He didnt diagnose anyone. And yes you can identify diseases/issues without having spoken to someone, for instance bloodtest results. Video recordings. Happens all the time.
This lawyer is absolutely amazing to destroy all theories of these “profesionals” by questioning their credibility and true knowledge. Amazing just as the rest of the team.
This psychiatrist is in love with his own voice. He is unprofessional, condescending and I can’t believe that the Judge didn’t throw out his testimony after telling him many times to just answer the question.
Hmmm...You haven't worked with a Lot of Doctors? He's a Classic case especially in Psyche. This guy just seems to have a very heavy NYC demeanor, accent and most certainly considers himself the top of the Intellect chain.
There's no way this guy is a Psychiatrist. The way he physically presents himself and talks alone make me wonder just how easy it is to be employed as a psychiatrist in America.
You'd be SURPRISED to realize how easy it is for basically any ambulatory transfer student at a community college to get into some of the best Universities and go on to get a Masters & PhD in Psychology as a mediocre student & person. The entire field of Psychology is one of the least competitive if not the least competitive of the "Sciences" to get a Degree.
This guy is so incredibly unprofessional. And he's dangerous because the state has recognized his authority as a doctor. He needs to be reviewed by a board and have past clients looked into.
Hannibal Lecter is a fellow Psychiatrist... Hannibal Lecter thinks he's a disgrace to the practice... Hannibal Lecter will invite him to a gourmet dinner.
@@WickedPhase King wrote something to this effect in Doctor Sleep when the story revisits the Overlook. Evil calling evil back home, or something like that.
This lawyer needs to be applauded. He played this perfectly. Sometimes it's best to just people on the stand ramble. More often than not, they end up hanging themselves all on their own! Well done.
Just because you have “Dr” in front of your name, does not mean you are a credible human being. Those days are gone, where people assume you are a decent person, based on your profession. You have to earn credibility.
Agree! I work at a very important place (i cant name the company obv) and some of the top doctors in the field that i meet every day ....are absolutely crazy and idiotic! One of them accidentally killed a woman by swapping out her trial date to make room for her tea party!! It's disgusting.
Definitely. I’ve worked with a lot of Drs as an assistant and I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard them gossip about patients conditions behind their back but put up a smile when they talk to them. A huge majority of ppl become Drs for the status and money and honestly they don’t give a crap about caring for patients at all.
This guy is hysterical. What a fun witness to watch. He's totally clueless that his combative narcissistic arrogance is making him look like a total tool and uncredible witness.
Well, the APA is a joke, designed like the ABA primarily to do two things: 1) keep salaries high 2) protect psychiatrists against suits brought by patients
I think his credibility was already very minimalistic and you have an incredibly accurate point - something he had was lacking throughout this entire process.
Freedom of Speech is amazing when given to any American, but very few are given the ability to transform speech into utterly words and meanings to not pertain to this human in any sense out of the hearing of his own voice
He is Atty. Wayne Dennison, for those who doesn't know his name, and yes, he is underrated. He did a very good job in this trial as much as Camille and Ben, and the other members of the legal team
This guy absolutely terrifies me. The way he speaks, the way he gestures around, what he is saying, his attitude... everything is raising red flags by me.
Yea I gotta say the clip of this guy talking doesn't help people who are already on the fence about seeking psychiatric help, it's scary to think about how many more people with a degree out there like this guy are just probably misdiagnosing people and destroying their minds with the wrong meds
Actually, it's depp's laywer that talks down and attacks the psychiatrist! It's kinda their job, so ok, -and if you listen to what's going on the psychiatrist is actually refusing to be manipulated and be talked down to, he does not let him self get affected by the game the laywer is playing.
You're a licensed therapist, okay. Anyone who offers advice is a "therapist." You probably have a Bachelor's Degree in Psychology. If that's all you've got, you should know you're not able to diagnose mental disorders.
As a licensed therapist you should know you can’t diagnose someone off anecdotal, and finite, trial testimony. Don’t do the same unprofessional thing you accuse him of doing
Nope, what's worse is if government entities commission him to do reports on people, like in the family court, justice system, child protection. That destroys lives.
It is literally unethical for any therapist to give a diagnosis without personally assessing an individual in their office. You just can't look at someone, listen to them and diagnose them just from that, without ever talking to them personally
Unfortunately, maybe a lawyer can confirm or deny there can be treating physicians or just experts who can speak in court based on generalized opinion. 😱
This lawyer was absolutely the best man for the job here. He let the witness ramble on just enough to contradict himself and discredit much of his 'evaluation'
He’s a partner for the firm. Him and Ben Chew have obviously been doing this for a longggggg time and I’m sure to have them represent you is so much money
Ridiculous! Seems like someone who escaped from an asylum rather than being a psychiatrist. I cannot believe a word he says. He tries to justify whatever he says and it still does not make sense!
Well yeah, he clearly stole a doctor’s clothes to sneak out, but on his way out people pulled him in for an emergency so he had to play along and he’s been playing along ever since because he didn’t think he’d ever get that far.
This man made all sorts of mistakes, but his biggest was being defensive like he was on trial himself. He is attacking, because he feels personally attacked.
@@YRWB98 Exactly. He went up there like this trial was about him, and that led to it getting really weird. Could've saved himself and AH some trouble if he just answered simply, and under control to play his part. The crazy hair and crackhead mannerisms was just icing on the cake.
And he is is feeling personally attacked... probably because he knows *he* is being called out publicly...in front of millions of ppl potentially...that he is not a person who should be qualified to do what he is doing. That man shouldn't be evaluating, treating, or advising anyone. If anything... He is quite dangerous. Just think of all the poor ppl that would seek out this man for help?
I don’t know what the law system is in America but in Germany you can’t study someone without their consent - in Germany he could get in to jail for one year for such a thing ✌️
Wow!! This is must definitely NOT Evidence-based Medicine. As a Medical Doctor I got no words to justify the behavior from this Psychiatrist. Also… I’m so IMPRESSED by Depp’s lawyer on stand. Amazing! He did his homework and got to the level of this psychiatrist to fight his argument eloquently.😍
“Johnny lacks empathy” WHAT!!?? The man who goes to many hospitals to visit children and makes them smile and hugs them and takes time to speak with them, that’s just one example..
@@ninixvean4156 lets people leech off of him, helped several fans he met throughout his life financially, makes friends and takes time to chat with everyone around him such as the stenographer, the security etc
And you...don't think narcissist can have a charming and nice facade? I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but that's kinda how they get away with it. Not saying that Depp is, but it's easy to be fooled by someone who know how to play nice. Btw. he has probaly done four visits in over ten years, all with cameras around.
He is a prime example of what makes people NOT seek mental health treatment. His own mental health seems questionable. I’m truly concerned for his prior patients and anyone who has been his victim by means of misdiagnosis, gross lack of judgment, and people he’s testified for/against in the past. Not only did he inaccurately assess Johnny, but he inaccurately assessed Amber also (which is what he was paid to do TBH). He completely had them reversed, and he shows some of those traits himself. The bit about Johnny lacking empathy and Amber being an empathetic person was just too much!
I understand what you're saying, but who knows what chain of events made him reach the position he found himself in. It seems like he knows how wrong he is but has no choice but to do it anyway. Hence the obvious discomfort and arrogance.
