'One of the greatest moments of my life was standing onstage next to David Bowie while he sang "Hurt" with me. I was outside of myself, thinking, "I'm standing onstage next to the most important influence I've ever had, and he's singing a song I wrote in my bedroom." It was just an awesome moment.' - Trent Reznor
and the reason he would feel that way is because David Bowie showed everyone how important they were or great of talent they had. He was a special kind of legend that made others shine without dimming his own. One of a kind there.
That first grin that crosses Trent's face( Hey, damn, this is Bowie on stage with me singing my song! ) was a look of ridiculous giddiness. Just a pure, insane happiness that feels like Trent has never known. Who else is here in Jan. 2024 with a tear in their eyes?
Just finding this today, October 2024. Spent a portion of the day thumbing through RUclips and missing Bowie. This just popped up to make me cry. Bowie was my hero growing up, and much respect for Reznor💔💔💔
I love the contrast of their voices. Trent's feels so much sharper, and Bowie's so much softer and more rounded off. Like a broken piece of glass, and a crystal ball, respectively.
@@Dizzula I love Labyrinth- Was always a favorite movie of mine ever since I was a little kid-I'd like to see it again as it's been so many years-I remember playing it for my son when he was younger too & I even thought I named my dog after the dog in that movie- There's that little guy who thinks hes so tough & he rode on the dog who was fearful So there were parts I always loved as a kid such as the little tiny guy saying 'I've got you surrounded & when the dog runs off he says 'Stop your embarrassing me in a very funny accent-I always thought it was 'Stop your embarrassing me Rufus so I named my dear dog- may he Rest In Peace-Rufus For so long I'd tell my son about this part of the movie I remembered from such a young age & when we finally watched it 1 day the dogs name wasn't Rufus-It was, something much longer like 'Bronfucious or something LOL It's my own funny story & my Rufus was the greatest pet-buddy ever-R.I.P. Rufus
+finkle stiener Trent recently did an interview about it, his words were "I'm standing onstage next to the most important influence I've ever had, and he's singing a song I wrote in my bedroom." Read more: www.rollingstone.com/music/news/trent-reznor-recalls-how-david-bowie-helped-him-get-sober-20160126#ixzz3yUGBm2uL Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook
+MightyCoont There are three versions of Hurt. The version from Downward Spiral, this live version w/ Bowie and Johnny Cash's version. Each is amazing in their own way, because each mean something completely different. Its a testament to how powerful of a song it is, to be sung by three amazing artists and tell three different stories. I have my personal preference, but in the face of that accomplishment....well, it hardly matters.
You know what, fuck Johnny Cash. Talented man, but his song this is not, nor is it Bowie's despite how great this duet is. How many songs did he write in his whole career? 20, 30-ish? I don't care if the comment is uncalled for, I'm tired of the inevitable "that song belongs to Cash now" comment...oh look, there's one below the OP. I won't bother to get into how Cash (for lack of a better word) raped the context of the song with his vastly differt sound and themes. Again, heavy word there, but I don't care. And I don't care how Trent feels, saying "it's not his song anymore". Fuck Trent. The guy who wrote this song died 17 years ago from an overdose. Much respect to the happy father of two who bears his name and still puts out good music, but he's not, nor will he ever be *there* again to write or own this song. It's the epitaph of a semi-fictional hollow, broken man, not a Christian who does country covers for the maudlin masses.
What I love about Hurt is that the original and the Cash version are both incredibly moving and amazing. However, they are sang as two different songs. This song embodies the angst and anguish a younger person would feel. Whereas the Cash version captures a lifetime of pain and regret. It's as if they are being song by a son and then a father back to him. Also this has David fucking Bowie in it. Rad.
Your comment is so right on. My son Jimmy passed away in 2008, he loved NIN but, when Johnny Cash sang it he actually did a thesis on how one song could be interpreted by the way two people of different generations sang it.I just had to comment because it’s so true
I agree, and I'd even add that this version is something else entirely, Trent has been on record saying his respect for David and this was a dream come true for him, you can see his emotions overflowing throughout the performance, an amazing piece of art
I made sure that this was the first concert I ever went to back when I was 13. I saw the Camden NJ date with Prick opening. The gradual transition between the NIN and Bowie sets is still uayched to this day.
