Dream Casting Survivor: Legends

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 сен 2020
  • In this video, I talk about who would be on my dream cast of Survivor: Legends. I do plan on continuing on with this season for other season themes I have already done in the past.
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 252

  • @abbeyt5533
    @abbeyt5533 3 года назад +69

    the way that Courtney Yates was slept on here is appalling sjdhfhdhd

    • @harpefix9822
      @harpefix9822 3 года назад

      period

    • @dionagrieche2304
      @dionagrieche2304 3 года назад +7

      The fact that Courtney win season 15 China fan favorites poll by fans is absolutely make her a legend LOL

    • @sideeswipe
      @sideeswipe 3 года назад

      the abbey show I love Courtney but she probably doesn’t cut it on a legends season even if I think that’d be absolutely amazing and cause on a legends season the cast would be filled to the brim with HVV players and she isn’t as big as Sandra, Cirie, Jerri and Parv

    • @dionagrieche2304
      @dionagrieche2304 3 года назад +3

      @@sideeswipe lets be real, so many old school woman who are legends will not back. I think Courtney stand a good chance to comeback, because no way Survivor will put so many new school player to legends season.

  • @lukebrennan3378
    @lukebrennan3378 3 года назад +92

    I’m boycotting this video. Chicken “damn” Morris is a legend.

  • @travherod9943
    @travherod9943 3 года назад +70

    It would be interesting to see a Legends Non Winners cast.

    • @TheMurrmursonbottle
      @TheMurrmursonbottle 3 года назад +10

      Amanda, Russell, Wentworth, Fairplay, and Aubry would be guaranteed spots

    • @travherod9943
      @travherod9943 3 года назад +11

      @@TheMurrmursonbottle Cirie, Colby, Jerri, Rob C, Rupert, Ciera, & Malcolm as well.

    • @spencernewman7041
      @spencernewman7041 3 года назад +6

      Honestly the only legends season I would want to see become a real season. There are enough non-winning legends to make a great cast of people who deserve another shot and at the same time it guarantees a non-winning legend a win.

    • @baileylynn5562
      @baileylynn5562 2 года назад +1

      @@travherod9943 and Coach

    • @nozzy8653
      @nozzy8653 2 года назад +1

      @@baileylynn5562 and Ozzy

  • @patrickcallahan9206
    @patrickcallahan9206 3 года назад +43

    i feel like tyson is more known in the survivor community then yul. he’s just played more times and is more iconic then yul.

  • @JMaster9877
    @JMaster9877 3 года назад +58

    I'd take out Yul and put Rupert. In a dream cast, love him or hate him, he's one of the most iconic players of all time

    • @willtriplett4128
      @willtriplett4128 3 года назад +1

      Yeah

    • @BC-fx2yt
      @BC-fx2yt 3 года назад

      He doesn’t really need to play again anyway imo

    • @JMaster9877
      @JMaster9877 3 года назад +2

      @@BC-fx2yt not really, but this is a dream cast.

    • @MrAgentTurner
      @MrAgentTurner Год назад +1

      Fully agreed. It's a crime punishable by death to not include Rupert in this type of season

  • @baki7337
    @baki7337 3 года назад +55

    When you got to Russel it just accrued to me that such a big chunk of the cast is from H v V I take for granted how godly casting was that season

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +3

      Occurred*

    • @MrAgentTurner
      @MrAgentTurner Год назад

      Few take it for granted, it was a better cast than WaW!

  • @Liam-gu8gs
    @Liam-gu8gs 3 года назад +18

    This is basically winners at war plus heroes vs villains apart from Johnny, Kathy, Wentworth, Hatch, Rob C and Tina

    • @MrAgentTurner
      @MrAgentTurner Год назад +3

      Hatch and Tina should've been on both those seasons anyway

  • @politicaelectonia6276
    @politicaelectonia6276 3 года назад +30

    Andrea or Steph should replace Sophie

  • @thepanpatriotsfan9295
    @thepanpatriotsfan9295 3 года назад +45

    I would put on Keith Nale. He’s too iconic

    • @techngamin
      @techngamin 3 года назад +6

      He may be iconic and hilarious, but he's far from legendary gameplay wise

    • @JayJayKz
      @JayJayKz 3 года назад +1

      @@techngamin I still tho k Keith is a good survivor I mean he went toe to toe with Joe alot in the immunity challenge and has made it T4 and T5 I mean he had a little bit of game play, and think he's worthy

    • @therealbensoule652
      @therealbensoule652 2 месяца назад

      @@techngaminwrong. stick to the plan bozo

  • @owengette8089
    @owengette8089 3 года назад +39

    Mind if I put a video idea out there?
    -Switching the winners with the fallen angels in every final tribal (winners are now fallen angels, fallen angels are with OG runner ups) and you say how you think the votes would be distributed. It’s a long one but such an interesting concept.

