@@VicDiCaraAstrology 🤣 I just really like to test predictions and see if they work."Yeah, science, b****!" I expected this kind of retort. You never disappoint, Vic! Love your videos and your channel. _()_
This content is amazing! It really helps us to move forward in these sciences as opposed to just blindly following. Really really really appreciate the work you're doing. THANK YOU!
Thanks for this thought provoking video, I always enjoy your thoughts. So far the sidereal chart seems to explain his lack of speech in the first 4 years better then the tropical. The 2nd lord is debilitated and in a Dushtana, and the karaka of speech, Mercury, is debilitated and closely conjunct Saturn (delay), although the latter is also true in the tropical zodiac. Further more, Ketu (absence, manifest) is in the house of speech in both systems. But to top it off, the sidereal 6th lord, Mars, is looking straight at his 2nd house of speech (although admittedly it gives an 8th glance in the tropical, but as a major functional Yoga Karaka). Another think that leans better toward the sidereal is the Mahapurusha Yoga of Venus in the 10th. The outcome of his labor is monumental and his fame will last for a long time. It made him an archetype of a genius, his name being synonymous with genius. Also the emphasis on Pisces in the sidereal chart is congruent with the subject matter of which he is famous for, which transcends the old mechanical framework of physics, paving the ground for quantum mechanics, which is far more Picean than Arian! I have the sense that his Mahapurusha Yoga of Mars in the 7th and an Aries holding the 10th house would make him more of an engineer than a theorist. But I can also glean how the tropical has it's justification, especially debilitated 7th lord aspecting the 7th and Mars. I'm regard both systems to work, but in a different way, since they are simply not the same frameworks. We normally don't debate which is more valid, signs or houses. The sidereal system is fixed to the stars, while the tropical is nodal, like the Lagna and houses, Rahu/Ketu etc. Anyway, I paused the video in the 8th minute, so you may raise some of these points later on. Back to watching :)
at 14:42 you cast doubt on the 7th lord being in the 9th. But it is very clearly in a Papakartari Yoga, with two malefics on each side. Even though the karaka, Venus, is exalted, it is also blemished by Saturn, and neither Jupiter nor Venus do so well in the sidereal Navamsha.
At 16:15 you refer to Saturn as a sidereal 9th lord and tropical 8th lord, hinting to the damage it may yield to Venus. I guess you emphasize the mulatrikona lordship here, but obviously Saturn rules the 8th in both systems.
At 20:31 you ask, why are the two intellectual planets, Mercury and Moon, debilitated. Apart from the cancellation you acknowledged, you have already emphasized his autism, which is sidereal may be better explained by these debilitations.
It is clear that both tropical and sidereal have a good case. However it seems to be built upon our subjective interpretation on Einstein's character and life work. I suggest a better test would be the predictability between the two versions and the events of his life, using both dashas and transits.. Thanks for the thought-provoking video.
Good comments. As I say at the very end, you have to be more patient, and put aside what you are thinking and try to understand what I am thinking. I know this sounds haughty, but its not crazy considering I am the one making the video and you are the one choosing to watch it. Venus in Mahāpuruṣa is completely antithetical to his love life. The "pisces-ness" of his chart is due to the prominence of moksha-sthan rulers, and the saggitarius moon, and the water ascendant. You are on the right track saying "more of an engineer than a theorist" - but abstract it a little more: "more of a scientist than a lover" Your suggestion about timing is a good one. I will take it up in the next video.
All his problems with relationships from sidereal perspective boil down to debilitated Moon in 6th that for Gemini usually gives amoral approach and wacky value system, 2nd house is family and values upon which we build our life on earth, this man didn't give a shit (this Moon is also not supported in any way). Mercury even though debilitated forms a Raj Yoga being 1st and 4th lord in 10th house which shows capacity to form complex abstract thoughts that can go beyond what can be seen through senses alone, of course this alone would give capacity to write fantasy books more than create complex physical theories but there is exalted Venus that is 5th lord, it pretty much shows creative, dharmic intelligence of a Gemini that has capacity to see harmony and beauty in universe and describe it by using language of math, there is also Saturn bringing focus on reality and Sun giving consistent purpouse. Most of this happen in 10th house which only underscores impact his actions had on the world. There are many other things but to me sidereal chart nails it completely, this man had very Piscean approach toward science, I advice to look for his quotes on Wikipedia.
Totally agree with the “Piscean approach to Science”! How do I know, I have Pisces Venus Exalted, but I won’t disclose what house it’s in. And other planets strongly linked to the 9th house. Or who are hanging out in my 12th house. LoL.
@@manuterra6307 Nah I don't do readings, I'm not a professional astrologer, it would be irresponsible. One thing is to analyze chart of a dead man knowing history of his life and other thing is to go blind into a birthchart of a person you know nothing about, it requires much more practice, skill and training under a guru than what you can learn by reading some books and listening to youtube vids ;D
This is an awesome analysis! I did notice too for Einstein's chart in Sidereal that his Ashtakavarga scores might be another element to this as well! Thank you so much Vic! As someone who started as a Tropical chart follower to reading more Sidereal, I really got to say this is refreshing and amazing. It leaves me at a loss for words.
Both charts are totally different, the Sideral one has a very strong dual nature with a predominance of water and air elements and no fire while the Tropical one has a movable emphasis with fire as a dominant element. I just can't see the logical and persistant man that he was in the Sideral chart. Air water people tend to have a hard time giving a concrete form to their ideas and they are not really persistant, assertive and ambitious in general (of course, depending upon the chart) - and Einstein was extremely active, with an impulsive and determined nature, already publishing in scientific journals in his early twenties - the Aries influence is pretty much there. Also a life full of ups and downs is much more common in a chart with more planets in malefic signs and malefic planets placed in angular houses - and that is clear in the Tropical chart. And of course, the relationship trouble is much more evident in his Tropical chart. I can see a person with his Sideral chart having an "easier" life, with more self contentment and less impulse to create something so revolutionary and meaninful as he did.
