Thank you for addressing the weight of each machine. You are the first one I have heard do this. I am a senior with a bad back so that is important to me. Great informative video.
Thanks for the comparison. I am hopeful Cricut will come out with the ability to work offline because I believe the Maker is THE better machine. When I bought an embroidery machine years ago a lady in the shop told me to buy a unit that was several steps above the level I was currently at so I wouldn't be very disappointed. My hubby bought me the top of the line unit and we have never regretted it. You never know when your interests are going to change and go in different directions.
@@xCARPx2014 maker is pretty good but there software is bad so I got the Silhouette software then save svg to cut on the cricuit. Just thought i let you know also cameo just came out with the cameo 4, but I like the maker machine not there software
I'm just learning about these machines so for the ease of software use, I'm leaning toward the Cricut. I think once we get the hang of it, my husband would also like it. He's quite artistic but not so much a techie. A Cricut may be the option for us.
What a fabulous review! Your explanation was so thorough and covered so many things that I would want to know. And you have such great enthusiasm and positivity!
Thank you for this review, I have been on the fence about which one is the right choice for me. I have friends telling me the cameo is the right choice, but I feel the cricut maker is able to do what I need a cutting machine to do.
I have 2 cricut makers and am buying a cameo 4 and keeping all . I want it because of the different software and something new to play around with but love Cricut to !
I really like the look/feel of the Cricut machines...I feel like it is a solid design and quality machine; however, I love the design software in the Cameo (which I own) because I am not limited to their patterns and can create my own unique designs (I have a Graphic Design/Multi-Media background). It is a must for business - doing something different than your competition. If I was a new crafter, Cricut would be the best choice....easier to use/learn software.....perfect for the home user.
Great video!!! I have an Explore Air 2 but I really want a Silhouette. I think I like the Silhouette software better. I wish Cricut would make Design Space, better, faster and offline.
I just beginning to shop, but I think I'm going to go with the circuit machine. Just trying to find a good price. Michaels seems to have the best price. Should I look for one with a bundle?
Yes! We also love the Cricut Explore Air 2, if you don't want to spend so much money on the Maker. The Air 2 is an amazing machine :) Cricut Explore Air 2: amzn.to/2VxAOos
We had the silhouette for over 7 yrs but Costco had a good deal on the cricut ultimate package for 399.99 it has the commercial stuff. The huge difference is you don’t need to pay for the free svg file upload but silhouette you need to pay to use the svg upload
Cameo 3 dont compaire to the maker so this is not a true comparision. Now if you was reviewing the cameo 4 and maker I would get it but this is not good
Recently received an email from Cricut regarding their development of design space offline capabilities hopefully by the end of year. Really looking forward to it
Hi, i'm new to this craft. But you really gave me a good infos regarding two different brands. Thus Cricut is android friendly or jst apple gadgets.?thank you
I got the Cricut Maker in February and completely regret it. I got it to use mainly for vinyl/various paper cutting. I regrettably did not start using the machine until recently and encountered so many issues. My main three gripes are 1)online design studio that freezes on me constantly and is just slow and I have fast internet. 2)The limited print then cut page space, its ridiculous how many paper space I waste because of the limited size. 3) The most frustrating is the misalignment when cutting, I'm not sure if it's my machine and a defect but I can not for the life of me cut anything out aligned. Everything cuts too far to the left, I tried to adjust the page on the mat to account for this but didnt work. Anyways, I'm in contact with Cricut regarding this, hoping that it gets resolved because I have a machine that I cant use. I was so frustrated and really needed something to assist with my paper goods orders and ended up getting the Silhouette Portrait at a discount and I am so impressed with it. Cuts beautifully and I love love love the design studio and the ability to outline what you are cutting, setting offsets and insets, being able to color code lines to cut and have the machine adjust blade automatically to cutting those lines in one go instead of having to reload, and I love the ability to use all the page during a print and cut. If the little portrait can do all this, I so regret not getting the cameo 3 instead.
@guess what Hey there! One of the main difference is the size of the machines. The portrait takes 8.5 inch wide x 11in or smaller paper, the mat is 8.5x12in. The Cameo takes in 12x12 sheets. If you will be cutting out images that big or projects that require that size paper I'd say go with the cameo. You can do alot more should you choose to because of paper size. However if you dont need that 12x12 size you can do alot with the portrait. I went with the portrait since currently I dont have a need to do anything bigger than the 8.5x11 and since I spent so much on the Maker. Just an update though, Cricut refunded me for the Maker which was so amazing. Thier customer service was phenomenal and helpful, so grateful I was able to send the machine back. I am holding out for the Silhouette Cameo 4 that's coming out :) Hope that helps! I love the Portrait, it's got a small form factor and so far has no let me down with all the stuff I had it do. You cant go wrong with either choice!
@guess what From my research it seems to just be improved on a number of things. One main feature is the cutting force is much more than Cameo 3. This is useful if you plan on cutting other hefty materials like leather or balsa wood. There is a dual-motor instead of single as well and the cutting speed is 3x faster. Honestly, if you are going to be working mainly with paper then I see no reason to not purchase the Cameo 3. Personally, I am just a techy person and love all the bright new shiny upgrades that come out. The Portrait has not let me down as of yet, it's small and fits my needs. I haven't got the need to purchase a bigger machine so although I say I'm waiting for the 4, I most likely will not be purchasing it any time soon. I recommend looking at the Cameo 3 and 4 youtube videos. There are a lot as well as a google search will give you sites where people compare the two. If you want to wait for the 4 because you like it more, then go for it. If you find that the Cameo 3 more than suits your need and use then I say go for that one. With the Silhouette, I say you can't go wrong with any :)
@@dustydreamer424 glad i read your experience. Quick question..i have my own programs that i create my own designs. Would i be able to transfer those images to the program that comes with portrait? Reason I'm asking is there was another review saying something about that but it was unclear
@@MegaChevy65 Hi! I believe you can. I usually create the original image in illustrator or photoshop, sometimes on my ipad and send to my computer for touch up. I save my image files as png or svg (you have to pay for svg add on I think for the silhouette program which I didnt mind doing since I loved the program so much) and am able to import it into the silhouette program with no issues. From there you can manipulate the image if needed (size, quantity on a page, adjust cut lines if you want a white line around the image or want it cut precisely on your draw line, etc). Just to be sure, you can download the silhouette program online for free and import the images you are creating to ensure you can without issue. I could be wrong but I dont think you need to purchase the machine before hand to get the program.
