He is an excellent witness. He speaks well, sounds educated, gives clear, concise, easy to comprehend information/evidence. No theatrics, no embellishment. IMO, completely believable.
1:37 When he says "B-list celebrities," he subtly looks at, nods at, and gestures towards Amber. This man is an absolute savage and I'm so glad he was included in the lineup of fantastic characters brought onto the stand. I feel bad for Johnny for the whole situation, but I'd be a filthy liar if I said there wasn't a truckload of entertainment to experience with this case.
"Characters" that's a well-chosen word. It was JD's strategy to bring likable, trained "actors" backed by curated, edited evidence, to the courtroom. He had the money to throw at them. Amber didn't. He was counting on a shallow public to conclude that, if it looks good, feels good, and sounds good, it must be the truth. The public completely forgot that narcissists and sociopaths are the best at putting on these acts. Real people are raw and rough around the edges. This guy and his team maliciously set Amber up. One day, they'll pay the price.
@@ADumbNut1985 When you say "apologist" it means you've already set Amber Heard up as a criminal in your mind. There IS sufficient evidence that she suffered abuse at the hands of someone at least 20 years older than her. What I'm talking about is everyday politics which everyone is vulnerable to. Anyone, including you, can be set up and framed with a good enough legal team. Please remember that nothing is black and white. Cancellation is neither logical nor a solution.
As a “victim”, she submitted the video to TMZ instead of the police, that already explains everything! If this is not defamation, I don’t know wtf is……
@@AS-fu1kd I already don't trust the justice system, so as much as I want him to win, I'm sadly not expecting it to happen. I just hope at the very least the throw her counterclaim back in her face bruised face
This is the most absolute and definitive proof Johnny's team have that actively proves that Turd tried to defame him. If he loses this defamation lawsuit I'll literally be pissed forever and ever.
Pretty easy when you recall only the truth. But I agree, he did explain that process very well but it’s also the Attorney who did a great job with questioning.
The only way TMZ could obtain copyright of the cupboard video is from the copyright owner itself. Amber Heard filmed the video. Funny how she said she didn’t want any attention and now a witness disproves it 🤡
The guy smartly described the processes and internal controls of TMZ and proved that the video was received from the original source, Amber Heard, and did it with such finesse that he wouldn't be sued by TMZ for breaking the NDA and Employment Contract. Johny Depp's legal team is smart af.
@@kburdy no. He contacted them three days before. They rehearsed his deposition for sure. No say they just put him up there without knowing exactly what he was going to say.
Amber should def now be charged with perjury. She flat out lied, emphatically when asked if she sold stories or tipped TMZ. She said she would NEVER do that, nor did she even know how to do that! I wish they could replay that in court right now!
Before this trial, I thought AH is "just" a lying spouse who just want money and fame from Depp. This trials show that she's way worse. She's greedy all right, but she definitely want to destroy Depp's life for some seemingly petty reason.
@@dianebannister4591 Aye, consider the pressure as well, before lunch we had the TMZ lawyer there to keep a legal eye on anything he said. That suggests he knew a bit more but was perhaps limited on what he could say without TMZ litigation.
@@TiberiusWallace TMZ is just part of the machine that allowed Heard to create this story, and have zero scrutiny or doubt, about what she was claiming. They were there to shoot her makeup made bruise. TMZ just wanted clicks, and played right along with the ruining of another person, without caring whether it was legitimate or not. Several women have done videos on the “Bruise kit,” which is actually what most call it, and even Heard called it, when testifying.
🎩 ELAINE WASHINGTON 🧢 HEARDS TEAM HASN'T SAID ANYTHING. AS HEARSAY OR I OBJECT BECAUSE THEY HAVE GIVEN UP ! HEARD IS SITTING THERE TRYING ACT INNOCENT BUT SHE HAS GUILT WRITTEN ALL OVER HER FACE ! THAT GUILT STANDS OUT LIKE NEON LIGHTS OR THOSE IMAGINERY BRUISES ! SHE COULDN'T HIDE ALL THAT DECEPTION !🎭
@@PleaseNThankYou Is TMZ leftist? I don't watch or follow TMZ but I thought it was just stupid celebrity gossip and info that is way to personal about celebrities. I don't see how that can be considered political, let alone partisan.
This is what happens when you bring in actual witnesses and experts in their field who have no personal stake in what's happening. Not automatically biased personal friends and professional witnesses just looking for a payday.
She walked her way around that subject with ease, she never made a direct question but always stated the facts for you to puzzle together. She is so good
@@TurntReynolds I believe that this is to undermine Heard's creditability, since she had claimed that she didn't want any attention, Depp's team had argued that Heard's motive was specifically to drive media interest to her case, to boost Aquaman and because otherwise "No one would be interested of what she had to say." Heard had earlier testified that she was not expecting there to be paparazzi at the courthouse and that she was surprised about it after getting the restraining order. This I believe is also to point out that she lied.
@@TurntReynolds - "how long does it cost to copyright something TMZ received FROM A TIPLINE?" - "It can take a while becuz you have to verify blah blah blah........" - "how long does it take for TMZ to obtain a copyright for something received DIRECTLY FROM THE SOURCE?" - "something in the realm of 15 mins ........" - "how much time had passed since you received the kitchen video to the time it was posted on TMZ?" - "15 mins." Pieced them together now?
I love how this man came forward and was pretty much like, “hey that famous video of Johnny slamming cabinets was recorded and sent to us by Amber wanting attention and here I can prove it.” So many turning points in this trial I freaking love it. ❤
Yup. Especially given the fact Harvey at TMZ has a VERY close relationship with heard and has openly stated his position in all this. 👍🏻👍🏻 God I want TMZ to cease to exist.
Camille, once again, has demonstrated how brilliant she is. She was able to prove Amber provided the "tip" without having provided the direct evidence.
He straight up testified that she was supposed to turn toward the camera so that they could photograph a "bruise".... yet.... SHE herself testified, under oath, that she didn't know the paps were going to be there. She was their source.
@@lamsss I know someone who was jailed for years for perjury (and it wasn't even perjury, but she was testifying against some high-profile people so they nailed her). Why can't Heard be jailed for perjury?
@@big_von6232 he might be found in breach of contract with TMZ, and sued by the latter later. Or even blacklisted in the journalism industry at the very least. So really, Tremaine has a lot to lose personally but nothing to gain, which makes his willingness to testify very admirable.
@@big_von6232 being fired from TMZ and losing his job, as an immediate consequence. furthermore, other workplaces where he might be trying to get a job in the future, might not want to be affiliated with him, since he "betrayed"/"revealed" TMZ's company secrets - essentially not finding a job anymore in the workfield he is currently in. and potentially more. so yes, there are definitely risks for him to step up into the witness stand. edit: if you've followed the trial, there was a lawyer, sent by TMZ, to argue a motion to not grant the witness (Mr. Tremaine) into court at all, since it would infringe on the journalist-source trust - essentially trying to silence the witness.
Another psychiatrist testified that Amber apparently ticked some of the boxes for BPD. And honestly, based off of the evidence and testimonies we've seen in this case, I'm inclined to believe it. She comes across as *dangerously* unstable.
This was a brilliant way to get around TMZ not wanting to reveal their sources. Again, Brilliant. Surpassed expectations. Edit: I am aware that he no longer works for TMZ. That's why it waS so brilliant. TMZ was afraid that he would reveal a source, and could come after him. So he and Camille avoided angering TMZ while simultaneously guiding the jury to the conclusion that it could ONLY have been AH's team. They also revealed how calculating her plan was, helping to prove malice.
Thanks for this comment. I was wondering why Vazquez never asked him if the two tips (for the courthouse and the lawyer's office) and the video of Depp in the kitchen came from Heard or one of her sources. So, TMZ and their employees can't reveal their sources, but in the case of a trial like this, they certainly can make it fairly apparent who sources probably were. Excellent. Thanks again.
@@elderassassin9673 He’s a very intelligent man. If he had signed a non disclosure agreement then he wouldn’t be testifying as a witness. He’s good, nice try though!
@@elderassassin9673 you believe or you actually know?? because he is on trial and has to swear an oath that his statement is true. So I doubt he is going to face anything legal considering he no longer works for TMZ either
7:42 he says 'we were instructed by the... news producer' he CLEARLY looks directly at Heard. A very clever and legally safe way to let everyone know she gave the tip-off without needing to actually say it.
So Amber Heard lied under oath when she said she didn't send the video to TMZ... got it! Elaine can't 'hearsay' her way out of this; it just shows desperation.
If her agent did it, it wasn’t considered to be Amber. But if I’m remembering correctly, JD’s lawyers asked her if she knew how it got leaked to TMZ and she said she didn’t know/recall. But if it got leaked by her agent and she found out about it, she definitely would have asked her agent about it. Pretty sure she does recall. Or at least she does now!!!
Clear, concise, straight to the point, no hesitation. No indication of who's side he is on,not biased one way or the other... literally just stating facts. The most believable out of every witness!!!
@@JustADudeGamer still just to remove any confusion and blames i'd say this witness still us the nost credible one so far just straight to the point answers
@@1stMikeWhite pretty much. It seems most Media is shifted toward supporting Johnny Depp though, suffice to say in their typical two faced antic, they just follow along whats trending. Regardless, Amber's done lol
She does it to anyone who has witnessed interactions between them or has information that shows Amber in bad light! She did the very same to the women who worked at the airport.
"We receive tips often times from publicists, managers, agents, or ..B-list celebrities." 😂😭 I'm dead at Treimane low-key calling Amber Heard a B-lister. Ouch.
"She was supposed to turn towards the camera so we could get a shot of a bruise on the right side of her face." Contradicts Amber's statement how the paparazzi just turned up. She knew!
@@FutureMediaPro nice so you mean the people dying in the movies are actually dead cause if a bruise can't be makeup how could a fully torn human carcass could be
@@FutureMediaPro Of course they would. It's a story that gets them subscribers and views on their website, and money in the bank when they sell it to the tabloids. My concern is that she previously denied any knowledge of knowing they would be there and has also said that she will never leave the house without makeup. She also did not need to be at that courthouse that day. Someone from her lawfirm could've filed whatever. It's their job. Yet, Amber Heard turns up in person to a courthouse without makeup and a bruise on her face. What's more, TMZ paps who just happened to be there, get the perfect shot. That did not look like she was trying to hide it, or that she was surprised. That goes to her credibility as a witness. That's 2 things she's lied about already.
@@nameless7546 what are you talking about? And I'm sure when she was in the courthouse getting restraining order they wouldn't notice the makeup sweating off her face while she's crying. Please I get it you an Amber hater because she report domestic violence and you a fan of JD. Gives no one the right to attack her and so more bullying and that's why this country has a high rate of domestic violence because people re victimized them. PLUS THIS IS NOT A 🤬 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ABUSE CASE ITS DEFAMATION OF CHARACTER AND DEPP HAS NOT PROVEN THAT. HOLLYWOOD AND REAL LIFE ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS.
This was the most compelling out of everything. An abused woman that just wants to move on and doesn’t want any attention literally selling footage to tmz and tipping them off every time she was about to do something to make Johny look bad. Sounds like a bitter, jealous abuser. She wanted to hurt him. Plain and simple.
This is the nail in the coffin for AH. If I were sitting in the jury, hearing all I had heard for the last month, this guys testimony would’ve finalized this case for me.
