We Bought 'em All: By Far The Best Right-Angle Impact DRIVER is...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 мар 2022
- Find it here: amzn.to/3Gh2G4F Per 4:21 it's $99
Our live rank list: torquetestchannel.etsy.com
We have some cool t-shirt designs: torque-test-channel.preview.t... On this one and done episode we visit impact drivers, and it's a 1 stop shop because well there's basically only 4 options on the cordless market. The Makita XLT01Z, Milwaukee M18 2667-20, M12 2467-2 and Skil RI574501. Their prices range massively, but their performance ranges even more...but not in the way you'd hope.
~We may earn from qualifying affiliate links here~
Torque of TTC is working for Astro Tools who also make impact wrenches (air). TTC is not the only testing out there, always consider multiple sources when looking at a tool 
Авто/Мото
Just used this thing yesterday on some drawer glides in a narrow drawer bank: amzn.to/3Gh2G4F I store it like a wrench, just battery and bit driver already installed, grab it when i need it then throw it back in the tool box. RA Impact drivers have been added to our live ranking: etsy.me/3G8j3QK
This episode is on *RIGHT-ANGLE IMPACT DRIVERS* , which are easily confused with right-angle drills, ratchets, wrenches, impact ratchets, RA adapters, old discontinued right-angle drivers, and anything from a power tool brand in an L shape :P
Torque of TTC is working for Astro Tools, who don't make impact drivers - but always consider multiple sources when looking at a tool. We're not the only game in town!
For the Europeans: DTL061Z is the item to search around 165€
Congrats, now they're sold out on Amazon 🤣
I know how to identify the grade of bolts by looking at them (6dashes=grade8 3dashes=grade5) but what the hell kind of bolt are you using???? The one with the giant "B" and has 12dashes????? Help me understand this plz LOL
Would love to see you test more skil tools! Maybe their impact wrench.
@@Diesel_Dude Bowmalloy, exceeds grade 9. Working on a vid about this stuff!
For the price of the Skil it doesn't matter what battery platform you're already on.
Well I'd be willing to pay more to not needing another type of charger on my wall. still seems its the only one that can deliver the bare minimum amount of beans right now tho..
I've gotten a Skil pwrcore12 drill driver kit with battery and the fancier charger for $30 on Woot. Now, that was pretty epic, but it's not that far off what you can often find them for.
Dammit, the secret is out. First, the Kobalt right angle impact, now this. Now I won't be one of only a handful of people with it. ;)
Amen
For sure. I've never really had a need for one, already have the new Makita new nut runner, but if I did, I'd buy this Skill in a heart beat.
Really interesting in those left angle impact drivers. Disappointed that you only briefly mentioned them.
ruclips.net/user/TorqueTestChannelsearch?query=angle+wrench
In the flour mill I worked at the right-angle impact was a godsend. That said, we used it for hoseclamps about 85% of the time and would figure out how to fit a socket or impact wrench in where we needed the beans.
Every tool has a purpose. You don't want or need high torque in every case. 20 could be more than enough.
This really shows the Genius of Torque Test Channel, would anyone previously have thought the Skil would totally destroy a Japanese Makita for power and such a low price? Love it!
Anyone that's used it would. It can't even get M8 (5/16") tight and you have to finish them off with a spanner. Tis an old tool and clearly not popular if they haven't bothered to update it.
@Jimbob I'm not much of a home-builder, but it seems this is such a niche line of tools for a need that a cheaper right-angle adapter and a beefier impact couldn't easily fulfill, so the brands don't have much innovation going here.
That being said, it's inexcusable for the Makita to bring so few beans.
@h8GW consider mechanics or any position where clearance is a premium.
channels like this and project farm are some of the handiest things to watch on the internet.
Add AvEs BOLTR (Bored Of Lame Tool Reviews) collection of videos. Dude takes them apart and analyzes the parts, possible failure modes, manufacturing processes etc.
