Israel at 75 - A nation in domestic crisis | DW Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 июл 2023
- The state of Israel is in political turmoil as it marks its 75th anniversary. While there is still no end in sight to the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, Israeli society itself is more divided than ever before.
The founding of the Jewish state was a dream come true for Jews around the world. It came just a few years after the genocide of the Holocaust and 2,000 years after the destruction of Jerusalem and the Second Temple and the exile from Israel.
On May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion read out the Israeli Declaration of Independence in a small building in the center of Tel Aviv. Ever since its foundation, Israel has had a checkered history. As well as ongoing conflict with the Palestinians, it has seen poverty and hardship, but also economic prosperity and social advances over the past 75 years. In addition, Israel enjoys political and military superiority in the region. At the same time, the state is now going through its deepest-ever domestic crisis. Israel is socially, politically and religiously polarized.
One reason for that are the plans put forward by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing religiously conservative government. The reforms are designed to reduce the power of the Supreme Court. Critics regard the move as an assault on democracy and an attempt to undermine the independence of the judiciary. For months now, hundreds of thousands of Israelis have been protesting against the proposals.
In his documentary, ZDF correspondent Michael Bewerunge investigates what has become of the aspirations of the nation’s founders and how people today are living the Jewish dream.
#documentary #dwdocumentary
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
Imagine someone breaking into your home and telling you that they used to live here 2000 years ago and that’s why you have to leave now. It’s a crime.
The "breaking into homes" has been going back and forth. No sides are innocent. Historically, the Brits are also OG troublemakers with a hand in all of the crap going on but never get blamed for anything.
Imagine the Israeli where there from more than 2000 years ago. An official country since King Saul, king David and king Solomon. Before even the region of Palestine existed.
@@lillylee2410bs lol plus the Palestinians themselves are closest by DNA to the land not some European zionists
Sure. In reality it's about who has the most guns and the better network.
@@lillylee2410imagine Canaan wasnt there at all, even before Israel claims. 😅
As a Native American it sickens me to see colonialism occurring like this, all in the name of religion…
Jews can't colonise the country they are from.
@@toyotaprius79 I'm not Native American but I was thinking the same thing.
Jews are indigenous tribes of Israel.
If anything it’s more like if native Americans took their lands back from Americans, displacing the whites.
@@toyotaprius79 human life was a commodity one time. Doesn’t make it right to control it.
it is their native land. they just came back. the problem is there are already new occupants. now, do you have a suggestion how to resolve that?
The audacity of that woman, Daniella. How hypocritical she is, settling on a land that does not belong to her and saying that they are peaceful. I mean...
To take others land is justified by saying God promised to them.... hence they can take the natives Palestinians land.
God gave her the permission
The personification of audacity.
@@miketiong8441 they have his phone number so they can call him at any time & forever
But GOD told her it was cool, so . . .
As a Jewish person, I am revolted that people with such a long history of religious and ethnic persecution would persecute others on the same basis.
Israel deserves to Exist. Israel will Exist!
What's wrong with you.. Israel was given to US We are the chosen
@@arnowisp6244 no one says it SHOULDNT! it should be RESPECTFUL OF LIFE, just like everyone else is!
An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind. - Gandhi
@@arnowisp6244😂😂😂 not for long
The settler lady in the Occupied West Bank telling about Peace whereas she lives in an illegal land is so insane.
Madness
She is crazy.
Don't worry about that God will punish them like Bible said they will be destroyed like God did using Babylon 🙏
As an Israeli, it is sad.
It's our version of the American Karen.
We need better education, better social systems and so forth, to make better people.
Israel needs to invest more in it's peripheral cities like most countries should.
PA President Abbas is in his 18th year of a 4 year elected term and refuses to hold elections. Does that bother you? If it doesn’t, you have problems.
Chosen people? Thats racism.
No it isn't. The people of Israel were the chosen one's up to the cross of Jesus, thereafter we áll are chosen in Christ!
@@eekay5710😂😂😂😂😂😂 since when? Video evidence is required in this century
Ephesians 1:3-6
Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ, just as He chose us in Him BEFORE THE FOUNDATION OF THE WORLD, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, having predestined us to adoption as sons by Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the good pleasure of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace, by which He made us accepted in the Beloved.
They chose themselves
@@kimnabi3988
Not according to the Bible who is inspired by the Holy Spirit who cannot lie.
Wow Just wow!! The sheer audacity to say that people will never have sovereignty and will be kicked out of their homes where they lived for generations while absolutely glorifying the settlers, just INSANE!!
But their book of magic tells them that they have a right…
Al masih ad dajjal
"The dream of the oppressed is to be the oppressor". This is an endless cycle
That’s only true when the oppressed do not know or respect God. They claim to be religious, but their actions make it clear they do not know Him.
