The thing about Venus taking on martial qualities makes a lot of sense for him. Think about his "brand" of militarism, everything from the Nazi uniforms to the stark architecture of Albert Speer. He didn't just want to conquer, he wanted to conquer in style
People tend to associate Hitler with Aries sign, but his Sun, Mars, Venus in tropical Taurus were also strong and prominent in his life, yet overlooked for his Arian traits. Taurus placements helped his artistic streak: a lover painting and opera, and he was often indolenent watching movies and eating pastries. Towards the end of WWII, he was very stubborn, forbidding retreat, and using sluggish fortress defense strategies (where armies would allow themselves to be surrounded in a certain stronghold and fought to the last man). At times he exhibited martian qualities (blitzkierg), and at other times Taurean qualities (fortress defense).
If you're saying Hitler was not idealistic, I feel sorry to say that, but you don't know much about Hitler. He believed strongly in his mission and fate and identified himself with lots of various things related to the terms such as 'occult', 'philosophy', and 'religion'. It's not a conspiracy, even though you won't read it on Wikipedia. I couldn't finish your video. You seem to be a professional, why don't you just research things before you create a final opinion?
Superb.... brilliantly presented....loved it... would love to see your analysis of Astrologer's chart .....Shri KN Rao, Pt. Sanjay Rath, Sam Geppi, BV Raman, Ernst Wilhelm, Marc Boney and identify patterns if any...please think about this request....thank you
Vic, thanks for this video. Using your technique of tropical rashis and sidereal nakshatras made better sense of his hatred and aggression. He has three planets in Purva-Ashada, the most violent of nakshatras. Jupiter and Ketu amplifies this violence and involvement of 10th lord Moon means he made a career out of it. He used Capricorn to give this tremendous rage a practical expression - first as a soldier (Is not army a Capricorn entity?) and then as a politician (once more Capricorn) and then as a dictator (Capricorn again!). Real culprit here is not the much vilified Mars or Saturn but Capricorn and Purva-Ashada. He was not a practical guy but a fanatic (Purva-Ashada) who used practical (Capricorn) methods in pursuit of his goal.
It's incorrect that Hitler was not spiritual, his entire contention with the jewish was their differentiation between animals and humans, this non-distinguishing thought of Adolf Hitler is clearly a sign of spiritual understanding and universalism. There is nothing to suggest that Hitler's actions can judge him a non-spiritualist, Hitler killed demons, Krsna killed demons, what is the difference of objective? If you read the diaries of Hitler's associates they describe his entire endeavour against the Jewish based on their cruelty toward lower life-forms, this is great compassion, this is not a symptom of a man of brutality, killing demons isn't brutality, but Dharma.
"Hence today I believe that I am acting in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator: by defending myself against the Jews, I am fighting for the work of the Lord."
One point that is in favor of the interpretation of Hitler's chart according to the Tropical Zodiac is the analysis of the Chandra Lagna. Who can believe that in Chandra lagna, the emotional nature of the native Hitler can have Hamsa Yoga in conjunction with the Moon? (and in trine with the Sun in Aries in 5th house), I have only seen such a conjunction in people of high ideals and even holiness, and it is even more unlikely that the lagna lord of Chandra lagna is in Hamsa yoga in sidereal. It is much more understandable The Lord of the lunar lagna and dipositor of the moon and Jupiter : Saturn in Leo in the 8th house in an enemy sign, and making an aspect to Libra lagna in D-1, which is also a probable sign of suicide ...
Please keep doing these videos ☺️. Also it makes sense for his first lord to be in 8th in its own sign. Anyone who can go from extremes from rags to riches should have strong 8th house. First house needs to be strong for the chart overall to be strong. Then he was very secretive and working behind the scenes.
I don't even know where to start... siderealy We have Libra asc with Venus in 7th house basically dominated by all these grahas in Aries. Mars in its own sign and exalted Sun plus Mercury, with this we can see enormous focus on other people in life, on society, country with Arian pursuit of victory and supremacy, these man was seeing his country in shambles after WWI and this propelled him to carry enormous burden through life... But before that during Sun dasha he was living in poor condition, Sun is cooking all grahas in 7th except Venus... such is nature of the Sun to turn into cinders material things, burn attachments so only soul remains... probably in this time Hitler found his true power that was beyond this world in one way or the other. Then came Moon dasha and WWI when he was fighting on a front, Saturn in 10th forms a Raj Yoga which shows his capacity, emotional fortitude and intelligence (4th and 10th) to carry the burden of responsibility plus his Moon is in 3rd delighted by Jupiter(3rd and 6th lord, fighting, enemies etc.) and joined Ketu... this guy had insane courage within him, probably during a war he was and inspiring figure to other soldiers. Also Purva Ashadha is not strategist and for sure is not pragmatic, Hitler was inspired and inspiring person fanatical even and it mainly comes from P.Ashadha. After the WWI seeing his country in shambles he shifted into Mars dasha what activated all this power in 7th, driven by Mars he gained fame , support and ultimately absolute power in a country what is more he was surrounded by extremely talented people that helped him turn almost bankrupt country into force that had capacity to challenge entire world. With tropical we get entirely different flavor, more grounded and materialistic... this guy was driven by fire!
