Recasting Survivor: Caramoan - What if Caramoan was All-Stars
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 ноя 2020
- In this video, I talk about who I think would have been cast had Survivor: Caramoan been an All-Star season instead of Fans vs. Favorites.
Развлечения
Развлечения
I honestly love Francesca lmao, I think she's really funny and actually a decent player, she just had SUPER bad luck
@@thesuperfan2457 i dont necessarily think that she HAD to have been on the season (especially not half returnees), but I do really like her and I think people might think of her very differently depending on how Caramoan went
Akka
@@CDawgBoi ....CDawg 👀
ikr
I only know Francesqua
Fun fact: Lisa from Philippines was considered but production decided against it because they thought it would be too much for a mother to go compete in back to back seasons of survivor. Or at least, what I heard.
Yeah that is true
Brenda definitely deserved to be on the favorites tribe
I think Dave Ball would have been an interesting person to consider from Samoa
Too bitter
Super happy to see Edna on the cast. Felt she was stuck in such a bad spot and dealt with Brandon's bullying in SoPa really well. She stuck to Coach really well, though there is no way she breaks that tightknit group of 5.
Who did Brandon bully in SoPa? He seemed like a nice kid there
@@user-we9xr8tx2m his treatment of edna and mikaela was pretty messed up. He uses religion to justify it but it's still messed up
You should do a top 10 favorite survivor characters. Not necessarily the best, just the most entertaining/compelling (the coaches, the tonys, etc)
Coach would just take all 10 spots though 😅
I don't think they'd ever bring Jane back, even at the time. There was a lot of shadiness that occurred when she claimed sash promised her money, etc. She wasn't a fan fave, I'm pretty sure it got rigged
I've been waiting for a Sabrina return forever :/
Sierra said yes to heroes vs villains but she couldn’t go because she was engaged to a producer :)
Another great video! I would love to see a video analyzing each time contestants drew rocks at tribal council and explaining what you think would have happened for each scenario/alternate timeline.
I would have wanted Matty back from Gabon... I’d have forgotten about Kenny to be quite honest.
Crystal cox should of been asked back
I would’ve loved to see Crystal/Susie/Ken from Gabon. Gabon is super underrated
Personally, I would rather burn down my TV set than to watch Philip again
Why he was funny and a good character
@@theman1213he was an annoying brat
loves these videos
You should make a legend video but NO WINNERS
jerri, andrea, aubry, ciera, danielle, cirie, amanda, jenna, eliza, wentworth
ozzy, rupert, malcolm, brad, colby, lex, coach, terry, spencer, russell
Dispenser Thats quite literally impossible, if you want real legends you need Tony, Sandra, Rob and Parvati
Michael Revere I like terry but he’s not a legend and Danielle no not really at all
@@sideeswipe yeah I wanted to see what his cast would be without those though. Like a dream cast kinda
Dispenser I guess but that’s not a legends cast if you’re going to exclude winners
My cast would be
1 Natalie
2 Erik
3Corrine
4 Matty
5 Taj
6 Brenda
7 Jane
8 Marty
9 Andrea
10 Ashley
11 Kenny (I forgot earlier)
12 Stephanie
13 Cochran
14 Edna
15 Jim
16 Dawn
17 Sabrina
18 Troyzan
19 Rc
20 Malcom
Ps I am aware this is unrealistic it’s just my favourite
I just simmed this season on BrantSteele and Erik won lol
👍👍
can i have the link please? do you have other season ?
Erick did not win
@@theman1213 in my sim he did. Not irl of course.
@@wordlifeecw he did not win he was out at 5
i have no idea why people think the favorites on caramoan are not favorites
Would you consider giving Amazing Race 24 a good cast? Like an actual all-stars season?
I think Ashley is a better pick than Nat. Ashley wins the game if Rob doesn't win final immunity, and she nearly had 0 votes cast against her the whole season. If this is All Stars I think she's 100% a lock at the time.
I agree, she was the only wrench in Rob's plans all season
I did a Brant Steele sim of this one (altered the characteristics) Malcolm Won in a tie-breaker with Ken with runner up Marty deciding the vote. An epic rock draw is forced in final 6.
