Grand Theft Auto IV | Side by Side | PS3 Xbox 360 Windows Xbox One X | Graphics Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- Join my Discord
/ discord
Brand New Side by Side. This time we have Grand Theft Auto 4, requested by my Patreon member LNCRFT. A great suggestion, and was glad to do it. Hope you like it.
Please Consider joining my Patreon
/ rookervision
Check out our shop
www.etsy.com/s....
Follow us on Facebook
/ rookervision
Follow us on Twitter
/ rookvision
Follow us on Instagram
/ rookervisio. .
LINKS...
Play GTA4 online 2019 steamcommunity...
Play GTA 4 60FPS
steamcommunity...
CryENB V3
www.gtaall.com...
Better City Textures
www.fileplanet...
Niko Head
www.gtainside....
HD Textures
www.gtainside....
Music in Video
Anthem.mp3
Coupe.mp3
Scratch-the-Itch.mp3
Still_Standing.mp3
The PS3 version ran at a lower resolution than the 360 version, the developers were struggling to get to grips with the PS3's architecture and were finding it very difficult to program the game on.The developers didn't find the PS3 to be at all user friendly to program for, so they weren't able to harness all of the PS3's potential and they took the easiest option by lowering the resolution to make the game less demanding.
yes sony explained this as you said. the only game that used full potential on the ps3 is the last of us and as someone that have finished the game couple of times, i can easily say they are one of the most beautiful graphics i ever saw and can be easily compared with pc
This happened to a lot of developers. The only teams that really mastered the architecture were Sony teams that worked on their exclusives. This is why I preferred 360 over Ps3. You really felt like you were getting a poor man's gaming experience with the Ps3 version of games.
@@Deadsea_1993 Also Xbox 360 first party games looked amazing ! Halo, gears, Bioshock (when it was still exclusive, even then its the better one) and so on.
@@srp770 don't forget Metal Gear 4
@@ajaakola2. Fallout 3 and New Vegas had game breaking bugs on Ps3, 360 didn't. It is the same today tbh. I have a Pro and an X and I like my X far more. Games run smoother, better services, and I'm a sucker for Game Pass. Game Pass just flat out dominates Stadia and Playstation Now like Andre The Giant style. I hate streaming games and that's why Game Pass is better. Better selections, can be played offline, isn't streamed at all. You download the games as you would if you owned them digitally and they are yours as long as your service is going.
I went from paying $60 often for one game (as gaming is a serious hobby of mine) to only paying $50 every 3 months for countless 360 and One games. The service is now even offering classic original Xbox games like Panzer Dragoon (which was based on a successful Sega Dreamcast game cause many creators from Sega that worked on the consoles and games joined Microsoft to work on Xbox).
GTA IV, the best Game in Story and Realism in the Series.
hahaha, *realism*
@@raccoonguy21 it has the best physics in the series.
@@raccoonguy21 it is in fact the most realistic GTA game, why are you laughing?
GTA4 HAS ASSETTO CORSA DRIVING PHYSICS
GTA5 HAS STYROFOAM MARIOKART DRIVING PHYSICS
@@AdolfHitler-xp1nx Why you have the name of a historic people from austria? Are you a nazi?
Hey RookerVision, let's go bowling!
I wish. I love bowling.
Ok
Roman
Midnight Club Still Cancelled Soz :/
Yea I loved that racing game
Independence is to play your own music like MP3 player station on GTA San Andreas. WHen you dont have anything put it will play newsbroadcasts and commercials only
That's also true. But it also plays funny commercials and has a dj that makes fun of music
Even better is you can rip all of the music, commercials and news with software
The 360 version has a sort of arty, smudgy filter that’s not in the PS3 version, which is why distant objects are probably a little more defined on PS3, despite the lower overall resolution.
Ah, gta 4, imo it has the best story mode
I agree
Indeed
I like more the luis López history
eddie ram it’s Luis mane
Yup
Oh yes, the best GTA ever created which Rockstar just seems want to forget.
No they Dont. They recently deleted the original GTA 4 and Added The Complete Edition which is the Main game and the DLC's. (Had to get into my Closet in order to find it but it wasn't that bad.
But San Andreas’ story was just a bit better
Triston L no
@@MaxwellJacobFriedman. your balls made it that's why it sucks
@@MaxwellJacobFriedman. actually, no. It was second best.
