@@tokyotourist It's flawed reasoning but makes a bit of sense for Production. They don't want to be a cause of him relapsing again. If his addiction issues are really gone then he's a lock to come back I think.
I’ve always wanted to see a season like this : Survivor : Idoled Vs Titled Vs Tribaled Titled - Players who have won the respect of fans or popular players Tribaled - Players screwed over from tribal changes as in swapping players Idoled - Players that were voted out because the use of an idol or holding their idol
Great concept, could also potentially have players that lost after drawing rocks. Would love to see someone like a Jessica Lewis from Millenials v Gen X play again, thought she was a solid player in a solid position that just got the unlucky draw.
I loved how you included all of the pictures of the winners when talking about them! As someone semi new (3 or so years,) it’s easier to recognize them by their face than just their names.
have you ever considered covering The Challenge? we’re starting to see a lot more Big Brother, Survivor, and The Amazing Race contestants on The Challenge and i think you’d definitely have a response from your subscribers! great video!
In all honesty, I rather have Tommy than Underwood. I want to see how his strategy would change and incorporate idols this time around. Plus, why did you do not consider Stephanie LaGrossa? It would be great to have her back.
Both work great, Tommy’s social game was great, and it’d be cool to see him play with not only returnees, but winners. Underwood is also a good choice, to see how he’d play without EoE in play, and see how he’d do. But I agree, I’d rather have Tommy back, even though they’re both awesome.
It would actually be interesting to see Chris play again given he was the most unpredictable winner on that season and to also see him have a better personal arc than he did not having one for his entire season.
Hey @TheMeranianReview. Here are some casting video ideas if your running out: Survivor: Fallen Angels (A season of final jury members) Survivor: Best to never win (season of only players who have played multiple times but never won) Survivor: idoled out (A season of everyone who was blindsided by a idol play) Survivor: challenge beasts (a season of contestants who had the most immunity wins in their seasons) Survivor: just short (a season of players who were voted off right before the jury stage of the game) I hope you like these ideas!!
@@daltonflores72 Russel is certainly legendary, but idk if that makes him a "legend" (does that make sense lol). Like Russel is iconic but.... very very poor social game
Jenna said in her ew interview a few weeks ago that she would love to play again and that she hasn't ever been involved with duis, that was a rumour...
This is a pretty solid cast, the only problem is that I don’t think Tina would ever play again, because of her age, but other than that, this would be a fun season.
@@58twright Survivor is never going off the air and Tony isn't human so he will never die. Also, if he has only played 6 times by 2078 I would be very depressed. He better have won 6 times by then. I had to stop watching the video when he said he didn't want tony back.
I don’t think Danni is 100% out, production loved her coming into WAW and she wants to play again. Although after everything that happened Idk if they like her anymore ://
@@justinpascal8332 Danni is one of the ones that's REALLY attacked how she was edited on the show, as apparently (And this is according to like her, Adam, and I think Denise as well) her boot was nowhere near as bad as the show portrayed it. Basically Ben and Parvati completely threw her under the bus for the Natalie boot, and the old school alliance just completely ditched her. Add onto that that she very openly feuded with both Natalie and Parvati on the edge, two of productions favorites, and the fact that she's from a mostly forgotten season and had the smallest edit on WAW, she's very unlikely to come back
@@brianregan5933 production asked her to be on alot of other seasons. She surprisingly gott asked for game changers and would have made it, but she declined
@@justinpascal8332 That's true, but I think her relationship with them is pretty done. She always said she would only ever come back for an all winners season, and on that very season, she was a flop, and attacked survivor after it aired. I doubt they feel good about her anymore
@@brianregan5933 Odd of her to be bitter about her edit, yeah she was kind of sidelined as a presence on the season but it's not like they portrayed her negatively. They probably did her a favor by not showing her feuding with Natalie and Parvati, she would've most likely come out looking poorly if they'd shown it. Plus there's not much reason to show all too much of the edge as that's not the main storyline of the show, the people actually still competing in the game are. Just seems like unnecessary bitterness and burning bridges for no reason.
