More importantly, the Balfour declaration was signed DURING WW1, which turned the World Zionists congress against Germany in order to fulfil the Balfour agreement
Let's pay to Allah that this wonderful insightful informative channel of brother Paul does not get hit. May Allah preserve him and brother Ahmed from being hit or called our because the brother is reading facts
@@snakejuce perhaps, not from our perspective. I'm in Canada, but I'm Brasilian. The censorship here, and in my country, are completely different. I'm sure you understand.
Important Fact often ignored. The Balfour declaration signed DURING ww1. Which turned the Theodore Hertzel and the World Zionists congress to side with England against Germany
I prefer the Palestinians in Gaza over the expression "the Gazans." Most of the people in Gaza are not from Gaza but are refugees from other parts of Palestine.
@robinbreeds9217 whether you like it or not, most Palestinians and people of the Levant are descendants of Jewish people who have converted over the centuries and cananites - who are the actual natives of the land. Levantine Arabs are almost genetically the same as Mizrahi Jews , more so than Ashkenazi jews who are Europeans and in no way indigenous to the middle east.
@@WallahSamarah How can they be that? Most Jews were murdered off or sent in exile during the Roman Wars. Those few remaining were butchered by invading Jihadi hordes in the 7th century,
Cannot thank you enough to both Paul and Ahmed Keeler. This is a chilling account. God help us all and most importantly Palestine and Gaza ameen ya Rabb.
@@bluestar6879 ... so, yet ANOTHER widespread absurdity!? The way Americans call anyone with dark skin "African American," as if they could tell, from across the street, that the person is AMERICAN and/or AFRICAN. I did NOT know that Semite is only for languages. Can you elucidate a bit? (This is VERY interesting!)
It was revoked in resolution 46/86, that's true, but you should also mention that resolution 46/86 was voted because Israel was only willing to enter the 1991 peacetalks if resolution 3379 was revoked
That was so old.....same stuff until now. Western aid is bombed that the message is clear, and yet Zionist still coward to wage war against the Islamic world just with Gaza.
@@EmreDemirkayaLoves true... but it is funny to think that it was not revuked because it was racist no more... but to please the racist... and in the end, they never respectedthe Oslo accords anyways.
A treasure trove of most valuable information for all religions. This channel deserves all the praise and support that we can muster. Thank you for yet another great video.
The only reason Western governments ever supported it was because it encouraged Jews to self deport from their lands to somewhere else. Later it became a convenient disrupter in the Middle East.
Brilliant! You Must have on your excellent show,the brilliant Jewish Rabbi professor Yaakov Shapero! Paul Keeper is absolutely brilliant! Sincerely Michael
@michaellamont2605 "a piece of Asia Minor" aka current day Isreal. "[T]wo territories come under consideration, Palestine and Argentina. In both countries important experiments in colonization have been made, though on the mistaken principle of a gradual infiltration of Jews. An infiltration is bound to end badly. It continues till the inevitable moment when the native population feels itself threatened, and forces the Government to stop a further influx of Jews. Immigration is consequently futile unless we have the sovereign right to continue such immigration." - Theodore Herzl
He also said in one of his memoirs "The anti-Semites will become our most dependable friends, the anti-Semitic countries our allies." HERZL, FATHER OF ZIONISM SAID THIS.
Lovely exposition. Lord Montague endures as an archetype, serving as a potent reminder that the human condition does not change much... He may as well be living with us TODAY and his words would STILL be just as relevant, if not more.
AND he'd be called a "self-hating Jew" by the zionist fascists or judeo-nazis... All the while, the original self-hating jew was Herzl, from whose self-hating ideas zionist fascism was born. In fact, he is revered by israHellis for his self-hating and hate-espousing ideas. All one has to do is read his diaries with an open and critical mind. He hated EVERYTHING about (his) jewishness! Everything! And wanted to reimagine jewishness in the image of those who hated Jews - the antisemites. One could, in fact, go as far as to claim that his image of the "new" Jew was the image of an antisemitic Jew. It's beyond grotesque, absurd, farsical and cynical!
Anyone with his right mind should oppose this. I'm Jewish but only at the age of 25 I understood by self learning that I was being fed with BS. My protest voice is as equal as anyone else and I will not let some country in the middle east to claim ownership over me and my family.
Assalam Alaykum and Jzakumullah khayran brothers Paul and Ahmed for this production. Amazing how Lord Montague told the British govt this was going to happen.
For all you fervent champions of democracy - remember that the Palestinians inhabitants were never given a choice. There was no referendum asking the indigenous Palestinians if they accepted giving up half their land.
The indigenous Palestinians were mostly the Jews. They weren’t given a choice to give up their land to the Roman Empire, Byzantine Empire, Arab empire, Ottoman Empire etc. And yet when they get it back, they’re called imperialist colonialist settlers, and 850,000 Jews are ethnically cleansed from Arab states. The modern “Palestinians” are Arabs, who colonised the Middle East from the 7th Century AD. Have you guys actually seen a map of the Middle East? Or picked up an independently written history book?
1. No such thing as indigenous Palestinians. They go back just a few decades. 2. Jews were given Israel after the war, but Arab Moslems made such a stink about allowing Jews to have a state in the Middle East, they threatened war, so 3/4th of the country was offered to them (only the nasty bits were then offered to the Jews). 3. The Muslims refused the offer and upon statehood, surrounding countries attacked with the intent of ethnic cleansing. All Jews were ethnically cleansed in all Islamic states and had to flee to Israel. Jews have nearly 4,000 years of continuous occupation in Judea.
