This was me. Years of combat finally caught up with me. PTSD broke me one day and led to a decade of addiction and imprisonment. I lost everything I cared about. In desperation I sat with a pistol in my lap and cried out to a God I didn't even believe in to help me or I was checking out. I still suffer from PTSD but now I help other veterans suffering the same. I have a beautiful wife and family and God has restored everything I lost and more. I owe him everything. I was looking at my young grandaughter today, who I love so deeply and realised that without God not only would I never have met her but she wouldn't even exist.
That song always makes me cry. My Daddy was Sam Stone but his name was Glen Allen Williams. He popped his last balloon in August, 1978. I found John Prines album in his collection which made me as a 15 year old , able to kind of understand that it really wasn't Daddy's fault. I never doubted that he loved me, just kind of mad that he left me.
Reading what you wrote here took me right back to the first time I heard this song in 1971, back when many of my classmates were "coming home" - and every time I've heard it since. Your Daddy loved you - don't be mad, he beat himself up enough back then.
John Prine was an American treasure. This is without doubt the most poignant song ever written about the Vietnam War. I am 76 years old, served in that war, and have never a more powerful song on the subject. Just shows you don't need to scream or curse... gentle, but truthful words, can be searing. A shot straight to the heart - if you're got one. RIP John Prine.
Beg to differ, Art. I'm pretty sure I've heard John say in interviews this was all about Viet Nam -- which would make more sense, too, as I doubt coming out with a heroin addiction was an issue in the Korean War (or nowhere near as prevalent, as this was a generational thing, for the most part). Obviously, John mentions the Korean War in the song, Hello in There, but that's an entirely unrelated connection. ♫♪
Sam stone is a CLASSIC!! My mom say's everytime i played sam stone, she'd say how depressing it is. BUT, ILL NEVER EVER GET TIRED OF IT!! And, there's dear abby, angel from Montgomery!! And, im too stoned to remember the rest of his material!! And what a shame, to die of this, FUCKING BULL SHIT DISEASE!! I DISPISE WTF IS GOING ON IN THIS FUCKED UP WORLD!! 😡😡
I first saw John in 1972. He continues to astonish and humble me. John wrote this song when kids were still calling vets "babykillers." I cannot say how many times i have listened to Sam Stone, but it still makes me cry.
I came home after 3 tours in Vietnam. I was lucky as a member of UDT and SEAL Team that my time in combat was honorable, justified and not deeply scarring to my soul. Went back to school at the University of Buffalo. Had a basement apartment that was more like a bunker than an apartment. That's when I discovered John Prine. Between Prine and Kris Kristofferson I found solace, redemption and a measure of hope. John's words touched and tickled me at the same time. God damn, he can sure turn a phrase! Sam Stone isn't a "happy" song but it sure touched a cord with me even though I was never troubled with those demons. Living off the GI Bill in those days meant lots of hot dogs & rice for meals and some cheap red wine now and then for a little self-medication. Then I'd put John on the record player and listen on headphones (so as not to disturb the folks upstairs). A great singer/songwriter like John is like a coach/teacher who touches the lives of so many and yet never realizes the depths to which they have connected with other souls. John, you may be gone but your songs and spirit will live forever. RIP Fellow Veteran!
You're the only Vietnam Vet I've heard say anything remotely similar...maybe you weren't infantry? Maybe you didnt see death up close? My Dad Platoon Sgt Rattelade (aka Sgt Rock) of Wolfhounds was called back the day after he left to ID his men who were blown to pieces shortly after he departed for Thailand.
@@heatherrattelade1178 I served 1 tour with Underwater Demolition Team 13 and 2 tours with SEAL Team One as OIC of direct action platoons. My respects to your Dad for his service. At the end of my 2nd tour I had to ID my point man and 4 other SEAL's killed in a helo crash. On my last tour my point man was killed by a mine as he searched an area. So yes I did see death up close and very personal. I consider my service and the sacrifice of my Teammates to have been honorable.
@Rick Eckler You may be absolutely right but leave the man alone. As a mental health nurse I could almost guarantee he has more demons than you will ever know. You don't lecture a man dying of emphysema about the dangers of smoking. Talk to others if you must, educate them towards a better world but this man has earned his peace.
I have no idea how John Prine flew under my radar until his passing. I searched him on RUclips and I am now completely obsessed with his music and lyrics.
Eric Olson. I found John Prine first on CBS Sunday Morning and was completely taken in by him and his music. Then I saw his 2018 Austin City Limits show. I became a full fledged fan of the man and his music. I'm so bummed that I didn't know about John Prine until he passed. So sad. So I know what you are feeling. Actually his 2018 ACL show was an encore performance just tonight on my PBS station. Happy and sad for the man and his music and our loss.
Same here. Just discovered him, and I’m pissed I didn’t much sooner. Yet his songs always hit me right in the feels.Every time. This man was Truly Amazing.
Ive listen to John since i was 9 an have been happy in my heart when i hear his voice. He will nevef be forgotten an will be new again.if that makes any sense
My first song I heard from John Prine in 1974. Been listening ever since. Had to recite a poem in American Lit class (many years later) written by an American writer. I chose Sam Stone. I had to practice so I could recite it and not sing. The class was silent. I nailed it. Thank you John Prine.
“Jesus Christ died for nothing I suppose” - one of the greatest lines. You have to be able to forgive yourself. I say this as someone who hates war and has spent my life fighting it. But soldiers have to forgive themselves and take up cause of peace rather than self destruct.
