It's the work of the KGB. Putin is laughing himself hoarse watching America tear itself apart over people wanting to twiddle with their sex organs and demonstrating in favour of Islamo-fascists who would kill most Americans as soon as they could. Putin didn't even have to fire a shot. His birthday present from the KGB and Iran, the Hamas attack on Oct.7th has lit the fuse, and knocked his murderous war in Ukraine out of the news cycle. People who are anti-Israel are his useful idiots.
American Jewry has to learn to vote Right so that the Left doesn’t take American Jewry for granted. Correct diagnosis: Students at American universities are being taught WHAT to think, instead of being taught HOW to think.
@@tb8865or Westerners supporting hamas is peak irony. Zionism is the belief in the existence of Israel. Obviously you do not believe Israel should exist.
@@evamurray2564 I don't care one way or the other. But the Jewish religion and Zionist worldview is hostile to Christianity, as hostile as the Muslim worldview is to Feminism, LGBTQ, etc. Christians think Jesus is God, and Jews think Jesus is burning in Hell.
More like definition of pure stupidity. He gives these people too much credit. They have no world knowledge but from TikTok and Instagram. The parents and schools are THE problem.
@@evamurray2564 exept that isreal is an ethno state that only believes non jews exists to serve or die. non jews zionists are bigger irony than queers and feminist for palestine and since all christians and muslims based their belief on the old testament and the christ...ouf.
There's a term you learn fighting against honest-to-Marx communists, like the ones we (somehow still) have here in the Philippines: Counter-revolutionary, This is probably the worst thing a communist can call someone. This is THE capital crime for them. Not only are you against the ideas and ideals of whatever flavor of communism the ones you challenge espouse, you are ACTIVELY working against it. Often, this means you're on a list for the kind of punishment gets meted out for capital crimes. I've always regarded modern-day American progressivism as the heirs of Robespierre and the Reign of Terror. Those guys were the original "Woke": you don't agree with the ideals of the French Revolution as defined by the Committee on Public Safety? OFF WITH YOUR HEAD. But I also see echoes of this communist thinking that anything against the purity of the Party's thought - the so-called "party line" - is anathema with your so-called "progressives", America. That lack of compromise. That insistence that they and only they have the right position. And if you were to even suggest that maybe they're the least bit wrong, well... off with your head. Digital or otherwise. It's just sad to see so many supposedly smart kids in your universities act not so very smart due to their indoctrination. Or, even worse, as Bill Maher put it recently, "the revolution is here for me." Then again, I also see echoes of how the National Democratic Front, the more-or-less "above ground" branch of the Communist Party of the Philippines, does its recruiting in our colleges and universities. Young people can't help but be idealistic. And the terminologies used to radicalize your uni students - whether for questions of gender, culture, the Arab-Israeli conflict, etc. - were designed to have such an effect. nothing triggers the young idealist's NEED to think they're changing the world for the better than the words used by the radical Left of America. There are probably real commissars and troopers in those ranks, but I fear a good chunk of your students have been recruited to causes they know only one side of. Typical. Took us a long time to even blunt the NDF's radicalization of our campuses. I don't even know if we've regressed now, given some of the things I've heard. But for the sake of the American Center, and maybe your... sensible Left, too, I hope you get a grip on your radical children. They don't know they're actually recruiting for your "Alt Right" :D
Waw this is by far the most honest talk i have heard on youtube . This is a common mans thoughts . I can relate absolutley with what mr gil troy is saying. Thank you .❤
Dear America the world is watching so are your enemies... please note: if America falls the world fails. Your existance as nation represents the very best of Western Civilisation and greatest culture known to all mankind. You went to war with eachother over idea of end of slavery and betterment that all man are equal. By your sacrifice on the altar of freedom you saved whole world in your fight aginst evil nations of WW2 who wanted to exterminate or inslave other nations, and by doing so rebuilding a shatterd world to live again... during the Cold-war you stretched out your wings as the undisputed superpower protecting the free world from communism. 50 yrs later you are know by your flag as gracious precious people who treasure their founding values that revealed America's uniqueness and resilience in leadership. As of now the world is witnessing America being in decline from within.... could it be the Lighthouse on the Hill has now run its course in time and that your beautiful flag is slaggering down from the winds within? O America you are magnificent miracle of Judea-Christian Western Civilisation at work a continue refinment 2000 yrs civilisation made right. I humbly pray before Almighty God, that the United States of America will continue to be the guardian of Freedom over Slavery.
@@captainhaddock6435 You are free to say that now... only because of the millions who sacrifice everything to what you take for granted. Looking back we are lucky to live in civilisation where we can look back and compare previous civilisation before us, knowing we have is a lot better.
A great book about this is *"war of all the people"* Its a must read from the 2010s, it shows all the ties between palestine, nazis, leftist movements, mexican cartels etc. Gives you a HUGE look into the reality of anti-west collaboration and subversion
No. It's not. The protests come from the conscientious world seeing footage of starvation, mutilation, torment, destruction, bombing, sniping, sadistic cruelty, and mass murder of civilians. Doesn't America stand for the law, for human rights, for protection of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness FOR ALL??
If they were, they would protest against the atrocities committed on October 7th. What you have written, has very little to do with reality or objective understanding of the roots of the conflict.
@@xtrajently The world did stand with Israel after Oct 7. Unfotunately.they became horrified that rather than uphold law, human rights, mercy, charity, respect for life that terrorists lack, USA and Israel returned the same lawlessness, brutality, sadistic nature, and bloodlust as terrorists, but on a massive scale. That makes them terrorists as well. You cant judge what you, yourselves, are indulging in. They lost all moral authority because of this. The Hague is waiting.
@@xtrajently What are the roots?? How did the people of Gaza end up there? The Nakba. In 1948 Gr Britain armed European immigrants to descend on Palestinian communities, with colonialist greed, to murder the native people, steal their belongings, homes, and land, force the survivors into barbed wired camps, then into the walled ghetto of Gaza. Israel then controlled, oppressed the people, and purposefully deprived the ghetto of basic needs until the UN had to intervene for Gazan survival. Not to mention the systematic "mowing the lawn" bombings and attacks against civilians for decades. Not to mention, the unjust imprisonment of children. Not to mention, apartheid, abuse, and illegal settlements. Not to mention, Netanyahu funding and empowering Hamas to control and prevent progress, there. All of these are massive war crimes. If done against any Western nation would be justified for legal resistance, even violent resistance, against Israeli oppression and onslaught. There's no justification. They are genetically the descendants of the ancient Hebrew people that never left the land. Their nation, land, and homes were stolen by entitled European immigrants.
@xtrajently I'm sorry, but whoever moderates this page removed my reply. The world was with Israel after Oct 7. Then we were horrified to see it return the same lawlessness, lack of empathy, brutality, and bloodlust as any terrorist organization. Israel lost its moral authority this way. USA, too. All who do such things are evil. You can not judge if you indulge in the same crimes.
