Wrong Ammo .17 HMR in a .22 Magnum Revolver
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- Wrong ammunition - What would happen if you fired 17 HMR from a 22 WMR chambered revolver?
This is a viewer funded channel. Support Buffalo's Outdoors on Patreon - / buffalosoutdoors
This is my Facebook page where I post links to all my videos if you'd rather catch them there -- / thebuffaloandricochetshow
Thanks to Greg Wilson and his daughter Megan for providing the banjo music. - • Buffalo Chimes
Disclaimer: My videos are for entertainment purposes only, imitation or the use of any instruction shown in this video is done at your own risk. Buffalo's Outdoors/BMCTrip or any other party involved in the making of this video will not be held liable for any injury to yourself (or others) or damage to your firearms resulting from attempting anything shown in this video or any of my videos.
I am a brass rat. The local club rules are you bust pick all your brass up when you are done shooting. No one does. I asked several directors on a workday if I can collect brass that was left. Basically if no one is on the range they said to take as much as I can. In the past year I have several hundred pounds. Now over tens of thousands of pieces I have seen some strange things. Worst was probably what I believe is 9mm luger fired in a 40 S&W. I find a bunch of that.
Seen a fire formed 308 prob put in 30,06 not just one almost a full box some people are just stupid
I accidentally fired a 223 out of my 6.8 spc.
Fortunately, I was taught "Line Clearance" in the medical device industry. You clear the workspace of EVERYTHING and then bring out ONLY one product to be filled/labelled/packaged, &etc. So, if I'm working with .40, anything and everything else stays locked up. Plus, don't trust the boxed cartridges from any manufacturer. I have found, though rarely, a 9mm Parabellum in a factory-sealed .40 box.
I've seen quite a few 9mm fired in a 40, and 40s fired in a 45.
I've put 222 rem in my bolt action 223 rem
Although this is something I would NEVER do, thanks for satisfying our curiosity. I thought it was very interesting.
Glad you enjoyed it!
22 mag is such a cool little round. Such a great choice as an all around lightweight but still effective caliber.
I have 2 and they are both great guns
One of the coolest there is.
17 hmr is no slouch either.. my CCI A17 rounds are sitting at about 2600 fps at 50 yards. from my Savage A17
They're a great game bird and varmint round
Appreciate the way you go the extra mile to answer a viewers question. To get them all on the paper is one thing, but that standard deviation number blew me away. Excellent video my friend 👊
Yeah that SD tripped me out a bit!
Buffalo is sitting in his armchair...deep in thought.🤔
Buffalo's wife looks over at him and thinks: "I'll bet he's thinking about other women"😠
Buffalo: "Hmmm, I wonder what happens if I fire .17 HMR in a .22 Magnum"🤔
Lol
"No practical purpose"...it may not but when a few dudes get together, questions like this naturally are posed. Now we have the answer for this one. Thanks again Buffalo
I disagree. Depending on your world views, we are living in precarious times. A Mad Max scenario is quite possible. I have a Makarov that chambers and fires .380acp reliably, Russians do make sturdy gats. It is good knowledge to have JIC = Just In Case.
I always enjoy a Buffalo's Outdoors video, and appreciate the message at the end too. I'm in my early 70's, and growing up in this great country, I never would have imagined the day would come that some of my fellow citizens would be eager to give up their own freedom, and to take mine away too, for a false feeling of security...
Thank you and I’m glad you enjoy my videos. I first heard that saying that I close my videos with a few years ago and it really struck a chord with me because like you I see so many people just ready and willing to throw away what few liberties they have left in the name of the greater good. I’m just one person but I try to remind everyone I can, every chance I get that freedom IS the greater good.
Sad deal for sure. At least you and I can remember when America was the land of the free. We got the last teast of what America used to be.
Depends on the stick 😂🤣😂🤣
This is the Buffalo we know and love - so glad to see you having fun 🙌🏻
Thank you. I did have a lot of fun putting this together.
5:12 The worst group Buffalo has ever shot out of a double action revolver.
Facts 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Man I wouldn't believe it had I not seen it . Beats the heck outta throwing rocks in a worse case scenario. Your lookn good Buffalo , hope the holidays was good to you an your family .
God bless everyone and peace & love to all
Thanks for the wonderful comment!
SD of 7! Wow! Who'd a-thunk-it? But, your big takeaway is a good one. In the event of absolute necessity it will work. Thanks!
Someone please explain that one! I don’t understand that SD being so low.
Good to see you here. It was in the minus degrees outside last night when KC beat Miami in KC.