I think it's amazing the sonic blend of their voices, both such TRUE musicians and amazing talents in their own right.Trents voice slicing through like a shard of broken glass, and bowie's backing vocals smoothing the edges while allowing that grit and power to really shine through. They killed it. I love the cash version (apparently an unpopular opinion, even though trent liked it too) but this version is a FIERCE rival. so glad they both exist so I don't HAVE to ever choose. someone earlier tried to say "ohhhh this is a song about a broken man....what would christian johnny cash know of any of that...not realizing that the man in black had his own struggles with drug and alcohol addiction and quite a lurid past himself, which I believe shone through in the visceral "pain" that can be felt in his version of "hurt". But whatever... I'll listen to and enjoy both while those oh so much wiser than me critique them and voice their opinions, ever the contrarian and critic. 😂
@@vegdagol2843 I don't think you're giving NIN fans enough credit. How young do you think they are? I'd venture to say many fans of NIN/Trent Reznor are and were familiar with Bowie... I mean it's David f*ckin Bowie - he wasn't exactly an opening act.
@@estherwells2298 Johnny Cash's version seemed to me to be more about his regret & his love for June Carter & his losses but I also believe back in his days he struggled with an H addiction too-I remember watching most of the movie 'I Walk The Line I think it was called-I didn't think it would be my type of movie as I don't listen to Country music but I remember enjoying how he wore all black & went against the mainstream Gospel music at that time & he was a Rocker in his own right & parts made me cry-I can't remember how it ended so I'd have to see it again -I remember in the movie he was married with kids but always in love with June Carter once he met her which was sad for his wife but I understood with all the time he spent with June on the road & I will say-I honestly have no idea if they ever actually got together-In his video when he covered 'Hurt I don't know if the pictures on walls are him & his wife or him & June or both but I can appreciate him singing it to both of them & being the only 1 left in the end & also driving loved ones away with his drug usage & struggles & anger & all that I often end up loving movie biography stories like that even if I never listened to the Artist before seeing the movie-Same with 'Sid & Nancy & 'The Doors
Hammer geil!!!Das waren noch große Musiker!!!Bravo... faszinierend!!!Werde jetzt im November 16 Jahre alt und liebe Bowie,seit meinem 16. Lebensjahr!Und "The Cure" fand ich auch immer super!👍❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏
It's beautiful seeing Trent glowing like that in spite of everything he was going through at the time. I can't imagine doing a duet with my biggest influence and not having them outshine me. Bowie backed him up perfectly, the way their voices intertwined in the choruses was mesmerizing. Instead of focusing on his own performance he gave Trent's shrill, emotional vocals a strong yet understated backbone. We need more people like that.
@@orbita1 Pretty severe addiction (heroin I think) and everything that results in/comes with that. You don't get stuff like NIN's early work from people who lead healthy, fulfilled lives. He seems like a pretty happy and down to earth guy nowadays, I'm currently in the depths of heroin addiction so it's inspiring to see someone I look up to as a musician having made it out and being legit happy.
Maybe an unpopular opinion but I prefer this to the original and the Cash cover. Their voices just blend together beautifully and you can just hear the emotion.
If not for David Bowie I never would've made it past HS, his music helped get me through a lot of depression and while everyday feels like a struggle I am proud I am now 29 because I fully expected to be dead by 18.
