I love the fact that Odysseus loves his wife so much that he could break through literal magic that was so powerful that Hermes needed to intercede to give him a chance Circe: sleep with me Odysseus: Wanna hear about my wife instead?
Odysseus talking about Penelope’s music coming in and him breaking through the spell and talking about his wife and how she is his power! That made me tear up 😭
I was thinking this also mad respect to him for this for real him and the crew deserves all the love for their hardworkin putting these series together for us and he is just so gracious ❤
I love the immediate confusion Odysseus has from that. He’s just like, “but no one ever helps us after being a threat to us???” He’s just so confused by her 180 and he doesn’t really believe it at first
I love how Jorge’s Borgee feels thee need to talk directly into the microphone. It’s like “I’m talking to you” whenever he gets the camera real close to his face to speak. Idk, just funny.
And it’s actually kinda sweet that he does that. It was already sweet with how much he interacts with his fanbase, and now with every video he makes it feel like a FaceTime call with him. It’s just so cool that he does this as not many people who I’m a fan of (granted, not that many) do this and it’s fun to see this change.
This has been the most fun hyperfixation I've had in a while. The credit is definitely due to how much work Mr. Jalapeño puts into each song and how they are all connected like the person in the video points out. But also the FANDOM, the discord is so fun to lurk in. Love Epic, love all yall 💜
Adding on the analysis, did you notice that for the final song of each saga (beside the first one) the recurring theme of "Just a man" appears? Cyclops: My goodbye-> Athena: " Because after all you are just a man" Storm: Ruthlessness-> When Poseidon sinks the ships: "When does a ripple becomes a tidal wave" Circe: There are other ways -> Odysseus: " I am just a man" Presumably, the final song of the Underworld saga is going to be Monster which perfectly close this theme of transformation of Odysseus from a man to a monster foreshadowed by the second song of the musical.
My favorite part is that I’m Done For, you can hear the same notes as in Horse and the Infant, which has been repeatedly used to show Odysseus’ wit and cunning
It's impossible to sit calmly while listening to "There Are Other Ways"! I just picture the live action snippets cuz they are so so good. I'm glad there's people talking about the genius of this song! 100% agree with the commentary. Looking forward to more Penelope call backs and teasers, especially!
I can't listen to all the current sagas without even singing along. I'm jamming out to all the songs. I'm borderline obsessed with it. I'm glad to be a part of such a supportive community.
Along with the low piano part which, I suspect, is alluding to going to the underworld (because the note is super low, and nothing is lower than the underworld). Also, the electronic sounds shortly after the piano low note are the same one's Jay has used for many of the underworld saga demo songs
That’s subtle? I’ve loved those moments in the musical since day 1. It shows how truly well-written the whole thing is. Speaking of which and jumping ahead, who’s excited for the Underworld Saga? Monster, from what I’ve been able to find, is so mastery written and BUILT UP TO. I’m just waiting for the whole story to be published so I can enjoy them all in peace, and I got my younger brothers hooked too!
StormLightMemes broke it all down so perfectly! My heart was breaking when I heard 'Just A Man' start to play, and then I cheered at the "I can't!" and wept at Penelope's motif. This was hands down my favorite, and the most powerful song of the Circe Saga for me. Jay, there was...So. Much. Power. Here. I love your brilliant attention to detail, and crave every new snippet and Saga. Thank you for Epic. You have given me everything I didn't know I needed in my life right now!
So I mean technically did DID and DIDNT at the same time yes he was seduced and she was trying to get him to do the unspeakable but he remembered his wife and why he wants to go home so badly it’s bc of HER so he stops circes bc he’s that committed to his Wife that he would never leave her not even being put under a spell bc his wife is his power his drive and how he broke out the spell (sorry for the long explanation)
@@dragonking1097 YA like technically when she said “Cus your all I’ve ever known” they could’ve been friends instead of lovers which is what I think ody meant when he replied to her when she said “Why can’t you just lie and say! (I love you) You do? (But not in the way you want me to)” bc he might have started to love her AS A FRIEND
@@Silly_n_Miley I read this awesome blurb on how he may have physically been seduced by Circe and Calypso (he did have 3 kids with Circe), but because both were goddesses and he was mortal, he was REQUIRED to listen to them. Plus, he never fell in love with them and any time he was ever given the chance, he immediately headed home. He was always compelled and never WILLINGLY chose to betray Penelope.
@@meredithm1569 Don't think Circe's children are actually in Homer's Odysse. I think, they appear in works of other authors (I like to call them fanfics, even though, they, of course, are from legend so either everything or nothing is fanfic). Anyways, I didn't read about them in the Odyssee. Also, good point, that he never really loved them. I think, I remember Hermes telling Odysseus to consume that Moly-herb, fight Circe and then sleep with her to make sure, they were on the same side. Circe says the same later, but they both don't seem very enthusiastic about it, which, I think, supports your point.
i actually never noticed the first one where Circe took Odysseus under her control but me and my younger cousin DID notice the "Just a Man" and "Penelope" motif. i actually went nuts over it
I loved every single thing from the Circe saga, and the subtle and not so subtle links to other songs is just so satisfying and emotional. It’s impossible not to recognize jay’s genius
Stop it, I’m crying! Literally was on the Crowdcast for eight hours, made a few friends, had TWO (kinda) poems written about me, and now we’re all in a discord server together gushing about Epic. This is legit the best musical I have ever come across for so many reasons. Thank you so much Jay for bringing this masterpiece to life.
This is such a brilliant breakdown of There Are Other Ways! Truly my favorite song on this saga even though the rest are brilliant too. I feel like not enough people are talking about the foreshadowing in Puppeteer, though! The very first musical motif we hear in the whole saga is reminiscent of Open Arms-and ultimately it is through “showing one act of kindness” that Circe helps Odysseus and frees his men. Even though Odysseus got such a harsh lesson in ruthlessness in the last saga, here we see that even through all of that, there will still be times and situations where kindness and genuine honesty are a strength.