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
I just discovered John Prine yesterday at 26 years old. I want to thank one of my favorite artists Nathaniel Rateliff for introducing me to John Prine. He covered his song named “Pretty Good”
A lot of us had John Prine 8 tracks and album's back then and this is a reality with a lot of Nam vets but Jesus is real and He is still setting captivs free
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
Makes me think of my friend Gordon Kawasaki who served with the 101st Airborne in Nam. Came back disillusioned with the War. Take a hill fall back, take a hill fall back violent no sense conflict. Came back with a monkey on his back he couldn't shake and purposely overdosed 4th of July 1988. R I.P. to all those who served and suffered.
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
John Prine was a great musician, one of my favorite times seeing him was at the tribute to Levon Helm, of the Band. at the midnight ramble at the Barn. he and Roger Waters performed among others and it was AWESOME!!!! then when the pandemic happened I heard that he got the virus. and he was in the hospital for about four or five days. and it was looking like was going to pull out of it. and then he took a turn for the worse and he died. it was definitely sad and it was a shame. and it shouldn't have happened to him. there were a lot of people that died from the covid virus that didn't have to. because of the fearless leader we had at the time. and that's all I'm going to say about that. John Prine was a great musician that left us too soon. it's a terrible shame and he will definitely be missed very much.
Don't be fooled by the numbers on Covd-19. I read where a man went in for a broken leg and they also listed him as a Covid-19 patient. Seriously. And it's CHINA VIRUS.
Thinking of all the Vets. The homeless so sad. I can't make it through this song without crying. Thank you to all the veterens you are loved and appreciated more than you know.
Had i heard this song 2 weeks ago i wouldnt have even listened to it. Listening to this exactly 1 week after my best friend relapsed and overdosed at 33.. I feel these lyrics deep in my heart. Rest in paradise Derek. I want you to know i love you and i wont forget you till the day im with you 💔🙏 4/18/90 - 2/28/24
My dear departed husband was one of John’s early fans. He was a Vietnam Nam veteran and this song was his favorite. I hope that he is able to survive COVID19 and stay with us for many years to come. There will never be another songwriter/singer as good as John.
RIP BROTHER John Prine one of the best in the world and overlooked by most. You can sing Merle and Johnny tonight. We love you man we needed alot more like you.
I remember hearing this for the first time somewhere around 1977-78. When life was fun, innocent and before the talons of my demons had me in the clutches. I understood the story in the song, but couldn't relate to Sam Stone's struggle. That was until 1989. I hit that place they call it a jumping off point. I couldn't take it anymore. I'd lost it all. Mostly I lost my sanity and the ability to realize reality. I still listen to this song, but today I know Sam's struggles. A John Prine song can put a smile on your face and a chorus later rip your heart out. A true master of his craft, Gods speed Mr Prine. You will forever be remembered. RIP...
In the latter 1970s I was a tree-trimmer in Memphis. We would climb high above the power lines with our ropes, limbing saws, and pole-pruners...3 climbers in the treetops singing John Prine songs as we did our craft. Strenuous, dangerous work that. “Sam Stone” was a favorite. God bless John.
This is such an amazing song. It says a lot about the Vietnam war. I wished our government learned from this but they didn’t. We have the Gulf war. When will we get it right 😢😢
John Prine has the ability to tell a complete story of a historical event like the Viet Nam war in five minutes in Sam Stone. He was an absolute master at putting his lyrical brush to canvas and creating a Mona Lisa.
Kris Kristofferson when he first heard John he said this guy is to deep at such a young age.His music is so true and moving there want be another John Prine.
This song is so beautiful and truthful , My mother and father were in nursing homes during the pandemic , I met many residents in these facilities , just saying hi and acknowledging them , their eyes lit up , that they mattered, Prine was one of our greatest songwriters
I remember all those wasted empty youthful days. We had what we called John Prine parties and at 15 l guessed that was our protest. Emotions run high on these re-runs. R.I.P. brothers.
@@CRyan71 means he was so high on drugs that it was no longer giving him a good feeling. Just my guess but it makes sense since he is talking about a lethal overdose. I can't imagine that is very pleasant... and " to he climbing walls" means to be suffering unpleasant feelings in an extreme way. So whilst he may simply appear to be sitting in a chair, inside he must be going through hell. That's my interpretation
@@CRyan71 I think it means that he was going through withdrawals and feelings anxious, feeling like he was climbing the walls. Then he takes his last fix and dies.
DangerDan I share your interpretation as well, also that this idea is oxymoronic because you can’t move up a wall while sitting so it’s clever in that sense.
If I've played this song once, I've played it a 1000 times.. When I perform at this one private venue, I'm "ALWAYS" asked to play some JP and I happily oblige because in my opinion, there has "NEVER" been a better singer/writer and person to follow then John Prine... RIP my friend
There but for the grace of God go I. Had a tough time after my return for Vietnam, but was fortunate enough not to get hooked on drugs. This song always reminds me of how lucky I am. Thanks John. RIP.
My sense of humor has saved me more than a couple of times in my life," Prine says. "If I can make myself laugh about something that I should be crying about, that's pretty good." RIP JP
Nope. John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
There's a whole in daddy's arm where all the money goes..... ..... that line pulls at my heart so hard. It's weird because my father didn't have any drug problems.
