What If Qui Gon Jinn Was In Revenge of the Sith?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • Part 2 of our Qui-Gon in the prequels story wraps up with Revenge of The Sith. Will Qiui-Gon save Anakin from the Dark side? Will the Jedi Order still fall as the Empire rises? Qui-Gon's influence would definitely have changed certain events considerably, but would he be enough to stop Palpatine from taking over the galaxy? Find out here, you scruffy lookin' nerf herders!
    Watch Part 1 here - • What If Qui Gon Jinn T...
    Concept art by - www.artstation...
    Download the episode here - channelawesome....
    Grab it on iTunes - podcasts.apple...
    Follow us on Twitch - / channelawesome
    Go to our Store for Awesome Stuff - theawesomestor...
    Get some Nostalgia Critic T-Shirts here - shrsl.com/?~96c0
    See more at our Site: channelawesome.com
    Facebook: / channelawesome
    Twitter: / channelawesome
    Instagram: / channelawesome
    Like Doug on Facebook: / 127127037353766
    The ONLY Official RUclips channel for the Nostalgia Critic and Channel Awesome.
    New Nostalgia Critic episodes every Wednesday at 5PM CST.
    #FanScription #StarWars #RevengeoftheSith

Комментарии • 831

  • @ChannelAwesome
    @ChannelAwesome  4 года назад +104

    Watch Part 1 here - ruclips.net/video/zj0-8f43il4/видео.html
    Concept art by - www.artstation.com/kuhleesee
    Download the episode here - channelawesome.libsyn.com/
    Grab it on iTunes - podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fanscription/id1449887688
    Follow us on Twitch - www.twitch.tv/channelawesome

    • @C0micfan
      @C0micfan 4 года назад +4

      Hey in you f.s. Series can you do what you did with Harley Quinn or the joker again
      Can you try adding other batman villain to other batman films like
      I would like to see Harvey dent From batman 1989 in Bat man forever
      Or
      I would like to see joker in batman returns or Penguin in bat man forever or even riddler in batman and robin
      Please respond

    • @RealMikeWazowski
      @RealMikeWazowski 4 года назад +2

      Channel Awesome I love Channel Awesome

    • @5secondstudio771
      @5secondstudio771 4 года назад +4

      Would you consider adapting a new hope with this version of the prequels as your foundation? But when you make that keep this in mind that even a minor change in the timeline can have unforeseeable consequences as the years spiral out. It was only about 13 years since the death of Qui-gon Jinn and the Battle on Mustafar in the original continuity and while the event itself still happened in the changes in the timeline the events leading up to it were quite different, even going so far as to have Grievous die first. It probably goes without saying but the events we saw change in this version are but the tip of the iceberg I mean what about the clone wars Kenobi's death prior to the clone wars changes the events on Mandalore durring the lone Wars and possibly Mandalorian Civil War that happens later, in fact depending on how much it changes the clone war it may even prevent the Mandalorian Civil War entirely. Not every change has to have a negative outcome on the timeline, but that actually brings up an interesting point anyways, because with an entire chapter in history being deleted something has to take it's place, (I think the best example of just how fast a minor change can damage the timeline happens in the arrowvers in the 2 part episode "Out of Time/Rogue Time") long story short the fact of the matter is that by the time of the events of A New Hope came along the timeline would be almost unrecognizable. If I were to pick up where you left of I would have it that something happened in his past that saw Galen Erso be loyal to the empire and not a rebel spy mascaraing as an imperialist to the point where even the people he's trying to help don't realize that he's in fact on their side, and no spy Galen Erso means no Death-star Weakness. but that is just one way that this universe can change going forward. The possibilities are essentially limitless. Still I hope you continue. maybe retcon out Duku's death so that it only seemed like he died.

    • @newbienoobframebyframe4108
      @newbienoobframebyframe4108 4 года назад +3

      Dude, bit random... But you should review "furry vengeance" the brendon Frasier one, not the porn. Its gotta be his worst film. I just watched it and immediately thought you should be subjected to it! Just an idea

    • @tylarg
      @tylarg 4 года назад +2

      @@newbienoobframebyframe4108 you just wanna see that thicc brendan fraser botty again

  • @marcossimian9583
    @marcossimian9583 4 года назад +609

    Vader: _"Luke, I am your brother!"_
    Luke: _"Wait... Really? Huh, well this is awkward!"_
    Vader: _"You're telling me."_

  • @victorbruant389
    @victorbruant389 4 года назад +783

    He would use a very particular set of skills that he had acquired over a very long career to save the Republic and Democracy.
    He would find Palpatine. And then he would kill him.

    • @gurrakalas5093
      @gurrakalas5093 4 года назад +14

      LMAO XD

    • @DavidRay39
      @DavidRay39 4 года назад +13

      I saw what you did there. Is that from Taken? Or whatever it's called?

    • @victorbruant389
      @victorbruant389 4 года назад +4

      @@DavidRay39 Yes

    • @jasonvcool1770
      @jasonvcool1770 4 года назад +8

      I doubt that I'm pretty sure on this theory qui Gon can turn Anakin back from the Darkside

    • @Hessed3712
      @Hessed3712 4 года назад +4

      Victor Bruant Yeeees!

  • @jakemorgan7477
    @jakemorgan7477 4 года назад +356

    If Anakin was trained by Qui-Gon. He would never have turned.

    • @coachgoltzbizpro23
      @coachgoltzbizpro23 3 года назад +33

      I think we all agree. Something tells me that's not the route ChannelAwesome wanted to go...

    • @alexbasha0508
      @alexbasha0508 3 года назад +40

      I think Qui-Gon was truly the only one to SUCCESSFULLY trainer Anakin and keep him on the right path.

