Part 1: Paul’s friend said he drove Alex to airport for vacation a month after the murders
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2023
- Nathan Tuten, a Walterboro #police officer and longtime #friend of #paulmurdaugh used to work as a “runner” for #alexmurdaugh former #lawfirm Tuten testified he drove Alex the #airport for a July 4th #floridakeys #vacation with #maggiemurdaugh family one month after her death. #news #trial #murdaugh #southcarolina
By "clearing Paul's name" he meant "I hope that by killing my son, I won't be liable for the $50 million I'm being sued for" in the boat case. He didn't give a flea's a** about his son's name, he only cared about the money.
EVERYTHING Alex does is for himself, never ever anyone else.
BINGO! You nailed it.
Doesnt work that way, he was listed as a defendant, Pauls death would not have ended that case at all nor remove Murdaugh from it. Murdaugh got literally no gain from their deaths at all, it is what kicked off the investigation into his finances.
There were alot of problems with this case if you watched any of it at all. Whether or not you think he killed them, the State did not meet their burden, which included prosecutorial abuse, literal physical impossibilities, and the State's own admission to reasonable doubt in their closing statements.
The last point is the most important, if someone as well connected, criminally insane, psychotically intelligent (which he would have to be to pull off these murders) and wealthy can be convicted beyond a reasonable doubt, while the people accussing him are saying theres reasonable doubt, what can they convict you of?
Absolutely agree BUT he does care about clearing Paul's name, not because he cared about Paul, but because of the stain that boat crash put on HIS Murdaugh name
Like one of the jurors said "If he didn't kill them, then how did he know exactly when to lie about not being there?"
A father who's wife and son were murdered, doesn't sdays later say "The most important thing now is to clear Paul's name." if he was innocent the most important thing would be to find his child's killer.
You can argue that it wasn't proven beyond a reasonable doubt, but he did kill his wife and son.
And he did have motive, for a sociopath even the stain of Paul killing that girl, on the Murdaugh name, is motive. Then Maggie was digging in to his finances and soon would realise he stole millions
Wait…he murders Maggie and then goes on vacation with her family? 🤬🤬🤬
Unbelievable. How could any of them be in the mood for a vacation?? Sickos.
Him cold-blooded and Maggie‘s family still getting manipulated.
He got off on knowing what he did and being that close to them.
Maggie and Paul have no markers? He's vacationing? Look there for $$$
@@TheLaurahar Exactly!! What a bunch of weirdos. I would not be in the mood for a vacation, especially with him.
So he was not interested in finding killer, just clearing Paul's name...strange way of doing so.
Alex clearing Pauls name means he believes he will not be sued therefore his financials not opened up to show where he hid his thieving money.
I think he meant getting Paul off hook for the boat crash charge.
@@SS11660 I think just about everyone thinks Alex Murdoch would be busy trying to find the killer or killers of his wife and son.
@@SS11660 And him out of paying the money!!
@@alvaroq2024 He didn't need to look there, he already knew the killer... Alex Murdaugh!!
HOW can anyone go on a relaxing vacation a month after their wife and son were brutally slaughtered?
Candy B: Only psychopaths can do that!
@@cynthiaarons9373 😂😂😂
And talk about beating the boat case 😂 , but nothing said about catching the killer of his wife and son 😂! What a 🤡😂😂
Alex, is as Crazy as a Sprayed Roach !!
easy....when youre a fully blown narc
There's the motive for the crime he could beat the boat case and keep the money
That is the craziest line of thinking. Kill your child so you can clear his name? Kill the child And his mother so you can clear the name? Dear God there Are people out there that Love to see that boy dead and all you guys can come up with it……well if I kill him and I kill his mother it will clear the child’s name
I agree! This has been my thought all along. I couldn’t wrap my head around the notion that he killed Paul & Maggie solely for sympathy or to divert attention away from his financial crimes. Not that his suddenly becoming a victim had no part in it but I always believed it was more than that. It truly seemed that the most important thing to Alex was to make this boat case go away, and when he saw that wasn’t happening and Paul was charged, Alex was faced with the fact that a Murdaugh (Paul) was (for the first time in history) going to be held accountable for his actions and daddy wasn’t going to be able to fix this one…his ego wouldn’t allow him to accept it.
