HOSTAGES: THE MEDIA GETS THE STORY WRONG

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025

Комментарии • 102

  • @ronmey7500
    @ronmey7500 5 месяцев назад +20

    These talks should be getting hundreds of thousands of views.

    • @leonid3438
      @leonid3438 5 месяцев назад

      to help them get there, don't forget to press the "Like" button! And of course, comment if there is something to say.

  • @alexgurevich5230
    @alexgurevich5230 4 месяца назад +1

    I LOVED!!! 99% of Gadi's attempt to "master" the English language joke!!! It seems that Gadi's superiority in English over 99% Israeli born, is a source of his pride ( and rightly so!!!) and pocking him right in it ...was hilarious !!! Gadi and Mike - keep up the good work , WE love you !!!
    PLEASE!!! Start paying more attention to propagating your wonderful thoughts and STOP being so shy about asking for Likes, subscriptions, media sharing etc,etc - both of you have a great sense of humor - you'll be able to squeeze in the request better than anyone else.
    Thank you !!!

  • @Catssandra13
    @Catssandra13 5 месяцев назад +6

    Thank you both for the excellent discussion.
    Gadi, you and I are on the same page, I agree with all you said about the leftists here - not one word condemning Hamas!!!
    I actually said the same things you said to my friends here in Israel, but some still insist that Bibi is the guilty party and they NEVER say Hamas.
    Which leaves me with one conclusion: they only care about bringing down Bibi and the hostages are not their priority.

  • @jackg9006
    @jackg9006 5 месяцев назад +11

    We need more than once a week episodes from you both. Please.

  • @elishevarochefort-hyatt4568
    @elishevarochefort-hyatt4568 5 месяцев назад +7

    M.Netanyahu is being a true statesman during this tragic war of Israel against Muslim terrorism and the cowardly corrupt or useful idiots of the progessist globalist agenda. M.Netanyahu stands as a true leader of the civilized and responsible Western nation-states. With respect and gratitude.

  • @Marchonello
    @Marchonello 5 месяцев назад +5

    I am Israeli and yet love to listen to your updates since it is impossible to listen to mainstream media.
    Thank you for your work!
    I think you weekly program is an important, really valuable for somone who interested in truth and clear thinking about Israel security issues.

  • @SigalAlon
    @SigalAlon Месяц назад

    Absolutely brilliant account of the current situation. Thank you both for keeping our sanity!

  • @lucylevina5140
    @lucylevina5140 5 месяцев назад +3

    I am from Australia and follow you religiously every Thursday as we are far ahead of you in time.

  • @SuperYonala
    @SuperYonala 5 месяцев назад +2

    This is the best account of the situation i've ever seen !!

  • @richardmartyn7865
    @richardmartyn7865 5 месяцев назад +11

    Carlson was obviously silent after 7/10.That's when I suspected his woke antisemitism.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад +2

      He always seemed suspicious to me.

  • @donwoolley5763
    @donwoolley5763 5 месяцев назад +9

    You two gentlemen are excellent & we support Netanyahu, Israel & their efforts!!!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇮🇱🇮🇱

  • @anchormax3597
    @anchormax3597 5 месяцев назад +17

    By Islam's decree, a permanent cease fire, is only permanent until such a time where the believers have the upper hand or the opportunity to further the cause of Islam.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад +1

      The “hudna” imperative.

    • @sababan1226
      @sababan1226 5 месяцев назад +2

      @@yonason6047 Treaty of al-Hudaybiya and the Koreish tribe.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад

      😃👍

  • @saritpeer7391
    @saritpeer7391 5 месяцев назад +1

    wow, that dumb mistake caught me off guard.... how did it became normal, to distort history like that, and just lie! truth has no meaning anymore. it's really disturbing, and so important of you to bring it to our attention. thank you for that, and please shed some more light on this.

  • @hollyylloh515
    @hollyylloh515 5 месяцев назад +9

    Excellent episode, thank you ❤🙏💯🇬🇧🌟🌟

  • @deborahfreedman333
    @deborahfreedman333 5 месяцев назад +8

    Glad to see you are still here. Missed your excellent analysis yesterday.