I really do adore that Circe is more of a foil to Odysseus than immediately appears, because she mentions the fact she trusted once and it cost her and her nymphs quite a bit, so now she takes no chances. She's basically in the same fence sitting position as Odysseus in that she makes ruthless choices to protect her daughters but her heart isn't entirely hardened to the level of just taking it for granted. Which goes from subtext to main text when they duet the line in Done For, and is reinforced when Circe lets one act of kindness pay off. Circe is concerned with becoming the puppeteer in full as much as Odysseus is in becoming a monster.
@@OpMegs Wow I really like your interpretation. One of my favorite parts pf the song is the end part of Circe's high note... it's just so gorgeous. I think reading your take helped me be a bit clear on those last 2 lines: "Maybe one day the world needs a puppeteer no more, or maybe one day the word needs a puppeteer moreeee"... it shows that it is not her choice to become this cold, ruthless, manipulative puppeteer, its her circumstance which made her into that (fun fact: this exact stuff is highlighted in the song Monster where he says "Did she learn to be colder when she got older..."). One day she hopes that she may no longer need to be a puppeteer....although why says next maybe it will need more... I'm not sure
Okay and I also noticed the very first few notes of Puppeteer are a melody we've heard a few times, but the way the notes are arranged, they line up perfectly with, "we should try to find a way no one ends up dead" which is very fitting for the beginning of this saga since it's right after most of his men have been killed by Poseidon. Very cool!!
I really like that, at the end of Done For, Circe says "everyone's true colors are revealed in acts of lust" and then in There Are Other Ways, she tries to seduce him, and it doesn't work, and THEN she chooses to help him... it took me too long to realize that he had passed a test. Also, I want to know what happened to Circe. She and her nymphs trusted strangers, and "faced a heavy loss," and she said that she had "been in love once before..." I'm reading WAY too much into this, but I like to think that she helped Odysseus both because he reminded her of the way she had been about her lover, and at the same time, was so unlike the way her lover ended up treating her.
I think her lover might have been Poseidon. She seemed eager to help Odysseus when he said Poseidon was after him. In mythology, Circe wasn't a goddess, but a mortal witch. I think Poseidon was her lover once and gave her her powers, then left her.
they faced heavy loss was sort of a Greek mythology come back. i can't remember the story right now but the nymphs do get...used sometimes so that could be what she is talking about. And i think the test was to see if Odysseus was like her lover and she wanted to make sure he wasn't.
@@IgnisInvicta Yeah I figured that's what had happened with the nymphs... with what I know about greek mythology that makes a lot of sense. And I agree about the test, it makes a ton of sense that she wouldn't have trust in men after whatever happened, especially if they'd used her nymphs and maybe her like that
"There Are Other Ways" made me think it was going to be another "Say No To This" from Hamilton but no, Odysseus stepped back and was loyal, fought back and oh, it's just so good. He loves his wife so much, even after 12 long years 😭 It's probably my favorite song out of the entire musical!
Honestly, I don't think I'm never going to be normal again either. Like, how am I supposed to be normal when Other Ways is playing in my headphones and there are recurring leitmotivs from earlier in series that I need to notice and listen to. Really sir, you really outdid yourself. Can't wait to hear final products for the Underworld Saga!
"I'm never gonna be a normal person again, and I'm not complaining" yup me too!, I'm at the exact same point of my life, all this episodes made me fall too madly in love for this musical 💙✨ Congratulation you're writting a masterpiece🤌
I love how there is references from other songs all through the saga one of my favourite ones is in ruthlessness when Poseidon says “I’m your darkest moment” which is something Odysseus says to Polyphemus in Remember Them. Basically Jorge you are very bloody clever!
Another thing about ‘Just a Man’ it is played so many times throughout the musical whenever Odysseus feels guilty, when someone is trying to guilt him, or it’s Eurylochus being stupid. When Odysseus first sings ‘Just a Man’ he feels guilty over being forced to kill the baby even though he needs to or he’ll die later on. In ‘My Goodbye’ we hear Athena’s backup voices sing a part of ‘Just a Man’. Athena was trying to guilt Odysseus into staying her pupil but it doesn’t work. Then, in ‘There Are Other Ways’ Odysseus sings ‘Just a Man’ because he feels guilty for nearly cheating on Penelope. Finally, in ‘Mutiny’ we hear Eurylochus sing ‘Just a Man’ because he’s saying ‘I’m human and I need to eat so I’m gonna kill a cow’ and that leads to ‘Thunder Bringer’. Which. Oof. Jorge you’re a genius and I praise you for it but I also slightly hate you for it.
Circe’s saga out: me happy Jorge happy: me happy Hermes being Hermes: me happy You all having such a great talent: me happy All the fandom fangirling and fanboying: we all happy 😆
One of my favorite parts of EPIC is all the little internal callbacks and references. It tells you so much about the characters and their thoughts without actually having to say them, it's just so brilliant. It also shows just how much time and effort and love Jay has put into these songs, which just makes them even more special.
Jorge is my inspiration. My therapist. My life. Thank you so much Jorge, you’re amazing. Really, thank you so much! I cannot wait for more, and after Epic is finished, I’ll stay your friend/fan, don’t worry!
