I just rewatched Pearl Islands and Sandra had a much better relationship with Jon than I remembered. They fought a few times but also worked together numerous times after the merge, plus they’re both Drake, so I definitely believe she votes Jon
@@riangiar1448 It was confirmed the Reunion poll was a lie that the cast agreed to fake Lil winning so she wouldn't cry and cause a scene again. Sandra confirmed in interviews many times she votes Fairplay over Lil easily. Reunion polls are always bull anyway, and only dumb people don't realize that.
Todd has gone on record in a reddit AMA saying he would've voted Courtney over Amanda and Denise and that Courtney would've won cause the jury favored her a lot more than the edit showed.
yeah courtney wins 100%, like coming into that ftc in the original season, if there was no ftc at the jurors just voted, i think it ends up being a 3-2-2 courtney wins
@@randomyoutuber0524 Exactly, the season they aired is the way it is because Todd is the winner. Had he been cut, we would've probably had much more Courtney content but since she's just the runner-up they probably didn't think it was necessary to show her too much. That's what Survivor fans always forget about, that the edited season is really just a fraction of what happened out there. F.e. we don't see anything of Heather in 41 because they edited her out and so we think she's an obvious goat to take to the end, but for the people on the show they see just as much of Heather as they do anyone else on the island so maybe she was making moves the entire game that we don't get to see because she's not the winner of the season.
For the Blood vs Water scenario. Gervase has said post-season that he thought Tyson was viewed as the seasons biggest villain and - having seen Russell Hantz lose the game twice, seeing Coach lose the game and seeing Chase lose the game all in relatively quick succession - so he thought Tyson was a goat because the jury would be bitter hence why I think he'd vote out Monica over Tyson.
Omg Tina being the first perfect game and also the First two time Winner. There is a slight chance to Tai be the other one. Tony and Sandra still would've won their all stars seasons, but became the last juror of their original season.
@@Blackinfernape Well Sandra does comeback for Heroes vs Villian, so there a chance she win that season, and maybe her not winning gives her a advantages of being even more under the radar but that such my opinion. (Also I know that this was 2 years so)
HvV: “Colby votes for Jerri” what an ending to a 3 season storyline. Colby votes for the girl he voted out season 2 and who got revenge on him in all stars. Nicaragua: would Fabio throw a vote at Holly for laughs? Koah Rong: that would be the first every final 3 where everyone gets multiple votes right?
Fabio has openly said he 100% for sure votes Chase in a Chase/Holly/Sash final 3 for sure. The Benry/Fabio/Chase trio were very close, even though both were closer to Benry than each other, and both Fabio and Benry got butthurt over Chase continually picking the women for food rewards over him.
The China final tribal had a massive impact on who got the votes. Both Courtney and Todd had fantastic final tribals, and Amanda’s final tribal was terrible, I don’t think Amanda wins no matter who she’s sitting next to, her final tribal was actually terrible.
@@landonweaver1040 I don’t think Russell’s was terrible, I just thinks he’s not an ass kisser lol so his pride is gonna get in the way. Whereas Amanda is trying to ass kiss and she still messes up lol
3:32 Jan somehow wins immunity lol. I will say I doubt Helen would vote for her considering she would have killed her and herself on that boat if she had a gun. It's why she never carries a gun.
Maybe she thinks Spencer is a bigger jury threat. Remember players often are clueless to how jurors are really thinking. Russell though Sandra was a goat, and Jerri and Parvati were both much bigger jury threats.
@@JonnieMayer17 Maybe she thought Spencer was the bigger jury threat. Remember they don't have Ponderosa footage or anything. We have seen some massive misreads before.
@@zacharygoldman2539 agreed, imo, jury honestly wasn’t incredibly bitter and she is an attorney which appealing to a jury, sounds pretty familiar to kass...
Spencer said on the show that if they kept Wentworth over him (leading to a Jeremy, Wentworth, Tasha final 3) that he would've done the same thing he did in Cagayan and convince everyone to vote for Wentworth. I think Spencer really saw him beating Jeremy in the end, and to be fair it should not have been a Jeremy sweep.
I’m pretty sure savage said he would have voted for Kelley to win over Jeremy so she wins anyway without Joe’s vote but honestly I still think she gets Joe’s vote anyway winning 7-3
@@sethbryant5539 Savage was pissed at Jeremy over how he treated Kimmi at the Final 6. The only reason he still voted Jeremy is he knew Tasha had no chance, and since he was even more annoyed at how Spencer acted towards both Jeremy and Kelley at the Final 4 tribal.
I'm 90% sure if Wentworth wins Cambodia if she makes the end. Ok not to take away from Michele's win in Kaoh Rong but HOLY SHIT Would the hypothetical Aubry/Cydney/Tai F3 been amazing (I've made it clear on REddit I'm in the "Aubry should have won camp" but I'd been fine with Cydney winning)
Imagine if Tony plays a perfect game in winners at war if Sarah wins final immunity and takes him to the end with Michele winning fire. He would then have played the best game ever, no questions asked. No one would top that lol
@@KevinGetchell Tony did not have a target on his back coming into Winners at War, especially after how terrible he did on Gamechangers, now was he a big threat to win coming into Winners at War? heck yeah... there's a difference between a big threat and a big target, people mistakenly conflate the two a lot.
