What changes will Southgate make to his starting XI vs Switzerland? 🏴
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/Subscri...
Kaveh Solhekol and Rob Dorsett reflect on England's dramatic last-16 game against Slovakia and look ahead to their quarter-final game against Switzerland.
#football #euro2024 #england
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysportsfootball
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.c...
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON RUclips:
►SKY SPORTS PREMIER LEAGUE: bit.ly/Subscri...
►SKY SPORTS FOOTBALL: bit.ly/Subscri...
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SKY SPORTS CRICKET: bit.ly/Subscrib...
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/Subscrib...
►SKY SPORTS: bit.ly/SkySport...
►SKY SPORTS GOLF: bit.ly/Subscri...
Southgate won't make any changes because in his head he's getting everything right
He is deluded to the highest order
This is true. I think he feels vindicated in his choice by that stroke of luck last game. Even the way he talked about being on Toney late Like it proved his plan was solid
Well he has to make changes because guehi is suspended and trippier is injured
U ain’t Neva lie
Southgate will make changes hes naming him self as a sub 😊
Phil Foden is left footed, they got that wrong
It's just that he's not a natural winger, he's not particularly good at beating a man by going down the outside on his left
Gordon is right footed but still can beat a man going either way and is much better at holding the width and impacting the game from there
Did you watch city the last few seasons mate
@@byBlazing He did not. Seemingly no one has
Well, I watched every minute he has played and he is considerably more effective in the centre or to the right of centre. He isn’t blessed with pace though and needs someone to overlap if he is played on the wing. Never saw the best of him there though, but since moving to the middle on a more permanent basis, he has excelled.
@@alfiewright1396 foden doing bad at england is simple Southgate tactic and squad he picked was poor
He only picked one natural left back (shaw) who is injured for the position we have trippier konsa eze saka all trying it out at times but they won't be good enough at giving proper service you expect from the full backs which is to overlap/invert since full backs are to assist the wingers as we use full backs ideally southgate should change formation with the squad we use to a 3-4-3 or 5-2-2-1 because the current formation isn't good for the squad we have selected which has an abundance if attacking players and more centre backs than native full backs so we need to put to good use our centre backs we have playing with a back 3/5 is definitely the way to go and change the way we start at the back to give a better momentum as the ball goes forward because atm we aren't defensively sound clearly and why we don't have much attacking threat
Can't blame Southgate for the lack of energy, forward runs or effort. We see it all the time players playing well for clubs but non existent for their country. It's wrong and needs to be addressed
He will make zero changes until the 88 min
And then it will be a defensive midfielder…..😂😂
89
90 + 1
@@stefangrant1989 and only cos of an injury
Be all good as long as we 3-0 up
Palmer and Gordon to start.
They should have started every game so far, also Watkins alongside Kane up front.
This change would have been the obvious one every game after Serbia but the fact that he has refused to make it leads me to assume that yet again he won’t
@@England-fan01 Yes to Gordon on the left. But Palmer?
Everyone would agree except for Southgate. Konsa for Gaehi that's it and we'll go out with a whimper
Ivan Toney
Phil Foden is left footed…. This is some shocking reporting.
The only changes he'll make is how they'll arrange themselves in the airplane this weekend
Airplane from Gelsenkirchen to Düsseldorf?🤦♂️
@marc.the.red1987 the red? is that liverpool or man u? LOL
Nice one!
ha ha ha ha ha
😂😂😂
He’ll name exactly the same team and still expect a different performance.
The definition of insanity
Yep, he is deluded and a coward.
Any time we win, he thinks it's vindication of his management, no matter how bad
The Swiss approach will be to attack in behind the fullbacks as often as possible, esp Walker..
It’s not the starting XI England need to make changes to. It’s the manager.
As much as I agree Southgate should go. Changing the starting xi is also vital, Kane should not be playing and cannot fit into the team with the likes of Bellingham and foden, it just doesn’t work.