    • @TheAusugn
      @TheAusugn 3 года назад +9

      Agreed

    • @williamschubert868
      @williamschubert868 3 года назад +15

      @@alexbasha0508 I think that id Anakin was trained by Windu or Yoda he would have never turned.

    • @savageshot3723
      @savageshot3723 3 года назад +3

      @Seamus McBratnie He means if he never died in phantom menace dude
      You trolling?

  • @pelicanking9596
    @pelicanking9596 4 года назад +170

    Personally in my opinion
    If Qui-Gon was still alive Count Dooku would have never turned and the Separatists would have most likely never formed

    • @apolloknight9521
      @apolloknight9521 4 года назад +20

      The Separatist would most likely still form but under different leadership with someone else

    • @fryanbeef178
      @fryanbeef178 3 года назад +1

      did count dooku turn after episode one? i thought he was sith before episode 1

    • @pelicanking9596
      @pelicanking9596 3 года назад +17

      @@fryanbeef178 No, it was Qui Gons death that essentially pushed him over the edge

    • @fryanbeef178
      @fryanbeef178 3 года назад +2

      @@pelicanking9596 o okay thanks

    • @trianglemoebius
      @trianglemoebius 2 года назад +4

      @@pelicanking9596 He'd probably still turn. The Death of Qui-Gon was the final push, not a catalyst for the whole transformation. He'd no doubt have had some other event serve as that final push.

  • @EmRose.r
    @EmRose.r 4 года назад +277

    "You killed my brother!"
    "No, Luke, I am your brother."

    • @calebjmelendez
      @calebjmelendez 4 года назад +17

      That's impossible!!!

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад +2

      Fantastic Caleb too common

    • @snakejesus
      @snakejesus 4 года назад +4

      Big question is if his half brother is Luke then that would mean his father would’ve been His uncle Lars having a Bastard child from Shmi

    • @EmperorShaoKahn123
      @EmperorShaoKahn123 4 года назад +1

      The funny part is that I already say that as an inside joke whenever I put ROTS Anakin and ROTJ Luke side by side
      Since they physically look more like brothers than a father and his son

    • @IceAlvaro13
      @IceAlvaro13 2 года назад

      Why is Luke her brother?, they is the son of Beru and Owen.

  • @firstnamelastname5716
    @firstnamelastname5716 4 года назад +240

    I would love to see this timeline continue on with the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy

  • @Bryce4Impact
    @Bryce4Impact 4 года назад +104

    So Darth Vader is Mister Freeze by the end?
    I love it!

  • @Gat-Man55
    @Gat-Man55 4 года назад +317

    Well if luke was never Vader’s son a lot of the emotional weight of their encounters would be gone

    • @auroradragen5920
      @auroradragen5920 4 года назад +24

      Not gone but shifted. It probably wouldnt be as powerful a thing but as someone with a few syblings meeting a older brother I know either nothing about, next to nothing about, or only knew that he was a Jedi and an Hero as they try and kill me would fuck my head up.

    • @auroradragen5920
      @auroradragen5920 4 года назад +7

      Like I'm not saying your completely wrong I'm just saying done right Vader and Luke's encounters would still have emotional weight

    • @Sentryman002
      @Sentryman002 4 года назад +5

      @@auroradragen5920 I agree. The story could play on the fact that neither really learned of each other until their confrontation in the next movie. Imagine how Luke would feel to find out he's Darth Vader's younger brother. That could mess up his confidence in ways that being his son never could.

    • @pandawolf5990
      @pandawolf5990 4 года назад +3

      Tbh the whole story is messed up then bc anakin is the chosen one bc he brings balance to the force aka luke and Leia are those balance ones a force user and ones

    • @joshfish2
      @joshfish2 4 года назад +1

      @@pandawolf5990 what?

  • @BobDylanFan1966
    @BobDylanFan1966 4 года назад +92

    Wow when you had Qui Gon call him son, I truly felt that.

  • @colourfaze86
    @colourfaze86 4 года назад +31

    Qui Gonn would have been suspicious of Palpatine after staying in power so long, escalating the clone wars, and especially how much time Anakin spent around him. I think he would have figured it out.

  • @silverblade357
    @silverblade357 4 года назад +86

    I like to think Qui-Gon, being the paragon he is, would have made good on his promise and gone back for Shmi. Anakin would need to be wary of attachment, but his master wouldn't leave him worrying for over a decade!

    • @trianglemoebius
      @trianglemoebius 2 года назад

      The Young Obi-Wan books were the EU "Source" on what Qui-Gon was like, and they had a few familiar names, but the characters were different from the versions Disney introduced. One of these was Satine Kryze, who again was Obi-Wan's girlfriend. In the EU, Qui-Gon quite literally leaves her in a situation where her death is inevitable (one he could have stopped) and when Obi-Wan goes to save her, leaves him to die with her. Obviously Obi-Wan survives, but there's no way Qui-Gon could have been sure of this. Qui-Gon's motive, by the way, was that he never truly lets himself get attached to people, and their deaths are (his would also be, at least he's not a hypocrite about it) secondary in the grand scheme of things.
      tl;dr EU Qui-Gon would totally leave Shimi to her fate.

    • @ORIGINALFBI
      @ORIGINALFBI Год назад +4

      @@trianglemoebius Yea that book sounds like trash. What we see on screen Qui-gon isn't like that.

