WATCH NEXT: Facial recognition is widely used by governments, police and corporations. But what happens when it gets into the hands of everyday people? - ruclips.net/video/Azg_5bKRtrs/видео.html
She also endangered the lives of all those people she interviewed. Thanks to her, they would now spend the rest of their lives in prison. I would be more worried about them than her.
Please, in future videos, protect the people you interview more. Even vague locations, tone of voice, and minor images of people can aid in them tracking people down. There truly is no such thing as privacy in China.
Elizabeth Lassiter Exactly, kinda makes me feel like it’s “anything goes” to get the story. These people still have to live there after HBO leaves 🤦🏻♂️
Chinese authorities will probably get hold of this video and arrest those giving interviews to western journalist. They expect loyalty to China first not Islam
I do think that Vice has some questionable coverage but they never fail to impress me when they go on site to report. It’s always super insightful of the actual situation going on and shows the viewer what they’re not usually shown so they can make their own judgement. One group can say there’s concentration camps, one can say that there’s training compounds. What do you see?
@@Agent3030-h1u It's very simple, close-up or voyeuristic camera language, dark color, gloomy background music😂 I even think that if you see this kind of editing report, better ignore it
@@Agent3030-h1u I’m not even saying china but all reports, every time you saw these kind biased reports like American factories or other stuff, just confidently ignore it cause its lying
@@ottodashppp I hardly think it's fair to call it biased because they put in a little mood music. Also, voyeuristic camera language? They were being voyeuristic. lol
@AlgerianFalcon Oh yeah I know. I think there needs to be better communication between government and its populace(populace usually tends to be sympathetic to good cause but government tends to be the culprit.). And the government should have more accountability to the populace.
+Last Word Maybe you weren't around for Pol Pot in Cambodia (Kampuchea): 2 million civilians killed. How about the Bosnian civil war during the early 1990s, or Rwanda (1994), where they tried to wipe out the Tutsi ethnic minority? The Rohingya situation has been ongoing in Burma (Myanmar) for some time now. So much for the 'peaceful' religion of buddhism, as buddhists gang up on muslims and Christians. ISIS and other islamic terrorists have been going after Christians in the Arab world ever since the so-called 'democratic' Arab Spring revolts. Kim Jong-un in North Korea is a butcher. He killed his uncle with an anti-aircraft gun and his half-brother with some shady chemical weapon. He builds nukes while peasants starved. His father before him was reported as saying, during a famine, that the death of 70 percent of his people would be acceptable so long as the regime survived. Sadly, this is par for the course. (Romans 3:23) 'For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.' But this is the first time in my memory that China has been exposed for 'ethnic cleansing'. This must be only a scratch on the surface of Chinese hypocrisy.
+@@geogrma6491 'Wow' doesn't explain to me what you are thinking. Could you be more clear? As for your being Chinese, what difference does that make? People are people across the whole wide world. (Romans 3:23) 'FOR ALL HAVE SINNED AND FALL SHORT OF THE GLORY OF GOD.' I mentioned quite a few instances of persecution. It so happens that in this case, Chines are doing it to Uighurs, using the EXCUSE of islamic terrorism. But the record of the CCP is well known. If it has murdered millions of its own CHINESE citizens in the past, why should it have difficulty commmiting crimes against a non-Chinese minority?
There's one point that the schoolmgirl mentioned shes a class president of her class. That just narrow it down where to find her. Now shes gone too. Thanks Vice for vanishing another human being
@River of Stars Well, once your city keep getting bomb by terrorists and seeing with your own eyes where your citizens getting blown up to pieces at Xinjiang, you'll have a different opinion on Re-education camps. The bombs going off got captured on camera, you can see for yourself here. Fighting terrorism in Xinjiang ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html If you hate a none violence alternative such as the re-education camp, how do you feel about the millions of Muslims getting killed from the 19 years war on terrors? Brown University’s Costs of War Project this month released a new estimate of the total death toll from the U.S. wars in three countries: Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The numbers, while conservatively estimated, are staggering. Brown’s researchers estimate that at least 480,000 people have been directly killed by violence over the course of these conflicts, more than 244,000 of them civilians. In addition to those killed by direct acts violence, the number of indirect deaths - those resulting from disease, displacement, and the loss of critical infrastructure - is believed to be several times higher, running into the millions. Source theintercept.com/2018/11/19/civilian-casualties-us-war-on-terror/
@@condorX2 nice information you were brought there. I'd always captivated with this polemic from the Chinese point of view. In my opinion, there is always a grey area within something like this. It depends on what point of view we were looking from.
@@echohart3612 Dude, you do know that lots of American companies have there products build there and that Chinese companies have shares in different, American companies right? They will never do something to destroy that relationship, because that would mean a big market crash. Governments always look at economic value first before doing any humanitarian actions in a foreign country,
If you hear what happens in that camps or just in their home you will vomit. Ok North Korea is harsh but they can reach phones, radio(under some pressure). But what they do to uyghurs is inhumanely. If you want details you can say me but I don't recommend it.
@748mes_original north korea recently executed a young adult for listening to K Pop and has prison camps where entire generations are used as slaves. That's not to say that there are horrible things in China going on too. A dark, logical end station of totalitarianism
@@748mes_original uighurs rebelled against china. Thats the reason why they were being punish. China has culture of very strict enforcement of the law. But uighurs keep on violating chinese laws.
And you literally have no evidence of the supposed stuff thats ongoing in the DPRK, yet there is actually evidence of the tremendous trafficking thats occuring in China, and people disappearing left and right. Including organ trade. The only thing you have about North Korea, are a few questionable "escapees" who cannot seem to hold their story together for longer than 2 minutes before they start contradicting each other, lets also ignore the fact that South Korean media a few years ago investigated the "defectors" actually getting money to say stuff that was not true which turned out to be a massive scandal for the South Korean government, yeah lets just ignore all of that shall we and pretend its all true. In fact only a pro-Chinese citizen would write dumb stuff like you because you are too afraid to question things, thats why you blindly follow whatever your state tells you to follow.
This is just Authoritarianism 101. Every Chinese person knows that what they say or do in public is always scrutinised by the government. Freedom of speech (politically) is non-existent.
ruclips.net/video/oX_r6PUcU2g/видео.html [Read comments under, "Go back to England, Michael, you will be dead soon if you stay in Cali" comment; which gives you in a nutshell on CCP spy network.]
网络评论员 搞搞清楚 What ancient times? Xinjiang had never been “the land of China” at ANY point during Song Dynasty while Islam had already been around for 600+ years at the start of it
1:08 The billboard recites, in red characters: "prosperity democracy civilization peaceful harmony freedom equality justice rule by law patriotism work ethic sincere trust friendliness" which are all words with very noble meanings... 25:36 The façade of the barbed wire kindergarden recites in red characters: ‘教师用心 孩子开心 家长放心’, i.e. "the teachers use the heart, the children are happy (lit. open the heart), the parents don't worry (lit. throw the heart)" 26:09 On the barbed wire fencegate of the second kindergarden: ‘播种梦想 放飞希望’ "sow dreams, spread the wings of hope (=let your hopes fly)" 29:37 ‘快乐成长 放飞梦想’ "grow up happy, spread the wings of dreams (=let your dreams fly)"
I agree. I feel like these interviews have definitely put them in danger. It’s even more unfair considering that they weren’t exactly aware of where the footage would end up. It’s a shame
Vice has always been 'in the game', it's just that they have a variety of other stuff that they also report on, y'know, the ones that the likes of you constantly complain about.
Randy Marsh Educating them by brainwashing, and erasing the experience that the Muslim people have to live under in China which they have done to them.
@@shadowthehedgehog3113 Bro i want to know what is the real histroy of Arab invasion on persia how the whole zorostrianism almost wipe out where is there tample relegious books literature I got nothing on internet I m not a zorostrian but i m interested in old persian histroy Sorry for mt bad English bro
“Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval”. Government here government there... what’s the purpose of living anymore if their lives are being 100% controlled by the government??
The sad thing is, as much as they tried to protect the identity of that individual on the train, the Chinese government can still tediously go through their records of when this reporter went on that train, see all of the people who boarded and/or bought a ticket, and be able to find out all of the ethnic Uighurs who were passengers. They can very easily find out who that man was, by process of elimination. They can get those answers out of the small handful of Uighurs who were on board, either through intimidation or torture.
21:13 watching the little girl come to her own conclusion that something was wrong with her mother and give her a hug was the most heartwarming thing ever
When the US and its western allies keep on spreading the misinformation, propaganda, about the genocidal campaign against the nation’s ethnic Uyghur population is a BIG FAT lie. It has been known, often, those videos from those so-called investigation journalists and often disguises as a tourist were staged the interview and paid to the person or persons who interviewed and put in the videos. So that the investigation journalists got exactly what they wanted in order to support their biased one-sided reporting journalism. Often the journalists would paid the interviewer from $500 to $1000 Renminbi; if that person in the video can show more emotional then would received more money. The whole damn video interview was staged and paid for by the journalist. Fact in point if there is really a genocidal campaign against the nation’s ethnic Uyghur population in Xinjiang, then how the hell you can explain the fact in the decade to 2020, the population of China’s ethnic minorities grew 10.3 per cent, while the Han majority expanded at just below 5 per cent, according to the National Bureau of Statistics. Last year, Han people accounted for 91 per cent of China’s 1.412 billion people. In any genocidal campaign the population should always keep on reducing and eventually down to a very significant in size or even down to nothing at all. As in the US, the Native American Indian was genocides by the US government during over two hundred years ago. The total American India tribes were reduced from several thousands to only few hundreds as nowadays. And this is what we called the genocidal campaign by the U S government to the Native American Indians. If you believe those video made by those investigating journalists you might as well believe that is a $3 US dollars bill in the US currency.
@@justthefacts5008 LOL! You're giving America too much credit. We honestly don't care enough about China to spread rumors, let alone anything outside of America; we have enough problems here. The CCP is just really bad at poker. America leaves Afghanistan, guess who shows up the next day to make peace and build a long-term future with the Afghans? Kind of a weird card to play for a country that isn't doing anything malicious.
Rumors stop at the wise. China has now opened its doors, so it's great to travel to Xinjiang and plan your own trip to enjoy the exotic scenery. By the way, let's take a look at the distorted situation in Xinjiang by Western countries.
Although there are now hundreds of Xinjiang videos about foreigners recording the real situation in Xinjiang, this prejudiced video continues to be played on RUclips, and some people still continue to believe that there is genocide and concentration camps in Xinjiang. It is really a ridiculous world.
@@dr.sadafkhan3630 you are really concerning about muslim in non-muslim country have u ever concerned about non-muslim or exMuslim in muslim majority.all people are talking about how muslim are persecuted,have u ever concerned about how exMuslim killed in 15 country where apostasy law is very active.just imagine you will be persecuted officially just because you left your beliefs.exmuslim don't have rights in muslim country
She didn’t. She was IN China. That man is not a spy. He is a policeman. He is watching them, day and night, but is IN his own country, working for his own government, you could call him a security operative, a cop, a civil servant, but he isn’t spying, in this situation SHE is the spy, trying to find information that she is not party to. No moral judgement here, but come on, use your brain a bit, huh?
@@Sashalexandros no you're wrong, it is courage because anyone would be frightened to approach the person who is probably in a government association due to getting locked up or punished severely, approaching would never be out of desperation in this context.
@@everythingandroidois You've never been followed, didn't you? Or atleast aware of that. The best way to detter them is to confront. You either will be locked in jail, or have a chance to confront them before you go there. Choose. A coward avoidance will not bring anything usefull.
@@Sashalexandros I have been followed, but it's a totally different thing in China so that's why I say so.... look the point is she has courage because she is confronting her fear. Say she did confront him, the gov. will just set up another person, so your point is kinda eradicated.
@@everythingandroidois What's the difference, if you're already deep in shit, why not going out with a bang? Ay? Next time you're followed, put a knife in your pocket, get to the stalker, confront them and ask the reason, and if the need arises, use the knife. Either way, you have nothing to lose. If it's your life at stake. Never surender.(As naive as it sounds)
@@IBlackyl this. Not sure what the other guy is talking about. Look all over social media and BLM protests and the majority of people complaining are non pocs.
They will never report in Christian persecution in these nations which is much more common all over the world, wont see it because it doesnt have the same appeal to a blind eye
if anyones wondering what the situation is like almost 5 years later; I visited xinjiang to visit my grandparents just a month ago, and it seems that covid has pretty much obliterated all the police in the area. when I visited in 2019, the highway security checkpoints were almost like clearing international airport security and customs, but now you don't even have to get out your vehicle. there are also way less police everywhere and the CCP seems to be taking a different turn with the region, tourism. the flight I was on from Beijing to urumqi was over 90% tourist groups and so many cities in xinjiang have been transformed into tourist hotspots.
@@thesovietshark8945I have an eerie feeling that its because the job is finished or they’re carrying things out more secretively due to more attention surrounding the topic.
@@indicaap0ppin662 well a big question is why would the chinese government feel the need to do this? minorities get preferential treatment in china, and it would be strange for there to be such a large genocide, especially with the lack of refugees
@@thesovietshark8945China’s policy towards minorities is super consistent- manage them and their potential threat to state unity. That can be accomplished by sticks or carrots. It is also not odd at all that a nation like china that spends more on internal security than their military, more in fact, than the rest of the world combined, is able to avoid massive refugee flight.
@@mumin9436 it has nothing to do with ethnicity. and everything to do with an ideology that is hell bend on destroying and converting anything and anyone. Islam is a cancer on this planet. a illness just like every religion. Atleast the communist try and do something about it.
@@patrickpedersen8167There are religious fundamentalists in the world but things are changing, All religions have reformed througout the history. Critical thinking and reasoning should be promoted and increased scientific temper among younger generations will bring about the changes. Thats the humane way to do it. Not concentration camps like these
What mother leaves five kids behind,, besides, I thought Chinese were not allowing more than 1-2 kids, this woman had 6 with a 7th on its way, obviously ruling didn’t apply for muslims?
Do you know in which country Muslims have been systematically disappearing since decades and the regime would never let any western journalist criticize them? In fact no western journalist would dare to criticize this " nation" 🤔
I agree with you 100%. There I was discrediting Vice for some of their past reports, yet here I am taking my words back. A good reminder to not judge a book by it's cover, nor judge a news media outlet over a few poorly written articles.
Any Chinese who thinks this is right should accept that their own children should be locked up in a so-called kindergarten where they are forced to sing pro CCP songs and praise the regime non-stop. There are even locks at the doors preventing anybody from gping in or out including these children's parents who might want to pick up their children after 'class'. Talking about parents, have you guys noticed they are nowhere to be seen and these children never go out? It's perhaps because it's not a kindergarten but it's actually a re-education camp thus a damning evidence ethnic cleansing is taking place in Xinjiang and the Communist Party is responsible for it. I just want to know if a single Chinese here would accept his own children to be treated this way? After all, you!re claiming Uyghurs are Chinese so I don't see why Han Chinese children should be treated differently if as a Chinese you condone such a pratice.
