Which is Nerdier: Star Wars or Star Trek?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- May the force help you live long and prosper.
Support CollegeHumor by signing up for DROPOUT: signup.dropout.tv. Tons of exclusive content, ad-free, for only $5 a month (that's like 17 cents a day).
CAST
Captain Picard - Sam Reich
Darth Vader - Mike Trapp
Geordi LaForge - Brian Murphy
Data - Evan Watkins
Worf - Evan Watkins
CREW
Writer - Brian Murphy
Producer - Sam Kirkpatrick
Animators - Lindsay and Alex Small-Butera
Sound Design - Tamara Johnson
Post-Production Supervisor - Evan Watkins
Post-Production Manager - Andrew Mallonee
Post-Production Coordinator - Cory McConnell 
Приколы
StarsWars: GEEKS!
StarTrek: NERDS!
Warhammer40k: *Laughs while painting plastic miniatures
Lmfaooo underrated comment
@Polarisque the lore is too over the top that nobody take it seriously anymore
More like Laugh while sipping paint water.
"Brother we must slay these heretics""
@Polarisque people like 40k because its not same as the other sci-fi.
Its the opposite to the refined tastes of star wars and star trek and others.
There is a reason why my sci-fi is slightly modeled after 40k instead of the other ones
“Star Wars is like philosophy for children!”
Vader: *_remembers that day at mustafar_*
"Don't play with fire or it will burn you."
I learned that lesson as a kid, Anikan never did.
ik how is Star Wars for children? You see a character burn alive! That shit would freak me out if I was a kid!
@@thebobrossappreciationcent8414 he said the philosophy in it
“philosophy for children”
Children, ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Well, the children kinda aren’t...
I am a cat person I mean they are probably AHEAD in philosophy classes
I love how Riker is doing the leg thing.
it's the first half of the Riker maneuver. ;-)
@@ledekou1983 it IS the riker maneuver
@@Ice-je8cd No the full Riker is only when he swings his leg over you and the chair. I was always waiting for him to do it with Data, but sadly the day never came.
I didn't understand that til you said it, but you're right! He has a leg up all the time
The reason for that is because the actor used to move furniture before he was an actor, and hurt his back.
Worf writing Vader a love letter after getting thrown through the wall is just too good
Doesn't Klingon mating involve the woman throwing things and the man reading poetry (and ducking)?
"Oh, so you have to be _magic_ then?"
*_Q enters_*
*condescending picard voice* "But Q isn't *magic,* his scientific knowledge is just far superior to ours, making it *seem* like magic!"
That part cracked me up
Yeah, technology can eventually be so advanced that it will be indistinguishable from magic.
@@Astrobaut Magic is just science we don't understand yet, literally.
Theres a whole anime that's based off of this system and its fascinating.
John Sandiego which one? The name?
I love how Picard is like, "We have plenty of action"
And then Data asks him about attending his poetry reading. It is so accurate!
Yes. We saw the video.
@Kainos Teleos Thanks, Captain Obvious.
Featuring Spot*
@@ananousous 😂
Accept Data doesn't like poetry, he prefers Opera.
Riker constantly trying to prop his leg up on something is hilarious.
Alpha Male gonad displays.
Interesting fact, Johnathan Frakes had a back injury and proping his leg up released the pressure on his back.
@@StarTrek4Life Well, it has the effect of making him look really cool on the show. So there’s that at least.
I searched for this comment.
Wasn't disappointed
@@StarTrek4Life its an iconic part of the character, sort of like Kirk's style of talking wasn't on purpose either.
“Oh, so you have to have MAGIC, then? That’s dumb.”
Q Continuum: Are we jokes to you?
More like Q Continuum: "Um, actually, WE are science too. Very, very advanced science. Indistinguishable from magic, but *completely* different."
Picard: ".....Just... please... shut up."
@@jessiehogue. If I am not mistaken harder SciFi tend to have stricter rules regarding psionics in-universe.
@@explosivemodesonicmauricet1597 Stricter rules compared to what?
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic
@@davidtaylor4284 Well... yes. That's kind of the joke here.
"Be nice to Data and don't be racist to aliens"
I'm rewatching TNG, and it seems like Vader knows all the answers.
invictus127 except he doesn’t. Star Trek rarely depicts racism. Ignore Kirk. There’s really no racism in Star Trek. TNG especially lacks racism.
Besides Vader doesn’t know the answer of why he still serves Palpatine when Padmé is dead, Palpatine is always trying to replace him, and Palpatine is obviously behind everything bad in their galaxy.
Be nice to data
*Warhammer 40k Joined the chat*
Vader forgot about the part about killing off anyone wearing red that's not important to the plot. Or is that more OS Than TNG?
"im a sith lord and you're a bald guy in pajamas"
Jeez the amount of people correcting me on which "you're" to use is ridiculous
You will be assimilated
And those pajamas are now the Walmart attire 😂
What's say star wars?
*you’re
You have a double ganger
Hmmm yes and I'm a tyrannical dictator of the USSR I defeated the NAZI German empire and the imperial Japanese empire single handedly.
"Your special effects are laaaaaame!"
"That's not the point!"
"Yes it iiiiis!"
Perfect ending. XD
The fun part is that ILM made the special effects for both.
best ending!
RevanBladeZ
It's right with irony
IKR
The irony is that Stat Wars have really lame special effect, at least episodes 4-6 you know the "good ones"
As a Trekkie I can confirm that we are nerdy and proud of it
sir, your username is amazing
and then there is you username...... Star wars fans are not nerdy
You're goddamn right! - wait...wrong franchise.