Mdpat the postman always delivers. My sense of humor has saved me more than a couple of times in my life," Prine says. "If I can make myself laugh about something that I should be crying about, that's pretty good." RIP JP
Dang, I heard this song probably 45 years ago in Victoria BC Canada, didn't get it, never did drugs, never served, but today living I think I get it, as I have friends with PTSD, and a tad myself, wow is all I can say,
I was born in 78, this song has always reminded me of my Papa who came back from vietnam with a hole in his arm where all the money went. Ofcourse I didn’t find this out until I was 10ish, he’s now deceased but I loved him with all of his troubles. War is ugly & destroys lives and families around the world. Figured I’d listen in tribute to Veterans Day 🇺🇸
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
What an excellent artist. Most people never really got exposed to his music. His music provides a certain peace when you just listen to it. It is hard to explain, but if you listen to alot of his music you understand what I am saying. Not many artists like him these days.
I've listened to this 100's of times, since the first time, that line, hole in daddy's arm, then Jesus died for nothin, I suppose, that is the most grabbing line of any song from any writer.
The most beautiful song about mental illness. I understand it's about war vets and give all respect to them. But also reminds me of my husband who died of mental illness when our daughter was 15 months old. Thank you Mr Prine. Special place in heaven for you Sir
Was busking with some friends (about 40 years ago) and this biker-looking guy requests "Sam Stone". We were in the middle of some other song so the fiddle player says .... "Sure, right after this song". The biker guy says .... "No, play it right now!" We all stopped mid-song and began almost in unison .... "There's a hole in Daddy's arm .... " Told this story many times and still remember the experience like it was yesterday. Thank-you John Prine for the powerful music.
Too many, far to many are still in I Corps, the Central Highlands or the Delta. Lost one in June after he struggled for decades. We all found out that for a lot of 11bravos or 0311's its never over.
The world has lost a great artist but more importantly a human who cared. His music empathised with all going through the pain and suffering of life. A beacon and an example to what we should aspire to. Ar dheis de go raibh a anam.
He wrote this one on his mail route after he got out of the Army. What an amazing talent. Side note, Jesus Christ died and rose again to end the suffering in the end.
Wow, what a great version of a beautiful song. I know and love it from the album version but this is even better, he gets so much emotion into it. I hope all you Americans appreciate and look after this guy, he's a national treasure if ever there was one.
He is indeed a national treasure! I started listening to him in the early ‘70s, thanks to my older sister’s albums. He was a lifeline of sanity tossed to this lonely, midwestern kid. He widened my view of the world. Yeah, sometimes things are messed up...if this guy sees it and made it through then maybe I could, too. Music is magic. John Prine is one of our most-skilled magicians. I wish our society valued musicians more and paid them better.
Good people are never no further away from us then a thought , a memory , a dream. they are what makes our next day better then our last. They've only been borrowed for a while.
As great as he was as a musician his lasting image will be that of a grounded, down-to-earth, beautiful human being. He made a HUGE mark in this world and will be greatly missed. I had a college roommate get me into John Prine around forty years ago although his type of music wasn't what I would normally listen to at the time. I was attracted to his biting, poignant, often funny lyrics. What a talent. RIP, John.
I came back from Nam in July of 1967. When I first heard this in the early 70’s, I was sure he had been there. He summed up the loss that so many of us felt and the anguish we had experienced.
RIP, Mr. Prine -- my life wouldn't have been the same without your painfully naked insights weaved so brilliantly in all your lyrics. It's a sad day sitting here today, mourning your passing, but I still have a wry smile on my face, mindful of your grace-filled view of this 'Big Old Goofy World' -- a bittersweet perspective on the short time we all have on this earth. Just keep smilin' that big ol' Illegal Smile in that 'already overcrowded' heaven you're sure to be in! ♫♪
I would like to have been in Chicago in the early 70's,when John Prine,Steve Goodman,and Jimmy Buffet were basically living together,trying to out-drink each other,out-write each other,and having each others back.Two of them are gone now.
I’m sure that John is playing in heaven right now not as a headliner but on some beautiful mountain overlooking a fast moving stream with an old dog by his side and a few thousand lovers of his music tapping their toes and remembering days gone by… Never another like you John Prine…
We played John Prine's music constantly in the 70s; brings back so many memories. His voice is one in a million. Then we were fortunate enough to see him with Bonnie Raitt in Memphis in the mid-80s. The entire audience sang along with every song he played, and he wore the biggest grin the entire set! LOVE YOU JOHN! Attention everyone! Please vote for John as inductee in the Rock and Roll Hall of fame! He deserves it so much... love always! xoxo
"...and the gold rolled through his veins, like a thousand railroad trains..." VERY powerful lyrics! That's exactly what it's like. The whole song is spot on.
Poetry In Motion:) 29 yrs Sober,Drug free lead me HERE :) As an addict I interpret the words from that side, as a Survivor I hear & feel it From the LIVING side !! :) As a Poet I feel the words !! Addiction sux !!Life-styles CAN change ! I rarely say it BUT I offer MYSELF as proof !!! :) Offer support where you can !BUT people have to WANT change,!!"Peace Takes Practice" r.i.p. John Prine. Rick
What i miss about the 60's and 70's is musicians that can pinpoint the issues of everyday folk and make you think hard about what is going on. It is human history in a song.