This woman's audacity to take people's land and property and tell them that they will never have sovereignty is insane.
Pick up a history book... SMH.
Israel has shamed god again, and god will give it to u when he does it
U didn't get Israel from god u got it from the wicked so u are wicked
@King_Julian01 isn't history meant to be history? Ohh wait, if that's the case, give back your current residence to the indigenous peoples from 4000 years ago!!! Who wrote the book? Hypocrite and worst answer to reply to a well liked comment you intellectually deficient clown!
Funny thing muslims are accusing that other people take land. Most of muslim countries today became islamic because their ancestors simply took land from the indigenous people. What goes around comes around.
The Settlers are just called "settlers attack" while they were trying to cause death to Palestinians by throwing objects at the Palestinian cars.
And the Palestinians called "Terrorist attack"
If you want to know who really rules over you, then find out who you can't criticise
Exactly
Exactly!
Exactly my thought too
My heart ❤goes fr the people of Palestine.. do not worry karma will hit ultimately..sooner or later..no power is greater than karma .
That old woman is delusional! My goodness, she has no shame either.
That one American dude I saw in a clip talking with a Palestinian family being displaced who had the confident audacity to tell them "If I don't take it, someone else will" told me everything I needed to know about the Israeli government. They've deliberately fostered an aura of privilege based on being a member of the Jewish religion to the point where people don't even bat an eye and are completely out in the open over outright genocidal type behaviors. It's been going on so long that it's on open secret and totally ingrained in the psyches of the ones who feel that way regardless of the country they're living in.
many israelis are secular. u need to learn the difference between jewish ethnicity and judaism. there are also ethiopian jews who arent treated well. theyre still jewish, but not jews.
Bro, this is nothing to do with just the Jewish identity ffs. 🙄 Any commentary on how Russia views itself the same way in taking Ukrainian land? Or America and Russia both just walking into the Middle East whenever they like? It has to do with extremism from a national identity based in geopolitics 🙄🙄 not even going into what Islamic extremists think. All of those examples are wrong btw. You singling out Jewish ppl tells me all I need to know about you.
@@helios7212and you fantasy about Ukraine tells me all I need to know about you child. Russia is doing nothing differently to what the nato peacekeepers did in former Yugoslavia. The people of Ukraine overthrew an elected government using threats of murder in a coup de tat, the donbass population quiet rightly objected, the Ukraine military started killing them. No one is disputing these facts on any side, you have a fantasy bias. Russia has stepped in to stop the violence nothing more.
No they're not secular😂how can an ethno state be secular and democratic at the same time@@andrewlee-py9zm
@@adhkhjcdar634 do u not understand what the word secular means?
Her statement proves how peace loving she is! She sounds very revengeful and ungrateful.
Hateful is the word.
The woman claiming that they do no harm, really lady? How would you call taking someone else’s home then?
This whole «we’re god’s chosen people» and sense of entitlement is very narcissistic, what a sad personality traits to pass on … complete absence of empathy there.
Totally agree !
Every single one vigorous nation is like that.
This 'we are so considerate to others that we don't even remove foreign criminals abusing our welfare system' mindset is, well, a sentiment of a dying people.
Who's here after the Palestinian attack?
Yip
We never hear about the conflict in the media. When we do Palestinians are labelled as ‘terrorists’. The definition of apartheid is “Apartheid refers to the implementation and maintenance of a system of legalized racial segregation in which one racial group is deprived of political and civil rights. Apartheid is a crime against humanity punishable under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.”
Am I missing something or is this the most unjust, morally wrong in every sense and a literally form of modern day colonialism ever ?
We are living also in a religious apartheid
Throwing anybody out of their home is wrong, no matter what way you look at it
I will keep that in mind thank you. It was never there home. Mind your business.
That's nonsense
@@ajvorob9117 thank you for your observation
@@Nimrod85It was there home and the settlers threw them out
UN resolutions condemns Israel
@@Nimrod85
According to what?!
"The oppressor never gives freedom voluntarily, but demands it for himself.”
“The oppressor's power is an illusion, as it is built on the oppression of others.”
- Martin Luther King Jr.
Always wanted to visit there, but seeing how things are in Israel/Palestine, I changed my mind. There’s way too much conflict there for me to feel safe taking my family. The situation is really sad too given that it’s supposed to be the holy land, the land of “milk and honey”. It seems like the land of nightmares to me.
That is because you only see the region on the news when there is trouble and it is inflated a 10 times than it is in reality I suggest you come visit and see the reality with your own eyes
I've heard that Tel Aviv is safe. You can check up with your local travel businesses what places to avoid
The guy at 11:36 is living the dream. He doesn't take ANYTHING from the state, while sitting in a room with electric (provided by the state) light, using water (pumped and purified by the state), flushing toilets (into state provided treatment facitlites), cooking with gas (provided by the state), on a street (paved and maintained by the state), getting health care for his 18 kids (provided by the state), living safely (guarded by the state), using currency (minted by the state), eating food (grown by the state), ... but who am I to judge?