I remember picking it up for my 360 when I was around 14. Take in mind that I was 14 in 2016. Having already played GTA V and Red Dead Redemption.
No clue why I got GTA IV out of all the games in the shop.
I'm sure glad I did. I received the complete edition with the episodes from Liberty city too.
I started it up. Drove Roman to his place.
GOD the car controls, GOD.
I played it almost 2 hours and it just didn't feel like a GTA title.
Oh boy, and then.. Little Jacob.
The first mission where you get to see the shooting system.
I was impressed, hooked on it. It was unreal. For me, the shooting in GTA IV has to be the best I've ever seen in an open world. It feels real, powerful, deadly. It s not about bullet rains.
The game finally felt okish. In time I started tot appreciate the driving system more, it felt realistic. The story felt real, it was a story of loss and revenge, tragedies and living in the past, it covered various themes of ethics.
I will admit, there were times where I would play for 3 hours and just ask Packie to go out to eat summin, then ask Roman out and such.
Let me tell you when I realised that this game is a 10/10.
>Call packie's sister for a date
>She accepts
>You pick her up and take her to a place she enjoys
>She feels nice but doesnt /invite you in/
>I ask her out again
>She enters the car, after a short time a small talk starts "you're still wearing the same clothes? Gross"
Hmm
>I take her on another date wearing something fancy this time
I got there with a completely dented car
>She replies "Jesus Niko what's up with your car?"
The level of realism, the impact it had on me, the feels... 10/10. GTA V might've had heists that gave you adrenaline, but GTA IV made me feel human.
Omg. Best comment. Add me. Lol
I agree with all of this
Award winning quote *GTA V might've had heists that gave you adrenaline, but GTA IV made me feel human.*
Ayee you're turning 18 this year right?
So no one is going to talk about how a kid that had only play gta v up to that point said that the iv controls didn't feel like gta? Huh? HUH?
It's just miserably sad to see how crippled the performance on PC is. The port is so crappy!
Otherwise the game itself is the best GTA to this date judging by the story
The PC version runs terrible for a PC game, but the console versions have never run well either and have always run worse.
Whatever issues this game has with optimization extends to all versions of the game.
@@TheFreeToaster Good thing we got GTA SA
while the port is bad is nowhere as bad as you make it out to be, the game is playable at playable framerates. Saints row 2, now that is a terrible port.
@@powalovesmusic I know the SR2, and how badly it's optimized. Yeah sure it's playable but you need to tamper the files a bit. But still it's infamously bad port from huge company that made massive success with the game!
my 1st proper PC ran the game at 1080p ultra every setting with 65fps avg lol
3570k 4.84ghz, EVGA gtx 670 FTW 4gb, 8gb ddr3 1333mhz
Why this game hasn’t been re-released on PS4 is baffling to me
Svpreme Kai they should update this game on Xbox one 4K patch also because the ps4 isn’t backwards combat like the xbox
They could just add it to psnow but id prefer a remaster. I tried Red Dead recently (on PS3 and PSNow) and GTA 4 on PS3 and it was pretty eye cancer. So much motion blur and the resolution was so low. The gameplay in this video honestly looks so much better than playing in person.
llJeezusll red dead redemption looks like a remaster on the Xbox one X . I also prefer a remasters so I can rebuy the game
@@llJeezusll yep
Why not on the switch
10:08 that voice crack tho
Lmao
"Hey cousin, let's go bowling!"
And you had to keep going too. Got so annoying.
@@RookerVision I remember when roman called me a wrong time during a mission where you had to follow a guy to an apartment building without being spotted roman calls and the guy runs away
@@NumaanTahir That's scripted, happens to everyone.
He is EVERYWHERE!
This is stupid that differences between console versions and PC version of this game are so hardly noticeable.
GTA 4 and it's episodes (TLaD & TBoGT) are the best.
DonMontana2001 My guy GTA 5 players don’t care that you said that they’d rather enjoy a game than argue like you fanboys.
