Golan Broshi - What is a Jew?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- We invite you to join us for Conversations with Jewish Believers in Jesus, hosted by Jeff Morgan. In this episode, Dr. Golan Broshi answers the simple but important question, “What makes someone a Jew?” Is it heritage, birthplace, bloodline, or religion? Dr. Broshi addresses all of this and more in this foundational conversation.
Golan Broshi was born and raised in Kibbutz Malkia in Israel. He has a bachelor's degree in Education, Sociology and Anthropology from the University of Haifa and a master's degree in Jewish Education at the University of Jerusalem. He completed his doctoral degree in Biblical Studies and Theology at Dallas Theological Seminary and is currently a professor at Israel College of the Bible - One for Israel: www.oneforisra...
Also be sure to follow Jews for Jesus online as well!
jewsforjesus.org
/ jewsforjesus
/ jewsforjesus
/ jewsforjesus
/ jewsforjesus
Brother Golan radiates Christ, he loves the Lord you can see it, you can feel it
Baruch HaShem 🙏🏽
Yes he does. ❤️
Amen!
Yes, he absolutely does.
I so absolutely love brother Golan, all thanks and praise to Adon Yeshua for him!
I believe he must be very very closely similar to brother Paul the apostle, in his zeal, passion and fire for the Lord! And also in his meekness, simplicity and childlike joy and innocence!!!
I hope one day soon the Lord will give me a husband like both of these amazing brothers, Golan and Paul (Shaul)!!!
God bless!
Shalom ❤
The most Jewish thing to do for a Jew is to accept Yeshua Hamachiach his own messiah. Great is The G-d of Israel
Incorrect!! True Jews wouldn’t believe in the NT. Tanakh doesn’t match the OT. Isaiah 9:6 is completely different!
You may be a Jew, not believe in Judaism. They worship the true God.
@@theartzscientist8012 it's always be him, always prophet isaiah 53 Michael 5:2 proverbs 30:4 isaiah 42 1_4 psalms 2 psalms 22 Daniel 9 11 12
Go to listen one for Israel, messianic rabbi zev porat, listen debats betwen messianic rabbi and rabbi Who don't believe listen the arguments. This is the end of everything. Yeshua The messiah is working to rebuild the kingdom of Israel. You are to far Come with your Jewish brothers and sisters Who accept the messiah, oui messiah.
May Hachem bless You and keep you
@@Nicolai.c so, God was born on Dec. 25th? Lol Isaiah never spoke of Jesus. Stop adding.
@@theartzscientist8012 He wasn't adding anything. He's speaking Truth. And no. Messiah wasn't born on Dec 25th.
1:41 🇧🇷 I'm not Jewish but I love the respect you have about God. I'm study the Bible and for me is important to understand the culture and history. I'm christian from 🇧🇷 I loved the channel because have many beautiful experience with Jesus and understand the culture too 🥰👏🌟💪🙏
I LOVE Golan Broshi - the Holy Spirit of Yeshua flows out of his wisdom, purity, and smile. I'm looking forward to ALL of Israel to be FILLED with God's Spirit like Brother Broshi. To God be the glory!!!
Shalom Jews for Jesus and thanks for sharing this great video! We are Chosen People Ministries Taiwan, and want to kindly ask your permission to translate it into Mandarin for Taiwanese believers. Is it ok?😃🙏
Yes! We’d be honored for you to do that!
This interview is strategic. Important. Ethnicity never changes. I've said for years, "You can change your Levis, but you cannot change your genes!!" Thank you, Jeff Morgan, and you, Dr. Broshi, for pressing the reality that ethnicity never changes, but Y'shua CAN change each of us!! GREAT word for us.
Haha love the Levi genes analogy ❤️
😂
But why does Christianity only believe in Jesus eventually, not God’s law, such as Peter eventually don’t follow kosher?
Very lovely. Thank you for the video and the message.
I have been gleaning from your inspired teaching all day, for hours. I am so glad I found you, or you found me. Super excited about the revelation of God's word. Thank you sir, will continue to glean, take notes. I'm from Crestview, Florida U.S.A. Love you, will pray for you, your ministry, expecting IJN, In Jesus Name that your American following will increase "BIG TIME," Amen, amen, amen. I pray for you, all you have and hope to be. IJN Brother, Scott Wilson
I so absolutely love brother Golan, thank Adon Yeshua for him!
I believe he must be very very closely similar to brother Paul the apostle, in his zeal, passion and fire for the Lord! And also in his meekness, simplicity and childlike joy and innocence!!!