So when you really take a deep dive into the famous Albert Einstein, you come to find that Einstein was nothing more than a fraud who was kicked out of his country by the scientific community. He then moved to America where the western media propped him up as he rose to fame. He was once married to his own cousin (1st cousin) and the work he presented wasnt of his own but from one of his wives(which he struggled to present in the first place). AE was just a puppet, like a Fauci & Elon is in today’s world. Oh and, like Fauci, Einstein refused to ever get in any debates. Anyway, thought I’d share for anyone interested.
I can see it both ways. Tropical works well for my chart and vargas but Einstein's chart works better with sidereal IMO. EX Venus = lots of relationships and celebrity. DB Moon = troubles with relationships. EX Mars in 8th = deep research. At the end of the day he is a celebrity know for his career as a researcher - shown by his strong 10th and 8th houses.
Very nice way of depicting the chart!!! Very unbiased and objective analysis. Clearly shows that if we have the right system, we don't have to screw out things. If someone is open and honest they will be open to exploring the options.
Finding this now so glad to see his chart comparison we have the same house signs in tropical. I’m Gemini ascendant in Vedic and cancer rising in tropical and find that makes more sense for me. But I have cancer stellium in Vedic and Leo stellium in tropical. But makes sense the planets change it and offset the differences in the two type of charts.
These kind of explorative, research oriented, new kind of videos and topics are things rare to get from astrologers and it was a delight watching the video. And, you take me closer to the universe while watching your videos. Closer to god and mythology too. U know a lot of mythology and sanskrit than people from my country India..quite amazing!. I love your explanations on krishna and Bagavat Geeta. U have a true attraction and interest for the divine. Keep rocking Best wishes
Tropical with Whole Signs, but also with Quadrant Houses: Uranus R in Virgo in 3rd house, Uranus in Regulus star/Virgo sign: a mathematical or scientific genious, a nerd, very clever and very authentic. Sidereal with Whole Signs: Uranus R in Leo in 3rd (Regulus/Magha Nakshatra). I think Tropical describes him more accurately, even if we follow the western aproach and rules.
if my pluto was in leo in western would it b e in cancer in Sidereal ?????? i kno you dont use pluto but i do , im not an astrologer but i love to study it ~`~
Hi Vic dicara sir, first of all it's a great thing u tried to research and produce some evidence and prove which is right..tropical or sidereal. In my humble opinion, Einstein was so engrossed in finding out about the nature of "time" and proving his relativity theory that he had less time to spend with his first wife. She couldn't understand his dream, he couldn't understand from her side. What i observed seeing a tv serial abt him was that, his intellect has stood in the way of his married life and connection with the outside world.
his first wife was on the way to become a great scientist herself. she ws the best student in one of the best tec universities worldwide! she understood very well. the ty serials are more soap operas. or like the gandhi film by attenborough. more fantasy than reality.
So Looks like vic big on karaka for love while forgetting that lord of 7th house Jupiter badly hammed between Saturn/sun on one hand and Mars/Rahu on that other side. In Navamsa lord of the 7th goes to 8th house and Navamsa lagna is also hammed between RA and MA. He divorced his wife in dasha of SU/SA which can seen from Sidereal chart. Venus also goes into 12th house in sidereal Navamsa. Even in yogini dasa divorce happned in SA/VE. Saturn also aspects 7th house from 10th as 8th lord. Tropically, exchange between SA/MA will actually save the marriage in Saturn period as Saturn own's the 7th house and aspects it back from 10 house. So, Can't say tropical chart explain love life better then sidereal chart at all. Karka is important but not everything. House and lord are more important than karka
7L is in the 9th house in good dignity. Now you want to say it is hemmed? Even if you hem a flower it is just a hemmed flower, it doesn't turn into a turd. Why play with navamsha lords when the birth time is not really too confident. It is an old chart. Anyway, how will a navamsha lordship override the d1 lordship? Get a system and stick too it, then you will be able to evaluate tropical vs. sidereal.
Thank goodness, I have moon debilitated and mercury debilitated with Gemini rising. I always had a strive to learn and improving my personal philosophy. I agree, the debilitation probably has to do with antisocial behavior and want or need to improve one’s learning abilities. I felt the need to prove my intelligence when I was younger because I was the youngest out of my 7 brothers and sisters-big family. 😅 Also, I can vouch for the eccentric part. ✋🏻😄 This is an incredibly informative interpretation Mr. Dicara. As always, stay bless and prosper! 😇🙏❤️
When a planet (enisteins Mercury) is involved with a planet that is forming a parivartana yoga (Saturn) the debilitation) is cancelled. Parivartnana yogas are the most powerful planets.
I find these comparisons fascinating. Personally I feel like I can relate to both my charts speaking for myself and my own nativity, although I lean towards tropical more but I aspire towards the sidereal. I think the key is they kinda blend into one anyway when simplified. I heard someone suggest that the tropical chart relates to your ancestors karma and the sidereal relates to your karma. It's an interesting proposition, I have my own ideas also not to dissimilar to that perspective in all honesty. Horses for courses as they say
Very fascinating. Wondering if you can suggest a crash course in astrology. Would certainly like to learn more. But being married, and working 50 hour work week gives me limited time for study. Love to hear your suggestions. Definitely feeling intrigued after this video.
My chart is so similar to his. And in different ways i am like him..not the cousins stuff but other ways for sure. My placements are almost the same as his. ..
On his genius side of things I would look more closely at Uranus contacts which I know isn’t particularly vedic (or is it…) but this can also explain a different point of view.