@@Khadafi_1986 so f'n what they need to know V sucked and they went in the wrong direction after IV
@@mrpersonguy7286 gta 5 is way better experience than 4
@@User-ge7ni maybe if you think reality is a cartoon. Otherwise no
"GTA IV modded on PC is the best"
GTA IV modded: **crashes**
I'm not exactly a genius when it comes to modding lmao
I put a SSD in my PS3 and it makes IV loading and pop in much better.
@Ps User It improves the loading/rendering part by a fucking LOT thats for sure, and maybe just a little bit in performance but i cant confirm this one.
My Xbox One has an hdd, the game takes around 20/30 seconds to load, and it's fine because the loading music is so good
You missed a thing. The Complete Edition on PS3 runs better and is less blurry than the vanilla PS3 Version cause it uses the improved Graphics from the second and last DLC (The Ballad of Gay Tony). Also this version makes the game run at native 720p on PS3. Would have been nice to see a comparison between the two versions of the Game.
First I'm hearing of this
What nonsense, I have The Complete Edition, GTA4 and Lost and Dammed the same blurry, only Ballad for Gay Tonny is already working clear. Unfortunately. I played the disс version and the PSN ver.
@@ReYDeR2k the complete edition looks better and has better graphics and runs better less polygons
@@_wanted_outlaw3007, you tell a me GTA4 without addon have more bad graphic? R* take real money for this soap crap?
@@ReYDeR2k the add-ons came out like 3 months later, they just made it more optimized and it looked better as a reason for someone to want to buy the add-ons who wants to play the game with better-looking assets....
Going to replay this for the first time again since 2008! Originally I played it on my PS3 back in '08. Now I am going to replay the 360 version on my Xbox One. This game definitely deserves a "Remastered Edition" with updated graphics, fps, and all DLC for the PS5 and Series X
Its running at 60 fps now on the series consoles
@@matthewjohnson1891 But only 720P :\
Glad someone finally made a video comparing the different versions of GTA IV.
"Everyone can enjoy" unless you have a PS4
I guess that's true...
Backwards comp 😎
@Colored Gaming No.
This is how it works
PS1 Discs work on PS2 and all models of the PS3.
PS2 Discs only work on Phat PS3 Models.
PS3 Discs work on nothing.
PS4 Discs work on the PS5.
PS4 does not accept PS1 discs, neither does the PS5.
@Colored Gaming Ok
The mods ruin the atmosphere of GTA IV, so those are a big miss for me.
The high framerate affects mainly the minigames, it's most noticeable when playing air hockey in the DLC.
In conclusion
PC - God
Xbox 360 - Pretty good
PS3 - Dumpser with a hard drive.
BigSmokeVEVO Nah. Still looks good.
Exactly the truth I am so glad I only play on Xbox 360 and Xbox 1
BigSmokeVEVO That’s stupid that isn’t true we all there all the same beside pc
xdddd
Hhhhhhhhhhhhh
Man this is a great game, sadly i just had to go through the pain of getting it to work on windows 10.
Yeah its a bit of a pain, not too bad though. I got it to work with 3 command lines and changing game properties.m
I played on my XBox 360 back in the day and replaying it right now on my XBox One X. Is nice to play it again with some improvement without having to buy another copy.
GTA IV is my favourite game in the series. Niko's just an amazing character in my opinion.
Other differences, the PS3/360 hold the UZI differently than the PC, also the pc has a different loading screen, and the pc version also has a Tie on the suit, while the ps3/360 have the suit without tie and open.
Yeah, I remember having the PS3 version of this, the map would not load and like I would just be floating in mid-air...
That happened to me too the character would literally just be falling for infinity
Than you should replace the hard drive
@@AI_KyunNotAnEgg or change disk if you play disk version
Why is this video called GTA San Andreas graphics comparison when it’s GTA IV
A goof
Noticed that too
RookerVision - Gaming Videos mistakes mistakes we all do it
LOLz 😂
Best HD era GTA
The PS3 version is my favourite, period
Last time I bought a game from Blockbuster. RIP
GTA 4 is my personal favorite in the series
PS3 version, as I grew up on this bad boys and it's fun as hell to play
I’m a PC gamer and my internet went one day, there was nothing to do so I fired up my Xbox. I literally can’t believe I used to play GTA 4 as a kid and thought 16-30 FPS was perfectly clear and realistic. Times have changed...
