So if Singapore wants to start a war they have to do it quick and take over Malaysia, better let them to develop Malaysia and become a very strong country, let Sabah and Sarawak to be an Independent country, most of their development are getting drag by the Malaysian Central Government, because they can't use the religious manefesto to take control of the Sabah Sarawak majority.
U see our fellow indonesian this is how u fight over a food who has better food ...not like u indonesia who always start to claiming dish from your country !! Stupid indonesia
Asean family group Malaysia : yo who tf stole my water Singapore : not me Indonesia : not me Brunei : not me Thailand : wasn’t me Myanmar : not me Philippines : wasn’t me Vietnam : you know its not me Malaysia : then who tf took it.... China : ni hao
@Beng Liew Lim China already tolerate those courntries. It is not our fault since we found those islands first in hundreds years ago. And china is not interested in others territory. If you konw the langfang repubilc you will understand this. Langfang republic was established by chinese people in kalimantan and Chinese emperor reject them to be part of china. ln addition, the rise of china can also be benefit to local ethnic chinese in malaysia. Although you are a malaysia citizen and you must be loyal to your nation chinese people in malaysia still have little political right.
Tbh tho, the militaries of both countries are built for different purposes. Singappre military are built to resemble Israel’s military in which they are excellent at early offensive attack and defending a small area. While Malaysian military are built to police the SEA waters. They are more of a pirate buster than a country conqueror. They both have very different doctrines and its very unlikely they would even want to fight each other
On behalf of both countries, I would like to apologize regarding how many uh... Passionate comments there are on this video. Hopefully the algorithm benefits outweigh the cons. Regardless, really interesting video. I like how in-depth you go in discussing the differences between the two countries military powers. Definitely subscribed!
Twandepan And so if I promote my new military project to either of the government I can use this video as a reference to increase the chance of my project getting funded. Like I should promote to Singapore side a quick solution that allows its infrastructures and equipment to self repair. Alright let me start drafting it with CAD programmes, should I use Pro Enginning or Auto desk inventor?
"War is the continuation of politics by other means." Clauswitz You cannot separate war from politics. But I'll indulge you. For Singapore and Malaysia to get to this stage, the politicians on both sides would have been utter imbeciles.
Simon Tay so everytime you arm wrestle with someone, you do so because you hate your opponent? Of course not. You just do so to see who has the bigger arm muscles. This is literally that.
Hi i am Bangladeshi .... i am a construction worker i live in singapore almost 5 years . I really don't expect any war between Singapore and Malaysia . Singaporean people are really nice and open mindful . I love Singapore from my heart.
It's funny to see people getting triggered about this and arguing lol... This is just a "what if" video and don't get too shitty about it. Malaysia and Singapore wouldn't really go to war because both countries have their own problems to solve. Salam to both Malaysian Citizens and Singapore's🙏
When the Japanese invaded Singapore, the locals expected the British to defend the island. Instead, the British just packed up and left. Singapore built its military with the mindset that there will be no one to rely on in case of an invasion, that's why they spend so much effort to build the biggest military force in the region. Their military training is professional and well equipped. They also take reservist training seriously. Also, Singapore hires Nepali Gurkha. With that mindset, the scenario of this video should be the other way around.
Malaysia: nasi lemak SG: chilli crab Malaysia: ayam penyet SG: bee hoon Malaysia: apam balik SG: curry fish head Thailand: HELLO THERE I HAVE (insert random number, 20-1010101010010010101) DISHES! Malaysia and SG: KO
Happens every time. It's one of the reason the US military used zombies in a recent planning exercise, so they didn't have to deal with a bunch of idiots taking things out of context.
That's why this topic shouldn't be a general discussion. It can form a negative perception in the general public and instill a passion for war for no reason.
Malaysia: declares war on Singapore Singapore: we need help America: sorry bud we're busy with covid Singapore: but they have oil America: *democracy intensifies
Until this thought experiment isnt just a thought, it has actually happened if you know the history behind Singapore and Malaysian. The threat to cut Singapore's water supplies, the joint military exercise held a mere 50km off Singapore's border and on a 'coincedental' National day parade where most military assets were on deployed for the march, the still unresolved airspace and sea borders. These are real life events that have happened. Going further back, Indonesian did openly threaten to go war with Malaysia when Singapore was still part of the federation. This video.is at best insensitive and at worst, a provocation. Thought experiment up his
My daughter was stationed at mountain home air force base for a couple of years. Her expertise was in the computer world and in intelligence. She told me she became friends with Singaporean air force pilots who were training at Mountain Home for some pretty intensive training. She told me these pilots were damned good and Singapore spared no expense in getting them the best training. Though many counties in the U.S. are bigger than this city-state, Singapore is an extremely well equipped military force to reckon with. The air force has top notch fighters, transports, and multi role helicopters. My daughter says Singapore invests millions, if not billions for defense annually and a lot of that money goes for training. She said any country in the region declaring war on Singapore would be suicidal as Singapore is well equipped, armed with missiles, bombs and the best jets and fighters. Like the U.S., the pilots get a lot of flight time with training from USAF flight instructors. Singapore can take care of herself at times of conflict. Why would Malaysia want to go to war with a powerhouse like Singapore?
Don't worry, the Malaysian 🇲🇾 artillery will do some damage to all Singaporean 🇸🇬 aircraft runway, so the Singaporean 🇸🇬 military pilot can't landed their plane 😎 .
@Alexandria School of Science Even Isra-Hell 🔥 with a strong military can't destroy Hamas, a small militia group from Palestine 🇵🇸 . So, how a small island country like Singapore 🇸🇬 can destroy a well trained Malaysian 🇲🇾 Armed Force ? 😎 .
@@wysrl Even Isra-Hell 🔥 have many F-35 aircraft, but they still can't destroy Hamas, a small militia group from Palestine 🇵🇸 . So, how F-35 aircraft owned by Singapore 🇸🇬 can destroy a well trained Malaysian 🇲🇾 Armed Force ? 😎 .
From Singapore here. This analysis is pretty commendable although there are strategies on our side here which I am certain can’t be openly shared. Nevertheless, we don’t want a war. We love Malaysia. Ask any Singaporeans and we will tell you we love Malaysia. Malaysians share very similar cultures to Singapore and we Singaporeans enjoy taking the random holidays to tour Malaysia. Nobody here in their right sense would want to fight Malaysia. I know, your analysis was based on hypothesis, but why would any of our countries want to destroy the many decades of peace and prosperity? Both sides will suffer greatly if a war do break out. It is better to exercise patience and understanding than to ruin the many years of harmony and interdependency.
But if theoretically if there is a war Singapore would try to have johor without fighting honestly consideirng alot of Singaporeans stay there and Malaysians that work in Singapore stays there.
Sometime war is an avenue to distract the population. Look at China invasion of Vietnam or Japanese invasion of Korea during the 1600s . Didn't Singapore always become a Malaysian target board whenever they had domestic issue. Well someone did says war is just part of political tool .
Sakiru Eiji not sure about that man. Fight or not really depends on the government of both countries. So vote wisely for the right government and we will have peace. As what Mark Ong said below in another reply, MY ministers for the last few decades have always used Singapore as a target board whenever they have their own domestic issues. By doing that they diverted all the attention and hatred of the citizens of Malaysia towards Singapore instead of themselves. I just hope the government over there will stand up and do a good job for the people rather than divert blames to us. This have always been my sincere wishes.
Mark Ong Yes it’s true. But we just got to exercise patience, not because we are a small country, but because it doesn’t benefit both sides in the long run.
@@andyhooutdoors I beg to differ in your opinion of both sides losses in war . Aggressor sometimes does pay . However lesson learned in 6 day war is that Israel gain it's strategic gap in Sinai peninsula . There are some parts up north look always juicy for me. The terrain up north is no walk in the park with high hills , jungle and if we are lucky plantation . Urban dwellers like the conscripts corps of ours may be boggles down in operation due to topology and logistics. Esienhower qouted all plan are useless when war start but planning is essential. We could talk till the cow comes home but history may be playing out otherwise. Sun Tzu says know your enemy know yourself and you shall be victorious in hundred battle . Do we know ourselves or do we know our enemies ? There is an on going joke in Singapore saying no war need to be fought as we had been invaded by foreigners. If you wanna go India go Changi business park. If you wanna go Philippines go lucky plaza. This is also true in the army . When I was conscripted left and right are true blue local . Some may have slang , some are hokkien Peng . Ultimately you know you have a common goal to defend your land . Fast forward 10 years down the road, I head back for reservist I got a shock of my life . Almost half of NSF is non local . RP russian, driver PRC, store man Myanmar, clerk Viet . And the best of the best part medic Nigerian . I almost got a shock of my life . I look at my helmet to make sure it's not blue because I thought I had been sent on a UN mission . So the phycology of things are very much different as compared to 20 years ago. On top of that are you lead by lions or sheep ? 1990 when we celebrate our 25 years of independence old fox up north mobilize a large exercise near us . Our grunts all given 120 rounds , standby at border waiting for them . Today one unarmed maritime boat park in our sovereign , use loud header talk non stop to ask them leave . If it was old man time , it will be no nonsense. Old man would had ordered the boat be forcefully boarded tow back to port and start negotiation. They will never allow some MB to parades in our waters . Lesson learned in beginning of WW2 french has the best tank Char 1b outgunned anything German panzar could throw at it. However French lost its land because leadership is passive . There was this interesting statement made by a reservist Sgt when I small talk with him in an MG nest . He says if the authority had given to him even with a pistol he will show aggressive stands and fire at the intruder. But every single time he needs to feedback and ask permission even with a bazooka he is powerless . There you go I pretty sums up everything , not by gun nor power but by the will of the men .
@@subie1019 actually Singapore is neutral. Friendly to both China and US. But not too friendly. Malaysia also did the same things, but not so neutral. Malaysia friendly with China and US also. But tend to more friendly towards China than US.
Singapore will never go to war with its neighbours. The culture of both countries are so similar, with families, relatives and friends on both sides of the Johor Straits. Unless, there are no other solutions and Singapore is pushed to the walls. The US would be involved way ahead, whether diplomatically or militarily. On tactics, the beachhead in western Johor is insufficient to defend in depth. Pushing to Malacca might allow sufficient space for various divisions to manoeuvre.