Allah is our Lord, Islam is our religion, Muhammad is our prophet, and the Qur’an is our book. We believe in the Lordship of Allah, His Divinity, His Names, His Attributes and their rules as stated in the Qur’an and Sunnah.
What people don't want to face is the reason why there will be no more hostages released by Hamas. The hostage women would need to be released first. But many of them have been raped and are now pregnant. According to the strict interpretation of Islamic law followed by Hamas, the children were fathered by Muslim men, and therefore must remain Muslim and in the possession of Islam. But to hide this horrifying situation, the mother's of these children will all be murdered after their babies are born. This, of course is truly a horrific situation, and it demonstrates the seriousness of the current war that civilization is now fighting against radical Islam.
Truly God bless you Paul for hosting an honorable British witness to enlighten the world about the atrocities that have been committed by Israeli zionist regime against Palestinian people
Palestinians are the decendents of Jews who converted to Christianity just after Jesus . And then eventually most families became Muslims , genetically they are Canaanites , the original Semitic people .
I follow Rabbi Yakov Shapiro for his extremely eloquent analysis and explanation concerning the meaning of Zionism as opposed to the meaning of Judaism. I learned very much from his discussions of the origins of Zionism and the massive problems with it.
I have alawys been saying to myself that soon people will find out what they really are. They have been covering the eyes, ears and mouths of people. Now people are seeing what they are, understanding their tricks and speaking out without fear.
Yes, their Hasbara propaganda machine has been very effective over the years, especially in the West, where they control over 70% of the mainstream media.
Thanks for your report. The distinction between "Jew" and "Zionist" is very important, during these times when Zionists are acting to inflame hatred toward Jews.
Excellent interview! Here btw. is an excellent book that sustains what your guests has said about Zionism: Reclaiming Judaism from Zionism: Stories of Personal Transformation Carolyn L. Karcher (Autor)
Brother Paul jazak Allahu khair Alhamdulillah for your guest Ahmed SubhanAllah we all need to be educated with the history. 😊 hope your Ramadan has strengthened your iman we are coming to the end sad may Allah SWT bless the ummah and make ease for us. Ameen
Nope. It is not and never will be antisemitic. Zionism is a violent settler/ colonial project born out of British Imperialism. Judaism is a non-violent, tolerant, peaceful religion. Two entirely different things.
Mr Ahmed Keeler, thank you for this lecture today. I have heard it before but I'm going to listen again because I think you give such a brilliant exposition of the situation we are now laboring within. I would like to make one correction though. I too am an Anglo-Catholic on my mother's side although I am American born and bred. When you said that Lord Montagu was appealing to the Christian country in which he resided when he said that actually, more than any other religion, the Christians have a stake, shall we say , in this land, I believe that is 100% correct for the following reason: If I were a Muslim, I would go to Mecca or Medina because that is where my religion was born. If I were a Jew, perhaps I would go to where Moses their leader came from which is Egypt and get to know the Egyptians since Moses was Egyptian. But I am a Christian and I want to go to the land where Christ was born and also where he died which is historic Palestine. I actually have been there and I have been to Egypt . I have not been to Mecca although I have been in Kuwait where I taught English and so I became quite familiar with some of the tenants of the Muslim religion. We created our own teaching books which actually used much of the Muslim religion as its template in which to immerse the students in English, thus using religion as the subject of the sentences. In all events, I was in the Holy Land in the 80s, when it was a bit more peaceful, and I was not aware of the terror under which it was born and the terror that has ensued for 75 years ever since, even preceding the birth of this man-made country called-- arbitrarily I will say-- Israel. My readings have said it could have been called Judah because the tribe of Judah existed there. Or it could have been called Benjamin because the tribe of Benjamin existed there. IT could have been called many things. The term Israel was chosen & the land itself was chosen arbitrarily because the zionists had their eye on Uganda & on land in America where there weren't many people. BUT in the end, because Hertzl knew for propaganda reasons that part of the world would work well, they chose historic Palestine,a land with lots of people & an ancient civilization. I always thought I would return to the Holy Land because I found it incredibly holy --it has a certain peaceful feeling about it, despite what was going on-- at least in the 80s it did. I realize now I can NEVER go back to the land where my religion was born because of the Jews --specifically the Zionist Jews in the Zionist land as well as the Zionist Jews around the world and the Zionist Protestants, have dessicrated it. I say Protestant zionists , furst because their goal of death and destruction is not Christian & also because-- if you know your original religion of Catholicism-- you will know that originally the state of Israel was not recognized by Catholics because they say the New Testament supersedes the Old Testament and the New Testament us our Bible. . I got in trouble in this comment ehich I put on another podcast where it was said that apparently Hitler said that as well. As they say, sometimes the worst of people have an idea that you agree with ! WHAT else can I say, tho they threatened to block my access to the internet. I myself always felt that way but i did NOT know that was Catholic dogma until I did some research. Unfortunately, Pope Paul II did do a nominal recognition of Israel which I think he felt he was compelled to do but actually the Catholic dogma does not allow for recognition of that state that is built upon historic Palestine. Christ would never countenance such a thing, not to mention the death destruction theft and deceit that has occurred in order to make that a reality. In addition, the current Pope is sitting on the fence and therefore being vilified by the Jews as well as probably by the Muslims because he won't take a stance other than to say there are terrible things happening. Anyway I'm going to go back to listening a second time to the rest of your video. BUT I did want to correct your misinterpretation (perhaps influenced by your current religion😉) of what Lord Montague said which I think was spot-on: Christ was born there. Christ died there. AND the Christian religion itself therefore has a deep attachment to that place, 😂 just as the Muslims do to Medina and Mecca and the Jews perhaps should have an attachment to the Sinai where Moses saw the burning bush and which I visited when I was in the Holy Land. I also remember seeing a sign at the border of the Sinai and the zionist state, saying that I could not go further, and I laughed and of course I walked into that bit of land. At that time, coming from what was then a democratic country ( ie the US) , I had no idea that the Holy Land was under the control of such a violent people. Luckily there was no Mossad there to shoot me dead. Praise the Lord. 🕊️
Thankyou for this Special Guest. Now add this amazing info to the video of Dr. Ralph Wilde, (Expert in International Law) speaking B4 the ICJ ( International Court of Justice) 15 Judges. ❤ Mind Blowing.