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +1

      Thats Smarrrrrrt

    • @benschroeder8773
      @benschroeder8773 3 года назад

      I am also very interested in this

    • @ethancostellostudent1698
      @ethancostellostudent1698 3 года назад

      Owen Gette yessss

    • @willtriplett4128
      @willtriplett4128 3 года назад

      That’s a cool idea

    • @bronteprestedge8195
      @bronteprestedge8195 3 года назад +1

      also another video where they switch the fallen angel with the runners up to and with the same style plus who he thinks played the better game between the two would be cool aswell as that !

  • @Codey0813
    @Codey0813 3 года назад +11

    My Cast would be:
    Males
    Richard Hatch, Colby Donaldson, ‘Boston Rob’ Mariano, Rupert Boneham, Jonny Fairplay, Rob Cesternino, Russell Hantz, Malcolm Freberg, Jeremy Collins, Tony Vlachos
    Females
    Tina Wesson, Jerri Manthey, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Cirie Fields, Parvati Shallow, Amanda Kimmel, Sophie Clarke, Sarah Lacina, Natalie Anderson, Kelley Wentworth

    • @taylorperry2541
      @taylorperry2541 3 года назад +2

      not ozzy!!!????

    • @Codey0813
      @Codey0813 3 года назад +2

      Taylor Perry it was very difficult leaving off Ozzy, as he has always one of my favorites. Overall, I ended up going with Malcolm over Ozzy, as I feel when it comes to them, they share a lot of similarities of course, but I feel Malcolm is the better overall player. But I really don’t think you could go wrong either way.

  • @ericburchill5717
    @ericburchill5717 3 года назад +5

    Literally the whole video I was so anxious about if you would put Natalie, Jeremy, and Kelly thank god you did

  • @gabihunter1749
    @gabihunter1749 3 года назад +8

    I like seeing your dream cast and can't wait for fallen angel rankings and would love to see you rank the players from every season and do more with US Survivor since I don't and can't watch international Survivor

  • @thelittlefish559
    @thelittlefish559 3 года назад +10

    I believe that Ozzy is way more of a legend than Jeremy, plus you could possibly have the dynamic of him and Amanda, and him and Coach, and him and Parvati, and him and Yul

    • @thelittlefish559
      @thelittlefish559 3 года назад +5

      And him and Sophie, and him and Cirie. I mean he has ties to most of the people in this cast, and it would be interesting to see how some of those relationships would turn out, out there

    • @lukefisher3417
      @lukefisher3417 3 года назад +3

      Plus you would have two of the biggest challenge beasts of all time, in Colby and Ozzy, in the same season

    • @amirulraziq
      @amirulraziq 3 года назад +2

      @@lukefisher3417 Except colby really sucked in HvV honestly. I was so infuriated seeing the amount of respect he gave the game. Can understand he did well in S2 though

    • @lukefisher3417
      @lukefisher3417 3 года назад +2

      @@amirulraziq My point there was that both of them are tied for most immunity wins in a single season, although I don’t know how good at challenges Colby is any more, since seeing him on HvV. So I definitely see your point

  • @salazarslytherin8580
    @salazarslytherin8580 3 года назад +2

    This would end up like winners at war but this time the old school vote out new school

  • @andrewthomas8687
    @andrewthomas8687 3 года назад +3

    I love that 9 of the players are from hvv

  • @Nicxon_02
    @Nicxon_02 3 года назад +7

    This is a great cast, but IMO you can't have a legends season without rupert. Dude is literally iconic

    • @oscaralvarenga4391
      @oscaralvarenga4391 3 года назад +1

      Rupert is an amazing no brainer as a legend. The first winner of the Fan Favorite Award!

