What I learned from this trial is that it’s okay for Amber and all her friends to do drugs and drink… paid for by Johnny whilst living in his penthouses for free yet he’s the devil for doing them.
Yeah, such a monster that they had to hang out and party til the drugs ran out. He might be no saint but having to put up with all her hangers on and then her haranguing him and everyone pointing the finger at him, the whole thing was so toxic. Oh Johnny is sooo badddd, pass me the crack pipe pleazzz
4 years ago I had 2 officemates as a couple and we learned that the guy in the relationship had temper issues but it only triggers when he is stressed in a relationship. Later, the guy became destructive where he would destroy things but doesnt hurt his partner. Making the story short, they broke up. Now, my friend, a girl, has been courted by this guy.. so me as a friend, at first, was being protective and told my friend to watchout for this guy since he has a history of being destructive and has temper issues. (As a friend, we advice our friends to avoid danger). She know the consequences and allowed the guy to be her boyfriend.. as of this writing, they are still together and there was no quarrel that led the guy to be stressed nor break stuff. On AH's case. It was different.. her friends didn't even bother to ask to stay away from JD. Instead, they had parties 🤷
Not it's not. Almost everyone hates her. The world turns against her. And most of the people are justifying his behaviors. Not hers. You should know that. Even some personality disorders " experts". People talking about things that until today only they, both J & A know. People who hates her love to see her weakness exposed but when is time to expose J then they argue others are thinking its ok what she do and not what he do. Who in this world, in a trial like this should be the only exposed ? Why? It'll be unfair. Look, there's some kind of people that don't care what he did, they just hate her. While her weakness was showing up there oh! wow! that evil women but when its J's turn to be exposed: oh its ok for her but not for him. I ask you: who said anything of this is good on both sides? Who? Not even the professional teams here.
Who is their next witness, Johnny’s kindergarten teacher that once witnessed him kick another kid in the playground?! They’re really scraping the barrel now and it’s getting embarrassing.
I love how all the ‘friends’ thought it acceptable to hang around, spend his money, use his drugs and booze for quite some time. Yet it’s suddenly now terrible that he did these things. They are all parasites and should be ashamed of themselves.
You spend a week alone with him and only his employees around. Or send your daughter or sister or mother. While hes on a drug and alcohol binge. And if you would happily be willing to do that with no hesitation. Then i suppose good for you. I would not. And thats what it comes down to for me. I cant defend something or someone that i know i wouldnt want myself to be in or a family member.
“Tossed” a bottle in her and many others’ general direction, in a hotel room fight happening between him and another dude. In the 90’s. This is their evidence of him being a DV abuser?
He tossed the bottle WHILE filming "Fear and Loathing in las Vegas" Johnny is a method actor, he has to be in character all the time even on his free time. ✌😁
I’ve thrown and broken numerous things. Ive yelled and called names. But I’m not an abuser. All of these things have shown nothing but stupidity on Ambers part.
Ellen barkin: he tossed a wine bottle in a tantrum 30 years ago once. No one was hurt and I don't remember who was there because we were all wasted. Also Ellen barkin: we slept together for 3 months and he suddenly stopped calling me then. And now I'm here 30 years later as a credible impartial witness!
@Mrs M yeah, 30 years ago. This woman's testimony does not provide a pattern of behaviour. All it does is show how bitter this woman is after a 3 month fling 30 freaking years ago. Be gone with you, Bot.
@@hallio111 Right...because people are incapable of change 🙄 Give me a break 🙄 You are aware that RDJ had issues with addiction? How tf do you explain his success today? Just because somebody is an addict doesn't make them abusive. Nice try, though 👏👏👏
People really don’t know how subpoenas work. If you are served with a subpoena you have to testify. If you refuse to testify, you will be fined and arrested for contempt of court.
You are partially right - that CAN happen, but it isn't guaranteed to happen. Amber's publicist was able to avoid the subpoena and nothing ever came of it.
@@playtone229 oh I know. I refused one myself and told the DA good luck finding me after he called threatening me but it’s still a risk and technically what always happens lol except sometimes they’re too lazy to follow through with the threats or enforcement.
Ellen Barkin : Johnny Depp threw a wine bottle across a room because he was arguing with some guy. The bottle did not hit her or anyone else. DE-SPA-RATION at this point for the defence team
I don't think none of us read CNN, but cnn and legacy media are trying to say he did **** her. Now they are a bunch of lying fak3 news propogand4 shill5 . CNN and Vogue .... fak3 media that make North Korea look like a bastion of free speech compared to cnn.
So he tossed a bottle in room full of people, her included, out of sheer negligence and frustration, but it wasn’t directed at anyone in particular. This is pathetic, lmao.
@@Julia-ow4st No but I did watch the video at 2:53 on unlike you, lmao. I'm not reciting anything untrue, this is literally her account in the video. It's the clickbait title that got you.
So is it your view that it is appropriate to throw a wine bottle around the room. Really are you that blinded by Pirates of the Carribean or are you a wife beater yourself. He has a long history of it. Wake up to yourself
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what holding a grudge for 28 years does to you, simply because the guy didn't want a serious relationship with her. It's unbelievable how you can feel the pent-up hurt in her every word.
What relevance does testimony from somebody who slept with Johnny Depp for a few months over 30 years ago have? Why not bring in more recent partners to testify? Answer: because they'd all say that he was absolutely lovely and never violent. Barkin is the only one they could find who said he once threw a bottle - but not even seriously threw it.
They are lying they right away caused him by canceling shows and now they want to say that is what past behaviors and then why they did t fired him in the oast
I’m pretty sure his kindergarten teacher said he didn’t share blocks one day because he wanted his tower to be taller than anyone else’s. Can we get a sworn statement from her?
Yeah I know right. I think their next witness is his teacher Once when he was a child he stuck a chewing gum below a table should his lack of character. Also when he was a toddler he didn't want to eat the food given to him showing he was incapable of ingesting anything other than drugs.
@#JohnnyDeppIsARapist!! #JohnnyDeppesracista you are one of countless bot accounts posting the exact same comment everywhere. Ambers PR team is truly pathetic.
Her actual testimony was he "tossed the bottle" not AT her but in the same direction as she was....not meant for her, she said he was fighting with other people.
By tossing that bottle, he potentially put it out of the reach of those who were arguing. In my own home, I will toss certain things just to get them out of my way and with the intention of doing the right thing with it the next time I leave my recliner. Tossing that bottle could have been a simple repetition of Johnny’s habit in his own home. (Tossing things out of the way until Arnold Schwarzenegger’s maid shows up to clean . . who’s the next baby daddy?)
@@sharonsybrandt4455 Hahaha . . you’re right! I’m just having a little fun with considering very unimportant possibilities to add to the craziness that Johnny couldn’t get away from Amber as often as the evidence suggests he tried. I feel bad for wealthy guys who are seduced by needy women. It seems they should be wise from their wealth and popularity, and they probably are very wise except for the few dingalings who trip them up.
"Barkin knew about Perelman’s intensity, his tendency to be controlling, and his ugly past divorces, her friends say. But she had her own legendary temper, and in one interview she said she believed her fuse was quicker to light than his." Well well well...
Years after this incident, Johnny got her a role in “Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.” So again, another person who Johnny helped out and was good to who is now coming back to make some money. These people are being compensated for their time.
Good ppl always get 💩 on this is the justice in life… at this point I can’t even be sure he will get any favor from the jury if an old flame could come here and say this so many years later nothing is impossible and ppl aren’t fair. many women leave relationships that are truly awful and life threateningly abusive and they walk away never look back and don’t seek money or anything because there is always the thought I loved that person once I believed in them so why hurt them. Only bitter vengeful evil ppl seek any kind of revenge or even restitution of monies. Most humans let it go even the ones with scars on the inside and outside who can’t ever forget the things done to them. This woman is ridiculous really you even got involved in this and painted a bad light on someone so many years later who gave you their time and affection at some point in life. Wow just wow she also makes women look evil cold heartless and full of bile and vengeful feelings just as much as Amber does.
@@ohrthgil nah, it’s just a small percentage of people who are horrible like this. Amber seems to have an orbit of these people around her that she is paying, extorting, and using to try and win this.
How horrible is this ..going through your life it's 30 years ago. I am sure we have all done things and been in a bad place. None of this means he was an abuser ..
@@78alJ0vle Imagine throwing a bottle in the general direction of someone, by accident, during a fight, in a drunken state, *30 years ago,* and that going towards "solid evidence" in a defamation trial vs you and your (current) ex wife. I've never done it either but it's far fetched no matter how ya look at it or can relate.