What I can’t quite figure out is, why both of them, Maggie & Paul? Maggie was at Edisto beach and wad lured there by Alex, under the guise of going with him to see his father because he was gravely ill. If he wanted to end Paul, it would’ve been easy enough to do so without taking Maggie’s life.🤷🏼♀️
Maggie was going to divorce and that was equally a problem. So two birds w one stone. Also Maggie would be devastated after her sons death.
@chubbard816 Excellent comment!! Another RUclipsr comment (carolmorris) might have answered your question about Maggie. Alex did not want to deal with Maggie's grief. Selfish!!!!
@carolmorris7483 ...you hit the nail on the head!!!
Trickster murders Maggie's sister then goes to the Florida keys with Maggie's family and tricks them all. Maggie's sister must be traumatized from Alex😮
Can't imagine the roller coaster of emotions and confusion she must still feel. She was afraid because she thought it must have been some unknown madman and then to come to the realization that it was someone much closer to her....her brother in law. I'm traumatized for her. 🙏👋
@@gwennk4962 sure makes you want to vacation 4 weeks after family members are murdered SMH
@@deew7014 I know that it's none of my business if Maggie's sister went on vacation. I know what it is like to lose someone close to me (murdered) and if I could I would have gone away somewhere else to try and heal. I now know that you don't really heal from some things in life. Hopefully, Maggie's sister will be able to forgive herself for her own feelings of blame. If Alex was planning this for a long time, he would have found a way to make it happen no matter where or how. All those people robbed by him will come to terms with it but she lost her only sister to someone she thought she knew. I would not wish that on my worst enemy. Just sayin. 👋
@@gwennk4962 I’m so sorry for you’re loss 💕🙏
I've heard that Maggie and Paul still don't have a real headstone, but they are going on vacation instead!! SMH
It can take years to have headstone made and set.
It can take years to have a headstone made and set.
I’m not sure about years.. my sister had a beautiful one within a few months.. it was copper and marble with the flower vase built inside.. They should have their headstones by now..
They may have had a headstone ready to go, but it might have said 'In memory of a loving wife and son' (i.e dedicated by Alex), so maybe they had to hold off erecting one until the court case was over.
@@rhondaclark5335 Was your sister murdered by a family member? Was there a two year wait to find out how she died?
I just don’t know how the man can smirk and grin I just don’t understand how he can do this 😢
The average person has empathy and would be grieving, not trying to clear the debt and save what is now his money! He smirked and smiles and will have a ball in prison giving advice to inmates for favours. He asked Buster to give an inmate money, for what? Another murder?
@myunk nownland I heard on a podcast, inmates will threaten him to give them a monthly amount of money. I would of never thought of it but I can see it now that I heard it goes on.
I had a sister who was not capable of remorse. Even as a teen, her psychiatrist told my Dad that she would end up dead or in jail. She did both. She could win anyone over in a heartbeat and would steal anything from anybody to get what she wanted. She never thought of the consequences and never felt guilty for what she did. She wasn't capable of it.
@@bunmonk1903 damm 😱 sorry to hear about your sister. 🙏🏻🌺
He is a wicked man!
Wow These are powerful people. How many cases they had get away with. All this witnesses have telling the truth. 🙏 Lord heal our Land.❤
Just like the Clinton's
But God is more POWERFUL!! For man, it's an illusion if used the wrong way. For this family it was used the wrong way.
@@charlenerevell7543 yep. I think they are a cautionary tale, a warning bc Christ is soon returning
God is going to destroy and wipe out the land, for he is absolutely disgusted with the amount of sin, Godless people and the zero repentance for it. Unfortunately, the repentant people will be dragged down as well and we will all suffer.
No wonder he thought he could get away with murder, buddy buddy with the local police lol
Friends and family in law enforcement? Oh, you betcha!! The photos of him and his "badge," *(that belonged to his father)* and how he displayed it in his car, on his person, and then standing up there explaining why...
