Recasting Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains - What if Season 20 Was Second Chance
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 июн 2024
- In this video, I return with another Recasting video, this one being based around remaking the cast of Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains if it was turned into a Second Chance season.
Twitch Channel: / themeranianreview
VOD Channel: / @themeranianreviewlive 
Развлечения
Casting Ace and moving Coach to the heroes tribe is so galaxy-brained I’m thoroughly impressed
“I’ve decided to switch Boston Rob for SPOILER.” Is the craziest thing I’ve heard on this channel and I’m all for it😂
This is probably your best casting video. You normally put a lot of boring gameplay focused people, but here is pretty balanced with great characters LOL
So much Gabon 🥰
I like this set of hypothetical casting choices. I like "second chance" in general as it gives more players a ago instead of players who have already won or played 2+ times.
Very glad you moved Candice to the Villains tribe as I was scratching my head at the time at her being on Heroes, having assumed that Sandra had been cast as a Hero instead. Admittedly, casting Parvati as a Hero would have been even weirder.
I'm glad that you raised the point about Russell, as I was already thinking that he'd be scratching his head as what he was doing on this season when, at the time of filming having wrapped up, he was sure he'd won (as was I until Erik's speech, I thought he might have won unanimously, and even after Erik's speech I probably would have bet on Russell still winning). They certainly found a way to circumvent a similar situation for the actual Second Chance.
Recasting BB14 if it was an all stars season
An interesting thing about the casting of Stephen is that I believe he was dating Courtney at the time. If they were to both make merge it could be super interesting, but I feel like they’d just get targeted super early because of it
Oh wow didn’t know Fischback had that in him
Yes I recall him mentioning that on his post when it started airing. A few months prior, other people alluded to them dating on forums, which made we wonder how they knew.
Rob and Amber 2.0
Stephen and Courtney were also dating at the time of Heroes vs Villains, so I think that would have been a really fun storyline.
I was surprised when you were struggling for a hero woman for 2nd chance you didn’t say Michelle yi. She was a strong player that got swapped screwed in her first season and is just an overall likable character. I think she would have been perfect for that season!
I pressed Dislike because King Randy was removed, I removed the dislike because Kenny was put on the cast, I pressed like because of Ace
Should have been Crystal in there too. I think she would play again knowing that Kenny and Randy were there. But I'm biased towards Gabon since it was my first season.
@@the_fd_180 Gabon’s was the fifth season I saw, right after DvG aired, I never understood the hate J saw it got from the community on RUclips and I rewatched it recently and it shot farther up on my list.
I like your recasting better than the original! The only question is… Who is winning this season? It would be so interesting!
Sean Rector >>> Gervase
So what I’m hearing is Russell just dominates the villians tribe even more masterfully
Villains tribe yes, but depending on how the pre-merge goes, (if the villains go into the merge down in numbers again) ain't no way he's tricking that heroes tribe especially with Laura who's the only one on the cast that knows what he's like
It was criminal that Shane wasn’t casted on Heroes v Villains in his prime….if they did a H v V (2) he might be an option but he’s much older and proab not as chaotic
This is my list:
HEROES
Sugar=Christy (Amazon)
Stephanie=Tracy (Micronesia)
Cirie=Michelle (Fiji)
Tom=Terry (Panama)
James=Erik (Micronesia)
JT=Stephen (Tocantins)
Amanda=Peih-Gee (China)
Candice=Kelly (Borneo)
Rupert=Savage (Pearl Islands)
Colby=Sean (Marquesas)
VILLAINS
Randy (Gabon) (still in)
Tyson (Tocantins) (still in)
Boston Rob=Shane (Panama)
Coach (Tocantins) (still in)
Courtney (China) (still in)
Danielle=Corinne (Gabon)
Jerri=Heidi (Amazon)
Hantz (Samoa) (still in)
Parvati=Natalie (Micronesia)
Sandra=Twila (Vanuatu)
It is shocking to me that production considered Candice and Parvati as more of a ‘hero’ than Sandra….
I think dumping the fish and blaming it on Christa is what did it for Sandra
So I wonder if Abuela's belief in the families gifts, fits the same criteria?
I think I like this cast more than we actually got. I would definitely root for Natalie Bolton. Poor Amy would be a first boot 😂
This might be a bit crazy but what if you recasted David vs Goliath if it was an All-Stars Season.
For the Davids, they'd be cast as players that had to constantly fight their way to the top. Constantly being targeted and they'd have pull a rabbit out of their hat so they can stay in the game a bit longer
For the Goliaths, they'd be cast as players that were absolute
powerhouses and were rarely even targeted. They'd just relax and assign the next target in the tribe
This is just my little idea and you'll likely not see this but it'd be cool if you saw and this and considered my little idea
I always had trouble seeing Parvati as the hero in the Candace case. In my eyes, however, Parvati is clearly more of a villain than a hero. Candace, of course, too. I don't understand why they didn't switch Sandra and Candace. Sandra is more of a hero. This would also have balanced the physical imbalance.
The issue with the Russell Hantz Samoa spoiler is his whole game in HvV was predicated on his Samoa game being believed to have won. If he realizes he didn’t win Samoa, that probably changes what he does in HvV.
Russell played similar games on Redemption Island and Australian Survivor so idk about that. If anything Russell might chalk it up to Samoa’s jury being bitter and think this cast would “respect his game” more.
@@vaporterra yeah I don’t see a world where Russell ever changes his game, his ego will never let him think him losing is his fault
@@baileylynn5562 losing was not his fault
@@spdprawcereal7181 how?
This is an excellent point. Russell is not incentivized to change what he believed was a winning game. I recall hearing somewhere that Production almost let it slip to him at the time that he hadn't won Samoa.
Beyond!
Yeah Erik was the male hero alternate while Natalie was the female villain alternate
Are we factoring in fan voting or no?
I think Natalia would end up winning
I would’ve put Marcus instead of ace tbh Marcus was way more of a physical presence on his season then ace was but that’s just me
Marcus doesn’t make much sense as a villain though
@@vaporterra I think he does I think he could be considered a villain
@@survivoramazing9460 He had the one kinda villainous confessional at the feast bragging about everyone throwing the idol into the ocean, but it paled in comparison to Randy’s
I see a Susie or Krystal more.
You should have replaced James with Rupert. Also no Tony???
Missing Sean Rector imo...
How I Would Have Cast This Season If Heroes vs. Villains Was Heroes vs. Villains: Second Chance
Heroes:
1. Kelly Wiglesworth
2. Teresa Cooper
3. Sean Rector
4. Ian Rosenberger
5. Terry Dietz
6. Candice Woodcock
7. Erik Reichenbach
8. Sugar Kiper
9. Taj Jordan-George
10. Stephen Fischbach
Villains:
1. Keith Famie
2. Matthew von Ertfelda
3. Andrew Savage
4. Twila Tanner
5. Amy O'Hara
6. Shane Powers
7. Danielle DiLorenzo
8. Courtney Yates
9. Natalie Bolton
10. Randy Bailey
coach is a villain becuz he doesn't respect women. I think a lot of male fans just don't see that as a villainous quality cuz it doesn't rly affect them. why would I root for someone who thinks I'm below them. Just like Russel and Rob cesternino. nails on a chalk board listening to those guys talk shit abt the women