  • @jesmccoy26
    @jesmccoy26 3 года назад +7

    Imagine if they really made a legends season legendary by have a cast of like 30 legends since there's so many people to choose from 😳

  • @aziz7461
    @aziz7461 3 года назад +9

    Lol imagine a Tony-Russell-Fairplay-Richard alliance

  • @kellydaunis
    @kellydaunis 3 года назад +1

    This is my Survivor: Legends Dream Cast
    Colby Donaldson
    Lex Van den Berghe
    Rob Cesternino
    Rob Mariano
    Jeremy Collins
    Tony Vlachos
    Rupert Boneham
    Tyson Apostol
    Russell Hantz
    Malcolm Freberg
    Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
    Cirie Fields
    Parvati Shallow
    Kelley Wentworth
    Tina Wesson
    Stephenie LaGrossa
    Amanda Kimmel
    Andrea Boehlke
    Sarah Lacina
    Jerri Manthey

  • @dionagrieche2304
    @dionagrieche2304 3 года назад +5

    My SURVIVOR LEGEND Cast :
    1. Colby
    2. Jerri
    3. Boston Rob
    4. Rupert
    5. Sandra
    6. Eliza
    7. Stephenie
    8. Cirie
    9. Ozzy
    10. Parvati
    11. James
    12. Amanda
    13. Coach
    14. Tyson
    15. Russell
    16. Malcolm
    17. Tony
    18. Kelly W
    19. Aubry
    20. Michelle
    Honorable Mention :
    1. Tina
    2. Ethan
    3. Lex
    4. Big Tom
    5. Shi Ann
    6. Rob C
    7. Ami
    8. Tom
    9. Danielle
    10. Yul
    11. Yau Man
    12. Courtney
    13. Corinne
    14. JT
    15. Andrea
    16. Philip
    17. Cochran
    18. Kass
    19. Natalie A
    20. Tai
    21. Rick Devens
    22. Amber
    23. Ciera
    I make my dream cast very realistic, so i didnt put people who have problem with production in cast & honorable mention, also i dont want too many Old School player so i put 5 New School player

  • @chasewilcox
    @chasewilcox 3 года назад +5

    YESSSSS! I LOVE THIS!

  • @kwads1909
    @kwads1909 3 года назад +6

    hoping for survivor- alternate history! Consisting of players who we’re screwed over by twists, swaps or flips.

  • @owennicholson8914
    @owennicholson8914 3 года назад +4

    I think Russel will play again and I wish Amanda would play again

  • @ricardothompson3205
    @ricardothompson3205 3 года назад +4

    Your list is almost my dream list. Imagine a Alliance of the 3 san juan del.sur and Cirie. Wow. Strong final.4
    I know Natalie lives Cirie. They would probably be a great duo.

  • @ethanrandolph4104
    @ethanrandolph4104 3 года назад +15

    Change the name of this video to Survivor: Want to see play again. How is Sophie a legend to the public

  • @brycelipman3995
    @brycelipman3995 3 года назад +1

    you should make a video on what ur dream cast is just a cast you would love to see

  • @birks2180
    @birks2180 3 года назад +3

    Queen Amanda Kimmel

  • @chickenchicken9072
    @chickenchicken9072 3 года назад +9

    Anywho, the winner of Survivor Legends is Natalie White.

  • @mgray3374
    @mgray3374 3 года назад +2

    Richard (1,8)
    Rob m (4,8,20,22,”39”,40)
    Rob c (6,8)
    Earl (14)
    Yau-man (14,16)
    Tyson (18,20,27,40)
    Russell (19,20,22)
    Malcolm (25,26,34)
    Tony (28,34,40)
    Jeremy (29,31,40)
    Jerri (2,8,20)
    Sandra (7,20,34,”39”,40)
    Stephenie (10,11,20)
    Cirie (12,16,20,34)
    Parvati (13,16,20,40)
    Amanda (15,16,20)
    Kim (24,40)
    Sarah (28,34,40)
    Natalie (29,40)
    Michaela (33,34)

    • @joshyboy5660
      @joshyboy5660 3 года назад +2

      Jeremys season numbers add up to 100. This makes me very oddly happy

  • @djspencer6498
    @djspencer6498 3 года назад +1

    Here’s who I would put on my dream cast
    Men:
    Rob Mariano
    Tony Vlachos
    Russell Hantz
    Rupert Boneham
    Colby Donaldson
    Ozzy Lusth
    Tyson Apostol
    Coach Wade
    Richard Hatch
    Jeremy Collins
    Women
    Parvati Shallow
    Jerri Manthey
    Cirie Fields
    Andrea Boehlke
    Kim Spradlin
    Sandra Diaz-Twine
    Tina Wesson
    Danielle DiLorenzo
    Stephenie LaGrossa
    Sarah Lacina