I am almost certain we would invade Malaysia the moment the water is cut back in the day we were reliant on them for it. But in 2020, I think true lah, won't invade even if they cut the water. Singapore don't need buffer de. I'm almost certain the strategy is to spearhead to KL in 7 days. SG really cannot take a long war, strategic depth is one thing but the economic aftermath is another.
@@ayuhmembawang5391 I'm Singaporean and while we probably can't do it in 7 days( that is straight BS ) REPORTS: From 0-30 days winner: SG 31-120 days: SG 120-180: SG/Malay 181-360: Malay 360+: we all die liao
Malaysia is currently in the midst of a political overhaul and is way too busy sorting out its own problems to be dealing with anything else, much less a nation that has the backing of basically every major superpower in the world
Lmao but this is still a poor scenario. Political power directly influences military power. For example Malaysia wouldn't touch Singapore shopping because it would risk war with other nations. Singapore would fight very offensively striking deep into the country with air/Navy or assassinate major leaders to force a quick surrender.
@@kakerake6018 THE WHOLE POINT OF IT IS AS A HYPOTHETICAL WAR OH MY GOD It's really, REALLY obvious that if Singapore gets US support they'll win but its isn't 'Singapore and US vs Malaysia' it's just Singapore and Malaysia
geez it's just a video guys. In reality anything could happen, Singapore might win, Malaysia might win, or it could be a stalemate and both countries enters into a peace agreement. No need to get hostile with each other over a war that will never happen. Malaysia and Singapore have great relations with each other and I don't see in any way, a war could break out between the two countries. So embarassed with triggered Malaysians and over-patriotic singaporeans in the comments smh.
Okay, I'm getting tired reading some of the comments here. So, if you people had not realize it yet, this is a scenario, not an actual declaration of war. It's not as if Malaysia would actually declare war on Singapore, Binkov's just making assumptions - with a very specific types of rules - IF a hypothetical war does happen. Not the actual war itself, nor it's cause. And as for the "Call allies" argument some people may rant about in the comments, Binkov clearly mentioned in the start of the video that "No allies are involved" or something similar to that. Again, of does not necessarily imply that they - Singapore and Malaysia - would have no allies whatsoever. But this video is simply depicting a plausible scenario of “IF” these two Nations declare war, with no allies, who would've the bigger the possibility of achieving victory. Please, know the difference. And lastly. This is a video, made by the same guy who made the video about Russia and China fighting the Us to kick them out of Japan. It's not entirely accurate when it comes to actual alliances and diplomacy. But I do have to give props to Binkov for doing a thorough research for each and everyone of his scenarios, as they are all well made, and somewhat believable.
During ww2 LT Adan and the Malay regiment sacrificed themselves to defend against the Imperial Japanese. if Malaysia and Singapore go to war, wouldnt his sacrifice be wasted?
This is just a tougue-in-cheek video, not to be taken seriously. If SG and MY go to war, both will be crippled badly. No sensible person or politician wants that. There's absolutely no reason for SG and MY to go to war, since we are virtually of the same racial stock and mix. SG and MY do not have some long historical enmity, and going to war is simply too far-fetched. And after WW2, most nations have learnt that it is far better to live in peace with each other.
@@IDK-fv3hu which is why we still quarrel over it. IMO malaysia has better Nasi Lemak, but we have better chicken rice. Still, we won't go to war over that
A lot of you are probably watching this channel for the first time and talk about how implausible this scenario is, about how 'my country would totally level your country' and other varying levels of patriotic chest thumping. I can mostly agree with you, but the videos here always carry the implied disclaimer (though Binkov doesn't always make this explicit) that, unless explicitly stated: - Alliances of any kind are ignored - Troop morale is ignored - History, internal politics and overall geopolitics is also ignored These are all just purely speculational and do not in any way reflect the channel's views or politics.
The Ordinary Dude a.k.a BABiFun like I said, it's SPECULATION, ignoring politics and common sense, and focused STRICTLY on military, logistics, and geography.
The focal point of Malaysia's defence used to be up north near Thai border during the communist insurgency. There's more overlapping claim in eastern Sabah than anywhere in the Peninsular. Singapore isn't priority.
Also Malaysian army did not even position their troops and equipment despite being the attacker in this scenario which doesn't make sense even for Russian army unless the Malaysian leadership are too stupid to declare war without proper mobilization, and even waiting to be invaded by Singapore
I tasted nasi goreng when I go to Indonesia working together with their marine and costrad/kostrad (sorry for the costrad thing I forget how to pronounce that unit) and they said "nasi goreng are their national dishes same as nasi pidang"
Malaysia and Singapore will forever need each other in every aspect in peacetime and war nomatter how we want to deny it. These 2 countries going to war is mindless not to mention the love we have for each other.
M,Sia n SG are unlikely to go for actual war, the only thing we afraid of is proxy war created by a third parties. MS/SG you like it or not is like one distance family
My god these comments. Half of them are just butthurt Malaysian and Singaporeans talking about allies and how it’ll never happen. This is all theoretical. He’s not saying they’ll go to war, he’s just implicating the strategies and outcomes IF a war were to happen (which is highly unlikely)
War War War...Stupiak,nobody goin to War,everyone in Singapore n Malaysia peace loving nation..if any War ever happen its from Big Strong powerful Country...where cooperation between Nation is utmost important to Defend our Shore....
Just a reminder this is hypothetical, guys. It's stupid to suddenly declare war IRL, but it's more stupid to get angry over a hypothetical war. This should make us appreciate the peace we have here in Southeast Asia, we should be grateful that our leaders, no matter however bad they were, are not warmongers.
@@lyhthegreat No world leader wants war Unless your Kim jong un Every country is spending money into military because their scare that they are gonna be left behind
@@fuxionxd4822 Sadly you are wrong, yes, most world leaders don't want to be directly involved in a war, but they want their enemies to be so that they can make money off selling weapons and weaken their rivals at the same time..
@@lyhthegreat no one would want malaysia and singapore in war lol What are they gonna do sell nukes to us ? Like just 1 nuke is able to destroy singapore and malaysia doesnt have a way to protect against nukes And we cant even buy that much weopens . We are like the too little siblings fighting to big country like china and us
Yeah in the event of a war neither side would really win. Singapore would most likely win in the short term with superior equipment and being able to mobilise most of its forces quickly (unless it was a preemptive strike by Malaysia taking Singapore by surprise) whereas Malaysia's forces are spread out. Singapore won't be able to actually hold and secure that much land taken from Malaysia and it would end in a stalemate with Singapore holding a buffer zone to protect the main city-state while Malaysia taking a major blow to its forces from the initial attack and unable to (immediately) push Singapore back. With the trade route cut off for being a war zone both Singapore and Malaysia would take a huge blow to their economies (Singapore even more so). Instead what would most likely happen is that both Singapore and Malaysia would become the playground for other major countries to step in and take advantage with the justification of their trade being affected (the Malacca Strait) and both Malaysia and Singapore would lose even more (for example China would likely seize the opportunity to intervene and then the US would also step in to counter China and so on.). So yeah, war between Malaysia and Singapore is highly unlikely and stupid and both sides would take every measure to prevent it from happening in the first place.
@Aiman Shaw yes, in long term war. We might be have no best in Tech military with cold war equipment but we have enough Manpower to fight back. Starting small war like Guerilla war here and there and the military flank em. Destory the water supplies line will cripple Singapore, and their citizen will start a riot here and there.
I did not see this coming. Anyways, there will be devestation on both sides as many singaporeans and malaysians have family on both sides, not to mention some coming from malaysia to go to school/work in singapore.
Kinda crazy to see such a small place like Singapore has such a strong military. I mean, the whole country is basically a city yet they have F-15s, tankers, AWACS, the works.
Both leaders are economy-driven. A war will badly affect the economy and the leaders themselves will be voted out in the coming elections. In my opinion, no war for at least 100 years. Any matter required to be resolved, both nations will resolve by diplomatic means or last resort bring it to international court for judgement. Additional information, 300k Malaysian working in Singapore and declare war is certainly suicidal for any leaders. Malaysian leaders killing their own people or Singaporean leaders deprive themselves skill labours. Don't see any win win situation in war for both parties. Peace man!
Ummm, that’s basically suicide if it is open air and no cover. Singapore is so small a medium sized nuke can take out a quarter to half of the country, with fallouts, shockwaves, etc
I think both countries Malaysia and Singapore are good in some way. Not just equipment and economy. The people of Malaysia are friendly in my understanding.
@@MrLEECHINSOON it was 1991 operation, both Malaysia and Indonesia already Suffer from Communists attack decades ago and since the Singapore government itself were Chinese and some of their politicians related to Communist party, that's why those groups were created
@@Syam_XI . Singapore Government is a multi racial Government, not Chinese Government. In 1991, there is no more communist threat to Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore.
@@MrLEECHINSOON they may be multi racial but don't forget that this is the past the year is 1991, years after communist war end in Malaysia and Indonesia so people are still afraid during that time since the communist attack took both by surprise that even the villagers had to learned to use rifle weapons and there is communist party in Malaysia. So by that mean after Singapore got independent, people here got worried by the winning party rule because they thought it would create another communist party (even though they're not) which is why the operation was created. after the diplomatic relations the operation was ceased
i do feel patriotic for my country after knowing how high of military tech we have but in all seriousness, i love my malaysian friends and i hope a war between us will NEVER EVER COME and instead we will work together to create a bright future as one
Fellow sinkie here. Technology is only half of the equation. The other half is whether our soldiers have superior motivation, morale and training. Having served ns I have serious doubts about the human factor..
@DL2R you're in the wrong place if you're looking for a serious discussion about geopolitics.. even if we are talking on binkovs channel. Edutainment at best. The human factor is difficult to estimate and depends on context. Is the country going to be invaded? Are our interests going to be affected? All the more reason to fight or else there'll be nothing left. Training standards are deliberately set lower than other professional armies like the USA and UK as the SAF is a conscripted army. It is dependent on public support and each training death is one too many. During a period of tension perhaps the training tempo will be ramped up? Will the conscripts match up to the professionals of an opposing force? Who knows.
