Family split on Kaitlyn Conley's conviction in Mary Yoder's poisoning death
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2020
- Kaitlyn Conley was very close with Mary Yoder and her family, and wrote a Facebook post the day after Yoder died: "If love could have saved you, you would have lived forever.” Conley is serving a 23-year sentence for first-degree manslaughter. From 2018: bit.ly/34kACxb
![TRASH or PASS! Eminem ( Houdini ) [REACTION!!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cB1WrZcMwMc/mqdefault.jpg)
8 heart attacks? that’s absolute torture
I know... I can’t even imagine! My Grandma had two consecutively and she suffered SO much!! It was hell for her and he’ll for me watching her go through those heart attacks that ultimately ended her life at 96 years old.
From watching how tortured she was, I hope I never have another loved one suffer like she did. Let alone x4!
Agonising like an elephant on your chest 😡
They said this lady was wholistic, my god if she was this was the last thing she wanted to be resuscitated 7 more times, that’s barbaric. RIP beautiful lady, your not being hurt anymore 💜
Yeah that's rough.
I know that made me so sad. She wanted to help people and took such care for her body. She never even did anything bad to anybody, she was just collateral damage. Sad
In the police interview, when she was caught out, instead of proclaiming her innocence, she starts crying my life is over. I think that says it all.
Those were your average narcissists answers!
Exactly
Right I didn't even think about that you're right
I think she felt guilty because her boyfriend told her about what he’d done and she didn’t tell police.. .
She also sobs during her final statement in court... while dry-eyed and/or expressionless during victim statements. Her demeanor and speaking pattern during the interrogations were major alarm bells. I hope JCS picks this up for a video too
Katie: I’ll go to jail forever
Detective: You won’t go to jail forever. You’ll be held in jail until your trial and then you will go to prison forever. There’s a distinction
😂😆
Excellent 🤣😂
🤣🤣🤣
LMAO
🤣🤣🤣
This poor women was surrounded by so much betrayal 😢
Cheating is gross, but it's 10x worse when it's a sibling involved.
Any family member, and unless they're completely intoxicated it usually means they're some type of narcissist. Thousands of single men and women everywhere, theres no reason for it
Is that what you took from this video? Lol.
@@LightoftheWest7 stfu
Definitely. If my sister went after a man of mine she is getting serious butt kicking. Id never kill her but would beat her ass
LightoftheWest7 apparently that’s what YOU heard her say 🤣 I understood what she was saying.
Cop: "Why did you murder her?"
Kaitlyn: "😭 MY life is overrrr 😭"
Cop: "What drove you to kill her?"
Kaitlyn" 😭 I'M going to prison 😭"
Typical narcissistic response.
Right there was when I knew she was guilty.......
My thoughts exactly
Always all about them. A person is DEAD and this person is worried about jail.
@Antonia Bareva You must have missed the part where the email account used to the purchase the drug (poison) was only accessed by Kaitlyn's phone and computer. She also admitted to writing the letters in an effort to frame the son.
But sure, screw the evidence and go with your emotions about the Husband.
@Antonia Bareva The husband certainly had motive and would be my first thought.
The son's impact statement felt hollow, empty and fake. Either of them wouldn't surprise me..
But the fact that she wrote the letter and made a fake email, leaving the receipt next to the labeled container...and searched how to poison someone on the internet..
I don't know how anyone can rationalize that. I really don't.
Imagine premeditating and carrying out the murder of your ex-boyfriend's mother in a brutal way and then framing that same boyfriend while you still have incriminating evidence on your phone and computer and only getting first degree manslaughter after two trials. Wild
Many young females of certain background, get half the sentences of the males. I think men should start asking for equal rights.
How a very cruel poisoning can ever be manslaughter??
Just makes no sense at all??
This woman deserves life!!
I am a detective for over 30 years, and I am 100% convinced the defendant is guilty of the murder and she got off easy with 23 years , she would be out in 10 years or even less. She placed the bottle in the young man's car and tried to frame him. She is wicked.
Do you think she acted alone?
@@Carmen_Rosabella Girls usually act alone from fear somebody would talk on an easy murder, but to take someone on a boat and drop him in the ocean , she would need at least a man.
10 yrs or less!?!?! Ridiculous!
She can’t handle rejection! Relationships would be dangerous for those she get involved with! Who’s to say she wouldn’t pick up where she left off , once released!?!?!?!
Smh! Judicial system needs an eye opener!
For a detective, you didn’t do much detective work or else you would be aware of the following which provides a
significant amount of reasonable doubt.
They missed out the fact Bill made them keep mobile phones in a different area of the office where he had access to them.
They claimed she used a VPN. Coincidentally, the vpn used was the one Bill had a subscription for, not her.
She wasn’t computer savvy at all. The son had to help her set up Wi-Fi, she didn’t even have a password on her phone
Both son and father had access to her work computer which they said had searches on it.
Bill told Kaitlyn to open any Items delivered to the office in Mary’s name because he was ordering her a gift (Why wouldn’t he just put it in his own name?)
Prosecution stated her dna was on the bottle but actually, there were three different DNA samples found on the bottle and it was said her dna couldn’t be excluded, not that it was actually hers.