Here are some quick facts about Amber that we know that are proven: 1) He wasn't the only alcoholic and drug abuser. She drank 2 bottles of wine a day, took drugs as well by her own admission. 2) Caught lying about using the makeup that didn't exist back then to "cover her bruises" frequently, which was refuted by the makeup company in court. 3) Past domestic violence arrest against her ex, literally charged and arrested. Plus admitted to domestic violence against Johnny. Plus suspicion of domestic violence against her own sister (her sister was discussing it with her friends by the poolside in a video clip), and assaulted her ex-best friend in public. In contrast Johnny has no history of being violent towards women, every single one of his ex gfs and spouses all speak highly of him, and has said he's never laid hands on them. 4) Audio recording of her admitting to cutting his finger in Australia (not allowed in this trial due to technicalities), proving again that her testimony was a lie. (one of the voices on the tape is now deceased and can't testify) 5) Her psychologist lied about Amber having no domestic violence history and was called out by Johnny's attorney. 6) Has NO witnesses or evidence (all conveniently random strangers that she doesn't know or deceased people like the bodyguard) 7) Her longtime assistant testified under oath that she did not once see or hear any physical abuse from Depp or ever saw any injuries on Heard in all the years. She also testified under oath that Heard spit ON her face when she asked for a raise 8) She visits Dr Kipper's office the day after an alleged incident where she was severely beaten, the doctor's medical report states her in perfect health, with no injuries of any kind on her, also state her skin was in perfect condition. Her explanation was "this was a partial report and I didn't have time to get into the details with the doctor about the injuries". (Day 16 of trial cross examination) 9) Allegedly got her nose broken, hit multiple times, her scalp and hair ripped off, penetrated by a bottle, dragged over broken glass and got her arms and legs "pretty cut up", then somehow felt safe enough to take sleeping pills with her "attacker" in the same house, woke up the next day and made him coffee, then went to James Corden's show miraculously healed. No marks, no scars, no pictures, no medical report . Hair stylist saw no signs of abuse, the hair stylist would've been inches away from her face looking at all the details while working on her appearance, and she saw 0 injuries. Multiple witnesses (including 3 cops) saw no signs of abuse. 10) Allegedly got raped and assaulted multiple times on her honeymoon, then wrote Johnny a love letter saying "it was the most amazing and beautiful honeymoon any girl could've ever dreamed of". (evidence presented in Day 18 of trial) 11) Claimed she wanted to leave Johnny, but in all the audio clips she was the one begging him to stay. Claimed she always tried to de-escalate, but in audio clips she was always the aggressor preventing him from leaving and taunting him . 12) In all her "crying", there's never a single tear coming out of her eyes, even when reciting the most "traumatic experience". 13) Allegedly feared for her life but bought him a large knife. 14) Testified under oath that she was beaten by Johnny with huge chunky rings on all his fingers, said she was "hit so many times in the face over and over again she lost count". The photos taken the next day shows her face completely spotless without any injuries, when cross examined, she answers "there do not appear to be any injuries on my face in that photo". 15) Caught lying under oath again saying she "didn't receive money" from Johnny when she got $7 million, and lying about "never assaulted" Johnny when she admits to it on tape. 16) Proven once again as a liar when she made public statement of donating 7 million dollars for children's hospital but in reality donated exactly 0 dollars before she was called out, also caught lying under oath about donating the money. Her sworn statement was "I donated the entire settlement of $7 million to charity", when cross examined, she states "I did not lie, I pledged the $7 million, "pledged" and "donated" are synonymous, they mean the same thing." (Day 16 of trial cross examination) 17) Blackmailing Depp with her attorney, trying to make a deal for 3 of the adjoining penthouses where they both lived, 50k monthly expenses, 500k in attorney fees and the SUV Depp let her drive in exchange for not filing the protection order. 18) Her publishing of the op-ed "domestic violence" piece is timed perfectly with the release of Aquaman film, it didn't get published when they divorced, or before, or right after, but instead it was published right when Aquaman was being released and when the "Me Too" movement was grabbing the most headlines. 19) Amber Heard's team desperately tried to stop the trial from being publicly broadcasted while Depp's team made sure it was made public 20) Long time friend and co worker of Amber Heard telling about her hardcore cocaine and drug habit dating all the way back to 2008 when they were close associates, (youtube show called "Steven and Jason" and in the newest episode titled "We need to talk about AH"). 21) Amber testified about having injuries such as “gross colored puss coming out of her temple” and “suffering a broken nose”, but when cross examined she changes the lines to “gross colored puss UNDER HER SCALP” and “FELT like a broken nose”, because she knew the evidence is about to show ZERO injuries visible on her. (How does she see gross colored puss under her scalp? With an X-ray machine??) 22) Allegedly got beaten up for FIVE YEARS and not a SINGLE injury shown on her face, no doctor visits, no dentists, no surgeons, no photos, despite countless appearances in public events and countless photos taken given her celebrity status, many of those public appearances were the night after "the beating", keep in mind the beating were all allegedly done by Depp with "huge chunky" rings on all his fingers, yet after five years of beating, she didn't need to visit the doctors once or show on sign of injury on her face, sounds like her facial bone density and durability of her skin can match that of armor platings. 23) Alleges Johnny slashed the soles of her feet, but was seen the next day walking completely normal, again no doctor visits or treatments of any kind even though she has a personal doctor on retainer. 24) Constantly changing details of her stories and allegations, she's already given 4 different versions of the poop incident, she has said "1: told security guard that she pooped and it was a practical joke gone wrong. 2: Johnny did it to frame her. 3: said it never happened and Johnny was gaslighting her. 4: said the tiny puppies did it." 25) Her lying under oath is not even worth mentioning anymore, there is too many to list, just to list a few in this trial alone. Lying about not receiving any money from Johnny, when in fact she received $7 million. Lying about having donated the money, when in fact she has donated $0 so far. Lying about never assaulted Johnny, when in fact she was recorded admitting to it multiple times. Lying about never assaulted anyone before, when in fact she's assaulted at least 4 that we have evidence of. Lying about her injuries, when a medical record showed absolutely no injuries. 26) She put someone through hell for years, publicly shamed and destroyed his career and life, just so she can be seen as a noble victim and use the attention and sympathy to advance her career and profile. She claims she's never wanted to be seen as a victim and wanted to move on, but appears in countless TV shows and articles talking about her "abuse" and "donation" non stop, literally appeared on every show she could to talk about her being a victim and being noble on the donation that never happened. 27) Amber's own friend, Tillet Wright, a long time close friend with Amber Heard, testified under oath that he's never seen or heard Amber being abused by Johnny Depp. (Day 20 of trial)
She was bringing men back to Jonny's home and cheating. She and her family and friends all lived off him. She wouldn't give him his meds when he really needed them. She had a dog hanging out window of a moving car and said it was Johnny. She's on tape telling him no one will believe he's been abused by her SHE WILL GET HER COMEUPPANCE and that's not a pledge or promise it's A FACT
Excellent. Did I also see her completely reverse the bathroom door incident in her deposition? She’s like a Smollet. Trying to up her acting worth by faking the fashionable victimhood of the day.... and failing miserably... Everyone calls her Amber Turd now 😂 Also - I’d lump her in with that Pinket creature - I’m betting Will has had some of this bs too. Basically these women (imho) are jealous of their megastar husbands. Although, I can believe Johnny might have jealousy issues too, I think he was provoked by her behaviour. You can see he was trusting and in love by the lack of pre-nup. Great analysis you’ve done here, saves me sifting through the boring bits. Please don’t forget, this is timed to have you otherwise engaged whilst they ruin your country. DONT ALLOW THEM to sign away your sovereignty to the WHO. Write to your reps now. This is important.
@@jackjones4578 No they are right, the donation was made by Johnny since it was his money, but then Amber ensured that the funds were redirected to her instead of directly to the ACLU, so technically, they are right.
@@lennonslemons4934 Jesus Christ 🤦🏻♂️ 😩, are you going around any comments about anything just being one of those people? Like did you go to the Last air bender RUclips video and get mad that they said the same thing too? You’re cringe asf
@@kimerietate8372 why are you watching this then? Why is anyone commenting bitching about anything other than the trial?!? Are y’all bored?! We re all here watching the TRIAL THUS WE RE COMMENTING ABOUT THE TRIAL
After all this and she doesn't go to jail I'd just go crawl into a hole lol. .....Honestly though I don't care what happens with her, just want Johnny to get back to acting!
''To capture her leaving the courthouse , and then, she was going to stop and turn towards the camera to display the bruise on the right side of her face'' BOOM!! SHE KNEW ABOUT EVERYTHING, SHE LIED UNDER OATH!!
Good on Camille for clarifying with her questions about obtaining a copyright from a direct source (Morgan's answer: "15 minutes") and Morgan's response to the next question of 'how long did it take you to obtain the copyright?' being "15mins" with a good, long pause after it. Let it hang with the jury. She really knows when to stop and give weight to witnesses' answers. She is so methodical, tactical and clear. It's fascinating watching this.
Yes, that was a clever workaround for the fact there could be some lawyers in between her and the " media buyer". He could maybe not say anything about the deal they have made but the way Camille asked verified that the media material had to come from the copyright owner itself.
The only critique I have is that she talks slightly monotone and sounds a bit too happy a lot of the time. So some of the points could be missed if you’re not paying attention fully to the actual words being said as it would sound like a pleasant conversation in the background. The pause becomes a bit more subtle than it could be.
Yup.. This testimony plus Amber Heard's slip up (when she accidentally said that TMZ was alerted and then covers her mouth with her hands) during her deposition back in 2016 show that she was the one that had been leaking all these informations to TMZ. It is pretty obvious.
How is it ok for a lawyer to shout "objection" just because she THINKS the witness is about to say something heresy before the witness even says anything ?????
I think it can be called if the question actually calls for hearsay, like if you ask "what did amber say to you" kind of thing that's hearsay because you're saying what someone else said. I could totally be wrong about this though
Morgan Tremaine is such a hero on so many levels! Of course he knows she's guilty. Thank you for coming forward. He is completely credible and just wanted to put out the truth! Justice has been served.
That just proves that Elaine already knows who is responsible!! Also, she thinks he's going to say her name and he's actually much more professional than that. Which makes it look even worse that Elaine calls him out for testify to get his 15 minutes of fame?!
She does and even though she objects, once the jury hears it they can’t forget it, they just can’t use it as a reason. So she is objecting before he says it so the jury never gets the chance to hear it.
It doesn't matter. He was very believable, and the best part was when he clearly looked and nodded towards Amber when talking about the video being sent in. He literally let the jury know that it was her without ever saying it. Priceless!
Her lying is just one of the reasons why she’s in court at all right now. Like many others, I just can’t imagine how the UK judge came to his conclusion, even if he’d had just half this information, as I’ve always read that the laws about lying in tabloids, are more strict in England. Maybe there will be a sea change against immediately acting as if a woman, with a similar story, couldn’t possibly be lying, especially when they use tabloids and recorded conversations, articles in a magazine,etc. to tell their story. All of these recordings, both audio and video, yet she never once got him actually coming after her? Come now. She didn’t want police involved, because her “bruise” that TMZ broke the story on, would’ve been seen then wiped away by anyone examining her. Look up videos on the bruise kit, which Heard even called it herself on the stand. I’ve seen several women apply the exact “shiner with foundation” she was setting up a situation for TMZ to film. The saddest thing about this, is that anyone actually being abused, now will face more scrutiny, especially if they’re a celebrity, in a messy relationship headed for divorce.
