Is Afghanistan SAFE? (its not what you’re thinking)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024

Комментарии • 2,9 тыс.

  • @eee3630
    @eee3630 Год назад +3023

    Is America safe or whole world is safe from America???????????

  • @Greenearth796
    @Greenearth796 7 месяцев назад +918

    I am hazara and i feel safe after America left our country.

    • @s.s.p.7357
      @s.s.p.7357 3 месяца назад +85

      Don't lie, u r Pashtoon,

    • @chauvintookaknee4blm268
      @chauvintookaknee4blm268 3 месяца назад +74

      Tell your ppl to leave Europe

    • @kimiko6732
      @kimiko6732 3 месяца назад

      Lies, afghanis hate hazara people

    • @na4i1
      @na4i1 3 месяца назад

      ​@@chauvintookaknee4blm268You should just get out of Europe, why should they

    • @CodeControl101
      @CodeControl101 3 месяца назад

      You are right. This women just talking after seeing Afganistan for some weeks?!
      I have a lots of friends there, and all of them are happy. Just these westerns are lying, because taleban destroyed there armies. Because they can't eat that one Muslim group defeated them all

  • @Bigred338
    @Bigred338 Год назад +2036

    Human progress US made ???
    😂😂😂😂😂
    Never laughed better in my life

    • @akritasdigenis4831
      @akritasdigenis4831 Год назад +496

      It's a white American woman that posted this video so what do you expect from her

    • @Ghazi682
      @Ghazi682 Год назад +1

      @@akritasdigenis4831 everyone is welcome in Afghanistan except Americans, we don’t want to see any of them here.

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +243

      @@akritasdigenis4831 I am a white European*/American that lives in the Middle East - travels extensively around the Middle East and Muslim-majority countries. Not sure what your point is 🥱

    • @junedshaikh967
      @junedshaikh967 Год назад +192

      ​@@elonakarafin"you're basic view about Islamic world is resist"
      That's they try to saying

    • @the_son_of_man
      @the_son_of_man Год назад +335

      ​@@elonakarafinyou just a femnists who has a propoganda against islam lol

  • @mohameddaoud7018
    @mohameddaoud7018 9 месяцев назад +476

    In summary she felt safe but she still repeats the bullshit she heard in the media.

    • @DemonArshan
      @DemonArshan 8 месяцев назад +17

      Why are their Women Cricket team not part of ICC events ?

    • @fallasleep9472
      @fallasleep9472 8 месяцев назад +44

      @@DemonArshan Women's sports suck most of the time so good on them not wasting money.

    • @DemonArshan
      @DemonArshan 8 месяцев назад +14

      @@fallasleep9472 Then suspend their Men's ODI Cricket team because acccording to laws of ICC Cricket in order to be a men's full member team you need to fill three criteras
      1- Proper staff and caches
      2- Cricket grounds
      3- Women and Men's both teams actively playing and participating in ICC events.
      If any one of the criterias are not filled team will be demoted or suspended. So by that logic Afghanistan men's cricket team should not be part of any ICC events as they failed to fill the criteria.

    • @fallasleep9472
      @fallasleep9472 8 месяцев назад +18

      @@DemonArshan Afghanistan is still playing and screw those stupid rules. Go tell that to the boss of ICC. I dgaf XD

    • @Highiman
      @Highiman 7 месяцев назад +9

      ​@@DemonArshanlet's us enjoy Afghanistans men team.

  • @Dobbyisfree000
    @Dobbyisfree000 2 месяца назад +120

    No drugs and alcohol no gang violence,you missed out these points

    • @kevinquattlebaum5422
      @kevinquattlebaum5422 2 месяца назад +46

      Yes the highest heroin producing country definitely doesn't have drugs.

    • @nicholasg9804
      @nicholasg9804 Месяц назад

      It's the epitome of gang violence. The Taliban is a gang

    • @legendarycinematics3091
      @legendarycinematics3091 Месяц назад

      Fucking ISIS maybe 💀

    • @thelord7627
      @thelord7627 Месяц назад

      over 10% of the Afghan population is addicted to heroin......look at that place😮would you really like to live there? and when I say look at the place I'm not talking about some of the beautiful scenery it has, but to actually live there would be hell😅💯

    • @epoxy1710
      @epoxy1710 Месяц назад +2

      ​@@kevinquattlebaum5422They dont use it

  • @McCarthy911
    @McCarthy911 Год назад +675

    Human progress??????
    Where was I living 😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @marvinjuarez3401
      @marvinjuarez3401 Год назад +7

      In a babble I guess 😂

    • @davidloco1215
      @davidloco1215 Год назад

      The US invaded Afghanistan to defeat the Taliban

    • @Essameerah
      @Essameerah Месяц назад +4

      Bro Americans think that world needs them as a criteria for progress.
      Honestly whenever I've to give examples in my family of how a society shouldn't be in terms of lewdness, women objectification, crimes etc America comes to my mind first

  • @marvinjuarez3401
    @marvinjuarez3401 Год назад +1023

    Is USA safe? It the depends to which ethnicity police asks.

    • @Mo-mg3fg
      @Mo-mg3fg Год назад +41

      💀💀True

    • @jscott8110
      @jscott8110 Год назад

      You’re comparing USA to Afghanistan. You’d get raped stoned and shot for just taking your head scarf off in Afghanistan. Americas crazy but this country just need nuked

    • @李莹莹-q7b
      @李莹莹-q7b Год назад

      because instead Afghanistan doesn't kill the Hazaras😂😂😂😂😂honestly I'm a black woman and the only time I suffered racism was from a Hispanic boy...and then in America all ethnic groups commit crimes not only white or blacks😊

    • @李莹莹-q7b
      @李莹莹-q7b Год назад +30

      ​@@Mo-mg3fgbecause instead Afghanistan doesn't kill the Hazaras😂😂😂😂😂Afghanistan is the last country in the world that can talk about human righs😘😘😘😘 I'm a black woman and the only time I suffered racism was from a Hispanic boy...and then in America all ethnic groups commit crimes not only white or blacks

    • @haroonafridi231
      @haroonafridi231 Год назад +41

      ​@@李莹莹-q7b who mentioned black and white
      Also why is black and white such a big thing in America?

  • @Zirgaam7755
    @Zirgaam7755 Год назад +716

    Look who’s speaking 😂😂😂 the one who basically killed hundreds and thousands and millions displaced

    • @Ghazi682
      @Ghazi682 Год назад

      Americans are the source of every problem on earth

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад +1

      American Hypocrisy is at its best, always try to play a saviour/messiah everywhere.☝️😉😏

    • @SlovenianMapping
      @SlovenianMapping Год назад

      ☠️ She ain’t the white death she didn’t kill millions. Also in that aspect your saying every human in america is responsible for millions of deaths. I am not American I am living in Germany. Does that mean every citizen is responsible for killing 27 million people and up?