@Chris Kozak Not very personal, though. Southern Man is another anti-white rant. I'm not surprising he's joined with Pfizer and the money people Neil Young sold half of his catalogue to Merck Mercuriadis’ Hipgnosis Song Management company on January 6, 2021. Later that year, Hipgnosis merged with Blackstone in a $1 billion deal. A month before the merger, Blackstone announced that they appointed Pfizer’s former Chairman and CEO, Jeffrey B Kindler, as the company’s Senior Advisor.
I don't know where I was, but I spent my whole life listening to country music and never heard of John Prine until after his death. What a shame. I love his simple rhythms with heart felt stories. It reminds me of Cash, but for some reason I enjoy Prine more.
A name vaguely in my mind once or twice, a whisper indirect via RUclips, or in a comment, but someone just today said I should listen to this gent. Four songs in and I wonder: where the hell has my brain been all these long years? Wow.
Thank you Lord Jesus, John Prine revealed an issue,that can happen to anyone, let us pray for all the Sam Stone or Jane Stone,God keep them strong ,and raise them back up on their feet. Just remember,When your back on your feet,and you will get back on your feet, as long as you Try,your always Recovering, never Recovered but you can do it.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
This was me. Years of combat finally caught up with me. PTSD broke me one day and led to a decade of addiction and imprisonment. I lost everything I cared about. In desperation I sat with a pistol in my lap and cried out to a God I didn't even believe in to help me or I was checking out. I still suffer from PTSD but now I help other veterans suffering the same. I have a beautiful wife and family and God has restored everything I lost and more. I owe him everything. I was looking at my young grandaughter today, who I love so deeply and realised that without God not only would I never have met her but she wouldn't even exist.
Keep looking up for the angels of loved ones are watching over, believe :o) !
God bless you Sir🙏
It seems we have to hit rock bottom before we cry out to the Lord. He is always there to pick us up out of our muck and mire.
Thank you for sacrificing everything and most of of all thank god for using you in a powerful way.
I pray for many who have been through the things similar to what you've been through. Be blessed.
That song always makes me cry. My Daddy was Sam Stone but his name was Glen Allen Williams. He popped his last balloon in August, 1978. I found John Prines album in his collection which made me as a 15 year old , able to kind of understand that it really wasn't Daddy's fault. I never doubted that he loved me, just kind of mad that he left me.
Reading what you wrote here took me right back to the first time I heard this song in 1971, back when many of my classmates were "coming home" - and every time I've heard it since. Your Daddy loved you - don't be mad, he beat himself up enough back then.
Thank you for sharing that, Jeff. May God bless you and your family and your dad, Glen Allen Williams.
Jeff Williams , so sorry.
@glenn davis Combat related PTSD sucks, the drugs are merely the medication.
I’m sorry Jeff. Love you brother. I’m so grateful for narcotics anonymous and my clean time. 12-28-15
I was a Sam Stone after service , got clean in 1976, been clean ever since thanks to this song and GOD
Good for you! Praise God❤
John Prine was an American treasure. This is without doubt the most poignant song ever written about the Vietnam War. I am 76 years old, served in that war, and have never a more powerful song on the subject. Just shows you don't need to scream or curse... gentle, but truthful words, can be searing. A shot straight to the heart - if you're got one. RIP John Prine.
Love you, man.
I haven't either. I cry each and every time I hear this song. Nothing else like it.
God bless you. Thank you for your service.
Thanks Man!
Big Red One '65-71 "Roger That John; thank you
J:P. go rest high on that mountain , man
This sounds so dumb but I’m sittin in a chair listening this to this with my friend and it is incredible. Rest in peace John. Your music continues.
No one ever wrote anything better about the cost of the Vietnam war. Thank-you and farewell John Prine.
Agreed. All the shattered lives. What a waste. Still hurts after 5 decades.
Brian, actually JP was singing about the Korean war / conflict in this song. Many Vietnam vets can relate. Rest in peace JP.
Beg to differ, Art. I'm pretty sure I've heard John say in interviews this was all about Viet Nam -- which would make more sense, too, as I doubt coming out with a heroin addiction was an issue in the Korean War (or nowhere near as prevalent, as this was a generational thing, for the most part). Obviously, John mentions the Korean War in the song, Hello in There, but that's an entirely unrelated connection. ♫♪
I'm guessing Vietnam as well - since he references "grew grass around the brain" - smoking pot more used during/after that conflict overseas.
This was referring to Vietnam. Hello In There refers to Korea. I believe that is where the confusion might lie.
I miss this man. I never met him, but when I play his albums I feel like I am hanging out with a long time friend.
I feel the same and try to introduce him to everyone
How many times can a person listen to John Prine sing Sam Stone before getting tired of it? I'll let you know if I ever find out. 💔
The only bad thing about a John Prine song is that it ends.
Sam stone is a CLASSIC!! My mom say's everytime i played sam stone, she'd say how depressing it is. BUT, ILL NEVER EVER GET TIRED OF IT!! And, there's dear abby, angel from Montgomery!! And, im too stoned to remember the rest of his material!! And what a shame, to die of this, FUCKING BULL SHIT DISEASE!! I DISPISE WTF IS GOING ON IN THIS FUCKED UP WORLD!! 😡😡
I am up over 1,000 probably. Listening again right now.
I first saw John in 1972. He continues to astonish and humble me. John wrote this song when kids were still calling vets "babykillers." I cannot say how many times i have listened to Sam Stone, but it still makes me cry.
@@juglansniger6649 Me too. I listen to Sam Stone pretty much once or twice a week.