I am not a Muslim, but I would urge everyone to read the book "The Invention of the Jewish People" by Shlomo Sand and Israeli academic. His findings are mind blowing.
I've been listening to what Ahmed Paul Keeler has been saying on here and on other podcasts and it's certainly making me think more about what Zionism actually is.
Really enjoyed this interview discussion. Mr Ahmed so clearly articulated his thoughts and indeed the whole world is now awake to the ideologies that have been so widely blindly accepted as mainstream and normal . 🎉🎉
0:14 May Allah Bless and Reward Both of You in this Life and in the Hereafter and also Help our Palestinian Brothers and Sisters against the Oppressors.
I'm learning so much. Growing up I learned about my people's genocide from my grandparents and saw how what was taught in school was sanitized and limited. Same with World History. The Arab Spring opened my eyes MORE to the Middle East. Thank you. You are my new Teacher's. I will be sharing this.
They have been using those people as human shields for more than a century. They falsely accuse others of doing the same. It's high time we don't fall for their baits and recognize that we have millions of well meaning friends in that community who need to be respected and cherished.
Ilan Pappé, Avi Shlaim, Miko Peled, Maté Gabor, Norman Finkelstein, Gideon Levy, Rabbi Shapiro, Rabbi Weiss are all people to be researched and followed.
The explicitly definition of this eyes opening report by Mr Ahmed Keeler is incredibly important yet stomach churning, knowing what sufferance our Palestinian brothers and sisters have been through and subjected by UK /USA and the Apartheid Zionist Israel Regime for decades and full viewing Genocide, still the world leaders remain silent. May Allah ease their sufferance, May we be forgiven in our failure in stopping this atrocities against humanity
⚖Al Quran: Surah 81. At-Takwir 8. And when the (infant) female buried alive shall be questioned. 9. For what sin/offence she was killed? 10. And when the written pages of deeds of every person shall be laid open...
This is exactly why Allahu wa’tala exiled the Jews from Israel over 2000 years ago. The Jews disobey Allah then and they are still doing the same disobedience today. Instead of waiting for the Messiah when they will learn why Allahu had exiled them. To hate the Palestinians to such an extent is wholly unacceptable because we are all Allahu creation.
Let me start out by saying that I agree with this guest on most of his points but with some questions. I am finding it a bit odd that in all these discussions of Zionism there is a entire chapter usually overlooked. The Russian Revolution heavily overlapped with Zionism at that time. Many of them (many secular humanist) where very much part of the Revolution since Stalin promised them a homeland in the what became the Soviet Union. Furthermore, it is not like Muslims don't have "Nationalism". Most people anywhere want to have something we call a "border" and it is perfectly reasonable to expect this sentiment. It also brings up questions about when is a country "your country". I was born in the USA. It is America for me. My mom's family has been here for hundreds of years. My dad immigrated from Germany since he is basically a war refugee. He as born in Berlin in 1928, Polish mom, and I think most would understand the troubling dynamic this caused from day 1 of the Blitzkrieg, and the end result of which was Berlin destroyed and my dad actually REQUIRED to shoot his way out of Berlin, never mind trying to stop bombing raids in "high school" from 1943-1945. It is what it is, but with his dad now deceased in the war, no prospect of a future, and a sister that had some health issues and needing to send money back home, you can probably understand why he also came to the USA and just made it is home. From my point of view there is a lot of blood on all sides, but I want nothing to do with Zionism, and this has been a troubling point of contention in what we call "America First"....and I think many of us understood that it was always on a collision course with Zionism....even if we still have far too many that want to pretend otherwise.