What makes you think Jenna would've taken Rob and not Amber to final 2? Seems more logical to me that she 'd take Amber knowing she just rode Rob's coattails...
@Raheem Fielder-Bey But she knows she beats Amber for sure. Like there is no chance she could lose to Amber or even come close to losing to Amber. Lex, Alicia, Tom, Kathy, and Rupert are 100% locked to vote Jenna over Amber, so her worst case is a 5-2 win. While there is a chance she loses to Rob 4-3 if Kathy, Rupert (due to being bitter at Jenna for voting him out), Amber, Shi Ann somehow all vote Rob. So taking Rob over Amber would actually be dumb when there isn't even a chance she could lose to Amber or even win only 4-3 over Amber.
I disagree with the idea of Jenna Lewis taking Boston Rob. She was a player that season and always saw that Rob was the much more strategically savvy player between him and Amber. So, I definitely think she takes that opportunity to take Amber to the end with her.
@Hampton Brooks I don't remember her saying that at all near the end so maybe she did. I haven't bothered watching that garbage season in a while cuz I don't like to waste my time. However, knowing Jenna that season I still lean towards her player mindset taking priority there and she votes Rob out.
@@kellydaunis Oof I mean to each their own lol. I'd just rather watch a season that's not unbelievably boring and not plagued with ugliness from what used to be great characters.
It seems clear from this and the final boots video that this person thinks the only person in the Ometepe 6 alliance (Rob, Ashley, Andrea, Phillip, Natalie T) that Rob would have lost a jury vote to is Grant. That he leans to him winning over Ashley, and strongly thinks he beats Andrea. I am not sure if I neccessarily agree on that. I agree Grant is the biggest jury threat of the Ometepe 6, but not sure if Rob beats anyone but Phillip or Natalie T. Still it is refreshing to hear a different opinion from the consensus one that Rob for sure loses to everyone but Phillip or Natalie T. I would laugh if anyone made a video that Phillip or Natalie T beat anyone else though, that would kill me.
How would different seasons or players have been edited if the boot order were different? I wonder if Fairplay, for example, would have had a more forgiving edit if he had won.
The ghost island one isn’t as simple, even in the regular scenario Angela votes for Wendell, so what would make her change her vote now? Laurel and donathan also probably should’ve voted Dom in theory but they didn’t. I think Wendell still wins.
@@sethbryant5539 honestly Angela seems like such a nonentity in ghost island I hadn’t considered the fact that she could feel emotions such as bitterness
basically the entire jury said they wouldve voted for fairplay. even rupert and sandra wouldve voted fairplay over lil because she didnt play the full 39 days
This has probably been requested before but I’d like to see a video on your ranking of final tribal council performances, either by the winners or just in general :)
21:23 Actually in an interview with I think entertainment weekly, Kass said she would have taken Tony to the end. I don't think that's the case in the moment but if it did, Tony wins against Kass I assume.
I could've sworn I saw somewhere that Fishbach would've voted for Wentworth, and also seeing the general reaction of the jury when she goes home makes me think that she wins no matter what.
Purple Kelly, Naonka, Alina would all be locked votes for Holly in a Holly-Chase-Sash F3. I think Marty probably votes Holly since he knows Sash has no shot to win. It depends if Holly can somehow pull Dan who hated all 3 of Holly, Dan, Sash, or possibly Brenda, more likely Dan. You are wrong that it is between Sash and Chase. It is really between Holly and Chase.
Thank you. I knew he would. The guy who owns this channel has his head so far up Lex's rear end, that he can't see straight. I wrote a comment on here saying that Ethan would have won. Actually, the only person that could have possibly beat Ethan happens to be T-Bird.
Bruce would never vote for anyone other than Danielle, no matter who's in final 2. im pretty sure he raised TWO hands for Danielle at the hypothesised Terry/Danielle final 2 at the S12 reunion
Now that Survivor 41 is over Heather wins immunity miraculously and the answer is pretty obvious. Heather takes Erika, leaving Deshawn and Xander in fire. If Xander wins he probably stays a zero vote finalist and if deshawn wins he still probably only gets one vote at most. Heather either gets zero votes or Ricard's vote and maybe 1 or 2 more due to Ricard campaigning for her but either way Erika still easily wins.
Christina has flat out said many times she was 100% targetting Kim if she won final immunity. I imagine she can atleast get Kim to make fire. Sabrina in that scenario I see atleast siding with Christina to try just as an act of self preservation, knowing how close Chelsea and Kim are. Chelsea would either force fire or outright vote Kim out (if she is actually trying to win the game she votes Kim out, although she probably loses to Sabrina anyway).
If Yau-Man won Final Immunity, he would have won because Jeff asked the jurors how they would have voted if Yau-Man was in the Final Tribal Council. I think in China, I think Denise would have won instead of Amanda because Denise in part would have delivered a compelling Final Tribal Council argument that she would have needed the money the most.
The fabled Devon/Chrissy/Ryan is easy: Desi:Devon. Cole:Devon. JP:Chrissy Joe:Ryan Lauren:Devon Ashley:Devon Mike:Chrissy Ben:Devon. Devon wins the same margin Ben won, with some votes shifted around. Chrissy just didnt connect enough and Ryan was seen as lazy. And Devon can articulate his game with Ash Lauren and Ben to back him up.