@@estebanstrangiato I remember reading people who were at that, Tour talking about huge crowds of people leaving after Nine Inch Nails- That's messed up but at least they made room for real fans to move up closer to the stage-I never heard of this concert until a few months ago & I'm just recently a Nine Inch Nails fan-David Bowie was a bit before my time but I always loved Labyrinth I also always loved 'The Little Drummer Boy-Rom pom pom pom-Just in time for Christmas as there are not many Christmas songs I'm into except that 1 & Mariah Carey & George Michael have great Christmas hits-Otherwise I just think of Christmas caroling & old fashioned type of music for the season- Of course there were some David Bowie songs on the radio I always knew & knew he was a legend but once I started listening to Nine Inch Nails I also grew more appreciation for more David Bowie songs-May he R.I.P.- like 'Scary Monsters-Super Creeps which I never listened to before seeing this concert online & I Love It Now
To think this is when Trent was near is worst, and possibly, if not for this moment we might not have all the amazing things Trent has done since. Thank you Mr. Bowie and Mr. Reznor.
This is hands-down my favorite Nine Inch Nails performance, above all of Trent's records, and even his work with Atticus Ross. Phenomenal, beyond words.
huh :( *le sigh* To think we're cut off from ever hearing that beautiful voice live again...Rest in peace dearest David. You inspired millions...you generated brilliance as easily as breathing. Thank you.
Not gonna lie, I'm a country fan (of the Cash, Nelson, Earle variety). Also not gonna lie, this is utterly mesmerizing. I think I've been waiting 25 years to see this video. I just didn't know it.
I can't watch this enough. Saw Bowie and Reznor perform this at the Shoreline Amphitheatre near SF in 1996. Still chills me, nearly 30 years later, how good this collaboration was - how darkly beautiful the arrangement and the performance
Growing up I remember when this song came out. Surprised such a beautiful mellow song came from such an abrasive sounding band like nine inch nails.... Immediately I knew as a young kid this was one of the greatest songs ever written and was timeless...... And when you have artist like David Bowie and Johnny cash paying TRIBUTE to this beautiful song.... Goes to show.... Trent really did it with this tune. True greatness
In Phoenix, Az at the Desert Sky Pavilion ( what it used to be called back then, that now its something else) David Bowie and Trent Reznor were there and I was able to go. When they both did hurt together it was almost hypnotic I loved that show. R.I.P David Bowie you will be missed.
It’s times like these I adore the internet! Came across this in my travels and can’t believe I haven’t seen it before. Just awesome!!! Truly awesome! ❤️🤟🏼 RIP my beautiful thin white duke, always my hero🥰
This person above is one of the luckiest people on this planet. By the time I was driving age, Bowie was long retired. Can’t imagine the atmosphere for this show.
@@foosbooze263 The ridiculous thing was the show I was at at least 1/3 of the audience left after it transitioned to all Bowie. They were there for NIN.
@@daved6762yes! I saw this show 2x during the Earthling Tour in Orange County CA. Great both nights. They traded off headlong these shows. Seemed more NIN younger fans. When Bowie came on they got schooled. Bowie always wins over his audience. (Seen him since '75 Spider's tour). The 2 of them together was an amazing experience. Especially moved by Hurt! NIN fan too. I was kinda surprised and pissed at their silent reaction. Clueless. A lot of them left. Oh well they missed this performance. Bowie was on it. Iman was below us on side of stage. My friend yelled "Iman, we love you". Bowie smiled at us. Took fam members. Figured not to be missed. It wasn't.
Adrian Belew is an unsung hero here, crazy how he can play everything from funk riffs, animal/machinery noises, to the atmospheric tapping here and still sound unmistakeably like Adrian Belew.
The guitarist is Reeves Gabrels, not Adrian Belew. Look Reeves up, along with the facts of David Bowie's Outside Tour of 1995. (Adrian made his last tour with Bowie in 1990.)
Awesome progression - hearing the generational versions of this song from Trent Reznor/NiN, David Bowie and Johnny Cash. A great song containing some universals truths about the human condition, and the damage we do to ourselves and to others. This song will live on longer than ever expected when it was first written.
People will hate me, I appreciate Bowie as an artist but was never into his music because I personally was never touched by his ways of singing and performing. But supporting Trent is shifting my perspective a little bit. And it's nice to see Trent grinning and happy. Must be an amazing experience to sing along with a legend and hero. 💚🎶 Nice move, Bowie. RIP
Truly amazing! Trent is one of the most talented musicians alive… and Bowie is one of the most talented musicians that are not - much to the regret of the world...
