Yes , I don't know who they think they are, disrupting people's lives for something that doesn't even exist, the climate change is just everyday weather, how are they going to change that, they can't. These people need to get a proper job and do something meaningful with their life.
Stop giving them airtime , ignore , arrest , jail or very heavy fines should be the order , these people need to have consequences to there actions ???
Give them their own little island with all their windmills, solar panels and tidal generators. Wait 5 years. Then return to the island and give them a proper burial.
Yeah, that was a bit of a banana skin she laid out for herself there. These people are lamentably simple. The only thing that prevents them being afforded 'terrorist' status is that there have not yet been any high-profile deaths as a result of their actions but that could change at anytime and undoubtedly will. Legislation pertaining to how terrorists should be dealt with is very clear indeed.
Makes me laugh... The Weather Service can't get next week's weather correct.... Yet we're supposed to believe the rantings of a bunch of soap dodgers on what the Planets climate is going to be like in 20 years time???
Members have been jailed, including their co-founder. They also want as many arrests and jail sentences as possible in order to further their cause and force action
Having spent 44 years of my life in meteorology/climatology, I'm still trying to figure out what the expression 'the climate' means. There are many different climates on planet Earth.
Brilliant interview today Ian; she really struggled with any of your statements of truth, especially how she would continue with her professional career. Blinder!
Unless you yourself are about 4, four years is not a very long time. And geologically, it doesn't even register. She could hold it up for 100 years, and it would be no less accurate.
@@pablocortando1 I think my comment was based more on her gender. Reflecting some more, I find it really interesting that people who show compassion for others, for the future of our children are considered fruitloops. But given that Ian Collins was suggesting that our self-serving, tax evading PM was some kind of higher power with all the answers, I guess these kind of comments are not that surprising here.
@@MsGerardot have you made an appointment for your booster jab ? You seem to believe everything you are told by our governments , your worried about your childrens future? With you Believing climate change and allowing the restrictions placed on our lives in the guise of saving the planet will ensure a terrible future for your kids
@@Richard482hi Richard just for your information Donald Trump dropped out of the Paris accord because 30000 scientists from the USA, of which over 900 were PhD holders in there specific fields of scientific endeavour.
@@Richard482 the latest research from NOAH (NASA’s weather service) shows that over the last 8 years the global temperature has actually flatlined and is actually cooling - despite billions of tons of CO2 being released over that time framework
@@stuartwood5448 No it isn't cooling. 2016 was an exceptionally strong El Nino year which gave 2016 the top spot. 2020, 21 and 22 have been La Nina years. Now to account for these warming and cooling events, scientists look at decadal averages, and each decade is getting warmer than the last. However it looks like 2023 will be another strong El Nino year. Sea surface temperatures have just broken a new record.
An Olympic sailor,what are the boats made from surly not the same stuff as those wind turbine blades that can’t be recycled and takes toxic chemicals to produce?
Yes, they wouldn't last long once our feral youth picked up their scent. Our city centre is a virtual no go area for ordinary folk going about their every day business. Groups of this lot would get eaten alive.
Listen to yourself love. You've had that placard saying 'Running out of time' for 4 YEARS!! You say that people have been talking about the emergency for 30 Years!!! If you can talk about it for 30 years, it isn't a blinking emergency! I demand you be quiet now.
She shot herself in the foot.with her first sentence(we need to stop everything oil based).IDIOCRISY doesnt she know human race runs on oil based stuff .
I'm not sure interviewing a deluded fantasist is very useful, I suppose it does highlight how moronic they are but does anyone doubt that at this point?
What percentage of carbon is actually in our atmosphere and historically what was the figure ? Has the hole in the ozone layer self healed or does no one talk about this anymore. Please publish the addresses of the activist so we can inconvenience them when we feel like it . Obviously not on a Wednesday as they will all be accepting their social handouts .
@@joedennehy386 Exactly, what I don't understand is why the interviewers don't challenge the activists with these facts, make me wonder if they're all in on the climate con. It seems facts have no place in the debate and I find that seriously alarming, the whole agenda is rooted in brainwashing!