How patriotic of you to shun accountability and vote for the guy who has repeatedly on record said he will overthrow democracy to become a dictator. Part and parcel what the constitution says and what our forefathers died for. You really are a smart one.
@@raftguy1376 Cry more. He had four years to supposedly "destroy democracy" and here we are talking about voting again. I only see one side right now that isn't interested in preserving our Constitutional Republic. It's the side that just gave up on even pretending to hold a presidential primary this cycle to replace the vegetable-in-chief.
What is seldom discussed is what the definitions of these terms of bigotry have become. We can all agree: racism = bad, so should be removed. But what is racism? It used to be treating people badly based on skin color, which is a simple and easy to grasp definition. But now, it's pretty much every action any white person takes, and that's not my belief that's what's written by so-called thinkers such as Ibram X Kendi and Robin D'Angelo. Racism is also anything where all races are not represented (unless it's a low status job or 100% minorities). So math, the most scientifically pure subject, has become racist, why? because certain groups don't perform as well on math tests. How exactly is it racist? That doesn't matter, the math tests don't get the results needed, so it MUST be racist. A government that has mostly white people is racist, but even if a government has mostly black people in it is STILL racist. Baltimore, a city entirely run by African American leaders, is racist because the government itself was started by white people (Breakfast Club Podcast). Naturally if a company has no white people, it's NOT racist, because apparently it's impossible to be racist towards white people. This is the problem I have today with people who say they "hate bigotry"...okay, which bigotry do you mean and how are you defining it? Because I am truly not sure anymore.
If racism is bad, then borders are unjust. Africa will then not stay in Africa. Europe will become Africa. America, Africa. India, Africa. Since racism is bad, civilization must die. Unless...
57:21 Yess what informative, a teacher that can teach. I never asked this question and never thought about it, and it occurs Al Ja zera and many many other news and documentary outlets always seem to fail to address this fact, that Jordan Neither Egypt had any right to those areas they took, when Gaza was Egyptian, and Jerusalem was completely Islamized and many archelogical artifacts from the temple was demolished and removed forever. And these 2 actions has to this day caused immensely harm to any sort of stability and peace for the Israelis today.
Being pro-Palestine has nothing to do with anything else but being human and caring about ending the mass slaughter and horrifying, torturous, inhumane treatment and abuse of a group of people who are part of our human family.
This tells me that you haven't heard both sides of the story and don't want to even try to listen. I find it very strange that you so readily believe that one sided narrative, yet don't seem to believe the stated aim of the people you are championing, which is a promise to annihilate all Jews, and after them everybody else who refuses to commit to Islam. Is that what you want for your future? And why do you only believe a part of what they're telling you but not all of it?
Being pro-palestinian and putting pressure on your government results in pressure being put on Israel, which is fighting for survival, and merely serves to prolong the war and the suffering of the "Palestinians" you espouse.
There is no "human family." There are nations, races, tribes. In Palestine, one tribe (the one you find sympathetic) explicitly seeks the annihilation of another. They've chosen to play the hard game, the fight the death. Why? Because they have faith in their God, something Leftists in the West cannot even comprehend.
Which history are you referring to? And whose version of the Arab-Israeli conflict tickles your fancy? Don’t be averse to impartial observations by distinguished scholars on the persisting vaunted ambition of violent extremists that are bent on destroying Israel.
@@Ohanwedike from what the world has been witnessing so far it's Gaza that's being annihilated. Or are you trying to suggest that Israelis should have greater right to a state than the Palestinians? In which case you consider Palestinians to have less worth as a people than the Israelis?
@@miraladak2314 I don't he is saying Palestinians have less worth as a people or right to have a state, just that they have been way more bent on destroying Israel or denying its existence than actually going about the business of creating a state of their own. Its sad, but unfortunately true.
There is no right side of history. This is an idiotic invention of communists, like Marx and Lenin, who thought they were on the right side. Well, Lenin's project failed, after killing tens of millions. The irony is that this concept of a right side of history is purely religious and derives from the Abrahamic religions in particular. Communism is a political religion, the most evil yet invented.
@@miraladak2314 There are no such thing as Palestinians anymore. Palestine was Arabs+Jews. That state doesn't exist anymore. Arabs got whole Jordan and now you are crying they can't have more? Oh, please!
Unfortunately, for the last 50 years, anyone in gov't, education, any administration position or media has to have passed several 'humanities' courses. Too pass these courses you have to agree with post modern philosophy, whose main tenant is 'there is only my/your truth' and no The Truth.
@@lesweizman388 lol. My ilk?? You mean like the US Department of Justice?? CRM 1-499 19. Genocide (18 U.S.C. 1091) Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code, prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war. Genocide is defined in § 1091 and includes violent attacks with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. Or (in case you're not American) how about the UN? According to the Convention, genocide is a crime that can take place both in time of war as well as in time of peace. The definition contained in Article II of the Convention describes genocide as a crime committed with the intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part. And btw, Israel is a signatory of that. If that is my "ilk", great!!!
@@lesweizman388 Lol, By my "ilk" do you mean those who accept the US definition of Genocide?? 19. Genocide (18 U.S.C. 1091) Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code, prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war. Genocide is defined in § 1091 and includes violent attacks with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. Or if you're not American, how about the UN definition?? According to the Convention, genocide is a crime that can take place both in time of war as well as in time of peace. The definition contained in Article II of the Convention describes genocide as a crime committed with the intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part. Or by my "ilk" do you mean those of us who know our power hungry deep state will do anything to stay in power and continue the Forever Wars. You know, so that Nancy Pelosi and others in Congress get rich off the profits?? Gotta be more specific about "ilk". BTW - President Eisenhower warned of the military industrial complex. Was he my "ilk" too??
The definition is fine. It is simply that Israel and America are hypocritical. They are in the mindset that Rules are for thee, not for me. Plus AIPAC and Israel rule the US, so we taxpayers get to pay tribute to them. They get universal Healthcare, low cost tuition and the cheapest cell phone plans I'm the world. While too many of our vets are homeless and our schools are trash. But continue to buy the govt narrative bruh.
Anybody with a shred of empathy is distressed about the terrible injustices done to the Palestinians over the last 75 years. To campaign for Palestinian rights is to campaign for justice. The only way it’s Anti American is in that it’s anti the America that’s sides with tyrants, corporate exploiters and the American Military Industrial complex. The only good thing about the Gaza situation is that it’s caused people to look deeply at the root causes and discover the insidious Israeli influence that’s thoroughly infected American politics. It’s also shone light on the, really, hysterical tone of this kind of utterly bogus claim.