Jami Womack my sister and i were discussing her Silhouette 3 the other day. I have 2 of the older Cricut machines that take cartridges and I asked her if her machine had that. She explained a little bit about how you get your images and I was like I think that would be too much for me to figure out lol I’m HORRIBLE with the computer. I still have all of my cartridges and other machines do i think i will probably choose the Cricut because it’s “user friendly” !!
I have had an Original cameo and a Cameo 3 I can't wait for the Cameo 4 pro to come out!! I use the Cameo for tons of stuff and it works great. of course I have used the cameo for years so I feel the Cameo program is so much easier the Cricut. But again could be because I have used it for so many years. AND THANKS FOR MAKING A VIDEO WITH A CAMEO!
Can you use svg or png designs with the cameo without buying the software? I have a few different software that I use with my laser machine and I have a ton of designs on my PC that I'd love to be able to just send to the cameo. It wasn't very clear in the video about the need for software. I'm not sure how all of that works:)
@@dianaw4072 your cameo comes with the basic software for svg you will need to upgrade to designer edition. But you can get cameo connect and cut direct form.corel draw and adobe illustrator.
@@dianaw4072 I don't have a cameo 3, but I was able to download the free software. I was able to save my inkscape svg design as a dxf file (Desktop Cutting Plotter). When it asks, select file type: ROBO-Master type of spline output. Click ok. I was able to open that dxf file in the program. It seems a little larger than my original design, and since I don't have the actual machine to test it on, it may be problematic, but I will keep working on it to see if I can figure out if the mistake was mine or theirs. (BTW dxf is an AutoCad drawing format. I used to work with AutoCad, and loved it. Just can't afford it now!) Hope that helps just a little! I also realize that by now, two months later, you may have already figured out your issue.
Well you sold me on the Cricut Maker :) I have had the Silhouette Cameo with the business designer edition software for a few years now and I have a love/hate relationship with it . I spend most time trying to find my Registration Marks to a point that I have almost tossed the entire thing out the window. Thanks for the review.
Mannnnn! If this isn't the story of my life. I truly understand what you mean and am soooo on the fence at what to do. As far as capabilities the Cameo would work best for me....but the registration mark thing....ugh! A thorn in my side!
Excellent review/comparison on both machines! I appreciate the unbiased information, just presenting the facts. I know nothing about either one, so this was very helpful, thank you. I must say, the "user friendly" speaks loudly, especially since I know nothing about this craft.
Are you able to cut multiple sheets of paper at the same time? Let's say for example I needed 30 students to have a card stop cut to a particular shape. Which would be the most time efficient to use? Also, If I want to cut out phrases, or words on vinyl. Do I need to do them at the same time, or is there a way to cut faster? I've never seen one used, time is my biggest concern. I want a tool that would be the fastest to cut. What do you recommend?
I love my Silhouette! If you're fairly comfortable using a pc then you'll do just fine. The graphic options are fanstatic. From what most Cricut users post, they have to use an a additional program like Inkscape to get more design options.
@@kineybus2473 bought a maker and rarely use it and bought a Glowforge and now I'm looking at a cameo like should I buy you and let you sit on the shelf too??? Decisions Decisions
Also, the cut file types for the Silhouette Cameo are .dxf which if you have Adobe Illustrator like I do you can export a file to .dxf and open it in the free Silhouette Studio software for custom designs.
I have the original Cricut that came out. I purchased thinking I would use and do alot of scapbooking when I retited.....so it was purchased about 11 years ago along with over $10,000.00 in all kinds of cartriges, scapbooking paper, books, embelisments and you name it. Now 11 years later I am just getting around to thinking about using it. Because it is so out dated and can not be hooked to Internet I am seriously thinking of purchasing the Explorer Air 2 because that is the only machine that still offers to be able to use the cartriges. I guess I don't want to feel my original purchase was a loss because so old but would like to stay with the times also. Like to see what your opinion would be on this situation and where you feel best place to purchase one would be if you agree with my thinking....and what price do you feel they should run. I was shocked when you told of price of Maker as I have never seen lower than 399, in Upstate NY. By the way I also am an Independent Designer for Chalk Couture....more as a Hobbyist though. That is my problem....I have too many Hobbies!!!!!! Would appreciate your feed back. Jo in NY.
Jo Terwilliger Hi! You can get an adapter for your machine to sync all your cartridges to your software. But yes, now the expression is outdated. I would recommend an air or Maker!
I just need something for my business. I want to be able to easily make my own vinyl lipgloss labels and making custom clothing (stencils for print making) etc.
Yes, with any newer machine you will use it digitally on a software like Design Space which you will use on your laptop, desktop, tablet, or smartphone.
You are awesome! I am in the process of choosing one! I heard these other ladies saying cameo was the best. Then I hear cricut maker is awesome! I am new snd confused
Wow, awesome review on both machines. I'm looking to use one of these machines to buy and print planner stickers off of Etsy onto my own sticker paper and then cut it. But I'm still not sure which one I should go with.