Another mistake that Mr Keeler makes is the following: HE says that the land niw called Israel is a European nation and that is wrong. In 1948, 85% of the Israeli Jews were of European origin but by 2016 only about 30% are of European origin, the rest are of Middle Eastern and North African descent. SO NO, the state called Israel is NOT a European nation and we have to stop letting them call the shots and define the terms and establish the language used. We must take back OUR power and OUR ability to call a spade a spade. Israel recently was allowed back into the Eurovision contest because they said they were European but they are not. Ironically the woman competing last name is Golan which probably comes from the Golan heights which as we all know was land stolen from the SYRIANS and which most of the world still considers to be a property of the SYRIANS , not of the Zionist state. The fact that the Ashkenazi Jews control the power in the Zionist State just shows how racist they are. It's not surprising that they're locking up Jews who do NOT agree with the current narrative of Netanyahu and his far-right government which are embracing the current values of the Zionist state which are death destruction theft and deception. AND I do not believe it is written anywhere that those are values of Jews. Hence the Zionist state is anti-Semitic on all levels and all grounds. When this criminal error is rectified, the people currentky residing there, may continue to stay on the land but the state as it is conceived and so named shall go the way of all things that are untrue--the center does not hold. I have contended for many months now that this area of the world can and shall become the new Andalusia with three faiths Christian, Muslim and Jewish-- all living together in harmony and creating an incredible civilization that is based on the arts, on science, on literature with a religious thread running through it such that all religions who abide by their truth shall blossom as never before. They eill no longer need or be given money by the rest of the world. The rest of the world will be envious of this New Andalusia. We may even call it just that-- The New Andalusia. The government of Israel owns 90% of the land, with only 10% in private ownership; hence, what Edward Said said can be done which is that all land owned by the government shall be returned to the Palestinian indigenous people. The Jewish zionists shall be able to remain on the land that they privately owned. PEACE shall return and those that are evil shall be removed and evil is defined by thise who embrace death,lies, destruction & theft. Peace shall reign 🕊️.
"Land you have to kill for is not yours, but land you have to die for is" such a deep and true statement!
My goodness, no kidding! I’m going to start saying this everywhere!!
Indeed 🇧🇷🇵🇸🇨🇦
More importantly, the Balfour declaration was signed DURING WW1, which turned the World Zionists congress against Germany in order to fulfil the Balfour agreement
Very important this was SIGNED DURING WW1 against German
extremely powerful quote. Impossible not to tear 😢up
Boy, hope we don't lose this beloved channel.
No reason for that to happen bud. It's not like the topics being discussed are radical lol.
Let's pay to Allah that this wonderful insightful informative channel of brother Paul does not get hit. May Allah preserve him and brother Ahmed from being hit or called our because the brother is reading facts
@@snakejuce perhaps, not from our perspective. I'm in Canada, but I'm Brasilian. The censorship here, and in my country, are completely different. I'm sure you understand.
Important Fact often ignored.
The Balfour declaration signed DURING ww1.
Which turned the Theodore Hertzel and the World Zionists congress to side with England against Germany
Of course
Ahmed Paul Keeler is an absolute legend. So sharp and intelligent, and his book is terrific.
He is simply an arrogant manipulator who cannot accept the truth, so he deceives unintelligent people like the people who write here.
I prefer the Palestinians in Gaza over the expression "the Gazans." Most of the people in Gaza are not from Gaza but are refugees from other parts of Palestine.
@robinbreeds9217 whether you like it or not, most Palestinians and people of the Levant are descendants of Jewish people who have converted over the centuries and cananites - who are the actual natives of the land. Levantine Arabs are almost genetically the same as Mizrahi Jews , more so than Ashkenazi jews who are Europeans and in no way indigenous to the middle east.
@@WallahSamarah
How can they be that?
Most Jews were murdered off or sent in exile during the Roman Wars.
Those few remaining were butchered by invading Jihadi hordes in the 7th century,
@@robinbreeds9217 bad guess... care to try again?
Cannot thank you enough to both Paul and Ahmed Keeler. This is a chilling account. God help us all and most importantly Palestine and Gaza ameen ya Rabb.
Zionists seeing the video title: you dare use my own spells against me, potter ?
I've been practically screaming that the palestinian are sementic people... And Israel do not have the monopoly on sementic
Same!! I post this every time I get a chance.
No people are ever semitic.
Only a language can be semitic.
@@bluestar6879 ... so, yet ANOTHER widespread absurdity!? The way Americans call anyone with dark skin "African American," as if they could tell, from across the street, that the person is AMERICAN and/or AFRICAN.
I did NOT know that Semite is only for languages. Can you elucidate a bit? (This is VERY interesting!)
@@andreaandrea6716
The semitic language group constitute Arabic, Hebrew, Amharic, Maltese, Tigrinya, Tigre and a few others.
@@bluestar6879 That is what I thought, but I did not know that one could not apply the term to people. So, one cannot say 'Semites'? It is incorrect?
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 3379,
Adopted on 10 November 1975
"Determines that Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination"
It was revoked in resolution 46/86, that's true, but you should also mention that resolution 46/86 was voted because Israel was only willing to enter the 1991 peacetalks if resolution 3379 was revoked
That was so old.....same stuff until now.
Western aid is bombed that the message is clear, and yet Zionist still coward to wage war against the Islamic world just with Gaza.
@@EmreDemirkayaLoves true... but it is funny to think that it was not revuked because it was racist no more... but to please the racist... and in the end, they never respectedthe Oslo accords anyways.
@@EmreDemirkayaLovesThanks for this updated information.
And why don't you criticise Islamism ? If you believe Muslims can have Islamism but Jews not allowed Zionism, then your argument is morally corrupt.
A treasure trove of most valuable information for all religions.
This channel deserves all the praise and support that we can muster.
Thank you for yet another great video.