  • @cjoh29n
    @cjoh29n 3 года назад +2

    You should cast a season for the last out before final tribal council. Like a “So close yet so far away”

  • @allmightyjeff9972
    @allmightyjeff9972 3 года назад +2

    Russell hantz said before s40 was going be all winners it was going be a legends and he was asked to play so him and production are in good terms

  • @EmmetAnderson
    @EmmetAnderson 3 года назад +8

    can you do a cast full of people on productions bad side? or just a run down of all the players who a return is warranted but production wouldn’t do it?

    • @aperson22222
      @aperson22222 3 года назад +1

      I don’t think you could get a whole season’s worth. It’s not that hard to avoid pissing off the powers that be; there are really only a few who both can’t help themselves and have a loud enough megaphone for the network to care.

  • @dylansanders1206
    @dylansanders1206 3 года назад +19

    My cast would be
    1. Richard Hatch
    2. Colby Donaldson
    3. Jerri Mattheny
    4. Rob Mariono
    5. Sandra Diaz Twine
    6. Rupert Boneham
    7. Johnny Fairplay
    8. Rob Cestenino
    9. Russel Hantz
    10. Tyson Apostol
    11. Coach "Wade"
    12. J.T
    13. Cirie Fields
    14. Amanda Kimmil
    15. James Clement
    16. Tony Vlanchos
    17. Parvati Shallow
    18. Ozzy Lusth
    19. Jonathen Penner
    20. Jeremy Collins
    P.s sorry if I misspelled a lot of these peoples names

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +1

      Lol vlanchos

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад

      It recommends blanches

    • @savageguineapig5857
      @savageguineapig5857 3 года назад +1

      Jerri Manthey, Rob Mariano, Russell Hantz, Amanda Kimmel, Tony Vlachos, Johnathan Penner
      Names are hard I understand

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +2

      Penner over Parvati? You’re crazy

    • @savageguineapig5857
      @savageguineapig5857 3 года назад +1

      OriSwag2010 parv is on there

  • @AubreyMichelle09
    @AubreyMichelle09 3 года назад +9

    I would love to see Sierra from Tocantins again. She would be a great underdog story but maybe fits a second chance season more. Also Jay from Millennials vs Gen X.

    • @BC-fx2yt
      @BC-fx2yt 3 года назад +2

      Neither of them are even close to being legends

  • @Nate9-9
    @Nate9-9 3 года назад +2

    No mention of Denise from Philippines?
    Also I would replace Coach with Tyson or Todd.
    I would really like to see Penner again, but with what he is going through in his personal life I don't see him ever returning.

  • @joephelan6144
    @joephelan6144 3 года назад +1

    Could you make a cast of only people who have received purple edits?

  • @survivorguy92
    @survivorguy92 3 года назад +1

    This would be my favorite cast and probably favorite season of all time if it were to actually happen!

  • @charlieradant
    @charlieradant 3 года назад +4

    I like making dream casta

  • @MrAgentTurner
    @MrAgentTurner Год назад +2

    You can't cut Rupert just because YOU don't think he can't keep up? Lol.
    Rupert is 1000% a lock for the ultimate Survivor Legends season.

  • @drewveflin2842
    @drewveflin2842 2 года назад

    THANK YOU FOR THE SOPHIE PICK

  • @expelgrizzly566
    @expelgrizzly566 3 года назад +9

    What the hell malcolm isnt on legends cast

  • @justinpascal8332
    @justinpascal8332 3 года назад +1

    Russell mentioned that he got called for season 40 before they changed the theme

  • @jessetorres8738
    @jessetorres8738 3 года назад +3

    I have a suggestion for a video: Your Top 10 Amazing Race Finalist Teams you would have preferred had won.

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +3

      Tyler and Corey DONE DONE AND DONE

    • @OriRozenthal
      @OriRozenthal 3 года назад +3

      Wait actually never mind compared to Colin and Kristie I would say they shouldn’t have won

    • @adamk9542
      @adamk9542 3 года назад +3

      Dustin & Kandice all the way

    • @kellydaunis
      @kellydaunis 3 года назад

      Jet & Cord.