Depending on what you want to do. The Silhouette software is so much better then the cricuit. If you are gonna do any fabric or would then get maker. But cameo came out with the cameo 4 which is like the maker. But if you just doing stickers I say the cameo one. Or get the maker and use the Silhouette software. What I do now as i don't have money for new machine
I am really hoping that cricut will make a standalone software for PC. it is seriously a pain in the butt to have to go online just to cut vinyl. What happens when the internet is down, do i take my cricut with me to the nearest starbucks and cut my design there?
I’m really looking forward to the Silhouette 4, would love to see that comparison. I did love my original Silhouette & I had the design version. Loved not relying on WiFi and Design Space going down all the time. Still have that machine.
Hello Tanner and welcome bak. Aloha.. thanks so much for this very informative video. I do love my Cricut and still learning the tips and tricks to it. Still using my Explorer 2. After I take your Pro class I plan to switch them out. I really appreciate you enhancing my view on both. Thanks, Karidad
i am so interested with cricut maker. i am living here in davao city philippines. where is the nearest store here that i can purchase this product? need it badly
You can purchase it right off the Cricut website! :) ruclips.net/user/redirect?v=eVupeRZIx2g&redir_token=YuR2MVrtmDmg3gYGtz9MYoTJad18MTU4ODA4MTc1MkAxNTg3OTk1MzUy&event=video_description&q=https%3A%2F%2Fgoo.gl%2FwHgGjr
you explained that so well, don't take any notice of people that think you were biased. A lot of "crafters" are not super tech savvy and you gave information that def helps make a choice in that aspect. Everyone needs to just take a breathe and not take this personally! You don't need to be so nasty grils!
Thank you very much for the comparison! It was great and unbiased and addressed just about every question I have except this one (I have been looking for the answer for a couple hours); do either of these machines cut longer sizes (ie for a sign that would be 46”) so it’s all on one piece of vinyl? Or will they have to be separate sheets? I already found that the cameo doesn’t require that you have a cutting board behind it like the Cricut does so does that mean I can cut longer?
Makers Gonna Learn yes it does! Too bad though lol I saw a tutorial on a sign done a year ago n she said she used the cameo (not sure version because she had the vinyl made already), it looked like it was all one piece so that’s why I was searching for the answer! Thank u for getting back so quickly ☺️
I ordered a Cricut Maker on 2/26. As of 3/9, the order was still in a processing status on their website. During that time I actually ordered (on 3/2) AND received (on 3/6) a Silhouette Cameo with no issues. So I called Cricut to cancel. The first rep I spoke with left me to die on hold for 25 minutes. The second rep I spoke with told me that she had cancelled the order and I'd be receiving an email about it. She straight up lied. The order was not cancelled. The company must threaten its employees with bad consequences for cancelling orders, that's the only reason this kind of thing happens. I emailed Cricut customer service and requested they fix it. They sent me back a copy/paste email saying "Good news, your order has been shipped! We're closing your ticket as resolved." Now I've had to go to my bank, dispute the charge, cancel my card and wait two weeks for a new one because of their dishonesty. Otherwise I'd have to mail back the Cricut at my own cost and pay a 20% restocking fee ($85) because they refused to cancel my order. I emailed the CEO and VP of Sales at Cricut last night explaining all of that and stating that I will either refuse the shipment or, if it's dropped off when I'm not home, hold it until they send me a return shipping label. As of yet I haven't received a reply. The whole experience has been an extreme hassle and aggravation from the start and I can't wait to be done with it. The company hasn't done one right or honest thing since the moment I placed my order. I couldn't in good conscience recommend anyone buying from them or continuing to deal with them. Especially considering the fact that the Silhouette is cheaper, can do everything the maker can do, and arrived quickly and with zero hassle. My email exchange with Cricut: Your request summary is: Joseph Hackman Mar 9, 9:03 PM MDT I placed this order on 2/25/2020 and expected to receive it within a week. When I had not received it by 3/3/2020, I put in an order for one of your competitor's products instead - a Silhouette Cameo 4. That company got me their product by 3/6/2020, the same week. Today I called your company at 11:10AM Eastern U.S. time to cancel my order with you, since it was still in "Processing" status. The first person I spoke with, a man, talked with me for about three minutes and then asked to put me on hold while he checked on the order. He left me on hold for another 23 minutes without ever checking back. I hung up the phone and called back. The second time I got a woman who, after putting me on hold for 15 minutes, came back and assured me that the order was cancelled and that I would be receiving an email notifying me of the cancellation and the expected refund date. I used to work for Sprint, the phone company, where they played these same shitty games, so I took the precaution of recording my conversations with both of your representatives just in case this exact thing happened. Either your employees make commission based on a low cancel percentage metric or their employment is negatively impacted by a high cancel percentage, so they outright lie to customers or let them die on hold rather than process a cancellation. Your employees did both today, and both conversations were recorded by me on a second phone, which is legal in the state of Kentucky as long as one party is aware that the conversation is being recorded, and I was that party. Knowing full well that the woman I spoke with lied as soon as the words came out of her mouth, I checked back on your website to see that the order still showed as "Processing" instead of "Cancelled". I also took timestamped screenshots of that order page before and after my conversations with your employees. I wanted to pursue the issue further with your company via email, like I'm doing now, but I had to stop what I was doing and take one of my sons hours away to see a doctor, which took all day. I just returned home to find that the order now shows a status of "Shipped". Let me explain to you what that means to me. If your company had processed my order correctly, I wouldn't own a Cameo, but you didn't. If your company had processed my cancellation properly and honestly as you were supposed to have, perhaps I would have found that I didn't like my Cameo and wanted to try Cricut again, or that later on I wanted to try Cricut again anyway to expand the variety of my work. But you didn't do that. Instead of making a friend or a potential FUTURE customer, you chose to make an enemy instead. There is no way I am keeping your machine at this point, not a chance in hell. I am returning it immediately after receipt. What happens after that point is entirely up to you. If your company reimburses me the full $423.99 payment on the order plus whatever shipping charges it costs me to return the machine to you that I never should have received, we can still part ways peacefully. If instead you choose to stand behind your employees lies, failure to cancel my order, and fraudulent shipping of this order and not reimburse me for my return shipping cost, I will go so very far out of my way to share all screenshots and recordings of your company's handling of my order in every online marketplace I can find where it will have the most impact, causing as much bad publicity for you as I possibly can, and I guarantee that it'll end up costing you more than processing my request to cancel the order would have. That's all I have to say. The ball is once again in your court.