  • @NeoConker626
    @NeoConker626 4 года назад +135

    Watching now, but one question- how did Dooku end up a Sith? His shatterpoint event, per se, was the death of Qui Gon. That was what filled him with anger and resentment, and caused him to leave the order (placing him in Sidious' sites). If Qui Gon lived, wouldn't he presumably remained Master Dooku, former apprentice of Yoda, and probably not candidate #1 for recruitment?

    • @TheHero136
      @TheHero136 4 года назад +19

      Strangely, I think this actually makes more sense. Think of it this way. Palpatine shows that Darth Maul killed Qui Gon, then Dooku would have presumably learned about Maul's connection to Palpatine? Wouldn't Dooku realized that Qui Gon's death was his master's fault? If so, wouldn't that mean that Dooku would want to avenge Qui Gon and/or return to the Jedi. And if not, doesn't that make Dooku a horribly stupid character?

    • @aurorauplinks
      @aurorauplinks 4 года назад +9

      @@TheHero136 dooku was fighting palpatine with half the republics might, his goal was subterfuge to kill palpatine, palpatine knew and wanted him to try to, that enabled his plan for anakin who he met after mauls death before dooku fell etc

    • @aurorauplinks
      @aurorauplinks 4 года назад +2

      Then dooku could reshape the jedi as he saw fit, as the figurehead and leader of a new republic, and supreme master of the jedi, not a jedi master, but a master of jedi

    • @TheHero136
      @TheHero136 4 года назад +3

      Aurora Uplinks nothing against you but can I please say how much I hate this way of writing. Where we can just ignore all plot holes or logic and say it’s part of Palpatine’s plan. It’s just so ridiculous to let all these leaps in logic just being written off as “part of the plan.”

    • @aurorauplinks
      @aurorauplinks 4 года назад +3

      @@TheHero136 ok....well then...palpatine corrupts and recruits dooku after the phantom menace, after he met anakin saying, he was looking forward to his careers future. All. In. The. .... future.... yes the script was augmented but anakin's future was being planned by palpatine after he met him and heard all about his potential, birth, and quigons demand he be trained against all customs and rules, after Qui gon and his apprentice killed the emperors apprentice, so presumingly the emperor values quigons opinion on the boy and became determined to have one capable of beating his former apprentice as his future apprentice. That's manipulative planning, every war and political leader does it, search for the best assets then plan how to maintain and use them cost effectively.
      I hate to say it, but regardless of how we feel, every movie has planning, just like this one, it's not ad-libbed in after, it's based on film events and dialogue, and I agree it's not the film Lucas planned on initially, jarjar was supposed to be a secret sith altering events but that had to be put in the background, otherwise we would have had a more fulfilling trillogy

  • @gibbs615
    @gibbs615 4 года назад +29

    Again, very nice work! However I always imagined that if Qui-Gon had lived he would've SAVED Anakin from turning to the dark side by training him to be balanced in the light and dark sides of the force and supporting him like a father and Anakin would NOT have needed Palpatine's help with anything! He would've also helped Anakin with his fears about Padme and ensured him to stay calm about her and always follow the will of the force.

  • @oakenshadow6763
    @oakenshadow6763 4 года назад +97

    Using Padmay to keep him loyal makes a lot of sense. More than the original.

  • @Flaris
    @Flaris 4 года назад +82

    I'm curious to see how things would have turned out. But I have to remind myself that Qui-Gon wasn't perfect. For the flaws that Obi-Wan had....Qui-Gon was the one that didn't train those flaws out of him. Of course I did enjoy this 'what-if' scenario since there are a lot of factors you can look at. Part of me can't help but think if he was still alive then things would have gone fairly similarly or honestly the guy probably gets assassinated since Palpatine is smart enough to try and deal with the biggest obstacles to his rise to power.

    • @alexman378
      @alexman378 4 года назад +7

      Obi Wan hadn’t really completed his training though, he was still an apprentice when Jinn died.

    • @MrAranton
      @MrAranton 4 года назад +2

      @@alexman378 I agree, Obi-Wan took on training Anakin way before he was ready to do that. Had Anakin been trained by Qui-Gon instead he would have become a very different jedi, probably a lot less susceptible to the dark side.

    • @justaguywhocomments4795
      @justaguywhocomments4795 3 года назад +1

      @@MrAranton The people who run this channel don't know their lore smh

    • @Elnont
      @Elnont 3 года назад +2

      Obi Wan wasn’t *flawed* he was just young and was stuck with a particularly difficult pads wan. Anakins choices were his own and you can’t blame Obi Wan, especially considering that Obi-Wan did love Anakin and trained him the best he could.

    • @justaguywhocomments4795
      @justaguywhocomments4795 3 года назад +1

      @@Elnont cap

  • @0predaking0
    @0predaking0 4 года назад +24

    Anakin falls in ROTS was by different factors
    -The trust and friendship with Palpatine
    -Anakin is loyal to his friends beyond reason
    - the fear of losing his dearest persons
    - his wishes to fulfill the promise to his mother (to stop people from dying)
    Edit 1
    That line was exactly what turns Anakin into the sith
    He is/was to dangerous to be keep alive
    Said by both Masters (Palpatine and also Mace)

    • @cnabutler07
      @cnabutler07 4 года назад +1

      Also don't forget before he went to the dark side was the jedi code when mace windu wanted to kill Palpatine instead of being tried in court that what send him to the dark side

    • @0predaking0
      @0predaking0 4 года назад

      @@cnabutler07 that was my edit 1

  • @safiuddinhanafy2014
    @safiuddinhanafy2014 2 года назад +4

    I just wished Anakin just went to Qui Gon to ask for advice.
    Although Palpatine was like a friend,Qui Gon was like a father.