@Mrs M Where have you been the whole trial? Him and Amber + all their friends were constantly doing drugs and drinking. Surely you didn't miss the bit where Amber's sister supposedly showed Johnny how to snort cocaine through a tampon shell? If he were so jealous he wouldn't have left and never spoken to her again after that. (Edit: "her" being the lady talking in the video.) There was obviously something else going on. You have your girlfriend and all her friends constantly gaslighting you and making you feel like everything is constantly your fault while you're the only one funding everything EVERYONE is doing; it's going to eventually hit you right in the mental. He got into a fight and tossed a bottle. Poor dude was probably lost and confused mentally, emotionally, and physically at that point. It actually sucks that the people closest to him only want to see his downfall. The people on her side will, of course, say what she is saying. If jealousy and malicious intent were Amber's opening words, jealousy and malicious intent will be her and her witnesses closing. There has been nothing said during the trial that even remotely proves Amber's innocence, and nothing that proves Johnny's malice.
@@78alJ0vle Throwing bottles does not make one an abuser. He's already admitted that he has previously used an immense amount of drugs, nobody's denying that, but it's a completely different step entirely to physically hurt someone else, even more so that you actually MEAN to hurt somebody, and by the by, this testimony was weak in proving intention to harm anyways. Also, to Mrs M, "he's the one" would seem to imply that there weren't two parties that may be acting on equal grounds. We've heard many occasions in which they were both toxic to each other. From what I've seen, there is no proof that he's hurt anybody at this time aside from a few questionable photos and equally questionable witnesses. No medical records? From when he "hit you so hard you lost count"? Where are the marks from his rings? No sign of injuries in terms of a concussion or anything similar? These questions are far too important to ignore.
Honestly, it didnt say much other than he can or has the capacity of being jealous which is.... nothing really. The case is about being violent within a relationship.
♦️♦️♦️♦️Ms. Barkin is at a stage in her life where she doesn't give a 💩 because she doesn't need Hollywood creeps. So she's free to speak her mind AND TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT WOMAN ABUSERS👍👍👍👏👏👏👏♦️♦️♦️♦️ PS: YOU'RE STILL A HOTTIE AND WAS HANDS DOWN THE SEXIEST WOMAN IN HOLLYWOOD.
They didn't date long. She was a fire cracker herself back in the day. A cougar then with a penchant for partying herself and quite sparky and full of combative fire. She's calm now she's alot older.. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I once got so upset because of something that happened at work that I threw a coke can and it accidentally went out my office door and rolled down the hall. Everyone thought it was hysterical. On the other hand, I'm still mortified. Let he who has never thrown an object in frustration cast the first stone.
@@MsCharlieTramp you have problems with being judgemental and thinking you know people and things you don’t actually know anything about. Stay humble ✌️
and watching her looking at her lawyer like see the same as what happened to me and her lawyer looking like oh god maybe this was not such a good idea to put her on.
Lol, how do you know? , it's just an assumption. She highly likely has a video of him shoving the bottle inside her she just waiting until the end of it, if all plans does not work she will go viral with huge evidence.
He BROKE it off with her, yet, he was jealous and wanted to control her. She is so full of it. Who does this after they dump you! No one. Yet, he was SO JEALOUS that she never heard from him again.
Right? That was amusing. She said he was so jealous and controlling and she implied he was cloying and naggy at the breakup. YET, he never once harassed her or even communicated with her post break up. Doesn't sound like a territorial or jealous man to me. Something is fishy
sounds sussed to me if he broke up with her why would he be jelous??? Lol 😂 I reckon Amber has something to do with this wouldn’t surprise me it’s a set up! Maybe payback because he left her.
This lady is to prove that JD has had a drug and alcohol problem for years. Jealous controlling and a hot head throwing things when angry. Even though Amber is no Angel what she says about his lifestyle has been that way for years. Affected every relationship as well as his career, that he can blame Noone for but himself!!!
Barkin is a pathetic witness. There’s too much she can’t seem to remember. If they were all partying how dependable is her memory from three decades ago?
He was jealous and controlling, yet he was the one that ended the relationship. And he threw a bottle while fighting with someone else and it didn't hit her. OK. That's the best they could find? Smh
And Ellen was the only honest one on that tape. . Johnny and Amber are both dishonest liars and were made for each other. Neither of them can let the other one go.. after all these years.
Do jealous and controlling people allow a bunch of freeloaders to live in their homes? Just doesn’t fit the profile. I’m not saying this guys any kind of angel, all that drinking and drugging is not a good thing, but it’s clear that he had a manner of handling conflict that was conflict avoidant, and to anyone who understands these types of personality disorders, that woman is a poster child…
I just read this. Wow. "Ellen Barkin had a very public and tortured divorce from one of her husband(s), Ron Perelman. He was EXTREMELY wealthy and she wanted it all. She was awarded $60,000,000.00. It was notorious and she was viewed negatively throughout the long divorce process. She’s had quite a few very public and very negative relationships." You never know who people are.
Heard's lawyer shouldn't have called her as a witness. They knew that the jury would think her testimony was irrelevant at best. Maybe she wanted her say after grinding her teeth for years, but Heard's lawyers did her a dirty by not explaining to her how this would come off.
@@TheWalf999 no she didn’t. There’s a witness who heard him say that he cut it off himself and a video tape. Oh and the dog pooped on the bed, said by another witness. Depp’s going to lose.
As you can see this woman has let herself go she is not glamorous or nice looking anymore and he probably dumped her that's why she has nothing nice to say about him she's gotten so old looking she should worry about herself and try to groom herself a little bit more she looks like she's about 85 years old
Ms. Barkin, left husband and wonderful actor, Gabriel Byrne, their two children, and the second act of her promising career in Hollywood, for a few all-nighters with Johnny Depp, who was at least 10 years younger than her, and she is bitter as if she is the victim here?!
You can tell she doesn't like talking against him like this though. Jealously isn't abnormal, excessive jealousy can ve attributed to low self esteem and lets be honest here, Amber was JUST as bad with her jealousy as he is.
Really? I think she's very openly sharing the violent behavior on Depp's part. It's disturbing how many people will turn a blind eye to some clearly erratic behavior because they want to dunk on Heard (who also has issues of her own)
Angry at times, controlling at times, jealous at times... these are words that describe MANY of us in relationships at times. Ok... great.... still nobody has ever accused Johnny of beating them. I have thrown an object at a wall before. If we are being honest - I am sure 75% or more of us have done something similar before. Under the influence of drugs or alcohol, people have done things they aren't proud of. THIS DOES NOT EQUATE TO BEATING YOUR WIFE REPEATEDLY. Amber Heard completely made up all of that.
@@Yanni75 She said he was jealous and controlling when they were together a lot. He also works, hangs out with friends, acts, does recreational activities, sleeps, eats, does other things....... so he's not that way all the time. She said they only hung out occasionally. Sometimes a couple times a week, sometimes weeks or months in between visits.... So, not all the time. And yes, jealousy is a very normal emotion and dynamic in relationships. It's normal to feel that way sometimes. We also don't know how it feels to be in a celebrity relationship. Controlling - he asked what she was doing, who she was with. WOW, how awful. Again....... these aren't the same as BEATING YOUR WIFE. Bye Laurel.
@@rewdskwid If you have never once thrown an object out of anger, then you're better than the rest of us. Most people have done that. Nobody said it's ok, but we all have behaved in a way that we aren't proud of at some point. If you're perfect, then congratulations. Most of us aren't.
Wow so a partner is not allowed to ask where the other partner was or what they were doing or who they were with without being accused of being jealous?
Even if they were - so WHAT? Jealousy is a common human emotion which the vast majority experience at least once in life! It DOESN'T mean the person is violent or abusive. I think the AH 'legal team' can be described by one phrase - "the missing link"!
5:08 Imagine being called "jealous" and "controlling" while asking where your date is going about so you won't have to worry about them... I Think caring was his biggest mistake.
Ok….so he was insecure in their relationship. However, he ain’t hit her or slap her or beat her up even while high. He threw a wine bottle in her general direction once during a fight with someone else. I can see why it should be mentioned, cause it happened but it still doesn’t explain why for all of his 58 years he has never actually laid hands on a woman….till Amber Heard….even while perhaps having a drug problem or an alcohol addiction. Interesting
♦️♦️♦️♦️Ms. Barkin is at a stage in her life where she doesn't give a 💩 because she doesn't need Hollywood creeps. So she's free to speak her mind AND TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT WOMAN ABUSERS👍👍👍👏👏👏👏♦️♦️♦️♦️ PS: YOU'RE STILL A HOTTIE AND WAS HANDS DOWN THE SEXIEST WOMAN IN HOLLYWOOD.
The fight was NOT between Johnny and Elen, instead with someone else. And the bottle was NOT tossed at her and the other, it was tossed across the room. No harm done, that simple.
