I feel as though what divides people into “Villains” and “Hero’s” is that being a hero means you play sorta emotionally and care for others While being a villain means you’re 100% strategic and don’t care about others, I don’t see being a villain isnt a bad thing though 😂
For the people trying to say that people like Ben aren`t a hero because of his play, I`d just like to point out that the original HvV was based on both gameplay and outside factors. So he is 100% a hero in the context of Survivor.
@@MsVitaD Dani would likely not even be his top 3. Paul (S19) would likely be #1. Keep in mind even if you ignore the fact that Paul is objectively better than Dani, TMR has a very peculiar philosophy towards Big Brother & Survivor that focuses very much on dominance and control. Many of us tend to disagree with him but if we assume what his personal rankings of the runner-ups Dani likely misses top 3. Dan and Paul likely fight for #1. I only give it to Paul because we openly know his only flaw in S19 was jury management... Which Dan (S14) also lacked and to a worse extent. Dan is objectively best player ever but Paul played the best non-winning game ever.
@@BC-fx2yt probably. I never watched S20 or S21. Stopped watching survivor and big brother after S19 of BB. Was sick of bitter juries and decided "screw it, either bitch about something that doesn't affect me or I just don't watch it" so I chose the latter but now with 2020 having these all stars seasons... Damn lol. I have been told Tyler was robbed though but I need to watch the season first.
Problem is that in Ghost Island, Wendell was the hero to Dom’s villain, and that was the dynamic that won him the game. Now he’d be a villain for sure though
Typically in the edit, being overtly strategic and cutthroat makes you a "villain". It doesn't make you unlikable to watch, ala rob, parvati, tyson, but in the game they're seen as villainous
theres really nothing wrong with having a negative edit, unless its like super negative when the show show a certain someone in really repulsive behavior
Yul, Adam and Nick are tough sells as "villains", but of the three...Yul enginereed voting out Cao Boi simply because of a dream CB had that could potentially threaten Yul.
I read that Parvati being a Villain in HvV has something to do with Rob disliking Candice being originally put in Villains tribe. IDK if this is right but its what I read. haha!
But she did it out of redemption for Jeremy which was seen as heroic, and she ends the season in mirror placement as her sister .... and she only turns on her allies after they turned on her and I dont believe anyone took it to personally
The only one I strongly disagree with is Adam, he is the ultimate hero from my point if veiw. However I understand that with all winners, pretty much everyone gets a positive edit to give a satisfying ending, so you're hands were kind of tied with that one. Definitely hard to fill up the villains tribe
He had a super noble motivation and he used that motivation to fuel him. Meanwhile, his style of play in and of itself was pretty villanous: do whatever it takes to get ahead, cut my threats, and win. For instance: blindsiding Figgy, eating Taylor's food, tricking Jay into playing his idol, and trying to axe David a round early.
@@malufetkim why Ethan? He's one of the better winners and it was great to see him again. Take out Adam and Sophie. Replace them with Earl/JT and Vecepia.
I would have the following winners placed on the opposite tribes: Yul Kwon, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Rob Mariano, Natalie Anderson, Kim Spradlin, Wendell Holland, and Danni Boatwright.
I would swap Natalie and Jeremy. (From a production standpoint she was up against the clear villains at the end of Missy and Baylor, versus Jeremy being up agains the clear hero/underdog of Kelley Wentworth.) Not saying that I view them as more villainous or heroic, but just from the arc during post merge. Also I think Wendell was more villainous than Nick, I think an underdog storyline fits more with the hero than one of the game controllers. Otherwise a fantastic list!
Good choices, except I would interchange Sophie with Kim. Kim was much more cutthroat in her season than Sophie in hers. Basically Sophie just wanted to coast to the end, Kim identified threats and eliminated then.
