How Sairat Uses Contrast to Tell the Story
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- Support this channel on Patreon
/ cbent
For educational purpose only.
According to the Indian Copyright Law, this video falls under Fair Use. This is NOT an infringement of copyright. Please refer to the following document.
copyright.gov.i...
This video tries to examine the central design principle around which Nargaj Manjule developed the Marathi blockbuster Sairat.
Film Details:
Name: Sairat
Director: Nagraj Manjule
Cinematographer: Sudhakar Reddy Yakkanti
Edited: Kutub Inamdar
Music: Ajay-Atul
Starring: Rinku Rajguru, Akash Thosar
Sairat Analysis by Ravish Kumar:
• Sairat Review by ndtv ...
#Sairat #Zingaat
Follow me here:
Facebook: tinyurl.com/zdf...
Twitter: / vinitmasram
Help us caption and translate this video!
Thank You! and Subscribe for more videos.
01. Correction: The lyrics of Jiya Jale from the part under focus are in Malayalam not Tamil. Stupid mistake! My Apologies!
02. Ravish Kumar has done a way better thematic analysis of Sairat. The link is provided in the description.
03. You can support the channel by pledging on Patreon so that the channel becomes financially viable to produce more of such content. The link to Patreon is also in the description.
04. Although I have touched on the science of Phonetics and Linguistics in the video, the field is far wider, complex and dense. I’d encourage people to dive into it if the field interests you.
Ravish review was more a social commentary rather than art piece analysis nevertheless I enjoyed it.
Cinema Beyond Entertainment Jiya jale from Dil se... Has Malayalam vocals not Tamil
How stupid of me to assume they are Tamil instead of doing a simple Google search! My apologies!
Cinema Beyond Entertainment No issues. Just wanted to point that out. Excellent analysis. Big fan
Loved your video. Great as always. Really hoped you would touch on that remake of sairat by Bollywood that came this year and how horribly they adapted it with all those clichés which this movie actually tried to modify. Superb analysis nonetheless.
Dude I want to kiss your head. I understand I am a casual movie goer and you are a movie student but still no one in India has gone to this depth in video analysis. Keep up the good work and be the proud Indian you are.
Sometimes I wonder, is proud India *too* proudy?
🤔
I also think the same
Nice lines😄
@@JohnLongPig maybe we want to make a mark!
@@JohnLongPig taking proud by something else that's doesn't belong to you is just bullshit in my eyes..you should only be proud for things taht has been done by yourself..being happy about something is different but taking proud out of them is bullshit
I wish if Dhadak makers had seen this analysis before making it
😂😂😂😂😂😂
If they had they would still be like "hum nahi sudharenge".
@@digvijaysingh568 😁😁🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
They wouldn't get this, in all probability..
😂😂😂😂😂very true
सैराटविषयी आजवर खूप काही वाचलं, ऐकलं आहे; पण आशय(content) आणि शैली(form) दोन्हींचं इतकं गहन मूल्यमापन पहिल्यांदाच बघितलं. धन्यवाद विनित.
खरंच. उत्तम विश्लेषण केलंय भावाने.
Whenever this movie has been debated, I have failed at explaining why it is a gem of a movie. Your analysis finally helped me understand why I loved it so much and why it is worthy of all the fame it has received. Thank you for this video.
I have seen sairat more than 100 times and I don't know Marathi.. Manjule's this film is a masterpiece.. Language is not a barrier
check out his other work- if you haven't already.
The master stroke for me was perspective change in the end. Manjule showed vulnerability of situation through the eyes of an infant rather than an adult who moves on with relationship (human nature).
and that scene of Sairat is the most tragic movie scene I have ever watched.
I have watched Sairat for multiple times. Always thought that i understood the art and craft of the movie. After watching your video, suddenly understood what i was missing. Thanks for such a superb analysis. This is a great insight into the subject.
Now watch once more bro
The analysis, the insight starting from 3:40 to 6:40 is absolutely genius my friend. Absolutely genius. You are single handedly changing my perception and idea of what a movie can be and what it should be. Sairat introduced me to Marathi cinema and what a movie to begin with. The subtle way in which Nagraj handles the issue of caste, romance and life in general was exceptional.
You can also watch Natrang, I wish this guy would analyse it.
I would like recommend "Deool"!
Best technical and detailed review I've ever saw of a movie. Make such analysis of other films too. Great job.
There more such videos on the channel. Do check them out!
The whole explanation about the feelings of the lead characters being expressed through the traditional maharashtrian folk instruments is something I had thought about too but you have gone on to explain it in the absolute depths. Ajay Atul are redefining the way music needs to be introduced in Indian cinema. This sir, has been a fantastic review! Keep enlightening us with your audio visuals! Cheers!
