Debunking "Islam is a Feminist Religion"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 май 2019
- Alaa Murabit in this TED talk speaks about how Islam is compatible with women's rights. I disagree - Islam and feminism are not compatible. Here is my response.
👉 IMPORTANT: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEW CHANNEL HERE: bit.ly/friendl... 👈
► My blog: friendlyexmusli...
➡️ Link to full TED Talk: www.ted.com/ta...
#AbdullahSameer
![[Paris Olympics] Performance by Australia's Olympic Break-dancer Rachael Gunn breaks the internet](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i1rl1KhKIjE/mqdefault.jpg)
Well said. Claims that Islam liberates women must be one of the greatest examples of cognitive dissonance in our time.
@@mangkadyo3057 am I to believe you are being sarcastic with this statement.
@HISmercies nbounties
You guys aren't caretakers, you cobtrols women's freedom so much which shoes that you are being their owner and you are treating women's like your slsves if they choose their basic freedom you mock them and you shame them and you don't even stop & your sharia law police willl throw them into jail if they don't wear a abaya/hijab, you guys are clearly violenting women's freedom.
@HISmercies nbounties we are, its called freedom. Dont like the western ways. Then go live in a middle eastern country. I am sure you will be right at home.
@HISmercies nbounties cant reply brain dead.
@
No wonder; she is born one, no other ways, even they know the truth their proud block them.
Someone already said these. I'm repeating
1. She is gaslighting herself
2. She suffers from cognitive dissonance
3. 'Taqiya' in action
“The UN just copy us “
At this point I knew that what ever came out of this woman mouth is going to be pretty useless and cringe worthy.
😁
This video propagates such Lies and Propaganda
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.
I laughed out loud 😂😂
love how people like her emigrate and enjoy western secular culture and liberties while espousing the religion which holds her sisters in shackles
Such Lies and Propaganda
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.
western culture is one of the main reasons why she fled and why her sisters in her homeland are oppressed
@@faraazsiddiqui653 the world is unsafe because of you Muslim men who say that a woman should stay within the walls of her house and if she goes out well she is called a prostitute she is beaten up . Control the Muslim men and the mullahs instead of controlling the women
True bro here in India Muslims have become president, leading actors in bollywood, politicians, billionare, etc they became from 2cr to 15 cr and the fact that they still say that Muslims in India are treated badly while saying that terrorists are not Muslims.
God the level of brainwashing. Cringe.
Yep I was trying to think of these exact words, she is the sort of person that sway innocent western women into Islam
Your moroccan aren't you
No brain washing stop being disingenuous. And pushing you agendas on to the Islam. Face it you just want the women to be corrupted. like the women the west .
"....these women...."
Mentions *only Khadija* for example.
and these chiristian
mention only jessus for example...
@@hassan32215 Jesus was a woman?
@@franciscopizarro8642 i think he was men.
@@hassan32215 Then what does he have to do with this discussion?
@@franciscopizarro8642 what does khadija did do with this discussion...
Woman in Iran are getting arrested for not wearing the Hijab. I side with those woman.
It's mandate by their religion. No one criticizes the jews for having their wives head cover as well the Christians nuns
@@coachlamont1083 Being alone is an absolute choice that a woman may make. Orthodox Judaism is criticised, and it is question from those within and outside the religion. When a headscarf is mandated as part of the law of a country and women have no choice, and those that protest are thrown in jail, then it’s a problem.
Those are the extremist people us from Morocco dont think that way heck most women here dont wear a hijab cuz iven doe its a staple of islam its not actually haram hope that clears the misunderstanding
@@coachlamont1083 Israel didn't put women to jail for not wearing head covering. Nor any church hit women for removing head scarf.
@@nutanfulmali3798 And the muslims don't neither . women in most cases chooses to ware the hijab because of there religion. You just bias toward Islam. And what business is it to you . how other cultures chooses to practice there religion. STOP the propaganda and prejudice behavior.
It's pretty much like saying Islam is an atheist religion.
Allah is being used for power over people.
Or saying Atheist are Islamic lol
She studies in a disbelieving country, then she thinks that it's Islam that gave her her freedom and feminist rights., It should be sent now to Saudi Arabia, because there she will be given quickly on the right path
Atheist = irreligious. its not a religion. and muslims become atheists to get rid of sharia law.
borrowed tomb and I would ‘convert’ to Islam if I was sent to prison. Would be safer.
Hahaha 😂😂.. United Nations copied quran 😂😂😂
@Diana Artemis Islam should be banned ,not UN.
