Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Nehemia Gordon - 2 - What is a Karaite Jew?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 май 2016
- Root Source interviews Israeli Jew Nehemia Gordon. In part 2 we learn about the differentiates Karaite Jews from Orthodox Jews, as well as what brings them together. Also covered are Karaite communities in Israel, and what Nehemia admires the most about those Jews with whom he disagrees.
![Chuckyy - Devil Hours [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f3wZGj0VnZU/mqdefault.jpg)
It's time for Karaite Judaism to spread all over the world, to make Karaism available to Jews everywhere and to seek out converts. Also to make Karaite Torah commentaries available.
I agree with Karaite Jews, and I'm not even a Jew -- yet.
I agree with Nehemia Gordon. It's Fascinating to hear someone speak in the same way I beleive and feel. I'm going to subscribed
if you have the same belief please contact me on facebook eliad jojo thank you
I agree also
Good conversation
Karaite Judaism is a way of life not an ethnicity.....exactly it’s about living by the Hebrew Bible as it is written...which is totally different from other forms of Judaism..Amen
Yup! Although, I believe in Yeshua, I absolutely, no doubt, be a Karaite otherwise.
@Tahnn Ju
Besides the fact nobody can live *exactly* according to the Torah and Prophets as written owing to certain objective limitations and circumstances, no matter how well intentioned they might be, Qaraite Judaism is a bit more off the mark in this sense than it could be. The main example for this is that Qaraism considers regular, twice-daily prayer on par of a commandment. But there is no unassailable *logical* inference that can be made from anywhere within the Jewish Bible that can warrant this interpretation.
I think another example is that Qaraite Judaism accepted the entire Miqra, even though the Ester Scroll ends by making Purim a mandatory observance, thereby adding to the Torah's commandments.
Can you response how the tanakh is the word of God? because that is how orthodox use to disgraced karaites and justify oral Torah as divine.
@Adam Kramer Funny! 🤣 Don't forget, Kararites are usually RH negative...
@Adam Kramer Or course. According to the internet, I'm either a Nephellim or a reptilian 👽 alien because of my blood type!
Talmud is not the law given to Moses by G’d. Adding and subtracting is prohibited by YHVH but the sages without a temple have too much free time to make their own laws and worse go against the Torah and against G’d’s commandment not to add or subtract. So much free time that they will write volumes of books reasoning why they add and subtract. When you read for example why they follow the mother lineage and not paternal as in the Torah they will write so much nonsense kindergarten like level of biblical knowledge that you clearly see the blinds are leading the blinds.
Can you response how the tanakh is the word of God? because that is how orthodox use to disgraced karaites and justify oral Torah as divine.
Have you heard of the Jew that was shipwrecked on a desert island? When his rescuers finally found him, they found three synagogues. One lone Jew and three synagogues! They asked him how this was possible.
“Simple,” he said. “This is my synagogue. That one over there is the synagogue I can’t afford to join. And that third one? That third one is the synagogue I wouldn’t be caught dead in!”
Wish they will grow to a million..
I think I am a Karaite Jew even though I don't know what I am... All I ever wanted was the absolute truth. To learn it and do it, do what Yehova want me to do, nothing else. Got a long way to go though, since I am not that learned in the Torah as most Torah-followers.
John Kenneth Stava absolute truth means filtering through a lot of lies. Satan counterfeits or twists everything of God. The satanists and christians would agree on one thing... there ultimately are two paths.
The luciferian new age gnosticism.. which comes under numerous names with subtle differences. For example the law of attraction means that a power is inherent in everyone. We are like gods.
Or
The need for a savior after falling from God.
The media is pushing their agenda all over.ie. the prince of the air or the god of this world has his control.
I highly recommend looking into the teachings of Jesus.
@wesfax1
Since you believe that all your sins have been "forgiven" because you believe J. Christ "the savior" died for and instead of you, you are in real trouble! Not only are you still sin-laden, you have added a new, terrible sin to the old batch! You are guilty of idolatry for worshiping a false "savior", god and messiah. YHWH's word plainly states that He (YHWH) alone is Savior; (Isaiah 43:11). He alone can forgive sin (Isaiah 43:25). He alone is the True Deity (Isaiah 43:10)!!
