@@Feefa99 Their first major war was to protect the world from the Barbary Coast Pirates. Two other major wars also contributed to world freedom including defeating the Nazis. They were also part of the cold war against the deadly cruelty of communism and socialism. They helped to liberate and protect South Korea but failed to save the Vietnamese from communist dictatorship. America and its allies went into but failed to. Then there was Grenada to eliminate a communist regime. They helped liberate Kuwait after the Iraqi invasion. The USA like any powerful nation has to defend its interests.
@@Dijahtal_Arts_Not_Digital_Arts @Dijahtal Arts Well fighting Nazis would did everyone, but two atomic bombs dropped to civilians population is too much. There are lots of questionable excuses from US about their intervention and fighting for freedom, they act like world police often without UN permission, because they want natural resources from country they protect, explain why they have almost 800 military bases around the globe and insane military budget higher even than China. I think you haven't heard enough of Chomsky so you're welcome. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 ruclips.net/video/5BXtgq0Nhsc/видео.html
America has never listened and never will. Any criticism of Israel is brushed aside as anti Semitism a few very brave Jews risked at least their livelihood if not their lives by telling the truth. This man is one of them along with Benjamin Freedmen, Alfred Lilienthal,Israel Shabaka,and Norman Finkelstein. Massive respect to them. They warn of the dangers of Zionism.
@@braven07 true democracy and Israel cannot be put in the same sentence.First learn what real democracy is and after come again for further details if you have questions
Dont you think Israel-Palastine issue is similar Pakistan-India(other religion people who used to live in Pakistan area) infact whole over the world nation are build such. In Palastines case we tend to recognize that, ulike the whole others we miss out(not intrested).
@@Ss-lb1tqLook at the position of India and their press. It is obvious, also the same bad actor caused both eternal situations, because it serves them well
That’s just the above board payouts ($10B). Having Israel as a friend is gigantic in terms of cost. The whole pentagon doesn’t give two shits what’s off the coast of Jersey. But if these things were over Tel-Aviv, they’d take action. It’s a trillion dollars per year , minimum. Plus the lives lost plus they oen congress & the senate. All is lost to an Israel. It takes some real looking into. Try Dr David Duke. Historian. They heaved James Forestall out of s 16-story window. In ‘49. They are the banks. Our preverbal goose is cooked
its simple in case of East . Russian media lost in front of Western media in spreading the propaganda. A fact is starting to print on my mind , That Indeed we are all free the new colonial powers from Europe and North america are enslaving us. The question is , do we have a better alternative ?
I think the fact that people like this exist, and yet we have to choose between people like Trump and Biden demonstrates just how corrupt a system we live in. We don’t choose who is elected, we just choose between two pawns that ultimately have no interest in honesty whatsoever.
@@ct9914 whaaaaat bs at least they gotta pass a damn intelligence test so to speak, the fuck look at America’s idiots that ran for office holy hell you have no idea how much better off your country is with the choices you get to the debate stage come on man seriously, not liking someone’s agenda or personally dosent equate to the popularity contest reality circus
@@pinchebruha405 I agree that America is worse off than France. But it’s quite clear that all over the world, we are seeing the same thing that’s happening currently in American politics happen elsewhere. The anti-lockdown riots really show the ignorance of people around the world. Sadly, America isn’t the only screwed up place.
there is no freedom or democracy it's a sham . Capitalists who call themselves "political donors" or "philanthropists" like "Sheldon Adelson" are the ones who decide who rules and who doesn't then those "elected puppets" decide who rules in the rest of the world through coups , rebel support , political support , etc .
Very few academic intellectuals run for office. Politics is a game which requires a different kind of intelligence that people like Chomsky either aren’t capable of, or don’t desire, to participate in.
" It will be a sad day when this man passes. " The world will be a slightly better place when he's gone, and no longer giving his semi-nonsensical lectures.
@@fredc.meekinsjr.5553 Nonsensical because theyre divorced from the real world we live in, not because I dont understand the arguments. Nothing really changes with him, which is what you expect from someone that had some success once, and then just thinks its like that forever. Must have been a real ego trip for chomsky when Chavez stood up at the UN and waved his book around. Now look at them, the best example in recent memory of a country in the process of decivilization.
@Legba daniels true....but then Noam is not a religious fanatic calling for the death of those who don’t follow his religion, or a man who makes his living airing unsubstantiated conspiracy theories or a fucking idiot who believes we are infiltrated and controlled by reptilian alien invaders. Credibility is earned.
He is a man with ZERO understanding of any important aspect of modern history.. Churchill, in spite of his faults, which he later corrected, was the greatest statesman of the 20th cntury. Chomsky is the anti-Churchill--anything but a statesman.
Absolute treasure is an understatement. Imagine those of us listening and understand this man, can come together and hang out? I bet we'd all have many things in common. 🙏
I would say in this case it is quite the opposite actually, it's about prophecy, because these people have all the power and control the money. what would you do if you maxed out on power and money ... religion, afterlife, etc.
There are places in the so called democratic world, where if you don't embrace the official narrative and you don't embrace jews suffering agenda, then you risk being imprisoned. Such place is Romania, member of E.U. and N.A.T.O. You can deny anything in the world, you can deny any historical facts, you can deny scientific evidence, you can deny existence or absence of god, you can deny ANYTHING, but you are not allowed to criticize jews or deny jews suffering or the so called holocaust. Think about it!
@@Guttlegob I think you're talking about nature karta ( spelling?). There are about twelve of them and the media drags them out to represent jews like they do snake handlers to represent christians. Believe me when I tell you that no one can be as anti semitic as an apostate jew.,which is not the group I referred to,they're just nuts.
Any US congressman who publicly opposes Israel can expect his career to be destroyed. For starters campaign funding will disappear. Then one time supporters will mysteriously stop taking his calls.
In 1943, the Mufti of Jerusalem went to Hitler in Germany to negotiate a "final solution to the Jewish question" in "Palestine". He was something like a dog for the Nazis, but a useful dog, and therefore, they agreed on the "liberation of Palestine from the Jews." Only the presence of British troops in the Middle East saved the Jews from this. The Mufti died in 1974 in one of the Arab countries and managed to create Hamas and other anti-Jewish terrorist organizations. When they talk about the "liberation of Palestine," they are not talking about the Palestinians, but about the territory "free of Jews." That's what a "free Palestine" is.
As a student of linguistics, I have become familiar with Noam Chomsky's work. Today, I watched a complete video of him, and it was nice to see that he is a historical philosopher and a peace advocate.
I'm not sure if I'm the first one to make this observation or not, but I believe he is the most videoed philosopher in history! There are countless videos of lectures, interviews, and talks that he has given on countless topics spanning decades which makes both his longevity and quantity of content unmatched. His countless clips are truly an article of history, like can you believe there is living footage of him debating Michel Foucault? People will undoubtably be watching his takes on philosophy, linguistics, politics, etc. for generations to come.
@@adityabahl Is Moses an outsider because he was ordered by the fictional god to conquer Canaan and kill all its inhabitants including children and women? lol
Chomsky literally opened my eyes about Israel. What kind of project it is and what Palestinian people have been going through... I already knew him as a legend from my computer science background. But I just realized he is a giant in many ways.
Formal language thoery is very fundamental for Computer Science. Have a look at Chomsky Hierarchy. In short, his work is important for programming languages and related things. Also huge influence on NLP and AI with his works on Cogntiive Science.@@SirManBossDudeBroGuy
The saddest part is the fact that it’s the majority of the country that can’t understand any of this very simple analysis, mainly because most just don’t want to.
@@AliceInChains243 everyone understands. they just dismiss them because he speaks of them in a historical vacuum. He’s forced to use modern western values to criticize modern western values. Like measure a ruler with the same ruler. He needs to analyze ancient and modern western values to make his conspiracy theories more relevant.
@Brad-ey4hb '''Tired of my tax dollars used for murder.'' That's weird, your account is a YEAR OLD, have you ever worked in your life, let alone PAID TAXES? You do sound like a leftist, indoctrinated pro Fakestinian supporter.
I feel sick over the recent perturbations in the crisis, and the history that underlies it. These institutions of power are choking our world. Wreaking havoc and devastation untold. Chomsky reminds me that dissenting is a crucial form of resistance and I must remember that.
Breathtaking clarity. His command of the facts is legendary. For those new to Chomsky, you might stop at after every couple of sentences and say to yourself, "Wait, that's not what I heard or was taught", and then when you get the official documents and check, you see that he is correct. Then comes that disturbing moment when you get a glimpse of how distorted, and sometimes outright false, the dominant narrative can be. And then comes a very difficult choice: when you test the waters by speaking up on these types of issues, you open yourself up to torrents of abuse, hysteria, and labeling. But when sufficient numbers of people keep asking the right questions, protesting, and refusing to back down, things can change. This has happened before many times, and it will happen again.
I comment on these videos in order to get people talking and thinking about what I judge to be important issues. And I'm okay with you insulting me; it doesn't add much to the discussion, however. In fact, when people look over these comments and decide for themselves what to think, I'm concerned that your only contribution will the above comment, which I think many folks will view not only as simply rude, but cowardly as well.
There is overwhelming evidence to that effect. Going only back to 1818, John Adams, Founding Father and second President of the United States, wrote, "I really wish the Jews again in Judea an independent nation...". The full reference is: Kark, Ruth (1994). American Consuls in the Holy Land, 1832-1914. Wayne State University Press. p. 23. But there are hundreds of such references from all across academia and politics. You can find them just as easily as I can. So, are there any other claims you need help establishing?
You've changed the subject. Let's get back to it: one of the main reasons that there is such fervent support for Israel in the Unites States is because of the strong zionist streak in Protestantism. That was Chomsky's claim, which you challenged, and which I answered. So, what other claims would you like documented?
I care, because I am morally responsible for what I do and what I can do - not what other people do. Therefore, if what I write might influence somebody to think about things in a new way, then I think that's a good thing. If I am ever in the mood to simply waste time or have a laugh, I'll watch a cooking video or a fail video. But what we are talking about is a serious topic and, in my view, the public has been fed a diet of propaganda. So when Chomsky challenges the propaganda, he backs up what he says with an impressive collection of facts - all in the public record and not in dispute.
This is for Jewish people to decide by what it means to them. One thing Jewishness is absolutely not is Zionism. This is a fundamental misunderstanding that is promoted and encouraged by the ultra-Zionist elite and their ultra-Zionist gofers to equate Zionism and Jewish people as interchangeable terms. They are not and never have been. Once that connection is erroneously made in the public mind - Jewish and non Jewish - exposure of ultra-Zionism and its extremists can be protected and censored by claiming that such criticism is by.definition always an attack on all Jewish people. From this the 'anti-Semitism' industry was born in which critics and ·exposers of ultra-Zionism are targeted and often silenced in the name of protecting Jewish people from 'racist bigots' and 'Nazis' when it's really all about protecting the ultra-Zionist elite from legitimate investigation. David iche - Book "The Trigger"
I think people know the history now especially after the huge offensive from Hamas, if one thing they did right is they atleast gave the world a history lesson. But unfortunately it ends there.
@@philipclock trying to bring the apocolype pretty much, wouldnt that make you the anti christ not the christ? Lol jus sayin, zionism is trying to do the act portrayde in the bible
Israelis are of European stock. Semites refers to Arabs. Please tell me again how the term “Anti-Semitic” applies to Israel. Do your research you moron.