@Diana Artemis 👍😊
😂 😂 😂
She’s out of her mind!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣
Funny lol
Women's right stands at 180 degrees to Islam !
No, human rights stand at 180 degrees to Islam!
Ur ignorant
@@468297
True that too
Why not in 360 degree
@@gangadharatimothy7000 Ask your math teacher
Woof!!!
BTW, I had the misfortune of seeing Linda Sarosur in person. Her speech was pure propaganda littered with strawmen.
Pray to daddy Dawkins for me
@@mmohon93 thx for Tha info, you made it a Lil serious with ur opinion.
Mohon Meh You’re very rude.
Mohon Meh Ok.
Ali Jr, In 1000 years your people and my people(followers of the Hitch) will be at war.
She says it , saying the United nations literally copied them but🤔 she does not quote it.
She full of crap.
@HISmercies nbounties
Do you know mohammad has 16 special privelages that his 'great allah god' given, what are they??
Jacqueline Moore ....she’s hallucinating lol
"So really the united nations copied from us!" why does stomach churn when i hear stuff like these?
your stomach churns because you know its true! haha
@@okaychampion1896 good that you added a haha there.. for a moment i thought you were serious
@@mrabeeh yes your moment was correct, im serious.
Your an idiot mate.
TED = Terrorist Extremist Declaration.
The best thing about your talks is, whenever I cross reference one of your quotes it always comes out to be true. Nothing is warped or twisted to make your point.
Well done, Abdullah.
I wonder how many condescending public lectures Murabit has given (wearing jeans and make-up) in Islamic countries.
@@mangkadyo3057 Please...
Well said!!!!
With out islam world is peaceful.
Am an exmuslim.
@Rod Veles Asura
No single word of LORD GOD JESUS hurts any but bring all together in an ambrella doesn't matter who they are.
The gospel message brings human beings together. No matter what you are what you religion represent no discrimination.
@Rod Veles Asura
First go and read Holy Bible with out prejudice it will talk to you well, this is my life experiences, once I too like you, in all occasions I insult LORD GOD JESUS as much as possible, but HIS everlasting love mould me to love all, so l left islam to be good human being and to be useful to all.
@Rod Veles Asura
Ever you notice why different types of religions migrate to Western Christian nations and buy lands and build their worship centers and religious complex fear free and share their religion publically? Because LORD GOD JESUS never teach to block any one, is it possible in your Saudi Arabia. Why? islam teaches forcefully bring all to Islam, any denies kill merciless.
@Rod Veles Asura
See, you approach Holy Bible with your already fed answer, you are not an exmuslim, but follow the same. I raised many points how Christans behave towards rest religion and gave examples too.
What about Islamic nations attitude towards rest religions?
She is right that Human Rights copied from her Hadith and Quran! THE BEST TAQIYYA(DECEPTION)LEVER MUSLIM WOMAN!
"Volume 1, Book 2, Number 28:
The Prophet said: "I was shown the Hell-fire and that the majority of its dwellers were women who were
ungrateful." It was asked, "Do they disbelieve in Allah?" (or are they ungrateful to Allah?) He replied, "They are
ungrateful to their husbands and are ungrateful for the favors and the good (charitable deeds) done to them. If
you have always been good (benevolent) to one of them and then she sees something in you (not of her liking), she
will say, 'I have never received any good from you."
Skeptic Psychologist that’s why until a year ago the can drive in Saudi
@Skeptic Psychologist Islam is still living in the 1400 but we all have evolved . That is the problem .
@Skeptic Psychologist arbitrarily , the point is Islam's problems arise from the fact that Muhammad called himself the last prophet . So now no one can edit the Quran as such the Muslims are stuck in the same mindset of a man of the medieval ages as all they think about is conquering , spreading Islam etc .
When the hijab is worn tightly enough, one accepts complete nonsense as fact.
Good one!!
Lol
A lot of crap from the speaker... Taqiyaa to hide behind that curtain 😂😂😂
People just want to think whatever they want. They don't actually learn. This is very sad.
it really is... getting indoctrinated is the worst thing you could ever do to a human being... well not the worst but you get the idea
Ha ngoc Minh - don't blame them. They just follow their religion based on what been taught to them without even checking the actual source of that teaching. Ask any muslim women about covering their hair, I am 100% sure they didn't know that Allah copied that idea from umar
@@kintaroicoc4020 muslims are not the ones to blame... their religion is the one to blame... its all about fear and being a slave to something that doesnt exist... some muslims how ever grow up and realize its fasle like me and many others... and some... dont dare to question their belief
@@shuaibahmed8141 ur the first muslim who has openly accepted that fault is in Islam not the people following it (Muslims). Most of the times I just see Muslim excuses as Islam is perfect but muslims are not but in reality Islam is not perfect just like every other religion.
your view is amazing.