I made a Brantsteele sim with this hypothetical season but I substituted Matty in the place of Mike
Tribes
Purple
Andrea
Dawn
Edna
Erik
Jim
Natalie T
Phillip
Sabrina
Fishback
Troyzan
Orange
Brenda
Corrine
Jane
Cochran
Kenny
Malcolm
Marty
Matty
Natalie B
RC
Episode 1
Orange wins reward
Purple wins immunity
Edna finds purple idol
Natalie B finds orange idol
Natalie B voted out 9-1 with idol in her pocket, 1 vote Jane
Episode 2
Purple wins immunity
Brenda finds orange idol
Brenda plays idol on Corrine
5 votes on Corrine none count
Marty 3 votes Jane 1 vote
Episode 3
Purple wins immunity
Kenny finds orange idol
RC voted out 5-3, 3 votes Jane
Episode 4
Purple wins reward
Orange wins immunity
Edna plays her idol negating 1 vote
Dawn voted out 6-3, 3 votes Erik
Episode 5
Orange wins immunity
Fishback finds purple idol
Fishback voted out 5-4 with idol in his pocket, 4 votes Natalie T
Episode 6
Purple wins reward
Orange wins immunity
Troyzan finds purple idol
Sabrina voted out 6-2, 2 votes Natalie T
Episode 7
Tribe Swap
Purple
Erik
Jane
Cochran
Malcolm
Matty
Phillip
Troyzan
Orange
Andrea
Brenda
Corrine
Edna
Jim
Kenny
Natalie T
Orange wins immunity
Matty voted out 6-1, 1 vote Jane
Episode 8
Purple wins reward
Orange wins immunity
3-3 tie between Phillip and Jane
Phillip voted out 3-1 on re-vote
Episode 9
Merge
Andrea
Brenda
Corrine
Edna
Erik
Jane
Jim
Cochran
Kenny
Malcolm
Natalie T
Troyzan
Natalie T wins immunity
6-6 tie between Malcolm and Jim
Jim voted out 6-4 on re-vote
Episode 10
Troyzan wins immunity
Troyzan finds merge idol
Natalie T voted out 6-5, 5 votes Malcolm
Natalie T juror 1
Episode 11
Malcolm wins immunity
Troyzan plays one of his idols (purple) negates 6 votes
Erik voted out 4-0
Erik juror 2
Episode 12
Kenny wins immunity
Troyzan plays merge idol negating 5 votes
Malcolm voted out 4-0
Malcolm juror 3
Episode 13 pt.1
Andrea wins immunity
Edna finds merge idol
Troyzan voted out 7-1, 1 vote Cochran
Troyzan juror 4
Episode 13 pt.2
Kenny wins immunity
Edna plays idol negating 0 votes
Jane voted out 4-3, 3 votes Andrea
Jane juror 5
Episode 14
Brenda wins immunity
Edna finds merge idol
3-3 tie between Kenny and Cochran
Cochran voted out 3-1 on re-vote
Cochran juror 6
Finale pt.1
Edna wins immunity
Kenny plays idol on himself negating 2 votes
Edna doesn’t play her idol
Corrine voted out 3-0
Corrine juror 7
Finale pt.2
Kenny wins immunity
Brenda voted out 3-1, 1 vote Edna
Reunion
Kenny wins 7-1-0
Edna 2nd
Andrea 3rd
Cochran wins fan favorite
Jim should’ve come back by now
I know it wasn't going to happen, but I would've loved to have Tarzan back.
Here’s who makes my cast:
Micronesia
Erik Reichenbach
Natalie Bolton
Gabon
Corinne Kaplan
Kenny Hoang
Tocantins
Stephen Fischbach
Samoa
Laura Morett
Monica Padilla
Natalie White
Nicaragua
Marty Piombo
Fabio Birza
Brenda Lowe
Redemption Island
Andrea Boehlke
Ashley Underwood
Phillip Sheppard
Grant Mattos
South Pacific
John Cochran
Sophie Clarke
One World
Kim Spradlin
Troyzan Robertson
Philippines
Malcolm Freberg
I really want a season of famous athletes and celebs vs famous survivor players. "Fame vs Game"
What about Debbie Beebe
I'd like to see you cast Winners At War if they did it for season 30 and who would have been there instead.
Favorites: Malcolm, arguably Cochran Erik. The Rest: Philip, Brenda, Brandon, Andrea, Dawn, Corinne, Fran
Dawn was a favourite going into the season I’d say. If she wasn’t a favourite of South Pacific who was 😂
@@gavinweaver5242 ozzy, coach, Cochran, Jim, all bigger favorites than dawn
@@gavinweaver5242 dawn was not a favorite
Are you planning to recasting the original All Star
You should do a “What if ____ was a Second Chance season?” This season for the general mold of what Second Chance in the 20’s could’ve looked like
Monica Padilla is a lot of fun, I’m glad she returned in Second Chance.
How do you know all this. Is there a place where CBS tells you who they’ve considered for a future season.
Nicaragua and Gabon should have so many returnees. From Nicaragua Jane/Holly/ and Marty should return
OK, can I just say that I PERSONALLY LOVED JANE ON NIQARAGUA! I feel like nowadays everyone’s hating on her but like why? I know she ain’t a player but neither was Rudy so I just don’t get it!
just had to get that off off my chest😄
Maybe because Rudy was on the first season?