    • @belittekleiner1
      @belittekleiner1 9 месяцев назад

      She killed hundreds of thousands of afghans?

    • @Rainwithsun
      @Rainwithsun 9 месяцев назад +3

      Sad fact😢

  • @Si_nengatcha
    @Si_nengatcha 3 месяца назад +46

    I'm from Indonesia, and I want to visit all countries in the world, including Afghanistan..

    • @linagharzai4104
      @linagharzai4104 2 месяца назад

      Why? I’m kinda sad bc you said that …. I come from Afghanistan and I’m in Afghanistan 🇦🇫….😢

    • @Si_nengatcha
      @Si_nengatcha 2 месяца назад +3

      @@linagharzai4104 why not? I think traveling makes us open our eyes and learn to appreciate differences, people, culture, etc.

    • @speed-of_cake
      @speed-of_cake Месяц назад

      @@linagharzai4104my dad was a soldier there and when I went there I held a ak-47 and my mum shot it

    • @jaerys8823
      @jaerys8823 Месяц назад

      ​@@Si_nengatchanot every culture is equal. Some are more dangerous than the others

    • @IwanPermana-oc7tk
      @IwanPermana-oc7tk Месяц назад

      The dangerous ones are America and NATO​@@jaerys8823

  • @Tod_x
    @Tod_x 4 месяца назад +145

    "No education"
    Show kid running with schoolbag*

    • @Rick-ko9bx
      @Rick-ko9bx 4 месяца назад +11

      Thats for females, boys had the bags.

    • @saralina9867
      @saralina9867 3 месяца назад +32

      ​@@Rick-ko9bx you can see 4 girls going to school with schoolbags

    • @Rick-ko9bx
      @Rick-ko9bx 3 месяца назад +2

      @saralina9867 Right you are, I was watching those kids running and missed them.

    • @roybolder9480
      @roybolder9480 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@@saralina9867ofc they're ... gotta love propaganda ... you also beleive ukraine and Palestina are democratic😂

    • @parwizghanezada3997
      @parwizghanezada3997 2 месяца назад

      Use your brain and do some research she’s not dumb to say that let me just say that when a FEMALE can only do schools till year 6 where boys do it until school is completely finished THERE

  • @sayed-elyas-haschimi8224
    @sayed-elyas-haschimi8224 Год назад +852

    Its Now Safe! Because we kicked the US cowards Army out from Afghanistan!

    • @TD-he6ov
      @TD-he6ov Год назад

      Human progress Us Made 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
      Boys are running and no freedom of expression 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
      In sort because they kick out the western puppies so they will be always bad its very simple maths .
      One more hypocrisy , not safe for minority may be but gov. Never killed anyone like in India , and blacks in USA
      Western seems to be becoming equal to hypocrite

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад +85

      Very welldone my brother BRAVO, may there be peace prosperity and progress in Afghanistan.👌😎👍

    • @sayed-elyas-haschimi8224
      @sayed-elyas-haschimi8224 Год назад +72

      @@majornukehazard1989 thank you , 🙏
      Actually it was the Help and Power of Allah swt

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад +1

      @@sayed-elyas-haschimi8224tell you what? the USA literally deserved that humiliation, b'coz those yankee bastards have a nasty habit of always keep poking their noses into others internal matter, rather than just kept to their own business.

    • @fahimabdul8733
      @fahimabdul8733 Год назад +8

      ​@@majornukehazard1989 fr

  • @ynptyty
    @ynptyty Год назад +192

    I Respect all the Afghans . Best wishes from South India.

  • @mk-cf7pm
    @mk-cf7pm Год назад +699

    Please STOP lying and stop divinding afghans by ethnicity!!!! There is NO problem with being Tajik!!! Absolutely NONE! We are tajik and my whole family lives there

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +30

      Yes, we are apl Afghans #UnitedAfghanistan ❤❤❤🏳🏳🏳

    • @ABEDEL06
      @ABEDEL06 10 месяцев назад +35

      And she even call Tajiks fot minority 😂

    • @Everything-Wii
      @Everything-Wii 9 месяцев назад +9

      I agree with you, however she was not intending to convey that message. And if you look at other videos, she mentions some of their hospitality.

    • @KhosrowSassani
      @KhosrowSassani 8 месяцев назад +14

      Ya Khoda, barādar if you are Tajik then you know how our people have been persecuted by the talib pashtoon khars, look at what they did in Panjshir 🤦‍♂️ Be omide khoda our people will be liberated ☝🏽💚🤍🖤🇹🇯

    • @xChillXVibesx
      @xChillXVibesx 8 месяцев назад +12

      Yh because Tajik people aren't targeted but Hazara are.

  • @MirMahmud2003
    @MirMahmud2003 9 месяцев назад +122

    At least Afghanistan doesn't have shootings in schools and malls 😛

    • @darkchocolate7188
      @darkchocolate7188 3 месяца назад

      they have a corrupt government

    • @chauvintookaknee4blm268
      @chauvintookaknee4blm268 3 месяца назад +48

      Yeah you have it in the streets and homes.

    • @neoneherefrom5836
      @neoneherefrom5836 3 месяца назад +38

      wait Afghanistan has schools and malls ?

    • @inthendwealldie
      @inthendwealldie 3 месяца назад +4

      In Afghanistan, the Toyota Corollas and SUVs used to go boom very often, thats why there used to be Afghani policemen in gray uniforms in Kabul, lots of checkpoints, checking every vehicle because they like to go boom

    • @chauvintookaknee4blm268
      @chauvintookaknee4blm268 3 месяца назад

      Mahmud is running away lol. How's that goatussy

  • @Aceo_0
    @Aceo_0 4 месяца назад +23

    It's safer than most of the neighboring countries specially in central regions and big cities

  • @kodvavi150
    @kodvavi150 Год назад +524

    The people who can't define a woman talk too much about what woman should do and should not do.

    • @chhaiderrazasura9430
      @chhaiderrazasura9430 Год назад +43

      LOL!!!!