The reports of genocide in Xinjiang always seemed stupid to me. 1) To lock down 12M+ Uyghurs and 8M other residents of the region to the point of genocide, you would probably need 500k+ soldiers. Possibly 1M soldiers since the residents are so spread out. The entire ground army of the PLA is about 1M soldiers. Nobody seriously thinks the PLA is keeping half or more of their ground army in Xinjiang. Even if the PLA had that many soldiers stationed there, they would have to build massive supply centers and have huge amounts of truck traffic to feed all the soldiers plus the millions of people supposedly locked up. We don't see anywhere near the amount of truck traffic and other logistics necessary to maintain anything approaching a genocide. 2) If millions of Uyghurs were locked up, they would be disproportionately the 18-54 demographic since they are the most likely to cause trouble. Taking that many workers out of the economy would mean that you simply don't have an economy. Russia has lost about 2M out of a population of 144M due to emigration and conscription in their military. And Russia already has severe labor shortages. 1-2 million Uyghurs would be the equivalent of 30-60M Americans of prime working age being locked up. We wouldn't have an economy at all. Instead, Xinjiang's economy is steadily growing. 3) A people being genocided would either fight back fiercely or flee. We see that in Ukraine and with the Rohingya in Myanmar or with the Palestinians in Gaza. We don't see any large scale refugee movements to neighboring countries like Kazakhstan even though the borders are massive. 4) In all cases where genocide is occurring, collaborators are hated and often killed. Yet Uyghurs have a massive presence in the Chinese entertainment industry. A Uyghur actress, Dilraba Dilmurat is the most popular and highest paid actress in all of China. Instead of being hated, Dilraba and other entertainers like Guli Nazha are just as popular in their home region as they are in the rest of China instead of being viewed as collaborators. 5) If Uyghurs were being genocided, China wouldn't have any friendly relations with their neighbors in the area. Instead, China is forging many relations with them and Chinese tourists are welcome there. 6) If Uyghurs were being genocided, there wouldn't be tens of millions of tourists visiting Xinjiang. These tourists don't just visit the cities. They visit the villages and fields as well. They bike or hike around as well as more traditional means of transportation. It would be impossible to hide the soldiers, truck traffic, supply dumps, and massive concentration camps needed for a genocide.
What about the actual Uyghur victims who share their torture and experience. Are they lying?. Even if china did this, it will not effect it's relations with other countries as they won't do anything that will be bad for their country.
@Freepalestine489 remember one country spend more than 1 billion for anti China propaganda instead for other stuff. Who said they not use these money for their own propaganda long before now?
@@Freepalestine489 whenever Xinjiang bring to topic, they always speak about genocide. Culture genocide, birth genocide. What is that supposed to mean? Culture genocide? Is that what assimilation about and nothing worth to said, because China money have Uyghur which mean they accept Uyghur culture existence and one of most famous actresses in China are Uyghur. Birth genocide? That is just birth control and entire country have strict birth control. Other countries also do that.
@@sanchikotjendrakasih9138 What about the "concentration camps". Or victims who sbared their story. Many say they were r***d and even abused. Why would it potentially target people like that??. Or is it simply not true?.
The Kindergarten is home to many school kids and the barbed wire is meant to keep out potential trespassers or kidnappers who may attempt to infiltrate the schools to harm the kids or abduct them, possibly into child trafficking and selling them off as slaves.
As an ordinary college student and an ethnic minority, such behavior is espionage. If you want to praise her for what she's done, okay, fine. I'm from a minority group, dong, we have our own language and our own culture, and the Chinese government has stepped up efforts in recent years, hoping that we can protect our cultural heritage. I have never been troubled by the fact that I am a minority. In fact, when I was in high school, there were more than 5,000 students in my school, most of whom were ethnic minorities. I can even say that there are many ethnic minorities in Guizhou province, China. Now it is distributed all over the country. I go home for the Spring Festival after the Spring Festival. I have never met any so-called trouble. If you don't believe it, I understand, if you simply believe it then I am shocked!! In China, there is only one kind of people in prison, that is to violate the social rules of China, such as splitting the country, this kind of behavior I feel is shameful!! If you don't know, there are 56 peoples in China!! Unless you do something extremely bad, prison is out of your reach. Believe it or not, a look will tell.
Much bias from the journalist. I feel the video was made with a certain purpose by twisting the truth. Most of the people have never been to Xinjiang, which makes it easy to confuse people's minds.
@@scottyang8487 China is not a good country. Many countries around the world dread china that's why many countrys are banning tik tok and also why many people in china dont have access to uncensored internet the thought of moving to the U.S sounds absolutely crazy to me however I would rather move to the U.S then China because they provide basic human rights down there compared to china.
China has 1.4 billions inhabitants and I can't think how this country would have become so rich without the government control. It is awful to see and hear what this people have to face but it is necessary to consider how China would be poor and how many millions of people would die from poverty and diseases in a caothic "democratic" state. There are many different ethnic groups in China and is very likely that they would have fought between them for independence or control, resulting in millions of deaths. The changes that need to be done in China will come through the hands of the new generation of chineses which are well educated and have access to a lot of resources and finance.
Because big corporate interests have a special relationship with China, where they can circumvent US workers' rights and make a lot more profit off their manufactured goods. It turns out when you don't have to pay people fair wages, you can make loads of cash. Who knew!
German international and Arsenal football player Mesut Ozil openly spoke about this situation on his social media and since then the owners of Arsenal shut him out from playing for the club but still pay his £350,000 a week. Chinese hackers took down Arsenal football matches all across China and cost Arsenal millions in revenue, that's when Arsenal decided to shut Mesut Ozil out of playing to try and diffuse what he was talking about. Massive shambles
That's some Colin Kapernick stuff right there but I don't know if Kapernick even got paid by the 49ers. Freakin' 49ers caved because of the fears over lost revenue too, greed ruins everything.
No. There weren't Chinese hackers. After he talked about it in Twitter, CCTV did not show the match. Then the Chinese Foreign Ministry said that Ozil was only making fake news.
Oti Tororo ugari do we really live in a world where you have to choose between being Ina. Re-education camp or dead? These people are having their youngest generation taken away in order to destroy their culture. The CCP are truly despicable in how they blatantly disregard international law and throw accusations around like we’re idiots, so far we’ve lived up to it.
Joshua张志鸿 trump isn’t too late. No matter how much the mainstream media pushed this narrative that criticizing China is racist the American people don’t bow down to any foreign power. The Canadians on the other hand have the weakest leader in the western world and they are a serious security threat for America because of how they sold out to the chinese.
Joshua张志鸿 the US is seeing a massive economic decoupling from China. If trump wins another term I could reasonably see the Is no longer being dependent on any Chinese manufacturing or research while China is still massively dependent on American investment. I’m just hoping that people stopping buying that calling out the communist party is racist. No one is saying anything about the chinese people , it’s the people among the decisions that are sick minded.
Chinese woman who said that the country should have same, culture, cuisine and etc to have unity, has obviously never heard of Chinatowns all over the world 🤦🏻♂️
@KAT you are just a hater , why you don't say that to Christians who oblige people to become Christians or face death READ SOME HISTORY YOU BLIND HATER
Ali Jaafari It’s funny cause now it’s the other way around, Mulism Extremist are pretty much doing the same thing Christians did thousands of years ago.
ruclips.net/video/BjgSOYRZqIo/видео.html See informations from various sources is better than believing only one statement. I suggest you watch the whole video, not only front part。
I am an American living in China, but I heard that I could not go to Xinjiang, unless in a organized, guided tour for foreigners. How did you manage to go there? Do they allow you with just a passport?
@@sunzwong5899My wife went to Xingjiang during the summer, but I did not as I was told a long time ago that I can only go there with special guided tours open to foreigners. Things might be ok now, but I have not checked for sure.
@@aria1117 Afaik, there's only a requirement for mandatory guided tours with a certified travel agency if you want to visit Tibet as non-Chinese citizen.
This legitmately makes me cry. Seeing millions of people be placed into concentration camps is enough to make anyone sick, but to have video proof of children of all ages being brainwashed into a mindless drones in these camps is nothing short of heart shattering.
What happened to your heart while millions of people turned into some mixture of meat and mud and gunpowder in the middle east for the past half-century?
There's a documentary about it and we'll this bs is false lol Ps congratulations ya'll are getting brainwashed by westerns media, perhaps ya'll should start worrying about it huh?
Anthony T whether if its false or not, torturing, separating families, discriminating a religion/race is not okay. and come on, whats with the wired barbed wall and strict security for a kindergarten???
Thank you for reporting such crimes agaist humanity. No one should be forced to abandon their culture, especially in a land they've inhabited for centuries.
@@tx6723 To an extent I do agree, that when one enters a country they must follow rules and laws and have a level of respect. Yet nowadays Western culture tries to flood themselves with foreign culture, bringing in other cultures food aswell like indian and chinese. They also advocate for freedom in general so if you are referring to a western country thats not the case according to them.
One could hardly blame a journalist for uncovering a tweet that ended their own career… In fact I personally appreciate that type of journalism, the that holds people accountable for publicly available thoughts and comments… it is possible for them both to exist simultaneously
@@swisshakilla What if the person doesn’t feel the same way they did 10 years ago when they made that tweet? What if social norms have changed have changed over time?
@@timshrader64 well coming out and disavowing said statement is what you call being held accountable. Whether or not others still choose to be associated with that person after learning what they said 10 years prior is based upon how apparent that change in their character is. Usually if someone is fired or reprimanded it is because they deflect the outrage by pointing out how long ago it was said instead taking accountability. What someone said 10 years prior may be indicative of their current views especially if they’re currently using dog whistle rhetoric, & being associated with people that substantiate the idea that they may still hold such views. Perfect example is Justin Bieber, it was revealed that he has said racist things when he was a teenager. Although there is a certain segment of the population that is outraged, it has not seriously effected his brand because he immediately took accountability & apologized.
Thomas C. you got some good thoughtful replies. I found them ( no matter the position) very thoughtful very good in formation Video on Kamala Harris Please watch them Videos give my views on Kamala Harris here are the links ruclips.net/video/0i1fekgBW6Q/видео.html ruclips.net/video/5kdv0srIyps/видео.html
@@embracemania9322 That Farmer lady would be OK, CCP need those stupid Han people... Local Muslims hate CCP. Without Han people CCP is nothing but invaders in that place. And Those 2 Young men are pure stupid, The Cops had already asked them gently to go away by said " But you shouldn't do this.." They still insist to "Promoting our City" hahaha I laughed my tears out
The video only showed how strict they are manage situation there after terrorism, it has nothing to do at all with the title vanishing muslim. It is very misleading. And what make me question the reliability of those people that did the interview is at 16:35 , that woman stated they give her letter stated she is terrorist, but they didn't even show us the content or a peek of that letter, isn't that supposed to be use as solid prove for their argument? And at 23:31 , the girl said 培訓(pei xun), which mean training, but the English subtitle wrote detainess. This video is full of weird play/manipulation/presentation.
@@TheExtraterrestrial99 You had to deny every other piece of evidence in this entire video to pinpoint on possible questions? Really dude? The entire video is full of damning evidence of what China is doing, along with countless reports, satellite surveillance, demographic data - all showing the same thing. This is not an argument. It's a fact. It's not "strict management". China has a whole shitload of horrific crimes which go on in their own city streets. I have literally been shown, folks being cut up with a cleaver in broad daylight in China. Are those not considered terrorism? Where are the re-education camps for them? I don't know if you're trying to deny it for your own mental comfort, for some deep bias, or for other nefarious reasons. But whoever is reading this, don't buy into the doubt he is trying to sow in your mind.
@@InaamHD Proved you don't really know China. Commit murder in China? That doesn't need re-education camp, it can go right to the death sentences or at least a very long sentence in prison. Ya, the so called "evidence" you found in video about Xinjiang, its is basically the same footage over and over again, and wonder if you notice, those video look kind of old. It is during the period they are cracking down terrorism. Re-education camp is not just for those already committed terrorism, it also for those have connection with them, to re-educated them to prevent this kind of act from happening again.
... one was a hit song and the other is a vice news video, you cant be so naive as to think that many people are going to watch a video from vice just because you think this is an important issue
@@WESTSIDEFOREVA its important issue and if you're smart enough you should see what happen around the world and education yourself more and tell people around you not listening to some music is gone make you know more about what happen around you.
@@wermelandia7302 so who’s gonna pay for the deaths of those hundreds of Han people and thousands who lost their families and homes? It’s pure terrorism.
@@Butch_117 damn another guy brainwashed by western media, don’t tell me u gonna remind me of that man in front of tank pic, u know the tank stopped and that rioter climbed in the tank and tank and pour gasoline into it don’t u? Those rioters burnt a soldier alive do u know that? so who’s gonna pay for that?
Isobel is a great journalist and is extremely brave. Confronting the man following her made me nervous for her. Along with this the entire aspect of going into a place where they don't want anything getting out and filming it to show the world is amazing. This world needs more people like her, brave people willing to risk their own safety for a greater cause. If you read this Isobel, never stop doing what you are doing. You are benefiting society to a degree that is unimaginable. Stay brave and stay safe.
isobel is brave and beautiful. i can tell you i would be too scared to go as an undercover reporter its soo scary the chinese gov. they are arresting all muslims age 16 to 65 to keep the black market organ trade supplied, taking the kids into foster care for reeducation (brainwashing) to undo all their birthparents taught them. as for the elderly they let them keep their physical freedom while knowing their kids and grandkids are being imprisoned for being muslim. the communist party is soo evil.i would not be surprised if they started processing them into food after harvesting their organs, theres been no news on the topic for over a year now. xinjiang is an open air prison for news. nothing gets in or out info wise.
Well if she reads this I hope she never visits China again, at least as long as the CCP is governing the country, because she might be detained and imprisoned. Unfortunately this might happen even if she visits a country with extradition treaty with China. In recent years this has happened to some journalists.
Now imagine how CCP is managing Covid-19 pendemic and information about the outbreak. This footage made me feel like China is a not far off from North Korea. Sad
Are US so innocent and holy .....dont point your fingers at others because anothe four fingers are pointing at you....Go to this link and watch how evil and cynical US is... ruclips.net/video/GDl9ecICIYg/видео.html
@ Is this the democracy and check and balance you are talking about in the US where you can take arms out to protest in the street? Is this the democracy when a narcissistic /imbecile and a inept businessman can also be elected to be POTUS.? What freedom you are talking about when your Gov can spend trillions of dollars to fight unnecessary wars around the world since WW2 and you taxpayers had to pay for the debts.? Changing of Gov is self indulgence and it serve no purpose because life has to go on whosoever became the President . Instead of building more infrastructure and highways your gov is wasting all your taxes to placate their cronies who supported him financially. To be a President of China you have to be elected as a grass member and work your way up and by the time they are selected to be a Provincial Governor they would have been at least 35 years experience and overlooking a population of at least 150 million people. The top Politburo of the CCP is elected by the Peoples Congress with a membership of at least 700 million. You go and figure out it yourself which system is better, The west is jealous and envy about China's progress and with their superiority complex no other nation must be better than them. Period.
