Battle of the Multi Tools! Dewalt Atomic 20v Max DCS354B vs XR DCS355 REVIEW

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 окт 2019
  • HAVE AN URGENT HOME RENO QUESTION?
    Call Brad right now... with video! paltap.me/brad
    How does the new Dewalt 20v Max Atomic MultiTool compare to the older XR multi-tool? A side by side comparison, DCS354B vs XR DCS355 in this review. Check it out on Amazon USA: amzn.to/2MuY6a4 , Amazon Canada: amzn.to/2qv92Ms
    Check out all the tools Brad loves to use:
    amazon.com/shop/hammerandhome
    The new Atomic Multi Tool with free battery on HomeDepot USA:
    homedepot.sjv.io/c/1879294/459...
    ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
    HAMMER & HOME MERCH
    Hoodies, Tshirts, Mugs & More
    teespring.com/stores/hammeran...
    ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
    Get your tools faster!
    Amazon Prime free 30-day trial USA: amzn.to/31FXbZK
    Amazon Prime free 30-day trial CANADA: amzn.to/2Mf6FES
    DISCLAIMER: This video and description contain affiliate link(s), which means that if you purchase via one of the product links, we’ll receive a small commission.
    HOW DID THIS VIDEO GET SO MANY VIEWS?
    If you're a RUclips creator and want to take your channel to the next level, check out Video Ranking Academy : courses.seancannell.com/a/203...
    #HammerandHome
  • ХоббиХобби

Комментарии • 244

  • @hammerandhome
    @hammerandhome  4 года назад +7

    Check out Brad's in-depth review and test of the XR Multi Tool: ruclips.net/video/Yhxs4CDtgSk/видео.html

  • @NaziHampster
    @NaziHampster 4 года назад +190

    Definitely a difference. One is quite obviously black & yellow while the other is yellow and black. Yay, must upgrade.

    • @babydyke416
      @babydyke416 3 года назад

      🤣🤣💖💯

    • @Johnbro8
      @Johnbro8 3 года назад +2

      Marketing ploy, can’t see the difference myself. Well done for saving us buying an upgrade, for no difference

    • @bjwilkins5357
      @bjwilkins5357 3 года назад +4

      🤣 makes me feel good about my purchase this week. Saw both tools side by side in the store. Figured i was doing a small grout job, and didnt need the best. The $50 price diiference for the DCS354B was a no brainer for me.
      Thanks

    • @johanponin1360
      @johanponin1360 3 года назад +1

      let's confuse our customers to the point they forget competition exists

  • @dannykobra
    @dannykobra 3 года назад +93

    For anyone actually wondering what the difference truly is. Dewalt will actually comment if you contact them directly on the matter. When discussing with them on the tools they indicated to me "The XR version and Atomic version are identical in performance however the Atomic version is designed with internals more suited for home owner around the house use, the XR model is designed with commercial daily heavy use in mind". the difference may not be noticeable in a test like what we are seeing here, however if you were to use these tools both side by side for a week straight in a heavy commercial setting, the atomic version i am sure would show its signs weather it be motor over heat, battery consumption rate or simple durability in significant drop tests".
    Not saying the atomic version is no good, it definitely is great and wil perform the same tasks as the XR version, but if your a general contractor who will be using this tool daily, you may want to spend the extra 5 - 10 % and go with the XR model of the Dewalt tool line up, as its designed more to handle heavy extreme use.

    • @Meme-zc4cw
      @Meme-zc4cw 3 года назад +8

      Isnt the XR cheaper? Its like $120 at Home Depot and the Atomic is like $140.

    • @johanponin1360
      @johanponin1360 3 года назад +8

      so you mean we should read it as at-home-ic ? was this a pun bet from the marketing dept? (thanks for your input)

    • @matthewkline7842
      @matthewkline7842 3 года назад +9

      I run a construction business and bought the atomic version when it first came out just to try it and it’s been working just fine and have had 0 problems with it and I use daily and especially when I’m cutting doorways when installing laminate flooring or tile etc or cutting sheet rock or any hard woods, the atomic is literally not bad at all and I know a lot of pros that use it as well and they switch prices around all the time sometimes the XR is cheaper than the atomic and sometimes the atomic is cheaper than the XR not sure why that is but that could just be at our Lowe’s and home depot but I’m sure it’s like that everywhere

    • @joeboxer6950
      @joeboxer6950 3 года назад +1

      You know what Danial K. That does make sense. I read a few other reviews on the atomic that stated that the handle overheated with prolonged use and the batteries die quickly. I have the DSC356B and I just cut a stump out of the ground and it took like an half an hour and it did not overheat nor did my 1.3amp battery die.

    • @tinman1955
      @tinman1955 3 года назад +1

      A cheaper build for the same price? Makes sense. Actually at this moment Home Depot is selling the XR $40 cheaper than the Atomic.

