Etienne Scott talks with Julia Hartley-Brewer | TalkTV | 19 April 2023 | Extinction Rebellion UK
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- Help XR mobilise and donate: chuffed.org/xr/uk
Extinction Rebellion UK: extinctionrebe...
Twitter: / xrebellionuk
Facebook: / xrebellionuk
Map of UK XR groups: map.extinction...
International: rebellion.global/
1. Tell The Truth
2. Act Now
3. Decide Together
#extinctionrebellion
#climatechange
#globalwarming
Those at the top are terrified of losing their profits from fossil fuel consumption. This presenter makes it very clear.
"Slavery is what made this country great! Why are you acting against it?"
In this woman’s lifetime 75% of the planet’s animals, 50% of forests and 50% of coral reefs have been destroyed, and the climate has warmed by 1C, yet she wants to carry on with the destruction. She doesn’t listen to his dialogue of eg. insulating houses 🙄 Evil person.
"People don't *want* an end to the fossil fuel era!" 🤦♂️ You won't make any sense of her. I'm convinced she doesn't even watch herself.
The ghoulish glee she gets when she wags her finger and "gets to" use a codescending voice, it's performative stupidity at its most cringe.
I pity people who cheer her on - "Yeh, get 'em, J!" All those idiots that want "clean water & air," "equitability," "government-accountability," "moderation," "foresight" and perhaps a chance at leaving the Earth somewhat 'as found,' for their kids... Yeah they're fucking terrorist nutjobs, them lot."
She's a lunatic. On the plus side, it gets better when you start ignoring her. I forgot she existed there for almost 6 months!
Now, to disinfect my eyes...
Agreed👍
That is NOT even close to what she said or believes!!!
If I had to explain media bias I would show this clip the vitriol and contempt behind every word uttered by the host.
I respect your patience sir.
I almost broke out in laughter watching this
' interview ' . She wasn't lying ! Because when fossil fuels are gone , the sponsors who's opinion she insinuates into the public mindstream ......... Will be gone . Then we won't have to listen to her strange presentations and insults possibly resulting from profound ignorance .
This IS the unraveling we are watching
And it is hilarious to see them squirm .
But who else will hire her ?
Julia doesn't understand the need to have clean air, she is completely irrational
LET HIM SPEAK. FFS!
Answer her question; "FFS"!!!
Julia makes the tragic assumption that you cant have a civilisation without fossil fuels. What about earlier civilisations that thrived without fossil fuels. This lady needs to get her blinkers off and wake up!
Julia said you can't do it by 17⁰⁰. She also states it would take time and even the proposed 2050 is not pragmatic. Listen!!!!
Thanks Etienne for your patience with this harridan woman.
Yes I voted this up for this humble and patient man
HYPOCRITES
HYPOCRITES
The interviewer seemed more interested in projecting her own view. Rather than being interested in the response and actually listening with any curiosity. Isn't the point of interviewing someone to listen to their views? It seemed she was trying to corral the interviewee to answer the question in a way that satisfies her preconceived idea of what the answer is. Personally, I find that very unskilled, inappropriate and highly unprofessional - she's talking over him much of the time - but that's just my view.
Totally agree! She just wanted to hear what she’s already decided…which seems not based on scientific fact but rather a back hander! Confirmation bias!
That thumbnail is amazing 😂
JHB is SO IGNORANT ITS PAINFUL!! 😵
She's not letting him talk. Every time he starts explaining anything, she starts talking over him. She's not interested in a discussion, not interesting in listening or understanding. She just wants to shut him up. I don't understand the point of inviting him on the show.
She asked him a question he skirts around... She is hosting a show that has a time crunch, this isn't the Tha k you speeches of the Oscar's. She begs him to answer the question and will come back to his message. SMFH
Julia you are living in self denial land
Would be nice to see an interview conducted with an open mind. 🤨😒
I truly wish that he spent his spurious funding educating people to all take responsibility to lower all emissions. Turn Up AC by a few⁰ Heating down⁰. Recycle but moreover choose a better packaged product. Use water better. For fux sake stop buying bottled water. Don't throw your unused medications down the toilet. In Europe we take them back to a pharmacist to be disposed of, here, the US, if you ask them to dispose of it, they look at one like u shat on the floor!!! Let's campaign for teaching the basics of taking better responsibility for protecting our planet in schools. Nothing extreme, Let's just all do our bit..... PULEEEEEEEESE!!!
What happens when reason means sensationalism. He's way out of his depth. She's absolutely brilliant at what she does and is well paid by corporations to do.
She says no civilisation without fossil fuels as if it was the substances themselves rather than the scientific development. Then she says that the same science behind climate modelling is nonsense 🤣🤣
It is very unfortunate that Julia is completely wrong and Etienne is right.
I don't think she understands how an interview works.
When she called the 1.5 degree warning rubbish, what are the sources you would’ve used?
Who would've used? I've scanned the transcript can't see where 1.5 is referred to.