HK Sun Wow just crazy how these people are brainwashed by thinking there is actually fairness in these “election”. And you’re accusing the U.S Gov of self-indulgence and wasteful uses of tax money when China is literally one of the most corrupted country on Earth. Just wow.
@@CarpsterKing you aren't electing shit. You can't even demonstrate. I'd rather have 10 idiot presidents and the freedom to elect another than having one dictator.
@@jebuschrist9161 nd one more thing just taake a trip to indonesia nd malaysia nd oman nd lebanon all islamic countries nd ask the minorities over there( christians included) how they are living there.... Im sure you'll be surprised nd shocked
Its really sad to see a mother who’s kids are in concentration camps while her husband is in jail. This makes me question humanity and human emotions. But i do believe in Karma n hereafter (hell).
@Yonis Ali I know, but it had touched everyone, the guilty and the innocent, I hope it will stop soon and China will be too busy with healing itself than to persecute our brothers and sisters
their father was probably a terrorist. these videos mention one side of the story - china bad, china bad, china bad putting Muslims in camps but they never mention the terrorist organisation the new turkestan Islamist movement and the innocent Chinese civilians killed by them
@@deathgamer8086 damn are you a Chinese bot or did you somehow actually get brainwashed by china's propaganda and think that it isn't a terrible place?
I mean the us probably has similar tech. Imagine being the most wanted person in the us probably like that bbut maybe even worse since they have cameras everywhere
@@sashaaaaaaaaaaaaa333If you look at this weird music and this weird tone, can't you see the orientation of this video? A video can have a completely different meaning just by editing, especially when the author of this video cut the video so fragmented. The truth needs to be seen with your own eyes, and you can buy your own tickets to come to Xinjiang to see it.
@@ziyi-nails Id there a cahnce that you are a Chinese troll and how do you access youtube. Of course the government gave you access. And if you have VPN you are very brave. There are camps for uyghur and there is footages. wHat do you do with that much people. They weren't happy in there. The women that escaped told all you did to preganat women. Just disgusting.
What? It has been proven by multiple different reputable sources that the Muslim Uyghurs of Xinjiang have been prosecuted and turned into slaves or killed. to say that that is not happening just off of personal experience is ignorant. The fact that journalists have to be approved by the government to speak on this speaks volumes.
@Natasel Wow bro, chill. First of all there is nothing with being a Muslim just like there is nothing wrong with being a Chinese. I won't start hating all Chinese just because China keeps claiming the region I live in as theirs (which they do btw).
@No No Really nothing could probably change your mindset, because you are misguided. Islam has poor representatives in general, but not entirely. One thing that I should clarify to you is that there is a big difference between terrorism and Islam. Say something against it, you will watch me prove you wrong.
The sad thing is that even if the children are reunited with the parent, they will be too indoctrinated to love or understand their parents and their plight anymore. Or maybe even their language.
When it's fake journalism you don't need to take those precautions because there are literally no risks. I'm surprised u gave Vice that much credit in the first place! Anyway I make vids straight out of China in case you're sick of all this bash-China propaganda lol
@Laura Cannon, somehow it gives us a glimmer of hope that the kid is not ignorance of what have happens to her family, her neighborhood and her community. That awareness is so precious.
They already do. It's not unusual for people to "disappear" in places like Hong Kong only to reappear on the Mainland in an interrogation room confessing to crimes against the state.
@Fabian Hofbauer, At least in China no journalist is put in jail for long time for "breaching" his/her bail condition. Have you ever heard about Julian Assange? How old are you boy?
< Terrorist sympathizer spotted! Joking aside. Here is your answer. I've been educating the mass and it's getting tiring. Please make it worth my time. Disclaimer: The below source contain bloody photo of civilians corpses, shred from the explosion by suicide bombers. "How do the Chinese people feel about Xinjiang reeducation camps" ? Roma Hudson: We'll feel safe First of all, I need to explain that I know a lot of information about Xinjiang re education camp and have watched the reports of BBC and New York Times. I haven't received brainwashing, which is often a misunderstanding of the Chinese people in other countries. First of all, the same event, when you use a different perspective to explain it, will have a completely different impact. The following news reports about many violent attacks in Xinjiang.All of these incidents happened before the construction of the education camp. May 22, 2014: an explosion occurred in the morning market of Gongyuan North Street, saybak District, Urumqi, which is a serious violent terrorist case of extremely bad nature. It is preliminarily understood that at about 7:50 on May 22, the mob drove two vehicles to break through the protective fence, smashed and crushed the crowd, detonated the explosive device, killing 31 people and injuring 94. 2014-5-1: an explosion occurred in the South Station of Urumqi railway, which was a serious violent terrorist attack. The mob held a knife to kill the people at the pick-up place at the exit of the South Station of Urumqi railway, and detonated the explosive device at the same time, causing 3 deaths and 79 injuries, including 4 serious injuries. March 1, 2014: 29 people were killed and 130 relatives were injured in a serious terrorist incident at Kunming railway station. More than 10 uniformed thugs, wearing masks and knives, killed innocent people in Kunming Railway Station Square, ticket office and other places. 2014-02-14: two people and seven policemen were injured in a police attack in Wushi County, Xinjiang. Eight people were killed and one was arrested by the police. Three suspects were killed in a suicide bombing at the time of the crime. January 24, 2014: an explosion occurred in a beauty salon and a vegetable market in Xinhe County, Aksu District, Xinjiang, killing one person and injuring two others. The public security officials quickly sent out police to deal with the situation and arrested three suspects. During the containment of a suspicious vehicle, the vehicle exploded and two people were killed. On January 26, the public security officials were attacked by rioters throwing explosive devices in the process of handling the violent terrorist cases in Xinhe County on January 24. Police killed 6 rioters and captured 5. 6 rioters died of self explosion when they committed crimes. One police officer was slightly injured and no casualties were found. A batch of explosive devices and crime tools were seized. On December 30, the Public Security Bureau of Shache County in Kashgar region of Xinjiang was attacked by violence and terrorism. Nine violent terrorists attacked with machetes, threw explosive devices and set fire to police cars. Police decisively dealt with it, killing 8 people and catching 1. On December 25, the "12.15" terrorist attacks in Shufu County, Xinjiang At about 23:00 on December 15, when the police of Shufu County Public Security Bureau in Kashi District of Xinjiang arrested the criminal suspect in saybage Township, several mobs threw explosive devices and attacked with machetes, resulting in the death of two police officers. Police have decisively dealt with it, killing 14 rioters. They have arrested 6 suspects and seized a batch of explosive devices, self-made guns, knives, etc. According to the preliminary determination of the police, the "12.15" case of Shufu County in Kashgar, Xinjiang is an organized and premeditated violent terrorist attack. Since August this year, a terrorist gang with 20 members has gradually formed, led by Aishan Simayi. The group has gathered for many times to watch violent and terrorist videos, publicize religious extremist ideas, manufacture explosive devices and guns, conduct trial explosions several times, and premeditate violent and terrorist activities. On November 16, police station in Selibuya Town, Bachu county was attacked At about 17:30 on November 16, 2013, nine thugs, including abraahiti, attacked the police station in Selibuya Town, Bachu county with swords and axes, resulting in the death of two policemen. Besides these, there are hundreds more. It can be said that these violent terrorist attacks led to the destruction of local people's lives in Xinjiang. I have to mention two major terrorist attacks. These two things have changed the whole Chinese view of Xinjiang. 1.July 5, 2009 serious violence in Urumqi Urumqi is the capital of Xinjiang. It was a peaceful day. But many Uighurs began to march on the streets, and then began to kill people and make fire. Even the old people who took the bus to the park for a walk were not spared. This is a photo recorded by passers-by with mobile phone. The mob did no difference to innocent civilians The violence killed 197 people, 1721 people were injured. most of them Han. A large number of Han shops were robbed and cars burned down. I once watched a video that the western media never published: those violent people cut at the sight of people, blood flowed on the ground, and then the army came, and they still rushed forward, until the army fired in order to prevent the self-defense warning, they were shot to the ground. I've experienced Tibetan riots, and I know the horror of religious fanatics losing their think. I used to have a little bit of hope for them until it happened. 2.March 1, 2014: terrorist attack on Kunming Railway Station The capital city, which is 4100 kilometers away by train, is a complex railway station where every civilian has been destroyed. The mob carries a pig killing knife. When he sees someone, he will cut it. (this is exactly the same way as the genocide in Rwanda)The terrorist attack killed 31 people and injured 141. Kunming citizens are praying. The slogan means: don't cry in Kunming Every Chinese is afraid. Because terrorism has gone out of Xinjiang. Even if they are far away, they will still happen. And all people are afraid of their actions, because they kill people indiscriminately and without reason at all. As a result, almost all citizens choose to support the government to take a stronger approach. At the same time, through this incident, I have known the double standards of Western media. On the left is the Kunming terrorist attack and on the right is the London terrorist attack on May 22, 2013. Xinjiang people are flooded with terrorism. They have received training from Al Qaeda. Most terrorists are only finish the junior high school. They are easy to be incited and kill indiscriminately. Western media ignored the problem. But it still exists, and if it is not solved, more people will die in the future. So China has set up a transformation camp. The idea was put forward by the team of Chen Quanguo, a former governor of Tibet. There were frequent violent attacks in Tibet, but he managed it successfully. The education camp has new and good facilities. They can play basketball and watch movies. In the BBC Documentary, we can see their national dance performances. The government provides them with job training and ideological education to prevent them from being affected by extremism again. Even after visiting the education camp, many Islamic ambassadors expressed their support for China. Only the West has been opposed. I don't deny the problems in the re education camp. If you want to ask me if I have been mistreated, I think there will be, after all, the contradictions among ethnic groups have been intensified. But this is not officially allowed, and abusive managers will be severely punished. The Chinese government does not want to deepen the hatred among nations again. At the same time, these education camps cost a lot of taxpayer money and created a high-pressure atmosphere in Xinjiang. But it's all bitter. We need to swallow it. I don't know if these camps will work in the long run. I think Chinese government officials still need to improve their policies and attitudes and improve their relations with Uighurs. But like most Chinese, I still support the re education camp. When the whole region is in violence, only this measure of the government can protect my safety. I don't want to be cut to death when I go out to eat one day, which happened every day in Xinjiang.In addition, at least until August 2019, Xinjiang has not had a terrorist attack in 23 months. I believe that security as a law-abiding citizen is more important than the human rights of terrorists. Source www.quora.com/How-do-the-Chinese-people-feel-about-Xinjiang-reeducation-camps/answer/Roma-Hudson-1?ch=99&share=3aea0ca8&srid=hHBzG Fighting terrorism in Xinjiang ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html
@@condorX2 It's almost like people don't like being forced to live under authoritarian regimes that murder and imprison them for expressing their desires to not live under authoritarian regimes. Nah, it's gotta be their religion or something, even though non-Chinese muslims are apparently super supportive of the CCP.
@@remembertotakeshowerspleas355 Wow! I didn't expect to get a rational reply on this outlet. I'm impressed with your respond of the justifications to violence by disrupting and killing ordinary civilians in the name of independent. Speaking of killing, what's your opinion on the war on terrors by the US? It still raging on for 19 years as we speak. And the Muslim civilian deaths are over millions. Do you prefer bombing campaign or none violence re-education camps? And I quote. Brown University’s Costs of War Project this month released a new estimate of the total death toll from the U.S. wars in three countries: Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The numbers, while conservatively estimated, are staggering. Brown’s researchers estimate that at least 480,000 people have been directly killed by violence over the course of these conflicts, more than 244,000 of them civilians. In addition to those killed by direct acts violence, the number of indirect deaths - those resulting from disease, displacement, and the loss of critical infrastructure - is believed to be several times higher, running into the millions. Source theintercept.com/2018/11/19/civilian-casualties-us-war-on-terror/
@@tw3ist , If you do some simple googling, you will find out that central doctrine and sole goal of Islam is physical extermination of every single non-Muslim man, woman and child by cutting of their heads. It is written in their book in plain Arabic, and it also says there that all teachings of Mohammed must be taken literally. So my question is: would you stand up for Nazis? Because Islam is nothing short of religious fascism!
@TheCrazyKid1381 , firstly, what is false exactly in my statement? Second, your screen name is totally on point, because religion is a last resort of stupid, crazy and weak... Modern civilization is way beyond it, and as of you trashing white people, do not forget who created the Internet you are trashing them on, the clothes you are wearing, food that you eat, the whole world of things that you live in...
I live in an ethnic minority area in the interior of China, where the conflict between ethnic minorities and communism is less obvious than on the frontiers. Partly because of industrialization and population movement (younger generations go to other cities to go to school)
I don't think China has a problem with ethnic minorities. The problem is with religion, especially Islam, which is simply incompatible with the communist party and with the main population. The Islamic religion has the problem of inability for muslims to merge with other people through marriage without others converting to Islam. This necessarily means that, through long time, either Islam takes over the country/region, or is taken out by force. Any third option of coexistence is simply temporary and hoping it lasts is delusional. This can already be seen in European nations that have serious conflicts between muslims and the secular society. Without dramatic policy changes, most European democracies will eventually be voted to become Islamic nations practicing Islamic laws due to demographic changes in a few decades.
Have you ever thought about this is probably not because of government, but it’s because of stronger culture? Just like more and more people study English and live a life like western, wear a jeans instead of Chinese traditional clothes. Can we say that is cultural invasion from America or uk?
They should have sent that "Clueless White guy" who orders in perfect Chinese. He could evade the cops by ordering dumplings in Fuzhounese and blowing their minds.
@Peng Qian They arent. Chinese citizins get 100+ social credit when they rat out crime. This could allow him to get him a 3th child or use public transport. Don't judge him. Judge the system
@@pengqian2132 these aren’t friendly American police officers, these guys will beat you and do bad things to you because it’s corrupt and they can get away with it.
@UCzJS0Xn7lyX0WCiuTZxNlKQ we are worse then the chinese government? speak out against the uiger genocide and concentration camps... wait u cant because you will go to jail, in fact ypu are using a VPN to avoid detection in order to use youtube...
@Jonny Sandtrap 1.8 billion people are muslims in the world. If they all believed in bad things and terrorism then it would be the greatest army in history and america/the west wouldnt be standing. Your own home would probably be blown to bits. And tell me why their was no "islam is bad opinion" before 2001? before 2001, for the 1400 years islam has existed, NO ONE in the world had a problem with islam as a religion, how come this "islam is bad" view has only resurfaced as of 2 decades? Your delusional and have just shown your level of education and ability for basic reasoning and logic.