I’ve not watched the video and this is my pre-video predictions for the tribes Edit: Spoilers Villans Boston Rob✅ Tony✅ Tyson✅ Nick✅ Wendell❌ Sarah✅ Sandra✅ Natalie✅ Parvati✅ Sophie✅ Heroes Yul ✅ Ethan✅ Jeremy✅ Adam❌ Ben✅ Danni✅ Michelle✅ Denise✅ Amber✅ Kim✅
I’m not trying to start anything, but so many people think Ben’s game wasn’t very good but I thought he played an amazing game. It doesn’t compare to like Rob’s or Tony’s but still.
This tribe split up is so great. We get so much more of those interactions we've been dying to see. Sandra and Parvati on the same tribe, Sandra Parvati Rob and Tyson and how they were all villains on hvv. Amber and Ethan on the same tribe, on the outs, forced to work together despite their interesting past. The villains tribe would obviously dominate just based on the strength on either side, but hey, I wouldn't hate to see that
I so wish they had split the tribes this way. Btw you were way too nice to the villains cast. They did so many sketch & unnecessarily mean things - from Tyson telling Katie that there was a seat waiting for her in the jury (before she lost at redemption island) to Sandra telling Russell Coach is after her in order to save herself & Courtney for another day, and Natalie literally calling out that dude & telling him he's a sexist/ bigot.... and even ready to get into a brawl with him.... I think they all earned it. I would put Amber on the villain's drive as she was in many ways the original Parvati and used her looks to get ahead. And I would also switch Sophie to the heroes tribe. She's a hero to me. She made sure her tribe stayed intact and no one pulled anything funny.. and unlike other people I don't see her as cold. I see her as an Introvert who took out Ozzie on her way to winning. Otherwise I love the split. And I don't think it's terrible to have Amer on Rob's team as Michelle & Wendell are on the same team.
Please reassess Survivor All Stars cast. I just came across a "master" alternates list for each season with returnees on Reddit. Very interesting. Amber was like the 4th choice for her "role" on the cast after Elizabeth, Colleen and Heidi
Ben is an interesting one because to Probst he is the ultimate hero IRL, but the way he played HHH was quite villainous. Would have loved to see him go from Heroes tribe to Villains tribe
I feel like the whole heroes vs villains thing is flawed. By nature the dynamics of a tribe of villains is more interesting and the players people usually like to see come back are the villains.
Survivor power pairs Tribe 1 1 Alex season 14 2 Reynold season 26 3 Nick season 37, 40 4 Dom season 36 5 Devons season 38 6 Natalie season 16 7 Cirie season 12, 16, 20, 34 8 Ciera season 27, 31, 34 9 Corrine season 17, 26 10 Alexis season 28 Tribe 2 1 Edgardo season 14 2 Eddie season 26 3 Mike season 37 4 Wendell season 36, 40 5 Dave season 33, 38 6 Alexis season 16 7 Michaela season 33, 34 8 Kelly season 19 9 Eliza season 9, 16 10 Jefra season 28
Agree with the assessment with only one switch. I would Switch Wendall with Nick. I think Nick being a David who over came adversity is more heroic than Wendall who not a direct villain himself was aligned with Dom who was more villainous than most others on his season. And Wendall would be a villain under the reverse logic they used for Sugar in actual HvV. Sugar was a “hero” because she wanted “good people” to win. Wendall would be a villain because he kept the villain around for so long. Basically the logic of not saying or doing anything about a negative is the same as encouraging it. But overall decent logic.
prediction before watching: Heroes - Michele, Danni, Amber, Natalie, Denise, Ethan, Jeremy, Ben, Yul, Wendell Villains - Sandra, Parvati, Sarah, Kim, Sophie, Rob, Tony, Tyson, Adam, Nick Edit: 18/20, not bad. I think my mind leaned Natalie toward Heroes so that she could be in the same starting tribe with Jeremy.
Imagine if they were just divided into boys vs girls and put in the same island instead of separately like Kim's season... AUTOMATICALLY A MORE DYNAMIC SEASON!