  • @Peripatetic_Proletariat
    @Peripatetic_Proletariat 3 года назад +8

    I picked up that atomic oscillator kit today at Home Depot. It included the Oscillator, an atomic drill, (now with hammer functionality), 2-1.5 Ah batteries, a bag and a charger for $159.99

  • @ricardovarajr
    @ricardovarajr 3 года назад +3

    I have the atomic oscillating tool. I love it. All my Dewalt stuff is the XR line and flex volt line. Only got the atomic since it was on sale for Black Friday. Use it daily. Works perfectly. Only atomic tool id buy though.

  • @nightmareperdomo1313
    @nightmareperdomo1313 4 года назад +11

    I have to buy a new, my old version was with me almost 4 years working everyday ,I don't know the atomic. Thank you for the video

  • @dailleztj
    @dailleztj 2 года назад +6

    Dewalt mastered the multi tool out of any brand by leaps and bounds....that quick blade release with the variable speed trigger with the lock and the rate of speed is unmatched

  • @doyen86
    @doyen86 4 года назад +14

    Just what I was looking for, thank you for saving me money.

  • @_P0tat07_
    @_P0tat07_ 3 года назад +2

    I have the corded dewalt model. It’s a beast! I would like the XR cordless 3 speed model though, just got control, as it does not have more OPM than the basic XR/corded models. I think one thing dewalt could improve is the oscillation angle. I think they’re claiming 1.5° which could be improved.

  • @TheFunnyCarpenter
    @TheFunnyCarpenter 3 года назад +3

    Some good info here! Just working on a review with the atomic vs the new m12.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      cool, thanks for watching

    • @foam27
      @foam27 3 года назад

      new m12 fuel sux, I have all m12 tools. Finicky tool change , dumb speed adjust wheel, plus bad ergo switch on top. Lots of vibration and noise cutting nothing, dim light. Immediately returned for atomic, $99 with batt and charger, Love it!

    • @TheFunnyCarpenter
      @TheFunnyCarpenter 3 года назад +1

      Keyboard Warrior with my experience I’m going to lean towards saying no.

  • @bigbearhungry983
    @bigbearhungry983 4 года назад +2

    Great Video. I say if you already have one keep it. If you're don't have one get what ever is the cheapest. Looks like about the same to me.

  • @hugoenriquez2558
    @hugoenriquez2558 4 года назад +3

    Awsome I've been trying to figure this out myself, nice to know that its not just me scratching my head. Sometimes its nice when you professionals can't figure it out. Just means that if you cant tell the difference (seeing how you deal with this stuff on a daily basis) I for sure won't be able to tell the difference. Thanks again. Awesome videos. I HAVE SUBSCRIBED...👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      thanks for watching and the kind words!

  • @wikolib6821
    @wikolib6821 6 месяцев назад

    Good comparison thanks.
    Just picked up the Atomic DCSW354B in store at HD for 99 dollars with a 2 AH battery with charge lights, a DCB112 2 Amp charger, two blades and a tool adapter.
    They had the XR DCS356 online for the same price with three speeds (my understanding is that you always run the tool at full speed), a 1.5 AH battery no charge lights and a 1.5 Amp DCB107 charger 2 blades, tool adapter and a tool bag.
    I went for the "bird in hand" in stock at the store and a more powerful battery (charge lights are nice too) and charger. Didn't need the bag, have a bunch of Husky bags. Haven't tried it yet so we'll see.
    My understanding is that Atomic line is discontinued and they're clearing them out. Doesn't matter to me as long as it works well. I saw some other Atomic labeled tools at HD as well, a small circular saw for example. Think Atomic is kind of a dumb name for a tool because it's not nuclear powered.
    Using it initially for a laminate flooring project.

  • @libertarian1637
    @libertarian1637 4 года назад +19

    I use my Dewalt oscillating tool a lot and can say the ability to install a belt loop is a must; I use the clip all the time. New tools shouldn’t loose utility and features.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +2

      I totally agree

    • @Redfour5
      @Redfour5 3 года назад +1

      UNLESS you are DeWalt trying to sell as many as you can...

    • @joeboxer6950
      @joeboxer6950 3 года назад +1

      Get this…the XR doesn’t even come with the clip. That sucks because I want one. I can’t even find it on dewalt’s website either. It’s almost like they stopped putting them with the new tools. I got a drill like two years ago and it didn’t come with the clip either and the picture shows it.

    • @libertarian1637
      @libertarian1637 3 года назад +1

      @@joeboxer6950: I run the belt clips and bit holders on every one of my DeWalt drills and impacts. The clips come on some drills/impacts; the bit holders also come on some. I just bought them on E-
      Bay as I have over a dozen drills/impacts with this stuff on them and I just wanted them all to match. The clips are quite cheep online; well worth the money.

