First Time Hearing: A Perfect Circle - Judith | REACTION!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- After countless requests I’ve finally gotten to APC! This was a massive request considering the connection to Maynard James Keenan from Tool!🙏🏻 enjoy🤟🏼
⭐️Get early access to all of my videos on Patreon:
Patreon.com/Drewfortune
👨👩👧👦Subscribe & Join the Community!
/ @drewfortune97
🤳🏻Follow Me On Instagram!
www.instagram....
If you are an independent artist/in a band/ know someone in a band that needs an opportunity to be heard - Email: ⚠️DFBusinessEnquiries@gmail.com⚠️
for an opportunity to have a 30 second snippet of your work aired at the beginning of one of my videos!🤘🏼
Sub count as of upload: 63,387
It is useful to mention that this song was written before Judith died. After she passed in 2003, Maynard calmed down and wrote 10,000 days/Wings praising her rather than being angry at her.
Was angry at her so much as angry at her fellow church goers who ostracized her after her aneurysm saying it was a punishment from god.
I tend to reserve my comments or judgment until the end of the song - I know some people give out about the lack of comment throughout...on the flip side - other people give out if you talk over the track or talk so there’s really no winning, lol. I’ll just do me and those who enjoy my style of ‘reacting’ then that’s perfect - I’ll offer insights before and after the track!🙏🏻
Fyi Maynard's mother's name was Judith Marie. Dig the vids sir, thx
Can you react to Language part 1 by The Contortionist? They're a must listen if you want to get into more progressive metal like Tool
I like how you you mostly leave the editorial till the song is over. On the other hand, a shout out "Damn! The drums are killer" without pausing is a true reaction in the moment and that's awesome! I personally skip the reactors that constantly pause. It ruins the continuity of the song plus they always stop it at the worst part! Lol keep it up 👍(your facial expressions say it all) also listen to a perfect circle The Outsider on tonight show. CRAZY
Hey man, I've been trying to get you to jam some Opeth and some Mastodon. You will enjoy a lot of their stuff I think. Not all but a lot. They are my favorites right behind Tool and with your new found ear, I'm sure you'll hear some things you like.
Opeth-
-Windowpane
-Blackwater Park
-Benighted
-Continuum
-A Fair Judgment
-Burden
Mastodon-
-Sultan's Curse
-Ember City
-The Motherload
-The Czar
-Roots Remain
-Asleep In The Deep
-Toe to Toes
-Oblivion
Maybe try listening straight through it with no stopping or commenting, and then take notes.
Immediately watch a second time and pause at the time stamp where you took your notes.
3 Libras should be next
Why? ... You tryna see me cry?
Sue Morgan like tool more buts that’s my favorite song on the planet
The live @ the tonight show version.
Mind Reader! God knows the final count on how many times I've listened to that song...
@@Stoitism no it's a bad quality video
The bassist on this album is Paz Lenchantin and she's an absolute badass
Nicholas Anderson sooooo hot 🔥👍
I can tie my laces that quick 😎
Until she got booted for breaking up with Billy Howerdel.
'Gravity'--it's a very slow, introverted sort of song but one of the most beautiful Maynard ever sang. After my only son died 4 years ago this song helped me to keep surviving, the line 'lift me back up to the sun/I choose to live' still sends a shiver through me.
I'm sorry for your loss. Your comment simultaneously broke my heart and affirmed my belief that music is the life blood of our human connection.
And that is a magical song
Love that track. It hits deep.
The Noose. I can't recommend enough.
One of the greatest songs of all time.
I'm more than just a little curious how you're planning to go about making your amends to the dead.
Probably my favorite apc song.
And you're right in recommending
In recommending, you are correct. The Noose and 3 Libras.
Do the Outsider next. It is another banger by them. Or Pet (counting bodies)
Yeah def the studio version
Counting Bodies is a cover of Pet. I honestly think Maynard is literally the only artist who can do a cover/sequel of his own song 😂😂😂. Counting Bodies gets called a sequel a lot, but it really is honestly a cover song of Pet.
If he listens to them, he should listen to Pet first and Counting Bodies second.
Pet is 💣
Pet!!!!
that entire album is so ridiculously good
Next track on album - Orestes is the most beautiful song you will ever hear
It really is.