DB Mercury can indicate the destruction of relationships and contractual obligations. DB Mercury also shows the breaking down of conceptual frameworks giving access to a more intuitive perception. His desire for freedom from the structure of marriage is the same free thinking which made him an unorthodox innovative thinker. His Mercury would become a tool of his Venus, his rationality would adjust to serve his strong sensual desires.
re: debiltated Mercury... it's got the Neecha Banga Raja Yoga since it's angular and conjunct the exaltation Lord of the sign it's in. And I think it's worth pointing out that the Lord of Mercury's sign, Jupiter, in parivartan Yoga (mutual reception) with Saturn which is conjunct Mercury. This makes Jupiter/Saturn very strong as they are exchanging signs, and Saturn is directly conjunct Mercury within a degree. With the exaltation Lord in the same sign, and Mercury being angular and ruler of the Asc... there can certainly be a sidereal perspective that this is a strong mercury despite it's debilitation.
I agree it is very subjective. The romantic dalliances with that rahu Mars in 8th, the Jupiter in 9th for higher education, moon in 6th in scorp (which I have seen in at least one other chart of someone who also pursued physics) support to me the sidereal case (which I know won’t be to your liking!) additionally the fact that merc is debilitated is somewhat adjusted given it is with Venus in Pisces. I would be curious to see conjunctions and squares against either the mercury/mars midpoints and or the mars/Venus midpoints which I have also noted are common in the charts of academic types. Sun in the tenth will give fame I believe. The speech impairments in childhood are probably more closely linked to Ketu in the second than the debilitated mercury. Anyways just my two cents. My bias is for sidereal. Though I understand the rationale of tropical, but the study of yogas and Dasha has me convinced that sidereal is what helps give me better results with vedic system. That said I hope to one day prove this empirically using real data on a large sample or charts. I am also a student of bhagavat purana so I am hesitant to disagree with the holy bhagavat If it is indeed the case that it is suggesting a tropical system
WhhOW awesome contribution Vic,.. Thank You so much. Always grateful for wisdom - full shares ! Blossom to You and Your Lovely. If I may share, very briefly, on the loveromancing chart,.. it had the intriguing degrees displayed. S: 7H LJU is in 4th pada ruled by MA and a Lion. T: SA 2p ruler VE and a Ms. Horsey. I luv the nakshatras and for me, S: Dhanishta / Dolphin boy, Lion wins this hippocampus pic of the day. lv langujz pls frgv al mstks. %- D
10:30 I think the explanation of the Venus is that actually it loses strength in the neechbhang since it goes to supporting mercury. I think the strong sexual appetite is more profoundly influenced by rahu and mars. The rahu mars in the third from moon is interesting given he only had one younger sister maja. From the lagna 3H lord sun in tenth with mercury, his sister was a scholar of Romance languages. Again we are kind of doing retrospective analysis here but, again another way of bolstering the sidereal narrative. Thanks for this presentation !!
Sir when ancient Vedic astrological texts were written perhaps the Tropical and Sidereal zodiacs overlapped each other? Therefore whether tropical or sidereal was used the results were the same. I think until around 285 AC they overlapped?
With regards to his terrible marriage relationships it can be easily seen in Sidereal because he has a severe Kuja Dosha in the 8th house. Mars in 8th conjunct Rahu. It doesn't get worse than that.
Could someone explain to me if I was born TODAY (11-9-2020) How would I be a Scorpio if my Sun is in Libra? I know its Scorpio Season according to the Tropical Zodiac But my sign is suppose to be because of the position of the Sun when I'm born right?
Please learn the basics of what a zodiac is, how it relates to calendars, and what the difference between sidereal and tropical is, at vicdicara.com/tropical
I’m remembering all my past lives and why I died and the lessons for this life of not to show how I learned. I have no friends and love to be alone and isolated and I have a perfectionist traits and a hoarder as well. So I’m all over the place, oh and I’m extremely sensitive to everyone and everything…classical music I like a lot and Math, Sciences and History are my favorite subjects…
Nice example to explain the difference between using Indian and Western astrology. I always focused on Indian astrology, but I am sold by using Western astrology with Nakshatras from the Indian astrology. My own horoscope makes more sense. Much love. Xx
Was waiting for you to mention the specific degrees & distinct #nakshatras it’s on. You likely might already know this, but #KapielRaaj briefly mentioned Venus exalted is not what people imagine it to be. Also, from another #VedicAstrology discussion on exalted vs debilitated planets:
yeah, they prefer to think Venus and Mars exalted is not what it should be. I prefer to realize that the planets are not exalted, they are in the next signs (Aries and Aquarius, resp.), and ARE what they should be.
When you analyse his romantic relationships shouldn’t his partners charts been included? Communicationwise I think he carried within himself a totally until then unknown reality which he at last could express in his E=mc2. I wonder maybe we were the ones who didn’t understand him. Even now I do not know what he meant. In my knowledge he suffered from dyslexia and his first wife who was a physicist too wrote Einsteins 1912´s manuscript... her name was never mentioned on the document because women at that time were not admitted in highranking scientific circles. Whether the sidereal chart is more relevant than the tropical chart we do carry them both within us. So gaining knowledge and understanding by learning can’t be but helpful. Thank you for this work of understanding 🙏.
its really impressive the amount of detail you can talk about in 27 minutes and give a coherent argument in your unique way. as an aside, you know u cant be a real vedic astrologer without doing a horoscope breakdown of amithab bacchan lmao. just kidding bro. i find his horoscope is really popular among indian astrologers and their youtube channels
Also...10th lord in the 9th house since Pisces is co-ruled by Jupiter... Here you can clearly see how his scientific develop and the intelligence thereof...always striving to merge science with religion since Jupiter there is the 9th of Aquarius... You can clearly see where his intelligence stems from...in this position he contends with intellectual opposition and goes against the grain of the Guru the teachers and tries prove his point to be right... Which is exactly what he did...but generally this is someone who is imaginative and knowledgeable enough to cause some rebellion in what is being taught....and Aquarius being coruled by Rahu gives him this quality
last video people complained i was too complicated with all the vargas. and this is a birth from a long time ago. how sure can we be of the exact time?
see vicdicara.com/tropical - it is very simple. To find nakshatras, use ayanamsha. That is what Ayanamsha is FOR. Ayanamsha measures distance between the N.Equinox and a reference star (typically Citra-tara, marking the exact middle of Citra-nakshatra). Once you know this you know where all the nakshatras are.