    • @bennygerow
      @bennygerow 2 года назад

      @@libertarian1637 thanks man

  • @akaredcrossbow
    @akaredcrossbow 4 года назад +3

    You can probably guarantee that numbers have been fudged and some corners cut, but IMO the DCS355 XR has been phased into the Atomic to keep the Atomic brand up and running, while introducing the new DCS356 XR with speed selector switch. I think the DCS355 XR was a mistake without the speed selector switch that couldn’t compete with its competitors that have a speed control dial! Sooner or later the DCS355 XR will get discontinued. It’s a good way to save money keeping older tools in circulation with new branding without paying for R&D and new molds to be made for new tools🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @Mikesfunbox
    @Mikesfunbox 3 года назад +6

    Great video. I like your honesty and candidness. It's always a struggle when shopping for these products. I think the reason they don't always have side-by-side comparisons is that there isn't much of a difference. Marketing and words sell products. "Atomic" must mean better, so if you are an impulsive shopper or in a hurry, you are likely to go for the one with the big adjective and font. I've been burned a few times and given away an extra $25-$100, even after spending an hour or two doing research. If the specifications are fairly similar it's probably not much of a difference. I am concerned that the older tools become less compatible over time with the new battery designs and I look for what has been added or subtracted in regards to accessories, such as the clip mounting that was mentioned in the video. It also depends on how you use the tool and if you are using it daily or once every couple of months. Thanks

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      thanks, glad you liked the vid, It's definitely tricky picking the right tool sometimes. also because the atomic runs at a lower rpm it doesn't get as hot as the xr on extended use.

    • @Mikesfunbox
      @Mikesfunbox 3 года назад +2

      @@hammerandhome I bought the Atomic, it came with a 20V 5amp battery for $125. It works great. Thanks

  • @TheCivicsiep3
    @TheCivicsiep3 Год назад +1

    the atomic drill and 3/8 impact are very nice and the difference in those tools is more noticeable. the atomic line is just compact 20v tools really not much more in it than that. atomic plus compact powerstack battery makes for a pretty good performing compact tool esp in that 20v size so idk if its necessary but they are definitely more compact than the normal xr line while maintaining most of the power

  • @tomgreen1721
    @tomgreen1721 3 года назад +17

    Since I have the XR version I'll say it way out performed the atomic version

    • @anthonymcmahan6373
      @anthonymcmahan6373 3 года назад +8

      Since I have the atomic I’ll say it out performed the XR 🤣🤣🤣

    • @aycht5787
      @aycht5787 2 года назад

      I’ve just tested both and did a side by side test, the atomic did seem to cut better than the XR, I found it strange too.

  • @aux1z11
    @aux1z11 Год назад

    I have the corded model and the xr 3 speed for when using outside like on the roof or working on a out building where you don't want to run extension cords but they are both great tools

  • @justgregnow
    @justgregnow 4 года назад +55

    DeWalt is doing some confusing stuff with the atomic line. The older model cost less and has more power which is a real head scratcher? Also the whole purpose of the atomic line is that it's supposed to be more compact and it's not. Just weird stuff going on there.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +4

      CraftManGreg yeah I’m definitely a bit confused my self. Thanks for watching 👍

    • @andrewk8636
      @andrewk8636 3 года назад

      Atomic line is smaller. Also im pretty sure he meant to say 18,000 oscillations per minute as opposed to 1800. Not as big a difference but the dcs345b is atomic also and has 20,000 oscillations too.

  • @Set_your_handle77
    @Set_your_handle77 4 года назад +7

    1:50 Yep, both metal.. I noticed that, too, a few days ago when trying to figure out what the differences were.
    Edit: I meant plastic...

  • @h2bbuilt
    @h2bbuilt 2 года назад +1

    I bought the atomic for $99 with a charger, two blades, and 2Ah battery included at home depot last week, 11/14/2021. They are on sale!

  • @9oldboi
    @9oldboi 4 года назад

    I think it’s for better control in working on small space. I was reading online something about finer cut ?

  • @Set_your_handle77
    @Set_your_handle77 4 года назад +3

    I got the silver one about ~2-3 weeks ago on sale from HD for $119 with a 3Ah battery. Didn't know it was being discontinued. I just got the orbital hand sander with the same battery for the same price.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад

      Gaston26 that sounds like a pretty sweet deal!

    • @miguelledezma1394
      @miguelledezma1394 4 года назад

      Its discountinued from HD. Lowes sells only the xr version

    • @joeboxer6950
      @joeboxer6950 3 года назад

      I just got the DCS356B XR 3 speed version from Lowe’s for $99.

  • @babydyke416
    @babydyke416 3 года назад

    Great video! I wonder how they would do head to head with cutting metals and wood with nails and bolts. Also checking the temps with a temp gun to see how different that really is 🤔

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      That’s some good questions. Perhaps I will make a vid. Thanks for watching

  • @IntensityDan
    @IntensityDan 4 года назад +4

    Does it make you biceps swole?

  • @akaredcrossbow
    @akaredcrossbow 4 года назад +3

    Has anyone tested the OPM on both the tools?

  • @abner20bushi
    @abner20bushi 4 года назад +20

    They just need to keep pushing new tools so they can continue to increase profits. It's that simple.