@@denniswilson6377 I didn't. I'm saying that to do that set up again coz unlike those boys vs girls season, they're all strangers, so they didn't really do anything different from other seasons. But in this S40, they all have relationships that can make it more complicated
@@denniswilson6377 the fire tokens were too sudden of a twist & Edge of Extinction only allows 2 opportunities to return instead of 3/4 to really mess them up. but just imagine a Black Widow 2.0 of Kim+Parvati+Sophie+Michelle+Amber & opposing alliance of Sarah+Sandra+Natalie alliances in girls tribe with Danni+Denise as the ones to grab. And imagine Ethan+Rob+Tyson old school alliance vs Tony+Jeremy+Wendell new school alliance with Yul taking the 1-time players Adam+Nick+Ben (&maybe Wendell but he would vibe with Jeremy immediately like in that merge). Just imagine the CHAOS and TV! 😍
@@eldin02211 Well the thing is he forced the distribution to be 10 and 10. In real life, if you divide a group of people between good guys and bad guys, you don't always get the same number on both sides. Here there are more villains than heroes in my opinion. Also, he forced it to be 5 men and 5 women are both sides. Another arbitrary (and totally sexist) constraint and I hate that.
@@eldin02211 Well yes if you are going to put two teams against each other they should have the same number of people. But if you just randomly pick 20 people it will not always be that 10 are villains and 10 are heroes. WaW was not designed as a heroe vs villain cast so it should not guarantee a 50 50 split. But yes I do agree a game should be balanced to be a good game. I just don't like forced distributions in general. Also if two countries go to war, it will not necessarily be balanced. That's how life is.
If I may. Adam HAD to play a very cutthroat game. His closest ally flipped on him and caused another one of his allies to be blindsided at the very first tribal. Yul on the other hand, was definitely more calculating and underhanded at times. For example, if it weren't for the mutiny than Ozzy would've been voted out next and Yul was the catalyst behind that decision. But when the mutiny happened, suddenly, Ozzy is Yul's best friend. Not to mention that Yul blatantly lied to Penner to flip his vote at the merge only to then vote him out only 2 rounds later. Adam played the way he did because his back was against the wall and he won. Also, come on, Nick as a villain?? Yul and Adam as Villains and Nick as a hero.
A fun idea :p What if someone else came back from the Edge of Extinction Examples: you would go through every person on the Edge (including Sandra) and see What would happen if someone beside Natalie came back, Like would the final 3 be different, would they make the final 3, would they win, what placement would they finish in, who would win and how many jury votes would they get if they made the end, Like say If Rob had made it maybe he would’ve made final 3 and won, or Adam, Parvati, Sandra, etc.
Singles 1 Cochran season 23, 26 2 James season 15, 16, 20 3 Carter season 25 4 Noura season 39 5 Nick season 32 6 Randy season 17, 20 7 Shambo season 19 8 Courtney season 12 9 Desiree season 36 10 Natalie season 29, 40 Taken 1 Christian season 38 2 Jessica season 35 3 Edgardo season 14 4 Holly season 21 5 Reed season 29 6 RC season 25 7 Philip season 22, 26 8 Amanda season 15, 16, 20 9 John K season 9 10 Elaine season 39
I think the argument could be made for each of the winners at war castaways to be on either tribe, they are villains in the way that they did whatever it took to win their season and they are heroes because they bring the entertainment viewers want. I think you struggled to move people to the villain tribe because most of them are people that we support the winning game of.
On this villains tribe, everyone would be freaked out by the four HvV players (also the 4 old school players) and the other 6 would probably align and target them.
They're either a villan or a hero there's nothing in between, I feel there is a lot of unnecessary explanation about them being in between. Should've been short
Survivor overrated vs underrated Overrated 1 Sarah season 28, 34, 40 2 Parvati season 13, 16, 20, 40 3 Tina season 2, 8, 27 4 Andrea season 22, 26, 34 5 Kelley season 29, 31, 38 6 Joe season 30, 31, 38 7 Dom season 36 8 Rupert season 7, 8, 20, 27 9 Rob season 4, 8, 20, 22, 40 10 Aras season 12, 27 Underrated 1 Tracy season 16 2 Jacquie season 17 3 Cassandra season 14 4 Ali season 35 5 Lucy season 33 6 Mike season 26 7 John K season 9 8 Rafe season 11 9 Mookie season 14 10 Chris season 38
@@regularperson7380 I agree Chrissy was too. On top of that she should have won that season as well. But my opinion on Ben wont change. We can agree to disagree on that
![FendiDa Rappa - Clock Dat ft. Shamar Marco [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3NBU8KHdxYY/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine this guy, Idoled Out, and Peridam in a season together
And once upon a island
Bruh, that would be scary, probably this guy would win out of that line up
I feel as though what divides people into “Villains” and “Hero’s” is that being a hero means you play sorta emotionally and care for others While being a villain means you’re 100% strategic and don’t care about others, I don’t see being a villain isnt a bad thing though 😂
A hero's a hero, but everyone loves a good villain
Most winners are neither villain or heroes.