ThaiDuiTx but it realistic tho
So glad to have the PC version back on Steam. Great game :)
I still think the graphics hold up well today, especially the cars
if you play on pc sure
8:50 you can install the game to your hard drive on Xbox 360.
GTA IV was only a bad port when unpatched while patched versions during 1.0.3.0 up to 1.0.5.0 it was pretty optimized... Till 1.0.6.0 was introduced and added RDR1's shadow system which looked good but took a good hit off performance due of it as well effected the environment shadows of some light sources that was there in the consoles and pre 1.0.5.0 PC version that was there when night shadows was off. Also btw having definition on disables the static blur, motionblur and DoF.
And great game and a great video, a perfect duo! However, I just want to point out that you didn't mention the saturation slider (visible only when you pause the game, not when it's freshly launched) which allows to make the game slightly more colorful and less gray. This is a thing on PC, but I'm not sure about the consoles.
There is also
Who can believe that GTA 4 despite being older it still looks much better and more realistic then GTA 5. Oh sweet nostalgia.
Nah
remembering playing this in superslim and alot of explosion in screen makes my system crazy as hell :v
@Ps User
nope. as i remember it doesn't crash. it only has some serious framedrops in most cases but still playable :3b
I mean your PC config is going to run it at 60fps, with tweaks, but the hardware is so much more powerful than the X360. So the X360 running sometimes more than 30fps at 720p isn't bad at all.
I heard stuff about ps5 having backwards compatibility hopefully they add old rockstar games and call of duty games and more.
Nah
"Now adays destiny has that beat at around 500 million"
*shows the budget on screen which is 140 million*
he probable doesnt knnow what hes talking bout, just clickbaiting
My biggest gripe with GTA 4 on PC is the negative mouse acceleration that prevents you from making very small adjustments when aiming.
Best Version of Every GTA game in my Opinion:
GTA 1: PC
GTA London: PC
GTA 2: Dreamcast
GTA 3: PC
GTA VC: PC
GTA SA: PS2
GTA LS: PSP
GTA VCS: PS2
GTA 4: XBOX 360
GTA China Town Wars: NDS
GTA 5: XBOX 360
I think gta5 is thr best version obviously ps5 and xbox series x
GTA 5 best version for the time was PS3. Obviously I'm not talking about the PS5/PC version or anything that released after 2013.
Ok, what makes the PS2 version of San Andreas better than the PC version?
And what makes the 360 version of GTA 5 better than like the PS4, PC or PS5 versions?
@@BrawlinEntertaintment2K i don't know about the gta 5, but gta vice city and san andreas on the ps2 are wayy better than the pc version, and i say it as a person who only played them on pc, just search the comparison on youtube, the ps2 version has such beautiful colors/vibe in vice city and san andreas
7:32 Yes that was a beautiful sight indeed.
#1 comment haha
I don't like mods that change colors in GTA IV, original dark-toned gritty colours match the story and setting perfectly, with that rainy & cloudy weather
Good show guys. Eventho I never played GTA4. BTW, wanna go bowling?
Just play it. 08-11 was peak console gaming with gears of war and GTA 4. It mostly sucks now
I have only played IV on the PS3. But I have played Lost and Damned on the PS3 and 360. There's just something that feels a lot better about the 360 version, like it feels more open and brighter or something?
3:41 Wrong. Saints Row 2 is worst port to pc ever.
Arkham knight: hold my beer
@@MetalMe55iah Arkham Knight is good now tho
Spider-Man 2: Hold my vodka
@@revenge1205 wut it was smooth and we'll optimized tho.
Rishi Sivakumar No the PC port was garbage
I always thought what Playstation delivers contrast to the other platforms is that to be able to play 60 fps stable gameplay? And all this years I actually played below 30? I can't believe it
I play the story mode for about a week!
1:21 my two favourite character just to each other
*I'm the favorite protagonist from GTA Series! I'M A SUCESS, I-CAN'T-BE-TOUCHED*
I remember the time when I tried to play on PC, passed a couple of missions, and stopped playing because of issues: road's textures glitching that doesn't show on the screen, low frame rate, and game crashing, even with bluescreen errors, lol. Regardless, I enjoyed it because the game had a charm, an atmosphere that I've never experienced before in gta series. The game is a masterpiece, and it never gets old.