C0unt1ng 5heep i completely agree. I’ve seen APC 3 times and the final time they played Orestes and I couldn’t believe they did because it’s my favorite song.
This is about how he was angry and couldn't figure out how his mother would love a god who "would do this to her".....I think.
And those at her church who turned on her--her affliction as a visitation for not being a good Christian.
Yes we all read the book
But obviously the dude doing the review didn’t
@Andy Dakin There's a 4 song linked to her - Orestes. It's always forgotten because touches a very hard thing.
@Andy Dakin Yup. Judith - Orestes - 10.000 days - Wings for marie, then there's some other song with Puscifer (I don't have listen to them, so someone more expert on them will fill it).
All 4 are the in different mood - rage for Judith, struggling with reality for Orestes, grief for 10.000 days, acceptation for Wing for marie.
The entire 13th Step album is pure therapy. It will lift and inspire you if you ever need comfort. Life saving for some even.
13th step got me through a big portion of high school. I remember walking between classes with my headphones on, cloudy and cold day...it really was a sort of therapy I needed in that moment. God bless them for making that beautiful piece of art 🙂✌️
13th Step genuinely helped be get out of a dark hole man. Couldn't agree more with your comment
Outsider, The Noose, By and Down the River, 3 Libras, The Doomed, Passive!!! All phenomenal songs from this band! Love the channel!
The noose for the lyricism and the outsider. Banger.
A Perfect Circle - Orestes
Now: Thomas, the package, the noose, the doomed, down by the river, pet, the outsider, thinking of you, 3 libras, disillusioned, Orestes, weak and powerless, Rose, Magdalena, just to start 🤟🏻
Brena
Vanishing and the hollow
So the 1st 2 albums 🤔🤣😍
Might as well just listen to the full albums
By and down *
Tool - no quarter
Best cover of all time 🤙🏼
I saw them do it in Tempe Arizona. I believe it was 2015 Halloween night. Monster Mash, one of the best shows ever! Tool opened up with no quarter! They were dressed like Zep!
@@jonmiller19845 sweet I only seen them once in dublin Ireland I think 2006. would love to see them again. Im not sure they will come back. I might have to travel. 😁🤘
@@rockerdude86 totally agree 👍😉🤘
You have to go back and watch the official vid for this...When you said "That Bass..." during the song, the bassist is a woman, and she's bad ass.
Paz is a god
That’s Paz Lenchantin.....Very cool bassist.
What? A woman playing music? That's prepostorous!
What a woman whew
She sings quite well too.
If you watch the original video, the sexiest moment in video history is Paz (the basest) putting her hair up.
Fun fact, she couldn't do it fast enough so they sped up the video to sync up with the song.
I recommend 3 Libras from this same album. Excellent song!
3 libras
You just opened up a whole new stream of MJK recommendations. Have fun going down the APC hole. It may not be as deep as Tool, but its just as satisfying. A 'next recommendation' would be difficult, but to throw my 2 cents in, The Noose or The Outsider are some incredibly written songs. Again, press play, specifically on the 13th Step album and wherever you land you wouldn't be off.
"Magdalena" is a killer track.
I can only imagine his reaction to "The Nurse Who Loved Me" lmfao
The Package is probably my favorite APC song, or the Noose, but they have a bunch of amazing tracks!.
Don't let this be the first and last one you react to as many do. They have alot of great music you should definitely hear and I'd love to watch your reactions.
I was a big fan of APC in the early 2000's and from them, I discovered Tool. Not the other way around as is usually is.
ditto my friend. this song ignited it all for me
Thank you my man! 🤜 Lol I was the dude stubbornly asking on every vid for this.
Now that you've jumped in, I would say:
1. "The Outsider" is arguably their best track
2. "Counting Bodies like Sheep to the Rhythm of the War Drums" is arguably their heaviest track and would make for an incredible reaction vid
Hard disagree, on Thirteenth Step "The Outsider" is one of my least favorite tracks (it is a masterpiece) but the others are on another level.
3 Libra's APC
"Thanks for all the fish" is a damn good track and video as well
Just as good as Tool imo. I have seen APC live and ohhhh boy are they incredible. Highly recommend The Noose, The Package, Orestes, Blue, Thinking of You.. hell anything, you can’t go wrong.