What made you say that he's a bad psychologist? I haven't seen any psychologist able to boast that they can accurately diagnose a mental condition based on movie actings and interviews. I bet this man is able to read thoughts through his special tv. If anything, he's the best psychologist in the world.
@@lightkira4119 obviously a lot of money is being paid to him, but maybe he's on the brink of bankruptcy after some catastrophic events where he's given up his last shits to give.
The fact that this guy is paid to give his professional opinion on people's mental states is absolutely terrifying... It also explains why so many people who need help remain utterly fcuked up...
I feel comfortable labelling this guy as "a cretinous, psychopathic narcissist" because clinically I know as much about him as he knows about Johnny Depp. He is deeply unprofessional.
He'd probably be able to "diagnose" you with 30 unknown underlying subtle cases of different personality disorders. "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "for the last time no" "ahh so you need anger management, gotcha, want an appointment tomorrow?"
Did you seen the video of this bloke on the stand. Looks like he's on drugs his jaw was all over the shop was terrible. Also jonny depps face and his lawyers face was priceless in response to this so called doctor 🙃😬🙄🤨🤨🤔🤔
I feel like I know people e.g my gf that are of a similar personality. I.e never answering questions directly, gaslighting, misrepresenting and misunderstanding on purpose all in the name of making themselves, atleast to themselves, appear better and more sane.
His patients leave feeling better because they aren’t as nuts as their doctor. How could Heard’s lawyers make this clown any part of this trial? They should have gone back to the muffins instead of putting him on the stand.
I live in Chesapeake which is very close to Norfolk, I can’t believe this man has a degree and actually treats people. I would feel so degraded by him.
Well assesment without actual contact is just crazy, it is like you record yourself, send your record to a doctor and said, go on doctor diagnose what is wrong with me
You know, I used to tell my cousin that there aren't real people who are as deranged as some of the characters in GTA. But then I watched this Trial and I found myself taking that statement back every time one of Amber's witnesses came up. Her whole legal team were a bunch of dribbling clowns.
Based on my lack of knowledge about this pysychiatrist, or his ability, or anything else, about him, I can attest to the fact that he is cognitively impaired.
Ironically enough, you have more knowledge about this man through the viewing of this clip alone than this man's knowledge of Johnny Depp, the person he supposedly has to examine thoroughly
He keeps using “fancy” terms to come off professional and knowledgeable but a true professional speaks in terms in which a general audience can understand (like how Dr. Curry did)
Where did they get this psychiatrist? I feel sorry for his patients. He is combative, loves to talk and I can only imagine him with a patient. He would be charging them to listen to him instead of the other way around.
He’s incompetent! He doesn’t know what he’s talking about! That line about “thats what we do in clinical medicine sir” is terrifying! Because is this the way he actually practices?!?!
I suspect he doesn’t actually have many patients. If I ran across this useless, arrogant, condescending, surly m/f’er for one of my therapy sessions I’d walk right out of the office, file a formal complaint and move on. I actually did do that once with someone quite like him. Then found someone who was phenomenal. A psychotherapist vs psychiatrist. I think the clowns with a med degree are insufferably arrogant.
I worked in law enforcement for many years… many of our arrests had to have mental health professionals give clearance for jail. I can’t EVER remember meeting a mental health worker that was sane themselves!!! True story!!! Mental health in our country is a DISASTER!!
That psychiatrist probably hurt Ambers case rather than help it. What a nightmare! He has no proper basis for his opinion, he is woefully inept, and his very demeanor is so awful it’s hard not to hate this guy.
This psychiatrist doesn’t seem legitimate. Not only did he broke one of the ethical rules in diagnosis that the person must be diagnosed directly, but also because he does not act professionally when cross-examined by Johnny Depp’s lawyers. Many of the patient reviews on him were one stars with a common issue that he treated his patients terribly, without respect. How did Dr. David Speigal even get this job anyways?
I’m sure he’s legit doctor, but a paid one. If they pay tens of thousands of dollars to testify in behalf of someone, surely you can find a doctor for it. And also, if your side wins, I bet you get lots of attention, something all older “experts” would love.
he's actually brilliant if you listen to him give serious answers - he's just got a lot of personality. nobody seemed to mind when Depp had that "colorful" witness who lives rent free in his penthouse
The Psychiatrist thought he was the smartest man in the room and thought that the back and forth between him and Johnnys team was a game, it’s very apparent in how he speaks and even to the point when he said he’s checking the lawyers “processing speed”. The problem for him was that he wasn’t the smartest man in the room and was thoroughly debunked, discredited, embarrassed, and even admonished by the judge.
Yeah, anyone called to give expert testimony should understand that you basically have no idea of what happens in a courtroom if you do not spend your professional life there, and you should be rather humbled by that fact.
From the look on Dr . Speigel face in the thumbnail I'm gonna guess his dog stepped on a bee . Offf . Wayne Dennison rocked him so hard . Props to Brown Rudnick 👏🙌👌😍💯
Johnny's attorney nails this guy in a Columbo style that is pure genius. A brilliant mind in action is truly beautiful to watch and Johnny's attorney comes across as both a gentleman and a genius,
1:45 love he’s so animated and overly responsive but when he gets trapped in a corner and has to admit, he lets out the weakest, faintest “mhm”. So pitiful Lmaoo
@@reneerakes7677 This doctor admitted that diagnosing Depp without seeing him is unethical, then proceeded to diagnose him without seeing him. This doctor is an unethical quack.
@@reneerakes7677 maybe the fact he’s never spoken/met him but has formed a ‘professional’ opinion. A credible professional would have done the evaluation face-to-face at least. Not to mention, how he compares his job to an actors. They are worlds apart, not comparable but to him, it’s his reference point. Nothing he says makes sense, he backtracks, he’s on stand and asks if he has to answer questions which obviously he does. It’s not so much JD’s lawyers word, it’s someone who is supposed to be a professionals word that we are hanging on to. This is supposed to be a professional and he is behaving like this, it’s outrageous.
I don’t think you know how a lot of doctors work. They don’t actually have to do the scan or test themselves, they can read the results/outcomes of the scan/test and evaluate and diagnose from that too.
This guy is so rude and condescending to the lawyer doing the Cross examination. I feel bad for his clients. Why do all of AH's witnesses look at the jury incessantly?? That's so annoying if you're a juror.
That's an actual trial strategy. You shouldn't do it each and every question but-- eye contact with members of the jury can create a sense of "honesty." You can also spot sympathetic jurors when doing it.
It's his career so he knows all the tactics, you're supposed to speak to the jurors because that is who you are giving your testimony to. He isn't trying to convince the other sides lawyer, he's trying to convince the jurors.
@@republicoftexas4651 Well, right after this case, that strategy is gonna be thrown outta the window since the entirety of AH's Inept people used it in exchange of logical arguments and solid evidences.
My father is an attorney and his sister (my aunt) is a psychologist. They are both completely appalled with how AH’s team has conducted themselves and my aunt can’t believe this guy is an expert witness.
@@chasermalloy7406 Why? Are you a psychologist? Cause you sound like just another overly eager narcissist, certain of your own superior intellect. You expect people to respect your opinion, yet you treat others like fools when they don't share it. Am I reading too much into a single sentence reply you uttered online? Maybe. You just come off as a total tool.