And its worth watching .
Keep it up , we have to stop making religion, a top priority or nation's goal
😂😂😂 son of the devils help him up..
Makeup = haram.
HARAM HARAM HARAM
it's a school information
My dear bro/sis..check the facts before posting .. make up is halal as long as it doesn't contains ingredients which are considered as haram in islam......
@@youareamazing14369 *but it can't be worn in public*
Allah uses the Quran to tell Mohammad’s wives to stop complaining about Mohammad...hmmm
And that is the eternal book, made by allah from the beginning of time...
Couldn’t He have just left a sticky note on the bathroom door?
@Hᴜꜱᴛʟᴇ Lᴏʏ you don't even understand the chain of narrations in Hadith and how it works . .let me teach u something today which hopefully will stick in your empty skull. ..when Islam defeated the Persians... there were many false hadiths coming out of that regions obviously to defamed the prophet. .so there are 6 Hadith books which are accepted as authentic Hadiths in Islam. ..if any Hadith that u qouting for eg....does not comform with any of the above 6. . mentioned. ..or with the Quran. .the hadith is rejected. ..hope you get this. .next time you quote hadith make sure you have confirmed it's authenticity. ...cheers
@Hᴜꜱᴛʟᴇ Lᴏʏ that not important what I am? ..u have quoted a hadith and I have advised you how careful one should be before quoting them. .another point of advise. ..did u know that Buhari started his narrations +250 years after the demise of the prophet. .so you can see. ..it's a long time. .so his sources of information was coming from 2/3/4/5/6 sources. ..and if the link in his narration were broken,the hadith could be very weak....I am just cautioning you to be careful. .when u quoting hadith. ..please check it's authenticity. ...cheers
Misty blue - hahaha you just got busted. Tell any muslim in public who agree with you about Sahih bukhari . even your 5 pillar of Islam came from hadith ,not quran , did you know that?
Abdullah, keep the truth coming!
Ahahahahahha
Islam and Feminism is an oxymoron.
Such Lies and Propaganda
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.
@@faraazsiddiqui653 Md. The perfect example of human was a pedophile. He had sex with another's wife after killing them. He had sex slaves. And anything that came from the proceeds of the 'right hand. That is the sword. Islam means submission.
He was a medieval warlord who used divine revelations to justify his lusting and sexual appitite which was enormous as recorded in a Hadith as taking 11 of his sex slaves a night!!!
Abdullah, I came across Murabit's TED Talk a couple of days ago and left the following comment. "Wrong title. Ms. Alaa Murabit gave a very impassioned speech advocating for the rights of women in Islam. I share her passion. However her speech did not give justice to the title. Ms. Murabit ignores Muhammad's dictates and is trying to moderate and whitewash Islam. So here is what Muhammad said about women.
1. Muhammad considered naming angels in the hereafter (an-Najm 53:27) with female names a horrible thing, so apparently all angels are males.
2. Muhammad said women had a deficiency of the intelligence.
3. Muhammad said that the majority of the occupants of hell were women.
4. Muhammad's 6 year old wife, Aisha, when she grew up complained that Muhammad made wives "equal to the dogs and the asses." Sahih Muslim 4:1039.
5. Muhammad gave men the permission to beat their wives.
6. Muhammad said that believing men, I assume those married and unmarried, when they get to heaven they would be rewarded with new virgin women who had never had sex with men or jinn. Heaven is described as a place where men have their choice of large eyed virgin women to have sex with. Muhammad said nothing about the reward that women would get.
7. Muhammad gave himself permission to have an unlimited number of wives and female slaves while limiting his male followers to just 4 wives but unlimited female slaves.
8. Muhammad gave permission to his male followers who were away at war permission to contract temporary marriages for the purpose of quenching their sexual appetites. So women were temporarily married just to use their bodies.
"So which of these favors of your lord would you deny?"
What kind of image or role of women is painted and modeled in those pronouncements? Muslims believe that Muhammad's words and instructions are infallible and that he speaks for god. He is also the final messenger with the final complete and perfect message for the rest of time. These pronouncements are not subject to change. Anyone who wishes to change these edicts of Muhammad should acknowledge that they are violating the words of Muhammad.
Well said, she should just quit islam if she wants women's rights. Because it can't b done under islam. Women rights in islam is an over statement.
Seems like any clown who can articulate properly can be part of TED talks.