@@chino2037 Don't be such a dick guy. "The root word Semite gives the false impression that antisemitism is directed against all Semitic people, e.g., including Arabs, Asyrians and Arameans. The compound word Antisemitismus ("antisemitism") was first used in print in Germany in 1879 as a scientific-sounding term for Judenhass ("Jew-hatred"), and this has been its common use since then." YOU should really do your research before being such a dick.
The U.S is the great, big country, so this great country deserves having great allies, not a tiny state like Isreal, where tax payers' money is being consumed to protect Isreal
Understand this. Islam will continue to rear it's terrorist head. Israel is an insurance premium, unlike the other countries that hate us and get a handout.
@@Dottor_J So that's why over 200 were killed in Paris? Gang rape in Germany? Foreign airlines hijacked in foreign countries? Islam is Islam, and will be Islam.
Only fairness, justice, rule of law, equality, equal opportunities, merit and human dignity can bring peace and harmony amongst all communities around the world. Thanks
Ok, so a 100% peaceful leader, with no army, no weapons. will somehow lead the world to peace? Or maybe a really strong leader with weapons and a MASSIVE tyrannical ARMY, to enforce that we act peacefully. All 9.8 BILLION people on the planet in 2050? The only way to have a full peace, is to enforce it tyrannically. There is NO SUCH THING as Global Peace without a dictatorship and tyrannical efforts to remove those who oppose tyranny. Subjects. Servants, who "accept" reeducation and subjectification. I doubt they would call it utopia for long. Ask a Chinese refugee, ask a N.Korean refugee about the utopia they thought they were getting.
to the repliers to the original comment: it is not 'duh' or 'kinda stating the obvious' -one might suggest, were they to have to hazard a guess, that vietnam might refer to it as its 'civil war'.
what we need to understand is that the conflict of Israel and Palestine is not a religious conflict, its what they want the masses to think. it's imperialism a colonial state who is taking land from natives and bringing settlers from 'the whole world.
Agreed. Fundamentally, it's not a religious conflict, but you should be telling that to Muslims, who go on and on about the plight of their 'Muslim brothers and sisters', emphasizing the religious aspect of the whole conflict. They've been doing that for decades. In fact it's like a stamp of approval for Muslims: ''a true Muslim supports Palestinians''
@@parisgermain523 western societies were like this also some 600 years ago.If you think about it,Muslims are in their dark ages considering they are most recent religion compared to christianity about the same number of years.Not an excuse,just a thought
@@AlfaBravo7777 How did you get that from my comment?? Read my comment again. Your statements belong in an entirely different discussion. This is about Muslims turning the Israel-Palestine conflict into a religious conflict, NOT about dark ages or whatever.
@@parisgermain523 prophet Mohammed said “The believers in their mutual kindness, compassion and sympathy are just like one body. When one of the limbs suffers, the whole body responds to it with wakefulness and fever”. So wether the war is religious or non-religious does not matter… as a family we will cry and help our family members with whatever we can. This unison and brotherhood is actually what makes Islam a stronger religion and what made people like Andrew tate and many others convert to Islam.
@@AlfaBravo7777Islam had its golden age before and its during that period that Muslims taught Europeans how to get out of their “dark ages”. Many of the Western sciences are based on Islamic ones (many sources prove that). Of course Europeans payed us by biting the hands that helped them. However, the weakness that Islam is going through at the moment was prophesied by prophet Mohammed 1400 years ago and the prophecy goes on to state that we will regain a much stronger power one day Inshallah
My father has known Noam for decades and what you see is who he is all the time. You see authentic, honest and a blisteringly intelligent individual. He is without a doubt one of the greatest thinkers of our time!
But 100 years from now when the genocide is recognized, the US will still veto the Resolution to Recognize the Palestine Genocide in the UN Security Council.
Israel didn't want to do a quick genocide to prevent comparison to nazi Germany. They think they can. Do a slow genocide. And they might be right. It's so disturbing.
@Ronald Hess religious bullshit has nothing to do with now. It has everything to do with POWER, just because some asshole wrote something 2000 years ago doesn't mean we should have blind faith in what is being told. Trust, but verify.
@Ronald Hess This is just pure blasphemy in every sense of the word. Theres nothing in the Bible that calls Christians to support and condone the monstrosities being committed in the Middle East. The United States doesnt need to go out of its way to stop Israel, but we are morally compelled to stop supporting them and their regime. Its one thing the US committed bloody wars and massacres in its goal of manifest destiny for the US. Its a whole another thing for the US to now do the same for manifest destiny of the Greater Israel project. If Zionists want to go expand their Israeli borders, they should spill their own blood and fight their own wars.
@@Slayer8957 by your the looks of your comment you know nothing about christians. christians believe that the ends times starts when the jews occupy the holy land "Jerusalem" and because of that the jews would be "sacrificed" so that christians can go to heaven. more or less that's how Christian interpreted it especially evangelical protestants....don't get me started on them and no "the state of israel" not the people but the state is a threat to world peace and should not exist "The United States doesnt need to go out of its way to stop Israel, but we are morally compelled to stop supporting them and their regime." actually they do need to go out of their way to stop that, that's like saying we condemn the holocausts but we shouldn't do anything about it. but hey whats a terrorist organization gonna say to another terrorist organization. "Its one thing the US committed bloody wars and massacres in its goal of manifest destiny for the US." one of the main reason of manifest destiny was religion and hatred towards what Americans at the time refer to as godless heathens or native americans, i mean christians at the time used the bibble to justify the slaughter of native americans and just like when they justify slavery. "If Zionists want to go expand their Israeli borders, they should spill their own blood and fight their own wars. " how bout we don't start wars and spill blood, i mean before the british came and made the Belfour declaration the Palestinians, Arabs, Turks, Jews and other groups was coexisting peacefully contrary to what the pro Israelis politicians and the media says so idk what your trying to defend here
Essentially did war crimes to steal land and resources for themselves, and without having to pay for the crimes ever, but get rewarded by the riches. The Bible says, thou shalt not kill.
@@sonnydayz2118 oil not so much and off shore, even gas they been relying on import until 2000 they found a gas surely they don't wait 60 years if they know there is those things and they certainly did not steal it . get some history book and read first how israel is established you are being too brainwashed to think israel is the big evil country.
The guy is an idiot. And I'm no fan of Israel. He is a prime example of when one is an expert in one field (linguistics) they think they are experts at everything.
I am blown away. The most concise and comprehensive summary I have ever heard from an individual which cuts through all the guff and tells you what’s what. Amazing man!
I agree. As an American Christian this is why we support Israel.. we want the prophecy to be fulfilled. We don’t support terrorism on the side of Hamas but we don’t want to see innocents being killed either.. especially children.😔🙏
Yes, it is a functional state Max Nordau stated in a speech in London (on June 16, 1920) that he believed that the Zionist state would be a country under the guardianship of Great Britain and that the Jews would stand guard along the dangerous road extending through the Near and Middle East to the borders of India.
Thank you so much for this channel. They need to teach about Noam Chomsky and his books to children in highschool. But I bet they do not want all of us to really be awake.
No pontificating, no bombast, no ego. A man with towering intellect who never wastes a word and gets his message across in a most measured and articulate way.
@@alessiodelcastillo1613 I have yet to see an actual example of him denying a genocide. What I have seen, is him discuss the conditions that lead to certain genocides. Which is obviously not the same thing as genocide denial.
Israel is a colonialist, I'm from Indonesia, just so you know, The Dutch colonized Indonesia but did not apartheid like Israel did, The Dutch colonized Indonesia only took Indonesia's natural wealth but the population or natives or Indonesian people were not evicted, they were killed by bulldozing their houses! now look at what has happened since 1948 Israel colonized Palestine they say Palestine are terrorists, it's the same as the Dutch when they wanted to re-colonize Indonesia in 1949, Indonesian fighters called terrorists, thankfully the land of Palestine is still alive, only Gaza remains because of resistance from Palestinian fighters (Hamas). now you see in Westbank every day children are killed and Palestinians' homes are evicted, their rights are not there The Zionist goal is colonization as well as mass genocide! one day Palestine will be independent and these colonialists will surrender! Open your eyes! That is the reality that exists now!
I have listened to Noam for decades. I took him seriously. But because I didn't have the time or education to understand him at the tine I set this in my way back memory. Here we are again. Thank you sir!
@@גייב-ב3פ european, white wanderers, surrounded by black Arabs.. land grabbing, grave robbing and theft of rare earth such as gold, diamonds and copper. All shrouded in a modern-day bs narrative.
Chomsky himself commented about that. If a non-Jew criticizes Israel, he's labelled antisemitic. If a Jew criticizes Israel, he's labelled a self-hating Jew. That covers 100% of possible criticism towards Israel.
You're both wrong. I live in Israel, and I also criticize Israel, on many occasions, its government, and sometimes the general public. But unlike too many critiques from all around the world - by too many Jews and non-Jews alike - I try my best to base my critique on facts and true context. Chomsky is one of the greatest manipulators (it's a compliment :-) when it comes to criticizing Israel: He gives you partial true facts, seasoned with some not so easy to catch lies, and in most of the cases he distorts the context. I cannot tell if such modus operandi - Chomsky's and others - stems from antisemitism (attitude) or plain hypocrisy (character), but it doesn't serve anything, except hurting the Jews and Israel. Here is a simple example: When it comes to fighting terror and terrorists, Israel is criticized for killing civilians (and children are on the top of the list) - even those who accept that it is not on purpose claim that it is out of proportion and illegal by international law. Here is the international law, Geneva Convention (IV): "Art. 28. The presence of a protected person may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations." ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/WebART/380-600033 Note that it doesn't say "don't hide military targets behind civilians" because those who are ready to do that will not obey international law anyway. It just says "If you hide behind civilians, it won't help you". In addition, "Art.29: The Party to the conflict in whose hands protected persons may be, is responsible for the treatment accorded to them by its agents, irrespective of any individual responsibility which may be incurred." ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/WebART/380-600034 It says, that if you plan a military operation from an area with civilians, you at least have to build shelters for them. But, as we know, Hamas builds military tunnels under hospitals, schools, etc. for his fighters - not for protecting civilians. The rest - go and learn (start by Google: Israel fights Terror. You may want to search for my name on the results) Yechiel Kimchi
@@yechielkimchi6041 zionist shitter trying to justify Israel's war crimes funnily enough go look at what idf does to normal unarmed citizens when they try to revolt or demonstrate somewhere, all you need to do is look at the recent arrests they've made and the numerous people they killed to know the only way to deal with such pigs is by an opposing equal force. Thieves and murders trying to act all civil in the 21st century.
@@yechielkimchi6041. I'm not as knowledgeable as you are in international law. But common sense says that you must provide some proof, that a legitimate target was hiding behind protected people. You can't bomb a residential building and later simply claim there were terrorists inside. And that's just an example of the many cases in which Israel breaks the law.
@@osamaqanbaz6111 @space cowboy None of you referred to the simple argument that I have presented. You can convince only antisemites - too many of them are here, you are included Hope springs eternal
The core linguistic theory he's know for is a retrograde, deterministic view of the development of language across cultures and is very compatible with eugenics. I would recommend you be careful before calling some academic a "genius".