But but but.... it went within the general vicinity of her personal (safe) space and so that counts as an 'extremely violent' act.... See, Amber Heard wasn't lying about her invisible non-swelling bruises... If Johnny can throw a bottle in the general vicinity of a woman then he is capable of anything....
@@chrisg8321 didn't you know? Any time a man is engaging in any type of toxic behaviour in the general vicinity of a woman, no matter the context or situation, or even if only someone else thinks she SHOULD feel uncomfortable around a certain act, it makes him a violent narcissist toxic misogynist abuser. /s
@@chrisg8321 well I guess we’ll never know how it happened exactly. She relied on some memory from 30ish years ago. IMO, this was a weak deposition and didn’t prove anything
@@SimplyJanemba The mislead is that it wasn’t thrown AT HER. If something is thrown in your direction, it could be 3 ft away. That doesn’t mean it was intended to hit you. I think it’s been absolutely proven that Johhny assaults doors , bottles, cabinets, and countertops when he gets wasted and loses his temper. So I’m still looking for irrefutable evidence of assault on a human.
What I know is that when I was with toxic people I surprised myself be nasty like them. When I am with normal people I act normal because I don’t need to justify everything all the time, argue over little things... Now I just choose better friends who respect me and it works perfect. I just live a calm and peaceful life.
So the bottle hit nobody… and since when is it a crime to be jealous and ask questions about where your partner got a scratch or think someone is being unfaithful? Next!
She sounds so bitter and frustrated.A lot of people are using drugs and alcohol, and not getting aggressive, and a lot of people are not using and getting aggressive. After hearing the audios with AmberT screaming and hysterically laughing, mocking and saying nonsense sentences, we can definitely say who's worse and needs a time out.
That’s exactly what i tell all Amber’s stans but it feels like you’re either talking to a wall or a 5 year old kid. Cocaine would be the last thing I saw someone become violent on tbh.
Ellen Barkin was very angered at Julia Roberts being chosen over her to play the prostitute in 'Pretty Woman' with Richard Gere. She stated Roberts was too fresh faced & didn't have a 'hooker' edgieness needed to play the roll. She was very bitter back then at being passed over. That's been her Hollywood trajectory.
She literally said he TOSSED a bottle across a room 25 to 30 years ago and this matters WHY again? Ellen wishes Depp had been jealous and controlling when in reality he hit it and quit it and she's still mad.
My kid once threw a water bottle in my direction...it didnt hit me but now that i think of it, he must be a wife beater too. Dang...who woulda guessed.
To all those saying she’s holding a grudge - Amber’s team subpoenaed her to testify. For all we know she hasn’t even thought about any of this stuff for the last 30 years. But Amber needs to scrape the bottom of the barrel for anything she can get.
@@panic_diver That’s not true at all. Of course you have to testify in court if the judge orders you, just like you have to tell the truth. Imagine if I got convicted of murder because my alibi just couldn’t be bothered to show up in court, or just didn’t like me. In the US the Fifth Amendment means you can’t be compelled to testify against yourself in a criminal case. Otherwise you have to.
Since they're bringin in Johnny's ex and Amber's friends to testify about Johnny's demeanor... I wonder why Johnny didn't ask Winona or Johnny's ex wife to come and testify what they said publicly in his defense.
@@brendafactor9307 So, giving evidence against someone is an attempt at publicity, is it? Using that logic, no famous or semi-famous person should ever be allowed to give evidence in a court of law. Right? You're SO smart !
@@kikihapexamendiosisaklepto7397 you make a valid point however one has to question her motivation in coming forward now after all these years. Maybe not fame or publicity but I hardly think it's out of principle or justice or out of due care.
Ambers lawyers : " now Ms Stinky Butt McPuttputt is it true that you witnessed Johnny Satan Depp doing cocaine out of a jar" Ms McPuttputt : "meow purr purr meow"
So they were all doing drugs and had struggles with addiction and had endless money to put towards whatever vices they wished...but Johnny is the bad guy for doing drugs and having struggles with addiction. Dude tossed a bottle across a room while drunk or high, apparently at no one. I've been to similar work parties with a bunch of buttoned-up accountants. Never ended up in a deposition over it, though.
No, that is not what they are arguing. The point here is whether Depp has a consistent behaviour of becoming aggressive and violent when drunk, and whether he has a jealous, controlling side. Nobody under the sun can deny that alcohol and drug usage are heavily correlated with paranoia and violence, as numerous assaults and murders will demonstrate. If they can go all the way back to 1990 to find examples of Depp being abusive (and Depp has been in trouble for assaulting people and trashing private property before), then this is highly damaging for Depp's case. He ought to look more worried. I have been a fan of his work for a long time, but if he loses this case, then that is that. He is a great actor, but he doesn't look like a great human being behind all the fame.
Absolutely, it’s not right, but it happens, and that’s life. Doesn’t makes someone a violent person, just someone who is angry. I’d rather they threw the bottle than hit it over my head..
One of the few comments that makes sense! I think Johnny Depp is an amazing actor, but the roles he plays are not real ! He isn’t Jack Sparrow people! He is an addicted human being that struggle with sobriety and is surrounded by enablers that wants him to believe that being on an island for few weeks is going to make him “normal “ again… is ridiculous!!!
@@Musicienne-DAB1995 Eres una vergüenza por decir esto....Estas juzgando a una persona que tenia una adicción. Pero no estas mirando realmente la pruebas,¿Lo estás haciendo? No te parece suficiente con tantas mentiras que dice Amber. Tan perfecto sos que te pones en un lugar inmaculado? Vergüenza me dan la gente como tú,que tienen todas las pruebas sin embargo siguen creyendo en lo que dice una cara bonita. Vos si que mereces que te lleven los Alien.
@@natasciaganau5581 Yo no soy Fan de Depp,pero fui una víctima de abusos. Y te puedo decir querida,que aca no se lo esta juzgando por tener adicciones. Y si yu crees que a una persona se lo puedo culpar simplemente por tener esta enfermedad de todo lo que se le acusa,se nota que tu vida no es muy bonita que digamos,las personas que se ponen el lugar de un juez siempre por lo general son las más amargadas del mundo. Ella también consumía,pero como es mujer tu y él otro no dicen nada? Ac nadie esta diciendo que él es un santo es una como tú y yo,y se merece tener la oportunidad de querer mejorar siempre,como lo hacemos todos los humanos. Aca lo ue se esta cuestionando es si él la violento y le hizo todo lo que ella dice ,pero que no tiene ninguna prueba solida, porque ningún testigo en realidad vio nada,todos dicen que solo lo escucharon por ella o que vieron los moretones ,que vamos a decir sinceros o lo voy hacer yo que sufri de puñetazos, jamás de los jamases ella pudo haber cubrir esas heridas y salir tan bien en esas fotos. Si le crees te invito que vayas con las verdaderas víctimas y les preguntes por eso ninguna le cree,bueno las que no se dejan llevar por el femenino.
Everyone can see that by having calling Barkin as a witness to testify, AH's team is really scraping the bottom of the barrel. Apparently, Barkin liked the "relationship" enough to keep going back for more. She doesn't even have AH's faux-victim "Because I loved him," statement to justify why she kept their "arrangement" going. Did JD's team not question Barkin?
they were very wise not to. 1) it made her look petty and foolish 2) It leaves them more time to question their rebuttal witnesses, whilst AH's lawyers wasted tons of time on all of today's useless witnesses.
But Barkin isn't saying the relationship was a bad one. She is just identifying that Depp had an alcohol, drug, and anger problem-- and I have not seen anyone who is able to deny that.
Johnny's already admitted that he has thrown things, never at anyone, but he's thrown them and taken his anger out on objects... that's a far cry from being abusive to a person.. I've been known to hit an object or two or of frustration..I think most of us have done this, not all. But most..
honestly when it's been that long, why would anyone want to testify? when you have zero connection with the relationship betweeen depp and heard or were not even around during amber-depp relationship, why would you accept to testify? unless it's against the law to refuse to testify
So, he threw a bottle decades ago when fighting with friends, not a significant other, and it didn't hurt or hit anyone. This is their evidence of him being a DV abuser? Even though his romantic partners after this relationship came out and defended him?
Who hasn't done something terrible 30 yrs ago? As part of an immature stage of growing up?! Ellen, you are a fallen star! Must you really strike your ball towards that direction? There is bad karma waiting for you!!!
And tossing a wine bottle across a room isn't anywhere near terrible anyway. He's already admitted to drugs and property damage, so this is a weird testimony to waste time on.
