@@jakobmoss6229 lmao I guess the person behind the camera did guide them and say faster now but it's still not entirely the best sound to hear during a performance
4 is almost my worst nightmare come true: people clapping off beat at different times and me messing up but the pianist was VERY talented so they didn’t mess up but I definitely would have lol
The problem is they took all the sound boards off the piano. Upright pianos are better if you just open the top and use the lid holders to keep the piano open. Even the lid is a sound board. The hammers and strings are not to be exposed. An upright piano is not a grand piano. Grands have better sound boars so it's OK to open them but never take the lid off. Use the lid holders on grands as well. This is about how to make the piano sound better not where the pianist come from. Piano and other keyboard instruments require lots of practice it's a common practice to spend at least 4 hours behind the piano or other keyboard instruments. It's hard work And not much time for foolish things like video games and such like. 73
@@akarty8318 I play the piano too. But if I’m playing a folk piece, I would mind people clapping along because that would make it fun. You gotta play with passion.
It looks like the girl closest to the camera is a friend clapping to keep beat, it sounds like the musician makes a request then she speeds up and the musicians follow. I dont speak the language so i have no idea what she said.
I got so triggered on #4 (and #2). DON'T CLAP WHILE SOMEONE IS PLAYING PIANO!!! IT DISTRACTS THE PIANIST!!! They started to speed up the beat so that would make really hard to play. At least she is a really good pianist and didn't mess up.
I didn't hear anyone clapping during his performance, just in the end. Unless clapping just bothers you in general Dude was just playing Waterfall Etude in peace
By recent you mean since more than 100 years ago because modern classical concert etiquette came into being in the mid to late romantic period and has been a tradition of classical concert since then, yes during Mozart's time clapping and talking was expected because performances where usually done in-front of a smaller audience of aristocrats and royalty but ever since classical music in the romantic period became more and more common as more lower class people where able to enjoy concerts(which is not bad in anyway) the expectation became that people kept silent during performance as to not distract the players and allow everyone to hear the music, also a lot of romantic composers such Wagner or Liszt used silence as deliberate musical tools to convey meaning to their pieces and clapping and talking during the performance is just as much of an interruption of the musical idea as going to the stage and taking the musicians instruments, i understand that people want to allow clapping in classical music to make it less intimidating and more mainstream but that would mean sacrificing a large part of the culture and meaning of many pieces of music all types of live performance have their own culture and etiquette and that must be respected.
@@OnyxKuro His was second-best behind Valentina Lisita in terms of technique and musicality, the video only shows the end of the piece. If you look at the pedal right at the beginning, it's pushed down, implying that he just finished playing a previous musical passage. The rest of them are just boring showoffs really...
Lock T Lol his is not very good. Missed notes, tempo, too fast. The one who played chopin etude is probably better, and Valentina is much better. The one who’s played the hungrsrion rhapsody is also pretty skilled.
@@awe331 Yeah. To people who don't know how to play the piano, it's 500 times more impressive than to someone who plays it (or at least to some high level).
Piano teacher: "what piece do you wanna learn first?" Me: "Moonlight Sonata (3rd movement)" Piano teacher: "Y-yeah.. heh... about another piece like your second?" Me: "Toccata in C major Op.7" Piano teacher: "you're not making this easy, kid"
5. Moonlight Sonata 3rd Movement - L.V. Beethoven - 0:00 4. Cubana Cubana - Maksim Mrvica (arr. ???) - 2:47 3. Hungarian Rhapsody No. 12 - Franz Liszt - 5:26 2. Ètude Op. 10, No. 1 (Waterfall) - Frederic Chopin - 8:27 1. Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 - Franz Liszt - 10:15 I don't really agree with this list, but these are the pieces played and the times they start. I do not know number 4 so if anyone knows that please comment it! Thank you :D Edit: Thank you, Hornythorynque (love that username) for commenting number 4! I still do not know who arranged it though.
I'm not sure if number 3 is hungarian rhapsody no.2, I think it's lizsts appasionata - i watched the vid where valentina(the pianist playing it) played it orginally
Tom Taylor it's extremely annoying too and you have to force yourself to seperate your mind from outside noises so it won't mix up their tempo and your tempo.
When I play the piano, I keep by time signature by tapping my foot so numpties who can't clap in time won't put me off. I suspect that is what they do.
Tom Taylor yea but when i do that i cant use the pedal. I mean i guess i can use my left lef to keep my tempo but den i have to focus on keeping both my legs in check which is frankly too much if your playing a difficult song.. Idk maybe im just not good with focusing on so manythings at once
Just wondering... Why are the known piano pieces only from the past? Like how come there aren't any new technically hard masterpieces that are played around the world? I mean there are so many crazy talented pianists..
warmantan studios you are so wrong, yes Asians are very good, but there are others, but I think you are having a shot at Lang Lang, jealousy is a curse!
that's not true because pianos are very expensive in asia and take up a lot of space, more people learn the violin or an instrument that takes up less space.
Number 3 was my favourite. She was IN THE ZONE. Her hands looked possessed by the spirits of great piano artists of times gone by. Such an elegant performance.
yet she still gives us the privilege of being able to listen to her play on the street- and she has her own youtube channel. not only is she virtuoso among the virtuoso, but she is also an amazing person in general!