St.Louis Riverport 11/10/95 The Entire Crowd LEFT when Bowie came out to do his Headline Set. It went NIN, collaboration songs between them, a break, then Bowie. The entire venue left 99%, gone, Me and my date, tripping shrooms, And my friends we're just stunned, to this day I have no idea why.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
'One of the greatest moments of my life was standing onstage next to David Bowie while he sang "Hurt" with me. I was outside of myself, thinking, "I'm standing onstage next to the most important influence I've ever had, and he's singing a song I wrote in my bedroom." It was just an awesome moment.' - Trent Reznor
Trent's major moment ;) yep. very cool.
and the reason he would feel that way is because David Bowie showed everyone how important they were or great of talent they had. He was a special kind of legend that made others shine without dimming his own. One of a kind there.
@@williemays2 Happens to the best of us, Dilaudid is tailor made for tortured artists. Glad he made it out and is still creating.
Lol though u was there for a seconnhaha
imagine if trent influenced david would be neat to see the outcome
That first grin that crosses Trent's face( Hey, damn, this is Bowie on stage with me singing my song! ) was a look of ridiculous giddiness. Just a pure, insane happiness that feels like Trent has never known. Who else is here in Jan. 2024 with a tear in their eyes?
Me!! I never even knew this existed until after Bowie died! Boy was missing out!
Cheers
I literally just found out this existed.
Just finding this today, October 2024. Spent a portion of the day thumbing through RUclips and missing Bowie. This just popped up to make me cry. Bowie was my hero growing up, and much respect for Reznor💔💔💔
"Everyone I Know Goes Away In The End..." R.I.P. STARMAN
I know right
I was at this concert. I am married to my soul mate because of this concert
Name or it didn’t happen
So fucking RAD!! RIP BOWIE!! See you on the other side!
God damn man! Congratulations to you both
True love 🖤
Badass
I love the contrast of their voices. Trent's feels so much sharper, and Bowie's so much softer and more rounded off. Like a broken piece of glass, and a crystal ball, respectively.
GoldenFox this is a perfect discription
Just like in Labyrinth. Good work.
Great analogy indeed. I think you hit the nail right on the head!
@@estherwells2298 pun intended?
@@Dizzula I love Labyrinth- Was always a favorite movie of mine ever since I was a little kid-I'd like to see it again as it's been so many years-I remember playing it for my son when he was younger too & I even thought I named my dog after the dog in that movie- There's that little guy who thinks hes so tough & he rode on the dog who was fearful
So there were parts I always loved as a kid such as the little tiny guy saying 'I've got you surrounded & when the dog runs off he says 'Stop your embarrassing me in a very funny accent-I always thought it was 'Stop your embarrassing me Rufus so I named my dear dog- may he Rest In Peace-Rufus
For so long I'd tell my son about this part of the movie I remembered from such a young age & when we finally watched it 1 day the dogs name wasn't Rufus-It was, something much longer like 'Bronfucious or something LOL
It's my own funny story & my Rufus was the greatest pet-buddy ever-R.I.P. Rufus
i love how happy trent looks at 2:45, like, 'holy shit im duetting with david bowie' surreal moment
+finkle stiener Trent recently did an interview about it, his words were "I'm standing onstage next to the most important influence I've ever had, and he's singing a song I wrote in my bedroom."
Read more: www.rollingstone.com/music/news/trent-reznor-recalls-how-david-bowie-helped-him-get-sober-20160126#ixzz3yUGBm2uL
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook
+David Robson I was gonna reply this.
That's what real high looks like
David Bowie & Johnny Cash is going to duet with Hurt in afterlife.
+Hmmmph I'm going to have to completely disagree with you
+Hmmmph Cash's version of Hurt is vastly inferior.
+MightyCoont There are three versions of Hurt. The version from Downward Spiral, this live version w/ Bowie and Johnny Cash's version. Each is amazing in their own way, because each mean something completely different. Its a testament to how powerful of a song it is, to be sung by three amazing artists and tell three different stories. I have my personal preference, but in the face of that accomplishment....well, it hardly matters.