    • @bashirabdulghaniy
      @bashirabdulghaniy Год назад +52

      Outstanding statement

    • @nadiamess3323
      @nadiamess3323 Год назад

      they are lost in their lgbtq and feminist views and wana run their mouths about a country who does not give a fuck about them !! like leave Afghanistan alone as well as all the muslim countries we don’t want your opinions or views stay in your mentally ill countries thanks

    • @AK-dd9od
      @AK-dd9od Год назад +62

      She says in her video the human progress the U.S. made over the last two decades. Since when are war crimes and the deaths of thousands and thousands "human progress"?

    • @AK-dd9od
      @AK-dd9od Год назад +9

      It's the video she made that needs to be taken with a grain of salt.

  • @Abubakar-ws9nh
    @Abubakar-ws9nh Год назад +491

    Is Texas, Philadelphia Michigan safer than AFGHANISTAN?

  • @ayaanaali8852
    @ayaanaali8852 Год назад +181

    God bless Afghanistan

    • @kittybellx3156
      @kittybellx3156 Год назад +2

      Wtf that don’t make sense u mean allah?

    • @ayaanaali8852
      @ayaanaali8852 Год назад

      Allah and God are the same entity (same thing)@@kittybellx3156

    • @kazakhstanisastate4614
      @kazakhstanisastate4614 Год назад

      allah and god are one in the same@@kittybellx3156

    • @EmbraceYourEmaan
      @EmbraceYourEmaan Год назад

      God = Allah. Your point? @@kittybellx3156

    • @Channel-ml4qv
      @Channel-ml4qv Год назад +20

      @@kittybellx3156 Allah means god in arabic, stop acting like you didn’t know that.

  • @ahmedbhayat8497
    @ahmedbhayat8497 4 месяца назад +43

    Looks safer than any Western country tbh

  • @That_dawg420
    @That_dawg420 7 месяцев назад +69

    Afghanistan is definitely safer than Wherever you came from maam. We are muslims ☝🗿

    • @missmysticrose7543
      @missmysticrose7543 5 месяцев назад +13

      Why women are not allowed for education in Afghanistan?

    • @That_dawg420
      @That_dawg420 5 месяцев назад +4

      @@missmysticrose7543 not true

    • @khouloud.chemini
      @khouloud.chemini 3 месяца назад

      ​@@missmysticrose7543Why don't you tire your fingers, stop being ignorant and look into the matter?

    • @IAmLiryx
      @IAmLiryx 2 месяца назад +4

      Lies

    • @BrajaMohanHalder-jn8to
      @BrajaMohanHalder-jn8to 2 месяца назад +13

      There are literally men walking with weapons and you are calling it safe 🤔

  • @antimatter4733
    @antimatter4733 Год назад +307

    I'm assuming the US progress you're talking about was the massive opium epidemic, corruption, torture, and genocide against the civilians?
    Also I really enjoyed the "Women and other ethnicities aren't safe, here's footage of me traveling the country completely safe and returning home so I can talk trash about it"

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +22

      Trash? Clearly you haven’t watched any of my content from Afghanistan. Carry on 😴👋🏼

    • @antimatter4733
      @antimatter4733 Год назад +132

      @@elonakarafin I've seen this video, it's enough. If I wanted western feminist propaganda I'd watch CNN 🤦🏻‍♂️

    • @test-ot1fz
      @test-ot1fz Год назад +58

      Don't forget how peaceful bush was in iraq
      Or obama when he sees children hospitals in yemen in 2015

    • @nohandle603
      @nohandle603 Год назад +13

      ​@@antimatter4733😂😂😂😂u blew her up

    • @Aak1898
      @Aak1898 Год назад +4

      @@antimatter4733man that was 🔥 😂

  • @Ghhhf-ft9qi
    @Ghhhf-ft9qi Год назад +306

    Half the taliban government is Tajik Uzbek and hazara what are you talking about

    • @BattingMyLashes
      @BattingMyLashes Год назад

      You’re a joke. We all know who the problem is.

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад

      Thank you! Taliban are multi-ethnic. These people who lie that they are only Pashtuns are disgusting and shameless.

    • @afQ_01
      @afQ_01 Год назад

      She doesn't know shit ...

    • @MysticWolf1223
      @MysticWolf1223 7 месяцев назад +15

      I've met many Uzbek. Very good people deserving of respect.

    • @payamSafi-qe1mc
      @payamSafi-qe1mc 7 месяцев назад +14

      Yes Bro, these are our interior affairs, I don't know why that strange girl talking about our interior issues.

  • @basirobaidi667
    @basirobaidi667 Год назад +175

    Basically you are lying, it is safe for all Afghana and ethnicities.

    • @markmandotcom
      @markmandotcom Год назад +12

      sure of course it is

    • @user-mf2sj7rd6m
      @user-mf2sj7rd6m Год назад

      @@markmandotcom keep making your assumptions when you have no idea, Mark. It’s obvious you’re just a Fox News mouth breather that can’t possibly imagine an enemy of the US being anything but evil🤡

    • @hercules_144
      @hercules_144 Год назад

      Good thing nobody actually believes you guys lol we can all see that muslim countries are full of hate and terrorism.

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +8

      ​@@markmandotcomyes, it is. We live in Afghanistan.

    • @markmandotcom
      @markmandotcom Год назад +21

      @@phoenixrising8640 yeah and are u gay, female, a protestor, human rights activist, poor, a us/russia supporter, trans, a non muslim, ot any other minority?

  • @truckihuzztr5049
    @truckihuzztr5049 8 месяцев назад +33

    Tajiks and Hazaras are also safe in Afghanistan. I say that as a Tajik person myself. So pls stop the Propaganda

    • @-respxct1557
      @-respxct1557 2 месяца назад +4

      hazaras are safe? please dont try to lie to make the rulers look good.

    • @itzmusawer2903
      @itzmusawer2903 Месяц назад

      @@-respxct1557Of course they are They are just victim players 😂

    • @eliaszamonke
      @eliaszamonke 29 дней назад +3

      ​@@itzmusawer2903Have you seen how many massacares happend to the hazaras?

    • @nargeshassani0526
      @nargeshassani0526 19 часов назад

      Oh really every day there is alot of hazara people dying and you say we are safe how safe we are ?

    • @itzmusawer2903
      @itzmusawer2903 19 часов назад

      @@eliaszamonke no never and l live in kabul afghanistan as well

  • @TheResistance-ye8bh
    @TheResistance-ye8bh Месяц назад +3

    This Woman: It's not safe if you're an ethnic minority like a Hazara or a Tajik
    The Taliban's Minister of Economy: *is literally Tajik*

  • @matikhorasani3842
    @matikhorasani3842 Год назад +354

    This is pure bullshit and propaganda. If you want to see the real side of Afghanistan, luckily there are dozens of vloggers now in Afghanistan going around making videos. I also know a whole bunch of Afghans who have travelled to the country since and were surprised with the peace and the rela attitude of people now that the war has ended.