🥱
@@Phillips596100% Foden should be dropped and not Kane
It's both.
@@lloydy11 why not Kane? What are you seeing from Kane that tells you he's a threat in the big games?
He calls Foden right footed and Italy the hosts...😅
If Southgate's bath was overflowing he would sit there and watch it flood his house because turning the taps off would force him into making a decision.
😂
He'd put Kane in his bath, just in case.
Southgate wouldn’t run a bath, just in case he flooded his house.
@@thewellandvalley2103 *amen*
And then when its full he'd open the front door letting it all pour out. Thus techincally solving the problem.
Most teams are playing a back 3 because it gives you more numbers in midfield. England should play a back 3 and make TAA and Saka wingbacks if Shaw is not yet fit. drop one of Foden or Bellingham, play Palmer
This!
@Best_game59 - Surely GS will have realised that everyone else has in that Terence Trent Darby should not be playing, it's like playing with 10 men with him there.
he wont hes way too stubborn
Why are they standing so close to each other
They have deffo fucked 100%
Was hoping it wasn't just me lol
This is because the camera does not have a wide lens, so they are side by side to fit into the frame and are in the centre of the frame and not on the outer sides.
Its no illusion. They're right next to each other 😂@hilal2050
because they're in love. stop being so homophobic.
This is Southgate we're talking about, it'll be as much the same as possible, he doesn't seem to realise there's more than one page in a playbook.
In the last euros he switched between a back 4 and a back 3 multiple times
@@alfiewright1396people have short memories though, they forget he used to switch between systems before at tournaments
Southgate could go through menopause and still not change
😂😂😂
zero pointless converation change the formation they get this is gareth southgate they are talking about dont they🤣
to answer that question is pretty much this: to understand the mind of a nut job you must become the nut job yourself? it's the only way of answering that question!
Typical Sky Sports getting the facts wrong. Foden is left footed on the left, so Kyle Walker & Phil Foden are the only TWO same footed players on the same wing. Please Sky do your research 🙏
They even commented on Saka's average position vs Slovakia without realising his average position was more inside because he played 20 minutes at LB. These two clowns are not sports analysts.
At least dump Trippier.
Injuries or suspensions is our only hope at getting a good team on the pitch now
Play bellinghamd as a no.8
Play foden no 10
Bring in Palmer and Gordon on the wings
We need width!!!! Saka and Foden refuse to
No changes just another 90 mins of absolute shite. If we’re lucky he makes a sub in the 89th minute
Don't want to rush it, there might be 7 minutes of extra time
Three things I want to see more than anything are Foden in the number 10 posiiton, Bellingham dropped back, and Palmer playing.
Toney has a higher goals per game ratio than Foden in the Premier league and already has one assist to Kane. Swiss are weak against set pieces and Toney is a target man.
@@MrHeyhomes I'm not against Toney playing. Kane looks better with someone like that next to him. You could have Bellingham and Rice as defensive mids, Foden more advanced and central, then Kane, Toney and Palmer as a front 3, and the wing backs providing width....maybe Saka in left back. Or just don't play Foden but it's not working with him on the left....that's my main thing tbh.
Kane is getting so deep you could cut out a midfielder and give him the 10 role. He has put out some great passes from that zone although it isn’t his job.
Let’s be real Southgate ain’t changing anything
Enough with trying to fit in Foden and trying to restrict your best player. Enough. He’s been playing in that 10 role unless you don’t watch the games. It’s stupid. He’s impeding your two best players. Enough. Make him an impact sub with significant minutes like what he’s doing with Palmer now.
I don't understand about strategies, but each England player receiving the ball and then standing still for several seconds allows the opposition time to regroup and stifle any England advance. You've got to keep moving and passing.
I've been saying since before we kicked a ball qt this tournament.. 1 player who would do that is 1 player who hasn't had a single minute. Wharton can make this team tick
It could be Southgate's last game in charge as England manager. The team Southgate selects to face Switzerland should just go for it .!!!! And get us to the semi - final's and the final .!!!!