Go back to watch the official music video to this one. It’s really cool to see the band members rocking this one. You don’t need to post it. Just watch it on your own time.
Many other APC songs aren't quite as aggressive as "Judith" but are just as good. As many others have commented, "The Outsider" "The Noose" and "Orestes" are all fantastic. APC does a great job of matching the feel of the music to the vocals. You're right, everything Maynard touches seems to turn gold. Check out their videos of the "Stone and Echo" live show... it's next level.
I remember seeing a comment on another page describing Tool as Maynard's intellect (super technical) and APC is Maynard's emotion. If you ever venture into checking out Puscifer, I'd start with either "Grand Canyon" or "The Remedy."
"passive" as well. It often gets overlooked
Yea Orestes live in awesome.
Hell yeah ! Do the whole album
Watch the official music video as well! It was directed by Fincher
Some songs you don't headbang to you just take it in and feel it
This song is 1 of a trilogy. Written about his mother’s life and subsequent death. Wings for Marie part 1 and 2 are the other 2
Sorry. Commented before I got to the end of video.
There is actually a fourth track to this saga. Most either don’t know about the final song in the “Maynard’s mom” saga, or don’t know what the song is actually about.
The Puscifer song Horizons is about him releasing his mother’s ashes, and the wind sweeping them away. If you haven’t, check it out.
southbayspike oh. I know the song. I’ll check out the lyrics now though. Thanks!!
@@queentwall4903 well technically 5th because jimmy was the first...its the perspective of him at 11 when his mom first had the stroke
Awesome assessment, lad. Delighted to have ya listen to APC and hear how Maynard sounds in a different musical environment. APC have a very gothic, melodic, dark atmosphere to them. This song is a classic, complete with searing, stabbing riffs, and was an ideal introduction to the band , 20 years ago.
They incorporate multi layers of synths, orchestration, and acoustic guitars to their songs. And with the songs not being in the same tuning as Tool stick to, its great hearing Maynard's voice take new shapes and sounds.. This debut album was met with critical acclaim, and I recommend ya listen to the whole ting, mate. My personal faves from it are "Hollow", "Magdelana", and the brilliant, bruised gem "Three Libras". That song is stunning,and is so cool hearing Maynard adapt a more I dunno, "gentle" vulnerable tone to carry the song. I think you'll like that one. Some of this album in general really shines alongside Tools coolest moments. Shorter songs than Tool, but with loads of atmosphere, like something from a movie.
Second album "Thirteenth Step" had a coupla bangers on there- like "The Outsider", but overall its a more chilled, deeper affair, taking more cues from bands like The Cure- which is a good ting aswell. Whatever ya listen to, enjoy ,man.
MJK has done a lot of songs about his mom. Judith, Wings for Mary 1 & 2, Jimmy, The Grudge and many many more. Anything from APC is perfect. A lot different from Tool but still great,
The Grudge? Forgive me, but I don't see it.
Myles Muir ‘The Grudge’ could be seen as Maynard talking to himself... trying to deal with the grudge(s) he holds - against God, those in “the congregation” he mentions in ‘Wings’, etc - surrounding his mothers ordeal. Eventually, he convinces himself to “let go” and that catharsis (the massive scream near the end of the song) clears the way for the spiritual journey that makes up the rest of the ‘Lateralus’ album.
@@mylesmuir2569 So MJK has often indicated that their songs are left for individual interpretations therefore mine is not necessarily right. My short version of the interpretation is that Maynard rid himself of the grudge he held about his mother's death. Grudge against his mother for clinging to the church who he did not think supported her, to the church itself etc. Also, the line "Saturn comes back around", in my interpretation, correlates to ~30 years when Saturn returns to earth's orbit which also matches how long his mother was first ill till she passed on. This song is him admitting that he has rid himself of his grudge. Again, just my interpretation(not to be taken as fact).
Loving son
APC TIME! Do Outsider! it's the best song, fight me. I am just going to write that on every video until you do it. Everybody else is going to ask for the rest so im calling dibs on The Outsider. its my alarm clock ringtone so wake up to it every day :)
A Perfect Circle is beyond a doubt my favorite band of all time.
Mer de Nom has some fine tracks, 3 libras is phenomenal. But the second album, Thirteenth Step, is an album without a single bad song! It's even got a cover of Failure's The Nurse who loved me!