That is the *behavior of all of the **_Good 'Ol Boys_** where I live* who *REFUSE to enforce my trespassing order against my neighbor.*
_That neighbor has also called every lawyer in the country making it a "conflict of interest" for them to talk to me._
He killed Paul and Maggie because Paul was going to trial which was decided on the 4th and Maggie wanted a divorce plus on the 10th he was due to show his finances in which on the 10th his dad also passed.
Alex killed his Wife and Son rather then let them live and take his own life. Now hell live behind bars rather then them living, as for Busta he stuck by his dad cos his dad covered for him when he murdered that Bisexual boy Busta was messing with.
I deeply feel Buster is headed for 'major trouble"!! He is a 'chip off the old block like his dad!!
Maybe he’ll spend life in prison he’s still got powerful friends that are a pos like him
Who killed the bisexual boy?
BINGO!!!
@@rachelt2844 Makes me side eye this Boy ..now. I had a weird feeling abt this " kid" and his answers. I am aware he is a cop now.. but still..
The disturbed justification that he told himself is that Alex must kill them "mercifully" now to spare them the pain about to unfold from the boat case. The narcissism and god complex is astounding,
Alex was obsessed with the Boat Case. Completely totally obsessed.
What other connection is there between the Murdaughs and Blanca’s law enforcement husband? What good cop would accept an offer from Alex to live at the scene of a double homicide. The only person of interest was 1. The husband and father of the deceased, 2. the person who discovered the bodies, 3. The last person to have seen the deceased alive, and 4. the person who dialed 911. I would think any rational cop would say: no thanks, my boss might think I’m involved or something.
Exactly what I said!!!
BrianWro: Well said!
MAGGIE FAMILY HAS ISSUES TOO!
This family took Alex on vacation after the murders. Guess they didn’t have a clue… right?
Not like *AleXxxxxss's* family.
What do you mean
@@adinalewis7118 They took him on vacation after the murders!
Hi Al!
@Shawna Atkinson-Martin Where did you hear that? Was in the trial? Defence cross?
I knew when I saw the judge of this the first time he was doin the lords work and that satanic monster was gonna have his tower took down
the judge was doing his job, because he is a good and competent person.
The Lord? Yeah, where was he when Mallory Beach was killed, or when Alex stole all the money from his young client who was fully paralyzed or when he stole all the money from the special needs young man which meant he was evicted.
If there is this Lord...he has too much to answer for to be worth ever thinking about.
@@greenman6141 that’s a sad way to move through life. That’s not God. Free will is a thing and the devil is hard at work trying to turn everyone from God. Truly hope you find your way.
@@tangie06_33 I'm fine and one of the reasons I'm fine is that I know what reality is and know that there's no Easter Bunny delivering chocolate eggs, no fat man with a bag of gifts stuck in my chimney and that all deliberate evil is the result of decisions made by humans, and all deliberate good is solely and only due to the good will, and endlessly hard work of the people who understand that this is the only source of it.
Fairy tales and fun to read. They won't butter your parsnips or stop predators like Murdaugh from destroying families. His family are all big church goers.
@@greenman6141 Ok, well Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny literally have nothing to do with God so that alone tells me where you are with things. Good luck to you.
@@tangie06_33 Santa & Hoppy are exactly the same as god. Bedtime stories, but without the misogyny, so much better really.
I also don't believe in luck, because like god, it also doesn't exist.
The House always wins baby.
The entire family is vile and duplicitous. Not to mention evil. Paul's debauchery that kills Mallory. The fellow left dead on the side of the road. The housekeeper assuming was pushed down the stairs. Maggie's was well aware of all this and covered it up. So sad. Greed , money and entitlement....SMH. ...Alex time has come, Buster is next!
The more you listen to this case, the worst it gets. Alex is EXACTLY where he belongs!!!!
With Paul dead the criminal charges into boat crash disappear, also so does the lawsuit. Or so Alec figured, but Mark Tinsley being the tiger that he was, had split the lawsuit into three, Alec Buster Paul and Maggie’s estate. If Alec failed to settle, he would go after each one of them individually. For instance Buster for giving Paul his ID to buy 🍻 whilst underage etc etc. As of now Buster has settled with the Beach family for his role, he used his inheritance from Maggie’s estate.