  • @gagekinsey3415
    @gagekinsey3415 4 года назад +16

    The story of padme dying and him preserving her body is very clever

  • @thatguyfromthatthing2476
    @thatguyfromthatthing2476 4 года назад +18

    He would’ve told Anakin to stay in the Jedi council room, and he woulda STAYED there, lol

    • @MarioLord14
      @MarioLord14 3 года назад

      Probably not. I don’t think that would have worked.

  • @saderin
    @saderin 2 года назад +6

    I feel this version justifys Anakin's turn better than Lucas did. Maul killing her would have set him crashing into the dark side, he could be easily conned by Palpatine.

  • @ExtremeZebra91
    @ExtremeZebra91 4 года назад +105

    I'm actually kinda surprised that it didn't really change that much from the actual movie, don't get me wrong it is different but not that different you know.

    • @trucetruce335
      @trucetruce335 4 года назад +3

      There’s plenty of “qui-gon raised Anakin” where everything changed. You can look those up if you want.

    • @Thebabysealpoacher
      @Thebabysealpoacher 4 года назад

      Well this is more a light rewrite than a contemplative what if

    • @trianglemoebius
      @trianglemoebius 2 года назад

      Remember: this is just one event changing. Yes, there is butterfly effect, but remember also: a lot of cards were already in place, and there was someone (Palp) already with plans to manipulate circumstances. The idea that a lot of things wouldn't just be somewhat altered versions of what we know is somewhat silly, if you ask me.

  • @seanboy4386
    @seanboy4386 Год назад +3

    Wow the voice acting in this was very good. Walter doing Anakin was great could really feel the emotions, and I'm loving Doug doing Qui-Gon. Great twist ending! This was well done.

  • @jonnriggins
    @jonnriggins 4 года назад +16

    Well, it definitely took a different turn than I anticipated! I like that Qui-gon went the way of Obi-Wan with the force ghost routine and that Yoda took up Obi-wan's place on Tatooine. I've always loved this concept of Qui-gon surviving but very few people actually still allow anakin to fall to the dark side. Many of these "What if's" have anakin remain a Jedi.

  • @josephagar1005
    @josephagar1005 4 года назад +49

    Can we have a sequel to this?

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад +5

      Joseph Agar I hope so until they reach the sequel trilogy by making Darth Plagueis or Darth talon as the main antagonist

  • @LeighMet
    @LeighMet 4 года назад +39

    Qui Gon was in ROTS however Liam Neason had broken his leg and could not film

  • @Th_Riddler_
    @Th_Riddler_ 2 года назад +4

    This feels like an audiobook, like I was legitimately surprised when maul killed padne

  • @ThePa1riot
    @ThePa1riot 4 года назад +5

    11:48 I love this part in particular because you can really feel the desperation and panic in Anakin as things just continue to fall apart around him.

  • @connorthompson8376
    @connorthompson8376 4 года назад +27

    I like this. I’d like to see how the rest of the franchise would play out after these events.

  • @ThenewTchannel
    @ThenewTchannel 4 года назад +15

    Loved this story. Fantastic setup. Also, I have an idea for a "What If" situation: What if Screenslaver was a conventional villain?
    By conventional, I mean that he's just a villain. No twist, no special secret identity. He's just a new villain that the Incredibles have to face. I think that a lot can be done with this idea while still keeping close to the original film.

    • @auroradragen5920
      @auroradragen5920 4 года назад +1

      I mean as Screenslaver she did almost everything right
      Make sure your identity stays a secret. check the patsy pizza man and never actually being at the scene of the crime gives almost no evidence to her being the screenslaver
      Use your power/tech/abilities correctly.
      Check like I said before the patsy but also using the mind control on all the powerful pieces in the game whilst also not actively hindrancing yourself
      The only thing she didnt really account for was the kids being so resourceful and to be honest lucky
      She was very very close to success in both her plan and getting away with it Scot free.

    • @auroradragen5920
      @auroradragen5920 4 года назад +1

      Like it was only a twist villan cause we knew her out of screenslaver mode but if we never met Evelyn in the movie it really wouldnt have been a 'special' secret identity just a regular one. So I wouldnt think that the story would change almost at all

  • @BiserAngelov1
    @BiserAngelov1 4 года назад +64

    There should be a timeline, where Anikin Skywalker doesn't go to the dark side. Instead he learns the power of force heal, somehow from accessing the ancient Jedi books. Then he and Aschoka Tano start to expose, that the Jedi have lost their way, which almost would have lead to the Sith takeover. They start to train a new generation of Jedi, in a way according to the ancient texts. To keep the force in balance. Not trying to repress the dark side, knowing that force can self correct itself, not allowing for the balance to be lost. A true wise Jedi isn't denying and suppressing his dark side. Instead he keeps it under control, not excluding that aspect of the force.

    • @brandonprater4613
      @brandonprater4613 4 года назад +1

      ... I'd watch that.👍

    • @paisleepunk
      @paisleepunk 4 года назад +1

      The story is how they got there, and their enemies are basically everyone that are fanatic for the light or dark.

    • @trianglemoebius
      @trianglemoebius 2 года назад

      @@archibald_raven EU had a lot of situations where Luke had the Jedi on the right path but still things went wrong. The most famous (and largest) is probably the Yuzon-Vong, but there are tonnes of others. Just because the Jedi are on-track isn't gonna stop everyone in the galaxy from doing bad things. Some of them will succeed, given probability.

  • @Native_Beats_
    @Native_Beats_ 4 года назад +10

    "BOI"
    - Senator Palpatine 19 BBY

  • @rileyfriend
    @rileyfriend 4 года назад +44

    Wow this is one of the best what if Star Wars what if’s I’ve seen in years

  • @JW-do2wc
    @JW-do2wc 4 года назад +23

    This alternative writing is very good.