No questions. If Singapore gets attacked, US and CHINA will be on their way within the first hour itself. That is “if” they get attacked. The sultan of Johore has multiple land and properties in Singapore I doubt he would do shit
Alahai Malaysians , no need to bash this guy la, I've been watching him long before this video was made. This is the basis of his channel, simulating war strategy of various scenarios. I do enjoy his opinion, and any malaysian know for a fact that our military is lacking in funding, proportionally affecting the superiority. So x pyh la suruh dia delete video la, suruh buat research la. Malu la, youtube ni satu dunia tgk
*War is good for Muslim soldiers especially for Malaysia and Indonesia soldiers because this is a golden chance for Malaysia and Indonesia Muslim soldiers to die in battle (martyr). This is an easy way for them to enter heaven. Every Muslim wants this. According to Islam, all Muslim men must become soldiers if war breakout* .
The presentation of this battle is amazing. Data for the Singaporean forces and probable actions by them do make sense. However, the start of this conflict seems off. As you mentioned that Malaysia would be offensive to take control Singapore, but the simulation shows that Malaysia was not even ready to begin with all their troops were not even positioned for offensive operation prior to the operation. If Malaysia was planning to take Singapore, wouldn't the simulation should start with Malaysian troops and assets well positioned in offensive manner as necessary? Anyway, the video is great :)
After seeing the video, I can agree on what you said. The presentation shows as if Malaysia just out of the blue declared war on Singapore without any preparation whatsoever, it's like they mistakenly pressed a button that declared war
@@BABiFun Actually I was kinda surprised to see of how this hypothetical/simulation of war was presented. I've watched almost all Binkov's videos so far and yet this is the first time I see such odd and inconsistent presentation of his. Maybe Binkov forgot that Malaysia was set to attack first? and another part is the Malaysian fighter jets are SU-30MKM. By review of expert, the jet is highly capable with high maneuverability but Binkov marked it as (Mediocre).
@@aidenschavell3218 ah yeah that too, I was kinda surprises as to how that plane is marked as is. But then again, the artillery alone will deal enough damage to the airfield that it could disable most if not all Singaporean planes within the beginning of the escalation
The simulation should be Malaysia trying to conquer Singapore, but not a single preemptive strike is made by Malaysia. Suddenly the "attacking" Malaysia forget about cutting supply lines through land & sea. They simply wait for Singapore to invade. Who is conquering who then?? And even marked SU-30MKM as mediocre by simply putting it as same as SU30 is just unacceptable when it is practically on par with SU35. Then treating a PT91 as the same spec as a T72 and placing it as mediocre.
Because in any sort of scenario where war was on the table, Singapore would strike first. SG watches Malaysia closely, and any movement of Msian assets to Johor are next to hide from SG intel, human and electronic. In our mutual history, SG always mobilized first and sent the terse messages. Malaysia will not mobilize first as SG will interpret that as a prelude to war, and strike first if the message to stop is unheeded
Its all started when Malaysia as the biggest producer of Palm Oil running of land to be sacrificed. Then those big INVESTORS come. And the general said "welcome". Since then Indonesia became no.1 and Malaysia no.2. Still Singapore have some rich people with some sleep fund ready to be invested.
@Gavin Lim thanks for that information i didn't know we asked India. That some new to me. My eldest brother also been called up to Thailand to stop the Vietnam coming in the place called Ayanraprathe in Thailand.
Malaysia and Singapore would help fight together but not against each other. We are family after all... When war comes, we support each other. All conflict are just verbal, it will be resolved.
Malaysia will not attack Singapore because both are culturally, economically, socially integrated, alot of Malaysian works in Singapore and alot of Singaporean lives in Malaysia, both country depends on each other economically, Singapore need the resources from Malaysia and Malaysia needs intellectuals and investment from Singapore.
It would take a lot of effort for to make the 2 countries go to war. Singapore knows it can't hold Johor, and Malaysia knows it can't hold Singapore. That's why they split in the first place. Citizens on both sides are also very anti war. Unlike ALL their other neighbors in South East Asia, both nations have never elected militarist factions and have never been led by one. They are more likely to ally with one another to check their neighbors. Singapore bringing in an advance standing army, with Malaysia providing strategic depth.
If it really came into an armed conflict it would probably due to disputed islands and maritime territories. So far the Pedra Branca Island issues is resolved as Malaysians built military installations on Middle Rocks which is near to Pedra Branca that is controlled by Singaporean navy. And yes, there are 'other' islands that is within Malaysian territory but is handled by Singaporean authorities. Not sure one day Malaysian government is starting to take back these islands and demand control over her southern neighbors.
Good Strategic Analysis & Studies, Good Work Mr. Binkov, you are a talented Military Strategy Analyst. If and only if a war starts between Malaysia and Singapore... most likely both will lose, and there is absolutely no reason why Malaysia & Singapore need to enter a war ^^ However, if it do happen, Both Sides will lose badly... Singapore & Malaysia Culture are so much knitted and integrated, it's so common to have Malaysians working in Singapore and vice versa, even have family and kids across the borders... so, it's kind of hard to have War... maybe some political squabbles, but it's really unlikely.
Tl:dr: Singapore has the upper-edge if it takes a first strike doctrine and make it a short war; Malaysia has the upper-edge if it is able to draw out the conflict and make it a long war.
@@kennethhew This video is just a hypothesis on what if thay actually went to war pls don't comment bUt SiNgApOrE aNd MaLaYsIa WiLL nEvEr Go To WaR this video was just made for entertainment and answer what if's
then indonesia would also join in the war to both : 1. Our nasi uduk is much better than your nasi lemak. 2. Malay claim batik, reog, and countless indonesian tradition and arts. 3. Indonesian felt singapore's chili crab is a downgraded copy of indonesia's kepiting saos padang. 4. more reason may arise on the run.
First of all, Malaysia is not interested to go war with Singapore when a significant portion of Singaporeans have family or blood-ties with Malaysians especially the Malays. Not to mention a slight introduction of lethal biological weapon such as viruses could wreck havoc in Singapore judging by how densely populated and tiny they are. No amount of money or artillery can save you from that. Meanwhile Malaysia on the other hand has vast untapped land allowing more room for survival.
Every building in Singapore has bomb shelter. Every single man in SG is/was a soldier. Singapore is hard to infiltrate because of the density of tall buildings. Imagine snipers everywhere.
@@Raul_Menendez you're right, actually Malaysia and singapore have a defense agreement with The UK,New Zealand n Australia called The Five Power Defense Agreement where if any of these country got attacked they would backup each others
@@Naufal-zc9cd While ANZACS, Indonesia and Malaysia provide the heavy fighting. Singapore will be the main HQ and house the important ranks and staffs. Plus Singapore is one of the few nations to have the Iron Dome System.
Except that Singapore's army is a deterrent force composed mainly of its reservist citizens. Singapore is so small they are not in it to fight or win wars. Their sole purpose is to tell you what you stand to lose if you ever invade them. Their citizens are basically given training to be ready to take arms and fight for their country if Malaysia ever invaded them, and they will go down dying along with millions of Malaysians. Win or lose, Singapore will not let its country be walked over. And that is the definition of a deterrence. If push comes to shove, why are you talking about citizens suffering?
@@cliftonaurelius3060 That if your country was invaded, are you going to say 'in war everyone is a loser.... the citizens will ultimately suffer the most', insinuating as if the citizens of the invaded country have a choice to avoid a war?
@@teerificbitch By losers, I meant losing your life, family and friends. Not quite as an insult like calling someone a loser. Or does the word loser triggers you because you relate to it personally? Either way, I'm sorry for what had happened to you.
if we see in the advance of military assets perspective Singapore win. economy Singapore win. number of soldier Malaysia win. food both almost similar I guess. conclusion just don't start any war just eat some rice and make friends. problems settle. Aku orang Kedah(I Kedah citizens). Kedah is one of the among 14 state in Malaysia
Man people aperently really dislike thought expirements. Like it's not even about If it is possible but literaly what the battle strategy would be If it happened.
I like this kind of video from Binkov. However, his thought experiment (at least in this video) is only focused on three traditional domain (land, sea, air) and not include the other, equally important, two (space, cyber). Why he didn't include it, maybe he knows nothing about the opposing nations' capabilities of these other two domains. Maybe it would make the analysis more complex. Maybe he don't really know about these other domains and as such omitted it.
Meanwhile the real life Singaporean and Malaysian just want to lepak corner and eat satay together. Sip kopi. All friends and family. Crazy outsiders with crazy ideas.
+ Singapore attacking Malaysia makes sense because they could really use some "buffer zone" and have their military somewhere else than being scattered in the capital.
The comment section in this video belike 50% Proud countryman try to defend their nation 20% indonesia watching the war and they are the real winner 30% about food war between malaysia and sinagpore
I know you never model third party intervention, but this war would close the Strait of Malacca, which would be such a blow to the world economy that some kind of foreign intervention would be all but inevitable IMO.
SIngapore has conducted exercises where they convert regular streets into runways in emergencies by taking down all lamposts and setting up for short takeoff and landing
@Sales Executive we wont require our army that much... Our tanks are all facing the north ready to fire... the rest we'll let our F15 Eagles lead the way but in a few years time new members --> the F35B will join our RSAF family..
Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore are practically brothers. It would take alot for these 3 to justify war with eachother. Hell, these 3 would most likely fight together if a major war broke out. brunei is a joke
Brunei is a stanch Singapore ally, more than Malaysia in fact. And don't forget that nutcase Mahathir already made a claim on parts of Singapore already by declaring part of Tuas port Malaysian territory.
Yo wtf are you blaming him he’s just doing what he likes to do and imo you and everyone else are the real stupid ones for getting easily triggered on a video witch you aren’t even the target audience
singapore to malaysia and indonesia is like israel to palestine and egypt. small country made up of minorities surrounded by much bigger countries but backed up by the biggest countries in the world. Israel (EU and US) / Singapore (US, EU, India and China).
Quick War - Singapore
Long War - Malaysia
Overall Winner - Indonesia
Hotel - Trivago
5 star analysis... nice
More like china is the overall winner
Take care????? Garnier......
