It was a good movie but I feel like it threw us into the “people trying to survive on their own” phase too quickly. The whole point of “Day One” should have been seeing humanity grapple with and try to understand what the heck these new creatures are, but the characters’ complete lack of curiosity regarding the aliens made it hard to feel that way.
Well said. We didn't even see a single character who was amazed/ obsessed with the creatures or trying to figure them out (even if it cost them their life). This movie is set in New York, USA, and I don't think I recall a single person shooting at the aliens in order for them to learn that the aliens are practically bulletproof. I could go on and on...
@@jase276 This series lost me after the 2nd movie. Which felt like a remake/retread of the first one. They literally just gave us the FIRST movie AGAIN. LAZY! It wouldn't suprise me if the "2nd movie" was based on an alternate version of the script from the first movie, that they dug up and adapted.
Honestly the more I think about this movie the more disappointing it is. No further explanation of the aliens. No taking advantage of how insane the initial invasion would be in a setting like new york. Way too unrealistic reactions to a situation like this. Emotional manipulation via most well behaved cat. No real stakes because our protagonist is on her deathbed anyway. This was a cash grab making no actual impact on this universe imo.
If they explained the aliens then the other movies would have to have some piece of that in them. Also, what's to know about the aliens that is _that_ game changing? Their Objective? I think they just want to take over the planet, and they have breeding grounds. Idk what else there is to possibly know that is as cut and dry as their objective.
I agree this was really bad for "day one". They fast tracked the day one when she passed out. So we didn't get to see how the people transitioned from first contact to suddenly everyone knows the rules. When she woke and they were in the church and there's so many people. That would be something you could organize months in. Not on day one lol. Any one person making a noise and then everyone gets killed. Btw the monsters knew to not jump into the water. Like they had mapped out into their brains the edge of a dock. Sure. But no explanation.
Maybe try to put yourself in the shoes of the characters? I think this movie was extremely well done. It shows a lot more about the death angels than in the previous movies. Honestly it’s like you went into the movie with so many expectations and because you didn’t get what you wanted the movie is bad… Imagine you’re a regular New Yorker going about your life and then this happens, something so incredibly traumatic and unthinkable. Literal god mod aliens crash land and start mowing people down in droves. The only way to barely make it is to be completely quiet. Imagine yourself in that situation. What would you do? The sheer trauma alone would more than definitely stun you, and you couldn’t scream if you wanted to. There’s a scene after the massive attack on all the people trying to get to the evacuation point, where Lupita and the British dude were walking in the rain and they see a lonesome girl walking quietly with her hands wrapped around her mouth, muffling the sound of her intense grief after witnessing disgusting atrocities on people by something she doesn’t understand. She’s locked in a state of total shock. Shit was riveting dude.
@@SquilliamSquarner they needed to show the part where people realize they need to be quiet. Not the military saying it from above (when did they find out?) or her waking up to a stranger with his hands on her mouth saying shhh.
Why can’t these creatures hear their heartbeats and pulses when they are inches from the humans ? They can hear coughs and fabric tearing from blocks away but not heartbeats from 2 inches away? Come on.
@@everforward5561 yeah; the logic of this universe makes no sense. Humans fart when they sleep, they snore, the breath heavy. They vomit and have diarrhea. We make too much involuntary noise for us to survive this scenario.
The funny part is they DO. One of the scenes when the creature is inching towards someone, they faintly hear their heartbeat but some helicopter or some nonsense conveniently flies by and they chase after that instead.
Plot armor! Without that glorious armor, we wouldn’t have a film. It would just be a depiction of mass slaughter. But yes, I agree - if they can hear a pin drop from a mile away, why can’t they hear a heart beat from inches away?
The problem with these Quiet Place movies is that they don't have the balls to make them Rated R. They feel way too PG when every time a monster takes someone out they just tackle them off screen... 😮💨
I dont think so. The movie relies on Mcguyver inventions to surivive the world. Making it more violent wouldlnt make it better. it needed a better story. This movie feels sequel bating.
My cat is broken. We got him from the shelter like 10 years ago and he has never meowed once, he purrs when you pet him but that’s it. The other one we have never shuts up..
It's pretty obvious they're blind when the nurse is in front of one and it doesn't attack him as long as he's quiet, when you're being hunted by anything it makes complete sense to logically just stay quiet. Doesn't mean they figured it out, it's just a reasonable thing to do.
Half the scenes do this in the entire movie. No explanation at all for where all the people went that were in the theater. They're just gone suddenly. And after the nurse guy dies it just immediately cuts to another scene instead of showing how Sam got away from that situation... as a matter of fact there's multiple scenes where the monsters are right next to them and then they just disappear into thin air once the main characters are quiet for a couple seconds.
I don’t understand the reason for this movie. They showed the initial invasion at the beginning of the second. When I called that out online for the trailer,someone tried explaining that this was going to be the whole movie this time. But , from what I’m hearing, they glaze over the invasion again this time. So wtf am I doing here? Why do I want to see this movie with these different characters?
I feel the same way... if they just show a bit of the invasion, no finding out why they come or how the humans figure out to be quiet... then what's the point?!
Granted, maybe humans never find out why the aliens come. So it's just a mystery.. but just feel like we need something different than just to be quiet or you die for a 3rd movie.
Watch and judge for yourself. I had never seen any QP movies and this one was pretty damn good. Sure a little silly tension building but I think you’d have to with how goofy the aliens look. But manages to keep it straightforward. Plus it’s a short movie. Made me interested in the first two movies
reminds me of fear the walking dead,suposed to be all about how it started....and then in an episode it literaly becomed TWD but worse...great...gj guys,whats next?doom of valyria spin off and in ep 2 its already destroyed?
The flashbacks in part 2 were more than enough that they needed to show us for what happened on the first day. Didn’t need a 2 hour movie about it that didn’t show anything new or different at all. Man what a letdown.
The irony is that the first 10 or so minutes of Part 2 when it first began was my favorite part of the film and I always said to myself, I wish they made an entire movie of that. Well, be careful what you wish for. I wanted Cloverfield and I got... Cloverfield Lane 10.
Should have done it i am legend style. Not a whole fucking movie. At the end of the day. Given the fact that humanity was wiped out by monsters with huge, very recognisable vulnerabilities.
It was a letdown. I wish we get a story regarding the point of view of a person in the military or even better a person from NASA. What did the satellite pick up before all these comets or whatnot fell on Earth? How much time did they have to prepare at least to pass the message to the military?
I don't care what you have to say, after seeing the first one in theaters there's no way I'd watch the sequel in one. Even if it was rated as the best sci-fi movie or whatever. Sitting in that theatre in total silence except for the sounds of the other people opening plastic wrappers and crunching away on their snacks had to be the aggravating theatre experience of my life lmao
I think this film was definitely a wasted opportunity to explore the beginning of the invasion. Id imagine it would take quite some time for people to figure out that they needed to stay quiet in order to survive, and this could’ve resulted in some pretty terrifying sequences as most peoples' initial reactions would’ve been to panic, scream, run, and make noise. Imagine a scene in Madison Square Garden at a concert or sporting event in which the aliens entered the venue. You think people would be quiet as they rushed for the exits? And even if someone did somehow figure out that the aliens couldn't see and hunted through sound, how would they reliably and efficiently communicate this to a large group of scared, panicking, confused, boneheaded, and stubborn New Yorkers and/or Tourists who didn't all speak the same language? I thought depicting this mass panic and inevitable confusion was the reason they chose to set the film in a bustling city like NY, which is infamous for being constantly noisy. But Sam gets knocked out literally at the beginning of the invasion and wakes up in a shelter with everyone already knowing to be quiet. This to me seemed like a missed opportunity to explore what the most intriguing part of the Day One premise was in my opinion - the initial mass panic and inevitable learning curve. How did they learn what to do and organize so quickly? Sam couldn't have been knocked out for more than a day since the title implies that the film takes place in a 24 hour period. So the film deliberately skipped the initial learning curve almost entirely and therefore missed out on what could've made the movie intriguing in a unique way that the first two weren't.