@@Laineelee-j9p If she was getting paid $7.50/hour, I would feel sorry for her too. But she's getting paid $300/hour at least plus the retainer. I doubt she feels sorry nor poor.
Her HORRIBLE acting on the stand was enough to convince me. Plus, I was shocked her PR team made her wear those clothes. For a minute I thought I was watching the movie Chicago! 😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡
Highly doubt tbh, any chance she could have is being destroyed now in the cross evidence stage… her tale is so full of holes that is impossible to think she didn’t write that article with malicious intent of ruining his life.
Yesterday I saw a video on here from a lawyer ( who was in this courtroom) and a behaviorist. The lawyer and he discussed mrs turds testimony and he said that the jury ( in his opinion) doesn’t sided with her.
I can't even comprehend how SCANDALOUS a person can be...to make up such vicious lies, fake bruises, and then tip off the paparazzi to film it? Wow....what a piece of work.
Happens alot. Women falsely accusing men out of bitterness or with something to gain. Hence why the believe women movement is utter nonsense. When these allegations occur for men, just as happened to Mr. Depp, they lose everything and their lives are ruined. Even being falsely accused of things as a man is enough to ruin your life due to the seriousness of the allegations. i believe any women falsely accusing a man of rape or sexual assault or battery should receive double the penalty for that which they are falsely accusing.
She's an awful person, and IMHO, she did all this, because Johnny had the nerve to leave her and want a divorce. People do NOT leave AH and get away with it scot free, in her mind. I believe this was punishment for him leaving her, her fear of abandonment. And $$ of course. She pledged the 7 million to charity and wanted something for herself. There REALLY should be punishment for outright lying about all this abuse, it makes a mockery of real victims of DV.
I wish the lawyers would ask for perjury charges once this is done. She made a mockery of domestic violence. Absolutely tarnished true victims.and has made a mockery of our system of justice as well
I agree 100% she is still using her narcissistic abuse right in court!! She has mocked all that have survived are still going through and those we have lost. She doesn't care about what she is putting her family and friends through. As a survivor we don't make eyecontact like she does we do not sit all cock and brave confident during and sometimes for the rest of our lives. I can't even express how much she needs jail..probation,community service in abuse shelters therapy and pay back every single cent to him!!!@
I do hope that TMZ does not try to sue this guy. He did not reveal his source, just that the source had direct ownership of the cupboard film. We can deduce the rest. Well done, young man. You did so well and held your own, especially knowing that the representative of TMZ was watching and listening to every word. 👏 TMZ should actually applaud you for your integrity - usually so lacking in media-land.
He definitely got his "15 mins of fame" and even more. He will continue to get more than that because he seems credible and a good witness, spitting unbiased facts. 👏👏👏
With so much of evidence against Amber, I just hope the jury will give out a verdict to the actual person who has been actually ABUSED, and that is MR. JOHNNY DEPP. Women like Amber is an insult to the millions of women who are actually abused every day for years. What an example she is setting for her child who will grow up to see the lies she has portrayed to get her way.
They don't have the ability to do that, but Depp can press charges if his statute of limitations doesn't expire. and in California, depending on the type and severity their are no limitations. He could persue it, but it was pretty cear he didn't feel comfortable calling her an abuser or yelling he's abused. He's unfortunately the most common type of survivor, silent and "just move on" type.
This Guy knows what he is talking about and you can tell that he doesnt like Amber, he really wanted to say guys she is behind all this but he couldnt do It. He really wanted to help Johnny. Johnny is not perfect but compared to Amber he is a Saint. He didnt hurt anyone but himself. I wish him the BEST.
Ya I noticed that when AH legal team tried to object him saying whose the source was, he gave them a look of despise like " I knew you would object but I havent say it yet".
This just solidifies that AH was truly "trapping" JD. She was like weaving an intricate web of narrative by filming JDs action and response as well as involving the press to capture certain moments in her actions to make it so as to paint herself in front of the people that she was the "bullied" one, the victim and abused and to come as "authentic" as possible and she almost gotten away from this...luckily, she was not that consistent and her narratives have cracks and loopholes. I didn't believe her from the start that it was not for the money...so why pledge when you can directly donate the money to its intended recipient? Also, it was good that this is a public hearing and you can judge yourself whether she was being "authentic" at this point in time. I'm not a huge fan of JD and certainly not an AH fan even when she appeared at Aquaman but I stand on the side of the logic and the truth and from my own formed opinion, AH is certainly not authentic...
You're absolutely right and isn't it ironic with all The Times she found him unknowingly there's never one instance of him hitting her like she claimed
you can tell ah has set JD up by everything she’s recorded- no one records or films their convos with their husband as a norm. Seems like ah has hours and hours of footage and recordings from the start.
There was a blind item published in 2015 about AH trying to get power of attorney over JD while they were dating and was advised that she should marry him. Would explain all the recordings and photos.
Well, making the objection before a witness says anything is normal. For instance if asked ”what did this guy say to you?” Objection hearsay, because what that guy said should be said by the guy himself as a separate witness. Not what someone says he allegedly said. Just an example.
It’s giving me comfort and some sort of closure to see someone important like JD coming forward about fake domestic abuse allegations while he was and is the one who got abused by AH . As a Man I was abused emotionally and physically for many years and didn’t say a thing and tried my best to fix it but at the end she cheated on me , and projected on me everything she had done to me for years. I lost everything because of it , it literally took me back financially 20 years , from owning 2 houses to not being able afford paying rent .. JD is lucky he didn’t have to fight for his child’s custody as well !.. I am a male survivor and all this hits home really hard !
The fact that he said she was laughing and smiling at the end of the video just shows she was doing it on purpose to try and make JD look bad. I seriously hope she gets jail time.
I AGREE! I am Not a Pro, yet, I have Studied Narcissism Extensively. The DSM Psychological Guideline for Diagnosis, requires that the Narc present themselves into Therapy, & admit that their ‘disposition’ is affecting their life adversely before an Official Diagnosis can be made. Narcissism is Created, due to a Traumatic Childhood, & starts w/Abandonment Issues. They say, that a Brain-Groove is Created that forms the Narcs. Perverse COPING Personality. This is Permanent, & can Never be Healed. The Best that can happen, is if there is a catastrophic event, like: PRISON, DEATH of A CHILD, or Other Extreme Event that Forces TRUTH, that they would not have Otherwise arrived at. This would allow for willful improvements, yet, would never come Natural, per se; as in- Lesson learned, & updated Beliefs. These are TRAUMATIZED CHILDREN, in ADULT BODIES. Trauma, Comes Out SIDEWAYS! From listening to Many on-line Therapists… This is part of the “Dark Triad,” & several used the Word EVIL. In So Many words, when someone ASKED, if there was a Spiritual Element, this One Gal, answered, “There are millions of Narcs. all over the world, & none of them have gone to school to Learn the Protocol that all Narcs live-by. Yet, each follows the NPD Tactics: which include (a few only): No Empathy, Control, Gaslighting, Brainwashing, Grooming, by Punishment & Reward, Devaluation, Word Manipulation/ Some, Considered Sophisticated BW Techniques (talking FBI stuff), Recruited Helpers, to sometimes include elements of Psychopathy, & Sociopathy. I AM Greatly worried for Amber, & want for her to Get the Help she Needs… Which, with Continuing Therapy, would Present Boundaries that she may learn to Follow, if she so Chose for Herself. .🙏🏻💛🕊🍃
Damn... Camille absolutly killed it with the way she worded everything and allowed the information to speak for itself. That guy made for an excellent witness. Clear and concise with his explanations, factual and to the point about everything. This is absolutly damning testimony against Amber, and should absolutly be one of the final nails in the coffin. I can't see a world where a jury would still rule in Ambers favor at this point.
Totally agree with you, however historically juries seem to be either gullible or dumber than dirt in high profile cases...I have no faith in them whatsoever. I hope I'm wrong.
He said it without saying it. AH gave us the tip/video = “it takes 15 minutes to process a tip/video for us to process its credibility and this tip/video took 15 minutes.” 💥
@@user-yt5dg8nf6y yes I'm sure she wrote some as well as the rest of the team while they were brainstorming together... what kind of question is that? Camille is a seasoned lawyer. 12+ years I believe.
A good example of someone who cares about the truth and knows has to come forward to do the right thing. Even though it can put him at risk. It's selfless and admirable
I guess you have to a certain kind of B``CH to even take the job to defend this devilish creature.. I hope these lawyers end up scrubbing floors after this.. No one will hire them again, i hope... But i guess they allready know they did a huge mistake by saying yes.
@@brettcantrell8650 no one said it was honorable. He would do great as a journalist and not a worker for TMZ as well. He has good qualities that they would look for. That's all the original poster is saying
@Victor B he is corrupt anyway. He just came for the limelight. He does not know who sent the video. He is just trying to cause a stir. He came prepared with well oiled and highlighted hair, etc.
@@brettcantrell8650 what the honor has to do with the money he was getting?? The kid is sharp indeed, only objection I might have is his painted black nails, not a sign of a cowboy. Not everyone can be saving the exotic wild parrots in Antarctica if that for you is an honorable job or a firefighter
This is probably the most damning testimony i have seen so far as far as defamation. It strongly suggests that she is the source and that she actively sought media exposure to put the business out there. Great witness
Im happy that Camille did the examination for this guy. Direct, compact and exact. And the guy's answer is direct and exact. No zigzag and no looking at the jurors.
The way the lawyer held the questioning in such an order that a listener is slowly but directly led to the realisation that the copyright owner aka AH must agree to a publication and therefore knew of it was SO SMOOTH. Hats off to her
I thought the same. Camille done a really good job. I was thinking: why she's doing so much questions about the way they follow a tip?...and then 15 minutes?!? 🤯🤯🤯
Yeh it's a really pitch perfect example of how to lay out information and lead a conversation. she can't just say ( that means amber leaked it) nor should see but she was made to make it clear that is the case without ever saying anything close to it
That's exactly what I thought, such a smart move. Did you notice how she poses after he says it was posted within 15 minutes after receiving it after explaining that would only be possible if it came form the person with ownership. MIC DROP! Well done Camille!
10:57 The most damning piece of evidence brought up during the questioning of this guy. She deliberately edited the video to make JD look bad but we all know this now but I just think it’s so fascinating how she actually thought she’d get away with this. I still think she needs to have perjury charges brought against her. She shouldn’t be free right now. I love how she’s pretending to write things but it’s been debunked that her pen was barely ever touching the paper or she was just scribbling to look busy.
@@Rorshach1004 how did Johnny rejected her? Johnny loved her so much. He was with Vanessa Paradise for 14 years, had two kids with her and didn't marry her. But married Amber after two years of dating. So he loved her. She abused his love
That's what they needed to prove... malingering malice is what is required to prove defamation. If WE see this, then you can have a pretty good feeling that the jurors did, too.
That was literally music to my ears, Camille is conducting those questions brilliantly and the witness cleverly leading us to make deductions that Amber herself leaked everything without him saying her name (preventing her layers to stop him further)
The way she left a pause after he said he didn't need to obtain copyright because they received it directly from the source She's very good at inserting pauses and letting the silence speak for the words
Relistening to this, I notice how smartly Camille led the questioning, in particular the question as to what circumstances would lead him to send reporters to the courthouse, leaving no doubt the story was leaked.
Courts normally HATE making perjury charges except when a witness in a criminal case stiffs the prosecution. I think that since this entire case has been based on perjured testimony, and tied up the court for weeks, MAYBE the state will step up and enforce the law to protect the court system. If perjury becomes commonplace, then no testimony can be trusted. She just might have stepped in it.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
He called her a "B list celebrity". I love this guy.