I hope one day soon the Lord will give me a husband like both of these amazing brothers, Golan and Paul (Shaul)!!!
God bless you both, brethren in Christ!
Thank you for this interview.
Baruch Atah Adonai Eloheinu Melech HaOlam
Amen!
I have discovered this discrimination as one with Jewish ethnicity in my father's and mother's family bloodline...ADONAI said to me Jewishness is not a matter of percentages (DNA), and numbers, nor of man-made rules, it is a matter of faith as Avraham demonstrated.....walking by faith, not by sight. I follow Yeshua Hamashiach the Jewish Messiah.
Todah Rabah for this clear explanation of Rabbinical Judaism that refutes the Hebrew Scriptures.
Shalom
Amazing Interview!!
The true Cristian gentiles, love Jews, and hope for them to come to Jesus! God Bless you!
Perfect 💗
If ye be reproached for the name of Christ, happy are ye;
for the spirit of glory and of God resteth upon you: on their
part he is evil spoken of, but on your part he is glorified.
-1Pe4.14
Amen
Jeff thank you SO much for putting light on the shade. It’s shocking that most Jewish people don’t look for the truth instead just following whatever the Rav says…thank you for these video. It’s really an oxygen in a polluted world!
A "jew" is a descendant of the tribe of Juda. Juda was Jacob's son. Jacob had 12 sons, the 12 tribes of Israel (Jacob's name). So Paul was not a "jew." Paul was a descendant from the tribe of Benjamin.
Yep, they always do this switcharoo
True. And GREAT promises will come through when ALL Israel (as under king David) become ONE- Ezekiel 37:15-28.
Amen !
The church is doing the same thing sadly when we want to obey the commandments of Yah
In my Christianity community, we says it is eventually able to eat everything if God says it it clean. What does the cleaning of the food mean in the New Testament?
BARNETT - My Jewish roots.Am I a Jew?
The surname was adopted by Jews in England in 1840-80s who emigrated from Russian ruled Poland who had endured the Pomgroms there.
The name was probably a hint to their tribe of Israel that they descended from. This was a way to ensure lineage and knowledge to pass down the generations in diaspora , so they knew where they come from.
Some agree the adaptation of the name BARNETT, was a form of BARUCH who was probably their ancestor.
Baruch Ben Neriah was a relative and a priestly scribe to the prophet Jeremiah during the time of the first diaspora from the Babylonian rule .
Both he and Jeremiah are of the tribe of Levi , which is the priestly tribe. And descendants of Levi the third son of Jacob. Given the ‘ set apart’ derivation by God because , they were the only Hebrews who did not worship the golden calf, during the time of Mose’s time at mount Tabor and the subsequent giving of the Ten Commandments. This ‘set apart’ role had been given to the first born sons tribe, but they forfeited due to their idolatry and the tribe of Levi who had refused to worship the idol was granted the special definition instead.
During the diaspora from Roman period. 70AD . The tribe of Levi among other tribes fled to Europe over the Caucus mountains. Where they eventually settled mostly in Eastern Europe. Until the Pomgroms under the Russian Empire when they then fled to further west to Germany, France, England etc.
During the 17th century England allowed migrants fleeing the Pomgroms and later the nazi persecution in the 20TH c to settle in parts of England. The BARNETTS are some of those that settled in Birmingham and established a Jewish quarter there , most traded as watch makers, jewellers, brass founders, etc. Some were Taylors.
They also built synagogues and schools and factories. BARNETT BRASS FOUNDRY being one on Avondale street.
My great grandmothers parents were BARNETTS who lived on Avondale street.
My forebears BARNETT took in a gentile lodger as he worked in the brass foundry there. One daughter Gertrude, married him and they moved about to differing close by places . Eventually to Watford so he could work as a manager to an engineering works there. Where my grandfather was born and subsequently my father.
Due to my grandfather being killed in WW2 my father eventually migrated with his mother ( gentile) and step father ( gentile) to New Zealand in 1950.
This is where I was born . My fathers family were cut off from him by his mothers desire for a new life and her desire to raise him as a Christian.
Consequently my father had no idea of his Hebraic roots until his return to England and subsequent death in 2017. We met long lost first cousins who affirmed that the grandmother was Jewish.
In addition, back in my fathers family lineage about the 14th century, a man had married a woman with the maiden name of Abrahams.
By the way I’m a Christian in my faith
👍
Does the New Testament a really story?
By definition, a jew is a person who's part of a cultural group of people who are the descendents of the ancient israelites of the middle east.