FINALLY I've been saying Zionism is anti-Semitic for a long time, it's time this idea became mainstream.
The only reason Western governments ever supported it was because it encouraged Jews to self deport from their lands to somewhere else. Later it became a convenient disrupter in the Middle East.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Read Roger Garaudy
Jewish Extremists started Zionism
Completely agree. I mentioned to my family that the ideology of Zionism is horrific and in the end it will only hurt Jewish people and not help.
Brilliant!
You Must have on your excellent show,the brilliant Jewish Rabbi professor Yaakov Shapero!
Paul Keeper is absolutely brilliant!
Sincerely Michael
Yes and Avi Shlaim whom I think Ahmed was referring to
Theodor Herzl (father of Zionism) proudly said of Zionism, “it is something colonial” in a letter he wrote to Cecil Rhodes in 1902.
Colonialism of Where?
@michaellamont2605 "a piece of Asia Minor" aka current day Isreal.
"[T]wo territories come under consideration, Palestine and Argentina. In both countries important experiments in colonization have been made, though on the mistaken principle of a gradual infiltration of Jews. An infiltration is bound to end badly. It continues till the inevitable moment when the native population feels itself threatened, and forces the Government to stop a further influx of Jews. Immigration is consequently futile unless we have the sovereign right to continue such immigration." - Theodore Herzl
Cecil Rhodes was a chief racist.
He also said in one of his memoirs "The anti-Semites will become our most dependable friends, the anti-Semitic countries our allies." HERZL, FATHER OF ZIONISM SAID THIS.
yes, but he denied Roth's offer to finance the founding...
so there had to be 2 ww, until it was realized!
Very insightful. Ahmed Paul Keeler is absolutely brilliant 👍 May Allah reward him and you both, brother Paul 🤲
I love this channel, never a dull intellectual topic.
Indeed 🧐
my cat loves u too!😺💗💗💗
Lovely exposition. Lord Montague endures as an archetype, serving as a potent reminder that the human condition does not change much... He may as well be living with us TODAY and his words would STILL be just as relevant, if not more.
AND he'd be called a "self-hating Jew" by the zionist fascists or judeo-nazis... All the while, the original self-hating jew was Herzl, from whose self-hating ideas zionist fascism was born. In fact, he is revered by israHellis for his self-hating and hate-espousing ideas. All one has to do is read his diaries with an open and critical mind. He hated EVERYTHING about (his) jewishness! Everything! And wanted to reimagine jewishness in the image of those who hated Jews - the antisemites. One could, in fact, go as far as to claim that his image of the "new" Jew was the image of an antisemitic Jew. It's beyond grotesque, absurd, farsical and cynical!
A VERY classic presentation covering many many books.
I don't believe anyone is purely evil by instinct, but Zionism is making a good argument.
ruclips.net/video/1VCQCmr0RVM/видео.htmlsi=DKVQ-vZGNjFGapqC
Anyone with his right mind should oppose this. I'm Jewish but only at the age of 25 I understood by self learning that I was being fed with BS. My protest voice is as equal as anyone else and I will not let some country in the middle east to claim ownership over me and my family.
Assalam Alaykum and Jzakumullah khayran brothers Paul and Ahmed for this production. Amazing how Lord Montague told the British govt this was going to happen.
wa alaikum assalam
Wasalam amigo!
For all you fervent champions of democracy - remember that the Palestinians inhabitants were never given a choice. There was no referendum asking the indigenous Palestinians if they accepted giving up half their land.
In the first place, they should never have been put in the position of having to agree or disagree to giving up half their land.
@@lanialost1320 agree absolutely
Kind of like the way that the Palestinians were never given a choice as to whether they would be part of the Ottoman Empire for centuries.
The indigenous Palestinians were mostly the Jews. They weren’t given a choice to give up their land to the Roman Empire, Byzantine Empire, Arab empire, Ottoman Empire etc.
And yet when they get it back, they’re called imperialist colonialist settlers, and 850,000 Jews are ethnically cleansed from Arab states.
The modern “Palestinians” are Arabs, who colonised the Middle East from the 7th Century AD.
Have you guys actually seen a map of the Middle East? Or picked up an independently written history book?
1. No such thing as indigenous Palestinians. They go back just a few decades.
2. Jews were given Israel after the war, but Arab Moslems made such a stink about allowing Jews to have a state in the Middle East, they threatened war, so 3/4th of the country was offered to them (only the nasty bits were then offered to the Jews).
3. The Muslims refused the offer and upon statehood, surrounding countries attacked with the intent of ethnic cleansing. All Jews were ethnically cleansed in all Islamic states and had to flee to Israel. Jews have nearly 4,000 years of continuous occupation in Judea.
When Paul meets Paul... another impressive presentation. Thank you for your time
Been saying this for years now...thanks for the video. May Allah bless you
@BloggingTheology . At 34:15 prof Keeler is talking about Prof Avi Shlaim. Highly recommended source. His Memoir is called Three Worlds.
He's got an excellent interview on The Think Muslim podcast
Thank you!
Allah is our Lord, Islam is our religion, Muhammad is our prophet, and the Qur’an is our book.
We believe in the Lordship of Allah, His Divinity, His Names, His Attributes and their rules as stated in the Qur’an and Sunnah.