Apparently, Kaitlyn had a day off work on the day she was supposed to have poisoned Mary. Coincidentally, they managed to “lose” their payroll files. This info was ruled inadmissible.
Also ruled inadmissible was the fact Kaitlyn was dating someone and there were texts with the son actually begging to get back with him.
I’ll be honest, this is a confusing case.
Her reactions seem fake but so does the son’s.
The father has lied about multiple things and it’s interesting how quickly they cremated her.
They all seem guilty so I think it’s very unreasonable to claim there isn’t enough reasonable doubt.
I hope she truly is guilty because if an innocent woman has been locked up for the best years of her life , that is a travesty and miscarriage of justice.
I don't care if my sister passed I WOULD NOT marry her husband it's weird.
Agree! The sister is pure trash!! (to marry your ex brother in-law). The husband is shit too!
No it’s hot.
very weird right? It kinda reeks of incest. Heavens
@@maureenlippincott9528 Stop being a player h8r
@@maureenlippincott9528 yes it's strange and still your sisters husband. I just don't get it.
Did I hear this correctly, that Bill was having an affair with his wife's sister? What kind of sister is that 🙄🤦🏼♀️?
Many people just don't care, my older sister slept with a guy I was seeing. Its a different kind of betrayal
A shitstain of a sister. Yep. And it happens a LOT.
You could equally ask what kind of husband sleeps with his sister-in-law??
@@misszillla4201 that’s awful. It’s one thing to do to a friend, but a sister? Absolutely not. I’m sorry that happens. Your sister is a twat with no dignity or self worth.
My cousins have kids with the same man, both were married to him too.. disgusting.. kids (2+7) are cousins and siblings..
23 years is an insult to Mary. May she rest in peace.
This literally makes me sick to my stomach...how could you do that to someone's mother? This woman must have been a complete psychopath.
Does anyone else love to watch these crime watch daily shows rather then the Podcast?
Yes
Yes...
I love both!
It costs a lot to research, film, edit and produce these episodes. They were made when this show had network TV backing. The series was canceled but they continued to do the podcasts because of the interest in the true crime genre.
I honestly thought I was the only one who opts to watch the actual episodes! Glad to know I’m not alone. Honestly I keep strolling right by the podcasts completely unbothered!
This whole case is confusing they all look guilty
That about sums it up!
To me all of them are in on it
I thought the same thing and then I kept going back to the sister asking the judge for leniency.. idk. But then again it was caitlyns phone and computer with evidence. So who knows
agreed
@@feitme great idea. Convict them all without evidence.
Good grief! Who needs enemies when you have family like this? They are ALL screwed up!
That poor woman nobody that she loved, loved her.
Her son and daughters did
I know the feeling
Her son did
Kaitlyn sent anonymous letters relating to Mary’s death, & the sisters still believe she didn’t have anything to do with it?? 😩 You can’t fix stupid.
I think they're letting emotions get in the way because they found out about the affair, plenty of folks have affairs but don't murder their spouses,
also, if the husband/son got convicted, who would the estate be going to,
It's plausible that the remaining sisters are angry about the affair & don't believe he deserves to keep their assets.
they probably were jealous of their sister
@Wingardium Leviosa 😒 **{**0:55**} Is this the sisTeR you'Re reFeRRinG too.????*
They think she was set up
@@battlerudee Ofc & I’d have my suspicions too if they hadn’t found her DNA behind the envelop stamps, & the email was only accessed on her phone. 😫
So the defense claims he broke up with her, then murdered his mother, then sent a letter framing himself in order to frame her? Her defense team should be put in jail too
@Carl Lennen has o
@Carl Lennen So she confesses just for the helluva it? They don't need a motive in a case although a jury likes one. Who knows? Maybe she blamed mommy for raising her son to be who he was and who he acted like to her. Maybe mom heard about the abortion and had issues with her about it. Maybe she just wanted to frame the son and did not care who she took out and mom fit as someone he was having problems with. Maybe she thought the son would turn to her if his mom died and she would get him back. Who knows? Maybe unbeknownst to others, she was jealous of his relationship with his mom or of what mom gave him--speaking of which, where is her family in all of this? Why is it the victim's sisters defending her?
The rest of it makes perfect sense. She had to send the letter as her plan was not working and they were focusing on the husband/father. Think about it, once she had their focus on him and she was brought in, she quickly told them he had confessed to her, she wanted him to go down. The detective even asked her why he would do that or confess and her answer just did not fly if you ask me...
It's a no brainer that the son was not going to frame himself and write the letter. It is unfortunate dad was having an affair which gave focus to him NATURALLY but what good would framing his son do, having an affair does not mean you want your ADULT child gone, again why?
You ask how she planted the things in the car? Well who knows, she was close to the family and once this happened, maybe she was close to the son again, or for sure the sisters, etc. for a time while dad was focused on. Anyone can put something in an unlocked car.
She worked for and with the woman and you ask how she could give it to her? The husband was not at the office that day when Mary got sick.
It comes back to her. The son would not use her phone or computer to frame himself for goodness sake.
I don't doubt he was not good to her, that the relationship may not have been good nor that she may have been abused it is entirely possible. She may have been very hurt over the pregnancy and perhaps thoughts she would marry into this family and again, where is hers? Maybe they were there for her and the show just did not focus on that, I don't really know.