And atleast our science is based in fact
Check the comments under videos of both franchisees to see which fans are smarter
Bald guy in Pijamas?
Snoke: allow me to introduce myself!
XD
Kylo: (turns on lightsaber)
Snoke:Aight, Imma head out.
Snoke. Well, that’s Disney’s sequel trilogy crap.
@Robert Ortiz-Wilson because this was in my recommended and i just realized this predicted snoke... and also the snoke/helmet joke was stolen from space balls. Disney has no soul
We don't speak of the odd numbers Star Trek movies OR the Star Wars trilogy made by Disney.
Patrick Stewart would DEFINITELY go to Data's poetry reading.
Everyone should be nice to Data!
Said I had to mess up my favourite number to like this comment.
ofc
A robots original poetry? I’d be curious
They all went. It was episode S013-88.
Star Trek is older therefore it is nerdier to like it
commodore256 Yeah but Doctor Who ran for a very long time. The latest episode of Doctor Who is more recent than the latest of Star Trek
Dubstep From God You know Dr.Who is older than star trek right?
star trek and doctor who are both nerdy as fuck
Dubstep From God Being older doesnt make it nerdier :3 What makes it nerdier is the actual info of it >.>
Alphabetical Nugget I watch none of them, i am just unsure if he knows
Oddly enough, both Picard and Vader are accomplished swordsmen.
Right but honestly there is absolutely no comparison between the two
@@12thstreetrag well, if we go there... Vader loses because lightsaber combat is a choreographed dance... Fencing is a martial art and a sport. That said, the Episode 4 fight with Kenobi is realistic, and so is 5 for the most part.
However, I'm willing to let Vader's skill rest on the context of his universe.
@@Mephilis78 Episode 4 fight is not realistic. It's just 2 old men waving sticks around. Vader's actor lied about having knowledge about swordfighting and it shows. That's why they got someone else for the sword scenes from episode 5 onwards.
@@nearlydead7510 you're lying about having knowledge. Because you don't know what real fencing looks like. Go look up a foil or epee match, right now. Real swords fights don't look anything like stage fights. No flips no spins, no wide telegraphed movements. Because that's how you die.
and neither one is from Nottingham
I like both, but star trek is definitely nerdier.
+King Duck I am here to protect you!
+King Duck it is the nerdiest show iv seen with their fancy words
+King Duck Was, now they are made pretty much the same.
+King Duck i mean, do they not both lie within the nerd realm?
(i know that sentence does)
+King Duck not disagreeing with you, agreeing that they are both nerdy, and are good
Star wars is like marvel
The movies aren't nerdy since almost everyone has seen one
But if you go into the extended universe than that's nerdy
bobbelonie I wouldn't say 'reduce' to the nerd level. I would say 'increase' to the nerd level
bobbelonie oh my god. It's so hard to imagine a star wars fan never having heard of our lord Vader. It brings genuine tears to my eyes.
That explains it nicely. Like, it only becomes nerdy when you start talking about the comics.
TV shows and games don’t count as nerdy either.
No man or woman should ever compare Star Wars to marvel.
let's not forget to mention, Spock's hair. Star Trek is definitely nerdier.
who is spock
@@a-aron691 the bowl cut guy.
well ... he is an alien... at least he didn't have to glue something on his nose every show, just the ears.
@@Sujiceel Spock wasn't even included because they used the next generation instead of original
a-a ron Spock is the best friend and First Officer of Captain James .T. Kirk. Spock is half Vulcan and half Human, but because of the strong emotions associated with his Vulcan half, he suppresses them. He may have a bowl cut hairstyle and pointy ears, but I think it’s cute. I don’t mind it. I kinda like it. 🖖
Picard should've Said
"At least my son doesn't kiss his own sister."
How does this only have 3 likes?
Vader: At least I have children.
You should reverse that.
PIcard probably would've had jokes about the Sequels, which would've made it even funnier
@@berniethekiwidragon4382 ST:Pic S3E2: I will end this man whole career
D&D fans: Let’s lay low.
I'll come over later with my pirated Stranger Things videos...lol
kris helfferich God Stranger Things sucks ass. It can’t even do D&D convincingly. Gravity Falls did D&D better than stranger things.
Also modern day D&D fandom sucks ass and I sincerely long for the old /tg/
Buy the old AD&D sets, and books. They even have one exploring a crashed space ship. "Expedition to the Barrier Peaks" written by Gary Gygax.
Regular show was the most hilarious parody of D&D with the realm of darthon. "Do we have a protractor?"
D&D fans vs Warhammer 40k fans
This was well-written. Surprisingly balanced, too, showing pros and cons on both. Nice job, guys.
cWg Studios 212
Finally a comment which is actually a comment.
Schazmen Rassir I know, right?
More subs than T-gay but less subs than PewDiePie yes!
Thanos: "Perfectly balanced... as everything else should be."
Geek: May the force be with you
Nerd: May the force be equal to mass times acceleration
This is the difference
Human vs Data
Other way around
Natalie Huang wait I thought he was just a super technical alien person mmm the more you know (I haven’t seen a lot of Star Trek FYI. Although I do like the idea just can’t get into the tv show, I like the movies though)
Oof, I do both. What does that make me?