It's 2023... I remember the same arguments... EXACTLY the same arguments, being made in 1985, by a teacher in school.... THIS is the first generation that has fallen for the rhetoric... These people need a new word to describe their stupidity... Its like.. "that person is stupid.. Not just normal stupid... He's EXTINCTION REBELLION, stupid..."... That type of thing.. Its no surprise or coincidence that we also live in a time where the same people believe a man can be a woman...Logic and reason are replaced with hysteria and delusion.
How do you manage to ignore all the horrific and heartbreaking climate impacts destroying whole states and vast areas of whole Countries? Floods, storms, droughts, fires, heatwaves..
@@laurabaldwinoly2862 it's exactly the same argument made today as 40 yrs ago.... THIS is the first time anybody has fallen for it.... You cannot take any argument seriously.... When it's main advocate was a mentally ill 17 Yr old girl... Only a lunatic would listen to a 17 Yr old girl.. Let alone one with a recognised mental illness... Its abject stupidity on an entirely new level
I'm on the Green Party of England and Wales Executive Campaigns Committee and the Global Greens Climate Emergency Working Group. And locally I spent 3 years on my town council climate action working group and set up a local community group called Portland 4 the Planet through which I lead on plantings g 3000 trees, establishing a community allotment, planting pocket orchards, organised an eco fair and gave talks to schools, businesses, councils etc..
So we're to go all green generated electric and no fossil fuels ? Problem is all green energy is either intermittent or unpredictable and we have no means of storing it even if we could generate enough. Perhaps these people could for once, enlighten us all as to exactly we're going do this amazing transition along with the economic and social impact this will have. Anyone with half a brain will already know what that would be.
I like the "you [,the news presenter,] have a platform" bit in these interviews. They always go on to to say that they should use their platform to argue for what the activist wants; as if the job of everyone else is to amplify your own views.
No Violence? No distruption? I wonder if this will happen from Friday to Monday. Have you noticed when you listen to these people they don't stop talking and will not listen to what the other persons view is and what they say is parrot fashion.
If she is ill and hospitalised will she insist that any drugs /items / tubes / plastic or other equipment that uses oil products in their manufacture are not used to save her life? Including the ambulance to take her to hospital that uses fuel.
She said that they have been meeting and debating for 30 years, try 40 years and none of the predictions has come true, what does that tell you. These people are an example of not being disciplined as children and getting participation medals at school.
Shes clearly terriffied of the abnormal inflationalry events that mean filling up the pool will never cost the same again. Its causing her to hallucinate
There's a contradiction in what she claimed. How can several million people end up living in an area that is uninhabitable? If it's uninhabitable, no one can live there.
She forgets that privilege she has had she wants no one rise to have that, they can't get even if we as a country went back to huts snd horses nothing on this planet would change😢
We need to go to B and M, to get one of those, them, that plastic clocks on her wall. Hope I haven't mis gendered. To stress the point about oil production.
Everything that is oil based she says , isn’t that almost everything ? However she my describe the movement it still sounds like a cult to me ! Doesn’t she realise that pets will be on their hit list ? Although she is more civil than most of their spokespeople, she still has the same crazy eyes .
What do we replace the energy with that we use now , If we stop using cars , are we going back to living our whole lives in a village and never leaving it. How do we go shopping when there are no small shops in a village . I am perfectly happy to admit that the notion of constant economic growth cannot be sustained but what are these nutters going to replace it with ?
UK is bonkers!! They destroyed property and for what? There is no climate crisis but in fact we live on an ever changing planet!! My deepest sympathy to the people who will be hurt by these ignorant people!
Firstly; If nobody else / governments are going along with this then our small 2% of the problem is not going to change anything. Secondly; Can she also stop ranting. Thirdly; Our lives are in the hands of a divine creator. Only when He says will the end come.
Should Extinction Rebellion protesters that are arrested face jail time?
you should ask them how they are going to select the people on these citizen assemblies , sounds like a coup to me , a commie coup
100%
They should be treated like a terrorist network and get long prison sentences
Yes , I don't know who they think they are, disrupting people's lives for something that doesn't even exist, the climate change is just everyday weather, how are they going to change that, they can't.