She's is entitled to tell her truth specially when she received a subpena. It's not like she was rushing to help the defense. Just becouse we like JD does not mean we can't hear some of the less unsavory truth 🤷🏽♀️ also it wasn't that bad what she said. Preety standard to me. He can be jealous and insecure does not mean he is an abuser.
I once threw my Walkman at my abusers head like 18 yrs ago because we arguing about something and I got mad and frustrated, I can't remember what, I instantly regretted it one because it only made him angrier and two because I'm not that kind of person I just lost control.
So it doesn't excuse his wrong dones 30 years back. Reminder that Ellen hasn't come begging to conplain about johnny here. She was bought here to relive her past. Belive in jurisdiction and shut up
After listening to some Amber Heard apologists I came here expecting a damning testimony proving Depp's violence. I am disappointed. He "tossed" a bottle that didn't hit anyone while he was fighting his friends or somebody Barkin doesn't remember in the general direction of a group of people standing around Barkin. That's it?
How did they even find someone he had upset from that far back in his life?? How many people from his history did they have to go through before they found her!
She's been in lots of movies and there are lots of photos of them together. She's one of those actors where you may not recognize her name but when you see her in movies its like oh yeah that's her.
I remember seeing Johnny swinging a sword at people! I also remember when he walked around with scissors on his hands, such a dangerous individual 🙄 no doubt this will become evidence 🤣
She is either holding a grudge for Johnny not pursuing a relationship with her 28 years ago or she was well compensated by Heard for the deposition. Either way it's a bit sad and pathetic in my opinion, lol.
I'm 35 and I have only vague memories of a dramatic relationship from 15 years ago. How can anyone recall events 28 years ago with even remote accuracy.
What a class act Barkin is now… not. Sounds like she is very bitter. Hard to believe she was married to the gorgeous Gabriel Byrne and has children with him.
LOL WHY THEY ALL HAVE SAME EXACT STORY LIKE THE BOTTLE IS IN EVERY SINGLE STORY,DRINKING OR DRUGS OR JEALOUSY !! they remember all those sruff but when they ask why did he do that or how it happened they be like ooohhh i don't remember that much like bitcg stop
What I learned from this trial is that it’s okay for Amber and all her friends to do drugs and drink… paid for by Johnny whilst living in his penthouses for free yet he’s the devil for doing them.
Everybody is allowed to party except Johnny
Yeah, such a monster that they had to hang out and party til the drugs ran out. He might be no saint but having to put up with all her hangers on and then her haranguing him and everyone pointing the finger at him, the whole thing was so toxic. Oh Johnny is sooo badddd, pass me the crack pipe pleazzz
A classic sign of any abuser is to distance the victim from friends or relatives. Quite the opposite here, isn't it?
4 years ago I had 2 officemates as a couple and we learned that the guy in the relationship had temper issues but it only triggers when he is stressed in a relationship. Later, the guy became destructive where he would destroy things but doesnt hurt his partner. Making the story short, they broke up.
Now, my friend, a girl, has been courted by this guy.. so me as a friend, at first, was being protective and told my friend to watchout for this guy since he has a history of being destructive and has temper issues. (As a friend, we advice our friends to avoid danger). She know the consequences and allowed the guy to be her boyfriend.. as of this writing, they are still together and there was no quarrel that led the guy to be stressed nor break stuff.
On AH's case. It was different.. her friends didn't even bother to ask to stay away from JD. Instead, they had parties 🤷
Not it's not. Almost everyone hates her. The world turns against her. And most of the people are justifying his behaviors. Not hers. You should know that. Even some personality disorders " experts". People talking about things that until today only they, both J & A know. People who hates her love to see her weakness exposed but when is time to expose J then they argue others are thinking its ok what she do and not what he do. Who in this world, in a trial like this should be the only exposed ? Why? It'll be unfair. Look, there's some kind of people that don't care what he did, they just hate her. While her weakness was showing up there oh! wow! that evil women but when its J's turn to be exposed: oh its ok for her but not for him. I ask you: who said anything of this is good on both sides? Who? Not even the professional teams here.
Who is their next witness, Johnny’s kindergarten teacher that once witnessed him kick another kid in the playground?! They’re really scraping the barrel now and it’s getting embarrassing.
They're trying bring people who had beef with JD in the past
😂
😂😂😂😂😂💀💀💀💀
😂😂😂
🤣🤣 1.4k comments and this by far is my favorite 1 👌🏼👌🏼
🤣🤣🤣
I love how all the ‘friends’ thought it acceptable to hang around, spend his money, use his drugs and booze for quite some time. Yet it’s suddenly now terrible that he did these things. They are all parasites and should be ashamed of themselves.
She was a succesful actress, she had lots of her own money. She ibbiously felt used and discarded by Depp. That's on him.
Disgusting..pathetic losers
You spend a week alone with him and only his employees around. Or send your daughter or sister or mother. While hes on a drug and alcohol binge. And if you would happily be willing to do that with no hesitation. Then i suppose good for you. I would not. And thats what it comes down to for me. I cant defend something or someone that i know i wouldnt want myself to be in or a family member.
I was thinking the same thing. It makes me sick.
@@Susie-l8m you do know that Amber and her sister were using heavily as well right? Why do you put the blame on him alone?
“Tossed” a bottle in her and many others’ general direction, in a hotel room fight happening between him and another dude. In the 90’s. This is their evidence of him being a DV abuser?
She wanted to be his girlfriend
He tossed the bottle WHILE filming "Fear and Loathing in las Vegas"
Johnny is a method actor, he has to be in character all the time even on his free time.
✌😁
You should do some research she's dated billionaires.
I’ve thrown and broken numerous things. Ive yelled and called names. But I’m not an abuser. All of these things have shown nothing but stupidity on Ambers part.
Scraping the bottom of the barrel
Ellen barkin: he tossed a wine bottle in a tantrum 30 years ago once. No one was hurt and I don't remember who was there because we were all wasted.
Also Ellen barkin: we slept together for 3 months and he suddenly stopped calling me then. And now I'm here 30 years later as a credible impartial witness!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@Mrs M yeah, 30 years ago. This woman's testimony does not provide a pattern of behaviour. All it does is show how bitter this woman is after a 3 month fling 30 freaking years ago. Be gone with you, Bot.
hahahahaha!
@@LilithGrey...FromHell yeah, Iam sure 30 more years of coke, alcohol and various other drugs cured his behavior.
@@hallio111 Right...because people are incapable of change 🙄 Give me a break 🙄
You are aware that RDJ had issues with addiction? How tf do you explain his success today? Just because somebody is an addict doesn't make them abusive. Nice try, though 👏👏👏
People really don’t know how subpoenas work. If you are served with a subpoena you have to testify. If you refuse to testify, you will be fined and arrested for contempt of court.
It's just, she's so smug or something? Barkin, is.
This is defamation case.
Unless you're a republican politician, and in that case, nothing will happen as we've seen.
You are partially right - that CAN happen, but it isn't guaranteed to happen. Amber's publicist was able to avoid the subpoena and nothing ever came of it.
@@playtone229 oh I know. I refused one myself and told the DA good luck finding me after he called threatening me but it’s still a risk and technically what always happens lol except sometimes they’re too lazy to follow through with the threats or enforcement.
Ellen Barkin : Johnny Depp threw a wine bottle across a room because he was arguing with some guy. The bottle did not hit her or anyone else. DE-SPA-RATION at this point for the defence team
She even clarified that it flew into her direction not that it was thrown at her.
And it was lobbed towards her not through hard. He was using maybe cause he was filming fear and loathing. Hello!
@@thejerk2030 I wonder how many times a day he has to shout that.
I don't think none of us read CNN, but cnn and legacy media are trying to say he did **** her. Now they are a bunch of lying fak3 news propogand4 shill5 . CNN and Vogue .... fak3 media that make North Korea look like a bastion of free speech compared to cnn.
"tossed" instead of "threw" is what she said at one point. Probably the truth she let slip.
So he tossed a bottle in room full of people, her included, out of sheer negligence and frustration, but it wasn’t directed at anyone in particular. This is pathetic, lmao.
were you there
@@Julia-ow4st No but I did watch the video at 2:53 on unlike you, lmao. I'm not reciting anything untrue, this is literally her account in the video. It's the clickbait title that got you.
@@Julia-ow4st You better get to bed, tomorrow is a school day young man!
So is it your view that it is appropriate to throw a wine bottle around the room. Really are you that blinded by Pirates of the Carribean or are you a wife beater yourself. He has a long history of it. Wake up to yourself
Guess Ellen needs money too
Johnny will not look at this woman either. Just how he told Amber.
In the words of a gentleman, "This is a pathetic attempt."
🤣you can say this aloud. So pathetic...