Brilliant
You know what, fuck Johnny Cash. Talented man, but his song this is not, nor is it Bowie's despite how great this duet is.
How many songs did he write in his whole career? 20, 30-ish? I don't care if the comment is uncalled for, I'm tired of the inevitable "that song belongs to Cash now" comment...oh look, there's one below the OP.
I won't bother to get into how Cash (for lack of a better word) raped the context of the song with his vastly differt sound and themes. Again, heavy word there, but I don't care.
And I don't care how Trent feels, saying "it's not his song anymore". Fuck Trent. The guy who wrote this song died 17 years ago from an overdose. Much respect to the happy father of two who bears his name and still puts out good music, but he's not, nor will he ever be *there* again to write or own this song. It's the epitaph of a semi-fictional hollow, broken man, not a Christian who does country covers for the maudlin masses.
What I love about Hurt is that the original and the Cash version are both incredibly moving and amazing. However, they are sang as two different songs. This song embodies the angst and anguish a younger person would feel. Whereas the Cash version captures a lifetime of pain and regret. It's as if they are being song by a son and then a father back to him. Also this has David fucking Bowie in it. Rad.
Your comment is so right on. My son Jimmy passed away in 2008, he loved NIN but, when Johnny Cash sang it he actually did a thesis on how one song could be interpreted by the way two people of different generations sang it.I just had to comment because it’s so true
I agree, and I'd even add that this version is something else entirely, Trent has been on record saying his respect for David and this was a dream come true for him, you can see his emotions overflowing throughout the performance, an amazing piece of art
Rad is right!
Well said
If I remember rightly, Cash was grieving the loss of his wife June?
2:32 i love how happy trent is to hear bowie singing harmony. like a child
those backing vocals are from an other world..gosh
To right,,❤9yrs later I reply,,,lol,,David Bowie RIP,bless,,ya done a good Job ,did you both,,timeless lockin ,,💯🔥🙌❤❤
I made sure that this was the first concert I ever went to back when I was 13. I saw the Camden NJ date with Prick opening. The gradual transition between the NIN and Bowie sets is still uayched to this day.
You can actually see how happy Trent is to sing with David
a good musician knows their voice. Bowie did not compete at all. just supported and followed Trent, made that song beautiful
the crowd seemed to appreciate Reznor more.
I think it's amazing the sonic blend of their voices, both such TRUE musicians and amazing talents in their own right.Trents voice slicing through like a shard of broken glass, and bowie's backing vocals smoothing the edges while allowing that grit and power to really shine through. They killed it. I love the cash version (apparently an unpopular opinion, even though trent liked it too) but this version is a FIERCE rival. so glad they both exist so I don't HAVE to ever choose. someone earlier tried to say "ohhhh this is a song about a broken man....what would christian johnny cash know of any of that...not realizing that the man in black had his own struggles with drug and alcohol addiction and quite a lurid past himself, which I believe shone through in the visceral "pain" that can be felt in his version of "hurt". But whatever... I'll listen to and enjoy both while those oh so much wiser than me critique them and voice their opinions, ever the contrarian and critic. 😂
@@vegdagol2843 I don't think you're giving NIN fans enough credit. How young do you think they are? I'd venture to say many fans of NIN/Trent Reznor are and were familiar with Bowie... I mean it's David f*ckin Bowie - he wasn't exactly an opening act.