Every witness and character they presented in this trial, shows how the legal system can easily be manipulated if done right. Imagine how many victims had to go through the same process but only to get demolished by a much smarter, calculated, non-violent and charismatic narcissist.
Maybe not smarter, exactly , rather more sneaky and willing to pick and choose, and mislead , i would say . And yes, your right , those test are not a iq test, nor a test for evaluate a person either. It van be quite misleading,actually.
The alarming thing is, most of Amber’s witnesses are always weird or seem off the rails. This is a normal occurrence in her life. These are people she surrounds herself with. Just shows you how batshit crazy Amber really is! 😩
Energy attracts energy. These people are also dark narcissistic souls. They are the only ones who would sell out and take money to destroy someone’s life that for all they know is innocent.
@@Peter-lb8pv If you watch carefully Peter you will notice that this gentleman has a propensity to destroy Johnny Depp’s character. Whom he hasn’t met ever in his life, for a few dollars. It’s called intuition. If you can’t see what’s happening, I feel as bad for you as I do the dr. On the stand
My ex girlfriend was narcissistic, controlling, spread lies about me, cheated and in the end stalked me. It's been 5 years and I still can't say her name and still have trust issues. If I had to face her in court and listen to her spew more lies about me I'd probably break down crying in all honesty. I cannot imagine how hard this has all been for Johnny. He puts on a brave face because he has to and disguises his pain with humor but he can't even say her name or look at her. I know he's hurting from all this so thank god he's got a good team who care about him.
I am glad the girlfriend you are talking about is an ex. Anything out of that is better for you. I was in a similar situation and I feel very happy that that person has become my ex too :)
Terrible. I know exactly what you're saying. They rip you apart. I don't know how he is coping in the court. I doubt he will ever trust a woman again. I also pray that you will find recovery as well.
The first girl I ever cared about was like that and it has made things hard on me even years after we broke up. Got someone good rn tho. I make it hard for her sometimes because of the things I think about but I'm working on it and I believe I found someone I'll spend the rest of my life with :)
He is actually a very intelligent scientist, but all those time travels took a huge toll on him.. I think it would be better for Marty to first help him straightened all those jumbled up timeline in his head before he showed up in court.. Poor professor..
So basically, this guy has never talked to Johnny *IN PERSON*, yet psychologically evaluated him by just watching his recorded deposition?! OMG, OMG, OMG! I feel so sorry for the American psychology and law fields :(( Such a travesty!
Right, watching an interview does not qualify you to render ANY diagnosis, and this guys is waaaay too vehement in his "professional" opinions without having done any proper assessment of the individual in question. This is so embarrassing for the psych profession, the legal system, and for everyone involved. What a f@@king circus
As a clinician myself that administers the mini mental status, this psychiatrist is wrong and one would not diagnose if it wasn't your patient especially not doing the full mini mental. There are numerous reasons a person wouldn't remember the 3 words. For example, he's thinking about something more pressing.
When I'm stressed out after 7 hours in an OR, we change staff. Or after 8 hours max because your cognitive abilty drops significantly under stress and when you have to concentrate on one thing for a long period of time. Pair that common occurence with ADHD and you know why someone can't remember three words. When I get out of work, I often can't build a straight sentence for half an hour because I have to adjust.
Yes, all in all a score of 27 or what he meant is totally fine. And especially these memory questions are tricky, people get those wrong all the time. Nothing to worry about. Also you would have to do an additional test, getting more into memory function if you suspect a disorder from these small mistakes, because it is just a quick screening instrument, not a full psychological test battery!
I was a nurse for many years, including 5 years working in an acute mental health inpatient unit. I completely agree with you 👍🏾 This gentleman is rather strange in my opinion. 🤦🏻♀️
The big red flag I had was he was constantly looking at the jury when Amber's lawyers were asking the questions But with Johnny's lawyer not once did he look at the jury...that alone tells me he's being biased and was rehearsed with Amber's lawyers what to say.
I believe that there is nothing wrong about being bias as a witness IF you reveal why (being paid big money would be a commun reason) and you don't go into exageration/stay true/professional ! And I saw no expert testimony here.
I'm scared for this guy's patients! He completely unraveled under cross. It's strange to have an "expert witness" act so emotional and agitated. He needs an eval ASAP!
I watched this bloke live and I just have to say, I don’t think he’ll be getting hired anywhere else after this Side note, Ben Chew’s expressions during this clown’s testimony are priceless......
This "Psychiatrist" actually seems like he himself needs a real Psychiatrist LMAO
😝😝😝
So true 😂😁
👏🙌
Yeah he looks and communicates very weirdly
🤣🤣😂😭
RIP to all those who got analyzed their mental status by this doctor. I'm sure Not many would have survived.
Apparently, according to reviews, people did die as a result of this man's incompetence.
they talk like him at the end of the therapy "you're fine to me now so you can go" he used to say.
Right? I feel sorry for his patients!!
Unbelievable that this man is still practicing! He should have been eliminated long time ago!!!
@@mrs_ana1236 And he's member of the Psychiatrist association itself. What a disgrace!
This doctor actually terrified me. Diagnosing someone despite never talking to him, what a shame of a “professional”
He didnt diagnose him. He stated that on the MMSE Depps memory was bad for a 58 year old.
The doctor admitted to diagnosing his patients the same way he deduced Johny’s cognitive state.
It is called forensic psychology. It is widely accepted in courtrooms and is nothing controversial.
He didnt diagnose anyone.
And yes you can identify diseases/issues without having spoken to someone, for instance bloodtest results. Video recordings. Happens all the time.
He should be in the next Silence of the Idiots…?
This lawyer is absolutely amazing to destroy all theories of these “profesionals” by questioning their credibility and true knowledge. Amazing just as the rest of the team.
This psychiatrist is in love with his own voice. He is unprofessional, condescending and I can’t believe that the Judge didn’t throw out his testimony after telling him many times to just answer the question.
Hmmm...You haven't worked with a Lot of Doctors? He's a Classic case especially in Psyche. This guy just seems to have a very heavy NYC demeanor, accent and most certainly considers himself the top of the Intellect chain.
Yeah, wonder what disorder HE is suffering from... He should go talk to someone. lol
He's also as mad as a box of Frogs!
Most psychiatrists are very condescending.
@@cynthiaburrus3901 so he's basically nuts and from new york
There's no way this guy is a Psychiatrist. The way he physically presents himself and talks alone make me wonder just how easy it is to be employed as a psychiatrist in America.
At a teaching hospital no less. I wonder if they will be reconsider his employment.
Scanning the comments to see if anyone recognizes him as an actor.
I personally find that some Psychiatrists are the craziest ones of all.
You'd be SURPRISED to realize how easy it is for basically any ambulatory transfer student at a community college to get into some of the best Universities and go on to get a Masters & PhD in Psychology as a mediocre student & person. The entire field of Psychology is one of the least competitive if not the least competitive of the "Sciences" to get a Degree.
@@shawndrarush1683 that's true, sadly
This guy is so incredibly unprofessional. And he's dangerous because the state has recognized his authority as a doctor. He needs to be reviewed by a board and have past clients looked into.
I'm impressed amber found such awful people, they stick together ig
Hannibal Lecter is a fellow Psychiatrist...
Hannibal Lecter thinks he's a disgrace to the practice...
Hannibal Lecter will invite him to a gourmet dinner.
