How is it that I was just thinking about this technique, working on it, thinking about Reuben's videos and this pops up in the suggested?? Darn Kids! Get off the Lawn!😊
Reub! Your ability to teach these various strokes is just what we needed. You don't "over complicate" the lesson, yet you give exactly what we NEED to know! Many Thanks! ~s.
Thanks . And great you acknowledge Han . He just turned 82 years young . Still so creative. Btw there are clips of Han playing more conventional jazz on RUclips. Swings like a 😈.
Wow Reuben, this is amazing. I'm turning sixty and refocusing my life to be a musician. Been doing these exercises several hours everyday for a month. So far I got the technique but I can't say I'm much faster using push pull however, I can hold my rolls and add accents significantly better and all around it has helped my playing significantly. Excited to see what these old bones can do. Thanks for the video.
For me Steve arthritis is setting in the fingers at 62. What we did for 40 years has affected our technique now with concerns for the fingers. I ruined my hands sheetrocking, then AC technician for 12 years. I am so envious of these individuals with uncanny sticking abilities
Age has nothing to do with us as a matter of fact if you were about to write estimate 16 years old you is the one in advantage being old for variety of reasons fortunately for us we grew upholding the standard grip and I played everything you could name except for one or two not gonna bother you with it now but if you want to study someone who is a genius Stewart Copeland from the police many videos and you're in for a shock everybody thinks he's a rock drummer he can do anything because he's old like me! I had a good of learning from Gym Chapin RIP his son Harry lived near me RIP Gym only taught talented students so he said well let me see what you can do so I sat at my side and I went around they set as fast as I could and the first thing he says wow man you "got great chops but you're working too hard "I had no idea what he meant he said let me show you. He said my drum set and taught me the Mouller technique which he was famous for. It helped me immediately! Then I don't want to go on and on and he invited me to sit in with his band in the Hamptons for the summer at some places that is probably gone to 100 years called the Yardbird or something. I was so flattered and unfortunately I had to support my family and I was starving artist so I said "Gym I am so honored but unfortunately I have to turn it down because I have to make a living" to be candid with you I didn't know why he was asking me because I didn't think I was a good knew I wasn't that good! But Jim was not looking at me for what I could play currently he saw what I was capable of playing later on! His prophecies came true as I progressed and Ruben Spyker is giving an excellent demo but the first thing he should've said is this is to flatter Buddy Rich RIP he is excellent but there are many ways to do this OK buddy rich dude with no effort he didn't have to go to the side he never twirled steak I never try to stick I can of course but I don't have to I can play but he's a hand with a variety of ways that differ from this. I hope before I drop dead to do various demonstration of how you can do everything with no effort the more calories you expend it works against you. I had the honor of meeting Buddy Rich's daughter; his manager Irving Kaye. who is in heaven and his grandson who couldn't stop playing the piano through the whole thing. This was a tribute I didn't know too buddy who died unfortunately recently and I attended to see Jack Jones who has the greatest voice of all time probably five octave but he never made it really like Frank Sinatra who was lucky if he could hit two. So I asked Irving why what is wrong with this guy he has the greatest voice in the world but nobody listens and when they do he puts people to sleep. I'm leaving out the quotes. He replied he can swing! In today's terminologies he can't rock! Music never changes you either can rock or swing or not you can't learn how to do it it's a feeling. I have a sore Jack Jones playing luck be a Lady tonight in the local clubs where we fell asleep. Then coincidentally I saw him seeing it in Carnegie Hall where he did it to the arrangement as a tribute to Frank Sinatra. Instead of putting you to sleep Nelson Riddle probably the greatest composer Director or whatever it's called of all time made Frank Sinatra into a star! Plus Sinatra had charisma and charm in and on and on. When Jack Jones saying it to Nelson Riddle it was the best tradition and history demand who put you to sleep got a 10 minute nonstop standing ovation! Now did he learn from that? Nope! Back to lullabies sad story. Anyway I'm sorry for this long post I hope our teacher here will look at it. But if you want to be in for a great shock study Stewart Copeland from the police he's all over the place what you can learn from him his incident he can do anything nobody Ridge does his opening statement he has a big ego which a lot of drummers of musicians have in some cases it's insulting in his case you just go OK yes sir! Can't argue with a talent! You're in for a shock when you study this guy famous for being a rock drummer. Surprise! Love ya never quit!