Moreover, you cannot "believe away" sin! Magic plays absolutely no role in the system of sin and atonement established by YHWH, the sole Creator of this universe. Atonement by "faith" is not part of YHWH's setup. The only way a sinner can get his sins forgiven is by repenting and by doing and fulfilling what YHWH wants him to do!! YHWH says: "Again, when I say to the wicked, you shall surely die; if he turn from his sin (repents) and do that which lawful and right ("good works")...he shall surely live, he shall NOT die!! NONE of his sins which he had committed shall be remembered against him! He has done that which is lawful and right! He shall surely LIVE!" (Ezekiel 33:14-16). Ezekiel was a prophet of YHWH. He wasn't a Christian preacher!
In Moses' day, the repentant sinner usually (NOT ALWAYS) offered an animal sacrifice to symbolize his "giving" and YHWH's "accepting".
Later prophets elaborated on how sacrifices are worthless without obedience:
"Behold, to OBEY is BETTER than sacrifice!" (1 Samuel 15:22). "Do I eat the flesh of bulls, or drink the blood of goats?" (Psalms 50:13)."By practicing mercy and truth is sin atoned for!" (Proverbs 16:6).
HOW can you come to YHWH? YHWH provides the answer: "Return, O Israel, to YHWH your almighty, for you have stumbled in your iniquity! Take with you WORDS and return to YHWH! (WHAT words?) Say to Him: forgive all iniquity and accept GOODNESS (good works). Thus, will we offer, INSTEAD of bullocks (blood) the offerings of our LIPS!" (Hosea 14:2-3).
According to YHWH's word, NO ONE can die for you! If you don't believe me, read Exodus 33:31-33; Deut. 24:16; Ezekiel 18:3-4. But YHWH's demands can be met by you, if only you will know the truth. You can come to YHWH on your own! Read YHWH's word! "With what offering can I come before YHWH, and bow myself before the Mighty One on high? Should I come to him with burnt offerings, with year-old calves? Will YHWH be pleased by thousands of rams, with ten thousand rivers of oil? Should I give my first-born for my transgression (human sacrifice, like the crucifixion!), the fruit of my body for the sin of my soul? It has been told you, O man, what is good, and what YHWH (not religious doctrine but YHWH!) requires of you: ONLY to DO what is just (YHWH's COMMANDMENTS) and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your Almighty!" (Micah 6:6-8).
Hallelu-Yahh, praise YHWH! His Salvation is open to all! No believing in fairy-stories, no bloody crucifixions! No "divine suicide" on a Roman Cross! Plain and simple is the Way of YHWH! Will you take Him at His Word today?
Remove the Jesucks scales from your eyes, loosen your neck and circumcise your heart to accept the Truth.
@@ZviJ1 AMEN
at minute 1:30 you are correct if the Torah is different from the oral Tora then throw away the oral Torah (Devarim 32:46-47)
We have the same problem in Islam. Sunnis and Shiites say that there is a second revelation, which is an oral revelation in addition to the Holy Qur’an, which led to many contradictions. In the recent period, a corrective movement has emerged called the Quranists, which adhere to nothing but the Book of God.
A Jew that says Moshe did not exist is not a Jew anymore according to the Torah. Unfortunately the concept of a "jewish soul" has entered so deep in the Jewish psyche that whether you are a moral etical person is less important than your "jewish" blood.
Sorry but you are not correct as being a Jew is not simply being a part of a religion but it is so much more. Judaism is a family which is comprised of a myriad of races, ethnicity and cultures. The family is full of dissenting opinions and people you may not like very much but we all share a common affinity and that is Judaism itself. It's not how we view Torah for we existed in some form before Torah and for thousands of years we have debated not only the interpretation of Torah but also its authorship. Its a Jewish text but its also a book about Moses more than it is a first hand account written by him. Its also a text written in the context of broader Mesopotamian society, borrowing most of its narrative from other cultural sources. So today many Jews see the Torah in the same light as Joseph Campbell who asserted that mythology represents a collective human experience written down as a particular cultural wisdom which is relevant for all generation in seeking answers to life's meaning.
yochanan agreed!
If the Oral Torah was so Oral, why has it been written down ??