My favorite moment of him winning a battle not by force or wit or strength, but by true love and authentic yearning- this is the moment circe is about to kill him and he changes her mind by so powerfully demonstrating his undying love for penelope!!!! It proves he's not a threat to her nymphs, that all he truly wants is to just go home, and she's like 'okay fine I'll give you a shot I guess' like this whole saga is a MASTERPIECE in musical composition and thematic storytelling I am so weak for motifs and symbolism GIMME IT ALLLLLLL
I loved her lining all the echoes up like that. It's one reason that My Goodbye is one of my all-time favorites. Athena brings up that Ody can't understand her lesson because he "just a man".
@@MauM. That's actually what I thought because the underworld is a spooky place and it does make sense for them to release it on Halloween. Kind of a bummer that we’ll have to wait until fall for the next saga if it's true tho.
this is one of the reasons I love Epic. You guys know how to tell a story!!! The Callbacks throughout the song all while keeping a smooth melody and transition is AMAZING!!! I'm so glad she pointed out/appreciated each one of them in this song. I can't wait for the day this is made into a live-action musical. It reminds me of the music in HTTYD and how there are callbacks with the character's themes. Keep going Epic!!!
Something else I noticed in the Circe Saga was that it starts with the instrumental of the part in "Full Speed Ahead" when Odysseus says "Polites gear up, you and I'll go ahead." Odysseus is thinking about and missing Polites.
Recently watched a guy do a reaction to random songs in the series and they were makking some wrong connections and I was like screaming! Bc you HAVE to listen to everything in sequence at least once to truly appreciate this masterpiece in the making!
DUUDe the comment about cosmere fans probably liking this is so true 'cause I'm a cosmere fan and a writer and a musician and I looove finding the connections between books and I looove finding the little musical connections in this, they're so genius I look for that kind of things in film and game osts as welll
I cannot tell you how much I adore the fact that almost all the background parts in act 2 so far have been composed of either references to act 1's motifs and lyrics or setup for more motifs and lyrics later (like the "ody is scary now" motif in Different Beast that gets reused in King). we are five songs into act 2 and i am thrashing on the ground like a cat throwing a tantrum yall
I've noticed all of these things too and it's why this is my favorite song from the musical. And I love how Odysseus talks about Penelope afterwards. And how it's his love for his wife that convince her to help him because as Circe said "everyone!s true colors are revealed in acts of lust" but in this case it was the resistance to abandon himself in an act of lust that revealed who Odysseus really is on the inside.
I live for the little Easter eggs and callbacks and foreshadowing that hides in the smallest folds in each and every song. This is the main reason why I’m so obsessed with epic. I can’t wait for the rest of the sagas to have the whole thing to listen to and dissect in detail!
StormlightMemes, you're not alone, that was my favorite song of this saga too!!! 😍For like - all the reasons you mentioned and MORE; love love love love LOVE it!! EPIC Odysseus is best Odysseus, hands down, no contest. "Done For" also, the hype!! 🤩🤩🤩
I definitely didn’t just watch this to find an awkward camera angle or a cursed moment when paused just to make it the playlist picture I have for all of the epic songs because there isn’t just one playlist with all the songs released so far
It’s awesome to see someone get so into There Are Other Ways! I absolutely LOVE the whole saga but I adore this song! The hand drums absolutely SENT ME the first time I listened because the use of the hand drums seemed to symbolize that Circle had gotten him to go to bang-town with him 😆 and then Odysseus all but verified that with his comments on mistakes and to forgive him. That section of the song has a tugging to it that lures you in just like Circe and ooooooooh I just love it so much! Editing to clarify: I’m in and have been in the camp of Odysseus was not consenting to Circe since my days studying the story in college, and it looks like that direction was taken here since she casts a spell on him. I laughed out of surprise for the hand drums being used due to how they’re played matching perfectly with what they’re trying to represent, and not having expected such obvious imagery in the music
"I don't think enough people are giving this song the hype that it deserves". Really??? "There are other ways" is my favourite song. It's a masterpiece: of melody, construction and execution. They are all wonderful songs, but this one fascinated me most of all. So much power...
I noticed this too and I love it so much, it reminds me of this tiny moment in the Spartacus show, anyone else seen that? There's a moment in one of the very last episodes where Spartacus is preparing for a battle/push towards the boarder, and he's looking down at the map after all his men have left and he's alone with his thoughts, and his and his wife's leitmotif (which is just a few notes, similar to Penelope's melody) plays quietly and just to be clear, this is season 4, his wife hasn't been a feature of the show since season 1, that story is long since resolved and he rarely mentions her, we haven't heard this bit of music in at least a year, but we immediately know what he's thinking, and sure enough he moves another bit of paper aside and his gaze is cast over his homeland on the map. He doesn't say anything, there's no image on screen of a flashback, nothing like that, but it does such a perfect job of conveying that longing that still permeates every moment he's not focused on something else. It was such an incredibly well crafted and powerful moment IMO and yeah this reminded me of that, this was superb. Anyways yeah I'm glad it gives you a happy that people notice this stuff, Jay. You do it so well and so many of us are into this. Me, my kid, my gf, and my bestie, we're all neurospicy and the layers you're putting into this is giving us happy brain scritches.
I can’t put into words how much i ADORE how Odysseus starts casting the spell on HIMSELF, LIKE ISNDKSJFOSNOFNS how she casts a spell on him AND HE JOINS???????? I cried, in fact I CRIED
I love everything that was said here. This is how i rant to my friends about the songs. I also really like in done for you get the opening of the horse and the infant mixed in with circe's tune as well
My theory is that at least one of these songs is for the Sirens and the reason why it is hidden is because all the girls from the project will be singing as the Sirens themselves as a surprise.
@@MauM. Dang, that is a good theory! I think one of the songs will be him confronting Polites after making the desicion to “be the monster” and Polites’ disappointment will ruin him and that;s why he wouldn’t fight Scylla.