#4 just shows how timing is same for professional pianists as breathing. She could play on time even if it meant going against the audience clapping. I know I would start playing off actual beat and in beat with the audience at some stage!
He did the recapitulation, reharmonized the 3rd theme a bit (played different inversions), and kinda improvised the cadenza towards the end... all the more impressive if you asked me that he can be flexible with it.
The last of the great composers without a doubt. I don't believe anyone, ever again, will join the ranks of Chopin, Liszt, Beethoven, etc. beside the great Rachmaninoff -- whose company we were graced with until 1943!
I'd say number 2 is harder (Chopin etude op10/1) and more technical than number 1 (Hungarian rhapsody no. 2) although it looks far more difficult it's actually not. Also number 1 should be the valentina listista lizst piece that was written in his youth, can't remember its name, but she championed it as it's far less known than the Hungarian rhapsdoies, but way way harder to play, almost impossible at full tempo, el contrabandista I think it's called.
Hungarian #2 is far harder than the Chopin muscle memory wise because of the wide jumps and 16th chords . The Chopin has the same type of scale the whole way on the right hand.
4, 2 and 1 are all the same places. There is Hongik book store in Shinchon, Korea. In front of that book store, that's where the piano is. Many super cool talented pianists find that place and play piano regularly, mostly at evening time. If you are in Korea and have times, go visit there. You'll see really wonderful performances.
Cristián Betanzo there is also that possibility too. I am just a old fashioned kind of guy if it is played too fast sometimes the rest don’t last as long and it sound off but yeah bro there is always that possibility
keepray oh, cool dude! I played much harder pieces when I was born... I only practised how to play with my feet.. yeah, now I play Chopin with my nose as well! (nice prof btw)
GonzaloLol1 I play with my friend "If I had a chicken" sometimes in school jff and some people clap when they stand next to us and watch us play haha its kinda disturbing but still so funny tho
That last kid on the Hungarian Rhapsody #2 is waaay underrated!! I don't think the spectators have any idea how hard it is to play that and play it right.😮 Wow!!😁👍
Is that Valentina Lisitsa at number 3? Isn't she like a pretty famous pianist? Also, someone get number 1 a metronome. He was on point with those notes but he butchered the tempo.
@@kuuderepiano2988 Exactly, if you are stupid there is nothing you can do about it, just showing off to even more stupid people than you and that's pretty much it.
Nice to see their own interpretation instead of being 100% technical, adds a new personality to the piece. Hardest technical is not always the nicest version of the piece being played. Awesome tinkling players! Love to see the front off the piano too, let's you feel what you are playing, best option for those on an upright.
Great to see and watch Valentina Lisitsa on a street piano - Nr. 3.....! Had the luck to be in three of her concerts in a small Bavarian town past ten years. One of the top musicians - she is just unbelievable.
Trollsey The Third No they are not. They are pianists who train and practice hard daily, probably more than you ever will. Really, just shaking off all their talents like that is a sign of envy and jealousy. I doubt you can do half as good as them.
lol ok. And all of them except for Lisitza have anything worthwhile to show for it. The rest are just rushing through some anime pieces, and butchering Classical pieces they can barely play to please a crowd. They play averagely.
I would argue that Beethovens moonlight sonata 3rd movement isn't actually that technically hard. Yes it's a hard piece but it fits quite nicely for the hand. Atleast for mine it does
Agree with dat, sum pieces have section that has a fast note and length more than an octave like liszt or chopin, especially liszt thrill (example : etude paganini 6 piano arr : liszt)
Well if anything its mainly technical. I guess if you practise less then 30-60 minutes a day your fingers cannot be fast or strong enough for the piece. I understand there are many harder pieces but if you are not a semi-professional this piece is almost unplayable
@@MyAnno1404 I think you are overestimating the piece. It is hard but not so hard that only semi professionals and above can play it. If you have 2 years of dedicated piano practice this piece I pretty do able.
@@op-th1yx Well there are always exceptions to a general statement but i am sure with less then 30 minutes a day of practise you are generelly far away. The piece is rated lvl 7 on henle - this compares to ABRSM (diplom). Which basically means it is considered university Level = professional / semi professional. Sure if you are a young Mozart maybe you are the one who can play it after 2 years but generelly this is not possible. Actuelly even the first movement is much harder (when played correctly) then most people think
@@MyAnno1404 of course there are exceptions. But in general if you are dedicated (practice between 1-3 hours a day with good and beneficial practice) this piece will not be so hard. If you practice 30 minutes a day it will take much more time. And yes the first movement is considered easy by beginners but little did they know that there is a thing called dynamics.
@@rufs6468 Simply piano is only a beginner app. It's actual trash when you try to progress to more harder pieces. I have an actual teacher and although it is expensive to take lessons, it was sooo worth it. She helped me fix everything and taught me tempo, articulation, time signatures, scales etc....and helped me play any pieces i wanted to learn. I have to 100% agree with you, simply piano is such a bad piano tool, you're much better off buying beginner books like alfred's beginner book if you're starting the piano. Never rely on simply piano.
@@fattit7598 I heard that some of the people they hire already play the piano one (heard this from another person some where, who said their friend was a performance pianist)... doesn't really surprise me because I'd be very surprised if anyone made the amount of progress they show in their ads just with the app
I notice a lot of these videos online show people attempting very difficult pieces of music, but they're not playing them flawlessly. I am not complaining. I wouldn't dare attempt any of these songs, I'm so much a newbie. But my ears aren't new. Does anyone else notice the mistakes in these videos of supposedly phenomenal players?