@@TheGreatVivek7 @TheGreatVivek7 Vivek, did you mean armchair writers? Because this wasn't a directorial issue. The directing was fine. It was an issue with the story and therefore the writers. Furthermore, do you disagree with my points? If so, why? Did you want a rehash of the first two films, just in a different setting? Did you not want them to utilize the "day one first contact" premise a bit more and explore the terrifying results of said premise? Or are you just being cynical? Im curious to see what you think from my armchair.
@@TheGreatVivek7this movie will Bomb. Glad this series is over. This should have been a comic book series. We leaned almost nothing. They made the creatures goofy video game enemies
Yes I agree, is not believable, in a couple of hours everybody knows not to make a sound, I don't know how millions of people.were dead or how they were evacuated in a couple of hours.....there's a lot of plot holes, also I didn't care for some that's on the verge of dying...i didn't agree with the review...nop is a hard pass, the first two movies are great
@@sosarene Everybody knows to not make a sound yet a day or so later they all decided to immediately go en masse in the streets with the loudest shit. Like, how did a guy in the crustiest wheelchair live that long? And it was so dumb how they kept having the creatures go RIGHT UP to people. Like, yeah, they can't see but surely they could feel someone profusely BREATHING on them 0.0001 cm away from them?!
@@sosareneIt's pretty obvious when you're being hunted by an predator that making sound is a detriment to you, it's just logical. Plus the helicopters went around with speakers telling any survivors who for whatever reason didn't know, that they're attracted by sound.
Is nobody going to mention that they were a lot louder in this movie, from walking and running to whispering. The first one they walked on sand. I this one I heard footsteps the whole time.
By the rules of the first movie, everyone in both the sequel and the prequel would be dead. The rules in this world are extremely inconsistent and it took me out completely.
@@youngrootv we don't mean that they aren't taking precaution. We mean that by the rules of the first movie, everyone in this movie would be dead by the 10 minute mark.
Sorry but that logic does not apply in Texas buddy…! If you know anything about Texas kitty cats? You know one thangs that’s for sure! You know that that Texas heat, mixed with that kitty cat fur gives them a different definition to the words (hot and bothered.) 😾😼
I have a theory that an entire Djimon Hounsou storyline got cut from this movie. His character is entirely superfluous and serves almost no purpose. Essentially, just a cameo. Aside from that, this movie was just okay. It reminds me of Civil War. It's really just a character drama set in the Quiet Place universe. You not gonna get much on what's happening or what's going on with the aliens or any kind of lore-building or interesting details about the invasion. You're really just here for 2 people getting to know each other in silence.
Have people forgotten his main focus is in A Quiet Place Part 2? I think you along with the Angey Joe guys need to rewatch that movie. He serves his purpose which was to tie in the other movies.
My Dune 2 experience was ruined by 2 freaking teenage girls that arrived 20 minutes into the movie, sat next to me and squeaked whenever Timothy Chalamet said anything.
@@baizuo_6246 there’s no much bad stuff to criticize about that film id long to write about it but i feel like people are so blinded by the visually and story telling they don’t see how awful some of the things i mentioned prior are. also zendaya’s character is nothing more than a high school love drama and she pouted when she didn’t get her man all to herself and not realizing a little romance wasn’t bigger then her ‘bf’s’ entire legacy and the millions that looked up to him as a god/leader. the whole love interest was nonsense.
The first movie was okay but I had to turn my brain off. Wouldn't a white noise machine be like a flashbang to these things? What about an actual flashbang? What about one of those sonic crowd suppression weapons? I'm about 100% sure I could make these things' brains explode.
Yeah that bothered me as well, we're pretty much capable of producing not only loud sounds but high frequency(flashbangs are already agonizing for our senses)
This movie was a 2/10 max and I wanna know how much they’re paying you. It was boring and they didn’t do anything new. They tried to save the movie with a cat, le reddit pizza humor, and a terminally ill character that you DO NOT CARE ABOUT. They tried to redeem the movie by manipulating your emotions but it doesn’t work unless you’re a smooth brained viewer.
They kinda gave away they didn’t like it in the spoiler section. I think they hyped it up in the beginning cuz of the large portion of their audience that’s very sappy. This move was a great concept with terrible execution. I think they didn’t want blowback over a movie that will be forgotten in 2 months.
The part where everyone was walking in a herd like sheep was definitely supposed to symbolize something since Lupita Nyong’o was walking opposite of them like a lone wolf
My theater was quiet during the parts of the film that were quiet. But as soon as there was any noise within the film, people starting talking and/or loudly whispering to make up for not doing so during the quiet portions of the film as if this was ok. This definitely tarnished the experience for me
This movie was TERRIBLE, the first half is decent but no actual invasion and completely bloodless, huge disappointment. Cloverfield is WAYYY better 🗣️💯
It annoyed me how so much of this movie didn't understand how things in the movie should actually work, and that so many things that could establish some "rules" happened off screen, and so we just have to go with it. People just figured out to stay silent in a matter of hours just 'cause. If the escape was at the Seaport, why wasn't the military setting up noisemakers uptown in, oh say... Harlem? Or along the East or Hudson River and taking shots from boats? A walking trip from Chinatown to Harlem took 3 days just 'cause they had to tread carefully to avoid aliens, but we never saw them have to do that once. The cat was so incredibly quiet just 'cause. The bridges were blown, but we hear nothing about the tunnels in and out of Manhattan just 'cause. Cancer meds could only be found at the one pharmacy, even though Manhattan has a RIDICULOUS number of pharmacies on every block.
They couldn't show too much military stuff because the military would easily mash these stupid aliens, it's just ridiculous how lame these bad-guys are
Yes the military will be able to harm creatures that literally fell from meteors without a scratch. It’s not like it didn’t show the only way you could kill them in the first 2 movies right?
@@pain2573 They could literally play loud speakers on helicopters to lure the majority of them in each city to an area to get missile striked to death or do two massive waves to go and get nuked at each coastline.
This movie looked so good and was so easy to make good and story so easy to tell apocalypse story and started so good But this was horrible after the 1st 20 minutes and pizza starts... Don't bother save your money sadly Watch at home in the dark on subscription service not worth $50 at the theater
Also some people in comments thinking to deep about it. She is dying of cancer and wants a last meal at her favorite pizza place its her dying wish that's it. So she goes to get it she'll die of cancer or the monsters she doesn't care anymore. She didn't force for him to tag along but after she got her final wish sort of she helped him to escape. She was going to pass quicker anyway because she has no more meds and suffering in pain.
Stop putting kids & animals, in horror movies if they arent gonna get killed off!!! They always get sparred therefore it just becomes sooo predictable and redundant.
Yeah the monsters in the second movie didn't know about water and jumped in and drowned. So this movie kind of breaks the second film, because apparently the aliens were smarter and aware of their vulnerability to water on day one, than they were on Day 474 when the ending of part II took place.
I found it disappointing because like you guys I was hoping for more of a military perspective. Plus it is quite strange how they learn quickly about sound and water and somehow they didn’t roll in the gunships like you said and then be able to wipe them out before the seemingly world domination since x amount of days pass with them still controlling the land.
Where to begin? Our lead character is introduced, and oh boy, she's a real gem. By gem, I mean she openly declares she's unpleasant. Fantastic! Nothing like spending 100 minutes trying to muster some care for a self-proclaimed jerk. Then, we meet another character who sets new standards for annoyance. But hey, they had a cat. That was a nice touch. A cat that never makes a noise. Never knocks anything over or gets scared, goes swimming with you in city sewers and when it runs off when the city is being destroyed it magically finds its owner, over and over again. Ya know, just like cats in real life?
The cat got scared multiple times during the movie, wdym? I have a cat, she never knocks shit over, she doesn't meow around. Now take into account that it's a service animal that's obviously been trained to be well behaved. I do agree however that plunging that cat into water multiple times is very unrealistic lmao. But the rest of what you said is nonsense
Well the cat is supposed to be an emotional support animal, so it is supposed to be trained. And it was attracted to eric because of the panic attacks, the cat knows he needs help, but yea it's super unrealistic lol
@@CemoreNetwork finding out the lady had a dad that played piano just doesnt cut it for me. this shouldve been a show, cuz it has all the bloating of a show. in my opinion, i know people loved this but i found it more Intresting the first one when they had figure shit out. i wanted to know more about the threat. i know that the monsters suppose to be a mistery but its already movie 3. like common and the movie is abysmally short. this was episode one of a series.
