You know what would be cool, a Transmission Fluid test, electric cars also use this oil, Tesla uses Dextron 6 in it's gearbox and the Front and Rear Drive Units.
Very curious about this one, I drive a titan XD and everyone pushes amsoil for smoother shift, I tried it, seems a bit smoother but nothing to write home about. but I feel like amsoil is like the audiophiles, I can't tell you the difference but the guys that know what they are looking for do... So they say ha ha
@@ArchCityCraftsmanA rougher shift preserves the life of the clutch material. If the shift is smoother that means the clutches are slipping a tiny bit more and the life of the transmission will be a little shorter.
I would love to see a budget drill showdown. Specifically, stores "House" brands. Wal-Mart's Hyper Tough, Target's Blue Ridge, Menard's Tool Shop, Harbor Freight's Drill Master, and maybe entry level Black and Decker because they can be found at lots of places.
For walmart I think it would be best to use the new hart tools, walmart has pushed them pretty hard. They're owned by the same conglomerate that owns milwaukee, ridgid, and ryobi. I wouldn't rely on them professionally, but they're actually decent for a DIY level.
@@doctordev97 Given that they are TTI products, I think that might be a bit unfair. I think a rebranded Ryobi drill would wipe the floor with those other brands.
@@ProjectFarm it would be a little different, but you should test Wasp/hornet sprays. I never know what will work best, shoot furthest, foam most, and spray more
I'd be interested in seeing how normal car oil compares to motorcycle oil, especially since they usually don't add friction modifiers due to the wet clutches
It's rubbish, lasts a few miles before its beaten to death. I once put castrol magna tec in a Honda cb1000 and rode for 300 miles running it in. When I drained it out after 1500miles it was like black water. The gearbox cuts the oil up apparently, that's why you have gearbox oil and engine oil.
no. the big tests that are important here for marine oil specifically was the anti corrosion/rust and the anti wear at rpm. Think about this, boats deal with much more moisture than any car will just due to operational environment. The corrosion resistance is important. Additionally, boats don't have multiple transmission gears to reduce engine rpm in use.. and so over their useful life see a lot more high rpm. while at a constant speed the marine oil 'only' performed 3% better, the ** about that is when you look at the regular use cases, the marine oil with less wear will make a much larger difference in the long run.
@@SuperWaterskiboy You are correct. Specially if you use 2 stroke gasoline engine. I mix my own gasoline to my mariner, usually shell v power and around 2.5-3% marine oil. runs much better than regular 95.
But we must also remember you’re usually not running a marine engine at extremely cold temps. I’d like to see an ambient/ average day temp viscosity test.
Your cold oil race narration was worth the watch all by itself. Thanks so much for keeping us informed - both from a product perspective and that of education. If you were a shop teacher, you would have the student's attention for sure - especially if you would load them into the farmbago racer.
If I were a student I would have raised my hand and asked why are you comparing apples or oranges? They duped everyone on here with a petroleum Honda marine oil vs a synthetic automotive oil. They should have been straight here and compared apples to apples, a synthetic marine oil with synthetic automotive oil.
Hey Brother. I know this is a shot in the dark that you would ever read this. I can only imagine all of us. Your fans. Would love to have you make a video of the process you go through to film your videos. It blows us away how thorough you are. How scientific you are with all of your tests and contraptions. I would give anything to watch a behind-the-scenes video of how you do things.
@@TheRCBasher69420 seriously! Could you imagine him filming a video about who he is. His name. What he does for a living. How he thinks about how to do all of these tests. I think he is absolutely brilliant. And I wish we could know him a little bit better
@@brianstauffacher ikr I just want to know what he does whilst waiting to say for this test when he was switching the pots if oil round on the hob what was he doing in the meantime was he going on his phone or doing odd jobs around the shop and like you I too would love to know what he does
@@ProjectFarm No, Thank you! I Love seeing all these products being put to the test. It really helps determine if the high dollar products are worth the extra money or are you just paying for the brand name. Also, what happened to the Farmabagoo? Is it still tearing down tree branches/limbs? lol
Test Idea I'm a woodworker and I believe that you probably have many woodworkers subscribing to your channel. Blades for planers and jointers are expensive to replace and they don't last very long. There are several different options all the way up to a helical insert type. Many people have the dewalt dw735 planer. It's considered a bit of an industry standard. Power consumption is also a big concern for using a planer and blades contribute quite a bit to load. One last item would be to see if there is a way to sharpen these blades with a commercially available tool. Lots of guys make home made fixtures and use sandpaper. I haven't seen anything commercial to do that task. Great channel. Probably my favorite channel of all. Extremely informative and very well done.
Realizing that it took a lot of time to do this test,I believe that's the most I've learned in 10 minutes and 10 seconds, you have a really great channel, Thanks! 🇺🇸
@@ProjectFarm If you are doing new Oil Testing. I'd love to see : Mobil 1 Extended Performance (non highmileage ) , Castrol Extended Performance against the Amsoil OE, XL & Signature Series Oils, and against Pennzoil Ultra Platinum & Royal Purple.
@@ProjectFarm so don't get me wrong, I loved the episode. But apples to apples, shouldn't it be say Honda auto oil vs Honda marine oil? It didn't surprise me that high a quality Pennzoil beat the Honda Marine. The Honda isn't synthetic, either. It DID do a better job at rust prevention. I don't know.......
@@Son_Of_Atreides I would love to hear Greg Woods commentating all of the "events" of one of these comparison videos, from the cold oil race to the endurance "heats" of the high temperature test.