Hi Reuben, Thank you for posting this well thought out, very detailed explanation of the Push-Pull technique. I am inspired to practice! My favorite for the right hand is the Classic Push Pull (German) because I want the speed & control for ride cymbal patterns. My favorite for the left hand is the Traditional Grip Push Pull. Thank you again!
definitely, Classic Push Pull (German) ¡¡ Thanks for your input. I love your sound. You have earned a fan, greetings from Buenos Aires City, Argentina.
I can't believe it's been four years since I first saw the first push pull video from Spyker. I'm grateful for gifts of flavor and techniques Reuben, thank you!
Johnny Rabb was the first person I ever saw using that "gravity blast" about 25 years ago. He has a book about using it for jungle & break beats. He was a Roland and DW clinician, too.
I love this video so much I give it its on tab in my PC, and stay there until I somehow get it down. Thank you very much. I am 68 and in the process of regain my traditional grip back after 50 years of abandoning it. I am very happy and excited same time upon seeing your video. I have 1 question: How long did it take you to master those techniques?
This is amazing. With the German grip push-pull, are you "pulling back" into any particular fingers over others, to get a smooth transition into the next push?
They all work together, index acts as more of a guide and the middle finger and thumb are the fulcrum. I’d say the most important part to pay attention to are the middle and thumb. You can do this technique with just those two.
Hi Reuben! Amazing vid! Very helpful! I've got a question: Ramon montagner is doing a lot of accenting in his push/pull. On the up strokes as well as on the downstrokes. Is there a way to adapt this to traditional? Maybe something like doing the soft notes with regular push pull and then "swivel" the accents?
мизинец обязательно должен участвовать в подхвате на 2:28? я восхищен твоим мастерством, я еще не видел кто бы так владел этим на таких больших скоростях
I didn’t use any books to develop this. You can use a lot of exercises that people use for developing finger control. Focusing on one hand for 4 bars then the other. You can increase or decrease the number of bars and then you can practice it with both hands as a single stroke roll.
Man you're great at this! I have a question. With german grip, are you using your fingers to push the stick on the upstroke, or do the fingers just move with the stick as you move your wrist back up? I've been doing this technique for some years, and with my right hand can sometimes get to 240-260bpm range, but you're taking it to the next level and I can't imagine how I could go any faster with the way I'm doing it right now, which is by pushing with the fingers on the upstroke. Cheers!
For some reason, I can do the push pull technique a lot faster with my right hand (in German grip) than my left, even though I'm left-handed. I play matched and traditional (in the left hand - I play right-handed drum set), in fact I'd say my trad grip is better overall, but I can't do the first two trad grip techniques at all. I think not angling the snare the way you do is a hindrance as well. Drop bounce seems to be the most doable for me, because I use my thumb instead of index/middle fingers for finger bounce technique, but it's still very early days.
Great job Reuben! Your hands are excellent! I discovered flattening out the push/pull later in life. My form is pretty good from learning it for double strokes and ride cymbal technique, my speed , not so good. Plus, I don't play things that require it to be all that fast if that makes sense. Anyway, thanks again, I just subscribed.
Seen your video where you did this with a pair of sunglasses. Everytime I would watch it I'd spend hours trying to get it and couldn't get it to flow....here we go again...
@@Koropokel Just about, but there have been seasons with less practice and then some where I really focus in things to improve. I don’t have a perfect practice schedule by any stretch.
Fantastic display of skill and control Rueben! I am fairly new to drumming and taking in as much i can. I got alot out of the first and second techniques and will be trying them along with this video at hand! I have not tried the traditional handgrip but am inspired now to give it a go, after watching you. I always believed it may not sit well with me but now i have a new outlook on that. Also this may sound like a noob question... the position of your snare, is this how you would practice? or for ease of viewing for video for the camera? Please excuse my amateurness :P
Me to brother, me too. I work on it every time I sit down to practice, but I seem to have hit my limit and it’s not useful in my playing. With chops stuff like this your mileage will vary.