Great question. The answer can be found in part V of the article about the man who made that decision: Yehuda HaNasi. www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/112279/jewish/Rabbi-Judah-the-Prince.htm
Hah! You got them! Great job
Thank you for that.
Are there places in America to meet with Karaites?
The short answer is the internet. Karaites are essentially Reform Jews from a time in history when atheism was non-existant. If they didn't hang on to the Tanach they would have been immediately killed by both Christian and Muslim powers. That is the only thing they had in common with their governmental rulers. If atheism was an option they would have ran to it. You can't look around you and say, "hey, there's a Karaite Jew." They are too secularized to be recognizable. There was only I believe two true Karaite synagogues in America, one on each end of the US. There are more ex-Christians who converted to Karaism in the US than there are true Karaites by birth. Even Nehemia here is not a true Karaite, nor the leader of the World Karaite Movement, they both left Orthodox Judaism. That's what Karaism is, its a rejection of Rabbinic Judaism by a later generation. The first true Karaite was a prominent rabbi who thought he should have inherited a position of basically the absolute leader of Judaism at the time. His brother was chosen by their peers instead. He refused to submit to his brother's new religious position. The muslim ruler at the time seen that as treason against his power since he only acknowledged one leader to represent the Jews. This rabbi sat in prison awaiting to be executed but just so happened to share the prison block with an intellectual muslim who knew enough about Islam and religious "rebellion" to teach him how to answer in court. He was referred to accept a position of the Sadduccees and claim he was the leader of this anti-rabbinic sect that had previously died out. He took his advice and claimed to be a scripturalist (aka Karaite), to the muslims, this is still "people of the book" a protected category in Islam. This saved his life. As a former prominent rabbinic leader, he now used his influence to drive people away from Orthodox Judaism and gain a following to legitimize his claim in court. Here it is today still the go-to-religion for people who leave the traditions of their people (a violation of the fifth commandment, among others). All I have to say is take a look at the Rechabites in Jeremiah. Their is no prohibition in the Bible for drinking wine, but their father commanded the generations, do not drink wine. Nehemiah's forefathers told him to live a certain way, a deviation from that way (halacha in Hebrew), is a sin because it is not only a deviation from the forefathers but a distancing from the Jewish society as a whole that provides a separation which is a sanctity that God called him to be born into, the Holy Nation of Israel.
The 5th direction is below the first direction. To honor is less than to obey righteousness. So to follow mans spoken or written rules is the sin. To honor those who are the reason for your existence is not to follow their life style when it is written to follow YHWH. So I agree with you ?
AimedResearch This seems more like the days of Judges to me. Synagogues were made in Babylon after 605 B.C.E. So mono e mono ? So maybe 800 years of this type of life? The promised land was entered 600 years after Abram was born?
Dalton Pyron Yes in daly city. Bay area
+Arieh ben avraham For starters, "AimedResearch10" regurgitated a debunked Rabbinic canard about `Anan ben Dawid, whom scholarship has found to NOT have conceived Qaraite Judaism, notably since his exegetical methods resembled the Rabbinic ones very much, rather than putting a premium on the Text's plain (but not necessarily literal) meaning.
There is no Abbasid record of `Anan ben Dawid having been imprisoned, even though the Abbasids were meticulous in recording all matters brought before the Calif and who was imprisoned. The myth not only does not show up until the 10th (possibly the 12th according to Nemoy) century, it also has two different versions: one which said that ‘Anan had a brother name Ḥananyah who succeeded the Exilarch Shelomo ben-Ḥisdai, while in the other it says the brother’s name was Yoshiyah. However, both are fiction and bear no relationship with historical fact, since Shelomo ben-Ḥisdai was succeeded by Yiṣḥaq Iskawi I, who was succeeded by Yehudah Zakkai. There never was an Exilarch named Ḥananyah or Yoshiyah.
The myth also claims that ‘Anan’s father was Shafaṭ and that he was only called ben-Dawid as a allusion to his Davidic descent. However, ‘Anan’s father was Dawid ben-Yehudah ben-Ḥisdai ben-Bustenai.
‘Anan ben-Shafaṭ disputed with the Exilarch Rav Huna II in the third century (Rav Huna II was Exilarch from 240 to 260), while the alleged imprisonment was supposed to have occurred in 769.
