Видео

Sum: Original S&W uses creative directions to better demonstrate the characters' feelings (and does so on the cheap). Meanwhile, the remake wastes budget by adding more scenery and movement just because it can.

The vibe, music, emotion was diamond. How they put with the scene was so beautiful heart warming ❤. The new one is not for us i hope so who watched the old gold Samirai X..

I'm a big fan of shaman king, and the reboot is so painful to watch, especially of you read the manga before The adaptation is so bad, it's way too fast, they cute a lot of moments that add personnality to the characters and intensity to the scene And the fights scenes...... Oh boy.....

I've always said OG FMA is better imo. And this is coming from someone who read the manga weekly on release. I was thrilled when I heard there was going to be an adaptation because I really liked the story and art, but to me the original animated also held its place along side the manga even if it didn't follow it. But thats the thing IT DIDN'T NEED to. The overall message and philosophical themes etc seen throughout are very much different than the source material. It made me see life in a different light and made me question my reality and what I believe in. I was very disappointed with the animation style they choose. There were so many fights that were brilliantly drawn in the manga that the animation (again I was imagining animation that WOULD SURPASS the 2003 version.. brotherhood did not meet that standard for me.) All and all both series hold their own I wish people would recognize the OG a little bit more because it was so much more deeper and the overall message that it portrays with the brother's journey. It was the life lesson I didn't know I needed at the time. (I ended up here because I went down the nostalgia rabbit hole by seeing that the soundtracks were on spotify and I looked up my fav OP Undo from the series I wanted to see the intro and this video was recommended next XD) I love the breakdown of the series given here as many people simply did not see the bigger picture FMA was trying to show us through its brilliant story telling. Brotherhood is nice but for me OG FMA will always be my favorite. That fight with greed is unmatched. XD you make me wanna do a rewatch now lol

i prefer the newer version when it comes to the beginning part to be honest. the og felt so slow and clunky in the beginning and the humor to me didn't really hit as hard and though it did add more to shinobu and ataru together, i couldn't really enjoy it as much. The og for ataru's character played more into the humor then the serious moments which also kinda made me not enjoy it as much. (although i really dont like how the newer one skipped over some moments between them like the date episode in favor of other stories like asuka)

Fate/Stay Night would be at least an 8/10 if it was rewritten without Shirou, or at least make him a background love interest for Sakura and make Rin the actual main character

I don't remember seeing Holo's recurring nightmare in the remake. In the OG it really hit home with her fear of being alone and the uncertainty of their journey and her future. Also, they should have kept the long ears for Holo.

did you forget it was bakubitch who started this whole so called rivalry which has no reason for deku becoming a hero after all deku was on bakubitch's mind 24, 7 and even if bakubitch wasn't in the series deku would still have tried out for U.A.

First time viewer, I would slow down from 140 word a minites to maybe 100. Very hard to follow along and stopped at the 5 minute mark. It sounded like you had some good info though.

'03 will always be superior for me. The character development, pacing, tone, none of it was matched by brotherhood for me.

If I'm not wrong this takes place a while before the original anime's timeline, so for him to be less experienced makes sense in that regard

Even if the show runner wanted to skim over the start of FMA Brotherhood because 2003 exists, wouldn't hold up when '03 becomes lost media compared to Brotherhood regarding how easy it is to access to even WATCH. It's such a lame excuse, really... I've also always been a person that believes if the show doesn't capture you within at least 5 episodes, the argument of "it gets better 10+ episodes in" doesn't make me want to sludge through to get to that point. First impression is VERY important, and Brotherhood failed extremely for that. Plus plus, rushing through a series as they did, made me not enjoy or want to enjoy the cast. =/ Which sucked, 'cause I loved '03's cast, especially Ed.

the remake feels wrong

6:30 ash and serena are 15-16 in XyZ

The original anime takes so much liberties and today feels dated. If you read the manga carefully you'll enjoy the new adaptation more.

i just hate his design, WTF, LOOK HOW THEY BUCHERED VASH, WHERES THE SPIKE, WHERES THE WASTELAND LOOK JACKET???

The manga is the reason for me being unsettled with the nina reveal. Theres something different about reading through, letting the dialogue stand out.

That scene with Envy is made worse when you realize that Mustang was about to bring some sweet flaming justice on it azz, and then everyone else shows up and starts chiding Mustang for essentially "being too angry". The show expects you to have sympathy for the monster instead of wanting to destroy the monster for its unrepentant evil. Some effed up morality there.

Watching FMA:B practically *speedrun* the story made me realize, it's okay to have SOME filler.

Found this video after googling "spice and wolf is confusing" after 6 episodes and me still completely lost on most of the economic stuff. I like Holo enough that I'm trying to stick with it for now, but it's definitely not my normal anime fare for sure. Anyway this video was really well done and I'll definitely be checking out more of your content in the future!

Ed’s final transmutation is just… really beautiful. He claps his hands, and places his hands over his chest, and literally transmutes himself. It’s honestly so poetic.

it just sounds like they ruined it completely altering the story and I have no problem with the animation with that said I think the classic was way better like why couldn't they keep his hair and glasses the same and the uniform but that's not as annoying as everything else i rather would of liked to see a continuation of the story rather then something I've already seen for the most part

The experience of Brotherhood pales in comparison to comparison to the experience if you have watched ‘03 prior. ‘03 rips your heat out while Brotherhood mends it back in the best tandem.