I highly suggest any and all APC songs from Stone and Echo Live at the Red Rock's.
yes, on to APC!! too many to recc - just all of them! and then Puscifer (puss-i-fer) ;)
"Judith" was released in 2000, "10000 days" was released 2006 - he obviously came to terms with her faith a bit more over those years
Tool - Consciousness
A Perfect Circle - Heart
Puscifer - Libido
Great reaction. I highly recommend Passive, 3 Libras, The Outsider, and Imagine (APC's cover).
Do “Thinking of you” next. It’s a great song about self pleasuring. “Tugging a rhythm to the vision that’s in my head”
The Hollow, 3 Libras, Weak And Powerless, Blue, The Pet - MUST!
Excited to see you go through APCs catalogue, it's not quite as strong as Tools but still very solid and therapeutic in its own right. You'll find a rhythm with their music with a few more tracks. Personally recommending Bréna, The Noose, The Package, Gravity and 3 Libras
Listen to these three in this order:
1. Counting Bodies Like Sheep To The Rhythm Of The War Drums
2. Lullaby
3. Pet
*(This is how I personally always listen to these tracks)*
Sometimes I'll even switch *Lullaby* and *Pet* and listen to *Pet* first, but I always listen to *Counting Bodies Like Sheep To The Rhythm Of The War Drums* first.
a perfect circle- the package, is a must
'The package' is my favorite as of now
Aw yeah perfect circle
the noose, the hollow, orestes, the outsider , 3 libras, pet, breña, weak and powerless
Imo, this is the most 'Tool' sounding song of theirs. They have their own sound. Maynard sings more, in general...
Alright! The new episode of Maynard’s artistic journey; have fun bruh!
The Noose Orestas Passive Gravity 3 Libras any of those A Perfect Circle tracks will be good choices.
well done my friend,you're right on with you reaction....
I clicked the video as soon as I saw it. I clicked like before the video started. I liked my own comment. I’m excited, Let’s watch 👀
For me, I’m also paralyzed and a pious Christian, and my mother also has past away & was Christian.
So you see, when I hear this song, my entire body tingles and I have a very surreal almost religious experience.
I’ve felt this anger, I understand it but I also love my God and maintain faith... it’s almost like my suffering emboldens my faith and this song lets me step outside myself to appreciate that. Thanks for reacting to this!
@@samuelwest6435 God bless you, Samuel! Hey, have you heard Pastor Rob Houghton react to Judith and Wings for Marie? Those reaction videos are, literally, religious experiences, too. Highly recommend, for you!
@@barkingmadman1169 thank you. I'll check it out!
Talking in chat about Smashing Pumpkins suggestions, drop them as a reply to this to keep them together.
Edit: Heh, 4 likes and no suggestions..
Guess I'll get the ball rolling.. "Bullet with butterfly wings", "Tonight tonight", "1979" and "Ava adore". Pick one and I'm sure more will come your way.
@Michael DeNunzio You don't say? I have everything they ever released and still listen regularly.
It's always better to start a new listener to any band with something more easily accessible for a first-timer, before pushing them deeper.
Don't be daft. The "Gish" album is a front-to-back masterpiece. Their best singular work.
@@donkeydarko77 Who exactly are you arguing with there? Nobody mentioned Gish..
Cherub Rock, Rhinoceros
Listen to their entire second album '13th step'. It's flawless.
Yes it is.
a perfect circle , weak and powerless and the outsider are good tracks
Hey drew, check out the official video for Judith-APC will grow on you like tool does-unlike tool they do appear in some of their videos-dive in bud! APC will draw you in like tool does-not as intense and the songs are not as long and intricate but stellar band!!!!
Gravity. Hauntingly fabulous!
Yay!!!!!!
If you get around to 'Orestes' by A Perfect Circle, please do the Live version from Stone and Echo at Red Rock.
PET next definitely, much heavier than Mer De Noms
lol, a TOOL snob! How far you have grown!
Check out Maynards other band Puscifer.
Do their album's like you did tool... they are amazing too
The video goes well with this song, the bass player, oh my!
Awesome stuff...you gotta try A Perfect Circle- Counting Bodies LIke Sheep if you can, You of my favourite tunes ever.