🇵🇸
No truer words said...
as are most of Israel's Arab citizens....
@@brianstockwood6635 You're American, right?
@@brianstockwood6635 You really have no idea what you're talking about. Sure, there is still a significant gray market economy in the Israeli Arab sector (and a lot of criminal activity), but the truth is that many Israeli Arabs are happy to work in regular jobs, pay taxes and enjoy living in a democratic, first world economy. Spend any extended time in Northern Israel and you will see Arabs filling roles at all levels, including many dentists, lawyers, doctors, judges, professors, programmers, hi-tech entrepreneurs, engineers, scientists, and more. As the Haredi community grows larger and becomes even more militantly separate from Israeli society, the Arab sector, on the whole, is becoming a willing, integral, and essential part of Israel's society and economy.
Seeing fascism thrive in a settlements of people who ran from fascism is terrible, how come they can’t look into history and learn the lesson.
the settlements are known to vote far-right
Maybe we will repeat the history of 1930-1940s again?
@@ankokunokayoubi 🙆🏿♂️🙆🏿♂️😱
😂😂😂man they only read their religious book and they torched shops selling smartphones...c'mon 😂
They don't care. ❤
The question remains: Why do the Israelis occupy Palestinian land?
The Question is what is Palestine???
Is they have their own language???
Own history???
Own religion????
Own ethnicity????
Own culture??????
Is there any Palestine before ottoman turks colonized judea for 800 and forcefully convert everyone into islam ☪️️ ????
@@anupamsatpathi2071 It is a piece of Arab land surrounded by an Arab identity and an Arab history from all sides..while Israel we see as a foreign body and its presence in that region does not make sense at all.
@@igotit8319 Well Arabs had their own country which known as a Saudi Arabia🇸🇦 but why Arabs Demanding another country in Judea??????
So is it another proxy state of Arabs right???? 🤔🤔🤔
@@igotit8319 well islam☪️️ originated in Saudi Arabia🇸🇦,approximately 1,500 years ago not in Judea,
Why those foreign religion follower demanding another country in Judea????
@@anupamsatpathi2071 Well said
2:08 gotta love it, she's gloating about taking over land that rightfully belongs to the palestinians and how DW's camera's are the first to see it, and DW dives right in immediately after saying "The new ILLEGAL outpost..."
Great work as always DW Documentary.
and a very militant choice of words "outpost"
This is not too dissimilar to how Britain artificially divided up its colonized British India post WW2 into two religiously differing partitions, Hindu majority India and Muslim majority Pakistan, with a little piece of land in the middle left to be fought over until the early 21st century.
Just like they decided as colonizer or Palestine they had the right to divy it up and play people against people.
The scars of colonization are many around the globe. Even Vietnam probably happened because of kowtowing to a colonizer grasping for its last bits of power.
Healing is needed.
Healing and rectifying the root cause of so much suffering esp by the Palestinian people. They have endured enough.
Every ONE of these countries had nothing but war going back to the first humans in that land…long before ‘colonialism’
What disgusting nation it is to illegally occupy someone else land. Sickening philosophy 😢.
Politics and religion is a deadly combination
when it comes to land ownership in my country, even family members could turn into enemies, many cases are even murder crimes. And I think that way of thinking is not rare around the world. We dont support terrorism but the way Palestinians react is understandable.
they fight for the land because of the silence of the world ... i feel upset for them to call them terrorists
You can have a theocracy, or you can have a democracy. But you can't have both.
works in Iran...
@@banto1Iran isn't a democracy
@@neptune3569 and not all youtube commentators are able to get sarcasm.
Theocracy is inherently democratic so I don’t know what you’re talking about
democracy exists in many forms and faces. people often equate democracy with liberalism/human rights. US has been a democratic nation since its inception, but still allow slavery practice and racial segregation for a century.
Always enjoy watching these documentaries to see what is going on in the world. Respect from Jamaica 🇯🇲
Africa loves u brother
Yamannnnnn respec from England
ONE LOVE JAHMAN❤
Beautiful country name ❤
Iree mon 🎉
Incredible comment at 3:32. "I don't have to invent a reason bigger than the Bible" that's just it right there. Some idea from some mythical religious book
This illegal settling is one of the reasons I have 0 sympathy for this religious community and I am happy to see the Palestinians are now pushing back against this invasion.
Thank you DW for this great documentary, very well put and very truthful.