@100 mil subs without vids 😂
Forget Riker's leg - Worf writing Vader a nerdy love letter was the best.
Great posing on the characters throughout the whole sketch.
Vader's chest panel looks like a Nintendo controller.
star wars was made before keep at home consoles ever existed, so would you say that nintendo controlers were inspired by darthvader's chest?
I'm talking about how his chest panel is depicted specifically in the cartoon above.
How it going DR Shaym fancy seeing you here
Dr Shaym because it's the NES Controller
I didn't know someone could be fluent in Obvious...
1:37 Be nice to Data and don't be racist to aliens. There, I solved Star Trek.
It's far more complicated than your dark side/light side nonsense! Star Wars is like philosophy for children!
+CatMaster90001 Yeah, sorry. We have to keep it simple to you know, move the plot along and have some action.
TheManicGamer Star Trek has plenty of action!! _Captain, will you be attending my poetry reading later?_ God, Data, seriously...
+CatMaster90001 the only strong Star Trek character gets his ass kicked all the time
Eve c Worf: ENOUGH!! I won't sit here any longer and be insulted!
Can...can we get a version actually voiced by Patrick Stewart and James Earl Jones? Cuz that would be legendary...
Time for a new Uber Eats commercial!
you saw the animation right? do you think they have that kinda budget? dropout, college humors streaming service is like $4.00
@@kuritech I mean, they did have Tony Hawk and Giancarlo Esposito on their show. I don't know about Patrick Stewart, but James Earl Jones seems like the kind of guy who would do it just for the fun of it.
@@dunkelfuchs3195 but this would be to record lines for a video they've already done before. It wouldn't be worth the time or effort
Idk sounds like you're trying to pay big name actors in YT exposure to me.
Picard coming out with that flute is such a deep TNG reference. I'm so glad they put that in there, because it shows what true sci-fi fans they are.
More like sci-fi NERDS.
But yes.
"We're so sorry we kidnapped and gaslit you into living a simulated life, here's a neat flute" - Aliens
@@DeusVult838 LOL!! So true.
@@DeusVult838 Did they even say sorry? lol
It's basically Roy: A life well lived from Rick & Morty
"Be nice to Data and don't be racist to aliens, there I've solved Star Trek"
He's right though.
And Star Wars can be summed up with "don't join the dark side". Both have their own complexity, but star wars focus more on action and star trek more on pondering the condition of life and the galaxy. Plenty of people are fans of both, and for good reasons =)
@@Luxai I haven't seen any Star trek series but Star wars really isn't complex , It's the same old dark side vs light side plot over and over again which centers around only one family.
@@karnasingh860 well, The Last Jedi TRIED to move away from the Skywalkers, but the fans threw a hissy fit so Disney made The Rise of Skywalker.
@@_somerandomguyontheinternet_ tried to move away? It practically spat on it
Someone hasnt watched DS9!
"Oh, so you have to be MAGIC then?"
* Q appears in the background *
Yes! I saw that too, I really liked it.
Q is a God, so it really depends on whether or not God is magic.
@@PaperbackWizard
Q isn't a God, he is a being so powerful and intelligent that he just appears godlike to humans.
He is not in all respects omniscient, omnipotent or eternal, thus he doesn't correspond to any of the three main characteristics of God.
And of course, Q's power is magic. He doesn't use technology or something, his species has innate abilities.
@@lars9925 Blasphemy. You're lucky he doesn't cast you out or smite you or something.
@@PaperbackWizard
I bet he doesn't know about me cause he isn't an omniscient god...
Did anybody notice that Vader's life support on his chest is a classic Nintendo Game Controller?
star wars was made before keep at home consoles ever existed, so would you say that nintendo controlers were inspired by darthvader's chest?
I never thought of that, good point
I first started watching TNG during quarantine and that makes this so much funnier now. Riker putting his leg on everything is GOLD!
But do you know the reason why he puts his leg up on everything?
@@Shinzon23 yep
Star Wars is made for children and as a kid growing I could never talk to anyone about Star Trek because they didn’t understand the difference.
1:09 "Oh great! So tell me, what does count, as Star Wars?"
"The Clone Wars cartoon, and the original three movies..."
*aged like a fine wine.*
What do you mean? It aged fairly well all things considered.
@@ninetails6218 Yes, that's exactly what I said. It aged well, because the new movies are also terrible. I said "well, that aged well..."
Yeah it's almost embarrassing being a star wars fan when you see how the fan base reacts.
Tbh, after binging Clone Wars, the prequels really aren't that bad, especially revenge of the sith. Especially compared to the sequels.
The new movies are great the last one was a bit of a let down but the first two were awesome.
The lack of certain sound effects was ... disturbing.
+Antoine Bandele *YOUR SO AWESOME!!!*
gooooooooooooooooooooooood Antoine goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood
LIGHTNING EFFECT!!
Ha ha Darth Antoine
Antoine Bandele 666 likes:0
"I'm a sith lord and you're a bald guy..." Vader, are you forgetting what's under that helmet??🤔🤔
+Mia Childers You're right. He's wearing pajamas with a helmet and a cape.
Also, know who else can use "The Force"? Vulcans, Romulans, and the ever annoying Q!
You didn't include what was said next! It wasn't mostly that he's bald! You are so idiotic! #averageTrekkie
He was burned by lava. What's Picard's excuse?
What, genetics aren't enough for you?