Hungarian rhapsody 2 (1) he makes a few mistakes but its an incredibly difficult piece and he still plays it brilliantly, in Hungarian 12 (3) its executed nearly flawlessly, but she is one of the most famous pianists in the world so
I can't imagine the intensive study, time and work that was put into these performances. When done well, it appears to be easy .. Nothing is further from the truth! :-) Kudos to all!
@@elias7748 this is a group of actual smart piano players. You’re literally the one arguing with an initial comment and you’re saying I’m negative. Just get out, ok? Leave, nobody wants you here.
it's a joke that she's been placed here at number 3, she can upstage Mr no. 1 here easily with her performance of his showy (but ultimately lacking in execution finesse) piece ruclips.net/video/LdH1hSWGFGU/видео.htmlm
bruhh why do people clap when they're playing? ITS A PIECE NOT A ROCK CONCERT omg- why did it really trigger me, like the audience acts like they're so great or something :/
Who even needs a Metronome when you can have Idiots stand in a circle around you clapping sometimes off beat
Lol
Hahahaha am i right
Yeah
I felt the same, I kinda cringed.
I think they thought it was a Polish song.
how psycHOTIC DO YOU HAVE TO BE TO CLAP ALONG A CLASSICAL PIANO PIECE??????????????
Not psychotic. *stUpiD*
Too play that piece you need a metronome (unless you are incredible). Those clappings were the metronome
@@jakobmoss6229 lmao I guess the person behind the camera did guide them and say faster now but it's still not entirely the best sound to hear during a performance
@@jakobmoss6229 what piece is no 4?
@@davidi.w.c2368 i think its toccata in c major, opus 7
If anyone started clapping while I was playing I'd stop immediately
HAHAHAHAHHAAH can you tackle the stress ahhhahhahaha
smack them one by one and say nothing and start playing hardcore yes
then playing in a live setting isn't for you. Stick to playing alone or in a studio.
@@xh0rsex I know, I think that playing in public it's really amazing
nobody would see you playing
4 is almost my worst nightmare come true: people clapping off beat at different times and me messing up but the pianist was VERY talented so they didn’t mess up but I definitely would have lol
Yeah saem
@ֺ when did i reply this
She was playing salsa piece, wasn’t even classical. So what do you expect? The work is half designed for that
The number 4 is pretty similar to an Yngwie Malmsteen song
F this. I gonna improvised this then turned into jazz
That kid actually played full speed hungarian rhapsody on a crappy public piano. That takes some next level confidence and balls lol.
That was for sure faster than full speed
The problem is they took all the sound boards off the piano. Upright pianos are better if you just open the top and use the lid holders to keep the piano open. Even the lid is a sound board. The hammers and strings are not to be exposed. An upright piano is not a grand piano. Grands have better sound boars so it's OK to open them but never take the lid off. Use the lid holders on grands as well.
This is about how to make the piano sound better not where the pianist come from. Piano and other keyboard instruments require lots of practice it's a common practice to spend at least 4 hours behind the piano or other keyboard instruments. It's hard work And not much time for foolish things like video games and such like. 73
Hes asian thats why
Ron B it was a joke
@@yeah2152
that was ludicrous speed
List of Pieces:
0:00 #5: Moonlight Sonata 3rd Movement - Beethoven
2:47 #4: Cubana Cubana - Mrvica
5:26 #3: Hungarian Rhapsody #12 [Allegro Zingarese] - Lizst
8:28 #2: "Waterfall" Etude (Op.10 No.1) - Chopin
10:14 #1: Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 [Friska] - Lizst
Thanks
@@joaquinfigueroa1193 You're welcome. Did you really just reply to an one year old comment? 😂
@@yoboifranny7021 yes i did 😂😂
Yes he did
Yes ,yes we did
I cringed so hard when they started to clap along
EXACTLY
It ruined it for me
True
omg, I know.
I actually skipped past that one, lol
Clapping is a sign of respect.
poor girl, she must have been so distracted with all that clapping.
I don't think so
@@elias7748 I play the piano so I just know that loud clapping would be bad :(
@@akarty8318 I play the piano too. But if I’m playing a folk piece, I would mind people clapping along because that would make it fun. You gotta play with passion.
@@elias7748 they weren't even clapping with the same timing. thats just going to throw u off.
It looks like the girl closest to the camera is a friend clapping to keep beat, it sounds like the musician makes a request then she speeds up and the musicians follow.
I dont speak the language so i have no idea what she said.
#3 is valentina lisitsa and she's a professional pianist, she's half assing the whole thing lmaooo I love her
i KNOW! n so much flair 2. u can tell out of everyone shes having a blast with it!
if you notice one of the piano keys does not work
World class pro.
Zyphrum Zypheny the Ivory’s off a G. A tuner says it’s a pretty good piano a bit out of tune. Her transportation was delayed.
Zyphrum Zypheny Key works, Ivory is off.
I got so triggered on #4 (and #2). DON'T CLAP WHILE SOMEONE IS PLAYING PIANO!!! IT DISTRACTS THE PIANIST!!! They started to speed up the beat so that would make really hard to play. At least she is a really good pianist and didn't mess up.
I didn't hear anyone clapping during his performance, just in the end.