Did no one else get upset that she wasnt willing at ALL to give up her DYING life for the guy running on the deck but he was willing to give up his life for HER F CAT! like girl i would have loved you if you gave your life for him to survive!
Not gonna lie I thought yall would tear this movie apart because I want my fucking money back , it’s like the characters literally did everything to die and plot said “ nah bro I gotchu “
I haven't seen it but I get what you're saying just based on the fact that is very common in fiction in general. The term plot armor is commonly known for sure. But that alone isn't an innately bad thing. Execution and context is everything. There would be a lot of very short stories where the people died quickly or very boring stories where they don't do anything to get into dangerous situations. I'm not dismissing your opinion just kind of thinking out loud about that kind of thing in general. It most definitely can come off really dumb or end up making dangerous situations LESS exciting. That's where R.R. Martin really hit the nail on the head with the books and setting up danger in the first book which allows there to be fear during danger while still letting main characters survive.
They still can't provide an adequate explanation why our weapons and militaries don't just wipe the monsters out. I think that's why they never concentrate on military action, because it would be absolute idiocy.
Because the military would get overwhelmed with the amount of creatures involved, I'd imagine, and in the end, they'd have to resort to nuking entire cities to try to contain them.
Easy answers, too fast to hit, armor too durable to penetrate. Even if something like a 50 Cal could, the odds of hitting the thing are almost 0. And at that point, even if you connected, you’ve DEFINITELY alerted every other creature in that vicinity which opens you up to being overwhelmed. And all of this assuming you’re able to make a coordinated plan silently to get the drop on these creatures before they notice you.
@@grilledleeks6514 Have you seen the movies? A couple Apache's or more advanced choppers would get obliterated by these things. Go watch World War Z, it'd be similar to that. Overwhelmed and not enough firepower.
Problems with Quiet Place: Day One 1. Never expands or explains why the Aliens vist 2. 10 min. of mediocre massacre and then the rest of the movie is just a rewatch of quiet place 2. 3. Boring
This movie was terrible, absolute TRASH. Do not waste your money on this one, it's nothing like the original. There's so much wrong with this movie that I don’t even know where to begin. The main issue is the writing, it SUCKS, I mean why wouldn’t they explore the alien side of things, like what are they, where do they come from, and how were they able to overwhelm the most powerful military on the planet??? Nope, instead we got a movie about a cat and some pizza...GTFOH, horrible choices for actors as well, they made the guy into a whiny, crybaby while the woman was the strong, empowered hero! Collectively, we’re all sick of that! One last thing, New Yorkers are armed up to the teeth, people would not be hiding like cowards while their loved ones, friends and neighbors are getting slaughtered, we would have fought back with everything we got, that's the movie I wanted to see, how we fight back and still loose! This was one of the worse movies I have ever seen...HOT GARBAGE!
I just started this movie and I'm already having problems with it. After the first scene with the aliens, she wakes up and everyone just knows what's going on. I guess the radio maybe told them but that "reveal" was a let down. The guy tried to turn off the generator, why turn it off? It already went loud, just stay the fuck away from it. Then all the people in a huge crowd like that....? No WAY I would join that crowd. You're just asking to die, if you lived long enough to still be alive then you'd know not to walk with a shuffling, coughing, heat score of a mob.... there were thousands of people walking together. I actually winced when a guy for no reason grabs her leg while she's under the car then screams for her to help him. That makes no sense, just crawl under with her and be quiet.
My cat rarely ever meow or hissed. If she did it was because she was in trouble or upset which was rare. So I found it believable that her cat made no vocal sounds. People who have taken care of different types of cats understand this
There are a million reasons why these movies don't make sense. The baby not crying as a baby would in the previous was even more unbelievable than the cat scenario. There are so many people who snore and don't even realize it. The list of logistical reasons why these films are dumb is a mountain high.
movie screening was packed (I had low expectations) and I fell asleep for 30 minutes!!! I woke up to them singing in mime in a bar, and yet I still knew what the (anti)-climax was building up to... other people were also yawning, and because its a "quiet" movie, I could hear them. it was hilarious 😂 nothing happens, then the predictable happens... CRAP
I was super, super, super lucky with my movie crowd. Almost immediately everyone realized rustling through food packaging and what not was too disruptive and it was dead quiet the rest of the way.
The movie should have been from the military's perspective. All out alien warfare. The first one was great, but if these things can't fly or swim then not only do we need the explanation of how they could ever take over the planet like that but it just would have been 1000% more entertaining than watching a dying lady try to get pizza.
@@nickwash3r3 there was like no marketing for it. I think I saw a trailer before I went to see Furiosa and that was the first I heard of it and then immediately forgot about it again
The movie I want to see is the cat used as a narrative vehicle; and we just follow the cat as it runs from group to group of people and doing something to get them eaten by the aliens. Maybe the first group it bats something off a table, the second group feeds it late in the morning and it meows - and after each time the aliens are summoned the kitty just runs off and gets away - off to find it's next group of people to bring the aliens towards! The aliens realize this, and end up worshiping the cats as the Ancient Egyptians did.
A 7 across the board is far too generous a score based on y’all’s specific critiques, which were spot on. Thought you guys were gonna go with a 5. That would’ve lined up better with you guys’ point by point evaluations.
@@positronichypersonic4928 yeah, it's partly why I unsubscribed. That, amongst other things... the constant interruptions when the others are giving their views was also difficult to sit through, consistently
People keep saying, "Cats would never be that quiet!" To that, is say, have you ever seen a scared cat before? I have a cat who is normally very loud, you can always hear her running throughout the house. But whenever it storms, she'll run in hide and you won't be able to find her for hours after the storm ends. Cats have survival instincts the same as anything else.
Well your cat isn't being chased by aliens now is it? I don't care how trained an animal is, if a big ass alien walks by the cat is freaking out. The cat ruined the immersion of the movie
A buddy and I were having this same conversation. Perhaps bodies of water reflect differently with their echo location and doesn’t reflect back like the other solid things around them. Maybe looks like a void that they know they should avoid. I wish we could’ve have seen that realization at the river as ppl were loading boats, and not broadcasted over a helicopter and shown in 1 scene. Surely there has to be a Learning curve for the aliens to know that swimming doesn’t work for them.
They make clicking sounds. They have some form of echo location. They aren't just mindless creatures, they obviously have some form of intelligence. Water interacts with sound differently compared to physical objects. The only thing that's bullshit, is if they have echo location, why can't they sense humans that are right infront of their face. That's the real plot hole. The aliens knowing where water is, is easily explainable lol.
I spent most of my time during this film in deep contemplating of the difference between: 1: The noises the Aliens hate, verses 2: The noises of the natural Environment, , verses 3: The noises the Aliens make
After three movies I’m just tryna learn more about the creatures motives and origin. I felt the fungal nest breeding ground shit didn’t get talked about enough. Too many unanswered questions
I usually agree with your reviews, i went yesterday to see the movie....man is a very very dumb movie, is not a good movie, i had a lot of great expectations and was a big letdown .....it was better choice to do it in a very little town instead of a big city with millions of people....didnt like a bit
To your point about “people don’t act that dumb in real life” as someone who works retail and food, yes people are indeed that stupid in real life lmao
I bought this when it was released digitally. I was pretty disappointed they cheesed out the "massacre phase" kind of aspect of a day one. I hate that they had Sam knockout and did a stupid time jump, and when she comes to, everyone knows to be quiet. Fear the Walking Dead missed this opportunity too. I wanted to see a whole shit ton of random attacks at different parts of the city, random people being massacred, the military being overrun and torn apart. Both of these films dropped the ball on that part, and that was a big part I was looking forward to for "prequel" movies.
This movie was a huge disappointment they exchanged jumpscares with loud noise in place of actual suspense built up by the story in the situations. On day one we should have been seeing the military fighting the aliens , we got none of that. What we got is one woman's story of walking halfway across town to get a slice of f****** Pizza, stupid Primus and bad writing. Also why was this movie so damn dark, why was there so much smoke, why were most of the scenes at night and why was every window covered with mud?? Bad movie , I warned all my friends to leave this alone
I liked it but wanted more the-world-is-collapsing mayhem. So many apocalyptic movies focus on the aftermath, and I want to see more of how it all goes down at the beginning. Certainly, that would involve more special effects and a higher budget, though.