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +32

      Lol ok, bro 😌

    • @ezerei2911
      @ezerei2911 Год назад +122

      @@elonakarafincan I know what US progress u were talking about ? Dropping bombs and killing hundreds of thousands of civilians?? And also are American coz u seem biased towards the USA

    • @Leader390
      @Leader390 Год назад +20

      There are many vlogger even from India and vlogging freely 😂

    • @kittybellx3156
      @kittybellx3156 Год назад +4

      @@ezerei2911can you state the progress the taliban made before and after the U.S. intervened ?

    • @kittybellx3156
      @kittybellx3156 Год назад +2

      @@ezerei2911I mean sorry that we spent $145 billion trying to rebuild Afghanistan, its security forces, civilian government institutions, economy, and civil society, and the Taliban has only ever caused war for the Afghanistan government or blow shit up so.

  • @zachazia443
    @zachazia443 Год назад +83

    Looking at the current situation in Afghanistan it's the safest it's been in 50 years with lots of construction taking place like the kosh tapa kanal, and lots of work in capital as well as helping people recover from prolong war that ended alhamdulillah

    • @Timtam99
      @Timtam99 Год назад +1

      Yeah except the people running the country have the mental capacity of literal animals. Its as if the clock turned back 5000 years. Imagine being ruled by a bunch of bloodthirsty idiots with egos so fragile that they'd rather murder those they disagree with just because an ancient book said so... The self entitlement of people spewing this crap about it being better now is insane.

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +3

      True. Alhamdulillah, we are making progress now

    • @moreafterthistime
      @moreafterthistime Год назад +7

      And what about women and girls b

    • @Azaarv
      @Azaarv Год назад +3

      @@moreafterthistime honestly it is much safer and now that the US has left for even one it’s still dangerous but it has gotten much better

    • @jamescook4402
      @jamescook4402 2 месяца назад

      Women should stay home and cook​@@moreafterthistime

  • @goatxgame
    @goatxgame Год назад +68

    First they used all natural resources and now giving lectures on freedom 😅😅😅

    • @xenon_silva
      @xenon_silva 13 дней назад +1

      Hypocrisy bro😂

    • @VladVlad-ul1io
      @VladVlad-ul1io 4 дня назад

      Eh? Only people using other's resources were the Afghans themselves that were living of Christians, Jews and Hindus tax money in the form of international help.

  • @KathrynHalsey
    @KathrynHalsey 3 месяца назад +3

    That Mosque is gorgeous

  • @AdnanAhmed-ht8ey
    @AdnanAhmed-ht8ey 4 месяца назад +6

    "Progress" is relative, but however you define it, the Afghan people need to be the architects of their own future. They need to own it, it has to be on their terms.

  • @AfghanPalestinianMujahed
    @AfghanPalestinianMujahed Год назад +69

    Free Dr.Afiya Siddiqui

    • @habibrahmani8927
      @habibrahmani8927 3 месяца назад +1

      A woman in jail for 25 years with out any criminal history 😢

  • @how890
    @how890 Год назад +226

    Who are you that the taliban will present you the plans etc. I am Afghani, they are doing well, than the previous governments. Never come again to Afghanistan. If you are a tourist, be a tourist.

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +19

      Thank you for your hospitality 😁 in fact, I can’t wait to be back!!

    • @how890
      @how890 Год назад +76

      @@elonakarafin Afghanistan is going through tough time it's getting better, the things you said in video divides our people. If you are not being like western media reporter and be tourist and spread positivity. You are always welcome. I wish you visited Afghanistan in previous government. You would have noticed changes.

    • @KamBam-ni3pt
      @KamBam-ni3pt 11 месяцев назад +23

      ​@elonakarafin never come back

    • @baharafghanzad_0093
      @baharafghanzad_0093 10 месяцев назад +1

      *You're probably not living in Afghanistan. Otherwise you wouldn't call the txliban txrrorists a "government". They were just armed and brought to Afghanistan for plundering reasons. That's why they fear education so much.*

    • @ABEDEL06
      @ABEDEL06 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@elonakarafinwe are definitely gonna report you as a spy to the government and make sure you will never set your foot in Afghanistan

  • @shabz4772
    @shabz4772 Год назад +60

    Reporter:Freedom of movement and girls education
    Video: showing four girls walking to school😅

    • @FahimFarooqFoto
      @FahimFarooqFoto Год назад +8

      Yeah until 6th grade. But not above

    • @robleyusuf2566
      @robleyusuf2566 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@FahimFarooqFoto Because Taliban want to make new Curriculum

    • @fallasleep9472
      @fallasleep9472 10 месяцев назад +9

      @@FahimFarooqFoto there are uni female students in Afghanistan that graduate ever year since the talisman came. And they didn't ban it, they post poned it in order to allocate some of the money to infrastructure and economy. Remember, Afghanistan is still a third world country and don't have the luxury to do all things at once since e America seized billions of dollars from them.

    • @xiontion9993
      @xiontion9993 9 месяцев назад +3

      @@FahimFarooqFoto dude you should give them money so they can go to school.....

    • @BROLY392
      @BROLY392 9 месяцев назад +3

      ​@@FahimFarooqFotothey were looking 6th graders to you?

  • @user-ns5ef2du8f
    @user-ns5ef2du8f 3 месяца назад +1

    Instead of asking US to stop 🛑 bombing civilians and criticising her own country, she is taking advantage of freely roaming around a safe country and then shamelessly criticising it too. That speaks so much about herself.

  • @payamSafi-qe1mc
    @payamSafi-qe1mc 7 месяцев назад +24

    It's none of your business, Hazara, Tajik. Pashton.....we are all brothers

    • @m.a9454
      @m.a9454 3 месяца назад

      زنکه جاسوس امریکاست . برای تفرقه اندازه بین افغان ها این ویدیو درست کرده . اما کور خوانده ما دیگه فریب پروگاندای این جاسوسان را نمیخوریم . همه افغان‌ها برادر استند .

    • @thanos8788
      @thanos8788 9 дней назад

      Only brothers when their accomplishment/unalive hit the news, shame on you.

  • @johnqahar6624
    @johnqahar6624 Год назад +122

    Yes I’m from afghan is safe

    • @martymcfly8731
      @martymcfly8731 Год назад +1

      If you’re a male, you can’t speak for everyone.

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад +5

      "Yes I'm from Afghanistan and it is safe", first learn to speak proper English.