I would want them to be matched: Danni v. Stephanie Aras v. Cirie Yul v. Ozzy Parvati v. Amanda JT. v. Stephen Denise v. Malcolm Natalie v. Baylor Jeremy v. Spencer Michele v. Aubry Wendell v. Domeneck
I actually came up with a similar concept a while back. However, I paired each winner up one of the best players to win from their season (tribes are still divided Champions vs Challengers). Essentially, if the challengers want to win, they will have to defeat the person who beat them the first time. I tried to keep this somewhat realistic: -Wendell/Dominick -Tony/Spencer -Chris/Devens -Parvarti/Amanda -Sandra/Jerri -Sarah/Cirie -Jeremy/Kelley W. -Tyson/Ciera -Michelle/Tai -Jenna M./Rob C. Alternates Pairs: -Tina/Colby -Adam/David -Ben/Chrissy -Tommy/Lauren or Janet -Mike/Joe or Carolyn -Yul/Penner or Ozzy
@Jawson Courtney Yates? Todd can’t play again and I thought Jerri would be a better person to include in an effort to add another OG player to the cast. Do you mean John Cochran? He’s not allowed to play again (and even if he could he doesn’t want to)?
It would actually be interesting to see Chris play again given he was the most unpredictable winner on that season and to also see him have a better personal arc than he did not having one for his entire season.
I like the cast Here's a fun idea. Survivor Idoled Out vs Idoled Play. Bring back people who got idoled out and bring back the person who got them out. Could be fun to watch their reactions on the same tribe again. Would they bury the hatchet or try and get the other out. Or if you don't want that drama just have them start on opposite tribes.
Your challengers tribe is wild...No Rob C, no Stephen, No Ian, No Steph, No Terry, No Rupert, No Russell, none of the people that really get mentioned in "best to never win" discussions other than Amanda and Cirie. I think leaving out the first 11 seasons entirely was a mistake. We get Tai and Lauren and Coach??? Come on.
Both Chris would be PERFECT for this season in my opinion. Two of the most unique wins ever and both are apparently open to playing again (although I read somewhere on reddit he has done health problems now? IDK.)
@@58twright yeah, I just notice the typo. I meant "he has some health problems." But yeah he is apparently in the obese threshold now but no one really knows it could just be rumours as survivor fans love that stuff. Let's remember that there were also rumours at one point that Russell was gay which he later addressed as BS and responded to by indirectly calling them homophobes lol
Your winners are good but the contenders for me would be Guys: Lex, Hayden, Dom, Malcolm and Wardog (alternates Jay (MVGX), Dean, Russel Hantz, Fairplay, Coach, Jon Misch and Sean Rector) Girls: Chrissy, Cirie, Holly Hoffman, Lauren, and Andrea Alternates (cierra, Carolyn (but I think out of older women to get far into the game, there’s better players), Stephanie legrossa, Jenna Lewis and Danielle) I think it’s maybe a little more straight forward with he women because let’s face it Wentworth was abysmal in EOE and so was Aubrey so players that could be they get taken off the board because their draw is their gameplay and sadly that’s now kind of irrelevant . My winners are pretty similar but: From WAW: Adam (especially if Jay were to be casted), Sophie, Tyson, Natalie, and Denise (over Tina for that archetype) Non WAW players: Men- Earl, Mike and Tommy or Chris underwood depending on who has better availability although I’d rather say Fabio to make it a little more age balanced for the tribes or go Brian. I think either of those two would do extremely well in a comeback season due to how little people have seen them over the years. Women- Vecepia and Jenna Marasco
because of the new burst of popularity survivor has gotten from netflix, can you do a casting celebrity survivor with all the celebrities who might be interested in participating?
Spencer Bledsoe accepted an offer to come back for 40 before it was changed to Winners at War. And he said he will come back if the time is right and the theme permits. So he would Make my challengers tribe. For me: Champions: Tina Wesson, Vecepia Towery, Jenna Morasca, Aras Baskauskas, Earl Cole, Natalie White, Fabio Birza, Tyson Apostol , Mike Holloway, Michele Fitzgerald & Tommy Sheehan. Challengers: Rupert Boneham , Cirie Fields, Malcolm Freberg, Andrea Boehlke, Ozzy Lusth , Kelley Wentworth, Russell Hantz, Stephenie Lagrossa, Spencer Bledsoe, & Aubry Bracco.
