The problem I hear are the words contracts and attorneys. I understand, at some point, you have to treat a band as a business, but if you need lawyers and managers to communicate with each other, your band is already fucked.
I totally agree... No one would even care that Tommy and Eric were in the band IF they had their own make up designs .... There would be no backlash at all ...
It may have to do with all the merchandise they already produced which show those 4 original members' characters. Then again, creating totally new characters would prompt fans to buy more NEW stuff, so who knows. The guy dressed as Ace was called a "supposed replacement for Ace" and he got pisssed!😅
@@fazole I wrote this comment after only seeing the first sentence of your comment, so keep that in mind when you read mine... But now that I see your full comment, you do understand :) Anyhow, my reply to your 1st sentence: I disagree because kiss could have easily still sold those items and die hard collectors would have still bought it up as well as spent more money to buy the new merch the band could have produced showing the new 4 makeups (Or whatever makeups Eric S. and Tommy T. would have worm, be it original or the fox and Ankh. It actually would have made for more merch to sell on top of still selling merch with the original 4 on it.
Guitar player weighs in: Peter is absolutely right. He's completely correct. The original Kiss is the only Kiss that matters. New Kiss? Peter doesn't buy it. Neither do I.
Not true. The band is bigger than the sum of its parts - they did the right thing getting rid of a drug-addled alcoholic who constantly complained, messed up shows and ultimately neglected his craft only to have to be taught how to play again BY A GUITARIST! His ego was greater than his playing ability
Much like in The Eagles, it was ultimately ego that destroys. Most bands start out on equal footing, then the "stars" develop, it goes to their head, and they start demanding a bigger piece, more control, etc. In my experience, you can't easily have a successful band if there are varying degrees of "importance". A vocalist thinks he's more important than the lead guitarist... the lead guitarist thinks he's more important than the rhythm guitarist, they all think they're more valuable than the drummer or the bassist.... then the band fractures. Look at the masters: The Beatles, Queen, Led Zeppelin..... they never replaced someone over egos. They had their run, then disbanded, and never tried to be "the new.......". by replacing someone.
@@Taylor.Dude. Zep and KISS ran their bands pretty much the same - four equal partners, (until they decided to Peter had to go in 1980 and had to vote to fire him because of the incorporation of the band. Then G&P bullied Ace by outvoting him on everything until he finally quit 2 years later). If you don't think that Rush and anyone else never had battles due to ego, you're believing a fantasy - they may have kept their laundry much more private, but ALL groups deal with ego BS at some level, it is generally the biggest cause for people to quit, get fired, or to break up.
What I had heard. And Ace kind of said this too. Ace told Peter he was making twice as much as him. So Peter got mad and refused to sign a new deal unless he made more money. Paul n Gene said no.
@@E.C.2Also heard that Ace didn’t know he was getting more Money then Peter once he found out he gave Peter the difference out of he’s own pocket To finish the tour Tells you a lot about Gene & Paul !! 🖕🏼ers 🤘✌️👍
Peter was not a consistent drummer. He couldn't read music, he was primarily self taught. He could sing and that was his strong point. Don't forget about the years of drugs and alcohol that were literally destroying him and the band. He was never a top notch player but he has a large ego. It basically boiled down to let him go, get a new drummer with fresh ideas and playing skills or keep Peter on with a band that would sink deep into the ocean because of all his problems that reached out to everyone in the band and drug them down. I'm glad KISS moved on and became bigger throughout the years with a different drummer.
KISS was never bigger after the founding version broke up than they were before. You claim Peter has a large ego in a band with Gene Simmons in it? Hell Ace is my favorite player but in a band with Ace in it? That's hilarious. Gene was a mid-bass player to have had the size ego he has. And as far as being self taught? How many huge musicians were? Ace was. Prince was. Hendrix was. John Bonham was. Couldn't read music? Neither can Ry Cooder. Neither could any of the Beatles, Eric Clapton, Stevie Wonder, or Hendrix. How about drummers? Bonham couldn't, Moon couldn't, Buddy Rich couldn't, Ringo Starr couldn't, Phil Collins couldn't. So what are we really talking about here? Was it all that or was it that he threatened the fiefdom like Ace did by expecting to be treated like he helped build it. Which he did?
Anybody with any professional training for any period of time knows there's not a single original Kiss member who was much more accomplishied than grade 6 music composition.
@@HerrinSchadenfreude The guy is being ridiculous. Anybody with any professional training for any period of time knows there's not a single original Kiss member who was much more accomplishied than grade 6 music composition.
Well said Peter! I was an athlete in my 20s and 30s - being a full time athlete you are always carrying an injury. You treat it preform and treat it again. It is the only way.
The original four had a symmetry, and Peter and Ace seemed like far and above more accomplished musicians in the band , they never sounded the same or produced the same quality of songs after they left
Check out "Kiss live Brazil 1983." They were on fire bro,sounded heavier than the Scorpions. Vinnie Vincent took them to the next level,should've kept going in that Direction. Paul's narcissism prevented them from growing in the mid-late 80's.
I once met Paul and there was only one other fan present. He refused to sign my album even though I told him I have been a fan for over 44 years. I also told him that I was present at the 1st Aussie tour 1980 VFL Park as a 13 yr old. He was arrogent and full of himself and refused to sign
I was at that concert on Peters birthday. I took my wife to her very first KISS concert. They brought out a cake for Peter. That concert was in Fresno. They brought a cake out and the works. We all sang Happy Birthday. That was my wifes Christmas present that year. That was back in '03. Man that was a long time ago.
It was KISS. Paul and Gene did by far most of the work in the 70's. Not much changed after Ace quit and Peter was fired. They ended up being replaced by better musicians and bandmates and people
My eyes have to match what I’m hearing you need the original 4 that’s just the bottom line Taking nothing away from Eric and Tommy they’re incredible musicians but the magic is only with the four that’s the way it is
Completely false. Why do you expect Paul and Gene to work with people that they don't get along with? Would you work with someone you don't get along with if you didn't have to? Of course not. Get over it. Ace is a lazy bum. Peter is a prick. They don't work well together. Time to move on
No era magia era juventud los primeros años de Eric y kulick mucha más magia y mejores conciertos eso es lo q hay kulick bmejor y Singer y Carr mucho mejor es lo qbyo he visto ....