The reply: Your request (2345878) has been updated. To add additional comments, reply to this email. Sandy (Cricut) Mar 10, 11:57 AM MDT Hello Joseph, Good news - Your package is on its way! The tracking number is 168574947729, 168574947730 It looks like it should arrive soon Here is a link so you can follow your package as it makes it's way to you! [link removed for privacy] Please let me know if there is anything else I can do! Thanks for being a valuable member of the Cricut family. :) Sandy Cricut Member Care Advocate 877-727-4288
Great video.Thanks for all the info. Don’t quite understand the Cricut WiFi thing. Does it have to be connected constantly while cutting, or just while using Design Space to design something/
I like how this guy talks, it’s relaxing.
Thank you for addressing the weight of each machine. You are the first one I have heard do this. I am a senior with a bad back so that is important to me. Great informative video.
Thank you for the help. I'm trying to buy one for my wife. I think I'm going with the Circuit Maker.
how sweet !
This was the most unbiased review I've watched, thank you!
Thank you so much for watching Natania! 💖
Thanks for the comparison. I am hopeful Cricut will come out with the ability to work offline because I believe the Maker is THE better machine. When I bought an embroidery machine years ago a lady in the shop told me to buy a unit that was several steps above the level I was currently at so I wouldn't be very disappointed. My hubby bought me the top of the line unit and we have never regretted it. You never know when your interests are going to change and go in different directions.
Cricut recently announced that they hope to have design space offline by the end of the year.
I'm brand new to the world of these machines (as in, just beginning my research) and this was super helpful! Thank you!
Glad you find this video helpful ❤
I'm literally just starting to do my "research" on these machines to buy one, which one did you end up buying?
@@xCARPx2014 maker is pretty good but there software is bad so I got the Silhouette software then save svg to cut on the cricuit. Just thought i let you know also cameo just came out with the cameo 4, but I like the maker machine not there software
marie du
I'm just learning about these machines so for the ease of software use, I'm leaning toward the Cricut. I think once we get the hang of it, my husband would also like it. He's quite artistic but not so much a techie. A Cricut may be the option for us.
I'm not techie either, and learning the Cricut and how to use the software was an easy process! :)
Why am I watching this I already bought the maker as an impulsive buy with my stimulus check 😂
The Cricut Maker is an incredible machine!! You'll love it!
I’m ded
How is this impulsive u can turn it into money a profitable business keep going
I haven't done a craft since elementary school, but I really want a Cricut!
Oh you need one!!! You will LOVE it! Cricut Explore Air 2: amzn.to/372w6F4
You had me at "user-friendly". Thanks so much!!
Thank you so much for watching 💖
What a fabulous review! Your explanation was so thorough and covered so many things that I would want to know. And you have such great enthusiasm and positivity!
Thank you so much for your kind words!
You explained and out lined everything so well! Thank you for your thoroughness!
Thank you so much!
You just have the sweetest and nicest vibe! Ty for the video!!!
Aww so sweet. Thank you so much for watching!
Thank you for this review, I have been on the fence about which one is the right choice for me. I have friends telling me the cameo is the right choice, but I feel the cricut maker is able to do what I need a cutting machine to do.
Love my cameo 3 and can download just about any design off the internet and cut it.
Thanks for the vid! You explain things in detail.
You're welcome! Glad you liked it. :)
I have 2 cricut makers and am buying a cameo 4 and keeping all . I want it because of the different software and something new to play around with but love Cricut to !
I really like the look/feel of the Cricut machines...I feel like it is a solid design and quality machine; however, I love the design software in the Cameo (which I own) because I am not limited to their patterns and can create my own unique designs (I have a Graphic Design/Multi-Media background). It is a must for business - doing something different than your competition. If I was a new crafter, Cricut would be the best choice....easier to use/learn software.....perfect for the home user.
You can import or create whatever u want with cricut. I have for years
Very helpful comparisons. Thank you so much for taking the time to post this.
Glad it was helpful!
thank you! i think im going to go with silhouette ! hope its not to complicated for me lol
I’m ready to throw my 4 out the window 😭
Lily Miichelle oh noooo! It is that tough? Lol should I stick with the 3 since that’s what he reviewed?
Great video!!! I have an Explore Air 2 but I really want a Silhouette. I think I like the Silhouette software better. I wish Cricut would make Design Space, better, faster and offline.
Thank you for watching :)
Which machine is more reliable and has good customer service?
Great job! I knew nothing about either machine so didn’t know what questions to ask . You covered it thoroughly in my estimation. Thankyou
So glad you enjoyed it! You should buy now your first Cricut machine, you'll fall in love!🙂
Can't wait for the comparison between the 4 and the Maker. Gods Speed for your traveling home from Hawaii
Thanks, Hannah!
I just beginning to shop, but I think I'm going to go with the circuit machine. Just trying to find a good price. Michaels seems to have the best price. Should I look for one with a bundle?
Yes! We also love the Cricut Explore Air 2, if you don't want to spend so much money on the Maker. The Air 2 is an amazing machine :) Cricut Explore Air 2: amzn.to/2VxAOos
Thank you for making a comparison video that wasn’t 40+ minutes long!
You're welcome!
You do such an AMAZING job explaining things. It has made my pro/con list easier. Thank you
Yay! Thank you so much for watching!