  • @h_man7225
    @h_man7225 3 года назад +2

    YOU PUT JOHNNY FAIRPLAY ON AND NOT RUPERT :(

  • @JT-295
    @JT-295 3 года назад +2

    No joke I would actually pick Francesqua

    • @kellydaunis
      @kellydaunis 3 года назад +1

      Oh yes. The legend of getting voted off first.

  • @politicaelectonia6276
    @politicaelectonia6276 3 года назад

    Yusss!!

  • @geeknotgamer1985
    @geeknotgamer1985 3 года назад +1

    Personally, I think Adam earned his spot as a legend in WaW. Not the best run, but I think the podium move was such a big move, despite it failing, plus his MvGX game would warrant him a legendary status

  • @j_g9724
    @j_g9724 3 года назад +1

    I would love Yau-Man, but he is really old now. I don't think they would bring him back, and he would be first boot because of challenge strength, but hold up, actually, he would be good at puzzles. They would know not to let him make the merge.

  • @jacoblangguth5125
    @jacoblangguth5125 3 года назад +3

    Where’s Mary

  • @techngamin
    @techngamin 3 года назад +1

    My favorite players are
    Yau Man
    Stephen Fischback
    Christian Hubicki
    Spencer Bledsoe
    Tyson Apostol
    Adam Klein
    Jonathan Penner
    Rupert Boneham
    Yul Kwon
    Parvati Shallow
    Cirie Fields
    Amanda Kimmel
    Jerri Manthey
    Tina Wesson
    Kass McQuillen
    Ciera Eastin
    Stephanie LaGrossa
    Denise Stapley

  • @hello-nb2pu
    @hello-nb2pu 3 года назад +1

    You should do predictions or simulate these on brantsteele!

  • @yotruongvu3154
    @yotruongvu3154 3 года назад +1

    I would pay big bucks to see Yul play again

  • @glassestarzan8702
    @glassestarzan8702 3 года назад +1

    I feel like a legends season would be the season where they have the best international players play against the US legends. Rob Bentele, Werner, Jericho, Pia, Lisa, etc. are all players who I would love to see play against the US legends and could likely hold their own ground with no trouble.

    • @jameswardle2841
      @jameswardle2841 3 года назад

      YESSSSSSSSSSSSS. pls pls pls make this happen somewhere out there!

  • @jacksullivan6695
    @jacksullivan6695 2 года назад

    russell vs tony would be so iconic

  • @erickgomez1879
    @erickgomez1879 3 года назад +1

    Gabon... is Gabon
    Damn

  • @seanperry2024
    @seanperry2024 3 года назад +1

    I would 100% put Kim on this season

  • @phobiccobra991
    @phobiccobra991 3 года назад

    YEESSSSS YESS

  • @milkshakedraws6944
    @milkshakedraws6944 Год назад

    I believe that FairPlay said relatively recently, in the last few years, that he’s on good terms with production. I still don’t think he’ll come back, I can’t think of another season where he’ll fit unless it’s Old players v New players, but he isn’t fully out of contention.

  • @CosmicPie67
    @CosmicPie67 3 года назад +6

    i would Put Rupert on the Cast.

  • @sudden_exlipsingstudio1728
    @sudden_exlipsingstudio1728 3 года назад +7

    I honestly would put Andrea on the cast over a Kathy because there’s already an older woman archetype with Tina

    • @superraul6449
      @superraul6449 3 года назад

      But to be fair Kathy Make more since

    • @ethancostellostudent1698
      @ethancostellostudent1698 3 года назад

      Aka_KingFlop Said it that'd make lore sense if it was casting making a legends season. This however is his opinion and he chose Kathy over Andrea

    • @sudden_exlipsingstudio1728
      @sudden_exlipsingstudio1728 3 года назад

      Ethan Costello ( Student ) yeah I can respect that, Kathy and Andrea are both legends no questions asked, I just would personally choose Andrea over her, no disrespect to Kathy or Him

  • @Isabella-vy7vx
    @Isabella-vy7vx 3 года назад

    Boston Rob has been on the same season with 17 of these people. That’s crazy

  • @filipeabreu2542
    @filipeabreu2542 3 года назад +1

    How do you not have Kim and Sarah? I think they are two of the biggest locks for the female players

  • @norbs3802
    @norbs3802 3 года назад

    The good thing about a legends season is that the majority of the cast will be old school players in Winners at War every old school player got taken out one by one but with a legends season there are gonna be less new school since some are good players like Aubry or Malcolm but they aren’t exactly legends so now I think it’s def possible an old school player will win a legends season

