it over, hold on to your butts!
Thank God! With current Hollywood's inability to write an ensemble cast. Maybe we wait another 20 years.
There are those who believe that gender here began out there, far across the safe space, with tribes of Karens who may have been the allies of the Gays, or the Transgender, or the Queer...
Rebooting is a fine balance. The two versions did well and most science fiction is misding.
I was offered Apple+ for 3 months free. After one week, I cancelled it. Crap TV. Please bring a decent script BG to SYFY. I saw Amazon treat The Expanse with respect. Maybe they might do the same with BG?
I hope it comes back. This attitude that every entry in a series needs to be a mindblowing blockbuster is harming creativity. BSG is amazing, but it can stand alone. Ghost in the Shell is my favorite "IP" and it has all kinds of entries that are good and bad in their own right, but I enjoy everyone for the different paths they take. Characters and settings are radically different but work their own
As a big fan of both BSG series (yes, I am that old) and Mr. Robot, I am really disappointed. I hope this reboot gets made eventually.
Loved bingeing BSG. Modern audience revisionism also ruined ARCHER.
Even tho I liked season 3 of Picard more than the first two seasons I wud worry that Matalis wud mess up BSG. I never watched the prequel but I thought the writing on BSG was so so great that I wudnt want someone else to try and do another show unless it was the original people. Picard season 3 still had some issues and I dont know all the sci fi writers in depth but all of the ones writing it right now other than Lower Decks and Prodigy havent really put out anything great even tho I liked the last season of Discovery it was that great. Dune is the only other sci fi thing i can think of right now that is good
I think cable is just DOA at this point. But yes, better to see a project languishing in development hell shelved or picked up by someone who wants to MAKE it successful than to destroy yet another franchise chasing the lowest common denominator low-effort low budget garbage that'll crap on the franchise and get cancelled if it doesn't make 500K times its investment in the first twenty minutes. Do it right or don't do it! (And "right doesn't automatically mean the flashiest, highest-budget attempt possible.)
The series pretty much told the whole story of the second Cylon war. I'd rather see a new BSG series set in the time of the first Cylon war.
I don't really want another BSG series right now. It's too soon since the last one. I can't say I am very interested.
There will never be a better BSG than Space Mutiny.
Hit the problem near the 7 minute mark. "Creativity"! Does that even exist anymore? Reboots and bad clones are all I seem to see. Even the so-called new shows are rarely good or creative.
There's no need for another one. Ronald Moore's and the original series are enough.
Will Brian Herbert be getting a cameo in the upcoming Dune 3 movie? 🤔
What really set apart Ronald Moore's BSG is that he told a coherent and cohesive story that not only appealed to men but also women who generally are not fans of science fiction.
Now if only we would get a remastered 4K Blu-ray version from Ronald Moore.
I know that Disney, like most major Hollywood studios, and not to mention their owners/founders, is plagued with vile rumors. As well as what most would probably agree are questionable business practices at best. Nevertheless, they used to produce quality products. Now look at them.
I am for any of these 2 Reallities. It was a Great series non-theless! I was not happy with the ending, but it Was an endining which huge budget shows do not allways give you! A New, even Small series would be "Interesting", though! These people should do another short story Internet series ant the very least!, Like they did before! I think that the Fans could forgive them! None of these foreruners like "RAZER", was Ever Bad!.. It was done Really Great!
Good… no new scifi series any more in the future… unless they manage to do it without any cost!
Maybe we get more grappy fantasy series instead with 50 cent budget!
TBH, I'd rather BSG not be made if it's not done right. But, then again, what is right? Would the world be better with a 3rd BSG series? That's why Hollywood's in trouble-- it's always trying to recreate things because it's too afraid to allow for originality.
They mess everything up I'm thinking.... Exec's are exec's wherever they work.
Who would do a good job?
Yeah, I don’t want a rushed subpar BSG show.
The original was great .
5:55 there problems isn’t hostility to the genre it’s the lack of skill when it comes to telling a good story heck ied even be willing for them to just upgrade to telling bad story’s over the good awful tripe they have been putting out of late.
I think putting out a bad story may be aiming a bit high maybe we should get them to aim for Awful? At least it’s a step up from godawful.
How sad is it that the canceling of this news is actually good news for fans