So if Singapore wants to start a war they have to do it quick and take over Malaysia, better let them to develop Malaysia and become a very strong country, let Sabah and Sarawak to be an Independent country, most of their development are getting drag by the Malaysian Central Government, because they can't use the religious manefesto to take control of the Sabah Sarawak majority.
@@Deezious that won't happen for one main reason. Indonesia.
The only war that can happen between them is an argument who’s nasi lemak and chicken rice is better
Malaysia's duh
Or a war over water supply amongst other things.. Currently it's in everyone's interest not to have a war
Who wants to start a war over who has rendang Indonesia v Malaysia
I like Malaysian’s nasi lemak. But Singapore’s chicken rice is the best
U see our fellow indonesian this is how u fight over a food who has better food ...not like u indonesia who always start to claiming dish from your country !! Stupid indonesia
War between Singapore and Malaysia is fought by keyboard warriors and armchair generals :P
*SINGAPOREAN KEYBOARD SPY AT BASE?*
瓜 alert singaporean keyboard spy in base
@@khantaung5442 Singaporean spy in the base?! Hut hut hut hut!
Not really. Malaysia kinda pawning itself with its governance while SG sits here in comfort.
Better than kinetic warfare huh.
Malaysia and Singapore are like a divorced couple, they argue a lot but couldn't forget on each other.
The only war between Malaysia and Singapore is which one has the best food 😂
Haha true Singapore wants peace not war
True so true
The only war I see between Malaysia and Singapore will be over Durians. Jk jk.
@@TheEcho112 DURIAN SEASON IS HERE!!!
@@captaindecade4705 true story. Come to Chong Pang in the evenings for good durian choices and reasonable prices.
Asean family group
Malaysia : yo who tf stole my water
Singapore : not me
Indonesia : not me
Brunei : not me
Thailand : wasn’t me
Myanmar : not me
Philippines : wasn’t me
Vietnam : you know its not me
Malaysia : then who tf took it....
China : ni hao
@@lbl8747 kid your name sounds like you have chinese ancestors
@Beng Liew Lim
十一段线在民国时期就划了。当时东南亚的各殖民政府都没有提出异议。结果各自独立建国之后都想要来分一杯羹。南沙在明代就拥有管辖权了。明清两代的地图都标的很清楚了，那个时候也不见东南亚各殖民地政府有什么意见啊。
@Beng Liew Lim
China already tolerate those courntries. It is not our fault since we found those islands first in hundreds years ago. And china is not interested in others territory. If you konw the langfang repubilc you will understand this. Langfang republic was established by chinese people in kalimantan and Chinese emperor reject them to be part of china. ln addition, the rise of china can also be benefit to local ethnic chinese in malaysia.
Although you are a malaysia citizen and you must be loyal to your nation chinese people in malaysia still have little political right.
@Beng Liew Lim
我是中国人，既然你站在马来西亚国民的立场上，那我也站在prc公民的立场上。你说习可以通过这个方式来宣称南海，可是早在明清时期的地图上就已经被标注了，而且还设有统治机构。11段线也是民国标的，跟习没关系，直到台湾马英九政府时期，他们还在主张“中華民國南海11段綫”，中业岛就是他们丢给菲律宾的。很何况11段线后来还被中共政府送了两段给越南。先在西方媒体有太多的anti china propaganda. 所以你看到的很多渲染中国威胁论的报道实际上是言过其实。况且就算有南海争端暂且也不会到马来西亚头上，就像你说的现在的中国政府很聪明又很谨慎。
@Beng Liew Lim
另外你提到的国族问题，我是这样理解的，理论上拥有哪国国籍且出生或直系祖先出生在该国的即为该国人。在中国的大学中有许多少数民族学生，他们都认为自己是中国人。我所说的大马华人和东南亚华人可以从中华人民共和国的崛起中获利其实与你们的国籍和国家认同无关。就像中国现在有很多朝鲜族积极学习朝鲜语，而蒙古族学习蒙古语的积极性却不高一样。因为韩国现在经济发达，因此朝鲜语的需求大，市场大，就业有保障。他们也没有把中国的利益放在韩国的利益后面。而现在由于中国的发展给了许多海外华人天然的优势，过去中国穷的时候你想到这边来卖产品我们也没钱买，当时的中国又封闭又落后，现在则不同了。更重要的是，你们的生命财产安全可能会多一份保障。李克强已经放话警告印尼不要再出现1998年那样的恶性事件了。就像东乌克兰的俄罗斯人也有俄罗斯在支持一样。大国的侨民、移民、后裔总归还是比小国甚至像犹太人这种当时没有祖国的侨民、后裔要有底气和保障。在中国不少少民并没有什么民族意识，这是由于中共的政策是保护少数民族的。但是在印尼和马来西亚情况则不同，因此中国的崛起一定程度上也是给了不少东南亚华人一个选择的机会。就像我看到油管上有不少印尼华人移民台湾，或者去大陆读书的。
Tbh tho, the militaries of both countries are built for different purposes. Singappre military are built to resemble Israel’s military in which they are excellent at early offensive attack and defending a small area. While Malaysian military are built to police the SEA waters. They are more of a pirate buster than a country conqueror. They both have very different doctrines and its very unlikely they would even want to fight each other
Wait a minute, so when Singapore joins Malaysia again they're going to have both experties in the military!
It could happen, if both of us remove the aspect of *politics.*
And neither of our countries would throw them away.
singapore army is so sissy.. not tough & robust
@@johnnyrico228 Malaysia had army radars that did not even respond when MH370 flew past them .Useless country
@@babicomel2469 well singapore did join malaysia before
But things didnt work out and malaysia kicked singapore out of malaysia
On behalf of both countries, I would like to apologize regarding how many uh... Passionate comments there are on this video. Hopefully the algorithm benefits outweigh the cons.
Regardless, really interesting video. I like how in-depth you go in discussing the differences between the two countries military powers. Definitely subscribed!
Why does nobody get the point of these video’s? It’s a military analysis, not a political one.
Twandepan And so if I promote my new military project to either of the government I can use this video as a reference to increase the chance of my project getting funded.
Like I should promote to Singapore side a quick solution that allows its infrastructures and equipment to self repair.
Alright let me start drafting it with CAD programmes, should I use Pro Enginning or Auto desk inventor?
"War is the continuation of politics by other means."
Clauswitz
You cannot separate war from politics.
But I'll indulge you.
For Singapore and Malaysia to get to this stage, the politicians on both sides would have been utter imbeciles.
If, military is not political, why then have a Ministry of Defence? Think again, apolitical?
Singapore and malaysia still support each other. Don't fight.
Simon Tay so everytime you arm wrestle with someone, you do so because you hate your opponent? Of course not. You just do so to see who has the bigger arm muscles. This is literally that.
Why don't people understand that this is just a hypothetical thing ....No one said it would really happen.
Some people just dont understand the concept of a hypothetical
Sickening thing about it is that some peoples be toxic about it smh
We like to poke one another, but low key, Singapore and Malaysia very tight
💯
*yes Singapore and Malaysia same power but to me Singapore stronger* 💪🇸🇬
Abil Batman no body near us will fight us with arms , they just squeeze our economy, we are dead.
@@dennislim9000 *ok!*
even in the past when malaysia just formed Singapore was part of malaysia
why the fuck are malaysians and Singaporeans arguing over a hypothetical situation, we should all be friend one lah
First day on the internet? 😂
Hi i am Bangladeshi .... i am a construction worker i live in singapore almost 5 years . I really don't expect any war between Singapore and Malaysia . Singaporean people are really nice and open mindful . I love Singapore from my heart.
Nah feel like they are one of the most apathetic people on Earth. source: am one of em
U are a good man, hope your conditions at your domitory gets better
Singaporean here. Ur a good Man with good heart sir. sadly, war has no place for good people. Fight or die
Thank you very much for your contribution Mr Hasan Zahid
M
The only war between the Singapore and malaysia is in the comment sections!
It's weird how it only happens on vids about Malaysia itself not gonna lie
@@ynog0978 yepp agreed
@AcTiveAK [Ace] and god forbid the paultan comment section that shit is brutal af too
When nationalists from different countries engage each other.
Indonesians: *watch the comment sections with popcorn*
@@ardantop132na6 hahaha yepp
I'm a Singaporean and I'm pretty sure i can kill 10 enemies and above with my keyboard
hahahaha
Hahahaha tru
I’m a Malaysian. Abang Phoenix can you sponsor me a keyboard
Hey, will you join Malaysia again?
Mobile Legends ??
It's funny to see people getting triggered about this and arguing lol... This is just a "what if" video and don't get too shitty about it.
Malaysia and Singapore wouldn't really go to war because both countries have their own problems to solve. Salam to both Malaysian Citizens and Singapore's🙏
I'm astounded at the amount of idiots in the comment section
Both country is part of FPDA so yes
When the Japanese invaded Singapore, the locals expected the British to defend the island. Instead, the British just packed up and left. Singapore built its military with the mindset that there will be no one to rely on in case of an invasion, that's why they spend so much effort to build the biggest military force in the region. Their military training is professional and well equipped. They also take reservist training seriously. Also, Singapore hires Nepali Gurkha. With that mindset, the scenario of this video should be the other way around.
Isreal of Asia lol
@@edyslavico3761 you arent wrong,singapore has israel tech
@@edyslavico3761 bro, Israel is in Asia. I believe you meant to say Israel of the East.
@@edyslavico3761 Yes very much so, and if I remembered correctly, Singapore consulted Israel when they were establishing their own military.
@@bytemegga technically yes, but most people consider the Middle East to be a region.
You are right, but you get what I mean
The only war Msia and SG will engage in is whose food is better. That's it.
I will volunteer as a soldier for both sides if that’s the case 😂😂😂
Malaysia: nasi lemak
SG: chilli crab
Malaysia: ayam penyet
SG: bee hoon
Malaysia: apam balik
SG: curry fish head
Thailand: HELLO THERE I HAVE (insert random number, 20-1010101010010010101) DISHES!