Unless clapping just bothers you in general
Dude was just playing Waterfall Etude in peace
I refer to No. 2
And it gets in the way of the pianist changing tempo.
By recent you mean since more than 100 years ago because modern classical concert etiquette came into being in the mid to late romantic period and has been a tradition of classical concert since then, yes during Mozart's time clapping and talking was expected because performances where usually done in-front of a smaller audience of aristocrats and royalty but ever since classical music in the romantic period became more and more common as more lower class people where able to enjoy concerts(which is not bad in anyway) the expectation became that people kept silent during performance as to not distract the players and allow everyone to hear the music, also a lot of romantic composers such Wagner or Liszt used silence as deliberate musical tools to convey meaning to their pieces and clapping and talking during the performance is just as much of an interruption of the musical idea as going to the stage and taking the musicians instruments, i understand that people want to allow clapping in classical music to make it less intimidating and more mainstream but that would mean sacrificing a large part of the culture and meaning of many pieces of music all types of live performance have their own culture and etiquette and that must be respected.
@@kuuderepiano2988 number 2 technically sound messed up .
Tips: clap in the wrong tempo when a person is playing piano.
Burn.
In.
Hell.
@@Mrncgntu do you know the name og song number 4?
@@absprov thank you very Much 👍
POV: You’re trying to find a comment that doesn’t say it’s so rude to clap along.
Edit: Guys ik its rude it’s a joke lol
It’s bc it can throw you off beat
it's disruptive to the player sometimes because it can really throw the player offbeat and sometimes mess up. That's why you wait till the end to clap
@@EpokDoge 69th like ;)
@@truxng yeah, but most people don't know about that, it's easier to say it instead of getting pissed alone
@@truxng I think it was part of it.
nobody is talking about the tempo of the first person playing moonlight sonata 3rd movement?? It's sooooooo fast.
thats the normal speed of that piece thats why
Ferhat Kambur no its not the piece itself is slower ,the piece here shown is too rushed also he skipped a lot of parts and missed some notes
@@OnyxKuro His was second-best behind Valentina Lisita in terms of technique and musicality, the video only shows the end of the piece. If you look at the pedal right at the beginning, it's pushed down, implying that he just finished playing a previous musical passage. The rest of them are just boring showoffs really...
Lock T
Lol his is not very good. Missed notes, tempo, too fast. The one who played chopin etude is probably better, and Valentina is much better. The one who’s played the hungrsrion rhapsody is also pretty skilled.
@@awe331 Yeah. To people who don't know how to play the piano, it's 500 times more impressive than to someone who plays it (or at least to some high level).
Piano teacher: "what piece do you wanna learn first?"
Me: "Moonlight Sonata (3rd movement)"
Piano teacher: "Y-yeah.. heh... about another piece like your second?"
Me: "Toccata in C major Op.7"
Piano teacher: "you're not making this easy, kid"
@@CLOWREADTECH if Your asian you Can easily start by la Campanella by Lizst or étude no4 (the Torrent) by Chopin
@@ko4la886 Or he just learns the "special version" of Twinkle Twinkle Little Star
@@ko4la886 Or Liszt Transcendental Etude no 4
Just begin with Italian Polka
Or some of Rachmaninoff's works
I really wanna learn flight of the bumblebee
Why are they clapping along with number 4? That's not a clap-along song.
What's song 4's name?
Un-Metaphorical Grapevine, its cubana cubana
thank you.
Cringing like hell XD
Let them clap all they want, that piano wasn't supposed to be there anyhow.
My respect for the girl in 4 place after they started clapping like idiots and she still kept playing so awesome📈📈📈
FR
Stupid people
Aram Moon! #4 in the bunch! A great musician.
All of them
Advertisement companies need to understand that rudely interrupting a video to show their products makes me NEVER want to buy that product.
Lol
So agree
+1!
So true it annoys and frustrates sometimes
Well to be fair it’s not the advertisement companies that put them there it’s the RUclipsr
Without knowing, the people who clapped are being completely roasted by thousands
Lets wait for them to see the comment section
I think it was part of it.
5. Moonlight Sonata 3rd Movement - L.V. Beethoven - 0:00
4. Cubana Cubana - Maksim Mrvica (arr. ???) - 2:47
3. Hungarian Rhapsody No. 12 - Franz Liszt - 5:26
2. Ètude Op. 10, No. 1 (Waterfall) - Frederic Chopin - 8:27
1. Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 - Franz Liszt - 10:15
I don't really agree with this list, but these are the pieces played and the times they start. I do not know number 4 so if anyone knows that please comment it! Thank you :D
Edit: Thank you, Hornythorynque (love that username) for commenting number 4! I still do not know who arranged it though.
Grande
I'm not sure if number 3 is hungarian rhapsody no.2, I think it's lizsts appasionata - i watched the vid where valentina(the pianist playing it) played it orginally
Who is that number 1 pianist? I saw his video a lot and he plays piano really cool
AceOfSpades, Thank you!
AceOfSpades
Hyden
5:35 Imagine you’re just passing by and see Valentina Lisitsa playing piano… normally You have to pay lots of money to listen her. Amazing 🥰
Yeah
was looking for her name, thanks for sharing. 3 was the best! Is she married? 😍
@@alwaysradical1613 yes
@@alwaysradical1613 😂😂😂
Ikr that would be so cool
Why can people not clap in time...