I like ALL the members of KISS...Peter, Paul, Ace, Gene, Tommy, Eric(Carr), Vinnie, Mark, Eric(Singer), and Bruce.(Some of them I had to look up because I'm old and couldn't remember...)
There is a video out there on RUclips that shows Peter singing Beth, Gene is backstage bitching gripping saying he is screwing it up, when the song was over Peter came backstage and asked how did I do, nobody said anything except for Ace, Ace told him that he did a great job. Then they went out to say goodbye to the fans and Ace was the only one that grabbed up T-shirts towels and stuff to throw out to the fans Gene and Paul did not grab up anything. ROCK ON ACE 🤟😃🤟
What video? The one where they are under the stage? The one I saw was one where HE got pissed off and started raging at the crew...Gene heard what was happening and knew he would be pissed. Ace was in lala land the whole time.
Of all the surviving kiss members ive met, ironically the nicest of the original line up were peter and ace. Bruce is also in that mix too. The rest i could have lived without.
I Agree with what Criss is saying here I only listen to the old stuff because in my opinion that's the Real kiss the other stuff the People the Fans we no Nothing about it we weren't behind the Scene seeing it.
I discovered a new song, new as in I had never noticed it before, by Peter that I really like, Blue Moon Over Brooklyn. I'm surprised it's not a bigger song than it is.
@@TheGodYouWishYouKnew hahaha well that's pretty harsh! We all have our different likes and don't likes. Would be pretty boring if we all liked the same thing I imagine. I'm sure we like and dislike a lot of the same things but that's ok.
I agree that the OG KISS was KISS. When Eric Carr, and Eventually Bruce Kulick, joined KISS, that was the New KISS. They would drop the makeup, of course; but Eric and Vinny had their own makeup... they didn't barrow Peter's and Ace's personas. I really felt it was a slap in the face to Peter and Ace that Tommy and Eric Singer didn't get their own KISS personas, but reused Peter's and Ace's. It was wrong, and Paul and Gene know it. Although, I'm probably not the most authoritative KISS fan... my 2 favorite KISS albums are Music from the Elder, and Ace's Solo Album. I also own Revenge, but only for Eric Carr's Jam track at the end of it.
New Contract? He is a founder. Maybe he should call Paul and cancel his contract. I guess he allowed himself to a minority member when he should be an equal share owner.
I heard they offered him $1 million flat for Australia & Japan,he said no,they replaced him. He should've played the tour,accepted the offer,and renegotiated after said dates were played. Very wealthy Men have different sets of problems than us.
Having been a lifelong KISS fan from the beginning of the band, I can say with 100% brutal honesty, Peter and Ace “HAD IT ALL AND, BLEW IT”! This will ruffle quite a few fan’s feathers but, que sera sera. If they could’ve kept a handle on their demons (NO, NOT GENE), and just did their jobs within the KISS family, they would still be in the band THEY HELPED CREATE!, BUT NO…THEY LET THE BOOZE AND DRUGS TAKE CONTROL AND THEY FUCKED UP, PLAIN AND SIMPLE!! They don’t have a leg to stand on. And, as far as Tommy and Eric wearing the ICONIC Spaceman and Cat makeup, it was trademarked BY KISS, which they gave up their rights to when they left. So, all I can say is “too bad, so sad”!!!
Not so nice when he cheated on his wife & destroyed his body & mind with vices & disrespected his fans by performing badly under the influence of vices. That's why he was fired.
When it comes to KISS, and Gene and Paul, it’s down to money. They wanted all of the money, and contracted “younger” talent because they didn’t pay them as much. The original four it was split four ways, new kiss it was split two ways, and even then they argued over money.
Peter always plays the victim with zero accountability and he's never honest or truthful. I saw em on their FIRST Farewell Tour and he could hardly play! Paul said he hit so soft that they had to use triggers set to their absolute maximum sensitivity level! He had health issues throughout the tour and they wanted to play longer shows and he was barely making it through the shorter one's.
100% this is the catalyst for not renewing his contract. Would they sell more tickets with Peter? Maybe. Would it be worth putting up with his lacklustre playing and drama? That was a hard no for them.
I'm not a big fan but respect their success. I can see Paul wanting to lift the quality of the band and Peter was a weak link. Add in personality problems and there you have it.
57 year old stroke having former drummer myself, I worshipped Peter & was lucky enough to catch my childhood obsession live on the Dynasty tour, shortly before he crushed my soul & left KISS. As a grown man, I will always love & respect Peter for what he gave KISS fans worldwide, especially me. That said, I belive what the other guys say about his time in KISS, cause its still excuse after excuse, same as when he got his wish the first round. Sooo, why didn't you play on so GD many KISS albums, Mr rockstar millionaire dream catcher Sir? Tummy ache? Room to cold? Fair enough. But what about group photos of you in flats, or live photos with half your makeup missing Mr semi talented / lucky af ? Feet hurting at that shoot, & eyes burning at that show? Ok then, sounds legit. lol Eddy Trunk's best work was when he produced the band ICON, while his worst work is his softball interviews of his rock idols - full stop
P&G couldn't have cared less as long the cash till kept getting filled. Bringing back A&P was just a vehicle for them to reestablish a then floundering makeup-less/identity-less band and start selling tickets again. Once that reunion audience momentum (with makeup) was established they brought in the scrubs to finish the deal. Without A&P they wouldn't have been able to reestablish the makeup era and institute the hired gun cruise control they've been riding now for 20+ years..
Tommy was the founder of the top KISS tribute group in LA / Hollywood back in the day called " Cold Gin " You can still see them here on RUclips !!! Also Eric was a well known Gunslinger on the drums playing for many top artists such as Black Sabbath, Alice Cooper, Lita Ford, Badlands, Brian May and Gary Moore as well as his own band ESP ... Not to mention Eric has always been a super nice guy to everyone !
Love the originals. But too much bullshit with Ace and Peter. Though I agree, shouldn’t have put the makeup on Eric and Tommy. However, before Paul lost his voice? Those guys were awesome. At the end, the farewell with Peter and Ace was terrible. Drums were terrible. Ace was back to being Ace.