I agree. I love Steven Dookie’s voice and if the song was like a half reprise of open arms while Odysseus sings something similar to Poseidon about Ruthlessness being his only option. It would also be super emotionally impactful. And it would explain why he couldn’t bring himself to fight Scylla, seeing as he seemed so resolute in “Monster.” @@MauM.
My husband introduced me to Epic, and it started a whole thing where every Wednesday watch something related to Greek Mythology (Percy Jackson and the Olympians, Blood of Zeus, next is Mission: Odessey). We also talk about it all the time, about different mediums, like an animated films series done by Powerhouse Studios or a stage musical (with an official recording release like Hamilton for those of us in the sticks, though I would totally find a way to get to my local playhouse if that ever happened) Anyway, all this to say that once this entire thing is done, any studio/production company would have to be pretty stupid not to adapt it if you optioned it, especially seeing the following you've gathered.
I was just talking to my sister-in-law about this!!!!!!!! About how he starts talking about his past mistakes and how that feels kind of random, but it's because he's BEING PUT UNDER A SPELL!!!!!!!! I FREAKING LOVE IT
I noticed some of the details but not all. It makes me very sad that I won't be able to experience this musical in person since I don't live in America, but thank you so much for the music Jorge, it's absolutely amazing and I've listen to these albums so many times!
I don't know how you did it Jay, but you brought out highschooler me again with Epic! I loved reading the Odyssey in highschool so much that I literally bought it at Barnes and Noble 😂
I Love Epic the Musical! Normally Musicals have their ups and Downs but this one has only perfekt songs. I hope you continue to create such masterpieces and i can't wait for the next one. Have fun and lots of inspiration
It makes me so happy that the viola was given to Penelopy because as a viola player it doesn't get enough recognition and it's such a beautiful instrument.
I love the throwback to the Troy saga with “I’m just a man”(out of the 2 Puppeteer and There Are Other Ways I prefer There Are Other Ways), nice catch on Penelope’s motif I didn’t get that when I picked up on Just A Man(not my favourite Troy song so I don’t listen to it as much, Open Arms is my favourite and I’m planning a Cyclops Saga Remember Them lyrics tattoo)
I’m really glad she pointed out the Penelope part because that was the one thing that I didn’t notice. Everything else I notice but that I didn’t notice and makes me love that song even more.
I love the fact that Odysseus loves his wife so much that he could break through literal magic that was so powerful that Hermes needed to intercede to give him a chance
Circe: sleep with me
Odysseus: Wanna hear about my wife instead?
Penelope got a man that is committed I think she won best husband
@@Silly_n_Miley she did even though he made that giant mistake of telling his name to Polyphemus, but hey, he’s just a man after all
@@Epic_Halfblood “But after all your JUST A MAN!”
Athena: Yea, see, you can't understand my lessons or point because you're #justaman!
odysseus, famously one of THEE wifeguys of greek mythology
Odysseus talking about Penelope’s music coming in and him breaking through the spell and talking about his wife and how she is his power! That made me tear up 😭
Same 😢❤
Also at the beginning of puppeteer, the Telemachus music is playing while Odysseus thinks about his family😀
@@BobDaTitan yessss!!! 😭
dude, i went HAM when i heard the penelope theme
Jay, I love how involved you are with your fandom. It really makes this journey feel so personal as we go through it with you
I was thinking this also mad respect to him for this for real him and the crew deserves all the love for their hardworkin putting these series together for us and he is just so gracious ❤
IKR! And he’s so enthusiastic watching any fan content - never fails to make me smile :D
My favorite part of the song is the instrumental of "I'll get you to the Underworld instead". IT'S SO BRILLIANT
Yess! The immediate change in atmosphere gives me chills every time I hear it.
YES THATS MY FAVORITE PART
YESSSSSSS ALSO THE WAY THE RHYTHM FLOWS
Like it's going back and forth--IT'S SO COOL.
I love the immediate confusion Odysseus has from that. He’s just like, “but no one ever helps us after being a threat to us???” He’s just so confused by her 180 and he doesn’t really believe it at first
Omg yess and I immediately realized the choir sounds were gonna be the motif of the underworld saga and I was right
The “yaas” had me immediately💀
I love how Jorge’s Borgee feels thee need to talk directly into the microphone. It’s like “I’m talking to you” whenever he gets the camera real close to his face to speak. Idk, just funny.
And it’s actually kinda sweet that he does that. It was already sweet with how much he interacts with his fanbase, and now with every video he makes it feel like a FaceTime call with him. It’s just so cool that he does this as not many people who I’m a fan of (granted, not that many) do this and it’s fun to see this change.
I wholly agree. Also is your name meant to sound religious or ominous, cuz I am currently debating. Your Cow pup doesn’t FEEL ominous.@@Epic_Halfblood
This has been the most fun hyperfixation I've had in a while. The credit is definitely due to how much work Mr. Jalapeño puts into each song and how they are all connected like the person in the video points out. But also the FANDOM, the discord is so fun to lurk in. Love Epic, love all yall 💜
Oh, dude, same! I’ve been loving noticing each little detail as I re-listen to each song
Adding on the analysis, did you notice that for the final song of each saga (beside the first one) the recurring theme of "Just a man" appears?
Cyclops: My goodbye-> Athena: " Because after all you are just a man"
Storm: Ruthlessness-> When Poseidon sinks the ships: "When does a ripple becomes a tidal wave"
Circe: There are other ways -> Odysseus: " I am just a man"
Presumably, the final song of the Underworld saga is going to be Monster which perfectly close this theme of transformation of Odysseus from a man to a monster foreshadowed by the second song of the musical.
I know!!! i noticed how "Just a Man" keeps coming back in different ways as Ody fights for his humanity basically.