Tom Taylor it's extremely annoying too and you have to force yourself to seperate your mind from outside noises so it won't mix up their tempo and your tempo.
When I play the piano, I keep by time signature by tapping my foot so numpties who can't clap in time won't put me off. I suspect that is what they do.
Tom Taylor yea but when i do that i cant use the pedal. I mean i guess i can use my left lef to keep my tempo but den i have to focus on keeping both my legs in check which is frankly too much if your playing a difficult song.. Idk maybe im just not good with focusing on so manythings at once
AUSTIN LEE yeah that is true. I can't play anywhere near as good as these guys. I practise by using my dominant foot to keep tempo and left to sustain
No sense of rhythm.
5=Moonlight Sonata Mvt.3 4=Maxim Cubana 3=Valentina Lisitsa 2=Chopin etud 10/1 1=Hungarian Rhapsody no.2
Cinnamon Moofan Thanks 👌
Valentina Lisitsa played hungarian rhapsody 12
How is #5 moonlight sonata? That piece is much slower...
bless you delicious cinnamon moofan.
@MarleeSky it's the third movement.
And than a dude came around: Do you know Boogie Woogie?
😂
Or “Do you know Bohemian Rhapsody?”
Dr. K, the Boogie Woogie legend. :)
Is it just me or does that dude and his fake ass videos annoy others aswell?
@@Eskii_NZL No! Not just you! Me too!
Clapping in the middle of performance is really SACRILEGIOUS!!!!!!
my brain hurts when people start clapping :/
sorry for your brain
My cousin is a serial killer whose victims are people who clap when they shouldn't.
Ramon O give him my thanks
Glad I'm not the only one
Yea, like can’t they wait for the piece to end?
With those hand coordination and speed... playing piano should be in Olympics.
Yup, pianist were one of the best... really, there so intelligent also for memorizing complicated pieces
Yea, basically professional musicians are athletes in their own instrument field XD
Noooo, don't clap! It's always the ones who cant keep time too :/
Gets on my nerves
It's like trying to not see ugly people in the street, it's just impossible
@@aitorjara100 Why do you bring your mirror on the streets?
@@tinyisnotugly9146 can you piss off moron
Can't
0:00 5.Moonlight sonata 3rd movement - Beethoven
2:47 4. Cubana Cubana - Maksim mrvica
5:26 3. Hungarian rhapsody no.12 (Allegro Zingarese ) - F. Liszt
8:28 2. F. Chopin - Etude op. 10 no. 1 (Waterfall)
10:14 1. F. Liszt - Hungarian rhapsody no.2 #Friska
Yes thank you
Just wondering... Why are the known piano pieces only from the past? Like how come there aren't any new technically hard masterpieces that are played around the world? I mean there are so many crazy talented pianists..
@@DiamondWhite91 classical Era was different
Nobody stops to watch piano players in Asia because they can play those song already
warmantan studios Thats Racist 😁
it's not
warmantan studios you are so wrong, yes Asians are very good, but there are others, but I think you are having a shot at Lang Lang, jealousy is a curse!
that's not true because pianos are very expensive in asia and take up a lot of space, more people learn the violin or an instrument that takes up less space.
warmantan studios Funny, but true too 😂😂😂😂
Number 3 was my favourite. She was IN THE ZONE. Her hands looked possessed by the spirits of great piano artists of times gone by.
Such an elegant performance.
Number 3 is the concert pianist Valentina Lista if you want to know who she was
Welp, she is Valentina Lisitsa after all lol (a great piano artist herself)
@@derekwang2215 thanks man I wasn't sure if it really was legend herself
@@derekwang2215 What a thrill it must have been to walk by and catch such an accomplished artist as Valentina playing at a public piano.
By the time the camera man gets his gear working, she is already landing on the next airport.
3:07 the clapping makes me wanna cry
It was part of it
@@elias7748 how?
then there is me, playing "happy birthday to you" with one finger.
felt the same thing
And u fail song
😂
That's quite Impressive
Idk but that sounded very depressing for some reason 😭😭
Number 3 is actually a professional pianist lol, she gets paid hundreds of thousands to perform..
yet she still gives us the privilege of being able to listen to her play on the street- and she has her own youtube channel. not only is she virtuoso among the virtuoso, but she is also an amazing person in general!
Rainbow Gaming. so is the second one
raining is just pointing out that she isnt a street artist lol
whats her name?
Neon Cloud Valentina R. she's world famous.
When they started clapping I felt like it’s my teacher telling me to go faster 😂☠️
I cant imagine what face would the composser's make while getting clapped during a masterpiece performance
#4 just shows how timing is same for professional pianists as breathing. She could play on time even if it meant going against the audience clapping. I know I would start playing off actual beat and in beat with the audience at some stage!
For the first one, number 5, I wish people would understand that playing it fast isn't making it more impressive. It sounds rushed and bled together.
I 100% agree, at first I thought he was missing chunks it felt so rushed
old man he actually was missing chunks
Yeah and he completely skipped some parts of it. The original is somewhere around 7 minutes long
He did the recapitulation, reharmonized the 3rd theme a bit (played different inversions), and kinda improvised the cadenza towards the end... all the more impressive if you asked me that he can be flexible with it.