@@wills.5762 you're 100% right. he's just so much more interesting in other ways as well that it's hard to always think of him like this.
Man I continue getting amazed by the reviews and performance of the Skil 12V line. I made a buddy buy the 5 piece brushless kit for $99 and I’ve been wishing I bought it too but I just really don’t want another battery platform.
Yes but...they're REALLY good for the price/performance.
Do it! 😀
That price is tempting enough to add another battery platform to my garage. $99 only gets you a 4-6Ah battery from a PRO brand and hardly gets you any decent tool from those brands at all.
The Skil Pwrcore is worth adding another battery platform.
Totally understand & agree! Bought it, this past Christmas for that same $99, for my SIL....he didn't have a need for it, so I (FOOLISHLY) returned it...STILL kicking myself in the A$$ for that gaf.
@@richardmejia254so what your saying is… don’t return it because I bought the 5 tool kit for 80$
I own four different 12 volt platforms. Some of the Skil tools are on point, and the line is a fantastic value.
Good stuff as always! I’m getting back into the automotive field and your testing has been so helpful for filling my new tool box with the correct beans for the job! KEEP IT UP!!
With these things, I find slow speed control more important than max torque.
Often I'm using them to drive smaller screws into tight places. For example - mounting drawer rails inside a cabinet.
I have a 12v Rigid from the NiCd era that has a bottom lever for a trigger that is super easy to control and has kept me from stripping out smaller screws when doing these types of jobs.
A great test. That Skill is truly a bargain!
Upgraded from an older 18v kit. ruclips.net/user/postUgkxW1vOBRCMrgTCDEijzpVzDWsgI-Jm2iQv I independently chose the drill and impact tool, before I came across the kit.I like the 3 speed impact gun. It seems more powerful than my older one, and it can be set to be really gentle. The drill is more appropriately sized for my use. I used to have a hammer drill, but I did not like that it was so big and it was not a great hammer drill. I rather have a smaller drill like this, and then get a corded hammer drill for the odd case I need that.
Finally SKIL is featured
I look forward to seeing more skil 12v test. I have a lot of the 12v tools. Pretty happy with all of them. I use them mostly for home use.
Can you please start testing skil brand tools. I don't ever remember them being on the channel before. I think they're pretty powerful tools especially for the price. Also almost all Cobalt tools are made by Chevron.
Be interesting to know if a standard impact driver could give more beans than these with a right angle adapter fitted.
I use my dewalt adapter with my driver all the time on our 4 Post ramp to drop undertrays etc
I would say not, but then again we're not talking big numbers here. I bet the top drivers with an extension could beat all of the ra's except for the skil.
Project Farm did a test with the right angle attachment. It did not go so good. A lot broke. Some lasted a while, but all of them lost quite a bit of torque in the process. You should check his channel out. One of the best ones out there.
they at best lost a lot of power and most eventually broke
Even if it did, you really have to use 2 hands (since the input torque side wants to spin with the driver's chuck), whereas a tool like this can be used 1-handed.
@@matt0198922 that's a good point about the 2 hand use.
Love that you guys are testing realistic numbers and even now showing hand tool stuff too. We literally talk about your videos on every tool truck. Keep up the great content guys
I use the m18 at work for accessory installation on work/fleet trucks. It’s awesome. Just the right amount of torque not to break things
Witch 1
I use that M18 Milwaukee for ALL my in-wall rough-in. I LOVE it as an electrician. Ive used mine for YEARS
I have the XRW012Z, the right angle 3/8 and 1/4 impact from Makita rated only 35 ft lbs. When it comes to doing interior panels or anything plastic I found myself not needing my regular impact driver. Replacing a sliding window, removing headlight assemblies and changing a valve cover gasket was all done with the right angle and it's now my favorite tool for light torque jobs
I am at Service and Plumber I service on demand tankless water heaters boiler all day every day and day, the m18 right angle impact driver Is my number one favorite tool of all time every day it has just come perfect to break lose the small fasteners and get done what I need but it doesn’t strip off or break the fasteners off…
Excellent review! Thank you for covering all the things I was wondering about the lineup
Love the channel and my only suggestion is to light up the liquid crystal gauges so we can see them.