Firstly I would like to thank you for all the knowledge that I gain from your videos. I often watch the charts of celebrities online, but somehow I find multiple similarities between Einstein's chart and my own chart. Like my 1st lord in the 3rd house, 5th lord in the 2nd house, 7th lord in the 1st house, 11th lord in the 8th house, moon in Sagittarius and many more things that I noticed. I was always good in arts, sports and academics. I have been trying to figure out a suitable career for me but I always feel torn between the choices I have. I would like to know if you do personal consultations as well. I have been trying to figure out my own chart and I appreciate everything that I have learned from your videos.
Very modern psychodynamic approach... I would think it would be better to have mercury conjunct exalted 5th lord in the 10th house to give the lagna capacity for such intellectual prowess. Strengthening Jupiter through the parivartana will help as well. The most salient feature of Einstein's autism was a disorder of speech which is indicated by both the debilitated mercury and debilitated moon as 2nd lord. Not being able to comprehend emotions is also related to weak moon... For affairs I'd look at the Navamsa 2nd house, based on the work of Freedom Cole which is up on RUclips. It's amazing how well the principle works in Einsteins chart as second lord Mars is squarely conjunct Venus in the vacuous sign of Aquarius. This principle is right out of Parashara ruclips.net/video/J10t_SuxGSU/видео.html
My son just ordered a reading from you tonight. He ordered the Astrological Guidance and will like to focus on career. I told him it would be an excellent reading. I did the complete chart breakdown and I'm still learning from it.
(Continuation) you could have told us about why his child was schizophrenic..what could have caused that..and about the death of his daughter..if possible make a video on the possible astrological reason, aspect. And there are interesting life incidents like him accidentally finding about the role of acceleration, while using an escalator or lift. He got clarity in relativity theory when he saw two toy trains.
juipter in the 8th with Rāhu. 5th lord in 7th, exchanging with the 10th. these are very negative for 5th house theme of children, but very positive for 5th house theme of intelligence
@@VicDiCaraAstrology insightful. And yeah..rahu is about obsessions, diseases..and jupiter which represents children is along..in the house of death (8th house).. Great explanation. Thank you sir. And as u said 5th lord involving intelligence is meeting 7th house and the house of career..the 10th..so now i guess it sure is destiny the reason for the things that happened in his life.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology i forgot to mention..rahu is about illusion too..it being with jupiter is the reason maybe a kid was schezophrenic.. sry if iam wrong.. Am not an astrology expert..just learning.. Astrology gives signs to predict from..thats it i guess..i feel its upto the beholder or astrolger to understand, predict. Astrology involves a lot of factors like stars, their luck, the house, aspects and planetary conjunctions...since all those have to be taken into consideration, given a point, i guess astrologers have a great deal of work to do..and a lot of wit is needed.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology the big doubt i usually have in my mind is, whether planets pass on their energy, vibrations to the living beings on earth, and create good and bad time or else its not any outside energy and "we are will" and a part of this universe, made of the 5 elements wind, water, fire etc. I slightly believe the second option..coz there is a concept where planets are responsible for even skin colour, and houses represent body parts. First house for the head and so on. You give a lot of explanations about astrology, and some of them might have an answer for this doubt already, but i just dont know which one..its hard to pull out the answer
I believe the Cancer Ascendant seem more relevant simply b/c of his treatment of women as wives… The Gemini Ascendant would make him more agreeable with women- more social and willing to appraise the wants and needs and be friendly with women.
Ok , no morality but deeply spiritual , thats exalted Venus it also gives deep hidden knowledge , namely mritsanjivani mantra , thats shukracharya for you
![Sean Rii, Karyon, Sharzkii - Taungule [My Love] (Official Music Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eJoMuypbSzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
It would be intersting to hear Vic interpret 2 version of personal chart (S and T) in a "blind study" format. And then learn a person's story.
would you also like me to jump through three rings of fire, live on youtube? =)
@@VicDiCaraAstrology 🤣 I just really like to test predictions and see if they work."Yeah, science, b****!" I expected this kind of retort. You never disappoint, Vic! Love your videos and your channel. _()_
@@VicDiCaraAstrology can you? Please
This content is amazing! It really helps us to move forward in these sciences as opposed to just blindly following. Really really really appreciate the work you're doing. THANK YOU!
Thanks for this thought provoking video, I always enjoy your thoughts.
So far the sidereal chart seems to explain his lack of speech in the first 4 years better then the tropical. The 2nd lord is debilitated and in a Dushtana, and the karaka of speech, Mercury, is debilitated and closely conjunct Saturn (delay), although the latter is also true in the tropical zodiac. Further more, Ketu (absence, manifest) is in the house of speech in both systems. But to top it off, the sidereal 6th lord, Mars, is looking straight at his 2nd house of speech (although admittedly it gives an 8th glance in the tropical, but as a major functional Yoga Karaka).
Another think that leans better toward the sidereal is the Mahapurusha Yoga of Venus in the 10th. The outcome of his labor is monumental and his fame will last for a long time. It made him an archetype of a genius, his name being synonymous with genius.
Also the emphasis on Pisces in the sidereal chart is congruent with the subject matter of which he is famous for, which transcends the old mechanical framework of physics, paving the ground for quantum mechanics, which is far more Picean than Arian! I have the sense that his Mahapurusha Yoga of Mars in the 7th and an Aries holding the 10th house would make him more of an engineer than a theorist.
But I can also glean how the tropical has it's justification, especially debilitated 7th lord aspecting the 7th and Mars. I'm regard both systems to work, but in a different way, since they are simply not the same frameworks. We normally don't debate which is more valid, signs or houses. The sidereal system is fixed to the stars, while the tropical is nodal, like the Lagna and houses, Rahu/Ketu etc.