    • @Redfour5
      @Redfour5 3 года назад

      You just need to buy the power detect version then the FlexVolt advantage version and go get one of the old brushed versions. Then you can REALLY do a comparison and get even more confused...but boy you will really be set for certain kinds of jobs... And then go buy an M12 version to get those precise jobs done... I have the XR...for when I really want to tear things up...

  • @patrickwhelan8118
    @patrickwhelan8118 3 года назад

    Great review. Watching from New Zealand

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      Awesome! Thanks for watching! I have great memories from my travels in NZ, such an incredible place!

  • @rooster7131
    @rooster7131 2 года назад

    Just bought an atomic one. Question. Is the blade suppose to be at a slight angle? When my blade is say in the 12 and 6 oclock holes it slightly cants to the right as you look at it from behind. Didnt know if that was normal. Thanks anyone

  • @d.j.supafly5672
    @d.j.supafly5672 3 года назад +1

    I think it’s just a marketing thing. I own Dewalt tools and i really like the Dewalt platform but hate they make you choose between 2 or more different series like that. Some times it makes you second guess your your self then end up with all of them and half the tools are sitting not being in use. Other brands just got one or 18 v and 12v lines, at least the 60v battery can be used on all the tools, that is a plus.

  • @TxGulfCoast16
    @TxGulfCoast16 4 года назад +5

    Just picked up the atomic at local Home Depot for $99. Love it so far

    • @yoshinakashima2248
      @yoshinakashima2248 4 года назад

      I bought the atomic recently. Would you take it over the xr ?

    • @babydyke416
      @babydyke416 3 года назад

      Same here! I haven't tried it out yet but I wanted to snag it up for my new tool kit! I got a bunch of Milwaukee power tools but this one I wanted the Dewalt!

  • @jmac6248
    @jmac6248 4 года назад +17

    Cut across the grain for more consistent results and a better comparison between the tools.

  • @paulhatcher8450
    @paulhatcher8450 4 года назад

    Love your videos mate 👍🏽

  • @FrederickDunn
    @FrederickDunn 3 года назад

    Oh man... I wanted to see some cross cutting! How long do you get out of those batteries? Looks like you could actually get into some wood carving with those! Thank you for sharing and thumbs UP... I jumped on the New version you mentioned... thanks!!!

  • @toolhead147
    @toolhead147 4 года назад +20

    Love my dewalt tools, probably one of the best. Dewalt is screwing them selves up by naming new tools with less power. They should release a new tool once they improve and surpass the current one.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      toolhead 147 it’s definitely confusing

    • @akaredcrossbow
      @akaredcrossbow 4 года назад +3

      toolhead 147 I think older tools are being rebranded with the Atomic name!

  • @jokaron__jo_designs_tattoo2626
    @jokaron__jo_designs_tattoo2626 4 месяца назад

    The terms "XR" and "brushless" refer to specific technologies used in DEWALT power tools, including oscillating tools. Here are the differences between the two:
    XR (eXtreme Runtime): XR is a range of DEWALT products characterized by enhanced performance and extended runtime due to the use of high-capacity batteries and optimized energy management. XR tools are designed to provide better energy efficiency and increased runtime, making them ideal for extended use and demanding professional applications.
    Brushless: Brushless motors are designed with brushless technology that offers several advantages over traditional brushed motors. Brushless motors are more efficient, produce less heat, and have a longer lifespan. They are also more compact and lightweight, allowing for the design of more powerful and compact tools.
    Thus, a DEWALT oscillating tool bearing the "XR" designation benefits from the advantages of the XR range, including better runtime and optimized performance, while a "brushless" model utilizes brushless motor technology for increased energy efficiency and extended lifespan. In some cases, oscillating tools may combine both technologies to deliver maximum performance and extended runtime.

  • @thebackwoodsmechanic5029
    @thebackwoodsmechanic5029 Год назад

    great comparison

  • @jamessickmore236
    @jamessickmore236 3 года назад +3

    Atomic on sale now 99.00 at HD with 2 amp hour battery and charger

  • @patmason7276
    @patmason7276 4 года назад +4

    No contest XR kills atomic in all tools. Home depot Carries the cheap atomic. Try the recepracating saw XR cuts faster going through wood and nails vs atomic just wood. The XR impact has better torque.

  • @icyrene1
    @icyrene1 4 года назад +1

    I also noticed that the atomic line has less vibrations/minute... but has less vibrations on the user and cuts the same.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад

      Icyrene yeah it definitely has less vibration. I think it might cut better. Still not sure.

  • @jpablo700
    @jpablo700 3 года назад +1

    The XR brushless is $99 at Ace right now. Comes with 1.5 amp max xr battery, charger and bag. I like the smaller battery because of length. The 4 or 5 amp batteries make the tool too long in some cabinets.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      totally agree, I always run slim batteries on this

  • @ChrisGilliamOffGrid
    @ChrisGilliamOffGrid 4 года назад +1

    My old one just died, idk why, not normally a problem with Dewalts. Anyway, ordered an Atomic from Ebay for $74, just to try different model. Maybe I'll take the old one apart and see if I can fix it.