A purely speculative analysis: The resonance of the driver + socket + fastener may be a big part of the design of these devices. I would be curious to see how your results differed if you used a 3/8" drive socket that was using a fastener that one of these would be expected to drive. (as opposed to the massive socket you tested these with)
Thank you for the video!
I use my Milwaukee M12 all the time. I only use it for 1/4 stainless zip screws when I have to connect the screws from the inside of 8”-4” diameter stainless pipe, tight space. I don’t use it for anything else. It’s a tool that may not be used in a year, but when it’s needed, it’s a lifesaver, and money well spent.
Love to see some Skil 12v added to the channel. I have multiple tools and all do everything I ask of them. Also, that 5 year warranty is a plus, had a free impact driver sent to me with no questions asked.
Great video. You guys really are one of the best consumer resources on the internet
I have a love for the skill 12 V line, picked up the five piece kit at Lowe’s back over Christmas for $99. They’re nearly the size of my 18 V tools, but everything being brushless with a few extra bells and whistles and plenty of power to boot. You can’t go wrong there
I bought the brushless 12v Skil set for $99 from lowes around Christmas time even though I currently own other 20v platforms. I am blown away by the performance and quality of the Skil stuff. I honestly reach for it more that the other stuff most of the time now. The 12v oscillating tool is awesome. They just need to expand their line up a little more.
This is a result where I'd absolutely abandon my battery brand for that Skil. It put on a great showing.
Plus it's cheaper as a kit than the others are for a bare tool. There's really no reason NOT to buy it
Skil has really been killing it lately. Their contractor table saw is crazy good for the price and their 10" compound mitre is probably the best available in it's class. Sometimes a brand just comes back and surprises everyone 🤷
Would be awesome if they brought some manufacturing back over into the states
Got the makita a couple years ago and absolutely love it for installing drawer slides, hardware, and getting in hard to reach places. Obviously not for heavy duty work.
Glad you like it, out of all the makita I own its the least favorite tool, was thoroughly dissatisfied with it; but your use case gives me hope i can find a reason to use it.
Holy hell, the light in the Skil is amazing! I need one
This test plus a couple other reviews convinced me to get the Skil. Great tool for tight places a regular impact driver can't fit. Feels solidly made and has nice features, like the halo light and the USB charging ports on both the charger and the battery.
I grabbed the skil right angle along with a bunch of their 12v tools during some promotions last year, and they've been pretty good.
The biggest complaint I find with the right angle and the regular driver is some impact socket adapters align with the cutoff for the bearing and can rob torque or get stuck in the shank; I've had this happen with some makita, ryobi and milwaukee adapters and the double relief ones with multiple bearing retention positions or ones that stop short without a hex shaft all the way though seem the worst. A straight shaft with no cutout for the bearing seems to work well in a pinch, but the bit or adapter can slide out then. Ultimately just a small inconvenience but it'll hammer away doing nothing if the adapter or bit doesn't fit.
It's been great for smaller fasteners in tight places, t25's, etc and running fasteners when not using a ratchet. Fit's well behind some intake manifolds too for those annoying to take out fasteners that aren't all that tight. It's been good for driving in tight screws for construction as well, quite useful when renovating existing structures as the light is great for this. I haven't found the 4ah very useful on the drivers, but it does seem to help out the circ saw and adds decent runtime to the oscillating tool.
I have several items in the Skill 12 volt lineup. They are excellent tools, especially for the price.
Absolutely love my makita lxt. It's my most used tool and has proven performance. Been my favorite tool.
Could always use a battery adaptor to get that skil into your red or yellow battery collection of tools..