These people need to get a proper job and do something meaningful with their life.
Give them life
Never see them protesting in China?!? I wonder why?
Or India or Russia or Brazil or Iran
Let's raise the airfares for them
personally I would love to see them protesting in China
Well they wouldn't get on a plane. When looking at GDP, China is 39th on the list of highest CO2 emitters.
@@Richard482 China's carbon dioxide emissions are much higher than the UK's per capita.
No point debating cult members,they're quite mad and only here to be laughed at 😂😂
Very true, that’s exactly what they are-a cult, brainwashed by the internet
Or arrested.
Laughed at in jail
They're all just so obtuse and incorrigible. But fun to laugh at, all the same.
can you imagine a tea party at her house... i would k!ll myself.
Stop giving them airtime , ignore , arrest , jail or very heavy fines should be the order , these people need to have consequences to there actions ???
👏👏👏
@@christiano8088 spot on. Common sense 👏 👌
"We need to stop everything that's oil based"
Fair enough sweetheart, when you end up in hospital, there will be no equipment or drugs to heal you.
She can right now, sell hose, live in cave or outside, take cloths off. Simply back to medival age :)
You can hear the uncontrolled hysteria in her voice
This isnt about the climate - its all about their own neurosis.
Correct
Yeah, climate change doesn't exist. Its just normal weather
These people are truly insane. And so are we for indulging this idiocy
Give them their own little island with all their windmills, solar panels and tidal generators. Wait 5 years. Then return to the island and give them a proper burial.
Perhaps some old school policing and turn the cameras off😂
She held up her 'running out of time' sign and with no irony at all, told us she's had it for four years.
You couldn't make that up
And she'llstill be holding that sign up in 10 yrs time.
Yeah, that was a bit of a banana skin she laid out for herself there. These people are lamentably simple. The only thing that prevents them being afforded 'terrorist' status is that there have not yet been any high-profile deaths as a result of their actions but that could change at anytime and undoubtedly will.
Legislation pertaining to how terrorists should be dealt with is very clear indeed.
Ha ha😂
I've had mine for nearly 50 years
Imagine the stench when 30,000 of them come together. That's the real extinction event.
You mean Ex Stink tion....
Made me tittered. Also veggie farts stink to high heaven.
Greatest challenge will be getting them out of bed in time.
Haha, too posh to wash..
@jonsteadisno1 half of them are in the 70s they'll be out of bed at 4am sharpish 😂
Makes me laugh... The Weather Service can't get next week's weather correct.... Yet we're supposed to believe the rantings of a bunch of soap dodgers on what the Planets climate is going to be like in 20 years time???
Has she spoken to the scientists who don’t agree with her view point?
Few and far between. What were the conclusions of the latest IPCC report?
@@Richard482 Science doesn't work on consensus - it works on evidence.
@@Richard482 science isn’t democratic. It is based on provable hypothesis and evidence. 99 can agree and 1 can disagree and be correct
Don't be silly!
A group can get away with things a single person would be charged for and jailed if they continued
Or sectioned for
Members have been jailed, including their co-founder. They also want as many arrests and jail sentences as possible in order to further their cause and force action
Which council estate was she brought up on? She doesn't know what it's like to grow up in a family having to struggle.
The IPCC have also said that it is impossible to forecast how the climate will change. The report uses 'could' and 'may' not 'will'
ACCORDING TO THE COMPUTER MODELLING
@@MrDrbld absolutely, not one of their computer model predictions has come true yet...
Having spent 44 years of my life in meteorology/climatology, I'm still trying to figure out what the expression 'the climate' means. There are many different climates on planet Earth.
@MrDrbld their modelling is atrocious. I watched a documentary about it once and its.. college grade at best.
@@czhaok Absolutely. Not real world evidence but computer muddling. See Climate Models and Climate Muddles report Eschenbach-Climate-Models.pdf
Brilliant interview today Ian; she really struggled with any of your statements of truth, especially how she would continue with her professional career. Blinder!