Clowngate is to much of a coward for that 🤣🤣
Seems the Average position of Saka (#7) on the 2nd image is skewed by him playing left-back for a portion of the game. Clearly there's still a problem with the #10 position being crowded, but Saka was actually providing width.
If Southgate were case in a war film, you just know he’d be the man quivering and crying in the trench.
Nah, he'd be the General, sending the men in to die while he sat back and watched, and did nothing
Start Ivan Toney he makes a massive difference to the squad
Do England have a Psychiatrist as well as a physio? Cos Southgate needs urgent help.
Southgate is just out of his depth in terms of tactics. Can’t wait to see the back of him.
Here thinking about changes to starting eleven?? I think sky crew may be getting ahead of thereselves here lmaol wv SG, expect nothing but thesame 11, only gueye not coming on due to trippier's fault. Which no one is talking about of😡
Switserland will be better obviously but somehow England will get trough given the luck they had so far
Cry
Cool chat by Sky Draper Solekah - Maths profs say Gareth 3 🦁 will win better w a 3-4-3 w Trent as a right wingback & Saka as Left WB. Harry does much better with partners like Palmer & Jude up front. Use Foden as an impact sub. Cmon, get 3 lions fans to pray & meditate for 3 lions' victory to end 58 yrs of hurt.
They tried everything else & lost over 58 yrs, so give prayer power a go this time.
Sorry does this rob dorsett actually know anything about England or football as a whole? foden on the lw right footed? he is definitely not right footed. and also, Switzerland didn't knock the hosts out he is quite clearly, to himself, stood somewhere in Germany not Italy. Honestly embarrassing to listen to
Toney looked a handful. Kane has no pace and needs to play behind a striker. England don't dominate games like Bayern do.
Agreed- an handful is a great way to describe him. Kane isn’t like that and with nothing going wide on the wings then cutting back that’s half of Kanes game gone
I’d also like to see Southgate switch to 3-4-3:
Pickford
Walker
Stones
Konza
TAA
Bellingham
Rice
Saka
Foden
Kane
Eze or Gordon.
No point in analysing Sakas average position because he played at LB for some of the game which adjusted that average position massively. He actually hugged the touchline for a lot of that game.
Gareth is afraid of players who take risks. He has played every single midfielder except from wharton.. the only player who loves to play forward.. yet 4 games in and we've played terrible in every game
☆Cmon, get the 3 lions fans to pray & meditate for 3 lions' victory to end 58 yrs of hurt. They tried everything else & lost over 58 yrs, so give spiritual power a go this time.
I think you will find that Phil Foden is left footed , not right footed as you have stated
I doubt there will be any changes apart from Konsa for Guehi. It would be nice if Southgate at least tried Saka LW and Foden RW.
Let's get real .do you think Southgate has a clue .don't think so
Southgate won’t change anything unless forced by injury or suspensions. He will never win a trophy.
Why do you say Italy are the hosts?
Because they think Foden is right footed, what do you expect?
Where's the support for the players, come on guys show some support for the lads. I would love to see Southgate win this tournament, come on guys yoh got this.
We all would love that, in the real world we'd just be happy with some coherent football, any....
Not one Englishman doesn't want England to win but blindly supporting something that is quite obviously failing in its execution without analysing it is just stupid.
@@cameronjones8641 Look I get your point and we will have to wait and see how things develop, and nothing wrong with what you are saying, the team needs to restore faith in the fans again so as an England supporter it only makes sense why fans have become very skeptical about the team winning.
All the best 🍷
Pickford
walker stones gomez
Trent. Rice. Bellingham. Saka
Foden
Kane. Watkins
Nice but gotta go Mainoo with Rice. Put Bellingham where Foden is and drop Foden. Then put Gordon on the left instead of Saka and Palmer instead of Trent further up. Should be 3/4 or 5 in defence at all times and frees up 5 players to be creative up front attacking. Perfect balance with Bellingham in the deep middle because he's got the full game of defence and attack, hold up and destroyer, heading and dribbling.