Star Trek is Science Fiction. Star Wars is Science Fantasy. I'd say SciFi is nerdier in general, but nerding out about SciFantasy is nerdier specifically.
Good comment, especially the part about Star Wars being Fantasy in space rather than Science Fiction.
I'm a nerd and I love them both, but star trek is nerdier then star wars.
Where as Star Wars fans are more like geeks.
That, is the same thing...
3Logic geek and nerd is not the same thing
It does n''t get any nerdier than a C3PO and an R2D2. I rest my case.
Exactly, it's nerdier and that's a good thing.
Nerd pride! Not everything has to appeal to everyone.
"Your Special Effects are laaaaaame...!"
-"That´s not the Point!"
"Yes, it iiiiiiiiis...!"
Best Part :D
The yes it iiiiiiiis is the best part
laughed hard that moment 😂
Actually, the corporation that made the special effects in Star Wars also did the special effects for Star Trek.
EscalationTV If you compare the originals, Star Trek is older as it had a 50th anniversary.
and Doctor Who is older than all of y'all.
1st:Star trek is way nerdier.
2nd edit so my comment doesn't have to be larger than the 2nd death star: Star trek is a almost pure science fiction story, star wars is a science fantasy that is about the classic story between good and evil. Star trek is nerdier due to a lot of pseudoscience. Its not bad to be a nerd, it just means you have an interest in something nerdy. Star wars movies aren't nerdy but canon and legends is nerdy but that's ok. And geeks are okay to. If you want to read more, read my book in the comment section about pros and cons of both franchises.
_now lisen here you cliché stereotype movie_
Star Trek is for nerds star wars is for geeks. Im a massive geek
@@azrael2435 _geek_
Well I'm a nerd
No wonder I love star trek so much
They have their own language
this animation is so expressive i still love this all these years later. (and now i can recognize all the voice actors)
Starwars: "You're special affects are laamme."
Startrek: "that not the point!"
Starwars: "Yes it is."
You're goddamned right
Im dieing at that point lol
they're actually the same visual fx company lol
@@Rhyex BUDGET fam BUDGET
@@Rhyex Yeah it's all ILM. And you can tell when it isn't. Insulting the VFX is a self burn on Star Wars.
Star Wars: Action RPG
Star Trek: Traditional RPG
Star trek
Star Wars: Kids movies
Star Trek: After you grow up and get laid
@@amkrause2004 if you watch Star trek you do not get laid.
@@zakl940 Lol. Well I can prove that theory wrong.
@@amkrause2004 you will boldly go where no Star trek fan has gone before!
LOL Couldn't stop cracking up at Riker always needing to put his foot on something.
Same! Haha
or when tori went "Hyaaahhh"
Tarkin and Vader putting their BFF heart pieces together just adds to it, seeing how Vader hated Tarkin.
Question - Which is Nerdier: Star Wars or Star Trek?
Answer - Doctor Who
+Andrew Ford Answer: Halo
Spatan exp
Well, considering Doctor Who has been around for 50+ Years, I think it's safe to say that Doctor Who probably has more of a following and a larger amount of stuff in the established wibbly-wobbly canon.
Andrew Ford Halo has a very large following worldwide probably wider than doctor who, which mainly just the uk. Star wars and star trek probably have a larger following because not everyone is a gamer but star trek is boring in my opinion.
+Christian Garcia That's not at all what he's saying. hes saying that doctor who is the nerdier show, regardless of how long its been around.
Christian Garcia
I never stated that Doctor Who was more popular than Star Trek or Star Wars, as I was replying to Spartan exp's comment, who explicitly mentioned Halo. Although, to be fair, Doctor Who has an expanded universe of it's own that is quite large. Not quite the same as Star Trek's or Star Wars', but it's unquestionably bigger than Halo's. As for it's following, Doctor Who isn't just big in the U.K it's massive in the U.S, Australia, New Zealand, several European Countries and it's slowly beginning to take other nations by storm. It's been the No.1 downloaded series on the Australian Broadcasting Corporation's iView player for the past several years, the most watched program on BBC America and has the Guinness World Record for the largest ever simulcast of a TV drama, after the 50th Anniversary special was broadcast in 94 countries across 6 continents.
As for you statement Spartan exp, I think that you're out of your depth when it comes to Doctor Who's involvement outside the UK. A massive official convention called the Doctor Who Festival was recently hosted in Sydney, where thousands upon thousands of people turned up over two days to see the cast and crew explain how the show is made. In earlier years, there have been events such as the Doctor Who World Tour and the Symphonic Spectaculars; each of which have been completely chockablock with fans. How do I know? Because I've been to practically all of them. Last time I checked, Halo didn't host events like that outside of the United States and it hasn't been breaking any international records within the same scope as Doctor Who.
And you know what the funny thing is? Most of this was accomplished in the past ten years since the series' revival in 2005. So, maybe that 50 Year thing wasn't necessary to say at all.
"Clone wars cartoon and the original three movies. Except the Ewoks, they're dumb." My thoughts exactly.