Great timing! I was very fortunate to find the exact same Pennzoil motor oil at my local Walmart on clearance for $1.99 each quart. When I watch you do the flow test, I feel like I'm at a horse race. LOL Great video as always!
@@ProjectFarm LMAO, I SIT HERE BY MYSELF & ME DAG OF COURSE, ROOTING LIKE AN IDIOT ( BY THE WAY ME DAG LOOKS AT ME ) FOR WHAT EVER OIL I WANT TO WIN. IT'S VERY EXCITING TOO ME ALSO, MAYBE I SHOULD GET OUT MORE ?
I would love to see an episode based on everyday carry (EDC) pocket knives! Could cover edge retention, lock strength, handle durability, and ease of maintenance plus other stuff too. Brands like Case, Kershaw, Coldsteel, etc. Maybe throw in a kitchen knife as a control.
574.55 degrees Kelvin and Fahrenheit are the same temperature. At -614.55 the Rankine and Celsius scales cross, but that is and impossible temperature because it is below absolute zero. What will they think of next? 🤔
I might have an interesting one for you... Angle grinder steel cutting discs! I work as a welder and it seems like there's a big difference in performance, like wear, stability, cutting speed, and so on
@@ProjectFarm I second this suggestion! Would love to see some of the Harbor Freight cutting discs up against some of the top dollar 3M etc. on some thick tough steel. I've also heard that the thin cutting discs are better, but maybe don't last as long?
Love to see a comparison between the old oil bath air filters vs paper filters. I read alot on the internet about how much better the paper is but I'm not so sure. Our old tractors all had oil bath and operated in severe dusty conditions and lasted many , many years between rebuilds. Thanks. Your video's are the best!
Yeah, I'm not sure. I remember a high school shop teacher explained to the class how the oil bath filters worked and told us they would filter out smaller micron particles and were less restrictive. I totally agree with you that paper elements would have been plugged very quickly.
I will say that my Honda Bf75 4 stroke outboard doesn't run nearly as hot as an automobile engine which may explain the difference in the evaporative test. Most automobile engine coolant temperatures are going to be 195 Fahrenheit or above, even pushing my 20 foot pontoon in the summer and 80 degree water it's rare for me to see 160 degrees on the gauge even after running 5500 rpm for hours
@@countryfamilyalways7280 I don't run that Honda oil, I believe the last change was quicksilver or Pennzoil marine, I was just saying that temperatures may be a small variable, still a poor showing from Honda OEM oil
@@kygunworks4982 I agree with you and I don't have a boat YET but am looking so appreciate your knowledge on the subject. Yah there has to be better oil then that Honda with that result. A automotive oil that comes to mind that might out do that Honda is Amsoil ZROD as it has high AW additives better then regular car oils, long lasting corrosion inhibitors, amsoil says about 2 years because people store classic cars so they made it that way and I'd bet it has better noack and or evap results then Honda oil. But on a second thought I'd bet Pennzoils marine oil might have better results also idk...
You have to be the most thorough tester ever! I’d love to see you test Sweet Project Car’s magic oil blend (he has a video with a special concoction of like 4 different oils)!
Great test. Marine engines tend to run cooler even at high load as the engine is constantly exchanging heat with the relatively cool river/sea water which will be more effective at removing heat than recirculating the same hot coolant in a loop through an air-cooled radiator. ...that might explain the lower flashpoint of the marine oil.
Was just about to say this. An unlimited supply of 40-80 degree water will keep an engine very cool even under full load conditions. It’s also why marinized car/truck engines often make more power in boats than in a car/truck. No heat issues.
For that reason people shouldn’t pay all that extra money for marine oil, regular oil will do the exact same job if not better, and that’s what I use in my mercruiser every season for the last 7 years without a problem, an engine is an engine no matter where you use it IMO
Not so sure it runs cooler, it still has a thermostat that controls the temperature. As long as the thermostat and water pump are working, there should never be overheating though. The closed loop of a automotive engine makes for more possibility of overheating though.
Hey Project Farm, hope you're having a great Sunday! Thanks for all the dedication you put in your videos and hope you receive due compensation for it 😁
I would like to propose two different items for comparison and testing. 1) Electric 1/4 sheet sanders. I just bought a $13 Walmart brand to get me by until I make sure of what I want; I was straight dewalt until I found this channel. 2) Although I have seen your oil comparisons, I have recently discovered a straight 30w synthetic oil for small 4 cycle engines and boasts that it can be used year around down to -30, branded Triax. Included in my last order was a booklet/brochure that boasts of very high anti wear and anti corrosive additives that are almost unbelievable. Including HST, gear, and automatic transmission fluids.
The thing is most marine engines run water cooling straight from the lake so they typically do not get very hot. They also rarely are run in the winter. They do take a pounding though, so the foaming test is important... as well as the friction.
Often their intakes get plugged with vegetation causing high temps and engine shut down. If radiatior is working properly on vehicle motors, their operating engine temps would be the same as marine motors as both have thermostats with similar operating temps.
@@CAN43725 But that is a maintenance issue. You could also have temp issues if your impellor starts to fail. I don't tend to think about that much because my dad was meticulous about proper maintenance, repairs, and winterizations on his boats over the years. I found it tedious myself and only had a boat for 3 years before selling it for more than I bought it for.