Yeah, silly lady. Climate change isn't real, it's just normal weather
I've met a few, most are trust fund kids, wish you'd asked what they do for a living
The police should arrest anyone breaking the law. Her sign that says we are running out of time, is four years old. Priceless
Unless you yourself are about 4, four years is not a very long time. And geologically, it doesn't even register. She could hold it up for 100 years, and it would be no less accurate.
If mr Collins doesn’t stop winding this fruit loop up,we’re going to have to get her sectioned earlier than expected.
So an educated woman is a fruitloop. Would you hold the same opinion if she were male?
@@MsGerardot Education doesn’t Barr you from the fruit loop Society,as you well know.
@@pablocortando1 I think my comment was based more on her gender. Reflecting some more, I find it really interesting that people who show compassion for others, for the future of our children are considered fruitloops. But given that Ian Collins was suggesting that our self-serving, tax evading PM was some kind of higher power with all the answers, I guess these kind of comments are not that surprising here.
@@MsGerardot gender knows no limit in the fruit loop fraternity.
@@MsGerardot have you made an appointment for your booster jab ? You seem to believe everything you are told by our governments , your worried about your childrens future? With you Believing climate change and allowing the restrictions placed on our lives in the guise of saving the planet will ensure a terrible future for your kids
has anyone noticed people in this group are either middle-class people or students....no one who has a job
Can they speak to the 1300 scientists who have written an open letter saying there is no climate emergency??
How many climate scientists or those in related fields in that list?
@@Richard482 1300.
@@Richard482hi Richard just for your information Donald Trump dropped out of the Paris accord because 30000 scientists from the USA, of which over 900 were PhD holders in there specific fields of scientific endeavour.
I’d love to go Monday, but I’m afraid I gotta go to work to earn a living.
Same here.
🤣🤣🤣
Here’s my placard which says “we are running out of time” she’s had the placard for 4 years- that’s tells me enough
We’re still running
Well doubling CO2 emissions from pre-industrial levels will take us back to the Pliocene.
@@Richard482 the latest research from NOAH (NASA’s weather service) shows that over the last 8 years the global temperature has actually flatlined and is actually cooling - despite billions of tons of CO2 being released over that time framework
@@stuartwood5448 No it isn't cooling. 2016 was an exceptionally strong El Nino year which gave 2016 the top spot. 2020, 21 and 22 have been La Nina years. Now to account for these warming and cooling events, scientists look at decadal averages, and each decade is getting warmer than the last. However it looks like 2023 will be another strong El Nino year. Sea surface temperatures have just broken a new record.
@@Richard482 I’m just following the science!
An Olympic sailor,what are the boats made from surly not the same stuff as those wind turbine blades that can’t be recycled and takes toxic chemicals to produce?
al gore has extended the date again, must be about 4 or 5 times he has extended the day the world will end
200 groups protesting for four days. When do these people actually do a full day's work.??
I remember being told at school 30+ years ago the ozone layer would collapse and we would all burn to death…
And Seven Suzuki was the Greta Thunberg of her day : who remembers her ?
Can't wait for this lot to travel up north 👊
Yes, they wouldn't last long once our feral youth picked up their scent. Our city centre is a virtual no go area for ordinary folk going about their every day business.
Groups of this lot would get eaten alive.
@@dilltdog1158 I'm in my mid 60s now. it would brighten my day up dragging the bastards out the road 😂👍
She looks like a mummy and daddy said I can do whatever I want type
In the 1960s, I am that old, we were told that 2000 the planet would uninhabitable. At school we practiced making igloos.
Listen to yourself love. You've had that placard saying 'Running out of time' for 4 YEARS!! You say that people have been talking about the emergency for 30 Years!!! If you can talk about it for 30 years, it isn't a blinking emergency! I demand you be quiet now.
Oh no! No more trains or buses for me then as a train or bus interior is mostly made from plastic (which is made from oil)!
Well to do - with nothing to do.
Just shouts over everyone like all the rest of them. No dialogue ever.
Can we talk to the many scientists who disagree with climate alarmism
She shot herself in the foot.with her first sentence(we need to stop everything oil based).IDIOCRISY doesnt she know human race runs on oil based stuff .
This is such an emergency that nothing has changed in the 4 YEARS that she's had that same placard. Put your tin hat away love!!!