The 10th/12th century myth records what it claims was a secret conversation between ‘Anan and the Muslim scholar Abu Ḥanifa an-Nu‘man ibn Tabit (ignoring the fact that Abu Ḥanifa died in AD 767, two years before ‘Anan’s alleged imprisonment) in which the Muslim convinces ‘Anan to say that he was not the head of the Jews but of a different religion. If there was such a secret conversation, how could the author of the myth be privy to what was said?
None of the Rabbanite opponents of ‘Anan during his lifetime or that of his son or his grandson or great-grandson mention a dispute of the Exilarchate with a brother or him being imprisoned. If the things in the 10th/12th century myth were true, why is it that none of the opponents of ‘Anan or the Karaites mention it until the 10th/12th century?
The Rabbanite Ga’on Naṭronai lived less than 90 years after ‘Anan, yet makes no mention of the alleged dispute over the office or imprisonment.
Leon Nemoy in his “Karaite Anthology”, p. 6-7 says that Naṭronai tells us nothing “about the contest for the office of the exilarch which allegedly served as the immediate cause of his apostasy. It seems reasonable to assume that Naṭronai’s silence signifies that he knew nothing about it, for it would have been to his advantage, had he knowledge of `Anan’s disqualification for the high office, to set it forth in detail in order to demonstrate the more convincingly, from his own point of view, `Anan’s unworthy and ungodly motives. Moreover, Naṭronai lived in the very center of the scene of `Anan’s activity and belonged to the higher strata of Rabbanite society, where the alleged particulars of `Anan’s secession should have been known best, had they been true.”
Someone who lived less than 90 years after ‘Anan would also know that the Exilarch Shelomo ben-Ḥisadai was succeeded by Yiṣḥaq Iskawi and he by Yehudah ben-Zakkai and that there was no Exilarch named Ḥananyah or Yoshiyah. Only someone from a much later time period could confuse the 3rd century ‘Anan ben-Shafaṭ and Rava Huna I with the 8th century ‘Anan ben-Dawid and a fictitious brother named Ḥananyah.
I made the mistake of assuming that you were Messianic, too. I have a much more open mind, now.
Non-Jewish people are not commanded to convert to Karaite Judaism - or Torah of Israel - faith in the Tanakh as far as I can tell. Does Karaite Judaism agree with that? If they do agree with that statement, do they think non-Jewish people should feel obligated to follow the actual universal covenant of Genesis 9, the sign being the rainbow. This appears to still be valid and in force for mankind. Are members of the rest of mankind beyond the covenanted land of Abraham obligated to follow Genesis 1:1 - 11:9, the religion of Noah, Shem, Ham and Japheth and their immediate successors?
Noahide Videos Shalom ! Karaite Jews do not believe in the existence of the Noahide Laws. We believe, that the whole Torah is for the whole humanity - no matter which nation or origin. It is quite easy to become a Karaite : Start obeying the laws of Torah - that's it. There is no long procedure of converting like Pharisees are accustomed to. So, it is all easy. Be blessed and Shabbat Shalom 😄
+Ale Goe What you presumably saw written in the KK website that is in line with your claim that one needs only to obey the Torah to become a Qaraite is not quite true. If you are non-Jewish, it would render you a Qaraite aspirant, or an Accompaniar to the people of Israel -- if you wish to join the Jewish people. Being a full-fledged Qaraite means being a Torah observant *Jew*. Those who wish to join the Jewish people as Qaraites need to "convert" through a bona fide Jewish movement, namely to be naturalized and adopted as a new citizen or member of the Jewish people. And thankfully, there is a route for those who wish to join this people through the Qaraite movement; I know of a few Qaraites who have joined the Jewish people by undergoing conversion through Reform rabbis who were informed in advance of their intention to practice Judaism as Qaraites.
@@fox9935Yes, I read that. Ruth did not have an Orthodox conversion.
Karaites are Kipchak Turkic Group, They are originally connected Khazarian empire. Khazarian empire was one of the most open society in terms of religious tolerance. Hence it has been influenced by Tengrism and Nestorian Christianity.