Best compliment she'll ever get🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@TOG292 Hahahahaha
Timestamp?
@@bubblesbubbles7988 1:37, he did not say her name but it is obvious that he refers to Amber.
@@angie_moon5261 thanks!
This guy is actually a really good witness. He doesn't go on about random junk and answers the questions truthfully and fully.
And he's not trying to win over the jury by gawking at them.
cos hes smart i guess
I was skeptical because of his association with TMZ, but this surprised me.
He is smart yeah but obviously a man with somewhat abnormal moral based on his line of work.
Yes
He is an excellent witness. He speaks well, sounds educated, gives clear, concise, easy to comprehend information/evidence. No theatrics, no embellishment. IMO, completely believable.
Hello Janys. How are you doing today?
thats how media do.
@@JefferyClifford-js8dj dawg
@@ferrarifem11 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@JefferyClifford-js8dj My man. I reckon you must be an Alabaman Prince or something.
1:37
When he says "B-list celebrities," he subtly looks at, nods at, and gestures towards Amber. This man is an absolute savage and I'm so glad he was included in the lineup of fantastic characters brought onto the stand. I feel bad for Johnny for the whole situation, but I'd be a filthy liar if I said there wasn't a truckload of entertainment to experience with this case.
"Characters" that's a well-chosen word. It was JD's strategy to bring likable, trained "actors" backed by curated, edited evidence, to the courtroom. He had the money to throw at them. Amber didn't.
He was counting on a shallow public to conclude that, if it looks good, feels good, and sounds good, it must be the truth. The public completely forgot that narcissists and sociopaths are the best at putting on these acts. Real people are raw and rough around the edges.
This guy and his team maliciously set Amber up. One day, they'll pay the price.
@@cosmicreindeer5570 oh please, looks like there's quite a few of these Amber heard apologist
@@ADumbNut1985 When you say "apologist" it means you've already set Amber Heard up as a criminal in your mind. There IS sufficient evidence that she suffered abuse at the hands of someone at least 20 years older than her.
What I'm talking about is everyday politics which everyone is vulnerable to. Anyone, including you, can be set up and framed with a good enough legal team. Please remember that nothing is black and white. Cancellation is neither logical nor a solution.
As a “victim”, she submitted the video to TMZ instead of the police, that already explains everything! If this is not defamation, I don’t know wtf is……
Money and publicity.
I wonder if TMZ paid Amber?
I wonder if police take any pictures themselves of Amber damaged face?
If Jonny doesn't win, I'll never trust the justice system ever again
It's the cupboard doors that are the real victims here. Let's not forget that.
@@AS-fu1kd I already don't trust the justice system, so as much as I want him to win, I'm sadly not expecting it to happen. I just hope at the very least the throw her counterclaim back in her face bruised face
The fact that video was shorter was really important
The way Camille let the Jury know that all these videos and information came from AH or any of her people was sooo good. Smoothly done.
Indeed!
She's a smooth operator and this guy knew how to answer....
Yes and it makes me wonder if everyone got it that needs to get it!
Exactly! Without directly asking!!😂🎉
The lead up was crazy! Yet in every question made Amber look worse n worse
This is the most absolute and definitive proof Johnny's team have that actively proves that Turd tried to defame him. If he loses this defamation lawsuit I'll literally be pissed forever and ever.
really appreciate a witness who clearly describes a complicated process that everyone now understands.
Amber should have taken advice from him how to answer questions in a trial
Pretty easy when you recall only the truth. But I agree, he did explain that process very well but it’s also the Attorney who did a great job with questioning.
He’s very articulate
Smart dude, well prepped
I actually saved the video I thought it was so interesting.
The only way TMZ could obtain copyright of the cupboard video is from the copyright owner itself. Amber Heard filmed the video. Funny how she said she didn’t want any attention and now a witness disproves it 🤡
bc idiots dont know nothing, dont understand everything in this world is data and marked by whatever owner
BOOOOOM. Snicker now Amber. You lies and setups coming crashing down.
Amber clown
🤣🤣🤣🤣..so satisfying
She lied
Tell us it was Amber without telling us it was Amber. Brilliant direct and brilliant testimony!!!
It’s 10000% illegal to expose clients and costumers information from somewhere you once worked
Damn, never seen a meme format fit so perfectly with the joke.
@@mit7198 is that even the case if it’s got a court case?
It was brilliant. Applause for Camille.
@@mit7198 lol first of all, it is “Customers”. Secondly, that is entirely dependent on any NDA signed, genius
This was actually very interesting to hear how the TMZ process works.
Many actors will suing TMZ for harrasment in near future
@@o.gcable8267 aa
Yep. Thanks AH! I’m DONE w/ tmz!
@@o.gcable8267 near future? Where have you been? Actors have been Suing TMZ for years 😂
@@teresadragstream8648 why did you ever begin 🤣
The guy smartly described the processes and internal controls of TMZ and proved that the video was received from the original source, Amber Heard, and did it with such finesse that he wouldn't be sued by TMZ for breaking the NDA and Employment Contract. Johny Depp's legal team is smart af.
To be fair attorneys will spend hours practicing your deposition with you first in a high profile case like this.
@@texanlady4except he came in VERY last minute, three people contacted JD’s legal team while watching the trial to offer statements in relation.
@@kburdy no. He contacted them three days before. They rehearsed his deposition for sure. No say they just put him up there without knowing exactly what he was going to say.
"Never try to destroy someone's life with a lie.... when yours could be destroyed by the truth" - Shayabarbaaz Shubh
What a line...salute you 😊👍👍
🙌🏾 💯💯
@@AbhinavDubey_2015 thanks mate! the truth always comes to light :)
@@BlessedWFavor 💙
Making a Tshirt!
Amber should def now be charged with perjury. She flat out lied, emphatically when asked if she sold stories or tipped TMZ. She said she would NEVER do that, nor did she even know how to do that! I wish they could replay that in court right now!
It’ll never happen in a civil case
The public is powerful. If enough people will demand it, they maybe will give in
Also she would bounce the blame to her lawyers
Don't have to replay it, the jury will have it for judgement
Rocky and Whitney,
You would think she’s a horrible person before knowing what she did, but the bar was raised again today.
After every day I think Amber can’t get any more despicable... But then the following day I realize she can be .
Before this trial, I thought AH is "just" a lying spouse who just want money and fame from Depp. This trials show that she's way worse.
She's greedy all right, but she definitely want to destroy Depp's life for some seemingly petty reason.
She is a self serving, annihilator. Very destructive
And the walls come tumbling down
Strategic Warfare of a crazed Woman. I never was a Fan of any Celebrity and I never was so much disgusted of one.
I love how Honest and straight forward he is with his testimony. I wish all humans could possess this level of directness.
It'd what happens when you're telling the truth
This guy was a great witness. Very concise straight to the point and very believable
That witness from TMZ expressed himself in the most intelligent and professional manner. That testimony leans heavy against Amber.
Well said.
That’s how you answer when you’re not lying.
@@dianebannister4591 Aye, consider the pressure as well, before lunch we had the TMZ lawyer there to keep a legal eye on anything he said. That suggests he knew a bit more but was perhaps limited on what he could say without TMZ litigation.
@@TiberiusWallace
TMZ is just part of the machine that allowed Heard to create this story, and have zero scrutiny or doubt, about what she was claiming.
They were there to shoot her makeup made bruise. TMZ just wanted clicks, and played right along with the ruining of another person, without caring whether it was legitimate or not.
Several women have done videos on the “Bruise kit,” which is actually what most call it, and even Heard called it, when testifying.
He’s a good witness.. wording things correctly so that he’s avoiding hearsay and other objections
She still objected to try and say hearsay and it got overruled xD
Great point 👍🏻
I noticed that he was very aware of the game. Good for him even though I dislike TMZ as a leftist organization.
🎩 ELAINE WASHINGTON 🧢
HEARDS TEAM HASN'T SAID
ANYTHING. AS HEARSAY OR I OBJECT
BECAUSE THEY HAVE GIVEN UP !
HEARD IS SITTING THERE TRYING
ACT INNOCENT BUT SHE HAS
GUILT WRITTEN ALL OVER HER
FACE ! THAT GUILT STANDS OUT LIKE NEON LIGHTS OR THOSE IMAGINERY
BRUISES ! SHE COULDN'T HIDE ALL
THAT DECEPTION !🎭
@@PleaseNThankYou Is TMZ leftist? I don't watch or follow TMZ but I thought it was just stupid celebrity gossip and info that is way to personal about celebrities. I don't see how that can be considered political, let alone partisan.
A clear-headed and exact witness. Well done. Just relating the truth of what had happened without spicing things up.
.
@@carrijas1995 wat
This is what happens when you bring in actual witnesses and experts in their field who have no personal stake in what's happening. Not automatically biased personal friends and professional witnesses just looking for a payday.
He did turn up the heat when he was taunted though, with that '15mins of fame' attack. 😂😂😂
Dr. Spiegel dislikes this comment
It's beautiful when people naturally speak the truth, the rich information just clearly pours out.
Yes, you are so correct. The truth flows without flaws, smooth and soft like butter.
@@nikkicastellinethe truth will set you free!
She walked her way around that subject with ease, she never made a direct question but always stated the facts for you to puzzle together. She is so good
she liberaled them hahaa
@@thomasgrabowski2202 still trying to decipher what this means can you help me
Not just good but the best😁
@@TurntReynolds I believe that this is to undermine Heard's creditability, since she had claimed that she didn't want any attention, Depp's team had argued that Heard's motive was specifically to drive media interest to her case, to boost Aquaman and because otherwise "No one would be interested of what she had to say." Heard had earlier testified that she was not expecting there to be paparazzi at the courthouse and that she was surprised about it after getting the restraining order. This I believe is also to point out that she lied.
@@TurntReynolds
- "how long does it cost to copyright something TMZ received FROM A TIPLINE?"
- "It can take a while becuz you have to verify blah blah blah........"
- "how long does it take for TMZ to obtain a copyright for something received DIRECTLY FROM THE SOURCE?"
- "something in the realm of 15 mins ........"
- "how much time had passed since you received the kitchen video to the time it was posted on TMZ?"
- "15 mins."
Pieced them together now?
Let's all take a moment to admit...this guy is EXACTLY what you'd think a TMZ employee looks like.
💀💀😂😂😂😂
Draco malfoy
😂😂
he looks like Carlisle from Twilight
Draco Malfoy on redemption arc
Wow this man was very clear with how he explained everything and he was straightforward. No BS. Glad he testified.
The cast of characters for this trial is just epic.
@@patrick4662 the cast? Im weak💀😂. It does feel like a show, un novela
@@crown_vic3759 daytime soap for sure.
I love how this man came forward and was pretty much like, “hey that famous video of Johnny slamming cabinets was recorded and sent to us by Amber wanting attention and here I can prove it.” So many turning points in this trial I freaking love it. ❤
@johnnydepp183❤
Amber Heard: “B-list celebrity.”
@johnnydepp183fake profile
@johnnydeppoflYou're not Johnny. Get a damn life and stop wasting your time and ours.
This is a herotic move for this Gentleman willing to stand out and reveal the truth. Mad respect.
Yup. Especially given the fact Harvey at TMZ has a VERY close relationship with heard and has openly stated his position in all this.
👍🏻👍🏻
God I want TMZ to cease to exist.