    • @zack6892
      @zack6892 4 года назад +1

      We have had great luck with the atomic at work. Sometimes I mix them up and the atomic feels like it's got low battery compared to xr but both will take a beating 👍

  • @michaelc7283
    @michaelc7283 4 года назад +12

    Hi Brad,
    The DeWalt DCS356 (3 speed) is not the atomic model. It's the same as the DCS355 oscillating speeds with 3 speeds.
    A DeWalt rep at home depot told me the difference between the atomic and the XR model is that the atomic handle does not get as hot as the XR when running it longer. Plus the items you describe in the video.
    I hope that helps. If you find any different information let us know.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      Michael C thanks for the info! I’m definitely confused because in the instruction booklet it shows the 3 speed version as an option for atomic. I’ll call my rep in town and see what he says. Thanks for watching 😊

    • @michaelc7283
      @michaelc7283 4 года назад +2

      @@hammerandhome
      What is Dewalt doing to us, LOL...No problem, just go on the DeWalt website and you will see all the information on the (DCS 356).

    • @doyen86
      @doyen86 4 года назад +1

      Nice. I have the original would love to see how it compares to the newer model. Can't find one on RUclips at all. Hopefully we can get a video?

  • @ThatGuy3714
    @ThatGuy3714 4 года назад +7

    Atomic is their lower grade line. But i guess thats why they call it "compact" even though its not any smaller then some of the XR tools depending on what type it is. They are tying to pass it off as a mid or small tool and not a full size tool. All of the tools slightly under perform the XR version. Some its so minor you cant tell. The one where its most apparent is in their impact drill. If you drive a 8" lag into a hard piece of wood atomic cant drive it all the way or get it out. XR can.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +2

      I have that atomic impact, and i would agree it is totally underpowered compared to the others. thanks for watching

    • @nexusly6720
      @nexusly6720 3 года назад +1

      Very important for diyers

  • @GlitterPoolParty
    @GlitterPoolParty 2 года назад

    Is the atomic brushless?

  • @dannymeil3294
    @dannymeil3294 2 года назад +1

    I bought the atomic oscillating tool with a 5.0 ah battery for 129.00 at the depot and picked it up yesterday 8/30/21

  • @MrWizards1974
    @MrWizards1974 4 года назад +25

    You cant do a head to head unless you take the human element out of the test.

  • @mra95662
    @mra95662 4 месяца назад

    I picked up the Atomic at HD for $89 with 1, 2 ah battery and charger. the other one was $129 with 1ah battery and charger

  • @SpokoSpoko
    @SpokoSpoko 7 месяцев назад

    Actually I noticed only now in your video that your XR doesn’t have that switch. Do the XR come in different versions, depending on region or country ?

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  7 месяцев назад

      3 different versions of the DEWALT Multi tool #tools #dewalt #renovation

  • @philipdove1705
    @philipdove1705 4 года назад +6

    I'd take the xr any day. I've used both for many hours. And really felt the atomic was a lot more vibration

    • @KaneLono
      @KaneLono 3 года назад +4

      100% nope. The XR is not better in all tools. My brother has been a Dewalt rep for many years.
      This one is almost exactly the same... except they slowed the atomic down a bit because the xr was overheating in the handle. Look it up.
      In all Dewalt XR... in batteries means extra runtime. But in tools means brushless. And that also gives you extra runtime. (They say 57% more. atomic and xr) Thats it. Nothing more or less. In this specific case the Atomic is a better tool. Same power. Also brushless, but it does not overheat. Not to mention it cost less. No brainer.

    • @silverwolf1075
      @silverwolf1075 2 года назад

      @@KaneLono so are all atomic line up better than the xr line up?

  • @chrismckay9875
    @chrismckay9875 4 года назад +6

    The dcs355 will be discounted and replaced by the dcs356 as the premium oscillating tool and the atomic will be the base one. The three speed tool is nice because you still have the variable speed trigger but with the 3 speed switch, you can lock the handle and run at lower speed for more versatility

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +2

      Chris McKay thanks for clarifying all that Chris. Makes more sense now. Thanks for watching!

    • @FusionBoost2.0
      @FusionBoost2.0 4 года назад

      Yeah the atomic is the 355 and the 356 is the new XR... Besides the 3 speeds it has less vibration then before etc The atomic will be cheaper usually as well. Both nice tools

    • @hellabull
      @hellabull 4 года назад

      What's funny to me is that the 355 and the 356 have the same oscillating power so that leads me to believe the 356 is the new XR and the 354 is just more of an entry-level model.
      I just bought the 356 today and looking forward to using it. Like it was mentioned above, I like the ability to be able to lock the trigger on lower speeds.

  • @SpokoSpoko
    @SpokoSpoko 7 месяцев назад

    Other reviewers pointed a three position speed switch on XR model. That’s rather important feature. How could you miss that?