Lake? Is that Lake Pacific or Lake Atlantic? Saltwater boats (that want to last) don't use raw water cooling. And those are the ones using 'car motors' or bigger. (IB or IB/OB)
For the millionth time: best channel on YT. In light of all the grease vids, do a degreaser comparison with heavy hitters like Oileater, Zep, Krud, etc. And throw in some Dawn. We have to clean up our mess, right?
@@rico76 I personally use Oileater. Bought a 55g drum about 6 yrs ago that I'm still using. It's biodegradable. Can be used around food areas. Clear. Smells great. I can't say if it's expensive, or not because it's worth whatever I paid. It's that good! They have a dilution chart on their website. I was cleaning dill pipe and casing threads using a 10:1, and thought it could be cut a little more. Tractor Supply should still carry the gallons and bottles.
Would love to see a diesel oil shoot out including cheap stuff like super tech, conventional vs. synthetic and specialty oils for old trucks like power driven diesel (with zddp).
Agree. Delo 15w40 has been my go-to diesel oil for ages. I've bought hundreds of gallons of that stuff over the years.. No complaints, and it's super common at fuel docks, but would be interesting to see it relative to say Rotella or others.
I'd like to see a comparison between regular stabil and marine stabil. It seems like the marine is more concentrated and is cheaper per oz required but I don't know if you can use it in a regular vehicle.
I always viewed Stabil marine (blue) as a treatment to use when you can't get ethanol-free gas. I only use ethanol-free and have always used red. Would like to get confirmation on this too.
thank you, I really liked this episode, especially the sports-like commentation on the oil race, I was very much laughing. i have noticed over the past few episodes some sort of new easter eggs that are fun and funny, and I really like looking for them, you not only are properly helping us, but you are making it a good time, you deserve all the praise and respect there is, and I hope those videos will keep coming, since I already eagerly await every new one.
My RUclips queue is backed up so I'm a little late to getting around to this video but superb as always! Also, congrats on hitting 2 million subscribers! Well deserved :)
This is very interesting for an amateur mechanic like myself. I was told “Oil is oil, just throw it in there.” Your tests prove that is not the case. Thank you so much for this test.
the coffee pot burn off test showing how oils vaporize under heat is a perfect visual representation to show people that an engine doesnt necessarily have to be "burning" oil or a bad engine for oil levels to go down and why you should periodically check your oil... as always good stuff and thank you!
If an engine has spots hot enough to cook off a substantial amount of oil between changes its going to sludge up prety fast. Gm 3.6 and ford turbo 4 cyl are bad about cooking the oil off and destroying the engine. If you cange the oil at 3000 miles they last a long time but stretch that out to 5000-7000 like they recomend and they just sludge up before they hit 100000 miles.
Video Suggestion! Window tint, ceramic vs non, heat rejection values, and do certain brands really block as much light as they claim. Also those sun visors you put in your windshield. Worth it to get the weather tech or do the cheapo parts store foldable ones do just as good?
It's really amazing boat engines last like they do. I have a 350 that pushes a "dry weight" boat of 6600 pounds. Sustained RPM of 3200 to 4000 to stay on plane depending on load. Doesn't miss a beat. I was bummed you didn't use Mercury oil in your test but love the content.
As usual you've level-up again; I love how scientific your videos are. Thanks for making the oil race much more exciting to watch than it would have otherwise been. :)
So scientific that they duped everyone on here with a petroleum marine oil vs a synthetic automotive oil. They should have been straight here and compared synthetic marine oil with synthetic automotive oil.
Video idea suggestion: Mercury vs Yamaha marine oil breakdown. Yamaha almost exclusively uses 10W30 for all 4-stroke outboard application. Mercury, on the other hand, has a variety of viscosities, especially for their supercharged engines. The Mercury motors I work on and change fluids for have the darkest used oil, and have operating temperatures for fluids as high as 212°, well beyond the point oil regularly burns, would love to see a breakdown of what their special team of oil engineers have done to keep their engines running!
This was some great information. I'd love to see the test repeated against a high quality diesel oil like Rotella T6 as a test for use in a boat since that is a common marine oil substitute.
@@TheGuruStud rotella t6 5w40 still is a great motorcycle oil alternative. I find it to be superior to the original Kawasaki 10W 40 motorcycle oil I have used before in my 2018 Z650
Great EP :) I would not mind seeing you do a oil mixing test, mixing the best synthetics to see if they dilute or improve some properties, mixing the best with the worst too, and then making a super mix of all the oils and sending it off to a lab to see what the report shows, Keep up the good work.
I’m glad I bet on the Penzoil to win … I really enjoyed this episode and the thorough investigation and consideration of the many factors involved …and the Motor Oil Derby ….Touché…
Yet another great test Todd thank you! Been watching your channel for quite awhile now it’s amazing seeing how much it’s progressed and how the quality has not suffered one bit in fact it has gotten better. Thank you I always look forward to Sunday now.
I freaking love these oil tests!!! This is genuinely a question I've asked before why is marine oil so much more expensive than regular oil, is it really better?
This was a bad test, Honda petroleum based marine oil vs a full synthetic automotive oil. An apples to apples comparison would have been synthetic marine to synthetic automotive.
Dear Todd, every Sunday we are looking forward for your new video, great job as usually (i personally like more videos with tools). I would like to ask your educational background, for sure much be in technical field....
Video Suggestion: Best battery powered ratchet. Makita have released a 18V version and I'd love to see how that compares against the SnapOn, Milwaukee and also Makitas own 12v version.