Karaite Judaism is a way of life...not an ethnicity
Thanks for sharing.
You bet
I heard Karaites still follow the lunar Sabbath is that true?
Not necessarily. What is lunar Sabbath, though? As far as I know, Sabbots are Friday eve to Satirday eve observance.
Alice, whoever spread such a ridiculous false rumor ought to be ashamed of themselves. That is a Christinsane invention that has nothing to do with the religion of Israel.
They do have a different calendar 🗓️ from Rabbinical.
Great video! I’m new to Torah. I heard you mention something about Austin. I’m in Conroe. Are there any Karaites in the Conroe area?
We don't know, but there might be a US-based organization that could answer that for you.
@@RootSource thank you! Do you know how I could find that out?
@@AbrahamsBridges There's an organization called Karaite Jews of America. They have a website you could look up.
I've read that Karaites say that the rabbis were never supposed to have power in the Sanhedrin but Devarim 17:8 says the You shall go to the priest and to the judge implying that they you don't need to be a priest to be a judge.
Amen! No men made authority!
But the Supreme Court at the Place YHWH Chooses is supposed to be priestly through majority. The Pharisees toppled this status quo and altered it, which invalidated the court's authority. When it ceased existing on the Temple Mt. altogether, it became even more worthless.
Kararites do not follow Jesus or New Testament.....none!
Many Jews of all creeds respect Yeshua as a great and radical rabbi of his time, the difference is that they do not consider him the messiah and definitely not a god, a son of a virgin, or beleive that he was Resurrected. Jews For Judaism (Michael Skobak) and Karaite Judaism USA (Filipe) RUclips channel presenters are good examples of Orthodox and Karaite Jews that do, I also have immense respect for Yeshua and wish Jews would "reclaim" him rather than live in ignorance of him as a reaction to Christianity and the movements to convert Jews. He is an important part of Jewish history and didn't seek a huge following, and the false religion wasn't created by him, it came later.
@@d0dg3st4r Sadly!
@Danny D
Please don't cite Felipe Gutierrez any more. He is a gentile impostor & fraudster, an arch-liar at that. He's neither a Jew nor a Qaraite and least of all a Qaraite teacher. He knows nothing about the Qaraite literature and almost no Hebrew, even though a QAraite teacher must be a master of Hebrew, according to the Qaraite principles of faith. Many of his claims are made up as he goes along and his "teachings" are out of step with every extant form of Judaism. The KJA (the main Qaraite organizsation in N. America) denies any affiliation with him and despite Felipe's lies, he has never stepped foot in their synagogue. In 3 of his video clips he recommended purchasing Rabbinic Tekhelet for Tzitzit and making Rabbinic Tzitzit, which is unacceptable by Qaraite standards.
To my own understanding so it's open to discussion. The pictograph Hebrew was a concrete language. Now meaning this current time period. The square script is like Greek or English being a abstract language is this true? My reasoning for this is the added letters
and changes in sound rather than meaning of a concrete language.
Pictographic/Paleohebrew was the common script of the Israelites due to Egyptian influence. The Ashuri or what I assume you mean as square script was the script/writing that God taught Moses at Sinai and the actual script at least the first set of tablets were written in. Even though the oldest extant Hebrew script is the paleohebrew, it is a little known point that the oldest extant record of the Bible such as the Greek "Septuagint" has textual errors that are easily explainable as translation errors of mistaken Hebrew Ashuri (block) text. That is, the document that the "Septuagint" was translated from was written in Ashuri Hebrew Script. If you don't believe me consider this. The book of Daniel records the Writing on the Wall. If it was paleohebrew the Babylonian wise men would have been familiar with the letters and could have easily figured out the meaning (they had men who knew all known languages in the Babylonian court). The only way that the Babylonians could not have been able to read the writing on the wall would be if it was written in an Alphabet they have never seen before. Daniel could read it because it was the script that the Torah scrolls were written in. And Ashuri means "lofty" or of a lofty status similar to the root of the name Asher. It has nothing to do with Assyria as secular scholars claim.