@@estherwells2298 Johnny Cash's version seemed to me to be more about his regret & his love for June Carter & his losses but I also believe back in his days he struggled with an H addiction too-I remember watching most of the movie 'I Walk The Line I think it was called-I didn't think it would be my type of movie as I don't listen to Country music but I remember enjoying how he wore all black & went against the mainstream Gospel music at that time & he was a Rocker in his own right & parts made me cry-I can't remember how it ended so I'd have to see it again
-I remember in the movie he was married with kids but always in love with June Carter once he met her which was sad for his wife but I understood with all the time he spent with June on the road & I will say-I honestly have no idea if they ever actually got together-In his video when he covered 'Hurt I don't know if the pictures on walls are him & his wife or him & June or both but I can appreciate him singing it to both of them & being the only 1 left in the end & also driving loved ones away with his drug usage & struggles & anger & all that
I often end up loving movie biography stories like that even if I never listened to the Artist before seeing the movie-Same with 'Sid & Nancy & 'The Doors
Hammer geil!!!Das waren noch große Musiker!!!Bravo... faszinierend!!!Werde jetzt im November 16 Jahre alt und liebe Bowie,seit meinem 16. Lebensjahr!Und "The Cure" fand ich auch immer super!👍❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏
It's beautiful seeing Trent glowing like that in spite of everything he was going through at the time. I can't imagine doing a duet with my biggest influence and not having them outshine me. Bowie backed him up perfectly, the way their voices intertwined in the choruses was mesmerizing. Instead of focusing on his own performance he gave Trent's shrill, emotional vocals a strong yet understated backbone. We need more people like that.
I've always loved Bowie's deep vibrato sound. I love how Trent has to keep from grinning like a jackass eating briars. ❤️
Yeah you can see that Bowie made a childhood dream come true for Trent and the result was absolutely beautiful
Sorry for my ignorance, what was trent going through during that period?
@@orbita1 Pretty severe addiction (heroin I think) and everything that results in/comes with that. You don't get stuff like NIN's early work from people who lead healthy, fulfilled lives. He seems like a pretty happy and down to earth guy nowadays, I'm currently in the depths of heroin addiction so it's inspiring to see someone I look up to as a musician having made it out and being legit happy.
@@TayTayMakesBeats hopeful you also make a full recovery. 👍
Wow. David Bowie & Trent Reznor on the same stage. This is beyond words.
+krizalidstayaway They were a thing for a while. (At least musically - I can't speak to the other. Only hope...)
The shipping is strong with this one.
i am 50 this year and my first view of this - incredible!
where have i been
2:56 Trent is smiling. The reality of the moment must have hit him.
RIP David Bowie! You will always be in our hearts. Hope to are magic dancing in heaven.
Imagine being at this concert. With not a single fucking cell phone out. Mind blowing!
Maybe an unpopular opinion but I prefer this to the original and the Cash cover. Their voices just blend together beautifully and you can just hear the emotion.
I saw Bowie with nin and prick. Didn’t realize the gravity of the moment till later in life. Blessed to be there
In Denver by any chance? That's where I caught them. Not sure if this video above is from that night in Denver or another stop.
@@ronrupert4728 it was in Chicago.
Trent you were so fkn lucky to know and perforate David Bowie!
David Bowie Dying... Now That Fucking Hurts...
If not for David Bowie I never would've made it past HS, his music helped get me through a lot of depression and while everyday feels like a struggle I am proud I am now 29 because I fully expected to be dead by 18.
He saved a lot of us
My first concert ever was this tour and Bowie came out in all black and Reznor in all white, I lost my mind. What a great show
Wow!
And that is how backup vocals should be used... So much warmth added to the chorus, wow. Thanks for the clinic Mr. Bowie
Bowie's vocals are incredible, my god. fantastic song. amazing performance
Condolences to Trent, . . . Peace eternal and thank you, David Jones / Bowie.
- Bleikr
I never realised David Bowie sang with NIN. It's like this song was made for Bowie's voice. It's incredible hearing these two sing it together.
Theres a Rolling Stone article where Trent is like, "We sold more tickets than Bowie, but no way were THEY going to open for US."