I came home after 3 tours in Vietnam. I was lucky as a member of UDT and SEAL Team that my time in combat was honorable, justified and not deeply scarring to my soul. Went back to school at the University of Buffalo. Had a basement apartment that was more like a bunker than an apartment. That's when I discovered John Prine. Between Prine and Kris Kristofferson I found solace, redemption and a measure of hope. John's words touched and tickled me at the same time. God damn, he can sure turn a phrase! Sam Stone isn't a "happy" song but it sure touched a cord with me even though I was never troubled with those demons. Living off the GI Bill in those days meant lots of hot dogs & rice for meals and some cheap red wine now and then for a little self-medication. Then I'd put John on the record player and listen on headphones (so as not to disturb the folks upstairs). A great singer/songwriter like John is like a coach/teacher who touches the lives of so many and yet never realizes the depths to which they have connected with other souls. John, you may be gone but your songs and spirit will live forever. RIP Fellow Veteran!
@Rick Eckler ❤
You're the only Vietnam Vet I've heard say anything remotely similar...maybe you weren't infantry? Maybe you didnt see death up close? My Dad Platoon Sgt Rattelade (aka Sgt Rock) of Wolfhounds was called back the day after he left to ID his men who were blown to pieces shortly after he departed for Thailand.
@@heatherrattelade1178 I served 1 tour with Underwater Demolition Team 13 and 2 tours with SEAL Team One as OIC of direct action platoons. My respects to your Dad for his service. At the end of my 2nd tour I had to ID my point man and 4 other SEAL's killed in a helo crash. On my last tour my point man was killed by a mine as he searched an area. So yes I did see death up close and very personal. I consider my service and the sacrifice of my Teammates to have been honorable.
Here's to you and John Prine. ❤️❤️
@Rick Eckler You may be absolutely right but leave the man alone. As a mental health nurse I could almost guarantee he has more demons than you will ever know. You don't lecture a man dying of emphysema about the dangers of smoking. Talk to others if you must, educate them towards a better world but this man has earned his peace.
Stay strong.. .And bless all who suffered from war.. .Bless them all and you.. .Now and forever
My brother sang John Prine songs. Im so glad he did. Rest in Peace John Prine. Your music is with us forever .
I cried the first time i heard this as a teenager. At 62 i still cry when it plays.
It is hard not to.
I have no idea how John Prine flew under my radar until his passing. I searched him on RUclips and I am now completely obsessed with his music and lyrics.
Try Steve Goodman 2
Eric Olson. I found John Prine first on CBS Sunday Morning and was completely taken in by him and his music. Then I saw his 2018 Austin City Limits show. I became a full fledged fan of the man and his music. I'm so bummed that I didn't know about John Prine until he passed. So sad. So I know what you are feeling.
Actually his 2018 ACL show was an encore performance just tonight on my PBS station. Happy and sad for the man and his music and our loss.
Same here. Just discovered him, and I’m pissed I didn’t much sooner. Yet his songs always hit me right in the feels.Every time. This man was Truly Amazing.
Ive listen to John since i was 9 an have been happy in my heart when i hear his voice. He will nevef be forgotten an will be new again.if that makes any sense
Same here i found this music 2 months ago and haven't. Listen to much except his lately
My first song I heard from John Prine in 1974. Been listening ever since. Had to recite a poem in American Lit class (many years later) written by an American writer. I chose Sam Stone. I had to practice so I could recite it and not sing. The class was silent. I nailed it. Thank you John Prine.
I did the same thing in 2002, i did Wish You Were Here... John, my friend, I wish you were here
funny, I heard him first 1973, a friend said you like Dylan, check him out. Ever since. Not saying I'm old, just mature.
Wreck On The Freeway? 1978 I was 18 at a friend's house when I first heard. Saw him '17 Portland Zoo. Our brother, Roll In Prine RIP
how could you not cry, reciting....
Props to you for finishing, I probably would have lost it and cried in front of the class 😅❤
John Prine was one of the greatest American songwriter of all time. No one could capture the emotion of people's lives like he could. What a genius.
John is, without a doubt, the Ernest Hemingway of story telling singers. RIP my dear friend
you-may-be-wrong-child
Well said. Can paint a picture so beautifully using simple language but poetic structure. Both fantastic storytellers. RIP to both.
I always wanted to talk to you John. Now I never will. Glad to be able to listen
“Jesus Christ died for nothing I suppose” - one of the greatest lines. You have to be able to forgive yourself. I say this as someone who hates war and has spent my life fighting it. But soldiers have to forgive themselves and take up cause of peace rather than self destruct.
Well said. Understandable. God bless
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood.
"If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
I just discovered John Prine yesterday at 26 years old. I want to thank one of my favorite artists Nathaniel Rateliff for introducing me to John Prine. He covered his song named “Pretty Good”
A lot of us had John Prine 8 tracks and album's back then and this is a reality with a lot of Nam vets but Jesus is real and He is still setting captivs free
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood.
"If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
Makes me think of my friend Gordon Kawasaki who served with the 101st Airborne in Nam. Came back disillusioned with the War. Take a hill fall back, take a hill fall back violent no sense conflict. Came back with a monkey on his back he couldn't shake and purposely overdosed 4th of July 1988. R I.P. to all those who served and suffered.
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood.
"If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
I’ve seen lots of musicians come and go in my 64, years, but I shed a tear when John Prine died. Sure miss him...
I saw John In Derry twice and once in Belfast he was singer songwriter legend
John would wish for you to share his music with others. To understand what he was telling us all, in a heart felt lyrics !