Anyway, I paused the video in the 8th minute, so you may raise some of these points later on. Back to watching :)
at 14:42 you cast doubt on the 7th lord being in the 9th. But it is very clearly in a Papakartari Yoga, with two malefics on each side. Even though the karaka, Venus, is exalted, it is also blemished by Saturn, and neither Jupiter nor Venus do so well in the sidereal Navamsha.
At 16:15 you refer to Saturn as a sidereal 9th lord and tropical 8th lord, hinting to the damage it may yield to Venus. I guess you emphasize the mulatrikona lordship here, but obviously Saturn rules the 8th in both systems.
At 20:31 you ask, why are the two intellectual planets, Mercury and Moon, debilitated. Apart from the cancellation you acknowledged, you have already emphasized his autism, which is sidereal may be better explained by these debilitations.
It is clear that both tropical and sidereal have a good case. However it seems to be built upon our subjective interpretation on Einstein's character and life work. I suggest a better test would be the predictability between the two versions and the events of his life, using both dashas and transits.. Thanks for the thought-provoking video.
Good comments.
As I say at the very end, you have to be more patient, and put aside what you are thinking and try to understand what I am thinking. I know this sounds haughty, but its not crazy considering I am the one making the video and you are the one choosing to watch it.
Venus in Mahāpuruṣa is completely antithetical to his love life.
The "pisces-ness" of his chart is due to the prominence of moksha-sthan rulers, and the saggitarius moon, and the water ascendant.
You are on the right track saying "more of an engineer than a theorist" - but abstract it a little more: "more of a scientist than a lover"
Your suggestion about timing is a good one. I will take it up in the next video.
All his problems with relationships from sidereal perspective boil down to debilitated Moon in 6th that for Gemini usually gives amoral approach and wacky value system, 2nd house is family and values upon which we build our life on earth, this man didn't give a shit (this Moon is also not supported in any way). Mercury even though debilitated forms a Raj Yoga being 1st and 4th lord in 10th house which shows capacity to form complex abstract thoughts that can go beyond what can be seen through senses alone, of course this alone would give capacity to write fantasy books more than create complex physical theories but there is exalted Venus that is 5th lord, it pretty much shows creative, dharmic intelligence of a Gemini that has capacity to see harmony and beauty in universe and describe it by using language of math, there is also Saturn bringing focus on reality and Sun giving consistent purpouse. Most of this happen in 10th house which only underscores impact his actions had on the world. There are many other things but to me sidereal chart nails it completely, this man had very Piscean approach toward science, I advice to look for his quotes on Wikipedia.
very well put..agree with you 100%
Totally agree with the “Piscean approach to Science”! How do I know, I have Pisces Venus Exalted, but I won’t disclose what house it’s in.
And other planets strongly linked to the 9th house.
Or who are hanging out in my 12th house. LoL.
Sebastian Gałecki your analysis seem to pretty nail Einstein's chart. Could you do my chart readings please? I'll send it over to you if you agree :)
@@manuterra6307 Nah I don't do readings, I'm not a professional astrologer, it would be irresponsible. One thing is to analyze chart of a dead man knowing history of his life and other thing is to go blind into a birthchart of a person you know nothing about, it requires much more practice, skill and training under a guru than what you can learn by reading some books and listening to youtube vids ;D
Sebastian Gałecki it's impressive though you say you are novice and untrained :) how did you catch up with vedic astrology?
Most excellent! ✨ These are great, Thx for sharing your insights.
This is an awesome analysis! I did notice too for Einstein's chart in Sidereal that his Ashtakavarga scores might be another element to this as well! Thank you so much Vic! As someone who started as a Tropical chart follower to reading more Sidereal, I really got to say this is refreshing and amazing. It leaves me at a loss for words.
Great video sir
Nice interpretation
Waiting for more this type of analysis
Both charts are totally different, the Sideral one has a very strong dual nature with a predominance of water and air elements and no fire while the Tropical one has a movable emphasis with fire as a dominant element. I just can't see the logical and persistant man that he was in the Sideral chart. Air water people tend to have a hard time giving a concrete form to their ideas and they are not really persistant, assertive and ambitious in general (of course, depending upon the chart) - and Einstein was extremely active, with an impulsive and determined nature, already publishing in scientific journals in his early twenties - the Aries influence is pretty much there. Also a life full of ups and downs is much more common in a chart with more planets in malefic signs and malefic planets placed in angular houses - and that is clear in the Tropical chart.
And of course, the relationship trouble is much more evident in his Tropical chart.
I can see a person with his Sideral chart having an "easier" life, with more self contentment and less impulse to create something so revolutionary and meaninful as he did.
Signs don't mean much in Sidereal, look to houses and rulerships.
So when you really take a deep dive into the famous Albert Einstein, you come to find that Einstein was nothing more than a fraud who was kicked out of his country by the scientific community. He then moved to America where the western media propped him up as he rose to fame. He was once married to his own cousin (1st cousin) and the work he presented wasnt of his own but from one of his wives(which he struggled to present in the first place). AE was just a puppet, like a Fauci & Elon is in today’s world. Oh and, like Fauci, Einstein refused to ever get in any debates. Anyway, thought I’d share for anyone interested.
I can see it both ways. Tropical works well for my chart and vargas but Einstein's chart works better with sidereal IMO.
EX Venus = lots of relationships and celebrity. DB Moon = troubles with relationships. EX Mars in 8th = deep research.
At the end of the day he is a celebrity know for his career as a researcher - shown by his strong 10th and 8th houses.
Awesome video, thank you :-)
Very nice way of depicting the chart!!!
Very unbiased and objective analysis. Clearly shows that if we have the right system, we don't have to screw out things.
If someone is open and honest they will be open to exploring the options.
My tropical chart makes a lot of sense than my sidereal one.
Finding this now so glad to see his chart comparison we have the same house signs in tropical. I’m Gemini ascendant in Vedic and cancer rising in tropical and find that makes more sense for me. But I have cancer stellium in Vedic and Leo stellium in tropical. But makes sense the planets change it and offset the differences in the two type of charts.
Can you please make a video someday about your journey of how you started getting interested in astrology, studying vedic astrology?