Foden is too lightweight in defence and needs to be in front of the box to affect the game.
@@commentarytalk1446👍🏻
@@commentarytalk1446 bellingham should be in midfield & rice should be in defence
he should have been playing three at the back all along with this group of players.
pickford pickford
stones rice walker stones rice walker
gordon trent bellingham saka OR trent mainoo bellingham saka
foden foden
palmer kane palmer kane
This formation was also boring to watch doesnt create much what r these people saying.
If Stones can’t play.. and with Guehi on suspension.. play a back 3, and put Saka at back left, Trent back right, and Walker at CB.
I would consider playing 3-1-4-2. Let Mainoo play defensive mid. Gordon and Palmer on wings. Foden and Jude in the center. Kane and Watkins up top. Alternatively could play 3-5-2. Gordon and Palmer on wings. Kane and Watkins up top. Foden at 10. Jude and Rice in the middle.
It’s just a fact - this experiment of Foden on the wing, Jude at 10, and Kane at the 9, with Saka on the wing, is simply not working. They are going to LOSE against the Swiss if they refuse to change this formation.
Saka would have to defend a bit..?
I just spoke to Roy Hodgson and he’s adamant Kane should take the corners 😂
Southgate must make changes or it's the England team will be coming home.
Eddie Howe to replace Southgate!!
Southgate's "if it's broken don't fix it" mentality can only last so long - probably only another 90 minutes.
But it is profoundly broken he just has his eyes screwed tightly shut.
You may be right. He's never lost a match at the Euros, though. (As either player or manager.)
@@bonglesnodkins329 surely that can’t be true cos we would have won
@@mikem9309 It's completely true. Penalty shootouts are not part of the match; they take place after the match if the match is still a draw at full time. FIFA and UEFA will record such matches as draws.
The final between Italy and England in 2021 was a draw, therefore a penalty shootout was held after the match to decide who won the cup.
All Southgate's Euro results:
As player:
England 1 - 1 Switzerland
England 2 - 0 Scotland
England 4 - 1 Netherlands
England 0 - 0 Spain
England 1 - 1 Germany
As manager:
England 1 - 0 Croatia
England 0 - 0 Scotland
England 1 - 0 Czech Republic
England 2 - 0 Germany
England 4 - 0 Ukraine
England 2 - 1 Denmark
England 1 - 1 Italy
England 1 - 0 Serbia
England 1 - 1 Denmark
England 0 - 0 Slovenia
England 2 - 1 Slovakia
Edit: Oh, actually, he did come on as a sub for the final nine minutes of England vs Romania in 2000, which was a 2-3 defeat thanks to Phil Neville's last minute blunder.
@@bonglesnodkins329 that’s a worrying low number of goals overall
FODEN is left footed. Don’t know what you’re talking about
No more goals though. They key with Kane is I think delivery at less expected times and in swinging balls from the wings are a good option. Spain have the best look don't they.
Phil Foden is left footed so these facts need to be checked.
Plesse correct yourself. Italy are not the hosts. The hosts are Germany, and we wont be getting knocked out of this tournament.
They think Foden is right footed. 🤦♂
Meant to say holders
He won't make any changes because he can't see the need to make any changes beyond loyalty to his senior entrusted players
Get Mansell, Hill and Button in midfield. Rooney and Owen up front. Sol Campbell and Terry in Defense. Bellingham in midfield too.
It's coming home.
Just need to get the clown coach out and it solves a lot of problems
NOTHING!
You should not speak about football if you do not know Foden is left footed
Southgate: We didn't attack well and that's why I'll go with 5 at the back.