Towerofbauer - I see you skipped your history lessons, so here’s a brief one: The west only revolutionized within the past 300 years or so, before that the Islamic empire was the symbol of human advancement. Europe was plunged in the dark and Middle Ages. Dieseas and unhygienic conditions were widespread . The church conducting horrific experiments, overall Europe was pretty backwards. However the Islamic empire was consistently making advancements in medicine, astronomy, mathematics and science which without Newton and Galleleo may not have made their advancements and many of the things you know of today may not have existed. Combine this with centralized and humane laws, good courts and a good economy and you got yourself the most developed empire in the world at that time. At the time did the muslims blame all christians as backwards because the church was? NO. Unlike society nowadays they helped them. Islamic scholars spread their ideologies to the west and kickstarted its advancement. It’s a shame that this advancement ceased to exist after the empire got sucked into wars after which all this ended.
If you are aware of the Uighur terrorist attack at the Kunming train station and the riots in Urumqi that killed 156 innocent people, you will understand this situation better.
@@noris1238u sound ignorant I am Muslim but telling someone to change their views is what causing. This issue everyone should stay and worry about their own community rather than trying to force anything on others
I had the privilege of befriending a Uyger woman when we were both at college. I live in a small Appalachian town of 2400 people and she was the first person that introduced me to a different world view. She would tell me about how awful it was in China and that she can’t see or talk with any of her family back in Xinjiang. This clip really highlighted how horrible the Uygers are treated. So sad
if she back to old home(without ccp), she need stay in home, dress black, no education, no Love marriage, if she dare love anyone who not appointed by his father, she will be die. so you happy for that?
@8dzenja6 no, is more like after American Civil War, one master kid goto China, tell ppl she was persecuted. but 20 million slaves don't think so, but they r too poor to speak out.
@@tanktang4018 lmao, you believe in that stereotypes that your government drilled your butthole with? damn, these bots are brainwashed. While I'm here freely driving a car and dating a dude. Yep, I'm oppressed alright
"This is a Kindergarden.... noone is supposed to go in !" The most shocking tho, was the support of some people, like the woman in the train. She talked like a real Nazi
She is not the minority who has that kind of thinking in China. In fact, most of people think like her. They just straightly think the people from Xinjiang are problematic.
@@ccczqqq While Im against such actions: the truth is there were many incidents in Xinjiang with violence/terrorism. I saw videos on liveleak for many years with Uighurs stabbing e.g. pregnant Han Chinese women in the Bus in the belly, to death etc.
The conversation you had with the lady on the train really put it into perspective how the han majority think of the minorities. This was a great documentary. Also very scary how they were following you the second trip especially the man in black he was so obvious.
Yup, the minorites need to be uplifted so that they could have better standard of living. Imagine trying to do business but you cant speak the language. Or couldnt do basic math...
The woman herself said that she was a farmer - in China it basically means that she is uneducated, and she herself stated that she interacts only with the Han Chinese, how could you expect her to give an objective answer?
@@eleethtahgra7182 with all due respect, the uyghur cutoff on the gaokao is 35% lower than the han chinese one, meaning someone could go to pku or one of the top colleges with the equivalent of a 1100 on the SAT
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
WATCH NEXT: Facial recognition is widely used by governments, police and corporations. But what happens when it gets into the hands of everyday people? - ruclips.net/video/Azg_5bKRtrs/видео.html
Idgaf
liar
same like the US ... the is no privacy at all ..
Long live the ccp thank you for protecting us from terrorism ❤️ long live The People's republic of China 🇨🇳
欢迎藏独、港独、台独和新疆独人士移民到国外。中国是独裁国家,美国是民主国家。中国有许多限制人身自由的法律;但世界第一的民主自由的美国让人民体会到了真正的自由。
美国的人民可以做的事情：枪支合法化、大麻合法化、童婚合法化、童工合法化......
哇！快点移民到国外！外国真是民主自由！中国政府太独裁了！
哦？黑人奴隶要人权？
哦？被屠杀的印地安人？
哦？抱歉，这些问题都是中国政府虚构出来的~是中国人奴役了世界~是中国人到处侵略和殖民世界~是中国人屠杀印地安人~是中国人贩卖黑人~是中国人参与八国联军轰开了美国的国门~是中国人殖民了印度~是中国人侵略朝鲜和韩国~是中国人投放原子弹在日本~是中国人在东京屠杀日本人~是中国人偷袭珍珠港~是中国人殖民东南亚各国~是中国人屠杀犹太人~是中国人屠杀叙利亚平民~中国人轰炸阿富汗~中国人轰炸索马里~是中国人让日本经济泡沫~是中国人控制了韩国让中国军队驻在韩~是中国人通过升息降息来控制人民币霸权~是中国人强迫各国人民食用鸦片~是中国人奴役黑人采集棉花~是中国人侵略了越南~是中国人......
是的，中国人是邪恶的存在~呵呵
Respect to the journalist who will never be able to go back to China even tho she probably spent years learning the language
i think she's chinese
She still able use this language in Taiwan
she is a chinese
@El Booty nope,isobele.
She also endangered the lives of all those people she interviewed. Thanks to her, they would now spend the rest of their lives in prison. I would be more worried about them than her.
Please, in future videos, protect the people you interview more. Even vague locations, tone of voice, and minor images of people can aid in them tracking people down. There truly is no such thing as privacy in China.
Elizabeth Lassiter Exactly, kinda makes me feel like it’s “anything goes” to get the story. These people still have to live there after HBO leaves 🤦🏻♂️
Chinese authorities will probably get hold of this video and arrest those giving interviews to western journalist. They expect loyalty to China first not Islam
are those ppl still ok?
Elizabeth Lassiter totally agree, I wonder that women on the train must have been sentenced already 😢
They are fine. This is fake news.
those local guys who stood up to the police for the journalists were quite brave
Yeah but they were just trying to save their asses.
@Langdon Alger I am sorry. No need to be agressive mate.
@Langdon Alger no need to be so rude
Fr! I’m surprised they actually helped them!
@@usefultutorials200 it did seem like they were trying to get the authorities off of the reporters backs
I do think that Vice has some questionable coverage but they never fail to impress me when they go on site to report. It’s always super insightful of the actual situation going on and shows the viewer what they’re not usually shown so they can make their own judgement. One group can say there’s concentration camps, one can say that there’s training compounds. What do you see?
I see western propaganda, this video is incredibly biased😂
@@faker3033How is it biased? (I just want to know)
@@Agent3030-h1u It's very simple, close-up or voyeuristic camera language, dark color, gloomy background music😂 I even think that if you see this kind of editing report, better ignore it
@@Agent3030-h1u I’m not even saying china but all reports, every time you saw these kind biased reports like American factories or other stuff, just confidently ignore it cause its lying
@@ottodashppp I hardly think it's fair to call it biased because they put in a little mood music. Also, voyeuristic camera language? They were being voyeuristic. lol
"Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval" This explains it all.
You know who the real cowards are; The so called Muslim Nations like Pakistan that still do business with China.
It's hard to make the choice where your country has to suffer. But i agree you always have a choice.
@AlgerianFalcon Oh yeah I know. I think there needs to be better communication between government and its populace(populace usually tends to be sympathetic to good cause but government tends to be the culprit.). And the government should have more accountability to the populace.
Sounds like Trumps administration members lol.
so censored country, can't even have a casual chat with tourists on the street
What happened to when the world said "never again" in 1945.
+Last Word
Maybe you weren't around for Pol Pot in Cambodia (Kampuchea): 2 million civilians killed. How about the Bosnian civil war during the early 1990s, or Rwanda (1994), where they tried to wipe out the Tutsi ethnic minority? The Rohingya situation has been ongoing in Burma (Myanmar) for some time now. So much for the 'peaceful' religion of buddhism, as buddhists gang up on muslims and Christians. ISIS and other islamic terrorists have been going after Christians in the Arab world ever since the so-called 'democratic' Arab Spring revolts.
Kim Jong-un in North Korea is a butcher. He killed his uncle with an anti-aircraft gun and his half-brother with some shady chemical weapon. He builds nukes while peasants starved. His father before him was reported as saying, during a famine, that the death of 70 percent of his people would be acceptable so long as the regime survived.
Sadly, this is par for the course. (Romans 3:23) 'For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.' But this is the first time in my memory that China has been exposed for 'ethnic cleansing'. This must be only a scratch on the surface of Chinese hypocrisy.
The world sadly quickly forgot.
@@jesusislordsavior6343 I'm a Chinese and i just think "wow"
We as humans have to believe in it too.
+@@geogrma6491
'Wow' doesn't explain to me what you are thinking. Could you be more clear? As for your being Chinese, what difference does that make? People are people across the whole wide world. (Romans 3:23) 'FOR ALL HAVE SINNED AND FALL SHORT OF THE GLORY OF GOD.'
I mentioned quite a few instances of persecution. It so happens that in this case, Chines are doing it to Uighurs, using the EXCUSE of islamic terrorism. But the record of the CCP is well known. If it has murdered millions of its own CHINESE citizens in the past, why should it have difficulty commmiting crimes against a non-Chinese minority?
“Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval”. This is some real dystopian kinda stuff.
That's communism.
Not exactly dystopian but censored enough
I went to xinjiang
ruclips.net/video/7oKvulTU8oU/видео.html
lola s *authoritarian state-capitalism
Individual cannot have baby without government approved. This is called 准生证。
This women has the biggest balls and is one of the best reporters, her and her team go so far sometimes I cant believe it.
You can call a woman brave without calling her having balls….. it’s the most patriarchal phrase to impose on women
These women, or this woman.
Vice should blur the faces of every person who is giving his personal opinion on any issue.
No doubt those people have also vanished
@@Hamza-dj3xm no doubt...
Vice just want the story they dont give a shit about the locals look how many times she lied
@@JoeAcapella CCP are slim ,shut your pie hole
There's one point that the schoolmgirl mentioned shes a class president of her class. That just narrow it down where to find her. Now shes gone too. Thanks Vice for vanishing another human being
I was more scared watching isobel going around China than she was. What a journalist. She deserves the biggest raise.
@River of Stars Well, once your city keep getting bomb by terrorists and seeing with your own eyes where your citizens getting blown up to pieces at Xinjiang, you'll have a different opinion on Re-education camps.
The bombs going off got captured on camera, you can see for yourself here.
Fighting terrorism in Xinjiang
ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html
If you hate a none violence alternative such as the re-education camp, how do you feel about the millions of Muslims getting killed from the 19 years war on terrors?
Brown University’s Costs of War Project this month released a new estimate of the total death toll from the U.S. wars in three countries: Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The numbers, while conservatively estimated, are staggering. Brown’s researchers estimate that at least 480,000 people have been directly killed by violence over the course of these conflicts, more than 244,000 of them civilians. In addition to those killed by direct acts violence, the number of indirect deaths - those resulting from disease, displacement, and the loss of critical infrastructure - is believed to be several times higher, running into the millions.
Source
theintercept.com/2018/11/19/civilian-casualties-us-war-on-terror/
@@condorX2 nice information you were brought there. I'd always captivated with this polemic from the Chinese point of view. In my opinion, there is always a grey area within something like this. It depends on what point of view we were looking from.
She's got HBO money
@@condorX2 What VPN are you using?
@@bluelight4907 Any good VPN you wanna recommend? And what's your opinion on the 19 years war on terrors?
This makes me feel sick and I find it insane how the U.N. will keep putting sanctions on Iran but ignore this crime
The UN is a big joke run by the US, Europe and China even Russia is not that powerful now
@@Ida-xe8pg I mean, I have hope the US currently can hold China accountable but idk about Europe.
You know why? Because Iran has oil, lots of oil.
Once oil is dicovered in Xinjiang some day, CIA is gonna send ten times agents there.
@@heinlich Xianjian has ~10 billion tons of oil reserves. That is 20% of Iran's capacity. It also has ~3 trillion cubic meter of natural gas
@@echohart3612 Dude, you do know that lots of American companies have there products build there and that Chinese companies have shares in different, American companies right? They will never do something to destroy that relationship, because that would mean a big market crash. Governments always look at economic value first before doing any humanitarian actions in a foreign country,
"Most Dystopian Place In The World"
North Korea: "Am I a joke to you?"
😀😀😀😀😀
If you hear what happens in that camps or just in their home you will vomit. Ok North Korea is harsh but they can reach phones, radio(under some pressure). But what they do to uyghurs is inhumanely. If you want details you can say me but I don't recommend it.
@748mes_original north korea recently executed a young adult for listening to K Pop and has prison camps where entire generations are used as slaves.
That's not to say that there are horrible things in China going on too. A dark, logical end station of totalitarianism
@@748mes_original uighurs rebelled against china. Thats the reason why they were being punish. China has culture of very strict enforcement of the law. But uighurs keep on violating chinese laws.
And you literally have no evidence of the supposed stuff thats ongoing in the DPRK, yet there is actually evidence of the tremendous trafficking thats occuring in China, and people disappearing left and right. Including organ trade.
The only thing you have about North Korea, are a few questionable "escapees" who cannot seem to hold their story together for longer than 2 minutes before they start contradicting each other, lets also ignore the fact that South Korean media a few years ago investigated the "defectors" actually getting money to say stuff that was not true which turned out to be a massive scandal for the South Korean government, yeah lets just ignore all of that shall we and pretend its all true.
In fact only a pro-Chinese citizen would write dumb stuff like you because you are too afraid to question things, thats why you blindly follow whatever your state tells you to follow.
So touching when the boy comforted his crying mother.
Crazymota it’s a girl but yeah 🥺
Yes that really good moment that they captured there .....so pure ...
i fuckn lost it there
Bubble n Squeak bush went to iraq and killed one million people and dont act like it didnt happen
:'(
"Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval"
WHAT THE ACTUAL FCK
this is actually a joke in China
This is just Authoritarianism 101. Every Chinese person knows that what they say or do in public is always scrutinised by the government. Freedom of speech (politically) is non-existent.
That's that cool Communism thing all the hipster students are raving about.
@@WaaDoku They're not raving about fascism. They're raving about social equality and democracy.
@@WaaDoku Nothing to do with communism you idiot, it's totalitarianism, a dictatorship, fascism, not the same thing.
Maaaaad respect to the journalist for bluntly confronting a ccp spy.
I AIN’T SCARED OF YA!!! I AIN’T SCARED!!! That’s what she say all the time to these folks. True journalism. Respect
@@网络评论员 Is that what the Communist Crap Party tells you
@@网络评论员 our ancestors pissed here so it's ours - Communist Party of China
ruclips.net/video/oX_r6PUcU2g/видео.html [Read comments under, "Go back to England, Michael, you will be dead soon if you stay in Cali" comment; which gives you in a nutshell on CCP spy network.]
网络评论员 搞搞清楚 What ancient times? Xinjiang had never been “the land of China” at ANY point during Song Dynasty while Islam had already been around for 600+ years at the start of it
1:08 The billboard recites, in red characters:
"prosperity democracy civilization peaceful harmony
freedom equality justice rule by law
patriotism work ethic sincere trust friendliness"
which are all words with very noble meanings...