An instrumental form of "But when does a comet become a meteor" already plays in part of Monster I believe, in one of the clips
This still holds true for the Thunder Saga
Jays facial expressions never cease to make me laugh! Epic is amazing!!!
My favorite part is that I’m Done For, you can hear the same notes as in Horse and the Infant, which has been repeatedly used to show Odysseus’ wit and cunning
It's impossible to sit calmly while listening to "There Are Other Ways"! I just picture the live action snippets cuz they are so so good. I'm glad there's people talking about the genius of this song! 100% agree with the commentary. Looking forward to more Penelope call backs and teasers, especially!
I can't listen to all the current sagas without even singing along. I'm jamming out to all the songs. I'm borderline obsessed with it. I'm glad to be a part of such a supportive community.
Penelope's motif is so gorgeous, I'm in love with it. ❤ Everything about the music in EPIC is just so perfect.
Oh come on, didn't even get to the best part! The reverb when she said "the prophet is dead" was just amazing!
Along with the low piano part which, I suspect, is alluding to going to the underworld (because the note is super low, and nothing is lower than the underworld). Also, the electronic sounds shortly after the piano low note are the same one's Jay has used for many of the underworld saga demo songs
Right?! I was like, “GREAT!…well, shit.”
YESS and i LOVE the very last part where she sings in increasing volume IT GIVES ME CHILLSSSS i actually love it sm
@@KevinFlowersJr "nothing is lower than the underworld"
tartarus:
Jay you deserve literally ALL your accolades. Don't ever think otherwise
Adding the Penelope motif makes that part of the song so freaking powerful!! Once I realized it was there my heart clenched and now I am in pain😢😢
That’s subtle? I’ve loved those moments in the musical since day 1. It shows how truly well-written the whole thing is. Speaking of which and jumping ahead, who’s excited for the Underworld Saga? Monster, from what I’ve been able to find, is so mastery written and BUILT UP TO. I’m just waiting for the whole story to be published so I can enjoy them all in peace, and I got my younger brothers hooked too!
Same!!!! so excited for the Underworld saga. Already planning my fan-made album cover for it lol
I have been watching Epic since before he dropped the Troy Saga, and i love Epic so much!!!
StormLightMemes broke it all down so perfectly! My heart was breaking when I heard 'Just A Man' start to play, and then I cheered at the "I can't!" and wept at Penelope's motif. This was hands down my favorite, and the most powerful song of the Circe Saga for me. Jay, there was...So. Much. Power. Here. I love your brilliant attention to detail, and crave every new snippet and Saga. Thank you for Epic. You have given me everything I didn't know I needed in my life right now!
Athena: “Never once has he cheated on his wife”
So she wasn’t lying…
Circe tried to seduce him like the rest of his men. But he didn’t take.
So I mean technically did DID and DIDNT at the same time yes he was seduced and she was trying to get him to do the unspeakable but he remembered his wife and why he wants to go home so badly it’s bc of HER so he stops circes bc he’s that committed to his Wife that he would never leave her not even being put under a spell bc his wife is his power his drive and how he broke out the spell (sorry for the long explanation)
@@Silly_n_Miley exactly my point. Plus we know how things with Calypso were going.
@@dragonking1097 YA like technically when she said “Cus your all I’ve ever known” they could’ve been friends instead of lovers which is what I think ody meant when he replied to her when she said “Why can’t you just lie and say! (I love you) You do? (But not in the way you want me to)” bc he might have started to love her AS A FRIEND
@@Silly_n_Miley I read this awesome blurb on how he may have physically been seduced by Circe and Calypso (he did have 3 kids with Circe), but because both were goddesses and he was mortal, he was REQUIRED to listen to them. Plus, he never fell in love with them and any time he was ever given the chance, he immediately headed home. He was always compelled and never WILLINGLY chose to betray Penelope.
@@meredithm1569 Don't think Circe's children are actually in Homer's Odysse. I think, they appear in works of other authors (I like to call them fanfics, even though, they, of course, are from legend so either everything or nothing is fanfic). Anyways, I didn't read about them in the Odyssee.
Also, good point, that he never really loved them. I think, I remember Hermes telling Odysseus to consume that Moly-herb, fight Circe and then sleep with her to make sure, they were on the same side. Circe says the same later, but they both don't seem very enthusiastic about it, which, I think, supports your point.
i actually never noticed the first one where Circe took Odysseus under her control but me and my younger cousin DID notice the "Just a Man" and "Penelope" motif. i actually went nuts over it
I remember listening to it and going THATS PENELOPE'S MOTIF!!!
Gave me goosebumps
I’m not sure if she realizes… MOST of us notice these things 🥹😭💕 JAY YOU ARE A MUSICAL GENIUS I LOVE THIS ALL SO MUCH. THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU DO!!!
I loved every single thing from the Circe saga, and the subtle and not so subtle links to other songs is just so satisfying and emotional. It’s impossible not to recognize jay’s genius
Stop it, I’m crying! Literally was on the Crowdcast for eight hours, made a few friends, had TWO (kinda) poems written about me, and now we’re all in a discord server together gushing about Epic. This is legit the best musical I have ever come across for so many reasons. Thank you so much Jay for bringing this masterpiece to life.
This is such a brilliant breakdown of There Are Other Ways! Truly my favorite song on this saga even though the rest are brilliant too.
I feel like not enough people are talking about the foreshadowing in Puppeteer, though! The very first musical motif we hear in the whole saga is reminiscent of Open Arms-and ultimately it is through “showing one act of kindness” that Circe helps Odysseus and frees his men. Even though Odysseus got such a harsh lesson in ruthlessness in the last saga, here we see that even through all of that, there will still be times and situations where kindness and genuine honesty are a strength.