Your absolutely right!!!!! Someone needs to call the ethics committee. This man is completely crazy and he’s caring for others. This is outrageous
@@jackrespi8369 Hannibal lecter is a fictional character.
@@WickedPhase King wrote something to this effect in Doctor Sleep when the story revisits the Overlook. Evil calling evil back home, or something like that.
This lawyer needs to be applauded. He played this perfectly. Sometimes it's best to just people on the stand ramble. More often than not, they end up hanging themselves all on their own! Well done.
He handed that poor guy a noose and just let him hang himself lol. What an absolute masterclass in lawyering.
Once he gets going.. then he rips them to shreds. Best on second viewing for full appreciation.
I was cracking up..At one point Dennison was smirking looking at the clock!!! (He allowed this looney witness to demolish himself) 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🙄🙄🙄
This guy was the real narcissist in the courtroom. Arrogant and rude
And crazy 🤣
I hate this guy
YES
Do not insult Amber Heard like that, how dare you lol
And sociopaat
Just because you have “Dr” in front of your name, does not mean you are a credible human being. Those days are gone, where people assume you are a decent person, based on your profession. You have to earn credibility.
Exactly!
He went to quack university
He seemed as much a narcisist as heard.. Flocks of a feather..
Agree! I work at a very important place (i cant name the company obv) and some of the top doctors in the field that i meet every day ....are absolutely crazy and idiotic! One of them accidentally killed a woman by swapping out her trial date to make room for her tea party!! It's disgusting.
Definitely. I’ve worked with a lot of Drs as an assistant and I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard them gossip about patients conditions behind their back but put up a smile when they talk to them. A huge majority of ppl become Drs for the status and money and honestly they don’t give a crap about caring for patients at all.
This guy is hysterical. What a fun witness to watch. He's totally clueless that his combative narcissistic arrogance is making him look like a total tool and uncredible witness.
It would be funny if it wasn’t so sad.
Tool. Sums it up.
This is like straight out of snl
I wonder how old he is ? He has to he way older than JD.
Leave him alone! After the trial they'll give him his Flux capacitor and he'll be gone
Imagine being ill, and in desperate need of help, and winding up on this guy's doorstep...
Imagine this guy has been your psychiatrist for years and you see him on TV. And you see how batshit crazy the man helping you is.
Good screenplay idea!
Right? It would literally make you question not only any diagnosis, but your own sanity.
I have not met one psychiatrist that was helpful or normal. This guy though, is absolutely horrifying. I hope his license is removed asap!
I’d rather not…
To be honest, this kind of Psychiatrist is perfect for Hollyweird.
This psychiatrist as an APA member brings the APA into gross disrepute. An evaluation of his competence is needed urgently.
That part!!!
Well, the APA is a joke, designed like the ABA primarily to do two things:
1) keep salaries high
2) protect psychiatrists against suits brought by patients
APA has been completely corrupted by insane left wing ideologues
He comes across as cold and dogmatic, not personable and sympathetic. I wonder what his patients feel about him? Seriously.
I’m pretty sure he was asked if he was an APA member and replied that he was not, therefore did not know the rules.
This guy is doing nothing for the case while also destroying his career and credibility.
And that's a good thing. He's only helping Johnny's case, not Amber's.
I think his credibility was already very minimalistic and you have an incredibly accurate point - something he had was lacking throughout this entire process.
He is doing something! He's eating up AH's time ;)
Freedom of Speech is amazing when given to any American, but very few are given the ability to transform speech into utterly words and meanings to not pertain to this human in any sense out of the hearing of his own voice
He's also reduced the already dubious reputation of the APA
He is Atty. Wayne Dennison, for those who doesn't know his name, and yes, he is underrated. He did a very good job in this trial as much as Camille and Ben, and the other members of the legal team
Interesting that none of Amber’s experts have met with JD and are, instead, basing things off movies and what they’ve been told 🧐
Exactly...isn't it "hearsay" 😂
The witnesses from yesterday seemed really combative too.
Exactly
Exactly! This whole thing is a movie! Comedy, drama, horror, incompetence...
@@lc4252 Experts are exempt from this rule. They can rely on hearsay to make an opinion
This guy absolutely terrifies me. The way he speaks, the way he gestures around, what he is saying, his attitude... everything is raising red flags by me.
He's nuts himself.
He's extremely unethical.
He looks murderer
When the first time i saw him, i be like "are they joking? This man cant be real 😦"
I swear watching this trial is like watching a fictional tv show 🤣 pure comedy and entertainment every second. This psychiatrist sounds unstable
I’m a doctor, this is absolutely not what we do in clinical medicine, this man is a massive weirdo
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Here for the MASSIVE WEIRDO lingo 😂💕
Not much of aa doctor either. Do all of you resort to name calling.
Hi doctor BBNBBNBBN!
Yea I gotta say the clip of this guy talking doesn't help people who are already on the fence about seeking psychiatric help, it's scary to think about how many more people with a degree out there like this guy are just probably misdiagnosing people and destroying their minds with the wrong meds
This man is seriously UNHINGED.
Aside from Amber, HE is the only one who needs a psychiatrist. Like ASAP!
He and AH are peas in a pod.
He and Amber take turns and become each others psychologists according to the needs.
The way that “psychiatrist” talks.. his demeanor… his body language… He’s always talking down to them. He is so off-putting I cant explain it
Yeah I think that’s why the lawyers let him go rogue a couple times- so the jury can clearly see his combative and off the rails demeanor
He’s cocky
He is on something
He needs a psychiatrist 😂
Actually, it's depp's laywer that talks down and attacks the psychiatrist! It's kinda their job, so ok, -and if you listen to what's going on the psychiatrist is actually refusing to be manipulated and be talked down to, he does not let him self get affected by the game the laywer is playing.
I feel sorry for anyone that encountered this doctor, especially for anybody who is looking for mental health help. Good grief!
🤣👏
This man would trigger my anxiety so badly. Jfc
He drinks Gatorade. Full of toxic ingrediants. He's probably mentally impaired himself
"doctor"
He probably hid the bodies in his backyard. He seems very unstable!
I’m a licensed therapist and this psychiatrist is a narcissist himself! Unfortunately LOTS of narcissists in the field with savior complexes…
You're a licensed therapist, okay. Anyone who offers advice is a "therapist." You probably have a Bachelor's Degree in Psychology. If that's all you've got, you should know you're not able to diagnose mental disorders.
100 percent NARC!!!
Yes, unfortunately LOTS of physicians are like him. Scary AF
Meanwhile you couldn’t help but chime in and announce you’re a therapist lol
As a licensed therapist you should know you can’t diagnose someone off anecdotal, and finite, trial testimony. Don’t do the same unprofessional thing you accuse him of doing
This attorney did a great job and was not given enough credit!
Very true.. he was excellent when he cross-examined the expert witnesses
Agree!
Are you serious?? If so, you need psychiatric help!
Camille got a lot of spotlight for the direct grilling of Heard, but this man has been crushing every expert witness that team Heard put on the stand.
You may be right about the Lawyer not getting enough credit but I hope he was at least given enough cash.
The saddest thing is, people who genuinely need help go to this guy.
Hopefully not after this!!
yeah but they probably quickly realise how they don't actually need any help at all but that he does.