Total speculation but she worked for the family, dated the son, the mother thought the world of her but that is per her sisters. One can look at this a couple of different ways and that is that she hooked onto this family as her own and behaved sweetly, and the son's breakup with her and maybe failure to marry was dashing her goals and she was realizing it would never happen... As far as the sisters, I am unsure what to think other than they clearly have a family rift and seem to have never been fond of their own nephew, did they hate that he was perhaps spoiled and the going on about the husband's intelligence seems also a bit far fetched and maybe a bit of jealousy factor as well...
How close were these sisters to Mary? How often did they see her? How much did they talk or do together? We have none of that. It struck me how the one says Mary was an enabler but she was just starting to put her foot down with her son... Uh-huh... Just starting, and it leads to murder and he frames himself, I don't think so. And enabling parents generally put their foot down and then backtrack and she was just "starting"... Bull.
The sister that spoke in this, don't get me wrong, I liked her and I felt her, but she is ignoring the facts and I feel she may just have a hatred of the husband and son, perhaps even a bit of guilt if not as close as she could have been with her sister.
Finally, why is it they do not think it could possibly the cheating sister who did this or killed Mary and framed their nephew. She would have more motive than the son but one does not hear that from her as a possibility...
Strange case but imo the evidence is there, there was a confession and the letter writing fits perfectly because the defendant wanted the son in trouble, not the dad...
All jmo and no offense but I don't see it. Do cops ever get blinders? Of course. However, they were looking at the dad, they then looked at the son after the letters, and even then the looked further and found female DNA... They in no way got tunnel vision...
So I differ. She is lucky to only have manslaughter and be a bit less than middle aged when she gets out.
@Carl Lennen I personally believe anyone in a toxic relationship has issues and beef with parents especially when abortion is involved and if the mom was actually gonna cut the son off I highly doubt she was being pleasant to the girlfriend I'd say that is a motive in itself i do agree with you though this should've been looked into more feels like a case of tunnel vision
@Carl Lennen Pull the wool from your eyes. By the way, I was somewhat respectful but I am not surprised at your tone and accusations. What is it you believe, some wild conspiracy theory where dad set up son and it traced back to this as well--
"Forensic evidence proved that Conley set up the email account that was used to order the colchicine, the drug that poisoned the victim and is normally used as a treatment for gout, prosecutors said. The password to the account was “adamisgay,” the Post-Standard reports." From the Star-Telegram.com.
It sounds to me like you think LE, juries and judges and our system are all corrupt and the answer in your opinion in each case is some far fetched conspiracy plot they missed.
So if you think it was dad, who was he trying to set up? His son? Or did he just KNOW the incompetent LE would dig deeper and he was setting her up? Wow.
Your beef isn't with me sweetheart, it is with the system apparently and all jurors? Okayyy...
The majority are stupid and only you can see it. Hmm.
I even can see these are programs and there is much we don't know unless you were personally involved in the case, the information and at trial?
A letter, you will find this and this and this under Adam's car seat. That is Kindergarten 101. The person sending it knows where everything is, where to find it and who did it because they put it there. Duh. Oh no, then of course no, he told her naturally when she was confronted.... Yah right.
That is the act of someone young and not real bright, or at least not real bright...
I don't see any reason to be nasty but if you want to dish it... Anyhow, have a great day.
@Carl Lennen LMBO. I'm not the one doubting the results in this case and inventing conspiracies and ignoring the facts. Yah, I do have far better things to do. I enjoy a good discussion but clearly you are not one to engage in it with. Too stuck in his own tunnel vision and manufacturing things to, I guess, fit a conspiracy scenario he wants to believe.
The people in my head are off on a trip today unfortunately. I know they aren't visiting you because there is no room in your big head for anything but your fantastical thoughts of conspiracies in a corrupt system in a case that makes perfect sense with the facts, and they were not planted by LE nor made to fit, other than some planting done by the ex-girlfriend ...
Thanks for the chuckles hun. Work on that anger and bitterness you have. Over and out. Happy Sunday!
She suffered soo much in her last days. 8 heart attacks. 😭 RIP mam
If I found out my dad betrayed my mother with her own sister there is no way I would be seen sitting next to him in court or anywhere else. How can he even look his children in the face? He is a disgusting human being.
Bill definitely did it
💯💯💯
The sisters want to believe so strongly that a woman could NEVER kill their sister that they ignore evidence to the contrary. Absolutely ridiculous and an insult to their sister's memory.
I think my younger cousin could kill her older sister.. easily.. (both were married to the same guy, both have children with him.. older was married to him first, had two kids with him, he was having an affair with the younger one, she had 7 kids with him..) I don't want to think that I share dna with the younger cousin..
I wasn't sure what to think until she, Kaitlyn, spoke in court....absolutely no tears. You're on trial for murder and no tears? Yeah sorry I'm not buying it.
@@einienj3281 that's horrible. Family drama is the worst coz you need to take sides but you have absolutely no control over the situation.
@@einienj3281 DARN
@@somethingcleverrrr yes that was not even slightly convincing.
My life is over? No Mary’s life is over! Selfish
Have a look at the facebook page her family set up filled with whinging about her not being able to see other family members including her dead grandfather. They have zero empathy at all. Her victim will never see her family again, all because she couldn't handle not owning their son like she wanted.