I really do adore that Circe is more of a foil to Odysseus than immediately appears, because she mentions the fact she trusted once and it cost her and her nymphs quite a bit, so now she takes no chances. She's basically in the same fence sitting position as Odysseus in that she makes ruthless choices to protect her daughters but her heart isn't entirely hardened to the level of just taking it for granted. Which goes from subtext to main text when they duet the line in Done For, and is reinforced when Circe lets one act of kindness pay off. Circe is concerned with becoming the puppeteer in full as much as Odysseus is in becoming a monster.
@@OpMegs Wow I really like your interpretation. One of my favorite parts pf the song is the end part of Circe's high note... it's just so gorgeous. I think reading your take helped me be a bit clear on those last 2 lines: "Maybe one day the world needs a puppeteer no more, or maybe one day the word needs a puppeteer moreeee"... it shows that it is not her choice to become this cold, ruthless, manipulative puppeteer, its her circumstance which made her into that (fun fact: this exact stuff is highlighted in the song Monster where he says "Did she learn to be colder when she got older..."). One day she hopes that she may no longer need to be a puppeteer....although why says next maybe it will need more... I'm not sure
i truly love seeing other people geeking out over this musical
Okay and I also noticed the very first few notes of Puppeteer are a melody we've heard a few times, but the way the notes are arranged, they line up perfectly with, "we should try to find a way no one ends up dead" which is very fitting for the beginning of this saga since it's right after most of his men have been killed by Poseidon. Very cool!!
I really like that, at the end of Done For, Circe says "everyone's true colors are revealed in acts of lust" and then in There Are Other Ways, she tries to seduce him, and it doesn't work, and THEN she chooses to help him... it took me too long to realize that he had passed a test.
Also, I want to know what happened to Circe. She and her nymphs trusted strangers, and "faced a heavy loss," and she said that she had "been in love once before..."
I'm reading WAY too much into this, but I like to think that she helped Odysseus both because he reminded her of the way she had been about her lover, and at the same time, was so unlike the way her lover ended up treating her.
I think her lover might have been Poseidon. She seemed eager to help Odysseus when he said Poseidon was after him. In mythology, Circe wasn't a goddess, but a mortal witch. I think Poseidon was her lover once and gave her her powers, then left her.
they faced heavy loss was sort of a Greek mythology come back. i can't remember the story right now but the nymphs do get...used sometimes so that could be what she is talking about. And i think the test was to see if Odysseus was like her lover and she wanted to make sure he wasn't.
@@booknerd525 Ooh I actually really love that it adds so much emotion to the
sigh "Poseidon, eh?" part!
@@IgnisInvicta Yeah I figured that's what had happened with the nymphs... with what I know about greek mythology that makes a lot of sense. And I agree about the test, it makes a ton of sense that she wouldn't have trust in men after whatever happened, especially if they'd used her nymphs and maybe her like that
"But a different kind of spell 😏😏"
- Mr Jalepeño
"There Are Other Ways" made me think it was going to be another "Say No To This" from Hamilton but no, Odysseus stepped back and was loyal, fought back and oh, it's just so good. He loves his wife so much, even after 12 long years 😭 It's probably my favorite song out of the entire musical!
AND ARE WE GUNNA TALK ABOUY CIRCE’S NOTE AT THE END???WHAT A WAY TO END A SAGA
Like seriously why aren't more people talking about it?? It's been stuck in my head ever since.
Honestly, I don't think I'm never going to be normal again either. Like, how am I supposed to be normal when Other Ways is playing in my headphones and there are recurring leitmotivs from earlier in series that I need to notice and listen to. Really sir, you really outdid yourself. Can't wait to hear final products for the Underworld Saga!
"I'm never gonna be a normal person again, and I'm not complaining" yup me too!, I'm at the exact same point of my life, all this episodes made me fall too madly in love for this musical 💙✨
Congratulation you're writting a masterpiece🤌
I love how there is references from other songs all through the saga one of my favourite ones is in ruthlessness when Poseidon says “I’m your darkest moment” which is something Odysseus says to Polyphemus in Remember Them. Basically Jorge you are very bloody clever!
Dude I felt the exact same way, that song has been stuck in my head the whole day!
I LOVE THE CIRCE SAGA OMGG PREACH WOMAN PREACCCHHH 😭😭💙💙
Another thing about ‘Just a Man’ it is played so many times throughout the musical whenever Odysseus feels guilty, when someone is trying to guilt him, or it’s Eurylochus being stupid. When Odysseus first sings ‘Just a Man’ he feels guilty over being forced to kill the baby even though he needs to or he’ll die later on. In ‘My Goodbye’ we hear Athena’s backup voices sing a part of ‘Just a Man’. Athena was trying to guilt Odysseus into staying her pupil but it doesn’t work. Then, in ‘There Are Other Ways’ Odysseus sings ‘Just a Man’ because he feels guilty for nearly cheating on Penelope. Finally, in ‘Mutiny’ we hear Eurylochus sing ‘Just a Man’ because he’s saying ‘I’m human and I need to eat so I’m gonna kill a cow’ and that leads to ‘Thunder Bringer’. Which. Oof. Jorge you’re a genius and I praise you for it but I also slightly hate you for it.
Circe’s saga out: me happy
Jorge happy: me happy
Hermes being Hermes: me happy
You all having such a great talent: me happy
All the fandom fangirling and fanboying: we all happy 😆
We all so happy.
Jorge makes new video about literally anything about Epic:Happy
Underworld saga releases: Ecstatic!!!
This song, THIS SONG, is so amazing!!! I have no words to say how much i loved this saga and specially TAOW!!! ❤❤❤
One of my favorite parts of EPIC is all the little internal callbacks and references. It tells you so much about the characters and their thoughts without actually having to say them, it's just so brilliant. It also shows just how much time and effort and love Jay has put into these songs, which just makes them even more special.