    • @rahimgamezz8179
      @rahimgamezz8179 Год назад +39

      @@majornukehazard1989 bro most afghans don’t know any English and I am afghan

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад +1

      @@rahimgamezz8179yeah I know most Afghans are unfamiliar with foreign languages (esp. English) but I'd say you should better start to learn if you want to connect with rest of the world, and to be recognized by the global community.

    • @rahimgamezz8179
      @rahimgamezz8179 Год назад +15

      @@majornukehazard1989 it depends on what country your going to and maybe they talk a different language and what do you mean by recognized by the global community

  • @christopherherrera921
    @christopherherrera921 Год назад +55

    I am still in disbelief how the taliban won the war against the best military in the world. The taliban wasn't just fight one military but several of the best milaries of the world. This is shocking abd very humbling experience to us here in the US. We must accept the fact that the taliban is the new government of Afghanistan and unfreeze that money that they deserve.

    • @Timtam99
      @Timtam99 Год назад +8

      Yeah if you think hiding for 10 years while the big bad security guard goes away is winning, they won. In reality, the Afghanistan governemnt was handed over the responsibility and equipment to defend themselves. They failed..

    • @dravidianking1298
      @dravidianking1298 Год назад

      @@Timtam99 wait you’re telling me the US flew in a bunch of corrupt tribal dictators who were only put into power because of their previous genocides against taliban tribes and they failed? No way dude, almost like American foreign policy is somehow more incompetent than the Taliban who literally want to live in the Stone Age 😂

    • @felipejose8834
      @felipejose8834 Год назад +11

      Afghanistan is on another level. These guys beat the Soviet Union and then the US Army along with NATO.

    • @mansooralt
      @mansooralt Год назад +3

      "The security Guard " handed fighter planes, helicopters,tanks, guns and armaments to the hiding rats while leaving ...
      The Security Guard left afganistan with his pants wet..

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад

      Thank u and drop the cruel sanctions against us❤❤❤🏳🏳🏳.
      Don't forget all their private contractors, Afghan puppets, advanced military technology and equipment too.
      Our Taliban had nothing.
      You weren't told the truth...our Taliban controlled most of Afghanistan for years and were gaining ground and support rapidly which is why the US had to negotiate the Doha deal for safe passage out of Afghanistan. Majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government and security forces now. It's only a minority of Afghans who don't support Taliban and most of those are US and NATO foreign invader terrorists puppets and those who benefitted from the foreign invader terrorists. Your media also never showed the heros welcomes Taliban got as they rolled through Afghanistan to Kabul or the fact that Taliban waited outside Kabul for the transfer of power as per Doha Deal. August 15th 2021 was the happiest day of majority of our Afghan lives...wjen Taliban regained Afghanistan for us and their rightful rule back.

  • @Oneisonekon
    @Oneisonekon Год назад +51

    My family in Afghanistan are so much happier and well off with the new government than when the western countries were there.
    You can watch what the government is doing in the Afghan channels. Just last week they were banning all the expired products from all the shops around Afghanistan and ensuring food hygienes are meeting all the requirements. Everything is slowly but surely improving. Afghanistan just needs their trillions dollars back from America 🇺🇸 France 🇫🇷 Britain 🇬🇧, Canada 🇨🇦 Australia 🇦🇺 Poland 🇵🇱 and many other western countries so that they can build their schools, hospitals, banks and many other things required for this new government to run smoothly. I don’t know why they are not just giving Afghanistans money back it’s very sad really.

    • @user-mf2sj7rd6m
      @user-mf2sj7rd6m Год назад

      I understand where you’re coming from, but are you seriously saying that you don’t understand why those countries are not giving Afghanistans money back? Are you dense?

    • @Redblood88-j5s
      @Redblood88-j5s Год назад +5

      ​@@user-mf2sj7rd6mwhy are they not giving it back ?

    • @Lktravel1
      @Lktravel1 Год назад +3

      The Taliban have not been known to do such things. The old Taliban enjoyed executions. What about the women in your family who worked and studied are they still doing good? How about shootings

    • @dravidianking1298
      @dravidianking1298 Год назад +3

      @@Lktravel1 I mean the old Taliban was basically a guerrilla army ofc they did bad things, the CIA which was responsible for their creation does worse all over the world, it’s just accepted in the name of “American Patriotism” and protecting our rights.
      At least now the Taliban is actually responsible for making sure their people are protected and healthy.
      I’m skeptical too and I don’t agree with their views but I’ll at least give ‘em a chance if it means people’s lives are improved. The women’s rights thing is very unfortunate but hopefully they see that loosening those restrictions and modernizing will make them seem more legitimate.

    • @rizwanqasem3444
      @rizwanqasem3444 Год назад

      Because you are taliban that’s why you are happy

  • @rja478
    @rja478 2 месяца назад +1

    I spoke to my friend in kabul
    He said after the Americans left
    Life is still the same
    Just the sanctions have destroyed the businesses built over 20 years

  • @satinikarsono1689
    @satinikarsono1689 2 месяца назад +2

    Hopefully in the future Afghanistan will become a developed and prosperous country. Greetings from Indonesia

  • @Mobile-pd1uc
    @Mobile-pd1uc Год назад +14

    Hazaras and Tajiks are safe.

    • @waliarab
      @waliarab Год назад +1

      Afg Pashtun 🏳️❤️

  • @hamidlogari1
    @hamidlogari1 Год назад +89

    Propaganda channel stop false information

  • @AuraNaturae
    @AuraNaturae Год назад +74

    So how you know actual reality . If you are a tourist and u treated well. Are u a spy, Part time?

    • @CasinoBanks-vd2xe
      @CasinoBanks-vd2xe Год назад

      This is a biased video. You can see it in her face - she is a woman full of makeup outsize to attract men at core , or compete with other women.
      The taliban are wrong with their treatment towards women education. But she is biased.
      The main problem is 7 billion $ of afghan money stolen and frozen. They can't develop when they are worried about the next bite to eat - as a whole

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +5

      fulltime *

    • @allahfirst3414
      @allahfirst3414 Год назад +39

      Then we afghans disapprove your baseless facts ( fake spy)

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +4

      @@allahfirst3414 lmfao

    • @গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য
      @গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য Год назад +13

      ​@@elonakarafin Afghan govt has seen your comment thread. If u wanna visit next time, RIP advance

  • @HassanYousaf-n9n
    @HassanYousaf-n9n 21 день назад +1

    Pakistani 🇵🇰 here may Allah protect the Afghani give them rights to get Education
    If 11 year old 🇦🇫 afghani neibourgs want to come pakistan..
    Your welcome anytime.