For the people trying to say that people like Ben aren`t a hero because of his play, I`d just like to point out that the original HvV was based on both gameplay and outside factors. So he is 100% a hero in the context of Survivor.
Just for being part of david tribe, nick is hero
But would you call Carl a hero
Sara Pesenacker for the majority of the season, yes until he got power hungry
I'd swap Nick and Wendell.
@@kyletucker3811I would swap Wendell for Domenick and put Domenick on Villains and Nick on hero. RIP Tiebreakers
Suggestion : Big Brother Runner Up Rankings
This would be interesting
If Dan and Danielle aren’t 1 and 2 I will lose my shit
@@MsVitaD Dani would likely not even be his top 3. Paul (S19) would likely be #1. Keep in mind even if you ignore the fact that Paul is objectively better than Dani, TMR has a very peculiar philosophy towards Big Brother & Survivor that focuses very much on dominance and control. Many of us tend to disagree with him but if we assume what his personal rankings of the runner-ups Dani likely misses top 3. Dan and Paul likely fight for #1. I only give it to Paul because we openly know his only flaw in S19 was jury management... Which Dan (S14) also lacked and to a worse extent. Dan is objectively best player ever but Paul played the best non-winning game ever.
@@glassestarzan8702 Tyler will probably be very high up too
@@BC-fx2yt probably. I never watched S20 or S21. Stopped watching survivor and big brother after S19 of BB. Was sick of bitter juries and decided "screw it, either bitch about something that doesn't affect me or I just don't watch it" so I chose the latter but now with 2020 having these all stars seasons... Damn lol. I have been told Tyler was robbed though but I need to watch the season first.
Recast some seasons to Brain Brawn Beauty!
Yes!!! I love that twist, I would really like to see something like that
Good call on yul because he got an aerial shot on exile island which is the total hero edit
Honestly switch Wendell and Adam and it’s perfect.
Why would Adam me a villain
Point God and why would Wendall be a hero
Owen Nicholson I think he’s in the middle but fits the villain side better on this cast
Problem is that in Ghost Island, Wendell was the hero to Dom’s villain, and that was the dynamic that won him the game. Now he’d be a villain for sure though
Ben could be a villain aswell
But why does being strategic show them in a negative light. For me that's a big positive.
Typically in the edit, being overtly strategic and cutthroat makes you a "villain". It doesn't make you unlikable to watch, ala rob, parvati, tyson, but in the game they're seen as villainous
True, for example, T Bird is strategic and she’s far from a villain
Josh Washburn It all depends on your personality really. If you take joy in taking people out your usually seen as a villain
Vladimir Lenin yeah I agree.
theres really nothing wrong with having a negative edit, unless its like super negative when the show show a certain someone in really repulsive behavior
i feel like post winners at war tony is a hero but before definitely a villain
This was an interesting video idea. I think it could be fun to try this for other returnee seasons if you think it's possible. Good job
My types: Heroes: Amber, Danni, Ethan, Yul, Michelle, Ben, Denise, Nick, Adam, Sophie Villains: Natalie, Tyson, Rob, Parvati, Sandra, Wendell, Tony, Sarah, Jeremy, Kim
Yul, Adam and Nick are tough sells as "villains", but of the three...Yul enginereed voting out Cao Boi simply because of a dream CB had that could potentially threaten Yul.
