My cast is Reynold (Caramonan) Hayden (Blood vs Water) Trish (Cagayan) Jon (San Juan Del Sur) Carolyn (World’s Apart) Jaoquin (World’s Apart) Cydney (Koah Rong) David (MvGX) Lauren (HvHvH) Chrissy (HvHvH)
I always wondered if Edge of Extinction returnees (Joe, Wentworth, David, Aubry) were originally called for Fans vs Favorites 3, but because they couldn’t get a few more people, they elected to go with Ghost Island and bring back the four later
Love this idea, and would totally want to see this, but this idea would take sooooooo long. I mean, if anyone would take on this challenge I know TheMeranianReview would, but its kinda a stretch. It would probably take like 4 separate videos, each like an hour long, which I would totally watch, but it would definitely be a monster of a challenge to put together.
Loved the video. Now that Survivor 45 is airing you should cast 46 likes it’s fans vs favorites. You could just go through the 46 cast and pick who you think would be entertaining
Excellent list, but you would have gotten a thumbs up just for including Baylor! The absolutely QUEEN of outlasting, she got at least one vote at almost every tribal she attended - including one from her own alliance (right Josh?) at her very first TC! #YayBaylor
If we're going by typical casting for Fans vs. Favorites, Spencer, Malcolm, Aubry, and Michaela wouldn't be included because they had played more than once by that point.
I loved this season honestly, I wouldn't change a thing. Dom vs Chris, Dom and Wendell's (Were gonna probably have to kill each other since we both are the biggest targets but we also need each other)
My Cast: Fans: Stephanie J. Morgan Libby Jenna Desiree Chris Donathan Jacob Brendan Michael Favs: Hali Worlds Apart Jenn Worlds Apart Katie Blood vs. Water Marissa Blood vs. Water RC Phillipines Rodney Worlds Apart Hayden Blood vs. Water Pete Phillipines Chase Nicaragua Reynold Caramoan Alternates/Replacements: Dominic Bradley Kellyn James Eddie Caramoan Holly Nicaragua Naonka Nicaragua Jeff Phillipines LJ Cagayan Morgan Cagayan Garrett Cagayan Jaclyn SJDS Baylor SJDS Wes SJDS Julie SJDS Reed SJDS Jon SJDS Joaquin Worlds Apart Carolyn Worlds apart Scott Kaoh Rong Nick Kaoh Rong Cydney Kaoh Rong Rachel MvsGX Cece MvsGX Mari MvsGX Ken MvsGX Jessica MvsGX Michelle MvsGX Joe HHH Cole HHH JP HHH Desi HHH Jessica HHH Alan HHH Alli HHH
Fans: Sebastian Domenick Wendell Jacob Michael Kellyn Libby Laurel Stephanie J Morgan Favorites: Carolyn Crissy Lauren Michaela Figgy Joe David Hayden Jay Brad
Here’s who I would have put on the favorites tribe Blood vs Water John Cody Cagayan Alexis Maxwell San Juan Del Sir Jon Misch Worlds Apart Carolyn Rivera Koah Rong Cydnee Gillon M vs G Jay Starrett David Wright Hannah Shapiro H vs H vs H Lauren Rimmer Alan Ball
Nothing is coming up in an online search or a news search, and I’ve even resorted to-ugh-reading his Tweets. Nothing noteworthy there either. Usually when one of these people goes crazy, those searches will uncover the details, but it seems he’s pretty invisible as far as I can tell. That being said, he’s no favorite of mine. I never cared for him. If he never appears again I won’t complain.
Is it weird that I liked the fans tribe of this one more than the favorites? Think it really shows that the Fans vs Favorites twist can only be done well if you actually have a couple of great names.
My Cast Would Have Been Fans Stephanie J Libby Laurel Kellyn Morgan Wendell Domenick Chris Michael Donathan Favorites Reynold (26) Hayden (27) LJ (28) Josh (29) Jay (33) Trish (28) Jaclyn (29) Carolyn (30) Cydney (32) Chrissy (35)
I really think production was planning this for a fans vs favorites but took the game changer idea instead and at that point most of their picks were already taken
Развлечения
Normally I’d be upset if a season lost half its players but with ghost island I can’t remember like three quarters of the players so bring it on!