..convertion to judaism makes one a jew in their religious system- .
@@mettemiriam148 by faith yes, but that doesn't change their ethnicity and conversion to Judaism doesn't happen as much because Jews generally keep to themselves about their culture. It's not just a religion but it's a nation of people with a language, land, and heritage. Hebrew and Ancient Israel are elements of their culture
But converts are still equally jewish. Theres so many mentions of this in the torah and talmud @@anthonyjat1964
@anthonyjat1964 the law of return also accepts converts as being jewish. If was not possible to become a jew then. The state of Israel as well as halacha wouldn't allow it.
@@alicoleman6098 yes, at that point a disagree with Israeli law because obviously a Palestinian has more right to be there than a convert
Just like Christianity nowadays. If you’re Jehovah Witness you’re not considered a Christian. If you’re not a Christian either. You have to believe if the Trinity to be Christian nowadays, but that wasn’t in the old testament at all.
Only halfway through the video so maybe it's address later in the video, but I'm curious what the opinion is on a convert if it's only about ethnicity. In Numbers 32:12, we see that Caleb is a Kennezite (or however it's spelled). But in Numbers 13:6 he's counted among the tribe of Judah. Obviously other examples exist such as Ruth who is in King David's line and thus Yeshua's ancestor. Also Acts 13:43 refers to righteous converts.
My wife is a Jewish convert and we came to believe in Yeshua only recently. While I do believe in Yeshua, I do disagree with Paul's take on how one inherits the promises (including Messiah) given to us. It directly contracts Hashem's words as revealed through the prophet Isaiah in 56:1-8. But he wouldn't be the first pharisee/rabbi to twist Tanakh in favor of invented ideas that contradict Hashem.
Are you Jewish yourself?
It seem to me that the rabbinic church as way to much power in Israel, We also see it with those who always wear black ( I do not remember the name). What about the separation between religion and state.
Dear Jews! If you are really looking for the truth and looking for the right and real way and not the easy and shiny way, verify what "experts" tell you! I will give an example: Golan said that the Jewish side that does not recognize Jesus as the Messiah sometimes deprives Jews of their Judaism when in practice this is simply not true. According to orthodox Jewish law, no matter how much a Jew has sinned, he will always be a Jew (Golan was probably confused with the time when many Jews converted to Christianity and were therefore abandoned by their families, but this happened for more than 500 years, today in most Jewish communities such a thing does not happen). Even the contemporaries of Jesus saw him as a Jew and did not remove the title "Jew" from him.
Golan claims at the beginning of the video that he has been told at least a million times that he is not Jewish, and this makes me sad because he probably lives in a community of dark and narrow-minded Jews, I am sure that if he lived in a place that was a little more inclusive, no one would have dared to say such a thing to him. That's why I really recommend Dam not to believe any nice man who thinks he understands something.
Good luck 🙂
Look in the first chapter of Numbers
Confusing...interesting...👍
Not all Jew are JewISH. My mother made me a Jew but I have to make myself JewISH.
100% Jew + Jesus = 100% Jew, 100% Christian and %0 JewISH,
I can't understand what is the difference between jews and white man.I thought jews means people who believed in old testament with Israeli nationality.I didn't know they are ethnically different or they are different race.I will never ever recognise who is jew and who is not if they wear normal clothes.
Wow so true, wow it’s all satans still working against gods beloved people
Indeed
Ethnicity changes only when you follow Jesus. Hmmmm
With all the antisemitism, why does the House of Israel divide ➗?
Who is the house of Israel?
@@mettemiriam148 Jews
One necessary requirement for being a Jew is being circumcised. Otherwise that Abrahamic necessity of being a Jew doesn’t exist
Jeremiah 13:23
[23] Can the Ethiopian change his skin, or the leopard his spots? then may ye also do good, that are accustomed to do evil.
The Pharisees are accustomed to do evil. We cannot change our ethnicity. A Jew remains a Jew. And believing in Yeshua Messiah is the most Jewish thing ever. Yeshua is more Jewish than those Pharisees will ever be.
How is it possible that one was a jewish because he or she is descendant from Jacob, but the origin of the word "jewish" is credited to Yehuda??? The Torah never says B'nai Yehuda, it says B'nai Israel. And that ethnic group is Arab. If jewish is an ethnicity, what do we do with Arab jews, do they have double ethnicity? Remember, Arab jews both of their parents are jewish but they are Arabs. But in Arabia, we have Arab Christians; Arab Muslims; Arab Druze; Arab jews.
Chinese is an ethnicity but jewish is not, you destroyed your own argument.