This video propagates such Lies and Propaganda
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.
The Hijabi Women is doing Taqiyya
I will give an excellent example.
Suppose,
One steals money and is caught by cleric in Pakistan.
The theif denies.
When the theif is asked to swear on Allah,
And asked,
""Have to stolen Pakistani currency?""
He does Taqiyaa and says No.
Because he has stolen Dollars and not rupees.
Do you see the difference?
Both are correct.
He actually did not steal local currency,
But he stole dollar.
Thats how they tackle truth.
She spoke about Khadija half ass style.
Khadija was the Boss of Prop. Mohd and was prosperous and strong before the revelation of so called Islam.
TAQIYAA TAQIYAA TAQIYAA
Uh..that's not how it works
@@BeNGALi4LFE
Then why would she say that Islam is the reason behind her development?
She lied publicly.
In fact,
Quresh Tribe were against Islam and all this,
Khadija Has an important role in the development of Prop.Mohd.
Cause,
If she had not allowed him to stay in cave and meditate and all,
If she would have deployed Prop.Mohd to some war or trade zone,
Nothing of so called Revelation would have taken place.
C'mon,
Read atleast.
@@subrotonag214 Taqqiya is hiding your faith in the face of persecution, which is why it is generally found more among the Shia, a persecuted minority. It was done by Moses' followers in front of Pharoah. Simply lying is not taqqiya. You guys just throw it around whenever you disagree with a Muslim's viewpoints. This lady may have lied or whatever, but its not taqqiya.
@@BeNGALi4LFE Bro, Its not about whether she is lying or whatever,
Its about
1. Provision for Lie
2. Even if Khadija was more important, she won't be worshiped like Mohd.
Let me give another example,
Once a famous bollywood celebrity was interviewed,
And he proudly said the verse, where killing one human is killing all humanity,
But the next following verses he did not,
which was about killing non-muslims.
Makes me feel, all these moderate peace loving muslims are vague and naive.
I feel, Wahabis are infact real muslims. Because they accept the true violence, no hiding, walk the talk kind of shit.
Moderate peace keeping muslims are just the proxy.
Cause when I see 100s of Muslims kids killed in school sucide attack by Al-Qaeda and its 5/10,
But when 50 muslims, from which most of them might be from humble background are killed, the world goes upside down.
I can keep going.
I don't hate muslims, i just cant digest the lies.
Thank You
Deception, Lying
and Taqiyya
Does Islam permit Muslims to lie?
Muslim scholars teach that Muslims should generally be truthful to each other, unless the purpose of lying is to "smooth over differences" or "gain the upper-hand over an enemy"
There are several forms of lying to non-believers that are permitted under certain circumstances, the best known being taqiyya (the Shia name). These circumstances are typically those that advance the cause of Islam - in some cases by gaining the trust of non-believers in order to draw out their vulnerability and defeat them.
Quran
Quran (16:106) - Establishes that there are circumstances that can "compel" a Muslim to tell a lie.
Quran (3:28) - This verse tells Muslims not to take those outside the faith as friends, unless it is to "guard themselves" against danger, meaning that there are times when a Muslim may appear friendly to non-Muslims, even though they should not feel friendly.
Quran (9:3) - "...Allah and His Messenger are free from liability to the idolaters..." The dissolution of oaths is with pagans who remained at Mecca following its capture. They did nothing wrong, but were evicted anyway. (The next verse refers only to those who have a personal agreement with Muhammad as individuals - see Ibn Kathir vol 4, p 49)
Quran (66:2) - "Allah has already ordained for you the dissolution of your oaths..."
Quran (40:28) - A man is introduced as a believer, but one who had to "hide his faith" among those who are not believers.
Quran (2:225) - "Allah will not call you to account for thoughtlessness in your oaths, but for the intention in your hearts"
Quran (3:54) - "And they (the disbelievers) schemed, and Allah schemed (against them): and Allah is the best of schemers." The Arabic word used here for scheme (or plot) is makara, which means 'cunning,' 'guile' and 'deceit'. If Allah is supremely deceitful toward unbelievers, then there is little basis for denying that Muslims are allowed to do the same. (See also 8:30 and 10:21)
Taken collectively these verses are interpreted to mean that there are circumstances when a Muslim may be "compelled" to deceive others for a greater purpose.
Hadith and Sira
Sahih Bukhari (52:269) - "The Prophet said, 'War is deceit.'" The context of this is thought to be the murder of Usayr ibn Zarim and his thirty unarmed companions by Muhammad's men after they were "guaranteed" safe passage (see Additional Notes below).