And I'd like to add as a concrete proof of my statement above is that Orthodox Judaism (Talmud) claims God gave two instructions in a single utterance concerning the Commandment of Shabbat. In Exodus 20 it says "Zachor - Remember" the Sabbath and in Deut. 5 it claims God said "Shamor - Keep" the Sabbath. This is only possible if you look at the Ashuri (block) Hebrew and analyze the scribal strokes that make up the word "Shamor". The last letters of both words are the same but you will notice that the Shin has an ending stroke that is essentially a Zayin and the Mem has a curved stroke that is essentially a Kaph. That means the word Zachor is contained in the word Shamor and only in the Script that God gave to Moses - Ashuri.
Nobody but Orthodox Jews and their gullible yeah-sayers among Jews and gentiles alike takes this unfounded Rabbinic tripe seriously. And at the moment I do not have the patience and time to present a detailed refutation or rebuttal.
Please turn on closed captioning.
For some reason they are not available for this RUclips video :-( ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@RootSource You clicked the approval box for subtitles, as a creator? Can you redo? 🤔
@@clarekuehn4372 I tried, honest!:-) Most of our videos have a CC option
The Talmud has become an idol.
Shalom! Would you please direct me to via links free e-books about Karaite Jews? Todah raba!
What are similarties between karaites jews and kirat of nepal
Nehemia told us he is not familiar with them. Is it a coincidence? If you research it let us know what you find out.
None
And might I add that even the Karaites stray. As a Jew read what Deuteronomy says only as the law. Add or subtract strictly nothing. That is the law. Moses repeats many times do only what he says in Deuteronomy and nothing more or less. How can anyone believe to be a Karaite miss this point? There is only one law and it is Deuteronomy.
In total, Gordon is outside of Israel more than he resides in it in a given year. So I do not see how he is Israeli.
That is like saying you can only be a catholic if you live in rome
This fundamentalist jew has been targeting the Bnei Miqra from a long time...he doesn’t believe in the Torah and only in a Talmud, which is supposedly a ‘simplification of the Torah’ but is actually a misguiding and made up document which actually has diluted the word YHWH
@Tracey Sojourner
What you did was like comparing meat to oranges. This is how truly ridiculous your reasoning is. "Israeli" is not a religion in case you had not noticed......
Gordon was an American Jew, moved to Israel, became an Israeli, but subsequently moved back to the US and virtually ceased even visiting Israel. He's not someone who spent his first years of life in Israel, spoke Hebrew from a tender age with an Israeli accent, and ultimately moved permanently to the US. While the latter can be considered somehow an Israeli, someone like Gordon cannot.
Because he is a citizen of Israel, no matter where he goes, he’s Israeli.
@@mirib5007 So...... the Israeli Jews who obtain Portuguese citizenship by dint of their distant Sephardic roots in Portugal, but do not move to Portugal or acquire characteristics of Portuguese civilians or citizens, are supposed to be considered Portuguese for it?? Nope, doesn't really compute. Gordon's case with Israeli citizenship and theirs with Portuguese is analogous.
I wouldn't call it the perfect word of God. Just a bit basic that thinking. It's a true enough book of history between God and Man, but it's not God dictated stuff. God gives guidance and words through the Tanakh, but it's not perfect. There are mistakes in chronicling history. There are issues. It's a book of it's era - a history book of its time. It's true - but it's not completely infallible.
Show me one mistake in the Torah. I am extremely interested
Please, do provide alleged errors Torah or Tanakh have. Waiting in anticipation.
@@aussiegardener1773 It has been a year and I see you are still awaiting your answer. There isn't one. Psalm 19v7 says "The Torah of YHWH is perfect..."
Where is your temple to sacrifice animals? How can you follow the Old Testament without a temple?
Don’t you follow the Tanakh or just the new testaments? If you don’t follow Tanakh where are your laws and commandments ? If Jesus was on this earth there was no New testament in existence....
Many thanks for this video, it’s very helpful. I have two questions: 1) what’s the difference between you and other Jewish communities such as Samaritans, who also believe only in the written words of god. 2) are you recognized as Jews before the Rabbinic authorities? how did Karaites accès the Israeli citizenship under the rubric of the Law of Retun?
@mike maid
Obviously your command of the Jewish Bible leaves much to be desired, or you would be aware that it provides a way for us to receive expiation and atonement in the absence of the great altar and Holy Temple, without any sacrificial offerings (animal and others) through repentance and prayer.