jenna is done after qutting aras is done and was only brought back because of his brother natalie white? seriously? she's not even in the community, no one can reach her fabio, not well liked season and we dont need to see him play again aubry is done after EoE kelley w is done after EoE everything else i agree with, if you respond i'll give you my list
@@apecentury228 Jenna is on my list because she wasn’t on WaW, and even thought she quit, Probst has said he would still bring her back because he understood why she quit and didn’t make her feel bad like NaOnka & Purple Kelly. They did want Aras back for WaW, but he declined because he wasn’t willing to leave his family. Natalie White is also on my list because she wasn’t on WaW (as crazy as it sounds, only 4 female winners weren’t on WaW, those being Tina, Vecepia, Jenna, & Natalie W.). Fabio is probably the only other male winner they could bring back, as Richard Hatch, Brian Heidik, & Chris Daugherty are hated by production, Tom Westman isn’t in the greatest health, John Cochran doesn’t want to play again, Bob Crowley is too old to play survivor again, Todd Herzog’s alcoholism will keep him from playing, & JT Thomas seems to have soured on Survivor. And personally, I loved Fabio on Nicaragua. I hated Chase Rice & Sash Lenahan. Aubry & Kelley on my list because I personally believe they would play again, provided this season happens several years from now. So, who would your Champs vs Challengers cast consist of??
@@djspencer6498 good explanations, although some of them i don't see happening bc i try to be realistic. My list is.... Champions: Tony, Sarah, Michele, Sophie, Tyson, Tina, Vecepia, Todd, Earl, Mike Challengers: Cirie, Rupert, Russell, Amanda, Malcolm, Coach, Ciera, Andrea, Michalea, Tai Basically my legends cast which I think would be more likely to happen
@@apecentury228 I completely forgot about some members of your challengers tribe. I would definitely put Coach on mine if I had more room. I left Amanda off mine because I feel like you can’t have her without James Clement on a season (kind of like you have to have Colby Donaldson & Jerri Manthey on the same cast.) Ciera just missed my cut. I don’t see Tai as best to never win, because he had no chance at winning either Kaoh Rong or Game Changers. I also don’t see Michaela as a best to never win either.
@@djspencer6498 The female field for challengers was difficult. Tai did come in 3rd and 4th and is a really likable player that plays idols. I think you can have Amanda without James by including Cirie. Yeah for me Rupert> Spencer because of legacy. You want to do second chance 2 casting?
I would personally love to see Hannah or Jay from season 33 especially with Adam on the other tribe, I think it could make for great tv. Surprised you didn’t consider Jay
Fun idea, but I don’t think it will ever happen after WaW. It’s pretty lopsided to have a tribe where 50%+ of the players have already played together.
8:46 He’s one of only I believe 7 players to be pre-jury, on the jury, and a finalist (Colby, Tina, Boston Rob, J.T., Ethan, and Stephenie are the others)
The main reason Tina was cut for Winners at War was indeed her age. Production probably wouldn't have cut her if it wasn't health-related, since she did so well in Blood vs. Water. Quite regrettable that we probably won't see her again. If I recall correctly, Tom wasn't called because of Medical issues. Also, something interesting to note is that Spencer is apparently open again, I've heard that he said this during a social media QnA
winners vs runner ups vs fallen angels vs fan favorites tommy jeremy michele chris underwood sophie gavin angelina dean domenick chrissy malcolm kelley cirie cydney rodney rupert james jane lisa russell
I would love to see Mike H. again but I don't think that it's going to happen. Supposedly he has hurt his relationship with production. I don't see Amanda playing again either, but I do think that she would likely be invited for this hypothetical season. I am also not confident about Earl ever accepting an invitation again.
I want to defend amber getting back in the game: she's like 20 years older and a mom now and without rob there it would force her to use a different strategy. Idk if she would be picked off immediately or fly under the radar.
Will you rank the premieres/finales, cast best to never win (realistic and dream) and rank all the players from each of the seasons and do more of the season retrospectives?
I’m sorry but you can’t have the next allstar season like this with at least one of Kelley, Ciera, Aubry, even Andrea. Kelley wants to play again but not if it was too soon, similar to Aubry I think both will definitely be back for this. I also think a lot of the people that played on the Sequester minis are the most open to playing again and Kelley and Andrea were on there.
I heard that Spencer is most open after a long time to make a return after the EW Q&A about Survivor.....for a season like this, I could think of him being selected over Russell and even Rupert
game changers vs invisible players GC 1 Danni season 11 2 Trish season 28 3 Steph season 10 4 Cassandra season 14 5 Missy season 39 6 Chris season 38 7 Davie season 37 8 Dan season 30 9 Michael season 36 10 Alan season 35 IV 1 Kelly season 30 2 Roark season 35 3 Krysta season 22 4 Sierra season 18 5 Jaclyn season 29 6 Matt season 26 7 Dean season 39 8 Dave season 19 9 Ibrehem season 10 10 Erik season 15
Развлечения
Please do a ranking of all returnees ever (103 returnees). This would be an amazing video. LOve your work man :)
This is the best idea I’ve heard in a while.