"You're too old to perform so we're going to replace you and keep going with another guy in your makeup" and "I'm too old to perform so I'm ending the band rather than be replaced by another guy in my makeup" -same person
My daughter asked me twice if I wanted to go to a KISS concert. I told her no. She asked why. I said I have been to at least 10 KISS concerts and it was fantastic, one of the best times of my life, I do not want to tarnish that memory by going to a KISS concert now without watching the REAL KISS MEMBERS. After Ace and Peter left I held on as long as I could but never went to a live event again.
I always have alot respect for Peter Criss and Ace Frehley I grew up during the Psycho Circus wra of KISS I always love Peter and Ace My Dad was friends with Ace Without the Original Members of KISS we wouldn't have KISS Today but Just my opinion Tommy Thayer should have been the Space Bandit and Eric Singer should have been a Lion, Dog or Hawk or Eagle those are just my opinion but Peter has his flaws he wasnt perfect but he manage to improve over the years im glad he is with us
Instead of doing a makeup reunion with Eric and Tommy. They should have just toured did new music with Eric and Bruce Kulick everything would have had more substance. Kulicks yrs had very solid albums and the old stuff would have been more acceptable. I saw the reunion show it was awesome Ace and Peter had they're chops for sure.
They haven't "thrived". They were irrelevant and almost broke and busted during a lot of the unmasked period. They copied every fad they could to try and keep up with everyone else in the industry until the reunion tour. Ace and Peter revived kiss and then Paul and gene dressed two imposters up and made kiss a tribute band because that's where the money is, that's all they're interested in, money.
Ace and Peter got to big to young. They didn't stay focused back in the day because drinking and drugs were more important. My opinion anyway. I saw the original Kiss in 77 and Ace play in 2022. Always will be a fan.
I love the original KISS, but over the years Peter has just come off as a baby. I'm not there, so I don't know any more than the avg. fan, but it is always him complaining and it gets old.
If Peter Criss was as great as he thinks he is then why didn’t he end up in another band? That’s right, because he isn’t worth much to anyone else. Sorry, but that’s the truth
Peter did not have the chops to play any of the songs with double bass or semi complicated fills. Eric Carr and Eric Singer were far superior drummers. Peter was my first drumming influence and I respect the work that he did.
Just imagine if George left the Beatles then later Ringo did. Both were replaced and the replacements were told they had to wear George and Ringo wigs and they had to wear the clothes that George and Ringo would wear?? Just no! People like the originals. It's familiar. There are two exceptions that immediately come to my mind. (Yes I know there are plenty of others) Fleetwood Mac who (absolutely no offence to Peter Green) skyrocketed with the addition of Stevie and Lindsay, and ACDC, who accepted Brian because he did not mimic Bon. On that note, Brian faced a very tough crowd. They powered through and won. The new members of each band brought new songs and sound earning them fan recognition. I applaud that. For me though, Kiss is Paul, Gene, Ace and Peter. I lost interest after that. To me it seemed the new members brought nothing new to the table.
@@ThePatcore KISS was the first band that I've ever seen in 1974, I was 12 years old, I seen them with Bruce, and they sucked, actually the worst KISS concert I ever seen, they are just not KISS without Peter and Ace 🙃
Must be a Paul Stanley fan you must like being ripped off paying for a non live show you must not know there are more than one side of a story Paul Stanley is a hypocrite and a egomaniac
@@brianstrutter1501 while I agree that Paul and Gene started the group Ace and Peter made up the core members of the band. They were right there with Paul and Gene paying their dues. They were there from the beginning. They created the personas. Yes, there were problematic moments in the past , and Paul and Gene managed to keep the band alive in a different direction, but you still can’t take that away from them. I totally get your argument (you’ve had a few retorts to some of these comments) , but then take the makeup and costumes off and perform the songs without it. Because it just comes off like a cash grab and they’re only delivering half the goods.
It will never be KISS without the original group members. Gene Simmons,Paul Stanley, Peter Criss,and Ace Frehley! They together made KISS! It wasn't the same after Peter and Ace left!😢
They SOLD THEIR RIGHTS TO THE IMMAGE!! FOR CASH!! It was ALWAYS Paul's band! Ace & Peter were hired! From the beginning!! Founding member?! That illusion was created by Bob! Paul & Gene (in spite of what's said, or whomever gets the credit) created "new characters" out of respect for the two original "hired guns"! Paul & Gene are geniuses!! They made the decisions that kept the cash flowing!! My ONLY issue with that fact is that I, too, contributed! And, if you're reading this, SO DID YOU! I'm certain that the two of them are grateful! 😂😂
I do agree that if it's a new Kiss, quit playing the Alive 1 setlist, drop the makeup. At the same time, this wasn't a huge surprise. If you read Peter's book, to hear him say he's not a complainer is just a false statement. His whole book is a whine fest. I didn't get this, I didn't get that. They had to hire a limo to take him to a bar gig because he needed to feel important. He isn't the greatest drummer,and humility was lost on him. Paul and Gene stayed hungry even after the money train rolled in. Ace and Peter got comfortable and stopped progressing. I love them both, but in my mind, Kiss stopped at Unmasked. It's been a new band ever since, and they should have branded it as such. I remember watching Mtv the day they took the makeup off. I felt duped that 2 guys were impostors.
When a family member falls off the wagon (drugs & alcohol) over and over again and is dangerous, you must, for self preservation, remove yourself from that dangerous person. Ace and Peter are dangerous.
Let’s be fair: Peter and Ace sucked by the end of it. Even in 1996. Tommy and Eric were an upgrade and a half. I don’t care about the makeup. The makeup is characters. Not people.
Peter Criss is my favorite singer in 💋 KISS, he wrote the song 🎵 Beth and that song was so Beautiful ❤No matter what people will think! As for Paul and Gene they should apologize to Peter for saying those awful things they said about him! And Paul Stanley also called Peter an Ace Anti- Simentic, when they were most definitely not!!! How do I know who said that because I read somewhere that Ace or Peter, I dont know who ever said that but they said that's ridiculous because they have Jewish friends!!! Paul needs to be a better person and a better friend!!!
We are going to have NEW KISS. Yes, they will look like old Kiss, they will dress like old Kiss, they will play the songs from old Kiss. The difference is with new Kiss we control everything and we can pay them less, that's new Kiss.