I wouldn't call him a genius. His certain views are idiotic, he has little knowledge on European history of 20th century and he is spewing idiotic bullshit most of the time with such sense of authority that it's laughable
He is as stupid as you are. Israel is the strong but it doesn't mean it is the wrong. It is actually the right. Zionism at it's basis is a center-left secular national movement. While it's adversaries are religious and nationalist right and left fanatics and extremists - a mixture of - Nazists. Fascists and stalinist Communists. Their supporters in the west are actually modern anti-semites - that is anti-zionists. And it doesn't matter whether they are Jews or not. The useful idiots, who think they are supporting the victims, that are practically violent perpetrators of crimes against innocent people that just want to live in peace and let it to others. Left idiots back bastards who wage aggressive continuous attempts to perform genocide and kill, hurt, harm as many people as they can. Extreme leftist fools support these criminals because they think weak means right. As strong means wrong. Nazis very like Arabs also thought that they are victims and Jews are to blame and to be punished. The so called Mufti of Jerusalem and Hitler were allies on these grounds. Arabs' violence has nothing to do with Israel, they've been murdering one another for hundreds of years. It is the result of more than a thousand year oppression by their rulers but as Jews started escaping from pogroms in Europe, Arabs that many of them came from neighboring territories after the Jews, found great justification why they have a right to do the same - murder Jews and to consider themselves heroes while perpetrating heinous crimes against men, women, children and elderly, just to get rid of their own inner personal problems coming of their culture of violence and despotism.
I'm 19 years old and boys of my age often would like to either go partying watch movies(propaganda) or do something amusing but I can listen to Noam Chomsky(my wisdom grandpa😊) all day and night long without blinking, I wish I could shake hands with him, but I'm living 10k miles away right here in beautiful Afghanistan.
it doesn't make sense, Britain never colonised the levant or the Middle East in general, when the Ottoman Empire collapsed Britain and France inherited the old Ottoman colonial territories.
@@chinchin6559 he uses the wrong words but he isnt wrong, the british didnt displace populations. The people who lived there were subjects of the crowns and were allowed to live there and follow their beliefs and not people from the isles. The item which the british did wrong was drawing borders with disregard to the ethnicity in the borders which is what causes wars.
That's right. Down to the bare bones of it. I think it's starting to eat itself now like a cancer. The all consuming is starting to consume itself. I'm starting to see it slowly cracking from the inside. Maybe a revolution is coming
The US economy is based upon war, if there were no wars for the US to sell weapons to both sides, the US would be bankrupt. Also, the US keeps many regions of the world unstable so that it can side with those who have oil and natural resources so it can procure them cheaply, remember without the perto-dollar the US economy would crash...
@@DangerRussDayZ6533 So, let's just keep murdering millions of innocent civilians then? Sorry but the only reason there was a global financial crash in 2008 was because of the greed of the banks who were the bailed out at the expense of the taxpayer, your government is lying to you, as are mine...
If you read your Bible it’s quite violent and the god of the Bible wanted punishment, vengeance, and war. All people of the Abrahamic cults cherry pick their religious text.
Not the whole story. Sure, Zionism was and is a force to be reckoned with, particularly in cultish parts of the Midwest. What Chomsky doesn't mention is Eisenhower's fury in 1956 when Israel first captured Gaza from Egypt, leading him to demand their withdrawal. And Israel's malevolent presence in the region was what provoked pan-Arab nationalism exacerbating cold war tensions. As for the Pentagon being supportive of Israel from the outset, it was George C Marshall as Secretary of State who famously fell out with Truman's spad Clark Clifford over recognition of the Israeli partition of Palestine - the Pentagon was always rightly worried about getting embroiled in ME wars started by Israeli aggression and expansion. It still is.
Reducing the modern American argument to it's core -- "If you're anti-Likud, anti-Netanyahu, anti-Occupation, then you're an antisemite, and the only logical conclusion possible is that you're pro-Hamas." Where there's a lack of facts/counterpoints but an abundance of passion, that's when they trot out the schoolyard name-calling. Don't you dare raise a question of the Likud's bloodshed -- only talk about Hamas's bloodshed -- because the second you begin pointing out that the majority of innocent blood spilt in this war is on Israeli hands, suddenly you're a Jew-hater.
Hamas has not been regarded as a terrorist group by most countries In the world including the UN, they're more often regarded as the resistant group of Palestinian people towards Israeli oppression, yet the media of the countries who allied with Israel often follows the government propaganda and calls them terrorist group. The moment they're labelled with group of terrorism, people can forget about the context and Israel are permitted to do anything they wanted in the name of fighting the terrorism, and that's including shelling the civilians, cutting of water, electricity, food and medical for two million people and dislocate one million.
@@haixinzheng9759 What Hamas did on 07 October by invading Israel and deliberately set about murdering women, children, aged people individually after torturing, mutilating and abusing their victims can only be considered terrorism. They were not "resisting israeli oppression" . They were bent on murder unconnected with military combat .
Perhaps. I don't follow all the policy choices of Pelosi (or most others) but I would say that equation is not accurate, because Chomsky wholeheartedly tries to be equitable while most politicians are exactly that: politicians. But in this world where might makes right playing the role of a do-gooder bent on fairness may be indeed a death sentence. So he wouldn't survive as a politician, and the lone nation that plays fair in a cheating game would lose.
@@postcarbonitelove5308 I totally disagree that he wholeheartedly tries to be equitable. Like any self respecting lefty he abides by a hierarchy of grievance, all thats up for debate is what identity group deserves top position, and whatever welfare comes along with it. We can take it for granted that most anglo-american white people don't even rate, as they're the "masters of the universe" .
@@lieshtmeiser5542 also have you actually listend to any of his talks, he doesn't really care about that identity shit as much as the centrist libs do, if you think they are the hard left you have alot of learning to do
Netanyahu announced in the September before Oct 7th that "Israel should annex the Gaza strip." Also, he knew a year in advance that the attack would occur and deliberately refused to send the IDF to guard the Israeli settlers, for which he publicly apologized for. He deliberately sacrificed the settlers for an excuse to invade and bomb Gaza...INMO.
I am a British person and i too approve of this message. the amount of people in my country who want to downplay our historical atrocities is shocking.
@user-ik1rx9uv7j so it's okay to shoot death to jews but death to Islam offends you. As a human they should offend you equally. Christians killed jews and Muslims during the crusades yet salladin gave Christians control over Jerusalem because he was more interested in his capitol of Baghdad. Now the Muslims claim control over Jerusalem and seek to kill Christians and jews. Only Israel allows all 3 to worship freely in Jerusalem.
I believe we should call for a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want. Simple. Very simple. It's not a thousands of years matter. Zionism is danger and should not be adopted by a state.
I love Noam, but wonder, given how much he knows about society and people in general, how the hell he gets out of bed in the morning...A clear, reasonable, calm, articulate sane voice drowned out by idiots with agendas...Thank you for the upload!
He gets out of bed because he's a leftist radical, and leftist radicals live to lecture. Note that he has no solutions to the problems, the last time a solution that he recommended was tried: eg Morsi in Egypt, it ended in a coup because Morsi tried to violate the constitution.
Lieshtmeiser If you’re against western imperialism you’re apparently a leftist for not wanting to see kids bombed or the US funding terrorist regimes. Who knew?
@@buzifalus What works against Chomsky in geopolitical ideology and commentary, unlike his work in linguistics, is that most of the leftist ideology and movements, eg post modernism, climate alarmism, etc, just fundamentally dont work, and do harm to human civilization and individuals. By siding so strongly with that side of the political spectrum, he dooms himself to being on the side that cannot build a lasting and good system. The great achievements of his side of politics are: Zimbabwe, Venezuela, North Korea, Vietnam, mass muslim migration to the EU, out of control latino migration to the US, etc. If the US had just isolated itself after World War 2, and vacated asia and europe, who knows how far communism wouldve spread, who knows how many more pol pot style purges we wouldve seen, who knows how many people wouldve been gulagged. He just takes it for granted that the world would be a safer place without superpowers trying to hold things together, I strongly doubt that.
@@lieshtmeiser5542 Usual America propaganda-wash. The USA has an important job but since it is not doing it, it is better if it wasn't even existing at all. Keep selling advanced killing tech to chimps and spreading the dollar in the world, that's exactly what those 3rd worlders don't need, and the proof everyone needs for knowing how much not of a savior USA is. The matter of the fact is that the USA can't keep playing the part of world sheriff (or gangster, or world bully) but also put naive face and act as if just another country in the world political affairs, or like you said, keeping to itself. USA citizens are massively sheltered while woes affect the rest of the globe.
@@levimatthew8911 Hamas and Hezbollah are products of the instability and oppression that has been prevalent in the region for decades. This instability is caused intentionally by the US through Israel as a proxy. Your antisemitic argument is not valid.
Noam Chomsky, one of the greatest intellectual humanitarians, a walking library of knowledge, understanding and objectivity. The world has gone insane, and voices of reason and facts are increasingly disappearing. May God bless and protect this man.
Didn't he say unvaccinated people with natural immunity to covid should be forced to take the vaccine or be banished from society and forced to fend for themselves? About 4 minutes 10 seconds into this video? ruclips.net/video/ruQH5A2Q4XU/видео.htmlsi=ru6JeQRL7yqMzPBO
Overrated, old, senile, demented, bloated pseudo-intellectual who's lived his entire life in freedom and comfort and has never ever been in war nor threatened. Everything he says is BS.
The subject is being described by the Zionist Chomsky to confuse simple leftist. Here is the reality, chomsky supports Israel. He is misleading people when he says Israel breaks international law. Israel is not breaking international law, there isnt an international law. if there was, the UN would punish Israel for the crimes it commits. Israel is above international law and can only be stopped by an attack from foreign powers. Chomsky is against this attack and punishment because he is a Zionist. He is just playing a heard of sheeple called leftist. Here is the reality. The good guys won ww2, they installed Israel after redrawing borders. Palestinians lost ww2. Palestinians still fight a lost war. With every attack the Palestinians perpetuate on the winners of ww2, the more land the Palestinians lose. The Palestinians would do better to surrender and exist next door to Israel in peace, but they wont do that. It's very important to understand the ottoman empire failed and that was the protection Palestinians had. We can see israel growing and the Palestinians losing. Israel will be under constant attack and that probably pleases Israel because Israel will be very happy to take more land and kill more enemies. Chomsky knows this, he is no fool. He is just playing fools and making money off of then.... like a good Zionist does. Look, if you're mad the good guys won ww2, then that sucks. Maybe Germany can go enforce that international UN law chomsky keeps talking about
@@EugVR6 obviously UN laws mean nothing. Otherwise, Israel would be punished for breaking the laws. Laws that are not enforced are nill. So as soon as a power emerges that can punish Israel, Israel will be punished. The germans tried very hard and failed. So the reality exist first and foremost, if Palestinians attack Israel, Israel will win and grab More land. If the UN decided to take military action actions Israel to stop it from the onslaught, then Israel will be stopped. But any country that attacks Israel will meet the fury of Israel. if the US decided not to veto votes of the UN, then punishment would have to be levied. That would mean a war with Israel and that war was already fought, it was called ww2. Israel was a spoil of ww2. So people who want to see Israel punished basically should wish the Germans won ww2
@Davide Fabbri borders are established by war. WW2 established the borders of Israel. Palestinians lost WW2. It seems Noam does not want to state it bluntly. He likes to sell what he says to leftwing thinkers. It can be perceived that the far left has caught up to the far right in terms of how they think about Israel. I mean if they really punished Israel, that would be insane lol
I’m back 7 years later watching this video again with my partner. Educating her about the conflicts today and how America has been the biggest instigator. This is a rerun. Every few years we’re revisiting the same scenario.