Love you Vic
These kind of explorative, research oriented, new kind of videos and topics are things rare to get from astrologers and it was a delight watching the video.
And, you take me closer to the universe while watching your videos. Closer to god and mythology too.
U know a lot of mythology and sanskrit than people from my country India..quite amazing!.
I love your explanations on krishna and Bagavat Geeta. U have a true attraction and interest for the divine.
Keep rocking
Best wishes
thank you
Thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏
Four minutes pause ......taking a deep breath oh my god ....who would be a genius
Damn I love astrology.....and this analysis simply sublime
This was great.
thank you
Tropical with Whole Signs, but also with Quadrant Houses: Uranus R in Virgo in 3rd house, Uranus in Regulus star/Virgo sign: a mathematical or scientific genious, a nerd, very clever and very authentic. Sidereal with Whole Signs: Uranus R in Leo in 3rd (Regulus/Magha Nakshatra). I think Tropical describes him more accurately, even if we follow the western aproach and rules.
Im so glad i found you vic holy shit god has revealed your channel to me and i am lucky for it
My god blesss u veryy good knowledge
if my pluto was in leo in western would it b e in cancer in Sidereal ?????? i kno you dont use pluto but i do , im not an astrologer but i love to study it ~`~
Hi Vic dicara sir, first of all it's a great thing u tried to research and produce some evidence and prove which is right..tropical or sidereal.
In my humble opinion, Einstein was so engrossed in finding out about the nature of "time" and proving his relativity theory that he had less time to spend with his first wife. She couldn't understand his dream, he couldn't understand from her side. What i observed seeing a tv serial abt him was that, his intellect has stood in the way of his married life and connection with the outside world.
his first wife was on the way to become a great scientist herself. she ws the best student in one of the best tec universities worldwide! she understood very well. the ty serials are more soap operas. or like the gandhi film by attenborough. more fantasy than reality.
Vic please make a video on rahu ketu dispositor conjunction
I was told that sidereal is when we make choices from our higher selves and tropical is when we work from our lower selves (earth based)
thats just someone making something up
So Looks like vic big on karaka for love while forgetting that lord of 7th house Jupiter badly hammed between Saturn/sun on one hand and Mars/Rahu on that other side. In Navamsa lord of the 7th goes to 8th house and Navamsa lagna is also hammed between RA and MA. He divorced his wife in dasha of SU/SA which can seen from Sidereal chart. Venus also goes into 12th house in sidereal Navamsa. Even in yogini dasa divorce happned in SA/VE. Saturn also aspects 7th house from 10th as 8th lord.
Tropically, exchange between SA/MA will actually save the marriage in Saturn period as Saturn own's the 7th house and aspects it back from 10 house.
So, Can't say tropical chart explain love life better then sidereal chart at all. Karka is important but not everything. House and lord are more important than karka
7L is in the 9th house in good dignity. Now you want to say it is hemmed? Even if you hem a flower it is just a hemmed flower, it doesn't turn into a turd.
Why play with navamsha lords when the birth time is not really too confident. It is an old chart. Anyway, how will a navamsha lordship override the d1 lordship? Get a system and stick too it, then you will be able to evaluate tropical vs. sidereal.
Thank goodness, I have moon debilitated and mercury debilitated with Gemini rising. I always had a strive to learn and improving my personal philosophy. I agree, the debilitation probably has to do with antisocial behavior and want or need to improve one’s learning abilities. I felt the need to prove my intelligence when I was younger because I was the youngest out of my 7 brothers and sisters-big family. 😅 Also, I can vouch for the eccentric part. ✋🏻😄
This is an incredibly informative interpretation Mr. Dicara. As always, stay bless and prosper! 😇🙏❤️
When a planet (enisteins Mercury) is involved with a planet that is forming a parivartana yoga (Saturn) the debilitation) is cancelled. Parivartnana yogas are the most powerful planets.
How does one calculate the dashas etc in the tropical systems? What about debilitation degrees?
the same exact way you calculate it sidereally, because the nakshatras are sidereal. debilitation degrees are the same.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology Vic I'm a bit confused how to calculate dashas. Are the dashas the same in Tropical and Sidreal?
I find these comparisons fascinating. Personally I feel like I can relate to both my charts speaking for myself and my own nativity, although I lean towards tropical more but I aspire towards the sidereal. I think the key is they kinda blend into one anyway when simplified. I heard someone suggest that the tropical chart relates to your ancestors karma and the sidereal relates to your karma. It's an interesting proposition, I have my own ideas also not to dissimilar to that perspective in all honesty. Horses for courses as they say
Very fascinating. Wondering if you can suggest a crash course in astrology. Would certainly like to learn more. But being married, and working 50 hour work week gives me limited time for study. Love to hear your suggestions.
Definitely feeling intrigued after this video.
Check these out vicdicara.com/courses
I will do a live intensive of all the 4 level one courses in November/December. Stay tuned.
My chart is so similar to his. And in different ways i am like him..not the cousins stuff but other ways for sure. My placements are almost the same as his. ..
On his genius side of things I would look more closely at Uranus contacts which I know isn’t particularly vedic (or is it…) but this can also explain a different point of view.
DB Mercury can indicate the destruction of relationships and contractual obligations. DB Mercury also shows the breaking down of conceptual frameworks giving access to a more intuitive perception. His desire for freedom from the structure of marriage is the same free thinking which made him an unorthodox innovative thinker. His Mercury would become a tool of his Venus, his rationality would adjust to serve his strong sensual desires.
re: debiltated Mercury... it's got the Neecha Banga Raja Yoga since it's angular and conjunct the exaltation Lord of the sign it's in. And I think it's worth pointing out that the Lord of Mercury's sign, Jupiter, in parivartan Yoga (mutual reception) with Saturn which is conjunct Mercury. This makes Jupiter/Saturn very strong as they are exchanging signs, and Saturn is directly conjunct Mercury within a degree. With the exaltation Lord in the same sign, and Mercury being angular and ruler of the Asc... there can certainly be a sidereal perspective that this is a strong mercury despite it's debilitation.