TMZ tried to not have him there. The court made him do it.
That must be the reason why they were trying to stop him from testifying
Well, if she was lying, she also betrayed TMZ. It seems fair for them to make an opposing move.
I mean when a court of law says you have to, you kinda have to or face the consequences.
Camille, once again, has demonstrated how brilliant she is. She was able to prove Amber provided the "tip" without having provided the direct evidence.
How are you doing?
Stop being thirsty Pollack
137 likes in 20 minutes, good luck trying to sleep with the notifications hahaha
She should be a Senior Partner, after this trial for sure!
And if Amber was truly an abuse victim, why is she smiling at the end of it, like an indignant brat!?
It’s literally impossible for this to NOT be ruled as defamation. She lost…
FACTS 💯
literally...did you read that?
@@beachboy13600 read what? Explain
@@beachboy13600 Hi Amber 👋🏾
I really support what you’re getting at but you are literally killing the meaning of literally.
He was certainly one of the stars of the show... Thank you so much Mr Tremaine!
He straight up testified that she was supposed to turn toward the camera so that they could photograph a "bruise".... yet.... SHE herself testified, under oath, that she didn't know the paps were going to be there. She was their source.
She’s lied under oath so many times she should be put in jail for lying while under oath… but she’s famous so she gets special treatment…
Or her publicist was the source. Nevertheless she knew TMZ were alerted by "someone".
@@Anna_Key He said the news stations told him. But it's almost certain she's the one who sent that video.
@@lamsss I know someone who was jailed for years for perjury (and it wasn't even perjury, but she was testifying against some high-profile people so they nailed her). Why can't Heard be jailed for perjury?
@@BreezeeGreenz she might be, if she ever sets foot in Australia again. Are there US-Oz extradition agreements in place?
Bravo to this man for risking everything to speak the TRUTH!!!! Outstanding job with the rebuttal as well!!! 🙌🏼🔥
A rarity in this trial, an unpaid witness with no family connection.
Wym risk?? What’s the risk
@@big_von6232 he might be found in breach of contract with TMZ, and sued by the latter later. Or even blacklisted in the journalism industry at the very least.
So really, Tremaine has a lot to lose personally but nothing to gain, which makes his willingness to testify very admirable.
@@big_von6232 being fired from TMZ and losing his job, as an immediate consequence. furthermore, other workplaces where he might be trying to get a job in the future, might not want to be affiliated with him, since he "betrayed"/"revealed" TMZ's company secrets - essentially not finding a job anymore in the workfield he is currently in. and potentially more. so yes, there are definitely risks for him to step up into the witness stand.
edit: if you've followed the trial, there was a lawyer, sent by TMZ, to argue a motion to not grant the witness (Mr. Tremaine) into court at all, since it would infringe on the journalist-source trust - essentially trying to silence the witness.
@@big_von6232 Exactly what @LilPeanutish said!
I like this guy, he is simply telling the truth. He has nothing much to gain and possibly a lot to loose. I wish him all the best for his future.
Yes!!
CORRECTION AMBER HURD,-TURD is NOT a CELEBRITY she lied and deceived her way around HOLLYWOOD 😠
I don't really understand how this is bad for him. He gives tmz name called for millions to see.
@@shawonmia2290 He doesn't work for TMZ at this moment.
@@dvklaveren ok but he still gave them a spotlight.
The guy speaks fluently because he is telling the truth.
Abused people want to get away from their attackers not call the media. Sick.
She had no proof of abuse in that video.
@@vinnguy3533 not Amber Turd 😭💀
She is the perpetrator and a demon
TMZ is not standing by this man. He doesn't work for them anymore
Another psychiatrist testified that Amber apparently ticked some of the boxes for BPD. And honestly, based off of the evidence and testimonies we've seen in this case, I'm inclined to believe it. She comes across as *dangerously* unstable.
I am so happy he got to say everything we wanted to hear!!!!! I am smiling for Mr Depp!!!!
Me too
Me too! I hope this helps Johnny’s case and he could win. And I hope this man’s career is not done, hopefully 🙏 a company will take him.
Me too👍👍
This was a brilliant way to get around TMZ not wanting to reveal their sources. Again, Brilliant. Surpassed expectations.
Edit: I am aware that he no longer works for TMZ. That's why it waS so brilliant. TMZ was afraid that he would reveal a source, and could come after him. So he and Camille avoided angering TMZ while simultaneously guiding the jury to the conclusion that it could ONLY have been AH's team. They also revealed how calculating her plan was, helping to prove malice.
Thanks for this comment. I was wondering why Vazquez never asked him if the two tips (for the courthouse and the lawyer's office) and the video of Depp in the kitchen came from Heard or one of her sources. So, TMZ and their employees can't reveal their sources, but in the case of a trial like this, they certainly can make it fairly apparent who sources probably were. Excellent. Thanks again.
He can face legal trouble for this he signed a non-disclosure agreement i believe.
The tactics... Vasquez is a genius
@@elderassassin9673 He’s a very intelligent man. If he had signed a non disclosure agreement then he wouldn’t be testifying as a witness. He’s good, nice try though!
@@elderassassin9673 you believe or you actually know?? because he is on trial and has to swear an oath that his statement is true. So I doubt he is going to face anything legal considering he no longer works for TMZ either
7:42 he says 'we were instructed by the... news producer' he CLEARLY looks directly at Heard. A very clever and legally safe way to let everyone know she gave the tip-off without needing to actually say it.
So Amber Heard lied under oath when she said she didn't send the video to TMZ... got it! Elaine can't 'hearsay' her way out of this; it just shows desperation.
If her agent did it, it wasn’t considered to be Amber. But if I’m remembering correctly, JD’s lawyers asked her if she knew how it got leaked to TMZ and she said she didn’t know/recall. But if it got leaked by her agent and she found out about it, she definitely would have asked her agent about it. Pretty sure she does recall. Or at least she does now!!!
but she will "What if Any" around it like nascar racer
In the live now, an expert was exposing all her bruised picures was edited.
She had said "I have never edited a picture" 🤣🤣🤣
@@Graavigala85 This Comment is Epically Great 👍🏽
@@folkfooted she is the original owner so she has to give permission for TMZ to make it public… this was all on her
Clear, concise, straight to the point, no hesitation.
No indication of who's side he is on,not biased one way or the other... literally just stating facts.
The most believable out of every witness!!!
I was thinking exactly the same. The best person on the stand in this whole trial.
Well im pretty sure he doesnt want to be guilty of purjery
Very clear concise reporting. Great guy
Yeah, this guy is clear minded and level headed. Perfect witness.
@@JustADudeGamer still just to remove any confusion and blames i'd say this witness still us the nost credible one so far just straight to the point answers
Elaine was so afraid he was going to reveal the source she kept objecting everything he was "about to say".😂😂😂
This incriminated Amber so much 😂😂😂😂
So glad her objections got overruled for a change
Gold moment.. we need more people like him on earth.. people who stand up for truth regardless of how risky it might be for their own advantage/gain.
Just like Johnny Depp.
100%, mad respect for all those who come out to speak the truth and do what is right, laudable
He worked for TMZ and they stand up for whatever is caught on camera lol. It’s good fortune that he still is telling the truth though
@@1stMikeWhite pretty much. It seems most Media is shifted toward supporting Johnny Depp though, suffice to say in their typical two faced antic, they just follow along whats trending. Regardless, Amber's done lol
Mad disrespect for being involved in paparazzi media, but fairplay to him for this.
right after this amber's lawyer accuesd him of wanting "15 minutes of fame"... i cannot express how frustrated i felt...
and he turned it back on her!
Loved his reply though
Elaine is very sorry she said that: watch another video of the witness answer: EPIC
But he put her in her place by saying the same could be said for her.
That was great.
She does it to anyone who has witnessed interactions between them or has information that shows Amber in bad light! She did the very same to the women who worked at the airport.
"We receive tips often times from publicists, managers, agents, or ..B-list celebrities." 😂😭
I'm dead at Treimane low-key calling Amber Heard a B-lister. Ouch.
He s wrong, she's not even on the C-List.
Caught that too
I wish I saw her reaction to that 😂
That comment was everything! 😂🤣
I totally caught that too! and it was hilarious!!!! This guy is very intelligent
Just noticed at 7:18 he said “in tht link was a VIDEOOO…” while stink eyeing elaine cuz she was hellbent on interrupting him lmao
"She was supposed to turn towards the camera so we could get a shot of a bruise on the right side of her face."
Contradicts Amber's statement how the paparazzi just turned up. She knew!
What are the chances paparazzi would be sitting at the freaking courthouse? Of course they were tipped off
Yet TMZ still took photos of her bruised face. Yes this toxic relationship was abuse. It's not defamation if it's true. The end....Amber wins.
@@FutureMediaPro nice so you mean the people dying in the movies are actually dead cause if a bruise can't be makeup how could a fully torn human carcass could be
@@FutureMediaPro Of course they would. It's a story that gets them subscribers and views on their website, and money in the bank when they sell it to the tabloids.
My concern is that she previously denied any knowledge of knowing they would be there and has also said that she will never leave the house without makeup.
She also did not need to be at that courthouse that day. Someone from her lawfirm could've filed whatever. It's their job.
Yet, Amber Heard turns up in person to a courthouse without makeup and a bruise on her face. What's more, TMZ paps who just happened to be there, get the perfect shot. That did not look like she was trying to hide it, or that she was surprised.
That goes to her credibility as a witness. That's 2 things she's lied about already.
@@nameless7546 what are you talking about? And I'm sure when she was in the courthouse getting restraining order they wouldn't notice the makeup sweating off her face while she's crying. Please I get it you an Amber hater because she report domestic violence and you a fan of JD. Gives no one the right to attack her and so more bullying and that's why this country has a high rate of domestic violence because people re victimized them. PLUS THIS IS NOT A 🤬 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ABUSE CASE ITS DEFAMATION OF CHARACTER AND DEPP HAS NOT PROVEN THAT. HOLLYWOOD AND REAL LIFE ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS.
This was the most compelling out of everything. An abused woman that just wants to move on and doesn’t want any attention literally selling footage to tmz and tipping them off every time she was about to do something to make Johny look bad. Sounds like a bitter, jealous abuser. She wanted to hurt him. Plain and simple.
and this is crucial to the defamation case- not only that she not he was the abuser but that she was acting maliciously to slander him
she doesn't want to hurt him she wants his money.
Did she make money?
@@lindaiio24 So far, 7 million.
@@alexstar5182 She wants to get his money AND to hurt him
This is the nail in the coffin for AH. If I were sitting in the jury, hearing all I had heard for the last month, this guys testimony would’ve finalized this case for me.
My thoughts 💬 exactly 💯
Yup
The lies never end.
You meant the umpteenth nail didn't you.
@@caffiend. oh I’d be wondering for sure this whole time but this would tip over the edge to guilty.
Unironically the most trustworthy person to take the stand for the entire trial
Here are some quick facts about Amber that we know that are proven:
1) He wasn't the only alcoholic and drug abuser. She drank 2 bottles of wine a day, took drugs as well by her own admission.
2) Caught lying about using the makeup that didn't exist back then to "cover her bruises" frequently, which was refuted by the makeup company in court.
3) Past domestic violence arrest against her ex, literally charged and arrested. Plus admitted to domestic violence against Johnny. Plus suspicion of domestic violence against her own sister (her sister was discussing it with her friends by the poolside in a video clip), and assaulted her ex-best friend in public. In contrast Johnny has no history of being violent towards women, every single one of his ex gfs and spouses all speak highly of him, and has said he's never laid hands on them.