  • @joejoejoeil3165
    @joejoejoeil3165 3 года назад +3

    I see Yul, I start a Yul chain

  • @VereditoRainbow1012
    @VereditoRainbow1012 3 года назад

    Yesssss

  • @radioranger12
    @radioranger12 3 года назад +1

    Can you do casting survivor America Vs. Australia Vs. South Africa

  • @dolphinz8116
    @dolphinz8116 3 года назад

    My cast
    -
    1. Richard Hatch
    2. Tina Wesson
    3. Jerri Manthey
    4. Lex can den Berghe
    5. Rob Cesternino
    6. Sandra Diaz-Twine
    7. Cirie Fields
    8. Parvati Shallow
    9. Earl Cole
    10. Todd Herzog
    11. Courtney Yates
    12. Erik Reichenbach
    13. Coach Wade
    14. Sophie Clarke
    15. Malcolm Freberg
    16. Tony Vlachos
    17. Natalie Anderson
    18. Jeremy Collins
    19. Kelley Wentworth
    20. Michele Fitzgerald

  • @pillowfeathers3990
    @pillowfeathers3990 3 года назад +1

    big brother runner up rankings?

  • @eliotedward2113
    @eliotedward2113 3 года назад +1

    I would rather see Michelle than Sophie, if Michelle makes its 3 times in a row to the final

  • @lisaann3063
    @lisaann3063 3 года назад +1

    This was great. Hey who knows???

  • @taylorperry2541
    @taylorperry2541 3 года назад

    My cast
    Men: Hatch, Colby, Rob, Rupert, Ozzy, James, Tyson/Coach, Russell, Tony, Cochran, Malcolm
    Momen: Jerri, Sandra, Amber, Parvati, Courtney, Amanda, Kim, Natalie

  • @GeauxWyatt
    @GeauxWyatt 3 года назад

    My Survivor Legends Dream Cast
    1. Hatch
    2. Colby
    3. Lex
    4. Rob
    5. Rupert
    6. Coach
    7. Russel (ugh fine)
    8. Tony
    9. Tyson
    10. Jeremy
    11. Parv
    12. Sandra
    13. Cirie
    14. Amanda
    15. Tina
    16. Jerri
    17. Natalie
    18. Stephanie
    19. Colleen (fuck it. It’s a dream cast)
    20. Vecepia
    Honorable mentions/Alternates
    Rob C
    Fairplay
    JT
    Sean Rector
    Greg
    Michelle
    Wentworth
    Devens
    Wendell
    Kass?
    Kim
    Gervase
    You can tell how old school biased I am. But if you want viewers to watch a LEGENDS season you gotta have some old school pride!