25:36 The façade of the barbed wire kindergarden recites in red characters:
‘教师用心 孩子开心 家长放心’, i.e.
"the teachers use the heart, the children are happy (lit. open the heart), the parents don't worry (lit. throw the heart)"
26:09 On the barbed wire fencegate of the second kindergarden:
‘播种梦想 放飞希望’
"sow dreams, spread the wings of hope (=let your hopes fly)"
29:37
‘快乐成长 放飞梦想’
"grow up happy, spread the wings of dreams (=let your dreams fly)"
thank you, someone who actually understands
I may be wrong, but I think almost everyone in the video should have had their identities censored, much like the man on the train.
Bro I watched that shit like 5 times😂
I agree
Saor Rombe exactly! I don’t like she did this and didn’t blank out everyone faces
I agree. I feel like these interviews have definitely put them in danger. It’s even more unfair considering that they weren’t exactly aware of where the footage would end up. It’s a shame
They r all chinese, they wont hurt expect the muslim ones
THIS. This is true journalism. Vice getting back in the game
@@randymarsh7204 totally kid
Vice has always been 'in the game', it's just that they have a variety of other stuff that they also report on, y'know, the ones that the likes of you constantly complain about.
TURE ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html
Randy Marsh Educating them by brainwashing, and erasing the experience that the Muslim people have to live under in China which they have done to them.
@@randymarsh7204 are you being serious? do you think this would fly in America?
How this woman is brave.
This is a real journalism we must have everywhere, and these are journalists who must get rewards
This is what needs to be broadcasted in mainstream media. Not all the superficial, puff pieces
I have been travelling 18 days all thru Xinjiang. Nothing can be further from reality
China Bot
Vice, I am glad you broke this story, but in situations like this, you have to take stronger measures at protecting people's identities.
R u zorostrian bro ?
@@peacefollower5026 No. I'm an atheist but I prefer Zoroastrianism to Islam.
@@shadowthehedgehog3113
Bro i want to know what is the real histroy of Arab invasion on persia how the whole zorostrianism almost wipe out where is there tample relegious books literature I got nothing on internet
I m not a zorostrian but i m interested in old persian histroy
Sorry for mt bad English bro
ruclips.net/video/pp3eOQAgYlw/видео.html 有必要保护人们的身份吗？
Lester Gutierrez how is Islam the most racist religion, tell me please
“Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval”. Government here government there... what’s the purpose of living anymore if their lives are being 100% controlled by the government??
its called fascism sub field of totalitarianism....
This reminds me of homefront: revolution SOOOO BAD
They're becoming the govt puppets..no more liberty..
China’s government really on like another level. They want to know every steps you make. Especially Islam. Looks like Islamophobic right there.
*implying your life isnt already owned and controlled by the government*
That small child that hugged her mom, as she cried, just broke my heart..
Ah but remember, only black lives matter.
Stephen Murray not the time or the place. Very inappropriate
True, that was really an emotional moment.
@@renehenriquez345 Oh it is.
@@stephenmurray2851 Completely irrelevant.
The sad thing is, as much as they tried to protect the identity of that individual on the train, the Chinese government can still tediously go through their records of when this reporter went on that train, see all of the people who boarded and/or bought a ticket, and be able to find out all of the ethnic Uighurs who were passengers. They can very easily find out who that man was, by process of elimination. They can get those answers out of the small handful of Uighurs who were on board, either through intimidation or torture.
21:13 watching the little girl come to her own conclusion that something was wrong with her mother and give her a hug was the most heartwarming thing ever
CCP mad heartless. How could anybody become this evil…
When the US and its western allies keep on spreading the misinformation, propaganda, about the genocidal campaign against the nation’s ethnic Uyghur population is a BIG FAT lie.
It has been known, often, those videos from those so-called investigation journalists and often disguises as a tourist were staged the interview and paid to the person or persons who interviewed and put in the videos. So that the investigation journalists got exactly what they wanted in order to support their biased one-sided reporting journalism. Often the journalists would paid the interviewer from $500 to $1000 Renminbi; if that person in the video can show more emotional then would received more money. The whole damn video interview was staged and paid for by the journalist. Fact in point if there is really a genocidal campaign against the nation’s ethnic Uyghur population in Xinjiang, then how the hell you can explain the fact in the decade to 2020, the population of China’s ethnic minorities grew 10.3 per cent, while the Han majority expanded at just below 5 per cent, according to the National Bureau of Statistics. Last year, Han people accounted for 91 per cent of China’s 1.412 billion people. In any genocidal campaign the population should always keep on reducing and eventually down to a very significant in size or even down to nothing at all. As in the US, the Native American Indian was genocides by the US government during over two hundred years ago. The total American India tribes were reduced from several thousands to only few hundreds as nowadays. And this is what we called the genocidal campaign by the U S government to the Native American Indians. If you believe those video made by those investigating journalists you might as well believe that is a $3 US dollars bill in the US currency.
@@justthefacts5008 LOL!
You're giving America too much credit. We honestly don't care enough about China to spread rumors, let alone anything outside of America; we have enough problems here. The CCP is just really bad at poker.
America leaves Afghanistan, guess who shows up the next day to make peace and build a long-term future with the Afghans? Kind of a weird card to play for a country that isn't doing anything malicious.
Looks staged
*boy
Idk but this journalist has them balls to do it
You mean to break the law of a sovereign country and to lie to its police officers in their faces?
@@cipheraero human rights 😲
@@cipheraero This "sovereign country" is putting innocent people to death and thousands in concentration camps.
Kevin Y you must be Chinese
@@abradford9424 And the evidence for your claim is ... ?
At this point, China has literally surpassed George Orwell's imagination.
Orwell had no idea how effective today's data collection would be. Literally every dictator's wet dream.
Guess which country surpassed Aldous Huxley's imagination...
Which one?
@@qaseemtak9368 Really? USA...
Have you even read that book?
Rumors stop at the wise. China has now opened its doors, so it's great to travel to Xinjiang and plan your own trip to enjoy the exotic scenery. By the way, let's take a look at the distorted situation in Xinjiang by Western countries.
Although there are now hundreds of Xinjiang videos about foreigners recording the real situation in Xinjiang, this prejudiced video continues to be played on RUclips, and some people still continue to believe that there is genocide and concentration camps in Xinjiang. It is really a ridiculous world.
I wish they blurred the faces of the Chinese civilians who spoke.
@@annagrudina6206 ?
@@KidGamer2002 A channel full of delusion and probably posted these videos as Chinese propaganda to make the country seem great lmao.
@@user_harddrive there are great things in china but unfortunately shady things do happen in china
so caring and genuine of them
same because china has face recognition
“America hates Muslims”
China hiding in the corner “Oh don’t mind Me”
Phoenix967 don't forget India too is going for nrc,caa, assalam, Maharashtra and Karnataka detention camps very soon ..
And as China is re-writing Quran and Bible Don't know what will happen
i hate muslil sying that like i would prefer to live in usa then china china is the reall enemie of islam not usa
@@dr.sadafkhan3630 you are really concerning about muslim in non-muslim country have u ever concerned about non-muslim or exMuslim in muslim majority.all people are talking about how muslim are persecuted,have u ever concerned about how exMuslim killed in 15 country where apostasy law is very active.just imagine you will be persecuted officially just because you left your beliefs.exmuslim don't have rights in muslim country
@@kilimounais9936 i would say both china and usa
Can’t believe this women confronted a Chinese spy damn
Time stamp?
Picsolve 27:35
Because she's a British. Imagine if she's Chinese or Uighur, she's already in camps.
She didn’t. She was IN China. That man is not a spy. He is a policeman. He is watching them, day and night, but is IN his own country, working for his own government, you could call him a security operative, a cop, a civil servant, but he isn’t spying, in this situation SHE is the spy, trying to find information that she is not party to. No moral judgement here, but come on, use your brain a bit, huh?
Because she's a British spy
next time, stream the videos to a local harddrive or if you have internet, then try to stream, to avoid deleting footage.
I was bored watching fake news on RUclips in China
-----------------------
Your version of fake news is so backwards
Nope that is not gonna happen
She’s got nerves of steel approaching the guy that was following them like that. So much respect
It's the last thing you can do before you lose complete control, is to approach the danger yourself. It's not courage, it's desperation.
@@Sashalexandros no you're wrong, it is courage because anyone would be frightened to approach the person who is probably in a government association due to getting locked up or punished severely, approaching would never be out of desperation in this context.
@@everythingandroidois You've never been followed, didn't you? Or atleast aware of that. The best way to detter them is to confront. You either will be locked in jail, or have a chance to confront them before you go there. Choose. A coward avoidance will not bring anything usefull.
@@Sashalexandros I have been followed, but it's a totally different thing in China so that's why I say so.... look the point is she has courage because she is confronting her fear. Say she did confront him, the gov. will just set up another person, so your point is kinda eradicated.
@@everythingandroidois What's the difference, if you're already deep in shit, why not going out with a bang? Ay? Next time you're followed, put a knife in your pocket, get to the stalker, confront them and ask the reason, and if the need arises, use the knife. Either way, you have nothing to lose. If it's your life at stake. Never surender.(As naive as it sounds)
Now I realize how much I take freedom of speech and privacy for granted. I wouldn't be able to stand living in a world like this.
And then you see white middle class kids protesting about how oppressed they are. Pathetic.
Happened to Muslims being surveilled and interned in america
if you have time, welcome to xinjiang , to see the truth
@Nigel Lush Are u stupid? Habe you seen Antifa/Feminist/BLM protests at all? They are all white, even BLM protests consit of like 50% white
@@IBlackyl this. Not sure what the other guy is talking about. Look all over social media and BLM protests and the majority of people complaining are non pocs.
"Individuals cannot accept interviews without government approval" OMFG. That is truly disturbing.
That's China for you. The CCP doesn't even legally allow people to film interviews without a government license.
They will never report in Christian persecution in these nations which is much more common all over the world, wont see it because it doesnt have the same appeal to a blind eye
That’s what these far left wing Democrats want for America! You don’t know what you got till it’s gone
This is China, this is normal. Comparing to 40 years ago, this is already good.
worst country ever
if anyones wondering what the situation is like almost 5 years later; I visited xinjiang to visit my grandparents just a month ago, and it seems that covid has pretty much obliterated all the police in the area. when I visited in 2019, the highway security checkpoints were almost like clearing international airport security and customs, but now you don't even have to get out your vehicle. there are also way less police everywhere and the CCP seems to be taking a different turn with the region, tourism. the flight I was on from Beijing to urumqi was over 90% tourist groups and so many cities in xinjiang have been transformed into tourist hotspots.
Ohh thats really cool. So do you think theres actually human rights violations in the region? I personally think evidence is pretty sketchy but still
@@thesovietshark8945I have an eerie feeling that its because the job is finished or they’re carrying things out more secretively due to more attention surrounding the topic.
@@indicaap0ppin662 well a big question is why would the chinese government feel the need to do this? minorities get preferential treatment in china, and it would be strange for there to be such a large genocide, especially with the lack of refugees
@@thesovietshark8945Xinjiang is an important area for a gas pipeline connecting Russia to China. Also the biggest terror attacks came from uyghurs.
@@thesovietshark8945China’s policy towards minorities is super consistent- manage them and their potential threat to state unity. That can be accomplished by sticks or carrots.
It is also not odd at all that a nation like china that spends more on internal security than their military, more in fact, than the rest of the world combined, is able to avoid massive refugee flight.
That lady who lost her kids and husband to chinese regime 😭 thats heartbreaking af.
Ik
@Ua la Halizeti you wipe out a complete popoulation of a ethnic community because some people of their ethnicity did a crime ?
@@mumin9436 it has nothing to do with ethnicity. and everything to do with an ideology that is hell bend on destroying and converting anything and anyone. Islam is a cancer on this planet. a illness just like every religion.
Atleast the communist try and do something about it.
@@patrickpedersen8167There are religious fundamentalists in the world but things are changing, All religions have reformed througout the history. Critical thinking and reasoning should be promoted and increased scientific temper among younger generations will bring about the changes. Thats the humane way to do it. Not concentration camps like these
What mother leaves five kids behind,, besides, I thought Chinese were not allowing more than 1-2 kids, this woman had 6 with a 7th on its way, obviously ruling didn’t apply for muslims?
Ahh yes, kindergarten with barb wires and metal detector.
It's not to keep the kids inside...
@@dukemedia-thedigitalmarket5256 r/woooosh
@@flowerfloc r/woooosh
Interestingly American high schools also have quite a few metal detectors of their own
if american had this, there will be much less school shooting
And here I was thinking that Vice lost it's balls 7 years ago. This is really impressive journalism. Props.
@Sol de Mayo Are you a Chinese bot?
Do you know in which country Muslims have been systematically disappearing since decades and the regime would never let any western journalist criticize them? In fact no western journalist would dare to criticize this " nation" 🤔
@@prblmchild83 Any of the Muslim countries the US invaded?
I agree with you 100%. There I was discrediting Vice for some of their past reports, yet here I am taking my words back. A good reminder to not judge a book by it's cover, nor judge a news media outlet over a few poorly written articles.
Any Chinese who thinks this is right should accept that their own children should be locked up in a so-called kindergarten where they are forced to sing pro CCP songs and praise the regime non-stop. There are even locks at the doors preventing anybody from gping in or out including these children's parents who might want to pick up their children after 'class'. Talking about parents, have you guys noticed they are nowhere to be seen and these children never go out? It's perhaps because it's not a kindergarten but it's actually a re-education camp thus a damning evidence ethnic cleansing is taking place in Xinjiang and the Communist Party is responsible for it.
I just want to know if a single Chinese here would accept his own children to be treated this way?
After all, you!re claiming Uyghurs are Chinese so I don't see why Han Chinese children should be treated differently if as a Chinese you condone such a pratice.
The reports of genocide in Xinjiang always seemed stupid to me.
1) To lock down 12M+ Uyghurs and 8M other residents of the region to the point of genocide, you would probably need 500k+ soldiers. Possibly 1M soldiers since the residents are so spread out. The entire ground army of the PLA is about 1M soldiers. Nobody seriously thinks the PLA is keeping half or more of their ground army in Xinjiang. Even if the PLA had that many soldiers stationed there, they would have to build massive supply centers and have huge amounts of truck traffic to feed all the soldiers plus the millions of people supposedly locked up. We don't see anywhere near the amount of truck traffic and other logistics necessary to maintain anything approaching a genocide.
2) If millions of Uyghurs were locked up, they would be disproportionately the 18-54 demographic since they are the most likely to cause trouble. Taking that many workers out of the economy would mean that you simply don't have an economy. Russia has lost about 2M out of a population of 144M due to emigration and conscription in their military. And Russia already has severe labor shortages. 1-2 million Uyghurs would be the equivalent of 30-60M Americans of prime working age being locked up. We wouldn't have an economy at all. Instead, Xinjiang's economy is steadily growing.
3) A people being genocided would either fight back fiercely or flee. We see that in Ukraine and with the Rohingya in Myanmar or with the Palestinians in Gaza. We don't see any large scale refugee movements to neighboring countries like Kazakhstan even though the borders are massive.