@@jamesstone9140september 18th 2023,just 19 days before "the attack" Israeli forces killed 38 Palestinian children....19days before!!!!! Now,who has the right to retaliate and defend itself??? Go check out operation protection edge on the deaths there.
the genocidal character of Karl Marx 'colonization' Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, “You must understand. The leading Bolsheviks who took over Russia were not Russians. They hated Russians. They hated Christians. Driven by ethnic hatred they tortured and slaughtered millions of Russians without a shred of human remorse. The October Revolution was not what you call in America the “Russian Revolution.” It was an invasion and conquest over the Russian people. More of my countrymen suffered horrific crimes at their bloodstained hands more than any people or nation ever suffered in the entirety of human history. It cannot be understated. Bolshevism was the greatest human slaughter of all time. The fact that most of the world is ignorant of this reality is proof that the global media itself is in the hands of the perpetrators.” “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his entire world view depends upon his not understanding it.”
I always liked his favorite quote from Walter Lippman, "the bewildered herd"... "The specialized class, the responsible men, carry out the executive function, which means they do the thinking and planning and understand the common interests. Then, there is the bewildered herd,..." Chomsky mocks it, but then, if anyone escapes from marxist leftist university and experiences the real world, they will understand over time why this is the case. Consider Jordan Petersons discussion of IQ, thats one reason why "the responsible men" are in control. Because if retarded people are in charge, theyll ruin everything...they may be so retarded they dont even realize theyre ruining it. Consider errors, mistakes and misfortune. There could be a genius, charismatic, a leader of people, a great and humanitarian person, they become a quadriplegic in an accident...cant even shave themselves to toilet themselves, such a person wont govern the country. We could go on like this...the world isnt an equal distribution of talents and successes for a variety of reasons.
Man I was wondering how NC is and found this. Everyone needs to say a prayer for him tonight. What a blessing this man was to his time and ours. Who will carry the torch of sage and wisdom? Brilliant post modern saint of any intellectual worth the letters behind their names. May he reincarnate immediately after passing. We STILL need him❤
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Let’s be real this is one of the primary reasons Bernie Sanders got the shaft. The second he publicly criticized support for Israel, it was over.
@Dylan Martens nobody' shafted him.He is a daft millionaire Marxist hypocrite. End of
@Dylan Martens The Marxist mafia promote any medicrities who support their genocidal ideology
@@Dijahtal_Arts_Not_Digital_Arts just rhetorical question......In how many wars USA were in last century to this day?
@@Feefa99 Their first major war was to protect the world from the Barbary Coast Pirates. Two other major wars also contributed to world freedom including defeating the Nazis. They were also part of the cold war against the deadly cruelty of communism and socialism. They helped to liberate and protect South Korea but failed to save the Vietnamese from communist dictatorship. America and its allies went into but failed to. Then there was Grenada to eliminate a communist regime. They helped liberate Kuwait after the Iraqi invasion. The USA like any powerful nation has to defend its interests.
@@Dijahtal_Arts_Not_Digital_Arts @Dijahtal Arts Well fighting Nazis would did everyone, but two atomic bombs dropped to civilians population is too much. There are lots of questionable excuses from US about their intervention and fighting for freedom, they act like world police often without UN permission, because they want natural resources from country they protect, explain why they have almost 800 military bases around the globe and insane military budget higher even than China. I think you haven't heard enough of Chomsky so you're welcome. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
ruclips.net/video/5BXtgq0Nhsc/видео.html
America has never listened and never will. Any criticism of Israel is brushed aside as anti Semitism a few very brave Jews risked at least their livelihood if not their lives by telling the truth. This man is one of them along with Benjamin Freedmen, Alfred Lilienthal,Israel Shabaka,and Norman Finkelstein. Massive respect to them. They warn of the dangers of Zionism.
The only true democracy in the Middle East is Israel. The culture and moral values of Judaism far exceeds of Islam.
@@braven07 true democracy and Israel cannot be put in the same sentence.First learn what real democracy is and after come again for further details if you have questions
And Gabor Mate too
Dont you think Israel-Palastine issue is similar Pakistan-India(other religion people who used to live in Pakistan area) infact whole over the world nation are build such. In Palastines case we tend to recognize that, ulike the whole others we miss out(not intrested).
@@Ss-lb1tqLook at the position of India and their press. It is obvious, also the same bad actor caused both eternal situations, because it serves them well
8 years ago. This speech was made 8 years ago, and people still say the war started on October 7th 2023.
So it’s still very relevant
@@ddarbela that's the OP's point 😉
Non c'est en 48 qu'elle a commencé !
@@augustinedebosson9343 Go back further in history!
@@augustinedebosson9343 It started in the 7th century with M00h44mmed the murdering rapist.
AIPAC pays senators in left and right about 100M per election to get 10B foreign aid every year from US taxpayers. It is an amazing deal for Israel
There is no 'left' in US 😂
And it fights the arab world for its own and US interests.
so they say, the best investment by israel
That’s just the above board payouts ($10B). Having Israel as a friend is gigantic in terms of cost. The whole pentagon doesn’t give two shits what’s off the coast of Jersey. But if these things were over Tel-Aviv, they’d take action. It’s a trillion dollars per year , minimum. Plus the lives lost plus they oen congress & the senate. All is lost to an Israel. It takes some real looking into. Try Dr David Duke. Historian. They heaved James Forestall out of s 16-story window. In ‘49. They are the banks. Our preverbal goose is cooked
25 billion currently
He’s describing exactly how the US media is behaving now
and Academia…
@@user-zq4fv8sj6v😂 its the contrary Noam chomsky is an acadamian.
Why don’t use a real compte
👉 Albert Einstein Letter to the New York Times
its simple in case of East .
Russian media lost in front of Western media in spreading the propaganda.
A fact is starting to print on my mind , That Indeed we are all free the new colonial powers from Europe and North america are enslaving us.
The question is , do we have a better alternative ?
jews are not indigenous to israel@@user-zq4fv8sj6v
I think the fact that people like this exist, and yet we have to choose between people like Trump and Biden demonstrates just how corrupt a system we live in. We don’t choose who is elected, we just choose between two pawns that ultimately have no interest in honesty whatsoever.
Very true. The people who could run our society in a rational way will never get the chance.
@@ct9914 whaaaaat bs at least they gotta pass a damn intelligence test so to speak, the fuck look at America’s idiots that ran for office holy hell you have no idea how much better off your country is with the choices you get to the debate stage come on man seriously, not liking someone’s agenda or personally dosent equate to the popularity contest reality circus
@@pinchebruha405 I agree that America is worse off than France. But it’s quite clear that all over the world, we are seeing the same thing that’s happening currently in American politics happen elsewhere. The anti-lockdown riots really show the ignorance of people around the world. Sadly, America isn’t the only screwed up place.
there is no freedom or democracy it's a sham .
Capitalists who call themselves "political donors" or "philanthropists" like "Sheldon Adelson" are the ones who decide who rules and who doesn't
then those "elected puppets" decide who rules in the rest of the world through coups , rebel support , political support , etc .
Very few academic intellectuals run for office. Politics is a game which requires a different kind of intelligence that people like Chomsky either aren’t capable of, or don’t desire, to participate in.
Here is a man who knows the truth that no "patriotic American" wants to hear. It will be a sad day when this man passes.
" It will be a sad day when this man passes.
"
The world will be a slightly better place when he's gone, and no longer giving his semi-nonsensical lectures.
@@lieshtmeiser5542 the fact that you can’t understand this man speaks tons about your intellect, not his.
@@fredc.meekinsjr.5553 Nonsensical because theyre divorced from the real world we live in, not because I dont understand the arguments.
Nothing really changes with him, which is what you expect from someone that had some success once, and then just thinks its like that forever.
Must have been a real ego trip for chomsky when Chavez stood up at the UN and waved his book around. Now look at them, the best example in recent memory of a country in the process of decivilization.
@Legba daniels true....but then Noam is not a religious fanatic calling for the death of those who don’t follow his religion, or a man who makes his living airing unsubstantiated conspiracy theories or a fucking idiot who believes we are infiltrated and controlled by reptilian alien invaders. Credibility is earned.
@Legba daniels "educating the American people"
Unnecessary and from what I can tell, mostly unwanted.
Chomsky is ALWAYS INFORMED AND CONCISE! Even in his golden years, he is sharper than most 20, 30 and 40-year-olds.
This man is a national treasure! 🙏🏼
Global treasure! 🤍 from India
He is a man with ZERO understanding of any important aspect of modern history.. Churchill, in spite of his faults, which he later corrected, was the greatest statesman of the 20th cntury. Chomsky is the anti-Churchill--anything but a statesman.
He is one of my favourite humans. From his talks and writing, i learned that integrity can withstand endless scrutiny.
@@stephenlawless4156: Exactly, you said it, Sir; “Integrity can withstand endless scrutiny.”
Absolute treasure is an understatement. Imagine those of us listening and understand this man, can come together and hang out? I bet we'd all have many things in common. 🙏
Our guy Noam is nearing the end of a long, beautiful life. I’m so happy I’ve gotten to read and watch and learn from him.
I'm so happy he is finally about to be gone now 😊
9 out of 10 times, it is about the money & the power.
more like 10 out of 10. You cannot find a case where it isn't about either money or power, or both.
I would say in this case it is quite the opposite actually, it's about prophecy, because these people have all the power and control the money.
what would you do if you maxed out on power and money ... religion, afterlife, etc.
Goran Vlacic Unfortunately with these elites you can never Max out money and power.
So 9 out 10 ISIS and taliban are just in it for the money and power? Im sure they feel powerful when their stolen toyotas get drone striked.
Lieshtmeiser The foot soldiers are brainwashed and mostly true believers; the leadership on the other hand different story.
'If you want to know who controls you, look at who you are not allowed to criticize'
There are places in the so called democratic world, where if you don't embrace the official narrative and you don't embrace jews suffering agenda, then you risk being imprisoned. Such place is Romania, member of E.U. and N.A.T.O.
You can deny anything in the world, you can deny any historical facts, you can deny scientific evidence, you can deny existence or absence of god, you can deny ANYTHING, but you are not allowed to criticize jews or deny jews suffering or the so called holocaust. Think about it!
100%
If your quote can easily get appropiated by bigots to denounce political correctness, it wasn't such a good quote to begin with.
I think one should be critical of Islam.
@@nadaproblem3023what are you trying to say?
So beautifully and honestly explained! Thank you so much, Mr Noam Chomsky. May you live long in health and prosperity. Amen.
This is exactly what's happening 6 years later in Gaza, with hopes that the narrative will be put in its right place.
I bet you are not from Gaza
@@levanpkh6882 so what
Yip. Ruled by vicious jihadists.
Screw Gaza
Let’s remember a fact that Chomsky is Jewish, many of his critics consider what he says as treasonous yet despite all that, he still pressed on
Self hating jews are ubiquitous. Its a big tribe,all leftists and all slap each other on the back..nothing brave about it, the opposite really.
@@wilfredruffian5002 self hating 😂 Maybe they're the ones admitting that what their country is doing is wrong
@@yazan774 a pathological oikophobe would do exactly that .
Self Hating? The most Orthodox Jews are anti Zionist.
@@Guttlegob I think you're talking about nature karta ( spelling?). There are about twelve of them and the media drags them out to represent jews
like they do snake handlers to represent christians. Believe me when I tell you that no one can be as anti semitic as an apostate jew.,which is not the group I referred to,they're just nuts.