Is thete any alternative to this? I find it hard to play punk songs because my arms eventually get so tired from blast beats and other variations. I need a technique to get speed with 1 hand @randydoak6638
Yup. That's why it seems I can't get it, when when I do it in the tempos I want to it just feels like the technique I've used for 25-ish years. And I'm thinking I can't get it because of my physical health issues capping my speed & stamina @@vincentkingsdale8334
Its not one of those things that you can really start slow and speed up imo, your right hand is basically twitching and when you first "get it" it happens by accident. You have to stay extremely relaxed, its not a finger strength thing
I dont understand how to do it in french grip with thumb. I can play about 240 with american grip and wrist mainly and i learned it pretty quickly but i want to get faster. Can someone explain how to push with your thumb and how to train it?
i've been playing drums for decades of years, and i've been trying for 15 years to learn these one-hand sticking techniques; i'm losing hope that i will ever get even one of them. it's heartbreaking. there's so much i can't do because i lack the ability to play this stuff properly.
Same idea. If you have large hands 2b should be the same thing. I can so rhe same stuff with 7a up to 2b. Also, it doesn't hurt to use multiple size sticks. It's like a toolbox. Small tools for finesse and big tools for more power.
Interview some years ago on the Carson/Tonight Show ... talking about Ed Shaunessy's "whip-cream roll" technique. Buddy Rich, I think, had mentioned it separately sometime also.
Which one was your favourite?
Definitely the german grip push pull !
Thanks for your insights.
@@rnm723 yep. Seems the most useful. Thanks Reuben!👊🏽
Awesome!
🤘
right hand : german grip push pull
left hand : drop bounce
I love the fact that you made it like “no big deal, just practice it enough and you’ll get it too”. Thank you for the tips ❤
Glad to see Han Bennink get some love!
One of the best lessons ive ever seen.
this is the best summary of all of the jojo mayer/ steve gadd/ buddy rich things ive seen over years. Thanks so much
Thanks! My pleasure. 🙂
I totally get Jojo and Buddy. But Gadd? Never seen Gadd do stuff like this. Gadd is amazing though.
How is it that I was just thinking about this technique, working on it, thinking about Reuben's videos and this pops up in the suggested?? Darn Kids! Get off the Lawn!😊
haven't seen/heard anyone else on yotube go to the extent you have with all these push&pull technique. you've honestly helped me so much
Stoked to hear that! 🙂🙏 Cheers
ruclips.net/video/chQg5_ZzPes/видео.html
@@ReubenSpyker awesome man!
Have you heard of this guy? ruclips.net/video/A6pFsLBwGvQ/видео.html
You are the first person to give this in detail, incredible tutorial. The left hand is technique is going to improve my playing
Reub!
Your ability to teach these various strokes is just what we needed. You don't "over complicate" the lesson, yet you give exactly what we NEED to know! Many Thanks!
~s.
Best video I've seen on push/pull technique.
Yup really enjoyed this.I also like the you can do this approach..excellent 👍
Thanks . And great you acknowledge Han . He just turned 82 years young . Still so creative. Btw there are clips of Han playing more conventional jazz on RUclips. Swings like a 😈.
Superbly clear explanations
Reuben, you have done an excellent job of explaining these techniques.
Wow Reuben, this is amazing. I'm turning sixty and refocusing my life to be a musician. Been doing these exercises several hours everyday for a month. So far I got the technique but I can't say I'm much faster using push pull however, I can hold my rolls and add accents significantly better and all around it has helped my playing significantly. Excited to see what these old bones can do. Thanks for the video.
Hi Steve! Can you give us an update after 10 months?
For me Steve arthritis is setting in the fingers at 62.
What we did for 40 years has affected our technique now with concerns for the fingers.
I ruined my hands sheetrocking, then AC technician for 12 years.