Video idea: Do a run down of every contestant on Survivor 41 and talk about their likelihood to return
He will probably do that during his season review once it’s over
Shan will return. Xander, Deshawn, Ricard, Evvie, and Tiffany are very likely JD has a chance Liana, and Sarah can be wtf returnees
@@justinpascal8332 liana seems like a case of we couldn’t get Shan so we’ll get her friend
What I would give to see Jay Starrett on Survivor again.
My cast is
Reynold (Caramonan)
Hayden (Blood vs Water)
Trish (Cagayan)
Jon (San Juan Del Sur)
Carolyn (World’s Apart)
Jaoquin (World’s Apart)
Cydney (Koah Rong)
David (MvGX)
Lauren (HvHvH)
Chrissy (HvHvH)
I always wondered if Edge of Extinction returnees (Joe, Wentworth, David, Aubry) were originally called for Fans vs Favorites 3, but because they couldn’t get a few more people, they elected to go with Ghost Island and bring back the four later
Biggest issue with this theory is everyone but David already playing once before. FvF has been second time players only
@@robbygoldman2846 Fair point.
@@robbygoldman2846 seasons 37 aired before extinction so David had only played once at that point.
@@ijitonline6439 yeah that’s the point I made. Everyone EXCEPT David had played twice
@@robbygoldman2846 ok gotcha. I didn't realize that til just now. Crazy that three of the 4 were on their 3rd time..
Video idea: do a ranking of every 1-time player in survivor history. You can even make it separate parts if you have to
Love this idea, and would totally want to see this, but this idea would take sooooooo long. I mean, if anyone would take on this challenge I know TheMeranianReview would, but its kinda a stretch. It would probably take like 4 separate videos, each like an hour long, which I would totally watch, but it would definitely be a monster of a challenge to put together.
YAAAASSSS keep the random videos coming
This makes me want a video ranking every noobie cast lmao.
I'm shocked you left Brendan out when arguably his biggest storyline was how long he applied for to finally get on.
Well guess he's gotta wait again!
Loved the video. Now that Survivor 45 is airing you should cast 46 likes it’s fans vs favorites. You could just go through the 46 cast and pick who you think would be entertaining
My Favorites:
Hayden (27)
LJ (28)
Baylor (29)
Carolyn (30)
Rodney (30)
Cydney (32)
Jay (33)
Figgy (33)
Mike (35)
Chrissy (35)
Excellent list, but you would have gotten a thumbs up just for including Baylor! The absolutely QUEEN of outlasting, she got at least one vote at almost every tribal she attended - including one from her own alliance (right Josh?) at her very first TC! #YayBaylor
Rodney! Would be awesome to see him return. I couldn't stand him but watching his demise was amazing.
I was thinking about this idea!!!
It would be a funny idea to do this for season 06 as well
Michelle instead of Figgy? A huge loss. Michelle might not have been a fan favourite after MvGenX but she would do incredibly well in FvF.
13:55 it’s cause production thought it would be a third chance since he already got on and won big brother and was on bvw.
So many times saying “not necessarily a favorite.” That’s most of the picks from Caramoan.
Could you do what if Big Brother 14 was All Stars 2?!?!?
i can't handle chris being gone sorry
Here is an idea for new top 10s.
Survivor/BB - Top 10 Social Players
Survivor/BB - Top 10 Strategic Players
Survivor/BB- Top 10 Physical Players
Just wanna say, having met J’Tia, she’s amazing and stunning and ready to go back out!
I would have Brice, Jay, Malcolm, Reed, Spencer, Aubrey, Carolyn, Michaela, Missy, and Hannah as my favorites
If we're going by typical casting for Fans vs. Favorites, Spencer, Malcolm, Aubry, and Michaela wouldn't be included because they had played more than once by that point.
I loved this season honestly, I wouldn't change a thing. Dom vs Chris, Dom and Wendell's (Were gonna probably have to kill each other since we both are the biggest targets but we also need each other)
favs:
reynold s26
hayden s27
jay s33
david s33
devon s35
trish s28
jaclyn s29
carolyn s30
cydney s32
chrissy s35
They should bring Erik back for every fans favs season
Best fan tribe ever?!?
Ngl… this is an awesome cast
I forgot half of this cast existed
I’m sorry but in what world would figgy or j’tia be on the favorites tribe
Very true. This list is garbage. The only good fan picks were Jay, David, Carolyn, and maybe Josh.