Todd not being on WaW was a big mistake. His story would’ve been amazing too.
Im pretty sure he had some pretty big addiction issues and they didn’t think he was in a good enough place to come back
@@ringomarks1972 He’s been sober for a few years now. Also he has a solid support system now so i think that reasoning is flawed
@@tokyotourist It's flawed reasoning but makes a bit of sense for Production. They don't want to be a cause of him relapsing again. If his addiction issues are really gone then he's a lock to come back I think.
@@cjtrules1 they’re gone
@@tokyotourist Who is "they"?
Spencer wants to play again, he was called for season 40 and accepted it, before the theme was changed to winners at war
wait really was this confirmed do you know who else was called for 40 before it was winners
Lucas Lupinski I admit I didn’t get it from the most reliable source, but I got from the survivor wiki
Do u know what the theme of season 40 was gonna be before WaW
I think that Russell Hantz was also called for s40, untill the theme was changed.
Sehaj Singh there was no theme at that point
I’ve always wanted to see a season like this :
Survivor : Idoled Vs Titled Vs Tribaled
Titled - Players who have won the respect of fans or popular players
Tribaled - Players screwed over from tribal changes as in swapping players
Idoled - Players that were voted out because the use of an idol or holding their idol
Before people go “isn’t that second chance” well yeah second chance except 3 tribes start the game based on if they fit Titled, Tribaled and Idoled
Love this 🏝⬆️
Great concept, could also potentially have players that lost after drawing rocks. Would love to see someone like a Jessica Lewis from Millenials v Gen X play again, thought she was a solid player in a solid position that just got the unlucky draw.
I loved how you included all of the pictures of the winners when talking about them! As someone semi new (3 or so years,) it’s easier to recognize them by their face than just their names.
Yo, how do you not recognize every winner after 3 years?
Hayden Moss needs to be on this season for sure
I agree
I want Jay on a season like this from MilvGenX
Yes!! Jay is one of my favorite recent players
have you ever considered covering The Challenge? we’re starting to see a lot more Big Brother, Survivor, and The Amazing Race contestants on The Challenge and i think you’d definitely have a response from your subscribers! great video!
In all honesty, I rather have Tommy than Underwood. I want to see how his strategy would change and incorporate idols this time around. Plus, why did you do not consider Stephanie LaGrossa? It would be great to have her back.
Both work great, Tommy’s social game was great, and it’d be cool to see him play with not only returnees, but winners. Underwood is also a good choice, to see how he’d play without EoE in play, and see how he’d do. But I agree, I’d rather have Tommy back, even though they’re both awesome.
It would actually be interesting to see Chris play again given he was the most unpredictable winner on that season and to also see him have a better personal arc than he did not having one for his entire season.
I think both of them should be brought back
Hey @TheMeranianReview. Here are some casting video ideas if your running out:
Survivor: Fallen Angels (A season of final jury members)
Survivor: Best to never win (season of only players who have played multiple times but never won)
Survivor: idoled out (A season of everyone who was blindsided by a idol play)
Survivor: challenge beasts (a season of contestants who had the most immunity wins in their seasons)
Survivor: just short (a season of players who were voted off right before the jury stage of the game)
I hope you like these ideas!!
Lauren has also said that she would definitely play again on her Tiktok
If you can’t have Colby without Jerry then you can’t have Amanda without james
IM PERSONALLY OFFENDED THAT YOU DIDNT PUT DK CHILLIN ON THR CAST
Mmmm, Deans ok. Not great, kinda just is a vibe, isn’t such a dynamic player. I respect your opinion!
Dean's game was so centered around advantages, which sucks to say cuz he was my favorite player
You forgot Hayden Moss!!! The biggest lock in my eyes., besides Dom
Spencer said in an interview with EW that he said yes to production to play in 40 before it was WAW
Do you know the theme of 40 if it wasn’t WAW?
I heard both legends and champions vs contenders. Both I think Spencer Qualifies for.
@@daltonflores72 Eh Spencer is not a legend in my eyes. That boy rubs me the wrong way and I find him annoying. But that's just me !!!
I don’t know if you consider Russell a legend but in his own words Spencer is a legend
@@daltonflores72 Russel is certainly legendary, but idk if that makes him a "legend" (does that make sense lol). Like Russel is iconic but.... very very poor social game
Loved your video sir...