I started putting Mobil 1 in a number of small outboards. Worked at least as well for me, a lot cheaper, oil lab tests looked good. I would like to see a showdown of consumer grade leaf blowers, particularly big box store backpack units. Great channel. Thanks.
You know what would be cool, a Transmission Fluid test, electric cars also use this oil, Tesla uses Dextron 6 in it's gearbox and the Front and Rear Drive Units.
And gear oils.
Very curious about this one, I drive a titan XD and everyone pushes amsoil for smoother shift, I tried it, seems a bit smoother but nothing to write home about. but I feel like amsoil is like the audiophiles, I can't tell you the difference but the guys that know what they are looking for do... So they say ha ha
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ArchCityCraftsman NO DISRESPECT Chase, Did you completely get ALL OF THE OLD TRANS. FLUID OUT before switching to Amsoil ? T.Y. SIR.
@@ArchCityCraftsmanA rougher shift preserves the life of the clutch material. If the shift is smoother that means the clutches are slipping a tiny bit more and the life of the transmission will be a little shorter.
Am I the only one who appreciates the commentary on the race of semi-frozen oils to victory? :D
Thanks for sharing!
Never heard oil performance be so exciting. I was on the edge of my seat!
no way man lol
I loved it
No I thought it was pretty good to
I would love to see a budget drill showdown.
Specifically, stores "House" brands. Wal-Mart's Hyper Tough, Target's Blue Ridge, Menard's Tool Shop, Harbor Freight's Drill Master, and maybe entry level Black and Decker because they can be found at lots of places.
For walmart I think it would be best to use the new hart tools, walmart has pushed them pretty hard. They're owned by the same conglomerate that owns milwaukee, ridgid, and ryobi. I wouldn't rely on them professionally, but they're actually decent for a DIY level.
@@doctordev97 Given that they are TTI products, I think that might be a bit unfair. I think a rebranded Ryobi drill would wipe the floor with those other brands.
I just love how much I learn from these episodes! Thanks, as always, for the effort you put into designing and carrying out these tests!
You are welcome!
This man is a modern day saint for the brilliant service he does for people in cutting through the marketing lies
Thanks!
Agreed!!
he really is and I genuinely look through his videos before a lot of purchases to see if he's tested it
He does a good job but let's not forget these videos bring in over a half a million dollars every year.
His sainthood is very much in question.
@@ProjectFarm it would be a little different, but you should test Wasp/hornet sprays. I never know what will work best, shoot furthest, foam most, and spray more
I'd be interested in seeing how normal car oil compares to motorcycle oil, especially since they usually don't add friction modifiers due to the wet clutches
Include the heavier motorcycle oils that were designed for dry clutch operation as well.
Thanks for the suggestion.
It's rubbish, lasts a few miles before its beaten to death. I once put castrol magna tec in a Honda cb1000 and rode for 300 miles running it in. When I drained it out after 1500miles it was like black water. The gearbox cuts the oil up apparently, that's why you have gearbox oil and engine oil.
@@ProjectFarm yea pls do,being In a country where everyone has a bike. I would really like to know.
Diesel vs motorcycle oil
This guy is so consistent someone should test the audio differences in all the times he said "and the cooked penzoil"
After watching and seeing the results, the reverse question might be - "Should boat owners upgrade to car oil?"
Honda won the important tests for marine engines
Agreed! That is the real question
Most boaters use car-oil. They know anything branded "marine" is just a ploy to charge more.
no. the big tests that are important here for marine oil specifically was the anti corrosion/rust and the anti wear at rpm.
Think about this, boats deal with much more moisture than any car will just due to operational environment. The corrosion resistance is important.
Additionally, boats don't have multiple transmission gears to reduce engine rpm in use.. and so over their useful life see a lot more high rpm. while at a constant speed the marine oil 'only' performed 3% better, the ** about that is when you look at the regular use cases, the marine oil with less wear will make a much larger difference in the long run.
@@SuperWaterskiboy You are correct. Specially if you use 2 stroke gasoline engine. I mix my own gasoline to my mariner, usually shell v power and around 2.5-3% marine oil. runs much better than regular 95.
The viscosity race was hilarious. I was literally on the edge of my seat. Best race yet.
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed!
But we must also remember you’re usually not running a marine engine at extremely cold temps. I’d like to see an ambient/ average day temp viscosity test.
With the new “WOKE” nascar….ill watch this instead!!
7:20 this was one of the most exciting oil races ever on the channel
It was intense for me! Thank you
I’m now a oil fanatic thanks to PF. Lmao
@@markm0000 The coming short film Fast Not Furious
You're the best thing to ever happen to RUclips. You deserve an award
Your cold oil race narration was worth the watch all by itself. Thanks so much for keeping us informed - both from a product perspective and that of education. If you were a shop teacher, you would have the student's attention for sure - especially if you would load them into the farmbago racer.
Thanks!
If I were a student I would have raised my hand and asked why are you comparing apples or oranges? They duped everyone on here with a petroleum Honda marine oil vs a synthetic automotive oil. They should have been straight here and compared apples to apples, a synthetic marine oil with synthetic automotive oil.
Hey Brother. I know this is a shot in the dark that you would ever read this. I can only imagine all of us. Your fans. Would love to have you make a video of the process you go through to film your videos. It blows us away how thorough you are. How scientific you are with all of your tests and contraptions. I would give anything to watch a behind-the-scenes video of how you do things.
Thanks for the suggestion!