Jorge is my inspiration. My therapist. My life. Thank you so much Jorge, you’re amazing. Really, thank you so much! I cannot wait for more, and after Epic is finished, I’ll stay your friend/fan, don’t worry!
I wouldn't say these things are subtle.
They're definitely amazing and fantastic storytelling by way of music with constant references, tho
This is one of my favorite musicals ever THANK YOU ps I’m totally the oracle of Delphi and I can tell your going to make it to broadway!
Congratulations for the Circe Saga!!!! There Are Other Ways is my favourite!!!! ❤❤❤❤
The call back to just a man and then the cords of Penelope killed me Jay!
My favorite moment of him winning a battle not by force or wit or strength, but by true love and authentic yearning- this is the moment circe is about to kill him and he changes her mind by so powerfully demonstrating his undying love for penelope!!!! It proves he's not a threat to her nymphs, that all he truly wants is to just go home, and she's like 'okay fine I'll give you a shot I guess' like this whole saga is a MASTERPIECE in musical composition and thematic storytelling I am so weak for motifs and symbolism GIMME IT ALLLLLLL
I wanted to happy cry through this saga because it's so good!!!! ❤️
You reacting to people appreciating Epic is amazing. Please continue doing that, because it means the world to us fans ❤🎉
I loved her lining all the echoes up like that. It's one reason that My Goodbye is one of my all-time favorites. Athena brings up that Ody can't understand her lesson because he "just a man".
Completely gorgeous musical man good work to all of you
I LOVE how she’s on the verge of tears while explaining this and he’s just like ☺️☺️☺️
This is THE BEST video I've seen since this morning before i went to the ER for almost 12 hours. God bless this franchise and Jay.
As a Cosmere fan, I can confirm that this is right up our alley
Hey Jay, when will we know when The Underworld Saga is coming out?
Halloween, perhaps?
@@MauM. That's actually what I thought because the underworld is a spooky place and it does make sense for them to release it on Halloween. Kind of a bummer that we’ll have to wait until fall for the next saga if it's true tho.
This musical has made me cry, and then laugh, and then cry, and then laugh, and then gasp, on a loop.
There is not a single thought behind this man’s eyes, just joy and vibes, and I am absolutely living for it
this is one of the reasons I love Epic. You guys know how to tell a story!!! The Callbacks throughout the song all while keeping a smooth melody and transition is AMAZING!!! I'm so glad she pointed out/appreciated each one of them in this song. I can't wait for the day this is made into a live-action musical. It reminds me of the music in HTTYD and how there are callbacks with the character's themes. Keep going Epic!!!
This woman is the reason I know about Epic. So glad to see her appreciated.
Omg yes!! The Penelope melody was a beautiful touch. Made me so emotional😢❤
The best gift you can give Jay is analyzing his songs!
Something else I noticed in the Circe Saga was that it starts with the instrumental of the part in "Full Speed Ahead" when Odysseus says "Polites gear up, you and I'll go ahead." Odysseus is thinking about and missing Polites.
That woman is an attentive genius
Recently watched a guy do a reaction to random songs in the series and they were makking some wrong connections and I was like screaming! Bc you HAVE to listen to everything in sequence at least once to truly appreciate this masterpiece in the making!
Like seriously, context is VERY important for this series
I love how happy Jalapeno always looks, hes fanboying over people fanboying over his project that he fanboys over
DUUDe the comment about cosmere fans probably liking this is so true 'cause I'm a cosmere fan and a writer and a musician and I looove finding the connections between books and I looove finding the little musical connections in this, they're so genius
I look for that kind of things in film and game osts as welll
I cannot tell you how much I adore the fact that almost all the background parts in act 2 so far have been composed of either references to act 1's motifs and lyrics or setup for more motifs and lyrics later (like the "ody is scary now" motif in Different Beast that gets reused in King). we are five songs into act 2 and i am thrashing on the ground like a cat throwing a tantrum yall
As a Cosmere nerd I can confirm it is right up my alley
I've noticed all of these things too and it's why this is my favorite song from the musical.
And I love how Odysseus talks about Penelope afterwards. And how it's his love for his wife that convince her to help him because as Circe said "everyone!s true colors are revealed in acts of lust" but in this case it was the resistance to abandon himself in an act of lust that revealed who Odysseus really is on the inside.
I live for the little Easter eggs and callbacks and foreshadowing that hides in the smallest folds in each and every song. This is the main reason why I’m so obsessed with epic. I can’t wait for the rest of the sagas to have the whole thing to listen to and dissect in detail!
Yasss I noticed all these! There is so much genius in this musical, it can never be appreciated enough. It's epic in more ways than just its name.
StormlightMemes, you're not alone, that was my favorite song of this saga too!!! 😍For like - all the reasons you mentioned and MORE; love love love love LOVE it!! EPIC Odysseus is best Odysseus, hands down, no contest. "Done For" also, the hype!! 🤩🤩🤩
I definitely didn’t just watch this to find an awkward camera angle or a cursed moment when paused just to make it the playlist picture I have for all of the epic songs because there isn’t just one playlist with all the songs released so far
It’s awesome to see someone get so into There Are Other Ways! I absolutely LOVE the whole saga but I adore this song! The hand drums absolutely SENT ME the first time I listened because the use of the hand drums seemed to symbolize that Circle had gotten him to go to bang-town with him 😆 and then Odysseus all but verified that with his comments on mistakes and to forgive him. That section of the song has a tugging to it that lures you in just like Circe and ooooooooh I just love it so much!