I'd go:
Hayden (S27)
Brice (S28)
Jacyln (S29)
Rodney (S30)
Carolyn (S30)
Cydney (S32)
Jay (S33)
David (S33)
Ali (S35)
Lauren (S35)
Now do ''what if Amazon was fans vs favorites''
Are Brendan and Hannah related?
Me: thinking the two returnees are chrissy and Devon
■Lauren and joe■
¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?
My Cast:
Fans:
Stephanie J.
Morgan
Libby
Jenna
Desiree
Chris
Donathan
Jacob
Brendan
Michael
Favs:
Hali Worlds Apart
Jenn Worlds Apart
Katie Blood vs. Water
Marissa Blood vs. Water
RC Phillipines
Rodney Worlds Apart
Hayden Blood vs. Water
Pete Phillipines
Chase Nicaragua
Reynold Caramoan
Alternates/Replacements:
Dominic
Bradley
Kellyn
James
Eddie Caramoan
Holly Nicaragua
Naonka Nicaragua
Jeff Phillipines
LJ Cagayan
Morgan Cagayan
Garrett Cagayan
Jaclyn SJDS
Baylor SJDS
Wes SJDS
Julie SJDS
Reed SJDS
Jon SJDS
Joaquin Worlds Apart
Carolyn Worlds apart
Scott Kaoh Rong
Nick Kaoh Rong
Cydney Kaoh Rong
Rachel MvsGX
Cece MvsGX
Mari MvsGX
Ken MvsGX
Jessica MvsGX
Michelle MvsGX
Joe HHH
Cole HHH
JP HHH
Desi HHH
Jessica HHH
Alan HHH
Alli HHH
Its a ok sea base i love you
I never understood what the problem was with reynold
Why is Hayden a controversial figure?
Fans:
Sebastian
Domenick
Wendell
Jacob
Michael
Kellyn
Libby
Laurel
Stephanie J
Morgan
Favorites:
Carolyn
Crissy
Lauren
Michaela
Figgy
Joe
David
Hayden
Jay
Brad
Here’s who I would have put on the favorites tribe
Blood vs Water
John Cody
Cagayan
Alexis Maxwell
San Juan Del Sir
Jon Misch
Worlds Apart
Carolyn Rivera
Koah Rong
Cydnee Gillon
M vs G
Jay Starrett
David Wright
Hannah Shapiro
H vs H vs H
Lauren Rimmer
Alan Ball
Beside losing Bradley and Brendan and also putting in two premergers, love this cast.
I love Joe Mena
Why is Hayden Controversial
13:28 What is he talking about, what’s Hayden do or was it about Kat.
Nothing is coming up in an online search or a news search, and I’ve even resorted to-ugh-reading his Tweets. Nothing noteworthy there either. Usually when one of these people goes crazy, those searches will uncover the details, but it seems he’s pretty invisible as far as I can tell.
That being said, he’s no favorite of mine. I never cared for him. If he never appears again I won’t complain.
It’s because he’s a trump supporter pretty sure
@@fishtailsauce Eww!
@@fishtailsauce source, like was it on Twitter or a Reddit thing
@@iamkonner4813 I say just look through Reddit threads and search up his name I don’t really know every detail lol but it’s decently bad
Nicer
Is it weird that I liked the fans tribe of this one more than the favorites? Think it really shows that the Fans vs Favorites twist can only be done well if you actually have a couple of great names.
,💗
Bruh Bradley should be on
if Survivor: Winners at War really were men vs. women
I want Hayden back so badly!
My Cast Would Have Been
Fans
Stephanie J
Libby
Laurel
Kellyn
Morgan
Wendell
Domenick
Chris
Michael
Donathan
Favorites
Reynold (26)
Hayden (27)
LJ (28)
Josh (29)
Jay (33)
Trish (28)
Jaclyn (29)
Carolyn (30)
Cydney (32)
Chrissy (35)
The Ashley Nolan erasure 💔💔💔💔
I would have Trish over J'Tia
Why is hayden controversial?
Why is Hayden controversial?
I really think production was planning this for a fans vs favorites but took the game changer idea instead and at that point most of their picks were already taken
jenna was robbed
What if Survivor 40 was heroes vs villains 2
Michael
Wendell
Donathan
Chris
James
Kelly
Libby
Stephenie
Laurel
Morgan
I'm really not a fan of this female cast. Really really weak to be honest aside from Carolyn and Cydney