    • @coachgoltzbizpro23
      @coachgoltzbizpro23 3 года назад

      Part 1's dialogue was MUCH better than what Lucas wrote for the Prequels, especially the arena scene...

  • @KamenRiderSeiryuXV0
    @KamenRiderSeiryuXV0 4 года назад +27

    Great idea! After the death of Obi Wan, it still remains on Qui Gun's sadness losing of his student.
    What if Qui Gon was alive and met Luke, he met on EP4 The New Hope?
    What if Luke raised Kylo properly into true full-pledged Jedi, while Rey is the Darkside and the main villain in the show?
    What if Han Solo didn't died on EP7?
    What if R2D2 have voice circuitry which can able to speak?

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      北岡霊人 what about the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the wise?

    • @dad251
      @dad251 4 года назад

      SR Striker what about the droid attack on the Wookiee’s?

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Dad well I don’t mind, but what do you think about Darth Plagueis?

    • @trianglemoebius
      @trianglemoebius 2 года назад

      What if R2D2 have voice circuitry which can able to speak?
      He'd have gotten shot in the fucking dome for mouthing off one-too-many times, no doubt. He was a sarcastic little shit, according to everyone who could understand him, he just got away with it because most people (and even those who could sometimes USUALLY) couldn't.

  • @ultimattprime2861
    @ultimattprime2861 4 года назад +12

    Damn, I want a continuation of this into the main Trilogy.

  • @Noob4745
    @Noob4745 4 года назад +17

    If Quai Gon Yi didnt die at ep 1, i highly doub Dookus would be a Sith and that makes me wonder who would train Grievous

    • @kalebbarber2527
      @kalebbarber2527 4 года назад +2

      Who the fuck is Quai Gon Yi

    • @lorealiiiii
      @lorealiiiii 4 года назад +2

      Kaleb Barber 💀

    • @user-oe9ph8qw7j
      @user-oe9ph8qw7j 4 года назад +2

      @@kalebbarber2527 lol im laughing so hard

    • @vladashlyavas500
      @vladashlyavas500 3 года назад

      @@kalebbarber2527 Ikr? I was asking the same thing, 😂🤣

  • @SHKstudios3
    @SHKstudios3 4 года назад +2

    Him: What if Qui Gon Jinn was in Revenge of the Sith
    Me: He have the High Ground

  • @elmsigreen
    @elmsigreen 4 года назад +6

    Why is it that every single time someone makes a "What if" version of the prequels it involves Darth Maul not dying in the first movie 😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @lpatterson787
      @lpatterson787 4 года назад

      Prolly cuz even in canon, he doesn't die and becomes a cyborg. He just doesn't show up in subsequent movies, and I think a lot of what-ifs try to fix that.

    • @elmsigreen
      @elmsigreen 4 года назад

      @@lpatterson787 The question was rhetorical. Everyone acknowledges that killing him off in Episode 1 was a stupid decision

  • @jadenmckillip1868
    @jadenmckillip1868 4 года назад +8

    Two Harry Potter suggestions:
    1. What if Harry Potter joined Slytherin?
    2. What if Harry Potter and Draco Malfoy switched places?

    • @RealMikeWazowski
      @RealMikeWazowski 4 года назад +1

      Jaden McKillip
      1. Harry would have been an asshole
      2. Harry would have been an asshole

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Jaden McKillip what about Daniel Bruhl played Grindelwald instead of Johnny Depp

  • @Sean_Last1995
    @Sean_Last1995 4 года назад +4

    The face and throat wounds to Anakin are a much better reason for the suit then being burned alive in lava which in my opinion was a bit overkill.

  • @neilc.8368
    @neilc.8368 4 года назад +16

    Okay, who else thought when Palpatine said “Get Padme to a medical centre” that she was gonna be in a Darth Vader suit??

  • @TheGeekWithTaste
    @TheGeekWithTaste 4 года назад +7

    I enjoy this take on its own, but I think for things to play out this way we have to accept that you're changing more details than simply Qui-Gon surviving Episode I. Most notably is Dooku taking on Maul as a secret apprentice, which seems like an entirely separate departure from the original that could happen whether or not Qui-Gon dies (but it didn't). I do agree that Qui-Gon's continued presence during Anakin's upbringing would have significantly changed things, but this introduces many more variable changes that I don't think are justified simply by keeping Qui-Gon alive through Episode I.
    That said, I still enjoyed the whole take. Good stuff!

    • @stevenirizarry1304
      @stevenirizarry1304 2 года назад

      Dooku could easily have adopted maul as his apprentice to lessen the blow from the realization that qui-Gon would NEVER join him
      Like a coping mechanism

    • @BayHarbo
      @BayHarbo Год назад

      They do that with almost every fanscription which makes it more fun imo

  • @Ihatetechnology
    @Ihatetechnology 4 года назад +19

    brother? Owen was Anakin's brother and if Luke is the real son of Owen that would make Luke his nephew not his brother.

    • @abhisargupta8234
      @abhisargupta8234 4 года назад +1

      Part 1 says shmi just gave birth to a new child. So Owen was lukes older brother.

    • @SeasideDetective2
      @SeasideDetective2 3 года назад

      @@abhisargupta8234 But who is Luke's father, then? Is he half-human, half-Force the way Anakin was?

    • @Ihatetechnology
      @Ihatetechnology 3 года назад

      @@abhisargupta8234 If Shmi gave birth to Owen that means he is Anakin's brother, not Luke's. Unless you are insinuating that inbreeding happened.