Thanks for this thorough video! This helps with which one I’m going with
yay! So glad this could help you!
I’ve been trying to figure out which one to get, thank you for clarifying things and getting me started😊
So what did you get?
Great video, but wondering if either machine is recommended for someone that would be using the system more for cutting fabric for quilting
The Cricut Maker: amzn.to/2S1iFNB is the best machine for cutting fabric :)
Just purchased the Cameo 3 , I hadn't watched this first, but glad I got what I did. I really like the unbiased comparison
Thank you!
I bought the Silhouette earlier this year now I think that I'm going to send it back, after listening to you.
Well we can't speak for the silhouette community, but we really enjoy our Cricuts and how easy they are to use!
looking to purchase for senior center. most clients are 65+ very good comparison
Thank you! Best of luck!
We had the silhouette for over 7 yrs but Costco had a good deal on the cricut ultimate package for 399.99 it has the commercial stuff. The huge difference is you don’t need to pay for the free svg file upload but silhouette you need to pay to use the svg upload
Tanner i hope you will do a comparison of the silhouette cameo 4 vs maker
Yes please !!
Cameo 3 dont compaire to the maker so this is not a true comparision. Now if you was reviewing the cameo 4 and maker I would get it but this is not good
@@RainorShine1 what is no good ?. Woul you recomend cameo 4 ?
Awesome review!! Thank u for this!❤️I'm probably going with the cricut!!
Recently received an email from Cricut regarding their development of design space offline capabilities hopefully by the end of year. Really looking forward to it
I'm so excited for the offline capability too!
Very good comparison! Thank you for the information. I’ve looked at so many videos. This one has helped tremendously!
We're so happy to hear that! Thank you so much for watching and commenting Nikia!
Best review of these I’ve seen; you were so informative! Thank you! 🙌🏻
I see the silhouette 4 comes out next month- any ideas how it will compare??
Great video! Very informative!
Thank you!
Hi, i'm new to this craft. But you really gave me a good infos regarding two different brands. Thus Cricut is android friendly or jst apple gadgets.?thank you
I got the Cricut Maker in February and completely regret it. I got it to use mainly for vinyl/various paper cutting. I regrettably did not start using the machine until recently and encountered so many issues. My main three gripes are 1)online design studio that freezes on me constantly and is just slow and I have fast internet. 2)The limited print then cut page space, its ridiculous how many paper space I waste because of the limited size. 3) The most frustrating is the misalignment when cutting, I'm not sure if it's my machine and a defect but I can not for the life of me cut anything out aligned. Everything cuts too far to the left, I tried to adjust the page on the mat to account for this but didnt work. Anyways, I'm in contact with Cricut regarding this, hoping that it gets resolved because I have a machine that I cant use. I was so frustrated and really needed something to assist with my paper goods orders and ended up getting the Silhouette Portrait at a discount and I am so impressed with it. Cuts beautifully and I love love love the design studio and the ability to outline what you are cutting, setting offsets and insets, being able to color code lines to cut and have the machine adjust blade automatically to cutting those lines in one go instead of having to reload, and I love the ability to use all the page during a print and cut. If the little portrait can do all this, I so regret not getting the cameo 3 instead.
@guess what Hey there! One of the main difference is the size of the machines. The portrait takes 8.5 inch wide x 11in or smaller paper, the mat is 8.5x12in. The Cameo takes in 12x12 sheets. If you will be cutting out images that big or projects that require that size paper I'd say go with the cameo. You can do alot more should you choose to because of paper size. However if you dont need that 12x12 size you can do alot with the portrait. I went with the portrait since currently I dont have a need to do anything bigger than the 8.5x11 and since I spent so much on the Maker. Just an update though, Cricut refunded me for the Maker which was so amazing. Thier customer service was phenomenal and helpful, so grateful I was able to send the machine back. I am holding out for the Silhouette Cameo 4 that's coming out :) Hope that helps! I love the Portrait, it's got a small form factor and so far has no let me down with all the stuff I had it do. You cant go wrong with either choice!
@guess what From my research it seems to just be improved on a number of things. One main feature is the cutting force is much more than Cameo 3. This is useful if you plan on cutting other hefty materials like leather or balsa wood. There is a dual-motor instead of single as well and the cutting speed is 3x faster. Honestly, if you are going to be working mainly with paper then I see no reason to not purchase the Cameo 3. Personally, I am just a techy person and love all the bright new shiny upgrades that come out. The Portrait has not let me down as of yet, it's small and fits my needs. I haven't got the need to purchase a bigger machine so although I say I'm waiting for the 4, I most likely will not be purchasing it any time soon. I recommend looking at the Cameo 3 and 4 youtube videos. There are a lot as well as a google search will give you sites where people compare the two. If you want to wait for the 4 because you like it more, then go for it. If you find that the Cameo 3 more than suits your need and use then I say go for that one. With the Silhouette, I say you can't go wrong with any :)
@guess what I think that's a great choice! I would have gotten that too if I didnt have the Portrait. Enjoy it!!!
@@dustydreamer424 glad i read your experience. Quick question..i have my own programs that i create my own designs. Would i be able to transfer those images to the program that comes with portrait? Reason I'm asking is there was another review saying something about that but it was unclear
@@MegaChevy65 Hi! I believe you can. I usually create the original image in illustrator or photoshop, sometimes on my ipad and send to my computer for touch up. I save my image files as png or svg (you have to pay for svg add on I think for the silhouette program which I didnt mind doing since I loved the program so much) and am able to import it into the silhouette program with no issues. From there you can manipulate the image if needed (size, quantity on a page, adjust cut lines if you want a white line around the image or want it cut precisely on your draw line, etc). Just to be sure, you can download the silhouette program online for free and import the images you are creating to ensure you can without issue. I could be wrong but I dont think you need to purchase the machine before hand to get the program.