Star Trek is nerdier. If it isn't, explain why the old die hard fans are so pissed off about the new ones with science fantasy rather than science fiction?
hunterkiller1440 "We don't speak of the odd numbered Star Trek movies."
hunterkiller1440 what cartoon are they refering to?
why do people always forget the first cartoon
Pelle Albers Both Clone Wars cartoon I think, the miniseries and the CGI animated series.
hunterkiller1440 - Yeah, because admitting to the existence of the prequel trilogy is about as embarrassing as having Jar-Jar Binks marry your sister!
hunterkiller1440
Fantasy vs Scifi has nothing to do with how "nerdy" either is. In fact, they're both pretty damn nerdy. They just come from different literary traditions with different fundamental premises that shape the story and the characters. Fantasy stories tend to have set premises that the characters cannot violate, and those characters are generally ordained to succeed or fail by fate, are often composed of gods, demi-gods or super-humans (in Wars' case, just being genetically superior is enough it seems) though not always, and generally are beyond criticism as a premise of the story. Science fiction allows for story premises which can be questions or even changed by the characters, and those characters are themselves generally ordinary, fallible (in fact an entire subgenre of scifi revolves around this idea), and navigate the story with tools and abilities available to the average person.
ST09 and STiD were neither, and frankly, I would have felt cheated as a Wars' fan had either been a Wars movie instead, because ST09 was a weak and unremarkable action flick, fun but forgettable, and STiD was just atrociously bad cinema and story in every regard.
just imagine this whole thing but at Comic-Con with people cosplaying them
I was under the impression that WAS Comic-Con?
I can see that
Why hello there, old sport
Freddy: I have found you Mr afton now
I will get my revenge *jumpscare*
I just keep coming back to this video again and again to watch Picard gesture with both hands and a foot, and to watch them wiggling their hands back and forth. 😀
I wish there was more done by this animator.
Watching Ryker in the background is like an entire B-Plot in itself.
That and Worf writing a love letter to Darth Vader.
Star Trek has the badge of "nerdy" honour.
Star Wars fans are the worst. Lucas himself Said He made the movies for children and yet they try tô elevate It to a status It Will never get.
Tô me the close se for tô star WARS was rogue one. Screw light side and Skywalker i want to see the Empire laying waste,How rebels formed you know..War!
Star Trek fans are the worst they’re full of themselves and think that they are superior to Star Wars fans and Star Wars is enjoyed by all ages.
@@WhiplashBunny star Trek came before,its star Wars fans that started this shit then they Took It in the stomach with the prequels
And now choose what is Canon and what isnt
Not rly the prequels were great and the best word to summarize Star Trek fans is “brats”
@@WhiplashBunny not true sw fans are the whiniest ones.
ST Took the word geek and Took It with pride
Riker is just putting his leg on everything
That's actually very accurate.
Did he do the Riker Maneuver in the video?
More like trying to hump everything
..
It's called the "riker Maneuver", and apparently hes so swaggy with has back and legs all the time due to an accident at a labour job in his past, so all the swagger and machismo is just chronic backpain with a grin lmao.
how else is this animation going to show the riker maneuver?
omg. this had me cracking up. and then all the bonus stuff happening in the background? pure genius. the writing on this was just fabulous.
Anyone else find the background characters hilarious?
That poor stormtrooper needs a pat in the head for being force choked
and riker putting his leg on everything
Even Dr. Crusher who sedated him.
“THAT’S NOT THE POINT!!!!!”
“yesitisssssssssssss...”
Edi: Wow! Thanks for the likes everyone!
It kinda is tho
@Konata Kagami it obviously is
But it’s just not
Lets be ohnest would you watch a movie if it wasnt asome anser no you wouldnt the old 19es horror movies understand that best so yes it apsolutley is the point
yes i acknowledge that these lines were in the video
now what
"Your special effects are laaaaaame!"
"That's not the point!"
"Yes it iiiiis!"
I think the best part of Vader's last part is that if you wear headphones, you can hear him going from one side to another XD
Yes it does !
Actually I thought TNG had really good special effects for a 90's tv show. Obviously it's not going to compare to a Star Wars movie.
And to be honest, it's not really true anyway! Star Trek has always been known for its groundbreaking visual effects.
Yes, but TOS's special effects were still pretty good for a TV show at the time. They didn't have a big budget like TNG did but they certainly did a good job on the effects.
Obvious bias here, but I always found something quite pleasant about Star Trek's effects. Except for insurrection though that was around the time of weird switches from practical to CGI.
I loved how Darth Vader's voice actually sounded like Dark Helmet's voice from Spaceballs.
Picard: So tell me, what DOES count as Star Wars?
Vader: The Clone Wars cartoon, and the original three movies... except the Ewoks. They're dumb.
Me: You're goddamn right Clone Wars counts.
Prequel novels count, due to added details not included in the movies. I didn't read them, but I skimmed through them.
Clone wars: Star Wars or Clone wars: The Star Wars. NGL the first was pretty fire too.
@@multifunfunman3241 revenge of the sith novel is awesome
Revenge of the Sith counts
Because that one was pretty good
And the prequels
Picard: “oh so you have to be magic”
(Suddenly Q)
Disappointed Optimist Q was one of the best weird characters in star trek.
Q vs Vader when
Sebastian Sinisterra in the words of Vader "the ability to force choke people is insignificant compared to the power of omnipotent beings"
Q doesn't count. Q is an anomaly in the Galaxy.
in starwars q would be the force itself ;)
In my opinion, football is nerdier. I mean, why the hell do you know so much about the players? They seem to know all their names going back decades, and can remember some of the most insignificant [to an non-football fan] moments, from games years ago. They collect things to do with their favourite show's (sorry, team's) and even buy the uniforms and where them out in public. They even have conventions where thousands of them all gather together and wear the uniforms. They argue about which show (sorry, team) is better. Who is the best captain? I could go on.
kolaxanthe Then religious fanatics are the biggest nerds of all.