4) In all cases where genocide is occurring, collaborators are hated and often killed. Yet Uyghurs have a massive presence in the Chinese entertainment industry. A Uyghur actress, Dilraba Dilmurat is the most popular and highest paid actress in all of China. Instead of being hated, Dilraba and other entertainers like Guli Nazha are just as popular in their home region as they are in the rest of China instead of being viewed as collaborators.
5) If Uyghurs were being genocided, China wouldn't have any friendly relations with their neighbors in the area. Instead, China is forging many relations with them and Chinese tourists are welcome there.
6) If Uyghurs were being genocided, there wouldn't be tens of millions of tourists visiting Xinjiang. These tourists don't just visit the cities. They visit the villages and fields as well. They bike or hike around as well as more traditional means of transportation. It would be impossible to hide the soldiers, truck traffic, supply dumps, and massive concentration camps needed for a genocide.
What about the actual Uyghur victims who share their torture and experience.
Are they lying?.
Even if china did this, it will not effect it's relations with other countries as they won't do anything that will be bad for their country.
@Freepalestine489 yes.
@Freepalestine489 remember one country spend more than 1 billion for anti China propaganda instead for other stuff. Who said they not use these money for their own propaganda long before now?
@@Freepalestine489 whenever Xinjiang bring to topic, they always speak about genocide. Culture genocide, birth genocide.
What is that supposed to mean?
Culture genocide?
Is that what assimilation about and nothing worth to said, because China money have Uyghur which mean they accept Uyghur culture existence and one of most famous actresses in China are Uyghur.
Birth genocide?
That is just birth control and entire country have strict birth control. Other countries also do that.
@@sanchikotjendrakasih9138 What about the "concentration camps".
Or victims who sbared their story.
Many say they were r***d and even abused. Why would it potentially target people like that??.
Or is it simply not true?.
awesome journalism, that was gutsy AF!
@@lainea8628 everyone should.
Wil top fan of you
@steven mathew you ok bruh?
steven mathew Truths can be hard to swallow
Lol, this came out of nowhere
Nothing says Kindergarden like a barbed wire on a fence
A rehabilitation for minors
The Kindergarten is home to many school kids and the barbed wire is meant to keep out potential trespassers or kidnappers who may attempt to infiltrate the schools to harm the kids or abduct them, possibly into child trafficking and selling them off as slaves.
Guys I think we have just been demonstrated the work of the 50 cent army.
@@Shenzhou. tell your boss he has the big gay
Exactly
This journalist has guts. The way she questioned the spy after them.
As an ordinary college student and an ethnic minority, such behavior is espionage.
If you want to praise her for what she's done, okay, fine.
I'm from a minority group, dong, we have our own language and our own culture, and the Chinese government has stepped up efforts in recent years, hoping that we can protect our cultural heritage.
I have never been troubled by the fact that I am a minority. In fact, when I was in high school, there were more than 5,000 students in my school, most of whom were ethnic minorities. I can even say that there are many ethnic minorities in Guizhou province, China.
Now it is distributed all over the country. I go home for the Spring Festival after the Spring Festival. I have never met any so-called trouble.
If you don't believe it, I understand, if you simply believe it then I am shocked!!
In China, there is only one kind of people in prison, that is to violate the social rules of China, such as splitting the country, this kind of behavior I feel is shameful!!
If you don't know, there are 56 peoples in China!!
Unless you do something extremely bad, prison is out of your reach.
Believe it or not, a look will tell.
@@scottyang8487 ok, if you are saying so.
Much bias from the journalist. I feel the video was made with a certain purpose by twisting the truth. Most of the people have never been to Xinjiang, which makes it easy to confuse people's minds.
@@scottyang8487 the video is talking about muslim not ethnic minority that are enslaved
@@scottyang8487 China is not a good country. Many countries around the world dread china that's why many countrys are banning tik tok and also why many people in china dont have access to uncensored internet the thought of moving to the U.S sounds absolutely crazy to me however I would rather move to the U.S then China because they provide basic human rights down there compared to china.
China has 1.4 billions inhabitants and I can't think how this country would have become so rich without the government control. It is awful to see and hear what this people have to face but it is necessary to consider how China would be poor and how many millions of people would die from poverty and diseases in a caothic "democratic" state. There are many different ethnic groups in China and is very likely that they would have fought between them for independence or control, resulting in millions of deaths.
The changes that need to be done in China will come through the hands of the new generation of chineses which are well educated and have access to a lot of resources and finance.
如果我说这个视频误导性非常重，我活了30年从来没有过压迫你们外国人会有人信吗？我们想出国其实很简单，要真是一直被压迫人早就跑完了😂
the lying flat generation 😂
this is fake news
西方人相信他们的观念是普世的，但是西方人从来没有管理过大国。美国也只是五十个小国的集合。
this is genocide. why isn't the UN doing anything? She's a very brave journalist.
One answer. Money is power.. china has got the world by its balls litterally.. unless each powerful country starts to stand up.
@@heroblue93 looks like world war 3 is near
Because big corporate interests have a special relationship with China, where they can circumvent US workers' rights and make a lot more profit off their manufactured goods. It turns out when you don't have to pay people fair wages, you can make loads of cash. Who knew!
UN was always a puppet org for rich and powerful
UN is thug
German international and Arsenal football player Mesut Ozil openly spoke about this situation on his social media and since then the owners of Arsenal shut him out from playing for the club but still pay his £350,000 a week. Chinese hackers took down Arsenal football matches all across China and cost Arsenal millions in revenue, that's when Arsenal decided to shut Mesut Ozil out of playing to try and diffuse what he was talking about. Massive shambles
Dang, that's some
at least
That's some Colin Kapernick stuff right there but I don't know if Kapernick even got paid by the 49ers. Freakin' 49ers caved because of the fears over lost revenue too, greed ruins everything.
No. There weren't Chinese hackers. After he talked about it in Twitter, CCTV did not show the match. Then the Chinese Foreign Ministry said that Ozil was only making fake news.
Interesting. I can add here about the US gaming company Blizzard who banned a pro player for speaking on HongKong. Blizzard has Chinese investors.
@Hoy Sum thats capitalisms fault not democracy
It’s crazy how the citizens can’t even talk about government issues or their opinions w out being scared of being arrested.
Oti Tororo ugari do we really live in a world where you have to choose between being Ina. Re-education camp or dead? These people are having their youngest generation taken away in order to destroy their culture. The CCP are truly despicable in how they blatantly disregard international law and throw accusations around like we’re idiots, so far we’ve lived up to it.
Joshua张志鸿 trump isn’t too late. No matter how much the mainstream media pushed this narrative that criticizing China is racist the American people don’t bow down to any foreign power. The Canadians on the other hand have the weakest leader in the western world and they are a serious security threat for America because of how they sold out to the chinese.
Joshua张志鸿 the US is seeing a massive economic decoupling from China. If trump wins another term I could reasonably see the Is no longer being dependent on any Chinese manufacturing or research while China is still massively dependent on American investment. I’m just hoping that people stopping buying that calling out the communist party is racist. No one is saying anything about the chinese people , it’s the people among the decisions that are sick minded.
Ži
Sarah Slavny Same is in india
The way she confronted that stalker requires serious courage.
Hayder Al-Gburi Funny thing is he backed off like the coward he is lol
the guy is not even chinese
haha such a troll
@fast cash but can't answer her question when he's being confronted is even worse rite?
@fast cash when someone id stalking you, you would be pissed too.
Chinese woman who said that the country should have same, culture, cuisine and etc to have unity, has obviously never heard of Chinatowns all over the world 🤦🏻♂️
@KAT Turkey wasn't a Christian country
KAT Turkey? Byzantine you mean?
China doesn't want Islam to dominate or influence their people and culture. Islam is the broom of the globalists.
@KAT you are just a hater , why you don't say that to Christians who oblige people to become Christians or face death READ SOME HISTORY YOU BLIND HATER
Ali Jaafari It’s funny cause now it’s the other way around, Mulism Extremist are pretty much doing the same thing Christians did thousands of years ago.
That is horrible and it’s extremely frustrating to watch.
ruclips.net/video/BjgSOYRZqIo/видео.html See informations from various sources is better than believing only one statement. I suggest you watch the whole video, not only front part。
@@karlbuchanan1363 Those who were colonized in the last century and native Americans probably also wish some people disappear from the earth
reupload ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html
@@Jetsetfastfood say who? Do you think Muslim just live in the freaking Arabian desert?
@@Jetsetfastfood Yes they hate the west but wow they sure want to go there.
I am an American living in China, but I heard that I could not go to Xinjiang, unless in a organized, guided tour for foreigners. How did you manage to go there? Do they allow you with just a passport?
Not true
you in china but you cant go xinjiang? so many american went to xinjiang and make video post on youtube. u tell me u cant go xinjiang? are you ok?
@@sunzwong5899My wife went to Xingjiang during the summer, but I did not as I was told a long time ago that I can only go there with special guided tours open to foreigners. Things might be ok now, but I have not checked for sure.
@@aria1117 Afaik, there's only a requirement for mandatory guided tours with a certified travel agency if you want to visit Tibet as non-Chinese citizen.
@@raychew1692many thanks!
This legitmately makes me cry. Seeing millions of people be placed into concentration camps is enough to make anyone sick, but to have video proof of children of all ages being brainwashed into a mindless drones in these camps is nothing short of heart shattering.
Norbit Official then do something about it instead of virtue signaling in the comments section
@@DrewsAutoReviews to be fair,
What can anyone do to stop it?
put pressure on us politicians or boycott Chinese bussiness
What happened to your heart while millions of people turned into some mixture of meat and mud and gunpowder in the middle east for the past half-century?
In the whole 31 minutes video showing street, peoples freely moving, where the so call concentration camp?
regardless of the religion, what they r doing to these people is inhumane!
Peter Lokin you’re wrong
Horrible
There's a documentary about it and we'll this bs is false lol
Ps congratulations ya'll are getting brainwashed by westerns media, perhaps ya'll should start worrying about it huh?
Anthony T whether if its false or not, torturing, separating families, discriminating a religion/race is not okay. and come on, whats with the wired barbed wall and strict security for a kindergarten???
Peter Lokin Well true but whats with the large amount of police patrolling around. something is still not right.
I am very curious, why don't you also do a video in Gaza. Report at a real open prison there.
When she confronted the guy following her-balls like a bull bro!
But she's a girl....
Stop saying balls bro. It's weird saying big balls or big vagina.
@@Varmth it's a figure of speech.
@@xxxluckycharmsxxx It would be weird of i said "woah bro! Your mother wasn't even scared! She's so masculine and her balls are so big!"
@@Varmth To you maybe, but to most the phrase of "oh, they got balls" is like calling someone "dude." It's gender neutral.
Isobel: *breathes*
Police: "BUT DO YOU HAVE A LICENSE?"
Sorry but you need goverment permission to comment.
@@Thegamingdino133 lmaoo
Ask Floyd can he breathe
Hey xi ping is that you, liking the dp.. 😂😂😂
I mean the police can ask identification especially if you are a foreigner you need to identify you are there legally
it’s messy that they didn’t mask all the voices of interviewees knowing that the government used voice recognition
Yana Rankine they also camera with no any mask they think they are safe aboard which is not actually
Was thinking the same thing, she’s probably dead now. They have face and voice recognition in China and they constantly monitor journalists.
语音识别？！兄弟，不要这么搞笑好伐~知识浅薄就去学习一下，或者请教下真正的专家。语音识别一个人现有的技术是非常难以达到的~
@@etonxu3763 你是從中國來的嗎？
@@kevinsantana9693 是的~~我就在中国~~~
Thank you for reporting such crimes agaist humanity. No one should be forced to abandon their culture, especially in a land they've inhabited for centuries.
I really feel bad for them but when I see Islamic Jihad in middle East I don't think they are the most secular people.
Gaza????
If ur an immigrant yes
@@tx6723 To an extent I do agree, that when one enters a country they must follow rules and laws and have a level of respect. Yet nowadays Western culture tries to flood themselves with foreign culture, bringing in other cultures food aswell like indian and chinese. They also advocate for freedom in general so if you are referring to a western country thats not the case according to them.
You do realize uighurs are not nativen to the region, they genocided the dzungurs who were native and related to Han chinese.
this is real journalism, not trying to end careers over tweets from like 10 years ago
One could hardly blame a journalist for uncovering a tweet that ended their own career… In fact I personally appreciate that type of journalism, the that holds people accountable for publicly available thoughts and comments… it is possible for them both to exist simultaneously
@@swisshakilla What if the person doesn’t feel the same way they did 10 years ago when they made that tweet? What if social norms have changed have changed over time?
@@timshrader64 well coming out and disavowing said statement is what you call being held accountable.
Whether or not others still choose to be associated with that person after learning what they said 10 years prior is based upon how apparent that change in their character is.
Usually if someone is fired or reprimanded it is because they deflect the outrage by pointing out how long ago it was said instead taking accountability.
What someone said 10 years prior may be indicative of their current views especially if they’re currently using dog whistle rhetoric, & being associated with people that substantiate the idea that they may still hold such views.
Perfect example is Justin Bieber, it was revealed that he has said racist things when he was a teenager. Although there is a certain segment of the population that is outraged, it has not seriously effected his brand because he immediately took accountability & apologized.
Thomas C. you got some good thoughtful replies. I found them ( no matter the position) very thoughtful very good in formation Video on Kamala Harris Please watch them Videos give my views on Kamala Harris here are the links ruclips.net/video/0i1fekgBW6Q/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/5kdv0srIyps/видео.html
@@timshrader64 It's funny. If someone made an extremely racist tweet 10 years ago, it would be the same if someone did that now.
Those local Han guys ain't no snitches, 'we're promoting our city' lmao.
MVPs
They actually gave them out by saying they are doing an interview.
I cant help but think once the CCP watches this those guys are gonna be spirited away, and that farmer lady on the train.😪
@@embracemania9322 That Farmer lady would be OK, CCP need those stupid Han people... Local Muslims hate CCP. Without Han people CCP is nothing but invaders in that place. And Those 2 Young men are pure stupid, The Cops had already asked them gently to go away by said " But you shouldn't do this.." They still insist to "Promoting our City" hahaha I laughed my tears out
Yep . I would rather be in syria then china reporting!
just hope everyone she interact with are safe... She can just leave. They can't
Agreed.
this interview is lie
@@荔女士 Why?
@@yaboi8644 ruclips.net/video/7KvC89nKCHo/видео.html this is really xinjiang
@@yaboi8644 ruclips.net/video/h3U-lKnMLwE/видео.html this is really school in xinjiang
The fact the police are so strict on these footage matters shows they're trying to hide something...
deep down they all know its a hideous thing worthy of retaliation
thank you sherlock
@@tiguilherman_plays they might as well be brainwashing those police aswell 😬
@@kings9724 yeahh rereading it now, my comment sounds pretty stupid 😐
Nilab Miran lmao no hate G
"please dont tell other people"
*5,340,096 views*
We need to pray for him.