I think Jeremy, Tony, Kim, Yul, Sarah, Ethan, Rob & Parvati are all done with survivor after their run on WAW
Spencer does wanna play again... He was cast for 40 until it was changed to winners, as was Lex and Russell
I think Fairplay was in consideration too, he at least got a call
@@denistuohy2535 yes he was also called for 40. but russell was selected to be sandras rival over him
Russell was cast again?!
@@sethbryant5539 he was cast for 40 yes
Everyone that are mad they left out an integral character: Get rid of Tai
Me whose favorite player is Tai:😳🕶🤏
Jenna said in her ew interview a few weeks ago that she would love to play again and that she hasn't ever been involved with duis, that was a rumour...
This is a pretty solid cast, the only problem is that I don’t think Tina would ever play again, because of her age, but other than that, this would be a fun season.
If you're talking about Tina Wesson she said even if she's 80 she'd go back.
tina has said pretty recently she’s just waiting for the call
@@rileyzimmerman1049 oh, I didn’t know that. Thank you
If Amanda is the first boot, than it'll be worth watching.
@@kellydaunis that would be epic
How did you not even consider Hayden?
NO! You don't like Tony! He needs to come back for the 6th time in 2078 at the age of 103
I dont think Tony will even be alive then & I don’t think survivor will still be going then
@@58twright Survivor is never going off the air and Tony isn't human so he will never die. Also, if he has only played 6 times by 2078 I would be very depressed. He better have won 6 times by then. I had to stop watching the video when he said he didn't want tony back.
@@58twright r/woooosh
@@58twright I'm shocked ur not a little kid
I don’t think Danni is 100% out, production loved her coming into WAW and she wants to play again. Although after everything that happened Idk if they like her anymore ://
What happened
@@justinpascal8332 Danni is one of the ones that's REALLY attacked how she was edited on the show, as apparently (And this is according to like her, Adam, and I think Denise as well) her boot was nowhere near as bad as the show portrayed it. Basically Ben and Parvati completely threw her under the bus for the Natalie boot, and the old school alliance just completely ditched her.
Add onto that that she very openly feuded with both Natalie and Parvati on the edge, two of productions favorites, and the fact that she's from a mostly forgotten season and had the smallest edit on WAW, she's very unlikely to come back
@@brianregan5933 production asked her to be on alot of other seasons. She surprisingly gott asked for game changers and would have made it, but she declined
@@justinpascal8332 That's true, but I think her relationship with them is pretty done. She always said she would only ever come back for an all winners season, and on that very season, she was a flop, and attacked survivor after it aired. I doubt they feel good about her anymore
@@brianregan5933 Odd of her to be bitter about her edit, yeah she was kind of sidelined as a presence on the season but it's not like they portrayed her negatively. They probably did her a favor by not showing her feuding with Natalie and Parvati, she would've most likely come out looking poorly if they'd shown it. Plus there's not much reason to show all too much of the edge as that's not the main storyline of the show, the people actually still competing in the game are. Just seems like unnecessary bitterness and burning bridges for no reason.
I would want them to be matched:
Danni v. Stephanie
Aras v. Cirie
Yul v. Ozzy
Parvati v. Amanda
JT. v. Stephen
Denise v. Malcolm
Natalie v. Baylor
Jeremy v. Spencer
Michele v. Aubry
Wendell v. Domeneck
I don't ever want to see Amanda play again. 3 times was 3 too many.
I actually came up with a similar concept a while back. However, I paired each winner up one of the best players to win from their season (tribes are still divided Champions vs Challengers). Essentially, if the challengers want to win, they will have to defeat the person who beat them the first time. I tried to keep this somewhat realistic:
-Wendell/Dominick
-Tony/Spencer
-Chris/Devens
-Parvarti/Amanda
-Sandra/Jerri
-Sarah/Cirie
-Jeremy/Kelley W.
-Tyson/Ciera
-Michelle/Tai
-Jenna M./Rob C.
Alternates Pairs:
-Tina/Colby
-Adam/David
-Ben/Chrissy
-Tommy/Lauren or Janet
-Mike/Joe or Carolyn
-Yul/Penner or Ozzy
@Jawson Courtney Yates? Todd can’t play again and I thought Jerri would be a better person to include in an effort to add another OG player to the cast. Do you mean John Cochran? He’s not allowed to play again (and even if he could he doesn’t want to)?
It would actually be interesting to see Chris play again given he was the most unpredictable winner on that season and to also see him have a better personal arc than he did not having one for his entire season.
this man saying he has had enough of tony.