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  7 месяцев назад

      Video coming just for you 😊

  • @Faranos007
    @Faranos007 4 года назад +2

    the difference is in the oscillation degrees. XP is 1.6deg atomic is 1.8 to 2.0 deg

  • @gjolinares23
    @gjolinares23 4 года назад +1

    The XR runs 139 and Atomic is 99. I would assume the XR is better as most XR tools are better than atomic counterparts. I have a couple atomics and they are good but they could be better imo. I plan on getting an XR when they put a deal out, no point in having 3 oscillating tools for shits and giggles.

  • @drewniakj
    @drewniakj 3 года назад +4

    This seems like more of a manufacturing difference than actual product differentiation.
    This tool sells well and is in mid-production cycle. You can increase profits by making manufacturing slightly cheaper by using slightly less material (now its lighter!) and having the battery last slightly longer by running at a lower OPM. Perhaps they are using a different motor...would love to see a side by side tear-down.
    To prevent pissing off your customer base, you give it some arbitrary name (ATOMIC!) and initially charge more for it while you phase the old tool out. When they stop selling the stock of XR, these will drop in price.
    A few cents in manufacturing savings might not seem like much, but over hundreds of lines and thousands of tools it adds up to millions of dollars.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      that's a very good point. thanks for watching!

  • @loucifer323
    @loucifer323 4 года назад +4

    I found out from Dewalt rep that the atomic line was home depot wanted a line to compete with Lowes because they got 12v line

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      very interesting, i hadn't heard that .thanks for watching

    • @zack6892
      @zack6892 3 года назад

      Well that was a bad move the 12v line was actually decent. Atomic made Dewalt look like cheap homeowner tools I know a bunch of guys at my work switching from Dewalt because of failed atomic line.

    • @loucifer323
      @loucifer323 3 года назад +3

      @@zack6892 The atomic hasn't failed it's a compact version of the 20v line and the drills are the best in it's class and the impact driver is good enough for anything it's supposed to be used for, screws not lag's you can use it in a pinch on lags but you will ruin your impact driver in fact they just came out with a band saw that is more compact than m12 bandsaw

    • @zack6892
      @zack6892 3 года назад +1

      Lou Cifer yeah they work but the build quality is worst then the old Dewalt max lineup and It’s all made in China. The atomic multi tool failed on us at work within the first 6 months and most of the people I know that went with atomic to replace their older Dewalt stuff had similar experience. I’m a carpenter so my prospective is above and beyond homeowner use so I get that maybe I wasn’t the targeted audience still no other name brand company is releasing cheaper tools they all improve each generation even the cheaper line look at Milwaukee compact brushless stuff or rigid or ryobi. I still love the Dewalt tools I own that’s why it disappoints me to see it. I haven’t seen the atomic band saw so I can’t comment but as far as atomic goes I would take the 12v xtreme over atomic they are smaller and comparable in power. I’m trying to hold out on switching as I prefer Dewalt since they are made in USA but it’s hard when all I see them do is rebrand roll lineups to ensure Lowe’s and Home Depot get their “exclusives”.

    • @loucifer323
      @loucifer323 3 года назад +4

      @@zack6892 Milwaukee is made in China and it's owned by China, Dewalt is the only American power tool company and you think DeWalt just sends their stuff to China and says make this and that, no they have rep's there making sure they are using quality materials to make their tools, but on the other hand Milwaukee is owned by China they have no quality assurance on their products they use the cheapest shit they can, that's why they have crappy chucks, collets and switches

  • @redcenturion88
    @redcenturion88 2 года назад

    Favorite tool in construction

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  2 года назад

      It’s a game changer ! Thx for watching

  • @nicolebeaty9888
    @nicolebeaty9888 2 года назад

    What about compared to the corded version?

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  2 года назад

      i have never even touched the corded version, i try to stay away from corded tools, unless its a specialty tool

  • @vladimirlopez7840
    @vladimirlopez7840 Год назад

    The atomic line is more of a homeowner grade. The XR is more of a contractor grade. Will they perform the same? Yes. But one should outlast the other if used heavily every day.

  • @robroberts2064
    @robroberts2064 3 года назад +2

    Just bought the Atomic + 5Ah battery for $99 shipped. HD Cyber Monday 2020.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      that's an amazing deal!

    • @SavedbyGrace1157
      @SavedbyGrace1157 3 года назад

      I got the $99 deal today too. Atomic tool, 2ah battery and charger with blades. Awesome deal. So excited

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      @@SavedbyGrace1157 that’s such a great deal! Enjoy, the more you use it the more you will love it. Thanks for watching 😁

    • @Jtwizzle
      @Jtwizzle 3 года назад

      That makes me question the xr 356 deal i got with bag charger and 1.5ah battery for $99. The 1.5ah battery is just to small to really do much with.

  • @isaacmoncix4142
    @isaacmoncix4142 3 года назад +1

    What's the extra screw it comes with for?

    • @joeboxer6950
      @joeboxer6950 3 года назад

      That’s for the star type attachments with the universal fit. They won’t clamp in, so you have to put the washer on then the attachment then the screw. They don’t even give you the Allen Key with it. You have to buy it separately.