With the exception of your repeated cautions and disclaimers, Buff, every aspect of this demonstration was a surprise. 😯 Yes, freedom is the greater good, and the banjo music is delightful! 👍
I couldn’t help but laugh and compare this video to an old Archie Bunker dialog with Edith when Archie asked Edith if she agreed with capital punishment. Edith replied: Sure Archie, as long as it’s not too severe. So when you want to shoot something but you don’t want it over-stated….
I'm guessing that it'll be sorta like flicking a pebble out of a piece of PVC pipe... 🤔 Just don't let your hypothetical attacker know that your bullets are a bust.
Wow, better than I expected. That was pretty interesting. Thanks Buffalo 👍
It went better than I expected too. I mean yeah it wasn't great but for a square peg in a round hole type of thing it actually worked. Glad you found it interesting.
Thanks for the chronograph portion!
"Depends on the stick!!!" Thank you. God Bless and stay safe.
Love this channel, real sportsman stuff
I’ve had a ton of .17HMR rounds laying around and wondered what would happen with a rough rider. Glad someone tried it so I wasn’t tempted to
Thanks so much for the great advice and video.
Tried it last summer in a rough rider and the rancher carbine. No probs
If you don’t need the 17 rounds I’ll buy them
Buffalo you look like your dress. Very warm. I don't know about you where you're at, but I'm in Kansas and it's about going to be eight blow tonight. It's pretty chilly for us and you got a little breeze jacket on 🤣🤣
...I wish manufacturers would make an assortment of 17 HMR pistols....
So do I. I have a Taurus with a 12" barrel in .17, but it's not much of a carry gun
9:48 will net you a laugh!
I knew I done stepped in it. Might as well ask for a comment 🤣
Loved the video!! This is right up my alley.
There are lots of people who say you can’t do this or that but most of the time they’re just offering unfounded opinion or regurgitating someone else’s words. 😉
So true! And I enjoy making these types of videos as I get to discover things as I go along. I appreciate you making time to watch my video. I appreciate your videos. Stay warm this week!
Good to see you back Buffalo! I think you shoot 22 WRF out of a 22WMR revolver too. Another reason why revolvers are so good :) 22lr can shoot 22 long, 22 short, 22 colibri…
Hey I just watched your video on your first new gun of 2024 earlier today. Congrats on the pick up!
You said it…”no practical
purpose”!
Some Hitman watching the video " You mean it still has that much energy, and no rifling on the bullet...and its not my firearms caliber either...win/win !!! 😅😂
LOL...this video will live in infamy sortof like the old video when the late Barry (cannot remember last name) did the torture test of shooting a 454 Casul out of a .410 shotgun 🤣
Yes. I miss old Barry who was on Iraq88 or whatever that channel is called. I eventually quit watching after Barry passed away.
A buddy of mine fell on hard times and needed some money, he was gonna take a gun to a pawnshop, but instead i loaned him the money and held the gun so he wouldnt owe no intrest of deal with no bullcrap..
It was a grey ruger american compact 45.. i didnt own a 45 anymore but i had some reloads i bought from a gun show years ago, so i figured id shoot itna few times and see if i liked it. I really liked the looks and feel of the gun, and was thinking about buying one just like it..
I was on the second mag and noticed a weird pop... the shell didnt eject, and when i ejected it, i noticed it was a 40 sw case bulged and split..
Shocked me, but didnt cause any damage.. needless to say, i went thru the bag and found 1 more 40 round mixed in...
I ended up keeping the gun because the dude screwed me on the money lol.. so i got a ruger american 45 for 300 bucks.
Thank you for all that you do sir. I always enjoy your videos and am envious of your skill with revolvers.
You’re very welcome and I appreciate you watching and commenting. It means a lot to me to know that people get enjoyment from my work.
👍👍surprising to say the least especially the SD. Thanks Buffalo
I had a rifle, chambered in a wildcat 218 mashburn bee cartridge in which I shot the standard .218 Bee cartridge. It expanded the shoulder to the mashburn dimensions and some trim work and I would reload to its specifications They called this fireforming the cases, for those unfamiliar with reloading. However, the same cartridge head, length, and caliber, making it safe.
Great video, brother.
God bless all here.
My uncle used to fire form brass but it’s been so long ago I can’t remember what cartridge he was making or which he was making it from. Thanks for watching!
@buffalosoutdoors it use to be fairly common on the reloading community. Almost all my friends reloaded. Many of us molded our own bullets as well. Loved it. If memory serves me, one buddy had a Thompson contender in a Herrett cartridge that I believe he had to fire form as well. It was a lot of fun.
maybe ,22 Hornet being fireformed into a .22 K-Hornet.@@buffalosoutdoors
9:43 That’s what she said, even though he told her to expect 9
9:47 Happy to oblige. LOL
I suppose it would be better than a rock...maybe.