Who’s wrote a song as amazing as this on their first album. Little or none. What a songwriter, what a man, what a loss.
John Prine was a great musician, one of my favorite times seeing him was at the tribute to Levon Helm, of the Band. at the midnight ramble at the Barn. he and Roger Waters performed among others and it was AWESOME!!!! then when the pandemic happened I heard that he got the virus. and he was in the hospital for about four or five days. and it was looking like was going to pull out of it. and then he took a turn for the worse and he died. it was definitely sad and it was a shame. and it shouldn't have happened to him. there were a lot of people that died from the covid virus that didn't have to. because of the fearless leader we had at the time. and that's all I'm going to say about that. John Prine was a great musician that left us too soon. it's a terrible shame and he will definitely be missed very much.
So very sad. A haunting song that has lasted for years.
RIP John. We’ll miss ya. To hell with C-19
Fucking plague against humanity
Don't be fooled by the numbers on Covd-19. I read where a man went in for a broken leg and they also listed him as a Covid-19 patient. Seriously. And it's CHINA VIRUS.
Thinking of all the Vets. The homeless so sad. I can't make it through this song without crying. Thank you to all the veterens you are loved and appreciated more than you know.
One of the most amazing pieces of music that I have ever heard
Had i heard this song 2 weeks ago i wouldnt have even listened to it. Listening to this exactly 1 week after my best friend relapsed and overdosed at 33.. I feel these lyrics deep in my heart. Rest in paradise Derek. I want you to know i love you and i wont forget you till the day im with you 💔🙏
4/18/90 - 2/28/24
My dear departed husband was one of John’s early fans. He was a Vietnam Nam veteran and this song was his favorite. I hope that he is able to survive COVID19 and stay with us for many years to come. There will never be another songwriter/singer as good as John.
God bless you Pat. It is my belief that Veteran's families also serve and sacrifice during and after the conflicts.
So thank-you for your service.
Patricia Paquette ...😢🦠
RIP BROTHER John Prine one of the best in the world and overlooked by most. You can sing Merle and Johnny tonight. We love you man we needed alot more like you.
SALUTE ALL SAM STONES
RIP to those gone. My friend was one.
My brother was another
God bless them all.
Wow , dam I am Sam Stone@@markwhite1780
I remember hearing this for the first time somewhere around 1977-78. When life was fun, innocent and before the talons of my demons had me in the clutches. I understood the story in the song, but couldn't relate to Sam Stone's struggle. That was until 1989. I hit that place they call it a jumping off point.
I couldn't take it anymore. I'd lost it all. Mostly I lost my sanity and the ability to realize reality.
I still listen to this song, but today I know Sam's struggles.
A John Prine song can put a smile on your face and a chorus later rip your heart out.
A true master of his craft,
Gods speed Mr Prine. You will forever be remembered. RIP...
In the latter 1970s I was a tree-trimmer in Memphis. We would climb high above the power lines with our ropes, limbing saws, and pole-pruners...3 climbers in the treetops singing John Prine songs as we did our craft. Strenuous, dangerous work that. “Sam Stone” was a favorite. God bless John.
When John Prine left us it felt like losing family. I'm still mourning him and probably always will. An amazing artist and human being
Well said. Lis ....
This is such an amazing song. It says a lot about the Vietnam war.
I wished our government learned from this but they didn’t. We have the Gulf war. When will we get it right 😢😢
John Prine has the ability to tell a complete story of a historical event like the Viet Nam war in five minutes in Sam Stone. He was an absolute master at putting his lyrical brush to canvas and creating a Mona Lisa.
Kris Kristofferson when he first heard John he said this guy is to deep at such a young age.His music is so true and moving there want be another John Prine.
He has inspired many to speak the truth about life hardships, and how to celebrate living :o)
Why do I always seem to be cutting onions when I hear this song?
I too, can't believe that I'd never heard of him til he was gone. Thank God he left his music for us all
This song is so beautiful and truthful , My mother and father were in nursing homes during the pandemic , I met many residents in these facilities , just saying hi and acknowledging them , their eyes lit up , that they mattered, Prine was one of our greatest songwriters
It doesn't matter how long it takes... 'you found John Prine.
I remember all those wasted empty youthful days. We had what we called John Prine parties and at 15 l guessed that was our protest. Emotions run high on these re-runs.
R.I.P. brothers.
Climbing walls while sitting in a chair.... Who could not see this picture in their mind while Prine sings it?
What does this line mean?
@@CRyan71 means he was so high on drugs that it was no longer giving him a good feeling. Just my guess but it makes sense since he is talking about a lethal overdose. I can't imagine that is very pleasant... and " to he climbing walls" means to be suffering unpleasant feelings in an extreme way. So whilst he may simply appear to be sitting in a chair, inside he must be going through hell. That's my interpretation
@@CRyan71 I think it means that he was going through withdrawals and feelings anxious, feeling like he was climbing the walls. Then he takes his last fix and dies.
DangerDan I share your interpretation as well, also that this idea is oxymoronic because you can’t move up a wall while sitting so it’s clever in that sense.
Tremendous amount of talent here 🖤 🇺🇸
WOW.....WHAT A GREAT BUT SAD SONG, GOOD TO REMEMBER THOSE THAT WERE LOST
If I've played this song once, I've played it a 1000 times.. When I perform at this one private venue, I'm "ALWAYS" asked to play some JP and I happily oblige because in my opinion, there has "NEVER" been a better singer/writer and person to follow then John Prine...