4) Audio recording of her admitting to cutting his finger in Australia (not allowed in this trial due to technicalities), proving again that her testimony was a lie. (one of the voices on the tape is now deceased and can't testify)
5) Her psychologist lied about Amber having no domestic violence history and was called out by Johnny's attorney.
6) Has NO witnesses or evidence (all conveniently random strangers that she doesn't know or deceased people like the bodyguard)
7) Her longtime assistant testified under oath that she did not once see or hear any physical abuse from Depp or ever saw any injuries on Heard in all the years. She also testified under oath that Heard spit ON her face when she asked for a raise
8) She visits Dr Kipper's office the day after an alleged incident where she was severely beaten, the doctor's medical report states her in perfect health, with no injuries of any kind on her, also state her skin was in perfect condition. Her explanation was "this was a partial report and I didn't have time to get into the details with the doctor about the injuries". (Day 16 of trial cross examination)
9) Allegedly got her nose broken, hit multiple times, her scalp and hair ripped off, penetrated by a bottle, dragged over broken glass and got her arms and legs "pretty cut up", then somehow felt safe enough to take sleeping pills with her "attacker" in the same house, woke up the next day and made him coffee, then went to James Corden's show miraculously healed. No marks, no scars, no pictures, no medical report . Hair stylist saw no signs of abuse, the hair stylist would've been inches away from her face looking at all the details while working on her appearance, and she saw 0 injuries. Multiple witnesses (including 3 cops) saw no signs of abuse.
10) Allegedly got raped and assaulted multiple times on her honeymoon, then wrote Johnny a love letter saying "it was the most amazing and beautiful honeymoon any girl could've ever dreamed of". (evidence presented in Day 18 of trial)
11) Claimed she wanted to leave Johnny, but in all the audio clips she was the one begging him to stay. Claimed she always tried to de-escalate, but in audio clips she was always the aggressor preventing him from leaving and taunting him .
12) In all her "crying", there's never a single tear coming out of her eyes, even when reciting the most "traumatic experience".
13) Allegedly feared for her life but bought him a large knife.
14) Testified under oath that she was beaten by Johnny with huge chunky rings on all his fingers, said she was "hit so many times in the face over and over again she lost count". The photos taken the next day shows her face completely spotless without any injuries, when cross examined, she answers "there do not appear to be any injuries on my face in that photo".
15) Caught lying under oath again saying she "didn't receive money" from Johnny when she got $7 million, and lying about "never assaulted" Johnny when she admits to it on tape.
16) Proven once again as a liar when she made public statement of donating 7 million dollars for children's hospital but in reality donated exactly 0 dollars before she was called out, also caught lying under oath about donating the money. Her sworn statement was "I donated the entire settlement of $7 million to charity", when cross examined, she states "I did not lie, I pledged the $7 million, "pledged" and "donated" are synonymous, they mean the same thing." (Day 16 of trial cross examination)
17) Blackmailing Depp with her attorney, trying to make a deal for 3 of the adjoining penthouses where they both lived, 50k monthly expenses, 500k in attorney fees and the SUV Depp let her drive in exchange for not filing the protection order.
18) Her publishing of the op-ed "domestic violence" piece is timed perfectly with the release of Aquaman film, it didn't get published when they divorced, or before, or right after, but instead it was published right when Aquaman was being released and when the "Me Too" movement was grabbing the most headlines.
19) Amber Heard's team desperately tried to stop the trial from being publicly broadcasted while Depp's team made sure it was made public
20) Long time friend and co worker of Amber Heard telling about her hardcore cocaine and drug habit dating all the way back to 2008 when they were close associates, (youtube show called "Steven and Jason" and in the newest episode titled "We need to talk about AH").
21) Amber testified about having injuries such as “gross colored puss coming out of her temple” and “suffering a broken nose”, but when cross examined she changes the lines to “gross colored puss UNDER HER SCALP” and “FELT like a broken nose”, because she knew the evidence is about to show ZERO injuries visible on her. (How does she see gross colored puss under her scalp? With an X-ray machine??)
22) Allegedly got beaten up for FIVE YEARS and not a SINGLE injury shown on her face, no doctor visits, no dentists, no surgeons, no photos, despite countless appearances in public events and countless photos taken given her celebrity status, many of those public appearances were the night after "the beating", keep in mind the beating were all allegedly done by Depp with "huge chunky" rings on all his fingers, yet after five years of beating, she didn't need to visit the doctors once or show on sign of injury on her face, sounds like her facial bone density and durability of her skin can match that of armor platings.
23) Alleges Johnny slashed the soles of her feet, but was seen the next day walking completely normal, again no doctor visits or treatments of any kind even though she has a personal doctor on retainer.
24) Constantly changing details of her stories and allegations, she's already given 4 different versions of the poop incident, she has said "1: told security guard that she pooped and it was a practical joke gone wrong. 2: Johnny did it to frame her. 3: said it never happened and Johnny was gaslighting her. 4: said the tiny puppies did it."
25) Her lying under oath is not even worth mentioning anymore, there is too many to list, just to list a few in this trial alone. Lying about not receiving any money from Johnny, when in fact she received $7 million. Lying about having donated the money, when in fact she has donated $0 so far. Lying about never assaulted Johnny, when in fact she was recorded admitting to it multiple times. Lying about never assaulted anyone before, when in fact she's assaulted at least 4 that we have evidence of. Lying about her injuries, when a medical record showed absolutely no injuries.
26) She put someone through hell for years, publicly shamed and destroyed his career and life, just so she can be seen as a noble victim and use the attention and sympathy to advance her career and profile. She claims she's never wanted to be seen as a victim and wanted to move on, but appears in countless TV shows and articles talking about her "abuse" and "donation" non stop, literally appeared on every show she could to talk about her being a victim and being noble on the donation that never happened.
27) Amber's own friend, Tillet Wright, a long time close friend with Amber Heard, testified under oath that he's never seen or heard Amber being abused by Johnny Depp. (Day 20 of trial)
She was bringing men back to Jonny's home and cheating.
She and her family and friends all lived off him.
She wouldn't give him his meds when he really needed them.
She had a dog hanging out window of a moving car and said it was Johnny.
She's on tape telling him no one will believe he's been abused by her
SHE WILL GET HER COMEUPPANCE and that's not a pledge or promise it's A FACT
Wow. Brilliant summary- pls post that comment across tonnes of videos and let’s flood the internet with the truth!!
You’re wrong about the $0 donations (watch again to confirm)
Excellent.
Did I also see her completely reverse the bathroom door incident in her deposition?
She’s like a Smollet. Trying to up her acting worth by faking the fashionable victimhood of the day.... and failing miserably...
Everyone calls her Amber Turd now 😂
Also - I’d lump her in with that Pinket creature - I’m betting Will has had some of this bs too.
Basically these women (imho) are jealous of their megastar husbands.
Although, I can believe Johnny might have jealousy issues too, I think he was provoked by her behaviour.
You can see he was trusting and in love by the lack of pre-nup.
Great analysis you’ve done here, saves me sifting through the boring bits.
Please don’t forget, this is timed to have you otherwise engaged whilst they ruin your country.
DONT ALLOW THEM to sign away your sovereignty to the WHO. Write to your reps now.
This is important.
@@jackjones4578 No they are right, the donation was made by Johnny since it was his money, but then Amber ensured that the funds were redirected to her instead of directly to the ACLU, so technically, they are right.
When the world needed him most, this man revealed himself, and we thank you good sir.
Ask the people of Uvalde Texas if they need this man right now.. he's a key witness, but have some perspective please.
"Good Sir"?Are you serious?
@@lennonslemons4934 Jesus Christ 🤦🏻♂️ 😩, are you going around any comments about anything just being one of those people? Like did you go to the Last air bender RUclips video and get mad that they said the same thing too? You’re cringe asf
@@stevem.5046 why are you here commenting then 🤣 don’t worry Steve everyone needs a little trash in their boring lives.. it’s ok 👍🏻
@@kimerietate8372 why are you watching this then? Why is anyone commenting bitching about anything other than the trial?!? Are y’all bored?! We re all here watching the TRIAL THUS WE RE COMMENTING ABOUT THE TRIAL
Just when you think she can’t look any worse, things like this just KEEP coming out
After all this and she doesn't go to jail I'd just go crawl into a hole lol. .....Honestly though I don't care what happens with her, just want Johnny to get back to acting!
She's busted !
Didn't you see the abusive messages from Deep? She's losing.
Can you imagine the things she has done to others? She is a living maniac!
@@icem8n usually I’d feel bad or take pity on someone but not her!!! Like ya say, she needs to be in jail!!!!
''To capture her leaving the courthouse , and then, she was going to stop and turn towards the camera to display the bruise on the right side of her face'' BOOM!! SHE KNEW ABOUT EVERYTHING, SHE LIED UNDER OATH!!
Good for him! There is right and wrong. She is defiantly in the wrong! He’s very, very, very, brave to speak out.
she's definitely in the wrong too
why defiantly
@@DawnDiggetyNoDoubt Yes I'd even say by her attitude, defiantly definitely wrong.
@@DawnDiggetyNoDoubt Honestly both lol
I don’t know, people. I think defiantly is oddly appropriate in this case.
Good on Camille for clarifying with her questions about obtaining a copyright from a direct source (Morgan's answer: "15 minutes") and Morgan's response to the next question of 'how long did it take you to obtain the copyright?' being "15mins" with a good, long pause after it. Let it hang with the jury. She really knows when to stop and give weight to witnesses' answers. She is so methodical, tactical and clear. It's fascinating watching this.
Yes, that was a clever workaround for the fact there could be some lawyers in between her and the " media buyer". He could maybe not say anything about the deal they have made but the way Camille asked verified that the media material had to come from the copyright owner itself.
The only critique I have is that she talks slightly monotone and sounds a bit too happy a lot of the time. So some of the points could be missed if you’re not paying attention fully to the actual words being said as it would sound like a pleasant conversation in the background. The pause becomes a bit more subtle than it could be.
Yup.. This testimony plus Amber Heard's slip up (when she accidentally said that TMZ was alerted and then covers her mouth with her hands) during her deposition back in 2016 show that she was the one that had been leaking all these informations to TMZ. It is pretty obvious.
Can she not ask him directly how or who he recieved the video from because that would be hearsay? Because if so then that was a brilliant work around
@@basketballguru9879 that and he could possibly be sued for directly revealing who sent it
How is it ok for a lawyer to shout "objection" just because she THINKS the witness is about to say something heresy before the witness even says anything ?????
Welcome to the justice system
I think it can be called if the question actually calls for hearsay, like if you ask "what did amber say to you" kind of thing that's hearsay because you're saying what someone else said. I could totally be wrong about this though
It’s not and a clear sign of fear of factual information being stated.
I think the objection was to the lawyers question in general
@@acemusic_va you are correct. Most of the time, you can call an objection whenever you hear a keyword or phrase
Morgan Tremaine is such a hero on so many levels! Of course he knows she's guilty. Thank you for coming forward. He is completely credible and just wanted to put out the truth! Justice has been served.
I like how AH's lawyer keeps objecting hearsay with "HE'S ABOUT TO SAY..." as if she knows what he's about to say
That just proves that Elaine already knows who is responsible!! Also, she thinks he's going to say her name and he's actually much more professional than that.
Which makes it look even worse that Elaine calls him out for testify to get his 15 minutes of fame?!