Super nice job on this one Buffalo!!
By the way, that's what she said
Cool vid! Thanks, Buffalo!
Entertaining as well as surprising.
Excellent as always, sir.
Interesting video. I'm also surprised that all this time I've been drinking ballistic water. Did not know that. Thanks.
This is one of the best presentations I have seen on this platform in a pretty good while. Nice work!
Love your videos man. Great seeing you’re still at it😊
Glad you enjoy them!
Wow . I agree with you about the Ammo.
Removed the stock Ruger lcrx 3inch 22 magnum grip and installed the smaller grip from the 2 inch lcrx for less than 30 bucks... Much more handier and concealable!!! And looks great.
Have tried that as I have both. You, Sir, are so very correct. Originally had the 2 inch snubby, and ordered the 3 inch, much to my surprise the 3 inch is a much bigger gun. Was expecting a 3 inch barrel snubby. But I guess at 3 inches it wouldn't be a snubby. All the best! "The JJ" SW Penna.
Awesome.
There's an old saying " just because you can doesn't mean you should . But still an interesting video
Great as always my friend.
"Insert your joke' is that my last date said to me! 😂
thanks for showing. this very educational. appreciate it.
Great job on shooting the facts out.
Thank you!
The .22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire (.22 WMR) has a maximum pressure of 24,000 psi (170 MPa), while the .17 HMR has a maximum pressure of 26,000 psi (180 MPa). The .17 HMR is a .17-caliber projectile housed in a necked-down .22 Magnum parent case.
The best shooting channel around
Pretty amazing. I'm surprised at how loud it is if nothing else.
Nice video Buffalo! Just now discovered your channel. Digging the content brother. Keep at it!
Thank you
Always love your videos
That was very entertaining . I thought you were pretty brave to try that test but you must have been pretty confident it wouldn't hurt the gun (or you) !
Glad you found it entertaining. I did my homework.
You wouldnt' want to be trying it the other way around
Turned into an air rifle. Lol. Your jokes caught me. 🤣🤣 Good stuff. 👍👍
Kind Thanks! I often wondered what the results would be shooting a 17HMR in a mag. Now I know thanks to you! Many Blessings! DaveyJO in Pennsylvania
You’re welcome. Glad you enjoyed the video!
Thanks for that interesting and entertaining review/analysis.
I was surprised by the results myself. Looking at the wound track, I'm questioning if the bullet didn't go into the block backwards. 😁
I wish I had a true high speed camera so we could see stuff like that. I feel like it turned inside the block but I can’t prove it.
It obviously did
I think you summarized it well with "Use it to get to something better" because it's certainly not ideal, but I would take that over nothing any day of the week.
Nice instructive video Buffalo on what not to do ..... One thing I thought that didn't happen was I figured every fired case would have a big split at the case neck because of the fire forming to the magnum chamber.
I expected the cases to split as well. The fact that they didn’t and the SD I got from those 5 shots over the chronograph were surprises for me.
“Insert your joke in the comments”😂
I'm guessing 800fps... effectively making it a pellet gun lol.
You was dang close!
Enjoyed that video! Great job as usual!!
Thank yee sir! Yes yes.
Your A WEALTH OF USEFUL INFORMATION 😵💫😳🤪🤔🤣
Ok you got me on this one . Never crossed my mind. From 2500 fps in rifle to 750 fps in revolver. Wow. 👍🏻
Interesting info to know as thanks for the testing.....Good stuff....
Had a guy ask me to look at a little rifle he’d bought for his son, a Rossi 22LR/410 combo. Only it wasn’t a 22, it was a 17 HMR that he shot a 22 in and the bullet was stuck in the barrel. I managed to get the slug out from the muzzle end without damaging the crown or the rifling and he was good to go. Offered to trade his 17/410 combo for a 22/410 that I had since that was what he had wanted to begin with. Nope, he wanted to keep it.
Heck yeah Buffalo experiments. The fire forming was cool. Not gonna touch the 7 inch penetration except the little red head got twisted 😂. Take care and stay warm it sucks right now in Ky.
Man it's sure gonna be cold this week. Stay warm my friend!
Now you have to review several sharpened sticks.
Buffalo, I am surprised that worked as well as it did!! (probably like most other people here). Thanks for a really video!
Great video! Another thing to keep in mind is the chamber pressure of the cartridges. The .17 HMR (26,000 psi) and .22 WMR (24,000 psi) have a 2,000 psi difference. It's not a huge pressure difference, but it's something worth mentioning.
Pressure is everything. In this scenario however there's no bullet to bore seal so pressures aren't approaching anywhere near spec.