Exactly!!!!!!
Well said.. exactly right !
Her life is over too if she gets prison time, it's all about perspective
I think if she knew nothing, she would’ve never said that. Just my opinion. I would’ve never felt hopeless as she was specially when I didn’t do the crime.
Mary's sisters are very strange. The fact that they are going to such a degree to claim Conley is innocent is beyond me. The evidence speaks for itself.
Its insane to think these sisters can't see how obviously guilty this women is they have tunnel vision on there own nephew it's very sad and honestly pathetic
Let me get this straight, Kaitlyn wrote letters blaming her ex that described exactly what killed Mary and where they would find the evidence, plus a receipt and a fake email that was similar to her ex's email, then admitted to police that she wrote the letters and there's evidence to prove that she was the only one with access to the fake email and letters, but Mary's sister still believes the husband did it even though the only motive is that he's dating the older sister?? That's insane.
The DA should hv never cut a deal wit the husband
@@coreyanderson5563That is what you think, there is just too much evidence against her, got a feeling you don’t think a woman is ever guilty.
@@coreyanderson5563 was the husband dating her sister????
Sounds like Mary's sister has convinced herself of what she wants to believe. On top of the overwhelming evidence, Kaitlyn never displayed the demeanor of an innocent person. She came across as a person caught for her crimes.
My thoughts exactly. The sisters that believe she's innocent are completely ignoring all the evidence that the girl deliberately tried to frame the son 🤦
But what kind of sister goes after her dead family member’s husband?! Gross!
Yeah, some people have no morals.
It happens more than you'd think. And is actually a biblical principle, at least for women to marry their dead husbands brother.
@@cmartini7057 ummm, yeah, but not for reasons as you guys are suggesting. It dates back to centuries ago when men went off to battle. The women and children who lost their husbands/fathers were absorbed into a brother’s family so they’d be taken care of.
@@mdbrf841 they still have this practice in some Asian cultures.
A lot of women and men do it I think it’s a form of trauma bonding that they took as falling in love. Because most of the time they won’t even last.
She’s crying saying “my life is over” uh no you’ll be alive in prison. The woman you killed her life is over. Smh.
For all the people that say how wonderful Kaitlyn was up until the point she became a murderer must not realize that narcissists don’t have real emotions so they study and mimic others from the day they are born. She spent a lot of time with animals and the elderly, probably because she wouldn’t have to put on fake emotions as often. She is sick and I just pray that she doesn’t do this to anyone else when she is out of prison in her 40’s!! 🙏🏼
Narcissists do have feeling. Their emotions and feelings are self serving so they don’t have a sense of altruism or empathy but they do have real emotions. It’s psychopaths and sociopaths who don’t have feeling or empathy. I feel like people use these words interchangeably. In any case, Kaitlyn definitely seems like her “crying” and reactions are forced or planned. It’s not convincing one bit and I do hope, like you, that she doesn’t do anything like this again. Getting out in her 40s is ridiculous.
Ummm. As someone who is not exactly "emotional" even in high-stress scenarios (my brain doesn't get overrided by the feelings but my body does feel it: lethargy, shaking hands, etc.), I want to say that not all non-emotional people are narcicistic. There's a difference between honesty over feelings and losing humanity and becoming just an animal because you let feelings/thought override your brain or conscience.
@@andreahl3494
I totally agree, I'm not a high strung or emotional person either. People think I'm cold because I'm not easily triggered. Yet, I'm the one most of my friends come to when they have a problem.
Well said Kelly. You couldn’t have said it any better.
How can intentionally poisoning someone be manslaughter?!
I was thinking the same thing. If this was a dude he’d have a gotten life at LEAST
Maybe she could argue that she didn’t mean to kill her, just make her sick
Because if laws that favor killers.
poison is the method used instead of a physical weapon like a knife or something therefore it is considered manslaughter it is an internal and almost invisible weapon. thats just my theory anyway
Its still 23 years. That's a life sentence in USA. Who cares? She is locked up.
This is one messy family 🤦🏽♀️
I'm not sure if I could have convicted her had I been on the jury, simply because there would have been reasonable doubt. Too many other suspects.
It’s just the lawyer trying anything to spin his pretty client out of the slammer.
The Sisters actually need to accept that maybe their sister and Bill was just the affair without murder, evidence points to Kaitlyn she's guilty but they still want to believe it's Bill and their older sister. .
Exactly! Well said. ❤
I've had a spiteful ex girlfriend use criminal charges against me that were purely made up just to harm me and my life. I say this just so people know it happens. Relationships and spite can make people do crazy things just to harm another, including malicious use of process
So Kaitlyn sent a letter to the police with all the correct details of Mary's death and the daughters still believe Kaitlyn is innocent? 😐
Her sisters are invalids. Omg how frustrating.
I think this sister has personal vendetta against the husband and son. And she loves to do interviews in media 😄
🤣🤦
an insult to her memory
Exactly! Lol
Kaitlyn Conley is so guilty. She tried to frame Adam with that letter and she stated in the letter about how his mother died. So guilty. She didnt seem innocent at all during that interrogation too. She should have gotten life in prison.
American juries vote for their favourite performer, like they vote for their politicians.