I love the Skil tool, I have use Skil and owned before, thank you for making this review.
This channel has helped me make several purchases, one of the most informed well thought out channels out there. The only thing missing is 1/4 electric tools :( I'm looking to buy a 1/4 electric ratchet & impact wrench and need some good insight. looking between Snap-op, Matco, & Milwaukee Good job and keep counting them beans!
I’m a Milwaukee guy, i have all Milwaukee. but lowes had a skil brushless set with an impact, drill, multi tool, Bluetooth speaker, two batteries and a work light for $140 and it has been solid
I've pretty much wore out my m12 2467. Been so helpful in so many situations. Much better on smaller automotive fasteners than the m12 ratchet. The ratchet will snap bolt heads off if you catch a ding in the threads going full speed. This will start impacting first letting you know it is encountering resistance. Love to see a fuel version with a 1/4" square drive.
I have the Milwaukee M12 version, for driving screws and loosening and tightening small bolts not really bad at all. It's a much older design along with the M18. Hoping for a fuel version of each, plus a fuel version of the 90 degree drill. Great test as always.
Would definitely like to see more skil tools get tested
Can yall do one on the right angle attachments for impact drivers? I’d be interested to see the torque loss between the different brands on the same impact.
Check out project farm he did one
I've had my M12 for over a year and it is fantastic for under dash work 👌🏻
Another great video guys. If you haven't already you should test 1/4" hex right angle adapters next.
I love my skil 12v stuff for work as a low voltage installer is the best bang for the buck. Their 12v jigsaw is the best 12v jigsaw out there. I wish skil would come out with a few things for the 12v line up like a multi head installation driver.
Great comparison! I didn't even know these things existed but if I ever need one, it's pretty obvious which one to get, even if the results were more equal. IMO Skil has always deserved more respect than it gets. Yes their tools are low-priced, but are still fairly solid. Their circular saw was THE go-to for years, everyone knows someone with a "Skil Saw."
And though it wasn't a right-angle impact driver, I remember buying my dad one of the first ever cordless 3/8" ratchet wrenches about 40 or so years ago, and it was made by Skil. Even had a full metal case.
I bought the skill just based on this video and it works awesome, I work in a body shop and use it with 1/4 inch socket adapter and use 10mm sockets on it and torx bits, works great on removing bumpers and other stuff. Would be nice to see it run on the gauntlet though to see how it compares against ratchets.
I have a 14V Makita for cabinet work. Probably 15 years old. Looks identical to the 18V. Also have an M18 Milwaukee for framing. Both have enough power for wood screws and the occasional lag bolt. The chuck on the Makita will allow a 2” bit to sit in in the standard position, plus it can drop into the chuck an extra inch. This feature makes the Makita the best tool for tight spaces.
Ingersoll Rand has supposed best one on the market and highest torque, nevermind I'm confusing drivers and wrenches. As a wrench man I didn't even realize that RA driver's existed.
Ayyy over 100k! Congrats man!
I recently got the skil 12v 5 piece kit with 2 batteries and a charger for only 99$ and are really great for the value!
You can get a 4.0 ah battery for $40 on Amazon for the 12v skill, which will boost the power a bit. I have slowly acquired most of the 12v line from skil and they are all excellent homegamer/diy tools.
Woooo thank you for another fantastic video! 🙏
You missed the Ridgid brushless Job Max with the right angle impact driver head, Job Max seems to be recently discontinued but still available. They also have brushed 12 & 18v models as well as corded and pneumatic versions still available at direct tool outlet . Would love to see how those compare!
Nice. That’s way I love watching this channel. One learns things they wouldn’t have :). Live confidently and peacefully
Chervon also makes Kobalt. I've been plenty pleased with the all-brushless Skil 12v line. I'll have to look and see if you tried my regular impact driver from that line, or any other tools. I like that performance! They are often available for great discounts too.