*words*
@@nateone6632 Lol, auto correct, my friend. F off
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what holding a grudge for 28 years does to you, simply because the guy didn't want a serious relationship with her. It's unbelievable how you can feel the pent-up hurt in her every word.
totally!
@@rl2388 looks like a pretty normal 66 year old to me...
fact !
I was just thinking the same thing the old bitty still holding a grudge
No
She sounds bitter and jealous. My gosh digging up evert bit of his past, that's horrible. Hope they do this for Amber, dig up her past :(
She dated a latín actor that already mention she was a devil dressed as an angel. He is Valentino Lanus, famous in our side
She wanted more of a relationship than he did. she was bitter when he didn't feel romantic towards her.
Stop gaslighting her.
What relevance does testimony from somebody who slept with Johnny Depp for a few months over 30 years ago have? Why not bring in more recent partners to testify? Answer: because they'd all say that he was absolutely lovely and never violent. Barkin is the only one they could find who said he once threw a bottle - but not even seriously threw it.
I want them to call Amber's ex-wife!
True
Because its show his behaviour obviously not rocket science 👍
They are lying they right away caused him by canceling shows and now they want to say that is what past behaviors and then why they did t fired him in the oast
Exactly
I’m pretty sure his kindergarten teacher said he didn’t share blocks one day because he wanted his tower to be taller than anyone else’s. Can we get a sworn statement from her?
Yeah I know right. I think their next witness is his teacher
Once when he was a child he stuck a chewing gum below a table should his lack of character.
Also when he was a toddler he didn't want to eat the food given to him showing he was incapable of ingesting anything other than drugs.
@#JohnnyDeppIsARapist!! #JohnnyDeppesracista you are one of countless bot accounts posting the exact same comment everywhere. Ambers PR team is truly pathetic.
@#JohnnyDeppIsARapist!! #JohnnyDeppesracista fire away
And Ellen was probably the teacher
Her actual testimony was he "tossed the bottle" not AT her but in the same direction as she was....not meant for her, she said he was fighting with other people.
By tossing that bottle, he potentially put it out of the reach of those who were arguing. In my own home, I will toss certain things just to get them out of my way and with the intention of doing the right thing with it the next time I leave my recliner. Tossing that bottle could have been a simple repetition of Johnny’s habit in his own home. (Tossing things out of the way until Arnold Schwarzenegger’s maid shows up to clean . . who’s the next baby daddy?)
@@tessangelabeck8958 That's a real stretch.
Title is definitely click bait!
@@sharonsybrandt4455 Hahaha . . you’re right! I’m just having a little fun with considering very unimportant possibilities to add to the craziness that Johnny couldn’t get away from Amber as often as the evidence suggests he tried. I feel bad for wealthy guys who are seduced by needy women. It seems they should be wise from their wealth and popularity, and they probably are very wise except for the few dingalings who trip them up.
Which supports the fact that he will attack cupboards, doors, items - RATHER THAN hit another person.
Amber's lawyers: "So he never showed up the prom that night?"
Johnny's 1st GF: "No, and I'm still waiting for him to this day."
🤣🤣🤣
hahahaha
hahaha
Lol...
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭😅😅😅
"Barkin knew about Perelman’s intensity, his tendency to be controlling, and his ugly past divorces, her friends say. But she had her own legendary temper, and in one interview she said she believed her fuse was quicker to light than his." Well well well...
Many men have lived to tell the tale.
Who was asking questions btw? Mrs penny?
Years after this incident, Johnny got her a role in “Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.”
So again, another person who Johnny helped out and was good to who is now coming back to make some money. These people are being compensated for their time.
This is why I’ve lost faith in humanity🤦🏻♀️
Good ppl always get 💩 on this is the justice in life… at this point I can’t even be sure he will get any favor from the jury if an old flame could come here and say this so many years later nothing is impossible and ppl aren’t fair. many women leave relationships that are truly awful and life threateningly abusive and they walk away never look back and don’t seek money or anything because there is always the thought I loved that person once I believed in them so why hurt them. Only bitter vengeful evil ppl seek any kind of revenge or even restitution of monies. Most humans let it go even the ones with scars on the inside and outside who can’t ever forget the things done to them. This woman is ridiculous really you even got involved in this and painted a bad light on someone so many years later who gave you their time and affection at some point in life. Wow just wow she also makes women look evil cold heartless and full of bile and vengeful feelings just as much as Amber does.
@@ohrthgil nah, it’s just a small percentage of people who are horrible like this. Amber seems to have an orbit of these people around her that she is paying, extorting, and using to try and win this.
Did Ellen Barkin make money for this?
In a weird way she's actually helping him by showing how pathetic & desperate they are. If I were Amber I'd be wondering if I just got played.
How horrible is this ..going through your life it's 30 years ago. I am sure we have all done things and been in a bad place. None of this means he was an abuser ..
@@78alJ0vle It was 30 years ago people make mistakes and can change
@@78alJ0vle Imagine throwing a bottle in the general direction of someone, by accident, during a fight, in a drunken state, *30 years ago,* and that going towards "solid evidence" in a defamation trial vs you and your (current) ex wife. I've never done it either but it's far fetched no matter how ya look at it or can relate.
@Mrs M Where have you been the whole trial? Him and Amber + all their friends were constantly doing drugs and drinking. Surely you didn't miss the bit where Amber's sister supposedly showed Johnny how to snort cocaine through a tampon shell? If he were so jealous he wouldn't have left and never spoken to her again after that. (Edit: "her" being the lady talking in the video.) There was obviously something else going on. You have your girlfriend and all her friends constantly gaslighting you and making you feel like everything is constantly your fault while you're the only one funding everything EVERYONE is doing; it's going to eventually hit you right in the mental. He got into a fight and tossed a bottle. Poor dude was probably lost and confused mentally, emotionally, and physically at that point. It actually sucks that the people closest to him only want to see his downfall. The people on her side will, of course, say what she is saying. If jealousy and malicious intent were Amber's opening words, jealousy and malicious intent will be her and her witnesses closing. There has been nothing said during the trial that even remotely proves Amber's innocence, and nothing that proves Johnny's malice.
@Mrs M This woman's testimony proves nothing of the sort. Keep reaching ya bot.
@@78alJ0vle Throwing bottles does not make one an abuser. He's already admitted that he has previously used an immense amount of drugs, nobody's denying that, but it's a completely different step entirely to physically hurt someone else, even more so that you actually MEAN to hurt somebody, and by the by, this testimony was weak in proving intention to harm anyways. Also, to Mrs M, "he's the one" would seem to imply that there weren't two parties that may be acting on equal grounds. We've heard many occasions in which they were both toxic to each other.
From what I've seen, there is no proof that he's hurt anybody at this time aside from a few questionable photos and equally questionable witnesses. No medical records? From when he "hit you so hard you lost count"? Where are the marks from his rings? No sign of injuries in terms of a concussion or anything similar? These questions are far too important to ignore.
I don’t get how you can clear a witness that is scorned by a relationship.
Exactly from almost 30 years ago!
Say it louder for the people in the back please.
Honestly, it didnt say much other than he can or has the capacity of being jealous which is.... nothing really. The case is about being violent within a relationship.
♦️♦️♦️♦️Ms. Barkin is at a stage in her life where she doesn't give a 💩 because she doesn't need Hollywood creeps. So she's free to speak her mind AND TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT WOMAN ABUSERS👍👍👍👏👏👏👏♦️♦️♦️♦️
PS: YOU'RE STILL A HOTTIE AND WAS HANDS DOWN THE SEXIEST WOMAN IN HOLLYWOOD.
They didn't date long. She was a fire cracker herself back in the day. A cougar then with a penchant for partying herself and quite sparky and full of combative fire. She's calm now she's alot older.. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I once got so upset because of something that happened at work that I threw a coke can and it accidentally went out my office door and rolled down the hall. Everyone thought it was hysterical. On the other hand, I'm still mortified. Let he who has never thrown an object in frustration cast the first stone.
I threw a stack of papers up in their air at work thru me once lol
Sounds like you have an anger issue.
you have anger issues then, and this is not normal behaviour
@@MsCharlieTramp you have problems with being judgemental and thinking you know people and things you don’t actually know anything about. Stay humble ✌️
Ambers lawyers are really scraping the bottom of the barrel here
and watching her looking at her lawyer like see the same as what happened to me and her lawyer looking like oh god maybe this was not such a good idea to put her on.
I would no longer go see her movies... However I don't think she even makes them anymore! What a washed up has been. One way to get some attention!
They desperate
Lol, how do you know? , it's just an assumption. She highly likely has a video of him shoving the bottle inside her she just waiting until the end of it, if all plans does not work she will go viral with huge evidence.
You can say that again.
He BROKE it off with her, yet, he was jealous and wanted to control her. She is so full of it. Who does this after they dump you! No one. Yet, he was SO JEALOUS that she never heard from him again.