    • @Ihatetechnology
      @Ihatetechnology 3 года назад

      @@SeasideDetective2 Luke's father is Anakin as in the original. Owen was birthed by Shmi after her owner fell in love with her. He married Shmi and paid to have her slave title removed. Sometime before Episode II, Shmi gave birth to Owen. This was before Anakin returned to find her kidnapped.
      In the original story Owen is Anakin's brother and Luke's uncle. I think the narrator miss spoke. I can't see why this would be done deliberately.

    • @Ihatetechnology
      @Ihatetechnology 3 года назад

      Also no, that was not Watto. lol He sold her to the man who would become Owen's father.

  • @swiftysolves2081
    @swiftysolves2081 4 года назад +16

    When I’m keeping up with yours and stupendous wave version of this what if and I’m confusing what happens in which

  • @sebastiancintron29
    @sebastiancintron29 4 года назад +21

    I seriously would love to see you guys do a Transformers fanscription.
    You guys have a great talent for this stuff.

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      TV and film kid too 🧹 under the carpet

  • @deadsince2023
    @deadsince2023 4 года назад +3

    Cool Darth Maul had a good role

  • @videogamersoasisdotcom
    @videogamersoasisdotcom 4 года назад +4

    I like this version! Very thick plot and good use of characters! Where are Disney writers like this one, when we need them, more than ever?

  • @Ravine777
    @Ravine777 4 года назад +59

    This sound like a better movie honestly😂

    • @scotswarrior9535
      @scotswarrior9535 4 года назад +10

      I loved ROTS, and I kinda agree

    • @brettt141
      @brettt141 4 года назад +1

      Honestly they didnt need Jin in this. They needed Darth Maul. They ruined the prequels really by killing off Darth Maul in the 1st movie.

    • @Josh-The_Spooky_Bastard-
      @Josh-The_Spooky_Bastard- 4 года назад

      Brett T You must not have watched the Clone Wars.

    • @brettt141
      @brettt141 4 года назад

      @@Josh-The_Spooky_Bastard- clearly did. the movie needed maul

    • @pelgervampireduck
      @pelgervampireduck 4 года назад

      no, this contradicts the original trilogy.

  • @kevinpeterson6468
    @kevinpeterson6468 4 года назад +4

    Padme: Anakin!?
    Saber through chest
    Padme: bye bye
    Me:😂😂

  • @matthewmann8969
    @matthewmann8969 4 года назад +10

    Qui Gon may be flawed but I doubt Anakin would turn with Qui Gon around after all Qui Gon was the one who freed Anakin from slavery and tried to at least free his Mom also Qui Gon was not a big follower of the Jedi Code or Jedi Council but follows the will of the living force more times then not and sometimes follows his own wants and needs but not too much also he may be in love with Padme but Qui Gon would teach him how to love her in a more less possessive way it may take a while but it could happen.

  • @zeus4804
    @zeus4804 4 года назад +3

    Please continue the story into the OT!
    I would love to hear the rest of this

  • @misablesk
    @misablesk 4 года назад +4

    This really is a Telltale among Fanfiction. Despite all different choices. Majority stayed exactly the same.

  • @sable-eyesonixdragon8642
    @sable-eyesonixdragon8642 4 года назад +7

    As powerful as Qui-Gon is he is more of a Wise master than a duelist. Obi-wan perfected defensive lightsaber fighting. Anakin's path to brash fighting styles would wallop Qui-Gon.

  • @numble9773
    @numble9773 4 года назад +3

    12:04
    when you find a really cool action figure.

  • @adamhoward1408
    @adamhoward1408 4 года назад +13

    What if Darth Maul killed Obi Wan Kenobe in the phantom menace instead of Qui Gon Jin?

    • @Noobhunter2012
      @Noobhunter2012 4 года назад +6

      I think that happens in part 1

    • @brettt141
      @brettt141 4 года назад +1

      The good star wars wouldnt make any sense

  • @yerduf
    @yerduf 4 года назад +5

    Awesome alternate story!!!

  • @RealMikeWazowski
    @RealMikeWazowski 4 года назад +3

    Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Mickey the wise?

    • @lpatterson787
      @lpatterson787 4 года назад

      I believe you mean Darth Mickey the Rich?

    • @RealMikeWazowski
      @RealMikeWazowski 4 года назад

      lpatterson787 Ah yes. He was a powerful dark lord.

  • @nightwing2199
    @nightwing2199 4 года назад +6

    Okay, after watching both parts of this What If...I kind of want to see how this plays out in the original trilogy. Sure I'm fairly certain that everything will end up being similar to the original script, albeit with the big reveal not being Vader is Luke and Leia's father, Yoda being in Obi's place and Qui Gon being in Yoda's place...but I think some dynamics of the story could possibly change in the long run. Think about it: Yoda was with Chewbacca during Episode 3, so that alone will have major significance I would believe...then again, maybe I'm just reading too much into it.

  • @brunosantos711
    @brunosantos711 4 года назад +8

    "I'm happy."
    "No ur not."
    "Ur rite."
    "Boy did I bet on the wrong horse."

  • @xxuniverse_gamingxx2513
    @xxuniverse_gamingxx2513 4 года назад +5

    I thought qui gon would have like calmed anakin down

  • @JamesPlaysGames95
    @JamesPlaysGames95 4 года назад +2

    I think this is the first Non nostalgia critic video I've watched on this channel

  • @quackingquackerson7619
    @quackingquackerson7619 4 года назад +3

    Y does Padme always have to die in every theory

  • @orcslayer0485
    @orcslayer0485 Год назад +1

    I just watched this. Now more than ever, we need to see FanScription's Original Trilogy follow up to Qui Gon's new role in Star Wars. Make some noise! Let's make it happen!!!