Same so would I
@@TheRCBasher69420 seriously! Could you imagine him filming a video about who he is. His name. What he does for a living. How he thinks about how to do all of these tests. I think he is absolutely brilliant. And I wish we could know him a little bit better
@@brianstauffacher ikr I just want to know what he does whilst waiting to say for this test when he was switching the pots if oil round on the hob what was he doing in the meantime was he going on his phone or doing odd jobs around the shop and like you I too would love to know what he does
That's a great price for any full synthetic
Remember the good ol' days when the bearing test used to spray oil everywhere? lol
lol. The setup has improved a lot! Thank you!
@@ProjectFarm … I kept looking for the Slick 50 … if you’re old enough to remember the commercials.
That oil race was something else. They should have an oil race show on prime time TV.
Thanks!
Can’t wait until the channel gets big enough that this man can compare trucks with one another
Thanks! That would be fun!
Video suggestion: What brake parts cleaner brand works the best. Love your videos!
Great suggestion! Thanks
Yes chlorinated or non chlorinated
If found the farm and fleet brand to be the best if you don’t know it’s a farm supply store in the Midwest
@@Heck_off I love Blaine's Farm and Fleet or Mills Fleet Farm depending on what state you are in.
Brake clean: great for cleaning anything but brakes.
This brings back the memories of Sunday horse races with the uncle
Great times!! Thank you
@@ProjectFarm I love watching Oil and other Fluid races! You are a good caller!
@@PierreaSweedieCat Japanese game shows? 😂
@@arthurmorgan8966 No, just how it is done on Project Farm!
Wow I've been watching your channel sense it started 4 years ago, I feel like a proud dad lol
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm No, Thank you! I Love seeing all these products being put to the test. It really helps determine if the high dollar products are worth the extra money or are you just paying for the brand name. Also, what happened to the Farmabagoo? Is it still tearing down tree branches/limbs? lol
Test Idea
I'm a woodworker and I believe that you probably have many woodworkers subscribing to your channel. Blades for planers and jointers are expensive to replace and they don't last very long. There are several different options all the way up to a helical insert type. Many people have the dewalt dw735 planer. It's considered a bit of an industry standard. Power consumption is also a big concern for using a planer and blades contribute quite a bit to load. One last item would be to see if there is a way to sharpen these blades with a commercially available tool. Lots of guys make home made fixtures and use sandpaper. I haven't seen anything commercial to do that task.
Great channel. Probably my favorite channel of all. Extremely informative and very well done.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Oh dang! I’m not used to seeing only two things on the table.
lol. Great point!
Realizing that it took a lot of time to do this test,I believe that's the most I've learned in 10 minutes and 10 seconds, you have a really great channel, Thanks! 🇺🇸
Thanks!
Best channel on RUclips hands down! Thank you for the hard work you put into these videos!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Just awesome work Project Farm! What would you say has been the best oil so far
PF never disappoints!
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm If you are doing new Oil Testing. I'd love to see : Mobil 1 Extended Performance (non highmileage ) , Castrol Extended Performance against the Amsoil OE, XL & Signature Series Oils, and against Pennzoil Ultra Platinum & Royal Purple.
@@ProjectFarm so don't get me wrong, I loved the episode. But apples to apples, shouldn't it be say Honda auto oil vs Honda marine oil? It didn't surprise me that high a quality Pennzoil beat the Honda Marine. The Honda isn't synthetic, either. It DID do a better job at rust prevention. I don't know.......
There's nothing quite like Todd calling a cold oil race play by play. I'll watch his oil races over any other race any day
I was wondering if I had switched over to the Marble League 5 meter race. Felt like I was listening to Greg Woods.
Thank you very much!
@@Son_Of_Atreides I would love to hear Greg Woods commentating all of the "events" of one of these comparison videos, from the cold oil race to the endurance "heats" of the high temperature test.
the play by play of the oil race is what im here for
I like it when he reads out the list of benefi...challenges on the product labels.
Great timing! I was very fortunate to find the exact same Pennzoil motor oil at my local Walmart on clearance for $1.99 each quart. When I watch you do the flow test, I feel like I'm at a horse race. LOL Great video as always!
That's a fantastic deal
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm LMAO, I SIT HERE BY MYSELF & ME DAG OF COURSE, ROOTING LIKE AN IDIOT ( BY THE WAY ME DAG LOOKS AT ME ) FOR WHAT EVER OIL I WANT TO WIN. IT'S VERY EXCITING TOO ME ALSO, MAYBE I SHOULD GET OUT MORE ?
The ol "I'm going to watch Project Farm in the isle before I buy something" trick, seen it a million times
@@endutubecensorship Isle, Minnesota?!
Welcome to Mille Lacs! 😎✌🏼
I would love to see an episode based on everyday carry (EDC) pocket knives! Could cover edge retention, lock strength, handle durability, and ease of maintenance plus other stuff too. Brands like Case, Kershaw, Coldsteel, etc. Maybe throw in a kitchen knife as a control.
Thanks for the suggestion.
and Milwaukee!!!!
don't forget Buck
That's like asking why Islam is better than Christianity. (well duh, no brainer)
Can you do a video on the best mold killer? I realize this may take a while. You are are the only person I trust to this kind of study.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I need to go to rehab. I have been binge watching all of your content and neglecting my own projects.
5:28 For anybody wondering, -40c is functionally the same as -40f.
Yes, thank you
Yes, the only time both F and C are the same. Good point...captjack..
574.55 degrees Kelvin and Fahrenheit are the same temperature.