@@memeview2566 Ok firstly, you responding to a 3 year old comment that has five likes is the most relatable thing ever and I love you for it
Christina was in the running for caramoan, surprised she didnt get a mention here
My Cast
The favorites that I kept
Malcolm
Andrea
Brenda
Erik
Philip
Corinne
Cochran
Who I added
Natalie Bolton
Bob
Kenny
Stephen
Monica
Fabio
Marty
Natalie
Sophie
Jim Rice
Kim
Sabrina
Troyzan
RC
I think Marty piombo will be on a second chance season I don’t know for sure however I think it is likely I don’t think Francesca really makes the cut because she was the first boot now that I think of it I would like to see Jim rice back idk how likely it is now though he was playing hard probst & production really liked him I think he was going to be on blood vs water however eventually him & his wife were not able to participate & had to decline I personally don’t think Jane bright from Nicaragua or Edna ma or rc really make the cut for me either however if Francesca was not on this cast she would not have earned her spot in survivor history as the first person voted out twice
Definitely like the cast
Wait, how did production love Ciera if BvW was her first season?
From her audition I’m guessing
@@edalive9739 yeah i guess so.
Matt on redemption island is a great actor
Plz do Winners at War recasting
Ok give my girl Sarah Dawson a chance. I loved her on Philippines 🇵🇭
You should do what if blood vs water was an all star season
By the way I think Brett should come back from Samoa
I think I saw that Brett clouser from Samoa declined second chance
Surprised you didn't put Albert in here, he was a great character from South Pacific.
Jane is my least favorite player ever, they definitely rigged the fan favorite award so she can win because I’ve never heard anyone say they liked her. Holly should have won in my opinion because winners can’t win the award and she was the second best person on the season behind Fabio.
jane queen love her
I was a little younger and i havent rewatched Nicaragua so i’m not sure. But I remember absolutely loving Jane.
winners can win. rob, kim, and jt all won fan favorite
@@nizzle428 I knew they won but some season they said online that they couldn’t win
I honestly really liked her
Still waiting for fallen angels ranking...
He said it might be the first video in January
If Caramoan Was An All Stars Season, I Would Have Cast These 20 Players:
1. Alexis Jones
2. Erik Reichenbach
3. Natalie Bolton
4. Corinne Kaplan
5. Matty Whitmore
6. Brendan Synnott
7. Stephen Fischbach
8. Dave Ball
9. Brett Clouser
10. Brenda Lowe
11. Chase Rice
12. Francesca Hogi
13. Andrea Boehlke
14. Dawn Meehan
15. Rick Nelson
16. Sophie Clarke
17. Michael Jefferson
18. Sabrina Thompson
19. Dana Lambert
20. Malcolm Freberg
Hell’s Kitchen season ranking?
Has Merainian watched Hell's kitchen? That would be pretty cool to see if he does
I don't think he's ever done a video about it.
@@isaakberghe837 i know
YESSSS
My picks from each season (one of each gender from each season)
Micronesia: Erik and Natalie
Gabon: Kenny and Crystal
Tocantins: Sierra and Brendan (with the knowledge that fishbach makes Cambodia)
Samoa: Jaison and Laura
Nicaragua: Holly and Tyrone
Redemption island: Ralph (or Steve) and Stephanie
South Pacific: Brandon and Whitney (kinda stretching it with interesting non winning females from that season)
One world: Troyzan and Kat
Philippines: abi Maria and Malcolm
You should recast big brother 14 as AllStars 2
Ik this is like a year late but I made an intro with this cast💀
My Cast:
Women:
Natalie
Corinne
Brenda
Jane
Andrea
Natalie
Christine
Edna
Sabrina
Abi-maria
Men:
Erik
Ken
Stephen
Marty
Phillip
Mike
John
Jim
Troyzan
Malcolm
Huh, the original favorites minus Brandon and Francesca. Accurate
An All Star season without winners? What?? Did I miss you saying why you weren't including them?
The lack of Stacey 😢
You should do more season player rankings! Doesn’t have to be all 20, could just be top 5 players per season
Would have been nice to see Chet back from fans vs favorites
Honestly if there is a legends season I would love to see Francesca on it.