You should do recasting Caramoan as All-Stars.
What does that even mean
Hunter Borne besides it being Fans vs Favorites he makes it Allstars, (he did a video like that for Micronesia already)
@@hunterborne2763 casting an all-stars season with the best 20 players from seasons 16-25
Not possible because you’d have to remove the entire favorites tribe
There weren’t _any_ stars on Caramoan.
I find it suspicious that the cast has exactly 10 villains and 10 heroes. Seems rigged to me.
I read that Parvati being a Villain in HvV has something to do with Rob disliking Candice being originally put in Villains tribe. IDK if this is right but its what I read. haha!
Parvati was gonna be on the Heroes tribe, but they didn't want too many people on Micronesia
switch adam and wendell
As far as Challenge strength, the tribes look fairly evenly matched.
Yeah, Natalie Anderson is definitely a villain. She played them all so hard, that’s an easy choice.
But she did it out of redemption for Jeremy which was seen as heroic, and she ends the season in mirror placement as her sister .... and she only turns on her allies after they turned on her and I dont believe anyone took it to personally
Definitely one of the easiest casting choices
The only one I strongly disagree with is Adam, he is the ultimate hero from my point if veiw. However I understand that with all winners, pretty much everyone gets a positive edit to give a satisfying ending, so you're hands were kind of tied with that one. Definitely hard to fill up the villains tribe
He had a super noble motivation and he used that motivation to fuel him. Meanwhile, his style of play in and of itself was pretty villanous: do whatever it takes to get ahead, cut my threats, and win. For instance: blindsiding Figgy, eating Taylor's food, tricking Jay into playing his idol, and trying to axe David a round early.
@@simplebutpowerful he never ONCE ate ANY of that food! XD
Villains:
Rob
Tyson
Wendell
Ben
Tony
Natalie
Parvati
Sandra
Sophie
Sarah
Heroes:
Adam
Ethan
Jeremy
Nick
Yul
Danni
Denise
Amber
Kim
Michele
Plz do Winners at War dream cast
I second this
@@chickenchicken9072 It would probably be pretty much the same
I'll take out amber nick ethan wendell
@@malufetkim why Ethan? He's one of the better winners and it was great to see him again. Take out Adam and Sophie. Replace them with Earl/JT and Vecepia.
I would have the following winners placed on the opposite tribes: Yul Kwon, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Rob Mariano, Natalie Anderson, Kim Spradlin, Wendell Holland, and Danni Boatwright.
I would swap Natalie and Jeremy. (From a production standpoint she was up against the clear villains at the end of Missy and Baylor, versus Jeremy being up agains the clear hero/underdog of Kelley Wentworth.) Not saying that I view them as more villainous or heroic, but just from the arc during post merge. Also I think Wendell was more villainous than Nick, I think an underdog storyline fits more with the hero than one of the game controllers. Otherwise a fantastic list!
Good choices, except I would interchange Sophie with Kim. Kim was much more cutthroat in her season than Sophie in hers. Basically Sophie just wanted to coast to the end, Kim identified threats and eliminated then.
When is recasting survivor caramoan as survivor all stars coming
I’ve not watched the video and this is my pre-video predictions for the tribes
Edit: Spoilers
Villans
Boston Rob✅
Tony✅
Tyson✅
Nick✅
Wendell❌
Sarah✅
Sandra✅
Natalie✅
Parvati✅
Sophie✅
Heroes
Yul ✅
Ethan✅
Jeremy✅
Adam❌
Ben✅
Danni✅
Michelle✅
Denise✅
Amber✅
Kim✅
This was my exact list before I watched the video.
I’m not trying to start anything, but so many people think Ben’s game wasn’t very good but I thought he played an amazing game. It doesn’t compare to like Rob’s or Tony’s but still.
Parvati was definitely a villain in Micronesia... she got a very negative edit and was mostly disliked until HvV.
Suggestion: Heroes vs Villians Big Brother
Sandra didn't blame Christa for the fish. Sandra just didn't come clean about dumping the fish herself.
How do you come up with this shit man! This is awesome dude!