If you can play it slowly, you can play it quickly •_•
#1 Someone bought him a drink we’re not gonna talk about that token of gratitude? Because I think that’s pretty awesome
I cringed pretty hard when the drink was put ON the piano tho...
it looks like the same guy from #2
Waiting for accident to happen :( not a good idea put drink to piano.
what song is number 1
@@keboi1553 moonlight sonata 3rd movement
*Rachmaninoff enters the group*
*Rach* : Why isn't anyone playing my pieces?
The last of the great composers without a doubt. I don't believe anyone, ever again, will join the ranks of Chopin, Liszt, Beethoven, etc. beside the great Rachmaninoff -- whose company we were graced with until 1943!
Because it’s even harder hahahha. he is the best 🥰🥰🥰ohh my favorite composer
@@karilam1663 Lizst is way harder than Rachmaninoff
Oof
Because my hands are small, not everything small though, sir
I love how passionate #2 is, he puts everything in that piece, wow
I'd say number 2 is harder (Chopin etude op10/1) and more technical than number 1 (Hungarian rhapsody no. 2) although it looks far more difficult it's actually not. Also number 1 should be the valentina listista lizst piece that was written in his youth, can't remember its name, but she championed it as it's far less known than the Hungarian rhapsdoies, but way way harder to play, almost impossible at full tempo, el contrabandista I think it's called.
Mark Fowler I completely agree lol
Mark Fowler do you know what number four was called? Sounds really interesting.
Do you mean "El Contrabandista"?
Hungarian #2 is far harder than the Chopin muscle memory wise because of the wide jumps and 16th chords . The Chopin has the same type of scale the whole way on the right hand.
It's Hungarian rhapsody no12
4, 2 and 1 are all the same places.
There is Hongik book store in Shinchon, Korea. In front of that book store, that's where the piano is.
Many super cool talented pianists find that place and play piano regularly, mostly at evening time.
If you are in Korea and have times, go visit there. You'll see really wonderful performances.
Any clues as to the pianist in #4? I clicked since she looked familiar.
the only major problem with clapping is if the piece has ritardandos or accelerandos
or if the audience sucks at keeping time...
Rin Kokonoe clapping during a performance is just annoying. Nothing more than that
Tomato トマト間トマト i mean yea, but it can br kinda fun sometimes. But i see what you mean
Rin Kokonoe it's ok if it's like a jam session. Not in a classical performance:/
Tomato トマト間トマト yea yea definitely.
The first guy playing Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata is going at a faster tempo I am guessing he was nervous.
Man I Wish that was A problem I have!
theo stenmark it’s not necessarily a good thing because u tend to rush more and make more mistakes if you play at a faster tempo out of nervousness.
Or maybe he like to play the song at that speed because he is too good. That's my opinion :)
Cristián Betanzo there is also that possibility too. I am just a old fashioned kind of guy if it is played too fast sometimes the rest don’t last as long and it sound off but yeah bro there is always that possibility
Yeah it was kinda messy tbh
Gosh, stop clapping!🙄
*second vid
Ibnu Alfandy Yusuf gosh then stop watching
@@archasion761 he has.
I think the same
Stop clapping their fucking idiot hands
Oh thank you, I can't see the video
Its SO annoying when people clap when i play!
was playing fantaisie improptu... ppl started clapping... the heck? :|
George Kaps Man how do you all do that :(
HardeBaas practise 😂
George Kaps No I was born and played it instantly
keepray oh, cool dude! I played much harder pieces when I was born... I only practised how to play with my feet.. yeah, now I play Chopin with my nose as well! (nice prof btw)
Love the 3rd movement of the moonlight sonata! And Valentina makes the impossible look so easy, even with cold hands!
Cold hands?
@@soloparaplaystation6624 yeah, she literally blew on her hand
People: start clapping
Me: *"THIS IS NOT SOME ROCK CONCERT!"*
Why they clap WHY
I don't fucking understand
they also dont understand, but it could be a motivating thing to some people
GonzaloLol1 they just all bloody nora
krnstrong true but they don't need your encouragement your just fucking up the song
GonzaloLol1 I play with my friend "If I had a chicken" sometimes in school jff and some people clap when they stand next to us and watch us play haha its kinda disturbing but still so funny tho
I agree, just here to say: use this ones(¡!) please
10:15/Liszt wants to know your location
I think he was too fast, I couldn't understand the measure
Itachi Milgr4u i wish playing too fast was my problem...
@@HIEkki I've listened to this piece quite a lot, before, and I noticed that he skipped a few parts.
@@cowzilla8 No he just startet at Friska.
La Campanella walks up: “hold my beer”
Le preux walks up: "hold mine"
@@nonen4733 ha
Rondo fantastique: "Hold my bottle"
Hungarian rhapsody 2 doesn’t have conpa ration
@@lanye2708 or feux follets/chasse neige
10:40
Number 2 gives a drink to num 1
XD
Very underrated comment
Nobody:
Rousseau:
Yessss!
Are you plugging my dads channel?
Christin Alcantar lmao what
Valentina is better then Rousseau. Much much better
성오 which Valentina?
That last kid on the Hungarian Rhapsody #2 is waaay underrated!! I don't think the spectators have any idea how hard it is to play that and play it right.😮 Wow!!😁👍
#3 is Valentina... Professional pianist, she's amazing 😍
The teacher: *"Okay class we have a new easy test tmr."*
The tests:
Is that Valentina Lisitsa at number 3? Isn't she like a pretty famous pianist?