User friendly has sold me on the Cricut for sure. Thank you so much for the honest review.
Jami Womack my sister and i were discussing her Silhouette 3 the other day. I have 2 of the older Cricut machines that take cartridges and I asked her if her machine had that. She explained a little bit about how you get your images and I was like I think that would be too much for me to figure out lol I’m HORRIBLE with the computer. I still have all of my cartridges and other machines do i think i will probably choose the Cricut because it’s “user friendly” !!
@@MichelleJ1822 Thanks for taking the time to answer my question. I need all the help I can get. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving.
Very helpful and concise! Thank you for not making this video super long.
Yay! Thank you for your kind words!
Thank you for this video! You are awesome! I’m going with a cricut maker! :)
I have had an Original cameo and a Cameo 3 I can't wait for the Cameo 4 pro to come out!! I use the Cameo for tons of stuff and it works great. of course I have used the cameo for years so I feel the Cameo program is so much easier the Cricut. But again could be because I have used it for so many years. AND THANKS FOR MAKING A VIDEO WITH A CAMEO!
I'm so excited about the Cameo 4 too! Thank you for watching :)
Can you use svg or png designs with the cameo without buying the software? I have a few different software that I use with my laser machine and I have a ton of designs on my PC that I'd love to be able to just send to the cameo. It wasn't very clear in the video about the need for software. I'm not sure how all of that works:)
@@dianaw4072 your cameo comes with the basic software for svg you will need to upgrade to designer edition. But you can get cameo connect and cut direct form.corel draw and adobe illustrator.
@@dianaw4072 I don't have a cameo 3, but I was able to download the free software. I was able to save my inkscape svg design as a dxf file (Desktop Cutting Plotter). When it asks, select file type: ROBO-Master type of spline output. Click ok. I was able to open that dxf file in the program. It seems a little larger than my original design, and since I don't have the actual machine to test it on, it may be problematic, but I will keep working on it to see if I can figure out if the mistake was mine or theirs. (BTW dxf is an AutoCad drawing format. I used to work with AutoCad, and loved it. Just can't afford it now!) Hope that helps just a little! I also realize that by now, two months later, you may have already figured out your issue.
Nice comparison, but was really hoping for like a side by side cut test, what it takes to cut each shape etc.
Great suggestion!
Omg your so cute and happy! thanks for this!
Thank you for watching!
Which one is better to make HTV SHIRTS???
Both can cut HTV fine, but we're partial to the Cricut because it's easier to learn and use :)
Well you sold me on the Cricut Maker :) I have had the Silhouette Cameo with the business designer edition software for a few years now and I have a love/hate relationship with it . I spend most time trying to find my Registration Marks to a point that I have almost tossed the entire thing out the window. Thanks for the review.
Mannnnn! If this isn't the story of my life. I truly understand what you mean and am soooo on the fence at what to do. As far as capabilities the Cameo would work best for me....but the registration mark thing....ugh! A thorn in my side!
Cricut is awful with finding the marks.
How does the Maker compare to the Cameo 4?
Excellent review/comparison on both machines! I appreciate the unbiased information, just presenting the facts. I know nothing about either one, so this was very helpful, thank you. I must say, the "user friendly" speaks loudly, especially since I know nothing about this craft.
I love your personality 💕
Awe, thank you so much!
Are you able to cut multiple sheets of paper at the same time? Let's say for example I needed 30 students to have a card stop cut to a particular shape. Which would be the most time efficient to use? Also, If I want to cut out phrases, or words on vinyl. Do I need to do them at the same time, or is there a way to cut faster? I've never seen one used, time is my biggest concern. I want a tool that would be the fastest to cut. What do you recommend?
You can cut as many as will fit on an 11.5x11.5 or 11.5x23.5 mat :)
Is cricket still wireless only now? Thank you so much this was great!
No, you can use the cord, we do 90% of the time :)
You are amazing, subscribed as I really enjoyed this...xoxo
Great vid exactly all the questions I had are answered
we're so glad :)
Thank you, great info and I've decided to go Cricut, thanks for helping!
You'll love your Cricut machine for sure. Thank you for watching :)
I love my Silhouette! If you're fairly comfortable using a pc then you'll do just fine. The graphic options are fanstatic. From what most Cricut users post, they have to use an a additional program like Inkscape to get more design options.
So this just made me realize I need BOTH... sigh..
How right you are!
@@kineybus2473 bought a maker and rarely use it and bought a Glowforge and now I'm looking at a cameo like should I buy you and let you sit on the shelf too??? Decisions Decisions
I decided on the cricut maker. I do like it so far.
Thank you for watching! :)
Also, the cut file types for the Silhouette Cameo are .dxf which if you have Adobe Illustrator like I do you can export a file to .dxf and open it in the free Silhouette Studio software for custom designs.
Thanks for watching and commenting!
If cricut is online based only, could theoretically in the future become obsolete once they stop supporting it? or can you also use other software?
@Bunkerd Paintball at Cowtown that sucks! That's why I think twice about buying one
I have the original Cricut that came out. I purchased thinking I would use and do alot of scapbooking when I retited.....so it was purchased about 11 years ago along with over $10,000.00 in all kinds of cartriges, scapbooking paper, books, embelisments and you name it. Now 11 years later I am just getting around to thinking about using it. Because it is so out dated and can not be hooked to Internet I am seriously thinking of purchasing the Explorer Air 2 because that is the only machine that still offers to be able to use the cartriges. I guess I don't want to feel my original purchase was a loss because so old but would like to stay with the times also. Like to see what your opinion would be on this situation and where you feel best place to purchase one would be if you agree with my thinking....and what price do you feel they should run. I was shocked when you told of price of Maker as I have never seen lower than 399, in Upstate NY. By the way I also am an Independent Designer for Chalk Couture....more as a Hobbyist though. That is my problem....I have too many Hobbies!!!!!! Would appreciate your feed back. Jo in NY.