I’m in 🇬🇧! I shouldn’t know so much about this case! 😂
Buster is going down like a burning plane & I see he is not going to be successful in life!!
@@RonSafreed oh come on! Don’t be so hard on Bus Bus
I'm glad Buster settled. He needs to find his own way now and find people who he can trust and be role models.He just lost his mom and brother. I doubt hes feeling anything positive about his dads actions.
@@RonSafreed you are heartless.
@@sashalu13, this is what narcisissm does of a parent in a family. It destroys the family. My father was very selfish & destroyed my mother & me & my brothers & 3 words always out of his mouth 'I don't care'!!
He’s not so much clearing Paul’s name as is was clearing HIS name. He seems like the type who would get angry at his son bringing shame to the family name, all whilst stealing and murdering and scheming.
Sinister guy Mr. Murdaugh
What a clever way to deflect suspicion with Maggies family. Maggie shared her concerns with her sister. The night of the murder she (Maggie) indicated that she though AM was up to something. Her sister encouraged her to go instead of telling her to stay away. I find that very very odd.
@Valerie Shealy
I think she only encouraged her to go only because Alex’s father was going in hospice as he was expected to die soon. (which he did 3 days later) But Alex had to be acting mighty strange in vacation
Why didn’t Maggie listen to her own doubt/intuition about Alex being very ‘fishy’ that night ? Maggie said that she had that strange feelings but then she ignored that strange feelings and went ahead anyway to meet Alex at the Kennel!?! Maggie’s sister encouraged Maggie to go and meet Alex that fateful night, I wondered how is she doing now knowing Maggie really shouldn’t have LISTENED TO HER and gone there that night, then being killed! 😢
It had to be so hard for Nathan Tuten to sit for the prosecution after having been friends w this whole family. AM has deeply hurt so many people. It's truly such a tragedy. AM did all for that for nothing. Didn't clear his son's name; if anything, ruined the family's legacy single-handedly.
He was worried that Paul would be the one to tear down the dynasty. With his out of control behaviour, alcoholic at such a young age, DUIs all over the case, conviction for the crash. Now look who is a convicted killer
@@suzymoroka297 unfortunately, I feel Paul would have another manslaughter on his hands within five yrs, had he survived. To always be bailed out, knowing one will, it just becomes that avalanche that can’t be prevented bc of all the enablers. Everything was already set in motion. Morgan is lucky she survived this relationship w Paul & the wreck they had in rolled truck w guns & empty alcoholic containers all over the place. Who helped w that again? His parents & good, old fixer…
John Marvin. No consequences.
The monster murdered his wife and son and had the audacity to visit and vacation with his murdered wife's sister and her family. Smh
*Maggie, Paul & Bubba got justice* ⚖️
Bubba?
@@jjsixtwofour - YES, BUBBA! Maggie's yellow Lab. Labs are extremely loyal and protective. That monster took the life of Bubba's 'momma'. He's with Blanca now, who I imagine is loving him like Maggie loved and cared for him 🐕
Or they already knew the climate within the family 🤔 rumors of smuggling with those flights wouldnt suprise me a bit for another plot twist from the in laws...
Damn straight, Bubba deserves his justice too. Especially with getting maliciously maligned with Alex's lying.
He is a manipulator, and has the audasity to do anything and everything. These types of people are unbelievable in what they think and do.
I saw Maggie’s sister sitting with and mingling with Alex’s siblings on a trial day, other than the one she testified on. That was very unsettling.
Maggie's sister is in denial. Maggie's was a stuck.up snob. Very duplicitous like her entire family. She did not deserve this. Maggie's covered up Paul's debauchery that killed Mallory. So many more cover ups
This guy planned everything
A cop..who is a runner for the firm..that's a dirty cop
Why is he still smirking for?
Wow, so upset about the murders of his wife & son and goes on vacation a month later. Thank you young man for speaking the truth. I hope everyone sees the smirk on his face.