She comes right out and said "Poison is a woman's way" 😁😂Mary's sisters all want Mary's husband but only one got him. Crazy family😛
Those sisters obviously hate the husband and try everything to get him in jail
This case is so weird and complicated and simple at the same time, it's confusing the fact that Mary's death was convenient for so many people, i wonder if she knew ...
I was thinking the same. How convenient her death ☠️ was for a quite a few people.
Kaitlyn was crying for herself...
CROCODILE TEARS
She didn’t even have any tears
@PeRFeCT IMPeRFeCTiON I'm glad that you acknowledge that you're perfectly imperfect. Your opinions really hold no substance. Thank you.
@@esh5168 Are you that dense?
If I was innocent of the actual crime I’d be crying for myself as well.
She is guilty as hell. Any innocent person, if that statement was made to them would say "I am innocent, I didn't do this" not "my life is over".
I bet you'd think different if you were ever a suspect in any case.
ana carolina Au contraire. My FIRST Statement WOULD be "I am innocent. I didn't do this".
@@agf1700 Yeah I wouldn't be that sure... Once you're a police suspect, you're screwed being innocent or guilty
@@ana-zb7ix No lol even in custody and on her first questioning where she is brought in as a witness and not a suspect, there is no way an innocent person would say "My life is over." Maybe it would of made more sense if it was on her last questionings if they had framed her and she realizes police is after her, but she never said she was innocent until trial- and when asked who wrote the letter she said it was her and that "her life was over." She knew her life was over because they were onto her, if you did not do it, there is no reason for you to believe you will go to jail.
I have seen other questionings where this man was framed for a murder, and he very clearly estates he is innocent from the beginning. It isn't until later questionings he realizes the police is trying to frame him (as well as the killer) and he realizes that he's done. Even the way he behaves gives up his innocence.
Didn’t she proclaim her innocence during her final statements in court?
So awful to suffer in that way, evil people do exist amongst us..GOD BLESS and Peace greetings to all.
They missed 1 main part “ she went to lunch and came back sick “ so, who did she eat lunch with that slipped her the poison?
She had a protein shake every day after her lunch run. The poison is powder and was put in her protein powder or almond milk.
Sounds like her motive was to take his mother away from him then frame him for it so that he'd loose his freedom.
Does anyone ever know the difference between lose or loose?
@@conniecanas1422 😂😂😂😂
@@conniecanas1422 I see this so much online too, what is with this word, I see it used wrong even in major publishing.
Connie Canas or lost and loss lol
@@conniecanas1422 Totally! Drives me crazy! It’s like everyone has suddenly forgotten that ‘lose’ actually exists!
She's guilty. The sisters just feel betrayed by the elder sister and brother in law. Petty.
We'll know for sure if Cathy ends up dead when Bill meets someone new?
total piece of expletive.
I just finished a book by M. Williams Phelps on this case. It's absolutely scary and terrible that even after proving Kaitlyn committed the crime, Mary's own sisters are pointing the finger at Bill and Adam. That shows the depths of this sociopath's manipulation and control. She is a dangerous individual. Thank God by the time she gets out of prison she won't have many childbearing years left. She is a terrible evil vile vicious person
Wait didn’t she confess? When she was being interrogated ? She was crying because her life was over.
Once she said her life was over in the interrogation room she should have been asked more questions like "why" to get a better confession as to a motive.
When there’s not much of a motive, folks seem to question the verdict. But people have murdered others over sneakers. Don’t try to rationalize crazy.
BIG FACTS 💯
But the vast majority of murderers do have a motive. Obviously that’s not the case for everyone, but if the story is that they just randomly murdered someone without a reason, that should be questioned and looked into further.
Truth
They just want to blame the male
@Mia Mee lol
IF SHE WAS NOT GUILTY THEN HOW DID SHE KNOW THE NAME OF THE POISON AND THE RECIPT
And why write the letters
Wow, if she did kill his Mom to get back at him, that is the most cold-blooded revenge I’ve ever seen! But it makes sense, especially with her”note” about where the poison was 😫
Even if she is guilty she screwed herself by writing that letter, she wasn't being looked at as a suspect! But because adam wasnt either she couldn't stand it & ended up turning the cops onto herself 🤦♀️
Exactly!! And when her first defence worked, and got a hung jury, she still wasn’t satisfied because Adam hadn’t been framed. She pretty much put herself in jail , what a moron
This family is screwed up, her sisters are really trying to free her killer; who made her suffer for 2 whole days before dying🤔🤔 in my opinion she shoud've got life.
Yea lock the sisters up to for being STUPID 🤦
Death penalty would have been better
I feel like the Dad/Husband and Son are Covert Narcs and l think they Manipulated and Brainwashed Katie...
@@bonniebester606 sorry Bonnie I think I think she did do it
@@kathydemartino362 what would be her reason? What did she have to gain? I guess I missed something here because l don't get it? And when even the Victims own Sisters points the Finger at her Husband and Son...?
That poor woman suffered seven heart attacks before dying!! This is horrible! I pray her family has some peace now!
She's guilty......she admits her life is over in the interview. SHE DID IT! PERIOD!
I hope no one ever tries to poison me. They’ll be like, she’s always sick so who the hell even knows what it was. She didn’t even notice something was different until she died 😩😩
"My sister was healthy- she lived on supplements." This is not healthy.