Nope, what's worse is if government entities commission him to do reports on people, like in the family court, justice system, child protection. That destroys lives.
There are MANY psychiatrists and doctors just like him!!
Wake up!
The real psychiatrist is tied up in his basement
It is literally unethical for any therapist to give a diagnosis without personally assessing an individual in their office. You just can't look at someone, listen to them and diagnose them just from that, without ever talking to them personally
Isn't there a difference between giving an expert opinion and a diagnosis?
@@nela3986 there is. One is a diagnosis that can be used to receive treatment that is generally not allowed. Other one is just an opinion
Unfortunately, maybe a lawyer can confirm or deny there can be treating physicians or just experts who can speak in court based on generalized opinion. 😱
Yes this guy is batshit crazy but he didn't diagnose anyone
Didn't you know, they have a crystal ball
This lawyer was absolutely the best man for the job here. He let the witness ramble on just enough to contradict himself and discredit much of his 'evaluation'
He’s a partner for the firm. Him and Ben Chew have obviously been doing this for a longggggg time and I’m sure to have them represent you is so much money
This lawyer oozes so much confidence despite having some sort of stuttering in his speaking ability.
💯
@@nazrey8910 His speech pattern made me nervous to start but not any more
Why It’s Time to Believe Amber Heard
BY RAVEN SMITH
May 17, 2022
This guy actually had the nerve to write a news article on how he was “hurt” by the backlash of this trial.
Are you serious? Where can I find it. He's probably driven more people to insanity than he's helped.
really! where can we find it?
@@richardkrupa7319 😂👏🏼
@@richardkrupa7319 and he had the nerve to use the same setup for his title that Amber used for her op-Ed
@@richardkrupa7319 ‘'I Testified in the Heard vs. Depp Trial. The Backlash Has Been Horrific”
*THIS Therapist needs a therapist*
And a COMB! 😅
And abusers need life in prison
He is beyond help
Who said he isn't seeing one already
this guy is stereotype for people thinking doctors have egos
When you accidentally hire a psychopath instead of a psychologist.
😁😁
😂
😅
🤣🤣🤣🤣
I like him😂😂😂
Ridiculous! Seems like someone who escaped from an asylum rather than being a psychiatrist. I cannot believe a word he says. He tries to justify whatever he says and it still does not make sense!
Make sense they are all liberals, another mental illness.
😭😭😭😭😭💯 this is the best comment ❤️👍
😂😂😂😂
Thought the same thing. Experts that are paid to testify not someone who treats Who would go to this character?
Well yeah, he clearly stole a doctor’s clothes to sneak out, but on his way out people pulled him in for an emergency so he had to play along and he’s been playing along ever since because he didn’t think he’d ever get that far.
Another fine performance for 'The Wizard Destroyer', Mr Dennison.
Imagine going to this guy for psychiatric help, and then realizing he needs it more than you do.
Ikr! 😂🤣
Lol so true!
Yeah, I've seen ones that never realize their mental issues but show off their knowledge on psychology to others.
Haha so true😂😂🤣🤣
This man made all sorts of mistakes, but his biggest was being defensive like he was on trial himself. He is attacking, because he feels personally attacked.
The biggest mistake was waking up in the morning and thinking "I'm gonna nail this questioning because I'm so much smarter than the lawyers"
Main character syndrome... In his mind this is all about him and his performance on the stand
@@YRWB98 Exactly. He went up there like this trial was about him, and that led to it getting really weird. Could've saved himself and AH some trouble if he just answered simply, and under control to play his part. The crazy hair and crackhead mannerisms was just icing on the cake.
And he is is feeling personally attacked... probably because he knows *he* is being called out publicly...in front of millions of ppl potentially...that he is not a person who should be qualified to do what he is doing. That man shouldn't be evaluating, treating, or advising anyone. If anything... He is quite dangerous. Just think of all the poor ppl that would seek out this man for help?
😂
The psychiatrist never talked to Johnny Depp during his studying of Depp's behaviour. WHAT ON EARTH?!
Exactly, why is he on the stand??
Where does Amber's team come up with these people? Grasping at straws
@@Octo-yo because he s one of the rare people to agree with her. Shows how bad her case is, if this is one of the best experts she has.
I don’t know what the law system is in America but in Germany you can’t study someone without their consent - in Germany he could get in to jail for one year for such a thing ✌️
unbelievable. 07:01 LMAO!!! TH......no b!tch I'm not going to let you answer!! hahaha blow to his ego
Wow!! This is must definitely NOT Evidence-based Medicine. As a Medical Doctor I got no words to justify the behavior from this Psychiatrist.
Also… I’m so IMPRESSED by Depp’s lawyer on stand. Amazing! He did his homework and got to the level of this psychiatrist to fight his argument eloquently.😍
It’s terrifying to know this psychiatrist is diagnosing people and guiding people with their lives.
I just posted a video about Johnny's expression when this crazy guy was talking lol check it out in my channel !!
Please keep me a million miles away from this so call psychiatrist! He likes to hear himself speak! My heavens!
I busted out laughing at your comment is it so true and funny 😂
And it's terrifying those lawyers try to defend an abuser
Well the guy himself is scary
“Johnny lacks empathy” WHAT!!?? The man who goes to many hospitals to visit children and makes them smile and hugs them and takes time to speak with them, that’s just one example..
How does he even KNOW Johnny lacks empathy??? Like has he ever even met him or assess him to know that enough?? This man is just weird 🙄
And welcome people to live in his houses for free🤷🏼♀️
@@ninixvean4156 lets people leech off of him, helped several fans he met throughout his life financially, makes friends and takes time to chat with everyone around him such as the stenographer, the security etc
Along with the millions johnny has donated to charity...unlike amber heard
And you...don't think narcissist can have a charming and nice facade? I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but that's kinda how they get away with it. Not saying that Depp is, but it's easy to be fooled by someone who know how to play nice. Btw. he has probaly done four visits in over ten years, all with cameras around.
Full marks to Depp’s attorney for keeping his cool and handing this “expert” a shovel to dig his own hole with the jury👍🏻
I’m sick and tired of the attempts to silence JD fans on social media!
Facts 💯
Shovel?..more like a backhoe!
You heard in his voice a couple of times that he wanted to just tell this twit to do one
@@mrabrasive51 🤣🤣🤣
Are you sure he’s the doctor or one of his patients stole his identify.
Lol nice
😅😅😅
Priceless. I thought AH team cannot go lower. But they can. Some people have no limits.
Everyday I see AH's team & each day they hit a new low
@@I_am_Sri true😅
This is turning into a game of how low can you go at this point 😂
They are really scrapping the bottom of the barrel given which "experts" testified today...
True!😆
This Psych has shown so much bias and unprofessionalism that it's surprising the judge has not thrown his testimony away
actually, I would say the total opposite!
@@hypsnos how exactly?
@@hypsnos may I ask how?
@@ItsmeBish584 i think that comment is trying to troll considering their name.
Agreed
He is a prime example of what makes people NOT seek mental health treatment. His own mental health seems questionable. I’m truly concerned for his prior patients and anyone who has been his victim by means of misdiagnosis, gross lack of judgment, and people he’s testified for/against in the past. Not only did he inaccurately assess Johnny, but he inaccurately assessed Amber also (which is what he was paid to do TBH). He completely had them reversed, and he shows some of those traits himself. The bit about Johnny lacking empathy and Amber being an empathetic person was just too much!