My husband used to serve in the IDF as medic (it's either that, or jail). During class in which they were instructed what do to in case of settelers-Palestinian conflict/violence, he asked: "What are the regulations in case it's the Jewish setteler who is aggresive and attacks the Palestinian? Am I'm allowed to warn-shoot?" The whole class started attacking him, how can he shoot a fellow Jew? (My husband is not Jewish mind you, the Rabbi didn't allow him to convert). He got so pissed off at the unfairness and descrimination against the Palesinians, since then he refuses to serve and trying to get discharged.
Until the notion that it doesn't matter if you're Jewish or Palestinian, you're still a HUMAN beign and deserve the same rights as everyone, until this will be in the heads and hearts of everyone in Israel, I don't believe the conflict will ever end. Unfortunatly, with the rise of the ultra-right-nationalist parties in Israel, it's just getting worse for all the people who still have their critical thinking intact. And as someone who used to live in a settelment in the West Bank, I HATE those settelers.
If you lived in a settlement once, you would have known that they are a very small minority
את מדברת עברית?
@@supermemememe605 כן, אבל לצערי הם מיעוט שמוביל את האיזור להסלמה ובעידוד הח"כים הנוכחים. רוב האנשים שגרו בישוב שלי גם כן היו נגדם, וגרו מעבר לקו לא מסיבות אידיאולוגיות (כלכליות/אהבו את השומרון). בעלי מילואימניק בשומרון לכן רוב מה שאני יודעת לגביי המצב מגיע ממנו ומה שהוא ראה וחווה.
Your husband is an honest person
If everyone in Israel thinks like you, there will be peace and prosperity in the Middle East. Make your voice be heard. The Palestinian people have suffered enough.
Yes we need peace for all! Literal both descendants from Abraham, no reason everyone shouldn't be able to live in peace like before the British occupation and Cold War 😔
Almost all global conflicts in the World has British fingerprints all over them. Yes, including and especially this one.
@concernedcitizens4110
British influence on the world has only been since ~400yrs. Invasions & domination by many countries/nations & religions have persisted longer than 'Britain' has existed as a nation.
1492, European colonialism: We discovered America.
1916, European colonialism: We are liberating the Holy land.
The imaginary state of Israel, master of fairy tales, are European colonialism..
I’m English and I’m only discovering this over the last year…it’s discusting
Yeah because the U.S. hands are clean 😅
This one has heavy Arab Islamic hands print on it.
As a Jew, I must agree with the strict critique that the Jewish people are being faced with. We do contain many problems, and foremost is in our interaction with the broader world. There is an aloofness to the normal dynamics between ourselves and others and there needs to be a rectification. We cannot assert ourselves by using the new culture to our advantage, for instance, victimhood. We must interact by the normal social rules whether it be in business or in any other other environment. We must not 'collude' together in our dealings with the world and must take each person at their own respective value. For our own identity we can do as we see fit and enjoy our traditions and customs appropriately. However, when in interaction outside of that identity, we must let go of the identity and treat Jews and gentiles with the same regard.
And yes, as one commenter had said bluntly, they [the jewish people] have always asserted their suffering without explaining what was their part in the violence. And surely we have avoided that part of the equation for many centuries. This is something that we must fix, since even if we got the bitter end of any engagement, we surely weren't taking those dynamics seriously enough.
That being said, I would request of those in critique of Jewishness, to study their own motives within their views.
I too will take account for the problems of my identity.
Like if you agree.
Well put!
😊
3:25 "I do not have to invent a reasoning bigger than the bible"
Imagine saying something this insane and thinking you're justified
Such a cruel and unjust reality far from what shown in mainstream media. I appreciate this channel reporting. Hatts Off to you guys .
Dont make them trick you. This is only Palestine. THey killed us and kicked us out by force
1492, European colonialism: We discovered America.
1916, European colonialism: We are liberating the Holy land.
The imaginary state of Israel, master of fairy tales, are European colonialism..
@@Ishi79of course you're a seething Palestine fanboy 😂
Wolves in sheep clothing
Holding their bible in the hands whilst devoured lives n lands
This gf channel is literally posting and saying the exact same bs as mainstream media about israel and the conflict there 💀 you’re watching the wrong channel if you want to know facts.
Like I bet you don’t know that many Palestinians and Israelis in Israel are actually working together in secret to make more peace. These propaganda channels will never tell you that, because they want you to think that all Israelis hate Palestinians, so create more online war between people 😉
Think about that for a second
Most of the comments stated that this could have been ended with agreements within both countries, but you hear the lady herself folks. No wonder this has happened for decades.
How can a human heart stand in front of two babies, a Palestinian and an Israeli one, and feel love only for one of those babies??
Explain to me how this is possible.
Always fascinates people when someone wrote some words thousands of years ago, and modern day people use it to justify taking other peoples land..