    • @michaeldoran3568
      @michaeldoran3568 5 месяцев назад +3

      Sorry about that. Rough schedule. Thanks for your support.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад +1

      I thought Gadi told us last time that you would be late this week?
      (I still checked yesterday, anyway. You guys are addictive. 😃)

  • @SuperYonala
    @SuperYonala 5 месяцев назад +2

    These two men are a perfect example of how to speak !

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад

      Shmoozing with intense focus?

  • @ronarubin
    @ronarubin 5 месяцев назад +1

    Love you guys so much. I wish these podcasts were 3 hours. I would listen

  • @sherylkruger3344
    @sherylkruger3344 5 месяцев назад +8

    Thank you. Love listening to you

  • @PolarNorthWis
    @PolarNorthWis 5 месяцев назад +18

    I had withdraws yesterday Tuesday not having the show❣️Praying that BiBi stays Strong to stay the course❗️Hamas playing the Israeli and World sympathies. Thank the Lord the crowd doesn’t steer the ship.
    Blessings, F.T.Duprey

    • @michaeldoran3568
      @michaeldoran3568 5 месяцев назад +3

      Thank you!

    • @mayaportner1665
      @mayaportner1665 5 месяцев назад +2

      Me too I kept refreshing my subscription page on RUclips

    • @PolarNorthWis
      @PolarNorthWis 5 месяцев назад

      @@mayaportner1665 Hi, I kept watching for it Tuesday, I forget you can refresh, Thanks, I will remember do Refresh with other channels I am watching for release❣️

    • @PolarNorthWis
      @PolarNorthWis 5 месяцев назад

      @@michaeldoran3568 Remember to tell Gadi to say to hit the Like 👍🏻 at beginning of Update, get that algorithm/exponential curve going Upward ⬆️ 😎

  • @thomaskimball3789
    @thomaskimball3789 5 месяцев назад +2

    What about the children who were decapitated in front of their parents and the others who were murdered during the unprovoked attack by hamas , wasn’t their lives worth anything?

  • @Rexident97
    @Rexident97 5 месяцев назад +10

    44:31 very important point here
    70% ~ Israeli want a hostage deal
    70% ~ Israeli also think we need to stay in Philadelphia
    The obvious solution would be make the deal & go back in after BUT thanks to Blinken & Co. we don’t know if we can. I blame all dead hostages on Iran Hamas & Biden Harris (in this order)

    • @Catssandra13
      @Catssandra13 5 месяцев назад +3

      Add Qatar to that list of who to blame, also Turkey and Egypt. All are complicit.

    • @Rexident97
      @Rexident97 5 месяцев назад

      @@Catssandra13 Turkey & Qatar 2 Islamic shitholes we don’t really care about them but the US our best Ally we need right now and we don’t get much from this administration > #jewsfortrump #trump2024

    • @unisophia
      @unisophia 5 месяцев назад

      we won’t be able to go back if we get out.

  • @Misty-r1k
    @Misty-r1k 5 месяцев назад +2

    I'm so thankful that I found you guys both the Israel Update and the Hudson Institute. Of course I LIKE every episode and cherish your inside insight. Please, occasionally, cover more of the slimy antisemites like Tucker Carlson so I can be informed about these online personalities. I never listen to them because I don't want to help their channels. If you put his name and picture on your the front of the video, you may also be able to attract his viewership to deprogramme them. Thanks again. ❤❤❤❤

  • @vintageglee6406
    @vintageglee6406 5 месяцев назад +9

    Excellent discussion! It is absolutely infuriating that people don’t want to understand how horribly difficult this situation is and more so, who we are dealing with, both on our enemies and our allies side. If there is anyone after October 7 who still doesn’t understand the situation Israel is in, they are blind and deaf.

  • @JLP4444
    @JLP4444 5 месяцев назад +1

    Mike has Martyr Made's number better than anyone else.

  • @dianasharonschenker7046
    @dianasharonschenker7046 5 месяцев назад +3

    NETANYAHU SHOULD STAY STRONG...

  • @SuperYonala
    @SuperYonala 5 месяцев назад +1

    I was having it out w a leftie friend ! I think Netanyahu is doing what he can and really is a good guy !

  • @SuperYonala
    @SuperYonala 5 месяцев назад +1

    This isrhe best account of the situation ive ever seen !!]