The video only showed how strict they are manage situation there after terrorism, it has nothing to do at all with the title vanishing muslim. It is very misleading.
And what make me question the reliability of those people that did the interview is at 16:35 , that woman stated they give her letter stated she is terrorist, but they didn't even show us the content or a peek of that letter, isn't that supposed to be use as solid prove for their argument?
And at 23:31 , the girl said 培訓(pei xun), which mean training, but the English subtitle wrote detainess. This video is full of weird play/manipulation/presentation.
The Extraterrestrial uh ok
@@TheExtraterrestrial99 You had to deny every other piece of evidence in this entire video to pinpoint on possible questions? Really dude? The entire video is full of damning evidence of what China is doing, along with countless reports, satellite surveillance, demographic data - all showing the same thing. This is not an argument. It's a fact. It's not "strict management". China has a whole shitload of horrific crimes which go on in their own city streets. I have literally been shown, folks being cut up with a cleaver in broad daylight in China. Are those not considered terrorism? Where are the re-education camps for them?
I don't know if you're trying to deny it for your own mental comfort, for some deep bias, or for other nefarious reasons. But whoever is reading this, don't buy into the doubt he is trying to sow in your mind.
@@InaamHD Proved you don't really know China. Commit murder in China? That doesn't need re-education camp, it can go right to the death sentences or at least a very long sentence in prison.
Ya, the so called "evidence" you found in video about Xinjiang, its is basically the same footage over and over again, and wonder if you notice, those video look kind of old. It is during the period they are cracking down terrorism. Re-education camp is not just for those already committed terrorism, it also for those have connection with them, to re-educated them to prevent this kind of act from happening again.
7 billion people saw despacito but only 6million saw this.
Sad truth about our world. Its really heartbreaking💔
... one was a hit song and the other is a vice news video, you cant be so naive as to think that many people are going to watch a video from vice just because you think this is an important issue
@@WESTSIDEFOREVA its important issue and if you're smart enough you should see what happen around the world and education yourself more and tell people around you not listening to some music is gone make you know more about what happen around you.
@@WESTSIDEFOREVA are you saying this isn’t an issue and for a human being to have the freedom of speech and religion isn’t important?
@@rishnasrasheed7414 not even three hundred million people watched Despacito
Fun fact this area is where the Aladdin story took place in the original story.
@@carterwow yup. Just look up alladin origin or alladin original Chinese story.
It’s scary how one talks at a corner and seconds later the police is there
only in Xinjiang cuz of the 2009.07.05 massacre against Han Chinese
@@josephjoestar6679 that is no excuse for cultural imperialism
@@wermelandia7302 so who’s gonna pay for the deaths of those hundreds of Han people and thousands who lost their families and homes? It’s pure terrorism.
@@josephjoestar6679 What about the Tiananmen Square massacre who’s gonna pay for the deaths of those hundreds of han deaths
@@Butch_117 damn another guy brainwashed by western media, don’t tell me u gonna remind me of that man in front of tank pic, u know the tank stopped and that rioter climbed in the tank and tank and pour gasoline into it don’t u? Those rioters burnt a soldier alive do u know that? so who’s gonna pay for that?
This all just seems like a black mirror episode but it´s reality...
happens almost everywhere in the daily world. even in usa
@@Cravberry cause "we waz kangz and shieeetttt"
which episode and season?
Which episode
Opposite of reality . wake up
Isobel is a great journalist and is extremely brave. Confronting the man following her made me nervous for her. Along with this the entire aspect of going into a place where they don't want anything getting out and filming it to show the world is amazing. This world needs more people like her, brave people willing to risk their own safety for a greater cause. If you read this Isobel, never stop doing what you are doing. You are benefiting society to a degree that is unimaginable. Stay brave and stay safe.
Why do many Muslims who shares hastag of save Palestinians don't share the same for save Uighur Muslims?
@@ebynmatthews they don't know about it bro
isobel is brave and beautiful. i can tell you i would be too scared to go as an undercover reporter its soo scary the chinese gov. they are arresting all muslims age 16 to 65 to keep the black market organ trade supplied, taking the kids into foster care for reeducation (brainwashing) to undo all their birthparents taught them. as for the elderly they let them keep their physical freedom while knowing their kids and grandkids are being imprisoned for being muslim. the communist party is soo evil.i would not be surprised if they started processing them into food after harvesting their organs, theres been no news on the topic for over a year now. xinjiang is an open air prison for news. nothing gets in or out info wise.
Well if she reads this I hope she never visits China again, at least as long as the CCP is governing the country, because she might be detained and imprisoned. Unfortunately this might happen even if she visits a country with extradition treaty with China. In recent years this has happened to some journalists.
*I would have started running to see if he can catch me. He doesn't look like much of a runner.*
Now imagine how CCP is managing Covid-19 pendemic and information about the outbreak. This footage made me feel like China is a not far off from North Korea. Sad
Are US so innocent and holy .....dont point your fingers at others because anothe four fingers are pointing at you....Go to this link and watch how evil and cynical US is...
ruclips.net/video/GDl9ecICIYg/видео.html
@@CarpsterKing NMSL
@ Is this the democracy and check and balance you are talking about
in the US where you can take arms out to
protest in the street? Is this the democracy
when a narcissistic /imbecile and a inept
businessman can also be elected to be POTUS.? What freedom you are talking about when your Gov can spend trillions of dollars to fight unnecessary wars around the world since WW2 and you taxpayers had to pay for the debts.? Changing of Gov is self indulgence and it serve no purpose because life has to go on whosoever became the President . Instead of building more infrastructure and highways your gov is wasting all your taxes to placate their
cronies who supported him financially.
To be a President of China you have to be
elected as a grass member and work your way up and by the time they are selected to be a Provincial Governor they would have been at least 35 years experience and overlooking a population of at least 150 million people. The top Politburo of the CCP is elected by the Peoples Congress with a membership of at least 700 million. You go and figure out it yourself which system is better, The west is jealous and envy about China's progress and with their superiority complex no other nation must be better than them. Period.
HK Sun Wow just crazy how these people are brainwashed by thinking there is actually fairness in these “election”. And you’re accusing the U.S Gov of self-indulgence and wasteful uses of tax money when China is literally one of the most corrupted country on Earth. Just wow.
@@CarpsterKing you aren't electing shit. You can't even demonstrate. I'd rather have 10 idiot presidents and the freedom to elect another than having one dictator.
This is very similar to nazi Germany I’m not the only one who thinks this right ?
I agree. Naziism and islam are very similar ideologies.
@@jebuschrist9161 do you even know wat islam is...?
akhtar Shagufta a death cult.
@@jebuschrist9161 no bro you are sadly mistaken....nd i pity you for your close minded thinking..peace✌
@@jebuschrist9161 nd one more thing just taake a trip to indonesia nd malaysia nd oman nd lebanon all islamic countries nd ask the minorities over there( christians included) how they are living there....
Im sure you'll be surprised nd shocked
“Quick, look like a tourist!”
*Rides a camel and throws peace signs*
Why the music sounds weird from the beginning?
Its really sad to see a mother who’s kids are in concentration camps while her husband is in jail. This makes me question humanity and human emotions. But i do believe in Karma n hereafter (hell).
@Yonis Ali I know, but it had touched everyone, the guilty and the innocent, I hope it will stop soon and China will be too busy with healing itself than to persecute our brothers and sisters
Yonis Ali China don’t even want to release the numbers of people that got sick. From corona but I pray for the people inside
their father was probably a terrorist. these videos mention one side of the story - china bad, china bad, china bad putting Muslims in camps but they never mention the terrorist organisation the new turkestan Islamist movement and the innocent Chinese civilians killed by them
@@deathgamer8086 damn are you a Chinese bot or did you somehow actually get brainwashed by china's propaganda and think that it isn't a terrible place?
@@deathgamer8086 they formed that group because they're being oppressed before then.
If I were her I'd never return. Their facial recognition tech is insane. I can't imagine what it would be like to be considered an enemy while there.
I mean the us probably has similar tech. Imagine being the most wanted person in the us probably like that bbut maybe even worse since they have cameras everywhere
The Chinese have cameras everywhere. I’m sure it would be worse in China.
1984 (the novel by george orwell) is imitating life.
LMAO when Isobel confronts the guy following them. She's the best correspondent on Vice for sure.
And he won't be winning any academy awards.
What a gutsy journalist!
I've never been more worried for a Vice correspondent than when she started following him....she's so fearless....always makes me nervous for her.
@Marxine St.Arline Chinese bot
@Marxine St.Arline chinese bot speak
wtf? I'm a Chinese who was born and raised in a Muslim neighborhood. How did they all vanish? They didn't. Liars.
The footage don't lie
@@sashaaaaaaaaaaaaa333If you look at this weird music and this weird tone, can't you see the orientation of this video? A video can have a completely different meaning just by editing, especially when the author of this video cut the video so fragmented. The truth needs to be seen with your own eyes, and you can buy your own tickets to come to Xinjiang to see it.
@@ziyi-nails Id there a cahnce that you are a Chinese troll and how do you access youtube. Of course the government gave you access. And if you have VPN you are very brave. There are camps for uyghur and there is footages. wHat do you do with that much people. They weren't happy in there. The women that escaped told all you did to preganat women. Just disgusting.
What? It has been proven by multiple different reputable sources that the Muslim Uyghurs of Xinjiang have been prosecuted and turned into slaves or killed. to say that that is not happening just off of personal experience is ignorant. The fact that journalists have to be approved by the government to speak on this speaks volumes.
did u watch the video.. or?
The amount of psychological damage that is going to happen to those poor children.
@Natasel so killing is ok but not using plane right.. got your point
@Natasel Wow bro, chill. First of all there is nothing with being a Muslim just like there is nothing wrong with being a Chinese. I won't start hating all Chinese just because China keeps claiming the region I live in as theirs (which they do btw).
Who cares they are already brainwashed
Natasel Are you on drugs?
@No No Really nothing could probably change your mindset, because you are misguided.
Islam has poor representatives in general, but not entirely. One thing that I should clarify to you is that there is a big difference between terrorism and Islam.
Say something against it, you will watch me prove you wrong.
That lady crying over her children is heartbreaking
Glasgow 420 Dude time stamp?
21:30
21:20*
The sad thing is that even if the children are reunited with the parent, they will be too indoctrinated to love or understand their parents and their plight anymore. Or maybe even their language.
雷肯佐 the Christian bible, nor any religion book is very ummm “terrorist” like. But not to the extreme of Islam
They can literally pin point what train you were on and look for that man! Like this should’ve been more well thought out showing faces
Gee Santini get some help. Like seriously, seek professional help for your dangerous mindset.
@Gee Santini How delusional can you get?
@Gee Santini Do you kiss your mother with that stupidity?
When it's fake journalism you don't need to take those precautions because there are literally no risks. I'm surprised u gave Vice that much credit in the first place! Anyway I make vids straight out of China in case you're sick of all this bash-China propaganda lol
numuves copy paste everywhere lmao who’s the propaganda now
This is so fucked up. What a lie
and this fucked up lie gets 11million view, hypercritical world lmaoo
My heart dropped when the class president said his sister has been gone for two years.
Spread awareness ❤
Same
I hate the CCP so much
@Dayou Su did u get ur 50 cents
@Laura Cannon, somehow it gives us a glimmer of hope that the kid is not ignorance of what have happens to her family, her neighborhood and her community. That awareness is so precious.
Next on vice "China's vanishing overseas reporters."
lol
They already do. It's not unusual for people to "disappear" in places like Hong Kong only to reappear on the Mainland in an interrogation room confessing to crimes against the state.
@@taoliu3949 damn
No need for that,they can make story in anywhere in the world.
@Fabian Hofbauer, At least in China no journalist is put in jail for long time for "breaching" his/her bail condition. Have you ever heard about Julian Assange? How old are you boy?
Damn, this made me on edge the whole time. They took a risk on this one.
Being an American midea they need scary stories to sell.
Other vlogers have not a lot issues filming in Xinjiang, why west midea alway's have? Think about it.
@Shaq Kobe Same thing but since they don't make up a large portion it just gets lumped with the Muslims.
@Justa Computa well Muslims are the targetttt geez. Let them have some exposure
At 10:00 , the translation should not be "Kill Kill Kill". This sentence has no meaning, but serves as a rhythmic particle.
This is clear violation of human rights, and serves as an example of corruption and evil in is purist form.
Liberty Prime Vice has awesome documentaries about corrupted countries, Mexico for example if you’re interested
Rote Blaubeere, I don’t know it’s pretty corrupt to assassinate people you disagree with.
< Terrorist sympathizer spotted!
Joking aside. Here is your answer.
I've been educating the mass and it's getting tiring. Please make it worth my time.
Disclaimer: The below source contain bloody photo of civilians corpses, shred from the explosion by suicide bombers.
"How do the Chinese people feel about Xinjiang reeducation camps" ?
Roma Hudson: We'll feel safe
First of all, I need to explain that I know a lot of information about Xinjiang re education camp and have watched the reports of BBC and New York Times. I haven't received brainwashing, which is often a misunderstanding of the Chinese people in other countries.
First of all, the same event, when you use a different perspective to explain it, will have a completely different impact.
The following news reports about many violent attacks in Xinjiang.All of these incidents happened before the construction of the education camp.
May 22, 2014: an explosion occurred in the morning market of Gongyuan North Street, saybak District, Urumqi, which is a serious violent terrorist case of extremely bad nature. It is preliminarily understood that at about 7:50 on May 22, the mob drove two vehicles to break through the protective fence, smashed and crushed the crowd, detonated the explosive device, killing 31 people and injuring 94.
2014-5-1: an explosion occurred in the South Station of Urumqi railway, which was a serious violent terrorist attack. The mob held a knife to kill the people at the pick-up place at the exit of the South Station of Urumqi railway, and detonated the explosive device at the same time, causing 3 deaths and 79 injuries, including 4 serious injuries.
March 1, 2014: 29 people were killed and 130 relatives were injured in a serious terrorist incident at Kunming railway station. More than 10 uniformed thugs, wearing masks and knives, killed innocent people in Kunming Railway Station Square, ticket office and other places.
2014-02-14: two people and seven policemen were injured in a police attack in Wushi County, Xinjiang. Eight people were killed and one was arrested by the police. Three suspects were killed in a suicide bombing at the time of the crime.
January 24, 2014: an explosion occurred in a beauty salon and a vegetable market in Xinhe County, Aksu District, Xinjiang, killing one person and injuring two others. The public security officials quickly sent out police to deal with the situation and arrested three suspects. During the containment of a suspicious vehicle, the vehicle exploded and two people were killed.
On January 26, the public security officials were attacked by rioters throwing explosive devices in the process of handling the violent terrorist cases in Xinhe County on January 24. Police killed 6 rioters and captured 5. 6 rioters died of self explosion when they committed crimes. One police officer was slightly injured and no casualties were found. A batch of explosive devices and crime tools were seized.