I agree that young people think they live in a profoundly racist society today, but don't have any idea what historical racism was really like. But I feel that contemporary Jewish commentators overuse the word 'antisemitism' and tend to deny anyone the right to criticise Israel in a tone of passionate amateurish activism - or to criticise Israel at all, especially rejecting or diminishing cherished foundational myths of Israel. In believing that anyone who challenges their core historical beliefs must be motivated by a sinister sickness called 'antisemitism' they are no more rational than the identitarians who attribute current social outcomes as proof of a dark hidden evil in white people called 'racism'. BOTH groups need to chill. Terms like antisemitism and racism have descriptive usefulness and long history but have referenced quite different issues in different places and times. What they have never been are mysterious forces - as if like evil spirits that inhabit and poison human souls. This is not the dark ages.
Professor Troy should go to Hebron or East Jerusalem. The settlers and IDF are disgusting in their racism. In addition, he should actually read something about the Civil Rights Movement. He is projecting a LOT about Islam and Iran.
A professor should never be enthusiastic about a students work unless they are showing the ability to argue effectively against their own deeply held beliefs.
I think being critical of Islam would be more peaceful than being critical of individuals. . . An idea or a philosophy can be dissected and debated. But peoples actions are fundamentally visceral in nature
It's no surprise when this America isn't what it actually pretends to be. We call ourselves "free and democratic" when our government is run by the donor class
30:45 This is very important. The ideologically captured (ie “woke”) have the same vocabulary, but use a different dictionary than the rest of us. The far-left nowadays is dominated by “queer marxism” and an easy rule of thumb is that most of their buzzwords like colonialism, racism, -phobia, patriarchy, etc can be roughly translated to “capitalism”.
There is a real propagandism in school curriculum: in some ELA curricula, every literary analysis comes down to the binary narrative, the powerful vs the powerless.
When tey came for the Gipsys I didn't saqy anything - I was not a Gipsy...! When they came for the Communists, I didn't say anything - I was nut a Communist...! When they came for the Disabled, I didn't say anything - I was not disabled...! When they came for the Jews, I didn't say anything - I was not a jew...! When they came for Me... There was No One left to say ANYTHING...!!!
"If they're Black, then it's a gang. If they're Italian, it's a mob, but if they're Jewish, it's a coincidence and should never speak about it" Dave Chappelle.
Dave is a talented guy but his comedy sometimes is just wrong and not helpful. He is a Muslim and antisemitism is in fact pervasive throughout the Islamic world on a scale much larger than Nazi Germany - a coincidence we shouldn’t ever speak about ?
✡✝☪FIGHT ANTISEMITISM!! Let the people of all faiths (Atheists welcome too!) unite to stop the ANTI-SEMITIC HOLOCAUST of the courageous people of GAZA. Thank you! ✡✝☪
50:01 Talking about false narratives, I still throughout have immensely hard time to understand how any College or University professor can talk about Palestine, Palestinians as a real thing, as it seems to be arabs who reinvented their cause of killing all the Jews of Israel in the 60´s Palestine and Palestinians as a nation, state or a people never existed before. They were Islamic Arabs living Israel, who under the Nakbar where they due to unsucsessfully in conduction of a Genocide against the new Jewish state fled home to Jordan, which was ruled by a minority of a Beduin tripe who had made a special deal with the British. So how can terrorism and unjust violence against innocent children and elderly indiscriminately legitimate a change in history and a sudden upspring in the history books of a Palestinian people with rights to move from Jordan to different settlements in Israel. .? To me it is crazy wrong, also from a Jewish (secular) professor.
TURN TO ALAHIM YAHUAH YAHUSHA AND RUACH HA QODESH FOR THE WELFARE OF YOUR SOUL. YOU OUGHT TO CONSIDER TURNING TO THE MOST HIGH. DOING PRAYER. BECAUSE AFTER ALL MANY PEOPLE UNDERSTAND DO PRAYER. PRAYER CHANGES THINGS. & PRAYER WILL.HELP YOU TO RECEIVE THE THINGS YOU NEED TO BE HAPPY IN YOUR LIFE.
The activities of the radical fringe of the pro Palestinian protests have been a gift to the “Israel is always right” wing of American opinion that has existed for decades. I have been unsurprised by the horrors being inflicted on the Palestinian people by Israel, this is after decades of dehumanising Palestinians by Israel. I’ve followed this issue for 50 years and read the Israeli press, I know that many Israelis themselves disagree with Israeli govt policy. What was once the extreme right is now the mainstream of Israeli politics so people can self righteously declare that opposing Israeli slaughter is being “pro-Hamas” but this is pure spin and avoids the central real issue of Israel’s brutality and cynical manipulation of the “peace process” to take more land.
That fringe is so small, pro-Israel groups are asking for volunteers to shout antisemitic things at these protests. Most people do NOT see that criticizing Israel or finally wanting the promised state for Palestinians are antisemitic, and rightfully so. Israel, AIPAC, the ADL, and this professor all want us to believe the opposite, even to the point of lying about the word "Intifada." He is lying or ignorant about why the Second Intifada occurred. The Palestinians demilitarized, they were willing to compromise, and then...Israel didn't move forward with their own promises. They continued to build settlements. They continued to steal land. The IDF were still brutal, reactionary, and viciously racist. The settlers were more and more violent. More checkpoints were put in place despite the fact that Palestinians had given up their firearms.
Israel has never offered the Palestinians a state. The best deal Israel has offered creates an entity with less control over its affairs than the average US city council, or native reservation. It would turn all Palestinian areas into miniature Gazas, fenced in, with Israel in complete control of what and who go in or come out and the IDF ready to bomb at the first sign of resistance. Israel could have had peace at any time since the early 1970's but it wants the land but not the people. Israelis have never been prepared to part with the land conquered in 1967 or to seriously address the division of Jerusalem and the status of refugees. Time is growing short; sanctions and divestment and coming and in two or three decades Israelis will wake up one day to find that their imperial patron, the US, has abandoned them. Then they will have to make peace not form their current position of dominance but in a true existential crisis.
@@Zensci18 no well educated. For Mathematicians it is well understood how to “prove” things out. Unlike you I am not listening to self-serving bias by only viewing the content that I align with. That is called an echo-chamber and I have not left this comments on Tel-Aviv lectures on why European Jews are refugee problem and not colonial problem.
@@Tas2270 it’s not colonial if your ancestors were expelled from their homeland and generations prayed, dreamt, and yearned for return to the land of their forefathers. Look up archeological studies of the area. What percentage of artifacts unearthed contain Hebrew and Jewish language and iconography versus Arab ? A lot higher % are Hebraic/Jewish origin and that should tell you something about how “colonial” the modern State of Israel is.