Any US congressman who publicly opposes Israel can expect his career to be destroyed. For starters campaign funding will disappear. Then one time supporters will mysteriously stop taking his calls.
They are all slaves of satan
not really though
People hate the truth. Israel is oppressive.
The Home of the Brave.
In 1943, the Mufti of Jerusalem went to Hitler in Germany to negotiate a "final solution to the Jewish question" in "Palestine". He was something like a dog for the Nazis, but a useful dog, and therefore, they agreed on the "liberation of Palestine from the Jews." Only the presence of British troops in the Middle East saved the Jews from this. The Mufti died in 1974 in one of the Arab countries and managed to create Hamas and other anti-Jewish terrorist organizations.
When they talk about the "liberation of Palestine," they are not talking about the Palestinians, but about the territory "free of Jews." That's what a "free Palestine" is.
As a student of linguistics, I have become familiar with Noam Chomsky's work. Today, I watched a complete video of him, and it was nice to see that he is a historical philosopher and a peace advocate.
I'm not sure if I'm the first one to make this observation or not, but I believe he is the most videoed philosopher in history! There are countless videos of lectures, interviews, and talks that he has given on countless topics spanning decades which makes both his longevity and quantity of content unmatched. His countless clips are truly an article of history, like can you believe there is living footage of him debating Michel Foucault? People will undoubtably be watching his takes on philosophy, linguistics, politics, etc. for generations to come.
There is no peace with Islam
My dude older than Israel, so when he talks, listen
god damn
xD
@@adityabahl He actually IS older than Israel. It was established in 1948. He was born in 1928.
@@adityabahl You're right, the land IS much, much older than Chomsky. But then again, that's like saying the US is millions of years old.
@@adityabahl Is Moses an outsider because he was ordered by the fictional god to conquer Canaan and kill all its inhabitants including children and women? lol
Chomsky literally opened my eyes about Israel. What kind of project it is and what Palestinian people have been going through... I already knew him as a legend from my computer science background. But I just realized he is a giant in many ways.
Good or bad way?
@@nanyabiznus4738 objective way.
I'm curious as to what/why you became aware of Noam Chomsky via Computer Science?
@@SirManBossDudeBroGuyme too! 😂
Formal language thoery is very fundamental for Computer Science. Have a look at Chomsky Hierarchy. In short, his work is important for programming languages and related things. Also huge influence on NLP and AI with his works on Cogntiive Science.@@SirManBossDudeBroGuy
Crazy to think so many still can't wrap their head around this today.
@@_inthefold It's not a history of zionism? He's just explaining the US and then British view of Israel and their zionist goals.
Most people understand these “historical out of context” conspiracy and views but, by the time most people-reach 30 they reject it as “non tenable “
The saddest part is the fact that it’s the majority of the country that can’t understand any of this very simple analysis, mainly because most just don’t want to.
@@AliceInChains243 everyone understands. they just dismiss them because he speaks of them in a historical vacuum. He’s forced to use modern western values to criticize modern western values. Like measure a ruler with the same ruler. He needs to analyze ancient and modern western values to make his conspiracy theories more relevant.
Some are willfully blind tooo
A wise, knowledgeable man.
few people know history. that why propaganda is working
💯🎯🎯👏
And because Barry Soetoro legalized propaganda in the US by repealing the Bain act in 2012 or 13
Yup history repeats a lot
I agree with you. Unfortunately Noam Chomsky is not one of those few people.
That’s right! Because of lack of knowledge, people fall for Chomsky’s crap.
Tired of my tax dollars used for murder.
Being tired that your Tax Dollars are going to murdah...
is ANTISEMITIC
😂
😂
You DO realize we give money to Israel's enemies, including the Palestinians, right?
So...what keeps you from keeping that money for yourself instead of giving it to the elite???
I stopped paying for all their hobbies a year ago.😊😊
Palestinians aren't lzrel's enemies, they're lzrel's VICTIMS
@Brad-ey4hb
'''Tired of my tax dollars used for murder.''
That's weird, your account is a YEAR OLD, have you ever worked in your life, let alone PAID TAXES?
You do sound like a leftist, indoctrinated pro Fakestinian supporter.
I feel sick over the recent perturbations in the crisis, and the history that underlies it. These institutions of power are choking our world. Wreaking havoc and devastation untold. Chomsky reminds me that dissenting is a crucial form of resistance and I must remember that.
"I consider myself a dissenter...not a malcontent." Thurgood Marshall, late Supreme Court Justice. Don't be a sheep!
You tried to use that “word of the day” today didn’t you lol
@@milagroman75 I appreciate your attempt at levity, but this isn't the topic for it.
This man should run the world. My respect to such a brilliant academic
The world is run by God, no man is in charge of nothing, you came with nothing and you take nothing. Amen
Breathtaking clarity. His command of the facts is legendary. For those new to Chomsky, you might stop at after every couple of sentences and say to yourself, "Wait, that's not what I heard or was taught", and then when you get the official documents and check, you see that he is correct. Then comes that disturbing moment when you get a glimpse of how distorted, and sometimes outright false, the dominant narrative can be. And then comes a very difficult choice: when you test the waters by speaking up on these types of issues, you open yourself up to torrents of abuse, hysteria, and labeling. But when sufficient numbers of people keep asking the right questions, protesting, and refusing to back down, things can change. This has happened before many times, and it will happen again.
I comment on these videos in order to get people talking and thinking about what I judge to be important issues. And I'm okay with you insulting me; it doesn't add much to the discussion, however. In fact, when people look over these comments and decide for themselves what to think, I'm concerned that your only contribution will the above comment, which I think many folks will view not only as simply rude, but cowardly as well.
I would be happy to. Which claim of his would you like documentation for?
There is overwhelming evidence to that effect. Going only back to 1818, John Adams, Founding Father and second President of the United States, wrote, "I really wish the Jews again in Judea an independent nation...". The full reference is: Kark, Ruth (1994). American Consuls in the Holy Land, 1832-1914. Wayne State University Press. p. 23.
But there are hundreds of such references from all across academia and politics. You can find them just as easily as I can.
So, are there any other claims you need help establishing?
You've changed the subject. Let's get back to it: one of the main reasons that there is such fervent support for Israel in the Unites States is because of the strong zionist streak in Protestantism. That was Chomsky's claim, which you challenged, and which I answered. So, what other claims would you like documented?
I care, because I am morally responsible for what I do and what I can do - not what other people do. Therefore, if what I write might influence somebody to think about things in a new way, then I think that's a good thing. If I am ever in the mood to simply waste time or have a laugh, I'll watch a cooking video or a fail video. But what we are talking about is a serious topic and, in my view, the public has been fed a diet of propaganda. So when Chomsky challenges the propaganda, he backs up what he says with an impressive collection of facts - all in the public record and not in dispute.
No one is bringing this history and context up when reporting on Israel.
This is for Jewish people to decide by what it means to them.
One thing Jewishness is absolutely not is Zionism. This is a fundamental
misunderstanding that is promoted and encouraged by the ultra-Zionist
elite and their ultra-Zionist gofers to equate Zionism and Jewish people
as interchangeable terms. They are not and never have been. Once that
connection is erroneously made in the public mind - Jewish and non Jewish - exposure of ultra-Zionism and its extremists can be protected
and censored by claiming that such criticism is by.definition always an
attack on all Jewish people. From this the 'anti-Semitism' industry was
born in which critics and ·exposers of ultra-Zionism are targeted and
often silenced in the name of protecting Jewish people from 'racist
bigots' and 'Nazis' when it's really all about protecting the ultra-Zionist
elite from legitimate investigation.
David iche - Book "The Trigger"
Well, YT is bringing it up now... apparently not only to me. After 7 years.
That's why we must help spread the Truth and double-down, then triple-down when we're called anti-semites.
They are you’re just watching garbage so you’re not seeing it
I think people know the history now especially after the huge offensive from Hamas, if one thing they did right is they atleast gave the world a history lesson. But unfortunately it ends there.
“Nothing is more anti-Semitic than Zionism”- Lowkey
'Splain please.
@@philipclock trying to bring the apocolype pretty much, wouldnt that make you the anti christ not the christ? Lol jus sayin, zionism is trying to do the act portrayde in the bible
Israelis are of European stock. Semites refers to Arabs. Please tell me again how the term “Anti-Semitic” applies to Israel. Do your research you moron.
@@chino2037 Don't be such a dick guy. "The root word Semite gives the false impression that antisemitism is directed against all Semitic people, e.g., including Arabs, Asyrians and Arameans. The compound word Antisemitismus ("antisemitism") was first used in print in Germany in 1879 as a scientific-sounding term for Judenhass ("Jew-hatred"), and this has been its common use since then."
YOU should really do your research before being such a dick.
@@ERROR204. thank you for educating racist idiots. Much appreciated.
This man is a gift to the world! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Excellent analysis. A great mind. A great thinker.
As a conservative myself, I’ve never understood why we give so many funds to Israel when we have problems to deal with in our own country
The U.S is the great, big country, so this great country deserves having great allies, not a tiny state like Isreal, where tax payers' money is being consumed to protect Isreal
Understand this. Islam will continue to rear it's terrorist head. Israel is an insurance premium, unlike the other countries that hate us and get a handout.
@@eltonron1558 I'd argue that terrorists are the byproduct of american intervention in the middle east.
@@Dottor_J So that's why over 200 were killed in Paris? Gang rape in Germany? Foreign airlines hijacked in foreign countries? Islam is Islam, and will be Islam.
@@eltonron1558, do you understand what the word 'byproduct' means?
I am very grateful for your knowledge, expertise, and honesty in discussing international affairs. This is hell.
Only fairness, justice, rule of law, equality, equal opportunities, merit and human dignity can bring peace and harmony amongst all communities around the world. Thanks
Ok, so a 100% peaceful leader, with no army, no weapons. will somehow lead the world to peace?
Or maybe a really strong leader with weapons and a MASSIVE tyrannical ARMY, to enforce that we act peacefully. All 9.8 BILLION people on the planet in 2050?
The only way to have a full peace, is to enforce it tyrannically.
There is NO SUCH THING as Global Peace without a dictatorship and tyrannical efforts to remove those who oppose tyranny.
Subjects.
Servants, who "accept" reeducation and subjectification.
I doubt they would call it utopia for long.
Ask a Chinese refugee, ask a N.Korean refugee about the utopia they thought they were getting.
Lgbt rainBow you want to feed whole world? Disgusting
Keep your Pride for yourself
True, but super naive to think it will ever happen. Corruption and Evil reign supreme in this world.
Do you have a plan for that?
Agree very much, although I would add freedom of expression and consensual choice.
"A herd of independent minds marching in support of State Power". Such a well thought phrase and so true universally even today. ❤️
Sounds like democrats
vietnam call's the war "The American war"
Duh
Kinda stating the obvious.
All the war are the blind alley for instigater.
to the repliers to the original comment: it is not 'duh' or 'kinda stating the obvious' -one might suggest, were they to have to hazard a guess, that vietnam might refer to it as its 'civil war'.
@@daktarioskarvannederhosen2568 1 word for you. Dick head.
Thank you for this great speech!
As it is said, the first casualty of war is the truth.
what we need to understand is that the conflict of Israel and Palestine is not a religious conflict, its what they want the masses to think. it's imperialism a colonial state who is taking land from natives and bringing settlers from 'the whole world.