After following your videos for a few years now, I'm just amazed to see how something so good can go so wrong, and with all your knowledge and wisdom, your persistence of proving your tropical system over traditional sidereal can lead you to such an absurd ignorance towards the most basic rules of astrology. So here are a few questions, I hope can help you with understanding the importance of the actual position of the planets in the sky regardless of the zodiac. As a matter of fact, I'm happy to see you coming to the conclusion that zodiacs are not that much of a factor compare to the house the planet occupies and how your tropical system can be so wrong in this regard. As you choose very famous people for your examples in the last 3 comparison charts, so the foremost and most outstanding factor for all these individuals is their fame, and their leadership, which brings different aspects related to the 10th house. Questions: 1- In Trump chart how can you totally ignore Sun as Atmakaraka (when interpreting a king chart in traditional Vedic astrology sense), especially when it's conjunct with Rahu and all those humiliations and adverse fame we all know about him? And how come you don't see the Jupiter in 2th house (FYI, he inherited all his wealth from his family)? 2- In the Einstein chart, the 10th house is even more outstanding when Sun, Saturn, Mercury, and Venus all occupy the 10, especially with his Saturn in 10th and his longlasting fame for his great contributions to humanity. The same goes for his Jupiter in the 9th house as the indication for his deep wisdom that guided many scientists to this day. How come you don't see that? 3- As for Hitler, again Saturn in 10th house and his longstanding fame for the destruction he caused. And also how can you ignore the combination of Moon and Ketu for someone who can penetrate into the minds of the people, with expanding influence by Jupiter conjunct the both, to move the masses only through the speeches he gave when all 3 Graha sits in the 3rd house of communication? As for his 7th house with Sun and Mars with the strong aspect of Saturn on 7th, again it should be obvious why he caused such misery and destruction to the people. All of the questions above are regardless of the zodiac. Just the houses. So the most important question that remains is how can you ignore all these obvious Vedic rules, (regardless of Zodiac) to prove tropical over Sidereal? I don't want to go deeper into more of these obvious flaws in your readings, as these few simple examples should be enough for someone who knows the basics of Vedic astrology. The more comparison video you make the more you disprove yourself to someone who knows Vedic astrology. Regardless of all the nice comments, you get from most of your followers who don't have a clue about Vedic astrology. I'm just so disappointed and sad again to see such a brilliant mind can go so wrong with his ego. (The dark side of all those nice comments someone gets from youtube?) Just to make it clear, I hope you understand that I have nothing against you personally, just love and respect for all the effort and your teachings. But I can't stand someone who guides the people in the wrong direction. I have a thing to fight for the truth. I hope this time instead of attacking or ignoring me you engage in a respectful debate. Peace and light.
Adel Moradi listen this video again , may be 10 times .. this is the best video for Vedic astrology till date ... why don’t you convince sidereal gurus to come up with such video , where differences are explained on basis of zodiac signs .. Vic did both interpretations and proves that both systems are correct but when we go deep down we can tuneup the interpretation ...
@@eisa17 I'm not sure if you know the basic of Vedic astrology, if so just ask yourself what make someone famous? What makes someone a strong leader? or other questions I proposed. Then look at the charts. you don't need to watch the video's for someone else tells you the truth. The charts speak for themselves. There's no need to blindly follow or defend someone you like. Use your own brain! All I have for Vic Ji is love and gratitude, and I believe he's one of the best Vedic astrologers on youtube. I learned so many things from him, and that's why I care about his teaching and spend time commenting on his videos. ISo don't get me wrong please that I'm here to discredit him. We are all here to learn and share our thoughts, hoping to find a way out of these dilemmas and confusion and revive the astrology to its rightful place as it used to be. I really won't mind if he would stick to his own system but his persistence in disproving and discrediting traditional Vedic astrology is something I can't cope with. Love & Light
Complaints If you think I know my stuff, then please question your opinion that I don’t grasp the basics of Vedic astrology. If you can’t do that, then question your opinion that I know my stuff. You can’t have both opinions: that I know my stuff but I don’t know my stuff. Reviewing your three objections, it is clear to me that you have a simple problem common to all new and perennial novices: you think that isolating a factor here and there is a superior methodology than the rigorous, complete, integrated (multi-)chart holistic approach I have shown in the three videos you are referring to. 1 - Atmakaraka for Trump You want me to use atmakaraka. I’m sorry, I don’t use Jaimini techniques. You may consider Jaimini “basic” but Jaimini did not consider Jaimini basic. Jaimini describes itself as an appendix to Parashari. After I have mastered Parashari I will try to master Jaimini. Nonetheless from what little I know of Jaimini I suspect that you are using the wrong karaka to see fame. I think one would use the 2nd (amatya), not the 1st (atma) karaka. Also, I have heard one rule in an eclipse, Rāhu becomes atmakaraka. Anyway, without that rule, and with a tropical Zodiac Trumps atmakaraka is his Mars, isn’t it? And that doesn’t seem to present any interpretive problem at all. Frankly I never use this system, so let’s not dabble. 2 - Einstein’s 10th You want to say that a house with 4 planets is better than a house with 3? It doesn’t get more novice than that. You need to either stop thinking I am someone worth listening to, or start watching my videos carefully and learning how to really do astrology. Real charts are actually way more complex than your 1-point questions. So please either give up on me, or watch my videos way more carefully and with an attitude of a student. Without that attitude you should save time and watch someone else. 3 - You Want Saturn in Hitler’s 10th house Your way of looking at a chart is absolutely novice. If you feel insulted by that statement, please forgive me and move on to some other knowledge-outlet for information on Vedic astrology. Rather than try unsuccessfully to summarize my entire presentations on Trump, Einstein, and Hitler in a reply to you, please allow me to request that you either write me off as a fool or take a more humble approach and watch these videos from the start with a fresh, clean slate mind, a few times - and see how astrology should be done. In fact not just you, but across the board I have found that the biggest challenge I face in demonstrating the practical superiority of the tropical zodiac is simply that no one agrees on how to practice astrology effectively in the first place.