Ameen🤲🏾🤲🏾🤲🏾
What people don't want to face is the reason why there will be no more hostages released by Hamas. The hostage women would need to be released first. But many of them have been raped and are now pregnant. According to the strict interpretation of Islamic law followed by Hamas, the children were fathered by Muslim men, and therefore must remain Muslim and in the possession of Islam. But to hide this horrifying situation, the mother's of these children will all be murdered after their babies are born. This, of course is truly a horrific situation, and it demonstrates the seriousness of the current war that civilization is now fighting against radical Islam.
"all is"
Ameen
Jesus verum lord
EXCELLENT VIDEO, thanks for that great history!
#ZionismIsAntiSemitism
Across the board, we must work together to identify and #UprootTheEvilOfZionism.
I love the beard on brother Keeler.
😂😂😂😂
The most depraved society on earth.
Muslim?
@@waltermesser9737
Not a society !
Your comment is depraved!
Truly God bless you Paul for hosting an honorable British witness to enlighten the world about the atrocities that have been committed by Israeli zionist regime against Palestinian people
@34:30 I believe he's referring to the historian Avi Shlaim. Crucial conversation! Thank you!
That is who I instantly thought he was referring to
Well, another great presentation of timely selected subjects. Thank you BT.
Palestinians are the decendents of Jews who converted to Christianity just after Jesus . And then eventually most families became Muslims , genetically they are Canaanites , the original Semitic people .
And none of the Ukrainian, Polish German, Lithuanian, zionists that call themselves israelies are Semites & can never become semites,
I follow Rabbi Yakov Shapiro for his extremely eloquent analysis and explanation concerning the meaning of Zionism as opposed to the meaning of Judaism. I learned very much from his discussions of the origins of Zionism and the massive problems with it.
Same, I love hearing him explaining things
Me too.
It is very hard and sad to hear this all truth fact. May Allah bless our pelestinian brother's and sister's.
Brother Paul you are doing an amazing work, you and your guests.
Alhamdulillah
💯✅️💯✅️
I have alawys been saying to myself that soon people will find out what they really are. They have been covering the eyes, ears and mouths of people. Now people are seeing what they are, understanding their tricks and speaking out without fear.
Yes, their Hasbara propaganda machine has been very effective over the years, especially in the West, where they control over 70% of the mainstream media.
Thanks for your report. The distinction between "Jew" and "Zionist" is very important, during these times when Zionists are acting to inflame hatred toward Jews.
Brilliant.
May Allah bless you both always.
ameen
May Allah bless you both for sharing your knowledge ameen
Excellent interview! Here btw. is an excellent book that sustains what your guests has said about Zionism:
Reclaiming Judaism from Zionism: Stories of Personal Transformation
Carolyn L. Karcher (Autor)
Great insight to issues and horror we are witnessing
Great conversation, very insightful
It would be great to get some Orthodox Torah abiding Jews to come here and explain the topic.
The only channel that I take very seriously.
Masha Allah ❤
Thank you both so very much for the clarity and compassion in this refreshingly educated dialogue. Bless!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Takbeer!!
THIEFS NEVER BECAME OWNERS. LYERS NEVER WILL KNOW TRUE.
🕊🇵🇸🕊🌍💎🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇷
This was brilliant, thank you for sharing your knowledge
Brother Paul jazak Allahu khair Alhamdulillah for your guest Ahmed SubhanAllah we all need to be educated with the history. 😊 hope your Ramadan has strengthened your iman we are coming to the end sad may Allah SWT bless the ummah and make ease for us. Ameen
Please take this to US mainstream media ASAP.
Helas they won't comply own by DC AKA zionit support
Salam to both brothers Allah bless u both...ameen
Very good. Thank you both so much.
Nope. It is not and never will be antisemitic. Zionism is a violent settler/ colonial project born out of British Imperialism. Judaism is a non-violent, tolerant, peaceful religion. Two entirely different things.
That Zionism and Judaism are two entirely different things is exactly the point of the video 🧐
THANK YOU
💯✅️
Thank you gentlemen for the information.
Calling everything Anti Semitic is a definition of "One trick pony".
Mr Ahmed Keeler, thank you for this lecture today. I have heard it before but I'm going to listen again because I think you give such a brilliant exposition of the situation we are now laboring within. I would like to make one correction though. I too am an Anglo-Catholic on my mother's side although I am American born and bred. When you said that Lord Montagu was appealing to the Christian country in which he resided when he said that actually, more than any other religion, the Christians have a stake, shall we say , in this land, I believe that is 100% correct for the following reason:
If I were a Muslim, I would go to Mecca or Medina because that is where my religion was born. If I were a Jew, perhaps I would go to where Moses their leader came from which is Egypt and get to know the Egyptians since Moses was Egyptian. But I am a Christian and I want to go to the land where Christ was born and also where he died which is historic Palestine. I actually have been there and I have been to Egypt . I have not been to Mecca although I have been in Kuwait where I taught English and so I became quite familiar with some of the tenants of the Muslim religion. We created our own teaching books which actually used much of the Muslim religion as its template in which to immerse the students in English, thus using religion as the subject of the sentences.