Why doesn't he or Karaite Jews recognize the NT?
Does he believe Yeshua of the NT to be the Savoir aka HaMashiach?
Because this Jesus failed the prophecy he didn't bring back the lost tribes back to Israel not only that the prophets nor God never said that someone will come to die for our sins. You will not find this anywhere in the old testament. No one can die for your sins as it says in Ezekiel 18:20, Psalm 49:7. Human sacrifice is an abomination to God Deuteronomy 12:31; 18:10. Sin animal sacrifice was when someone committed a sin by accident Leviticus 4:2, 13, 22-23, 27-28 etc Not intentionally or planed. Also the altar was used for offerings not just for animal sacrifice, Leviticus 2:1. How God forgives sin is by turning away from your sins Ezekiel 18:21-22. God even forgave King David without sacrifice in 2 Samuel 12:13. In the book of Jonah everyone in Nineveh Repented and God didn't destroy the city, they all turned away from their sins and didn't do any sacrifice they where not even Israelite's to being with. God is the only one who forgives and God is our savior Isaiah 43:11 "I, even I, am the LORD; and beside me there is no savior." Not this Jesus that's blasphemy. If Jesus was truly sinless(righteous) he could only save himself and no one else Ezekiel 14:14 "even if these three men--Noah, Daniel and Job--were in it, they could save only themselves by their righteousness, declares the Sovereign LORD." If you understand the old testament as it is you will see why the Jews don't believe in the new testament.. so many contradictions. So many things in the new testament which misquote the old testament example "Again the anger of the Lord was aroused against Israel, and He moved David against them to say, “Go, number Israel and Judah.” (2 Samuel 24:1) vs "Now Satan stood up against Israel, and moved David to number Israel." (1 Chronicles 21:1) So who was it God or this Satan? This is one of many.. misquotes. The new testament was written in Greek whoever wrote the new testament clearly had no understanding in the old testament it also has a lot of pagan ideologies in it which is no surprise since a Greek wrote it. But lets say all that the new testament is true why would God reviled something in Greek instead of Hebrew? That just makes no sense. It's just not of God. Shalom
Isaiah 43 v 11 that is why
@@blueknew yet, Moses bagged God to take His life for thousands of others.
@@blueknew He was not a human sacrifice. He clearly stated that he died vulentariely for his friends. John 15:13. It was not a forceful sacrificial death. Please reconsider your views.
Get all the answers why they don't accept the Non Testament through faithstrengthened.karaitejudaism.org/FS_TOC.html . Read and weep :)
The avalanche of denominations in christianity begun only after 1517...
Is that the year of the big split?
@@christopherbayne9061 it is the Luther's year... beginning of the reformation... western split.
@@petersonnenberg9526 Cool.
Payot is d'oraisa: Leviticus 19:27
You shall not round off the hair on your temples or mar the edges of your beard.
As in this case, "D'Oraita" is usually a Rabbinical contortion of some Torah commandment. Worse, you're mistranslating the verse.
What it actually states is, "You are not to round off the edge-growth of your head, you are not to diminish the edgegrowth of your beard."
This commands to refrain from cutting one's hair in a rounded manner as was done by idol worshipers and not to disfigure one's beard's corner. *None of this means one must grow "Pious" (sidelocks).*
How and why in the world is Nehemia Gordon NOT a Christian!?!?
He does not consider Jesus divine, a savior or the Messiah. He respects Jesus as a historical figure and discusses him.
@@RootSource Again, how can a person be so educated in The Scriptures and still not be able to see that Yeshua was and is the prophesied Messiah?
@@casesusa See at faithstrengthened.karaitejudaism.org/FS_TOC.html
I realize you'll never understand, owing to cognitive disonance. But your false messiah did not fulfill even one of the Messiahship criteria laid out in the Miqra (Jewish Bible).
There are NUMEROUS things talked about in Tanak that has the commandment "YOu shall do this" yet there is NO EXPLAINATION OF HOW TO DO IT IN TANAK!
What is a Sukkah? How do you know what a Sukkah is? What is Tefflin? How do you put on Tefflin? Tanak says to inscribe Torah around your neck, why aren't you following Scripture and putting something around your neck?