Vic DiCara's Astrology Dear , I think few people consider Astrology as religion and any change in religion is not acceptable to them unless they are convinced that some avatar /prophet is here to amend their religious texts ..interesting thing is that it’s not even in the books still they believe it’s there , it’s very tough task you are trying to achieve .. you can make new followers but to break old mindset towards you is near to impossible.
You have me sold on the tropical argument. Although I wish sidereal was the right one (because according to that chart I have like 4 raj yogas regarding my ascendant lord & ascendant sign shift) I gotta stick with my not-so-stellar tropical version in comparison. Really interesting video though Vic. You on the up and up.
Oh, he didn't design "his" logo :)) " In Hinduism, the symbol with arms pointing clockwise (卐) is called swastika, symbolizing surya ('sun'), prosperity and good luck, while the counterclockwise symbol (卍) is called sauvastika, symbolizing night or tantric aspects of Kali."
He did design the logo, apart from swastika there are other elements, he put all these elements together as per his vision, swastika doesnt equal to logo
@@surveysergei3209 "his vision" ,, please. The "logo" is white circle on red background. The flag has a few black stripes- great vision, great design. Ok.
Omg... my chart is very similar :// :)) Rahu in 10H ; Sa in Leo ; Ve + Sun in Taurus ; Me in Aries ..:)) I can't get used to the look of these charts - I use the wheel for Siderial .
Hello Vic, I have got Venus and Jupiter in exact degree and Neptune in 1.5 degree orb all in Moola Nakshatra. This mean Jupiter will loss even if it's in his own house?
Subbed, feeling drawn to Vedic. I have been studying both systems but I love the detail you go into and Vedic seems to provide the deeper meanings. Anyone you recommend for certification in Vedic as an astrologer? Thanks for your hard work.
In southern part of the india, there are several literature around ego and how to get rid of ego, etc. And it's a practice even today to ask the married couples to be separated in june-july (basically to avoid having sex) so that the Baby won't be born in April-May as the Baby will then have an exalted Sun. And with exalted Sun, one tend to have excessive ego.? Wish Hitler's parents were separated like that :P
You invite ppl to debate with you on the tropical sidereal issue and then, even go on to delete their comments to your videos. Why delete the comment made by Richard Fidler? If you want siderealists to react constructively on your criticism of them, you shd we willing to do the same from your side as well. If you don't agree with them, you can simply ignore isn't it? Let the comment stay there and ppl can decide for themselves. Disappointing.
Regarding Richard Fidler: I don't know what you are referring to, but if you give more detail I will undelete that. Either I wasn't the one who deleted it, or it was unintentional. Do you remember any of the text from his comment? What else did I delete?
So I was actually thinking through the Sidereal and Tropical stuff and I think there’s an interesting point about tropical- because Tropical is bound to the seasons- I wouldn’t exactly call it astrology. It’s more like a kind of geomancy where the stars are actually signs of EARTHLY influences, think about it. The signs being ties to the seasons means the primary influence is earthly because the seasons are an earthly phenomenon and an important one when it comes to character development. I mean, the earth IS a celestial body and has the most profound impact, so that’s a thing. The parts of tropical astrology then that are actually astrological in the strictest sense would be aspects. So considering it this way, it’s not really so much about the influence of the stars in their current positions, it’s about using the stars as markers for the earth’s influence.
Hitlers chart has in tropical , Chiron ( deepest wound) in the ninth house. Showing relationship between higher learning relationship to farther and it really was his deepest wound.
How about doing Pablo Picasso? I don't know much about his life aside that he was a successful painter, but apparently in sidereal vedic he has 4 debilitated planets.