Also, someone get number 1 a metronome. He was on point with those notes but he butchered the tempo.
InfinityBeard The tempo is supposed to change
Yes! I was also wondering. Her hand movement gave her away
@@zkepes2679 her blonde hair, posture and smile gave her away
Yes she is 😊
@@kuuderepiano2988 Exactly, if you are stupid there is nothing you can do about it, just showing off to even more stupid people than you and that's pretty much it.
Boys!! How are these god damn street pianos so in tune!!
For a street piano they really are good in tune but not for new ones
4 : She is amazing without being distracted with the claps. Absolutely Brilliant 💯
Nice to see their own interpretation instead of being 100% technical, adds a new personality to the piece. Hardest technical is not always the nicest version of the piece being played. Awesome tinkling players! Love to see the front off the piano too, let's you feel what you are playing, best option for those on an upright.
I love how some gave the guy a drink at number one.
Great to see and watch Valentina Lisitsa on a street piano - Nr. 3.....! Had the luck to be in three of her concerts in a small Bavarian town past ten years. One of the top musicians - she is just unbelievable.
My goodness, how great these pieces are and the precise way they are played!
the 3rd is so elegant, her hands are dancing along the notes as if she was dancing to a symphony it's truly, beautiful; marvellous even.
she is pro pianist tho
10:31 Somebody buys the last pianist coffee and puts it on his piano.... :O
So nice, but if it spilled...... ._.
Loli Rancher coffee for a kid? 🤔
Light PixelGamer wdym that guy is 16+ lol
@@archasion761 Wtf? I started drinking cofee with 14.
@@Felix-th8yx 14? I started drinking coffee when I was like 5..
@@erike4898 Where are u from? (Country) In Germany its pretty normal to start drinking coffee with 15.
sometimes I like to pretend it's me playing the piano when I watch videos like this because I can't even play all of Fur Elise without failing.
Ashlee Fleming haha
Not sometimes it is always
With variations?
Ashlee Fleming keep practicing scales it helps a lot trust me and try to sight read if at that level
AAAAWWWWW!!!!!!!!!! VERY SAD!!!!!!!
8:28 this is absoluetly incredible. he plays so clean
clapping. Why. What goes through your head to start CLAPPING-
All these player are Great! but #3 She is a genius. Her subtle movements and touch are what separates her from the rest. watch closely.
Nik
She is the concert pianist
amongst them.
She is the famous pianist, everyone else in this video is some Schoolboy Pianist wannabe who took classes 20 years ago
Yes, she is one of the best concert pianists. Her name is Valentina Lisitsa.
Trollsey The Third No they are not. They are pianists who train and practice hard daily, probably more than you ever will. Really, just shaking off all their talents like that is a sign of envy and jealousy. I doubt you can do half as good as them.
lol ok. And all of them except for Lisitza have anything worthwhile to show for it. The rest are just rushing through some anime pieces, and butchering Classical pieces they can barely play to please a crowd. They play averagely.
I would argue that Beethovens moonlight sonata 3rd movement isn't actually that technically hard. Yes it's a hard piece but it fits quite nicely for the hand. Atleast for mine it does
Agree with dat, sum pieces have section that has a fast note and length more than an octave like liszt or chopin, especially liszt thrill (example : etude paganini 6 piano arr : liszt)
Well if anything its mainly technical. I guess if you practise less then 30-60 minutes a day your fingers cannot be fast or strong enough for the piece. I understand there are many harder pieces but if you are not a semi-professional this piece is almost unplayable
@@MyAnno1404 I think you are overestimating the piece. It is hard but not so hard that only semi professionals and above can play it. If you have 2 years of dedicated piano practice this piece I pretty do able.
@@op-th1yx Well there are always exceptions to a general statement but i am sure with less then 30 minutes a day of practise you are generelly far away. The piece is rated lvl 7 on henle - this compares to ABRSM (diplom). Which basically means it is considered university Level = professional / semi professional. Sure if you are a young Mozart maybe you are the one who can play it after 2 years but generelly this is not possible. Actuelly even the first movement is much harder (when played correctly) then most people think
@@MyAnno1404 of course there are exceptions. But in general if you are dedicated (practice between 1-3 hours a day with good and beneficial practice) this piece will not be so hard. If you practice 30 minutes a day it will take much more time. And yes the first movement is considered easy by beginners but little did they know that there is a thing called dynamics.
*Me watching this*
Me: "I wish I can play piano"
*Ad pops up about simply piano*
........
Me: Wow gee thanks😶
###### UnknownCaller2444 *me looking at this comment*
Me:You can
Now to find a piano😂
If you want to learn don't use simply piano by itself, you really do need an actual teacher
@@rufs6468 Simply piano is only a beginner app. It's actual trash when you try to progress to more harder pieces. I have an actual teacher and although it is expensive to take lessons, it was sooo worth it. She helped me fix everything and taught me tempo, articulation, time signatures, scales etc....and helped me play any pieces i wanted to learn. I have to 100% agree with you, simply piano is such a bad piano tool, you're much better off buying beginner books like alfred's beginner book if you're starting the piano. Never rely on simply piano.
@@fattit7598 I heard that some of the people they hire already play the piano one (heard this from another person some where, who said their friend was a performance pianist)... doesn't really surprise me because I'd be very surprised if anyone made the amount of progress they show in their ads just with the app
The 8 year old boy who's turn is next: "I don't feel like playing anymore"
I can clearly see jerry hitting those strings at no. 1...