Thats definitely 1st degree murder, when you plan it out
@@kimsmith819 that's exactly what I was thinking! There was so much planning and premeditation involved in this. I feel like she just got it downgraded because she's a young, pretty, soft-spoken white girl. So infuriating.
It's a figure of speech...duh.
@Vincent Cuttolo like that has not been getting alot of people off lightly . The world knows that those are the criteria that qualify alot of people to be let off criminal penalities lightly
Having the right face more specifically the right skin colour gets you lighter sentences thats if you even get sentenced at all
@@kilibubblecata6266 when Mary's husband was saying would anyone want her dating their son etc, I was screaming "No" at the screen. Who would want that around their family. There is no rehabilitating a sociopath.
OMG!!! With sisters like that who needs enemies???
I'm shocked!!!
This case is a clear example of…folks only being related because of semen and that act alone does not make them family. SMH! All she loved, clearly, did not love her and that sucks.
Whoever thinks kaitlyn is innocent then you are completely delusional 🙄
I agree but the sister is so upset over the husband marrying the other sister they have used this to get that murderer a new trial
Her sisters didn’t love her and it’s so clear , it’s sad honestly
I don't see how the sisters can see the police interviews with Kaitlyn and NOT think she did it.
I CAN'T believe the victim's sister
backing up a murder suspect.
Kaitlyn with that FAKE letter accusing her ex
and being the last person to be with a victim says Enough.
Kaitlyn is where she deserves to be at.
I mean we don’t know that for sure. A lot of things don’t seem to be adding up
The oA a-?.zz z nly way 🍈
@@seanmedvitz9056 she did it
@PeRFeCT IMPeRFeCTiON the way she shed zero tears and looked straight into the camera after spouting her sob story 🤣
imagine how disappointed and betrayed Mary probably feels from the afterlife right now, seeing that her own sister actively supports her murderer, and even wants to free her from prison.
I swear, sometimes the defense is so absurd I can't believe they have the audacity to present it to the judge and jury
Pls don’t swear. The bible says we should not (Matthew 5)🙏🙏
She is definitely guilty just the fact the she was the one who accessed the email from her phone and it was proved that the son couldn’t access her phone proves it to me. 🤷🏼♀️ The way she acted when she was confronted also screams guilty to me, “my life is over” not, “I am innocent”.
It sounds like the sisters want to punish their brother in law, and can’t see the actual facts of the case!
Right! They have no evidence whatsoever, they are just mad he is dating another sister. Yeah that's shocking but it is not a crime... They just want to punish the brother in law
Exactly
@@hylleny3209 Maybe this sister here is also having an affair with her bro/in/law😁Jealousy is a terrible beast, it's eating them up! Kaitlyn wrote the letters, planted the bottle under the seat 2 months later. The sister that didn't get the man is angry, steam coming from her nose😤
Why would the son put the drugs in his own car!? She is guilty not the son!
I'm not a master criminal or even an experienced criminal but common sense says to not keep the evidence around.
Absolutely, he was being framed
Damn' this case is so sad! Mary had no one to count on alive or dead. I hope no one got her inheritance.
No inheritance. No insurance money.
She literally said herself that her life was over. She knows she was guilty.
Kaitlyn did it. Mary's sister, Janine, is so delusional, it is sickening.
The phone and email address are the strongest evidence against her
@@BeerkegGarage anybody could have used her phone. Are you telling me that her boyfriend Adam didn’t have access to her phone??
@@wordsleuth992 At the time of the logins they weren't together or near each other lol. She is a psychopath.
@@wordsleuth992 anybody can not just access your phone, sorry that's not a good argument. Phones have highly sophisticated encryption and if you watch the interviews carefully she basically confesses to doing it. She is a sociopath and she has obviously fooled many people.. if the dad is as smart as they say he would never kill his wife, he would I just divorce her. Cmon people use your brain
Motive?
Poison is a "lady's weapon"?!!!? Sounds like she was just bragging, not a slip of the tongue. It sounds like she said it proudly.
@dreamland we are all sitting here watching true crime videos lol
The detective was slick! Tapping his hand induced a metronome effect setting the mood, then added "men do it also", causing her to retort!
Graham Young was a male and poisoned many people
Not to mention, incredibly stupid. After all, she admits to writing the letter, so if she's of the belief that he did it, why would she contradict the officer that way?
Then there is this idea that the son (or anyone really) would keep the detailed evidence in his car where it could easily be found? And how would she know exactly where it was and what those details were? And the email that placed the order came from electronics that were never in his possession, but hers only?
As the old saying goes, denial ain't just a river in Egypt.
Isn't it weird that these sisters are defending their sister's killer?
She damn near confessed to it. Said that her life is over.
Husband gets with other sister.
Damn, what a family
It seems that Mary’s family have always disliked her husband’s family, and then grief made their side into an echo chamber.
The sisters are stupid. How did the young lady know about the poison and the name of the poison and where to find it in her ex boyfriend's vehicle? She wrote that letter when she saw that the police didn't even think of her ex as a suspect. She had the email address. She did this. But she doesn't stop there....she now broke up the sisters and all the family because she won't come clean with what she did.
I think the sisters want Mary's wealth, by gaining her husband or put him and her son to jail.