:o
you can never have enough tony
I like the cast
Here's a fun idea. Survivor Idoled Out vs Idoled Play. Bring back people who got idoled out and bring back the person who got them out. Could be fun to watch their reactions on the same tribe again. Would they bury the hatchet or try and get the other out. Or if you don't want that drama just have them start on opposite tribes.
Would Personally love to See Jeremy Back again too
i think Jeremy will come back in a legends season or another huge season like waw
@@xakdish4169 Jeremy is so cool me and him talk on Snapchat a lot
@@justinvanveenar2953 oh my god really? I love Jeremy. He is my favorite of all time.
@@xakdish4169 yeah I Literally have no clue how I found him on Snapchat
Good video yeah this should be a good season
When I read the title I thought it was people from MTVs the Challenge. I am dumb
I mean if we’re talking about a hypothetical perfect season of this, Russel and Ozzy would 100% have to be on it
Jerri and Wentworth for the challengers
Your challengers tribe is wild...No Rob C, no Stephen, No Ian, No Steph, No Terry, No Rupert, No Russell, none of the people that really get mentioned in "best to never win" discussions other than Amanda and Cirie. I think leaving out the first 11 seasons entirely was a mistake. We get Tai and Lauren and Coach??? Come on.
i mean tai and coach are locks tho, but yeah rupert should replace rick d
I'm convinced you never wanna talk about Brian ever
Production hates Brian so for a realistic cast it makes sense to just skip him
Julie from Vanatu on champions tribe since she won Jeff probst
But she lost him later
@@chuckjokic4557 still a win lol
Julie will never play again she can’t because she dated probst & has a lot of inside information
Yeah, this season doesn’t work without Russell, the actual best to never win
Both Chris would be PERFECT for this season in my opinion. Two of the most unique wins ever and both are apparently open to playing again (although I read somewhere on reddit he has done health problems now? IDK.)
I believe Chris Daugherty is very overweight now
@@58twright yeah, I just notice the typo. I meant "he has some health problems." But yeah he is apparently in the obese threshold now but no one really knows it could just be rumours as survivor fans love that stuff. Let's remember that there were also rumours at one point that Russell was gay which he later addressed as BS and responded to by indirectly calling them homophobes lol
I personally would like to see Tai and Chrissy on a Heroes vs Villains season.
Your winners are good but the contenders for me would be
Guys: Lex, Hayden, Dom, Malcolm and Wardog (alternates Jay (MVGX), Dean, Russel Hantz, Fairplay, Coach, Jon Misch and Sean Rector)
Girls: Chrissy, Cirie, Holly Hoffman, Lauren, and Andrea
Alternates (cierra, Carolyn (but I think out of older women to get far into the game, there’s better players), Stephanie legrossa, Jenna Lewis and Danielle)
I think it’s maybe a little more straight forward with he women because let’s face it Wentworth was abysmal in EOE and so was Aubrey so players that could be they get taken off the board because their draw is their gameplay and sadly that’s now kind of irrelevant .
My winners are pretty similar but:
From WAW: Adam (especially if Jay were to be casted), Sophie, Tyson, Natalie, and Denise (over Tina for that archetype)
Non WAW players:
Men- Earl, Mike and Tommy or Chris underwood depending on who has better availability although I’d rather say Fabio to make it a little more age balanced for the tribes or go Brian. I think either of those two would do extremely well in a comeback season due to how little people have seen them over the years.
Women- Vecepia and Jenna Marasco
David vs Goliath hands down Angelina! She was one of the best never to win!
Do dream champions vs Challengers
We need to see Tommy play again to see just how good he is
Janet over Lauren from S39
(Just my opinion, but great video! I love your casting videos!)
Lauren played a far better game but Janet is a much more compelling character. I'd be fine with either.
because of the new burst of popularity survivor has gotten from netflix, can you do a casting celebrity survivor with all the celebrities who might be interested in participating?
Spencer Bledsoe accepted an offer to come back for 40 before it was changed to Winners at War. And he said he will come back if the time is right and the theme permits. So he would Make my challengers tribe.
For me:
Champions:
Tina Wesson, Vecepia Towery, Jenna Morasca, Aras Baskauskas, Earl Cole, Natalie White, Fabio Birza, Tyson Apostol , Mike Holloway, Michele Fitzgerald & Tommy Sheehan.