@@BombusMonticola 10:28
@@Lowequay thanks. I work long late shifts...eyes half shut perhaps
I'm shocked by the views of this woman, we don't have much time left to turn things round.
Plenty of fossil fuels left just wring her out
I think she should have learned science in school instead of debating.
No matter how low I might be in my life at least I'm not her husband 😂
LOL!! I'm glad I'm not her husband either!!
Pointless to have someone on when you shout over them and don't have any kind of civil conversation. Noone is informed when you don't let your guest speak and give you the answers. The main person speaking here is Julia. Pointless woman.
This isn't an interview it's a blistering hostile attack by her and he is obviously unprepared or unsuitable to respond in a logical defense manner. Or possibly it's staged
what an awful woman
People Do want an end to the fossil fuel era, Julia. I think you are somewhat out of touch with reality or perhaps just living in a bubble.
shes such a vulture but i wish he had done research on renewables before coming on air, he should have been prepared for this vitrual. there are whole countries (portugal) & villages(bangladesh,solar) running on renewables with no fossil fuels
and lithium and sodium batteries are a thing dammnit
Julia understands the problem, but seems to be playing devil's advocate. I assume this benefits her somehow.
She is so stuck up.
Wow, has she listened to herself ! Has she any children....... I suppose you think save your country........ OMG listen to the science woman !!!
There's no doubt that fossil fuels have played a most significant role in our success, indeed one would argue, overly successful domination of this planet. But even after 30 years, since 92, and the recognition of the harm we are doing to the biosphere, we still acquire about 80-81% of our energy from coal, gas, and petrol. At current rates of use of petrol, about 100 million barrels PER DAY, we run out of all proven reserves in about 45 years...maybe sooner because consumption is increasing at 17% per decade. So we are screwed anyway even if models are incorrect in predicting crop destroying summer high temps 4-6 C higher than normal during the summer growth season. Unlikely that geneticists working on thermal reg genes in crops will be able to modify RUBISCO or other proteins to continue current yield outputs. Land use changes, rapid glacial melt, fires in Siberia, melting permafrost, and ocean changes are also catching up with us. Keep in mind, as we run out of fuel agric production will tank, because you need gas for Haber N fertilizer production. We are in overshoot! 8 billion humans, 1 billion pigs, nearly 1.5 billion cows, 50-60 billion chickens, and 1.5 billion cars, trucks, and motorcycles running trillions and trillions of miles per year! It is insane! Something rapidly must be done about it as we are using up our C budget at 1% per month. Millions will die in Europe, Asia, and Euroasia from heat and crop failure in the next year or two as the El Nino moves heat from the oceans to the atmosphere. No doubt we will see even more intense droughts, storms, storm surge, heat waves, and famine. In the coming decade or two the number of refugees will grow to 100s of millions as large parts of the earth become uninhabitable. We are headed for a WASTELAND! This is not quite yet a Scifi apocalypse but we are fast approaching it. WAKE UP ALREADY!
BULL 💩
Ach yer bollocks… 😂
@@IronBhoy You can't ignore reality. In the US wastelands already exist in regions of the country where resources have dried up. Financialization and globalization along with global trade is keeping the system afloat...but not for long. Russia's war and it's reduction to world oil markets of just 3% threw the commodities market into chaos. The volatility in the minerals market since 2005-2006 is an indicator that the system is near terminal. Consider that the true heating of the atmosphere from GHGs is about 2.3 C. Global avg temps are not this high obviously because of the global dimming from aerosol particulates which provide a cooling of about 0.9 C. When China and India finally get around to cleaning up their mess temps will rise. Last year Siberian tundra and taiga (boreal forests) fires were again extensive and extreme. This fall and summer an intensive El Nino will develop. On top of this the solar cycle is finally returning to normal levels of irradiance (these past 2 solar cycles have often been described as a solar minimum yet temps on earth increased). Given we observed exceptional drought in China during the rainy season, Germany, and midwest such that the Yangtze, Rhine, and Mississippi dried up during a La Nina it's a fair bet that we will see drought in China and Europe again. The US south will probably experience monumental innundations and some severe hurricanes. We will wait and see. But be assured that oil is a nonrenewable resource. So XR and Just Stop Oil will eventually see their demands materialize. At 100 million barrels per day we will run out or at least the price will get so high econ activity is severly depressed. Just Google the price of oil a few months before the Subprime Crash in US before 08 and 09. The same econ indicators are now appearing on the horizon again. WE ARE SCREWED! ONLY 20 YEARS LEFT OF THIS INDUSTRIAL MESS BEFORE COLLAPSE. GOOD LUCK!
ZzzzZzzZzzz The last three words spoke ro me deeply XXX
That was painful 😆
Julia the Puppet
Talk TV? Are you going on GB News next?
She also is pretty rude, ignoring him and checking her notes instead of listening to what her guest is saying. Perhaps she should have done a bit more research and she wouldn't sound so ignorant of alternative technologies. She should be sacked. A bit underwhelming really. Constant interruptions, speaking over Etienne all the time! Please go and read something other than a tabloid paper!