I own a milwaukee m12 impact angle is a great tool on small spaces i used all time drilling small holes and installing screws great tool not complaint or anything
The skil look by far the best purchased also love the ring light on it
I agree with everything you mentioned the skil is well worth the coin.
Thank you. Saved us a bunch of money. No need to upgrade when the advantage gained is so small.
I would love to see more tests with the Skil brushless line. I wonder if any of their other offerings can hold their own against the "big boy" brands
Well that settles it for me… I run a custom woodworking/ cabinetry shop. There are many times where I need to fasten screws in narrow cabinets and install hardware. I have gotten by with the right angle attachments… owning the Milwaukee and honestly favoring the dewalt because it’s smaller and less cumbersome… it’s always awkward juggling that contraption + the drill + keeping good alignment on the head of the screw + contorting your body to get into the space.
I’m a makita guy for generic shop tools. I would have bought the makita, but after going brushless, I’m never going back. I wanted to keep the batteries/ chargers all the same. But quite frankly it SUCKED in the test. Maybe one day if they actually update it.
After I post this I’m placing an order for the Skil.
That thing hands down just blew away the competition in all regards. And I’m excited about the light that actually illuminates the point of where the work is taking place!
The skil works very well for mobile cleaning, $15 pack of drill brushes and the skil is cheap but decent enough to keep it turning in even the thickest grease
Interested in seeing Skil's normal 12v impact driver on the dyno. I got one as part of a kit for next to nothing (5 tools and 2 batteries for $99) and really like it.
I am die hard Milwaukee and purchased the M12 as a pre-order. I use it for crammed spaces on screws etc but also smaller spade bits. I have often wanted needed more power. That skill is tempting me "AHEM MILWAUKEE"
I work in reinstalling cabinets. I bought the Skil first and it is a good little right angle. I sold it and bought the Makita. Not because of performance, obviously you guys have shown that, but because the Makita is longer and the head is quite a bit more compact. For me the Makita is the way to go. I do wish they would put a brushless motor in it and maybe make the hammer mechanism have a little more mass so it would hit harder but for me the Makita fits behind sinks a lot better.
Great job as always.
I know this video is old. I was looking at the skill 12v cutter. And found the right angle. It’s a steal for the price I just bought it from Amazon. I can’t wait until it gets here. Battery with the usb is a great option also.
Most people arent using an impact for mechanics tho, most are using it for carpentry and joinery. its more than enough for use on wood.
Thank you for all the work you do.
Skil for me.
I just got one of the Skil pwrcore 12 impact drivers with a $10 off coupon for the kit. It works almost as well as the old impact driver.
Great test
I was already going to buy the skil simply because of price. This sealed the deal!!
That Makita has been a godsend for the last 10 years I've been using it (has it been that long ?) When working on cars without access to a hoist, removing bumper bars and such, I need the tightest access possible with just enough torque not to strip Torx T20, R25 and T30 screws in plastic, or round off philips heads. With the M18 battery, I can go 2-4weeks between charges sometimes.
For high torque applications, I use a different set of tools. If anything, I'd love an even smaller head version, maybe with a through drive setup.
But sure, Makita or Milwaukee, if you want to make a brushless version of one these, with a very small head and variable power settings, I'd be all for it.
I'm sunk into Makita, and it works so much better than the drill attachment while freeing up a hand.
I'm a Makita guy, but that brushless SKIL was impressive
I have that Skil and it's great. Also have There 12volt drill and jigsaw, which are great as well.
Episode idea: Do a comparison of what you can get on a single brand of batteries. IOW, what if you buy into M18 batteries? Dewalt batteries? Skill, Makita, Craftsman, etc.