Sairat is a masterpiece movie with goosebumps music 😘😍😘😍
Hatsoff for whole sairat team 🙏🙏🙏
Nagraj manjule such a great director 🙏🙏
Tarun Singh right dear .
This movie is cursed to the society and people like you make it worse
@@clashmaniacs2788 so this movie a curse which tells people about the truth of society . And what you mean by 'people like you' ? You cannot judge anyone to think that you are right .
My favourite part in terms of music was the smooth transition post zingaat .Ajay-Atul give you a catchy party song .When they get into the car ,the transition is so sleek you tend to forget you were listening to a party song and immediately catch up with the romantic tune followed by the serious tune.It brilliantly captures three different emotions in a matter of minutes
Finally someone noticed that.... It was the best scene in terms of music transition .. You could actually feel getting in the car and hearbeat pacing... Amazing
The most in-depth review of this masterpiece of a movie. "Because when a director captures the imagination of a huge amount of population, it doesn't happen by accident, it happens by design." Super!
Oh this analysis is so comprehensive! Although I watch movies casually, I went back to the movie again to see for myself the elements I was missing till now :) Thanks a lot for doing this :)
And thanks for referring to Ravish ji's video.
Your voice gave me chills, especially for this one.
Sanket Netragaonkar aagri bro😆
Khup mast...... Loved it🙌
And bollywood and KJ will teach you how to ruin a classic....😐
Please please review Fandry. That is only movie which shook my heart to the core. I consider that movie can be easily placed in top 10 world cinemas.
Seems like that rock hit you in the feels.
Yes fandry is way better as a cinematic experience.
Absolutely bro. That rock throwing scene is one of the best ending scenes I have seen.
Yeah bro totally, Fandry is Just up there.
Easily among top 3 films I watched in my life.
I closed my eyes at the last rock throwing scene.😑
The medium and the manner in which you share knowledge is brilliant. It makes ordinary people with no background in film making curious about the craft. I also love your simple, easy to follow and perfectly paced narration. No over the top drama like many other channels. You are proving yet again that content is definitely the king! Thank you for enlightening the likes of me.
I am speechless. You explained this with exceptional perfection, grace and intellect
You were a true beacon of hope for Cinema! Thank you for giving us these brilliant essays, they shall be forever remembered.
May your soul rest in peace, this loss really feels personal!
I hope you are in a safe place, Vinit ♥️❤
Finally someone from india explaining indian films like foreign RUclips channels.. like storytellers and in depth cine.
I can't imagine better analysis and narration of any film than this.
This was so knowledged and beautiful.
Rest in peace my man!
Are you a Human?
ankit saxsena why broo
@@arnabsarkar3906 he has gone to such a depth that this guy is confused if this is a human or a alien explaining
GREAT... Next time I will use this.
I cannot seem to stop getting goosebumps while watching this. Your insight is really deep. Sairat is really a masterpiece.
this video has blown me in the same way the movie did. Hats off to the number of efforts and time you have invested in. this video is an enigma machine for Nagraj Manjule's direction.
Why did you stop making videos? I cannot express how happy I feel whenever I watch your videos, the tears in my eyes say more. Please make a comeback, we need analysts like you. ❤️❤️
I can't imagine brother how much knowledge you have on cinema. Everytime when i watch your analytical videos i just think how ? How this guy thinks.
wow! I hope Manjule watches this video
My brother, never stop making these videos. We seriously lack film critics in India, and someone of your calibre is thereby way way more valuable than the average critic channel.
This entire video was breathtaking. The video is underlined with so much nuance and feelings that most mainstream movies struggle to even fathom.
Your voice is so soothing man...
the best part is none of this is visible to an audience and they just move down the groove
This video is impressive. It makes me happy that our mainstream cinema is moving on from just heart-touching story lines and exploring what film, as a medium of expression, has to offer. We also need more people like yourself so that more people can really appreciate the film as a whole.
I really don't have any words to express myself, I am Stunned.
I wanted to make a video talking about Sairat, but you did it and I'd say it has done Justice to the Film.
I'm sharing this video everywhere.
3:56 u get goosebumps when u here the beats
You made me fall in love with sairat again..आभारी आहे
I'm thinking whether film makers had thought this deep.
If yes then hat's off to them.
Your videos always make me realize that film making is not easy at all. Some crazy shit is going on in each & every scene.
abc xyz ...so you think changed focus in that Classroom scene was because
camera changed focus on its own....
Nothing in Good films happen randomly...
Angry Indian
I didn't think the meaning of camera focus was Female protagonist's dominance. But now i blown away by knowing that.
That's dope!
The director is genius, if you could watch Fandry you will know... He used the effect of cinema to that last scene in Fandry you would have never seen before.