Oh dear. 1. Tell the truth. Yes our way of life will be dramatically be more difficult. Or we go extinct. Extinction rebellion!
Reminded me of that Monty Python sketch; But an argument isn't just saying, 'No it isn't'. Yes it is.
I know that XR have to do the rounds, but if there's any hair-shirt-ism going on here it's on the part of the XR guy putting himself through this. I suppose it shows that JHB starts from a position of an antagonist, there is nothing 'fair and balanced' about her 'journalism'. Maybe she gives some of her viewers a break by shouting at the television for them?
Brava, Julia! Scott was dissembling all over the place when asked straightforward questions.
MR Scott SIR is that a plastic pen in your right hand ???
I almost felt sorry him. Then I remembered what an absolute clown he is and continued laughing
WELL Said JAMES Gill everything has oil in it from the shoes on his feet to the shirt on his back HYPOCRITES THE JOB LOT OF THEM
Our human race with current means of energy and power has been compared to a teenager at the wheel. Now no offence to todays emerging youth in general, you are the care takers of this worlds tomorrow but the meaning is our human nature is currently tipping the gung-ho scale a bit (and then some collectively, and there's a few of us these days). And as fuel to the fire, I don't expect Hartly-Brewer and others to pipe down any time soon, it's their role to pipe up. But by way of the old saying 'you've made you bed now lie in it', lets look after ourselves and with an outlook for the future. Fundamentals like good rest is what we need, physically and psychologically, we need to pipe down, get some meaning recuperation as a species and listen up and wise up, as I've heard XR speakers say.
what on earth actually goes on at Oxford University.
It used to educate at a high level that required a atiff entrance exam etc, now the everyman, diversity brigade allowed a load of undeserving plebs to get in so that they can sit giggling and talking amongst themselves when highly educated people from around the oweld are willing to give their experience & time to address world issues!!!!
You aren't a rebellion. You are children of the state.
Just a little poem about another BIG problem.
Plastic, oh plastic, so versatile and cheap,
But its impact on the Earth is nothing to keep.
From bottles to bags, from straws to lids,
The world is drowning in a sea of synthetic grids.
The landfills overflow, the oceans are clogged,
Wildlife is dying, and their habitats are fogged.
Birds with their bellies full of colorful shreds,
Fish with their gills choked with tiny plastic threads.
The planet is suffering, the air is unclean,
The waters are tainted, and the soil is obscene.
And we, humans, are not immune to the harm,
As the toxins from plastics slowly spread like a swarm.
Perhaps cancer, infertility, allergies, and disease,
The list goes on, as we continue to please,
Our desire for convenience and ease,
At the cost of the planet and our own health decrees.
But it's not too late, we can still make a change,
By reducing, reusing, and properly managing our range.
Let's join hands and take a stand,
To protect our planet and safeguard our land.
Let's educate, inspire, and innovate,
To find sustainable solutions before it's too late.
For plastic, oh plastic, it's time to break free,
From the hold, it has on us, to let our planet breathe.
Regenerate response
Well said. Thank you ☯️
Why would you publish this on RUclips? How does this help you? To me it seems like she won every point. All Etienne had to offer were XR talking points aka the consequences of our past behaviour and how it gets worse if we don't stop. Sadly, Etienne faced someone with questions he couldn't answer, because he can't admit that an angry populous is a threat to those in positions of false and/or lawfully evil authority. Governments are full of people elected and hired by the elected to produce legislation, not to rule over debtslaves, and yet they turn into weasels when law and cultural enforcement try to hold them to account. Etienne knows this, but he's trying to manage the mob by focusing on the potential positives, which is a bias that warps his worldview. Climate change is not just a threat, it's a threat multiplier, compounding other problems. Julia should feel threatened, because the alternative is complacency. Above all, remember the precautionary principle: clever use of the scientific method may yet keep us alive for a bit longer, and doesn't require us to hope. It requires us to work through Hell and die trying, without hope, without witness, without reward (credit to Capaldi's Dr Who).
She didn't win any point because she came over as completely nuts!! Mad as a bag of spanners!!
But she's absolutely ridiculous.. she's a climate denying closed minded hateful person
Apologies to anyone who has replied with a comment that I can't see. At this time RUclips says there are two replies but I can only see one. :/
@@TheWalrusWasDanny Please be specific. The XR talking points are technically correct, but he doesn't answer her questions. Her points are also correct, in that if we stop burning fossil fuels we lose whatever heating-related comforts we currently have access to, wherever we are on Earth. Isn't that threat worth getting a little uppity about?
@@karlfuderer1350 i think the point is we are not moving in the right direction.. nobody is about to cut off the nations gas supply without putting alternatives in place first. Also she isn't getting uppity, she's gone doolally! She's a known climate denier.
JHB comes across as a fool here. But she does know what a woman is, unlike XR.
Etienne Scott made to look a complete bin lid on live TV and Radio