Aman Bedi Astrology speaking with Gitanshu Malhotra on exalted vs debilitated planets
I usually take tropical house system and sidereal system for planet placements on the signs. I myself and my friends resonate better with that.
I could watch these Tropical vs. Sidereal comparisons all day! It's so refreshing to see a real astrologer actually read the charts.
Thank you!
I agree it is very subjective. The romantic dalliances with that rahu Mars in 8th, the Jupiter in 9th for higher education, moon in 6th in scorp (which I have seen in at least one other chart of someone who also pursued physics) support to me the sidereal case (which I know won’t be to your liking!) additionally the fact that merc is debilitated is somewhat adjusted given it is with Venus in Pisces. I would be curious to see conjunctions and squares against either the mercury/mars midpoints and or the mars/Venus midpoints which I have also noted are common in the charts of academic types. Sun in the tenth will give fame I believe. The speech impairments in childhood are probably more closely linked to Ketu in the second than the debilitated mercury. Anyways just my two cents. My bias is for sidereal. Though I understand the rationale of tropical, but the study of yogas and Dasha has me convinced that sidereal is what helps give me better results with vedic system. That said I hope to one day prove this empirically using real data on a large sample or charts. I am also a student of bhagavat purana so I am hesitant to disagree with the holy bhagavat If it is indeed the case that it is suggesting a tropical system
I’m interested in a reading, what do you suggest in regarding what type of reading I need?
a chart overview report
@@VicDiCaraAstrology okay. Thank you
Oh my God!!!! Your mind is unbelievable. Can barely grasp half of the information ...Sure have learnt a lot though. Thank you.
WhhOW awesome contribution Vic,.. Thank You so much. Always grateful for wisdom - full shares ! Blossom to You and Your Lovely. If I may share, very briefly, on the loveromancing chart,.. it had the intriguing degrees displayed. S: 7H LJU is in 4th pada ruled by MA and a Lion. T: SA 2p ruler VE and a Ms. Horsey. I luv the nakshatras and for me, S: Dhanishta / Dolphin boy, Lion wins this hippocampus pic of the day. lv langujz pls frgv al mstks. %- D
10:30 I think the explanation of the Venus is that actually it loses strength in the neechbhang since it goes to supporting mercury. I think the strong sexual appetite is more profoundly influenced by rahu and mars. The rahu mars in the third from moon is interesting given he only had one younger sister maja. From the lagna 3H lord sun in tenth with mercury, his sister was a scholar of Romance languages. Again we are kind of doing retrospective analysis here but, again another way of bolstering the sidereal narrative.
Thanks for this presentation !!
Sir when ancient Vedic astrological texts were written perhaps the Tropical and Sidereal zodiacs overlapped each other? Therefore whether tropical or sidereal was used the results were the same. I think until around 285 AC they overlapped?
With regards to his terrible marriage relationships it can be easily seen in Sidereal because he has a severe Kuja Dosha in the 8th house. Mars in 8th conjunct Rahu. It doesn't get worse than that.
Could someone explain to me if I was born TODAY (11-9-2020) How would I be a Scorpio if my Sun is in Libra? I know its Scorpio Season according to the Tropical Zodiac But my sign is suppose to be because of the position of the Sun when I'm born right?
Please learn the basics of what a zodiac is, how it relates to calendars, and what the difference between sidereal and tropical is, at vicdicara.com/tropical
Wouldn’t you also look at Navamsa for marriage and life after a certain age?
I’m remembering all my past lives and why I died and the lessons for this life of not to show how I learned. I have no friends and love to be alone and isolated and I have a perfectionist traits and a hoarder as well. So I’m all over the place, oh and I’m extremely sensitive to everyone and everything…classical music I like a lot and Math, Sciences and History are my favorite subjects…
And?
Nice example to explain the difference between using Indian and Western astrology. I always focused on Indian astrology, but I am sold by using Western astrology with Nakshatras from the Indian astrology. My own horoscope makes more sense. Much love. Xx
Which do you find more resonating, as am also in dilemma after getting to know about tropical zodiac?
Doesn't tropical 5th L in 10th H mean famous for intellect in a way?
Was waiting for you to mention the specific degrees & distinct #nakshatras it’s on. You likely might already know this, but #KapielRaaj briefly mentioned Venus exalted is not what people imagine it to be. Also, from another #VedicAstrology discussion on exalted vs debilitated planets:
yeah, they prefer to think Venus and Mars exalted is not what it should be. I prefer to realize that the planets are not exalted, they are in the next signs (Aries and Aquarius, resp.), and ARE what they should be.
WWE in Vic dicara's 😂 boy I loved it.
When you analyse his romantic relationships shouldn’t his partners charts been included? Communicationwise I think he carried within himself a totally until then unknown reality which he at last could express in his E=mc2. I wonder maybe we were the ones who didn’t understand him. Even now I do not know what he meant. In my knowledge he suffered from dyslexia and his first wife who was a physicist too wrote Einsteins 1912´s manuscript... her name was never mentioned on the document because women at that time were not admitted in highranking scientific circles.
Whether the sidereal chart is more relevant than the tropical chart we do carry them both within us. So gaining knowledge and understanding by learning can’t be but helpful. Thank you for this work of understanding 🙏.
no you dont need a partner's chart to understands a person's relationship traits.
I am only 47 Albert Einstein chart is nearly exactly as mine.
its really impressive the amount of detail you can talk about in 27 minutes and give a coherent argument in your unique way. as an aside, you know u cant be a real vedic astrologer without doing a horoscope breakdown of amithab bacchan lmao. just kidding bro. i find his horoscope is really popular among indian astrologers and their youtube channels
lol
What website do you use for Vedic? I don’t know which is more accurate
I don't use a website. I am a pro, I have my own software
Vic DiCara's Astrology is it a software that can be downloaded for a price?
@@dannyshephard6292 get kala software for this astrological school.