  • @bennymcshea2448
    @bennymcshea2448 3 года назад

    Yess Dream

  • @christianmccarty2213
    @christianmccarty2213 3 года назад

    Where is Purple Kelly???? Absolute legend

  • @aperson22222
    @aperson22222 3 года назад +2

    No harm in daydreaming I suppose, but this talk of a "Legends" season seems pointless to me, for a number of reasons:
    1. Now that there's been an all winners season, you're never going to find an even more competitive field.
    2. Three all-star seasons in the last ten, versus two out of the first thirty? Too many trips back to the well. You'll have to wait quite a long time before another will feel special, and by then . . .
    3. The greatest appetite is for old-timers, but they're fast aging out of consideration, if they haven't already. They're not going to cast a season dominated by people over fifty; and if you only bring in a handful of old-timers, they'll get whupped by the newer players again, as they did in S40. Since this is all make-believe I suppose you could imagine the old-timers are time-displaced back to when they were each at their prime, but that's such a wild fantasy you might as well bring back the dead players while you're at it. (Ru-dy! Ru-dy! Ru-dy!)
    4. Kind of repetitive from the last point, but I do think it bears repeating: S40 set this precedent for an inter-generational rivalry. This would quickly suck all the air out of the room.
    5. After S40 so many of the giants made it explicitly clear that they're done. The greatest of the non-winners, Cirie, said the same thing after S34. So many of the legends have passed on. (In a metaphorical sense; they haven't died, of course. Except for Rudy, but he was like two hundred years old.)
    6. For those who've been out of the game for a long time and have been chomping at the bit to get back in, I feel like it would be nothing but a vanity project for them, and would generate very little interest. I almost pity many of them as they keep trying to bask in long-ago glory.
    7. I really think there should be a three-season cap on the number of times people can play. After that they rapidly hit a point of diminishing returns and stop being fun to watch. (Yes, Rob finally got his win his fourth time around, but while many fans were happy for him, no one actually enjoyed watching it; and if we're being brutally honest, he really only won because things were heavily stacked in his favor.)
    8. There's no consensus on who is and is not a legend. There are a few people that would be relatively uncontroversial, but nowhere near enough to fill a cast, and you can't help but invite scrutiny of why casting zigged instead of zagged that will detract mightily from the magic of the moment. It's always been this way: S8 had some pretty dubious choices for all-star status, even when they were drawing from a much smaller pool (though some of the lesser lights wound up being among the most successful, including the final three). S34 felt like a random jumble of legacy players resting on their laurels and forgettable obscurities, only a few of whom could claim to have changed the game at all. Both the Favorites tribes included people who didn't qualify as favorites; one could argue that the S26 tribe didn't include anyone who _did._ Even S20 didn't manage to avoid this trap: Sugar wasn't anyone's hero!
    Only S31 and S40 managed to overcome this. S31 because, while there certainly wasn't consensus among viewers that anywhere close to everyone belonged, the transparency of the casting process is hard to argue with; and S40 because, while I could name a handful of players whom I wished had been traded out for other winners (and others whom I wished had never won at all), everyone had already cleared a very high bar to get there. But "legend" doesn't have the same strict criteria as "winner," and even if casting is done by electoral politics as it was in S31, you're opening it up to grumbling that some people only got canonized as legendary through popular publicity stunts. Either way, a Legends season couldn't possibly live up to the hype.

  • @kalebdunaway
    @kalebdunaway 3 года назад +1

    I love Cestrinino, but I don’t think he’s a legend. He was great on the show, but he is so big because of the podcast. I think you should’ve had Rupert, Ozzy, Penner, Tyson, or JT over him and Yul. I also think that you should’ve had Stephanie on over Kathy or Sophie. Great video!
    My Cast:
    1. Hatch
    2. Colby
    3. Boston Rob
    4. Rupert
    5. Ozzy
    6. Coach
    7. JT
    8. Tyson
    9. Russell
    10. Tony
    11. Jerri
    12. Tina
    13. Sandra
    14. Stephanie
    15. Cirie
    16. Parvati
    17. Amanda
    18. Ciera
    19. Natalie A.
    20. Wentworth

  • @willtriplett4128
    @willtriplett4128 3 года назад +1

    I feel like the point of dream casting is cast based off of just the theme, not picking whoever you want. Not gonna be rude, but I think you could have explained it better.

  • @mirandawatson99
    @mirandawatson99 3 года назад

    My pick would be:
    1. Cirie
    2. Amanda
    3. Parvati
    4. Wentworth
    5.Ciera Eastin
    6. Steph
    7. Andrea
    8. Michelle
    9. Brenda
    10. Devens
    11. Malcolm
    12. Tyson
    13. Hatch
    14. Ozzy
    15. Cochran
    16. Joe
    17. Spencer
    18. Rupert

  • @MusicNerdDavid
    @MusicNerdDavid 3 года назад +1

    Do a tough as nails season 1 review!!

  • @gymrules27
    @gymrules27 2 месяца назад

    How I Would Have Cast Survivor: Legends:
    1. Amanda Kimmel
    2. Andrea Boehlke
    3. Aubry Bracco
    4. Cirie Fields
    5. Coach Wade
    6. Colby Donaldson
    7. James Clement
    8. Jeremy Collins
    9. Jerri Manthey
    10. Kelley Wentworth
    11. Natalie Anderson
    12. Ozzy Lusth
    13. Parvati Shallow
    14. Rob Cesternino
    15. Rupert Boneham
    16. Sandra Diaz-Twine
    17. Sarah Lacina
    18. Tony Vlachos
    19. Tyson Apostol
    20. Yau-Man Chan

  • @ambaar13
    @ambaar13 3 года назад +1

    How can you not do a legends season without russel hantz good character and a top tier legend no matter how production feels would be a massive waste not to put on a legends season

  • @user-jb9xy3hc4g
    @user-jb9xy3hc4g 3 года назад +1

    Plz do dream cast survivor winner at War

  • @larrydaher411
    @larrydaher411 3 года назад

    do a ranking of the fallen angels!