I feel his asexual traits point at a 8th house Taurus without Lodgers and a limitedvenus in 7th house. He hated the fact that being penetrated and vulnerable and loving is essential to the human existence. Denial of something so natural reminds me of someone in power today btw. Love this channel
You look like a lion does the animal also act on the appearance of the naksatra? And also does the last pada like for example 22.40 degrees I saw it spills in dhanishta cause my ascendant falls in that range I'm not sure
Do yall think maybe this guy wasnt so evil as people think... i think he was spiritual not religious if u really study this guy alot stuff will blow your mind...
He definitely isnt as bad as other dictators i feel like he did want to help his country but went too far and was also on meth which didnt help either hes very interesting
@@VicDiCaraAstrology I think he believed in forces higher then himself the meta physical he definitely studied the Egypt pantheon of dietys heru the son he was in tune with nature he was into the occult knowledge I can go on and on
@@roflswamp6 maybe maybe not I read stuff about that ....when u fighting evil forces and your not that u need something sometimes to put u in that mind set to bring out that dark aspect of u to go to war don't mean nothing
@@energy_kit_999 i get what ur saying sometimes u gotta get faded when u know ur about to scrap fools even tho u dont actually wanna harm nobody sometimes u just gotta be down
@@VicDiCaraAstrology Rewatched your video, my mistake. I just found the April 20th birthday and the two words being a homonym such a strange coincidence - was that day the first of Taurus that year, a cusp? Thanks.
Yep, his big three are a Sun and a rising Taurus, and a Cap moon. I have a similar big three, just my Sun is in Libra, Moon in Cap, and a Taurus rising. Lol. Really close to my mom, not my father (was never close and don't really know him, but I'm not going around killing a bunch of people, or being a menace. I'm in a very poor situation, always been rough, loved art, and piano when I was a kid, but didn't get the chance to be successful at it. Wasn't great with school, students, or teachers.
@@dannyshephard6292 So I'm Cancer Sun, Aries Moon & Leo ascendant in my Western Zodiac, what would my Nakshatras be here? Would it be the same as they were in Vedic?
I dont belive in sideral only tropical! In the tropical im aries,sideral pisces. IM ARIES 100 PRECENT, i did martial arts,im aggressive,have no diplomacy,,no manipulation skills like pisces.im masculine for a woman,i wore military trousers n boots. This cant explain maybe im pisces in sideral but i have 5 planets in aries ,thats why. Neither in sideral or tropical i have other planets or rising in aries. THERE is no way im pisces! SIDERAL doesnt do it for me! Were here guverned by the 4 seasons,that repetitive rhythm,has nothing to do with the real position of planets that changed over time.
Mahatma Gandhi isn't who you think he is..he's a demagogue who didn't give a damn about non violence. He didn't save Bhagat Singh and he didn't help during Moplah riots. He also slept with his own 14 year old grand niece because he wanted to test his own celibacy. He didn't let his wife use medication when she was sick and let her die. He also supported casteism. Basically he was a disgusting duplicitous human being. But as Noam Chomsky says propaganda is to democracy what arms are to a dictatorship. Sigh!
The thing about Venus taking on martial qualities makes a lot of sense for him. Think about his "brand" of militarism, everything from the Nazi uniforms to the stark architecture of Albert Speer. He didn't just want to conquer, he wanted to conquer in style
Also their flag itself, which is very neat and stylish, but evocative of aggression
People tend to associate Hitler with Aries sign, but his Sun, Mars, Venus in tropical Taurus were also strong and prominent in his life, yet overlooked for his Arian traits. Taurus placements helped his artistic streak: a lover painting and opera, and he was often indolenent watching movies and eating pastries. Towards the end of WWII, he was very stubborn, forbidding retreat, and using sluggish fortress defense strategies (where armies would allow themselves to be surrounded in a certain stronghold and fought to the last man). At times he exhibited martian qualities (blitzkierg), and at other times Taurean qualities (fortress defense).
And he had Taurean qualities like extremely stubborn ( since we are the very first fixed sign) and money minded.
i wish i had the money to get my chart read like this..
If you're saying Hitler was not idealistic, I feel sorry to say that, but you don't know much about Hitler. He believed strongly in his mission and fate and identified himself with lots of various things related to the terms such as 'occult', 'philosophy', and 'religion'. It's not a conspiracy, even though you won't read it on Wikipedia. I couldn't finish your video. You seem to be a professional, why don't you just research things before you create a final opinion?
Superb.... brilliantly presented....loved it... would love to see your analysis of Astrologer's chart .....Shri KN Rao, Pt. Sanjay Rath, Sam Geppi, BV Raman, Ernst Wilhelm, Marc Boney and identify patterns if any...please think about this request....thank you
Could you do a video like this on painter Picasso or physicist Nicola Tesla? They are quite interesting people..😊 Please sir...
Stalin and Mao may have killed more people. It was the Vienna Art School who refused his admission.