I understand what you're saying, but who knows what chain of events made him reach the position he found himself in.
It seems like he knows how wrong he is but has no choice but to do it anyway. Hence the obvious discomfort and arrogance.
@@JoeyJoeJoe87 $1000 per hour of deposition and $5000 per day of court.
What made you say that he's a bad psychologist? I haven't seen any psychologist able to boast that they can accurately diagnose a mental condition based on movie actings and interviews. I bet this man is able to read thoughts through his special tv. If anything, he's the best psychologist in the world.
@@lightkira4119 obviously a lot of money is being paid to him, but maybe he's on the brink of bankruptcy after some catastrophic events where he's given up his last shits to give.
@@mic300391 had me in the first half, ngl
100% he stood up and walked off the stand, thinking he “won” the cross examination.
I am so sorry to any person who has ever been treated by this “professional”. I hope you had better treatment elsewhere ♥️
Why It’s Time to Believe Amber Heard
BY RAVEN SMITH
May 17, 2022
Is this crap of a thing a psychiatrist? Jesus Christ!
Marija, please seek psychiatric help. You are in dire need of it
@@marijacvitanovic4298 ????
Look up his reviews..shocking
The fact that this guy is paid to give his professional opinion on people's mental states is absolutely terrifying...
It also explains why so many people who need help remain utterly fcuked up...
They sell their souls to devil. Absolutely clowns.
😭😭😭
Right that scares me because he is someone they would have evaluate murders. Smh so sad
Exactly
Ha ha ha absolutely brilliantly said 🤣
This guy thinks he's the smartest man in the room. He's a fool. Who in their right mind would trust him?
Exactly
he probably is the smartest person in that courtroom though…
He ended up becoming the biggest fool. Hahahahah
Hate to admit this but maybe just maybe Scientology is right about Psychology
AH clearly trusts him, shes a giant fool
Guys like this are why getting a second opinion is important. The fact that Heard's team thought this guy should on the stand says everything.
I feel comfortable labelling this guy as "a cretinous, psychopathic narcissist" because clinically I know as much about him as he knows about Johnny Depp. He is deeply unprofessional.
If everyone was “diagnosed” over a few out of context videos or whatever, then 95% of the world would be labelled as crazy and depressed
True😂
Truly unprofessional and disturbing.
Lol
A normal person can just call him unprofessional by just his responses
Such a provocative psychiatrist. I would never go to him for any consultation
Facts. I feel like I would need to see a real psychiatrist after speaking to him 1 on 1.
That's because he's a con man... and a terrible con man at that.
Ditto!
He'd probably be able to "diagnose" you with 30 unknown underlying subtle cases of different personality disorders. "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "no" "so are you angry?" "for the last time no" "ahh so you need anger management, gotcha, want an appointment tomorrow?"
You know, it’s quite scary knowing that this “psychiatrist” has a license. He comes across really sketchy.
He looks like he stole his license from a man he knifed in a dark alleyway 😬
He's the only one that would accept the job.
Flocks of the clowns sticks together.
Ahahahaha I know wtf
This "PSYCHIATRIST" is and UNHINGED LUNATIC... how he still has a license to practice Medicine is beyond my realm of logical comprehension.
Its been more than a month and i still cant wrap my head around the decision of AH legal team to put this guy there…
I'am sure they regret not having a 3 hour meeting/dinner with this 🤭 "expert witness" 😉
To think that this man is diagnosing, „helping“ and „guiding“ people is actually scary.
You're right! But I don't think we have to worry about that, not if they've watched him testify.
Did you seen the video of this bloke on the stand. Looks like he's on drugs his jaw was all over the shop was terrible. Also jonny depps face and his lawyers face was priceless in response to this so called doctor 🙃😬🙄🤨🤨🤔🤔
I would run away from him in seconds.
I’d really be worried if he were my doctor. Seriously!
This is so bad...imagine having him as a psychiatrist and just feeling 100x worse then you did initially. Absolutely worrysome 😕
I feel like I know people e.g my gf that are of a similar personality. I.e never answering questions directly, gaslighting, misrepresenting and misunderstanding on purpose all in the name of making themselves, atleast to themselves, appear better and more sane.
Scary
His patients leave feeling better because they aren’t as nuts as their doctor. How could Heard’s lawyers make this clown any part of this trial? They should have gone back to the muffins instead of putting him on the stand.
He’s rich
My life will always get blame even that are not fault.. because of them
This man was so unprofessional… it was hard to watch.
It was soooo funny. A bit of entertainment for the day before starting work
And this guy is qualified to diagnose your sanity? Scary.
I live in Chesapeake which is very close to Norfolk, I can’t believe this man has a degree and actually treats people. I would feel so degraded by him.
HE IS THE BEST IN HIS FIELD. WHAT DO U KNOW ABOUT PSYCHIATRY?
@@stylishboy004 bot account detected
@@deb4him yes he said at the beginning he works at Norfolk general
@@lucasfreeland8412 HE IS THE BEST OF THE BEST. AMBER'S TEAM HIRED THE BEST. RESPECT AND BOW DOWN TO.HIM.
@@stylishboy004 lol nice trolling, u managed to get one dude haha. L
For a man not in medical field the way JD s attorney handled this guy deserves applauds.
Exactly!
Applause?
It's just Logic, anything else.
Well assesment without actual contact is just crazy, it is like you record yourself, send your record to a doctor and said, go on doctor diagnose what is wrong with me
I rather go crazy than have this guy as my therapist.
😆 Brilliant
yep!
Lmaooo
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
You know, I used to tell my cousin that there aren't real people who are as deranged as some of the characters in GTA. But then I watched this Trial and I found myself taking that statement back every time one of Amber's witnesses came up. Her whole legal team were a bunch of dribbling clowns.
Based on my lack of knowledge about this pysychiatrist, or his ability, or anything else, about him, I can attest to the fact that he is cognitively impaired.
😂😂😂😂😂 great shout😂😂😂 I'm.laughen me head of here..
Agreed..
Ironically enough, you have more knowledge about this man through the viewing of this clip alone than this man's knowledge of Johnny Depp, the person he supposedly has to examine thoroughly
and egotistically constipated
Lol!!!😂😂😅
He keeps using “fancy” terms to come off professional and knowledgeable but a true professional speaks in terms in which a general audience can understand (like how Dr. Curry did)
My exact thoughts!
Totally agree
Agreed, any doctor or professional in that field will always use simpler words in their explanation so that common people can understand
Yes, or they typically use professional terms and then they explain in detail what that exactly means
I haven't heard a single fancy term yet. He's just a s*** talking gaslighting ahole
I did not realize that if you get caught lying on the stand, under oath, all you have to say is, "I'm sorry. I guess I misspoke." Good to know.
LOL
“I’m thinking back” , that he should have stayed home today. 🤣😂🤣
Where did they get this psychiatrist? I feel sorry for his patients. He is combative, loves to talk and I can only imagine him with a patient. He would be charging them to listen to him instead of the other way around.
He’s incompetent! He doesn’t know what he’s talking about! That line about “thats what we do in clinical medicine sir” is terrifying! Because is this the way he actually practices?!?!