Nice comparison i wish you increased the contrast on pc version it just look a bit off
Please compare far cry 3 next
what made it fun is : Native trainer + graphics mod + map mod
without all of it, console remaster is unnecessary
L.A Noire next?
i think the ps3 has a slight edge over 360 in terms of graphics, slightly better lighting, less aliasing and quicker texture loads, but framerate isnt so good.
The aliasing is actually worse on PS3 (360 version uses 2×MSAA compared to the PS3 version's QAA) & the lighting is about the same on both.
@@paulbell3682 it may have "worse aliasing" but it has less jagged edges on PS3. In terms of lighting different times of day seem to be more colorful on PS3, idk why it's like that but yeah. I played on 360 when I had GTA 4 so I'm not being biased but the PS3 looks kind of nicer
@@thedrbat9572 I agree. The 360 has aa and the ps3 doesn't but it still looks rough and dithered compared to the ps3, which uses the blur filter to smooth it out. The ps3 does still have some jaggies which stand out though. The ps3 uses a better lighting system which makes it look more realistic (fp16 vs fp10 on the 360). The 360 also has bigger framerate drops because it isn't 30fps capped like the ps3, so it can go from like 40 to 30 or under quickly. I have both and overall prefer the ps3 even though the 360 is technically superior in specs. The 360 looks too gamey and cartoony whereas the ps3 looks more like a film, which suits my taste more.
@@F_Arrow95 yea I wish the PS3 and 360 were the same, it annoys me a little bit that rockstar changed the graphics on the two consoles.
@@thedrbat9572 Yeah apparently it's because the ps3 was harder to code for, though they did a great job with it nonetheless and in some ways looks just as good as the 360, if not better. It also has the little added bonus of sixaxis and more importantly, free online play.
I hadnt played the GTA series, but picked up a Xbox 360 version for $3.
The problem with the frame rate was that it was completely unlocked on Xbox 360.
This leads to horrific frame pacing since the frame rate can not line up evenly with your monitor's refresh rate. the 360 didn't suffer as much because of the fact it rarely went past the low 30s so it wasn't that bad.
but playing on the Xbox One actually renders it almost unplayable to some people me included because the frame rate jumps all over the place and it gets extremely janky.
Fortunately playing on the Xbox One X puts you in the upper 40s to 60 frames per second most of the time meaning if you have a freesync TV or monitor, it'll play perfectly playable Xbox One X.
Does the xbox one works with freesync? Also with gsync monitors?
It works with freesync but not g-sync
@@gt362gamer Freesync won't completely save you from this game, even on the X it will drop to framerates Freesync doesnt support
I really like the xbox's Yellow environment
Once a busta you always a busta
Me too, PC has a blue tint to it.
@@thanos_n9s145 man you jacked up shit sounds ridiculous
@@ekanshnehra4409 gyeeaaah homie gyeeeaaahh..the PC version is good apart from optimisation and environment
@@Demoprofile the code is a mess
Flipping the controller to reload on PS3 is actually somewhat useful. I kept it enabled. It's also in GTAV.
The LCC on PS3 had a massive glitch in TBoGT where the floor deletes itself.
You can just install the game to the Xbox 360's hard drive from the xbox home you know. That way you wouldn't have as much texture pop-in.
This was 2008, the Xbox 360 didn't had Hard Drive by default
So games had to run off the disk
You should do LA Noire next.
Can't. I don't have a switch
There was a time when I was young kid, in deep denial that the Xbox 360 graphically was usually superior to PS3. PS3 was the first and only way I played GTA IV when I was a kid, but last year bought a copy of the complete edition on Xbox 360, and have yet to play it. I played and beat it on PC and it looks miles better than what I played on PS3.
*huh, whenever I play GTA IV on my PC, its FPS is always 60 when driving, but when walking, it goes to 53 FPS. Sometimes it goes up to 61 or 63 FPS. Note, I am not using any mods or any ways to get always 60 FPS.*
VSYNC
Gta 4 was my life
The PS3 version just isn't as good as tge Xbox 360 version as it eas still relatively early in its lifetime when developers had issues with the hardware. Oh well, GTA 5 was graphically superior on PS3 over Xbox 360, although it didn't run quite as smooth.
I recently got Complete Edition for my PS3, now I'm trying to get 100%
It's a pain in the ass.