  • @Mirabenjamin348
    @Mirabenjamin348 2 месяца назад +2

    Saying the human progress that the US made is effectively wiped out makes me wonder who invited the US there in the first place ??

  • @jonathanbethune9075
    @jonathanbethune9075 Год назад +88

    You need to broaden your perspective.

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +12

      enlighten me, Jonathan

    • @jonathanbethune9075
      @jonathanbethune9075 Год назад +45

      @Elona Karafin
      They fought for 40 years to preserve a conservative view of Islam. A way of life that is strict in its interpretation of the Koran. Word for word.
      It is a small sliver of the world that I think the Muslim community view as a reservation for the devout. A place all there own , hard fought for and won.
      It may in the fullness of time surprise the more liberal minds of the world what an alternate way of life might produce , for everyone in there society. There economics and social stricture will be distinctive.
      As far as feminist values goes, go somewhere else. Your perfectly free to do so and butt out of a place your views " knowingly " destabilize.
      It's up to there societal evolution to fight ideologies you import.
      That said , I was a proponent of democratic reforms when the coalition was there , thought it something profoundly good, and it was rejected ,on mass.

    • @TRKZ786
      @TRKZ786 Год назад +32

      ​@Jonathan Bethune It's quite funny how some entitled westerners act all like "we should respect all cultures", "diversity is great", but when a culture has the slightest bit of disagreement with their world view, it's considered a horrible crime. I'm sure she didn't even see any human right violations there and got all the stuff from the media. I've been to Afghanistan many times before and after the government change and spoiler alert: girls and women still go outside alone and attend schools and universities. Y'all should question her credibility now.

    • @jonathanbethune9075
      @jonathanbethune9075 Год назад +10

      @R. Khan were pickled in the brine social engineering. I agree.
      Takes a long time for people to be able to think for themselves, if ever.
      I've come to see independent and disciplined " thought" a really rare thing.

    • @TRKZ786
      @TRKZ786 Год назад +3

      @Jonathan Bethune Sadly that's fax

  • @AA-mw7zc
    @AA-mw7zc Год назад +60

    This is totally bull sh......!

    • @mudasirrahimi3673
      @mudasirrahimi3673 Год назад

      wtf do u mean twat

    • @TD-he6ov
      @TD-he6ov Год назад +5

      💯

    • @wirginiamobillio
      @wirginiamobillio Год назад +4

      On behalf of her, I'm sorry for her ignorance (i think she is ukrainian like me), some of us in Ukraine know the reality and write bad about USA (the posts on Facebook are in ukrainian, people slowly start to wake up and see the real face of America)

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +1

      Yes

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +1

      ​@@wirginiamobilliomay u have peace in your country.

  • @ertugrulbae46
    @ertugrulbae46 Год назад +19

    I knew this is western sponsored propaganda when she said "progress US made".

  • @Universal_Bro
    @Universal_Bro 11 дней назад

    Yvonne Ridley herself is an example of Taliban's character and hospitality

  • @Jake-Lockley
    @Jake-Lockley 11 месяцев назад +3

    I am really a fan of simplicity, amicable, ego-less, full of self respect nature of afghan brothers. they don't bolster or pretend something they aren't unlike our some neighbours, how afghani people suffererd due to superpowers and highy corrupted, dollar hungry militarymen of their neighbourhood, their economy got crumbled still they are driving their country very well without asking for single dollar to some one. love and respect from India.
    long live afgans 🇮🇳🧡🇦🇫

  • @shafootodess
    @shafootodess Год назад +20

    "the human progress the US made"
    you have to be joking

  • @LoyaAfghanistan
    @LoyaAfghanistan Год назад +49

    😂 now much safer you lucky now where as before robbery was number crime very baies

    • @optiger4371
      @optiger4371 Год назад

      Apka Pakistan bhot acha ha ate Afghanistan ko bura bolte ha

    • @TD-he6ov
      @TD-he6ov Год назад +2

      ​@@optiger4371 bhai aap English nhi samajhte kya wo Afganistan ki tarif kar rha

    • @optiger4371
      @optiger4371 Год назад

      ​@@TD-he6ov ha roobry aou crime bola Raha ha aur tri se acha samjtha ho English 😎

    • @TD-he6ov
      @TD-he6ov Год назад

      @@optiger4371 bhai robbery ka spelling to shi likh le ,aur bewakoof wo hai na pahle se compare kar rha abhi ko aur kah rha hai ki pahle afganistan me robery hota tha ab nhi hota . Kyunki talib me sab safe hai . Pahle jo America ke pille the unme safe nhi tha

  • @ShayarRana
    @ShayarRana 3 месяца назад +3

    Is america safe 😂😂??

  • @dhanjivarsani3214
    @dhanjivarsani3214 2 месяца назад +2

    if you are sunni muslim follow the countrys law and traditions you are probably safe

  • @Rahmani122
    @Rahmani122 Год назад +11

    You exaggerated in this video not like this as you explain 😅😂

  • @SK-xp9xi
    @SK-xp9xi Год назад +15

    What a propaganda video! 😂😂

  • @sweetiepie4328
    @sweetiepie4328 3 месяца назад +8

    They don't hate women in islam . Women are protected. It's culture That puts restriction on women not islam .islam Is perfect , it's people that are not perfect

    • @srebaayao9616
      @srebaayao9616 12 дней назад

      Islam is dead w/o the believers. The believers breathe life to Islam. Islam w/o the believers is a dead religion. Hence, Islam is = to the believers. If the believers are perverted so is Islam. Perverted. You don't excuse Islam per se as perfect. Cause the believers could easily hijacked Islam. The living Islam is made evil by the believers. A dead thing cannot do harm. That is why it is perfect.

  • @user-ns5ef2du8f
    @user-ns5ef2du8f 3 месяца назад +22

    Criticising the very country she safely roamed about in. 😂

  • @nomedigaasi
    @nomedigaasi 3 месяца назад +2

    Tourists? Tourists? What tourists? 😳

  • @Fotosynthesis858
    @Fotosynthesis858 7 месяцев назад +10

    Afghanistan is on my bucket list. I’ve been fascinated with that country ever since the Nat-Geo magazine cover of the Afghani girl with the brilliant eyes. Much love from California, USA ✌🏾

  • @della1731
    @della1731 10 месяцев назад +11

    The only thing dangerous in this video is this lady

  • @Laibapukhtana
    @Laibapukhtana 3 месяца назад +5

    I visit afganistan in every 6 months and i can say it's safe out there ❤

  • @RandomBestEdits
    @RandomBestEdits 7 месяцев назад +1

    I love afghans they are so kind and helpful may god bless them

  • @lorenzochimelis7359
    @lorenzochimelis7359 4 месяца назад +2

    The country is safe from the moral and spiritual cancer that is obliterating the socio cultural fabric of the Christian world and that is the safety that truly matters

  • @sitimrs3221
    @sitimrs3221 6 месяцев назад +4

    Even the roads are not proper yet..look how clean it is..congrats afgans..