At -614.55 the Rankine and Celsius scales cross, but that is and impossible temperature because it is below absolute zero.
What will they think of next? 🤔
I might have an interesting one for you... Angle grinder steel cutting discs!
I work as a welder and it seems like there's a big difference in performance, like wear, stability, cutting speed, and so on
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm I second this suggestion! Would love to see some of the Harbor Freight cutting discs up against some of the top dollar 3M etc. on some thick tough steel.
I've also heard that the thin cutting discs are better, but maybe don't last as long?
Google 'project farm angle grinder disks' he's tested grinders, cutters, and flap disks
That viscosity test was cut together perfectly. You would make a great race announcer lol
Thank you!
I’ve never been so excited by commentary over the frozen oil samples race 🤣
Best video ever
Thanks so much!
Why do I get so excited when he says "we're gunna test that!"
Thanks!
Love to see a comparison between the old oil bath air filters vs paper filters. I read alot on the internet about how much better the paper is but I'm not so sure. Our old tractors all had oil bath and operated in severe dusty conditions and lasted many
, many years between rebuilds. Thanks. Your video's are the best!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Yeah, I'm not sure. I remember a high school shop teacher explained to the class how the oil bath filters worked and told us they would filter out smaller micron particles and were less restrictive. I totally agree with you that paper elements would have been plugged very quickly.
Yes and all air filters in general.
I love the narrated cooked/uncooked drag races. Too much fun AND very scientific!
Thanks!
PF is the GOLD STANDARD for testing products.
Thanks!
The oil race was so much more exciting than it should have been 🤣
Great results!
Thanks!
I will say that my Honda Bf75 4 stroke outboard doesn't run nearly as hot as an automobile engine which may explain the difference in the evaporative test. Most automobile engine coolant temperatures are going to be 195 Fahrenheit or above, even pushing my 20 foot pontoon in the summer and 80 degree water it's rare for me to see 160 degrees on the gauge even after running 5500 rpm for hours
Great point! Thank you
Very good information to add to this discussion!
With that being said I still would like to find a better marine oil then that Honda marine oil because that evap result didn't look good at all....
@@countryfamilyalways7280 I don't run that Honda oil, I believe the last change was quicksilver or Pennzoil marine, I was just saying that temperatures may be a small variable, still a poor showing from Honda OEM oil
@@kygunworks4982 I agree with you and I don't have a boat YET but am looking so appreciate your knowledge on the subject.
Yah there has to be better oil then that Honda with that result.
A automotive oil that comes to mind that might out do that Honda is Amsoil ZROD as it has high AW additives better then regular car oils, long lasting corrosion inhibitors, amsoil says about 2 years because people store classic cars so they made it that way and I'd bet it has better noack and or evap results then Honda oil.
But on a second thought I'd bet Pennzoils marine oil might have better results also idk...
You have to be the most thorough tester ever! I’d love to see you test Sweet Project Car’s magic oil blend (he has a video with a special concoction of like 4 different oils)!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Would love to see four stroke marine oil challenge… amsoil,yamalube, mercury/quicksilver,Suzuki, Honda, sierra.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Great test.
Marine engines tend to run cooler even at high load as the engine is constantly exchanging heat with the relatively cool river/sea water which will be more effective at removing heat than recirculating the same hot coolant in a loop through an air-cooled radiator.
...that might explain the lower flashpoint of the marine oil.
Was just about to say this. An unlimited supply of 40-80 degree water will keep an engine very cool even under full load conditions. It’s also why marinized car/truck engines often make more power in boats than in a car/truck. No heat issues.
For that reason people shouldn’t pay all that extra money for marine oil, regular oil will do the exact same job if not better, and that’s what I use in my mercruiser every season for the last 7 years without a problem, an engine is an engine no matter where you use it IMO
That's a good point when I run my motor in a trash can the water temp goes up to like 150f and it runs like ass
Not so sure it runs cooler, it still has a thermostat that controls the temperature. As long as the thermostat and water pump are working, there should never be overheating though. The closed loop of a automotive engine makes for more possibility of overheating though.
Thanks for the feedback.
Hey Project Farm, hope you're having a great Sunday! Thanks for all the dedication you put in your videos and hope you receive due compensation for it 😁
Thank you very much and I wish you a great Sunday too!
I would like to propose two different items for comparison and testing. 1) Electric 1/4 sheet sanders. I just bought a $13 Walmart brand to get me by until I make sure of what I want; I was straight dewalt until I found this channel.
2) Although I have seen your oil comparisons, I have recently discovered a straight 30w synthetic oil for small 4 cycle engines and boasts that it can be used year around down to -30, branded Triax. Included in my last order was a booklet/brochure that boasts of very high anti wear and anti corrosive additives that are almost unbelievable. Including HST, gear, and automatic transmission fluids.
Thanks for the suggestions!
Your improvised high RPM test is another stroke of genius. It's part of the charm that the channel has. Scientific testing on a modest budget.
Thanks!
The thing is most marine engines run water cooling straight from the lake so they typically do not get very hot. They also rarely are run in the winter. They do take a pounding though, so the foaming test is important... as well as the friction.
they do long high rpms and storage
Thanks for the feedback.
Often their intakes get plugged with vegetation causing high temps and engine shut down. If radiatior is working properly on vehicle motors, their operating engine temps would be the same as marine motors as both have thermostats with similar operating temps.