Did you really say Scot & Jason vote for Tai in Kaoh Rong!? Did you not hear their final speeches and how everyone thought Tai flip flopped all over the place? Tai literally betrayed both of them that led to both being voted out. They probably would still be bitter at Cydney too so they vote Aubry.
Eddie probably gets a lot of credit from the fans tribe. Eddie almost for sure gets Brenda Reynold and Malcom. Could also snag Andrea’s vote bc they seemed somewhat close in the edit, as well as even Michael’s vote
Keith easily wins SJDS as long as nat is gone because Baylor Wes and Jon are obviously gonna vote for there loved ones so that leaves 5 votes where 3 of them easily go to Keith
You forgot to mention in game changers jeff asked the jury what they would do with Tai vs Brad. Brad came out ahead in a tie with Troy's tiebreaking vote. Ofcourse that doesnt mean it would have happened that way but worth a note.
Using the Survivor Sucks analogy Rudy gets bamboozled in All Stars Mama Kim, Neleh, and Shiianne take out Keith and Lex and then save Amber over Jerri before Boston Rob breaks his word. Sandra quits FvF, Cirie takes out Dreamz and Becky. Cirie takes Parv over Denise(China) to final two Johnny Fairplay becomes the first two time winner beating Cirie Fields and Russell Hantz in HvV. Spencer and Woo take out Kass in SC.
I think for the hypothetical F3's you're biased in favor of all 3 players getting votes, period. A lot of the votes you're assuming are "locks" probably aren't, in the context of jury members wanting to vote their second-preference over "wasting" their vote on a lost cause. You're forgetting how much discussion happens behind the scenes at Ponderosa, and it is VERY common for one jury vote to decide between A or B winning. Meanwhile, the closest we've ever had to a "split Jury" (3-2-2 or 4-3-3) was Todd winning 4-2-1 (the 3rd F3 EVER, over a decade ago), and the closest thing since was Natalie winning 5-2-1 that's with the two others having super-locked votes from their loved ones.
Why are you so sure Lauren takes Tommy? Yes, they were allies most of the game, but I think Lauren could see the threat Tommy was. I think she takes Noura, and makes Tommy and Dean square off.
Do Survivor: What if every season had EOE (but not with fire tokens like 40 that's too many variables to predict) Who comes back at merge? At final 6? Alan Ball and Stephanie Gonzalez could re enter at their merge, how does this change the post merge? Chris Noble comes back at final 5 and suddenly Chris-Donathan-Angela could potentially thwart Dom-Wendell-Laurel. Woo could return in Cambodia and be utr for a while. Most prolly go right back out but u never know. Michaela comes back in MvGX how wild is that scenario? Malcolm coming back in Gamechangers would make my heart glad bc he was screwed or shit TONY coming back or JT. GC mighta sucked less. Then after Advantagegeddon Ozzy or Caleb probly return and suddenly Tai has a friend. Culpeper had been so nasty to him he'd run right into beastmode cowboys arms and Aubry would be down too. Suddenly Sarah/Brad/Troy aren't in charge. This might be a fun exercise at least for the New School Seasons. Like Brad coming back in Blood Vs. Water, Drew or Rocker or Wentworth in SJDS, shit what if Jon Misch came back 1 round after his final 6 blindside
With your scenarios, Tony doesn't win Cagayan, so he doesn't even make Winners at War. What a completely different season that would have been - and I can't imagine how it could have been nearly as good with Woo in the game instead of Tony.....
If Rudy wins final immunity he takes hatch with him to the end & he wins the game, if Keith wins final immunity I think he takes Colby & he looses by a landslide 7-0 vote I think lex wins I think Kathy wins rob cesternino definitely wins, terry dietz definitely wins cirie definitely wins this is kind of tough with a final 3 to figure out what happens Tina would probably win again in blood vs water & probably would have been on winners at war
@@Lexie-gr9tv oh wow maybe he would have thought he’d have a better chance against Tina Keith still would have been clean swept by either Tina or colby
S35- Ben goes home S36- Wendell or Angela goes home (laurel maybe forces a tie, and angela goes in a firemaking) S37- Kara or Mike goes home (none of those situations matter) S38- Devons goes home S39- Lauren goes home S40- Michele & Natalie vote Tony, Sarah & Tony votes Michele, Michele goes home
@@dezarae3216 he was very cocky and over bearing lol but I really don’t get how people hated Queen Carolyn cause her and Mike were the only good things about the entire season lmao
I don’t feel that Woo’s win is as set in stone. Woo didn’t have much gameplay, so Tony might vote her, Morgan might vote her, and Sarah possibly votes with Tony
Nah. Morgan, Sarah, and Trish all HATED Kass. Kass even said in an AMA that those three women treated her terribly and Ponderosa and said awful things to and about her. Spencer also said Kass had zero chance of winning the game and called her the biggest goat, and said Woo was an idiot for not bringing her over Tony. The votes would probably be: Woo - Tony, Spencer, Trish, Jeremiah, Morgan, Sarah I think there's a potential that Tasha, Jeffra, and possibly LJ could vote for Kass. LJ was pretty bitter towards Tony and Woo turning on him, and Kass said Jeffra was very kind to her, that she and Tasha were both isolated at Ponderosa & sat together on the plane home. But either way, Woo definitely wins
Jeremy goes home Spencer is willing to cut him self preservation and Tasha was close with Spencer I doubt she stick her neck out with Jeremy regardless Kelly probably wins cuz she getting Kass, Ciera, Abi, Keith, Kimmi and probably Joe they have a decent relationship.