Vic, thanks for this video. Using your technique of tropical rashis and sidereal nakshatras made better sense of his hatred and aggression. He has three planets in Purva-Ashada, the most violent of nakshatras. Jupiter and Ketu amplifies this violence and involvement of 10th lord Moon means he made a career out of it. He used Capricorn to give this tremendous rage a practical expression - first as a soldier (Is not army a Capricorn entity?) and then as a politician (once more Capricorn) and then as a dictator (Capricorn again!). Real culprit here is not the much vilified Mars or Saturn but Capricorn and Purva-Ashada. He was not a practical guy but a fanatic (Purva-Ashada) who used practical (Capricorn) methods in pursuit of his goal.
It's incorrect that Hitler was not spiritual, his entire contention with the jewish was their differentiation between animals and humans, this non-distinguishing thought of Adolf Hitler is clearly a sign of spiritual understanding and universalism. There is nothing to suggest that Hitler's actions can judge him a non-spiritualist, Hitler killed demons, Krsna killed demons, what is the difference of objective? If you read the diaries of Hitler's associates they describe his entire endeavour against the Jewish based on their cruelty toward lower life-forms, this is great compassion, this is not a symptom of a man of brutality, killing demons isn't brutality, but Dharma.
wow. "Hitler killed demons."
"Hence today I believe that I am acting in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator: by defending myself against the Jews, I am fighting for the work of the Lord."
Nice! Thanks for this. I hope you will do more charts!
Wow. Thank you. Remarkable explanations. You're helping my learning. Much appreciated.
One point that is in favor of the interpretation of Hitler's chart according to the Tropical Zodiac is the analysis of the Chandra Lagna. Who can believe that in Chandra lagna, the emotional nature of the native Hitler can have Hamsa Yoga in conjunction with the Moon? (and in trine with the Sun in Aries in 5th house), I have only seen such a conjunction in people of high ideals and even holiness, and it is even more unlikely that the lagna lord of Chandra lagna is in Hamsa yoga in sidereal. It is much more understandable The Lord of the lunar lagna and dipositor of the moon and Jupiter : Saturn in Leo in the 8th house in an enemy sign, and making an aspect to Libra lagna in D-1, which is also a probable sign of suicide ...
That's why he was a complete vegan despite being a psychopath.
Please keep doing these videos ☺️. Also it makes sense for his first lord to be in 8th in its own sign. Anyone who can go from extremes from rags to riches should have strong 8th house. First house needs to be strong for the chart overall to be strong. Then he was very secretive and working behind the scenes.
😀
Wow, Vic, what a fascinating analysis... learned a lot!...thank you for your thorough research and great presentation and teaching!!
Most lied about man in history. By far.
I don't even know where to start... siderealy We have Libra asc with Venus in 7th house basically dominated by all these grahas in Aries. Mars in its own sign and exalted Sun plus Mercury, with this we can see enormous focus on other people in life, on society, country with Arian pursuit of victory and supremacy, these man was seeing his country in shambles after WWI and this propelled him to carry enormous burden through life... But before that during Sun dasha he was living in poor condition, Sun is cooking all grahas in 7th except Venus... such is nature of the Sun to turn into cinders material things, burn attachments so only soul remains... probably in this time Hitler found his true power that was beyond this world in one way or the other. Then came Moon dasha and WWI when he was fighting on a front, Saturn in 10th forms a Raj Yoga which shows his capacity, emotional fortitude and intelligence (4th and 10th) to carry the burden of responsibility plus his Moon is in 3rd delighted by Jupiter(3rd and 6th lord, fighting, enemies etc.) and joined Ketu... this guy had insane courage within him, probably during a war he was and inspiring figure to other soldiers. Also Purva Ashadha is not strategist and for sure is not pragmatic, Hitler was inspired and inspiring person fanatical even and it mainly comes from P.Ashadha. After the WWI seeing his country in shambles he shifted into Mars dasha what activated all this power in 7th, driven by Mars he gained fame , support and ultimately absolute power in a country what is more he was surrounded by extremely talented people that helped him turn almost bankrupt country into force that had capacity to challenge entire world. With tropical we get entirely different flavor, more grounded and materialistic... this guy was driven by fire!
but, he also conquered a lot of earth-land, through a war machine industry.
@@silvercamp3303 basically Aries powerhouse....
land, factories, labor camps, comfiscating wealth, dead bodies. he wasnt a gardener.. have a nice saturday night sir
saturn in leo is about obstacles or resistanse so ..also libra asc is air sign :u r not foolin anybody ,with techn details.
amey naik talks much but says nothing.
Breathtaking clarity ....so easy to then apply the methodology to ones fiends charts
After following your videos for a few years now, I'm just amazed to see how something so good can go so wrong, and with all your knowledge and wisdom, your persistence of proving your tropical system over traditional sidereal can lead you to such an absurd ignorance towards the most basic rules of astrology.
So here are a few questions, I hope can help you with understanding the importance of the actual position of the planets in the sky regardless of the zodiac. As a matter of fact, I'm happy to see you coming to the conclusion that zodiacs are not that much of a factor compare to the house the planet occupies and how your tropical system can be so wrong in this regard.