Wish it was true , taking peoples land based on fiction books
lol I love how you don't realise that other secular historical documents say it is their Ancestral land as well
@@chibuikee7482 pls enlighten us.. happy to learn, links and notes would be of great help. Tks..
@@chibuikee7482 😆😅🤣😂
It is just double-standards, chose what benefits them. Can a native American walk into the farm and claim the land belong to their ancestors?
Never failed to deliver the truth..congratulations DW
Pure lies
What truth? All I saw were lies and Zionist propaganda here.
Dw has a history of being very bias
LOL.
DW never...failed...to deliver... truth....???
God, is this some joke attempt?
I appreciate ( here in Canada) your reporting on crucial elements of our world. We need more of this.
Hey Martin, thanks for watching! We appreciate your feedback. Greetings from Germany :)
@@DWDocumentary what about Yemen Sir?
not as if the cbc will show you the truth...
You think they can make docu about every topic in 1 day???@@peacefollower5026
beware of dw, it's code of conduct is clearly supporting zionist agenda to systematically remove all palestinian from their land
@5:42 a very angry peaceful woman.
Thank you for this DW. I always look forward to your documentaries. Greetings from 🇵🇭
For context, the Haredi (Ultra-Orthodox) man speaking at 12:45, is a member of a specific group within Ultra-Orthodoxy, one of the few, who claim "try to take nothing from the state."
As a whole, the Ultra-Orthodox sector gets the largest amount of social welfare and benefits from the state, while having low economic contribution, less than 50% of the men in the community work, practically no military or national service, all funded by the taxpayers. This year alone, Netanyahu's coalition allocated over $2 Billion for their yeshivas and kollels (religious schools for children and married men alike), as well as massive budgets for the celebration of days commemorating renowned rabbis. This is the largest budget they've received to date, while countless other sectors are miserably underfunded. A majority have no problem taking from the state, from people like me, even though they spite the state. This is not to say that I disagree with funding schools, nor do I disagree with a welfare state that protects it's citizens, I disagree with the massive unbalance and unfairness of how this is distributed vs. how it's contributed to.
Netanyahu isnt any better than Putin.
So?
Putin is a whole next level of savagery and brutality but you are correct in there's something that rhymes in Putin's insisting that Eastern Europe is "his" and Israel's insistence that certain lands are "theirs", in both cases without regard for whoever is living there and has been for a long time.
Absolutely
I didn't know Netanyahu assassinates his political opponents.
not all israelis think like these settlers, personally I live in haifa which is a city in which arabs and jews live peacefully, i dont like seeing people taking over these lands and settling in it and i believe it is wrong. israelis and palestinians are not enjoying this situation and the constant fighting, it leads to hatred between both sides. Me and most of other israelis wish for peace and to end this conflict. nobody is benefitting from this.
The government is supporting them.
Most Israelis actually sheer for settlers, even the "progressive" left does nothing to block the advance of settlements in the west bank.
I wish all israelites and your government think and were like you...
I'm going to use the "god gave it to me" tactic and try stealing a car.
:)))
One cannot live on a lie forever.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸v
Islam won't go anywhere.
Maybe because all of us are mortals?
@@caustictoad or because evil is mortal....🤷♂️🤷♀️🤷
@@FahadFSA Nah. We - humans,are mortal
Wow I feel so bad for the world. We will never have peace😢
War in the east! War in the west! Everywhere is war!
Not until jesus return to judge the entire inhabited earth. We will have peace but not in this system..not in this world but in the new world to come Read
💎Revelation 21:3, 4;
💎1 John 3:8-10;💎John 12:31-35; 💎1 John 5:18, 19. 🤷🏿♀️
What can we do 🤷🏻 how can you have a peace when muslims exists be logical
time to black to shine
@@whatsgood3854 did you not watch the video
Incredible! Override a Supreme Court? And the U.S. sends billions to this country???😢😢
Yes. We back Saudi Arabia, too. Their supreme court has nothing to do with Americans.
Nazi imitators 🥴
Can this old lady live in this times like 20th century
Damn the lady who said Israelis are non-violent should be the president of America (i'm sure she has a double citizenship anyways lol)... denying violence with that ease ain't an easy skill.
Thank you DW for letting us know what different corners of the world are like in the most objective way. Excellent work as always 👏🏼
I live in Israel. This video is clearly not objective. In addition the video contains embarrassing factual errors. For example, it is said at the end of the video that the government plans to pass a law according to which it will be able to override over any ruling of the supreme court (overcoming clause). And another law that would give the coalition a majority. But *It's bullshit*.
Regarding the override clause, 8 months ago the government suggested that the government could overcome the Supreme Court's verdict of canceling laws if that verdict were not accepted unanimously. However, this offer was dropped from the proposal a few months ago and is no longer part of the government's planned reform.