Alexander Salt Absolutely!!!
kolaxanthe Don't get started on fantasy football...*shivers*
Alexander Salt I wouldn't go that far... Maybe just geeks.
Alexander Salt people behave religiously when it comes to many things: country, army, sport, music, famous people. these fanatics are also the worst imo.
I have watches this so many times over the years. How have a never noticed that worf was writing a love note for Vader!
Darth Vader's Chest Plate is an NES controller
I noticed that too!!!
King Bowser Koopa Game Videos lol I just notice
Very astute
Meanwhile we got Doctor Who eating popcorn watching this fight.
Cheers, human. Feel free to grab a bucket. My lovely TARDIS made more than enough popcorn, and it's the real deal, not that replicator nonsense. XD
+Yorky Gonzalez (Take a look at my profile picture.)
Love the Doctor!👉❤👈
And Donna, too!😂
Oh great, tarded people are here too.
hey speaking of bullshit pseudoscience
how about shoveling exposition into every season that contradicts itself because time travel solves everything
or preaching about "not using violence" yet destroying entire civilizations
Star Trek inspired a generation of scientists while Star Wars inspired a generation of film makers.
GuyWithAnAmazingHat Scientists are hands down nerdier than film makers.
Star Trek is therefore nerdier.
GuyWithAnAmazingHat Well, one of the film makers inspired by Star Wars made two Star Trek movies...
Alexander Freyr They are both sides of the same nerd coin, however it is quite true that a scientific nerd is much more powerful than a film nerd.
GuyWithAnAmazingHat Well, star trek does inspire films, and star wars does inspire computer engineers and mechanical scientists... whatever a mechanical scientist is.... don't use words well..... words no good....
GuyWithAnAmazingHat It does both ways....
The best bit of this was the throw away Riker stance joke...classic!
RIP Dave Prowse, the man in the suit. Star Wars wouldn’t have been the same without him
You sure tho? Lucas probably could have gotten anyone with a similar body shape to David Prowse, and we'd be fine. Still, pay your respects.
@@JonathanSmith-ge4pi Fair point, objectively speaking. But _A Clockwork Orange_ wouldn't be the same without him tho.
Lucas: haha yeah but hayden christiansen was better
WAIT HE DIED
@@arnavdespande384 may the force be with him
I get every single reference in this video. Am I a nerd??
Nooooo. Thats just beginners stuff. :D
Lorem Ipsum you're kind of born with it...
Lorem Ipsum, Yes, but that's alright I'm a nerd as well.
I am happy to announce you are a fuckin nerd my dude,welcome to the club
1:55 the guy grows a third arm to hold that poster lol
Data's a guy.
i see four arms xD
lol
good old Data...
1:43 Riker has no Body/Legs
Wow this was so well done with an accurate ending and everything. Can't believe I haven't seen it before now. Too funny through and through, both sides got it so good.
Star wars was arguably the greatest trilogy of all time, just compare how many people were excited for star trek into darkness to star wars episode 7.
you get a like because Marvin rules
+Marvin Marvin wins!
+Marvin
That's not really comparable or even meaningful to success (otherwise that means Justin Bieber is the best singer of all time.) and that's from someone who loves star wars.
eee saga yes. trilogy is lord of the rings.
Dat Max I never said it makes the movies better, I just mean that more people like it then star trek because of that, and justin bieber applies to this aswell.
" Almost as funny as Star Trek five!"
"... We don't talk about the odd numbered Star Trek movies. "
French Soldier u see comrade now we have the red side
Wait does that mean the first star trek suck
Fair enough.
We wont talk about the SW prequels or sequels...
@@jadenterwillegar760 Funnily, yes. It was considered a poor mans 2001 backnin the day. Its why the Wrath of Khan was considered a far superior movie.
And then Search for Spock was a letdown, and the Star Trek 4 was considered one of the best Star Trek movies made, and you get the idea. It was an up & down rollercoaster until Nemesis
Star Trek 3: Search for Spock wasn't a bad movie though.....
Anyone else notice the stuff with Riker in the background?
+josiah jenks Thats the best thing in this video :).
I was laughing my ass off it was hilarious!!
+josiah jenks Holy fuck. I've seen this video like 5 times but only know I noticed Riker trying to put his foot everywhere! Hilarious XD
+ObsidiusFan
So you didn't notice he does in the actual show too?
Schwarzer Ritter I don't watch Star Trek, let alone Next Generation. It only took me one quick Google search to know he does that very often in the show.
I know, I should. Don't tell me to do so.
As a trekie myself I admit Star Trek is nerdier but that’s what makes it awesome. All the science and info they have is what makes it soooooo much better.
"ugh, I feel like I'm in science class but I'm getting dumber"
Alex Williams you want to talk about pseudoscience? Midi-chlorians, then!
Why can't we agree that the force is internet, and midichlorians are wifi
also the force has no need for any gender
@@masonjones7777 The force has no gender and it uses whoever the f**k it wants
@@farmgirl400 someone talked about actually doing teleportation and in order to do so you literally have to kill the orginal and 'clone' it elsewhere. So star trek teleportation is pseudo science
@@sheilaolfieway1885 exactly, I don't know why everything needs that sort of association, I mean it's a frikken "force" as in a sort of vague science/magic presence that can be called upon by those who are adept
despite what lego games may have you believe there is no tangible "dark" or "light", Luke can choke a gmorien guard and sith can do basically anything a jedi can do if they had learned how.
it has no personality, is an amalgamation of strange energy and does not have any reason to be personified, let alone be called "male" or "female"
Of course star trek is nerdier. It takes over 700 hours to watch the whole series. Star Wars takes 70. Addendum: Why didn't Vader make fun of how many times the holodeck breaks down?