Peter knew Ace wasn't going to go on the tour BEFORE he agreed to do the tour. He could've just said no, I'm not going on the tour unless Ace is there. Instead of kvetching about it later. Also if Peter has a problem with the other guy wearing the make up, he didn't have to sell the rights to the Kiss Corporation
Without Peter Kriss kiss is not the same with out any of the founding members kiss IS NOT THE SAME. The fans want the original group !!!! Or it ant the same !!! Ace ,Paul ,gene , Peter or it’s ITS NOT KISS put your stuff aside with each other and give fans what they want .
I'm KISS now. Some guy broke my legs like that Casablanca guy threatened to do for not giving up their Double Platinum Three Times Chinchilla Billboard Topping Album of the year without being paid first. They broke my legs, every year for practically a decade and stole every album of the year. Left me drugged, crippled, homeless , penniless , with countless amounts of medical problems like a smashed face and heart problems. Just goes to show ya.
I kinda wish the original line-up was Paul, Ace, Gene, and Eric Carr....Carr was a much more competent drummer than Peter Criss. ...WAY, WAY better chops! I have YET to find a drummer that disagrees with that statement!
I'm a fan of Peter and Ace, but being in bands my whole life, sometimes ya gotta cut the fat. KISS would have been done after Dynasty if it wasn't for Paul Stanely holding the fort together.
I agree. Even though Charlie Watts of The Rolling Stones could still play at his age before dying, The Stones had a far different tempo to their music. Even Charlie before he died could keep up with The Stones, but just couldn't last playing with KISS. I mean really. Peter could never be a drummer for a band like Slayer or Megadeth, even in his prime back in the 80s.
Peter’s vocal on black diamond is the best…might be my favorite KISS song ever
He rocked that with his raspy voice my fav track as well
He absolutely was amazing on a ton of songs, but Peter Criss and Ace guitar 🎸 solo, was frickin amazing on Black Diamond!!!!
He should’ve started a band called Kriss
With Ace !
How many lawsuits
Wouldve been a brilliant plan to leverage KISS into paying them millions. They would have settled & Pete & Ace would have came out pretty well.
You’re a genius.
🤟😆🤟
The problem I hear are the words contracts and attorneys. I understand, at some point, you have to treat a band as a business, but if you need lawyers and managers to communicate with each other, your band is already fucked.
The biggest Kiss blunder was putting Ace and Peter’s makeup on Eric and Tommy. Embarrassing.
I totally agree... No one would even care that Tommy and Eric were in the band IF they had their own make up designs .... There would be no backlash at all ...
It may have to do with all the merchandise they already produced which show those 4 original members' characters. Then again, creating totally new characters would prompt fans to buy more NEW stuff, so who knows. The guy dressed as Ace was called a "supposed replacement for Ace" and he got pisssed!😅
Agree, if they had Eric and tommy wear new makeup, or even had them wear the fox and Ankh, i woulda been cool with it.
@@fazole I wrote this comment after only seeing the first sentence of your comment, so keep that in mind when you read mine... But now that I see your full comment, you do understand :) Anyhow, my reply to your 1st sentence: I disagree because kiss could have easily still sold those items and die hard collectors would have still bought it up as well as spent more money to buy the new merch the band could have produced showing the new 4 makeups (Or whatever makeups Eric S. and Tommy T. would have worm, be it original or the fox and Ankh. It actually would have made for more merch to sell on top of still selling merch with the original 4 on it.
Not really . People are still buying tickets .
My first time I heard and saw kiss was kiss alive 2 album, the image of that album cover and stage shot when you opened the double album blew my mind.
I can’t count how many nights I fell asleep with that album in my hand rocking to it when I was a kid
Rock and roll over my 1st hard luck woman and baby driver best songs
Forever Gene Paul Ace and Peter in my heart... It's always you, Pete...
Thanx for sharing 🙏
Love from Sweden 💖
Kiss without Peter and Ace, wasn't really Kiss!
Guitar player
weighs in:
Peter is absolutely
right. He's completely
correct. The original
Kiss is the only Kiss
that matters. New
Kiss? Peter doesn't
buy it. Neither do I.
Not true. The band is bigger than the sum of its parts - they did the right thing getting rid of a drug-addled alcoholic who constantly
complained, messed up shows and ultimately neglected his craft only to have to be taught how to play again BY A GUITARIST! His ego was greater than his playing ability
Ace and Peter deserved better treatment at the end. Real diehard Kiss fans will always know this.
More went on behind the scenes than the fans know about.
Maybe the shouldn't have been drunken drug addicts.
No
I'll take Ace and Peter over Jean and Paul any day
I agree totally. Without Ace and Peter Nothing would have come after
Much like in The Eagles, it was ultimately ego that destroys. Most bands start out on equal footing, then the "stars" develop, it goes to their head, and they start demanding a bigger piece, more control, etc. In my experience, you can't easily have a successful band if there are varying degrees of "importance". A vocalist thinks he's more important than the lead guitarist... the lead guitarist thinks he's more important than the rhythm guitarist, they all think they're more valuable than the drummer or the bassist.... then the band fractures. Look at the masters: The Beatles, Queen, Led Zeppelin..... they never replaced someone over egos. They had their run, then disbanded, and never tried to be "the new.......". by replacing someone.
Led Zeppelin and Rush never let egos get in the way, thankfully! They were all equals.
Drummers and bass players are a dime a dozen, you can make it with hired guns for these spots
Def Leopard stayed together. Original VH another ego implosion.
@@hwagnerDUI You mean after they kicked out Pete Willis I assume.
@@Taylor.Dude. Zep and KISS ran their bands pretty much the same - four equal partners, (until they decided to Peter had to go in 1980 and had to vote to fire him because of the incorporation of the band. Then G&P bullied Ace by outvoting him on everything until he finally quit 2 years later).
If you don't think that Rush and anyone else never had battles due to ego, you're believing a fantasy - they may have kept their laundry much more private, but ALL groups deal with ego BS at some level, it is generally the biggest cause for people to quit, get fired, or to break up.
What I had heard. And Ace kind of said this too. Ace told Peter he was making twice as much as him. So Peter got mad and refused to sign a new deal unless he made more money. Paul n Gene said no.
He never made twice as much-but he DID make a little more for a while, yes.