If the son did it she would know because he told her about it.
Speculating; the ex-boyfriend Adam sounds a little bit psychotic and narcissistic. The fact that he said it’s the defendant in court, in such a cold manner, and the fact that he was accused of domestic assault, shows his current personality I think… He thinks he’s slick and got away with something. Imagine if Adam actually knew the passcode to her phone, her password to her email, Etc.? He thinks he got away with framing her successfully. Again, I’m just speculating. I have no opinion either way… But his tone in court because volumes in my opinion. “Make no mistake, I hate the defendant, Kaitlyn Conley. “I mean… In addition to the abuse allegation… It could almost appear as though she has her psychologically under control and framed her for that. She even mentioned that in her interrogation. They asked why would he admit it? She said she doesn’t know, but “some kind of a control issue.” Unfortunately I think both parties in this case thought they were more slick than they turned out to actually be. They both in essence got caught with their pants down… The messiest person involved ended up paying the price. Innocent or not,Adam is really no better than his Aunts
@@erikm8372 read the book “We thought we knew you”. It’s horrifying how this girls plays with people. Like a wild cat with crippled mice.
@@erikm8372 yeah I’m totally with you on this one. I think the dad and son wanted Mary dead for their own personal gain, money and the affair with Mary’s sister. The son could’ve very easily gotten access to kaitlyn’s phone but also she could’ve just as easily been in on it if she was promised money or something? she seems like she already isn’t very independent and could be easily manipulated. Would be interesting to see text messages between the husband and sister, the husband and son, and the son and kaitlyn leading up to the day Mary died and even up until now. I don’t think Kaitlyn acted alone
SON:”HAHA!, I have successfully poisoned my mother with this very specific substance. Now I will put the bottle, receipt, order detail, and cardboard under my car seat for over two months and confess to my sort of ex girlfriend what and where of the crime.”
😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😒
I was thinking how totally stupid that sounded 😹
There! Mary's sisters are stupid for ignoring all the forensic evidence, including the one screwing her brother in law.
Right!😂
@John Hicks thats literally what I feel I honestly feel the son did it !!!
Right!!! It makes no sense. They clearly have the right girl.
Funny to me that no one mentioned any suspicion of the sister who 2 months later was with her deceased sister’s husband. 🤔
Motives: Husband = gets all the assets, doesn't have to pay alimony after the divorce, can freely be with the other woman. Cheating Sister = Gets the man, any assets that come with him. Son = Gets money since it's rumored that momma had decided to stop paying his way in life. Kaitlyn = Has to be a sociopath who does sloppy work at covering up her tracks.
I'm in like half the video and my brain is already giving up on this, this has to many twists! 🤯🤯🤯🤯
That girl is guilty as the day is long. The sisters are upset because the husband & older sister are in a relationship. They keep saying things about infidelity. However, she ADMITTED to writing the letters & having the access to the email account that ordered the medicine. Some people can be so blinded by hurt that they throw common sense out the window. That girl killed their sister!
👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿 you are a 100% right
Exactly!
Yep they are so blinded by him cheating they can't see past it.
Saved me from typing that. You are correct my dear
Hmmmm... I’m not so convinced.
I think the sisters just don't like the husband because of the affair but all the evidence points to Kaitlyn.
how do we know Bill didn't pay the chick to kill his wife?
@@pinkpugginz she would have wrote that in the letter!! 🤣
Right?! They are crazy!?
@@pinkpugginz She would have said that. Not try to make it look like Adam. It wouldn't make any sense.
I live near Syracuse NY now I use to live in Utica, and this case hit me hard it’s so sad. It’s sad to me her sisters are over looking all the evidence it’s sad
The fact that her sister married her husband after she was murdered smh
.....and I thought my family was koo-koo....
😂
D. Z.
Me too
😂
😄😅😂👍
Is that how you spell it?
Imagine her going to a family dinner with her dead sister husband.
It happens more than you'd think
Yes,you sit and eat
@@ostapbendervan7874 or you stab a fork in the cheaters eye.
That's how Hunter Biden must have felt. He was together with his dead brothers wife not but 2 months after his brother Beau Bidens death. Both mom & dad, Joe Biden & Jill Biden, approved of it. Forget all the kids involved or why they think "moms dating Uncle Hunter now" or the mental toll on the kids. Luckily they broke up.
@@dickfitswell3437 sounds like a classy family! They should definitely be our new President and First Lady. 🤣
The victim’s sisters are just as or maybe more evil than her sister’s killer for trying to end two innocent men and family member’s lives by falsely convicting them of murder. Pure ignorance and evil. 🤦♂️
She went to the hospital for help...why was suicide even considered?!?! 🙄
She comes off as a real airhead - no wonder she thought she'd get away with this.
Good thing she was dumb as a box of rocks, too because until she sent those letters the authorities were well on their way to getting the husband incarcerated for it. He looked like a REALLY guilty party until Kaitlin gave them a smoking gun.
Or a complete psychopath who thought her self entitlement was gonna make a difference and she still is professing her innocence which shows just how calculating she truly is
Just think, if she had never written the letter, she probably would’ve gotten away with it and the husband probably would’ve been at least tried for it. Wow.
Yes! I knew I would find a comment thinking thr exact as me.