As you choose very famous people for your examples in the last 3 comparison charts, so the foremost and most outstanding factor for all these individuals is their fame, and their leadership, which brings different aspects related to the 10th house.
Questions:
1- In Trump chart how can you totally ignore Sun as Atmakaraka (when interpreting a king chart in traditional Vedic astrology sense), especially when it's conjunct with Rahu and all those humiliations and adverse fame we all know about him? And how come you don't see the Jupiter in 2th house (FYI, he inherited all his wealth from his family)?
2- In the Einstein chart, the 10th house is even more outstanding when Sun, Saturn, Mercury, and Venus all occupy the 10, especially with his Saturn in 10th and his longlasting fame for his great contributions to humanity. The same goes for his Jupiter in the 9th house as the indication for his deep wisdom that guided many scientists to this day. How come you don't see that?
3- As for Hitler, again Saturn in 10th house and his longstanding fame for the destruction he caused. And also how can you ignore the combination of Moon and Ketu for someone who can penetrate into the minds of the people, with expanding influence by Jupiter conjunct the both, to move the masses only through the speeches he gave when all 3 Graha sits in the 3rd house of communication?
As for his 7th house with Sun and Mars with the strong aspect of Saturn on 7th, again it should be obvious why he caused such misery and destruction to the people.
All of the questions above are regardless of the zodiac. Just the houses. So the most important question that remains is how can you ignore all these obvious Vedic rules, (regardless of Zodiac) to prove tropical over Sidereal?
I don't want to go deeper into more of these obvious flaws in your readings, as these few simple examples should be enough for someone who knows the basics of Vedic astrology. The more comparison video you make the more you disprove yourself to someone who knows Vedic astrology. Regardless of all the nice comments, you get from most of your followers who don't have a clue about Vedic astrology. I'm just so disappointed and sad again to see such a brilliant mind can go so wrong with his ego. (The dark side of all those nice comments someone gets from youtube?)
Just to make it clear, I hope you understand that I have nothing against you personally, just love and respect for all the effort and your teachings. But I can't stand someone who guides the people in the wrong direction. I have a thing to fight for the truth. I hope this time instead of attacking or ignoring me you engage in a respectful debate.
Peace and light.
Adel Moradi listen this video again , may be 10 times .. this is the best video for Vedic astrology till date ... why don’t you convince sidereal gurus to come up with such video , where differences are explained on basis of zodiac signs .. Vic did both interpretations and proves that both systems are correct but when we go deep down we can tuneup the interpretation ...
@@eisa17 I'm not sure if you know the basic of Vedic astrology, if so just ask yourself what make someone famous? What makes someone a strong leader? or other questions I proposed. Then look at the charts. you don't need to watch the video's for someone else tells you the truth. The charts speak for themselves. There's no need to blindly follow or defend someone you like. Use your own brain!
All I have for Vic Ji is love and gratitude, and I believe he's one of the best Vedic astrologers on youtube. I learned so many things from him, and that's why I care about his teaching and spend time commenting on his videos. ISo don't get me wrong please that I'm here to discredit him. We are all here to learn and share our thoughts, hoping to find a way out of these dilemmas and confusion and revive the astrology to its rightful place as it used to be. I really won't mind if he would stick to his own system but his persistence in disproving and discrediting traditional Vedic astrology is something I can't cope with. Love & Light
Adel, are you bored ? "But I can't stand someone who guides the people in the wrong direction." It's not that serious :)))
Complaints
If you think I know my stuff, then please question your opinion that I don’t grasp the basics of Vedic astrology. If you can’t do that, then question your opinion that I know my stuff. You can’t have both opinions: that I know my stuff but I don’t know my stuff.
Reviewing your three objections, it is clear to me that you have a simple problem common to all new and perennial novices: you think that isolating a factor here and there is a superior methodology than the rigorous, complete, integrated (multi-)chart holistic approach I have shown in the three videos you are referring to.
1 - Atmakaraka for Trump
You want me to use atmakaraka. I’m sorry, I don’t use Jaimini techniques. You may consider Jaimini “basic” but Jaimini did not consider Jaimini basic. Jaimini describes itself as an appendix to Parashari. After I have mastered Parashari I will try to master Jaimini. Nonetheless from what little I know of Jaimini I suspect that you are using the wrong karaka to see fame. I think one would use the 2nd (amatya), not the 1st (atma) karaka. Also, I have heard one rule in an eclipse, Rāhu becomes atmakaraka. Anyway, without that rule, and with a tropical Zodiac Trumps atmakaraka is his Mars, isn’t it? And that doesn’t seem to present any interpretive problem at all. Frankly I never use this system, so let’s not dabble.
2 - Einstein’s 10th
You want to say that a house with 4 planets is better than a house with 3? It doesn’t get more novice than that.
You need to either stop thinking I am someone worth listening to, or start watching my videos carefully and learning how to really do astrology. Real charts are actually way more complex than your 1-point questions. So please either give up on me, or watch my videos way more carefully and with an attitude of a student. Without that attitude you should save time and watch someone else.