I love your "What if" and ranking Survivor videos. Please never stop making them lol.
Sandra has confirmed she would have voted for Fairplay.
I just rewatched Pearl Islands and Sandra had a much better relationship with Jon than I remembered. They fought a few times but also worked together numerous times after the merge, plus they’re both Drake, so I definitely believe she votes Jon
excellent choice if u ask me
No, sandra will vote Lill..you can watched result and reunion
Sandra will vote Lill , because she already said she will screw jon and burton
@@riangiar1448 It was confirmed the Reunion poll was a lie that the cast agreed to fake Lil winning so she wouldn't cry and cause a scene again. Sandra confirmed in interviews many times she votes Fairplay over Lil easily. Reunion polls are always bull anyway, and only dumb people don't realize that.
@@riangiar1448 Are ya dumb. She respected Jon more then Lil.
Todd has gone on record in a reddit AMA saying he would've voted Courtney over Amanda and Denise and that Courtney would've won cause the jury favored her a lot more than the edit showed.
yeah courtney wins 100%, like coming into that ftc in the original season, if there was no ftc at the jurors just voted, i think it ends up being a 3-2-2 courtney wins
@Raheem Fielder-Bey the AMA was posted way after the season aired on tv :) let’s not forget that there’s a lot left out of the edit each episode
@@randomyoutuber0524 Exactly, the season they aired is the way it is because Todd is the winner. Had he been cut, we would've probably had much more Courtney content but since she's just the runner-up they probably didn't think it was necessary to show her too much. That's what Survivor fans always forget about, that the edited season is really just a fraction of what happened out there. F.e. we don't see anything of Heather in 41 because they edited her out and so we think she's an obvious goat to take to the end, but for the people on the show they see just as much of Heather as they do anyone else on the island so maybe she was making moves the entire game that we don't get to see because she's not the winner of the season.
Hell, Todd even thought that Courtney had beaten him and Amanda 4-3-0, since he thought she had James/Denise/Erik/Frosti.
For the Blood vs Water scenario.
Gervase has said post-season that he thought Tyson was viewed as the seasons biggest villain and - having seen Russell Hantz lose the game twice, seeing Coach lose the game and seeing Chase lose the game all in relatively quick succession - so he thought Tyson was a goat because the jury would be bitter hence why I think he'd vote out Monica over Tyson.
Another great video. Who would have thought Caramoan turns into one of the more interesting end games in this scenario
Yau-Man wins. That jury LOVED him even during the show. He was the ultimate underdog and that jury gave SO MUCH HATE to Dreamz for that move.
Omg Tina being the first perfect game and also the First two time Winner. There is a slight chance to Tai be the other one. Tony and Sandra still would've won their all stars seasons, but became the last juror of their original season.
Blood vs Water was after Heroes vs Villains. Sandra would have still been the first 2 time winner.
and technically since tony wouldnt have won cagayan, he wouldnt have been eligible for winners at war, and therefore he wouldnt have won that either
@@meredithwhite5790 sandra didn’t win PI in this
@@Blackinfernape I was looking at each season in isolation. not as if they all occurred on the same timeline.
@@Blackinfernape Well Sandra does comeback for Heroes vs Villian, so there a chance she win that season, and maybe her not winning gives her a advantages of being even more under the radar but that such my opinion. (Also I know that this was 2 years so)
HvV: “Colby votes for Jerri” what an ending to a 3 season storyline. Colby votes for the girl he voted out season 2 and who got revenge on him in all stars.
Nicaragua: would Fabio throw a vote at Holly for laughs?
Koah Rong: that would be the first every final 3 where everyone gets multiple votes right?
No all 3 in Worlds Apart got at least 1
@@parkerduncan978 I was thinking at 2 each.
Survivor Sa 5. Graham had 5 Sivu had 3 Buhle had 2
Fabio has openly said he 100% for sure votes Chase in a Chase/Holly/Sash final 3 for sure. The Benry/Fabio/Chase trio were very close, even though both were closer to Benry than each other, and both Fabio and Benry got butthurt over Chase continually picking the women for food rewards over him.
All 3 finalists in china got a vote
The China final tribal had a massive impact on who got the votes. Both Courtney and Todd had fantastic final tribals, and Amanda’s final tribal was terrible, I don’t think Amanda wins no matter who she’s sitting next to, her final tribal was actually terrible.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who was thinking this lol
Amanda would be final two with a ROCK and that rock would STILL win survivor 😆😅😅😂😂😂
@@JonnieMayer17 Amanda, Colby, and Twila have the worst final tribals ever. Russell is close though.
@@landonweaver1040 I think Russell was worse than Twila but I agree with you those 4 were cringe to watch lol
@@landonweaver1040 I don’t think Russell’s was terrible, I just thinks he’s not an ass kisser lol so his pride is gonna get in the way. Whereas Amanda is trying to ass kiss and she still messes up lol
3:32 Jan somehow wins immunity lol. I will say I doubt Helen would vote for her considering she would have killed her and herself on that boat if she had a gun. It's why she never carries a gun.