They used to walk about with placards saying the end is nigh, now our goverment is in on it.
All the main parties are, including Reform
What a crap presentation of her flimsy case. The United Nations have been having meetings for 30 years on this? The cost of living crisis?
Bring back stocks for these fools
I'm not sure interviewing a deluded fantasist is very useful, I suppose it does highlight how moronic they are but does anyone doubt that at this point?
What percentage of carbon is actually in our atmosphere and historically what was the figure ?
Has the hole in the ozone layer self healed or does no one talk about this anymore.
Please publish the addresses of the activist so we can inconvenience them when we feel like it .
Obviously not on a Wednesday as they will all be accepting their social handouts .
The current levels of CO2 are 0.04%, less than 0.02% and the plants die, FACT. Zero emissions will kill all plant life and destroy food production.
The percentage of our atmosphere of co2 is 0.04%. Mankind's contribution to that 0.04% is 4%. 4% of 0.04% is vanishingly small
@@joedennehy386 Exactly, what I don't understand is why the interviewers don't challenge the activists with these facts, make me wonder if they're all in on the climate con. It seems facts have no place in the debate and I find that seriously alarming, the whole agenda is rooted in brainwashing!
@@joedennehy386 So how did we increase CO2 contractions from 280ppm to 420ppm? You're argument is flawed.
Please don’t tell her that what she believes is bullshit. She’ll get hysterical like an 6 year old being told Father Christmas doesn’t exist.
It's 2023... I remember the same arguments... EXACTLY the same arguments, being made in 1985, by a teacher in school.... THIS is the first generation that has fallen for the rhetoric... These people need a new word to describe their stupidity... Its like.. "that person is stupid.. Not just normal stupid... He's EXTINCTION REBELLION, stupid..."... That type of thing.. Its no surprise or coincidence that we also live in a time where the same people believe a man can be a woman...Logic and reason are replaced with hysteria and delusion.
How do you manage to ignore all the horrific and heartbreaking climate impacts destroying whole states and vast areas of whole Countries? Floods, storms, droughts, fires, heatwaves..
@@laurabaldwinoly2862 it's exactly the same argument made today as 40 yrs ago.... THIS is the first time anybody has fallen for it.... You cannot take any argument seriously.... When it's main advocate was a mentally ill 17 Yr old girl... Only a lunatic would listen to a 17 Yr old girl.. Let alone one with a recognised mental illness... Its abject stupidity on an entirely new level
Its life Jim but not as we know it
'all voices' except the millions that know she is wrong eh?
Cranks!!!!.
Not meaning to be rude…. She is Bonkers 🤦♀️
Away with the faries
I'll lend them my voice. But it'll be for legislation to bring back 2 stroke motorcycles. What a sweet smell.
Carbon is life
FACT. OIL IS NOT A FOSSIL FUEL.
Stand for parliament if you think you have the right ideas
I'm on the Green Party of England and Wales Executive Campaigns Committee and the Global Greens Climate Emergency Working Group. And locally I spent 3 years on my town council climate action working group and set up a local community group called Portland 4 the Planet through which I lead on plantings g 3000 trees, establishing a community allotment, planting pocket orchards, organised an eco fair and gave talks to schools, businesses, councils etc..
I've yet to see a realistic, actionable plan to make this happen, but understand it's because it's not realistic.
They do have a plan when you ask them its Marxism.
Even if they said this and the goal was the year 2100 I'd say its hit and miss.
These people are beginning to bore me!!!!
So we're to go all green generated electric and no fossil fuels ? Problem is all green energy is either intermittent or unpredictable and we have no means of storing it even if we could generate enough. Perhaps these people could for once, enlighten us all as to exactly we're going do this amazing transition along with the economic and social impact this will have. Anyone with half a brain will already know what that would be.
I like the "you [,the news presenter,] have a platform" bit in these interviews. They always go on to to say that they should use their platform to argue for what the activist wants; as if the job of everyone else is to amplify your own views.