Regarding the selection of judges, according to the updated proposal, the government wants to change the composition of the committee for selecting judges so that the coalition and the opposition have an equal share. No one will have a majority and they will have to compromise. Different from the absurd situation today where the judges in Israel choose themselves (there is no normal country in the world where this is the case). By the way, in Germany, France and most European countries the coalition has a majority.
Most of the video shows extreme and delusional fringes that do not represent Israel. For example, the ultra-orthodox who spoke are radically different from the average ultra-Orthodox you will meet in Israel
that could be any where like pi
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Israel 🇮🇱 brutality 😆 no sanctions? Hypocrite
The most objective way? He said illegal Jewish outpost. You call that objective? Israel owns the entire region. Period. Put that in your pipe and smoke it (objectively of course)
This is so upsetting! Why can’t they just share and live in peace? They both have holy lands and can recognize each other in peace. Hated and violence just breeds more hatred and violence
True, but unfortunately life doesn't work like that! Humanity is doomed!
So the ‘promised land’ was not given by God, but by the British?
Are you seriously learning about religion from a news station on youtube? What country did you go school in?
@@thor.halsli DW Documentary is actually one of the few decent sources on youtube
Very funy promised land is for muslim masjid gaza not israil and musa was muslim isa was muslim also israil does not exist
A country within someone else's country.
Hate only fuels more hate. We lived in a finite world. At the end everyone need everyone. Peace
someone in germany was right
Hopefully one day there will be peace and tolerance between Israel and Palestine
It is a disastrous land. If it is a chosen land, residents who are from different religions should peacefully live together rather than war here.
isreali be like "why many people around the world hate us?" while they do things like this
Yeah I'm glad to see there's pushback from within israel, but how many of these people are just protesting the changes that will now inconvenience them, after a lifetime of reaping the rewards that the national religious agenda has provided? They seem to be having a pretty good time at the beach while the zealots expand the territory. Don't forget, military service is mandatory, so literally everyone has either directly or indirectly participated and supported that agenda.
@@soth897 I liked your comment so I'll respond to it.
Being a part of the IDF is mandatory since Israel has been attacked many times, and will probably be again in the future, by other countries.
I agree it's a shame soldier have to do the Government's sometimes questionable decisions, but overall the its a net good to serve.
Also, of course people are "fighting for their rights now, when it causes an inconvenience to them", I think that's always the case, in every country.
Finally, I am not sure which rewards the national religious agenda has provided.
Israel was built on atheistic values by non-believers, but the amount of religious people grew due to immigration and well... high birth rates.
The "religious agenda" therefor, is hardly a national one, and most surly wasn't until the last election, which even then, these maniacs are only getting what they want, since Bibi will give them anything for them to support him at his weakest.
We need better education for these populations, like we should support better education for the Palestinians, then perhaps it will be easier to think of the other side as people and not an enemy.
Most Israelis want piece, most don't want anything to do with is happening politically to them and to the Palestinians, and most will give back the west bank gladly.
Yeah, not like there was any antisemitism Before the creation of Israel 😐
@@erniescrabshackwhen the victim becomes the perpetrator you can't pull the victim card😐
I really appreciate this documenter opening my eyes to the variance of vision that happening in the state of Israel right now. This does not only happen in Israel, but it also happens in my country Indonesia, which is getting more polarized than before, since we opened to democracy in 1998. Live for peace and freedom of peace to all nations!!
Kerusuhan Mei 1998 has nothing to do with Democracy.
if they'd all realise they are brainwashed by a fantasy religion, a peaceful solution would be much easier to accomplish
🙏🙏🙏😔😔
@@subswithoutvids-dw6dvjadi apa donk bang?
Same in nigeria, democracy has away of making enemies for people thanks to its foot soldiers (politicians) who are solely mandated to to occupy the leadrship class, more restrictions and censorship should limit their actions on divide and rule but guess what, they are the law makers as well
I am sooo saddened by this!
One word: Religion...
Fascism
Apartheid
Imposters
Hitler and Stalin killed millions of people on the basis of secular ideologies...
If you want good people to do terrible things, you'll need religion (Christopher Hitchens)
Promised land by the British 😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂 yeah very funy
I love the couple with their wedding dress shop and kids. What an inspiration in a country that wants them gone
The audacity is unbelievable!!
Israel's shift to the extreme right under Netanyahu is a depressing and unpleasant thing to see. His 14 years ruling Israel aren't what the United States should be eager to endorse.
Right wing is better than loony left wing
@@thegreataynrand7210 Hitler is better than Stalin is your argument at that rate?
I would argue why embrace either extreme side.
Not surprising. It was always a question of when and not if!
@@thegreataynrand7210 No offense intended, but I'm tired of extremist wings - left or right.