In all events, I was in the Holy Land in the 80s, when it was a bit more peaceful, and I was not aware of the terror under which it was born and the terror that has ensued for 75 years ever since, even preceding the birth of this man-made country called-- arbitrarily I will say-- Israel. My readings have said it could have been called Judah because the tribe of Judah existed there. Or it could have been called Benjamin because the tribe of Benjamin existed there. IT could have been called many things. The term Israel was chosen & the land itself was chosen arbitrarily because the zionists had their eye on Uganda & on land in America where there weren't many people. BUT in the end, because Hertzl knew for propaganda reasons that part of the world would work well, they chose historic Palestine,a land with lots of people & an ancient civilization.
I always thought I would return to the Holy Land because I found it incredibly holy --it has a certain peaceful feeling about it, despite what was going on-- at least in the 80s it did. I realize now I can NEVER go back to the land where my religion was born because of the Jews --specifically the Zionist Jews in the Zionist land as well as the Zionist Jews around the world and the Zionist Protestants, have dessicrated it. I say Protestant zionists , furst because their goal of death and destruction is not Christian & also because-- if you know your original religion of Catholicism-- you will know that originally the state of Israel was not recognized by Catholics because they say the New Testament supersedes the Old Testament and the New Testament us our Bible. . I got in trouble in this comment ehich I put on another podcast where it was said that apparently Hitler said that as well. As they say, sometimes the worst of people have an idea that you agree with ! WHAT else can I say, tho they threatened to block my access to the internet.
I myself always felt that way but i did NOT know that was Catholic dogma until I did some research. Unfortunately, Pope Paul II did do a nominal recognition of Israel which I think he felt he was compelled to do but actually the Catholic dogma does not allow for recognition of that state that is built upon historic Palestine. Christ would never countenance such a thing, not to mention the death destruction theft and deceit that has occurred in order to make that a reality. In addition, the current Pope is sitting on the fence and therefore being vilified by the Jews as well as probably by the Muslims because he won't take a stance other than to say there are terrible things happening.
Anyway I'm going to go back to listening a second time to the rest of your video. BUT I did want to correct your misinterpretation (perhaps influenced by your current religion😉) of what Lord Montague said which I think was spot-on: Christ was born there. Christ died there. AND the Christian religion itself therefore has a deep attachment to that place, 😂 just as the Muslims do to Medina and Mecca and the Jews perhaps should have an attachment to the Sinai where Moses saw the burning bush and which I visited when I was in the Holy Land.
I also remember seeing a sign at the border of the Sinai and the zionist state, saying that I could not go further, and I laughed and of course I walked into that bit of land. At that time, coming from what was then a democratic country ( ie the US) , I had no idea that the Holy Land was under the control of such a violent people. Luckily there was no Mossad there to shoot me dead. Praise the Lord. 🕊️
Thankyou for this Special Guest. Now add this amazing info to the video of Dr. Ralph Wilde, (Expert in International Law) speaking B4 the ICJ ( International Court of Justice) 15 Judges. ❤ Mind Blowing.
I am not a Muslim, but I would urge everyone to read the book "The Invention of the Jewish People" by Shlomo Sand and Israeli academic. His findings are mind blowing.
Excellent presentation
AllahuAkbar MashaAllah ❤
Extraordinário!
Thanks, from Brazil.
We need translet in indonesia🙏..it's very instersting subject...
To many other languages. Portuguse Spanish, Italian, French etc.
Sudah ada terjemahabny secara otomatis, dan bisa dilihat di bagian fitur penerjemahan,di pojok kiri.
JAZAKALAH KHAIR BROTHER PAUL! MAY ALLAH REWARD YOUR EFFORTS!
ameen
Great channel very informative 🙏🙏
I've been listening to what Ahmed Paul Keeler has been saying on here and on other podcasts and it's certainly making me think more about what Zionism actually is.
Really enjoyed this interview discussion. Mr Ahmed so clearly articulated his thoughts and indeed the whole world is now awake to the ideologies that have been so widely blindly accepted as mainstream and normal . 🎉🎉
0:14 May Allah Bless and Reward Both of You in this Life and in the Hereafter and also Help our Palestinian Brothers and Sisters against the Oppressors.
I agree with this premise.
I'm learning so much. Growing up I learned about my people's genocide from my grandparents and saw how what was taught in school was sanitized and limited. Same with World History.
The Arab Spring opened my eyes MORE to the Middle East.
Thank you. You are my new Teacher's. I will be sharing this.
May Allah reward you with goodness. This is resourceful Channel
💯
ameen
I think Mr Ahmed Paul keeler is referring to mr avi shlaim- an Iraqi jew historian, who has spoken endlessly about the terrible things about zionism.
Masha Allah ❤❤❤
"The anti-Semites shall be our best friends... the anti-Semitic countries, our allies!" (From the Diaries of Theodore Hertzl).
Thank you
Free Palestine
Great content. thank you
It was called Palestine for a reason.
APK puts the case extremely clearly and reflects my own sentiments entirely.
Allah bless you. Good insight indeed.
ameen
They did not learn from their Fathers and Grandfathers misfortunes during the Holocaust. It is black ingratitude that blinds the Israeli people.
They have been using those people as human shields for more than a century. They falsely accuse others of doing the same. It's high time we don't fall for their baits and recognize that we have millions of well meaning friends in that community who need to be respected and cherished.
Which friends? KSA, UAE, Egypt,etc.? Like everybody they don´t care about Palis and they are right.
@@waltermesser9737
Friends in the Jewish community. When the veil is lifted, vast majority of Jews will support the Palestinian cause.