What a letdown of a movie, compared to the other 2, this woulda been great if they did multiple character stories explaining the story, but no just 2 hours of nothing
Why does everyone defend/ love A Quiet Place? I pitched watching it ata family reunion, and we all were mocking it/ laughing our asses off at how bad it was
Wouldn't these creatures need to use eco location of sorts to navigate terrains if not they would just run into buildings and walls all the time they clearly know where objects are. So How would they not notice people moving around them even if they aren't making sound?
You guys really missed the mark on this one. Movie is a 5/10, mostly because of visuals. You have soo many complaints. This is NOT "A Quiet Place: Day One" This is just "A Quiet Place: Day 5 (with another sneak peak at day One!)" What's the plot of this movie? Pizza. Who's the main character of this movie? Kitty cat.
I was exceptecting them to shit on this one. But with their audience I can see why they didn’t. Didn’t wanna deal with the bs. Great concept bad execution. This movie was not good. I went into this one extremely hyped.
Idk about woke. Sam just happens to be black, that's about it. And there's no romance in the film, the two just bond through trauma. That being said, yeah it was pretty bad.
@jase276 part racially, but more woke on other grounds, including entitlement and giving a free pass to the boo-hoo mindset. Even that's not an issue, if it were Picket Fences - the Movie, not a horror movie that movie-goers come to watch for the thrills and suspense. Watch Quiet Place 1 & 2 again, and you'll understand.
I loved Quiet Place 1 and 2. The only reason Im not seeing this one is because it's a prequel, and I don't really care about prequels. I'm just waiting for a quiet place, part 3, the true sequel to Quiet place and part 2.
I understand your opinion my man. I know many people don’t like movies that are prequels to the 1st & the 2nd. But it wouldn’t hurt to do some world building and storytelling to the series universe of “A Quiet Place” of a dark setting where humanity was almost wiped out from making a single noise.
TRUUUUE. I don't hate prequels but with prequels you gotta be so safe and careful making the story that it just doesn't leave room for stakes or surprises.
If your cat is knocking things off, they are bored from being cooped up inside all the time. Let your cat outside into a fenced area if you can, harness leash-adapt them if you can't.
@@Rizingzon Mine is. Been harness trained since I got her. Harness = outside to her, and she's never deliberately knocked over a single thing. Look up "zoochosis" and realize that there is nothing that says it can't affect pets.
What a horrible concept, I would not want some fuck head ruining the movie experience by constantly going to every fucking person asking if they want overpriced garbage. No wonder theaters are dying, and good riddance.
A Pizza Place : Part I
It was a good movie but I feel like it threw us into the “people trying to survive on their own” phase too quickly. The whole point of “Day One” should have been seeing humanity grapple with and try to understand what the heck these new creatures are, but the characters’ complete lack of curiosity regarding the aliens made it hard to feel that way.
Well said. We didn't even see a single character who was amazed/ obsessed with the creatures or trying to figure them out (even if it cost them their life). This movie is set in New York, USA, and I don't think I recall a single person shooting at the aliens in order for them to learn that the aliens are practically bulletproof. I could go on and on...
At this point, Cloverfield is unironically a better "what if" Day One than this film.
@@jase276 This series lost me after the 2nd movie. Which felt like a remake/retread of the first one. They literally just gave us the FIRST movie AGAIN. LAZY! It wouldn't suprise me if the "2nd movie" was based on an alternate version of the script from the first movie, that they dug up and adapted.
everybody who was curious died, thats the story.
That’s cliche and predictable I enjoyed what they did here
Honestly the more I think about this movie the more disappointing it is. No further explanation of the aliens. No taking advantage of how insane the initial invasion would be in a setting like new york. Way too unrealistic reactions to a situation like this. Emotional manipulation via most well behaved cat. No real stakes because our protagonist is on her deathbed anyway.
This was a cash grab making no actual impact on this universe imo.
110%
If they explained the aliens then the other movies would have to have some piece of that in them.
Also, what's to know about the aliens that is _that_ game changing? Their Objective? I think they just want to take over the planet, and they have breeding grounds.
Idk what else there is to possibly know that is as cut and dry as their objective.
I agree this was really bad for "day one". They fast tracked the day one when she passed out. So we didn't get to see how the people transitioned from first contact to suddenly everyone knows the rules.
When she woke and they were in the church and there's so many people. That would be something you could organize months in. Not on day one lol. Any one person making a noise and then everyone gets killed.
Btw the monsters knew to not jump into the water. Like they had mapped out into their brains the edge of a dock. Sure. But no explanation.
Maybe try to put yourself in the shoes of the characters? I think this movie was extremely well done. It shows a lot more about the death angels than in the previous movies. Honestly it’s like you went into the movie with so many expectations and because you didn’t get what you wanted the movie is bad… Imagine you’re a regular New Yorker going about your life and then this happens, something so incredibly traumatic and unthinkable. Literal god mod aliens crash land and start mowing people down in droves. The only way to barely make it is to be completely quiet. Imagine yourself in that situation. What would you do? The sheer trauma alone would more than definitely stun you, and you couldn’t scream if you wanted to. There’s a scene after the massive attack on all the people trying to get to the evacuation point, where Lupita and the British dude were walking in the rain and they see a lonesome girl walking quietly with her hands wrapped around her mouth, muffling the sound of her intense grief after witnessing disgusting atrocities on people by something she doesn’t understand. She’s locked in a state of total shock. Shit was riveting dude.
@@SquilliamSquarner they needed to show the part where people realize they need to be quiet. Not the military saying it from above (when did they find out?) or her waking up to a stranger with his hands on her mouth saying shhh.
Why can’t these creatures hear their heartbeats and pulses when they are inches from the humans ? They can hear coughs and fabric tearing from blocks away but not heartbeats from 2 inches away? Come on.
Or BREATHING, which humans are ALWAYS DOING. Their hearing sensitivity is about as reliable as the NYPD.
@@everforward5561 yeah; the logic of this universe makes no sense. Humans fart when they sleep, they snore, the breath heavy. They vomit and have diarrhea.
We make too much involuntary noise for us to survive this scenario.
The funny part is they DO. One of the scenes when the creature is inching towards someone, they faintly hear their heartbeat but some helicopter or some nonsense conveniently flies by and they chase after that instead.
There is a scene where they hear a heartbeat
Plot armor! Without that glorious armor, we wouldn’t have a film. It would just be a depiction of mass slaughter. But yes, I agree - if they can hear a pin drop from a mile away, why can’t they hear a heart beat from inches away?
The problem with these Quiet Place movies is that they don't have the balls to make them Rated R. They feel way too PG when every time a monster takes someone out they just tackle them off screen... 😮💨
Yes !
That's very true. It could really be something like the Aliens franchise if they kicked it up a notch.
Meh you may be right but I like that I was comfortable taking my kid to see it
@@sidjay1220 people are still killed, just unrealistically.
I dont think so. The movie relies on Mcguyver inventions to surivive the world. Making it more violent wouldlnt make it better. it needed a better story. This movie feels sequel bating.
My cat is broken. We got him from the shelter like 10 years ago and he has never meowed once, he purrs when you pet him but that’s it. The other one we have never shuts up..
My cat is 8 years old, I have only heard her meow a handful of times till date. It’s completely alright lol
I'll do you one better. I know a cat that acts like a dog. They don't meow, but they sure do pant and drool.
@@jase276 panting should not be taken lightly. Mine started panting out of nowhere this year, but as it turns out, it was because of the heatstroke
A Quiet Place Cat Multiverse: Confirmed
I will be extremely disapppinted if you never named your cats "Jay and Silent Bob." Rename them NOW! Maybe Penn and Teller?!
They didnt even show how they figured out the monsters can't see, just a cheap cut to black, and then everyone just knows.
Right!
took us less than 20 minutes to figure it out without being told during the first movie.