I am so envious of these individuals with uncanny sticking abilities
Age has nothing to do with us as a matter of fact if you were about to write estimate 16 years old you is the one in advantage being old for variety of reasons fortunately for us we grew upholding the standard grip and I played everything you could name except for one or two not gonna bother you with it now but if you want to study someone who is a genius Stewart Copeland from the police many videos and you're in for a shock everybody thinks he's a rock drummer he can do anything because he's old like me! I had a good of learning from Gym Chapin RIP his son Harry lived near me RIP Gym only taught talented students so he said well let me see what you can do so I sat at my side and I went around they set as fast as I could and the first thing he says wow man you "got great chops but you're working too hard "I had no idea what he meant he said let me show you. He said my drum set and taught me the Mouller technique which he was famous for. It helped me immediately! Then I don't want to go on and on and he invited me to sit in with his band in the Hamptons for the summer at some places that is probably gone to 100 years called the Yardbird or something. I was so flattered and unfortunately I had to support my family and I was starving artist so I said "Gym I am so honored but unfortunately I have to turn it down because I have to make a living" to be candid with you I didn't know why he was asking me because I didn't think I was a good knew I wasn't that good! But Jim was not looking at me for what I could play currently he saw what I was capable of playing later on! His prophecies came true as I progressed and Ruben Spyker is giving an excellent demo but the first thing he should've said is this is to flatter Buddy Rich RIP he is excellent but there are many ways to do this OK buddy rich dude with no effort he didn't have to go to the side he never twirled steak I never try to stick I can of course but I don't have to I can play but he's a hand with a variety of ways that differ from this. I hope before I drop dead to do various demonstration of how you can do everything with no effort the more calories you expend it works against you. I had the honor of meeting Buddy Rich's daughter; his manager Irving Kaye. who is in heaven and his grandson who couldn't stop playing the piano through the whole thing. This was a tribute I didn't know too buddy who died unfortunately recently and I attended to see Jack Jones who has the greatest voice of all time probably five octave but he never made it really like Frank Sinatra who was lucky if he could hit two. So I asked Irving why what is wrong with this guy he has the greatest voice in the world but nobody listens and when they do he puts people to sleep. I'm leaving out the quotes. He replied he can swing! In today's terminologies he can't rock! Music never changes you either can rock or swing or not you can't learn how to do it it's a feeling. I have a sore Jack Jones playing luck be a Lady tonight in the local clubs where we fell asleep. Then coincidentally I saw him seeing it in Carnegie Hall where he did it to the arrangement as a tribute to Frank Sinatra. Instead of putting you to sleep Nelson Riddle probably the greatest composer Director or whatever it's called of all time made Frank Sinatra into a star! Plus Sinatra had charisma and charm in and on and on. When Jack Jones saying it to Nelson Riddle it was the best tradition and history demand who put you to sleep got a 10 minute nonstop standing ovation! Now did he learn from that? Nope! Back to lullabies sad story. Anyway I'm sorry for this long post I hope our teacher here will look at it. But if you want to be in for a great shock study Stewart Copeland from the police he's all over the place what you can learn from him his incident he can do anything nobody Ridge does his opening statement he has a big ego which a lot of drummers of musicians have in some cases it's insulting in his case you just go OK yes sir! Can't argue with a talent! You're in for a shock when you study this guy famous for being a rock drummer. Surprise! Love ya never quit!
Han Bennink is absolutely one of my favourite players of all time. Thanks for the insight into his left hand technique.
Nice video, I'll have to experiment but the second one I can relate to.
Hi Reuben, Thank you for posting this well thought out, very detailed explanation of the Push-Pull technique. I am inspired to practice! My favorite for the right hand is the Classic Push Pull (German) because I want the speed & control for ride cymbal patterns. My favorite for the left hand is the Traditional Grip Push Pull. Thank you again!
Thanks mate, thorough and easy to grasp. Just what I was looking for to refresh my drumming!
Thks you . I've learnt the push and pull technique
Thanks, great explanation and technique
Reuben, Excellent instructional video. Time for me to get busy.
GREAT Demo & explanation.
definitely, Classic Push Pull (German) ¡¡ Thanks for your input. I love your sound. You have earned a fan, greetings from Buenos Aires City, Argentina.
Thank you for the kind words. 🙂🙏
Excellent information.Your a master of stick control.
He is one of my favorite Drummers, So dedicated & unique. Excellent taste in Drum Equipment, Gorgeous Drums !!!
This is absolutely peak level quality instructional video, thanks a lot.
I annoy enough people drumming on tables as it is !! This is going to take it to a new level 😁
Funny pic for the video. Thanks for the extreme detail
Tysm for the drop bounce on trad. I was so confused with all other versions and tutorials
Really good explanation and tuition. Well done. Thanks from everyone.
Johnny Rabb is awesome at this.
I can't believe it's been four years since I first saw the first push pull video from Spyker. I'm grateful for gifts of flavor and techniques Reuben, thank you!
Jojo Mayer is also a master at this. Excellent video.
You're really good at this sir.
Very nice, Sir.