Paul and gene being greedy? That's never been heard of before...
Ten thousand a show more. Ace is a much bigger star.
My friend told me Peter's playing was awesome during the 00 tour.
@@E.C.2Also heard that Ace didn’t know he was getting more Money then Peter once he found out he gave Peter the difference out of he’s own pocket
To finish the tour Tells you a lot about Gene & Paul !! 🖕🏼ers 🤘✌️👍
WITHOUT ACE AND PETER..IT WAS A TRIBUTE BAND JUST LIKE GRAND FUNK WITHOUT FARNER...TRIBUTE BAND.
Peter was not a consistent drummer. He couldn't read music, he was primarily self taught. He could sing and that was his strong point. Don't forget about the years of drugs and alcohol that were literally destroying him and the band. He was never a top notch player but he has a large ego. It basically boiled down to let him go, get a new drummer with fresh ideas and playing skills or keep Peter on with a band that would sink deep into the ocean because of all his problems that reached out to everyone in the band and drug them down. I'm glad KISS moved on and became bigger throughout the years with a different drummer.
KISS was never bigger after the founding version broke up than they were before. You claim Peter has a large ego in a band with Gene Simmons in it? Hell Ace is my favorite player but in a band with Ace in it? That's hilarious. Gene was a mid-bass player to have had the size ego he has. And as far as being self taught? How many huge musicians were? Ace was. Prince was. Hendrix was. John Bonham was. Couldn't read music? Neither can Ry Cooder. Neither could any of the Beatles, Eric Clapton, Stevie Wonder, or Hendrix. How about drummers? Bonham couldn't, Moon couldn't, Buddy Rich couldn't, Ringo Starr couldn't, Phil Collins couldn't. So what are we really talking about here? Was it all that or was it that he threatened the fiefdom like Ace did by expecting to be treated like he helped build it. Which he did?
Anybody with any professional training for any period of time knows there's not a single original Kiss member who was much more accomplishied than grade 6 music composition.
@@HerrinSchadenfreude The guy is being ridiculous. Anybody with any professional training for any period of time knows there's not a single original Kiss member who was much more accomplishied than grade 6 music composition.
And the other three were like Mozart or something?
@@heftosprod No one ever said that.
Well said Peter! I was an athlete in my 20s and 30s - being a full time athlete you are always carrying an injury. You treat it preform and treat it again. It is the only way.
Paul almost had it right, they should have named the band PISS after Peter and Ace left 😀
Except for the one song, I Love it Loud," I TOTALLY agree with you.
The millions they made and countless hit songs after those two hooligans were fired prove otherwise.
The original four had a symmetry, and Peter and Ace seemed like far and above more accomplished musicians in the band , they never sounded the same or produced the same quality of songs after they left
Check out "Kiss live Brazil 1983." They were on fire bro,sounded heavier than the Scorpions. Vinnie Vincent took them to the next level,should've kept going in that Direction. Paul's narcissism prevented them from growing in the mid-late 80's.
So true
Thank you again and again!! Honest, it is that simple
If you were fired then you were an employee and not a band member
I once met Paul and there was only one other fan present. He refused to sign my album even though I told him I have been a fan for over 44 years. I also told him that I was present at the 1st Aussie tour 1980 VFL Park as a 13 yr old. He was arrogent and full of himself and refused to sign
That’s Peter, alright!
that is pathetic
In my opinion kiss is and always will be peter paul gene and ace that's kiss that will always be kiss
Amen!!!
I was at that concert on Peters birthday. I took my wife to her very first KISS concert. They brought out a cake for Peter. That concert was in Fresno. They brought a cake out and the works. We all sang Happy Birthday. That was my wifes Christmas present that year. That was back in '03. Man that was a long time ago.
Anyone ever seen Paul Stanley and Ronald MacDonald in the same room
Peter, Paul, Ace, and Gene are Kiss to me, and always will be.
Agreed, only ones as well!!@
Same here. It was those four personalities combined that made KISS.
So true
I think being fired from Kiss is a bit like being fired from Dollar store. Not a big thing.
When kiss came out I enjoyed them when they got rid Peter and ace it was not Kiss
It was KISS. Paul and Gene did by far most of the work in the 70's. Not much changed after Ace quit and Peter was fired. They ended up being replaced by better musicians and bandmates and people
I agree that was when they quit getting my money too.
They didn't get rid of Ace. He quit
@@brianstrutter1501No. It wasn’t.
Yeah they were . I wanted the originals too but subsequent units if Kiss got the job done too .
Without Ace, and Peter...Kiss is squat..
Exactly.. Tommy, Eric are kick ass musicians, but they are not Ace or Peter... only 1 KISS w makeup... Peter, Ace, Gene, Paul
My eyes have to match what I’m hearing you need the original 4 that’s just the bottom line
Taking nothing away from Eric and Tommy they’re incredible musicians but the magic is only with the four that’s the way it is
Right on man!
Completely false. Why do you expect Paul and Gene to work with people that they don't get along with? Would you work with someone you don't get along with if you didn't have to? Of course not. Get over it. Ace is a lazy bum. Peter is a prick. They don't work well together. Time to move on
Ace Peter and gene an Paul that's kiss. Not that imposter line up
No era magia era juventud los primeros años de Eric y kulick mucha más magia y mejores conciertos eso es lo q hay kulick bmejor y Singer y Carr mucho mejor es lo qbyo he visto ....
@@TimothyWarner-q7ssi tu llegas a un trabajo y hay otros q llevan más antigüedad q tu. Ah siiii eres un impostor !!
I like ALL the members of KISS...Peter, Paul, Ace, Gene, Tommy, Eric(Carr), Vinnie, Mark, Eric(Singer), and Bruce.(Some of them I had to look up because I'm old and couldn't remember...)
There is a video out there on RUclips that shows Peter singing Beth, Gene is backstage bitching gripping saying he is screwing it up, when the song was over Peter came backstage and asked how did I do, nobody said anything except for Ace, Ace told him that he did a great job. Then they went out to say goodbye to the fans and Ace was the only one that grabbed up T-shirts towels and stuff to throw out to the fans Gene and Paul did not grab up anything. ROCK ON ACE 🤟😃🤟
What video? The one where they are under the stage? The one I saw was one where HE got pissed off and started raging at the crew...Gene heard what was happening and knew he would be pissed. Ace was in lala land the whole time.
