I believe the drummer is Gene Trautmann, but on the Rated R sessions they also employed a drummer named Nick Lucero from the group The Flys. They each played on about half the record, and at one point it was even considered having them both play live. There's some promo photos out there. It definitely wasn't Dave, he didn't show up until Songs for the Deaf replacing Gene, but you can still hear him on Go With the Flow and You Think I Ain't Worth Dollar, But I Feel Like A Millionaire.
Wow I'm a huge fan of the first 3 albums (and other early tracks like this one) but I didn't know that stuff about the consideration of having the both drummers play live.
Matt Cameron played in the first Gamma Ray ( before they named Queens Of The Stone Age) and played the first shows with his partner in Wellwater Conspiracy, John McBain ( you must to check Wellwater Conspiracy, Psychedelic 60's garage rock ) . Also Alfredo Hernandez played in the first demos . But you are listening here a rerecording of the song with several changes, like the heavy bass , and I think is Gene Trautman playing here . Remember this is another version of the song , not the original played in 97
One of my favourite current groups. Every drummer who’s played with them is fantastic, although Grohl is one of my favourites. (Especially love his drumming in Them Crooked Vultures.) As a bassist, The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret is one of my favourite tracks to play.
@@buzzbomb67 His description was cool. He said it was the sound of a group of robots programed to play music, but you found them after the apocalypse, still playing, but all broken down.
Near as I have been able to find out, it may have been Matt Cameron. The EP lists Vic Indrizzo. On the b-side version, Nick Lucero. But Grohl was hanging around with them from late Kyuss to Songs for the Deaf.
according to the world of webs matt Cameron was the drummer on this track wich they recorded before they were called queens of the stone age they were called gamma ray he was the drummer of Soundgarden now it did say that they re recorded this as it was never released on any album so wither or not it was recorded again with Dave ghrol god knows but its awesome none the less great pic top video have a great day Mr Rooney
@AndrewRooneyDrums that information comenfrom redit I think but on Wikipedia Vic "The Stick" Indrizzo whoever that is was on drums lol they only had 2 tracks according to Wikipedia hula and I'd only everything so god knows who done them drums interesting stuff lol 😆
As a drummer having been Inspired at 10 by Grohls drumming on the song Drain You to start playing and have been following his drumming on everything he plays on, this is Dave’s style 100% he typically plays similarly with most projects he drums on he is known for his power stripped down back n forth snare tom snare tom fills keeping the beat pumping with the constant bass and he’s definitely the king of hard flams don’t really know how else to explain how I see his style. Maybe if everyone interested listens to the song Isabella Grohl played drums on for buzz’s solo ep it might make it clear what I mean.
I prefer the first recording of this song to this version (even though it's way more lofi), at least as far as the first two parts of the song go. This is still awesome though.
This was the version that came out as a B Side too Lullabies to Paralyze. This tries to sound edgier. I like the last part of this, and everything else on the first version of this song, that sounds more chill than this.
There are two different versions with two different drummer, first one as Gamma Ray with Gene Trautman: m.ruclips.net/video/L6ie_8ZDi5A/видео.html&pp=ygUWYm9ybiB0byBodWxhIGdhbW1hIHJheQ%3D%3D This one here is with Alfredo Hernandéz on the drums, he left the band very earlier after they went in the studio for recording Rated R, because of disagreements with Josh! So 2 or 3 songs on the Rated R record are still recorded with Alfredo on the drums and then Gene Trautman taking over!
Ya, I kinda thought youd done Song For The Dead, but I couldnt remember for sure. I didn’t mention the drummer because I couldnt identify who it was, either haha BUT, I agree, it DOES kinda sound Dave Grohlish. The earlier version, the beat was there, but the fill wasnt. Also pretty cool, but not quite as interesting. That version was 1&2&1-2-3-4, where this is more like a 1&2&12345678 count I almost requested on old Carpenters video, so you could do Karen Carpenter’s jazz drumming. She was really good!! Anyway, yes, your assessment was exactly my thought, as well. Knew you would love it! Ps frankly, I often think lo-fi sounds better. :) PPS on some live versions, the middle part speeds up radically over the latter part of that section, then drops back down for the final section.
This band is so underrated. You should be reacting to whole albums by these guys
They were so big, so good, and I absolutely love them….. but I have the same problem … I keep forgetting about them! Lol so weird…
🎯💯
Josh Homme is a musical freaking genius, plain and simple.
I would listen to him play a dead rat and a small gourd.
Agree
I believe the drummer is Gene Trautmann, but on the Rated R sessions they also employed a drummer named Nick Lucero from the group The Flys. They each played on about half the record, and at one point it was even considered having them both play live. There's some promo photos out there. It definitely wasn't Dave, he didn't show up until Songs for the Deaf replacing Gene, but you can still hear him on Go With the Flow and You Think I Ain't Worth Dollar, But I Feel Like A Millionaire.
Wow I'm a huge fan of the first 3 albums (and other early tracks like this one) but I didn't know that stuff about the consideration of having the both drummers play live.