Sahih Bukhari (49:857) - "He who makes peace between the people by inventing good information or saying good things, is not a liar." Lying is permitted when the end justifies the means.
Sahih Bukhari (84:64-65) - Speaking from a position of power at the time, Ali confirms that lying is permitted in order to deceive an "enemy." The Quran defines the 'enemy' as "disbelievers" (4:101).
Sahih Muslim (32:6303) - "...he did not hear that exemption was granted in anything what the people speak as lie but in three cases: in battle, for bringing reconciliation amongst persons and the narration of the words of the husband to his wife, and the narration of the words of a wife to her husband (in a twisted form in order to bring reconciliation between them)."
Sahih Bukhari (50:369) - Recounts the murder of a poet, Ka'b bin al-Ashraf, at Muhammad's insistence. The men who volunteered for the assassination used dishonesty to gain Ka'b's trust, pretending that they had turned against Muhammad. This drew the victim out of his fortress, whereupon he was brutally slaughtered.
From Islamic Law:
Reliance of the Traveler (p. 746 - 8.2) - "Speaking is a means to achieve objectives. If a praiseworthy aim is attainable through both telling the truth and lying, it is unlawful to accomplish through lying because there is no need for it. When it is possible to achieve such an aim by lying but not by telling the truth, it is permissible to lie if attaining the goal is permissible (N:i.e. when the purpose of lying is to circumvent someone who is preventing one from doing something permissible), and obligatory to lie if the goal is obligatory... it is religiously precautionary in all cases to employ words that give a misleading impression... (See the Permissible Lying section on the Sharia page for more)
"One should compare the bad consequences entailed by lying to those entailed by telling the truth, and if the consequences of telling the truth are more damaging, one is entitled to lie."
Notes
The Hadith makes it clear that Muslims are allowed to lie to unbelievers in order to defeat them or protect themselves. There are several forms:
Taqiyya - Saying something that isn't true as it relates to the Muslim identity. This is a Shiite term: the Sunni counterpart is Muda'rat.
Kitman - Lying by omission. An example would be when Muslim apologists quote only a fragment of verse 5:32 (that if anyone kills "it shall be as if he had killed all mankind") while neglecting to mention that the rest of the verse (and the next) mandate murder in undefined cases of "corruption" and "mischief."
Tawriya - Intentionally creating a false impression.
Muruna - 'Blending in' by setting aside some practices of Islam or Sharia in order to advance others.
"United Nation Just copied us" hahahahahha
Was starting to think that I was the only one who heard that
She's not happy in Canada, poor thing, hope she moved to middle east.
Hahahaha
It's so sad that this topic needs a debunking! Thank you, Abdullah.
As an Atheist, debunking Christianity would be tough (if I were to chose to try to do that). But debunking Islam would be child's play. Islam debunks itself.
Debunking christianity is also childs play bro. 😂
@@shivamgusain5185Is Aisha a minor or an adult
If shes an adult: Aisha committed haram by keeping and playing with dolls
If shes a minor: Mohammad is a pedofile.
There, islam and it’s prophet contradict itself.
that TED talk.. everything she said exposes just what a mental prison religion is
@HISmercies nbounties if you don't understand religion go and live some years in a religious country like I did, you'll quickly see, it really is an eye opener, the evil of it. People in Europe like you have forgotten what religion is, you have no clue about the mental illness, no clue of the mental cancer that it is.
Having seen what religion is and does to the mind, I had no surprise watching this video, that woman reminds me of a canary inside a cage singing about how free she is inside that cage, she can go anywhere in that cage, she's telling the free birds outside (audience) to join her in that cage of freedom, and the tragedy is that some are naive enough or stupid enough to do so.
Religion is a self imposed mental cage, blind belief in irrational ideas and blind worship of a fictitious all-powerful being who judges your every move with intent to punish you for anything you do that is disapproved of.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.why do Muslim lie. 1) fear is the key! !
Olalekan Tosin taqqya
They lie and they dream that those lies one day will be true, they long for truth,Iin Islam they can not find it, so they make up things
If you ain't Muslim how do you know they lieing, are you Muslim or are they, Who knows better
A woman praising Islam is like a turkey celebrating Thanksgiving (Copied from a comment).
I spat out my drink at the monitor at this title...
you owe me a new monitor lol
A father can sleep with his daughter that came out of a non marriage relationship ...
@They don't like it up em best video on that topic deep into Islam only Islamic reliable sources : Christian Prince on the YT channel: The Arabian Prophet
Its true or not,,
@ i mean real daughter
@@mangkadyo3057 step daughter , yes. If the daughter belongs to his current wife but she came from a different husband, yes .