@@estebanstrangiato I remember reading people who were at that, Tour talking about huge crowds of people leaving after Nine Inch Nails- That's messed up but at least they made room for real fans to move up closer to the stage-I never heard of this concert until a few months ago & I'm just recently a Nine Inch Nails fan-David Bowie was a bit before my time but I always loved Labyrinth
I also always loved 'The Little Drummer Boy-Rom pom pom pom-Just in time for Christmas as there are not many Christmas songs I'm into except that 1 & Mariah Carey & George Michael have great Christmas hits-Otherwise I just think of Christmas caroling & old fashioned type of music for the season-
Of course there were some David Bowie songs on the radio I always knew & knew he was a legend but once I started listening to Nine Inch Nails I also grew more appreciation for more David Bowie songs-May he R.I.P.- like 'Scary Monsters-Super Creeps which I never listened to before seeing this concert online & I Love It Now
To see someone as powerful in the industry as Trent absolutely beside himself because of Bowie... Just beautiful.
Almost 30 years ago, and Trent still sings/performs this with the exact same intensity ... Says a lot, i think ...
Fuel to make me cry, every damn time.
Carlos Alomar coming in with that ultra clean guitar with Reeves Grabrels haunting hammer on sound is mesmerizing 25 years ago and to day still
To think this is when Trent was near is worst, and possibly, if not for this moment we might not have all the amazing things Trent has done since. Thank you Mr. Bowie and Mr. Reznor.
this is hands down my favorite version of hurt, it's so damn beautiful
One of the best songs ever written
This is hands-down my favorite Nine Inch Nails performance, above all of Trent's records, and even his work with Atticus Ross. Phenomenal, beyond words.
It’s bowies band! They switched it up a lot on this tour, bowie did a lot on NIN and nine inch nails did some Bowie songs too. So good!
Treznor's smile is the meaning of personal success, the accomplishment of a dream
David's vocals are incredible, resonating, perfect pitch!!!! RIP.
I love seeing Trent happy, it warms my heart
This was my first concert!!!!
huh :( *le sigh*
To think we're cut off from ever hearing that beautiful voice live again...Rest in peace dearest David. You inspired millions...you generated brilliance as easily as breathing. Thank you.
The definition of a higher existance and pure chaotic bliss. ❤🖤🎶
The two of them bring about such beauty with this song. Always been a good song. It always brings me to tears
I just really love Bowie’s harmony with Reznor’s melody. It seems to make the song that much sadder, and touching.
Not gonna lie, I'm a country fan (of the Cash, Nelson, Earle variety). Also not gonna lie, this is utterly mesmerizing. I think I've been waiting 25 years to see this video. I just didn't know it.
1000 times cooler than I imagined it to be.
2 heroes
"Hurt" is the one of the American best songs ever written. Trent Reznor is a great composer.
I can't watch this enough. Saw Bowie and Reznor perform this at the Shoreline Amphitheatre near SF in 1996. Still chills me, nearly 30 years later, how good this collaboration was - how darkly beautiful the arrangement and the performance
what a ridiculously good version of this song
R.i.p. david/ziggy/Jareth...you will be missed..
it upsets me so much that there is not an album of this performance. I want to blast this version from my car all the damn time
One of my favorite performances and artists collabs ever.... RIP Mr Bowie....
Less is more… two very different people with “one voice”. Arrangement, performance - all just cry about the unison))
Two ABSOLUTE legends.
Growing up I remember when this song came out. Surprised such a beautiful mellow song came from such an abrasive sounding band like nine inch nails.... Immediately I knew as a young kid this was one of the greatest songs ever written and was timeless...... And when you have artist like David Bowie and Johnny cash paying TRIBUTE to this beautiful song.... Goes to show.... Trent really did it with this tune. True greatness
In Phoenix, Az at the Desert Sky Pavilion ( what it used to be called back then, that now its something else) David Bowie and Trent Reznor were there and I was able to go. When they both did hurt together it was almost hypnotic I loved that show. R.I.P David Bowie you will be missed.
The smile on his face lol, you can have it all
Made me cry brings so many emotions watching and listening to such talented people. so hauntingly beautiful.
This is the right version, the remastered version is a different recording than the closure dvd.
It’s times like these I adore the internet! Came across this in my travels and can’t believe I haven’t seen it before. Just awesome!!! Truly awesome! ❤️🤟🏼
RIP my beautiful thin white duke, always my hero🥰
this is definitely my favorite version of the song, which it would be put onto streaming
R.I.P. David Bowie! Thanks for decades of inspiration...