Malaysia and SG: KO
Lol
@@zacharytang3840 Malaysia and Singapore to Thailand: STFU you CB stay out of this
Asking which food is better, Malaysian or Singaporean, can be a touchy issue. 😂
Too many people in the comments are getting mad, thinking this is real.
Ryszmarine yeah people today aren’t very bright
Happens every time. It's one of the reason the US military used zombies in a recent planning exercise, so they didn't have to deal with a bunch of idiots taking things out of context.
That's why this topic shouldn't be a general discussion. It can form a negative perception in the general public and instill a passion for war for no reason.
You're right s gaming channel.
May the only conflict between Malaysians and Singaporeans be about whose food is better
Malaysia: declares war on Singapore
Singapore: we need help
America: sorry bud we're busy with covid
Singapore: but they have oil
America: *democracy intensifies
Malaysia doesn't have much oil. But Brunei does.
@@iqbal5826 Malaysia has a LOT of oil but it's currently being contested by CCP
@@Justineexy What.
@@iqbal5826 He is talking about the presumed oil fields in the Spratleys but honestly I've yet to see proof there is anything under there.
@@iqbal5826 where do you think petronas get their oil from
I don’t know how binkov can stand these big brains in the comments that don’t understand what a thought experiment is
@@ngkhaijie damn, hope things get better. Here in the states the corrupt government keeps trying to get rid of privacy laws.
@@ngkhaijie Don't lie to audience. The ISA has been abolished in 2011 by 6th Prime Minister.
@@ngkhaijie ISA is long, long over, mate.
Until this thought experiment isnt just a thought, it has actually happened if you know the history behind Singapore and Malaysian. The threat to cut Singapore's water supplies, the joint military exercise held a mere 50km off Singapore's border and on a 'coincedental' National day parade where most military assets were on deployed for the march, the still unresolved airspace and sea borders. These are real life events that have happened. Going further back, Indonesian did openly threaten to go war with Malaysia when Singapore was still part of the federation. This video.is at best insensitive and at worst, a provocation. Thought experiment up his
@@ngkhaijie and my country is china.... fake democracy is better than no democracy lol
Nah, our military too busy laughing at us both citizen fighting over Whose Nasi lemak is better...
My daughter was stationed at mountain home air force base for a couple of years. Her expertise was in the computer world and in intelligence. She told me she became friends with Singaporean air force pilots who were training at Mountain Home for some pretty intensive training. She told me these pilots were damned good and Singapore spared no expense in getting them the best training. Though many counties in the U.S. are bigger than this city-state, Singapore is an extremely well equipped military force to reckon with. The air force has top notch fighters, transports, and multi role helicopters. My daughter says Singapore invests millions, if not billions for defense annually and a lot of that money goes for training. She said any country in the region declaring war on Singapore would be suicidal as Singapore is well equipped, armed with missiles, bombs and the best jets and fighters. Like the U.S., the pilots get a lot of flight time with training from USAF flight instructors. Singapore can take care of herself at times of conflict. Why would Malaysia want to go to war with a powerhouse like Singapore?
Never trust Israel and their allies...no war..sarang tebuan jangan dijolok..
Don't worry, the Malaysian 🇲🇾 artillery will do some damage to all Singaporean 🇸🇬 aircraft runway, so the Singaporean 🇸🇬 military pilot can't landed their plane 😎 .
@@fadzilhashim.0910 read up on f35 vertical take off fighters… something which malaysia could never afford
@Alexandria School of Science
Even Isra-Hell 🔥 with a strong military can't destroy Hamas, a small militia group from Palestine 🇵🇸 .
So, how a small island country like Singapore 🇸🇬 can destroy a well trained Malaysian 🇲🇾 Armed Force ? 😎 .
@@wysrl
Even Isra-Hell 🔥 have many F-35 aircraft, but they still can't destroy Hamas, a small militia group from Palestine 🇵🇸 .
So, how F-35 aircraft owned by Singapore 🇸🇬 can destroy a well trained Malaysian 🇲🇾 Armed Force ? 😎 .
From Singapore here. This analysis is pretty commendable although there are strategies on our side here which I am certain can’t be openly shared. Nevertheless, we don’t want a war. We love Malaysia. Ask any Singaporeans and we will tell you we love Malaysia. Malaysians share very similar cultures to Singapore and we Singaporeans enjoy taking the random holidays to tour Malaysia. Nobody here in their right sense would want to fight Malaysia. I know, your analysis was based on hypothesis, but why would any of our countries want to destroy the many decades of peace and prosperity? Both sides will suffer greatly if a war do break out. It is better to exercise patience and understanding than to ruin the many years of harmony and interdependency.
But if theoretically if there is a war Singapore would try to have johor without fighting honestly consideirng alot of Singaporeans stay there and Malaysians that work in Singapore stays there.
Sometime war is an avenue to distract the population. Look at China invasion of Vietnam or Japanese invasion of Korea during the 1600s . Didn't Singapore always become a Malaysian target board whenever they had domestic issue. Well someone did says war is just part of political tool .
Sakiru Eiji not sure about that man. Fight or not really depends on the government of both countries. So vote wisely for the right government and we will have peace. As what Mark Ong said below in another reply, MY ministers for the last few decades have always used Singapore as a target board whenever they have their own domestic issues. By doing that they diverted all the attention and hatred of the citizens of Malaysia towards Singapore instead of themselves. I just hope the government over there will stand up and do a good job for the people rather than divert blames to us. This have always been my sincere wishes.
Mark Ong Yes it’s true. But we just got to exercise patience, not because we are a small country, but because it doesn’t benefit both sides in the long run.
@@andyhooutdoors I beg to differ in your opinion of both sides losses in war . Aggressor sometimes does pay . However lesson learned in 6 day war is that Israel gain it's strategic gap in Sinai peninsula . There are some parts up north look always juicy for me. The terrain up north is no walk in the park with high hills , jungle and if we are lucky plantation . Urban dwellers like the conscripts corps of ours may be boggles down in operation due to topology and logistics. Esienhower qouted all plan are useless when war start but planning is essential. We could talk till the cow comes home but history may be playing out otherwise. Sun Tzu says know your enemy know yourself and you shall be victorious in hundred battle . Do we know ourselves or do we know our enemies ? There is an on going joke in Singapore saying no war need to be fought as we had been invaded by foreigners. If you wanna go India go Changi business park. If you wanna go Philippines go lucky plaza. This is also true in the army . When I was conscripted left and right are true blue local . Some may have slang , some are hokkien Peng . Ultimately you know you have a common goal to defend your land . Fast forward 10 years down the road, I head back for reservist I got a shock of my life . Almost half of NSF is non local . RP russian, driver PRC, store man Myanmar, clerk Viet . And the best of the best part medic Nigerian . I almost got a shock of my life . I look at my helmet to make sure it's not blue because I thought I had been sent on a UN mission . So the phycology of things are very much different as compared to 20 years ago. On top of that are you lead by lions or sheep ? 1990 when we celebrate our 25 years of independence old fox up north mobilize a large exercise near us . Our grunts all given 120 rounds , standby at border waiting for them . Today one unarmed maritime boat park in our sovereign , use loud header talk non stop to ask them leave . If it was old man time , it will be no nonsense. Old man would had ordered the boat be forcefully boarded tow back to port and start negotiation. They will never allow some MB to parades in our waters . Lesson learned in beginning of WW2 french has the best tank Char 1b outgunned anything German panzar could throw at it. However French lost its land because leadership is passive .
There was this interesting statement made by a reservist Sgt when I small talk with him in an MG nest . He says if the authority had given to him even with a pistol he will show aggressive stands and fire at the intruder. But every single time he needs to feedback and ask permission even with a bazooka he is powerless .
There you go I pretty sums up everything , not by gun nor power but by the will of the men .
ASEAN wont fight each other since they have a bigger problem named CHINA.
Yeeeees finally something we can agree on
Hahahahaha
China is a bully, don’t you see Singapore sucking up to China. Now China can fly to Singapore where most of the import cases are
@@subie1019 very true
@@subie1019 actually Singapore is neutral. Friendly to both China and US. But not too friendly. Malaysia also did the same things, but not so neutral. Malaysia friendly with China and US also. But tend to more friendly towards China than US.
Singapore will never go to war with its neighbours. The culture of both countries are so similar, with families, relatives and friends on both sides of the Johor Straits. Unless, there are no other solutions and Singapore is pushed to the walls. The US would be involved way ahead, whether diplomatically or militarily. On tactics, the beachhead in western Johor is insufficient to defend in depth. Pushing to Malacca might allow sufficient space for various divisions to manoeuvre.
Edwin Kwan it’s kind of just a hypothetical situation but yeah I completely agree
I am almost certain we would invade Malaysia the moment the water is cut back in the day we were reliant on them for it. But in 2020, I think true lah, won't invade even if they cut the water. Singapore don't need buffer de. I'm almost certain the strategy is to spearhead to KL in 7 days. SG really cannot take a long war, strategic depth is one thing but the economic aftermath is another.
@@matthewleong2726 kahkah 7 days..wow high dream in Singapore 's brain.
@@ayuhmembawang5391 I'm Singaporean and while we probably can't do it in 7 days( that is straight BS ) REPORTS:
From 0-30 days winner: SG
31-120 days: SG
120-180: SG/Malay
181-360: Malay
360+: we all die liao
Malaysia is currently in the midst of a political overhaul and is way too busy sorting out its own problems to be dealing with anything else, much less a nation that has the backing of basically every major superpower in the world
This is just a hypothetical scenario lol
Malaysia is busy to sort its internal issue, but anything external trying to attack us, we are united and ready anytime.
Sorry we ( Malaysian - Singaporean) are not interested to war n wanna live in peace. #peacenowar
#🇲🇾love🇸🇬
Org barat lebih tahu.. Dia menusuk ibarat barah jika ko lalai leka tanah dipijak milik org..
I made this comment just to made this statement ok, I mean we both protect our butt together
Pakistan Turkey İran vs İsrael Saudi Arabia Egypt. Who would win?