@@Zensci18 so Iran should own India and Pakistan and Italy should own UK. For most of the world whose artifacts are plundered and sit in London and New York museum they don’t invader the country and kill their in habitants in the most savage and brutal way they pay tickets to see it. But clearly such civility is below your sensibility. You know what they say about a horse you can lead to water but can’t force it to drink, the bloodlust and savagary for the made up nationalism of a group that had forsaken god is just astounding. American were given permission by their Christian Gods to purge the savages from North America and South America and Australia. Africans were enslaved to restore the natural order of light vs.dark. In the end it’s your lack of equity and sense of inequality that is making Jews unsafe and wanting an ethnic-state a contradiction to egalitarian approach of the modern century. Aryan and Sanskrit are older than Jewish tribes and Hebrew so maybe learn from that, instead of making up languages and claiming created since 2000 years ago like Abercrombie stores. You cannot dress up entitlement even if it is born out of suffering at the hand of your ancestors and their friends.
@@Zensci18 responded twice, YT removed it. Don't really care, everyone yearns for equality. One's statehood is not above the others, but be stuck in antiquated dialogues along the religious lines in your narrow historical box. Your comments does not make you enlightened, informed or reformed just another neo-con with a fascist flare.
My immediate reaction to his first sentence was, "You need to learn more history." And then it turns out this guy is a historian. No, civil rights movement was not all fluffy. There was Stokely Carmichael, and Elijah Mohammed, and Louis Farrakhan, and Black Panthers, and many politicized gangs. And a lot of things have happened since. For example, Martin Luther King is practically forgotten today.
It's not like Gil Troy has skin in the game, no sir.🤣 Yes, he wants you to hate, and fight, his enemies for him. It's his only interest in you. And he'll destroy your society while you're at the front.
@@maltija1 I'm perfectly aware of my skin in the game but I don't pretend otherwise. Excuse me for noticing that parasites like Gil Troy have been destroying my civilization. Fortunately, no one loves yall any more.
The only time Hamas troops entered Israel was Oct 7th 2023. Other than that, it has been the IDF occupying Palestinian territory. What does that tell you?
They don't care, they don't see Palestinians as human. Literally anything they do in self defence is illegitimate to Zionists and racists, anything Israel does is correct by definition
It tells me that you don’t know a single thing about history And don’t know how to use Google. There have been hundreds of attacks on Israel from Hamas. One list is titled, “Suicide and Other Bombing Attacks in Israel Since the Declaration of Principles (Sept 1993)”
What is Palestinian territory? What do you consider to be that territory? Are you talking about all of historical Palestine? Or are you talking only about Gaza and the West bank? These are important issues, and you should clarify yourself.
@ianbridge3270 considering that the Palestinians represent some of the worst aspects of Muslim culture, and that they are supported by literal Maoist Communists in Western countries, no, I do not support the Palestinian cause. Do I think they're not people? No, that is simply your particular twist on the theme.
When there’s an actual Genocide - fine. But the only genocidal action that’s taken place was in October 7. Meanwhile 20% of Israel’s citizens are Arab, and more aide has entered Gaza in the history of Gaza - that’s genocide? That’s insulting to MY intelligence.
@@themissingpeace7956 The Palestinians constantly state their desire to commit genocide against Jews and erase Israel from the earth but they don't have the power to do it. On the other hand, Israel has the power to wipe out every Palestinian in Gaza and the West Bank--but doesn't. That tells you everything about the difference in values. There is no genocide against Palestinians. Even with the losses from the war, the Palestinian population will increase this year. Telling lies about genocide and ethnic cleansing just makes you look ridiculous to the 80% of Americans who can think rationally and support Israel.
We're witness to an American brand of mass Psychosis
It’s a nightmare. Social media hijacking un/malformed brains into fractured chaotic unproductive anger.
Yes you are right
You’re right. Someone really needs to talk to these pro-Israel people. They’re really terrible people.
It's the work of the KGB. Putin is laughing himself hoarse watching America tear itself apart over people wanting to twiddle with their sex organs and demonstrating in favour of Islamo-fascists who would kill most Americans as soon as they could. Putin didn't even have to fire a shot. His birthday present from the KGB and Iran, the Hamas attack on Oct.7th has lit the fuse, and knocked his murderous war in Ukraine out of the news cycle. People who are anti-Israel are his useful idiots.
Another one
Thank you for this conversation.
American Jewry has to learn to vote Right so that the Left doesn’t take American Jewry for granted.
Correct diagnosis: Students at American universities are being taught WHAT to think, instead of being taught HOW to think.
The definition of irony is queers and feminists for Palestine
Almost as ironic as "Christian Zionists"
@@tb8865or Westerners supporting hamas is peak irony. Zionism is the belief in the existence of Israel. Obviously you do not believe Israel should exist.
@@evamurray2564 I don't care one way or the other. But the Jewish religion and Zionist worldview is hostile to Christianity, as hostile as the Muslim worldview is to Feminism, LGBTQ, etc. Christians think Jesus is God, and Jews think Jesus is burning in Hell.
More like definition of pure stupidity. He gives these people too much credit. They have no world knowledge but from TikTok and Instagram. The parents and schools are THE problem.
@@evamurray2564 exept that isreal is an ethno state that only believes non jews exists to serve or die.
non jews zionists are bigger irony than queers and feminist for palestine and since all christians and muslims based their belief on the old testament and the christ...ouf.
Thank you Professor Troy!
There's a term you learn fighting against honest-to-Marx communists, like the ones we (somehow still) have here in the Philippines:
Counter-revolutionary,
This is probably the worst thing a communist can call someone. This is THE capital crime for them. Not only are you against the ideas and ideals of whatever flavor of communism the ones you challenge espouse, you are ACTIVELY working against it. Often, this means you're on a list for the kind of punishment gets meted out for capital crimes.
I've always regarded modern-day American progressivism as the heirs of Robespierre and the Reign of Terror. Those guys were the original "Woke": you don't agree with the ideals of the French Revolution as defined by the Committee on Public Safety? OFF WITH YOUR HEAD.
But I also see echoes of this communist thinking that anything against the purity of the Party's thought - the so-called "party line" - is anathema with your so-called "progressives", America. That lack of compromise. That insistence that they and only they have the right position.
And if you were to even suggest that maybe they're the least bit wrong, well... off with your head. Digital or otherwise.
It's just sad to see so many supposedly smart kids in your universities act not so very smart due to their indoctrination. Or, even worse, as Bill Maher put it recently, "the revolution is here for me."
Then again, I also see echoes of how the National Democratic Front, the more-or-less "above ground" branch of the Communist Party of the Philippines, does its recruiting in our colleges and universities. Young people can't help but be idealistic. And the terminologies used to radicalize your uni students - whether for questions of gender, culture, the Arab-Israeli conflict, etc. - were designed to have such an effect. nothing triggers the young idealist's NEED to think they're changing the world for the better than the words used by the radical Left of America.