**LET'S GO BOWLING!**
1:22 the moment you saw SOAP in no. 12 press "F"
Glad price hanged makarov
Who still play gta iv in 2019?
2020 now. Bought it a few days ago for ps3 because it runs so bad on my pc. Fucking Love that game. Best physics in gta and I Love the shoot feeling with the camera near the head. Also Love the gun sounds. More satisfying without Auto aiming ❤️
I’ve gotten GTA IV running smoothly on my PC, which is not what I would describe as a high end gaming machine, and the install is pretty vanilla other than some mods to remove Games for Windows live or whatever that pos is called.
What did u do?
PRetty obvious most people are waiting for gta 5
I like the orange nature of gta iv
The 360 version looks blurry, so if you're saying the PS3 version is blurry then fuck! I'm definitely not buying it again. I'll stay with the 360. It just looks so washed out.
Glad that you finally made this! Nice! Want to go bowling?
Thank you
Maybe do a side by side need for speed undercover next?
GTA IV is my favorite too, i love the serious yet sarcastic and dark tone
The PC graphics are blurrier than the 360? What? No.
Gta4 was my favorite game for the ps3 i still play it i like that line lets go blowing
I wish there were more differences between console and PC versions of GTA IV, TLAD and TBOGT. I mean PC versions would contain different mission dialogues (the storylines would still be the same on all versions), more possibilities and less glitches. I wish these differences were more noticeable.
This is my favourite GTA I absolutely loved playing it I played it over and over again and it just didn’t get boring the story behind is just so good! Overall an amazing game i wish they bought it on ps4 but oh well just sad we won’t get another GTA like that
Ps3 version is just unplayable.
Too blurry and yellowish.
Gta v however runs quite good on ps3
I loved this masterpiece... In my opinion the GTA with the best story
Its a shame to play at 20fps... its lower than amovie
this game out in 2008 dude, the physics were too great for the PS3 and X360
at 7:23 the X360 dropped at 12fps, the PS3 wouldnt be a problem but the Cell was too complex for R*
I remember the day I got this game, my dad took me to a GameStop and he bought this for me, those were good times.
Just a great comparison of the video. Would have been good to mention that that was the pre-rerated Australian version (MA15+) besides that there's nothing to complain. Great as always and keep it up. :D
I used to play on the ps3 version and I don't ever remember it being that blurry
You might've gotten used to it
@@runninglate9672 I guess so
I guess you optimised your tv picture settings to make it look better than normal
The title says San Andreas. It should be GTA IV
A goof
@@RookerVision just a friendly reminder :)
Anyone that calls GTA 4 the worst PC port of all time has obviously never played Saints Row 2, or Deadly Premonition, or Dark Souls on PC. Those are the top 3 easily in that order
Ps3 Version Bad
Xbox 360 Version OK
PC Version awesome
PC version is so unoptimized... I bought it yesterday and it's very hard to maintain 60fps...
I play on Xbox one and honestly it still feels modern
Gta5 PS4 pro vs Xbox 1 X plz
Pro actually looks better.
Neither Console got an upgrade for the game so they look the same as the base systems. PS4 looked better than the Xone.
So since they look the same, pro will technically look better
@@nighttimestalker and performance??
@@I_hate_you_Forza_motorsport
Both play at 30 frames per second just like the base consoles.
Except I'd imagine both are probably locked at 30 unlike the base consoles which can drop below that.
@@nighttimestalker I know that both are locked at 30 FPS BUT which is more stable ??
@@I_hate_you_Forza_motorsport
considering both the base Xbox one and PlayStation 4 offered free much the exact same performance as each other, I imagine the X and pro a probably fairly identical in performance
GTA4 on PS3 can't upscale to 1080p if you disabled 720p on "screen settings".
" You will get 60 fps all the time"
What if I have a low end PC.
What are your specs?
@@gabrielbrouwer Pentium 4, 4 GB Ram, Nvdia; geforce 710(2gb graphics card).
My PC is so old that I don't remember what are the other specs put in..
@@p0rtalraider214 that seems good enough
@@joaquingonzalez834 Nope, with this setup I get less than 30 fps, I think of upgrading it.
try getting some patches or find a guide to optimize it
Gta 4 has the best physics imo