Alaric Williams That very true, that and it's safety measures get overridden way to often.
*Cough cough* Extended universe *Cough cough*
Let's see a lot of talking teleporting inperirising a lot of kissing and a lot of science and a old man who looks like he wearing pajamas and boring shooting scenes let's see what star wars has lightsaber fights ship shooting scenes epic wars scenes and Luke finds Vader is he's father and badass charther named Han sole bar scenes death star explodes
Quantum Explosion 12 movies, 30 seasons over 6 shows, and God knows how many books and comics.
Vs
6 movies (+ The Clone Wars), various childrens' shows - most of which are junk. and a similar amount of books and comics.
***** Well I'm not to familiar with the Star Trek universe and fan base, but how I measure how nerdy something is, is by the fans. When I said the extended universe I meant how fans created a whole universe based on six movies. There's hundreds of wars, planets, species, and bad ass characters. If Star Trek has a fan base that created the rest of the universe then I'd say they're both equally nerdy.
"You special effects are laaamee....,.."
"THATS NOT THE POINT!!!"
"Yes it iiiiiis..."
Alexander Albinsson That's pretty weird considering Star Trek has matched Star Wars' effects plenty of times.
true story *****
***** And if I remember correctly, didn't TNG, DS9, and Voyager all use Lucas' special effects company?
Alexander Albinsson "Yes, it is"
Star Wars is only nerdy if you actually get into it
Star Trek is just nerdy in general
Star Wars and Star Trek have only ONE thing in common!...The word "Star"in the title. Other than that, you're comparing apples to oranges. I actually am a fan of both.
I enjoy the stories of both, but would never call myself a fan of either genre.
***** 80% of Star Wars was stolen from Trek by George Lucas. He mostly just added a whole bunch of explosions and lightsabers.
***** Umm.... you're not allowed to be a fan of both. That's like a paradox.
You can only like one or the other.
Charlie Thales Just saying the first star wars movie came out 2 years before the first star trek movie
Charlie Thales It was stolen from dune
I love the Ewok beating up the stormtroopers in the background 😂
LoL I like when the Professor Stormtrooper tries to poke him and the Ewok threatens him with the spear. What was the deal with that little guy? Was he trying to join the imperial legion? And how'd even get on the Death Star? =)
knightofetro13 I hate the Ewoks beating up the stormtroopers in the MOVIE!!!!!
I love Commander riker who stands on everybodys heads
And Riker attempting to do the Riker Maneuver on everything.
That is not the Riker Maneuver, that is the Riker Lean, since there is no chair involved.
I love Commander Riker's exaggerated need of having to lean his leg everywhere, it's one of those things you don't really notice until it's pointed out. And TNG's strongest character is Data, not Worf, but they're right in that he does get his ass handed to him a fair number of times..
Gabriel Gutierrez Video for people who haven't notice the Riker Maneuver before: watch?v=lVIGhYMwRgs
Gabriel Gutierrez You should see how he sits on chairs :)
Edit: I didn't see that greenyodadude posted it.
Gabriel Gutierrez I've always noticed it.
Gabriel Gutierrez How could you not have noticed it in the show? It's pretty clear, you don't need a video to point it out.
Daniel Bradley I guess it would be if you're actively looking for it, but to me it was just Riker being Riker. I always found the way he moved to just be subtle, he's nowhere near in your face about it as it is in this video.
We’ll see how tough Darth Vader is when he gets assimilated by the Borg. Should be easy work for them anyway since he’s already half machine.
I love the background stuff - Riker leaning on everything and everyone until Beverly knocks him out and uses him as a footstool; Deanna grabbing the bat'leth, all, "HAAA!"; the "dumb" Ewok terrorizing the stormtroopers; Data's poetry reading. Honestly, this whole thing is sheer perfection. I love both Star Trek and Star Wars, and this makes me laugh so hard. Thanks so much for sharing it, @CollegeHumor! :D
I love both as well.
Darth Vader: Oh, ok, the force is dumb, but you beaming people all over the place isn't.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard: It's SCIENCE! 😂😂
David Mariscal it is science. Star Wars is just magic and constant battles over territory that’s all actually influenced by the divious sith lord Palpatine
Clone Rayne Both sides were correct
Clone Rayne Star Trek does have plenty of action and it’s more politically applicable to today’s society than Star Wars. Star Wars is for kids and sexually deprived deviants.
Clone Rayne so I say something meaningful and you resort to calling out my childhood because you’re unhappy with me being right?
Clone Rayne actually as a kid I was the one hurting others
Funny enough, the special effects for star wars and Star Trek are made by the same company, Industrial Lights and Magic.
Which Star Trek films though?
Definitely not films from the sixties or whenever the first films were released, but some time after Star Wars was released as ILM was made before the films release.
@@SWDude2710 ILM was founded in 1975. So no, they didn't work on TOS. However, every series since and movie since the Motion Picture in 1979 has had the special effects done by ILM.
@@zachthelamb ahhhhhhhh.
Thank you.
I wasn't sure myself about that.