It's pretty obvious they're blind when the nurse is in front of one and it doesn't attack him as long as he's quiet, when you're being hunted by anything it makes complete sense to logically just stay quiet. Doesn't mean they figured it out, it's just a reasonable thing to do.
the bait and switch of "day one" lmao
Half the scenes do this in the entire movie. No explanation at all for where all the people went that were in the theater. They're just gone suddenly. And after the nurse guy dies it just immediately cuts to another scene instead of showing how Sam got away from that situation... as a matter of fact there's multiple scenes where the monsters are right next to them and then they just disappear into thin air once the main characters are quiet for a couple seconds.
I don’t understand the reason for this movie. They showed the initial invasion at the beginning of the second. When I called that out online for the trailer,someone tried explaining that this was going to be the whole movie this time. But , from what I’m hearing, they glaze over the invasion again this time. So wtf am I doing here? Why do I want to see this movie with these different characters?
I feel the same way... if they just show a bit of the invasion, no finding out why they come or how the humans figure out to be quiet... then what's the point?!
Granted, maybe humans never find out why the aliens come. So it's just a mystery.. but just feel like we need something different than just to be quiet or you die for a 3rd movie.
Watch and judge for yourself. I had never seen any QP movies and this one was pretty damn good. Sure a little silly tension building but I think you’d have to with how goofy the aliens look. But manages to keep it straightforward. Plus it’s a short movie. Made me interested in the first two movies
reminds me of fear the walking dead,suposed to be all about how it started....and then in an episode it literaly becomed TWD but worse...great...gj guys,whats next?doom of valyria spin off and in ep 2 its already destroyed?
So you can see the woke version this time
Some guy 2 seats away from me was literally unwrapping candy and talking to himself the whole movie
Lol
It was me. I am sorry but it's rough out there.
Schizophrenics would be the first to go in the Quiet Place Universe, if that's any consolation to you.
The movie was Dumpster Juice !!! The Cat should get a Oscar 🗑️
The flashbacks in part 2 were more than enough that they needed to show us for what happened on the first day. Didn’t need a 2 hour movie about it that didn’t show anything new or different at all. Man what a letdown.
Huge let down
The irony is that the first 10 or so minutes of Part 2 when it first began was my favorite part of the film and I always said to myself, I wish they made an entire movie of that. Well, be careful what you wish for. I wanted Cloverfield and I got... Cloverfield Lane 10.
Expect cloverfield land was actually pretty good even if it basically nothing to do with the aliens 😅😅@jase276
Should have done it i am legend style. Not a whole fucking movie. At the end of the day. Given the fact that humanity was wiped out by monsters with huge, very recognisable vulnerabilities.
It was a letdown. I wish we get a story regarding the point of view of a person in the military or even better a person from NASA. What did the satellite pick up before all these comets or whatnot fell on Earth? How much time did they have to prepare at least to pass the message to the military?
This is the ONLY horror movie where i would say, "Splitting up is a good idea"
I don't care what you have to say, after seeing the first one in theaters there's no way I'd watch the sequel in one. Even if it was rated as the best sci-fi movie or whatever. Sitting in that theatre in total silence except for the sounds of the other people opening plastic wrappers and crunching away on their snacks had to be the aggravating theatre experience of my life lmao
I think this film was definitely a wasted opportunity to explore the beginning of the invasion. Id imagine it would take quite some time for people to figure out that they needed to stay quiet in order to survive, and this could’ve resulted in some pretty terrifying sequences as most peoples' initial reactions would’ve been to panic, scream, run, and make noise.
Imagine a scene in Madison Square Garden at a concert or sporting event in which the aliens entered the venue. You think people would be quiet as they rushed for the exits? And even if someone did somehow figure out that the aliens couldn't see and hunted through sound, how would they reliably and efficiently communicate this to a large group of scared, panicking, confused, boneheaded, and stubborn New Yorkers and/or Tourists who didn't all speak the same language?
I thought depicting this mass panic and inevitable confusion was the reason they chose to set the film in a bustling city like NY, which is infamous for being constantly noisy. But Sam gets knocked out literally at the beginning of the invasion and wakes up in a shelter with everyone already knowing to be quiet. This to me seemed like a missed opportunity to explore what the most intriguing part of the Day One premise was in my opinion - the initial mass panic and inevitable learning curve.
How did they learn what to do and organize so quickly? Sam couldn't have been knocked out for more than a day since the title implies that the film takes place in a 24 hour period. So the film deliberately skipped the initial learning curve almost entirely and therefore missed out on what could've made the movie intriguing in a unique way that the first two weren't.
Yes exactly, they certainly fumbled the football. What a disappointment.
So many armchair directors running around on the internet these days.
@@TheGreatVivek7 @TheGreatVivek7 Vivek, did you mean armchair writers? Because this wasn't a directorial issue. The directing was fine. It was an issue with the story and therefore the writers.
Furthermore, do you disagree with my points? If so, why? Did you want a rehash of the first two films, just in a different setting? Did you not want them to utilize the "day one first contact" premise a bit more and explore the terrifying results of said premise? Or are you just being cynical? Im curious to see what you think from my armchair.
Facts
@@TheGreatVivek7this movie will
Bomb. Glad this series is over. This should have been a comic book series. We leaned almost nothing. They made the creatures goofy video game enemies
This movie was disappointing, so many possibilities and this is the best they could come up with? What a shame
Yes I agree, is not believable, in a couple of hours everybody knows not to make a sound, I don't know how millions of people.were dead or how they were evacuated in a couple of hours.....there's a lot of plot holes, also I didn't care for some that's on the verge of dying...i didn't agree with the review...nop is a hard pass, the first two movies are great
True tbh they should have dropped this movie first than drop the rest , they left us still confused about the alien and what happen
@@sosarene Everybody knows to not make a sound yet a day or so later they all decided to immediately go en masse in the streets with the loudest shit. Like, how did a guy in the crustiest wheelchair live that long? And it was so dumb how they kept having the creatures go RIGHT UP to people. Like, yeah, they can't see but surely they could feel someone profusely BREATHING on them 0.0001 cm away from them?!
@@sosareneIt's pretty obvious when you're being hunted by an predator that making sound is a detriment to you, it's just logical. Plus the helicopters went around with speakers telling any survivors who for whatever reason didn't know, that they're attracted by sound.
Finally, someone speaking the truth!
So fun fact This film was made for a 1/3 the Budget of the Acolyte 65m
It wouldn't have if they put all this other suggested bullshit. That's why Acolyte and big blockbuster trash for 200 million exsist.
Is nobody going to mention that they were a lot louder in this movie, from walking and running to whispering. The first one they walked on sand. I this one I heard footsteps the whole time.
By the rules of the first movie, everyone in both the sequel and the prequel would be dead. The rules in this world are extremely inconsistent and it took me out completely.
I mean the name of the movie is Day One, so why would they be doing any of that already? The first Quiet Place movie takes place way after this one.
@@youngrootv we don't mean that they aren't taking precaution. We mean that by the rules of the first movie, everyone in this movie would be dead by the 10 minute mark.
Did the director think Day one is set in 2001? She has an iPOD? And nobody has smart phones? Stores have iPod charging speakers in 2020?
I thought the cat was good. Every cat is different. There are plenty of cats like that. Especially cats that free feed.
Sorry but that logic does not apply in Texas buddy…! If you know anything about Texas kitty cats? You know one thangs that’s for sure! You know that that Texas heat, mixed with that kitty cat fur gives them a different definition to the words (hot and bothered.) 😾😼
@@Soccerloumike you dumb or stupid?
I had the luck that my theatre audience was ultra quiet. And it was in IMAX
That's maybe because it was almost empty.
@@nuclearwinter391Burn
I was the one screaming girlishly.
@nuclearwinter391 was pretty full, actually. I believe dutch movie theatres are pretty well visited compared to American theatres
@@A_RUclips_Commenter you! 🤣🤣
Biggest complaint of the second one was they didn’t expand on the aliens. They didn’t do the same for this one. A repeat of the past two movies. Fail
what are you talking about? what about the nest scene? with the purple goo?
What else do you need from the aliens side, they're Aliens and they wipe out humanity before they could be studied
@@maxo8917 ye it was there but I wanted a lil more with it ngl. I enjoyed the movie though.