Right? That was amusing. She said he was so jealous and controlling and she implied he was cloying and naggy at the breakup. YET, he never once harassed her or even communicated with her post break up. Doesn't sound like a territorial or jealous man to me. Something is fishy
@@melissak8892 That doesn’t make any sense .
😮😮😮
Yes some girls get burned alive for leaving a man …
sounds sussed to me if he broke up with her why would he be jelous??? Lol 😂 I reckon Amber has something to do with this wouldn’t surprise me it’s a set up! Maybe payback because he left her.
“From your understanding what had he drunk to become drunk” 😭😂
Why is she even involved in this? Who dug her up?
@@gnyc7284 I get your reference and it's really an eeeww moment.
A H team did. they are DESPERATE>
I think the grim reaper dug her up.
This lady is to prove that JD has had a drug and alcohol problem for years. Jealous controlling and a hot head throwing things when angry. Even though Amber is no Angel what she says about his lifestyle has been that way for years. Affected every relationship as well as his career, that he can blame Noone for but himself!!!
@@paulabrown5992 what?
She said “tossed” she’s bitter and miserable. Waste of time
LMFAO
Your the reason why no one wants to testify.
Pilled up
Ellen's a recovering alcoholic
@@lyte4240 she looks it, sadly
Barkin is a pathetic witness. There’s too much she can’t seem to remember. If they were all partying how dependable is her memory from three decades ago?
He was jealous and controlling, yet he was the one that ended the relationship. And he threw a bottle while fighting with someone else and it didn't hit her.
OK. That's the best they could find? Smh
If it even happened.
And Ellen was the only honest one on that tape. . Johnny and Amber are both dishonest liars and were made for each other. Neither of them can let the other one go.. after all these years.
People who are bad drunks do not change. They are always bad drunks.
She rephrased " tossed the bottle "
Do jealous and controlling people allow a bunch of freeloaders to live in their homes? Just doesn’t fit the profile. I’m not saying this guys any kind of angel, all that drinking and drugging is not a good thing, but it’s clear that he had a manner of handling conflict that was conflict avoidant, and to anyone who understands these types of personality disorders, that woman is a poster child…
I just read this. Wow. "Ellen Barkin had a very public and tortured divorce from one of her husband(s), Ron Perelman. He was EXTREMELY wealthy and she wanted it all. She was awarded $60,000,000.00. It was notorious and she was viewed negatively throughout the long divorce process. She’s had quite a few very public and very negative relationships." You never know who people are.
🤭
At least she's consistent
@@katherinethouret6110 You can say that!
Ew another gold digger. I’m beginning to see AH as her when she’s older.
well she seems like she'd be a real barrel of laughs to be with.
Well we know she looks like 20 miles of bad road.
Funny to listen her talk about Johnny's 'drinking habits' decades ago, when she herself has a proper alcoholic voice!
He still has the same drug habits drinking and more.
@@bevwilliams2528 oh but he’s the good kind of drunk and druggie. You know the super sexy talented kind.
My first impression was that she's on drugs.
The title should be changed to "Ellen Barkin alleges Johnny Depp threw a bottle of wine at the wall 30 years ago."
😂😂😂😂😂
Best comment!
Pathetic, isn't it?
AH with yet another extremely credible witness here from 30 years ago. Great work AH lawyers. You’re all doing great.
Heard's lawyer shouldn't have called her as a witness. They knew that the jury would think her testimony was irrelevant at best. Maybe she wanted her say after grinding her teeth for years, but Heard's lawyers did her a dirty by not explaining to her how this would come off.
Hahahaha. They should get a gold sticker and a pat on the head for this achievement.
Poor JD...got involved with a narcissist who is still grudgy after 30 years for being dumped...get over it Barkin....
'He never called me again'
Bitter much 🍋🍋
Amber threw the bottle at Johnny, there’s a tape proving this! She is trying
To twist things!
No, Johnny admitted to others and he’s on tape stating he cut his own finger off. Why are you lying?
@@theartzscientist8012 no he didn't. Why are you lying libby ?
@@theartzscientist8012 he never said it.
@@TheWalf999 no she didn’t. There’s a witness who heard him say that he cut it off himself and a video tape. Oh and the dog pooped on the bed, said by another witness. Depp’s going to lose.
@@chrisbishop9531 narcs always defend narcs.
Did she say "Mr. Barkin"? 😆
She sounds like Marge Simpson's chainsmoking twin sisters.
No not towards her a friend. Why did she get on her anyways??? Yes we know he likes wine and drugs we got it. WHERE IS THE PROOF HE IS A ABUSER?????
This is pathetic!!!how is this relevent?
Was it a 5yr old asking the questions?.
Oh my. I hope that I never get sued. Who knows? A third grade classmate might testify against me.
😂😂😂 God forbid they call your kindergarten teacher to the stand.
LMAO
@@ana-maria6443 oh my! that would not go well for me! 🙂
@@ana-maria6443 He snorted glue in 3rd grade
This is beyond pathetic bringing her to the courtroom. This is c r a z y ----- that this would have any bearing on this trial.
Well, they are desperate...!
As you can see this woman has let herself go she is not glamorous or nice looking anymore and he probably dumped her that's why she has nothing nice to say about him she's gotten so old looking she should worry about herself and try to groom herself a little bit more she looks like she's about 85 years old
Boy I bet she was happy to come in and testify against him after leaving her without word. Smh
100M
@@deniseslack7116 She sounds like she could be on something.
Ms. Barkin, left husband and wonderful actor, Gabriel Byrne, their two children, and the second act of her promising career in Hollywood, for a few all-nighters with Johnny Depp, who was at least 10 years younger than her, and she is bitter as if she is the victim here?!
That's Hollywood...not shocked
You can tell she doesn't like talking against him like this though. Jealously isn't abnormal, excessive jealousy can ve attributed to low self esteem and lets be honest here, Amber was JUST as bad with her jealousy as he is.
Ellen has aged so horribly
@@foxontherun2951 jealousy will do that to you!
@@foxontherun2951 yes.
Really? I think she's very openly sharing the violent behavior on Depp's part. It's disturbing how many people will turn a blind eye to some clearly erratic behavior because they want to dunk on Heard (who also has issues of her own)
Is it too much to ask that your gf keeps her clothes on and doesn't act like a hoebag?
Angry at times, controlling at times, jealous at times... these are words that describe MANY of us in relationships at times. Ok... great.... still nobody has ever accused Johnny of beating them. I have thrown an object at a wall before. If we are being honest - I am sure 75% or more of us have done something similar before. Under the influence of drugs or alcohol, people have done things they aren't proud of. THIS DOES NOT EQUATE TO BEATING YOUR WIFE REPEATEDLY. Amber Heard completely made up all of that.
She said _allll_ the time. And no, this isn't normal behavior. If you think it is, you need therapy too.
@@Yanni75 She said he was jealous and controlling when they were together a lot. He also works, hangs out with friends, acts, does recreational activities, sleeps, eats, does other things....... so he's not that way all the time. She said they only hung out occasionally. Sometimes a couple times a week, sometimes weeks or months in between visits.... So, not all the time.
And yes, jealousy is a very normal emotion and dynamic in relationships. It's normal to feel that way sometimes. We also don't know how it feels to be in a celebrity relationship. Controlling - he asked what she was doing, who she was with. WOW, how awful. Again....... these aren't the same as BEATING YOUR WIFE. Bye Laurel.
Throwing objects out of anger especially towards your significant other is not normal or okay at all
@@rewdskwid If you have never once thrown an object out of anger, then you're better than the rest of us. Most people have done that. Nobody said it's ok, but we all have behaved in a way that we aren't proud of at some point. If you're perfect, then congratulations. Most of us aren't.
@@blue84freak no I’ve never known anyone throw an object in anger. It is not normal and is kind of sad that you think it is.
Wow so a partner is not allowed to ask where the other partner was or what they were doing or who they were with without being accused of being jealous?
Even if they were - so WHAT? Jealousy is a common human emotion which the vast majority experience at least once in life! It DOESN'T mean the person is violent or abusive. I think the AH 'legal team' can be described by one phrase - "the missing link"!
5:08 Imagine being called "jealous" and "controlling" while asking where your date is going about so you won't have to worry about them... I Think caring was his biggest mistake.
I thought the same thing lol those questions I ask family just in case something were to happen to them during their evening out.
Ok….so he was insecure in their relationship. However, he ain’t hit her or slap her or beat her up even while high. He threw a wine bottle in her general direction once during a fight with someone else. I can see why it should be mentioned, cause it happened but it still doesn’t explain why for all of his 58 years he has never actually laid hands on a woman….till Amber Heard….even while perhaps having a drug problem or an alcohol addiction. Interesting
She said he threw it at his friends. Why do y'all lie? So tired of media doing this, now you guys? Are you for real?