It's not always a defensive formation, you can attack with it if you let the wing backs get forward
@@alfiewright1396that's true though and I want to see 5 with TAA, walker at CB and Trippier lwb or Shaw if he's available
gordon - Gomez or Konza - Stones- Walker- TAA
. Pickford
TAA Stones Konsa Walker
Mainoo Rice
Saka Bellingham Gordon
Toney
Bellingham and Foden doesn't work. Both are good tens and you can't play with 2 tens. Saka and Gordon can hold the width... Then the midfield will work better
Southgate will pick the same starting 11. Thats all he knows.
Second time Rob Dorsett is doing the same mistake - saying Foden is right footed
After watching that performance they come to the conclusion that we need to play more centre backs? Who are these two herberts?
None
As if Southgate will make any changes.
Simply put……NONE. 😂
Do a 1 - 2 -7. That should bring in the goals.
this guy is so negative... starting right out with the team feeling "drained"... what about "elated" or a "new sense of confidence" from the game against Slovakia. Again, same guy talking about how "drained" the team are said to rest Bellingham for the Slovakia game.
have you been watching England or the darts, cos anyone who has watched even 5 minutes of England would be incapable of using any positive words to describe it
Dorsett, Switzerland didn't knock the hosts out did they? The hosts are Germany who are still in.
He obviously means the holders, it's not a big deal 😂
@@shanebrown1544 For the money and perks of his job I expect him to be more professional than basic errors like that.
He did say holder's
@@kevinstreet5709 Listen at 1.11 into the video. He says "Hosts".
@@kevinstreet5709 Yes he did later on but earlier said "Hosts".
ANSWER: NONE.
Next question….
None ocourse. He doesn't even make subs.
Non , he’s frightened to make changes. Unless we are losing and we have a minute left to play.
So if England want to win against Switzerland please look in the mirror as you are not an amazing player just because you are paid a lot of cash! Yet cannot rev up and keep in toes and kick with both feet, difficult to respect this crowd of prima donners!
Team against Swiss!
No Pickford, play Ramsdale!
Back 3: Walker, Gueye, Stones
Def mid: Rice, Bellingham, Palmer
Att mid: Foden, Saka, Kane
Attack: Toney
We should play a 4-2-3-1
TAA-stones-ghehi-Walker
Rice-Bellingham
Saka-Foden-palmer
Kane
Guehi can’t play
@@ConnorReece1 he’s been decent imo I’d prefer him over Maguire
@@David_Mc_Our_God_Reigns he got booked against Slovakia he misses the next game. I like him too but he is suspended against the Swiss.
@@ConnorReece1 hmm 🤔 i didn’t know that. Who do we have decent enough to replace him? Who’s your preferred choice?? It looks as if it will have to be Joe Gomez. I can’t believe branthwaite wasn’t picked for the squad
@@David_Mc_Our_God_Reigns I think Southgate will probably play Konsa and that’s why he brought him on as a late sub in the last game too
Southgate dont need to change the formation ,he only has to utilized the players in there best positions , He dont want to play Foden as No10, the game vs Swiss, he have to start Foden no10, Palmer RW, Gordon LW, Toney No9, Mainnoo & Wharton Dm ,Trippier LB,Walker RB, Konsa & Stones CB. Give stones ,Dm/pivote role, free pass ,to move up the pitch .Drop Jude & Rice for 2nd half
I find all the Southgate hate kinda ridiculous. Have we played well? No! But look at previous SG tournaments. Simi final. Final. Simi final. Then this tournament: top of the group. Last 16: win. Yet he gets SO much hate. It’s utterly ridiculous and appalling imo.
He won't make any that's the problem
He wont change unless it's enforced. Maybe, at a push, he'll change from Walker, but he believes he's right and been vindicated by progressing. It'll probably be a more open game against the Swiss but Trent on right, Gomez on left, and Gordon in for Foden is really basic and needed.