Agreed. Fundamentally, it's not a religious conflict, but you should be telling that to Muslims, who go on and on about the plight of their 'Muslim brothers and sisters', emphasizing the religious aspect of the whole conflict. They've been doing that for decades. In fact it's like a stamp of approval for Muslims: ''a true Muslim supports Palestinians''
@@parisgermain523 western societies were like this also some 600 years ago.If you think about it,Muslims are in their dark ages considering they are most recent religion compared to christianity about the same number of years.Not an excuse,just a thought
@@AlfaBravo7777 How did you get that from my comment?? Read my comment again. Your statements belong in an entirely different discussion. This is about Muslims turning the Israel-Palestine conflict into a religious conflict, NOT about dark ages or whatever.
@@parisgermain523 prophet Mohammed said “The believers in their mutual kindness, compassion and sympathy are just like one body. When one of the limbs suffers, the whole body responds to it with wakefulness and fever”. So wether the war is religious or non-religious does not matter… as a family we will cry and help our family members with whatever we can. This unison and brotherhood is actually what makes Islam a stronger religion and what made people like Andrew tate and many others convert to Islam.
@@AlfaBravo7777Islam had its golden age before and its during that period that Muslims taught Europeans how to get out of their “dark ages”. Many of the Western sciences are based on Islamic ones (many sources prove that). Of course Europeans payed us by biting the hands that helped them. However, the weakness that Islam is going through at the moment was prophesied by prophet Mohammed 1400 years ago and the prophecy goes on to state that we will regain a much stronger power one day Inshallah
no government or state is beyond criticism. i don’t understand why people turn a blind eye to israel
Because China, North Korea, Russia etc is so much easier to bash.
Preach.
@@wongalex2089Everyone bashes the U.S. wdym.
@@wongalex2089it's not true just media Wake up bro
Média is the arm in the hands criminals
My father has known Noam for decades and what you see is who he is all the time. You see authentic, honest and a blisteringly intelligent individual. He is without a doubt one of the greatest thinkers of our time!
💯🫶
He is one of my main idols. You’re very lucky to actually know him.
Yes he's ❤
It's not his intellect that makes him popular - it's his love of socialism and hatred of Western Civilization that carries him.
So, so, so lucky! Can I bring the wine for the next dinner? Such intellectual integrity and honesty!
Almost 8 minutes of brutal truths. Wow.
So in simple words he is saying that what’s going on in Palestine now is a genocide but maybe we will recognize it after a hundred years. Agree (
But 100 years from now when the genocide is recognized, the US will still veto the Resolution to Recognize the Palestine Genocide in the UN Security Council.
US should be finished by then.
Israel didn't want to do a quick genocide to prevent comparison to nazi Germany.
They think they can. Do a slow genocide. And they might be right. It's so disturbing.
I wish chomsky would address the current crisis in gaza.
@@tothelighthouse9843the UN won’t survive that long anyway
The United States of Israel.
@Ronald Hess religious bullshit has nothing to do with now. It has everything to do with POWER, just because some asshole wrote something 2000 years ago doesn't mean we should have blind faith in what is being told.
Trust, but verify.
@Ronald Hess This is just pure blasphemy in every sense of the word. Theres nothing in the Bible that calls Christians to support and condone the monstrosities being committed in the Middle East. The United States doesnt need to go out of its way to stop Israel, but we are morally compelled to stop supporting them and their regime. Its one thing the US committed bloody wars and massacres in its goal of manifest destiny for the US. Its a whole another thing for the US to now do the same for manifest destiny of the Greater Israel project. If Zionists want to go expand their Israeli borders, they should spill their own blood and fight their own wars.
@@Slayer8957 by your the looks of your comment you know nothing about christians. christians believe that the ends times starts when the jews occupy the holy land "Jerusalem" and because of that the jews would be "sacrificed" so that christians can go to heaven.
more or less that's how Christian interpreted it especially evangelical protestants....don't get me started on them
and no "the state of israel" not the people but the state is a threat to world peace and should not exist
"The United States doesnt need to go out of its way to stop Israel, but we are morally compelled to stop supporting them and their regime."
actually they do need to go out of their way to stop that, that's like saying we condemn the holocausts but we shouldn't do anything about it. but hey whats a terrorist organization gonna say to another terrorist organization.
"Its one thing the US committed bloody wars and massacres in its goal of manifest destiny for the US."
one of the main reason of manifest destiny was religion and hatred towards what Americans at the time refer to as godless heathens or native americans, i mean christians at the time used the bibble to justify the slaughter of native americans and just like when they justify slavery.
"If Zionists want to go expand their Israeli borders, they should spill their own blood and fight their own wars.
"
how bout we don't start wars and spill blood, i mean before the british came and made the Belfour declaration the Palestinians, Arabs, Turks, Jews and other groups was coexisting peacefully contrary to what the pro Israelis politicians and the media says
so idk what your trying to defend here
@Ronald Hess stop with that bullshit
@Tobias just ask the evangelical protestant
Essentially did war crimes to steal land and resources for themselves, and without having to pay for the crimes ever, but get rewarded by the riches. The Bible says, thou shalt not kill.
soo what the hell is the resources in middle of desert 1945 israel area was?
@@carval51 , oil, gas and land.
@@sonnydayz2118 oil not so much and off shore, even gas they been relying on import until 2000 they found a gas surely they don't wait 60 years if they know there is those things and they certainly did not steal it . get some history book and read first how israel is established you are being too brainwashed to think israel is the big evil country.
@Ragged Dick , yeah you are right. War is big business.
Technically thal shall not murder. Killing an enemy is ok. Murdering the King is discuraged.
Very very clever man. Commendable approach to the truth
He never turns away from telling the truth even if it causes him lot of trouble .A great and just man ❤
The guy is an idiot. And I'm no fan of Israel. He is a prime example of when one is an expert in one field (linguistics) they think they are experts at everything.
Yeet a blo avross the room
Causes him trouble? Seriously. Does he not live freely in the free-world, Brilliant and interesting orator, yes. But hardly Solzhenitsyn etc etc
You are a Moscow troll.
Chomsky, like so many other 'Intelligentsia', is good at pointing out the faults, but absolute rubbish when it comes to offering solutions.
I am blown away. The most concise and comprehensive summary I have ever heard from an individual which cuts through all the guff and tells you what’s what. Amazing man!
Not really.
No? Then maybe Max Blumenthal can help. ruclips.net/video/7dbLAiEdQv4/видео.html
I agree. As an American Christian this is why we support Israel.. we want the prophecy to be fulfilled. We don’t support terrorism on the side of Hamas but we don’t want to see innocents being killed either.. especially children.😔🙏
Israhell is a terr0rist state fuck u America and Britain you fukin Zionists
@@haziqmalik8273 I’m
Sorry that you are so angry. By the way, don’t group all Americans and brits together because many do support Palestine.
Coming back to this today, October 9th 2023, hits differently
Free Palestine
ikr omg
crazy for real , free my brothers from palestine
@@kishiyomo993acts of terrorism gain you no supporters. Perhaps we should cancel you like we did with Mia Khalifa :)
@@KozinskowitzkyYou’re literally gaslighting others
A giant of a man with the intellect & conscience to match. RESPECT!
💫🧞💓🧞💫
thanks Noam💓
Wishing you health and vitality.
Russian ?
What kind of pravda frick
It's just an US military base in the middle East.
Exactly
Yes, it is a functional state
Max Nordau stated in a speech in London (on June 16, 1920) that he believed that the Zionist state would be a country under the guardianship of Great Britain and that the Jews would stand guard along the dangerous road extending through the Near and Middle East to the borders of India.
@@top2025five religious extremism
Same way they use the Kurds.
The US doesn't have military bases in Israel
Thank you so much for this channel. They need to teach about Noam Chomsky and his books to children in highschool. But I bet they do not want all of us to really be awake.
They love woke, not awake 😅
2:10 Those are major cultural factors...
There are also Jewstrategic factors.
No pontificating, no bombast, no ego. A man with towering intellect who never wastes a word and gets his message across in a most measured and articulate way.
And yet a man that is dismissed by the right and marginalized by mass media and the left.
He is a genocide denialist. Screw him
@@alessiodelcastillo1613 I have yet to see an actual example of him denying a genocide. What I have seen, is him discuss the conditions that lead to certain genocides. Which is obviously not the same thing as genocide denial.
@@GlassesAndCoffeeMugs ruclips.net/video/VCcX_xTLDIY/видео.htmlsi=ONqKfn6EmvnDyNdm
Israel is a colonialist, I'm from Indonesia, just so you know,
The Dutch colonized Indonesia but did not apartheid like Israel did,
The Dutch colonized Indonesia only took Indonesia's natural wealth but the population or natives or
Indonesian people were not evicted, they were killed by bulldozing their houses!
now look at what has happened since 1948 Israel colonized Palestine they say Palestine
are terrorists, it's the same as the Dutch when they wanted to re-colonize Indonesia in 1949, Indonesian fighters
called terrorists, thankfully the land of Palestine is still alive, only Gaza remains because of resistance from
Palestinian fighters (Hamas).
now you see in Westbank every day children are killed and Palestinians' homes are evicted, their rights are not there
The Zionist goal is colonization as well as mass genocide!
one day Palestine will be independent and these colonialists will surrender! Open your eyes! That is the reality that exists now!
It's nice to hear an intelligent independent thinker, they are a rare breed...
@Hello there, how are you doing this blessed day?
Yes 😢
I have listened to Noam for decades. I took him seriously. But because I didn't have the time or education to understand him at the tine I set this in my way back memory. Here we are again. Thank you sir!
Yes , what makes you thing now you understand any of it ....
@@גייב-ב3פwhat makes you think they didn’t? Do you always assume others are fools??
@@גייב-ב3פ european, white wanderers, surrounded by black Arabs.. land grabbing, grave robbing and theft of rare earth such as gold, diamonds and copper. All shrouded in a modern-day bs narrative.
@@CG-dd9tbits a jewish bot ffs 😂 moomy screamed 1000100101 when it was vomited out
This is The Truth I was looking for to make up mi mind and to be free of the lies of the media !!
He is a truthful man. He open our eyes thank you
History is different than he is pictured. 180 degrees different.
Was your eyes closed before ? 😊
He’s a Jew. If you knew, that would be enough.
@@leonidtimashpolsky755Ur eyes are 180 degree different...
@@yassineabdelmaksoud90 Hurrdurr ''ur'', yomamaz eyez are 360 degrees different, better call the exorcist.
This is the most important video on youtube right now
@kawasaki_kid8704remind me of what he said please 🙏
💯
Only because they don’t allow any sort of truth regarding who the Nazi’s were, what Hitler stood for, and who the aggressors were. This is gay.
He's been called a "self-loathing Jew" since he is anti-Zionist. Sad.
Chomsky himself commented about that. If a non-Jew criticizes Israel, he's labelled antisemitic. If a Jew criticizes Israel, he's labelled a self-hating Jew. That covers 100% of possible criticism towards Israel.
You're both wrong. I live in Israel, and I also criticize Israel, on many occasions, its government, and sometimes the general public.
But unlike too many critiques from all around the world - by too many Jews and non-Jews alike - I try my best to base my critique on facts and true context.
Chomsky is one of the greatest manipulators (it's a compliment :-) when it comes to criticizing Israel: He gives you partial true facts, seasoned with some not so easy to catch lies, and in most of the cases he distorts the context. I cannot tell if such modus operandi - Chomsky's and others - stems from antisemitism (attitude) or plain hypocrisy (character), but it doesn't serve anything, except hurting the Jews and Israel.