Jo Terwilliger Hi! You can get an adapter for your machine to sync all your cartridges to your software.
But yes, now the expression is outdated. I would recommend an air or Maker!
Now that The cameo 4 is out, will you be doing another comparison video? This was very helpful btw, leaning more toward the cricut I think 🤔
I just need something for my business. I want to be able to easily make my own vinyl lipgloss labels and making custom clothing (stencils for print making) etc.
Which one did you buy?
I think the cricut air 2 will be more for you.
i use both machines
so, which one has more functionalities? why u are not making a table where you write the differences?
The Cricut Maker has more functionalities :) Feel free to be writing down the differences as you hear them
Thanks for your views I'm really thinking about hopping in on one of these. Thanks man 👊
Thank you for watching and commenting!
Ok i know this is a year old but is cricut still internet based? Am I going to need internet to use the machine all the time?
Yes, with any newer machine you will use it digitally on a software like Design Space which you will use on your laptop, desktop, tablet, or smartphone.
You are awesome! I am in the process of choosing one! I heard these other ladies saying cameo was the best. Then I hear cricut maker is awesome! I am new snd confused
this helped thanks! you're so adorable! great video
I'm so glad! Thanks for watching and commenting!
I use silhouette and I upload free svgs. I’ve never paid to use them in the software. (Using it since August 2018)
Same. And I have the cricut maker
Michaela McRae how are you uploading for free
Same
@@CluelessMamaD she didn't answer lol
I have used SVG files in the studio as well. You just open them as a new project. 🤷♀️ I use the free Beta version of the software.
Wow, awesome review on both machines. I'm looking to use one of these machines to buy and print planner stickers off of Etsy onto my own sticker paper and then cut it. But I'm still not sure which one I should go with.
Depending on what you want to do. The Silhouette software is so much better then the cricuit. If you are gonna do any fabric or would then get maker. But cameo came out with the cameo 4 which is like the maker. But if you just doing stickers I say the cameo one. Or get the maker and use the Silhouette software. What I do now as i don't have money for new machine
I am really hoping that cricut will make a standalone software for PC. it is seriously a pain in the butt to have to go online just to cut vinyl. What happens when the internet is down, do i take my cricut with me to the nearest starbucks and cut my design there?
The older models of the cricut don't need a PC, but it just cuts basic shapes or preloaded cartridges.
They actually just announced that they will have just that by the end of the year!
I’m really looking forward to the Silhouette 4, would love to see that comparison. I did love my original Silhouette & I had the design version. Loved not relying on WiFi and Design Space going down all the time. Still have that machine.
I'm so excited about the Cameo 4 too! Thank you for watching :)
I would also like to see a comparison of the Cameo 4.
So helpful to this newbie! Thanks!☺️
Glad you find this video helpful ❤ Thank you for watching!
Thanks...the Cricut for me
Good choice! :)
Didnt tallk about the print and cut! The maker can only cut images mesa than a letter size page while the Cameo can cut up to 12 inches by 24 inches..
yes, thats cool
I am a Cricut user, I have the maker, but I am looking at purchasing a Silhouette for its ability to do rhinestones. Any suggestions?
So I’m looking for a machine that can cut up to 19 inches high... which machine does that?
Jennifer Harding Cricut can cut 11 1/2 x23 1/2
Where and how ,can I purchase the cricut maker for $359.
Thank u .
Amazon has it for $357.49 as of 10/21/19
Michaels is 350.00
Thank you this was definitely helpful! Now I need to choose between the maker or the explorer - I'm not sure what is available in South Africa!
We recommend the Maker just because you're not really limited if in the future you were interested in using more of the adaptive tools :)
Do you have to have an iPad to use these
Great comparison video ~ thank you! ❤️
Great review
thank you
Hello Tanner and welcome bak. Aloha.. thanks so much for this very informative video. I do love my Cricut and still learning the tips and tricks to it. Still using my Explorer 2. After I take your Pro class I plan to switch them out. I really appreciate you enhancing my view on both.
Thanks,
Karidad
YAY! See you at the Pro class :)
Thank you this was very helpful as a newbie I'm headed toward a cricut.
You will LOVE your Cricut! We highly recommend them!
i am so interested with cricut maker. i am living here in davao city philippines. where is the nearest store here that i can purchase this product? need it badly
You can purchase it right off the Cricut website! :) ruclips.net/user/redirect?v=eVupeRZIx2g&redir_token=YuR2MVrtmDmg3gYGtz9MYoTJad18MTU4ODA4MTc1MkAxNTg3OTk1MzUy&event=video_description&q=https%3A%2F%2Fgoo.gl%2FwHgGjr
you explained that so well, don't take any notice of people that think you were biased. A lot of "crafters" are not super tech savvy and you gave information that def helps make a choice in that aspect. Everyone needs to just take a breathe and not take this personally! You don't need to be so nasty grils!
Thank you for your kind words :) We're glad you enjoyed the video Miss Sally!
Thanks so much for this informative video!
Thank you Lisa. 💖
Thank you very much for the comparison! It was great and unbiased and addressed just about every question I have except this one (I have been looking for the answer for a couple hours); do either of these machines cut longer sizes (ie for a sign that would be 46”) so it’s all on one piece of vinyl? Or will they have to be separate sheets? I already found that the cameo doesn’t require that you have a cutting board behind it like the Cricut does so does that mean I can cut longer?
Great question! It would have to be multiple pieces of vinyl. Hope this helps.