What happened to three years to save the planet ? - now it’s decades
No Violence? No distruption? I wonder if this will happen from Friday to Monday. Have you noticed when you listen to these people they don't stop talking and will not listen to what the other persons view is and what they say is parrot fashion.
The scientist’s 😂 made me spit my coffee out
Man, remember when Doomsday cults would just shave their heads and drink poisoned Kool-Aid? They were better times. I miss those times
She’s Lying through her back teeth
KNITS ALL HER OWN NOODLES
Noodle knitting, using interpretive dance, in a neoclassical style is what she hopes to study at Uselessity.
0.04 percent of Co2 in atmosphere really life ending !
No
@@blah329 Finally a light of truth in the darkness. I've been telling people this for years!!!!!!
If she is ill and hospitalised will she insist that any drugs /items / tubes / plastic or other equipment that uses oil products in their manufacture are not used to save her life? Including the ambulance to take her to hospital that uses fuel.
We’ve had screaming rich Olympiads rowers,sailors some of the most unproductive people on our lovely planet
Moaning about nothing 😂😂😂😂
She said that they have been meeting and debating for 30 years, try 40 years and none of the predictions has come true, what does that tell you. These people are an example of not being disciplined as children and getting participation medals at school.
Stop giving them so much bl00dy air time 😡
Why on gods green earth would I ask a nurse or a doctor about the climate crisis ( that doesn't exist) 😂
Always the same,so many years before it all ends,sadly this retric has been doing the rounds for decades.
Death cult
The fact she held that up with the words 'running out of time' on it and says shes had it for 4 years was hilarious. Well i thought so anyway
These people are a serious threat to our future.
They are in for a long walk to London are they not?
Shes clearly terriffied of the abnormal inflationalry events that mean filling up the pool will never cost the same again. Its causing her to hallucinate
There's a contradiction in what she claimed. How can several million people end up living in an area that is uninhabitable? If it's uninhabitable, no one can live there.
Tell other countries we only create 2% of global emissions what viable alternatives do we have
Even her clock is not right . So sad for these people .
What should happen is people should find out where these protesters live and go round and disrupt their everyday lives
First it was zero emissions by 2000, then it was 2020, then 2030, then 2035, now it's 2050... I don't think I can endure these people until 2050.
They should be put on show and mocked.
These bullies need a dose of reality.
She forgets that privilege she has had she wants no one rise to have that, they can't get even if we as a country went back to huts snd horses nothing on this planet would change😢
We need to go to B and M, to get one of those, them, that plastic clocks on her wall. Hope I haven't mis gendered. To stress the point about oil production.
Everything that is oil based she says , isn’t that almost everything ? However she my describe the movement it still sounds like a cult to me ! Doesn’t she realise that pets will be on their hit list ? Although she is more civil than most of their spokespeople, she still has the same crazy eyes .
Sorry maybe a daft question? What is the difference between a protestor and a demonstrator?
What do we replace the energy with that we use now ,
If we stop using cars , are we going back to living our whole lives in a village and never leaving it.
How do we go shopping when there are no small shops in a village .
I am perfectly happy to admit that the notion of constant economic growth cannot be sustained but what are these nutters going to replace it with ?
She will decide who is in the citizens' assembly. She won't want common folk in the assembly.
The tipping point date keeps changing😂😂😂😂😂
UK is bonkers!! They destroyed property and for what? There is no climate crisis but in fact we live on an ever changing planet!! My deepest sympathy to the people who will be hurt by these ignorant people!
Doesn't she realise this is all part of the WEF playbook ?
Are they revolting in China and Russia? This shows who directs them.
''We need to get to zero not net-zero''? Sorry, are these people absolutely stark-raving mad?
Firstly; If nobody else / governments are going along with this then our small 2% of the problem is not going to change anything.
Secondly; Can she also stop ranting.
Thirdly; Our lives are in the hands of a divine creator. Only when He says will the end come.
bored middle class sauvignon socialist
Always climate, never weather.
Wait till she finds out water vapour is a green house gass 😂😂
If she gets her way her friends will destroy her dog as it is terrible for her carbon footprint. I wonder what she thinks of that.
Getting all these climate disinformation Woketards in one place at the same time is just too good an opportunity to miss.😂