Though the ruling is not 100 % clear about yr own biological daughters, there has been quite a number of Muslim marrying marrying their own daughters ...
www.deccanchronicle.com/lifestyle/viral-and-trending/061117/muslim-cleric-says-man-can-marry-own-daughter-twitterati-react-furiously.html
Your a lier lol
How provoking it is when she says the United nations copied us
You have done rational work ,,,good job sameer
Ask the lady who allows u to put a skintight jeans? Islam..... Hmmmm got married in six to 50year old.
It was the 6 year old's choice to marry a 50 year old....getting it?
@@pnirmal5900 six year old baby making choice, wow
@@followthetruth2660 I said the same when a guy told me this.😁
She is making me hard. She is making me sin and therefore Allah will punish her instead of me if I touch her. Long live Islam.
UN copied human rights declaration from quron....
This statement is enough to realize the true color of islam.
Nicely done. Bro 👍
they come to Canada lives their whole life there. then goes back to their beautiful Islamic sharia countries comes back and talks about how good it is and why we should have sharia in Canada and Islamic rule in the western world. if ur country is so great and Canada is bad bloody stay in ur country don't come back.
Are you sure madam? Have you really understand Qur'an? Oh yeah, wife beating, slave to husband etc is the right of a women? Your idea of right is funny😄
You lucky girl, you were not married at young age, otherwise your life would be like life's of many young girls from Afghanistan or Pakistan, you are very lucky indeed
@@ureedaharshad2244 that's what exactly I mean, your manners
@@goddessr3065
Well said 👌
How much did she get paid to read that script?
HISmercies nbounties it’s called sarcasm, look it up.
That woman, a veil and skinny jeans. And a big mouth to kafirs. She wouldn't dare to do that in a mosque to men, So hypocritical!
12:46 very important message about why cherrypicking is not an excuse. Thanks for being mature and honest as always, Abdullah.
Such Lies and Propaganda
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.
@@faraazsiddiqui653 you’re delusional. Stop. You probably hate women and see them as sex objects as is stated in your first section.
Short, simple, detailed, and at point. 👍
Thank you sameer
It is not the first time I get disappointed with TED talks.
Retrofitting and cherry picking. These same principals can be found explicitly, implicitly, metaphorically, from ancient myths to every fantasy/sci-fi novel ever written. This is what pisses me off, most people from modern Muslim to non-religious do not know enough about the Quran to disagree with her. This is why Abdullah Sameer, Secular Jihadist, Yasmine, Sarah Haider, etc are priceless. We need them to correct these misleading statements.
Thank you for everything you do. It takes guts to finally come to your senses after questioning beliefs you've been taught since you were born (like any religion), not to mention going public and educating people on the truth. It really saddens me how humanity in general cannot critically think for themselves. People really believe in things that have never been proven because they have been told to believe in them and threatened with punishment and reward accordingly, neither of which is guaranteed, because again there's no evidence. But I'm thankful for brave people like you. Gives me hope that the "thinking for yourself" still exists~ fellow ex-muslim
"...O wives of the Prophet, whoever of you should commit a clear immorality - for her the punishment would be doubled two fold.." Surah 33:30
The fact this lady is wearing a headscarf her God demands she wears makes this even funnier. Modesty my ass.
So what this lady is saying is that if you take vague/broad verses from the Quran and Hadith, they could be applied to treating women equally. I would tend to say that nothing she said was incorrect. You only need to ignore the other verses and Hadiths that do allow for persecution and oppression to make it work. There is nothing wrong with someone wanting to see the positive side of things. Let each person apply and work through their own cognitive dissonance. I see nothing wrong with this lady’s speech because she’s trying to highlight the positive.
LoL...
@@transformoktav4481 also chuckling. crowbar needed to get fem into islam.
I agree, I support highlighting the positive but not , when it's used to hide the evil that it pepertrate . There is far far far more, what's negative about Islam, then positive .
By focussing only on the positives, she helps to obscure and obsfucate the teaching of Islam , that are highly detrimental to women . She is giving a Veneeer of respectability to Islam.
People listening , might think, hey Islam is not so bad, maybe those mullahs, supporting honour killings, acid throwing , subjugation, don't know, Islam like she does , when nothing could be further from the truth .
In the light of hyper sensitive , western feminism, where a hand shake, hug could be contrived to be toxic maculanity , it's strange, western women, are perfectly comfortable with Muslim women being subjugated !