Of all the surviving kiss members ive met, ironically the nicest of the original line up were peter and ace.
Bruce is also in that mix too.
The rest i could have lived without.
I Agree with what Criss is saying here I only listen to the old stuff because in my opinion that's the Real kiss the other stuff the People the Fans we no Nothing about it we weren't behind the Scene seeing it.
It's *Criss not Chris.
@@MarkDrumzEntertainment thank you I changed it.
@@JarvisGandy No Problem You're welcome. Have a wonderful Day👍🏼🙂
"Creatures of the Night."
Long live the OG Catman Peter Criss
There is no other kiss drummer the catman is king!!!
Kiss sucked without Ace and Peter.
My favorite member of KISS, and the reason I became a drummer. 🤘🏻
I discovered a new song, new as in I had never noticed it before, by Peter that I really like, Blue Moon Over Brooklyn. I'm surprised it's not a bigger song than it is.
It's terrible.
crisscat#1 album great song
It sounds like something a 12 year old wrote and recorded.
@@TheGodYouWishYouKnew hahaha well that's pretty harsh! We all have our different likes and don't likes. Would be pretty boring if we all liked the same thing I imagine. I'm sure we like and dislike a lot of the same things but that's ok.
I agree that the OG KISS was KISS. When Eric Carr, and Eventually Bruce Kulick, joined KISS, that was the New KISS.
They would drop the makeup, of course; but Eric and Vinny had their own makeup... they didn't barrow Peter's and Ace's personas.
I really felt it was a slap in the face to Peter and Ace that Tommy and Eric Singer didn't get their own KISS personas, but reused Peter's and Ace's. It was wrong, and Paul and Gene know it.
Although, I'm probably not the most authoritative KISS fan... my 2 favorite KISS albums are Music from the Elder, and Ace's Solo Album. I also own Revenge, but only for Eric Carr's Jam track at the end of it.
wasn't fired they just didn't renew his contract
THAT'S FIRED!
New Contract? He is a founder. Maybe he should call Paul and cancel his contract.
I guess he allowed himself to a minority member when he should be an equal share owner.
I heard they offered him $1 million flat for Australia & Japan,he said no,they replaced him. He should've played the tour,accepted the offer,and renegotiated after said dates were played. Very wealthy Men have different sets of problems than us.
Sounds like a wise nice man.
This was 21 years ago.
Without Ace Frehley's guitar, they aren't squat. The ONLY true KISS is Ace, Gene, Peter and Paul with makeup and identities unknown.
Those guys just wanted to undercut Ace and Peter. He knew he could get the other two to play way cheaper.
Yep
Having been a lifelong KISS fan from the beginning of the band, I can say with 100% brutal honesty, Peter and Ace “HAD IT ALL AND, BLEW IT”! This will ruffle quite a few fan’s feathers but, que sera sera. If they could’ve kept a handle on their demons (NO, NOT GENE), and just did their jobs within the KISS family, they would still be in the band THEY HELPED CREATE!, BUT NO…THEY LET THE BOOZE AND DRUGS TAKE CONTROL AND THEY FUCKED UP, PLAIN AND SIMPLE!! They don’t have a leg to stand on. And, as far as Tommy and Eric wearing the ICONIC Spaceman and Cat makeup, it was trademarked BY KISS, which they gave up their rights to when they left. So, all I can say is “too bad, so sad”!!!
i agree with Peter. Paul and Gene should of that what peter said
Peter is one of the nicest people he is humble and always forth coming honest
Incorrect. Pathological liar and a prick to his bandmates
Not so nice when he cheated on his wife & destroyed his body & mind with vices & disrespected his fans by performing badly under the influence of vices.
That's why he was fired.
Clearly you’ve never met him then…especially on a bad day.
When it comes to KISS, and Gene and Paul, it’s down to money. They wanted all of the money, and contracted “younger” talent because they didn’t pay them as much. The original four it was split four ways, new kiss it was split two ways, and even then they argued over money.
For me, Kiss are Paul, Gene, Ace, Peter, Eric Carr, Vinnie and Bruce! That‘s it!
Believe it or not... Peter was a beast in 2003/04 and was in his best shape ever (after Alive) its facts..
I will take “or not”
@@TheGodYouWishYouKnew Thats ur opinion :)
He was absolutely one of the best five drummers on planet earth 🌏 from 74-78!!!!
@@kevinchandler179 You don't know much about drumming, do you?
@@kevinchandler179Hardly. But if he was your favorite, what does it matter?
Peter always plays the victim with zero accountability and he's never honest or truthful. I saw em on their FIRST Farewell Tour and he could hardly play! Paul said he hit so soft that they had to use triggers set to their absolute maximum sensitivity level! He had health issues throughout the tour and they wanted to play longer shows and he was barely making it through the shorter one's.
U r a lying sellout
100% this is the catalyst for not renewing his contract. Would they sell more tickets with Peter? Maybe. Would it be worth putting up with his lacklustre playing and drama? That was a hard no for them.
Is this gene Simmons
I'm not a big fan but respect their success. I can see Paul wanting to lift the quality of the band and Peter was a weak link. Add in personality problems and there you have it.
He forgot to mention the interesting fact that he sold the rights to his make up for a lot of money.
57 year old stroke having former drummer myself, I worshipped Peter & was lucky enough to catch my childhood obsession live on the Dynasty tour, shortly before he crushed my soul & left KISS. As a grown man, I will always love & respect Peter for what he gave KISS fans worldwide, especially me. That said, I belive what the other guys say about his time in KISS, cause its still excuse after excuse, same as when he got his wish the first round. Sooo, why didn't you play on so GD many KISS albums, Mr rockstar millionaire dream catcher Sir? Tummy ache? Room to cold? Fair enough. But what about group photos of you in flats, or live photos with half your makeup missing Mr semi talented / lucky af ? Feet hurting at that shoot, & eyes burning at that show? Ok then, sounds legit. lol Eddy Trunk's best work was when he produced the band ICON, while his worst work is his softball interviews of his rock idols - full stop
I love these guys but, both Peter and Ace sold their makeup. Why are we still complaining?
because it doesn't matter to the fans, what G&P did is wrong anyways
"Why I hate everyone significant from my past"
By Paul Stanley
“Because they undermine my sense of superiority”
i simply can't listen to Eddie Trunk
I can't stand
I can't stand trunk
What don’t you like about? Trunk I mean.