There are probably real commissars and troopers in those ranks, but I fear a good chunk of your students have been recruited to causes they know only one side of. Typical. Took us a long time to even blunt the NDF's radicalization of our campuses. I don't even know if we've regressed now, given some of the things I've heard.
But for the sake of the American Center, and maybe your... sensible Left, too, I hope you get a grip on your radical children. They don't know they're actually recruiting for your "Alt Right" :D
What a clear breakdown of the current madness we are witnessing since 7/10
Waw this is by far the most honest talk i have heard on youtube . This is a common mans thoughts . I can relate absolutley with what mr gil troy is saying. Thank you .❤
I am thankful there are brave people like yourselves speaking out on these issues. Hopefully speaking out can change the way things are turning out.
Dear America the world is watching so are your enemies... please note: if America falls the world fails. Your existance as nation represents the very best of Western Civilisation and greatest culture known to all mankind. You went to war with eachother over idea of end of slavery and betterment that all man are equal. By your sacrifice on the altar of freedom you saved whole world in your fight aginst evil nations of WW2 who wanted to exterminate or inslave other nations, and by doing so rebuilding a shatterd world to live again... during the Cold-war you stretched out your wings as the undisputed superpower protecting the free world from communism. 50 yrs later you are know by your flag as gracious precious people who treasure their founding values that revealed America's uniqueness and resilience in leadership. As of now the world is witnessing America being in decline from within.... could it be the Lighthouse on the Hill has now run its course in time and that your beautiful flag is slaggering down from the winds within? O America you are magnificent miracle of Judea-Christian Western Civilisation at work a continue refinment 2000 yrs civilisation made right. I humbly pray before Almighty God, that the United States of America will continue to be the guardian of Freedom over Slavery.
I've never seen a more pathetic display of nationalist delusion. The world despises America and its hypocrisy
Oh dear. You don't really believe all that, do you?
Please tell me that's sarcasm
@@Pedro17841 Let say America lost Japan won, Nazi won... Soviet won. Slave to a system of misery knowing what we have now?
@@captainhaddock6435 You are free to say that now... only because of the millions who sacrifice everything to what you take for granted. Looking back we are lucky to live in civilisation where we can look back and compare previous civilisation before us, knowing we have is a lot better.
A great book about this is *"war of all the people"*
Its a must read from the 2010s, it shows all the ties between palestine, nazis, leftist movements, mexican cartels etc. Gives you a HUGE look into the reality of anti-west collaboration and subversion
Thank you for the book recommendation. I'll look for it. ❤
Factual conversation.
No. It's not. The protests come from the conscientious world seeing footage of starvation, mutilation, torment, destruction, bombing, sniping, sadistic cruelty, and mass murder of civilians. Doesn't America stand for the law, for human rights, for protection of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness FOR ALL??
If they were, they would protest against the atrocities committed on October 7th.
What you have written, has very little to do with reality or objective understanding of the roots of the conflict.
@@xtrajently The world did stand with Israel after Oct 7. Unfotunately.they became horrified that rather than uphold law, human rights, mercy, charity, respect for life that terrorists lack, USA and Israel returned the same lawlessness, brutality, sadistic nature, and bloodlust as terrorists, but on a massive scale. That makes them terrorists as well. You cant judge what you, yourselves, are indulging in. They lost all moral authority because of this. The Hague is waiting.
@@xtrajently What are the roots?? How did the people of Gaza end up there? The Nakba. In 1948 Gr Britain armed European immigrants to descend on Palestinian communities, with colonialist greed, to murder the native people, steal their belongings, homes, and land, force the survivors into barbed wired camps, then into the walled ghetto of Gaza. Israel then controlled, oppressed the people, and purposefully deprived the ghetto of basic needs until the UN had to intervene for Gazan survival. Not to mention the systematic "mowing the lawn" bombings and attacks against civilians for decades. Not to mention, the unjust imprisonment of children. Not to mention, apartheid, abuse, and illegal settlements. Not to mention, Netanyahu funding and empowering Hamas to control and prevent progress, there. All of these are massive war crimes. If done against any Western nation would be justified for legal resistance, even violent resistance, against Israeli oppression and onslaught. There's no justification. They are genetically the descendants of the ancient Hebrew people that never left the land. Their nation, land, and homes were stolen by entitled European immigrants.
@xtrajently I'm sorry, but whoever moderates this page removed my reply. The world was with Israel after Oct 7. Then we were horrified to see it return the same lawlessness, lack of empathy, brutality, and bloodlust as any terrorist organization. Israel lost its moral authority this way. USA, too. All who do such things are evil. You can not judge if you indulge in the same crimes.
@@xtrajently The cowards here won't let me reply. Hit a nerve?
It's actually pro-Hamas and antisemitic. You don't think they're that worked up over Palestinians, do you?
100
Just because you’re a psychopath who thinks it’s cool to see thousands of mutilated dead kids doesn’t mean everyone else thinks like you.
That goes deeper than that. It it the Muslim Brotherhood propaganda machine that hijacks the woke and the bamboozling of the young students.
Critical thinking is your friend. Please make the effort to better acquaint yourself with it.
@@omp199 I don't swallow propaganda whole and uncooked. And I don't need you to tell me how to think.
If you’re “wounded” by my words , that’s totally Your problem, not mine. The only thing left for me to do is vote Republican right down the ballot.
How patriotic of you to shun accountability and vote for the guy who has repeatedly on record said he will overthrow democracy to become a dictator.
Part and parcel what the constitution says and what our forefathers died for.
You really are a smart one.
@@raftguy1376 Cry more. He had four years to supposedly "destroy democracy" and here we are talking about voting again. I only see one side right now that isn't interested in preserving our Constitutional Republic. It's the side that just gave up on even pretending to hold a presidential primary this cycle to replace the vegetable-in-chief.
@@raftguy1376 Also, repeating this "dictator" nonsense tells everyone here that you're a sheep that follows MSM rhetoric.
this was so so good thank you!
but dr troy, the problem is islam
just talk to ex-muslims
Thank you. Very informative
Excellent exposition of the situation.
Cool dude Gil Troy.
It is awful what we are seeing all over the world
Thank you.
Thank you for a very thoughtful interview.
Excellent discussion, thank you for bringing Professor Troy to your channel, a true thinker and protector of traditional liberalism 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
What is seldom discussed is what the definitions of these terms of bigotry have become. We can all agree: racism = bad, so should be removed. But what is racism? It used to be treating people badly based on skin color, which is a simple and easy to grasp definition. But now, it's pretty much every action any white person takes, and that's not my belief that's what's written by so-called thinkers such as Ibram X Kendi and Robin D'Angelo. Racism is also anything where all races are not represented (unless it's a low status job or 100% minorities). So math, the most scientifically pure subject, has become racist, why? because certain groups don't perform as well on math tests. How exactly is it racist? That doesn't matter, the math tests don't get the results needed, so it MUST be racist. A government that has mostly white people is racist, but even if a government has mostly black people in it is STILL racist. Baltimore, a city entirely run by African American leaders, is racist because the government itself was started by white people (Breakfast Club Podcast). Naturally if a company has no white people, it's NOT racist, because apparently it's impossible to be racist towards white people. This is the problem I have today with people who say they "hate bigotry"...okay, which bigotry do you mean and how are you defining it? Because I am truly not sure anymore.