Alex was shooting at close range. Both victims first recieved painful injuries and both were looking at Alex just before he fired at their heads to finally kill them. He got off on inflicting pain and knew very well that his victims suffered horrific pain and both knew it was deliberate and at his hands.
I'm sorry but did nobody catch how the lawyer twisted his words to say what he wanted him to say. The man said " he would like to clear Paul's name" that's far different than saying "now I can beat that rap". I know the man is guilty of something I just don't think it's like they're trying to say completely. I just can't stand how every one of these prosecution lawyers constantly twist words around and put words in people's mouth. Has anybody noticed how they do that and I mean all the prosecution lawyers do it.
I agree with you. So much was twisted. But Idk if he’s the monster to kill his own family. I don’t know.
Maybe he did. It’s true what the lady said, Paul and Maggie still don’t have headstones.
@@kathydoyle5134 so much of what they try to prove things with can be reasonably argued. Like having different clothes on. How many people out there change their clothes several times a day depending on the weather, where they're going, who they are seeing. I know myself come home and something different then I left in all the time, then something goes missing and it'll turn up two years later.
Then I think about how many people he's double-crossed and cheated, and that includes every single one of those lawyers he works with. That's a lot of powerful men who are now out of jobs because of his actions. All this GPS to from his car and the phones. Anybody could have held him at gunpoint while they walked around with the phones and made it look like what it look like and then make him take the blame for it, and if he says anything they'll take out Buster in his brothers.... that's their leverage over him. I don't know I just have a hard time believing the man could kill his son.
Father and son are done!
well obviously Alex son is done, he's dead. Alex is still alive. Buster should be charged to but killing that kid
That is right. Buster is next. The only problem is there are no more family members left to lay the blame on.
Thank God in the end no one gets away with anything , no one
Alex is always consistently evil.
Maggie's family?
Terrible for a friend. Doesn’t want to be there.
Well he finally cleared pauls
name .😢
Just like I've thought and said, Alex's motive is to not have to pay out the money to the family in reference to the boat case. It's all about money to him in order to save his families reputation and the fact he's been a thief for a LONG time! 😢
Just imagine how much this family has gotten away with over the generations. I wonder how many bodies they really have.
I would want to clear my child's name too
So very telling.
I had always said he killed them to get rid of the boat murder investigation. and collect some sort of life insurance or money off their deaths.
This family is messed up. Buster probably killed that kid found near their esttae
Very odd
He says all kinds of things you have to read between the lines. For example I got myself wed to that. Maggie contributed zero financially unless he made it happen through misdeeds. Like putting the property in her name to Shield it and then having it revert back to him after he got rid of their lives. So he would inherit it. I heard a bunch of other ones as well for example she didn't work. Also she was always sick when she was pregnant. When he left in the morning she was sick she was sick at lunch time and when he got home she was still sick. that was a few years of no sex I'm sure for him. Plus her whining. I have more in my mind that he has said between the lines. However this post is long enough for now
yip...he sure turned paul into paw paw
In Pennsylvania, what Alec said to Paul’s friend would be considered hear-say. I’m not sure about SC law though.
It her family needed to getaway. They didn’t suspect him at that time
This guy is so smooth but to the point.
Watch Part 2: Paul’s Friend Said He Drove Alex To Airport For Vacation A Month After The Murders
ruclips.net/user/shortsQ2gsHpok-N0
Cant believe him he a cop.
I dont know how I missed this before?