  • @maxwagner3351
    @maxwagner3351 3 года назад +1

    The difference is this the atomic costs them less to make so they can put it in the dewalt kits for cheaper

  • @pawelpaluchniak4416
    @pawelpaluchniak4416 4 года назад +1

    Was the xr part of the 10 tool combo kit?

  • @kaomatic
    @kaomatic 3 года назад

    been on the 20v xr platform for years, i love it
    i see literally no purpose in owning the Atomic line

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      Agreed. Not worth it. Stick with the standard line up

  • @casemods
    @casemods 3 года назад +2

    Got the 369 for $80 shipped on eBay. It was cheaper so I got it.

  • @jamison74
    @jamison74 Год назад

    You thought the X-RAY chuck was metal because why? The color?

  • @Kevincleveland77
    @Kevincleveland77 4 года назад +1

    Not positive but aren’t the atomics designed to use less battery consumption and work just as well as previous versions?

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад

      i have never heard that before, ill look into it, thanks for watching

    • @scottwood5098
      @scottwood5098 3 года назад

      my atomic really does seem to go a really long time on a 2 amp battery. though the sawsall atomic eats batteries 4 amp need it that

  • @elizabetholiviaclark
    @elizabetholiviaclark 3 года назад

    I have the xr. I guess I'll stay with that, then. I'm wanting a table saw, and I'd rather put my money into that, especially since there's no discernable difference between the xr and the atomic.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад

      Sounds like a good plan. Are you going with a corded table saw or battery?

    • @zack6892
      @zack6892 3 года назад

      XR will hold up better in the long run. If your shopping table saws Dewalt just released a corded one with a bigger motor best table saw hands down. Steel frame will last forever.

  • @Hamchuck112
    @Hamchuck112 3 года назад +1

    3:57 Why do we still feel the need to manually oscillate oscillating tools?

  • @jamesbaumbach3294
    @jamesbaumbach3294 3 года назад +1

    They both rip. I use the XR for heavy use...Atomic for Fine detail.

  • @turbojoe2
    @turbojoe2 3 года назад +1

    Got both in my hands right now and I'm pulling straws as to what the difference is.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      there are a lot of opinions, 1, dewalt trying to sell another line, 2. lower OPM so the motor doesn't overheat as easily. 3. who knows. I like both, good luck

    • @turbojoe2
      @turbojoe2 3 года назад +2

      @@hammerandhome Well, I did the cut test myself and.... they are the same. As an electrician I know when you increase the load on a motor it slows down and power goes up. Shit. I think i just busted this wide open. DeWalt had to lower the output speed to make the motor or gearing last longer.... Anyone? Prove me wrong here. (literally I just thought of that while I was typing this).

    • @turbojoe2
      @turbojoe2 3 года назад +2

      HELP AVE!!!!!

    • @turbojoe2
      @turbojoe2 3 года назад +2

      @@hammerandhome #2 is right eh. Cheers.

  • @texaselevated7160
    @texaselevated7160 4 года назад +10

    Everyone is still talking about those two when DeWALT brought out the 3 speed XR DCS356 months ago

  • @Dunkasnu
    @Dunkasnu 3 года назад +2

    Battle of the multi tool but I’m over half way in and the only opinion he has is “idk guys”

  • @contessa.adella
    @contessa.adella 2 года назад

    I just bought the regular 356 with 3 speeds. It does not say ‘Atomic’ on the box, it has a silver blade release lever and the spec plate says 20,000 opm. So it seems there must be an Atomic version of the 356 and also a regular version of the 356….why? who knows!
    Anyways….IF the only difference with an ‘Atomic’ is LOWER max operating speed…then that can only be a dis-advantage….right?

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  2 года назад

      right, they seem to both work the same, its almost impossible to find the difference, from my experience

  • @ivlark1
    @ivlark1 2 года назад

    Xr has better battery life.. I’m still trying to find a comparison video.

  • @jordancypihot496
    @jordancypihot496 4 года назад +8

    atomic is garbage,Im a carpenter and only use dewalt but the atomic line is not worth the price, I would not buy them keep buying XR .

  • @donnysanner342
    @donnysanner342 3 года назад +3

    Take it apart .. ...you'll see the difference

  • @bobseguin2195
    @bobseguin2195 5 месяцев назад

    Dumb thing is, right now at homedepot in canada, the xr is$129.00 and the atomic is $190.00...........crazy.......😅

  • @billrehm3590
    @billrehm3590 4 года назад

    Does home depot sell the atomic exclusive.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад

      Bill Rehm I have heard they are the only ones selling it. You can also find them on amazon.

    • @andybub45
      @andybub45 4 года назад

      DeWalt is now only sold at Home Depot, it was originally lowes but they have Craftsman (rebadged DeWalt) so there is no point in DeWalt at lowes.