@@DM-cy7hy he (nagraj) has bad habit of shocking his audience in just one scene and compel them to think about that for long..
of course .....great films are not just accidents
Wonderful video! I really loved the fact that sairaat could break so many norms and shine the way it did. I did find a few problems with the story, such as the girl and the guy being "alphas" of their clique. They often showed bullying nature and a flawed moral compass. The boy with rickets was really treated badly. I believe if naagraj wanted he could have normalized his disability. I felt as if the other friends' existence was to further the leads' love story, because god forbid they have a life of their own. I on the other hand really liked the rawness it showcased in the second half.
Overall, I have to say im really impressed by it. I do feel music had a big part in it, as it was the one thing there that had absolutely no flaws
Come on man . This man is under rated. He should have bigger audience. The way he narrates the scenes is too briefly detailed. Being a student of film making, missed points by me while watching is covered by him. Damn. Good job. Keep making more videos.
The way you analyzed makes us to watch a movie like true piece art, the music analysis you've done in this video is great. Oh, god i'm proud to have one of the genuine critic like you for Indian cinema.🙏🙏🙏👏👏👏👏👌👌
What a brilliant analysis man.. I hadn't realised the sheer nuance behind the magic of Sairat songs even though I keep listening to them always. Never did it dawn upon me why the song Yaad Lagla is such a audio visual masterpiece until you explained it. Watching the movie now is twice as enjoyable. Kudos to you🙏
this is what we mean when we say movie review .... hats off to you.
Wo nahi rahe rip vinit sir aka cinema beyond entertainment
@@gchudasamadarshit9111 sad to know that.. Rip
I love this film and have watched it 6 times but the details you just tell us through your video is just insane. Now I love this movie even more. Thank you.
I saw the movie yesterday after watching your analysis & I must say, it is one of the best movies I've ever seen. Thanks man.
Never imagined that the vowels and consonants used in song lyrics would create a desired emotional effects in the audience's mind. Thanks for explaining that.
If U can make video on fandry too.
Really bro , That film also deserve a explanation
And what about ' Pistulya' short film by Nagaraj Anna
Mavla Me I have watched that short film also.
Animal Lovers please watch the love letter scene
Man, ur narration is so soothing...I am immersed
i just loved your way of description of everything and anything about the movie!!!!
I have read a lot about Sairat since I watched the movie. I have explored a number of aspects of the movie.
So when I clicked on this video I did not expect anything new.
I could not be more wrong.
You explored a number of aspects like instruments, language among other things which were just brilliant.
Thanks for doing this video, will look forward to the new one!
Rongte khade hue sir. Aisa lag raha tha kabhi khatam hi na ho yeh video. Abhi tak ka sab se behtareen appreciation aapne hi kiya hua. Ek hi word hai aapke liye CLASSIC!!🙏🙏
Phenomenal... I was waiting for someone to analyze Sairat.. and here it comes... Easily one of the best directions...
OMG THIS IS GOLD. Subscribed. I enjoy analyzing movies on my own, but hearing about it in such depth, and in such a concise manner is so fulfilling! Thank you!!!
The way you analyze the movies so deeply and so much detailed... I think even the makers didn't thought these things while making😅... Keep it up 🙏
Makers actually think about it.... As he said in the end " it's not just by a coincidence, it's a design."
Man you are awesome. Such a in depth narrative of movie haven’t seen till today. After watching this I can definitely say we all didn’t understand the movie the way director wanted us to. But after watching this I would say this is one of the best movie of Indian cinema till date.
Keep up the great work.
I've watched Sairat 5 times. But I'd never thought so deep about this. Kudos bro🎉🎉
I have watched sairat some 20+ times. N I am a huge fan of ur work too. The moment I saw a thumbnail of ur analysis on Sairat, I was like "" YESSSSSSS"" 😍😍
Thank you sir & keep going.
This channel is so underrated. Lots of love brother
My god ....your intelligence is remarkable....
I feel so proud of you , just for the fact that someone can get into the skin of cinema so deeply. Kudos sir.
I'll be delighted to watch a review of Queen .
Vineet what a beautiful breakdown of the whole movie ,very pragmatic& uplifting narration .. loved it
I stumbled upon your channel by accident. Amongst the recent reaction review controversy comments, I came across your channel’s name. I just saw your Sairat Video and my mind is blown. Never have I ever heard such details about designing of a movie. Needless to say will be watching all your videos over the weekend. Thank you for enriching my movie experience.
Dude,
Your channel does actually mark a new chapter in my interests on youtube (and in general).
I am sure, this level of simplification of such deep & richness of "class design" of movie, camera work appreciation will educate us & initiate us to look for such experiences while movie-watching!
Grateful to your work!