She does and even though she objects, once the jury hears it they can’t forget it, they just can’t use it as a reason. So she is objecting before he says it so the jury never gets the chance to hear it.
she knew he was about to tell the truth so, better find a reason, any reason, to stop him
It doesn't matter. He was very believable, and the best part was when he clearly looked and nodded towards Amber when talking about the video being sent in. He literally let the jury know that it was her without ever saying it. Priceless!
Thank You!!!
the audacity for Amber to lie in the court shows what kind of a person she is, she has no shame for her own reputation.
And to top it off she uses the MeToo movement as cover. Not only is she lying but she's basically invalidating any cred that movement gained.
Are you new to Fox News?
She SNORTED COKE IN THE COURTROOM - she has no shame. Videos all over social media including RUclips showing same. She's vile
Her lying is just one of the reasons why she’s in court at all right now. Like many others, I just can’t imagine how the UK judge came to his conclusion, even if he’d had just half this information, as I’ve always read that the laws about lying in tabloids, are more strict in England.
Maybe there will be a sea change against immediately acting as if a woman, with a similar story, couldn’t possibly be lying, especially when they use tabloids and recorded conversations, articles in a magazine,etc. to tell their story.
All of these recordings, both audio and video, yet she never once got him actually coming after her? Come now.
She didn’t want police involved, because her “bruise” that TMZ broke the story on, would’ve been seen then wiped away by anyone examining her.
Look up videos on the bruise kit, which Heard even called it herself on the stand.
I’ve seen several women apply the exact “shiner with foundation” she was setting up a situation for TMZ to film.
The saddest thing about this, is that anyone actually being abused, now will face more scrutiny, especially if they’re a celebrity, in a messy relationship headed for divorce.
@@CorbCorbin she's not doing real rape victims a favour is she
Elaine: “OBJECTION”
Judge: “Okay, explain?”
Elaine: “uhhhh I don’t know?”
She's trying...she's trying...
Hahaha
Poor Elaine had a hard time with this case. I wonder if it’s just the lack of evidence or if she is just a bad lawyer all around.
😂😂😂💀
@@Laineelee-j9p If she was getting paid $7.50/hour, I would feel sorry for her too. But she's getting paid $300/hour at least plus the retainer. I doubt she feels sorry nor poor.
This witness literally showed the lengths ah would go to to lie and cover-up her tracks. Destroyed her credibility altogether on his own
If this doesn’t make the jury side 100% for Johnny because AH lied I will be so disappointed. She schemed and she committed perjury
Nobody cares about your disappointment
Her HORRIBLE acting on the stand was enough to convince me. Plus, I was shocked her PR team made her wear those clothes. For a minute I thought I was watching the movie Chicago! 😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡
AT*
Highly doubt tbh, any chance she could have is being destroyed now in the cross evidence stage… her tale is so full of holes that is impossible to think she didn’t write that article with malicious intent of ruining his life.
Yesterday I saw a video on here from a lawyer ( who was in this courtroom) and a behaviorist. The lawyer and he discussed mrs turds testimony and he said that the jury ( in his opinion) doesn’t sided with her.
Isn’t it pathetic to object for something she thinks “he is about to say”? In many cases for questions not even calling for hearsay
It baffles me. If I was the judge I would have done told that lawyer to shut up and let em talk first
@@KULDSWET what baffled me is when Amber heard called the court hearing "The Johnny Depp Show"- why was there no objection to that? AH is the monster
@@valerievelarde62 Yes she's trying to frame it as something he created, but she is counter-suing, so it's as much her show too.
@@valerievelarde62 "Don't interrupt when your enemy is making a mistake"
It's because the lawyer is aware how damaging this testimony really is. it shoots big holes in a large part of Heard's defense.
This chick has lied so much under oath!! There should seriously be consequences for her nonsense!! This is ridiculous!!!!
lying for amber is like her routine,
unfortunately she’s probably not going to be called out because y’know those rules dont apply to rich white girls lmao
@@adabong rich people in general darlin
@@sossaa2962 i know but especially white girls
Can there be jail time for lying under oath?
This guy is so good that he has a true integrity in his heart. This is great courage that he took to sit there as a witness.
I'm sorry, but she was snickering at the end of the video and she edited that part before she sent it to TMZ?
Amber, you're just unbelievable.
She did mess with the photos and other media
She’s low of the lowest and lowest of the low.
Yeah when I heard about the snickering I was shocked
Especially when you know he just found out his parent passed away that morning. Who taunts someone during that time?
Now the jury has both, unedited and edit version of that video.
I can't even comprehend how SCANDALOUS a person can be...to make up such vicious lies, fake bruises, and then tip off the paparazzi to film it? Wow....what a piece of work.
She has to much time
Happens alot. Women falsely accusing men out of bitterness or with something to gain. Hence why the believe women movement is utter nonsense. When these allegations occur for men, just as happened to Mr. Depp, they lose everything and their lives are ruined. Even being falsely accused of things as a man is enough to ruin your life due to the seriousness of the allegations. i believe any women falsely accusing a man of rape or sexual assault or battery should receive double the penalty for that which they are falsely accusing.
Evil plan from an evil person
and now she reaps the whirlwind, bankruptcy for which she whining on about now lol
She's an awful person, and IMHO, she did all this, because Johnny had the nerve to leave her and want a divorce. People do NOT leave AH and get away with it scot free, in her mind.
I believe this was punishment for him leaving her, her fear of abandonment. And $$ of course. She pledged the 7 million to charity and wanted something for herself.
There REALLY should be punishment for outright lying about all this abuse, it makes a mockery of real victims of DV.
I wish the lawyers would ask for perjury charges once this is done. She made a mockery of domestic violence. Absolutely tarnished true victims.and has made a mockery of our system of justice as well
I agree 100% she is still using her narcissistic abuse right in court!! She has mocked all that have survived are still going through and those we have lost. She doesn't care about what she is putting her family and friends through.
As a survivor we don't make eyecontact like she does we do not sit all cock and brave confident during and sometimes for the rest of our lives. I can't even express how much she needs jail..probation,community service in abuse shelters therapy and pay back every single cent to him!!!@
It ain't over yet! I think the judge may be waiting for the end of the trial so she can rack up some more charges! She isn't finished lying yet!
@@gretabenoit2415 ....Well said and I agree with you completely.
Yes!
Never going to happen
I do hope that TMZ does not try to sue this guy. He did not reveal his source, just that the source had direct ownership of the cupboard film. We can deduce the rest.
Well done, young man. You did so well and held your own, especially knowing that the representative of TMZ was watching and listening to every word. 👏 TMZ should actually applaud you for your integrity - usually so lacking in media-land.
He definitely got his "15 mins of fame" and even more. He will continue to get more than that because he seems credible and a good witness, spitting unbiased facts. 👏👏👏
I love your name!
It's not his 15 mins of fame it's the truth.
I LOVE how adamantly her lawyer is trying to stop this, but shes powerless.
She is doing her job and you don’t know if is powerful or not Because you are not a lawyer and you don’t have expertise in this matter
@@mit7198 well the fact that she was continuously overruled says that.
@@mit7198 cope
@@mit7198 cope
@@mit7198 cope
This dude just stole the show. I was howling with his “15 minutes of fame” answer!!! 😭😭😭
It was great!! Everyone else is afraid to make fun of dumb things the heard lawyers say. He made us all laugh.
I spit my tea 🤣😂
The guy is a boss 📸
Me too! It was the best response ever to AHs lawyers ridiculous continued attempt at bully witnesses. An attempt that keeps failing lmao
He didn’t even need 15 minutes. K.O. Elaine in two seconds and that’s enough 🤣🤣🤣🤣
With so much of evidence against Amber, I just hope the jury will give out a verdict to the actual person who has been actually ABUSED, and that is MR. JOHNNY DEPP. Women like Amber is an insult to the millions of women who are actually abused every day for years. What an example she is setting for her child who will grow up to see the lies she has portrayed to get her way.
This isn't about AH abusing JD, it's about whether AH calling JD a wife beater affected his career or not.
**Not actually his career but whether can it be categorised as defamation.
They don't have the ability to do that, but Depp can press charges if his statute of limitations doesn't expire. and in California, depending on the type and severity their are no limitations. He could persue it, but it was pretty cear he didn't feel comfortable calling her an abuser or yelling he's abused. He's unfortunately the most common type of survivor, silent and "just move on" type.
This Guy knows what he is talking about and you can tell that he doesnt like Amber, he really wanted to say guys she is behind all this but he couldnt do It. He really wanted to help Johnny. Johnny is not perfect but compared to Amber he is a Saint. He didnt hurt anyone but himself. I wish him the BEST.
Lol "Guys, she's behind all this..."
Ya I noticed that when AH legal team tried to object him saying whose the source was, he gave them a look of despise like " I knew you would object but I havent say it yet".
@@howardho8467 The defense lawyer's objection accidentally, but completely telegraphed what she didn't want him to say regarding the source.
I think so too...he was so calm answering to camille but was looking irritated when it was ellaine's turn
Why couldn’t he just say she was behind it though?
Camille is a fabulous Lawyer...
The delivery of her questioning is nothing less than brilliant...
Short concise questions...👍
Open questions to her witnesses, closed questions in cross-examination. She knows her job.
It's scary to think for how long in years people believed the mainstream media, and did not take Johnny's side at all.
Ppl are too afraid to side against the woman these days and the media will always support a woman's claims especially now with the me too movement
Happens to a lot of abuse victims sadly. And i dont really blame the layman for believing it. Hopefully this trial will help create more awareness
Ever been to Family/Divorce court?
* did not? still “ they do not a
Reality is futile. You must trust the heart of people and not the media, for social media is the mother of all evil.
He is a strong and credible witness, since he’s actually received and reviewed the video.
This just solidifies that AH was truly "trapping" JD. She was like weaving an intricate web of narrative by filming JDs action and response as well as involving the press to capture certain moments in her actions to make it so as to paint herself in front of the people that she was the "bullied" one, the victim and abused and to come as "authentic" as possible and she almost gotten away from this...luckily, she was not that consistent and her narratives have cracks and loopholes. I didn't believe her from the start that it was not for the money...so why pledge when you can directly donate the money to its intended recipient? Also, it was good that this is a public hearing and you can judge yourself whether she was being "authentic" at this point in time. I'm not a huge fan of JD and certainly not an AH fan even when she appeared at Aquaman but I stand on the side of the logic and the truth and from my own formed opinion, AH is certainly not authentic...
You're absolutely right and isn't it ironic with all The Times she found him unknowingly there's never one instance of him hitting her like she claimed
Is correction filmed not found
Even the cuts on her left arm look like self inflicted by a right handed person
Named Amber
So straight are the cuts must be deliberate
you can tell ah has set JD up by everything she’s recorded- no one records or films their convos with their husband as a norm. Seems like ah has hours and hours of footage and recordings from the start.
There was a blind item published in 2015 about AH trying to get power of attorney over JD while they were dating and was advised that she should marry him. Would explain all the recordings and photos.
Geeze! Her lawyer now thinks she can predict the future. “Objection, hearsay, I think he is about to say something that is hearsay”. 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
She has seen tens of thousands of such witnesses.
I know right?? 🤣
Well, making the objection before a witness says anything is normal. For instance if asked ”what did this guy say to you?” Objection hearsay, because what that guy said should be said by the guy himself as a separate witness. Not what someone says he allegedly said. Just an example.
Desperation. “Please don’t say something that will damage our case further!!”