Same!
Right? I had that episode on VHS. Funny to hear this song after all of these years :D
I would have stopped playing and yelled at them to stOp CLAPPING
and then you watch them all walk away saying how rude
God who cares ? its your play anyways.
God if you tell them to stop clapping, you're not rude. It's actually the people that clapped are rude
Audrey M me too 😂
You don't sound like a pianist. Clapping indicates a connection with the audience. ie: the entire point of music performance.
5 ways to play this song:
1. Beginner
2. Intermediate
3. Hard
4. Impossible
5. Asian
ButterDatCorn asian???
Well as far as I know, the current best and most famous piano players aren't asian.
ButterDatCorn Asian....😂
Asian or not, I know what those fingers are good at 😬
ButterDatCorn wait, I think I can guess it, playing piano?
That clap actually hurts my ears I'm done with the internet today
I notice a lot of these videos online show people attempting very difficult pieces of music, but they're not playing them flawlessly. I am not complaining. I wouldn't dare attempt any of these songs, I'm so much a newbie. But my ears aren't new. Does anyone else notice the mistakes in these videos of supposedly phenomenal players?
You watch too much tv. They are human and this is off the cuff.
Hungarian rhapsody 2 (1) he makes a few mistakes but its an incredibly difficult piece and he still plays it brilliantly, in Hungarian 12 (3) its executed nearly flawlessly, but she is one of the most famous pianists in the world so
The ones in this video were all great except for #1 he played it far too fast :(
I can't imagine the intensive study, time and work that was put into these performances. When done well, it appears to be easy .. Nothing is further from the truth! :-) Kudos to all!
10:26 What's going through her mind as she stares at those fast fingers
………
💦
Whoever claps during the performance, I give my sincere F to you.
These were street performances. Not a concert. So be quiet.
@@elias7748 this is a comment section. Not a stupidity section. So be quiet.
@@bobross7626 What about you be quiet because your comment was nothing but negativity because I was right.
@Annabelle Phen Lee Oh please be quiet. Everybody taking this so seriously. What is? A comment section full of introverted 16 years old?
@@elias7748 this is a group of actual smart piano players. You’re literally the one arguing with an initial comment and you’re saying I’m negative. Just get out, ok? Leave, nobody wants you here.
The guy that left the drink for him in the end.
Hats off to that guy :)
i was looking for this comment haha yeah that was very nice
Such a pure soul♥️
02:55 their hands are very scary, they seem terrifying.
U must play in right positions if u dont want ur hands to fall of
Goddammit. Should have kept going with my piano lessons.
5:27 Valentina Lisitsa playing street piano and some people around dont even know they just have once in a life moment right there right now...
Yeah true.
Realmente. Hay gente que desea toda su vida poder ver (pagando) a Valentina y ella toca gratis para gente que ni la conoce. Una Grande !!
Yaas..I'd be damn Soo lucky
6:05 it's Valentina Lisitsa!
Do you happen to know what she played?
@@ARosas that’s Liszt Hungarian Rhapsody #12
I like how three of these are played on the exact same piano in Sinchon lol
HOLD THE PHONE was that Valentina lisitza playing Hungarian rhapsody no 12?
unless she has a twin sister, yes. :)
it's a joke that she's been placed here at number 3, she can upstage Mr no. 1 here easily with her performance of his showy (but ultimately lacking in execution finesse) piece ruclips.net/video/LdH1hSWGFGU/видео.htmlm
bruhh why do people clap when they're playing? ITS A PIECE NOT A ROCK CONCERT
omg- why did it really trigger me, like the audience acts like they're so great or something :/
I like ur pfp uwu
Clapping aside, number 3 was so incredibly beautiful
In vid #1 when the guy put the drink down made me go 🥺❤️
OMG NO DONT CLAP IT THROWS THE PERSON OFF TEMPO-
Valentina makes it look so effortless.
#1 - Tom did it better. And he had a mouse distracting him.
And with only 4 fingers per hand!
And no thumbs
and with his feet!
OMG XD
We all thought that way
Aram Moon, the fabulous South Korean pianist deserves to perform in the main European and American States.
8:43
Lol look at the couple at the back
The lady is like: omg i wish you were this good
YOU SHOULD LIST WHO IS THESE PLAYING ARTIST SO WE CAN VISIT THEIR CHANNEL ALSO
top 3 is Valentina lisitsa
Yeah u should liszt them up (hahaha never been done before ever i hate my life )
What was Valentina lisitsa’ piece that she was playing called
Owais The BIG chungus Hungarian Rhapsody No . 12
MarauderLP I thought it was but I didn’t recognise it because they cut out the start
note on fridge ----, "Can't Handel Chopin Liszt now, am Debussy at the mall, Bach in a Minuet"
It feels so good seeing a song I can play on these types of videos. It’s like I’ve finally made it.
Which one? Waterfall?
@@mikaschmidt2110 , no, moonlight sonatas third movement.
@@prometheuspalpatine9718cool beeeaaans my guy
At 3:21someone said it in Chinese to tell everybody to start clapping.😭😭 bro I’m so done so with those people.
When I see those little hammers hitting the piano cords it seems to me that the pianists have more than 10 fingers on each hand.