Cheers.
after watching the video, my finger automatically moved towards subscription button..great video, looking for more such video..
Goosebumps ! Wow ! .. looking forward to watching your movies someday. I'm new to this channel... excuse me for my ignorance , have you directed any short movies?
You too are a great storyteller sir..
i got chills listening to the music again
as a cinema student , we have lot to learn from you.
kudos !!
This is absolutely amazing analyses, you make us love a movie. Keep it up!
Never seen such a awesome and wonderful review of everything about the cinema (in India).... As natural and fluent as the movie SAIRAAT... Keep it up brother ✌️👌👍
I have watched Sairat multiple times and will watch many more times. But I would have never comprehended what you have explained in this video. This 9 minutes video was really a great education of the cinema as a craft. I wish you get some serious response for your work so that you will feel to create more of such videos.
BTW I am watching this video for fourth time.
Dude... Your videos are really very thought provoking 😊.. and although I am a casual movie watcher, your videos have made me pay more attention to details and appreciate the subtext of some scenes from good movies which I would have otherwise missed out on. Thank you. Keep up the good work 😊👍
watching your videos make us feel smarter, even though a few get the whole essence of your video.
ur knowledge about movie making, philosophy etc is on next level
Best thing to appear in my RUclips feed in a long long time! :D
I can't wait to see what more Mr. Manjule has to offer. I am excited for his next work Jhund!
Indepth and Comprehensive analysis of socio- cultural and technical aspects!
Your channel is the only channel I know which has a constructive discussion about Indian Cinema. We needed that! Our own type of every frame a painting . Hope to see more from you in the future
we all loved the movie but the way its narrated is just tooo good and perfect
loved it.
Amazing editing man.. 🙌Well deep analysis of how music play their part in story telling.. Sairat and Nagraj Manjulae ❤🥰
So much depth...so much things to look ..great analysis
When ever I feel tired or depressed i watch your videos. Your hard work and skills are truly appreciated. It encourage me to work hard. Sairat is very close to my heart. You made me realize why it is so.
I've watched this movie soo many times , yet everything you mentioned in the video never catched my eye ... i think dats the difference between a normal movie goer and a movie admirer . This video taught me so many things .. one of them being how to watch a movie . Please i request you to never quit making these videos , coz this is hella masterclass of film appreciation . I know how underrated you are .... but trust me you have the most loyal subscriber imo . So just never stop making these videos .... and a Big Hug to you for making this !!!!!!!!
You are evolving into a great cinema scholar, Vinit. Keep going.
Bro u shld narrate a story every month..just narrate the gd stories for us..ur voice is pleasing, refreshing nd euphoria..😍😍😘😘
broooo.... u are just perfect... i watched this movie 4-5 times bt never thought this much while watching sairat...
Vinit I must really compliment you for the depth and nuance you bring to each of the videos. The content of your channel is something that I look forward to consuming everytime. As always this one is also amazing. Thank you for putting together such amazing content everytime.
Amazing analysis!
Have you watched Fandry?(Nagraj's first film)
It deserves analysis as well.
So much indeep analysis !!! Didn't know such channel do also exists in our country.. Great !!😍😍
I wish I could watch all my favorite movies with you. It is amazing to get to know your insights into classic such as this. Thank you!
What a perfect breakdown! I like how you systematically tackle different aspects one by one. Great work.
What a great explanation. I am just an ordinary audience, but after watching several videos of your movie analysis I must say, I can look back on some of my favourite movies to understand why I liked them. I hope you continue your hard work. I love to hear the analysis whenever you post.
BTW Sairat is one of my most favourite movies
Wow..Respect. Your review is as epic as movie itself.
I really liked your analysis. Many reviewers commented on the 'gender subversion' in sairat including you. I think that
the agency/bravado that the girl exhibits emanates from her caste location, precisely her "upper caste" position in the social order. It is not just a portrayal of a "brave" girl.On the other hand, the boy from low strata/caste has difficulty in exercising agency/showing confidence. Mr. Manjule , who is well aware of that caste reality might have created the characters by keeping this in his mind.
Plz plz release sairat once again though I don't understand Marathi Soo much but still want to watch the movie in theatre plz don't want to miss this iconic piece
Masterpiece Analysis by Vinit. As a Nagraj's fan, I totally enjoyed it.
I feel extremely sorry to have not found your channel earlier. It gave me goosebumps as I was listening to this detailing. You are a genius. Keep it up.
You know it's my first time I watched your video.. I don't subscribe if it doesn't click me. But your way of demonstration compelled me to subscribe and watch all your videos... Amazing... Love u from Pakistan
Never ever anyone gave me such a perspective on movies!! You changed my perspective bro!! Loved it ... Keep it up!! (Its still running in my head) 🤗👏👏