You are jews as Moses🙏judaism is not a religion, is a culture of jewish people.nobody can take away your nationality or culture.
Promoting idolatry to G-d’s chosen people… Major chillul Hashem
Doesn’t make sense…….
How not?
@@jewsforjesus it doesn’t make sense that just because a Jewish person has accepted Jesus into their heart they wouldn’t be considered Jewish .
@@yellowbird3235what is a Jewish person? Genealogy is not reliable
Being hebrew is not a religion it is a person's decent and culture.
Everybodys a Jew we’re all from the 12 tribes of Israel everybody who was on the ark with Noah was Jewish even the arabs are Jewish there all from the 12 tribes of Israel but for me I love Jesus (Yeshua) which makes me Jewish in my relationship with him as I am a bride of Christ💖
...well, I thought the name Judah was the origin of the word jew?! Juda has a beautiful meaning: "Jahuda"= praise Jah(God)-- he was son of Jacob son of Isak son of Abraham. Great prophesy for Judah in Genesis 49:8-12!❤
You are a messianic Jew is you believe in Jesus. Jesus isn’t God. Messianic’s are Christian and there’s no such person as Yeshua in any early scripture. That’s Joshua.
My friend, please continue to study the NT more.
@@johnpratts2856 I have, which is how I know you are false.
@@theartzscientist8012 I doubt that. 🤣
But I do understand that not all who have ears, won't be able to hear. Best of luck with Atonement and the Book of Life, my friend.
@@johnpratts2856 Jesus never said he was dying for your sin.
@@theartzscientist8012 Yes He did. In John 3.
The main problem preventing you from experiencing success in life is having JC as a role model. Read Matthew 12:38-42. Jesus was conceited and arrogant, and he claimed he was better than Solomon as well as the prophet Jonah. Arrogant people are pathetic role models as modesty is the best policy. Jesus' arrogance got so out of control that God Himself had to eventually put JC in his place. When God heard Matthew 12:38-42, God probably said something like: "Oh really. We'll see if you're really better than both Solomon as well as the Prophet Jonah once you're tightly nailed down and can't move freely. We'll see if I help you once you start crying to Me for help."
You see JC was like a childish 6 year old playground punk who comes up to you on the playground & says: “I’m better than you! I can do more push-ups than you!” And then throws sand in your face.
Grow up and start worshipping God. And stop looking up to a playground punk as your role model!
🥀, surely you will one day regret these words... time will tell YOU👈🏻. At the name of JESUS ✨every knee shall bow!✨☺️
@@shullamitequeen Yes. He's not reading the book correctly.
Hi
God raised His only begotten Son from the dead after He was obedient unto death even the cross of shame according to the prophet Isaiah chapter 53! Check out the irrefutable scientifically verified evidence of Yeshua’s burial Shroud image caused by His resurrection! AND READ THE TANACH WITHOUT RABBINIC INTERPRETATION!
Shalom to us only in Christ Yeshua returning soon to reign over the world government from Jerusalem.
Your main problem in life holding you back is having JC as a role model. Read Matthew 12:38-42. Jesus was conceited and arrogant, and he claimed he was better than Solomon as well as the prophet Jonah. Arrogant people are pathetic role models as modesty is the best policy. Jesus' arrogance got so out of control that God Himself had to eventually put JC in his place. When God heard Matthew 12:38-42, God probably said something like: "Oh really. We'll see if you're really better than both Solomon as well as the Prophet Jonah once you're tightly nailed down and can't move freely. We'll see if I help you once you start crying to Me for help."
You see JC was like a childish 6 year old playground punk who comes up to you on the playground & says: “I’m better than you! I can do more push-ups than you!” And then throws sand in your face.
Grow up and start worshipping God. And stop looking up to a playground punk as your role model!
“For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in. And so all Israel shall be saved: as it is written, There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob. For this is my covenant unto them, when I shall take away their sins. As concerning the gospel, they are enemies for your sakes: but as touching the election, they are beloved for the fathers' sakes. For the gifts and calling of God are without repentance. For as ye in times past have not believed God, yet have now obtained mercy through their unbelief: Even so have these also now not believed, that through your mercy they also may obtain mercy. For God hath concluded them all in unbelief, that he might have mercy upon all. O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out! For who hath known the mind of the Lord? or who hath been his counsellor? Or who hath first given to him, and it shall be recompensed unto him again? For of him, and through him, and to him, are all things: to whom be glory for ever. Amen. (Romans 11:25-36) 📖🔥🕊