That's what Coward said
@@tangocharliedd-2146 the winner is the true
PSA: avoid the comments section if you're not Malaysian or Singaporean
Indonesia: "oh no, this is too entertaining to miss"
@insyaallah ganteng correction: grabs indomie
@@andrasafirgemintang3028 correction. *grabs popmie*
@@Author_Paluthor Me malaysian: Grabs Nasi lemak copi-o
tf is this comment section with people not understanding that the video does not bother with politics and only focuses on military power
Yeah are they not watching the beginning of the video
Lmao but this is still a poor scenario. Political power directly influences military power. For example Malaysia wouldn't touch Singapore shopping because it would risk war with other nations.
Singapore would fight very offensively striking deep into the country with air/Navy or assassinate major leaders to force a quick surrender.
@@kakerake6018 THE WHOLE POINT OF IT IS AS A HYPOTHETICAL WAR OH MY GOD
It's really, REALLY obvious that if Singapore gets US support they'll win but its isn't 'Singapore and US vs Malaysia' it's just Singapore and Malaysia
geez it's just a video guys. In reality anything could happen, Singapore might win, Malaysia might win, or it could be a stalemate and both countries enters into a peace agreement. No need to get hostile with each other over a war that will never happen. Malaysia and Singapore have great relations with each other and I don't see in any way, a war could break out between the two countries. So embarassed with triggered Malaysians and over-patriotic singaporeans in the comments smh.
Okay, I'm getting tired reading some of the comments here.
So, if you people had not realize it yet, this is a scenario, not an actual declaration of war. It's not as if Malaysia would actually declare war on Singapore, Binkov's just making assumptions - with a very specific types of rules - IF a hypothetical war does happen. Not the actual war itself, nor it's cause. And as for the "Call allies" argument some people may rant about in the comments, Binkov clearly mentioned in the start of the video that "No allies are involved" or something similar to that. Again, of does not necessarily imply that they - Singapore and Malaysia - would have no allies whatsoever. But this video is simply depicting a plausible scenario of “IF” these two Nations declare war, with no allies, who would've the bigger the possibility of achieving victory.
Please, know the difference. And lastly. This is a video, made by the same guy who made the video about Russia and China fighting the Us to kick them out of Japan. It's not entirely accurate when it comes to actual alliances and diplomacy. But I do have to give props to Binkov for doing a thorough research for each and everyone of his scenarios, as they are all well made, and somewhat believable.
Finally..Something that makes sense
Google translate
True
Can u draw its to long 😂😂😂
well said!
Suddenly, everyone's a military expert.
I think SAF is still headhunting military experts to raise their tactical awareness during this economic downturn, maybe they should apply >:D
During ww2 LT Adan and the Malay regiment sacrificed themselves to defend against the Imperial Japanese. if Malaysia and Singapore go to war, wouldnt his sacrifice be wasted?
Yes. He wouldnt want to have another war after his death.
Yes but in u cannot tell what will happen in the future
Anything can happen in the future
Wow there sure are a lot of war experts and strategists on this comment section.
yep
Actually the cause of war is because they are arguing which country nasi lemak is better
Thanos also can't do nothing about it
Rendang also
Ah yes... rendang, * stop fighting it ours *
Zul Kapan *Indonesia has entered the chat*
This is just a tougue-in-cheek video, not to be taken seriously. If SG and MY go to war, both will be crippled badly. No sensible person or politician wants that. There's absolutely no reason for SG and MY to go to war, since we are virtually of the same racial stock and mix. SG and MY do not have some long historical enmity, and going to war is simply too far-fetched. And after WW2, most nations have learnt that it is far better to live in peace with each other.
Malaysia and Singapore declared war
Reason ; who's food is better..😂😂😂
I thought both country have the same food?
Surely Malaysia will win in term of food because Singapore was part of Malaysia
@@IDK-fv3hu which is why we still quarrel over it. IMO malaysia has better Nasi Lemak, but we have better chicken rice. Still, we won't go to war over that
@@str2010 malaysia's chicken rice better. XD
@@mohdhusaini4530 Technically, most of Singapore's foods is from Britain because Singapore was colonised by the British in the past.
We are tied very closly, and not interested in fighting each other, this the most peaceful region in the world, neighbours dont fight.
then why does singapore have mandatory conscription if its so safe?
A lot of you are probably watching this channel for the first time and talk about how implausible this scenario is, about how 'my country would totally level your country' and other varying levels of patriotic chest thumping. I can mostly agree with you, but the videos here always carry the implied disclaimer (though Binkov doesn't always make this explicit) that, unless explicitly stated:
- Alliances of any kind are ignored
- Troop morale is ignored
- History, internal politics and overall geopolitics is also ignored
These are all just purely speculational and do not in any way reflect the channel's views or politics.
We know nothing about who Colonel Binkov really is.
The Ordinary Dude a.k.a BABiFun like I said, it's SPECULATION, ignoring politics and common sense, and focused STRICTLY on military, logistics, and geography.
Victor Gee that’s the way it is done.
The focal point of Malaysia's defence used to be up north near Thai border during the communist insurgency. There's more overlapping claim in eastern Sabah than anywhere in the Peninsular. Singapore isn't priority.
Also Malaysian army did not even position their troops and equipment despite being the attacker in this scenario which doesn't make sense even for Russian army unless the Malaysian leadership are too stupid to declare war without proper mobilization, and even waiting to be invaded by Singapore
Malaysia would attack with its large amounts of Nasi Goreng, but would be countered by the latest Singaporean Laksa....
P N nasi lemak
😂
And Pasembur, Mee Goreng Mamak, Laksa Penang, Roti Canai, Murtabak and Teh Tarik too 😍😍😍😍😍
I tasted nasi goreng when I go to Indonesia working together with their marine and costrad/kostrad (sorry for the costrad thing I forget how to pronounce that unit) and they said "nasi goreng are their national dishes same as nasi pidang"
@@tangocharliedd-2146 yeah yeah Indonesian claiming everything comes from their country..it's not something new though 😂😂
People in the comment forgets that this was just a "what if"
Yes, absolutely , it is unlikely for both ends to wage war on each other.
Malaysia and Singapore will forever need each other in every aspect in peacetime and war nomatter how we want to deny it. These 2 countries going to war is mindless not to mention the love we have for each other.
M,Sia n SG are unlikely to go for actual war, the only thing we afraid of is proxy war created by a third parties. MS/SG you like it or not is like one distance family
Nay will never happen. These 2 countries only argue with mouths but deep down, they are brothers, ah bang.
Mantap bossku
My god these comments. Half of them are just butthurt Malaysian and Singaporeans talking about allies and how it’ll never happen. This is all theoretical. He’s not saying they’ll go to war, he’s just implicating the strategies and outcomes IF a war were to happen (which is highly unlikely)
All I see are meme comments wtf you talking about
War War War...Stupiak,nobody goin to War,everyone in Singapore n Malaysia peace loving nation..if any War ever happen its from Big Strong powerful Country...where cooperation between Nation is utmost important to Defend our Shore....
@@zulkifliebinjaffar.zulkifl9337 With the media.
Western will start calling us F***** terrorist.
@@wetpapertowel5677 if u see this video comment section earlier around when this video just get released..u see alot of tht type of comments
People make fun of this bcos it will never happen🤷🤦
Just a reminder this is hypothetical, guys. It's stupid to suddenly declare war IRL, but it's more stupid to get angry over a hypothetical war. This should make us appreciate the peace we have here in Southeast Asia, we should be grateful that our leaders, no matter however bad they were, are not warmongers.
if everyone thinks like you the world would have been a much more peaceful place..unfortunately reality is rarely like this.
@@lyhthegreat No world leader wants war Unless your Kim jong un
Every country is spending money into military because their scare that they are gonna be left behind
@@fuxionxd4822 Sadly you are wrong, yes, most world leaders don't want to be directly involved in a war, but they want their enemies to be so that they can make money off selling weapons and weaken their rivals at the same time..
@@lyhthegreat no one would want malaysia and singapore in war lol
What are they gonna do sell nukes to us ?
Like just 1 nuke is able to destroy singapore and malaysia doesnt have a way to protect against nukes
And we cant even buy that much weopens .
We are like the too little siblings fighting to big country like china and us
@@lyhthegreat We have a bigger threat its China
what stupid question is this.. we are the best of neighbours
Yeah in the event of a war neither side would really win. Singapore would most likely win in the short term with superior equipment and being able to mobilise most of its forces quickly (unless it was a preemptive strike by Malaysia taking Singapore by surprise) whereas Malaysia's forces are spread out. Singapore won't be able to actually hold and secure that much land taken from Malaysia and it would end in a stalemate with Singapore holding a buffer zone to protect the main city-state while Malaysia taking a major blow to its forces from the initial attack and unable to (immediately) push Singapore back. With the trade route cut off for being a war zone both Singapore and Malaysia would take a huge blow to their economies (Singapore even more so).
Instead what would most likely happen is that both Singapore and Malaysia would become the playground for other major countries to step in and take advantage with the justification of their trade being affected (the Malacca Strait) and both Malaysia and Singapore would lose even more (for example China would likely seize the opportunity to intervene and then the US would also step in to counter China and so on.). So yeah, war between Malaysia and Singapore is highly unlikely and stupid and both sides would take every measure to prevent it from happening in the first place.
After all. We're brothers and look out for each other.
Better if ASEAN vs China. This what I wanna see.
@Aiman Shaw yes, in long term war. We might be have no best in Tech military with cold war equipment but we have enough Manpower to fight back.
Starting small war like Guerilla war here and there and the military flank em. Destory the water supplies line will cripple Singapore, and their citizen will start a riot here and there.
I did not see this coming. Anyways, there will be devestation on both sides as many singaporeans and malaysians have family on both sides, not to mention some coming from malaysia to go to school/work in singapore.
Kinda crazy to see such a small place like Singapore has such a strong military. I mean, the whole country is basically a city yet they have F-15s, tankers, AWACS, the works.
Randomly Entertaining and in the near future F-35s
James Kresnik similar geopolitical position though diplomacy is still the best tool
@James Kresnik Israelis set up the SAF
Yeah overcompensating is something men with small jewels tend to do
Singapore outspend Malaysia in defence by a factor of 2 for decades. The result is obvious.
Both leaders are economy-driven. A war will badly affect the economy and the leaders themselves will be voted out in the coming elections. In my opinion, no war for at least 100 years.