Tasha literally said she is 10times closer to Spencer then she was Jeremy. Why would she vote Spencer over Jeremy.
Seriously lol like they were from the same original season and were close then, and even closer on cambodia
I know. I really like watching his videos but he needs to rewatch seasons.
Maybe she thinks Spencer is a bigger jury threat. Remember players often are clueless to how jurors are really thinking. Russell though Sandra was a goat, and Jerri and Parvati were both much bigger jury threats.
@@JonnieMayer17 Maybe she thought Spencer was the bigger jury threat. Remember they don't have Ponderosa footage or anything. We have seen some massive misreads before.
You should do a "what if there wasn't any tribe swaps" and go thru the scenarios of if a tribe lost more challenges up to the merge
7:53 Coby was more willing to vote for Ian than Tom
kass actually said she takes tony cause she knew she couldn’t win and she wanted good tv , she said in her ponderosa video
She's said both at various times. She's also adamant that she could've beaten Woo lol.
@@MrBen51309 I think she could beat Woo w a good tribal council
@@zacharygoldman2539 agreed, imo, jury honestly wasn’t incredibly bitter and she is an attorney which appealing to a jury, sounds pretty familiar to kass...
Kass is a notorious troll and not the best source of information. She’ll say whatever she thinks will generate the most noise depending on the day
@@Godwilla39 that’s true, if i’m being honest i’d just love to see kass and woo duke it out in a mock tribal, would be kind of funny!
Spencer said on the show that if they kept Wentworth over him (leading to a Jeremy, Wentworth, Tasha final 3) that he would've done the same thing he did in Cagayan and convince everyone to vote for Wentworth. I think Spencer really saw him beating Jeremy in the end, and to be fair it should not have been a Jeremy sweep.
Spencer maybe could've locked in some votes, but his arrogance and lack of social game started showing again near the end.
It'd be kinda cool if Tina had won BvW and become the second two time winner, though honestly Tyson winning is the best case scenario for this finale.
I’m pretty sure savage said he would have voted for Kelley to win over Jeremy so she wins anyway without Joe’s vote but honestly I still think she gets Joe’s vote anyway winning 7-3
Where did Savage say he would’ve voted for Wentworth? I do think Kelley beats Jeremy and Tasha, but I don’t think she gets Savage’s vote
@@sethbryant5539 Savage was pissed at Jeremy over how he treated Kimmi at the Final 6. The only reason he still voted Jeremy is he knew Tasha had no chance, and since he was even more annoyed at how Spencer acted towards both Jeremy and Kelley at the Final 4 tribal.
@@sethbryant5539 He said it in an exit interview I don’t know where though
I'm 90% sure if Wentworth wins Cambodia if she makes the end.
Ok not to take away from Michele's win in Kaoh Rong but HOLY SHIT Would the hypothetical Aubry/Cydney/Tai F3 been amazing (I've made it clear on REddit I'm in the "Aubry should have won camp" but I'd been fine with Cydney winning)
i saw the title and said wowww that's a cool video idea excited to watch this :)
Imagine if Tony plays a perfect game in winners at war if Sarah wins final immunity and takes him to the end with Michele winning fire. He would then have played the best game ever, no questions asked. No one would top that lol
I still think Tony played a perfect game. He was one of the biggest targets coming into the game yet nobody could execute voting him out
@@KevinGetchell Tony did not have a target on his back coming into Winners at War, especially after how terrible he did on Gamechangers, now was he a big threat to win coming into Winners at War? heck yeah... there's a difference between a big threat and a big target, people mistakenly conflate the two a lot.
What makes you think Jenna would've taken Rob and not Amber to final 2? Seems more logical to me that she 'd take Amber knowing she just rode Rob's coattails...
@Raheem Fielder-Bey She said so on the DVD commentary for All-Stars
@Raheem Fielder-Bey But she knows she beats Amber for sure. Like there is no chance she could lose to Amber or even come close to losing to Amber. Lex, Alicia, Tom, Kathy, and Rupert are 100% locked to vote Jenna over Amber, so her worst case is a 5-2 win. While there is a chance she loses to Rob 4-3 if Kathy, Rupert (due to being bitter at Jenna for voting him out), Amber, Shi Ann somehow all vote Rob. So taking Rob over Amber would actually be dumb when there isn't even a chance she could lose to Amber or even win only 4-3 over Amber.
@Raheem Fielder-Bey The hilarious thing is she almost for sure beats Amber, but might lose to Rob.
She said in the finale that she would've taken Rob
I disagree with the idea of Jenna Lewis taking Boston Rob. She was a player that season and always saw that Rob was the much more strategically savvy player between him and Amber. So, I definitely think she takes that opportunity to take Amber to the end with her.
@Hampton Brooks I don't remember her saying that at all near the end so maybe she did. I haven't bothered watching that garbage season in a while cuz I don't like to waste my time. However, knowing Jenna that season I still lean towards her player mindset taking priority there and she votes Rob out.
@@nelsdanburg5407 All-Stars is one of my favorite seasons.
@@kellydaunis Oof I mean to each their own lol. I'd just rather watch a season that's not unbelievably boring and not plagued with ugliness from what used to be great characters.