Very cool, thank you
All I wanna say is Amazing !!! and thank you for sharing these !!!
Great lesson! Thank you!👍
My pleasure!
Awesome, congrats👏👍
Thank you!
Thank you for making this video! Awesome technique
thank you. I've learned something! appreciated
Thank you for this video.
One word : BRAVO.
You have released the genie with the Ramon Montagner technique. Super lesson!! Nice George Way drums. Well demonstrated!
Parabéns 👏👏👏👏 amigo mt boa sua informação na forma de boas técnicas 🤠 gostei muito abrs Luiz Carlos Brasil
Thanks very much. Helped a lot.
Excellent video and explanation man. I have subbed can't wait to see what other content you have. 🤙
Johnny Rabb was the first person I ever saw using that "gravity blast" about 25 years ago. He has a book about using it for jungle & break beats. He was a Roland and DW clinician, too.
Dude are a really good drummer. Nice single strokes and thanks for the information.
Thanks so much it helps alot❤️👍
Glad it was helpful!
Nice technique man.
Thanks 4 sharing. 🤘
Great stuff!!
this is a great video im disappointed it hasnt been seen more
Solid!
awesome thanks brother ! i like them all haha !
My pleasure!
Pretty awesome!! I can already do one handed press rolls. They come in handy...never.😊
Fleetwood Mac OVER MY HEAD .. tasty little ghost-note press-rolls
you are unreal ! and funny , wow I wish I had your talent
Yes can we
Very nice sir
Thank you so much
German grip @ 5:00
Thank you this was great.
I love this video so much I give it its on tab in my PC, and stay there until I somehow get it down. Thank you very much. I am 68 and in the process of regain my traditional grip back after 50 years of abandoning it. I am very happy and excited same time upon seeing your video. I have 1 question: How long did it take you to master those techniques?
Awesome video Reuben!
Thank you! 🙂
Always interesting how people take the techniques I want for blsstbeats, and use for other stuff
I own that same beautiful snare drum
Dude what was your practice routine to get this?
Awesome....
Thanks!
I wish I had a nickel for every youtube shmuck Ive seen that thinks he can teach me the push\pull and failed. So far you got me the closest, thanks!
skill issue
Wasn’t expecting that voice 😇
3:04 did you just play Bleed with one hand ???
This is amazing. With the German grip push-pull, are you "pulling back" into any particular fingers over others, to get a smooth transition into the next push?
They all work together, index acts as more of a guide and the middle finger and thumb are the fulcrum. I’d say the most important part to pay attention to are the middle and thumb. You can do this technique with just those two.
@@ReubenSpyker Thanks Reuben!
Plz also explain RICCARDO MERLINI method
great !!
Hi Reuben! Amazing vid! Very helpful!
I've got a question: Ramon montagner is doing a lot of accenting in his push/pull. On the up strokes as well as on the downstrokes. Is there a way to adapt this to traditional? Maybe something like doing the soft notes with regular push pull and then "swivel" the accents?
Thanks for watching! Yes you can totally do that. That’s actually exactly what I do in traditional for those kind of ideas. 🙂
great!
мизинец обязательно должен участвовать в подхвате на 2:28? я восхищен твоим мастерством, я еще не видел кто бы так владел этим на таких больших скоростях
Great video and explanation. Do u know a brook with exercises to put this techniques on practice?
I didn’t use any books to develop this. You can use a lot of exercises that people use for developing finger control. Focusing on one hand for 4 bars then the other. You can increase or decrease the number of bars and then you can practice it with both hands as a single stroke roll.
Man you're great at this! I have a question. With german grip, are you using your fingers to push the stick on the upstroke, or do the fingers just move with the stick as you move your wrist back up? I've been doing this technique for some years, and with my right hand can sometimes get to 240-260bpm range, but you're taking it to the next level and I can't imagine how I could go any faster with the way I'm doing it right now, which is by pushing with the fingers on the upstroke. Cheers!
You can use your fingers to help push and to pull. The wrist and fingers work together to make the motion happen,. Thanks for the kind words!
4:24 Explains German grip, but the subsequent demonstration looks exactly like French? I'm really struggling to distinguish between these techniques.
3:52 - You say firewood. I say John Bonham signature model.