Here is a simple example: When it comes to fighting terror and terrorists, Israel is criticized for killing civilians (and children are on the top of the list) - even those who accept that it is not on purpose claim that it is out of proportion and illegal by international law. Here is the international law, Geneva Convention (IV):
"Art. 28. The presence of a protected person may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations."
ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/WebART/380-600033
Note that it doesn't say "don't hide military targets behind civilians" because those who are ready to do that will not obey international law anyway. It just says "If you hide behind civilians, it won't help you".
In addition,
"Art.29: The Party to the conflict in whose hands protected persons may be, is responsible for the treatment accorded to them by its agents, irrespective of any individual responsibility which may be incurred."
ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/WebART/380-600034
It says, that if you plan a military operation from an area with civilians, you at least have to build shelters for them.
But, as we know, Hamas builds military tunnels under hospitals, schools, etc. for his fighters - not for protecting civilians.
The rest - go and learn (start by Google: Israel fights Terror. You may want to search for my name on the results)
Yechiel Kimchi
@@yechielkimchi6041 zionist shitter trying to justify Israel's war crimes funnily enough go look at what idf does to normal unarmed citizens when they try to revolt or demonstrate somewhere, all you need to do is look at the recent arrests they've made and the numerous people they killed to know the only way to deal with such pigs is by an opposing equal force. Thieves and murders trying to act all civil in the 21st century.
@@yechielkimchi6041. I'm not as knowledgeable as you are in international law. But common sense says that you must provide some proof, that a legitimate target was hiding behind protected people. You can't bomb a residential building and later simply claim there were terrorists inside.
And that's just an example of the many cases in which Israel breaks the law.
@@osamaqanbaz6111 @space cowboy
None of you referred to the simple argument that I have presented.
You can convince only antisemites - too many of them are here, you are included
Hope springs eternal
Thank you Professor Chomsky. The truth is a rare pearl.
Lol
@KMartin-jf5kw maybe you need to unpack it.
That’s how Fox News and BBC always covered up what US and Israel did
However bad the Beeb is, not sure I'd put it on a par with Fox or anything approaching it...
My eyes have been opened many times over the years by Mr. Chomsky. What a gift he is to the world.
What a pity he is now getting old. May he live for many more years. We need people like him desperately.
One of the greatest, if not the greatest critical minds ever to exist.
😢 Yes! But no one listens to his logic!
@@RodDavisSaints44 I'm not sure, but I heard it through the grapevine that Donald Trump is a big fan.
That... is the gist of why we are in this mess! No one wants to listen to rational solutions to an irresponsible decision!
The genius of this man to dissect world political events is accurate and a breath of fresh air in the current sea of stupidity.
Is he a genius just because he's validating your opinions and he's in a position of authority?
The core linguistic theory he's know for is a retrograde, deterministic view of the development of language across cultures and is very compatible with eugenics. I would recommend you be careful before calling some academic a "genius".
I wouldn't call him a genius. His certain views are idiotic, he has little knowledge on European history of 20th century and he is spewing idiotic bullshit most of the time with such sense of authority that it's laughable
He is as stupid as you are.
Israel is the strong but it doesn't mean it is the wrong. It is actually the right. Zionism at it's basis is a center-left secular national movement. While it's adversaries are religious and nationalist right and left fanatics and extremists - a mixture of - Nazists. Fascists and stalinist Communists. Their supporters in the west are actually modern anti-semites - that is anti-zionists. And it doesn't matter whether they are Jews or not. The useful idiots, who think they are supporting the victims, that are practically violent perpetrators of crimes against innocent people that just want to live in peace and let it to others. Left idiots back bastards who wage aggressive continuous attempts to perform genocide and kill, hurt, harm as many people as they can. Extreme leftist fools support these criminals because they think weak means right. As strong means wrong. Nazis very like Arabs also thought that they are victims and Jews are to blame and to be punished. The so called Mufti of Jerusalem and Hitler were allies on these grounds. Arabs' violence has nothing to do with Israel, they've been murdering one another for hundreds of years. It is the result of more than a thousand year oppression by their rulers but as Jews started escaping from pogroms in Europe, Arabs that many of them came from neighboring territories after the Jews, found great justification why they have a right to do the same - murder Jews and to consider themselves heroes while perpetrating heinous crimes against men, women, children and elderly, just to get rid of their own inner personal problems coming of their culture of violence and despotism.
sharpshooterparker that is the most rubbish I ever read. I don’t know wether to laugh🤣 or cry 😭at your stupidity.
I'm 19 years old and boys of my age often would like to either go partying watch movies(propaganda) or do something amusing but I can listen to Noam Chomsky(my wisdom grandpa😊) all day and night long without blinking, I wish I could shake hands with him, but I'm living 10k miles away right here in beautiful Afghanistan.
Brilliant analysis...I had never thought about the settler colonial/emprialist argument but it makes perfect sense....thank you yeut again Mr Chomsky!
it doesn't make sense, Britain never colonised the levant or the Middle East in general, when the Ottoman Empire collapsed Britain and France inherited the old Ottoman colonial territories.
@@lewistaylor2858 are u like 12 year old or sth. NEVER COLONIZED ??? Inherited????? The hell u saying bud. Go educate ur self in history
@@chinchin6559 he uses the wrong words but he isnt wrong, the british didnt displace populations. The people who lived there were subjects of the crowns and were allowed to live there and follow their beliefs and not people from the isles. The item which the british did wrong was drawing borders with disregard to the ethnicity in the borders which is what causes wars.
@Ashraf Amri You should read what I wrote again
@Ashraf Amri you colonised Egypt ffs- look at your name
There's also a lot of money to be made by war profiteers.
That's right. Down to the bare bones of it.
I think it's starting to eat itself now like a cancer. The all consuming is starting to consume itself. I'm starting to see it slowly cracking from the inside. Maybe a revolution is coming
General Smedly Butler said it right, War is a Racket
The US economy is based upon war, if there were no wars for the US to sell weapons to both sides, the US would be bankrupt.
Also, the US keeps many regions of the world unstable so that it can side with those who have oil and natural resources so it can procure them cheaply, remember without the perto-dollar the US economy would crash...
@@jasonbyrne8487 But because of the US's meddling, if the US economy crashes, the world economy crashes.
@@DangerRussDayZ6533 So, let's just keep murdering millions of innocent civilians then?
Sorry but the only reason there was a global financial crash in 2008 was because of the greed of the banks who were the bailed out at the expense of the taxpayer, your government is lying to you, as are mine...
I fear for the people in power who manipulate God's word to commit atrocities. We will all answer for our sins.
No, you won't, and they know it. That's why they are acting like this.
Kike Christopher said many years ago, ''If you want good people to do bad things, you need religion".
If you read your Bible it’s quite violent and the god of the Bible wanted punishment, vengeance, and war. All people of the Abrahamic cults cherry pick their religious text.
Exactly what is happening
they think they are the god's chosen people, what do u expect?
Not the whole story. Sure, Zionism was and is a force to be reckoned with, particularly in cultish parts of the Midwest. What Chomsky doesn't mention is Eisenhower's fury in 1956 when Israel first captured Gaza from Egypt, leading him to demand their withdrawal. And Israel's malevolent presence in the region was what provoked pan-Arab nationalism exacerbating cold war tensions. As for the Pentagon being supportive of Israel from the outset, it was George C Marshall as Secretary of State who famously fell out with Truman's spad Clark Clifford over recognition of the Israeli partition of Palestine - the Pentagon was always rightly worried about getting embroiled in ME wars started by Israeli aggression and expansion. It still is.
Wow...why have i only just started listening to this great man? He has opened my eyes.
He was woke
Shut up he is older than state of Israel and he is stating facts
Reducing the modern American argument to it's core -- "If you're anti-Likud, anti-Netanyahu, anti-Occupation, then you're an antisemite, and the only logical conclusion possible is that you're pro-Hamas." Where there's a lack of facts/counterpoints but an abundance of passion, that's when they trot out the schoolyard name-calling. Don't you dare raise a question of the Likud's bloodshed -- only talk about Hamas's bloodshed -- because the second you begin pointing out that the majority of innocent blood spilt in this war is on Israeli hands, suddenly you're a Jew-hater.
Because the media is controlled and it is showing only one side.
This is what I’m learning as I learn this history of this situation.
Hamas has not been regarded as a terrorist group by most countries In the world including the UN, they're more often regarded as the resistant group of Palestinian people towards Israeli oppression, yet the media of the countries who allied with Israel often follows the government propaganda and calls them terrorist group. The moment they're labelled with group of terrorism, people can forget about the context and Israel are permitted to do anything they wanted in the name of fighting the terrorism, and that's including shelling the civilians, cutting of water, electricity, food and medical for two million people and dislocate one million.
Maybe it's obvious to some but Chomsky is Jewish. I looked it up and think it's worthy of note here.
@@haixinzheng9759 What Hamas did on 07 October by invading Israel and deliberately set about murdering women, children, aged people individually after torturing, mutilating and abusing their victims can only be considered terrorism. They were not "resisting israeli oppression" . They were bent on murder unconnected with military combat .
The horror is that there is no equivalent to Chomsky, may he live long enough to save us from ourselves.
All i can say is that America dodged a bullet that Chomsky didnt go into politics...he wouldve just been nancy pelosi on steroids.
Perhaps. I don't follow all the policy choices of Pelosi (or most others) but I would say that equation is not accurate, because Chomsky wholeheartedly tries to be equitable while most politicians are exactly that: politicians. But in this world where might makes right playing the role of a do-gooder bent on fairness may be indeed a death sentence. So he wouldn't survive as a politician, and the lone nation that plays fair in a cheating game would lose.
@@postcarbonitelove5308 I totally disagree that he wholeheartedly tries to be equitable. Like any self respecting lefty he abides by a hierarchy of grievance, all thats up for debate is what identity group deserves top position, and whatever welfare comes along with it. We can take it for granted that most anglo-american white people don't even rate, as they're the "masters of the universe" .
@@lieshtmeiser5542 but why, stating that he doesnt agree with you theirfor he is bad makes you seem like an idiot
@@lieshtmeiser5542 also have you actually listend to any of his talks, he doesn't really care about that identity shit as much as the centrist libs do, if you think they are the hard left you have alot of learning to do
Netanyahu announced in the September before Oct 7th that "Israel should annex the Gaza strip." Also, he knew a year in advance that the attack would occur and deliberately refused to send the IDF to guard the Israeli settlers, for which he publicly apologized for. He deliberately sacrificed the settlers for an excuse to invade and bomb Gaza...INMO.
I am an American and approve of this message as a fair-minded, rational human being with justice and a rational person.
❤
I am a British person and i too approve of this message.
the amount of people in my country who want to downplay our historical atrocities is shocking.
From which country? The United States?
You're not rational at all you're bigoted.
@user-ik1rx9uv7j so it's okay to shoot death to jews but death to Islam offends you. As a human they should offend you equally. Christians killed jews and Muslims during the crusades yet salladin gave Christians control over Jerusalem because he was more interested in his capitol of Baghdad. Now the Muslims claim control over Jerusalem and seek to kill Christians and jews. Only Israel allows all 3 to worship freely in Jerusalem.
*_Wow I didn't lost attention once during his talk.This is kind of rare for me.But gems like him are rare too_*
How do you Italicize the text in RUclips?
@@Ali-uz8qg put * on both start and end of your sentence. Right next to it without any spacing.