  • @Clown5556
    @Clown5556 Год назад +10

    Human progress Us made?😂😂😂😂

  • @fatima.aliyan
    @fatima.aliyan Год назад +24

    Beautiful Afghanistan Masha Allah ✨🍂❤️

  • @chauvintookaknee4blm268
    @chauvintookaknee4blm268 3 месяца назад +2

    Notice no Muslim is trying to debate her lol. They never are. Just victims

  • @XxFootballeditzxX
    @XxFootballeditzxX 11 месяцев назад +2

    I been to Afghanistan 1 month ago I can confirm its safe I promise, Wallahi it was safe for me when I went.

  • @dipanjanachoudhury2047
    @dipanjanachoudhury2047 5 месяцев назад +13

    KFC progress for chickens 🐔 still better than >>>> USA progress in Afghanistan .
    Not even kidding 😅😅😅

  • @FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp
    @FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp 2 месяца назад +4

    Every country in the world has its own religion and rules that you can disagree with, but you must respect them in France, as secular rules prohibit women from wearing a niqab that hides the face.

  • @ferdawshaidary2731
    @ferdawshaidary2731 10 месяцев назад +10

    Everything this woman said is true and yes i am an afghan and for those people saying that this woman is lying and girls are allowed to go to school you are half right girls are allowed to get education till 6th grade and after that they are not allowed to go to school so basically they are allowed to learn the basics like reading writing and some math idk why some of these americans think they are helping afghans by taking the talibans side they are not good people they have done some good after taking control over afghanistan but not much

    • @god-of-logic99
      @god-of-logic99 6 месяцев назад

      Thank you for saying the truth people hate the Americans too much and unfairly and I am not even american. Europeans and Saudis shit on the USA yet they beg for them later. I talked to a few Afghans who ran away during the Taliban takeover.

    • @ernestocamarena3545
      @ernestocamarena3545 4 месяца назад

      Cuz Americans will stretch anything to hate their own government. And thank you for an unbiased explanation

  • @M-UltraInstinct
    @M-UltraInstinct Месяц назад +1

    She's right about minorities tho...

  • @dirtyvet5404
    @dirtyvet5404 Месяц назад

    I am in love with those eyes!!!!!!!!!!! Afghan women are a hidden gem.

  • @basirobaidi667
    @basirobaidi667 Год назад +16

    Human progress 😀😀😀

  • @MattsBarbershopLvganoLugano
    @MattsBarbershopLvganoLugano Год назад +11

    Are you saying that now a foreign tourist is kinda safe to travel?

  • @Ghurshah
    @Ghurshah Год назад +37

    Tajiks are not a minority and Pashtuns are not a majority. This report is somewhat problematic. Why so much make up ?

    • @we-qv7ge
      @we-qv7ge Год назад

      Yes pusthun is majority stupid

    • @eatinsomtin9984
      @eatinsomtin9984 Год назад +13

      Pashtuns are a majority, we are 60-70%

    • @Ghurshah
      @Ghurshah Год назад +1

      @@eatinsomtin9984 No you are not. If that was the case so much would be different. All these external invasions would not be necessary to help Pashtuns and all the fraud and lies and terrorism would not be needed, nor would all the drugs be needed to put Pashtun slaves of ISI into power. Pashtuns are not even a majority in most of the south, where they are supposed to be the majority, that is why no census was ever allowed to take place. Afghanistan is Khurasan and the Persian speakers are the majority 65%-70% being Persian speaking peoples with the remained 35% speaking Non Persian languages but majority of them knowing Persian as second language, e.g. Pashtuns and Uzbeks.
      Pashtun homeland is entirely within Pakistan and they are the main proxy of Pakistani occupiers.

    • @majornukehazard1989
      @majornukehazard1989 Год назад

      And what about the Uzbeks huh?🤔

    • @Ghurshah
      @Ghurshah Год назад

      @@majornukehazard1989 Uzbeks are a significant minority less than 10%. They mostly speak Persian alongside Uzbeki, since Persian is their cultural and the everyone's Lingua Franca. But Uzbek nationalism and Pan Turkish ideas have made many of the Uzbeks into internal enemies of the land, where they act as proxies for Uzbekistan and Turkey, and Russia. More recently they even worked with Turkey to promote ISIS in northern Afghanistan.

  • @Zantigableiaust
    @Zantigableiaust 2 месяца назад +1

    I'm from Indonesia and I really interested to visit Iran, Afghanistan, China and Bakhtria aka Kyrgyzstan one day Insya'Allah:]..

  • @ayshakarbelkar1726
    @ayshakarbelkar1726 11 месяцев назад +2

    Oh really,US progress 😂😂😂... Or US terror , U.S wipe out thousand of locals Afghans by claiming them as terrorist... The people who even didn't had bread to eat , and bombing them for no reason ... Now Afghans are more happier than U.S occupation

  • @S1AKEEB
    @S1AKEEB Год назад +5

    oh stop the bs minorities are safe and this is from a tajik and my relatives are in high positions in the health sector

  • @hibbakhan2231
    @hibbakhan2231 4 месяца назад +5

    girl the human progress? 😂 did u just forget all the people that were killed in the war waged by america when america had absolutely no right to invade their country

  • @notforyou1083
    @notforyou1083 4 месяца назад +11

    you spreading lies about afghanistan

  • @YakrifZee
    @YakrifZee 9 месяцев назад +2

    First America invades other countries, call their freedom fighters as terrorists and after getting defeated they come back to make propaganda movies. 😂

  • @velociraptor3313
    @velociraptor3313 4 месяца назад +2

    The way I look at it when visiting a different country be respectful, learn about the history and experience the culture and the people. Don't be entitled or arrogant. I met an elderly Afghanistan man last year when I was walking my dog and we talked for a little bit about philosophy, the war in Afghanistan and if there is a possibility for the middle east to find peace. He was a good man, I always enjoy meeting new people, getting their thoughts on different things and having a civil discussion. Greetings from Australia.