So close to my list! I switched wendall and nick. But i had the same thoughts as you overall.
suggestion: what if every season had same f4 format as now
Seems like a fun concept to hypothesize!
This tribe split up is so great. We get so much more of those interactions we've been dying to see. Sandra and Parvati on the same tribe, Sandra Parvati Rob and Tyson and how they were all villains on hvv. Amber and Ethan on the same tribe, on the outs, forced to work together despite their interesting past. The villains tribe would obviously dominate just based on the strength on either side, but hey, I wouldn't hate to see that
Sandra is an anti-hero rather than a clear villain. She verbally bitch slaps villains.
I think Ben and Wendell should be switched with Adam and Nick and then we good.
Ben stays
Natalie is a villain, she was really nasty on the Edge along with Parvati, and she fought with Yul
Ben definitely belongs on the heroes just like in his season
I tried doing the same thing with the cast for All Stars. Dunno how but I managed to do it, maybe that's an idea?
I would flip Nick and Wendell but other than that great division !
I’m sure you have seen this idea everywhere but I would love big brother US runner up rankings
Heroes
Adam
Nick
Sophie
Michelle
Ben
Denise
Amber
Danni
Ethan
Yul
Villains
Tony
Sarah
Natalie
Wendell
Kim
Jeremy
Sandra
Rob
Parvati
Tyson
I so wish they had split the tribes this way. Btw you were way too nice to the villains cast. They did so many sketch & unnecessarily mean things - from Tyson telling Katie that there was a seat waiting for her in the jury (before she lost at redemption island) to Sandra telling Russell Coach is after her in order to save herself & Courtney for another day, and Natalie literally calling out that dude & telling him he's a sexist/ bigot.... and even ready to get into a brawl with him.... I think they all earned it. I would put Amber on the villain's drive as she was in many ways the original Parvati and used her looks to get ahead. And I would also switch Sophie to the heroes tribe. She's a hero to me. She made sure her tribe stayed intact and no one pulled anything funny.. and unlike other people I don't see her as cold. I see her as an Introvert who took out Ozzie on her way to winning. Otherwise I love the split. And I don't think it's terrible to have Amer on Rob's team as Michelle & Wendell are on the same team.
Caramoan as All stars
you should do a video of the best final boots in survivor. Like David Wright, Devens, Keith Nale, Sarah, etc.
Please do Big Brother Runner Up Rankings!
The amazing race 32 cast assessment?
Please reassess Survivor All Stars cast. I just came across a "master" alternates list for each season with returnees on Reddit. Very interesting. Amber was like the 4th choice for her "role" on the cast after Elizabeth, Colleen and Heidi
Ben is an interesting one because to Probst he is the ultimate hero IRL, but the way he played HHH was quite villainous. Would have loved to see him go from Heroes tribe to Villains tribe
Ben ain't a villain
I feel like the whole heroes vs villains thing is flawed. By nature the dynamics of a tribe of villains is more interesting and the players people usually like to see come back are the villains.
It's crazy to think a vote here or there could have had the entire original villains on this season
I think Kim should be a villain just because of how charming and deceiving she was, similar to Parvati prior to 20
Seth Rollins but then again... sugar was in the hero’s 🙄
I would love to see an all time amazing race teams
Survivor power pairs
Tribe 1
1 Alex season 14
2 Reynold season 26
3 Nick season 37, 40
4 Dom season 36
5 Devons season 38
6 Natalie season 16
7 Cirie season 12, 16, 20, 34
8 Ciera season 27, 31, 34
9 Corrine season 17, 26
10 Alexis season 28
Tribe 2
1 Edgardo season 14
2 Eddie season 26
3 Mike season 37
4 Wendell season 36, 40
5 Dave season 33, 38
6 Alexis season 16
7 Michaela season 33, 34
8 Kelly season 19
9 Eliza season 9, 16
10 Jefra season 28
James was also on Fans vs Favorites so there would have been 4 players from that season
Agree with the assessment with only one switch. I would Switch Wendall with Nick. I think Nick being a David who over came adversity is more heroic than Wendall who not a direct villain himself was aligned with Dom who was more villainous than most others on his season. And Wendall would be a villain under the reverse logic they used for Sugar in actual HvV. Sugar was a “hero” because she wanted “good people” to win. Wendall would be a villain because he kept the villain around for so long. Basically the logic of not saying or doing anything about a negative is the same as encouraging it. But overall decent logic.