*Noam*
@@youisstupid2586 - The star on both ends of the sentence just makes the fonts 'bold' but does not italicize them (slanting on right).
@@Ali-uz8qg oh.... I didn’t see the italic. Heres how to make the text italic: _ word _ (without the space between the symbol and word ofc)
_Noam_
@@youisstupid2586 - *_Thanks friend, I learnt something new._*
Oh my deepest heart. I just came across watching this. This man words are so clear and wise beyond moon.
I believe we should call for a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want.
Simple. Very simple.
It's not a thousands of years matter.
Zionism is danger and should not be adopted by a state.
Adoro quest'uomo! Puro onesto con una morale e dei sentimenti intatti...non ha paura di dire la verità...grazie di ❤ Mr. Chomsky
I’m so grateful for what you’ve taught me about history and continue to teach. Thank you.
I love Noam, but wonder, given how much he knows about society and people in general, how the hell he gets out of bed in the morning...A clear, reasonable, calm, articulate sane voice drowned out by idiots with agendas...Thank you for the upload!
He gets out of bed because he's a leftist radical, and leftist radicals live to lecture.
Note that he has no solutions to the problems, the last time a solution that he recommended was tried: eg Morsi in Egypt, it ended in a coup because Morsi tried to violate the constitution.
Lieshtmeiser If you’re against western imperialism you’re apparently a leftist for not wanting to see kids bombed or the US funding terrorist regimes. Who knew?
@@lieshtmeiser5542 He admits in this video that intellectuals like him are usually not game changers, even the other way around.
@@buzifalus What works against Chomsky in geopolitical ideology and commentary, unlike his work in linguistics, is that most of the leftist ideology and movements, eg post modernism, climate alarmism, etc, just fundamentally dont work, and do harm to human civilization and individuals.
By siding so strongly with that side of the political spectrum, he dooms himself to being on the side that cannot build a lasting and good system.
The great achievements of his side of politics are: Zimbabwe, Venezuela, North Korea, Vietnam, mass muslim migration to the EU, out of control latino migration to the US, etc.
If the US had just isolated itself after World War 2, and vacated asia and europe, who knows how far communism wouldve spread, who knows how many more pol pot style purges we wouldve seen, who knows how many people wouldve been gulagged. He just takes it for granted that the world would be a safer place without superpowers trying to hold things together, I strongly doubt that.
@@lieshtmeiser5542 Usual America propaganda-wash. The USA has an important job but since it is not doing it, it is better if it wasn't even existing at all. Keep selling advanced killing tech to chimps and spreading the dollar in the world, that's exactly what those 3rd worlders don't need, and the proof everyone needs for knowing how much not of a savior USA is. The matter of the fact is that the USA can't keep playing the part of world sheriff (or gangster, or world bully) but also put naive face and act as if just another country in the world political affairs, or like you said, keeping to itself. USA citizens are massively sheltered while woes affect the rest of the globe.
Netanyahu must be brought to justice the only reason this continues is because he knows he will be an international criminal court when this ends
The US will take him out before too long
Hope you're right.
Ya ignore hamas and hezbollah. Go after the Jews. What else is new?
@@levimatthew8911 being a jew does not give people a free pass for killing entire etnic groups.
@@levimatthew8911 Hamas and Hezbollah are products of the instability and oppression that has been prevalent in the region for decades. This instability is caused intentionally by the US through Israel as a proxy. Your antisemitic argument is not valid.
One of our greatest contemporaries. We are blessed to have this man.🙏🏼🙏🏼🌍🙏🏼🙏🏼
Noam Chomsky, one of the greatest intellectual humanitarians, a walking library of knowledge, understanding and objectivity. The world has gone insane, and voices of reason and facts are increasingly disappearing. May God bless and protect this man.
Didn't he say unvaccinated people with natural immunity to covid should be forced to take the vaccine or be banished from society and forced to fend for themselves?
About 4 minutes 10 seconds into this video?
ruclips.net/video/ruQH5A2Q4XU/видео.htmlsi=ru6JeQRL7yqMzPBO
Jeez. The man is trained as a linguist. He just grabs onto a hot topic and desperately tries to stay relevant. Shut up Noam
For geopolitical topics he is terrible lol and genuinely wrong
I’m sure he was engaging in intellectual pursuits during his time on Epstein island. I’m sure he taught those kids a lot.
A j.w and a fraud.
That's a man who knows the truth and speaks it
HE IS A MAN OF INTEGRITY AND PROBITY LONG LIVE CHOMSKY
"A herd of independent minds." Nice one. thx fr post.
The words “anti-semitism” are pulled out when they want to manipulate a situation.
Anti-semitism is also what have been doing to Muslims to a long time. But they like to change the meaning of the words to their advantage.
Similar to "racism", a tactic to prevent "true free speech". Free speech allows change and that is something poeple in power need to prevent.
Noam Chomsky always provides a clear, no-holds-barred analysis of matters.
Yes, he is a great professor.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That's exactly why the media shall never give him a platform, especially here in the U.S.
Fun fact.
Antisemit = prohumanity❤❤❤
Unfortunately only american'S Old/Gen Z that has it.😢
Overrated, old, senile, demented, bloated pseudo-intellectual who's lived his entire life in freedom and comfort and has never ever been in war nor threatened. Everything he says is BS.
truth hurts. but thank you mr. chomsky for telling the truth
Thank you sir 🙏 for speaking whats covered up hard
Thanks for this. A subject not talked about in the US.
Americans are the most propagandized people on earth. In other countries where people have brains & spines they force them to comply. We volunteer
The subject is being described by the Zionist Chomsky to confuse simple leftist. Here is the reality, chomsky supports Israel. He is misleading people when he says Israel breaks international law. Israel is not breaking international law, there isnt an international law. if there was, the UN would punish Israel for the crimes it commits. Israel is above international law and can only be stopped by an attack from foreign powers. Chomsky is against this attack and punishment because he is a Zionist. He is just playing a heard of sheeple called leftist. Here is the reality. The good guys won ww2, they installed Israel after redrawing borders. Palestinians lost ww2. Palestinians still fight a lost war. With every attack the Palestinians perpetuate on the winners of ww2, the more land the Palestinians lose. The Palestinians would do better to surrender and exist next door to Israel in peace, but they wont do that. It's very important to understand the ottoman empire failed and that was the protection Palestinians had. We can see israel growing and the Palestinians losing. Israel will be under constant attack and that probably pleases Israel because Israel will be very happy to take more land and kill more enemies. Chomsky knows this, he is no fool. He is just playing fools and making money off of then.... like a good Zionist does. Look, if you're mad the good guys won ww2, then that sucks. Maybe Germany can go enforce that international UN law chomsky keeps talking about
@@TimezUp23 America uses its veto in the UN everytime sanctions are put on Israel.
Israel has more UN violations than any other country.
@@EugVR6 obviously UN laws mean nothing. Otherwise, Israel would be punished for breaking the laws. Laws that are not enforced are nill. So as soon as a power emerges that can punish Israel, Israel will be punished. The germans tried very hard and failed. So the reality exist first and foremost, if Palestinians attack Israel, Israel will win and grab
More land. If the UN decided to take military action actions Israel to stop it from the onslaught, then Israel will be stopped. But any country that attacks Israel will meet the fury of Israel. if the US decided not to veto votes of the UN, then punishment would have to be levied. That would mean a war with Israel and that war was already fought, it was called ww2. Israel was a spoil of ww2. So people who want to see Israel punished basically should wish the Germans won ww2
@Davide Fabbri borders are established by war. WW2 established the borders of Israel. Palestinians lost WW2. It seems Noam does not want to state it bluntly. He likes to sell what he says to leftwing thinkers. It can be perceived that the far left has caught up to the far right in terms of how they think about Israel. I mean if they really punished Israel, that would be insane lol
Wow, this speech brings many things in perspective.
I’m back 7 years later watching this video again with my partner. Educating her about the conflicts today and how America has been the biggest instigator. This is a rerun. Every few years we’re revisiting the same scenario.
Yeah, Hamas needs to not attack Israel.
So sad we still haven't learned!
@@jamesstone9140september 18th 2023,just 19 days before "the attack" Israeli forces killed 38 Palestinian children....19days before!!!!! Now,who has the right to retaliate and defend itself??? Go check out operation protection edge on the deaths there.
I think the UK plays a large hand in the conflict too.
And how did America instigate this war? Did we make Hamas attack Israel? Give me a break.
Mr. Chompoky I wish you were on the ballot. Two thums up to you, Sir
Much respect
“Intelligent” doesn’t mean free thinking and herd mentality is always dangerous, so many times history is rewritten!
"Genocidal character of british colonization"
'British' !
@@MrAnubhabd Maybe they should kick you out then.
the genocidal character of Karl Marx 'colonization'
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn,
“You must understand. The leading Bolsheviks who took over Russia were not Russians.
They hated Russians. They hated Christians. Driven by ethnic hatred they tortured and slaughtered millions of Russians without a shred of human remorse.
The October Revolution was not what you call in America the “Russian Revolution.”
It was an invasion and conquest over the Russian people.
More of my countrymen suffered horrific crimes at their bloodstained
hands more than any people or nation ever suffered in the entirety of human history.
It cannot be understated. Bolshevism was the greatest human slaughter of all time.
The fact that most of the world is ignorant of this reality is
proof that the global media itself is in the hands of the perpetrators.”
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something,
when his entire world view depends upon his not understanding it.”
@@lorenzo6mm
So who were the Bolsheviks?
Who did they represent?
@@dukadarodear2176 the killers the psychos the mass murderers
see alexander solzhentisyn
Thanks Uncle Noam! Succinct and deeply engaging. As relevant and important now as ever.
"Thanks Uncle Noam!"
Uncle Sam was the first image that came to mind, and Uncle Joe Stalin was the 2nd.
Truth that makes sense & has reason.
Wow.
“A herd of independent minds”.
lol. yeh. ikr.
I always liked his favorite quote from Walter Lippman, "the bewildered herd"...
"The specialized class, the responsible men, carry out the executive function, which means they do the thinking and planning and understand the common interests. Then, there is the bewildered herd,..."
Chomsky mocks it, but then, if anyone escapes from marxist leftist university and experiences the real world, they will understand over time why this is the case.
Consider Jordan Petersons discussion of IQ, thats one reason why "the responsible men" are in control. Because if retarded people are in charge, theyll ruin everything...they may be so retarded they dont even realize theyre ruining it.
Consider errors, mistakes and misfortune. There could be a genius, charismatic, a leader of people, a great and humanitarian person, they become a quadriplegic in an accident...cant even shave themselves to toilet themselves, such a person wont govern the country.
We could go on like this...the world isnt an equal distribution of talents and successes for a variety of reasons.
@@MarkHopewell Its just interesting. Its one of Chomsky's favorite quotes..obviously you havent read as much chomsky as I have.
bernie bros
@@lieshtmeiser5542 i clapped when he called out bernie for the sierra blanca dumpsite
Being honest is not everyones cup of tea 💕...
Love you sir 💯
🇲🇨🇵🇸❤
Watched this video in 2024,what a brilliat men.the truth he spokes,nobody cant deny it😢
Man I was wondering how NC is and found this. Everyone needs to say a prayer for him tonight. What a blessing this man was to his time and ours. Who will carry the torch of sage and wisdom? Brilliant post modern saint of any intellectual worth the letters behind their names. May he reincarnate immediately after passing. We STILL need him❤