Great job, Sameer! You, the Apostate Profit, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, and Dr. Bill Warner are all brave men who call Islam out for its inaccuracies, hypocrisy, and cruelty. Thank God for giving the world such courageous and articulate men and women at this dangerous time. Thank you for all you do!
I lost it when she said -Un copied islam🤡🤡
Why people are finding human rights in religious books....
why people getting graduate for better life???
Look hard enough for something and you'll find it, even if it's not there
@@hassan32215 that analogy is just outta this world.
@@AdamAdamHDL one day u want to own slave become ur Muhammad owne many and u have right to own
@@NaveenKumar-fs1yf
Own a slave!? What the hell... I don't want slaves.
I allways thought that TED was an event to respect because great minds were speakong there.
But after seeing the intro of this video I am no longer thinking that way.
Are we talking about the female Dementors? Everytime I see them covered in the full black clothing that's what I think of. Harry Potters Dementors shrouds. ahahaha And yes, I'm going to post this every where I can. Make it a meme.
Thank you for posting this Sameer.
Lol me 2. Liberal are loose their mind.
Thanks Abdullah for speaking the truth.
I cringed while listening to her, and I said to myself she must have read a different different Quran than the rest of us.
Did she do her research in Libia before or after ISIS took over?
It's like trying to mix water and oil. They just don't mix.
'Taking to strange men = haram.' Then why did she do the presentation?
« United Nation copied the Qu’ran »
Sometimes I’m really asking myself if we got the same version of the Qu’ran or nah.
The weed this young girl is smoking is too strong........
"Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand." - Quran 4:34
I'm so thankful you tackled this TED talk.
Well said Abdullahi. Recently, Somalia increased the marriageable age to 18 and made marital rape illegal. The Ulema/Sheikhs of Somalia came together in a conference to say that the new law is against Islam. Somalia also made anothet law saying at least 30% of MPs should be women, yet again the sheikhs started to denouce this. Islam is totally again women's rights.
As ex muslim somali girl am happy❤
I cringed everytime that woman spoke.
Haha, me too
This could have been a good step forward if she would have accepted that Qur'an is archaic and we need reforms, like Christianity did.
Yup. How can we help theses mental ill people to reform.
Yes I am proud not be part of any of these cults. And regarding reforms, I meant the reforms after crusade age which led to a tolerant form of Christianity. Since Islam is the newest religion compared to all others, Muslims are still riding high on the drug that is Islam. Today's Islamic radicalism is akin to Christian crusades in the Europe in 1100s. I am sure this religion will also pass through that phase and die down to the state that you just described of Christianity. That is if all Muslims are not Wahabised and go on blowing themselves up here and there.
Like they say woman defend Islam same as like chicken defend KFC.
She lives in West and went to Libya think women are empowered...West has definitely empowered her to think that and she is illusions to think UN copied from the cult book. I like to see her taking off her hi-jab for a month in Libya, praying in "moss" with the man for a month, etc...
Can a girl get most of her father's property according to islam?
Mohammad father’s family was idols worshiper like Hindu religion. I think black stone in cabba is king Lah idol. Rest of 364 were destroyed by Mohammad at end of his life when he Concord Macca. Only kept his father’s god idol.
King Lah = The Lah = Al Lah =Allah = son of Hindu nabi Ram son Lah who lived in Lahore 3 thousands years ago.
Yup. Very true.
I thought they worshiped pegan god though.
martha black ,
Idols worshiping is pagan god worship but in older Punjab it was known as Sindhu/ Hindu.
It is same older concept .
is sad. How Mohammed destroyed that culture. And art. And muslim look at him as a hero.
I had a caged parrot and I couldn't make out why it wouldn't fly away when left open
Hey, Islam is not Islamic guys.
OmG. Quran is so cruel for humanity especially women.
How can a woman like her find silver linings in the scripture !
The cheek of this ignoramus to compare UN women's rights with those mentioned in quran. Nothing could be more idiotic. She requires to be, post haste, despatched to Saudi to understand her true position in islam. Thanks Sameer for your clear commentary on the matter.
Whatever people's thoughts below,I am going with Mr.Sameer God bless you sir ,and happy Monday .
She definitely needs to get her IQ tested😎
Funny to hear...🤭🤭🤭United nation copied from ussssssssss..😬😬😬🤭🤭🤭😂😂😂
khadija was never a muslim until she married mohammad , which was very late, she was already successful businessperson
She is intentionally ignoring the abuse muslim women experience, and looking the other way, because it contradicts what she wants to believe. She says she didn't have to look far to find examples of Muslim women who are leaders, and then she stopped. Tell us, where are these women? Instead of looking for examples of strong muslim women, why not acknowledge the muslim women right under your nose, who are being subjugated and oppressed.