There's nothing wrong with something in the middle of the spectrum - rather than having to endure fanatics from either end constantly out to destroy the other.
Uncontrolled communism or uncontrolled fascism - those are the only choices? No wonder things are so miserable.
Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
@@pm3302 Trump vs Biden is like having to decide if the president is going to be governing from a prison cell or an assisted-care facility. Blimey! 😳
@27:13 This Part! What a good final few words to sum up the core of the situation.
You must all go back to the Balfour declaration
its sad that nobody can have an apolitical documentary.
I wonder if comment section will stay open
Don't count on it. Germans beat the bandwagon of freedom of speech untill it comes to Israel.
I was surprised myself, and even more so when I saw it wasn't Just a deluge of antisemitism.
All in the name of religion. Doesn't seem very fair to anyone else who doesn't have the same beliefs? How about equal treatment for all? Seems like religion separates more than bringing together. Seems like religion is more about control.
They use religion as a shield to their apartheid, violence and ethnical cleansing.
65% of Israeli say that they are either not religious or convinced atheists this is according to gallup.
Guess what? Not everyone believes in secularism and liberalism either. Theology states grant control to God whereas your ideology grants control to humans.
Religion is just a tool for the politicians, businessmen, criminal organizations and war profiteers.
if it was just about religion, any goy could convert to Judaism and get treated equally but that's not really the case, is it? try claiming birthright when you're just a gentile convert lol, they'll boot you out so fast it'll make your head spin (after a dna test)
Daniela Weiss is wrong. The land of Palestinians is not Jewish's Land!
Where was she and her ancestors for thousands of years if it was her land
Excellent documentary...
🇵🇸
Excellent documentary.... DW Documentaries are the best!.
She sickened me
Question: why did tou remove thr Israel documentary?
I love DW Documentary channel. The best!
🇵🇸
you should read dw code of conduct that give special treatment to the creation of settler colonialism in Palestine
I did not understand the documentary, why Jews are settling illegally in Israel?
The guy with 18 kids, doesn't work, and yet denies the Israeli state and the woman at 5:08 are really something else.
My grandfather left Budapest after the II. WW at the age of 16 and joined the british Army in Palestine. He also stole ammunition for Irgun, Stern and Hagana and supported them by other means too. They fought to establish the independent jewish state. He married a hungarian women and had a son, whom he left in Haifa in 1955 after he returned to Budapest, Hungary. My uncle had a wife and two children who lived in Tel Aviv, but now the whole family is preparing to leave their country. After the election they became too desperate and took part in the demonstrations. Beside that a criminal is leading their country, their conflict is not only with the government but those supporters of the government, like ortodox religious persons, who do not contribute (not paying taxes, refusing military training) only taking benefits (healthcare, voting) while they are also provoking conflicts. After living for like 70 years in a country of constant conflicts you get tired of it specially when you see that the biggest domestic crisis is caused by religion, nationalism and extremism between jews itself. I think many, many israelies think the same as my uncle and as some people in this video which will cause an emigration wave from Israel. For this reason this become a very sad 75th birthday for Israel.
So sorry to see you go! Just a tip: don't forget to continue paying the Social Security payments, would be a shame if when you eventually return you would be hit by a massive surprise payment.
Not a sad day we made it a horrible dream for what you are doing in Palestine InshaAllah ready
What was built with lies, will never stay
Which Country was their Country that they were leaving?
stenen gooien komt van moslims ze stenegen hun vrouwen en ik zie niets van wat je zegt als ze eens 2 kinderen namen inplaats van 20 en werken dan heb je ruimte en goed eten ga wat verbouwen
That Oro program is a very very forward thinking idea I have never even considered that ever.
Found this video while trying to understand what just happened yesterday, 07.10.2023, when Hamas launched an unprecedented attack on Israel. All I can say is what history has taught us: war brings consolidation of power. One plus one is always equal to two.
thats exactly why i am here
Same
Great documentary, thanks, from Brazil. Just wish for negotiation ASAP.
In depth, thought provoking piece. Excellent work, DW!
🇵🇸
whats a non kosher cell phone ? I never even heard of that company. I know like nikiea and apple.
July 25/23 The Portuguese parliament has overwhelmingly voted in favor of a resolution recognizing Nakba Day or “Day of Catastrophe,” when Israel was created at the expense of the forced expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homeland.
The parliament also praised the Palestinian struggle to obtain the right to self-determination.
At the same time, the Portuguese resolution condemned the Israeli regime’s expansionist and annexation policies, emphasizing that the practices are in blatant violation of international laws.
This is AWESOME! Thank you so much for that wonderful information. (Meanwhile, here in the U.S. the Congress felt it just HAD to pass a ridiculous resolution stating that Israel is not an apartheid state. The only way to see that in a positive light is that it's a reaction to the growing understanding, even in Israel-financing-USA, that indeed it IS an apartheid state.)