Makers Gonna Learn yes it does! Too bad though lol I saw a tutorial on a sign done a year ago n she said she used the cameo (not sure version because she had the vinyl made already), it looked like it was all one piece so that’s why I was searching for the answer! Thank u for getting back so quickly ☺️
I ordered a Cricut Maker on 2/26. As of 3/9, the order was still in a processing status on their website. During that time I actually ordered (on 3/2) AND received (on 3/6) a Silhouette Cameo with no issues. So I called Cricut to cancel. The first rep I spoke with left me to die on hold for 25 minutes. The second rep I spoke with told me that she had cancelled the order and I'd be receiving an email about it. She straight up lied. The order was not cancelled. The company must threaten its employees with bad consequences for cancelling orders, that's the only reason this kind of thing happens.
I emailed Cricut customer service and requested they fix it. They sent me back a copy/paste email saying "Good news, your order has been shipped! We're closing your ticket as resolved." Now I've had to go to my bank, dispute the charge, cancel my card and wait two weeks for a new one because of their dishonesty. Otherwise I'd have to mail back the Cricut at my own cost and pay a 20% restocking fee ($85) because they refused to cancel my order.
I emailed the CEO and VP of Sales at Cricut last night explaining all of that and stating that I will either refuse the shipment or, if it's dropped off when I'm not home, hold it until they send me a return shipping label. As of yet I haven't received a reply.
The whole experience has been an extreme hassle and aggravation from the start and I can't wait to be done with it. The company hasn't done one right or honest thing since the moment I placed my order. I couldn't in good conscience recommend anyone buying from them or continuing to deal with them. Especially considering the fact that the Silhouette is cheaper, can do everything the maker can do, and arrived quickly and with zero hassle.
My email exchange with Cricut:
Your request summary is:
Joseph Hackman
Mar 9, 9:03 PM MDT
I placed this order on 2/25/2020 and expected to receive it within a
week. When I had not received it by 3/3/2020, I put in an order for one
of your competitor's products instead - a Silhouette Cameo 4. That
company got me their product by 3/6/2020, the same week.
Today I called your company at 11:10AM Eastern U.S. time to cancel my
order with you, since it was still in "Processing" status. The first person I
spoke with, a man, talked with me for about three minutes and then
asked to put me on hold while he checked on the order. He left me on
hold for another 23 minutes without ever checking back. I hung up the
phone and called back. The second time I got a woman who, after
putting me on hold for 15 minutes, came back and assured me that the
order was cancelled and that I would be receiving an email notifying me
of the cancellation and the expected refund date.
I used to work for Sprint, the phone company, where they played these
same shitty games, so I took the precaution of recording my
conversations with both of your representatives just in case this exact
thing happened. Either your employees make commission based on a
low cancel percentage metric or their employment is negatively
impacted by a high cancel percentage, so they outright lie to customers
or let them die on hold rather than process a cancellation. Your
employees did both today, and both conversations were recorded by
me on a second phone, which is legal in the state of Kentucky as long
as one party is aware that the conversation is being recorded, and I was
that party.
Knowing full well that the woman I spoke with lied as soon as the
words came out of her mouth, I checked back on your website to see
that the order still showed as "Processing" instead of "Cancelled". I also
took timestamped screenshots of that order page before and after my
conversations with your employees. I wanted to pursue the issue
further with your company via email, like I'm doing now, but I had to
stop what I was doing and take one of my sons hours away to see a
doctor, which took all day.
I just returned home to find that the order now shows a status of
"Shipped". Let me explain to you what that means to me.
If your company had processed my order correctly, I wouldn't own a
Cameo, but you didn't. If your company had processed my cancellation
properly and honestly as you were supposed to have, perhaps I would
have found that I didn't like my Cameo and wanted to try Cricut again,
or that later on I wanted to try Cricut again anyway to expand the
variety of my work. But you didn't do that. Instead of making a friend or
a potential FUTURE customer, you chose to make an enemy instead.
There is no way I am keeping your machine at this point, not a chance
in hell. I am returning it immediately after receipt. What happens after
that point is entirely up to you. If your company reimburses me the full
$423.99 payment on the order plus whatever shipping charges it costs
me to return the machine to you that I never should have received, we
can still part ways peacefully. If instead you choose to stand behind
your employees lies, failure to cancel my order, and fraudulent
shipping of this order and not reimburse me for my return shipping
cost, I will go so very far out of my way to share all screenshots and
recordings of your company's handling of my order in every online
marketplace I can find where it will have the most impact, causing as
much bad publicity for you as I possibly can, and I guarantee that it'll
end up costing you more than processing my request to cancel the
order would have. That's all I have to say. The ball is once again in your
court.
The reply:
Your request (2345878) has been updated. To add additional comments, reply to this
email.
Sandy (Cricut)
Mar 10, 11:57 AM MDT
Hello Joseph,
Good news - Your package is on its way!
The tracking number is 168574947729, 168574947730
It looks like it should arrive soon
Here is a link so you can follow your package as it makes it's way to you!
[link removed for privacy]
Please let me know if there is anything else I can do! Thanks for being a valuable
member of the Cricut family. :)
Sandy
Cricut Member Care Advocate
877-727-4288
Sorry to hear about your issues, I hope you can get crafty soon!
Can you only use a iPad with the cricut? I'm looking for a cutter that I can use a tablet with.
You can use most tablets too, yes
Can I use a iPad to set up the Cricut and use for project? Or do I need a computer?
you can use an Ipad :)
Thank you so much my friend love your channel.
Thank you, sweet Kiki!
I’ve been wanting to get one of these for a while now and you definitely hit all the points for the questions I had!! Ty!! 😊
Thank you so much for watching Jessica!
Great video.Thanks for all the info. Don’t quite understand the Cricut WiFi thing. Does it have to be connected constantly while cutting, or just while using Design Space to design something/
I believe IOS has an iphone/ ipad app that allows it to work offline, but I´m not 100% sure. Otherwise no, it needs to be online.
Loved your comparison!!! I hope to upgrade soon!!!!
Thank you, Brenda 😊