If racism is bad, then borders are unjust. Africa will then not stay in Africa. Europe will become Africa. America, Africa. India, Africa. Since racism is bad, civilization must die. Unless...
57:21 Yess what informative, a teacher that can teach. I never asked this question and never thought about it, and it occurs Al Ja zera and many many other news and documentary outlets always seem to fail to address this fact, that Jordan Neither Egypt had any right to those areas they took, when Gaza was Egyptian, and Jerusalem was completely Islamized and many archelogical artifacts from the temple was demolished and removed forever. And these 2 actions has to this day caused immensely harm to any sort of stability and peace for the Israelis today.
EXCELLENT!
We want the return of common sense
Being pro-Palestine has nothing to do with anything else but being human and caring about ending the mass slaughter and horrifying, torturous, inhumane treatment and abuse of a group of people who are part of our human family.
HOW BOUT....NOOOOOOO
This tells me that you haven't heard both sides of the story and don't want to even try to listen. I find it very strange that you so readily believe that one sided narrative, yet don't seem to believe the stated aim of the people you are championing, which is a promise to annihilate all Jews, and after them everybody else who refuses to commit to Islam. Is that what you want for your future? And why do you only believe a part of what they're telling you but not all of it?
Huh..I call you out on that serious Bullshit.
Being pro-palestinian and putting pressure on your government results in pressure being put on Israel, which is fighting for survival, and merely serves to prolong the war and the suffering of the "Palestinians" you espouse.
There is no "human family." There are nations, races, tribes. In Palestine, one tribe (the one you find sympathetic) explicitly seeks the annihilation of another. They've chosen to play the hard game, the fight the death. Why? Because they have faith in their God, something Leftists in the West cannot even comprehend.
The framing is incorrect. This has nothing to do with the civil rights movement.
Proof that even distinguished scholars can be on the wrong side of history
Which history are you referring to? And whose version of the Arab-Israeli conflict tickles your fancy? Don’t be averse to impartial observations by distinguished scholars on the persisting vaunted ambition of violent extremists that are bent on destroying Israel.
@@Ohanwedike from what the world has been witnessing so far it's Gaza that's being annihilated. Or are you trying to suggest that Israelis should have greater right to a state than the Palestinians? In which case you consider Palestinians to have less worth as a people than the Israelis?
@@miraladak2314 I don't he is saying Palestinians have less worth as a people or right to have a state, just that they have been way more bent on destroying Israel or denying its existence than actually going about the business of creating a state of their own. Its sad, but unfortunately true.
There is no right side of history. This is an idiotic invention of communists, like Marx and Lenin, who thought they were on the right side. Well, Lenin's project failed, after killing tens of millions. The irony is that this concept of a right side of history is purely religious and derives from the Abrahamic religions in particular. Communism is a political religion, the most evil yet invented.
@@miraladak2314 There are no such thing as Palestinians anymore. Palestine was Arabs+Jews. That state doesn't exist anymore. Arabs got whole Jordan and now you are crying they can't have more? Oh, please!
Unfortunately, for the last 50 years, anyone in gov't, education, any administration position or media has to have passed several 'humanities' courses. Too pass these courses you have to agree with post modern philosophy, whose main tenant is 'there is only my/your truth' and no The Truth.
In other words, genocide is pro American.
you and your ilk have made the term "genocide" meaningless
but that was the goal all along...wasnt it?
@@lesweizman388 lol. My ilk??
You mean like the US Department of Justice??
CRM 1-499
19. Genocide (18 U.S.C. 1091)
Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code, prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war. Genocide is defined in § 1091 and includes violent attacks with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.
Or (in case you're not American) how about the UN?
According to the Convention, genocide is a crime that can take place both in time of war as well as in time of peace. The definition contained in Article II of the Convention describes genocide as a crime committed with the intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious
group, in whole or in part.
And btw, Israel is a signatory of that.
If that is my "ilk", great!!!
@@lesweizman388 Lol, By my "ilk" do you mean those who accept the US definition of Genocide??
19. Genocide (18 U.S.C. 1091)
Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code, prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war. Genocide is defined in § 1091 and includes violent attacks with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.
Or if you're not American, how about the UN definition??
According to the Convention, genocide is a crime that can take place both in time of war as well as in time of peace. The definition contained in Article II of the Convention describes genocide as a crime committed with the intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part.
Or by my "ilk" do you mean those of us who know our power hungry deep state will do anything to stay in power and continue the Forever Wars. You know, so that Nancy Pelosi and others in Congress get rich off the profits??
Gotta be more specific about "ilk".
BTW - President Eisenhower warned of the military industrial complex. Was he my "ilk" too??
In other words, genocide has no more meaning anymore when the term can be used so inaccurately and menacingly that it starts to mean nothing.
The definition is fine. It is simply that Israel and America are hypocritical.
They are in the mindset that
Rules are for thee, not for me.
Plus AIPAC and Israel rule the US, so we taxpayers get to pay tribute to them. They get universal Healthcare, low cost tuition and the cheapest cell phone plans I'm the world.
While too many of our vets are homeless and our schools are trash.
But continue to buy the govt narrative bruh.
The moment any academic uses the phrase anti-American" seriously, I can't take them seriously. And incidentally, it's not.
Your fooling yourself
Hello from Germany.
Could some one please give me the full Name of the Paul guy and his book?
If you touch the “more” tab under the video, all the information you want is there.
Thanks.
I have done that.
The author he talks about is not listed and in the transcript the Name is written wrong.
Anybody with a shred of empathy is distressed about the terrible injustices done to the Palestinians over the last 75 years. To campaign for Palestinian rights is to campaign for justice. The only way it’s Anti American is in that it’s anti the America that’s sides with tyrants, corporate exploiters and the American Military Industrial complex. The only good thing about the Gaza situation is that it’s caused people to look deeply at the root causes and discover the insidious Israeli influence that’s thoroughly infected American politics. It’s also shone light on the, really, hysterical tone of this kind of utterly bogus claim.
Anyone who can tell me what book he was mentioning in the end?