@@CAN43725 But that is a maintenance issue. You could also have temp issues if your impellor starts to fail. I don't tend to think about that much because my dad was meticulous about proper maintenance, repairs, and winterizations on his boats over the years. I found it tedious myself and only had a boat for 3 years before selling it for more than I bought it for.
Lake? Is that Lake Pacific or Lake Atlantic? Saltwater boats (that want to last) don't use raw water cooling. And those are the ones using 'car motors' or bigger. (IB or IB/OB)
For the millionth time: best channel on YT. In light of all the grease vids, do a degreaser comparison with heavy hitters like Oileater, Zep, Krud, etc. And throw in some Dawn. We have to clean up our mess, right?
Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.
I'd like to see this too! Are the more expensive cleaners really that much better?!
@@rico76 I personally use Oileater. Bought a 55g drum about 6 yrs ago that I'm still using. It's biodegradable. Can be used around food areas. Clear. Smells great. I can't say if it's expensive, or not because it's worth whatever I paid. It's that good! They have a dilution chart on their website. I was cleaning dill pipe and casing threads using a 10:1, and thought it could be cut a little more. Tractor Supply should still carry the gallons and bottles.
This guy is who I aspire to be , I mean I will never come close but a man has to have a goal . Best channel on RUclips!
Thanks! Thanks for the nice comment!
@@ProjectFarm you are very welcome , thank you for the excellent content!
Thank you for another excellent test. Two items I would like to see tests on: pruning shears and bug splash removal.
Great suggestions! Thank you.
Every time you do a cold oil flow test, you remind me of sports play-by-play commentator. You'll be good at it. Love it.
Thanks!
Would love to see a diesel oil shoot out including cheap stuff like super tech, conventional vs. synthetic and specialty oils for old trucks like power driven diesel (with zddp).
My old 92 Mercury Sable with the 3.8 V6 loved Rotella 15w40.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Agree. Delo 15w40 has been my go-to diesel oil for ages. I've bought hundreds of gallons of that stuff over the years.. No complaints, and it's super common at fuel docks, but would be interesting to see it relative to say Rotella or others.
I'd love this as well. Throw Shaffer's and rotella t6 in there too
@@RyanEvansrifi I believe he did a T4 vs T6 already
I don't buy anything these days without checking if PF has tested it first.....another excellent video.
Thanks!
Project Farm has the best comments section on RUclips on his videos, hands down!
Thanks!
I'd like to see a comparison between regular stabil and marine stabil. It seems like the marine is more concentrated and is cheaper per oz required but I don't know if you can use it in a regular vehicle.
Thank you for the video idea!
My friend use marine 2 stroke oil in his bike and he said that bike performed better
@@Islandwaterjet HHO project? 🤔
@@alfrescrow Not a great idea. Marine 2 stroke oil is designed for much lower operating temperatures.
I always viewed Stabil marine (blue) as a treatment to use when you can't get ethanol-free gas. I only use ethanol-free and have always used red. Would like to get confirmation on this too.
thank you, I really liked this episode, especially the sports-like commentation on the oil race, I was very much laughing.
i have noticed over the past few episodes some sort of new easter eggs that are fun and funny, and I really like looking for them, you not only are properly helping us, but you are making it a good time, you deserve all the praise and respect there is, and I hope those videos will keep coming, since I already eagerly await every new one.
Thanks, will do!
My RUclips queue is backed up so I'm a little late to getting around to this video but superb as always!
Also, congrats on hitting 2 million subscribers! Well deserved :)
Thanks so much! You are welcome!
This is very interesting for an amateur mechanic like myself. I was told “Oil is oil, just throw it in there.” Your tests prove that is not the case. Thank you so much for this test.
Thank you for the feedback!
Great job as always. And Blackstone does a great job, I've been using there data analysis for a decade on all my vehicles.
Thank you! I'm very impressed with Blackstone too
Beautiful and thorough test as always. Thanks Todd. Viscosity test had me sitting on the edge of my seat!
Thank you very much! It was probably them most intense race I've experienced yet
@@ProjectFarm You called the action like a pro! 🐎👍🏼🤣 (Definitely one for your "highlights reel!")
Hey Project Farm, what I would love to see is efficacy of different dishwashing liquids, particularly their de-greasing abilities.
Great suggestion! Thank you.
So glad I am not the only one who nerds out to this channel
Thanks for watching!
Would be interesting to do a showdown and comparison of oils designed for Diesel,gas,LPG seeing the difference in the oil qualities
the coffee pot burn off test showing how oils vaporize under heat is a perfect visual representation to show people that an engine doesnt necessarily have to be "burning" oil or a bad engine for oil levels to go down and why you should periodically check your oil... as always good stuff and thank you!
If an engine has spots hot enough to cook off a substantial amount of oil between changes its going to sludge up prety fast. Gm 3.6 and ford turbo 4 cyl are bad about cooking the oil off and destroying the engine. If you cange the oil at 3000 miles they last a long time but stretch that out to 5000-7000 like they recomend and they just sludge up before they hit 100000 miles.
You are welcome!
Could someone please explain the text on the screen at 3:36? I don’t get where the 200g came from.
Oh I think I get it. The difference must be the weight of the coffee pot.
I'm more interested in these videos than I was in Mythbusters. Keep up the awesome content!
Thanks for the feedback.
Another great video! Of course, at this point, I expect nothing less from your channel. Always looking forward to what will come next!
Thank you very much!
I was just thinking that we haven't seen an oil video in a while, and we get an oil video!
Testing oil is a lot of fun! Thank you!
Video Suggestion! Window tint, ceramic vs non, heat rejection values, and do certain brands really block as much light as they claim.