Wondering how you can “clear” someone’s name when guilt is confirmed by so many independent sources. And #2…it makes you see a definitive reason for killing his kid. I think he was a “protective family annihilator” at least in his mind. First i don’t believe he actually “liked” Paul. This kid was out of control (even though a monster of their own making. I do not like to speak ill of the dead, but that young man was out of control and they clearly contributed as parents). Still, nobody deserves to be killed. And just my opinion but i think he killed Paul to 1. Protect him from going to jail which he was most likely headed for and 2. Because he was responsible for bringing down Alex’s house of cards of stealing people’s money down all around them. And 3. (Possibly) Paul could have hidden or flushed his drugs and that is a huge no no for an addict because it could put him in withdrawal. But i doubt this was the reason, regardless. And i think he decided since Maggie was going to be so humiliated by what he had done he would 1. Spare her from having to live with loss of her son and 2. “spare her” that humiliation of his thefts and disbarment while also saving his own skin (which is way more important to him of course). I do not know how Buster or his family could have any faith in him at all. Once u know all the details, it would be so hard to come to any other conclusion. I think Buster is between a serious rock and a hard place. And possibly he is even afraid of his father and knows if he got free he might do same to him if he did not support him as a defense witness. He does not seem to wholeheartedly agree with his dad on the phone calls, even telling him he has to follow rules of the land like anyone else. When alex asked him if he wanted to go hunting at Moselle, he seemed shocked he would even ask and said “no i will not be going hunting there at all”. U could tell it bothered him quite a bit. I do not like the way the girlfriend and Buster seemed to support alex in jailhouse calls BUT that may have been in beginning before all the evidence came out. I do not know Buster’s reputation but if he did do something wrong in the smith death, I am sure it will come out now. If the father and brother’s possibly?? killed him to keep Buster from being with him, because they found it unpalatable, it would not surprise me either. Alex clearly manipulates and lies to everyone around him. That much is obvious from the trial and the jailhouse calls. Stealing is not the same as murder but the extremely callous attitude Alex exhibits to be able to steal so easily from a beloved housekeeper, to teens who trusted him to a quadriplegic, even his own brother just show what kind of person he was. That wanton disregard of another human’s feelings is exactly what it would take to murder even family in cold blood. In my opinion. Just watching azget account reenactments on tiktok using all available onstar and cell phone info show exactly how he could have easily managed it. Pretty convincing. I cannot imagine why else he would have his brothers go remove certain guns from his mom and dad’s home before search warrants were served…..he is a lawyer and thought he was smart enough to get away with it and might have been if not for the damning Snapchat.
He wasn't even scared for his own life. Brave Ole Alex
Apparently Alex thought he could track down the real murderer in the Florida Keys.
That's why he did that to paul didnt want him getting in trouble over it the boat crash getting Time Maggie The house was in her name
Since when did the State of SC get tiktok??
Wow!
Wow ! How telling!
His testimony that he would go to the bank and bring back envelopes full of cash to Alex's office where various officials and law enforcement people were sitting waiting.
I'm watching the 4 hour ,2part movie right now on lifetime and so far it's really good! Especially when I didn't know this case. There's been several things about this case in my feed for a while now but I always watch a different case. ..He is 1 guy that has dug his own grave and his sons too by being greedy and spoiling him! Nothing good ever comes when u spoil a child to that extent!
How can you really call it a vacation if he’s going with Maggie’s family? It obviously was the family trying to getaway from everything and be with family, even if it had been pre-planned. Why is this trip being vilified?
Vacationing with his wife's family he murdered a month earlier.
Because he’s holidaying with the family of the woman he murdered, pretending he didn’t murder her!
Who’s thinking about a vacation only a month after?.. who got the bill for that vacation? Did Maggie’s family know he had been fired for theft and supposedly had no money?… rich folk!… smh
At this time they had not figured out that Alex was responsible. They were trying to help Alex and buster that they thought were grieving.
@@rayshelldaniels5899 he was not sacked a month after the murders. I believe he was sacked in September 2021? 🤨🤔
🤬🤬
The boat 🛥️ accident has brought everyone of this family dirt out … and Lord knows how much more in there 😮
Alex looked up and smiled ? ??
so the trial started for the boat case now. I watched the whole murdough trial for 6 weeks. Saw him get the guilty verdicts said to him and his sentencing by the judge I knew he was guilty and I thank God he's in jail where he belongs and I'm sure he'll be in prison the rest of his life, he needs to be. I'm asking cuz I don't remember this guy on the stand in Alex's trial. I didn't realize this trial has started already I see part one on here.
I'm going to have to check the court channel and watched the trial with the boat and getting Justice for Mallory Beach and her family.
Murdaugh a manipulater
Wow.
I dont get it...what are u trying to prove with this short clip? I dont think hes innocent by no means but this is a stretch armstrong level stretch!
am is one sick man