She basically put herself in the investor's radar.
She did it to you frame him, that's was the point of the murder!
But she didn't want the husband to go to jail but the son, that's why she had to write a letter or do something to somehow point at him. But she made so many mistakes here
She’ll learn from that mistake. She’s such a good girl she should be free in ten years. Hide your sons!
Cuz her entire scheme was to kill Adam's mom, and blame Adam for it. That's why she sent the letters. That's why she ordered the poison with a fake email that had his name on it, and thats why she planted the poison along with the sales receipt in his car. Duh
Pls do a follow up on this case!! Ty .
Kaitlyn: I am going to jail forever
Officer: you wont go forever
Me: How long is forever, longer than any sentence, longer than any life, well played Officer!
She is guilty...she tried to set up her boyfriend...the victim's son. She got off easy.
The letters have me thrower as well but you think maybe the husband and the sister but like you said those letters are damning
@PeRFeCT IMPeRFeCTiON I agree. But I couldn't understand what was her motive??
@PeRFeCT IMPeRFeCTiON you said it so well. I was also thinking about the possible motiv and all I can think of is that she did it to get revenge kn her ex boyfriend. First to hurt him jy killing his kom and then to blame him for the murder, but who knows what goes on in her crazy head. Just like you said; you can reason with crazy and you can't make sense out of their actions.
I am simply shocked how blind and stupid her sisters are, to defend her when is so obvious she killed her
@PeRFeCT IMPeRFeCTiON that is not important. You made a great point and you explained the whole case.
@@antonelabakavic4045 she was angry and she wanted to punish him. Framing him for his mother's murder was her revenge against him. She wanted to inflict maximum damage. She's a psychopath and an idiot.
Ok.. this woman murder her ex boyfriends mother?? Over absolutely nothing really!! This is damn weird af🤷🏻♂️
Dammmmnnnn, big bro tell me why I just watched this and randomly scrolled through the comments and seen you in the comments haha. Coming from Etowah, and seeing your comment by chance.... talk about a small ass world lmao
Uhh0hh yea that’s crazy bro...small world an yea I watched it randomly too💯
it was less about killing her, and more about framing her ex BF i imagine.
THANK YOU!! Like tf? The ex husband has to be involved. He had 2 PHDs!! He and the son masterminded this. I think outside the box and can see what they did. Sick people..
@@NaTe.oo7 It was her email address and her phone being used when no one was around. There is absolutely no evidence to suggest that either men just because one had an affair and the other had a falling out with his mother had anything to do with it other than the fact that it was in his car which could obviously be easily accessed by his ex. Kids have falling outs with their parents all the goshdang time and people cheat all the time too, doesn't mean they murder because of it.
why in the world would she do that? i don't understand why someone throw her/his life like that? this is so stupid!
If Kaitlyn wasn't involved, how did she know that the toxic medicine was under the seat of her boyfriend's Jeep. Why were those implicating searches found not only on the work computer but on her personal phone while she was at home? It doesn't make sense that the boyfriend or his father could be involved. She could have explained a lot more when the police were interrogating her and especially when they caught her lying. Her arguments and those that defend her don't add up to much .
Nobody:
Sammi Sweetheart: WHO WROTE THE NOTE!!??!
Underrated comment
Dead🤦🏼♀☠️
😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣 good one
😂😂
Killing an innocent mother that has nothing to do with all of this, insane! The ex-girlfriend is surely coldblood murderer.
I'd rather let the murderer go.... instead of arresting the wrong person
Why the hell would they need immunity if they are not guilty of anything? That's nuts!!
“My life is over!!!”
“No it’s not, Katie...”
That man is better than I am... I would’ve said, “Yup! You screwed yourself BIG time!”
😄frfr
Just to get more info out of her. Interrogation technique. Most likely not his real thoughts haha
@@womaninthewave Of course! Cops lie lie lie to get you to confess. This is why, even if you're ass is guilty as sin, you committed that crime, you need to ask for a lawyer and stfu.
"Don't say that! You got your whole life ahead of you! In prison 😉
Yikes..... I guess they won't be having family gatherings anymore.
Sadly!!!
Most probably
*Ex Boyfriend Speaks: No Tears*
*Ex's Father Speaks: No Tears*
*She Herself Speaks: Cries Like A Baby*
*She did it. If someone tries to tell me I murdered someone and called me a murder to my face, I'll be crying to whole time, not gonna lie. I also feel like the sisters had a hand in this.*
This expletive story has a expletive load of people. I expletive lost track of the expletive story!
So the family think it can't just be coincidence that the husband was having an affair. He must have done it.
But it can be coincidence that Kaitlyn was doing Internet searches on the poison used to kill the woman. Gimme a break.
She basically admitted her guilt in the police interview. "My life is over..." That says it all.
Exactly that's what I said
What is most disturbing to me is that the CrimeWatch interviewer don’t challenge her sister’s lunacy! She never asked her delusional and hateful sister why on earth Kaitlyn search for poisons, and later send emails to frame Adam. Bill’s not meeting her standard of morality doesn’t make him a killer. On what basis her sister could ignore all of Kaitlyn’s google searches, police interviews, planting evidence to frame Adam is just incredible to me.
I can’t believe some of Mary Yoder’s family insulting her by trying to free her killer...