For a country that has Superstars playing in the EPL and Europe, the midfielders and Kane have been very disappointing since the 1st half of the Serbia game....Southgate got lucky and he might get lucky again against the Swiss but you don't win games on lucky - you need some innovation and common sense on the ground too.
He'll do nothing. Nepotism FC will play his usual squad & fluke his way through because of the quality of our players, or lose to a well organised Switzerland. But I'll give Southgate some credit, it's far better to be lucky than good.
3-5-2 Pickford / Walker-Stones-Konsa / TrentAA-Mainoo-Bellingham-Rice-Saka / Foden-Kane . Defence and PIckford need to trust Mainoo to take ball on half-turn more. Mainoo needs to demand it.
Some awful takes here to be honest…
Regarding width, if you have possession you stretch the pitch, if you don’t you come narrow… Portugal and Spain have had the most poses in this tournament by a long way so of course their average positions will look wider…
Very easy to look at stats and diagrams and create a narrative around it
I think that no matter what formation or changes he makes he will keep his 2 defensive midfielders, and play defensively, which is a crime with this group of attacking players, , instead of attacking teams and making them defend meaning they can't attack us , he will go all out defensive and let the swiss come at us , and again he will hope the luck stays with us and hope the team goes through instead of giving the team what it needs a chance to attack, if we get beat and go out it will be the FAs fault for not sacking Southgate after the last game ,
It's the chicken and egg saga we want to win and go through, but we also want to perform better, so what do we want first , performance or the win ,,,,, imagine have the best game of the tournament and losing , or we win again but we have the worst performance, ideally we would all love to see us a great performance and the win
Man the fella on the right chats some shite, Italy hosts? Foden right footed?? And Kaveh, last England played 3-4-3 was Germany at Euro 2020? How about the final they lost 🧐
Probably won't make any changes (except forced) Personally I don't think it is entirely a midfield problem, you need runners in attacking positions and Kane is not a target man or a runner. JMHO
Without Marc Guehi, England will get embarrassed, i strongly suggest Gallagher to start in a 4-5-1 formation with Gordon on the left because you will need to play on the break for most parts of the game
I am afraid "Boys" Gareth Southgate will no idea what you are talking about. Just check out a video montage
of Southgate passing back to his goalkeeper as a player. He doesn't know anything else.
Congratulations to Switzerland on reaching the Semis.
England mismanaged from game one of this tournament and far longer, sadly.
I see a cagey match, likely with England going out on Pens.
if he names another sqaud and gets wrong he’ll get even more hate than sticking with same … or they could just win it all and shut everyone up. but doubt that would happen even of Engl win. 😅
IMO, GS won't change much, Konza obviously but I can see Saka starting ahead of Trippier, Palmer would then start. 3 at the back is an option
If they stick to a back 4, bring Wharton in, Get Rice driving as an 8 and keep Bellingham in the 10. Saka and Gordon each wing. Wharton is the Carrick type solution.
Talking facts. He’s better than Rice
@@tshepomokoena5246 Wharton is unproven at this level. Thats a step too far. And dont forget he's flourishing under a great coach at Palace whereas this is Southgate who destroys decent players
Southgate might change Kobbie for Trent. Or he might not, depends on what Mystic Meg has to say on Friday really. That's where Southgate gets most of his tactics from
Needs to go with 2 up front and 5 at the back, Trent and shaw/saka full backs, tuck walker inside with stones and konsa. Rice Bellingham mainoo, kane Toney/watkins
Trent massively scape goated. Created most chances for England in the tournament. Mainoo, Bellingham and rice have all given the ball away sloppily in that midfield
Gareth will switch to a 352 - the only formation he knows since El Tel back in 96. Jude up top with H, Foden in a midfield 3 - Saka LWB.
The conversation about England is sounding insane because our manager is insane. So wot's the point?
Using Portugal as the example of playing wide and saying "this is what England really need to do" when Portugal also failed to score against Slovenia in 120 minutes