Alaa is full of hypcrisy
▓▒░ Whoever speaks to an audience
and begins to quote this and that
*MUST* give the reference -
which book; which volume number;
which chapter; which verse.
Then...
...YOU must look up the references in at
least *three* different translations.
(Three will give you a three-dimensional
picture of what the actual message says.)
If the message doesn't line up with what
the speaker claims...well,
at least YOU would know the truth.
░
░
_And the truth shall set you free._ ☺ ░▒▓
`
Most western translations are garbage.
send this woman to iran or saudia plz, they shall guide her to the right path
I have seen the whole talk and i think she is genuinely trying to help.
She is talking while dreaming...
OH! UN copied from you? just like Muhammad was the perfect man on the earth.
If Islam is a feminist religion, then the Catholic clergy is women only and the Kaaba is a white marshmallow!
Feminist lefties go: 'oh she is so special, she has a uniform...wish we could have the same moral high ground'
She is bullshiting them
Jewish rich wife Khatga lunched new cult for her Hindu husband , that is why Mohammad prayed to Israel direction for 14 years, until 15 years older then him lived.
It was Khatga who told Mohammad , you are Nabi and her cousin warka bin Nufaul conformed According to Jewish religion. And Khatga was first Muslim ever.
My question is , what make her Muslim? Book was not even started yet .
Mohammad father’s family was idols worshiper like Hindu religion. I think black stone in cabba is king Lah idol.
King Lah = The Lah = Al Lah =Allah = son of Hindu nabi Ram son Lah who lived in Lahore 3 thousands years ago.
It pretty much impossible to just read the "Islam is a Feminist Religion" without keeping a straight face.
She is talking from the privilege being from a non-Islamic country without strict adherence to Islamic laws. She has no right to speak about the rights of women in Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan etc.
2:50 Beautifying yourself in front of others - Women aren't allowed to display their physical beauty in front of non-related adult men because most men in general judge most women first by their physical beauty and then by other parameters. That's a fact. If most men were given a chance they would sleep around with every woman they find even remotely attractive. A woman is allowed to dress freely among women for as long as she is not being too indecent.
2:54 taking off your headscarf in front of men - Same reason as above.
2:58 Listening to Music - Music can be incredibly beautiful and therapeutic but it is a fact that the vast majority of music today contains a lot of themes that are detrimental to society like the objectification of women, guns, violence, drugs, and alcohol. Many Muslim youths listen to such kind of music even when it is clearly prohibited so you can imagine why prohibited it.
3:00 Wearing perfume - So that women don't attract unnecessary male attention.
3:05 A women's role is at home - Women are allowed to go out and do jobs within certain limits, but you have to realize the world has always been very unsafe for women, and it still is in many parts of the world.
3:18 Women being relegated to the back of the mosque - Yes because women bending and praying in front of men will be distracting, to say the least.
3:28 Most masjids in India don't even have a women's area - Because most women in India don't even go to mosques.
3:34 Women's area in mosques is tiny, dimly-lit, isolated - That may be because very few women attend prayers. There is no such discrimination in Islam. If the women's area is dimly lit then it's the fault of the people in charge of the mosque.
4:50 Khadijah's wealth was actually drained after Islam - Khadijah WILLINGLY donated her money for helping her loving husband. Women are not obligated in Islam to share their money with their husbands, on the other hand a man has to provide for at least the basic shelter, food, and clothing for his wife.
5:15 Best place for a woman to pray is her home, in the most isolated part - Yes because that's where the most privacy and safety is. Remember much of the world was very unsafe in history for men so you can imagine how vulnerable women were.
5:40 Women are not allowed to travel without a male guardian - Again it is an issue of safety. Even today a lot of the world is unsafe for women and sadly will continue to be so for a very long time.
6:41 Women are given half of the inheritance a brother will receive - Because a woman gets to keep the inheritance all to herself whereas a man has to provide for his family. A woman is not obligated to pay any money to her husband.
6:47 Women are not allowed to divorce their husbands - They are totally ALLOWED to divorce their husbands.
11:50 You can mary your adopted son's wife - No there is no concept of an adopted son in Islam
12:07 Prophet saying I am best to my wives - Through numerous authentic hadiths, we come to know how great of a husband he was.
12:15 Wives were miserable - Very wrong information, all of his wives were very happy with him.
12:54 Islamic societies don't treat women well - It is because Muslim men don't understand and implement the teachings of Islam.