Carlos what’s up homie hope all is well
It's definitely Gene Trautmann.
The Flys drummer played on Rated R?!
Matt Cameron played in the first Gamma Ray ( before they named Queens Of The Stone Age) and played the first shows with his partner in Wellwater Conspiracy, John McBain ( you must to check Wellwater Conspiracy, Psychedelic 60's garage rock ) . Also Alfredo Hernandez played in the first demos .
But you are listening here a rerecording of the song with several changes, like the heavy bass , and I think is Gene Trautman playing here . Remember this is another version of the song , not the original played in 97
One of my favourite current groups. Every drummer who’s played with them is fantastic, although Grohl is one of my favourites. (Especially love his drumming in Them Crooked Vultures.) As a bassist, The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret is one of my favourite tracks to play.
Grohl all time legend
would love to see some QOTSA covers from you!
You'll find 'No One Knows' on my e-kit :)
Great song. Love the lo-fi grit.
YES
Old QOTSA is so good. Homme called it Robot Rock.
Lol that always made me laugh, when he called it that.
@@buzzbomb67 His description was cool. He said it was the sound of a group of robots programed to play music, but you found them after the apocalypse, still playing, but all broken down.
@@BockwinkleB and damn, but those brokedown robots still sounded pretty good lol
This is NOT Dave Grohl playing. It’s Gene Trautmann!
Near as I have been able to find out, it may have been Matt Cameron. The EP lists Vic Indrizzo. On the b-side version, Nick Lucero. But Grohl was hanging around with them from late Kyuss to Songs for the Deaf.
Think it’s lucero 😊
@@craigreid481Who might actually be my favourite QOTSA drummer
according to the world of webs matt Cameron was the drummer on this track wich they recorded before they were called queens of the stone age they were called gamma ray he was the drummer of Soundgarden now it did say that they re recorded this as it was never released on any album so wither or not it was recorded again with Dave ghrol god knows but its awesome none the less great pic top video have a great day Mr Rooney
Matt Cameron!?
No way!
@AndrewRooneyDrums that information comenfrom redit I think but on Wikipedia Vic "The Stick" Indrizzo whoever that is was on drums lol they only had 2 tracks according to Wikipedia hula and I'd only everything so god knows who done them drums interesting stuff lol 😆
This song is a banger.
I dig it!!!
As a drummer having been Inspired at 10 by Grohls drumming on the song Drain You to start playing and have been following his drumming on everything he plays on, this is Dave’s style 100% he typically plays similarly with most projects he drums on he is known for his power stripped down back n forth snare tom snare tom fills keeping the beat pumping with the constant bass and he’s definitely the king of hard flams don’t really know how else to explain how I see his style. Maybe if everyone interested listens to the song Isabella Grohl played drums on for buzz’s solo ep it might make it clear what I mean.
I prefer the first recording of this song to this version (even though it's way more lofi), at least as far as the first two parts of the song go. This is still awesome though.
The cover Josh Homme did was “Let’s Dance”. He does a damn fine David Bowie. ❤
This was the version that came out as a B Side too Lullabies to Paralyze. This tries to sound edgier. I like the last part of this, and everything else on the first version of this song, that sounds more chill than this.
There are two different versions with two different drummer, first one as Gamma Ray with Gene Trautman:
m.ruclips.net/video/L6ie_8ZDi5A/видео.html&pp=ygUWYm9ybiB0byBodWxhIGdhbW1hIHJheQ%3D%3D
This one here is with Alfredo Hernandéz on the drums, he left the band very earlier after they went in the studio for recording Rated R, because of disagreements with Josh!
So 2 or 3 songs on the Rated R record are still recorded with Alfredo on the drums and then Gene Trautman taking over!
sounds like Dave ghrol king of the triplet fill
Same to me
Ya, I kinda thought youd done Song For The Dead, but I couldnt remember for sure.
I didn’t mention the drummer because I couldnt identify who it was, either haha BUT, I agree, it DOES kinda sound Dave Grohlish. The earlier version, the beat was there, but the fill wasnt. Also pretty cool, but not quite as interesting. That version was 1&2&1-2-3-4, where this is more like a 1&2&12345678 count
I almost requested on old Carpenters video, so you could do Karen Carpenter’s jazz drumming. She was really good!!
Anyway, yes, your assessment was exactly my thought, as well. Knew you would love it!
Ps frankly, I often think lo-fi sounds better. :)
PPS on some live versions, the middle part speeds up radically over the latter part of that section, then drops back down for the final section.
You should react to a few of Lord Marco's playthroughs. I highly recommend his playthrough of The Husk by ROS
The face you made when the last part starts is the same one I make every time I hear it too. Filthy is right.
Gene-o is the drummer
Could it be Alfredo Hernandez?
Is not Alfredo
He might have done the original Born to Hula, but by this version he had moved on from the band.
That is signature Dave G.
Has to be!
The last section is the best, that guy is tripping.
Self-titled - S tier
R - S tier
SFTD - A tier
Lullabies - B tier
Era - B tier
Like Clockwork - B tier
Villains - C tier
Times New Roman - D tier