The business side is, they’d rather pay 2 guys than pay 4 guys.
He sucked at drums when he got old. What the prob? Show must go on.
P&G couldn't have cared less as long the cash till kept getting filled. Bringing back A&P was just a vehicle for them to reestablish a then floundering makeup-less/identity-less band and start selling tickets again. Once that reunion audience momentum (with makeup) was established they brought in the scrubs to finish the deal. Without A&P they wouldn't have been able to reestablish the makeup era and institute the hired gun cruise control they've been riding now for 20+ years..
Tommy was the founder of the top KISS tribute group in LA / Hollywood back in the day called " Cold Gin " You can still see them here on RUclips !!! Also Eric was a well known Gunslinger on the drums playing for many top artists such as Black Sabbath, Alice Cooper, Lita Ford, Badlands, Brian May and Gary Moore as well as his own band ESP ... Not to mention Eric has always been a super nice guy to everyone !
Peter is his own drummer 🥁 I liked
Interesting. So they (the members other than PC) wanted new, younger blood in the band. Did they also plan to replace themselves?
Kiss is a brand,no matter who’s behind these masks
Love the originals. But too much bullshit with Ace and Peter. Though I agree, shouldn’t have put the makeup on Eric and Tommy. However, before Paul lost his voice? Those guys were awesome. At the end, the farewell with Peter and Ace was terrible. Drums were terrible. Ace was back to being Ace.
Put up with them like the Stones put up with Keith Richards.
I think all parties involved here have handled all of this well though..🤔👍
I know Ace is still out there rocking 😀
"You're too old to perform so we're going to replace you and keep going with another guy in your makeup"
and
"I'm too old to perform so I'm ending the band rather than be replaced by another guy in my makeup"
-same person
I love all eras of KISS but I truly think we should have had the original line up for the EOTR tour.
My daughter asked me twice if I wanted to go to a KISS concert. I told her no. She asked why. I said I have been to at least 10 KISS concerts and it was fantastic, one of the best times of my life, I do not want to tarnish that memory by going to a KISS concert now without watching the REAL KISS MEMBERS. After Ace and Peter left I held on as long as I could but never went to a live event again.
I always have alot respect for Peter Criss and Ace Frehley I grew up during the Psycho Circus wra of KISS I always love Peter and Ace My Dad was friends with Ace Without the Original Members of KISS we wouldn't have KISS Today but Just my opinion Tommy Thayer should have been the Space Bandit and Eric Singer should have been a Lion, Dog or Hawk or Eagle those are just my opinion but Peter has his flaws he wasnt perfect but he manage to improve over the years im glad he is with us
He'll be seventy-nine this year.
Instead of doing a makeup reunion with Eric and Tommy.
They should have just toured did new music with Eric and Bruce Kulick everything would have had more substance. Kulicks yrs had very solid albums and the old stuff would have been more acceptable. I saw the reunion show it was awesome Ace and Peter had they're chops for sure.
Apologize to burst the bubble, better Kiss without Ace & Peter...
ummm.. no
First time Detroit 1974 free outdoor concert on Belle isle followed that evening at the MICHIGAN PALACE
April 7, 1974
Gene has always been a Hard Taskmaster
That's Y Kiss has survived
And Thrived from their products
Same with Paul
They haven't "thrived". They were irrelevant and almost broke and busted during a lot of the unmasked period. They copied every fad they could to try and keep up with everyone else in the industry until the reunion tour. Ace and Peter revived kiss and then Paul and gene dressed two imposters up and made kiss a tribute band because that's where the money is, that's all they're interested in, money.
@@pauli.vanili… you hit the nail on the head.
Ace and Peter got to big to young. They didn't stay focused back in the day because drinking and drugs were more important. My opinion anyway. I saw the original Kiss in 77 and Ace play in 2022. Always will be a fan.
I love the original KISS, but over the years Peter has just come off as a baby. I'm not there, so I don't know any more than the avg. fan, but it is always him complaining and it gets old.
If Peter Criss was as great as he thinks he is then why didn’t he end up in another band? That’s right, because he isn’t worth much to anyone else. Sorry, but that’s the truth
Peter did not have the chops to play any of the songs with double bass or semi complicated fills. Eric Carr and Eric Singer were far superior drummers. Peter was my first drumming influence and I respect the work that he did.
Paul Stanley hasn't had the 'chops' to sing in KISS for 15 years! Didn't stop him from foisting his hoarseness and fakery on the fans..
@@ufmwc No argument here.
Just imagine if George left the Beatles then later Ringo did. Both were replaced and the replacements were told they had to wear George and Ringo wigs and they had to wear the clothes that George and Ringo would wear??
Just no!
People like the originals. It's familiar. There are two exceptions that immediately come to my mind. (Yes I know there are plenty of others) Fleetwood Mac who (absolutely no offence to Peter Green) skyrocketed with the addition of Stevie and Lindsay, and ACDC, who accepted Brian because he did not mimic Bon. On that note, Brian faced a very tough crowd. They powered through and won. The new members of each band brought new songs and sound earning them fan recognition. I applaud that.
For me though, Kiss is Paul, Gene, Ace and Peter.
I lost interest after that. To me it seemed the new members brought nothing new to the table.
Without Ace and Peter, it's just a tribute band 🙃
Without Ace and Peter, they shoulda either created new characters for Eric and Tommy, or just taken the makeup back off and brought back Bruce Kulick.
@@ThePatcore KISS was the first band that I've ever seen in 1974, I was 12 years old, I seen them with Bruce, and they sucked, actually the worst KISS concert I ever seen, they are just not KISS without Peter and Ace 🙃
Paul almost had it right, they should have named the band PISS😀
Like every other band with replacement members?
Got it.
@@jeffhodge7272 when Bon Scott died, and Brian took his place, I can see that, they are still AC DC, but KISS , that's different.