Also...10th lord in the 9th house since Pisces is co-ruled by Jupiter... Here you can clearly see how his scientific develop and the intelligence thereof...always striving to merge science with religion since Jupiter there is the 9th of Aquarius... You can clearly see where his intelligence stems from...in this position he contends with intellectual opposition and goes against the grain of the Guru the teachers and tries prove his point to be right... Which is exactly what he did...but generally this is someone who is imaginative and knowledgeable enough to cause some rebellion in what is being taught....and Aquarius being coruled by Rahu gives him this quality
But what about the D7 and D9?
last video people complained i was too complicated with all the vargas. and this is a birth from a long time ago. how sure can we be of the exact time?
Also I really don't understand this whole mixing tropical with sidereal, I mean how am I supposed to find out the nakshatras.
see vicdicara.com/tropical - it is very simple. To find nakshatras, use ayanamsha. That is what Ayanamsha is FOR. Ayanamsha measures distance between the N.Equinox and a reference star (typically Citra-tara, marking the exact middle of Citra-nakshatra). Once you know this you know where all the nakshatras are.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology kewll thanks I'll check it out
Vic you should you use your own chart, so that you can tell which one best describes you.
uh... what makes you think i havent done that?
@@VicDiCaraAstrology yhhs plzz you doo your chart sideriall and tropicallll
@@VicDiCaraAstrology I meant you should make a video about it
Firstly I would like to thank you for all the knowledge that I gain from your videos. I often watch the charts of celebrities online, but somehow I find multiple similarities between Einstein's chart and my own chart. Like my 1st lord in the 3rd house, 5th lord in the 2nd house, 7th lord in the 1st house, 11th lord in the 8th house, moon in Sagittarius and many more things that I noticed. I was always good in arts, sports and academics. I have been trying to figure out a suitable career for me but I always feel torn between the choices I have. I would like to know if you do personal consultations as well. I have been trying to figure out my own chart and I appreciate everything that I have learned from your videos.
Thank you, for readings please see www.vicdicara.com
I think I have autism and I have the almost same symptoms in this chart.
Very modern psychodynamic approach...
I would think it would be better to have mercury conjunct exalted 5th lord in the 10th house to give the lagna capacity for such intellectual prowess. Strengthening Jupiter through the parivartana will help as well.
The most salient feature of Einstein's autism was a disorder of speech which is indicated by both the debilitated mercury and debilitated moon as 2nd lord. Not being able to comprehend emotions is also related to weak moon...
For affairs I'd look at the Navamsa 2nd house, based on the work of Freedom Cole which is up on RUclips. It's amazing how well the principle works in Einsteins chart as second lord Mars is squarely conjunct Venus in the vacuous sign of Aquarius. This principle is right out of Parashara ruclips.net/video/J10t_SuxGSU/видео.html
What you said about autism is right on the money. They want to do complicated things.
My son just ordered a reading from you tonight. He ordered the Astrological Guidance and will like to focus on career. I told him it would be an excellent reading. I did the complete chart breakdown and I'm still learning from it.
( The video title says " Albert Einstien " instead of Einstein- just good for the algorithm of YT maybe to change that ? )
Thanks
(Continuation) you could have told us about why his child was schizophrenic..what could have caused that..and about the death of his daughter..if possible make a video on the possible astrological reason, aspect.
And there are interesting life incidents like him accidentally finding about the role of acceleration, while using an escalator or lift. He got clarity in relativity theory when he saw two toy trains.
juipter in the 8th with Rāhu. 5th lord in 7th, exchanging with the 10th. these are very negative for 5th house theme of children, but very positive for 5th house theme of intelligence
@@VicDiCaraAstrology insightful. And yeah..rahu is about obsessions, diseases..and jupiter which represents children is along..in the house of death (8th house).. Great explanation. Thank you sir. And as u said 5th lord involving intelligence is meeting 7th house and the house of career..the 10th..so now i guess it sure is destiny the reason for the things that happened in his life.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology i forgot to mention..rahu is about illusion too..it being with jupiter is the reason maybe a kid was schezophrenic.. sry if iam wrong..
Am not an astrology expert..just learning..
Astrology gives signs to predict from..thats it i guess..i feel its upto the beholder or astrolger to understand, predict.
Astrology involves a lot of factors like stars, their luck, the house, aspects and planetary conjunctions...since all those have to be taken into consideration, given a point, i guess astrologers have a great deal of work to do..and a lot of wit is needed.
@@VicDiCaraAstrology the big doubt i usually have in my mind is, whether planets pass on their energy, vibrations to the living beings on earth, and create good and bad time or else its not any outside energy and "we are will" and a part of this universe, made of the 5 elements wind, water, fire etc. I slightly believe the second option..coz there is a concept where planets are responsible for even skin colour, and houses represent body parts. First house for the head and so on.
You give a lot of explanations about astrology, and some of them might have an answer for this doubt already, but i just dont know which one..its hard to pull out the answer
in tropical he has 4 planets in fire sign, in sidereal he has no planets in fire sign
I felt the bias in this video
I believe the Cancer Ascendant seem more relevant simply b/c of his treatment of women as wives…
The Gemini Ascendant would make him more agreeable with women- more social and willing to appraise the wants and needs and be friendly with women.
Ok , no morality but deeply spiritual , thats exalted Venus it also gives deep hidden knowledge , namely mritsanjivani mantra , thats shukracharya for you
venus in 1st house is love of self not other that seems to be him ,,, = the cheating ~`~
he doesn't have Venus in the 1st house. its in the 10th
Venus with debilitated Mercury in Pisces cancels the debilitation....
which makes no sense because his poor intellect was not saved by his great sense of cooperation or marriage, etc.
I have heard it being interpreted as the cancellation of neech Mercury by the exaltation of Venus in Pisces.
Instead of tesla it would make more sense to make a chart of Cristiano ronaldo
That neecha bhanga seems interesting...born without ability to speak well but later gains the capability 🤔
just bad :)