  • @elmsigreen
    @elmsigreen 4 года назад +3

    WAIT, WAIT, WAIT!!! So... you are removing the eventual ,,I am your father" line from your version? I don't think ,,I am your brother" would be nearly as impactful

  • @MasterAnakinSkyWalker
    @MasterAnakinSkyWalker 4 года назад +7

    This was an interesting theory.

  • @yvonnerogers6429
    @yvonnerogers6429 4 года назад +3

    💯👍🏻❤️🙏🤩 That was really good! I really appreciate how imaginative y’all get with this series.

  • @jadekissling8983
    @jadekissling8983 2 года назад +1

    This is a complete masterpiece for the Prequels.

  • @user-nq2mc4qw9y
    @user-nq2mc4qw9y 4 года назад +2

    Ok, i need more of this. Please. This is best fanfiction i ever heard.

  • @wildwind413
    @wildwind413 4 года назад +1

    Rob has the best Palpatine voice

  • @izzymaedavidson1974
    @izzymaedavidson1974 4 года назад +1

    This is where the fun begins

  • @jedicrush1497
    @jedicrush1497 3 года назад +1

    Qui Gon Jinn:
    Anakin, all I did was hold you back? Now I'm gonna whip dat ass!

  • @swiftysolves2081
    @swiftysolves2081 4 года назад +4

    Do a part 3

  • @MightyCousintube-fg4jf
    @MightyCousintube-fg4jf 4 года назад +1

    “Annie...son” damn that hit harder than a softball hitting your nutsack.

  • @jeffflowers4701
    @jeffflowers4701 3 года назад +4

    I respectfully disagree. One reason he fell was he needed a father figure to trust. He trusted qui gon. If he survived he would have told quigon about him and padme. Sense quigon argued with the council a lot, he wouldnt tell them. He didnt tell them when he discovered the force priestesses until the clone wars.

  • @sharms_silly
    @sharms_silly 4 года назад +3

    I think Dooku would’ve told them who Palpatine actually was.

  • @majorastorm
    @majorastorm 4 года назад +2

    You've taken over SW Theory! Lol he has done a what if in years

  • @patriceperry8784
    @patriceperry8784 4 года назад +2

    Can you make a episode on if the other half was snapped ?

  • @Chemical_Argentum
    @Chemical_Argentum 4 года назад +3

    Omg guys, it's past 1 am here, I was about to hit bed xD

  • @TripAces
    @TripAces 2 года назад

    Mace:' I always knew it would come down to this '
    Was the most badass impromptu line befitting the BMF

  • @tremorsfan
    @tremorsfan 4 года назад +6

    So now you have to rewrite the entire original trilogy.

  • @popculturefanxxi4391
    @popculturefanxxi4391 4 года назад +7

    That Darth Maul voice sounds a bit like Kratos in a way but it’s awesome

  • @TheCreepypro
    @TheCreepypro 4 года назад +2

    honestly I love this rewrite and would love to see you carry these ideas into your own version of episode 4 if possible

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      TheCreepypro and maybe till the sequel trilogy where Darth talon or Darth Plagueis are the main villain

  • @lorenzogoglee1320
    @lorenzogoglee1320 4 года назад +5

    malcolm is a great darth maul

  • @owensmith9912
    @owensmith9912 4 года назад +14

    I don’t think it was right to have Grievous killed off so quickly, because that means he would barely have any screen time. But other than that everything was good!

    • @lapplandkun9273
      @lapplandkun9273 4 года назад

      clone wars

    • @owensmith9912
      @owensmith9912 4 года назад

      John Zhou I was only talking about the movie

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Owen Smith taking the place of Dooku

    • @owensmith9912
      @owensmith9912 4 года назад

      SR Striker yeah but still he could do more than just be a character to get killed off immediately

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Owen Smith and that goes the same for Snoke

  • @erika_fuzzbottom
    @erika_fuzzbottom 4 года назад +3

    Was interesting, but I did not expect changes that would result in differences in the original trilogy. Those differences were kinda glossed over, and I'm curious to hear them in more detail.

  • @KYTEOYT
    @KYTEOYT 3 года назад +1

    I don’t believe anything about the movies would be the same if Qui-Gonn trained Anakin. But that probably wouldn’t be very entertaining tbh so great job

  • @jackreacherreviewsandgamin1875
    @jackreacherreviewsandgamin1875 4 года назад +4

    I would like to see an original trilogy from this

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Jack Reacher Reviews and Gaming and the sequel trilogy

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Jack Reacher Reviews and Gaming and the sequel trilogy?

  • @Mr_Furry
    @Mr_Furry 4 года назад +1

    This is better than the original one!

  • @gangofheroes
    @gangofheroes 4 года назад +4

    Very Interesting and enjoyable take definitely would like to see this continued. You know the one Jedi I believe it they had been Anakin's master the may have not fallen to the dark side is Mace Windu

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад +1

      Gang of Heroes he ether die a hero or live to become a villain

  • @oliverliu5065
    @oliverliu5065 4 года назад +6

    wow, walter is a better anakin than hayden.
    Okay that wasn't much of a compliment. You're a guy with mad talent.

    • @defiantparrot6245
      @defiantparrot6245 4 года назад +1

      I mean to give Hayden some credit it's not that he's awful it's that the writing and direction of the Prequels was terrible

    • @Darthmessiah66
      @Darthmessiah66 4 года назад +1

      i think his Anakin's impression was awfull, sorry.

    • @Darthmessiah66
      @Darthmessiah66 4 года назад

      but i think he did Qui Gon and Sidius well.