It seems clear from this and the final boots video that this person thinks the only person in the Ometepe 6 alliance (Rob, Ashley, Andrea, Phillip, Natalie T) that Rob would have lost a jury vote to is Grant. That he leans to him winning over Ashley, and strongly thinks he beats Andrea. I am not sure if I neccessarily agree on that. I agree Grant is the biggest jury threat of the Ometepe 6, but not sure if Rob beats anyone but Phillip or Natalie T. Still it is refreshing to hear a different opinion from the consensus one that Rob for sure loses to everyone but Phillip or Natalie T. I would laugh if anyone made a video that Phillip or Natalie T beat anyone else though, that would kill me.
I met Janet at Hearts of Reality in December. She told me Tommy would have won against Lauren
@@layla1863 She was really nice and awesome in person. Love that woman
nah maybe she’d vote tommy but lauren would win
Nah it’s either a 6-4 or a 5-5 with Kellee and Jamal being the swing votes
I love this what if videos. You should do some of these with the amazing Race
How would different seasons or players have been edited if the boot order were different? I wonder if Fairplay, for example, would have had a more forgiving edit if he had won.
The ghost island one isn’t as simple, even in the regular scenario Angela votes for Wendell, so what would make her change her vote now? Laurel and donathan also probably should’ve voted Dom in theory but they didn’t. I think Wendell still wins.
Angela wouldn’t be bitter against Dom for putting her in fire, and I bet she votes for Domenick if she is the tie-breaker in the final 3
@@sethbryant5539 honestly Angela seems like such a nonentity in ghost island I hadn’t considered the fact that she could feel emotions such as bitterness
basically the entire jury said they wouldve voted for fairplay. even rupert and sandra wouldve voted fairplay over lil because she didnt play the full 39 days
This has probably been requested before but I’d like to see a video on your ranking of final tribal council performances, either by the winners or just in general :)
U don’t think Holly gets any votes in Nicaragua?
21:23 Actually in an interview with I think entertainment weekly, Kass said she would have taken Tony to the end. I don't think that's the case in the moment but if it did, Tony wins against Kass I assume.
I think in HvV sandra and parvati are smart enough to at least go to fire voting out russel at final 4
I could've sworn I saw somewhere that Fishbach would've voted for Wentworth, and also seeing the general reaction of the jury when she goes home makes me think that she wins no matter what.
fishbach and jeremy were extremely close out there.. and after the idol play where jeremy literally saved him he was 100% loyal to jeremy
You should do best player of the season regardless of who won
Purple Kelly, Naonka, Alina would all be locked votes for Holly in a Holly-Chase-Sash F3. I think Marty probably votes Holly since he knows Sash has no shot to win. It depends if Holly can somehow pull Dan who hated all 3 of Holly, Dan, Sash, or possibly Brenda, more likely Dan. You are wrong that it is between Sash and Chase. It is really between Holly and Chase.
The finale 2 if Rudy and rich would've been my favourite final 2 off all time
The last time I was this early Survivor Borneo just started
16:32 He seemed to hate Sash and Chase, so I would put him as a Holly vote
I think that he votes Sash because in final 6 he switched his vote to Chase to show how he hated him and Holly had drowned his shoes
@That Dude Dan's vote would be fascinating in this Final 3. I think he defaults to Chase, but wow he would have hated voting here.
15:26 Rupert is a locked Sandra vote
8:39 Plus, he told Danni he was okay with being voted out
You should do "ranking survivor seasons based on how bazzare they are" i think it would be interesting
@@frankiecisneros3268 Gabon is definitely number 1
gabon, nicaragua, and panama are the top three
South Pacific or Edge of Extinction would win that. Or CvC1.
South Pacific is creepy, EOE is a Survivor parody, and CvC1 is a weird fever dream
@@jacksonhart5961 it’s crazy how benji had the most confessionals in CvC1, but didn’t get a confessional until like episode 7
Gabon
I think Rob probably loses to Ashley, but I think he has a better shot against Ashley than he did against Grant and probably even Andrea.
T-Bird said Ethan beats Lex. You can ask her yourself
Thank you. I knew he would. The guy who owns this channel has his head so far up Lex's rear end, that he can't see straight. I wrote a comment on here saying that Ethan would have won. Actually, the only person that could have possibly beat Ethan happens to be T-Bird.
Jeff asked Game Changers Jury who would vote who if Sarah got 4th, it was a tie 5-5 with Troyzan then voting BRad
Bruce would never vote for anyone other than Danielle, no matter who's in final 2. im pretty sure he raised TWO hands for Danielle at the hypothesised Terry/Danielle final 2 at the S12 reunion
Now that Survivor 41 is over Heather wins immunity miraculously and the answer is pretty obvious. Heather takes Erika, leaving Deshawn and Xander in fire. If Xander wins he probably stays a zero vote finalist and if deshawn wins he still probably only gets one vote at most. Heather either gets zero votes or Ricard's vote and maybe 1 or 2 more due to Ricard campaigning for her but either way Erika still easily wins.
What about if the first merge boot won immunity?