RIP my friend
There but for the grace of God go I. Had a tough time after my return for Vietnam, but was fortunate enough not to get hooked on drugs. This song always reminds me of how lucky I am. Thanks John. RIP.
My sense of humor has saved me more than a couple of times in my life," Prine says. "If I can make myself laugh about something that I should be crying about, that's pretty good."
RIP JP
Now isn't that the truth.!
IM 71 I still cry at this song , Sorry John but JC died for us All. God Bless hopefully you Happy.
Nope. John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood.
"If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
John got better singing this song over time! Rip legand
WHAT A SONG, WHAT A MAN. Rest in peace John Prine.
There's a whole in daddy's arm where all the money goes..... ..... that line pulls at my heart so hard. It's weird because my father didn't have any drug problems.
I am heartbroken...as I am sure so many others are. Thank you, Mr. Singing Mailman. You helped me out in some rough times...
Mdpat the postman always delivers. My sense of humor has saved me more than a couple of times in my life," Prine says. "If I can make myself laugh about something that I should be crying about, that's pretty good."
RIP JP
@@artwilmeth6944 Thank you for those words sir.
@@artwilmeth6944 Thanks man...
Dang, I heard this song probably 45 years ago in Victoria BC Canada, didn't get it, never did drugs, never served, but today living I think I get it, as I have friends with PTSD, and a tad myself, wow is all I can say,
Our greatest story tellers (in no particular order)are!!,Mark Twain, Ernest Hemingway, and John Prine. Period!!
I was born in 78, this song has always reminded me of my Papa who came back from vietnam with a hole in his arm where all the money went. Ofcourse I didn’t find this out until I was 10ish, he’s now deceased but I loved him with all of his troubles. War is ugly & destroys lives and families around the world. Figured I’d listen in tribute to Veterans Day 🇺🇸
I'm a big, strong guy.
This song makes me cry.
Why did they have to die.
Nobody knows why.
Remember Alan Ginsberg wrote:
‘Imagine there was a War
And nobody came.......’
@@0otee I pray for the day when swords are turned into plowshares.
John Prine was right. Jesus said he is the Way for us to walk and this story proves what the Crucifixion was about and that's not sacrifice. It's forgiveness. "Forgive them for they know not what they do." With mercy we end wars instead of making men heroes for their sacrifice. It's a dead end and Jesus knew that. It was the disciples that didn't understand what Jesus taught and many Christians today haven't understood.
"If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent."
Don’t glorify war. It swallows the righteous and the evil alike
Beautiful said💪♥️🙏
What an excellent artist. Most people never really got exposed to his music. His music provides a certain peace when you just listen to it. It is hard to explain, but if you listen to alot of his music you understand what I am saying. Not many artists like him these days.
I've listened to this 100's of times, since the first time, that line, hole in daddy's arm, then Jesus died for nothin, I suppose, that is the most grabbing line of any song from any writer.
The most beautiful song about mental illness. I understand it's about war vets and give all respect to them. But also reminds me of my husband who died of mental illness when our daughter was 15 months old. Thank you Mr Prine. Special place in heaven for you Sir
Was busking with some friends (about 40 years ago) and this biker-looking guy requests "Sam Stone". We were in the middle of some other song so the fiddle player says .... "Sure, right after this song".
The biker guy says .... "No, play it right now!"
We all stopped mid-song and began almost in unison .... "There's a hole in Daddy's arm .... "
Told this story many times and still remember the experience like it was yesterday.
Thank-you John Prine for the powerful music.
Johnny Mike's stuff.
Joe Blow )
This kid was a genius
I've listened to this song a thousand times and it still tears me up everytime I hear it.
Me too. I've been listening to this for over 40 yrs and it still get's me.
Too many, far to many are still in I Corps, the Central Highlands or the Delta. Lost one in June after he struggled for decades. We all found out that for a lot of 11bravos or 0311's its never over.
@@TheIoniaboy Thank you for serving!
Same here. Especially Veteran's day weekend.
Very Sorry for the loss
The world has lost a great artist but more importantly a human who cared. His music empathised with all going through the pain and suffering of life. A beacon and an example to what we should aspire to. Ar dheis de go raibh a anam.
Well said
Tà an ceart agat. Amhrān and amhrānaí do-chreidte.
He wrote this one on his mail route after he got out of the Army. What an amazing talent. Side note, Jesus Christ died and rose again to end the suffering in the end.
“Sweet songs never last too long...on broken radios.” Perfection.
That line is so true about the lies that addicts tell, and the empty promises. Such a great line.
That line has always sent chills down my spine.
This song is a classic of mine….2.something hits……sad man…life was sooo different back then
Wow, what a great version of a beautiful song. I know and love it from the album version but this is even better, he gets so much emotion into it.
I hope all you Americans appreciate and look after this guy, he's a national treasure if ever there was one.
Thank you 🇺🇸. We're proud of him. In which Country are you? If it's ok to ask?
Thank you. 🇺🇸 We're proud of him. In which Country are you? If it's ok to ask?
He is indeed a national treasure! I started listening to him in the early ‘70s, thanks to my older sister’s albums. He was a lifeline of sanity tossed to this lonely, midwestern kid. He widened my view of the world. Yeah, sometimes things are messed up...if this guy sees it and made it through then maybe I could, too. Music is magic. John Prine is one of our most-skilled magicians. I wish our society valued musicians more and paid them better.