  • @bkobick1
    @bkobick1 3 года назад +2

    Cast a legends season of The Amazing Race

  • @LiamP589
    @LiamP589 3 года назад +1

    Yul got swap screwed in WaW. So yeh I'd like to see him again

    • @BC-fx2yt
      @BC-fx2yt 3 года назад

      What? No he didn’t

    • @LiamP589
      @LiamP589 3 года назад

      @@BC-fx2ythe was in the dominant spot in the red tribe. When tribes were split into 3 he got removed from his alliance. Then when voted out it was by 3 people who were friends before the game.

    • @BC-fx2yt
      @BC-fx2yt 3 года назад

      @@LiamP589 He had a pregame alliance with them too. He shouldn’t have let himself be put into a position to be voted out on that tribe anyway

  • @annbauman6123
    @annbauman6123 3 года назад

    He is a legend he would be on mine and legrossa and penner

  • @conormurphy6407
    @conormurphy6407 3 года назад

    Can you do a Big Brother Legends dream cast

  • @seangoodwin3084
    @seangoodwin3084 3 года назад +1

    Omg NO LEX but Boston Rob is back???? This is my nightmare. At least put Sean Rector instead of Boston Rob... but Lex should be the FIRST Legend!

  • @benwilson7672
    @benwilson7672 3 года назад +4

    You should do a video talking about the most over edited players in survivor history.

    • @tdt8854
      @tdt8854 3 года назад +6

      10. Russell Hantz
      9. Russell Hantz
      8. Russell Hantz
      7. Russell Hantz
      6. Russell Hantz
      5. Russell Hantz
      4. Russell Hantz
      3. Russell Hantz
      2. Russell Hantz
      1. Russell Hantz

    • @benwilson7672
      @benwilson7672 3 года назад +2

      @@tdt8854 not really, more so someone like Michelle.

    • @chickenchicken9072
      @chickenchicken9072 3 года назад

      Ben Wilson Lmao we get it you like Russell and hate every other player

    • @benwilson7672
      @benwilson7672 3 года назад

      @@chickenchicken9072 well on Somoa there wasn't really anyone else to edit. 😂😂

  • @jaimeabaya6728
    @jaimeabaya6728 Год назад

    For tribe wise
    Old School:
    Richard Hatch
    Colby Donaldson
    Kathy Vanvrick O’Brien
    Jerri Manthy
    Rob “Boston Rob” Mariano
    Robb Cesternino
    Jonny Fairplay
    Stephanie LaGrossa
    Shane Powers
    Cirie Fields
    New School:
    Stephen Fishbach
    Russell Hantz
    Brenda Lowe
    Coach Wade
    Troyzan Robertson
    Malcolm Freberg
    John Cochran
    Ciera Easton
    Tony Vlachos
    Tai Trang

  • @annbauman6123
    @annbauman6123 3 года назад

    What about Ian from palau because he is a legend

  • @jordanchillout7989
    @jordanchillout7989 3 года назад

    Here it is
    1. Richard hatch
    2. Boston Rob
    3. Johny Fairplay
    4.Rupert
    5. James
    6. Coach
    7.Cochran
    8.Tony
    9. Tyson
    10. Ozzy
    11. Sue Hawk
    12. Kathy
    13. Sandra
    14. Cirie
    15.Parvati
    16. Sarah
    17.Kelly Wentwotrh
    18. Kass
    19. Kim
    20. Denise

  • @apecentury228
    @apecentury228 3 года назад +1

    i disagree with the sarah story being over...i could see her winning again if tony isn't on the cast

    • @BC-fx2yt
      @BC-fx2yt 3 года назад

      Nah, she’s too high profile now

  • @brendan3297
    @brendan3297 3 года назад

    bro how do u not cast Malcolm that’s a joke💀

  • @bigbrotherlivefeeds8625
    @bigbrotherlivefeeds8625 3 года назад

    you should rank all of the three time players

  • @xakdish4169
    @xakdish4169 3 года назад +1

    i like this cast. but i would remove johnny fairplay, kathy and tina. And replace them with malcolm, kass and kim.

  • @brendanfechter4889
    @brendanfechter4889 3 года назад

    Hey you know Russ fully believes he's playing again right? Why r u so convinced he isn't? He's sure of it. You sayin he's delusional? Why wouldn't he?

  • @benlaplume6469
    @benlaplume6469 3 года назад +1

    Brooo Cochran shoulda been on winners at war instead of Adam