Challengers: Rupert Boneham , Cirie Fields, Malcolm Freberg, Andrea Boehlke, Ozzy Lusth , Kelley Wentworth, Russell Hantz, Stephenie Lagrossa, Spencer Bledsoe, & Aubry Bracco.
jenna is done after qutting
aras is done and was only brought back because of his brother
natalie white? seriously? she's not even in the community, no one can reach her
fabio, not well liked season and we dont need to see him play again
aubry is done after EoE
kelley w is done after EoE
everything else i agree with, if you respond i'll give you my list
@@apecentury228 Jenna is on my list because she wasn’t on WaW, and even thought she quit, Probst has said he would still bring her back because he understood why she quit and didn’t make her feel bad like NaOnka & Purple Kelly.
They did want Aras back for WaW, but he declined because he wasn’t willing to leave his family.
Natalie White is also on my list because she wasn’t on WaW (as crazy as it sounds, only 4 female winners weren’t on WaW, those being Tina, Vecepia, Jenna, & Natalie W.).
Fabio is probably the only other male winner they could bring back, as Richard Hatch, Brian Heidik, & Chris Daugherty are hated by production, Tom Westman isn’t in the greatest health, John Cochran doesn’t want to play again, Bob Crowley is too old to play survivor again, Todd Herzog’s alcoholism will keep him from playing, & JT Thomas seems to have soured on Survivor. And personally, I loved Fabio on Nicaragua. I hated Chase Rice & Sash Lenahan.
Aubry & Kelley on my list because I personally believe they would play again, provided this season happens several years from now.
So, who would your Champs vs Challengers cast consist of??
@@djspencer6498 good explanations, although some of them i don't see happening bc i try to be realistic. My list is....
Champions: Tony, Sarah, Michele, Sophie, Tyson, Tina, Vecepia, Todd, Earl, Mike
Challengers: Cirie, Rupert, Russell, Amanda, Malcolm, Coach, Ciera, Andrea, Michalea, Tai
Basically my legends cast which I think would be more likely to happen
@@apecentury228 I completely forgot about some members of your challengers tribe. I would definitely put Coach on mine if I had more room. I left Amanda off mine because I feel like you can’t have her without James Clement on a season (kind of like you have to have Colby Donaldson & Jerri Manthey on the same cast.) Ciera just missed my cut. I don’t see Tai as best to never win, because he had no chance at winning either Kaoh Rong or Game Changers. I also don’t see Michaela as a best to never win either.
@@djspencer6498 The female field for challengers was difficult. Tai did come in 3rd and 4th and is a really likable player that plays idols. I think you can have Amanda without James by including Cirie. Yeah for me Rupert> Spencer because of legacy.
You want to do second chance 2 casting?
Out of the winners that weren’t on winners at war I think earl is the only one that will play again tony will definitely play again
@@thesuperfan2457 he said he would definitely play again at the winners at war finale
I would personally love to see Hannah or Jay from season 33 especially with Adam on the other tribe, I think it could make for great tv. Surprised you didn’t consider Jay
Earl would most likely win if he returned
This was called Champions vs. Contenders in Australian Survivor
Contenders is newbies. Challengers is the best to never win
Russell I feel would be more of a champion then a contender
I know she isn't a winner but I did love seeing Jane kick ass at the challenges id like to see her do it again
does trish from cagayan not want to play again?
If u want to, think of this as if season 40 was champions vs challengers to make the champions tribe easier to cast
TINA!!
This was a fantastic idea!
I’m pretty sure Jenna has recently expressed interest in playing again so if they’d contact her, I’m sure she’d come back
My only gripe with this cast is the champions tribe seems a lot stronger physically (at least in tribe comps) but I do love the cast’
Fun idea, but I don’t think it will ever happen after WaW. It’s pretty lopsided to have a tribe where 50%+ of the players have already played together.
You should do a who would I vote for if the winner wasn’t there in the final 3 making it a final 2.
Lex was called for 40 and accepted before it was all winners
8:46 He’s one of only I believe 7 players to be pre-jury, on the jury, and a finalist (Colby, Tina, Boston Rob, J.T., Ethan, and Stephenie are the others)
A HVV vs others season would be great
Can you do survivor edge of extinction player rankings of that season
The main reason Tina was cut for Winners at War was indeed her age. Production probably wouldn't have cut her if it wasn't health-related, since she did so well in Blood vs. Water. Quite regrettable that we probably won't see her again. If I recall correctly, Tom wasn't called because of Medical issues.