There are literally a list of over 100 things mentioned in Torah that Israel is to DO but has ZERO explanation in Torah/Tanak but are fully explained in Oral Torah.
Your entire video recks of Christianity.
What is a cow? How do you know what a cow is??? Because we do... We didn't need to wait for the pharisees to invent the oral traditions in 150bce in order to know what a cow was nor how to observe the Torah! Give ONE mention of an oral torah in the entire tanakh... Go on.
Danny D it’s so refreshing to see that in the midst of this madness created by talmudists you still have common sense out there. שקום
And what these Talmudists don't get is that they will never manage to completely obliterate it from the Jewish people.
Reference 1 just 1 thing in the Oral torah that you say disagrees with Torah and Law? Just 1 lol. I'll wait.
@@d0dg3st4r Correct, Hanukkah nor Purim were Holy Days mandated by Yah.
I thought it said KARATE Jew.
Judaism (Leviticus 11; Genesis 28:22) is NOT Christianity (Mark 7:14-19; Luke 11:41).
at minute 11:11 I am in the same way with you I don't follow the rabbi I don't follow the Karaite tradition I only follow the Torah and why is so? because the Karaite don't follow the correct calendar, not the correct Shavuot, not the correct unleavened bread for 7 days, (must be made only from barley ) not the correct Shavuot because to count for Shavuot if you read Leviticus 23:15 you should count after the day the priest wave of the barley and it says that is not permitted to eat the barley grains until is waved by the priest (Leviticus 23:14 ) which in my opinion this wave of barley is made on the first sabbath of the Abib month,... and on the Pesah the day before the second sabbath of the month of Abib, we got permitted to eat lamb /goat in the 14th Abib because the barley was waved and the next day for 7 days we must to eat the sadness bread which doesn't have wheat, this barley bread is a special bread because it did not ferment after 18 minutes as usually the bread ferment. if read Exodus 12: 34 ) as the Israelites exited the Egyptian community after some hour they rested that was the first sabbath for the jews on the 15th of Abib. and they eat the unfermented bread ..however, to count to Shavuot (Leviticus 23:15-16 Devarim 16:9 ) we must start the count on the 9th of Abib because on the 8th of Abib was the first sabbath of the Abib month, we got commanded by our Elohim to come 3 times a year on Pesah Shavuot and Sukkot but never commanded us to come to commemorate the day we got the 10 commandments which mean on Shavuot we must come for the priest to wave two loaves of bread made from the new wheat which was seeded on the spring and collected after 100 days (Leviticus 23:15-16 or Devarim 16:9.
Can you response how the tanakh is the word of God? because that is how orthodox use to disgraced karaites and justify oral Torah as divine.
I am not clear what your question is, please try to rephrase it.
with out the oral torah the Torah would be just another religious book, so much in Torah are not explained, it is split in neg and pos, mitvahs, or Laws, thou shalt slaughter a goat as i ahve told you, funny, never told us in Torah, was it told to moses to have thing to teach each generation about, was it a law before time of Moses like a noah law which was seven. Though shalt not seethe a calf in its mothers milk, their is no one answer, we have commentaries and all are good, some rabbi's belive more of one than another, but all have truth, so we are carefull to get every possible meaning if not of oral commentary and i do not mean interpretations, so we know do not cook a lamb or goat in milk, but it goes on, we dod not drink milk with meat, it is not good for u anyway and to me sounds didgusting, we do not kill a calf in front of the mother, so one little thing can have mant meanings not given in torah, The new testament is basically all pos commands , do , this, that shalt t do tis and that, no room for discussion, so i dissagree with not having books that are a treasure trove of over 2000 years of study to be considered worthless, Gentiles who felt like you rapped rebs in talmud scrolls and burned them alive, book burning
Our channel and our website root-source.com has hundreds of videos that show the value and beauty of the oral law. The Jewish teachers on our site are all Orthodox Jews, but we try to be friendly towards everyone, including Nehemia Gordon, even though his beliefs are not the same. Neither do we try to influence Christians to keep the Torah, even though many do so in a manner and style that is quite similar to Nehemia. Our site is about respectful understanding and learning.