To the rhythm of the war drums
Only 4 albums to discover-mer de noms, 13th step, album of covers/anti war album then eat the elephant-enjoy!!
Apc - counting bodies
Oh good lord....please just say *part* over and over again. Maynard is gold indeed. This is one of my favorites of his of all time including tool and puscifer.
When The Levee Breaks...
Please, please do more APC! Talk Talk, Pet, Counting Bodies Like Sheep to the Rhythm of the War Drums, Orestes, Three Libras, Disillusioned... just to name a few. (Like I said in another comment, listen to Pet first before Counting Bodies. Pet is the original song, Counting Bodies is a cover/sequel they did to it).
PET next!!!!!!!
Finally some APC. The Outsider, Pet or The Package next please
It's so awesome to have seen you go from not knowing how to pronounce aenima to educating people on maynard like youve been listening for years, great to see. keep spiralling bro
So much APC to get to!
A bit of backstory on APC: Billy was a guitar tech for Tool for many years and started writing music with maynard whilst on tour. The writing process for Mers De Noms lasted about 13 years before they actually got in the studio and laid down the track.
APC: The package
After the Rabbit Hole, there's the Perfect Circle. This band includes amazing musicians and it's very collaborative and inspiring. The Noose and Weak and Powerless are two of the most beautiful songs from them. But then again.. all are in their own way.
Thanks for checking them out!
The album, "Thirteenth Step," is an homage to friends lost to drugs. Each song is sung from a different affected individual's perspective, from the addict ("The Package", "Weak and Powerless", "Gravity"), to a close friend ("The Noose", "Vanishing", "A Stranger", "The Outsider") to the drug itself's perspective ("Pet").
Pretty great stuff.
Legendary director David Fincher directed this, always a plus for me!
One of my favorite songs by Tool.. (I'm sorry I mean A Perfect Circle.)
Maynard's mom, Judith was confined to a wheelchair for 10,000 Days; thus the 10,000 Days album..
Welcome down the A Perfect Circle rabbit hole.
I certainly recommend the A Perfect Circle songs, "3 Libras" and "Orestes." #SpiralOut
Glad to see you starting the APC journey. This is from their first album. Their next album, 13th Step, is a bit more polished and less raw as you might expect. I recommend Weak and Powerless followed by 3 Libras, then wind back to Mer de Noms with Orestes and Thomas. You will ultimately fall in love with them, especially the first two albums.
The noose, is even better.
“The nurse who loved me.” It honestly isn’t the best to review but it is my favorite a perfect circle song. Like your vids, keep it up.
Say hello to the rugs typography. A line ive used one too many times after falling or simply looking for a dropped crayon on the floor.
Check out the original version by the band Failure. APC’s version is a well done cover
His most expensive wine is also named Judith.
Billy Howerdel also used to be Adam Jones guitar tech during the aenima tour.
Glad to see you are hitting some APC! Great song, but keep going, there are so many more better APC songs.
Excellent!
I'm new. This just came up in my recommended. I LOVE A Perfect Circle and Puscifer. Momma Sed is soooo good.
Howedel was Adam Jones' guitar tech up to first Ænema tour date in '96. I could tell you the exact date only because I have the bootleg videa in which Maynard thanks him and acknowledges it's his last show with the band. Is it sad I know these things? LOL And if you're wondering Mer De Noms is french for "Book of Names". A large % of titles are names.
Outsider
Pet
Passive
That's my favorite 3
Their latest album (Eat The Elephant) is very different from everything else they do and there are a few tracks on there worth reacting to - Disillusioned comes to mind for me.
A Perfect Circle - Brena
So glad to see this! It’s how my Maynard journey began. Magdalena, Rose, and Judith are my favorites!
Check out the video, it's good.
I Remember when APC was brand new. If you are able, it is always nice to compartmentalize; as in, try listening to this band as if TOOL is in another universe, it will surely help the appreciation for this band, especially the first two albums. MJK definitely grew as an artist in this band.
Nice reaction, great song, and what a great group of musicians.
Thanks, Peace
An amazing different take on Maynard's vocals. The music video is awesome for this song, you should give the 3 Libras video a watch. Cheers dude.
I’m on a this a little late…hopefully someone told you Howerdel was Adams guitar tech for TOOL. And then there’s Paz…and there’s Freese. And Iha. Just outstanding