  • @ToasterToastingToast
    @ToasterToastingToast 5 месяцев назад

    Reminder: Gadi tell us about Nadal's dumb take on news & Mike never told us about Sen. Schumer's squats during Netanyahu's Congress address.

  • @yonason6047
    @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад +4

    Thank you for the abu ali express tip!

  • @jomartvr
    @jomartvr 5 месяцев назад +4

    Tucker Carlson is a refined version of Patrick Buchanan, IMHO

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад

      Good point.
      This just in at the Powerline blog
      “THE TUCKER OP: A FOOTNOTE” by Scott Johnson
      “As anyone who pays the price of shedding brain cells to listen to the video will discover, Carlson agrees with Cooper. He isn’t just asking questions. He seeks to promote Cooper’s views.”

  • @TheEuclid26
    @TheEuclid26 5 месяцев назад +4

    Why didn't/doesn't Netanyahu push back against the Hamas numbers of deaths during the war. He only did when talking about the Rafah operation, but everyone seems to accept the Hamas death count. The 1 to 1 radio is not a push back!

  • @jomartvr
    @jomartvr 5 месяцев назад +3

    How does Israel move forward when Israeli society is divided so sharply into two camps?

    • @sababan1226
      @sababan1226 5 месяцев назад +2

      @jomartvr: very carefully...this is why enemies (and friends) conduct information warfare operations to achieve their policy (other) goals.

  • @russhouldin5774
    @russhouldin5774 5 месяцев назад +1

    Very interesting. Question: why does not Netanyahu fire Gallant? Does Gallant control a block of the Likud? I know Bibi had to back off firing him once but that was over Levin;s justice reforms.

  • @kaisersoza7937
    @kaisersoza7937 4 месяца назад

    Cooper is a squirrel, worried about Tucker though. He doesn’t speak for America on Israel. Bless the IDF great show. Keep the faith.

  • @ShelleyBradford-s9l
    @ShelleyBradford-s9l 5 месяцев назад +2

    I wondered where was the Tuesday podcast 😊

  • @mayaportner1665
    @mayaportner1665 5 месяцев назад +1

    So good

  • @lucylevina5140
    @lucylevina5140 5 месяцев назад +1

    There are two other organisations Fond Tikva and fond Gvura or Gvira of relatives of hostages and solders which are completely oppose any negotiations and deal and insist on increasing an army pressure on hamas and stopping “humanitarian aid” to hamas. I am very surprised that you guys do not mentioned them. They protested at Bibi residence in Jerusalem agains these deals etc.

  • @peterdalton649
    @peterdalton649 5 месяцев назад +3

    Re: Tablet/Israel Update Sep 4, 2024
    Excellent analysis, thank you.
    Gentlemen:
    I have been considering some questions, and would like your opinion, perhaps these could form a discussion point in a future Tablet/Israel Update?
    1. Why am I wrong: The US should give Iran 24 hours to return all hostages, produce unconditional surrender of both Hamas and Hezbollah, and stand-down the Yemeni rebels. In 24 hours and one minute, if these have not been completed, the US military will destroy strategic targets throughout Iran, blockade all land/sea/air ports, interrupt inter-Iranian communications, halt all inter-Iranian financial transactions, and demand regime change from Iran.
    a) Is it because these consequences would be perceived as acts of war, as compared with acts of defense for an ally?
    b) Would the US Congress be required to vote for such an action, such as a war declaration?
    c) Would this achieve the goals Israel has outlined?
    d) Do you think recent Sino/Russian "alliances" would stand behind Iran militarily?
    I was thinking that, as we observe there are no genuine consequences that can be delivered against a sub-state terror army, does endangering the viability of it's sponsor change the calculus? And, from the glass house archives, we must ask, "Would the US be able to mount a successful defense were it's actions similarly challenged?"