  • @rock096
    @rock096 6 месяцев назад +3

    Afghanistan is safe if you keep grenades, AK-47 and other weapons

  • @NasirKhan-kx3uq
    @NasirKhan-kx3uq 10 месяцев назад +2

    Long live Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.
    America and western dogs should respect our culture.
    We tought NATO and its father America

  • @MataRazy
    @MataRazy 2 месяца назад +3

    Skewed and juxtaposed assertions ⁉️

  • @rcvujijin
    @rcvujijin 11 месяцев назад +1

    بیشک سب اسلام کے پیچھے پڑے ہے کیوں کہ اسلام سب سے آگے ہے😊❤

  • @sindanonegongo1199
    @sindanonegongo1199 7 месяцев назад +2

    For a blackman it is heaven here😂

  • @SayedMNaimKhalid
    @SayedMNaimKhalid Год назад +9

    Before: 400 people died daily
    Now: no one dies due to war.
    Before: daily war spending $300 million
    Now: 0 dollar spent on war
    Before: you could not to half Afghanistan
    Today: you travel the entire country

  • @msh870
    @msh870 Год назад +11

    I wish you inform yourself better. Killing cultures, and enslaving them is not progress. progress made by US !! .. you mean killing 300,000 person or dropping more that 90,000 bomb by US in Afghanistan? or you mean kidnapping countless of afghans and taking them to Guantanamo bay?.. which progress you are talking about made by US ?
    also Tajik are not a minority in Afghanistan, even the chief of Taliban army in a Tajik

    • @CharlesLandell25
      @CharlesLandell25 Год назад

      Those were friendly bombs.

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад +2

      ​@@CharlesLandell25so drop them in the US😊

    • @CharlesLandell25
      @CharlesLandell25 Год назад

      @@phoenixrising8640 They're for long distance friends ☺️

    • @phoenixrising8640
      @phoenixrising8640 Год назад

      @C9-0L2-7BV8 nah, we have standards, so we are definitely not friends with foreign invader terrorists and bullies of the World.

    • @m.a9454
      @m.a9454 3 месяца назад

      این زن جاسوس امریکاست

  • @uwaismohammed1364
    @uwaismohammed1364 5 месяцев назад +1

    I wish I was born an afghan long live Afghanistan 🇦🇫🖤🐅from India .

    • @MycribsDirty
      @MycribsDirty 5 месяцев назад

      I know being a indian sucks bhai 😢

  • @Ayush_artist590
    @Ayush_artist590 7 месяцев назад +1

    Islam free world=heaven😢

  • @fuadashraf870
    @fuadashraf870 9 месяцев назад +5

    Definition of peace.
    USA: genocide
    Afghanistan: no bloodshed.

  • @beeyondphd5717
    @beeyondphd5717 2 месяца назад +3

    This video is hilarious. What human progress are you talking about?!

  • @IrishVlogs.
    @IrishVlogs. Год назад +31

    There is nothing wrong with our Muslim states except we don't want change we are happy with what we know we don't want to learn a new way or a Christian way simple end of everyone's discussion I said it like how it is

    • @lea24457
      @lea24457 Год назад +5

      Don’t you guys want to evolve a little more ? I totally understand you are happy with all you’ve ever known and that’s absolutely fine , but do you guys not want to move on a little learn more, have more freedom etc (no hate from me btw)

    • @MR.FlyingMonkey
      @MR.FlyingMonkey Год назад +4

      ​​@@lea24457es we want.
      How is that possible tell please !

    • @abuomarr
      @abuomarr Год назад

      @@lea24457 No, we have our own form of freedom, our definition for freedom is different from the western definition. Women being able to get money from a man they choose without having to work is freedom for women. Instead of men using her body for a 1 day date, a man uses her body and she uses his body and he protects her for the rest of his life, give her money, clothes, home food, children.

    • @Jam-rx2zb
      @Jam-rx2zb Год назад +10

      @@lea24457 Nah, Sharia law is fine and it is the best way to get freedom.

    • @user-mf2sj7rd6m
      @user-mf2sj7rd6m Год назад +7

      @@Jam-rx2zbdefinitely not😂😂

  • @bestuan
    @bestuan 4 месяца назад +1

    The hazara problem isn't about ethnicity. it's about sectarianism

  • @scarlettmauner475
    @scarlettmauner475 8 месяцев назад +1

    this comment section is confusing me. i see a lot of afghans online usually talking about how they don't feel safe or how much they hate the taliban. but on this video i see the opposite. the one thing i have seen most people agree on is that they are happy there is no more U.S. presence in afghanistan. is it just like a lesser of two evils thing? i've seen many people talk about how people they know have been arrested unfairly, etc. does it just depend on gender/status/location that makes some people feel safe and others not?

  • @AZ-kh7np
    @AZ-kh7np Год назад +23

    Almost every point you made is plain wrong. I’ve reported your video, hopefully it’ll get taken down. You’re just a plain liar, you’re not even trying

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +4

      keep commenting and ill get more engagement 🤭 thank you in advance

    • @AZ-kh7np
      @AZ-kh7np Год назад +12

      @@elonakarafin calling it “human progress” as if the way of life of Muslims who disagree with the way of life of the west is “non-human” is pathetic. Saying the threat to women and girls is “incomprehensible” when crime rates according to UN themselves (who hate the Taliban) has gone down, again, shows this is a half assed attempt at gaining clout by talking about an ongoing issue without any actual knowledge. Thirdly, saying ethnic minorities are in danger when the Hazara people were for the first time in a very long time protected in their acts of worship under the taliban is again…just plain bs. Please please pleaaaseeee understand that Muslims live and believe in completely different way of life to you. We believe you’re wrong. You might disagree, that’s okay, but please just let us live our way of life without the constant misinformation and threat of violence and invasions. And having read the comments on your video, will you metaphorically man up and take it down after having offended so many people with your misinformation?

    • @elonakarafin
      @elonakarafin  Год назад +1

      @@AZ-kh7np metaphorically ... still no.

    • @janeslater8004
      @janeslater8004 Год назад +2

      @@AZ-kh7np no other muslim country treats women as bad as afganistan its barbaric ..whole world thinks that.

    • @armaanchowdhury1690
      @armaanchowdhury1690 4 месяца назад

      ​@@AZ-kh7npyour way of life is honor killing. The international community should not let you stone women. This is above culture, it is basic human rights.

  • @muminbhat4621
    @muminbhat4621 2 месяца назад +3

    We don't need your America. We are poor but we are happy and have peace.

    • @Tirana-qg1ft
      @Tirana-qg1ft Месяц назад

      Family, country and happiness is more important than money!