@@maxo8917 dumb excuse. We sat through this movie for a 30 second scenes? Lol
I have a theory that an entire Djimon Hounsou storyline got cut from this movie. His character is entirely superfluous and serves almost no purpose. Essentially, just a cameo.
Aside from that, this movie was just okay. It reminds me of Civil War. It's really just a character drama set in the Quiet Place universe. You not gonna get much on what's happening or what's going on with the aliens or any kind of lore-building or interesting details about the invasion. You're really just here for 2 people getting to know each other in silence.
His character was just there to tie in with the 2nd movie wasnt it? Since he appeared on the survivor’s island and subsequently died.
Have people forgotten his main focus is in A Quiet Place Part 2? I think you along with the Angey Joe guys need to rewatch that movie.
He serves his purpose which was to tie in the other movies.
@@MsFated Like I said, a cameo.
He was meant to be a cameo just to tie in with Part Two. Which he had a bigger role.
My Dune 2 experience was ruined by 2 freaking teenage girls that arrived 20 minutes into the movie, sat next to me and squeaked whenever Timothy Chalamet said anything.
They were just cosplaying Stilgar.
you ran into stan twitter irl lmao
dune 2 was so bad don’t worry. best part about it was the visuals. writing and character development was bottom of the barrel type of stuff
@@plutodestroyer12disagree
@@baizuo_6246 there’s no much bad stuff to criticize about that film id long to write about it but i feel like people are so blinded by the visually and story telling they don’t see how awful some of the things i mentioned prior are. also zendaya’s character is nothing more than a high school love drama and she pouted when she didn’t get her man all to herself and not realizing a little romance wasn’t bigger then her ‘bf’s’ entire legacy and the millions that looked up to him as a god/leader. the whole love interest was nonsense.
"A Quiet Place Day 1 But Really Day 28"
That cut to black was such a shitty cop out.
The first movie was okay but I had to turn my brain off.
Wouldn't a white noise machine be like a flashbang to these things? What about an actual flashbang? What about one of those sonic crowd suppression weapons?
I'm about 100% sure I could make these things' brains explode.
Agreed, the premise is so ridiculous from the start.
Yeah that bothered me as well, we're pretty much capable of producing not only loud sounds but high frequency(flashbangs are already agonizing for our senses)
I really wanna see one of these movies with the main character having uncontrollable flatulence.
@@purefoldnz3070 😆😆😆
Exactly! In this movie when they are all following the helicopters. I'm like shit draw them all to one spot and unload on em!!!
Alex's face when Joe says "making a mogol out of an ant hill" 😂😂😂
That can happen on ski slopes 😂😂😂
And when AJ brought up his hawk tuah on popcorn 😅😅😅😂
@@M0RGAT0RYzzooooooooommmmeerrrrrr
This movie was a 2/10 max and I wanna know how much they’re paying you. It was boring and they didn’t do anything new. They tried to save the movie with a cat, le reddit pizza humor, and a terminally ill character that you DO NOT CARE ABOUT. They tried to redeem the movie by manipulating your emotions but it doesn’t work unless you’re a smooth brained viewer.
They kinda gave away they didn’t like it in the spoiler section. I think they hyped it up in the beginning cuz of the large portion of their audience that’s very sappy. This move was a great concept with terrible execution. I think they didn’t want blowback over a movie that will be forgotten in 2 months.
@@Stevo0929 Yeah, you’re probably right. All signs pointed to them not liking the movie.
The part where everyone was walking in a herd like sheep was definitely supposed to symbolize something since Lupita Nyong’o was walking opposite of them like a lone wolf
I really liked this movie. My screening was somewhat empty which added to the experience.
Same. Had Friday off an saw a nice early matinee. Only 7 of us in the entire IMAX theatre. Best way to watch a movie.
My theater was quiet during the parts of the film that were quiet. But as soon as there was any noise within the film, people starting talking and/or loudly whispering to make up for not doing so during the quiet portions of the film as if this was ok. This definitely tarnished the experience for me
This movie was TERRIBLE, the first half is decent but no actual invasion and completely bloodless, huge disappointment.
Cloverfield is WAYYY better 🗣️💯
Cloverfield was great when I was twelve.
It annoyed me how so much of this movie didn't understand how things in the movie should actually work, and that so many things that could establish some "rules" happened off screen, and so we just have to go with it. People just figured out to stay silent in a matter of hours just 'cause. If the escape was at the Seaport, why wasn't the military setting up noisemakers uptown in, oh say... Harlem? Or along the East or Hudson River and taking shots from boats? A walking trip from Chinatown to Harlem took 3 days just 'cause they had to tread carefully to avoid aliens, but we never saw them have to do that once. The cat was so incredibly quiet just 'cause. The bridges were blown, but we hear nothing about the tunnels in and out of Manhattan just 'cause. Cancer meds could only be found at the one pharmacy, even though Manhattan has a RIDICULOUS number of pharmacies on every block.
Sounds like it should be 5 but y'all give it 7 after all those negatives
It's a 5 for sure
They always give ratings like this above 5 even if in reality, it's mid.
they went soft on this one for sure. a 7 is a passable , spend money on it type of grade.
Absolutely!
I think it was a 3. The second one was a 5....
They couldn't show too much military stuff because the military would easily mash these stupid aliens, it's just ridiculous how lame these bad-guys are
Yes the military will be able to harm creatures that literally fell from meteors without a scratch.
It’s not like it didn’t show the only way you could kill them in the first 2 movies right?
@@mohsaic3489 Google an Apache Gunship and tell me what you think after watching what those attack helicopters are capable of.
Did you forget the busted up tank? These aliens are ridiculously strong and durable.
@@pain2573 They could literally play loud speakers on helicopters to lure the majority of them in each city to an area to get missile striked to death or do two massive waves to go and get nuked at each coastline.
This movie looked so good and was so easy to make good and story so easy to tell apocalypse story and started so good
But this was horrible after the 1st 20 minutes and pizza starts...
Don't bother save your money sadly
Watch at home in the dark on subscription service not worth $50 at the theater
Also some people in comments thinking to deep about it. She is dying of cancer and wants a last meal at her favorite pizza place its her dying wish that's it. So she goes to get it she'll die of cancer or the monsters she doesn't care anymore. She didn't force for him to tag along but after she got her final wish sort of she helped him to escape. She was going to pass quicker anyway because she has no more meds and suffering in pain.
It was her family's place
Alex Wolffs character was pointless
it was all pointless. I was so hopeful but could've walked out. And I've only done that twice in my life.
@@keithkong1985Jesus , maybe just stick to anime’s or tv shows , movie was good , lol , check the rotten tomatoes 🍅 they don’t lie
Stop putting kids & animals, in horror movies if they arent gonna get killed off!!! They always get sparred therefore it just becomes sooo predictable and redundant.
How do the aliens know that's where the water is and know not to jump off the bridge?
Yeah the monsters in the second movie didn't know about water and jumped in and drowned. So this movie kind of breaks the second film, because apparently the aliens were smarter and aware of their vulnerability to water on day one, than they were on Day 474 when the ending of part II took place.
They pulled a "bait & switch" with the trailer 😢
Just streamed it at home. Dodged a bullet by not seeing this turd in the theater. I would have been so mad walking out of that place.
There was nothing good about this movie. It’s wild hearing people who review content for a living compliment this.
I found it disappointing because like you guys I was hoping for more of a military perspective. Plus it is quite strange how they learn quickly about sound and water and somehow they didn’t roll in the gunships like you said and then be able to wipe them out before the seemingly world domination since x amount of days pass with them still controlling the land.
Where to begin? Our lead character is introduced, and oh boy, she's a real gem. By gem, I mean she openly declares she's unpleasant. Fantastic! Nothing like spending 100 minutes trying to muster some care for a self-proclaimed jerk. Then, we meet another character who sets new standards for annoyance. But hey, they had a cat. That was a nice touch. A cat that never makes a noise. Never knocks anything over or gets scared, goes swimming with you in city sewers and when it runs off when the city is being destroyed it magically finds its owner, over and over again. Ya know, just like cats in real life?
The cat got scared multiple times during the movie, wdym? I have a cat, she never knocks shit over, she doesn't meow around. Now take into account that it's a service animal that's obviously been trained to be well behaved.