@@buffalosoutdoors True, a .17 caliber bullet travelling down a .22 caliber bore diameter will not increase the chamber pressure. But, just picture someone loading .38 Super (36,500 psi) into a handgun chambered for .38 ACP (26,500 psi). Both cartridges have the same external dimensions, but have a difference of 10,000 psi in chamber pressure...🤕
@@user-jm6hh7op3w Hence the warning at the start of the video. 👍
I enjoy and appreciate your videos, just discovered you. I find your voice relaxing as well, as weird as that probably sounds 😂
@@jmilfy glad you enjoy the videos! Lots more coming.
I wasn’t surprised by the outcome- about what I expected- no accuracy but did fire.
Better than a handful of pea gravel, thanks Buffalo. 🇺🇸
Your video was interesting to me. Thanks.
Cool and Fun video. Thanks Buffalo !
Thanks for doing this, interesting results.
Still bad news for a squirrel, at close range.😂
Thanks for the information. I never even thought about trying it.
Great video, thank you sir.
I like your style man.
Love your videos
Neat demonstration. I have done a lot of sub-caliber testing and it won't hurt the firearm to shoot a sub-caliber cartridge in it. NEVER go the other way, such as shooting an 8 mm Mauser round in a 30/06. That will cause catastrophic pressures.
When the bullet is below bore diameter the pressure will be low and powder will not burn effectively, just as you demonstrated.
Great video , and very surprising results, thanx for posting
Fun video. Enjoyed watching it.
It's almost better than a pointy stick lol
Can it kill zombies though, and if so... how many? Too many questions left unanswered. Glad it didn't break anything :)
wrong caliber firing is my favorite haha just gotta make sure the pressure is lower than the caliber the weapon is and make sure the bore diameter is equal or larger than the wrong caliber. following those rules ive never had an issue.
I always enjoy your videos, maybe as much as you enjoy making them.
This is why I enjoy making them. This is the reward. Knowing people enjoy them!
Wow,that was really surprising!
I figured you'd hit the paper ,but the penetration on the milk jug was un expected and I definitely didn't expect it to go through both sides of the tomato can ( honestly I was kinda worried about a ricochet on that) then 7 inches on the ballistic gel was crazy ! Good video 👍
I was surprised as well. If it had stopped in the water jug the video would have ended there. I expected it to.
Guy at the range , was shooting his lever gun...couldnt hit the side of a barn...and lots of smoke coming out of the action. He asked me to try it, I looked at the rifle...44 mag ...looked at the ammo...30-30 winchester. The 30-30 was there behind him , leaning in the rifle stand...he mixed up the ammo sometime during setup.
Nice see a well-rounded and otherwise well-presented video
Amazing ... I was actually wondering about this very thing just the other day. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed the video!
Happy New Year, Buffalo.
Edit: First, I'm telling her...
Second, that bullet looks long enough that I wouldn't want one turning around inside of me.
😂 Happy New Year
interesting how it stretched perfectly to fit the chamber without tearing makes me wonder if they took a 22-magnum cartridge and necked it down when manufacturing to fit the 17-caliber bullet.
also is weird how bullet wound up backwards in ballistic gel was it tumbling in flight or just went in heaviest end first with slow velocity
Had a friend now passed, that took a rifle in pawn. When it wasn't reclaimed he took it and tried it out using .22lr ammo, it wasn't accurate at all and he wondered what he was going to do with it. Then he checked the markings on the receiver, .22 WMR, he used the proper ammo and it worked just fine.
Hi Buffalo, that really surprised me. Did shooting that 17hmr through that Ruger do any damage to the cylinder or bore?
I can't see it hurting the cylinder but it could bang around in the bore a little bit
No damage whatsoever. Thanks for watching!
Good video ,bro , thank you .
Buffalo have you ever fired .243 Winchester or 7mm-08 out of a 308 Winchester barrel? Heard a guy talking about doing it while in a conversation at a gun store about 30 or 35 years ago. Fire forming brass probably because the 243 and 7 are essentially just necked down from the 308 Winchester parent cartridge. At the same time he was talking about making .45 cal. pistol brass from his old 308 brass. I have never done this but by the measurements and eye balling, sure looks like it would work.
Thanks for sharing your reviews and keep your videos coming.
Thank you, gonna keep it going as long as I’m able!
Me 2 , did not think it would have that much force, being that it builds no pressure, Nasty little round though. Can believe the shell didn't got stuck in the cylinder. !!
As always take care and blessings to the Whole family 🙏🛡️🇺🇸🛡️❗
It surprised me too. Thanks for the comment.
VERY INTERESTING, and that ain’t no joke :)
Absolutely great video.😂❤