My bad.
xd
What's really funny, is that thanks to ILM, they're in the same cinematic universe as R2-D2 exists in both of them.
Star Trek is obviously better than Star Wars, no question.
Star Wars is worse Writing anyway.
But Stargate is better anyway. They're doing all the subjects and points better, like for example, the Origin of the Races. Just an example.
Looks like we have a comment section where the Star Trek fans and the Star Wars fans are getting along, nice
I wish so
Lmao riker trying to put his leg on everything
I was looking for comment like this!
I lost my shit at that, so true.
*****
A space pimp, no DNA strand too far
I almost died when I noticed it
xXthecrazymeXx
"Clone Wars cartoon and the original three movies. Except the Ewoks, they're dumb."
VERY WELL PHRASED, LORD VADER
ShadowNny when did a star trek movie ever made the general public excited and make over a billion dollars?
Xx_SupremeCroc_xX # lol rip so true
ShadowNny Jesus no need to be such a dick about it. 😂
"So uncivilised"
Insert Some Witty Name Here be glad he didn't say TFA or TLJ.
ShadowNny Disney as our new lord? Heck no!!! Have you seen TFA or TLJ? TFA is a New hope and TLJ is every other movie in a blender with plot holes and terrible writing. Don't believe me go listen to Palpatines lines on death star two then go listen to snokes lines. They are the exact same lines!
Wait a minute... a federation ship, actually, blowing something up? Thats a first!
Aaron Harrington How much Star Trek have you watched?
Jack Andrews A season of the TNG, DS9. and VOY.
+Jack Andrews He seen an episode of "Enterprise" lol
J.T. Windley No, actually I have seen 2 seasons of TNG, and VOY. I haven't even touched Enterprise.
+Aaron Harrington Relax guy, it was just a joke.
It's funny to me that Vader says "your special effects are lame", because a lot of the special effects in the Star Trek series were done by Industrial Light and Magic, which is SFX division of Lucasfilm.
Hahahaha Riker trying to put his leg on everything
[Hypospray to the neck]
that's what he does
Jordan Sullivan It was not an episode of The Next Generation without Riker putting his crotch in someones face.
a clear loyalist to the show haha
Lol, yeah
Star Trek is nerdier
***** jup but i still like it XD
***** Yeah, star trek is sci-fi and starwars is just... fantasy
NicksDomain101 And fantasy isnt nerdy?
NicksDomain101 Fantasy isn't nerdy at all (zooms into typical dragons and knights etc)
Ayygent of Teal yeah
Galactic politics are actually interesting and add to the world building, that’s one of my favorite parts of the Prequels.
In principle I agree, except the galactic politics and world building in Star Wars stinks.
Games, Gear, & Gadgets In the sequels, but I feel the prequels do it pretty well.
Tons of the Legends stuff was about galactic politics, so I was well conditioned for it in the prequels.
@@carlsiouxfalls Legends was great, a pity it got screwed over by Lucasfilm/Disney
And the clone wars cartoon.
I wanna hear Data's poetry reading. I enjoyed all the times in Star Trek when crew members do performance art just for fun. :3
I lol'd at Riker putting his fucking leg up. XDD
Yeah, that was the best!
a secret yeah i dont "lol" i just laugh
Timothy Cowin So you laugh silently? Don't know about you but that seems a bit weird.
a secret it's because he's such a dick he needs to give it more air than usual
a secret It's the Riker Manoeuvre ;D
Riker in the background doing the leg thing was hilarious
It was Riker's maneuver
@@davidfilonenko90 I thought the Riker Manoeuvre was how he sat down
@@DelthinTheRanger The right order:
#1 lean on things
#2 mount things
#3 mount women
Jonathan Frakes had like a back problem where he would be in pain except for when he was in certain positions
Vader: Your special effects are lame!
Piccard: Says the man whose voice carries through the vacuum of space!
Vader: What? Did you say something?
Piccard: I said I'm more scientifically accurate.
***** Really? I hadn't noticed that about myself!
Voices in the vacuum of space were never in the movies and it was a comms link so Vader's voice was being projected onto the ship.
Oris Cinn Sure, up until the moment when the com link was destroyed along with the Death Star itself. Vader was drifting through space, getting one last remark in that Picard could somehow hear.
computernerd1101 What's your point?
YES!!! Totally more accurate!!!
"Star Wars is like philosophy for children"
He's not wrong.
As a Trekkie, I can safely say that this is beautiful.
Agreed
As someone who was raised to love Star Wars, and seeing Star Trek later on in life, I’m a great fan of both! And yes, I can confirm, it’s beautiful.
Star trek is definetly nerdier I don't even know why that is a question
oooh yeah!
Gamer Player I’d say Star Wars is more “geeky” the nerdy
DPGamez Derek Meaningless distinction.
Absolutely, Star Trek lingo alone makes it way more nerdy.
Also Star Trek seems more scientific and Star Wars seems more surreal if anything, but I love both of them because let’s face it, the force is badass.
Gamer Player agreed
Sorry for my lack of Star Trek knowledge but the guy kneeling on people in the background is hilarious
The Riker Manoeuvre, look into it
@@aleksandarmarkovic221 isn't the riker manoeuvre the sitting thing ?
Number 1 or the first officer commander riker. Aka the co pilot
Grand Khan yes, you are right actually
its Commander Riker
WHY have I not run across this before?????????
I LOVE IT!!!!
This would have been a great weekly mini series!!!! LOL