I can’t believe how badly I’m waiting for season 2.

I was pissed as a kid when XY was replaced with SM on Netflix.

Can we also talk about the music 😭😭😭😭

I don't like it too😭😭I watched it when I was younger, didn't have the feeling so I guess I'll look for the old one

I don't like it too😭😭I watched it when I was younger, didn't have the feeling so I guess I'll look for the old one

Serena best pokegirl

Conclusion: old is gold

After watching the first season of the remake, I highly disagree. The Oniwabanshu and Saito Hajime fights are way better in the remake.

it really frustrates me that brotherhood didn’t do the liore arc justice, it’s a fantastic introduction to the brothers at their best and i hate that they just say what al and ed have gone through immediately, it’s so fucking dumb and it just hurts the series as a whole. 2003 didn’t even take that long to adapt these chapters, from what i remember anyway, so it honestly irks me so so much. also, they cut so many of the scenes set during the ishvalan war that flesh out the conflict it brung to all of the adult characters. brotherhood strips away some of the depth the adult characters had so much just to focus on ed and maybe, just maybe, sometimes al. brotherhood just lacks subtlety at times.

You really should watch it with with English subs. And no, not because the voice acting is better or anything (which it is but that's besides the point) but because the English dub removes ALL the fantastic and incredibly hype music and replace it with absolute trash. It entirely makes the difference in battles. The English dub doesn't want to pay royalties is the reason why it's not used.

As a relatively new fate/type moon fan (started like a year or two ago), I get where you're coming from. I got sucked with UBW and from there, I went on to continue my journey with Grand Order (the game so my first visual novel sorta), Apocrypha, a little bit of Extra, and Samurai Remnant. I haven't touched Zero and I don't really wanna bother to. Not cause I'm some VN purist or because I'm against darker themed stories. I've just been turned off by how people treat the rest of the franchise after watching it and, in some cases, downplaying Nasu's skill as a writer. Also I just find Kara no Kyokai and tsukihime remake (not fate, I know) to be way better than Zero. Probably should've just led with this, but it really does suck to hear that an ok adaptation of UBW has led to many fans not truly appreciating (completely fine if you don't like them) the characters and story.

Generic is probably the best way to describe this anime

Larson Tunnel

3 words. Anji the Destroyer!!!

Honestly, I haven't watched the OG and neither did I read the LN, but man do I love this anime! It pulled me in right at the first episode with that interesting intro which was, I just discovered, a foreshadow. I think the important thing here is to realize that this reboot hasn't been produced to satisfy the old fanbase, but rather pull in a new (younger) audience. You can't do that with an Inuyasha type animation style which was applied to the OG S&W. For me, at the very least, the studio did a perfect job of pulling me in and I am totally hooked now! I love the story, I love the style, the only thing I miss compared to some parts of the OG I've seen is more emotion and wittiness, but alas, can't have your cake and eat it too. I hope the foreshadow was meant as a hint that they are intending on animating the whole story rather than volumes 1, 2, 3 and 4, because there would literally be no point to this reboot otherwise. So I am quite confident we will see more of the source adapted as time goes on, but in how long, I can't say, but I hope it will be before I get married and have kids and won't have time anymore...

about that'a All Might's quirk what he said at 13:44 is wrong cause that's Yoichi's quirk that's been past in generations to defeat AFO. Nothing of that it was All Might's quirk

Fun fact [spolier for season 7] The moment mirio tell tomura shigiraki that he has no friends got me thinking like this if mirio got one for all, Gentle criminal: [tells his story of his broken dream] Mirio: I bet you are a loser!! [beats up gentle criminal with no reform] Lady nagant: [tells her story of corruption of HPSC] Mirio: Take this old hag!!! [beats up lady nagant with no reform] mirio with one for all vs Shigiraki be like Tomura: [begins his speech on heros and villains and failing of society from season 6] mirio: Oh yeah!!! Screw you for beating up my friends [mirio kills tomura with no hesitation] Ending: Hero society will remain terrible and the status quo is still set.

1:14 Naruto isn’t the chosen one though why do people keep getting this wrong? 9:19 also you’re missing the point of Tanjiro’s character other than that I can agree with you

Thank you so much for making this video

Well said. 👍

The reboot is boring and ugly to look at. Both could be subjective opinions but i stick to them. A manga or comic book isn't a movie nor is it fully animated or filmed show. Directly copying a book or manga doesn't translate to a good show. Moving images are something drastically different from a still image on a piece of paper.

i discover your channel via the fullmetal alchemist videos, you do a great job, your narration is calm and smooth and goes to the point, i wanna hear your thoughts on the animated movies this show has, keep the great work 🫡

So far i agree with you. I wonder Is the manga good? I don't wanna be dissapointed like i was with Shaman King source material, i've watched both animes and i wanna know if the original story holds up because the remake did a poorly job to present me the characters and plot.

I pretty much agree. The excessive exposition, bland perspective angles and the still frame poweropoints are part of the reason i haven't kept up with reboot. This kinda feels like a checklist of subplots vs. an actual npassion project. At this point I kinda just want to see how the climax of the Kyoto arc will be handled and to see the Jinchu arc animated. Even then I'm probably won't be impressed considering how underwhelming the clicps i've seen of the Saito fight was in comparision to it's 90's counterpart.

Shaman King was always mid. Takei could never surpass Watsuki

Btw we have reditt community if you wanna share your thoughts