For some reason, I can do the push pull technique a lot faster with my right hand (in German grip) than my left, even though I'm left-handed. I play matched and traditional (in the left hand - I play right-handed drum set), in fact I'd say my trad grip is better overall, but I can't do the first two trad grip techniques at all. I think not angling the snare the way you do is a hindrance as well. Drop bounce seems to be the most doable for me, because I use my thumb instead of index/middle fingers for finger bounce technique, but it's still very early days.
Would love to see you do a lesson on the uptempo, two-handed jump blues shuffles (e.g. "Prima shuffle", 235bpm).
3:12 Can someone please write the name oft the Push-Pull-Master named here? Thank you :)
Will technique 4 work on a high hat or only a snare with the Rim? Thanks great vid
Great job Reuben! Your hands are excellent! I discovered flattening out the push/pull later in life. My form is pretty good from learning it for double strokes and ride cymbal technique, my speed , not so good. Plus, I don't play things that require it to be all that fast if that makes sense. Anyway, thanks again, I just subscribed.
Thank you! Keep up the drumming. 🙂
Hi Rueben! How do you normally end the roll? The push or pull motion?
Great video btw!! Thanks!
You can practice both ways. When you want to play different groupings or patterns, you will end up ending with both. 🙂
Seen your video where you did this with a pair of sunglasses. Everytime I would watch it I'd spend hours trying to get it and couldn't get it to flow....here we go again...
This is the updated version. 😉 Enjoy the practice, let me know if you have any questions.
how long have you been practicing for this kind of speed??
I’ve been practicing push pull stuff for probably 7 years now. Each year I get a little more control and speed. 🙂
@@ReubenSpyker every day???
@@Koropokel Just about, but there have been seasons with less practice and then some where I really focus in things to improve. I don’t have a perfect practice schedule by any stretch.
Fantastic display of skill and control Rueben! I am fairly new to drumming and taking in as much i can. I got alot out of the first and second techniques and will be trying them along with this video at hand! I have not tried the traditional handgrip but am inspired now to give it a go, after watching you. I always believed it may not sit well with me but now i have a new outlook on that.
Also this may sound like a noob question... the position of your snare, is this how you would practice? or for ease of viewing for video for the camera? Please excuse my amateurness :P
I've been trying this for 20 years & Still can't get it.
Me to brother, me too. I work on it every time I sit down to practice, but I seem to have hit my limit and it’s not useful in my playing. With chops stuff like this your mileage will vary.
Is thete any alternative to this? I find it hard to play punk songs because my arms eventually get so tired from blast beats and other variations. I need a technique to get speed with 1 hand @randydoak6638
Seems as the faster he goes, the smaller and more subtle the movements are (compared to the initial explanation)
Yup. That's why it seems I can't get it, when when I do it in the tempos I want to it just feels like the technique I've used for 25-ish years. And I'm thinking I can't get it because of my physical health issues capping my speed & stamina @@vincentkingsdale8334
Its not one of those things that you can really start slow and speed up imo, your right hand is basically twitching and when you first "get it" it happens by accident. You have to stay extremely relaxed, its not a finger strength thing
Now that I think about it, I saw a vid of Carl Palmer doing just this in a snare demo.
How long did you practice these techniques before you really got good at
what snare drum is that? G way Maple solid shell?
I dont understand how to do it in french grip with thumb. I can play about 240 with american grip and wrist mainly and i learned it pretty quickly but i want to get faster. Can someone explain how to push with your thumb and how to train it?
i've been playing drums for decades of years, and i've been trying for 15 years to learn these one-hand sticking techniques; i'm losing hope that i will ever get even one of them. it's heartbreaking. there's so much i can't do because i lack the ability to play this stuff properly.
what happens if your thumbs don't look like that?
Exactly!!!! My thumb doesnt do this!!
This is amazing thanks Reuben - genuinely interested how this would go with heavier sticks (2b)..?
Same idea. If you have large hands 2b should be the same thing. I can so rhe same stuff with 7a up to 2b. Also, it doesn't hurt to use multiple size sticks. It's like a toolbox. Small tools for finesse and big tools for more power.
That's Wrist control or?
I know another Push Pull,which works,too,great.
i've seen people do a swivel action in match grip. this looks wild and would like to find a video breaking this down
Interview some years ago on the Carson/Tonight Show ... talking about Ed Shaunessy's "whip-cream roll" technique. Buddy Rich, I think, had mentioned it separately sometime also.