I saw them on this tour. Wow! I've also seen them both individually, but together? Magic! Glad this is here to help me relive the experience.
This person above is one of the luckiest people on this planet. By the time I was driving age, Bowie was long retired. Can’t imagine the atmosphere for this show.
@@foosbooze263 The ridiculous thing was the show I was at at least 1/3 of the audience left after it transitioned to all Bowie. They were there for NIN.
@@daved6762yes! I saw this show 2x during the Earthling Tour in Orange County CA. Great both nights. They traded off headlong these shows.
Seemed more NIN younger fans. When Bowie came on they got schooled. Bowie always wins over his audience. (Seen him since '75 Spider's tour). The 2 of them together was an amazing experience. Especially moved by Hurt! NIN fan too.
I was kinda surprised and pissed at their silent reaction. Clueless. A lot of them left. Oh well they missed this performance.
Bowie was on it. Iman was below us on side of stage. My friend yelled "Iman, we love you". Bowie smiled at us. Took fam members. Figured not to be missed. It wasn't.
Best Mercury Rev lineup ever. Incredible drummer. I saw lots of concerts in my life abd this tour might one of the best I‘ve ever seen.
Why am I just finding this today? Deep respect for both and this is incredible
davids voice is perfect.
David Bowie's wonderful voice.
This duo resonates eternal
Wow this was beautiful. Been a NIN fan since Pretty Hate Machine came out but never saw this before now. Loved it. RIP Bowie.
Adrian Belew is an unsung hero here, crazy how he can play everything from funk riffs, animal/machinery noises, to the atmospheric tapping here and still sound unmistakeably like Adrian Belew.
The guitarist is Reeves Gabrels, not Adrian Belew. Look Reeves up, along with the facts of David Bowie's Outside Tour of 1995. (Adrian made his last tour with Bowie in 1990.)
Awesome progression - hearing the generational versions of this song from Trent Reznor/NiN, David Bowie and Johnny Cash. A great song containing some universals truths about the human condition, and the damage we do to ourselves and to others. This song will live on longer than ever expected when it was first written.
I never tire of watching this.👩🎤
People will hate me, I appreciate Bowie as an artist but was never into his music because I personally was never touched by his ways of singing and performing. But supporting Trent is shifting my perspective a little bit. And it's nice to see Trent grinning and happy. Must be an amazing experience to sing along with a legend and hero. 💚🎶 Nice move, Bowie. RIP
Simply, SPECTACULAR...
The voices, the music, the melody...
Thank you, for your music and thoughts, Eric Watson Sr
I cry.
Chilled to the bone... amazing musicians
Just wow. Incredible collab
Wow. Super. Two of my all time favorites together.
Of all of the versions of this song I have heard this is by far the most powerful. Thank you for posting this video. It gave me chills
One of the most amazing things I have ever seen.
Truly amazing!
Trent is one of the most talented musicians alive… and Bowie is one of the most talented musicians that are not - much to the regret of the world...
St.Louis Riverport 11/10/95
The Entire Crowd LEFT when Bowie came out to do his Headline Set. It went NIN, collaboration songs between them, a break, then Bowie. The entire venue left 99%, gone, Me and my date, tripping shrooms, And my friends we're just stunned, to this day I have no idea why.
Yes I hear loud and clear great show man
Just one more listen…
RIP David Bowie. So great. What an amazing concert. These two together is just great.
Can you hear me, Major Tom?
:( RIP Mr. Bowie...
This tour and performance was actually in 1995.
Sick, dope, whatever. Those 2 are legends. ❤
RIP David bowie
Yes.
I do.
❤U
Extraordinary combo! 🙂
Bowie is one of the music greatest 60 to 2024 +
what a masterful interpretation I love so much
Thanks for uploading this.... I was in the crowd for this concert.
What a gem! Thank you for sharing.
Oh the magic, the beauty.