    • @sababan1226
      @sababan1226 5 месяцев назад

      @peterdalton649: At this moment and under this administration, especially fighting for its life politically and electorally, not to mention intellectually from its abhorrent public and foreign policy, what incentive (leaving aside proportional justification) do you think this administration has to specifically make threats and attack another country, especially when they've stated on the record (dishonestly) that Iran had nothing to do with Hamas's invasion of Israel.
      You're stating an opinion, which can be wrong, but it's difficult to disprove an opinion. There are risks, benefits, and potential repercussions (bilaterally and internationally) to all potential actions.
      Let's be clear: Hamas just executed an American Citizen. Grounds for action are established, but the all-out war you call for is a bit of a stretch with international law now (this is not Sarajevo, 1914 with the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand).
      a) perceived by whom? US public? Other nations? Individual critics of the US? International organizations and institutions?
      b) if it were a declaration of war it would require Congress to declare it per the constitution (yet many military actions have circumvented this throughout history).
      c) IF the US could pull all that off, COULD it achieve all that you've asked? Doubtful.
      d) I don't believe an official defense alliance currently exists with China or Russia, but it's been discussed publicly for a while now. I would suspect that such actions by the US against Iran would elicit responses from either or both countries (likely the Chinese would allow Russia to do the dirty work as they're oft-inclined).
      These are my opinions, clearly not those of the hosts, but IMHO this is a bit of a stretch.

  • @Art-dr7no
    @Art-dr7no 5 месяцев назад

    Relevant to Anglio-Zionist Conspiracy b.s., imo: Caroll Quigley-Tragedy and Hope: A History of the World in Our Times, 1981

  • @atarporat3454
    @atarporat3454 5 месяцев назад

    Question for Mike- in one of your lectures in Hillsdale College you mentioned the Obama-Biden view of the middle east. The assumptions and approach towards the balance of power in the middles east seems to have a connecting line to the State Department's views in the 50's as described in your book, Ike's Gamble. How did the situation come about where there is an entrenched deep state bureaucratic machine in the State Dept with these views that seem to dictate appeasement policies towards America's (and Israel's adversaries)? PS. Mike would you say that Gadi is the male right wing version of a "childless cat lady"?

  • @PeterRichmond-x1k
    @PeterRichmond-x1k 5 месяцев назад +3

    😊😊😊😊😊

  • @stevenrosenberg5998
    @stevenrosenberg5998 5 месяцев назад +4

    I think thisd was your best episode. I appreciated the explanation of what I see as misguided coverage of the demonstrations in Israel that were very upsetting to me. Do you have any breakdown of the demonstrators and how it correlates to the general population? My hunch is the demonstrators are a very thin slice of Israeli society -- but you would not know that by the coverage.

  • @yanivreif7379
    @yanivreif7379 5 месяцев назад

    The real problem of the deal is not even Philadelphi which is a problem but it’s that Gazans will be allowed to come back to northern Gaza in 3rd or 7th day (I don’t remember rn) of the ceasefire.
    If the Gazans comes back to northern the war will be affectively over because Israel will have a world of trouble to evacuate the people who came back in case Hamas breaks the deal and the second phase won’t will be stuck.
    In that case the war would be stoped with an Israeli defeat and Hamas still holding a few dozens of hostages.

  • @nirginat100
    @nirginat100 5 месяцев назад

    לצוות של גדי טאוב יש לכם תוכנית נהדרת אני אומנם קורא באנגלית אבל היה לכם תוכניות עם תרגום בעברית שהיה נהדר להשלים את ההבנה באופן מלא אני חושב שאתם צריכים לפנות בתוכנית ההסברה המצוינת הזאת של דוקטור גדי טאוב התותח עם תרגום בעברית כי זה יגדיל את החשיפה.

  • @BHF1912
    @BHF1912 5 месяцев назад

    Netanjahu, Galant, settlers occuparors soon in Den Haag Netherlands 😁

  • @eliyahukonn3245
    @eliyahukonn3245 5 месяцев назад

    Your/our weakness is that there is a discussion that there be a violent response.....no, duh.

  • @unisophia
    @unisophia 5 месяцев назад

    @MahyarTousiTV, you must see this to understand what’s going on in Israel, for real.

  • @eliyahukonn3245
    @eliyahukonn3245 5 месяцев назад

    It is likely not the majority, the so-called will of the people since shas and utj always go to the highest bidder.