Amber's team is grasping at straws
I suspect he doesn’t actually have many patients. If I ran across this useless, arrogant, condescending, surly m/f’er for one of my therapy sessions I’d walk right out of the office, file a formal complaint and move on. I actually did do that once with someone quite like him. Then found someone who was phenomenal. A psychotherapist vs psychiatrist. I think the clowns with a med degree are insufferably arrogant.
I worked in law enforcement for many years… many of our arrests had to have mental health professionals give clearance for jail. I can’t EVER remember meeting a mental health worker that was sane themselves!!! True story!!!
Mental health in our country is a DISASTER!!
He bought his degree rather than earned it from the looks
The lawyer is sharp. He is very calculative. He managed to lead the jury to cast doubt on the doctors credibility. And made fun of him while doing so.
He is the kind of lawyer u would recommend or want on your team 😉
I don't think that it's really all that hard to cast doubt on 'expert witnesses' who presented themselves with this kind of manner.
That psychiatrist probably hurt Ambers case rather than help it. What a nightmare! He has no proper basis for his opinion, he is woefully inept, and his very demeanor is so awful it’s hard not to hate this guy.
Yep
This is the BEST AH's team could get?
Wait amber had a case to begin with?
I think your right, seems like he was very biased.
@@piyush7322 lol
Imagine being unwell and they send that guy to help you...
This psychiatrist doesn’t seem legitimate. Not only did he broke one of the ethical rules in diagnosis that the person must be diagnosed directly, but also because he does not act professionally when cross-examined by Johnny Depp’s lawyers. Many of the patient reviews on him were one stars with a common issue that he treated his patients terribly, without respect. How did Dr. David Speigal even get this job anyways?
I’m sure he’s legit doctor, but a paid one. If they pay tens of thousands of dollars to testify in behalf of someone, surely you can find a doctor for it. And also, if your side wins, I bet you get lots of attention, something all older “experts” would love.
He based his theory on the paycheck
Objection your Honor 🙋🏻♂️, the answer is lack of foundation
Corruption in Health Care System.
@@andybelcher1767 amen
Wow. I feel so bad for those who ever have had this man as their psychiatrist :(
My thoughts too
This psychiatrist needs a psychiatrist
@Jay R I agree bro 💯
he's actually brilliant if you listen to him give serious answers - he's just got a lot of personality. nobody seemed to mind when Depp had that "colorful" witness who lives rent free in his penthouse
The Psychiatrist thought he was the smartest man in the room and thought that the back and forth between him and Johnnys team was a game, it’s very apparent in how he speaks and even to the point when he said he’s checking the lawyers “processing speed”. The problem for him was that he wasn’t the smartest man in the room and was thoroughly debunked, discredited, embarrassed, and even admonished by the judge.
Yeah, anyone called to give expert testimony should understand that you basically have no idea of what happens in a courtroom if you do not spend your professional life there, and you should be rather humbled by that fact.
That's how he treats patients.
From the look on Dr . Speigel face in the thumbnail I'm gonna guess his dog stepped on a bee . Offf . Wayne Dennison rocked him so hard . Props to Brown Rudnick 👏🙌👌😍💯
Johnny's attorney nails this guy in a Columbo style that is pure genius. A brilliant mind in action is truly beautiful to watch and Johnny's attorney comes across as both a gentleman and a genius,
1:45 love he’s so animated and overly responsive but when he gets trapped in a corner and has to admit, he lets out the weakest, faintest “mhm”. So pitiful Lmaoo
This Dr is great. I'm trying to understand why u guys believe abd hang on every word Depp attorney says lol 😂
@@reneerakes7677 This doctor admitted that diagnosing Depp without seeing him is unethical, then proceeded to diagnose him without seeing him.
This doctor is an unethical quack.
Nope, seconds before that he already answered and explained. The lawyer thought repeating the question would suddenly get a different response.
@@reneerakes7677 maybe the fact he’s never spoken/met him but has formed a ‘professional’ opinion. A credible professional would have done the evaluation face-to-face at least. Not to mention, how he compares his job to an actors. They are worlds apart, not comparable but to him, it’s his reference point. Nothing he says makes sense, he backtracks, he’s on stand and asks if he has to answer questions which obviously he does. It’s not so much JD’s lawyers word, it’s someone who is supposed to be a professionals word that we are hanging on to. This is supposed to be a professional and he is behaving like this, it’s outrageous.
He was saying yes, seems like you've no idea what's going on lol
He is like a doctor going round diagnosing people with cancer without ever scanning or testing them
I don’t think you know how a lot of doctors work. They don’t actually have to do the scan or test themselves, they can read the results/outcomes of the scan/test and evaluate and diagnose from that too.
@@JuneInjoy I do know and I also know you can’t come to a complete conclusion with incorrect and insufficient examination and results
He looks like a Mad Scientist,, Lmao!!! 😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫
This guy is so rude and condescending to the lawyer doing the Cross examination. I feel bad for his clients.
Why do all of AH's witnesses look at the jury incessantly?? That's so annoying if you're a juror.
Because they all are trained and paid actors from AH side.
That's an actual trial strategy.
You shouldn't do it each and every question but-- eye contact with members of the jury can create a sense of "honesty." You can also spot sympathetic jurors when doing it.
It's his career so he knows all the tactics, you're supposed to speak to the jurors because that is who you are giving your testimony to. He isn't trying to convince the other sides lawyer, he's trying to convince the jurors.
The worst is AH and her sad puppy dog eyes at the jury CONSTANTLY…even when the attorney’s are up talking to the judge…not just during her testimony 👀
@@republicoftexas4651 Well, right after this case, that strategy is gonna be thrown outta the window since the entirety of AH's Inept people used it in exchange of logical arguments and solid evidences.
Very well handled by mr Depp's lawyer. What a tool this " psychiatrist" is. I feel sad for the people that have gone to him for help.
My crack ohhh wot 🙃🙃🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪
He got cooked by the lawyer. Made his assesment look like it was a blind guess which basicly it was.
This guy is all over the place. My wife is a Psychiatrist and she face palming herself with disgust upon hearing this guys speak.🤦🏽♂️
My father is an attorney and his sister (my aunt) is a psychologist. They are both completely appalled with how AH’s team has conducted themselves and my aunt can’t believe this guy is an expert witness.
Why because he telling the truth about how majority (NOT ALL), MAJORITY psychiatrists unethically diagnoses patients?
If your wife is really a psychiatrist she should have easily recognized the absolute wreck depp is.
@@chasermalloy7406 Depp doesn't hide it..... you don't need an expert for that.
You think this is some kind of attack, it really isn't.
@@chasermalloy7406 Why? Are you a psychologist? Cause you sound like just another overly eager narcissist, certain of your own superior intellect. You expect people to respect your opinion, yet you treat others like fools when they don't share it.
Am I reading too much into a single sentence reply you uttered online? Maybe. You just come off as a total tool.
I can’t believe that this man is actually a Doctor, how is he qualified to treat, diagnose or evaluate anyone??
Hello fan
What an unprofessional individual
Absolutely embarrassing to even listen to him speak. Good GOD I'd hate him as a psychiatrist
imagine if you're an ACTUAL psychiatrist listening to this nut.
I feel like if he had to treat me with my mental illness, I would probably be more likely to actually off myself than without his treatment 😬
Every witness and character they presented in this trial, shows how the legal system can easily be manipulated if done right. Imagine how many victims had to go through the same process but only to get demolished by a much smarter, calculated, non-violent and charismatic narcissist.