prediction before watching:
Heroes - Michele, Danni, Amber, Natalie, Denise, Ethan, Jeremy, Ben, Yul, Wendell
Villains - Sandra, Parvati, Sarah, Kim, Sophie, Rob, Tony, Tyson, Adam, Nick
Edit: 18/20, not bad. I think my mind leaned Natalie toward Heroes so that she could be in the same starting tribe with Jeremy.
Who did you got wrong buddy?
Hephzibah Kim and Natalie
I think Kim and Natalie would get swapped
I already know the villains should be Sarah, Sandra, Natalie, Sophie, Parvati
i would definitely switch ben for either adam or nick but i get what you’re saying about productions obsession with ben
I disagree slightly with some of the reasoning but I agree with every place you put every person
I would switch Wendell and Nick/Adam, but just my opinion!
Unpopular opinion: I think winners at war is better than heroes vs villains
Imagine if they were just divided into boys vs girls and put in the same island instead of separately like Kim's season... AUTOMATICALLY A MORE DYNAMIC SEASON!
did you miss One Word when that was airing or????
@@denniswilson6377 I didn't. I'm saying that to do that set up again coz unlike those boys vs girls season, they're all strangers, so they didn't really do anything different from other seasons. But in this S40, they all have relationships that can make it more complicated
@@ramilleanthonymartinez3702 winners at war was already complicated. Doing this twist would have just been complete unnecessary chaos.
@@denniswilson6377 the fire tokens were too sudden of a twist & Edge of Extinction only allows 2 opportunities to return instead of 3/4 to really mess them up. but just imagine a Black Widow 2.0 of Kim+Parvati+Sophie+Michelle+Amber & opposing alliance of Sarah+Sandra+Natalie alliances in girls tribe with Danni+Denise as the ones to grab. And imagine Ethan+Rob+Tyson old school alliance vs Tony+Jeremy+Wendell new school alliance with Yul taking the 1-time players Adam+Nick+Ben (&maybe Wendell but he would vibe with Jeremy immediately like in that merge). Just imagine the CHAOS and TV! 😍
I thought the same while lying alone in bed ..................... lonely.
Sandra should have been a hero in hvV I'd say she's more hero in all her runs.
Denise is an easy villian call.
Ambaah could be a villain as we saw in the Amazing Race
Parv is 100 villain.
can we get season 40 who would be on heroes vs villians??
to me yul is the most heroic on the cast
Because you struggle with coming up with the Villin tribe is the reason why this video is stupid. You lost me at Paverti
What lmao
Kim blindsided Kat, that was a villain move
But this guy rigged his list to have it 10 heroes and 10 villains....
Andrew Smith how is it rigged, that was literally the number of contestants and people from each tribe.
@@eldin02211 Well the thing is he forced the distribution to be 10 and 10.
In real life, if you divide a group of people between good guys and bad guys, you don't always get the same number on both sides. Here there are more villains than heroes in my opinion.
Also, he forced it to be 5 men and 5 women are both sides. Another arbitrary (and totally sexist) constraint and I hate that.
Andrew Smith can’t it be equal, like if your doing a reality show make it fair.
@@eldin02211 Well yes if you are going to put two teams against each other they should have the same number of people.
But if you just randomly pick 20 people it will not always be that 10 are villains and 10 are heroes. WaW was not designed as a heroe vs villain cast so it should not guarantee a 50 50 split.
But yes I do agree a game should be balanced to be a good game. I just don't like forced distributions in general. Also if two countries go to war, it will not necessarily be balanced. That's how life is.