Any matter required to be resolved, both nations will resolve by diplomatic means or last resort bring it to international court for judgement.
Additional information, 300k Malaysian working in Singapore and declare war is certainly suicidal for any leaders. Malaysian leaders killing their own people or Singaporean leaders deprive themselves skill labours. Don't see any win win situation in war for both parties.
Peace man!
Singapore: we testing a Nuclear Bomb Somewhere in the singapore
The Earth: You ....what?
They be killin themselves... And others
@@04mmar lol
Ummm, that’s basically suicide if it is open air and no cover. Singapore is so small a medium sized nuke can take out a quarter to half of the country, with fallouts, shockwaves, etc
@@famoterlhh4993 bruh
@@famoterlhh4993 that's... The joke...
As a Malaysian, I still think Singapore is more advance than Malaysia😂
It is actually the only developed country in ASEAN
No war we are neighbor
I think both countries Malaysia and Singapore are good in some way. Not just equipment and economy. The people of Malaysia are friendly in my understanding.
@Stain yeah it is something like the SG is economically advance than MY but majority of the citizens live in HDB flats. In MY you have more choices
We are like brothers and sisters.
Google and find out what is "Operation Total Wipe Out"
@@MrLEECHINSOON it was 1991 operation, both Malaysia and Indonesia already Suffer from Communists attack decades ago and since the Singapore government itself were Chinese and some of their politicians related to Communist party, that's why those groups were created
@@Syam_XI . Singapore Government is a multi racial Government, not Chinese Government. In 1991, there is no more communist threat to Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore.
@@Syam_XI . How about last year, Malaysia vessels illegal intrusion in Singapore western water?
@@MrLEECHINSOON they may be multi racial but don't forget that this is the past the year is 1991, years after communist war end in Malaysia and Indonesia so people are still afraid during that time since the communist attack took both by surprise that even the villagers had to learned to use rifle weapons and there is communist party in Malaysia. So by that mean after Singapore got independent, people here got worried by the winning party rule because they thought it would create another communist party (even though they're not) which is why the operation was created. after the diplomatic relations the operation was ceased
Just cut the durian supply and Singapore will surrender in no time
Haha just cut the water supply
No
@@Buka.nsapasapa it was a joke we ban durians on trains
@@davidteo879Hahhhhaa
Fckkkkkk. How could chu?!
i do feel patriotic for my country after knowing how high of military tech we have but in all seriousness, i love my malaysian friends and i hope a war between us will NEVER EVER COME and instead we will work together to create a bright future as one
Fellow sinkie here. Technology is only half of the equation. The other half is whether our soldiers have superior motivation, morale and training. Having served ns I have serious doubts about the human factor..
@DL2R you're in the wrong place if you're looking for a serious discussion about geopolitics.. even if we are talking on binkovs channel. Edutainment at best.
The human factor is difficult to estimate and depends on context. Is the country going to be invaded? Are our interests going to be affected? All the more reason to fight or else there'll be nothing left.
Training standards are deliberately set lower than other professional armies like the USA and UK as the SAF is a conscripted army. It is dependent on public support and each training death is one too many. During a period of tension perhaps the training tempo will be ramped up? Will the conscripts match up to the professionals of an opposing force? Who knows.
You are the first singaporean that actually said something positive for what I can see lol
@@IDK-fv3hu I like this guy
I do hope you will help us, Malaysian if somehow Kim jong un declared war on becuz of that issue lmao
No questions. If Singapore gets attacked, US and CHINA will be on their way within the first hour itself. That is “if” they get attacked. The sultan of Johore has multiple land and properties in Singapore I doubt he would do shit
Alahai Malaysians , no need to bash this guy la, I've been watching him long before this video was made. This is the basis of his channel, simulating war strategy of various scenarios. I do enjoy his opinion, and any malaysian know for a fact that our military is lacking in funding, proportionally affecting the superiority. So x pyh la suruh dia delete video la, suruh buat research la. Malu la, youtube ni satu dunia tgk
Strategi malaysia just ez..jauh kan 3 biji bimb
Top One no lah msia confirm just mass manpower singapore and we lose but ofc not before kamikaze yall
Would be really weird for Malaysia to conquer Singapore when they were the ones that kicked them out of the country in the first place.
It would not be a conquering move, it would be a reunification of Singapore back to the Malaysian federation.
@@kenhew4641 That's a conquest use a dictionary.
*War is good for Muslim soldiers especially for Malaysia and Indonesia soldiers because this is a golden chance for Malaysia and Indonesia Muslim soldiers to die in battle (martyr). This is an easy way for them to enter heaven. Every Muslim wants this. According to Islam, all Muslim men must become soldiers if war breakout*
.
@@kenhew4641it would be stupid since they were expelled due to malaysia wanting a continued dominance of the malay race
The presentation of this battle is amazing. Data for the Singaporean forces and probable actions by them do make sense. However, the start of this conflict seems off. As you mentioned that Malaysia would be offensive to take control Singapore, but the simulation shows that Malaysia was not even ready to begin with all their troops were not even positioned for offensive operation prior to the operation.
If Malaysia was planning to take Singapore, wouldn't the simulation should start with Malaysian troops and assets well positioned in offensive manner as necessary? Anyway, the video is great :)
After seeing the video, I can agree on what you said. The presentation shows as if Malaysia just out of the blue declared war on Singapore without any preparation whatsoever, it's like they mistakenly pressed a button that declared war
@@BABiFun Actually I was kinda surprised to see of how this hypothetical/simulation of war was presented. I've watched almost all Binkov's videos so far and yet this is the first time I see such odd and inconsistent presentation of his. Maybe Binkov forgot that Malaysia was set to attack first? and another part is the Malaysian fighter jets are SU-30MKM. By review of expert, the jet is highly capable with high maneuverability but Binkov marked it as (Mediocre).
@@aidenschavell3218 ah yeah that too, I was kinda surprises as to how that plane is marked as is.
But then again, the artillery alone will deal enough damage to the airfield that it could disable most if not all Singaporean planes within the beginning of the escalation
The simulation should be Malaysia trying to conquer Singapore, but not a single preemptive strike is made by Malaysia. Suddenly the "attacking" Malaysia forget about cutting supply lines through land & sea. They simply wait for Singapore to invade. Who is conquering who then?? And even marked SU-30MKM as mediocre by simply putting it as same as SU30 is just unacceptable when it is practically on par with SU35. Then treating a PT91 as the same spec as a T72 and placing it as mediocre.
Because in any sort of scenario where war was on the table, Singapore would strike first. SG watches Malaysia closely, and any movement of Msian assets to Johor are next to hide from SG intel, human and electronic.
In our mutual history, SG always mobilized first and sent the terse messages. Malaysia will not mobilize first as SG will interpret that as a prelude to war, and strike first if the message to stop is unheeded
The annual haze from nearby Indonesia is a bigger threat to both Singapore and Malaysia.
*ok!*
Yesss
And may people know that some of the companies are owned by Singaporean and Malaysian 😆
@@sultanarsakor I thought it was the farmers burning down the forest
@@str2010 famers dont have that huge ANOTHER NEW land to open.
Its all started when Malaysia as the biggest producer of Palm Oil running of land to be sacrificed. Then those big INVESTORS come. And the general said "welcome".
Since then Indonesia became no.1 and Malaysia no.2. Still Singapore have some rich people with some sleep fund ready to be invested.
The greatest casualty of all though. Is the brave fallen keyboard warriors who are truly experts in military tactics
Ha
Lest we forget.
Yes. But be fair, keyboard warriors can afford to be Maverick sat inside Firefox. Hang the military budget!
Lol
Even Erwin Rommel, Von Menstein, Bernard Montgomery and Omar Bravo will surrender with keyboard warrior experts 😂😂😂😂
In the case of war, both sides will lose. We'd rather cooperate to build ASEAN to be as good as EU
Indonesia invading Singapore would be more interesting, I think it is gonna be six day war 2.0 but in South East Asia and Singapore is the Israel one.
Our commando during the 70s been trained by Israeli. My brother was one of them.
@Gavin Lim thanks for that information i didn't know we asked India. That some new to me. My eldest brother also been called up to Thailand to stop the Vietnam coming in the place called Ayanraprathe in Thailand.
Malaysia and Singapore would help fight together but not against each other. We are family after all... When war comes, we support each other. All conflict are just verbal, it will be resolved.
Malaysia will not attack Singapore because both are culturally, economically, socially integrated, alot of Malaysian works in Singapore and alot of Singaporean lives in Malaysia, both country depends on each other economically, Singapore need the resources from Malaysia and Malaysia needs intellectuals and investment from Singapore.
Google and find out what is "Operation Total Wipe Out"
@@MrLEECHINSOON can't you just send the sources instead of telling us to Google?
war between us is stupid. both nations needed each other to thrive.
It would take a lot of effort for to make the 2 countries go to war. Singapore knows it can't hold Johor, and Malaysia knows it can't hold Singapore. That's why they split in the first place. Citizens on both sides are also very anti war. Unlike ALL their other neighbors in South East Asia, both nations have never elected militarist factions and have never been led by one. They are more likely to ally with one another to check their neighbors. Singapore bringing in an advance standing army, with Malaysia providing strategic depth.
Should I tell you that this is just a "What If" situation not some political shits
I think most of us know that.
But the comment section somehow became a warzone.
If it really came into an armed conflict it would probably due to disputed islands and maritime territories. So far the Pedra Branca Island issues is resolved as Malaysians built military installations on Middle Rocks which is near to Pedra Branca that is controlled by Singaporean navy.
And yes, there are 'other' islands that is within Malaysian territory but is handled by Singaporean authorities. Not sure one day Malaysian government is starting to take back these islands and demand control over her southern neighbors.
I'm from Batu Pahat, Johor. Sultan Johor have many armed forces💪
Good Strategic Analysis & Studies, Good Work Mr. Binkov, you are a talented Military Strategy Analyst. If and only if a war starts between Malaysia and Singapore... most likely both will lose, and there is absolutely no reason why Malaysia & Singapore need to enter a war ^^ However, if it do happen, Both Sides will lose badly... Singapore & Malaysia Culture are so much knitted and integrated, it's so common to have Malaysians working in Singapore and vice versa, even have family and kids across the borders... so, it's kind of hard to have War... maybe some political squabbles, but it's really unlikely.