But what is a role of this person in this case...
Maybe not smarter, exactly , rather more sneaky and willing to pick and choose, and mislead , i would say .
And yes, your right , those test are not a iq test, nor a test for evaluate a person either. It van be quite misleading,actually.
I’m so glad this is being televised. The media spun giving these clowns credibility is very worrying
so true
I’ve been there
As soon as he started talking I went WTF??? Is he the "Doc" from back to the future?
The alarming thing is, most of Amber’s witnesses are always weird or seem off the rails. This is a normal occurrence in her life. These are people she surrounds herself with. Just shows you how batshit crazy Amber really is! 😩
True!! I was just thinking that. She realy has surrounded herself with a very weird collection of flying monkeys.
birds of a feather, these are all ppl that she okay'd
Energy attracts energy. These people are also dark narcissistic souls. They are the only ones who would sell out and take money to destroy someone’s life that for all they know is innocent.
Is that your diagnosis without actually meeting her : )
@@Peter-lb8pv If you watch carefully Peter you will notice that this gentleman has a propensity to destroy Johnny Depp’s character. Whom he hasn’t met ever in his life, for a few dollars. It’s called intuition. If you can’t see what’s happening, I feel as bad for you as I do the dr. On the stand
The psychiatrist is truly unhinged. This was hilarious to watch 😂
He's an embarrassment....
😆🤣
Omg he is so funny and I actually think he knows what he is talking about. We all know poor JD has lost some brain cells from all the trauma 😒
He's a terrible excuse for a doctor of any kind. My dogs are better psychiatrists.
Can you believe this man has the authority to prescribe POWERful meds? Scary
My ex girlfriend was narcissistic, controlling, spread lies about me, cheated and in the end stalked me. It's been 5 years and I still can't say her name and still have trust issues. If I had to face her in court and listen to her spew more lies about me I'd probably break down crying in all honesty. I cannot imagine how hard this has all been for Johnny. He puts on a brave face because he has to and disguises his pain with humor but he can't even say her name or look at her. I know he's hurting from all this so thank god he's got a good team who care about him.
I am glad the girlfriend you are talking about is an ex. Anything out of that is better for you. I was in a similar situation and I feel very happy that that person has become my ex too :)
Terrible. I know exactly what you're saying. They rip you apart. I don't know how he is coping in the court. I doubt he will ever trust a woman again. I also pray that you will find recovery as well.
Sorry you went through that
The first girl I ever cared about was like that and it has made things hard on me even years after we broke up. Got someone good rn tho. I make it hard for her sometimes because of the things I think about but I'm working on it and I believe I found someone I'll spend the rest of my life with :)
People who haven’t had to deal with someone like this don’t understand the scars they cause. Shyt never goes away have fun trusting again.
He's really a patient what a joke. And that tongue plz make it make sense 😂🤣🤣
He is actually a very intelligent scientist, but all those time travels took a huge toll on him.. I think it would be better for Marty to first help him straightened all those jumbled up timeline in his head before he showed up in court..
Poor professor..
I was looking for someone who spotted his resemblance 😂
Excellent!!!
This comment!!! 😅😅😅😅
MARTY MARTY, I'M ADDICTED TO METHAPHETIMES MARTY
I NEED TO TAKE ON THIS GIG MARTY IT'LL HELP ME GET MY NEXT FIX MARTY
😄😄😄 I had to look up Back to the Future to get his name before I read this comment!!
Apparently this psychiatrist has a bunch of negative reviews. There's even one claiming that he killed one of his patients 3 years ago. Yikes.
Whattt
Let's not throw assumptions
@@Iza56 they’re just saying what they heard and learned. They aint throwing assumptions
@@AlexRodriguez-wh3el So... Objection, Hearsay? Did I do that right?
@@Polaremal sustained
He’s utterly unprofessional ….. !! I’d even go as far as to say “UNHINGED” …..
I loovveeeee this lawyer!!! He is sooooo relaxed and on point!!!
So basically, this guy has never talked to Johnny *IN PERSON*, yet psychologically evaluated him by just watching his recorded deposition?! OMG, OMG, OMG! I feel so sorry for the American psychology and law fields :(( Such a travesty!
Don't short change him... he watched pirates of the Caribbean too lol
@@marcusthompson548 but not 21 jump street
@@darbanville13 right lol. How could I forget that?
Right, watching an interview does not qualify you to render ANY diagnosis, and this guys is waaaay too vehement in his "professional" opinions without having done any proper assessment of the individual in question. This is so embarrassing for the psych profession, the legal system, and for everyone involved. What a f@@king circus
@@darbanville13 but not watching Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was also just as unforgivable.
As a clinician myself that administers the mini mental status, this psychiatrist is wrong and one would not diagnose if it wasn't your patient especially not doing the full mini mental. There are numerous reasons a person wouldn't remember the 3 words. For example, he's thinking about something more pressing.
I was wondering this, doesn’t stress lower your cognitive functioning? Seems pretty obvious to me.
As a pharmacist, i agree and he can't judge by the question only ( he kept saying that would be very telling )
When I'm stressed out after 7 hours in an OR, we change staff. Or after 8 hours max because your cognitive abilty drops significantly under stress and when you have to concentrate on one thing for a long period of time. Pair that common occurence with ADHD and you know why someone can't remember three words. When I get out of work, I often can't build a straight sentence for half an hour because I have to adjust.
Yes, all in all a score of 27 or what he meant is totally fine. And especially these memory questions are tricky, people get those wrong all the time. Nothing to worry about. Also you would have to do an additional test, getting more into memory function if you suspect a disorder from these small mistakes, because it is just a quick screening instrument, not a full psychological test battery!
I was a nurse for many years, including 5 years working in an acute mental health inpatient unit. I completely agree with you 👍🏾
This gentleman is rather strange in my opinion. 🤦🏻♀️
He was as bias and unprofessional as Heard's physciatrist that also diagnosed Johnny without meeting him. They hurt Amber's case, not help it.
The big red flag I had was he was constantly looking at the jury when Amber's lawyers were asking the questions
But with Johnny's lawyer not once did he look at the jury...that alone tells me he's being biased and was rehearsed with Amber's lawyers what to say.
I believe that there is nothing wrong about being bias as a witness IF you reveal why (being paid big money would be a commun reason) and you don't go into exageration/stay true/professional !
And I saw no expert testimony here.
Ben Chew is my spirit animal with his facial expressions! 🤣
I'm scared for this guy's patients! He completely unraveled under cross. It's strange to have an "expert witness" act so emotional and agitated. He needs an eval ASAP!
By Dr. Curry
@@himwiththehair8118 omg yes
That’s my psychiatrist and also my dealer, he has the best coke in town 😂🔥
Best comment online right now. 👏 👏 👏
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Does it burn bad and last a little too long? That’s meth
I watched this bloke live and I just have to say, I don’t think he’ll be getting hired anywhere else after this
Side note, Ben Chew’s expressions during this clown’s testimony are priceless......
I love Ben Chew!!!
Johnny's aswell. I loved both of their faces watching this riciculous man
He should lose his license, for starters.
Oh my. This guy is as crazy as a fox
LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!
The Nut doctor thinks he's smarter than the lawyers in a courtroom.