I agree that young people think they live in a profoundly racist society today, but don't have any idea what historical racism was really like. But I feel that contemporary Jewish commentators overuse the word 'antisemitism' and tend to deny anyone the right to criticise Israel in a tone of passionate amateurish activism - or to criticise Israel at all, especially rejecting or diminishing cherished foundational myths of Israel. In believing that anyone who challenges their core historical beliefs must be motivated by a sinister sickness called 'antisemitism' they are no more rational than the identitarians who attribute current social outcomes as proof of a dark hidden evil in white people called 'racism'. BOTH groups need to chill. Terms like antisemitism and racism have descriptive usefulness and long history but have referenced quite different issues in different places and times. What they have never been are mysterious forces - as if like evil spirits that inhabit and poison human souls. This is not the dark ages.
Professor Troy should go to Hebron or East Jerusalem. The settlers and IDF are disgusting in their racism. In addition, he should actually read something about the Civil Rights Movement.
He is projecting a LOT about Islam and Iran.
@@rachael_greyHave you seen this with your own eyes? Have you been there?
Islamoleftist social engineering.
A professor should never be enthusiastic about a students work unless they are showing the ability to argue effectively against their own deeply held beliefs.
This video is proof of Chomsky's aphorism, "Never underestimate the moral cowardice of intellectuals". What a crock!
Perhaps it's not him. 🤔
@@jalemairliha ?
@@gmw3083 Well, I think you should always make up your own mind, but to be fair, the title alone suggests major BS!
Its Chomsky that is the crook
@@clementcahan1541 Read more closely...
The far left would have us hand the keys over to savages. I'm glad the adults in control are not letting this happen.
I think being critical of Islam would be more peaceful than being critical of individuals. . . An idea or a philosophy can be dissected and debated. But peoples actions are fundamentally visceral in nature
Yes
Microscopic aggressions--
or none at all.
That's the reality.
"Anti-American" -- well, now we know why it is so popular on college campuses.
It's no surprise when this America isn't what it actually pretends to be. We call ourselves "free and democratic" when our government is run by the donor class
30:45 This is very important. The ideologically captured (ie “woke”) have the same vocabulary, but use a different dictionary than the rest of us. The far-left nowadays is dominated by “queer marxism” and an easy rule of thumb is that most of their buzzwords like colonialism, racism, -phobia, patriarchy, etc can be roughly translated to “capitalism”.
Definition of a post graduate. He will learn later that movements against war crimes are worth fighting for even if he doesn't see it yet.
As a liberal progressive, I am with John Fetterman 100%.
There is a real propagandism in school curriculum: in some ELA curricula, every literary analysis comes down to the binary narrative, the powerful vs the powerless.
Yadda yadda yadda.......
When tey came for the Gipsys I didn't saqy anything - I was not a Gipsy...!
When they came for the Communists, I didn't say anything - I was nut a Communist...!
When they came for the Disabled, I didn't say anything - I was not disabled...!
When they came for the Jews, I didn't say anything - I was not a jew...!
When they came for Me... There was No One left to say ANYTHING...!!!
"If they're Black, then it's a gang. If they're Italian, it's a mob, but if they're Jewish, it's a coincidence and should never speak about it" Dave Chappelle.
Dave is a talented guy but his comedy sometimes is just wrong and not helpful. He is a Muslim and antisemitism is in fact pervasive throughout the Islamic world on a scale much larger than Nazi Germany - a coincidence we shouldn’t ever speak about ?
✡✝☪FIGHT ANTISEMITISM!! Let the people of all faiths (Atheists welcome too!) unite to stop the ANTI-SEMITIC HOLOCAUST of the courageous people of GAZA. Thank you! ✡✝☪
50:01 Talking about false narratives, I still throughout have immensely hard time to understand how any College or University professor can talk about Palestine, Palestinians as a real thing, as it seems to be arabs who reinvented their cause of killing all the Jews of Israel in the 60´s Palestine and Palestinians as a nation, state or a people never existed before. They were Islamic Arabs living Israel, who under the Nakbar where they due to unsucsessfully in conduction of a Genocide against the new Jewish state fled home to Jordan, which was ruled by a minority of a Beduin tripe who had made a special deal with the British. So how can terrorism and unjust violence against innocent children and elderly indiscriminately legitimate a change in history and a sudden upspring in the history books of a Palestinian people with rights to move from Jordan to different settlements in Israel. .? To me it is crazy wrong, also from a Jewish (secular) professor.
Нужна сила которая будет им противостоять иначе они объединятся с другими силами и вся власть будет захвачены в америке.
In case you were wondering - yes, this guy is on AIPAC payroll 😂😂😂
Paid to push Zionist propaganda, not surprising
You can't accept that he's a Jew and therefore naturally has no sympathy for an organization founded specifically to kill him?
There was NO doubt. He is parroting the same ahistorical talking points, with the addition of completely retconning the Civil Rights Movement.
46:30 u r not so different from those leftists professors...
TURN TO ALAHIM YAHUAH YAHUSHA AND RUACH HA QODESH FOR THE WELFARE OF YOUR SOUL. YOU OUGHT TO CONSIDER TURNING TO THE MOST HIGH. DOING PRAYER. BECAUSE AFTER ALL MANY PEOPLE UNDERSTAND DO PRAYER. PRAYER CHANGES THINGS. & PRAYER WILL.HELP YOU TO RECEIVE THE THINGS YOU NEED TO BE HAPPY IN YOUR LIFE.
And while you babble and theorize, they act and win and destroy. what are you doing to combat that? more talking?
It is mostly a war of ideas. And ideas are expressed through words. Words are very important.
The earth is flat
That's so funny 🇮🇱🐷🇮🇱
The activities of the radical fringe of the pro Palestinian protests have been a gift to the “Israel is always right” wing of American opinion that has existed for decades. I have been unsurprised by the horrors being inflicted on the Palestinian people by Israel, this is after decades of dehumanising Palestinians by Israel. I’ve followed this issue for 50 years and read the Israeli press, I know that many Israelis themselves disagree with Israeli govt policy. What was once the extreme right is now the mainstream of Israeli politics so people can self righteously declare that opposing Israeli slaughter is being “pro-Hamas” but this is pure spin and avoids the central real issue of Israel’s brutality and cynical manipulation of the “peace process” to take more land.
I'm glad that someone understands what is happening.
That fringe is so small, pro-Israel groups are asking for volunteers to shout antisemitic things at these protests. Most people do NOT see that criticizing Israel or finally wanting the promised state for Palestinians are antisemitic, and rightfully so. Israel, AIPAC, the ADL, and this professor all want us to believe the opposite, even to the point of lying about the word "Intifada."
He is lying or ignorant about why the Second Intifada occurred. The Palestinians demilitarized, they were willing to compromise, and then...Israel didn't move forward with their own promises. They continued to build settlements. They continued to steal land. The IDF were still brutal, reactionary, and viciously racist. The settlers were more and more violent. More checkpoints were put in place despite the fact that Palestinians had given up their firearms.