Tl:dr: Singapore has the upper-edge if it takes a first strike doctrine and make it a short war; Malaysia has the upper-edge if it is able to draw out the conflict and make it a long war.
So what it is good for both countries having a war? Absolutely nothing
@@kennethhew This video is just a hypothesis on what if thay actually went to war pls don't comment bUt SiNgApOrE aNd MaLaYsIa WiLL nEvEr Go To WaR this video was just made for entertainment and answer what if's
Why fight when both countries can have a koraoke competition?
@@zafrullahyazid9358 nah organize a nasi lemak cook off between two
@@dantheslayer1023 Please no hot dogs with the nasi lemak.
Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia should never engage in warefare. We have worked so long for peace, war would reverse this progress drastically
Indonesia did bomb and killed ppl before in Singapore during 1965
@@huh5921 so what's your point
@@user-dv4rh2my1x I mean Indonesia did bomb some of our buildings before we were independent and it got a few people killed
@@huh5921 it was a war
@@agnostikisbetter1893 they never declare war on us
Lol I Could See Only 1 Reason Why Malaysia Would Declare War On Singapore
1. Singapore Claim Nasi Lemak As Their National Dishes
then indonesia would also join in the war to both :
1. Our nasi uduk is much better than your nasi lemak.
2. Malay claim batik, reog, and countless indonesian tradition and arts.
3. Indonesian felt singapore's chili crab is a downgraded copy of indonesia's kepiting saos padang.
4. more reason may arise on the run.
*Indonesia join the chat*
@@snake45aiman why cusines can lead to war?
Why is all the dishes in Singapore so sweet..chilli sauce is sweet. Mee robus is sweet..chicken rice sweet n blue?
Never try to sell nazi lemak in singapore
First of all, Malaysia is not interested to go war with Singapore when a significant portion of Singaporeans have family or blood-ties with Malaysians especially the Malays. Not to mention a slight introduction of lethal biological weapon such as viruses could wreck havoc in Singapore judging by how densely populated and tiny they are. No amount of money or artillery can save you from that. Meanwhile Malaysia on the other hand has vast untapped land allowing more room for survival.
Wrong. Singapore can easily export viruses up north and wreck havoc in Malaysia. We die together. Ever heard of the poisonous shrimp theory?
Ok bro that is call warcrime...uncool
Nah not if its not proven
@@chiujiayi277 Use of Lethal bio chemical is also war crimes.
Watch out; the comment section below is full of expert military strategists, economical advisors, and political influencers.
Wkwkwk
Every building in Singapore has bomb shelter. Every single man in SG is/was a soldier. Singapore is hard to infiltrate because of the density of tall buildings. Imagine snipers everywhere.
You sure about that?
@@myazid3587 those are facts
Not every single man in Singapore was or is a soldier
dreaming.
@@1Quazeewtf do you mean, men are forced to join the army for 2 years once they turn 18. Even if you reject, you will be put into imprisonment
Attacking Singapore is giving America and Israel a reason to invade Malaysia . Wanna take the risk ?
British?
Attacking its own successful brother is like taking out your family sole bread winner.
Both may argue but they're both allies in war.
@@Raul_Menendez you're right, actually Malaysia and singapore have a defense agreement with The UK,New Zealand n Australia called The Five Power Defense Agreement where if any of these country got attacked they would backup each others
@@Naufal-zc9cd While ANZACS, Indonesia and Malaysia provide the heavy fighting.
Singapore will be the main HQ and house the important ranks and staffs.
Plus Singapore is one of the few nations to have the Iron Dome System.
No need america and Israel.. Malaysia also cannot win Singapore.. U know why?? Because Chinese and india behind will burning ..
Our respect to Malaysia and the Malaysian army from Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦🇲🇾
Thank you sir
In war, everyone is a loser. The citizens will ultimately suffer the most.
Except that Singapore's army is a deterrent force composed mainly of its reservist citizens. Singapore is so small they are not in it to fight or win wars. Their sole purpose is to tell you what you stand to lose if you ever invade them. Their citizens are basically given training to be ready to take arms and fight for their country if Malaysia ever invaded them, and they will go down dying along with millions of Malaysians. Win or lose, Singapore will not let its country be walked over. And that is the definition of a deterrence. If push comes to shove, why are you talking about citizens suffering?
@@teerificbitch What's your point
@@cliftonaurelius3060 That if your country was invaded, are you going to say 'in war everyone is a loser.... the citizens will ultimately suffer the most', insinuating as if the citizens of the invaded country have a choice to avoid a war?
@@teerificbitch By losers, I meant losing your life, family and friends. Not quite as an insult like calling someone a loser. Or does the word loser triggers you because you relate to it personally? Either way, I'm sorry for what had happened to you.
@@cliftonaurelius3060 Wow This Video Is a bad idea. haha Dude Trust Chill man.
if we see in the advance of military assets perspective Singapore win. economy Singapore win. number of soldier Malaysia win. food both almost similar I guess. conclusion just don't start any war just eat some rice and make friends. problems settle. Aku orang Kedah(I Kedah citizens). Kedah is one of the among 14 state in Malaysia
Don't mind me. Just here to read the comments left by all the keyboard generals.
Hahaha don't forget the nationalists from both sides.
Yes
The real war....... Is the comment section.
Yes PASKAL, this comment right here
Grandpa mahathir will defeat Singapore using long boring speeches
12 second ago holy moly
Wow, scary
slow clap.exe
Atleast no one calls him as Churchill tho
👍👍👍
So we all getting this recommended now?
Malaysia vs Singapore
Winner : USA, UK, Australia, Israel, New Zeland
Reward :Billion of billion gallon oil
China would be one to 'invest' in the aftermath too
lol billions of billions of gallon of oil
Man people aperently really dislike thought expirements. Like it's not even about If it is possible but literaly what the battle strategy would be If it happened.
I like this kind of video from Binkov.
However, his thought experiment (at least in this video) is only focused on three traditional domain (land, sea, air) and not include the other, equally important, two (space, cyber). Why he didn't include it, maybe he knows nothing about the opposing nations' capabilities of these other two domains. Maybe it would make the analysis more complex. Maybe he don't really know about these other domains and as such omitted it.
@@musab.k.9870 space isnt really a part of this. The entire world would body anybody who tried anything in space.
I lived in northern Singapore for a while and I enjoyed seeing the fighter jets fly by several times a day. Loud but amazing!
make sure to check those ears
Meanwhile the real life Singaporean and Malaysian just want to lepak corner and eat satay together. Sip kopi. All friends and family. Crazy outsiders with crazy ideas.
Come on la this one is simulation only why must bash on ang moh like that sia
I've learned something today, there are at least 3 switzerlands in the world (Izrael, Singapore, Switzerland itself)
+ Singapore attacking Malaysia makes sense because they could really use some "buffer zone" and have their military somewhere else than being scattered in the capital.
@@theghostkillz8921 singapore actually has a large number of Malaysian Singaporeans so theres no way they would attack Malaysia unless provoked
minecraftian 1045 u go back to Malaysia.
@@Tommashelbyeee u evil
At least 3 Switzerland tf do u mean
The comment section in this video belike
50% Proud countryman try to defend their nation
20% indonesia watching the war and they are the real winner
30% about food war between malaysia and sinagpore
Let's be honest. Us Singaporeans can't survive without imported food and water.
We're an island with no land resources.
SEA comment section in the nutshell (I assume)
Good food is a must in both SG and MAS.
I know you never model third party intervention, but this war would close the Strait of Malacca, which would be such a blow to the world economy that some kind of foreign intervention would be all but inevitable IMO.
Also, Brinkov forgot that the most eastern singaporean island is actually a huge-ass military base
Yes! The US Pacific Fleet gets involved and the Malaysian Army instantly surrenders, both US and SG Wins!
Type 218SG
China: *saw both sides are in worst state*
Also China: *It's free real estate*
SIngapore has conducted exercises where they convert regular streets into runways in emergencies by taking down all lamposts and setting up for short takeoff and landing
I see where you're referring at but lets not say as we love our nation..
@Sales Executive we wont require our army that much... Our tanks are all facing the north ready to fire... the rest we'll let our F15 Eagles lead the way but in a few years time new members --> the F35B will join our RSAF family..
Error at 14:50 the flag beside “Malaysian tank” is Singaporean
Possibly a defector
thank you, great elder Renault Ft
Why won't you do Japan, S. Korea, and Tawain vs China and N. Korea?
Agreed
Maybe cz u rnt there to say this on patreon ??
Indonesia: aww yeah, free real life action movie *Grab Indomie*
@GreenTeaKitKat Malaysia: No oil to fund the country? I open for Anchuluss
Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore are practically brothers.
It would take alot for these 3 to justify war with eachother. Hell, these 3 would most likely fight together if a major war broke out.
brunei is a joke
Brunei is a stanch Singapore ally, more than Malaysia in fact. And don't forget that nutcase Mahathir already made a claim on parts of Singapore already by declaring part of Tuas port Malaysian territory.
As an nsman who had been to Brunei during my JCC course, i can safely say Brunei's armed forces is no joke and can defend Brunei
Malaysians and Singaporeans in the comments: We are freaking family
A weird historian kermit: WAR
Ikr 😂
Yo wtf are you blaming him he’s just doing what he likes to do and imo you and everyone else are the real stupid ones for getting easily triggered on a video witch you aren’t even the target audience
Not only that it’s not like he’s provoking he doesn’t even go into how it could happen
(The politics)
Let's face it. Both sides have drawer plans in case it happens for whatever reason.
Impossible scenario because Singapore and Malaysia are like brother
singapore to malaysia and indonesia is like israel to palestine and egypt.
small country made up of minorities surrounded by much bigger countries but backed up by the biggest countries in the world.
Israel (EU and US) / Singapore (US, EU, India and China).
*_Singapore and malaysia just declare war on each other_*
Me who just wake up from 12 hours sleep: wait wtf is happening?!?!
14:51 you put Singapore's flag instead of Malaysia's flag.