🤣🤣🤣🤣
This guy makes a better lawyer then any of Heards team. Sharp, confident and on point.
i really wanna see one amber supporter defending her on this
He's not a lawyer
@@darklaboratory1697 if
This man needs to study law and take and pass the bar, in my opinion he is considered and a good talker. Be a great lawyer
Considerent
It’s giving me comfort and some sort of closure to see someone important like JD coming forward about fake domestic abuse allegations while he was and is the one who got abused by AH . As a Man I was abused emotionally and physically for many years and didn’t say a thing and tried my best to fix it but at the end she cheated on me , and projected on me everything she had done to me for years. I lost everything because of it , it literally took me back financially 20 years , from owning 2 houses to not being able afford paying rent .. JD is lucky he didn’t have to fight for his child’s custody as well !.. I am a male survivor and all this hits home really hard !
So glad ur out of that situation and moving towards a positive direction! Stay safe!!
Appreciate your honesty. I only know first hand about male survivors of DV as my son-in-law was abused by his spouse. Thank you for your comment.
I'm so happy you are out of the situation and csn find solace in this trial and verdict. Sending much love x
🫂🧡🌷
🙏🏾
The fact that he said she was laughing and smiling at the end of the video just shows she was doing it on purpose to try and make JD look bad. I seriously hope she gets jail time.
She can’t get jail time for this trial. It’s not that type of trial
@@PharySoul Yes she can be charged for perjury after the trial ends. that is up to a year in jail,I've seen it happen before
She need a harsh punishment, she needs to be a example for all women thinking about pulling this mess, it happens every single day..smh
I AGREE! I am Not a Pro, yet, I have Studied Narcissism Extensively. The DSM Psychological Guideline for Diagnosis, requires that the Narc present themselves into Therapy, & admit that their ‘disposition’ is affecting their life adversely before an Official Diagnosis can be made.
Narcissism is Created, due to a Traumatic Childhood, & starts w/Abandonment Issues. They say, that a Brain-Groove is Created that forms the Narcs. Perverse COPING Personality. This is Permanent, & can Never be Healed. The Best that can happen, is if there is a catastrophic event, like: PRISON, DEATH of A CHILD, or Other Extreme Event that Forces TRUTH, that they would not have Otherwise arrived at. This would allow for willful improvements, yet, would never come Natural, per se; as in- Lesson learned, & updated Beliefs.
These are TRAUMATIZED CHILDREN, in ADULT BODIES. Trauma, Comes Out SIDEWAYS!
From listening to Many on-line Therapists… This is part of the “Dark Triad,” & several used the Word EVIL. In So Many words, when someone ASKED, if there was a Spiritual Element, this One Gal, answered, “There are millions of Narcs. all over the world, & none of them have gone to school to Learn the Protocol that all Narcs live-by. Yet, each follows the NPD Tactics: which include (a few only): No Empathy, Control, Gaslighting, Brainwashing, Grooming, by Punishment & Reward, Devaluation, Word Manipulation/ Some, Considered Sophisticated BW Techniques (talking FBI stuff), Recruited Helpers, to sometimes include elements of Psychopathy, & Sociopathy.
I AM Greatly worried for Amber, & want for her to Get the Help she Needs… Which, with Continuing Therapy, would Present Boundaries that she may learn to Follow, if she so Chose for Herself. .🙏🏻💛🕊🍃
I hope too🙏
Damn... Camille absolutly killed it with the way she worded everything and allowed the information to speak for itself. That guy made for an excellent witness. Clear and concise with his explanations, factual and to the point about everything. This is absolutly damning testimony against Amber, and should absolutly be one of the final nails in the coffin. I can't see a world where a jury would still rule in Ambers favor at this point.
Totally agree with you, however historically juries seem to be either gullible or dumber than dirt in high profile cases...I have no faith in them whatsoever. I hope I'm wrong.
Do you think Camille writes these questions by herself? All she does is ask questions.
He said it without saying it. AH gave us the tip/video = “it takes 15 minutes to process a tip/video for us to process its credibility and this tip/video took 15 minutes.” 💥
@@user-yt5dg8nf6y yes I'm sure she wrote some as well as the rest of the team while they were brainstorming together... what kind of question is that? Camille is a seasoned lawyer. 12+ years I believe.
@@user-yt5dg8nf6y and no, she does quite a bit more than just ask questions...
This man is a class act. Hands up to him for being honest and taking no crap from Elaine! 15 minutes of fame 😂
I mean I don't know how much "class" a giy that work for TMZ can have but yeah at least it seems that he is telling the truth here
😂😂
@@camirovi8364 I think It was just a job for him he’s now working in gaming isn’t he?
@@luluah1198 is he? I really hope so, I wouldn't want someone like him to stay in such buisness as TMZ, gaming however, pretty nice.
@@Lunaticmist yes , he is , watch his entire testimony he mentioned it at first
A good example of someone who cares about the truth and knows has to come forward to do the right thing. Even though it can put him at risk. It's selfless and admirable
Elaine loves insulting witnesses, that's for sure. But this guy let her taste her own medicine. How satisfying can that be?!!! Hooray!!!
Very very very very satisfying.
Funny how Ambers team sounds toxic like her....
Yeah！ finally! Elaine deserve this. Very satisfying to see Elaine taste her own medicine.
I guess you have to a certain kind of B``CH to even take the job to defend this devilish creature.. I hope these lawyers end up scrubbing floors after this.. No one will hire them again, i hope... But i guess they allready know they did a huge mistake by saying yes.
He slaps her very gently but using at the same time the Infinity Gaunlet lol
This guy is pure class. Glad he's moved on from TMZ and taken his talents elsewhere.
This gent is sharp as a tack. No wonder TMZ employed him operationally at such a young age.
employed to run after public figures for gossip columns? what an honorable job indeed!!!!!!
@@brettcantrell8650 no one said it was honorable. He would do great as a journalist and not a worker for TMZ as well. He has good qualities that they would look for. That's all the original poster is saying
@Victor B he is corrupt anyway. He just came for the limelight. He does not know who sent the video. He is just trying to cause a stir. He came prepared with well oiled and highlighted hair, etc.
He was WELL coached.
@@brettcantrell8650 what the honor has to do with the money he was getting?? The kid is sharp indeed, only objection I might have is his painted black nails, not a sign of a cowboy. Not everyone can be saving the exotic wild parrots in Antarctica if that for you is an honorable job or a firefighter
So much for “protecting” him like she always love to point out.
My day started off horribly... then this guy showed up and my heart was full of joy again.
Haha
Tis a day of bliss 😁🤘🤘🤘
nice last name
Yes his testimony was so satisfying
My day was horrible after crying over the texas school shooting :(
Now Im hooked again
This is probably the most damning testimony i have seen so far as far as defamation. It strongly suggests that she is the source and that she actively sought media exposure to put the business out there. Great witness
The photographer damned her even more. Amber's team was scrambling with him.
Suggest? Are you paying attention? TMZ can't post a video unless it's been bought by the original owner, who took the video
@@altovelli0883 Tremaine heavily implied Amber sent the video without actually directly stating she sent the video.
@@LiveLoveLaugh102310 Correct, that's was my Replied to Zechariah. That was a smart move by Depps lawyers
@@altovelli0883 Much like Ms Turd never mentioned JD by name in the article... but you know *exactly* who is meant.
The most honest Employee TMZ ever had…possibly…RESPECT for this wonderful man!
He is under aoth, I believe
Probably why he doesn't work there anymore. Good for him what a horrible company.
Yeah paparazzi and tmz is a disgusting job . Wonder why this guy isn’t working for them anymore .
Exactly. Paparazzi and TMZ are all so terrible and judgmental.
Definitely gained my respect, honest, unbiased and fair responses.
“B-List celebrities….” *Glances at Amber* 😂🤣
Im happy that Camille did the examination for this guy. Direct, compact and exact.
And the guy's answer is direct and exact. No zigzag and no looking at the jurors.
But, what about the muffins?
The way the lawyer held the questioning in such an order that a listener is slowly but directly led to the realisation that the copyright owner aka AH must agree to a publication and therefore knew of it was SO SMOOTH. Hats off to her
I thought the same. Camille done a really good job. I was thinking: why she's doing so much questions about the way they follow a tip?...and then 15 minutes?!? 🤯🤯🤯
Yeh it's a really pitch perfect example of how to lay out information and lead a conversation.
she can't just say ( that means amber leaked it) nor should see but she was made to make it clear that is the case without ever saying anything close to it
The other attorney tried to interrupt to wreck the rhythm but was shot down. Even the judge wanted to know the inner workings of tmz
The phrasing of her questions and way she tiptoed around any possible hearsay objections but still got her point across is quite masterful
That's exactly what I thought, such a smart move. Did you notice how she poses after he says it was posted within 15 minutes after receiving it after explaining that would only be possible if it came form the person with ownership. MIC DROP! Well done Camille!
I love how he had an emphasis on “B list actors,” as if he’s trying to imply something about a certain person…………
Exactly
I noticed that as well. What a sly snarky move. Lol
Right? The way he let it sear in the hot pan, and by the time he said "15 mins", voila, burrrnt to perfection 👌
Caught that shade! 🌴
One of the slyest burns I’ve ever seen
10:57 The most damning piece of evidence brought up during the questioning of this guy. She deliberately edited the video to make JD look bad but we all know this now but I just think it’s so fascinating how she actually thought she’d get away with this. I still think she needs to have perjury charges brought against her. She shouldn’t be free right now. I love how she’s pretending to write things but it’s been debunked that her pen was barely ever touching the paper or she was just scribbling to look busy.
This Heard woman is diabolical. Talk about destroying yourself in the process of destroying an innocent other
I think she really loved Depp, and that love turned into hate when he rejected her, due to her bad character and behaviour.
Demonic entity on two legs.
@@Rorshach1004 I highly doubt that.
@@Rorshach1004 how did Johnny rejected her? Johnny loved her so much. He was with Vanessa Paradise for 14 years, had two kids with her and didn't marry her. But married Amber after two years of dating. So he loved her. She abused his love
I'm loving it, so many women have gotten away with this nonsense....they make real victims look like jokes.
This is AMAZING because it's direct evidence that Amber was intentionally defaming him from the start!
That's what they needed to prove... malingering malice is what is required to prove defamation. If WE see this, then you can have a pretty good feeling that the jurors did, too.
That was literally music to my ears, Camille is conducting those questions brilliantly and the witness cleverly leading us to make deductions that Amber herself leaked everything without him saying her name (preventing her layers to stop him further)
The way she left a pause after he said he didn't need to obtain copyright because they received it directly from the source
She's very good at inserting pauses and letting the silence speak for the words
EXACTLY! That's how real lawyers do it👏👏
Watch and learn Elaine 😂
Inferences, not deductions.
Relistening to this, I notice how smartly Camille led the questioning, in particular the question as to what circumstances would lead him to send reporters to the courthouse, leaving no doubt the story was leaked.
she perjured herself multiple times over - there should be consequences
Courts normally HATE making perjury charges except when a witness in a criminal case stiffs the prosecution. I think that since this entire case has been based on perjured testimony, and tied up the court for weeks, MAYBE the state will step up and enforce the law to protect the court system. If perjury becomes commonplace, then no testimony can be trusted. She just might have stepped in it.
What A man.. he said Alleged bruise two times.. great choosing of terms 💚
Yes. Very smart. Straight to the point.
He promptly and clearly answered all questions
15 minutes not only a fame.. but a born of a new hero