3 - You Want Saturn in Hitler’s 10th house
Your way of looking at a chart is absolutely novice. If you feel insulted by that statement, please forgive me and move on to some other knowledge-outlet for information on Vedic astrology.
Rather than try unsuccessfully to summarize my entire presentations on Trump, Einstein, and Hitler in a reply to you, please allow me to request that you either write me off as a fool or take a more humble approach and watch these videos from the start with a fresh, clean slate mind, a few times - and see how astrology should be done.
In fact not just you, but across the board I have found that the biggest challenge I face in demonstrating the practical superiority of the tropical zodiac is simply that no one agrees on how to practice astrology effectively in the first place.
Vic DiCara's Astrology Dear , I think few people consider Astrology as religion and any change in religion is not acceptable to them unless they are convinced that some avatar /prophet is here to amend their religious texts ..interesting thing is that it’s not even in the books still they believe it’s there , it’s very tough task you are trying to achieve .. you can make new followers but to break old mindset towards you is near to impossible.
You have me sold on the tropical argument. Although I wish sidereal was the right one (because according to that chart I have like 4 raj yogas regarding my ascendant lord & ascendant sign shift) I gotta stick with my not-so-stellar tropical version in comparison.
Really interesting video though Vic. You on the up and up.
Same in vedic i like my placements i dont like pisces moon in tropical but this video is defenitely convincing
The terrible thing about having a preconception about someone (Malcolm X)
I learn a lot from these videos where we listen to you interpret charts.
Oh, he didn't design "his" logo :)) " In Hinduism, the symbol with arms pointing clockwise (卐) is called swastika, symbolizing surya ('sun'), prosperity and good luck, while the counterclockwise symbol (卍) is called sauvastika, symbolizing night or tantric aspects of Kali."
Of course I am aware of that.
Your right the sun also 360 degrees of life
He did design the logo, apart from swastika there are other elements, he put all these elements together as per his vision, swastika doesnt equal to logo
@@surveysergei3209 what elements are u talkin bout
@@surveysergei3209 "his vision" ,, please. The "logo" is white circle on red background. The flag has a few black stripes- great vision, great design. Ok.
Omg... my chart is very similar :// :)) Rahu in 10H ; Sa in Leo ; Ve + Sun in Taurus ; Me in Aries ..:)) I can't get used to the look of these charts - I use the wheel for Siderial .
same, I have many similarities... I have moon in Capricorn, libra rising, venus and mars in taurus and mercury in Aries
Hello Vic, I have got Venus and Jupiter in exact degree and Neptune in 1.5 degree orb all in Moola Nakshatra. This mean Jupiter will loss even if it's in his own house?
Subbed, feeling drawn to Vedic. I have been studying both systems but I love the detail you go into and Vedic seems to provide the deeper meanings. Anyone you recommend for certification in Vedic as an astrologer? Thanks for your hard work.
In southern part of the india, there are several literature around ego and how to get rid of ego, etc. And it's a practice even today to ask the married couples to be separated in june-july (basically to avoid having sex) so that the Baby won't be born in April-May as the Baby will then have an exalted Sun. And with exalted Sun, one tend to have excessive ego.? Wish Hitler's parents were separated like that :P
You invite ppl to debate with you on the tropical sidereal issue and then, even go on to delete their comments to your videos.
Why delete the comment made by Richard Fidler? If you want siderealists to react constructively on your criticism of them, you shd we willing to do the same from your side as well.
If you don't agree with them, you can simply ignore isn't it? Let the comment stay there and ppl can decide for themselves. Disappointing.
Regarding Richard Fidler: I don't know what you are referring to, but if you give more detail I will undelete that. Either I wasn't the one who deleted it, or it was unintentional. Do you remember any of the text from his comment?
What else did I delete?
So I was actually thinking through the Sidereal and Tropical stuff and I think there’s an interesting point about tropical- because Tropical is bound to the seasons- I wouldn’t exactly call it astrology. It’s more like a kind of geomancy where the stars are actually signs of EARTHLY influences, think about it. The signs being ties to the seasons means the primary influence is earthly because the seasons are an earthly phenomenon and an important one when it comes to character development. I mean, the earth IS a celestial body and has the most profound impact, so that’s a thing.
The parts of tropical astrology then that are actually astrological in the strictest sense would be aspects. So considering it this way, it’s not really so much about the influence of the stars in their current positions, it’s about using the stars as markers for the earth’s influence.
Excellent, clear and concise Thank you
Hi sir! You should do live chart comparison for random people. That would be interesting to see. :)
Hitlers chart has in tropical , Chiron ( deepest wound) in the ninth house. Showing relationship between higher learning relationship to farther and it really was his deepest wound.
I'm black but my moon is is in Capricorn,and my rising is Libra, my sun is Pisces, this is scary, I'm going to church
Moon and rising are a small part of natal chart. It's like 8% of the natal chart. Many ppl have the same combo.