On December 30, the Public Security Bureau of Shache County in Kashgar region of Xinjiang was attacked by violence and terrorism. Nine violent terrorists attacked with machetes, threw explosive devices and set fire to police cars. Police decisively dealt with it, killing 8 people and catching 1.
On December 25, the "12.15" terrorist attacks in Shufu County, Xinjiang
At about 23:00 on December 15, when the police of Shufu County Public Security Bureau in Kashi District of Xinjiang arrested the criminal suspect in saybage Township, several mobs threw explosive devices and attacked with machetes, resulting in the death of two police officers. Police have decisively dealt with it, killing 14 rioters. They have arrested 6 suspects and seized a batch of explosive devices, self-made guns, knives, etc.
According to the preliminary determination of the police, the "12.15" case of Shufu County in Kashgar, Xinjiang is an organized and premeditated violent terrorist attack. Since August this year, a terrorist gang with 20 members has gradually formed, led by Aishan Simayi. The group has gathered for many times to watch violent and terrorist videos, publicize religious extremist ideas, manufacture explosive devices and guns, conduct trial explosions several times, and premeditate violent and terrorist activities.
On November 16, police station in Selibuya Town, Bachu county was attacked
At about 17:30 on November 16, 2013, nine thugs, including abraahiti, attacked the police station in Selibuya Town, Bachu county with swords and axes, resulting in the death of two policemen.
Besides these, there are hundreds more. It can be said that these violent terrorist attacks led to the destruction of local people's lives in Xinjiang.
I have to mention two major terrorist attacks. These two things have changed the whole Chinese view of Xinjiang.
1.July 5, 2009 serious violence in Urumqi
Urumqi is the capital of Xinjiang. It was a peaceful day. But many Uighurs began to march on the streets, and then began to kill people and make fire. Even the old people who took the bus to the park for a walk were not spared.
This is a photo recorded by passers-by with mobile phone. The mob did no difference to innocent civilians
The violence killed 197 people, 1721 people were injured. most of them Han. A large number of Han shops were robbed and cars burned down. I once watched a video that the western media never published: those violent people cut at the sight of people, blood flowed on the ground, and then the army came, and they still rushed forward, until the army fired in order to prevent the self-defense warning, they were shot to the ground.
I've experienced Tibetan riots, and I know the horror of religious fanatics losing their think.
I used to have a little bit of hope for them until it happened.
2.March 1, 2014: terrorist attack on Kunming Railway Station
The capital city, which is 4100 kilometers away by train, is a complex railway station where every civilian has been destroyed. The mob carries a pig killing knife. When he sees someone, he will cut it. (this is exactly the same way as the genocide in Rwanda)The terrorist attack killed 31 people and injured 141.
Kunming citizens are praying. The slogan means: don't cry in Kunming
Every Chinese is afraid. Because terrorism has gone out of Xinjiang. Even if they are far away, they will still happen. And all people are afraid of their actions, because they kill people indiscriminately and without reason at all. As a result, almost all citizens choose to support the government to take a stronger approach.
At the same time, through this incident, I have known the double standards of Western media.
On the left is the Kunming terrorist attack and on the right is the London terrorist attack on May 22, 2013.
Xinjiang people are flooded with terrorism. They have received training from Al Qaeda. Most terrorists are only finish the junior high school. They are easy to be incited and kill indiscriminately.
Western media ignored the problem. But it still exists, and if it is not solved, more people will die in the future. So China has set up a transformation camp.
The idea was put forward by the team of Chen Quanguo, a former governor of Tibet. There were frequent violent attacks in Tibet, but he managed it successfully.
The education camp has new and good facilities. They can play basketball and watch movies. In the BBC Documentary, we can see their national dance performances. The government provides them with job training and ideological education to prevent them from being affected by extremism again.
Even after visiting the education camp, many Islamic ambassadors expressed their support for China.
Only the West has been opposed.
I don't deny the problems in the re education camp. If you want to ask me if I have been mistreated, I think there will be, after all, the contradictions among ethnic groups have been intensified. But this is not officially allowed, and abusive managers will be severely punished. The Chinese government does not want to deepen the hatred among nations again. At the same time, these education camps cost a lot of taxpayer money and created a high-pressure atmosphere in Xinjiang. But it's all bitter. We need to swallow it. I don't know if these camps will work in the long run. I think Chinese government officials still need to improve their policies and attitudes and improve their relations with Uighurs. But like most Chinese, I still support the re education camp. When the whole region is in violence, only this measure of the government can protect my safety. I don't want to be cut to death when I go out to eat one day, which happened every day in Xinjiang.In addition, at least until August 2019, Xinjiang has not had a terrorist attack in 23 months.
I believe that security as a law-abiding citizen is more important than the human rights of terrorists.
Source
www.quora.com/How-do-the-Chinese-people-feel-about-Xinjiang-reeducation-camps/answer/Roma-Hudson-1?ch=99&share=3aea0ca8&srid=hHBzG
Fighting terrorism in Xinjiang
ruclips.net/video/u4cYE6E27_g/видео.html
@@condorX2 It's almost like people don't like being forced to live under authoritarian regimes that murder and imprison them for expressing their desires to not live under authoritarian regimes. Nah, it's gotta be their religion or something, even though non-Chinese muslims are apparently super supportive of the CCP.
@@remembertotakeshowerspleas355 Wow! I didn't expect to get a rational reply on this outlet. I'm impressed with your respond of the justifications to violence by disrupting and killing ordinary civilians in the name of independent.
Speaking of killing, what's your opinion on the war on terrors by the US? It still raging on for 19 years as we speak. And the Muslim civilian deaths are over millions. Do you prefer bombing campaign or none violence re-education camps? And I quote.
Brown University’s Costs of War Project this month released a new estimate of the total death toll from the U.S. wars in three countries: Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. The numbers, while conservatively estimated, are staggering. Brown’s researchers estimate that at least 480,000 people have been directly killed by violence over the course of these conflicts, more than 244,000 of them civilians. In addition to those killed by direct acts violence, the number of indirect deaths - those resulting from disease, displacement, and the loss of critical infrastructure - is believed to be several times higher, running into the millions.
Source
theintercept.com/2018/11/19/civilian-casualties-us-war-on-terror/
WTF!!!!! This should be on front page of youtube for everyone.
ruclips.net/video/EovpQE6dZeE/видео.html
You would think all the Muslim countries would go to there aid, but they have been quite, I wonder why, ???
I know right? This is almost like some dystopia movie...
@@millzy9460 lol
This is stupid . if they want war we will give you war
21:15 Beautiful moment when the baby noticed his mom was sad and comforted her.
RakkasanMedic it’s so sad
@@Zatvornik Our cover is blown.
@@Zatvornik Absolute nutjob you are.
@@tw3ist , If you do some simple googling, you will find out that central doctrine and sole goal of Islam is physical extermination of every single non-Muslim man, woman and child by cutting of their heads. It is written in their book in plain Arabic, and it also says there that all teachings of Mohammed must be taken literally. So my question is: would you stand up for Nazis? Because Islam is nothing short of religious fascism!
@TheCrazyKid1381 , firstly, what is false exactly in my statement? Second, your screen name is totally on point, because religion is a last resort of stupid, crazy and weak... Modern civilization is way beyond it, and as of you trashing white people, do not forget who created the Internet you are trashing them on, the clothes you are wearing, food that you eat, the whole world of things that you live in...
I live in an ethnic minority area in the interior of China, where the conflict between ethnic minorities and communism is less obvious than on the frontiers. Partly because of industrialization and population movement (younger generations go to other cities to go to school)
I don't think China has a problem with ethnic minorities. The problem is with religion, especially Islam, which is simply incompatible with the communist party and with the main population. The Islamic religion has the problem of inability for muslims to merge with other people through marriage without others converting to Islam. This necessarily means that, through long time, either Islam takes over the country/region, or is taken out by force. Any third option of coexistence is simply temporary and hoping it lasts is delusional. This can already be seen in European nations that have serious conflicts between muslims and the secular society. Without dramatic policy changes, most European democracies will eventually be voted to become Islamic nations practicing Islamic laws due to demographic changes in a few decades.
Have you ever thought about this is probably not because of government, but it’s because of stronger culture? Just like more and more people study English and live a life like western, wear a jeans instead of Chinese traditional clothes. Can we say that is cultural invasion from America or uk?
i'd be extremely terrified walking around even if i didn't have a camera... this is some scary shit
They should have sent that "Clueless White guy" who orders in perfect Chinese.
He could evade the cops by ordering dumplings in Fuzhounese and blowing their minds.
LOL
XioamaNYC :P
Interesting fact:The dude also banned in Chinese websites
LOLLLLLL
@@jeongminio you mean that food guy ? Trevor something ?
my heart raced when she started confronting the man in black, so brave!!
They are police. Why would anyone be afraid of Police tho?
@Peng Qian They arent. Chinese citizins get 100+ social credit when they rat out crime. This could allow him to get him a 3th child or use public transport. Don't judge him. Judge the system
She should have followed the black man
@@pengqian2132 these aren’t friendly American police officers, these guys will beat you and do bad things to you because it’s corrupt and they can get away with it.
@@Ayeato Hahahaha, alright then. Thank you for you kindness tho. lol
Much respect to this brave WOMEN for the job they try and have done on this story. Humanity 😢
😂不要被欺骗了，这都是谎言，你亲自来中国一趟感受一下。
@@生在中国的小粉红Chinese bot😂
This is so crazy to watch; the fact that this is still happening and there are most definitely millions of people still in "re-education" camps...
coming to america soon if the dems get their way
@UCzJS0Xn7lyX0WCiuTZxNlKQ we are worse then the chinese government? speak out against the uiger genocide and concentration camps... wait u cant because you will go to jail, in fact ypu are using a VPN to avoid detection in order to use youtube...
and they say they are NOT terrorists ?
@@annehopkins2079 what do u mean?
@@rashidamiri258: she doesn't know pay her know mind.
One of the best pieces of journalism I’ve seen. This girl is so good.
And the world does business with China , still. Go figure.
Ggcc Dcjjmmk and Saudi Arabia
@No No are you trying to say that what china is doing isn't inhumane
@No No okay you are a terrible human being. In what world is it okay to jail millions, because of a few bad people.
@No No I'm not crying, I'm just perplexed by your ignorance
This reminds me of the early days of Vice. Not a big fan of where they've ended up, but good Lord this is phenomenal journalism.
@Jonny Sandtrap Islam has it share of problems, but it is not sociopathic communism that will solve that.
@Jonny Sandtrap yes Islam is bad so lets send people who practice it to concentration camps. Hope you can see the issue on that.
@Jonny Sandtrap 1.8 billion people are muslims in the world. If they all believed in bad things and terrorism then it would be the greatest army in history and america/the west wouldnt be standing. Your own home would probably be blown to bits. And tell me why their was no "islam is bad opinion" before 2001? before 2001, for the 1400 years islam has existed, NO ONE in the world had a problem with islam as a religion, how come this "islam is bad" view has only resurfaced as of 2 decades? Your delusional and have just shown your level of education and ability for basic reasoning and logic.
Flouride Productions literally has been friction between the west and Islam since Islam began. All of Europe thought Islam was bad
Towerofbauer - I see you skipped your history lessons, so here’s a brief one: The west only revolutionized within the past 300 years or so, before that the Islamic empire was the symbol of human advancement. Europe was plunged in the dark and Middle Ages. Dieseas and unhygienic conditions were widespread . The church conducting horrific experiments, overall Europe was pretty backwards.
However the Islamic empire was consistently making advancements in medicine, astronomy, mathematics and science which without Newton and Galleleo may not have made their advancements and many of the things you know of today may not have existed. Combine this with centralized and humane laws, good courts and a good economy and you got yourself the most developed empire in the world at that time. At the time did the muslims blame all christians as backwards because the church was? NO. Unlike society nowadays they helped them. Islamic scholars spread their ideologies to the west and kickstarted its advancement. It’s a shame that this advancement ceased to exist after the empire got sucked into wars after which all this ended.
If you are aware of the Uighur terrorist attack at the Kunming train station and the riots in Urumqi that killed 156 innocent people, you will understand this situation better.
just stop worshiping idols 😅
The west doesn’t want to mention that, they love twist stories
@@noris1238u sound ignorant I am Muslim but telling someone to change their views is what causing. This issue everyone should stay and worry about their own community rather than trying to force anything on others
@@Ggbpirne I agree. Out of curiosity, would you support others of your religion that are extremists?
I had the privilege of befriending a Uyger woman when we were both at college. I live in a small Appalachian town of 2400 people and she was the first person that introduced me to a different world view. She would tell me about how awful it was in China and that she can’t see or talk with any of her family back in Xinjiang. This clip really highlighted how horrible the Uygers are treated. So sad
if she back to old home(without ccp), she need stay in home, dress black, no education, no Love marriage, if she dare love anyone who not appointed by his father, she will be die. so you happy for that?
@8dzenja6 no, is more like after American Civil War, one master kid goto China, tell ppl she was persecuted. but 20 million slaves don't think so, but they r too poor to speak out.
tank tang they not that strict and no education? Wdym just look at malaysian or brunei muslims
@@vatem9870 if anyone need run to other country, then must is that type family. because, live in China is not a hard thing for normal Muslims.
@@tanktang4018 lmao, you believe in that stereotypes that your government drilled your butthole with? damn, these bots are brainwashed. While I'm here freely driving a car and dating a dude. Yep, I'm oppressed alright
"This is a Kindergarden.... noone is supposed to go in !"
The most shocking tho, was the support of some people, like the woman in the train. She talked like a real Nazi
She is not the minority who has that kind of thinking in China. In fact, most of people think like her. They just straightly think the people from Xinjiang are problematic.
Or she knew she was being recorded...what else was she supposed to say?
@@modernmodest5659 i doubt it
@@ccczqqq While Im against such actions: the truth is there were many incidents in Xinjiang with violence/terrorism. I saw videos on liveleak for many years with Uighurs stabbing e.g. pregnant Han Chinese women in the Bus in the belly, to death etc.
Tobias what are your sources? You have links or reference?
The conversation you had with the lady on the train really put it into perspective how the han majority think of the minorities. This was a great documentary. Also very scary how they were following you the second trip especially the man in black he was so obvious.
Yup, the minorites need to be uplifted so that they could have better standard of living.
Imagine trying to do business but you cant speak the language. Or couldnt do basic math...
The woman herself said that she was a farmer - in China it basically means that she is uneducated, and she herself stated that she interacts only with the Han Chinese, how could you expect her to give an objective answer?
The man following her looks like a Uighur.
@@eleethtahgra7182 with all due respect, the uyghur cutoff on the gaokao is 35% lower than the han chinese one, meaning someone could go to pku or one of the top colleges with the equivalent of a 1100 on the SAT
@@governoret
Meaning the uyghur could enter good college with lower grade compared to the hans?