I do agree however that plunging that cat into water multiple times is very unrealistic lmao. But the rest of what you said is nonsense
Well the cat is supposed to be an emotional support animal, so it is supposed to be trained. And it was attracted to eric because of the panic attacks, the cat knows he needs help, but yea it's super unrealistic lol
I fell asleep. It was nice, quiet and cool. On that recliner I was so comfortable I slept like a baby.
Movie was ass! SLow CrAwl! Its the 3rd movie, being ambigous about the monsters at this point is so boring. Waiting for someone to die sucks
It makes sense. We already know the threat. Let’s get to know some great characters trying to survive in the big city
@@CemoreNetwork finding out the lady had a dad that played piano just doesnt cut it for me. this shouldve been a show, cuz it has all the bloating of a show. in my opinion, i know people loved this but i found it more Intresting the first one when they had figure shit out. i wanted to know more about the threat. i know that the monsters suppose to be a mistery but its already movie 3. like common and the movie is abysmally short. this was episode one of a series.
Did no one else get upset that she wasnt willing at ALL to give up her DYING life for the guy running on the deck but he was willing to give up his life for HER F CAT! like girl i would have loved you if you gave your life for him to survive!
Not gonna lie I thought yall would tear this movie apart because I want my fucking money back , it’s like the characters literally did everything to die and plot said “ nah bro I gotchu “
They are desperate for things to enjoy. The bar is SUPER low.
I haven't seen it but I get what you're saying just based on the fact that is very common in fiction in general.
The term plot armor is commonly known for sure.
But that alone isn't an innately bad thing. Execution and context is everything.
There would be a lot of very short stories where the people died quickly or very boring stories where they don't do anything to get into dangerous situations.
I'm not dismissing your opinion just kind of thinking out loud about that kind of thing in general.
It most definitely can come off really dumb or end up making dangerous situations LESS exciting. That's where R.R. Martin really hit the nail on the head with the books and setting up danger in the first book which allows there to be fear during danger while still letting main characters survive.
@@glowyrm nooo this is a lot worse than the norm when you go watch count how many “ they should’ve been dead “ with the main characters
It was a good moviel. Not exceptional, but good
If you are walking into a movie to find things not to like you’re gonna find them.
i would really like to know why the aliens are there.
They still can't provide an adequate explanation why our weapons and militaries don't just wipe the monsters out. I think that's why they never concentrate on military action, because it would be absolute idiocy.
Because the military would get overwhelmed with the amount of creatures involved, I'd imagine, and in the end, they'd have to resort to nuking entire cities to try to contain them.
Yeah, they did engage the Aliens, and once the evacuation was complete they probably would have.
Easy answers, too fast to hit, armor too durable to penetrate. Even if something like a 50 Cal could, the odds of hitting the thing are almost 0. And at that point, even if you connected, you’ve DEFINITELY alerted every other creature in that vicinity which opens you up to being overwhelmed. And all of this assuming you’re able to make a coordinated plan silently to get the drop on these creatures before they notice you.
@@LordLOCno. They wouldn't. A couple helicopters would wipe these out
@@grilledleeks6514 Have you seen the movies? A couple Apache's or more advanced choppers would get obliterated by these things. Go watch World War Z, it'd be similar to that. Overwhelmed and not enough firepower.
Problems with Quiet Place: Day One
1. Never expands or explains why the Aliens vist
2. 10 min. of mediocre massacre and then the rest of the movie is just a rewatch of quiet place 2.
3. Boring
This movie was terrible, absolute TRASH. Do not waste your money on this one, it's nothing like the original. There's so much wrong with this movie that I don’t even know where to begin. The main issue is the writing, it SUCKS, I mean why wouldn’t they explore the alien side of things, like what are they, where do they come from, and how were they able to overwhelm the most powerful military on the planet??? Nope, instead we got a movie about a cat and some pizza...GTFOH, horrible choices for actors as well, they made the guy into a whiny, crybaby while the woman was the strong, empowered hero! Collectively, we’re all sick of that!
One last thing, New Yorkers are armed up to the teeth, people would not be hiding like cowards while their loved ones, friends and neighbors are getting slaughtered, we would have fought back with everything we got, that's the movie I wanted to see, how we fight back and still loose!
This was one of the worse movies I have ever seen...HOT GARBAGE!
I live in a 3rd world so we just torrent it. It's not even worth torrenting.
I just started this movie and I'm already having problems with it. After the first scene with the aliens, she wakes up and everyone just knows what's going on. I guess the radio maybe told them but that "reveal" was a let down. The guy tried to turn off the generator, why turn it off? It already went loud, just stay the fuck away from it. Then all the people in a huge crowd like that....? No WAY I would join that crowd. You're just asking to die, if you lived long enough to still be alive then you'd know not to walk with a shuffling, coughing, heat score of a mob.... there were thousands of people walking together. I actually winced when a guy for no reason grabs her leg while she's under the car then screams for her to help him. That makes no sense, just crawl under with her and be quiet.
If the shows series was set in medieval times I would be able to believe this could happen and I think it would have been a little scarier.
I was actually thinking that exact thing. How many medieval alien invasion stories have we even gotten anyway? Seems like an untapped well.
@@powerhouse6165 Dudes invent the trebuchet and think they are on the cutting edge then these things show up. 💀
My cat rarely ever meow or hissed. If she did it was because she was in trouble or upset which was rare. So I found it believable that her cat made no vocal sounds. People who have taken care of different types of cats understand this
They should’ve linked clover field to quiet place
There are a million reasons why these movies don't make sense. The baby not crying as a baby would in the previous was even more unbelievable than the cat scenario. There are so many people who snore and don't even realize it. The list of logistical reasons why these films are dumb is a mountain high.
I was out at movie 2
It's a stupid concept and not interesting
Aw poor thing
the first movie did a great job. the second lost it's way... this third instalment, is an absolute dumpster fire
Yeah I think first was meh/overrated, second was not good, 3rd might be the best but I will never know.
No need to fear Timestamp guy is here
Start: 0:00
End: 46:26
movie screening was packed (I had low expectations) and I fell asleep for 30 minutes!!! I woke up to them singing in mime in a bar, and yet I still knew what the (anti)-climax was building up to... other people were also yawning, and because its a "quiet" movie, I could hear them. it was hilarious 😂 nothing happens, then the predictable happens... CRAP
I was super, super, super lucky with my movie crowd. Almost immediately everyone realized rustling through food packaging and what not was too disruptive and it was dead quiet the rest of the way.
The girl didn't join the boat because she's dead. There's no medicine left, so she would only suffer in pain till she dies.
The stupidest thing about the quiet place franchise is why would u have the toddler walking in the back
I really liked the movie and had very little to no issues. It was quick and fun!
The movie should have been from the military's perspective. All out alien warfare. The first one was great, but if these things can't fly or swim then not only do we need the explanation of how they could ever take over the planet like that but it just would have been 1000% more entertaining than watching a dying lady try to get pizza.
Forget Rocket money. Listen to Margret’s web by black sheep shepherds. Best song you’ve never heard yet
I forgot this was actually even a thing
i didn't even know this was a thing coming out
@@nickwash3r3 there was like no marketing for it. I think I saw a trailer before I went to see Furiosa and that was the first I heard of it and then immediately forgot about it again
The movie I want to see is the cat used as a narrative vehicle; and we just follow the cat as it runs from group to group of people and doing something to get them eaten by the aliens. Maybe the first group it bats something off a table, the second group feeds it late in the morning and it meows - and after each time the aliens are summoned the kitty just runs off and gets away - off to find it's next group of people to bring the aliens towards!
The aliens realize this, and end up worshiping the cats as the Ancient Egyptians did.
A 7 across the board is far too generous a score based on y’all’s specific critiques, which were spot on. Thought you guys were gonna go with a 5. That would’ve lined up better with you guys’ point by point evaluations.
7 is actually so generous, it's upsetting. this movie is a 3/10 at best... I do agree, they're not consistent with their scoring and critiques
@@MaticulousGamer right?
@@positronichypersonic4928 yeah, it's partly why I unsubscribed. That, amongst other things... the constant interruptions when the others are giving their views was also difficult to sit through, consistently
@@MaticulousGamer I see. I only occasionally watch him.