Israel has never offered the Palestinians a state. The best deal Israel has offered creates an entity with less control over its affairs than the average US city council, or native reservation. It would turn all Palestinian areas into miniature Gazas, fenced in, with Israel in complete control of what and who go in or come out and the IDF ready to bomb at the first sign of resistance.
Israel could have had peace at any time since the early 1970's but it wants the land but not the people. Israelis have never been prepared to part with the land conquered in 1967 or to seriously address the division of Jerusalem and the status of refugees. Time is growing short; sanctions and divestment and coming and in two or three decades Israelis will wake up one day to find that their imperial patron, the US, has abandoned them. Then they will have to make peace not form their current position of dominance but in a true existential crisis.
🤮
Keep lying
Keep bullshitting
I am an american. Everything I do is American. By definition. Unsubscribed.
Goto Gaza fool.
Not at airport. You don't have to announce your departure.
That's very much not the case. The USA has overarching values and you can act in accordance with them or not.
What a whole bunch of garbage with half-truths and straw man argument.
Biased are we?
@@Zensci18 no well educated. For Mathematicians it is well understood how to “prove” things out. Unlike you I am not listening to self-serving bias by only viewing the content that I align with. That is called an echo-chamber and I have not left this comments on Tel-Aviv lectures on why European Jews are refugee problem and not colonial problem.
@@Tas2270 it’s not colonial if your ancestors were expelled from their homeland and generations prayed, dreamt, and yearned for return to the land of their forefathers. Look up archeological studies of the area. What percentage of artifacts unearthed contain Hebrew and Jewish language and iconography versus Arab ? A lot higher % are Hebraic/Jewish origin and that should tell you something about how “colonial” the modern State of Israel is.
@@Zensci18 so Iran should own India and Pakistan and Italy should own UK. For most of the world whose artifacts are plundered and sit in London and New York museum they don’t invader the country and kill their in habitants in the most savage and brutal way they pay tickets to see it. But clearly such civility is below your sensibility. You know what they say about a horse you can lead to water but can’t force it to drink, the bloodlust and savagary for the made up nationalism of a group that had forsaken god is just astounding. American were given permission by their Christian Gods to purge the savages from North America and South America and Australia. Africans were enslaved to restore the natural order of light vs.dark. In the end it’s your lack of equity and sense of inequality that is making Jews unsafe and wanting an ethnic-state a contradiction to egalitarian approach of the modern century. Aryan and Sanskrit are older than Jewish tribes and Hebrew so maybe learn from that, instead of making up languages and claiming created since 2000 years ago like Abercrombie stores. You cannot dress up entitlement even if it is born out of suffering at the hand of your ancestors and their friends.
@@Zensci18 responded twice, YT removed it. Don't really care, everyone yearns for equality. One's statehood is not above the others, but be stuck in antiquated dialogues along the religious lines in your narrow historical box. Your comments does not make you enlightened, informed or reformed just another neo-con with a fascist flare.
Native americans ?????
This is his Opinion. Nothing more. Everyone has one. 😊
you should be able to listen to criticism and evalaute facts at face value
oyveyyy
My immediate reaction to his first sentence was, "You need to learn more history."
And then it turns out this guy is a historian.
No, civil rights movement was not all fluffy. There was Stokely Carmichael, and Elijah Mohammed, and Louis Farrakhan, and Black Panthers, and many politicized gangs. And a lot of things have happened since. For example, Martin Luther King is practically forgotten today.
You really do need to go and spend some months in the middle-east.
@@maltija1 , I did. In Israel.
I you were walking down the street and saw someone getting the 💩 kicked out of them buy a much bigger person , would you just stand there and watch ?
If I witnessed the smaller person raping a woman to DEATH and cutting her baby's head off, I'd HELP.👍🏼
So, like when Israel (the little guy) is attacked over and over again by the Arab and Muslim world.......
So in this case Israel backed by the US and UK is the bully, right?
Of course my sympathy would be with the smaller person. However, I could be in the wrong. The small person may have attacked the big one with a knife.
@@TheBeatle49 @coryparni3620 .... or lobbed thousands of rockets at the "big one".
The youth who are protesting are the leaders of the future. You are on the wrong side of history.
It's not like Gil Troy has skin in the game, no sir.🤣
Yes, he wants you to hate, and fight, his enemies for him. It's his only interest in you. And he'll destroy your society while you're at the front.
We all have skin in the game, even you, though you don't yet know it.
@@maltija1 I'm perfectly aware of my skin in the game but I don't pretend otherwise. Excuse me for noticing that parasites like Gil Troy have been destroying my civilization. Fortunately, no one loves yall any more.
The only time Hamas troops entered Israel was Oct 7th 2023. Other than that, it has been the IDF occupying Palestinian territory. What does that tell you?
They don't care, they don't see Palestinians as human. Literally anything they do in self defence is illegitimate to Zionists and racists, anything Israel does is correct by definition
It tells me that you don’t know a single thing about history And don’t know how to use Google.
There have been hundreds of attacks on Israel from Hamas.
One list is titled, “Suicide and Other Bombing Attacks in Israel Since the Declaration of Principles (Sept 1993)”
It tells you that Hamas lacks the ability to sustain itself on Israeli soil. There is no civilian population for them to hide in.
What is Palestinian territory? What do you consider to be that territory? Are you talking about all of historical Palestine? Or are you talking only about Gaza and the West bank? These are important issues, and you should clarify yourself.
@ianbridge3270 considering that the Palestinians represent some of the worst aspects of Muslim culture, and that they are supported by literal Maoist Communists in Western countries, no, I do not support the Palestinian cause. Do I think they're not people? No, that is simply your particular twist on the theme.
What is anti-American about protesting genocide? These comments are self-serving and insulting to our intelligence.
When there’s an actual Genocide - fine. But the only genocidal action that’s taken place was in October 7. Meanwhile 20% of Israel’s citizens are Arab, and more aide has entered Gaza in the history of Gaza - that’s genocide? That’s insulting to MY intelligence.
Abby Martin has come out COMPLETELY in support of Hamas. Yup.
And what does that make you? Pro-genocide and ethnic cleansing?
@@themissingpeace7956 Go sit in the corner.
@@themissingpeace7956 The Palestinians constantly state their desire to commit genocide against Jews and erase Israel from the earth but they don't have the power to do it. On the other hand, Israel has the power to wipe out every Palestinian in Gaza and the West Bank--but doesn't. That tells you everything about the difference in values. There is no genocide against Palestinians. Even with the losses from the war, the Palestinian population will increase this year. Telling lies about genocide and ethnic cleansing just makes you look ridiculous to the 80% of Americans who can think rationally and support Israel.
@@themissingpeace7956themissingbrain7956 needs to examine, without bias, both sides of this issue.
@@maltija1 I’m not the one using fear to enslave their own people