  • @The_Crimson_Shogun
    @The_Crimson_Shogun 4 года назад

    Dudes these voices are amazing! I especially like palpatines

  • @project_boredom2940
    @project_boredom2940 4 года назад +12

    Can you do a fanscription on a James Bond Movie. Like “If Gerorge Lazenby was in Diamonds are Forever”. That would be great!

    • @j.m.turner1756
      @j.m.turner1756 4 года назад

      Y'know, I was thinking about that, too (only I considered it "Diamonds are Forever if it were good"). I figured it would focus more on Bond getting revenge for his wife.

    • @project_boredom2940
      @project_boredom2940 4 года назад

      delta squad4577 Yes exactly! And we would need George in it for sure. And I feel like he would have done “Live and Let Die” and “Man with the golden gun” then Dalton would have taken it from there. (Moore maybe but I’m not to sure)

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Project_Boredom well I wish that Daniel Bruhl was the villain that help Blofeld escape prison

  • @gabrieldean4111
    @gabrieldean4111 4 года назад +2

    Why is qui gonn so much stronger in this than he actually is

    • @SESKE_5
      @SESKE_5 4 года назад

      becase he is actually really strong

    • @gabrieldean4111
      @gabrieldean4111 4 года назад

      Swavvle he is no where near anakins level

    • @SESKE_5
      @SESKE_5 4 года назад

      @@gabrieldean4111 did i say that

    • @gabrieldean4111
      @gabrieldean4111 4 года назад

      @@SESKE_5 you couldve worded that better, because in the video qui gon beats anakin. so i thought you meant anakin would lose to qui-gon

    • @SESKE_5
      @SESKE_5 4 года назад

      @@gabrieldean4111 lol

  • @Sentryman002
    @Sentryman002 4 года назад +1

    You kbock it out of the park once again. Could you do a fanscription on A New Hope based on this episode next? Keep up the good work!

  • @axeltime3141
    @axeltime3141 4 года назад +1

    Idea: what if order 66 never happened?

  • @OmniTerror
    @OmniTerror 4 года назад +24

    What if Darth Plagueis was in episode 9 instand of the emperor

    • @motor4X4kombat
      @motor4X4kombat 4 года назад +2

      It will be just as dumb because its just the role of a throw away villain at the last minute. Hell even in the original script there was Also an powerfull overlord under kylos shadow like snoke was, when kylo should have beeing the main villain from the start with no creepy asshole with a Gollum voice overshadowing him

    • @motor4X4kombat
      @motor4X4kombat 4 года назад +2

      The better question would be what if kylo ren was the main villain of episode ix? Or what if he wasn't reedem.

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад +1

      motor4X4kombat but he is the emperor’s mentor after if he could pull off an illusion that he was dead especially if he is Anakin’s creator

    • @motor4X4kombat
      @motor4X4kombat 4 года назад +1

      @@srstriker6420 it would be even worse because to quote just write "it make scense for the fans, but not for the story". Darth plagues was mention ONCE in the saga do you really thing people that didn't read any EU material Will imidiatly recognize him and put him in kylo story, when just snoke and Darth Vader where More than enough? Brining him back would be just as dumb as brining darth maul in solo, that fanservise shit only speck to anti-social fanboy rather than actual storytelling.

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      motor4X4kombat well I agree on Darth maul in Solo since it shouldn’t have been made in the first place, but since he is named after a plague doesn’t that make him scary because what he going to do give us aids or that virus that people are talking about now

  • @selftaughtmilly-rocker.8626
    @selftaughtmilly-rocker.8626 4 года назад +1

    Anakin probably wouldn’t have turned to the dark side if Qui-Gon was his master.

  • @earnestbrown6524
    @earnestbrown6524 4 года назад +1

    Now the kiss in Empire won't be icky.

  • @joshuawells835
    @joshuawells835 4 года назад +2

    Well "I am your brother" isn't as iconic as "I am your father". In this case, I would have Leia still lead the Rebellion and be arrested over Tatooine. Luke and Yoda still retrieve R2-D2 and C-3PO, then find Han Solo and Chewbacca. Alderaan is still destroyed. Yoda survives his duel with Darth Vader while Luke and Leia become closer. Since they're not related, it's less creepy. Luke still destroys the First Death Star and Yoda continues to train Luke. After the Battle of Hoth, Luke joins Yoda and Qui-Gon's ghost on Dagabah. Here, Luke passes his trials and becomes a Jedi Knight. He then faces his brother Vader on Cloud City. Sensing the good that Qui-Gon once had, Luke spares Vader and escapes with Leia and Lando. At the Battle of Endor, Luke turns Vader back and they battle Sidious together. Sidious kills Vader, but Luke is able to strike him down, ending his reign of tyranny (for now). With the Empire crumbling, Yoda and Luke then track down Ezra Bridger, Ahsoka Tano (if she's still in the story), Cal Kestis, Cere Junda, and any other surviving Jedi and form a New Jedi Order. It is here that Yoda begins to pass away and where he tells Luke to pass on what he had learned. Leia is still Force-Sensitive, so she also becomes a Jedi.

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Joshua Wells well I thought of that before the last Jedi and the death of Snoke

    • @joshuawells835
      @joshuawells835 4 года назад

      @@srstriker6420 It is, but I just wasn't sure how to add the Sequel Trilogy in, so I left it ambiguous

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Joshua Wells but also have you heard of the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the wise?

    • @joshuawells835
      @joshuawells835 4 года назад

      @@srstriker6420 I have

    • @srstriker6420
      @srstriker6420 4 года назад

      Joshua Wells and I guess you could see the potential for the sequel trilogy?