@@positronichypersonic4928 yeah, same... some of his takes are okay
All i can say is I was really disappointed when i left the theatre. 💔👎
You can't subtract points because of your poor personal theatre experience. This doesn't affect the quality of the film, for everyone else..
People keep saying, "Cats would never be that quiet!" To that, is say, have you ever seen a scared cat before? I have a cat who is normally very loud, you can always hear her running throughout the house. But whenever it storms, she'll run in hide and you won't be able to find her for hours after the storm ends. Cats have survival instincts the same as anything else.
Well your cat isn't being chased by aliens now is it? I don't care how trained an animal is, if a big ass alien walks by the cat is freaking out. The cat ruined the immersion of the movie
How the Aliens know about the river? Wouldn’t they just jump off the pier?
Maybe some did
A buddy and I were having this same conversation. Perhaps bodies of water reflect differently with their echo location and doesn’t reflect back like the other solid things around them. Maybe looks like a void that they know they should avoid. I wish we could’ve have seen that realization at the river as ppl were loading boats, and not broadcasted over a helicopter and shown in 1 scene. Surely there has to be a Learning curve for the aliens to know that swimming doesn’t work for them.
Yeah water and rain don't make any noise. I guess if one jumps in not all were going to jump in
@@JpmshizzleI'm sure it LOOKS like a void to Aliens that have no vision.
They make clicking sounds. They have some form of echo location. They aren't just mindless creatures, they obviously have some form of intelligence.
Water interacts with sound differently compared to physical objects. The only thing that's bullshit, is if they have echo location, why can't they sense humans that are right infront of their face. That's the real plot hole.
The aliens knowing where water is, is easily explainable lol.
I spent most of my time during this film in deep contemplating of the difference between:
1: The noises the Aliens hate, verses
2: The noises of the natural Environment, , verses
3: The noises the Aliens make
Watch Kalki 2898 AD
(I know they'll not watch it)
అలాగే ఈ పూకుగాళ్ళు చూసినా కూడా వీళ్ళకి ఏం అర్ధం కాదు
After three movies I’m just tryna learn more about the creatures motives and origin. I felt the fungal nest breeding ground shit didn’t get talked about enough. Too many unanswered questions
I usually agree with your reviews, i went yesterday to see the movie....man is a very very dumb movie, is not a good movie, i had a lot of great expectations and was a big letdown .....it was better choice to do it in a very little town instead of a big city with millions of people....didnt like a bit
To your point about “people don’t act that dumb in real life” as someone who works retail and food, yes people are indeed that stupid in real life lmao
4:38 so far what I'm hearing is: "it wasn't _good,_ but it *didn't* piss me off."
I bought this when it was released digitally. I was pretty disappointed they cheesed out the "massacre phase" kind of aspect of a day one. I hate that they had Sam knockout and did a stupid time jump, and when she comes to, everyone knows to be quiet.
Fear the Walking Dead missed this opportunity too. I wanted to see a whole shit ton of random attacks at different parts of the city, random people being massacred, the military being overrun and torn apart.
Both of these films dropped the ball on that part, and that was a big part I was looking forward to for "prequel" movies.
AJ does not check his sponsors anymore. Fuck this shit, I’m out.
We’ll miss you m8
@@fpkonly thanks buddy
Out? Lmao for that?
No one cares lol
So what
This movie was a huge disappointment they exchanged jumpscares with loud noise in place of actual suspense built up by the story in the situations. On day one we should have been seeing the military fighting the aliens , we got none of that. What we got is one woman's story of walking halfway across town to get a slice of f****** Pizza, stupid Primus and bad writing. Also why was this movie so damn dark, why was there so much smoke, why were most of the scenes at night and why was every window covered with mud?? Bad movie , I warned all my friends to leave this alone
Dang Angry joe show really recommended companies that steal your info then complain in the news videos not to do that . Hypocrites
I liked it but wanted more the-world-is-collapsing mayhem. So many apocalyptic movies focus on the aftermath, and I want to see more of how it all goes down at the beginning. Certainly, that would involve more special effects and a higher budget, though.
What a letdown of a movie, compared to the other 2, this woulda been great if they did multiple character stories explaining the story, but no just 2 hours of nothing
Why does everyone defend/ love A Quiet Place? I pitched watching it ata family reunion, and we all were mocking it/ laughing our asses off at how bad it was
Movie was brutality boring, first movie I legit fell asleep durring at the theaters.
Why did you bother with this one then 😂
See a doctor. You might be diabetic.
@Huda88754 saw the 1st 2 movies and I liked them enough to get the 4k steelbooks, but this one was bad imo
They should have ended on her playing piano like her dad used to! It would've been much, much better than just playing a song on the portable stereo.
a 7 is crazy. they just loved that cat and its the main reason they gave it a 7.
Wouldn't these creatures need to use eco location of sorts to navigate terrains if not they would just run into buildings and walls all the time they clearly know where objects are. So How would they not notice people moving around them even if they aren't making sound?
You guys really missed the mark on this one. Movie is a 5/10, mostly because of visuals.
You have soo many complaints.
This is NOT "A Quiet Place: Day One"
This is just "A Quiet Place: Day 5 (with another sneak peak at day One!)"
What's the plot of this movie? Pizza.
Who's the main character of this movie? Kitty cat.
I was exceptecting them to shit on this one. But with their audience I can see why they didn’t. Didn’t wanna deal with the bs. Great concept bad execution. This movie was not good. I went into this one extremely hyped.
The worst block buster movie I've seen this year.
Remove the monsters, and you got a woke hobo Titanic movie on your hands.
Idk about woke. Sam just happens to be black, that's about it. And there's no romance in the film, the two just bond through trauma. That being said, yeah it was pretty bad.
@jase276 part racially, but more woke on other grounds, including entitlement and giving a free pass to the boo-hoo mindset.
Even that's not an issue, if it were Picket Fences - the Movie, not a horror movie that movie-goers come to watch for the thrills and suspense.
Watch Quiet Place 1 & 2 again, and you'll understand.
but there was a black man in A Quiet Place 2
THIS HAD TO BE AN ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY FOR A NINJA TURTLE PROJECT "LAST SLICE AWAY"
All cats are selfish, cat lover or not this movie was dumb real rating is like 4/10 lol writers nowadays suck
Idk man I've had some cool ass cats. Not gonna say this cat was 100% cat accurate but I've had some cool cats
She strong woman, he weak man the end
I loved Quiet Place 1 and 2. The only reason Im not seeing this one is because it's a prequel, and I don't really care about prequels. I'm just waiting for a quiet place, part 3, the true sequel to Quiet place and part 2.
Lol this is the dumbest thing I've read today
@@jovendiego2270 how is it dumb?
@@jovendiego2270Same here lol
I understand your opinion my man.
I know many people don’t like movies that are prequels to the 1st & the 2nd. But it wouldn’t hurt to do some world building and storytelling to the series universe of “A Quiet Place” of a dark setting where humanity was almost wiped out from making a single noise.
TRUUUUE. I don't hate prequels but with prequels you gotta be so safe and careful making the story that it just doesn't leave room for stakes or surprises.
If your cat is knocking things off, they are bored from being cooped up inside all the time. Let your cat outside into a fenced area if you can, harness leash-adapt them if you can't.
Or just let them be cats 😂 harness training? I leave that to my ravaging kids and no, cats are NOT in house animals to begin with
@@Rizingzon Mine is. Been harness trained since I got her. Harness = outside to her, and she's never deliberately knocked over a single thing.
Look up "zoochosis" and realize that there is nothing that says it can't affect pets.
3:33 you guys have waiters in theatres??
EDIT: 6:48 OMG IM EXACTLY LIKE OJ LMAO
at the Emagine theater they have ppl come while the films being played to take your order.
There's a lot of fancy theaters that you can order food and drinks, Alamo Drafthouse is the most famous
@@denjiurameshi4699 I see, if you sit in the middle of the theatre wouldn’t that annoy other people lol
@@Ryukachoo thanks for the info! I’ve never been to ones like those :0
What a horrible concept, I would not want some fuck head ruining the movie experience by constantly going to every fucking person asking if they want overpriced garbage. No wonder theaters are dying, and good riddance.