As a mechanic, high torque isn’t always what I want with a right angle driver. Typically I’m using the right angle driver in tight spaces with bolts not requiring higher torque, but maybe that’s just me. The biggest downside to skil one is it’s thickness when trying to squeeze it into a tight engine bay. It’s also worth noting that you can buy a dewalt right angle attachment for a normal impact driver for $40 at Lowe’s, which is cheapest than any other mentioned option if you just want the cheapestx
Great video as always! I'd be curious how the Milwaukee Installation tool stacks up with it's various interchangeable heads
Weaker, and with worse ergonomics than the DeWalt 12V installation tool (dcd703). I had both and sold the Milwaukee. Comparing either one to an impact driver is like comparing apples and dragonfruit, however.
WASN'T, MUCH OF A SHOWDOWN ,,, BUT I AM A DEDICATED FAN SO IT'S MY DUTY TO WATCH THE SHOW . THANKS, TTC !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm working on a 3d printable battery adapter to power Skill's new line off of Milwaukee's m12. I started originally when I was looking at auto-hammers and found the Skill to me MUCH more useful than the Milwaukee version. I'll update this once I get a working prototype I'm happy with.
Can’t wait for the skil 20v impact wrench and driver 😍😍,
Idk if you’d be able to find one but there is a old craftsman nextec 12v right angle impact as well. But the line was ended when craftsman got bought. Good tools though I have the multi tool, auto hammer, basic drill and impact and have loved them
The skill is on sale today on Amazon for $89. I finally ordered one today and while I was at it I ordered the Skill 12v 3/8 In. Compact Impact Wrench IW6744A-10. The 3/8” compact claims 125ft lbs. If only there were someone who could test that…
For how little I have to use a right angle driver I just bought the adapter for my impact driver. The one with the handle is the best. Can’t remember the name. But I’ve put thousands of screws and deck bolts in with my dewalt. You should test the adapters
I'm buying it! .... Done .... Always wanted something for impact driving those rusty screws and bolts, but with some advantages over standart impact drivers because my car service has good King tony pneumatic impacters, and there was no need for electric ones, but if it is so narrow, it will do better in some places.
Check out the combo kits on Lowes and Amazon before buying the single tool.
Great info
Don’t forget to show TTC a little appreciation! Give them a thumbs up 👍 and share the vid, if you can. 🙏 Hope everyone has a stellar day and an even better weekend.
Thanks guys.
I love how All these companies rely on the fact that people only buy a lot of their stuff is because they already have those batteries but as soon as people learn you can go online anywhere and find adapters for sale that will pair ANY battery with any tool.
All you wrench spinners, the M12 version is a fantastic fit in the small places for broken exhaust manifold bolts on all your 1/2 ton and bigger trucks.
I've the Skil 20 volt platform, and they don't have the variation of tools...Yet. But they are good prosumer products. But I'm not convinced they are better than the Skil 12 Volt platform, because the 20 volts are a little under-impressive. But I'm stuck with a lot of the batteries so I'm attached to that level. Still nice comparison, thank you guys.
Gotta love a great underdog story!
You can tell just by looking at them. The gear box on the Skil actually looks big enough to handle some torque.
Well, I don’t know about left angle drivers, but I have a few wrong angle drivers in my collection.
I am glad to see the Skil logo/brand making a comeback. 35 years ago, Skil made some good stuff, but then lost our favor to Milwaukee and Makita. A couple Makita tools of late, the tool in this review and their drywall screw gun, sent me on a quest for a new line. Skil might be it, if they continue to build out with this quality. I almost bought back into Milwaukee, having surrendered to their PEX expander, but I will keep the old wait-and-see until we see how things develop.
I just went on Amazon and placed my order. You better see how many of those Skils they sell this month. And I will just leave the battery in the one 12 volt Skil tool I own. I have a right angle drill, but this impact will be much nicer for screws in tight spaces.
after looking at cordless ratchets i decided to buy the husky ratchet with non removeable battery. sure it's not the strongest but is compact and works great for what i use it for . i don't work on cars. it's just for really tight situations to spin a bolt or nut.then you finish or start by hand like a regular ratchet. .once you add batteries to the ratchets they get way bigger. ones with square batteries are useless to me.