How about doing Pablo Picasso? I don't know much about his life aside that he was a successful painter, but apparently in sidereal vedic he has 4 debilitated planets.
you use sidereal based Vimshottari dasha ?
yes
That's not more than anybody else in history. Gengis Kahn, Joseph Stalin, Mao...
I feel his asexual traits point at a 8th house Taurus without Lodgers and a limitedvenus in 7th house. He hated the fact that being penetrated and vulnerable and loving is essential to the human existence. Denial of something so natural reminds me of someone in power today btw. Love this channel
You look like a lion does the animal also act on the appearance of the naksatra? And also does the last pada like for example 22.40 degrees I saw it spills in dhanishta cause my ascendant falls in that range I'm not sure
panter black a like more more looks He
It was not his country. He was Austrian.
Sun in taurus ascendant in libra. Oh my god. Dude i i i just don't know man..
Same
😂
Do yall think maybe this guy wasnt so evil as people think... i think he was spiritual not religious if u really study this guy alot stuff will blow your mind...
depends on how you want to define "spiritual" - he himself openly despised "spirituality." He was entirely practical and pragmatic.
He definitely isnt as bad as other dictators i feel like he did want to help his country but went too far and was also on meth which didnt help either hes very interesting
@@VicDiCaraAstrology I think he believed in forces higher then himself the meta physical he definitely studied the Egypt pantheon of dietys heru the son he was in tune with nature he was into the occult knowledge I can go on and on
@@roflswamp6 maybe maybe not I read stuff about that ....when u fighting evil forces and your not that u need something sometimes to put u in that mind set to bring out that dark aspect of u to go to war don't mean nothing
@@energy_kit_999 i get what ur saying sometimes u gotta get faded when u know ur about to scrap fools even tho u dont actually wanna harm nobody sometimes u just gotta be down
So he really was an Arien("Aryan")...
not at all
@@VicDiCaraAstrology Rewatched your video, my mistake. I just found the April 20th birthday and the two words being a homonym such a strange coincidence - was that day the first of Taurus that year, a cusp? Thanks.
Yep, his big three are a Sun and a rising Taurus, and a Cap moon. I have a similar big three, just my Sun is in Libra, Moon in Cap, and a Taurus rising. Lol. Really close to my mom, not my father (was never close and don't really know him, but I'm not going around killing a bunch of people, or being a menace. I'm in a very poor situation, always been rough, loved art, and piano when I was a kid, but didn't get the chance to be successful at it. Wasn't great with school, students, or teachers.
Superb analysis
I level up my skill by 10 in 24 minutes... THANK YOU SO MUCH!
Love these debunking videos. Using tropical zodiac with sidereal nakshatras is so profound.
Carolyn Gutman Dey he uses the tropical zodiac and sidereal nakshatras. Basically there two separate wheels that are not bound together
Carolyn Gutman Dey no problem :)
So is it the better way using Tropical placements with Sidereal Nakshatras?
@@KillShot-ln6mn way better
@@dannyshephard6292 So I'm Cancer Sun, Aries Moon & Leo ascendant in my Western Zodiac, what would my Nakshatras be here? Would it be the same as they were in Vedic?
i get a sense that some siderealists admire hitler, while trops are more critical.
so, Rahu in 10th is a highly potential position for fame?
Can be, but one would really need other help, like a Sun conjunct Rahu in the 10th.
Love these charts analysis videos ❤️ Thank you 🙏🏽
Have You ever done a chart for Karl Marx?
Brilliant 👌 flawless presentation 🎉
who would "get all the booty" in an absolute conjunction of Merc/Saturn?
It would depend on the higher declination
Hitler was a Taurus. Sweet, me too!
Yes he was . True
Wait we both have venus and mars also i have sun as well conjunction and i have them squared in saturn..
Do Trump next
did trump a few videos previous
Hi , Vic . He had shiv yog. Thanku.
Elon musk please?
pls can you do on bill gates and any relationship with corona virus?
Great. Really great !
I dont belive in sideral only tropical!
In the tropical im aries,sideral pisces.
IM ARIES 100 PRECENT, i did martial arts,im aggressive,have no diplomacy,,no manipulation skills like pisces.im masculine for a woman,i wore military trousers n boots.
This cant explain maybe im pisces in sideral but i have 5 planets in aries ,thats why.
Neither in sideral or tropical i have other planets or rising in aries.
THERE is no way im pisces!
SIDERAL doesnt do it for me!
Were here guverned by the 4 seasons,that repetitive rhythm,has nothing to do with the real position of planets that changed over time.
U have 5 planets in Aries in sidereal?
Thank you 🙏pls compare his chart with Mahatma Gandhi 🙏
Mahatma Gandhi isn't who you think he is..he's a demagogue who didn't give a damn about non violence. He didn't save Bhagat Singh and he didn't help during Moplah riots. He also slept with his own 14 year old grand niece because he wanted to test his own celibacy. He didn't let his wife use medication when she was sick and let her die. He also supported casteism. Basically he was a disgusting duplicitous human being. But as Noam Chomsky says propaganda is to democracy what arms are to a dictatorship. Sigh!