Kass takes Tony look at her Ponderosa
28:02 *The fire-making challenge. Troyzan had no shot of winning the game against anybody
Christina has flat out said many times she was 100% targetting Kim if she won final immunity. I imagine she can atleast get Kim to make fire. Sabrina in that scenario I see atleast siding with Christina to try just as an act of self preservation, knowing how close Chelsea and Kim are. Chelsea would either force fire or outright vote Kim out (if she is actually trying to win the game she votes Kim out, although she probably loses to Sabrina anyway).
If Yau-Man won Final Immunity, he would have won because Jeff asked the jurors how they would have voted if Yau-Man was in the Final Tribal Council. I think in China, I think Denise would have won instead of Amanda because Denise in part would have delivered a compelling Final Tribal Council argument that she would have needed the money the most.
What if Redemption Island (twist, not season) didn’t exist?
The fabled Devon/Chrissy/Ryan is easy: Desi:Devon. Cole:Devon. JP:Chrissy Joe:Ryan Lauren:Devon Ashley:Devon Mike:Chrissy Ben:Devon. Devon wins the same margin Ben won, with some votes shifted around. Chrissy just didnt connect enough and Ryan was seen as lazy. And Devon can articulate his game with Ash Lauren and Ben to back him up.
Did you really say Scot & Jason vote for Tai in Kaoh Rong!? Did you not hear their final speeches and how everyone thought Tai flip flopped all over the place? Tai literally betrayed both of them that led to both being voted out. They probably would still be bitter at Cydney too so they vote Aubry.
I feel like Sarah would look out for her own game and force Natalie and Tony into fire if she won final immunity.
This is a solid video. U should do what it's for big brother
Does Dawn win 7-1-0 against Eddie and Sherri with Brenda’s vote going to either Sherri and Eddie because she’s made about the teeth incident?
reynold also votes for eddie
@@nizzle428 oh I forgot to think about that.
Eddie probably gets a lot of credit from the fans tribe. Eddie almost for sure gets Brenda Reynold and Malcom. Could also snag Andrea’s vote bc they seemed somewhat close in the edit, as well as even Michael’s vote
*Mad. Eddie gets Reynold, Erik, and Michael. Dawn gets Andrea, Malcolm, Cochran, and maybe Phillip
@@sethbryant5539 Malcolm and Andrea would vote Eddie over Dawn
Tai is so underrated
14:54 I think Jerri would have a better chance since she grew a lot, she hasn’t won before.
I like the idea of this video keep up the hard work
What if other tribe wins final pre merge challenge.
homie just called kelley wentworth kelly wiglesworth
love this series!
Keith easily wins SJDS as long as nat is gone because Baylor Wes and Jon are obviously gonna vote for there loved ones so that leaves 5 votes where 3 of them easily go to Keith
this would be a sort of short one, but maybe “what if the legacy advantage never happened”?
You forgot to mention in game changers jeff asked the jury what they would do with Tai vs Brad. Brad came out ahead in a tie with Troy's tiebreaking vote. Ofcourse that doesnt mean it would have happened that way but worth a note.
Hali herself said immediately after the fact she votes tai soooo
Jesse woulda won 8-0 in Survivor 43
Using the Survivor Sucks analogy
Rudy gets bamboozled in All Stars
Mama Kim, Neleh, and Shiianne take out Keith and Lex and then save Amber over Jerri before Boston Rob breaks his word.
Sandra quits FvF, Cirie takes out Dreamz and Becky.
Cirie takes Parv over Denise(China) to final two
Johnny Fairplay becomes the first two time winner beating Cirie Fields and Russell Hantz in HvV.
Spencer and Woo take out Kass in SC.
Good video do the final 5 video
Bruce would have 100% voted for Danielle. Bruce and Danielle were really close.
He liked terry a lot too
@@58twright Yeah, but he votes for Danielle against anyone, even Terry.
This is like watching alternative history videos for survivor. “What if Nazis won” “what if this person won immunity”
Imagine Tai as a 2 time winner, LOL! Most hilarious thing ever.
Cydney, Michelle, Tai? I think it's 5-4-0 Michelle. Tai still doesn't get shit
Love tai a lot but he isn’t a great player… just so sweet. I doubt he ever wins the game tho
I think for the hypothetical F3's you're biased in favor of all 3 players getting votes, period. A lot of the votes you're assuming are "locks" probably aren't, in the context of jury members wanting to vote their second-preference over "wasting" their vote on a lost cause. You're forgetting how much discussion happens behind the scenes at Ponderosa, and it is VERY common for one jury vote to decide between A or B winning. Meanwhile, the closest we've ever had to a "split Jury" (3-2-2 or 4-3-3) was Todd winning 4-2-1 (the 3rd F3 EVER, over a decade ago), and the closest thing since was Natalie winning 5-2-1 that's with the two others having super-locked votes from their loved ones.
I wish the final 3 in WAW were Tony, Michele, Sarah. That would've been awesome.