Editing to clarify: I’m in and have been in the camp of Odysseus was not consenting to Circe since my days studying the story in college, and it looks like that direction was taken here since she casts a spell on him. I laughed out of surprise for the hand drums being used due to how they’re played matching perfectly with what they’re trying to represent, and not having expected such obvious imagery in the music
"I don't think enough people are giving this song the hype that it deserves". Really??? "There are other ways" is my favourite song. It's a masterpiece: of melody, construction and execution. They are all wonderful songs, but this one fascinated me most of all. So much power...
I noticed this too and I love it so much, it reminds me of this tiny moment in the Spartacus show, anyone else seen that? There's a moment in one of the very last episodes where Spartacus is preparing for a battle/push towards the boarder, and he's looking down at the map after all his men have left and he's alone with his thoughts, and his and his wife's leitmotif (which is just a few notes, similar to Penelope's melody) plays quietly and just to be clear, this is season 4, his wife hasn't been a feature of the show since season 1, that story is long since resolved and he rarely mentions her, we haven't heard this bit of music in at least a year, but we immediately know what he's thinking, and sure enough he moves another bit of paper aside and his gaze is cast over his homeland on the map. He doesn't say anything, there's no image on screen of a flashback, nothing like that, but it does such a perfect job of conveying that longing that still permeates every moment he's not focused on something else. It was such an incredibly well crafted and powerful moment IMO and yeah this reminded me of that, this was superb.
Anyways yeah I'm glad it gives you a happy that people notice this stuff, Jay. You do it so well and so many of us are into this. Me, my kid, my gf, and my bestie, we're all neurospicy and the layers you're putting into this is giving us happy brain scritches.
I love looking for these little things in this music. Just shows how incredible of a songwriter Jay is!
Yes!! I screamed when I heard this song so incredibly good and brilliant!
I can’t put into words how much i ADORE how Odysseus starts casting the spell on HIMSELF, LIKE ISNDKSJFOSNOFNS how she casts a spell on him AND HE JOINS???????? I cried, in fact I CRIED
I love everything that was said here. This is how i rant to my friends about the songs. I also really like in done for you get the opening of the horse and the infant mixed in with circe's tune as well
Can you please give us a at least a hint to why those first two songs of act two are hidden?!
My theory is that at least one of these songs is for the Sirens and the reason why it is hidden is because all the girls from the project will be singing as the Sirens themselves as a surprise.
@@MauM. Dang, that is a good theory! I think one of the songs will be him confronting Polites after making the desicion to “be the monster” and Polites’ disappointment will ruin him and that;s why he wouldn’t fight Scylla.
@@MauM. Polites’ soul in the underworld, that is
@@DrakeDragonton
Dude, that possibility hadn't even crossed my mind until now! It would be awesome!
I agree. I love Steven Dookie’s voice and if the song was like a half reprise of open arms while Odysseus sings something similar to Poseidon about Ruthlessness being his only option. It would also be super emotionally impactful. And it would explain why he couldn’t bring himself to fight Scylla, seeing as he seemed so resolute in “Monster.” @@MauM.
“ I know of a brilliant prophet….”
“ Only problem is that this prophet is dead…”
I think we all noticed all these things but she might be the only one to truly appreciate them
My husband introduced me to Epic, and it started a whole thing where every Wednesday watch something related to Greek Mythology (Percy Jackson and the Olympians, Blood of Zeus, next is Mission: Odessey). We also talk about it all the time, about different mediums, like an animated films series done by Powerhouse Studios or a stage musical (with an official recording release like Hamilton for those of us in the sticks, though I would totally find a way to get to my local playhouse if that ever happened) Anyway, all this to say that once this entire thing is done, any studio/production company would have to be pretty stupid not to adapt it if you optioned it, especially seeing the following you've gathered.
I love all the references of the other songs in every song and I think I'm obsessed with searching all the details hidden in them🤩😍
Literally one of the first things i noticed (other than the call back lyrics) was the Penelope tune and i got so excited about it!
I was just talking to my sister-in-law about this!!!!!!!! About how he starts talking about his past mistakes and how that feels kind of random, but it's because he's BEING PUT UNDER A SPELL!!!!!!!! I FREAKING LOVE IT
I noticed some of the details but not all. It makes me very sad that I won't be able to experience this musical in person since I don't live in America, but thank you so much for the music Jorge, it's absolutely amazing and I've listen to these albums so many times!
I don't know how you did it Jay, but you brought out highschooler me again with Epic! I loved reading the Odyssey in highschool so much that I literally bought it at Barnes and Noble 😂
I love this guy and I love his music and I love his storytelling and I AM OBSESSED
I agree with her breakdown! The beauty of the last song with each part is so incredible with all the layers and call backs
Aahhh Cosmere fandom is the best. Long live Brando Sando
I love Stormlight Memes. She introduced me to you.
I Love Epic the Musical! Normally Musicals have their ups and Downs but this one has only perfekt songs. I hope you continue to create such masterpieces and i can't wait for the next one.
Have fun and lots of inspiration
Love the Stormlight-Epic crossover!
It makes me so happy that the viola was given to Penelopy because as a viola player it doesn't get enough recognition and it's such a beautiful instrument.
Mr Jalapeño deserves his fandom! Epic is such am amazing creation, with all these carefully thought out details, I just can't get enough
I love the throwback to the Troy saga with “I’m just a man”(out of the 2 Puppeteer and There Are Other Ways I prefer There Are Other Ways), nice catch on Penelope’s motif I didn’t get that when I picked up on Just A Man(not my favourite Troy song so I don’t listen to it as much, Open Arms is my favourite and I’m planning a Cyclops Saga Remember Them lyrics tattoo)
I’m really glad she pointed out the Penelope part because that was the one thing that I didn’t notice. Everything else I notice but that I didn’t notice and makes me love that song even more.
“There Are Other Ways” is my fav song from the saga rn
Jay being happy makes me so happy ngl!