  • @eliyahukonn3245
    @eliyahukonn3245 5 месяцев назад

    I think you two may consider that just because someone doesn't take Israel seriously, that that doesn't equate to antisemitism. And maybe you shouldn't place all your eggs in that basket since we have among us those that seems to hate us more than any outsider. Of course you are correct that getting views is everyone's main goal, yours being for the good of the world. It's complicated.

  • @sababan1226
    @sababan1226 5 месяцев назад +2

    Intractable, maybe? 🙂 (your word: inextractably, possibly a combination of your 40+ brain combining inextricably and not extractable). It might be also that they are inextricably geographically linked or intertwined and a situation out of which they cannot extract themselves because of the geographic entanglements.
    But don't be so stubborn or worry...Gaza 2005 is your guide and Israel can just leave YSH and reconquer it anytime (extreme sarcasm alert) with likely a renewed energy towards bilateral and permanent peace. The Palestinians will inherit all that infrastructure and housing and will be so thankful to Israel for providing it for them as they are when such things were gifted in the past! They can have a Switzerland in the West Bank and a Singapore in Gaza. Then again, maybe it might, just perhaps, turn out differently from the imaginings of people who are so disconnected from how the real world works between Jihadis and dhimmis in the Middle East.

  • @unisophia
    @unisophia 5 месяцев назад

    check Tucker’s sponsors. he’s a sellout.

  • @BernardGifford
    @BernardGifford 5 месяцев назад +3

    Are you claiming that all of the critics of the Prime Minister incorrect, or stupid, or cowards?
    Also, are you also claiming that President Biden, a 40-year ally of Israel, has no grounds for criticizing the Prime Minister?
    I look forward to your podcast, even though I often disagree with you. But today's conversation was outrageous.

    • @marchess286
      @marchess286 5 месяцев назад

      "are you also claiming that President Biden, a 40-year ally of Israel, has no grounds for criticizing the Prime Minister". Actually, Mike and Gadi are not so naive or dishonest to believe or claim that Biden is a "40-year ally of Israel", unless someone can be an ally by saying nice and hamish things before wealthy, foolish, soft American Jewish donors. Allies don't support the Iran nuclear deal that funded 07.10. Or, they at least reverse course afterwards.

    • @lucylevina5140
      @lucylevina5140 5 месяцев назад

      IMHO this conversation is the best! If you still did not realise that biden is a puppet and a puppet master is obama, too bad.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад

      @user-no6tp6nr4k
      Nice summary of Bibi’s critics.
      Old Joe is just showing his true colors, comfortably pandering to whoever he thinks will give him the most votes.

  • @elisolomon8741
    @elisolomon8741 5 месяцев назад +3

    C'mon, fellas.
    Its too loose and folksy.
    The subject matter warrants a little more. Sorry to be a critic.
    I do appreciate your content.
    Am Yisrael Chai. 🇮🇱

    • @michaeldoran3568
      @michaeldoran3568 5 месяцев назад +5

      A couple of people have made this criticism. I'll discuss it with Gadi. I understand what you are saying, but I don't think we are going to change the format/style, partly because these are real conversations that we enjoy having, not scripted at all. I look forward to our weekly talk, partly because I enjoy having a laugh with him.

    • @marchess286
      @marchess286 5 месяцев назад

      not too "folksy". We all realize there is an existential war going on. Many of us have relatives over there. But Gadi is an Israeli and Mike is a NATSEC pro with a deep love of and connection to Israel. This is more like the sort of tension relieving humor common among cops, ER nurses, etc. Better than the fake sincerity from some news anchors.

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад +6

      I vote DON’T CHANGE!
      I think you are certainly serious enough when appropriate. You come across as very sincere. I think that forcing yourselves to be somber against your natures, would spoil that.

    • @sababan1226
      @sababan1226 5 месяцев назад +4

      @@michaeldoran3568 For the record (as a former scholar in this area in a previous career a long time ago), even though I want a lot of high yield discussion, I absolutely LOVE the banter and chemistry between you two 90% of the time :-) The greedy intellectual in me agrees with the commenter, but the side of me that often takes life too seriously appreciates the humor and levity brought to such difficult subjects (for most).

    • @yonason6047
      @yonason6047 5 месяцев назад

      It just occurred to me how to summarize your multidimensional discussions:
      You expose the bad, highlight the good and ridicule the nonsense, all with high efficiency and relevance.