How do YOU know, you weren’t there🤔
@@passiveaggressive6175 Hmmm, I wonder?
@@TheWalf999 What is your question. Be specific.
He "tossed" ok
I think this women is still harboring anger at him for him breaking up with her
Exactly - and I think she's got together with Heard to try to make much out of what amounts to nothing.
The defense is more desperate than me trying to run away from Cuba 😂
Jajajaja
😂😂
Johnny Depp must be thinking 'Did I really?' 'Man I must've been stoned'
Why is the Rum gone? 😂
Sounds like she wants payback.
♦️♦️♦️♦️Ms. Barkin is at a stage in her life where she doesn't give a 💩 because she doesn't need Hollywood creeps. So she's free to speak her mind AND TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT WOMAN ABUSERS👍👍👍👏👏👏👏♦️♦️♦️♦️
PS: YOU'RE STILL A HOTTIE AND WAS HANDS DOWN THE SEXIEST WOMAN IN HOLLYWOOD.
The fight was NOT between Johnny and Elen, instead with someone else. And the bottle was NOT tossed at her and the other, it was tossed across the room. No harm done, that simple.
But but but.... it went within the general vicinity of her personal (safe) space and so that counts as an 'extremely violent' act.... See, Amber Heard wasn't lying about her invisible non-swelling bruises... If Johnny can throw a bottle in the general vicinity of a woman then he is capable of anything....
@@chrisg8321 didn't you know? Any time a man is engaging in any type of toxic behaviour in the general vicinity of a woman, no matter the context or situation, or even if only someone else thinks she SHOULD feel uncomfortable around a certain act, it makes him a violent narcissist toxic misogynist abuser. /s
@@chrisg8321 well I guess we’ll never know how it happened exactly. She relied on some memory from 30ish years ago. IMO, this was a weak deposition and didn’t prove anything
@@nadya8332 and it was the 90s, seems like typical occurance
this donald duck😂😂
Wow sour grapes, Ellen? Do you hold grudges against every man who doesn’t want you?
Her actual testimony is that he was arguing with SOMEONE ELSE and threw the wine bottle. This title is misleading
she was also asked if the bottle was thrown in her direction and she said yes so where mislead?
@@SimplyJanemba The mislead is that it wasn’t thrown AT HER. If something is thrown in your direction, it could be 3 ft away. That doesn’t mean it was intended to hit you.
I think it’s been absolutely proven that Johhny assaults doors , bottles, cabinets, and countertops when he gets wasted and loses his temper. So I’m still looking for irrefutable evidence of assault on a human.
Anybody can notice that woman Ellen Berkin is still resentful that Johnny Depp never called again...! I don't believe her at all.
She didn’t ask Ellen if she did drugs too with them. Notice that
I was thinking the same thing. She was probably partying too! They had a 3-5 month fling over 30yrs ago.
What I know is that when I was with toxic people I surprised myself be nasty like them. When I am with normal people I act normal because I don’t need to justify everything all the time, argue over little things... Now I just choose better friends who respect me and it works perfect. I just live a calm and peaceful life.
So the bottle hit nobody… and since when is it a crime to be jealous and ask questions about where your partner got a scratch or think someone is being unfaithful? Next!
He threw a bottle at me.
Did it hit you?
No.
it wasn't AT her. it was near her.
“I was always aware…” Lord, no wonder she looks so exhausted! I haven’t seen Ellen Barkin for years! I really liked her 1980 and 90s stuff.
Shes almost 70 she looks fine
Bitterness makes people ugly.
@@goldenautumn3073 she whispers back, “so do genetics and failed cosmetic procedures.”🧬😆
She sounds so bitter and frustrated.A lot of people are using drugs and alcohol, and not getting aggressive, and a lot of people are not using and getting aggressive. After hearing the audios with AmberT screaming and hysterically laughing, mocking and saying nonsense sentences, we can definitely say who's worse and needs a time out.
That’s exactly what i tell all Amber’s stans but it feels like you’re either talking to a wall or a 5 year old kid. Cocaine would be the last thing I saw someone become violent on tbh.
Gotta remember this was the 80's when they were together. Cocaine was king then. Pretty much every celebrity was doing it.
I absolut agree old greepy 😅
Ellen Barkin was very angered at Julia Roberts being chosen over her to play the prostitute in 'Pretty Woman' with Richard Gere. She stated Roberts was too fresh faced & didn't have a 'hooker' edgieness needed to play the roll. She was very bitter back then at being passed over. That's been her Hollywood trajectory.
she did not sound bitter at all to me. very unemotional.
Where's the police reports?
She literally said he TOSSED a bottle across a room 25 to 30 years ago and this matters WHY again? Ellen wishes Depp had been jealous and controlling when in reality he hit it and quit it and she's still mad.
and they only dated 3 months and it was 30 years ago...wtf. compare his relationship with paradis with 14 years together.....
@@cchen-wq2nm I'd like to know, if this woman's testimony matters enough for her to be a "witness", why weren't any of his other partners called?
@@sabrinashelton1997 Because they'd support him.
@@goldenautumn3073 I mean called by him.
My kid once threw a water bottle in my direction...it didnt hit me but now that i think of it, he must be a wife beater too.
Dang...who woulda guessed.
To all those saying she’s holding a grudge - Amber’s team subpoenaed her to testify. For all we know she hasn’t even thought about any of this stuff for the last 30 years. But Amber needs to scrape the bottom of the barrel for anything she can get.
She can always refuse to testify, nobody can force her.
@@panic_diver if you receive a subpoena, you must testify. That is my understanding.
I thought this was recorded back in 2019...
@@panic_diver That’s not true at all. Of course you have to testify in court if the judge orders you, just like you have to tell the truth.
Imagine if I got convicted of murder because my alibi just couldn’t be bothered to show up in court, or just didn’t like me.
In the US the Fifth Amendment means you can’t be compelled to testify against yourself in a criminal case. Otherwise you have to.
@@panic_diver uh, no, you have to testify if you are served with a subpoena. If you refuse, you can be jailed for contempt of court.
Since they're bringin in Johnny's ex and Amber's friends to testify about Johnny's demeanor... I wonder why Johnny didn't ask Winona or Johnny's ex wife to come and testify what they said publicly in his defense.
Poor Ellen, a dismal attempt at publicity. She was fired from Animal Kingdom, last I heard.
@@brendafactor9307 So, giving evidence against someone is an attempt at publicity, is it? Using that logic, no famous or semi-famous person should ever be allowed to give evidence in a court of law. Right? You're SO smart !
@@kikihapexamendiosisaklepto7397 you make a valid point however one has to question her motivation in coming forward now after all these years. Maybe not fame or publicity but I hardly think it's out of principle or justice or out of due care.
So these people were High and drinking too such hypocrites
For God sake, what follows, the cat, the dog to testify he uses drugs etc.
the dog is suing Amber for defamation for her lies about him pooping on the bed when it was really her
@@KenMabie oooh that's funny
Awwe hahahaha.
Ambers lawyers : " now Ms Stinky Butt McPuttputt is it true that you witnessed Johnny Satan Depp doing cocaine out of a jar"
Ms McPuttputt : "meow purr purr meow"
So they were all doing drugs and had struggles with addiction and had endless money to put towards whatever vices they wished...but Johnny is the bad guy for doing drugs and having struggles with addiction.
Dude tossed a bottle across a room while drunk or high, apparently at no one. I've been to similar work parties with a bunch of buttoned-up accountants.
Never ended up in a deposition over it, though.
No, that is not what they are arguing. The point here is whether Depp has a consistent behaviour of becoming aggressive and violent when drunk, and whether he has a jealous, controlling side. Nobody under the sun can deny that alcohol and drug usage are heavily correlated with paranoia and violence, as numerous assaults and murders will demonstrate. If they can go all the way back to 1990 to find examples of Depp being abusive (and Depp has been in trouble for assaulting people and trashing private property before), then this is highly damaging for Depp's case. He ought to look more worried. I have been a fan of his work for a long time, but if he loses this case, then that is that. He is a great actor, but he doesn't look like a great human being behind all the fame.
Absolutely, it’s not right, but it happens, and that’s life. Doesn’t makes someone a violent person, just someone who is angry. I’d rather they threw the bottle than hit it over my head..
One of the few comments that makes sense! I think Johnny Depp is an amazing actor, but the roles he plays are not real ! He isn’t Jack Sparrow people! He is an addicted human being that struggle with sobriety and is surrounded by enablers that wants him to believe that being on an island for few weeks is going to make him “normal “ again… is ridiculous!!!