Also those sun visors you put in your windshield. Worth it to get the weather tech or do the cheapo parts store foldable ones do just as good?
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm I don't even care about window tints, but I'd watch that, avidly :-)
You can easilyfind how much heat a tint blocks through the products data sheets.
@@tsslaporte "We're gonna test that..."
It's really amazing boat engines last like they do. I have a 350 that pushes a "dry weight" boat of 6600 pounds. Sustained RPM of 3200 to 4000 to stay on plane depending on load. Doesn't miss a beat. I was bummed you didn't use Mercury oil in your test but love the content.
Thanks! Thanks for the constructive feedback.
As usual you've level-up again; I love how scientific your videos are. Thanks for making the oil race much more exciting to watch than it would have otherwise been. :)
You are welcome!
So scientific that they duped everyone on here with a petroleum marine oil vs a synthetic automotive oil. They should have been straight here and compared synthetic marine oil with synthetic automotive oil.
I do love the oil/fluid tests. Glad it's happened again
Thanks!
I’ve never heard of marine oil. This is going to be interesting, let’s get started. That was enjoyable. Thanks
You are welcome!
It is 15% more, like everything 'marine'.
@@eddiefoy3701 is that 15 or 50% more
I think a test of 5 gallon buckets would be really valuable! Thank you for all the work you do here.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Thanks for the reply! Keep up the good work!
Video idea suggestion: Mercury vs Yamaha marine oil breakdown. Yamaha almost exclusively uses 10W30 for all 4-stroke outboard application. Mercury, on the other hand, has a variety of viscosities, especially for their supercharged engines. The Mercury motors I work on and change fluids for have the darkest used oil, and have operating temperatures for fluids as high as 212°, well beyond the point oil regularly burns, would love to see a breakdown of what their special team of oil engineers have done to keep their engines running!
Wish u put high performance motorcycle oil in the test too
Great suggestion for a future video!
I agree
Woohoo! A new motor oil vid!
Keep up the amazing work!
How about a hacksaw showdown?
Great suggestion!
Another outstanding video test!! What will PF test next? “We’re gonna test that!”
Thank you!
Would love to see a round 2 of the oil tournament maybe with racing oils, different brands, or high mileage oil
Thanks for the suggestion.
Do a video on the different brands and styles "wipe on and such" of polyurethane for wood.
Thanks for the suggestion!
This was some great information. I'd love to see the test repeated against a high quality diesel oil like Rotella T6 as a test for use in a boat since that is a common marine oil substitute.
I’d also like to see a marine vs rotella. I have been using both.
Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.
Shell cut the additive package years ago.
@@TheGuruStud rotella t6 5w40 still is a great motorcycle oil alternative. I find it to be superior to the original Kawasaki 10W 40 motorcycle oil I have used before in my 2018 Z650
Amsoil marine diesel vs Rotella
Great EP :) I would not mind seeing you do a oil mixing test, mixing the best synthetics to see if they dilute or improve some properties, mixing the best with the worst too, and then making a super mix of all the oils and sending it off to a lab to see what the report shows, Keep up the good work.
The end was worth the watch! Not what I expected considering the additives the marine would need for the moisture issues.
Thanks!
Guy at the oil lab: "Oh my god, now what?"
made me lol
I’m glad I bet on the Penzoil to win … I really enjoyed this episode and the thorough investigation and consideration of the many factors involved …and the Motor Oil Derby ….Touché…
Thanks!
I love how simple the rigs are that you use.
Thanks!
If you want to know the difference between products this is the Channel u want to follow.
Thanks for the feedback.
Yet another great test Todd thank you! Been watching your channel for quite awhile now it’s amazing seeing how much it’s progressed and how the quality has not suffered one bit in fact it has gotten better.
Thank you I always look forward to Sunday now.
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
That cold new/cooked oil race had me on the edge of my seat 😂 great shoutcasting 👍🏽
Thanks!
Great work as always! I would love to see a test between Yamalube Marine Oil vs Pennzoil Ultra Platinum 5-30.
Please due a test comparing best air purifiers! Love what you do.
Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.
I freaking love these oil tests!!! This is genuinely a question I've asked before why is marine oil so much more expensive than regular oil, is it really better?
Thanks!
Probably just more expensive to make - less demand.
@@dudeguybro Good point.
This was a bad test, Honda petroleum based marine oil vs a full synthetic automotive oil. An apples to apples comparison would have been synthetic marine to synthetic automotive.
How many Marines drank this with crayons thinking it was a Marine energy drink.
....what
Who needs consumer reports when we have Project Farm.
Thanks for the nice comment.
I asked for this video for awhile. Thanks. I’d like to see more marine comparisons.
Dear Todd, every Sunday we are looking forward for your new video, great job as usually (i personally like more videos with tools). I would like to ask your educational background, for sure much be in technical field....
Video Suggestion: Best battery powered ratchet. Makita have released a 18V version and I'd love to see how that compares against the SnapOn, Milwaukee and also Makitas own 12v version.
Thank you for the video idea!
Torque Test Channel tests all of them
It’s pretty impressive how the oil race was put together. The different camera angles and the announcing. :)
Thanks!
I started putting Mobil 1 in a number of small outboards. Worked at least as well for me, a lot cheaper, oil lab tests looked good. I would like to see a showdown of consumer grade leaf blowers, particularly big box store backpack units. Great channel. Thanks.
Thanks for sharing! Thanks for the video idea.