@@joydworkin I'm sure your conclusion that Israel is an apartheid state is based on your extensive travel within the country and a willingness to talk to people on both sides of the conflict....
@@brianstockwood6635 Yes, actually.....
Cry me a river
Long live Israel!
@@brianstockwood6635even human rights group within Israel calling Israel an apartheid state and they themselves are Israelis
Unfortunately for the Palestinians the loss in 47 essentially gave Israel a green light to do whatever they want. The recent attack was all Israel needed to get some sympathy around the world and an excuse to permanently remove the Palestinians.
That woman is a demon
There is probably not a most poisoned land due to religion and nationalism in the history of the whole humanity.
When you take another man’s freedom you might as well forget about your own freedom!
This conflict is so complex that everyone is guilty of something. Comprehending its complexity leads me to the conclusion that taking sides doesn't make justice to anyone and is mostly based on a lazy and simplistic interpretation.
So please explain what opinion would be best. At some point you are either for or against Israel. There will always be a bottom line.
@@teec. Zionism itself is an extremely unethical ideology, and the conflict is a direct result of Zionist ideology unfolding, so ultimately, Israel should not have been established to begin with. Since it's here, an exist explicitly under law as an ethno-state for Jewish people, the only real solution is to entirely dismantle it, and in fact dismantle every part of the two-state solution entirely. A new secular state built on equal rights ad representation must be built from the ground up, but that's not gonna happen without a bunch of bloodshed at this point.
Upvote. The simplistic urge to divide players into good and evil is so frustrating, especially in these last weeks. People cheering for or shrugging off death on whichever side they dislike... An excuse to forget one's own humanity
How can you have peace ? when you are stealing lands??
The Israeli people should have defended human rights when they had the chance. It’s no longer just the Palestinians who suffer. It’s everyday Israelis’ turn now.
Salam, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace.
The Condition Set For The Children Of Israel, Is The Covenant, They Disobey Torah On The Native Palestinians Treatment. Now The IDF Attack Their Own Israeli People For Having Another Point Of View.
Israelis dont exist.
@@victoriatsi9778 its not karma actually, left wing supporters are discriminated by netanyahu circle same as he discriminates to palestinian. nothing to talk about karma, mostly left wing israelis are tolerate to palestinians
We have this going on in the USA right now - the Fascist states are making life worse for the very people who are pro-Fascism. Also see Brexit in the UK.
Israel is often ranked in top 10 "happy nation" idex.
May Allah protect our Palestinian brothers and sisters
Free Palestine
What is "paliestan"?
@@triola3983 it has been the name of this land for thousands of years. it had also been called kanàn, but never Israel.
Israel is the name of a kingdom that ruled over part of Palestine. it's like if we call iran as akamenidia because thousands of years ago it was ruled by the akamenids
@@triola3983Ask uncle google ??!!
I’m sure you know Auschwitz???!!!
Free Palestine and its people☝️
@m.h.m7509 The kingdom of Israel existed, we can't say the same about kingdom of "paliestan"
This is crazy.....so purposefully creating settlements although they know it's illegal...
So sad, the Palestinians are losing their land because of religion.... I just wonder sometimes how come Rich Muslim country dont help them... I guess there will be no straight forward answer...
To help them you have to go to war
To fight you have to get weapones and equipments
Arab industry lacks alot in manifauction of weapones most of their armies relies on military deals with foreign countries like US, UK, france, russian, china and south korea
So they can't handle big casualties in equipment and the arab hate high rate of human casualties because even if they defeated israel they have to be ready for the NATO intervention to restore israel back
@@deemahalsanonah1944
It's problamatic but it can be dealt with
They will use nuclear weapones when their military is totally defeated
But here is a problem, if they use nuclear weapones, they will be effected by the radiation and the effects of the bombing because their lands with the arabs is close to each other unlike US and Russia situation or even China
Second to use nuclear weapones against the arab cities kills the option of peaceful surrender, how do you think the soldiers will treat israelite citizens when they know their cities been attacked nuclear bombs
Also this will open the that these countries retalite by the same weapones like pakistan and maybe iran if that ever happen in the near future
But the hardest obstecle is the counter attack of the Nato
@@BESTINTHEWORLD0007or they know the truth hence Arabs talking about peace with Israel because they can't win
No one wants them beaceuse they belive arabs shouldnt loose land. Also phalestinians might destabizle the rich arab country they get in. Lebanon civil war is largely casued by this
@BESTINTHEWORLD0007 it literally would start the ww 3
Excellent coverage of a very real issue. Sadly the Likes and views for the video remains quite scare. 😢
"I do not have to invent any reasoning..." while saying an invisible man told her it's ok