    • @prestonpeters6858
      @prestonpeters6858 4 года назад

      Lowe’s still sells Dewalt (at least in NC) but they aren’t getting the Atomic line. THAT is exclusive to Home Depot for now. You are right about Lowe’s pushing Craftsman.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад

      We have found it on Amazon if that is easier for you: amzn.to/2MuY6a4

    • @hellabull
      @hellabull 4 года назад

      I've noticed only Lowe's carries the Dewalt 12v line, Home Depot does not.

  • @VINNY5674
    @VINNY5674 4 года назад +6

    I returned my Atomic tools the XR is so much better...

  • @GIMow-xz2pf
    @GIMow-xz2pf 3 года назад

    Both are MTD manufactured

  • @habana6595
    @habana6595 4 года назад +10

    The only different is..... MARKETING !

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      Wass. D I’m told the Handel doesn’t get as hot on the atomic version.

    • @zack6892
      @zack6892 4 года назад

      The atomic is less powerful for sure we have both at work and whenever I grab the atomic I check the battery after using it cause it feels low on battery.

  • @atbien21
    @atbien21 4 года назад +1

    I just got the atomic. Did you mean to say 18,000 vs 20,000? You said 1,800.

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  4 года назад +1

      Yes that's why we posted a title underneath saying "it's actually 18,000". Thanks for watching!

  • @scraplifetrashtocash4551
    @scraplifetrashtocash4551 3 года назад

    I had both. Let the Atomic go and kept the Xr. The atomic gets hot to easy.

  • @lightandtheheat
    @lightandtheheat 3 года назад +3

    Thanks for the comparison. Friendly tip for future videos: please lower the volume of the tool in action in your video editor. It's not necessary to retain its relative loudness to your voice, and it's annoying to have to mute or turn down the video every time you use it.

  • @johntuazon1366
    @johntuazon1366 4 года назад +1

    Could you just send me one of those? Co'z you said you can't have too many of it. I can't afford to buy one. Watching from the Philippines.

  • @kirillkhizhnyak3749
    @kirillkhizhnyak3749 4 года назад +1

    let me help you figure out the diff , no diff , just price , tools get killed

  • @louindorato6855
    @louindorato6855 3 года назад +1

    I bought the Atomic bcuz it was supposed to be compact. But it's the same size. I don't gettit either

    • @hammerandhome
      @hammerandhome  3 года назад +1

      It’s a head scratcher. Better off buying a first gen model.

    • @louindorato6855
      @louindorato6855 3 года назад +1

      @@hammerandhome I use the XR at work & Atomic @ home

  • @muscleman369
    @muscleman369 3 года назад +2

    One is super compact and the other is HUGE! LOL it's pretty much the same tool With a different name. Dewalt is struggling with rebranding their tools. Problem is, ppl, especially paying customers have caught on to dewalt trying to urge ppl to go out and buy the same tool they already own... Dewalt is starting to lose my business. I had the atomic multi tool dcs354 and 98days later the trigger is surging the rpms up and down randomly. So it was returned and I ordered the xr with the 3 speed switch. If the trigger fails like the last did (also my xr dcf887 impact had the same trigger issues and I sold that too) then my business will go to the M-18 tools. C'mon dewalt quit thinking we are dumb.

  • @peachypound6108
    @peachypound6108 4 года назад

    I’m sorry did you say the Atomic has 1,800( 18hundred) compared to the XR which has 20,000( 20THOUSAND)!? That’s a huge difference. Did u mean 18,000? Or 2,000

  • @danmatthews6176
    @danmatthews6176 2 года назад

    For the minimal performance, I’ll stick to my XR

    • @contessa.adella
      @contessa.adella 2 года назад

      It’s LESS performance, by 2000 opm with Atomic!!! Sticking with XR is a no brainer. DeWalt just hope the Atomic label will bring in fresh orders.

  • @aryehcohen4403
    @aryehcohen4403 3 года назад

    You hit the vain

  • @anthonychase4945
    @anthonychase4945 3 года назад

    Isnt one brushless and the other isnt ?

  • @Ryux4x4
    @Ryux4x4 2 года назад

    So basically the only difference is the price

  • @dannydee9919
    @dannydee9919 4 года назад

    That whole atomic line didn't make any sense. The only tool in the atomic that is worth buying is the 4.5 inch saw. And even that, in my opinion dewalt dropped the ball as it it could of been Waaay better

  • @Mike-ff7ib
    @Mike-ff7ib 3 года назад

    I think the release lever is magnesium and not plastic but i could be wrong.

  • @abelcortes2754
    @abelcortes2754 3 года назад

    Atomic Iine has lower performance than XR in every single tool I have tried so far.

  • @irvingg.1437
    @irvingg.1437 4 года назад

    I'm confused what the thinking of DeWalt Atomic lines purpose. They are not compact nor are they any better. Actually they are less inferior. Reviews have showed they suck.

  • @joshbenton810
    @joshbenton810 4 года назад +2

    Theres zero reason to get atomic gear over XR. Period. Its worse, and hardly lighter

    • @stevenbate5544
      @stevenbate5544 4 года назад +1

      Worse? You mean a new model with almost zero difference? As such, not "worse", but less value?