Also, something interesting to note is that Spencer is apparently open again, I've heard that he said this during a social media QnA
Davie returning would be awesome
Natalie was supposed to be on Game Changers until she got a concussion
Russell is a lock dude. He was cast for 40 before it was changed to winners...
winners vs runner ups vs fallen angels vs fan favorites
tommy
jeremy
michele
chris underwood
sophie
gavin
angelina
dean
domenick
chrissy
malcolm
kelley
cirie
cydney
rodney
rupert
james
jane
lisa
russell
wtf is this theme lmao
18:25 Kind of surprised you didn’t consider Woo, given if he voted Tony out, he easily beats Kass
I would love to see Mike H. again but I don't think that it's going to happen. Supposedly he has hurt his relationship with production.
I don't see Amanda playing again either, but I do think that she would likely be invited for this hypothetical season. I am also not confident about Earl ever accepting an invitation again.
How has he hurt his relationship with production?
I thought Earl wanted to come back for waw, but he had a small baby at home, so he refused. :/
@@divdesmitpieci6767 On RHAP he said if they ever shot a season in the fall or winter again that he would be way more likely to do it.
I would love to see Amanda play again idk for sure if she wants too but I think she’ll definitely be asked
If Vecepia wasn’t called for Winners at War, why would production want to put her on any other season?
I want to defend amber getting back in the game: she's like 20 years older and a mom now and without rob there it would force her to use a different strategy. Idk if she would be picked off immediately or fly under the radar.
Will you rank the premieres/finales, cast best to never win (realistic and dream) and rank all the players from each of the seasons and do more of the season retrospectives?
do a casting video for Winners at War Survivor vs Big Brother
Why aren’t you a big tony fan? Personally, I love his gameplay and root for him every season he’s on!
You didn’t consider Rupert as a challenger?
I think Rupert's had his chance, he's come back for All-Stars, Heroes vs. Villains and Blood vs. Water
Where's Yau Man??
15:32 She only got one vote for her in China, but Micronesia she only needed one more to force a tie
I feel like Parvati will only come back if there’s a legends season
You literally could’ve commented everything on one comment yet decided to make 20 different comments lmao.
@@survivor8518 If it was all one comment, it would be all over the place. Some RUclipsrs like reading comments
Apparently Jeff has stated he’s open to a Russell return if the season calls for it?
Ok but im offended that taj is not in there
14:24 Maybe not on this cast, but Terry deserves a third chance
Seems like we should just do a champions season, too many good players left out
I don’t feel that production would be compelled to have Mike or V back. Maybe V at this point but I think Ben is more likely to play again than Mike
no ben is done after giving his spot up....also his story was concluded
But production loves Ben so we'll see
I want to see JT Back.
lex over tai and then i would be really happy with this
I love Tai so I wouldn't him back. Tho Lex also should come back too.
you can rank players each season.
Russell Hantz or Swan? I would like both to come back
@@thesuperfan2457 I liked swan Because he was a leader
@@thesuperfan2457 Ight
why didn’t u go in depth about natalie white : (
4:52 They probably figured he would decline
jeff wants carolyn back. carolyn very openly has said she wants to come back. what’s the hold up????
@@thesuperfan2457 i’m just saying for a future returner season
I’m sorry but you can’t have the next allstar season like this with at least one of Kelley, Ciera, Aubry, even Andrea. Kelley wants to play again but not if it was too soon, similar to Aubry I think both will definitely be back for this. I also think a lot of the people that played on the Sequester minis are the most open to playing again and Kelley and Andrea were on there.
I heard that Spencer is most open after a long time to make a return after the EW Q&A about Survivor.....for a season like this, I could think of him being selected over Russell and even Rupert
I love this guys casting videos
3:21 And still the only one
Can you make a big brother runner up ranking
My Final 6
Earl, Vecepia, Carolyn, Chrissy, Dominic, Lauren
Y’all decide who wins
Earl
Carolyn
Dom
Dom
You’re going to put Adam over Todd?
Todd is sadly never playing again due to his alcoholism
Don't need Tony? We all need more Tony
game changers vs invisible players
GC
1 Danni season 11
2 Trish season 28
3 Steph season 10
4 Cassandra season 14
5 Missy season 39
6 Chris season 38
7 Davie season 37
8 Dan season 30
9 Michael season 36
10 Alan season 35
IV
1 Kelly season 30
2 Roark season 35
3 Krysta season 22
4 Sierra season 18
5 Jaclyn season 29
6 Matt season 26
7 Dean season 39
8 Dave season 19
9 Ibrehem season 10
10 Erik season 15
Cassandra is not a game changer. She was invisible. Erik was on season 16 and he certainly wasn't invisible.