@@Musicienne-DAB1995 Eres una vergüenza por decir esto....Estas juzgando a una persona que tenia una adicción.
Pero no estas mirando realmente la pruebas,¿Lo estás haciendo? No te parece suficiente con tantas mentiras que dice Amber.
Tan perfecto sos que te pones en un lugar inmaculado?
Vergüenza me dan la gente como tú,que tienen todas las pruebas sin embargo siguen creyendo en lo que dice una cara bonita.
Vos si que mereces que te lleven los Alien.
@@natasciaganau5581 Yo no soy Fan de Depp,pero fui una víctima de abusos.
Y te puedo decir querida,que aca no se lo esta juzgando por tener adicciones.
Y si yu crees que a una persona se lo puedo culpar simplemente por tener esta enfermedad de todo lo que se le acusa,se nota que tu vida no es muy bonita que digamos,las personas que se ponen el lugar de un juez siempre por lo general son las más amargadas del mundo.
Ella también consumía,pero como es mujer tu y él otro no dicen nada?
Ac nadie esta diciendo que él es un santo es una como tú y yo,y se merece tener la oportunidad de querer mejorar siempre,como lo hacemos todos los humanos.
Aca lo ue se esta cuestionando es si él la violento y le hizo todo lo que ella dice ,pero que no tiene ninguna prueba solida, porque ningún testigo en realidad vio nada,todos dicen que solo lo escucharon por ella o que vieron los moretones ,que vamos a decir sinceros o lo voy hacer yo que sufri de puñetazos, jamás de los jamases ella pudo haber cubrir esas heridas y salir tan bien en esas fotos.
Si le crees te invito que vayas con las verdaderas víctimas y les preguntes por eso ninguna le cree,bueno las que no se dejan llevar por el femenino.
30 years ago. They’re reaching.
I think it's in truth stretching reality.
Everyone can see that by having calling Barkin as a witness to testify, AH's team is really scraping the bottom of the barrel. Apparently, Barkin liked the "relationship" enough to keep going back for more. She doesn't even have AH's faux-victim "Because I loved him," statement to justify why she kept their "arrangement" going. Did JD's team not question Barkin?
Nope. Just AH's lawyers.
they were very wise not to. 1) it made her look petty and foolish 2) It leaves them more time to question their rebuttal witnesses, whilst AH's lawyers wasted tons of time on all of today's useless witnesses.
But Barkin isn't saying the relationship was a bad one. She is just identifying that Depp had an alcohol, drug, and anger problem-- and I have not seen anyone who is able to deny that.
No Barking said after the bottle incident she stayed in LA and never saw Johnny again after that. Pay attention dude!
Johnny's already admitted that he has thrown things, never at anyone, but he's thrown them and taken his anger out on objects... that's a far cry from being abusive to a person.. I've been known to hit an object or two or of frustration..I think most of us have done this, not all. But most..
My gosh what has Johnny Depp done to deserve all this bs!!?? No wonder he does drugs because he is surrounded by people like this!!
Users, the lot of them. It's a miracle he still became the legend he is. I would have fallen off the wagon years ago
Jealous woman!...This must be why Pacino suspected her in 'Sea of Love'....God...I'm revealing my age with that reference!
How is it possible that every AH witnessws, aren't even real witnesses from this case, the only one was her sister, and she even lived in JD's place 😅
honestly when it's been that long, why would anyone want to testify? when you have zero connection with the relationship betweeen depp and heard or were not even around during amber-depp relationship, why would you accept to testify? unless it's against the law to refuse to testify
Why didn't she accuse him of anything at that time?????
So, he threw a bottle decades ago when fighting with friends, not a significant other, and it didn't hurt or hit anyone. This is their evidence of him being a DV abuser? Even though his romantic partners after this relationship came out and defended him?
ikr!!!!! they can't prove that JD is an abuser!!!! no evidence at all!!! if the roles were reversed, JD will be in jail in not time
So let me get this straight johnny has been in court because throwing things slamming things and jealousy and getting angry lol 🤣😆😆🤣🤣
at this point Depp threw a bottle at me from halfway across the world
Who hasn't done something terrible 30 yrs ago? As part of an immature stage of growing up?!
Ellen, you are a fallen star! Must you really strike your ball towards that direction? There is bad karma waiting for you!!!
If she wanted to further her career she’d not be there
And tossing a wine bottle across a room isn't anywhere near terrible anyway. He's already admitted to drugs and property damage, so this is a weird testimony to waste time on.
She's is entitled to tell her truth specially when she received a subpena. It's not like she was rushing to help the defense. Just becouse we like JD does not mean we can't hear some of the less unsavory truth 🤷🏽♀️ also it wasn't that bad what she said. Preety standard to me. He can be jealous and insecure does not mean he is an abuser.
I once threw my Walkman at my abusers head like 18 yrs ago because we arguing about something and I got mad and frustrated, I can't remember what, I instantly regretted it one because it only made him angrier and two because I'm not that kind of person I just lost control.
So it doesn't excuse his wrong dones 30 years back. Reminder that Ellen hasn't come begging to conplain about johnny here. She was bought here to relive her past. Belive in jurisdiction and shut up
this is embarassing for her. her resting face looks miserable.
There was once a time when Ellen Barkin would never have been thought of as being something scraped from the bottom of a barrel. She is now.
Explain that statement cause I see a poised honest hardworking legend on that stand.
@@toscanoplaster5603 legend? 🤣🤣🤣
She's a waste of time
@#JohnnyDeppIsARapist!! #JohnnyDeppesracista troll incoming
Yepper. Perhaps a faded movie career has taken its toll?
Sad Ellen Barkin. Just sad.
So wait… he was fighting with a friend and not her? The mainstream media sold this like he assaulted her!
This is really bizarre.
After listening to some Amber Heard apologists I came here expecting a damning testimony proving Depp's violence. I am disappointed. He "tossed" a bottle that didn't hit anyone while he was fighting his friends or somebody Barkin doesn't remember in the general direction of a group of people standing around Barkin. That's it?
🤣🤣 👏 💯
How did they even find someone he had upset from that far back in his life??
How many people from his history did they have to go through before they found her!
She's been in lots of movies and there are lots of photos of them together. She's one of those actors where you may not recognize her name but when you see her in movies its like oh yeah that's her.
Because she's never stopped going on about being dumped for 28 years
she is a good example of what can happen to you if you don't move on from disappointment in your life
@@tidalwaves8761 the second example is Depp. He has also not moved on.
@@DrTiwade from Amber? he probably needs to keep healing
I remember seeing Johnny swinging a sword at people! I also remember when he walked around with scissors on his hands, such a dangerous individual 🙄 no doubt this will become evidence 🤣
Haha
You forgot the cut throat razors, he was also 'Sweeney Todd'
He also gave candy to children a very dangerous person he is what a joke this has all been
@@ziggypop8106 wow you're right, lock him up quick!!
@@instahawk8422 🤣 the latest slip from Amber is the best so far "my bruise kit, er um, crap, what did I just say"!!
Why does Johnny Depp's ex Ellen look old enough to be his mother lololololol
She is either holding a grudge for Johnny not pursuing a relationship with her 28 years ago or she was well compensated by Heard for the deposition. Either way it's a bit sad and pathetic in my opinion, lol.
It's the compensation most likely
I'm 35 and I have only vague memories of a dramatic relationship from 15 years ago. How can anyone recall events 28 years ago with even remote accuracy.
This is free publicity for her she hasn't been relevant for a very long time.and clearly she resents that she wasn't his girlfriend
or you know ... she is telling the truth...
Can you think of another possibility?
Johnny Slept and Left. Nothing to see here.
🤭
Wow… just wow. This is embarrassing
What a class act Barkin is now… not. Sounds like she is very bitter. Hard to believe she was married to the gorgeous Gabriel Byrne and has children with him.
She’s been waiting for decades to get back at him……ugh, these women are horrible. JD has to raise the bar going forward !
Der Mann hat Sie ohne viel viel Rotwein nicht ansehen können und dass verstehe Ich 😜
LOL WHY THEY ALL HAVE SAME EXACT STORY LIKE THE BOTTLE IS IN EVERY SINGLE STORY,DRINKING OR DRUGS OR JEALOUSY !! they remember all those sruff but when they ask why did he do that or how it happened they be like ooohhh i don't remember that much like bitcg stop
Why tf do they even mention weed, it just makes you less violent!
Smurfs ALIVE! 😱🤣🤣.
And how much Amber paid her to testify such a ridiculous attempt to make Johnny look bad ?
This is ridiculous what a relationship has to do with this case when Amber was 6 years old. Do we behave the same from 30 years ago to now.
☠