finally justice for edna
It would have been cool to see kenny play again but it probably won't happe at this point
2nd Chance: 24 Players
Red Tribe
Dom (36)
Chrissy (35l
Davie (37)
Victoria 38
Devens 38
Angelina 37
Michael Yerger 36
Lauren Beck 39
Jamal 39
Figgy 33
Devon 35
Anna Khait 32
Blue Tribe
Wardog 38
Noura 39
Christian 37
Lauren O'Connell 38
Dean 39
Mama C 30
Jay 33
Ali Eliot 35
Donathan 36
Julia Sokolowski 32
Joe Mena 35
R.C 25
this cast seems so boring predictable lol, I only really like julia rc and ali
Dom is predictable? Noura? Devon? Jamal? Joe Mena? Rick Devens? DK Chillin? Jay? WARDOG? They're all so predictable
@@brendanfechter4889 i'm not saying their predictable on their own, but the casting choices are so predictable
@@brendanfechter4889 not to mention R.C is the only person here under season 30, and she's season 25
I’d love to see Victoria back she was arguably the best player of that season
Natalie Tenerelli the 🐐
“ferdagame”
DEBBIE was called for Caramoan
Fincher and Monica Padilla are my underrated picks
They trade Holly for Dawn.....Holly is a way better
MASTER CHEF WINNER RANKING.
you can rank the worst playrs
I am little sad. Why is not here Jay from season 24. He is such a good character.
I agree, so underrated and very good-looking as a bonus
ummm Natalie? no. I thought this is viewers choice e.i. favorites. not productions
My ideal cast would be:
Males - Erik, Ken, Ace, Stephen, Fabio, Marty, Philip, Cochran, Malcolm, Jeff
Females - Natalie B, Tracy, Corinne, Holly, Brenda, Andrea, Sophie, Kim, Denise, Sabrina
WHERES CRYSTALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
This dude needs to stop hyping up Jim rice. He did nothing be a complete ass and sleezball throughout the entire season and couldn’t even get over his big ego to have any human decency for Cochran, and the fact that this dude likes him so much is just mind blowing and obnoxious
I would rather David, than mike
Christine robbed from the cast
My cast if Caramoan was All Stars 2:
*Bikal:*
Stacey Powell
Angie Layton
Stephanie Valencia
Jane Bright
Crystal Cox
Dave Ball
Stephen Fishbach
Matty Whitmore
Phillip Shepard
Malcolm Freberg
*Gota:*
Erik Reichenbach
Natalie Bolton
Sandy Burgin
Betsy Bolan
Sash Lenahan
John Cochran
Tarzan Smith
Chelsea Meissner
Jim Rice
Francesca Hogi
e
Cochran still wins though
....ok.
I mean this is a very boring cast to me IMO. Jane and Edna are horrendous picks, Natalie T did nothing on her season and I would love to see some premergers on this cast tbh, here would be my personal semi realistic cast
MICRONESIA
Tracy Hughes Wolf : Underrated queen, she nearly dethroned Ozzy
Erik Reichenbacher : I wanna give individual immunity to Natalie
Natalie Bolton : Got Erik to GIVE UP immunity, was a black widow and the last fan standing
GABON
Ace : One of the funniest pre merge villains of all time, was in the running for heroes vs villains no reason for him not to come back in a season like this.
Marcus Lehman : One of the most underrated players, one thing goes differently for him that season and he potentially wins that game. I really want to see him play again!
Corrine Kaplan : Queen!
TOCANTINS
Stephen Fishbach : I am still reeling at the fact that they picked BRANDON HANTZ over Fishbach like whatt
NICARAGUA
Brenda Lowe : She implemented the Parvati strategy and it worked!
Jud 'Fabio' Birza : Honestly, does not get enough credit for his game!
REDEMPTION ISLAND
Francesca Hogi : I think she was a really iconic first boot IMO I never understood why a first boot cannot be a favorite if they are well liked?
Stephanie Valencia : She was strong and fiesty and opinionated, not afraid to let people talk about her.
Andrea Boehlke : She had a great story that season warranting a return
Phillip Sheppard : Was going to come back anyway, might as well throw in Francesca in there for some drama
SOUTH PACIFIC
Christine : This is kind of a wild pick, but I have always loved Christine, I mean she fought soo hard in those duels and was a surprising challenge beast!
Jim Brice : REALLY fun character and reckless player. Love to ya buddy!
John Cochran : His flip at the merge was iconic!
Sophie Clarke : Idk if she comes back at this point but she would really be a great pick!
PHILLIPINES
Pete Yurkowski : An honestly underrated fun villain catalyzing the Abi -RC drama, could be a breakout star this season
Abi Maria Gomez : I think RC in this timeline, is still going to BvW so we need our brazilian bombshell!
Malcolm Fredberg : Do I even need to explain this pick?
So yeahh that's my group of 20. I think especially in this era, there are some great female pre mergers that should be given a second shot, and I like this cast more because it adds more diversity in the people being chosen. Not everyone just you know...made it far in the game, there are genuine stories of redemption!
I’m commenting before the video, but if ur abt to tell me Cochran wasn’t a favorite, you’d be wrong and a liar
Huh? Nobody liked him back then
@@BC-fx2yt Well I've always liked him
Early
First