Do this for all the seasons
Adam's negativity at the merge was just stupidity. Also Adam absolutely not close to a villain imo, but hey your opinion
Iwould switch Kim and nick
If I may. Adam HAD to play a very cutthroat game. His closest ally flipped on him and caused another one of his allies to be blindsided at the very first tribal. Yul on the other hand, was definitely more calculating and underhanded at times. For example, if it weren't for the mutiny than Ozzy would've been voted out next and Yul was the catalyst behind that decision. But when the mutiny happened, suddenly, Ozzy is Yul's best friend. Not to mention that Yul blatantly lied to Penner to flip his vote at the merge only to then vote him out only 2 rounds later. Adam played the way he did because his back was against the wall and he won. Also, come on, Nick as a villain?? Yul and Adam as Villains and Nick as a hero.
A fun idea :p
What if someone else came back from the Edge of Extinction
Examples: you would go through every person on the Edge (including Sandra) and see What would happen if someone beside Natalie came back, Like would the final 3 be different, would they make the final 3, would they win, what placement would they finish in, who would win and how many jury votes would they get if they made the end,
Like say If Rob had made it maybe he would’ve made final 3 and won, or Adam, Parvati, Sandra, etc.
I loved this!
Singles
1 Cochran season 23, 26
2 James season 15, 16, 20
3 Carter season 25
4 Noura season 39
5 Nick season 32
6 Randy season 17, 20
7 Shambo season 19
8 Courtney season 12
9 Desiree season 36
10 Natalie season 29, 40
Taken
1 Christian season 38
2 Jessica season 35
3 Edgardo season 14
4 Holly season 21
5 Reed season 29
6 RC season 25
7 Philip season 22, 26
8 Amanda season 15, 16, 20
9 John K season 9
10 Elaine season 39
I think the argument could be made for each of the winners at war castaways to be on either tribe, they are villains in the way that they did whatever it took to win their season and they are heroes because they bring the entertainment viewers want. I think you struggled to move people to the villain tribe because most of them are people that we support the winning game of.
Somebody out there please Link a custom brantsteel of this
Good video next do final 3 into final 2 and remove the winner
i love this idea
Nick is not a villain
Decievious should be added to the dictionary
Why ?!! Is Adam a villain
i just realized wendell is wearing kobes
On this villains tribe, everyone would be freaked out by the four HvV players (also the 4 old school players) and the other 6 would probably align and target them.
What if S40 was MEN vs WOMEN?
Ryan Spears Let’s hope the challenges aren’t jumping off of boats
They're either a villan or a hero there's nothing in between, I feel there is a lot of unnecessary explanation about them being in between. Should've been short
doing this brantesteele later
Interesting video. Can’t wait for others like this.
Damn before I watched this video I was like the one person who is going to be a hero will be Nick and I got bamboozled
DANNI QUUUUUUEEEEEEENNNNNN
Survivor overrated vs underrated
Overrated
1 Sarah season 28, 34, 40
2 Parvati season 13, 16, 20, 40
3 Tina season 2, 8, 27
4 Andrea season 22, 26, 34
5 Kelley season 29, 31, 38
6 Joe season 30, 31, 38
7 Dom season 36
8 Rupert season 7, 8, 20, 27
9 Rob season 4, 8, 20, 22, 40
10 Aras season 12, 27
Underrated
1 Tracy season 16
2 Jacquie season 17
3 Cassandra season 14
4 Ali season 35
5 Lucy season 33
6 Mike season 26
7 John K season 9
8 Rafe season 11
9 Mookie season 14
10 Chris season 38
Do this with australia or south africa
you should divide some seasons into blood vs water!!!
You guys are so bored lol
Sorry I would not consider Ben a hero at all!!! Gamewise that is. Same with Wendell
Ben is definitely a hero not a villain
@@regularperson7380 we can agree to disagree
@@elgringolocoMaldonado wrong Ben ain't a villain that was Chrissy
@@regularperson7380 I agree Chrissy was too. On top of that she should have won that season as well. But my opinion on Ben wont change. We can agree to disagree on that
Ben will never be a hero to me.
The dude is an actual hero in real life kind of hard to see him as a "villain"
Ben is NOT a villain