Down with Zionism 😡😡😡
The Belfour Declaration allowed the British Empire and Zionist to play God......
Fantastic perspective and very enlightened may Allah reward you
ameen
Ilan Pappé, Avi Shlaim, Miko Peled, Maté Gabor, Norman Finkelstein, Gideon Levy, Rabbi Shapiro, Rabbi Weiss are all people to be researched and followed.
The explicitly definition of this eyes opening report by Mr Ahmed Keeler is incredibly important yet stomach churning, knowing what sufferance our Palestinian brothers and sisters have been through and subjected by UK /USA and the Apartheid Zionist Israel Regime for decades and full viewing Genocide, still the world leaders remain silent. May Allah ease their sufferance, May we be forgiven in our failure in stopping this atrocities against humanity
Please let your speaker tell his story
⚖Al Quran: Surah 81. At-Takwir
8. And when the (infant) female buried alive shall be questioned.
9. For what sin/offence she was killed?
10. And when the written pages of deeds of every person shall be laid open...
Salamat 💚🙏🏽
This is exactly why Allahu wa’tala exiled the Jews from Israel over 2000 years ago. The Jews disobey Allah then and they are still doing the same disobedience today. Instead of waiting for the Messiah when they will learn why Allahu had exiled them. To hate the Palestinians to such an extent is wholly unacceptable because we are all Allahu creation.
ماشاءاللہ ❤
Let me start out by saying that I agree with this guest on most of his points but with some questions. I am finding it a bit odd that in all these discussions of Zionism there is a entire chapter usually overlooked. The Russian Revolution heavily overlapped with Zionism at that time. Many of them (many secular humanist) where very much part of the Revolution since Stalin promised them a homeland in the what became the Soviet Union. Furthermore, it is not like Muslims don't have "Nationalism". Most people anywhere want to have something we call a "border" and it is perfectly reasonable to expect this sentiment. It also brings up questions about when is a country "your country". I was born in the USA. It is America for me. My mom's family has been here for hundreds of years. My dad immigrated from Germany since he is basically a war refugee. He as born in Berlin in 1928, Polish mom, and I think most would understand the troubling dynamic this caused from day 1 of the Blitzkrieg, and the end result of which was Berlin destroyed and my dad actually REQUIRED to shoot his way out of Berlin, never mind trying to stop bombing raids in "high school" from 1943-1945. It is what it is, but with his dad now deceased in the war, no prospect of a future, and a sister that had some health issues and needing to send money back home, you can probably understand why he also came to the USA and just made it is home. From my point of view there is a lot of blood on all sides, but I want nothing to do with Zionism, and this has been a troubling point of contention in what we call "America First"....and I think many of us understood that it was always on a collision course with Zionism....even if we still have far too many that want to pretend otherwise.
This Gentleman is a Great man
Zionism is political not religious
Very enlightening discussion 🤔
Ассаламу Алайкум ВарахматуЛлахи вабаракатуху. Из Москва.
wa alikom salam.
Freeeeeeeeee Palestine now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
For those who were wondering what the Iraq Jew Ahmed Paul Keeler was referring to, I believe it's Avi Shlaim, his work is quite interesting.
So right. . History repeating itself .. 17 years prior to oct 2023
Another mistake that Mr Keeler makes is the following:
HE says that the land niw called Israel is a European nation and that is wrong. In 1948, 85% of the Israeli Jews were of European origin but by 2016 only about 30% are of European origin, the rest are of Middle Eastern and North African descent. SO NO, the state called Israel is NOT a European nation and we have to stop letting them call the shots and define the terms and establish the language used. We must take back OUR power and OUR ability to call a spade a spade. Israel recently was allowed back into the Eurovision contest because they said they were European but they are not. Ironically the woman competing last name is Golan which probably comes from the Golan heights which as we all know was land stolen from the SYRIANS and which most of the world still considers to be a property of the SYRIANS , not of the Zionist state. The fact that the Ashkenazi Jews control the power in the Zionist State just shows how racist they are. It's not surprising that they're locking up Jews who do NOT agree with the current narrative of Netanyahu and his far-right government which are embracing the current values of the Zionist state which are death destruction theft and deception. AND I do not believe it is written anywhere that those are values of Jews. Hence the Zionist state is anti-Semitic on all levels and all grounds. When this criminal error is rectified, the people currentky residing there, may continue to stay on the land but the state as it is conceived and so named shall go the way of all things that are untrue--the center does not hold.
I have contended for many months now that this area of the world can and shall become the new Andalusia with three faiths Christian, Muslim and Jewish-- all living together in harmony and creating an incredible civilization that is based on the arts, on science, on literature with a religious thread running through it such that all religions who abide by their truth shall blossom as never before. They eill no longer need or be given money by the rest of the world. The rest of the world will be envious of this New Andalusia. We may even call it just that-- The New Andalusia. The government of Israel owns 90% of the land, with only 10% in private ownership; hence, what Edward Said said can be done which is that all land owned by the government shall be returned to the Palestinian indigenous people. The Jewish zionists shall be able to remain on the land that they privately owned. PEACE shall return and those that are evil shall be removed and evil is defined by thise who embrace death,lies, destruction & theft. Peace shall reign 🕊️.
Thank you very much for these Informations and thoughts. It helped me to become clearer in my argumentation.
This channel has more commercials(interruptions/distractions) than any other channel that I've watched.