One of the best songwriters I've heard this song especially has a special place in my heart
@@moondancer3157 I just sent hate mail to Google for changing UNITED STATES of AMERICA to lower case smaller font u s !
Good people are never no further away from us then a thought , a memory , a dream. they are what makes our next day better then our last. They've only been borrowed for a while.
As great as he was as a musician his lasting image will be that of a grounded, down-to-earth, beautiful human being. He made a HUGE mark in this world and will be greatly missed. I had a college roommate get me into John Prine around forty years ago although his type of music wasn't what I would normally listen to at the time. I was attracted to his biting, poignant, often funny lyrics. What a talent. RIP, John.
Sad sad song. RIP John Prine.
It'll take a long time not to shred a tear when I listen his songs. R.I.P. John from a VietNam Vet
I played 'Sam Stone' 4 my fiancee who is a Viet Nam vet ( sharpnull and all) and saw him cry 4 the first time.
Even Johnny Cash didn't have the balls to sing this song "as is". Thank you John Prine for keeping it real.
I heard this for the first time yesterday and I am completely staggered by the beauty of it.
I suppose he did !
Live with it!
Timeless
Touche pal 👌
Happy veterans day. Prine cared more about veterans and the average person then any politician ever will.
Seeing the comments makes me happy to be a lifetime fan.
1 person at a time..he spoke to each one of us intimately it seemed
I, too; feel the connection. He's casting a bigger spell than ever on all his fans.
I came back from Nam in July of 1967. When I first heard this in the early 70’s, I was sure he had been there. He summed up the loss that so many of us felt and the anguish we had experienced.
RIP, Mr. Prine -- my life wouldn't have been the same without your painfully naked insights weaved so brilliantly in all your lyrics. It's a sad day sitting here today, mourning your passing, but I still have a wry smile on my face, mindful of your grace-filled view of this 'Big Old Goofy World' -- a bittersweet perspective on the short time we all have on this earth. Just keep smilin' that big ol' Illegal Smile in that 'already overcrowded' heaven you're sure to be in! ♫♪
How war will change a person God Bless all of y'all service Men and Women Thank ya for your service
No artist had ever touched my soul , until I heard John prune sing Sam Stone. Farewell John.you are truly one of the Greats!
we love and miss you John.........
I would like to have been in Chicago in the early 70's,when John Prine,Steve Goodman,and Jimmy Buffet were basically living together,trying to out-drink each other,out-write each other,and having each others back.Two of them are gone now.
I’m sure that John is playing in heaven right now not as a headliner but on some beautiful mountain overlooking a fast moving stream with an old dog by his side and a few thousand lovers of his music tapping their toes and remembering days gone by… Never another like you John Prine…
Still get a lump in my throat hearing this, may he rest easy in God’s hands now😢
I cry every time I her this sad but wonderful song.
We played John Prine's music constantly in the 70s; brings back so many memories. His voice is one in a million.
Then we were fortunate enough to see him with Bonnie Raitt in Memphis in the mid-80s. The entire audience sang along with every song he played, and he wore the biggest grin the entire set! LOVE YOU JOHN!
Attention everyone! Please vote for John as inductee in the Rock and Roll Hall of fame! He deserves it so much...
love always! xoxo
Dave Jacques does SUCH a hauntingly good job with his bow.
"...and the gold rolled through his veins, like a thousand railroad trains..." VERY powerful lyrics! That's exactly what it's like. The whole song is spot on.
"climbing walls while sitting in a chair"
Poetry In Motion:) 29 yrs Sober,Drug free lead me HERE :) As an addict I interpret the words from that side, as a Survivor I hear & feel it From the LIVING side !! :) As a Poet I feel the words !! Addiction sux !!Life-styles CAN change ! I rarely say it BUT I offer MYSELF as proof !!! :) Offer support where you can !BUT people have to WANT change,!!"Peace Takes Practice" r.i.p. John Prine. Rick
What i miss about the 60's and 70's is musicians that can pinpoint the issues of everyday folk and make you think hard about what is going on. It is human history in a song.
@Chris Kozak Not very personal, though. Southern Man is another anti-white rant. I'm not surprising he's joined with Pfizer and the money people
Neil Young sold half of his catalogue to Merck Mercuriadis’ Hipgnosis Song Management company on January 6, 2021. Later that year, Hipgnosis merged with Blackstone in a $1 billion deal. A month before the merger, Blackstone announced that they appointed Pfizer’s former Chairman and CEO, Jeffrey B Kindler, as the company’s Senior Advisor.
I don't know where I was, but I spent my whole life listening to country music and never heard of John Prine until after his death. What a shame. I love his simple rhythms with heart felt stories. It reminds me of Cash, but for some reason I enjoy Prine more.
One of the most beautifully sad songs ever written. Genius at work. RIP, John Prine.
Exquisitely compassionate and truthful.
A name vaguely in my mind once or twice, a whisper indirect via RUclips, or in a comment, but someone just today said I should listen to this gent. Four songs in and I wonder: where the hell has my brain been all these long years? Wow.
Thank you Lord Jesus, John Prine revealed an issue,that can happen to anyone, let us pray for all the Sam Stone or Jane Stone,God keep them strong ,and raise them back up on their feet.
Just remember,When your back on your feet,and you will get back on your feet, as long as you Try,your always Recovering, never Recovered but you can do it.
Would love to send my condolences to the Prine Family......seeing John in Philly was gonna be special!