Yup, screw edge of extinction
Why are you so sure Lauren takes Tommy? Yes, they were allies most of the game, but I think Lauren could see the threat Tommy was. I think she takes Noura, and makes Tommy and Dean square off.
yeah she’s a tik toker and talked ab how she would have stayed loyal and kept him
For final 3s you should do the final juror replaces the most undeserving person which is HHH is Ryan in my mind
That has to be a joke. Ben by far played the worst game of that original final 3
Do Survivor: What if every season had EOE (but not with fire tokens like 40 that's too many variables to predict) Who comes back at merge? At final 6? Alan Ball and Stephanie Gonzalez could re enter at their merge, how does this change the post merge? Chris Noble comes back at final 5 and suddenly Chris-Donathan-Angela could potentially thwart Dom-Wendell-Laurel. Woo could return in Cambodia and be utr for a while. Most prolly go right back out but u never know. Michaela comes back in MvGX how wild is that scenario? Malcolm coming back in Gamechangers would make my heart glad bc he was screwed or shit TONY coming back or JT. GC mighta sucked less. Then after Advantagegeddon Ozzy or Caleb probly return and suddenly Tai has a friend. Culpeper had been so nasty to him he'd run right into beastmode cowboys arms and Aubry would be down too. Suddenly Sarah/Brad/Troy aren't in charge. This might be a fun exercise at least for the New School Seasons. Like Brad coming back in Blood Vs. Water, Drew or Rocker or Wentworth in SJDS, shit what if Jon Misch came back 1 round after his final 6 blindside
7:33 plate-able lol
18:31 she was actually behind Kim in the immunity challenge so it's not that ridiculous as Dan Lembo winning
With your scenarios, Tony doesn't win Cagayan, so he doesn't even make Winners at War. What a completely different season that would have been - and I can't imagine how it could have been nearly as good with Woo in the game instead of Tony.....
i saw this title and instantly thought of Yau-Man
Maybe unpopular opinion but Kaôh Rōng would've been way more frustrating if Tai won in a Tai-Aubry-Cydney Final 3
Do this one for big brother! Final juror won final HOH! And what happens
If Rudy wins final immunity he takes hatch with him to the end & he wins the game, if Keith wins final immunity I think he takes Colby & he looses by a landslide 7-0 vote I think lex wins I think Kathy wins rob cesternino definitely wins, terry dietz definitely wins cirie definitely wins this is kind of tough with a final 3 to figure out what happens Tina would probably win again in blood vs water & probably would have been on winners at war
Keith said he would've voted out Colby
@@Lexie-gr9tv oh wow maybe he would have thought he’d have a better chance against Tina Keith still would have been clean swept by either Tina or colby
What if every mandatory final 4 fire making challenges were just normal vote-offs?
S35- Ben goes home
S36- Wendell or Angela goes home (laurel maybe forces a tie, and angela goes in a firemaking)
S37- Kara or Mike goes home (none of those situations matter)
S38- Devons goes home
S39- Lauren goes home
S40- Michele & Natalie vote Tony, Sarah & Tony votes Michele, Michele goes home
I feel Tai would be a 2× winner if this had happened
Because if he had won Koah Rong
He'd have an upper hand
Most of the time the person who is the final juror will most likely win the season
rodney would’ve beat carolyn. the no collars absolutely hated carolyn, jenn was even talking about how much she disliked carolyn in her final words
They all hated Rodney too tho so it really could have gone either way
@@JonnieMayer17 they did 😭? all i can remember about that season is rodneys impression of mike. this season was like a fever dream to me.
@@dezarae3216 he was very cocky and over bearing lol but I really don’t get how people hated Queen Carolyn cause her and Mike were the only good things about the entire season lmao
What if The Final Jurror won Final HoH
Or
What if the person eliminated at final 4 won final pov
S21: i know if Can Holly win but im sûre that Sash will not win
Bruce would’ve voted for Danielle. I know it doesn’t matter but thought I’d say that
Do what if the final 3 immunity win person took the other person to the end
are we surre holly gets 0 votes in nicaragua?
I don’t feel that Woo’s win is as set in stone. Woo didn’t have much gameplay, so Tony might vote her, Morgan might vote her, and Sarah possibly votes with Tony
Nah. Morgan, Sarah, and Trish all HATED Kass. Kass even said in an AMA that those three women treated her terribly and Ponderosa and said awful things to and about her. Spencer also said Kass had zero chance of winning the game and called her the biggest goat, and said Woo was an idiot for not bringing her over Tony. The votes would probably be:
Woo - Tony, Spencer, Trish, Jeremiah, Morgan, Sarah
I think there's a potential that Tasha, Jeffra, and possibly LJ could vote for Kass. LJ was pretty bitter towards Tony and Woo turning on him, and Kass said Jeffra was very kind to her, that she and Tasha were both isolated at Ponderosa & sat together on the plane home. But either way, Woo definitely wins
How about a cast of the greatest characters in your opinion?
Phillip and Coach
Brandon Hantz
you should talk about BBUK
Why would Brendon vote Erinn over Stephen? That makes no sense at all.
I think Courtney would beat Denise and Amanda at a final 3 tbh
Not necessarily in Mattys case. Matty would win over Susie and sugar if Bob is not there. All the bob votes were mainly against Susie and vice versa.
S22: impossible to change the winner, productions and others will not let you gather this infos
S28: woo will not have beat kass
He was not respected
Weasel Woo would not have 5 votes to win
Jeremy goes home Spencer is willing to cut him self preservation and Tasha was close with Spencer I doubt she stick her neck out with Jeremy regardless Kelly probably wins cuz she getting Kass, Ciera, Abi, Keith, Kimmi and probably Joe they have a decent relationship.