Pete checked out of the band after 5 years
Then ace 2 years later. Not your band anymore
Paul Stanley just wanted to have total control he wanted people who only do what they are told to do no back talk or anything
Not true. That's what Peter wants you to believe
Must be a Paul Stanley fan you must like being ripped off paying for a non live show you must not know there are more than one side of a story Paul Stanley is a hypocrite and a egomaniac
@@brianstrutter1501 while I agree that Paul and Gene started the group Ace and Peter made up the core members of the band. They were right there with Paul and Gene paying their dues. They were there from the beginning. They created the personas. Yes, there were problematic moments in the past , and Paul and Gene managed to keep the band alive in a different direction, but you still can’t take that away from them. I totally get your argument (you’ve had a few retorts to some of these comments) , but then take the makeup and costumes off and perform the songs without it. Because it just comes off like a cash grab and they’re only delivering half the goods.
@@butchstevenson7029 I Agree and I have been a fan for 44 years
I met Paul and he was one Arrogant man / Full of himself
It will never be KISS without the original group members. Gene Simmons,Paul Stanley, Peter Criss,and Ace Frehley! They together made KISS! It wasn't the same after Peter and Ace left!😢
Kiss fucked up.
Several times...
Agreed . And unfortunately it was several times .
Ace and Peter fucked up several times
Must be why Paul and Gene have more more money than they could spend in 5 lifetimes.
They SOLD THEIR RIGHTS TO THE IMMAGE!! FOR CASH!! It was ALWAYS Paul's band! Ace & Peter were hired! From the beginning!! Founding member?! That illusion was created by Bob! Paul & Gene (in spite of what's said, or whomever gets the credit) created "new characters" out of respect for the two original "hired guns"! Paul & Gene are geniuses!! They made the decisions that kept the cash flowing!! My ONLY issue with that fact is that I, too, contributed! And, if you're reading this, SO DID YOU! I'm certain that the two of them are grateful! 😂😂
Thats what cost them thier dis popularity.......KISS went downhill after the 78 solo albums
i agree... 100% my entire kiss collection is only stuff from the 1970s...
I do agree that if it's a new Kiss, quit playing the Alive 1 setlist, drop the makeup. At the same time, this wasn't a huge surprise. If you read Peter's book, to hear him say he's not a complainer is just a false statement. His whole book is a whine fest. I didn't get this, I didn't get that. They had to hire a limo to take him to a bar gig because he needed to feel important. He isn't the greatest drummer,and humility was lost on him. Paul and Gene stayed hungry even after the money train rolled in. Ace and Peter got comfortable and stopped progressing. I love them both, but in my mind, Kiss stopped at Unmasked. It's been a new band ever since, and they should have branded it as such. I remember watching Mtv the day they took the makeup off. I felt duped that 2 guys were impostors.
When a family member falls off the wagon (drugs & alcohol) over and over again and is dangerous, you must, for self preservation, remove yourself from that dangerous person.
Ace and Peter are dangerous.
Let’s be fair: Peter and Ace sucked by the end of it. Even in 1996. Tommy and Eric were an upgrade and a half. I don’t care about the makeup. The makeup is characters. Not people.
glad KISS is over. seeing 2 guys not even real members rake in the cash that peter and ace could have shared is bothersome
Yall act like Kiss wasnt a band without Tommy & Eric for like 15 years give or take..
@@andrewhatcher2702a better band at that
Let`s be honest now 25 years later. He was too old. He couldn`t pull off a 2 hour show. It was pretty obvious already on the second tour in 97.
Peter Criss is my favorite singer in 💋 KISS, he wrote the song 🎵 Beth and that song was so Beautiful ❤No matter what people will think! As for Paul and Gene they should apologize to Peter for saying those awful things they said about him! And Paul Stanley also called Peter an Ace Anti- Simentic, when they were most definitely not!!! How do I know who said that because I read somewhere that Ace or Peter, I dont know who ever said that but they said that's ridiculous because they have Jewish friends!!! Paul needs to be a better person and a better friend!!!
We are going to have NEW KISS. Yes, they will look like old Kiss, they will dress like old Kiss, they will play the songs from old Kiss. The difference is with new Kiss we control everything and we can pay them less, that's new Kiss.
Peter knew Ace wasn't going to go on the tour BEFORE he agreed to do the tour. He could've just said no, I'm not going on the tour unless Ace is there. Instead of kvetching about it later. Also if Peter has a problem with the other guy wearing the make up, he didn't have to sell the rights to the Kiss Corporation
tommy and eric singeer gave the band new life ,and 20 more years.Drumming is hard and peter was struggling
Well… Peter always had to ask his wrists in ice after the shows when they did the reunion tours. It was hard on him back then…
In those days KISS could only fill MUCH smaller venues. They could not book the large arenas again until the Reunion with Ace & Peter back again.
I was told his playing was fantastic on the 00 tour.
Without Peter Kriss kiss is not the same with out any of the founding members kiss IS NOT THE SAME. The fans want the original group !!!! Or it ant the same !!! Ace ,Paul ,gene , Peter or it’s ITS NOT KISS put your stuff aside with each other and give fans what they want .
Ace was the only talented member.
I'm KISS now. Some guy broke my legs like that Casablanca guy threatened to do for not giving up their Double Platinum Three Times Chinchilla Billboard Topping Album of the year without being paid first. They broke my legs, every year for practically a decade and stole every album of the year. Left me drugged, crippled, homeless , penniless , with countless amounts of medical problems like a smashed face and heart problems. Just goes to show ya.
I kinda wish the original line-up was Paul, Ace, Gene, and Eric Carr....Carr was a much more competent drummer than Peter Criss.
...WAY, WAY better chops!
I have YET to find a drummer that disagrees with that statement!
I'm a fan of Peter and Ace, but being in bands my whole life, sometimes ya gotta cut the fat. KISS would have been done after Dynasty if it wasn't for Paul Stanely holding the fort together.
Ty!
Went on for 20 more years. Gotta do what ya gotta do. He physically could not do it anymore
I agree. Even though Charlie Watts of The Rolling Stones could still play at his age before dying, The Stones had a far different tempo to their music. Even Charlie before he died could keep up with The Stones, but just couldn't last playing with KISS. I mean really. Peter could never be a drummer for a band like Slayer or Megadeth, even in his prime back in the 80s.
If Peter couldn't play, they should have stopped.